HomeMy WebLinkAboutMN-SMC-1995 SIX MILE CREEK COMMITTEE
MINUTES OF MEETING OF
JANUARY 10, 1995
Attending members : John Johnson, Marjorie Olds, Beth Mulholland,
Peter , Dick , Richard ,
Nancy , Dan Hoffman, Rick Gray (Liaison) ,
Jill Tripp (Liaison)
Guests : Valerie Saul, Rick Ferrel, Chuck , Larry
Fabbroni
Report from Valerie Saul on options for recruiting gorge rangers .
Valerie suggests contacting local environmental groups and other
gorge users for local residents who might be interested in seasonal
work. City would be willing to pay for First Aid training for
trainee and security guard training to meet minimal requirements
for job. Questions for committee: would we be interested in
having several part-time positions or one full-time position?
Committee is willing to be flexible, wait and see what applicants
are interested in.
Options for Groups to Contact: Cayuga Nature Center, Finger Lakes
Land Trust, Cornell Plantations
Time Line:
February 1st - posting of job opening
March 15th - filing date for applicants
Early April - interviews
Memorial Day - begin working
Report from Rick Ferrel. Twelve signs have been received,
discussion on sign placement. Beth requested one at Penny Lane
entrance, Peter and Beth have proposed locations marked on map,
general agreement with suggested locations, parks crew will
install, probably within next two weeks .
Report from Beth on Van Natta ' s Pond area, beaver have been sighted
with some loss of small plantings . Discussion of beaver damage and
policy for dealing with beaver. Evidence of beaver activity up to
60 foot dam, also elsewhere in city (Fall Creek and Stewart Park) .
Report from Beth on Natural Areas Commission report.
Some proposals : an interim Natural Areas Commission composed
of Chairs of certain groups .
not specific commission, but regular
networking meeting composed of green space
groups .
Larry Fabbroni reported on upgrading of road for dam access,
continue emptying of silt dams when weather permits . Study being
developed to look at options for water supply for the city.
Timeline: RFP out this month
April - consultant selection
12-15 month study duration
Meeting adjourned at 6 : 10 p.m.
Minutes respectively submitted by
Signature illegible
JJ/cjh
SIX MILE CREEK ADVISORY COMMITTEE
MINUTES OF MARCH 9, 1995
PRESENT: Rick Ferrel, Andy , Bill Dress, Peter Fortunato,
Beth Mulholland, Nancy Ramage, Dan Hoffman, John Johnson
LAND ACQUISITION UPDATE
John led a discussion of the Public Works Water and Sewer Proposed
Guidelines for acquisition and protection of land in the City ' s
watershed. Six Mile Creek Committee will forward its list to the •
Board of Public Works and the Planning Committee.
GORGE RANGER
Beth and Peter will do the initial review of applications and make
recommendations to the committee.
SIX MILE CREEK MAINTENANCE
Since Circle Greenway is now part of the Parks Commission, Beth
will do maintenance for one year. We need an apprentice to work
with her this year and take it over next year. We agreed that we
will conduct the Spring Wild Flower Walk. We may want to involve
the city environmental committees . Beth reported that Adam had
accompanied her on a gorge walk and maintenance tasks had been
done. If we are to do anything with handicapped access, the DAC
needs to be involved. Adam is making a new bulletin board.
NATURAL AREAS PROPOSAL
We will vote on the proposal for this commission at our April
meeting.
VAN ETTA UPGRADE
There was a consensus we would proceed with the benches .
APRIL 10, 1995 AGENDA
Gorge Ranger
Natural Areas Commission
Plant Fair (May 13, 1995 )
Beth ' s Report
BACKGROUND
Comments:
This Commission is designed to
1) make recommendations regarding general policy concerning
natural areas and
2) provide a forum for the member committees in which "the right
hand will know what the left hand is doing" .
It will work through the DPW and report to the Board of Public
Works and Common Council.
The Natural Areas Commission will be a "twin" of the Parks
Commission, both being concerned about City open green space; it
would have the same organization as the Parks Commission, (i.e.
representatives and individuals) .
The Chairs of the two commissions or their representatives would
work together on common problems.
DRAFT
RESOLUTION CONCERNING THE FORMATION OF A CITY NATURAL AREAS
COMMISSION
WHEREAS, the City of Ithaca has several natural areas, and will
soon be acquiring several more by alienation or purchase, and
WHEREAS, these areas, open to the public, will require subtle and
knowledgeable management, and
WHEREAS, the skills required for natural areas management are quite
different than those required for parks, and
WHEREAS, the Parks Commission already has a great deal of
responsibility overseeing our 19 maintained parks, and
WHEREAS, our natural areas as well as our parks are important
resources for the residents of the City of Ithaca and our growing
tourist industry; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, That the City of Ithaca form a Natural Areas Commission
to advise the Department, and Board of Public Works in the
management of natural areas such as the Six Mile Creek Wildflower
Preserve, Fuertes Bird Sanctuary, Ithaca Falls Area, the Festival
Lands, Negundo Woods, and certain creekside areas .
BACKGROUND
Comments:
This Commission is designed to
1) make recommendations regarding general policy concerning
natural areas and,2) provide a forum for the member committees
in which "the right hand will know what the left hand is
r-
doing" .
It will work through the DPW and report to the BPW and CC.
The Natural Areas Commission will be a "twin" of the Parks
Commission, both being concerned about City open green space; it
would have the same organization as the Parks Commission,( i.e.
representatives and individuals).
The Chairs of the two commissions or their representatives would
work together on common problems.
DRAFT
RESOLUTION CONCERNING THE FORMATