Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutMN-B&A-1990-05-16 BUDGET AND ADMINISTRATION COMMITTEE MINUTES REGULAR MEETING 7:30 PM MAY 16, 1990 Present• Committee Members: Booth, Peterson, Romanowski, Cummings, Golder Other Council Members: Mayor Nichols Others Present: City Controller - Cafferillo Deputy Controller - Thayer Superintendent of Public Works - Thadani City Attorney - Guttman Director, Planning and Development - Van Cort City Chamberlain - Parsons Youth Bureau Director - Cohen Personnel Administrator - Walker Personnel Associate - Patz City Engineer - Gray BPW Commissioner - Reeves Fire Chief - Olmstead Activities Center Coordinator, G. I.A.C. - Fort Representatives from G. I.A.C. Representatives from R.C.I. Members of the Media 1. Opening Comments Chairperson Booth stated that the following items would be added to the Agenda: A. Personnel - Decision on B.P.W. labor contract/fire officers and executive unit contracts relating to possibly hiring an outside negotiator. B. Report on the Northside Study Committee Chairperson Booth then asked for any public comments; there were no speakers from the public. 2 . Planning Department - Possible Acquisition of Property The Committee voted 5-0 to move to executive session to discuss the possibility of a property purchase. Following a brief executive session, Chairperson Booth stated that the Committee took no action relating to the possible purchase of property. 3 . D.P.W. A. City Court Facility Report BUDGET & ADMINISTRATION MINUTES - 5/16/90 Superintendent of Public Works Thadani reported to the Committee on the current status of the City Court facility. Superintendent Thadani stated that the possibility of building to the side of the current Police Station was discussed; however the owner of that property, Roy Park, does not wish to sell that property. Mr. Park is worried about the possibility that construction would destabilize the bank near the creek. Superintendent Thadani felt this was a reasonable concern. Superintendent Thadani suggested that an addition to the current building would be more complicated and more expensive than building a new structure across the street. Further meetings will be held relating to the City Court facility. Chairperson Booth suggested that a written record of all the Court facility meetings be maintained in case of future problems with the State of New York relating to this issue. Alderperson Romanowski suggested that the possibility of some type of an access to cross the street, if that plan is selected, should be also included in the plan. No further discussion was made, and the Committee took no action on this issue. It was noted, further reports will be made on this subject. B. Trash Talc and Recycling Program Report Superintendent Thadani reported to the Committee on the current status of the trash tag and recycling programs. He stated that the City has adopted a half-tag trash program for bags containing 17-1/2 pounds of garbage. Each sheet will cost $5 and contain 12 tags. The tags would be a different color than the full price trash tags. The County had no objections to the half-tag program. It was noted that the half-tags would be available to the public in about three weeks. Superintendent Thadani stated that currently the trash tag program is operating with a high level of compliance and with few problems. A brief discussion on the possibility of a curbside junk pickup took place. Superintendent Thadani stated that the recycling center is open and located at Streets and Facilities and is in operation five days a week, 7 A.M. to 7 P.M. The DPW would like to have a full time employee at the Recycling Center. At the present time the B.P.W. is considering the possibility of having a full time employee at the Recycling Center and the possibility of having the Center open on the weekends. Superintendent Thadani stated that the seven items collected for recycling are as follows: 2 BUDGET & ADMINISTRATION MINUTES - 5/16/90 1 - 3 . Three types of glass 4. Plastic 5. Cardboard 6. Paper 7. Aluminum Superintendent Thadani stated that the number of garbage trucks going to the dump is diminishing. Chairperson Booth asked Superintendent Thadani to prepare a memo stating the numbers of trucks going to the dump. City Controller Cafferillo stated that the money collected fnr trash tags sold, through April 30, 1990, is $128,666. The amount of the tipping fee charges imposed by the County is approximately $36, 000. Controller Cafferillo stated that the revenue amount is currently much higher than the County charges because the City is selling trash tags to the public well in advance of those tags being used and well in advance of the County's assessment of tipping fee charges. These numbers will be monitored throughout the year with periodic reports given to the Committee. No action was taken. C. Hudson Street Status Report Chairperson Booth asked for a financial update on the status of the Hudson Street project. Superintendent Thadani suggested that a confidential memo stating the financial aspects of this project as they currently stand would be sent to the Committee. The Committee agreed. No action was taken. D. Request to Amend the 1990 budget City Engineer Gray presented a request to amend the 1990 budget in the Standpipe Maintenance account for the replacement of the Haller Blvd. tank. Engineer Gray stated that the Standpipe Maintenance account currently has $120, 000 for the 1990 year. The $120,000 was to be used to paint two water tanks during the summer. However, because the Haller Blvd. has to be replaced this year, only one tank will get painted this summer. Now, the Haller Blvd tank will be replaced at a cost of $120, 000 and the Cornell Street tank will be repaired and repainted for $80,000 for a total of $200,000. Engineer Gray presented the resolution approved by the B.P.W. for a 1990 budget amendment of $80, 000, which would increase the standpipe account from $120, 000 to $200, 000. The additional $80, 000 would be funded from the Water Fund budget. The following motion was made: WHEREAS, the 1990 Water Fund Budget line item F8344-475 Standpipe Maintenance included $120, 000, which in part had been allocated to repair the Haller Blvd. water tank, and 3 BUDGET & ADMINISTRATION MINUTES - 5/16/90 WHEREAS, the D.P.W. has determined that it would not be cost effective to repair the Haller Blvd. water tank, and has instead recommended that said tank be replaced, now therefore, be it RESOLVED, that the 1990 Water Fund Budget be amended by transferring $80, 000 from Account F8341-435 General Maintenance Contractual Services, to Account F8344-475 Standpipe Maintenance, to fund the differential cost of replacing such water tank. Resolution passed 5-0. E. Ithaca Transit Operating Assistance Funds City Controller Cafferillo presented contracts with the New York State Department of Transportation for Section 18 Federal Assistance from the Urban Mass Transportation Act of 1964. Controller Cafferillo stated that this is a recurring contract with the State, and this year's agreement is for $85, 000. This Federal money received assists the City for payment in the operation of the City's Transit operations. After a brief discussion, the following motion was made: WHEREAS, the City of Ithaca has submitted a request for a grant of funds to the New York State Department of Transportation and the United Stated Department of Transportation, pursuant to Section 18 of the Urban Mass Transportation Act of 1964, as amended, for a project to provide operating assistance funds for transportation services within the City of Ithaca and partly in two adjoining municipalities, provided by the City of Ithaca Transit for fixed routes that are scheduled, open and available to the general public during the period January 1, 1990 to December 31, 1990 (PIN 3798.21.406) ; now, therefore, be it RESOLVED, that Mayor Benjamin Nichols be authorized to sign the agreement(s) between the City of Ithaca and the State of New York for the above named project, and be it further RESOLVED, that Mayor Benjamin Nichols is authorized to act on behalf of the City of Ithaca to proceed and complete this above named project. Motion passed 5-0. F. Establishment of City Forester Position Superintendent of Public Works Thadani presented a resolution which was approved by the B.P.W. for the establishment of a City Forester position. 4 BUDGET & ADMINISTRATION MINUTES - 5/16/90 It was stated that currently this position is being funded on a Personnel Services Contract basis. The City is now using this position on a continuous basis and it makes sense to create a permanent position. The resolution presented tonight simply establishes the position of City Forester and sets a range for the salary. The appointment will be made at a later date after the interviewing process has been completed. It was the consensus of the Committee that the establishment of this position would be a great asset to the City. The following motion was made: RESOLVED, that the Personnel Roster of the Department of Public Works be amended by adding the position of City Forester, and be it further RESOLVED, that the position of City Forester be assigned to the City Executive Association at a 1990 salary range of $32,244 - $40,702 (Grade 2) . Motion passed 5-0. After a brief discussion the Committee voted, 5-0, to go into executive session to discuss a D.P.W. personnel item. 4 . Report From Executive Session Chairperson Booth stated the following action was made in executive session: WHEREAS, the Superintendent of Public Works has recommended Peter Albertsman for an Employee Incentive Award pursuant to the terms of the CSEA Administrative Unit contract, and WHEREAS, the Superintendent of Public Works has provided the Budget and Administration Committee with substantial justification for granting this Employee Incentive Award, and WHEREAS, the Superintendent of Public Works' recommendation complies with the procedure and guidelines outlined in the CSEA Administrative Unit Contract; now, therefore, be it RESOLVED, that Peter Albertsman's salary be increased by eight (8) percent to an annual salary of $23, 066 effective June 8, 1990. Said motion passed 3-2 . Chairperson Booth voted against the motion because he was in favor of a lower percentage merit increase. Alderperson Golder voted against the motion because he does not support the merit increase concept. 5. Domestic Partnership Report 5 BUDGET & ADMINISTRATION MINUTES - 5/16/90 Chairperson Booth stated that the Domestic Partnership issue was referred by Common Council to the Committee. Chairperson Booth suggested that the Committee consider directing the City Controller to investigate: 1) the potential costs and liabilities to the City if the City were to undertake the Domestic Partnership issue, and 2) the implications the City may incur if the City unilaterally creates domestic partnership benefits outside of contract negotiations. Alderperson Cummings was concerned that during the process of gathering information on the Domestic Partnership issue the possibility exists of violating civil rights. City Controller Cafferillo stated that the investigation into this issue would be assisted by the Personnel Office. He stated further that only general assumptions would be made and information about information about particular individuals would not be collected. This issue would be discussed with the City's Insurance Carriers, Program Administrators and the City Attorney. Also, the IRS and the State Insurance Department would be contacted. The Committee was in agreement that the City Controller should investigate the Domestic Partnership issue, using general assumptions in order to develop estimates regarding the potential costs, liabilities and other implications to the City involved with the implementation of a domestic partnership ordinance and should report back to the Committee when the investigation is complete. 6. Youth Bureau A. Request for Transfer of Funds Youth Bureau Director Cohen presented a request to transfer $2, 500 from the Youth Development part time salary account to the equipment account, for the purchase of a computer for the Youth Employment Service. Because of a contract with Cornell the Youth Bureau will not have to decrease the number of summer workers as a result of this transfer; in fact, the number of summer employees will increase by 11. The new computer would be used by the Y.E.S. Program and also the Recreation Mainstream Program. The computer will also assist with the Youth Bureau's Budget and will assist in providing information to the County. The following motion was made: RESOLVED, that the authorized equipment list for the Youth Bureau be amended to include a computer system and related software for the Y.E.S. Program, and be it further 6 BUDGET & ADMINISTRATION MINUTES - 5/16/90 RESOLVED, that the acquisition of said equipment is authorized to be made within the existing Youth Bureau operating budget, by transferring $2,500 from account A7310-120, Parttime Seasonal Salaries, to account A7310-210, Office Equipment. Said motion passed 5-0. Chairperson Booth asked Youth Bureau Director Cohen to report to the Committee next month on the current status of discussions with the County on next year's County involvement in Youth Bureau programs. B. G.I.A.C. Building Renovations Youth Bureau Director Cohen and representatives from G. I.A.C. presented an updated facility report on G.I.A.C. Chairperson Booth stated that Council referred this item to the B&A Committee to set guidelines so that the Planning Department can solicit proposals from Architectural firms for the design phase of the G.I.A.C. building. Activities Center Coordinator Fort suggested to the Committee that G.I.A.C. would like the Committee to release funds so that an Architect can be selected to design the renovations. Planning Director Van Cort recommended that the same architect should be used throughout the project. City Controller Cafferillo stated that an amount not to exceed $10, 000 was authorized in 1989 for the design phase of the project. It was noted this amount was not encumbered at the end of 1989, but can be taken from the 1990 fund balance as a prior period adjustment. The G.I.A.C. renovations capital project was never established by Council, only the $10, 000 amount for the conceptual design of the project. Planning Director Van Cort suggested that the conceptual design may cost closer to $15, 000. Controller Cafferillo stated that $25, 000 was originally put into 1989 's Restricted Contingency for planning and design of the project at G.I.A.C. In 1989 $10, 000 was allocated for the conceptual design, and $1, 000 was allocated for work by the Community Dispute Resolution Center. At this point $14, 000 remains for a possible down payment on a G.I.A.C. project. If more than $10, 000 were needed for the conceptual design, that matter would have to come back to this Committee and then to Council for approval. Planning Director Van Cort said he would come back with an architect proposal in about two months. The Committee agreed with the Planning Director on the proposals. Chairperson Booth stated he had some problems with the updated report presented to the Committee. The following 7 BUDGET & ADMINISTRATION MINUTES - 5/16/90 problems with the report need to be clarified by the G. I.A.C. staff: 1. Clarify what the existing condition of the G.I.A.C. building is - particularly in terms of programs. 2 . Clarify what the existing G.I.A.C. uses are and of the various rooms and spaces in G. I.A.C. , what existing non-G. I.A.C. uses are. 3 . Clarify what the future G.I.A.C. and non-G.I.A.C. uses of the rooms and spaces in G.I.A.C. are likely to be. 4. Clarify the day to day and week to week use of the G.I.A.C. building, so that it is clear how the building is used on a regular basis, as contrasted with its use at special times (e.g. , holidays, Saturdays, summer) . No formal action was taken. However the previous suggestions relating to the selection of the architect and the clarification of the G. I.A.C. report will be implemented by the Planning Department and G.I.A.C. staff and brought back to this Committee at a later date. 7. Finance Department - Pay Phone Proposal Representatives from R.C. I. were present to answer questions regarding the Pay Phone Proposal made to the City two months ago. This item had been tabled at a prior B&A meeting. Alderperson Romanowski stated that because he works for New York Telephone, he wished to abstain from any voting on this issue for conflict of interest reasons. He may ask questions and take part in discussion, but he will not vote. A discussion on the City's pay phone service currently being used by the City took place. It was emphasized that this proposal is for non-coin use of the City's pay phones. The projected $3, 500 annual commission, if the City approved this proposal, would be an additional amount of revenue to the City on top of what AT&T is currently giving the City for coin operated calls. A discussion on the type of service that the City would receive if the proposal were approved followed. It was noted that AT&T has been asked to submit a proposal for non-coin use to the City; AT&T has yet to respond. The Committee wanted to receive AT&T's proposal prior to making a decision on this issue. 8 BUDGET & ADMINISTRATION MINUTES - 5/16/90 A price comparison, quality comparison and phone numbers to test were presented to the Committee by the representatives of R.C.I. The Committee took no action on this issue. 8. Fire Department A. Transfer of Money For Repairs to Engine 902 Fire Chief Olmstead presented a request regarding the costs of repairing fire engine 902 . The money for these repairs is to come from an insurance recovery received by the Fire Department, and the Fire Chief requested that the insurance receipts be credited to the Fire Department's repair account. City Controller Cafferillo explained to the Fire Chief that the insurance revenue needs to be maintained separately from the expenditures; therefore the insurance revenue cannot be booked to the expenditure account. Controller Cafferillo recommended that the repair be made and booked to the appropriate repair expense account and if transfers need to be made at the end of the year to cover expenditures, the Council will take the appropriate action at that time. No action was taken on this item. B. Request to Amend Authorized Equipment List Fire Chief Olmstead presented a request to amend the Fire Department's 1990 Authorized Equipment list. Chief Olmstead stated that three portable radios were stolen from City fire trucks. One of the radios stolen has been recovered through insurance, and currently recovery for the other two radios is being pursued. This request would amend the 1990 equipment list by adding one radio. The funding for this request would be offset indirectly by the insurance recovery. After a brief discussion on security, the following motion was made: RESOLVED, that the authorized equipment list for the Fire Department be amended to include the replacement of one portable two-way radio for $882, and be it further RESOLVED, that said acquisition shall be offset indirectly by insurance recoveries received from our Insurance Carrier. Motion passed 5-0. C. Request to Amend Personnel Roster Fire Chief Olmstead presented a request to amend the 1990 Fire Department Personnel Roster. The request was to add one additional firefighter position for a period of two weeks contingent on the retirement of a current firefighter. It was noted that if the retirement does not take place, 9 BUDGET & ADMINISTRATION MINUTES - 5/16/90 this request will be nullified. The Town of Ithaca will be sent a copy of the resolution if approved. After a brief discussion the following motion was made: RESOLVED, that the Personnel Roster of the Fire Department be temporarily increased by one (1) firefighter position, to allow for the hiring and training of a new firefighter in conjunction with the anticipated retirement of a current firefighter, and be it further RESOLVED, that said roster shall be reduced to its original staffing level upon the retirement of the current firefighter, and be it further RESOLVED, that should the current firefighter not retire, this authorization to hire a new firefighter shall be revoked. Said motion passed 5-0. The Committee voted 5-0 to move into executive session to discuss the remaining Fire Department issue. 9. Fire Department - Report From Executive Session Chairperson Booth stated that a Fire Department Personnel item was referred to the next Common Council meeting with a possible resolution coming from that meeting. 10. Finance Department - City Chamberlain Request For Council Resolution City Chamberlain Parsons presented a request to pass a resolution objecting to a County proposal to collect County taxes in two installments. Chamberlain Parsons stated that the possibility of two installment dates for County taxes would greatly confuse the public on tax due dates because the County taxes would have different due dates than the City tax installments. Furthermore, the difference in timing and procedures between the County and City taxes would greatly increase the possibility of incorrect payments. A number of objections regarding the tax installment issue have been received by the County from other affected municipalities. It was noted the County would charge the taxpayer a service charge if the installment payment were used. (Currently, the City opts not to charge the taxpayer for using the installment method of payment. ) The City Chamberlain strongly recommended to the Committee that the County's installment procedure be rejected. The following motion was made: WHEREAS, Tompkins County is considering a Local Law that would allow County taxes to be paid in two installments, and 10 .. ..._.........................,....,................�.a...� .�...............:..,wu. __ .....x.>.:i . .......................................... . r..:.:es..�. .�..-. :...is...r.-.... ..,..>.'S: .... _. .,:3: BUDGET & ADMINISTRATION MINUTES - 5/16/90 WHEREAS, the Tompkins County -Board of Representatives has requested Common Council to express an opinion regarding said Local Law, and WHEREAS, while sensitive to the intent of the Tompkins County Board of Representatives to afford taxpayers an opportunity to pay taxes in two installments, the issuance of County installment tax bills and City installment tax bills with different due dates, different bill arrangements, and different penalty structures increases the probability of payment errors leading to penalties for taxpayers and poses an extreme administrative problem for the C4amberlain's office during the peak tax collection period, now therefore, be it RESOLVED, that the Common Council of the City of Ithaca does not endorse Tompkins County Proposed Local Law No. 5 and urges the Tompkins County Board of Representatives not to adopt this proposed Local Law. Said motion passed 5-0. 11. Mayor - Status Report of Northside Disposition Committee Mayor Nichols reported on the status of the -Northside Disposition Committee. The Northside Disposition Committee wanted to let the B&A Committee know where it was headed. It was the consensus of the Committee to move into executive session to discuss the land issue. The Committee voted 5-0 to move into executive session. After a brief executive session, Chairperson Booth stated that the Committee took no action on the Northside Disposition Committee status report. 12 . Capital Projects Review Process Planning Director Van Cort discussed with the Committee the current Capital Project Review Process and suggestions to improve this process for 1990 and future years. The current Capital Project Review process begins with the receipt of all the Capital Project applications in the Planning Department. Then, a clerical compilation of the Capital Project applications is done. Then, the listing of the Capital Projects is passed on to the CIRC Committee. At this point the CIRC which includes the Controller, Planning Director, elected officials, BPW Board Members, and Planning Board members, should review and evaluate the list of possible Capital Projects and send a list of recommended projects to the Mayor. However, in the past few years this process has not operated efficiently and needs to be improved. 11 BUDGET & ADMINISTRATION MINUTES - 5/16/90 Director of Planning Van Cort recommended the following: A. All the steps in the capital review process should be consolidated and made more structural and detailed. A compilation should be done by the Planning Department and then sent to the Committee. The Committee should spend a considerable amount of time reviewing the proposed projects before sending its recommendations to the Mayor. The Committee to review the compilation should consist of the same members as presented above. B. The BPW should prepare projections for all the infrastructure in the City (i.e. replacement and repair of sewers, storm sewers, water mains, roads and bridges) . There should be an infrastructure replacement and repair schedule for the next 5 to 20 years. C. Each application for a capital project should be typewritten and the number of possible projects should be reduced to a smaller working number. Chairperson Booth urged that the Capital Projects Review Committee prioritize the capital projects that are proposed for the Mayor's consideration, with an indication of: 1) Which projects are most important for next year 2) What funding priorities should be set in the budget for next year, and 3) What alternative funding mechanisms might be available for individual projects. A discussion followed on the process by which an elected official could submit a capital project application. Following the discussion, the consensus of the B&A Committee was to have the Planning Director come back next month with a report on the Capital Project Review process. 13 . Personnel Department - Request for Reclassification Personnel Administrator Walker presented a detailed request to reclassify the Personnel Department's current Senior Stenographer to an Administrative Secretary. Funding for the reclassification would come from within the Personnel Department's 1990 budget. After a brief discussion the following motion was made: RESOLVED, that the Personnel Roster of the Personnel Department be amended as follows: Delete: One (1) Senior Stenographer Add: One (1) Administrative Secretary 12 '.,+.a-..:aa...wx...wsan..v.....a...i�.«�... «,.-.. ... -_:... ___.� i-<c� ': ..•;`ser...:..a._._e' ..�:+_:_.:...a ..:s"....: ..r -.::2..__ .t._,...:_t_..a.-.a,.i3:'...._x�v ..._... ...-._ _.._..-.s..,__..« ..._... r_....._.»_-. .... BUDGET & ADMINISTRATION MINUTES - 5/16/90 and be it further RESOLVED, that S. Denise Malone be permanently appointed to the position of Administrative Secretary at an annual salary of $19,805 effective June 11, 1990. Resolution passed 5-0. 14 . Personnel Department - Outside Negotiator for City Union Contracts Personnel Administrator Walker presented to the Committee the option of hiring an outside negotiator to negotiate three contracts; the Executive Unit, the Chief Officers of Fire Department and DPW labor unions. In the past an outside negotiator was hired to negotiate these types of contracts. Personnel Administrator Walker recommended that the Committee approve hiring an outside negotiator for the Chief Officers of the Fire and the DPW labor unions negotiations and that the Executive Unit could be negotiated in-house by the Personnel Administrator. The consensus of the Committee was to agree with the Personnel Administrator's recommendation. Chairperson Booth suggested that a RFP would not be needed for the outside negotiations because an RFP was done in 1987, 1988 and 1989. The outside negotiator could be paid through a Personal Service Contract. The consensus of the Committee was to have the Personnel Administrator get a proposal from a negotiator respecting the negotiations for the two units that will be handled outside and come back next month to get the authorization for the funds. No formal action was taken. 15. Police Department - Traffic Enforcement Officer Chairperson Booth stated that Common Council, has referred to the Committee the issue of hiring an additional Traffic Enforcement Officer. Chairperson Booth suggested to the Committee that a decision on this topic should be delayed until the Police Department makes its personnel requests for the 1991 Budget. The consensus of the Committee was to agree with Chairperson Booth. 16. Parking Revenue Report City Controller Cafferillo presented a memo on Parking Revenue for 1990. For the first quarter of 1990, total Parking Revenue was up 49% overall. A breakdown of the revenues per parking lot and permits was also presented. Controller Cafferillo noted that the revenue from Parking 13 BUDGET & ADMINISTRATION MINUTES - 5/16/90 Lot D was misleading due to the number of contractors paying for parking who are working on the County building construction. A discussion followed on the 24 hour coverage of the Dryden Road parking garage. Chairperson Booth suggested that the DPW should be urged to get a better compilation of the parking loads in the City lots and garages so that a conclusion can be made on the effect of the parking fee increases. City Controller Cafferillo also stated that the 1990 Sales Tax Revenue for the first quarter was up significantly from the prior year. He noted that new revenue sources must be found during the 1991 Budget discussions. A brief discussion on current and future revenue sources followed. No action was taken. The meeting was adjourned at 12: 05 A.M. s 14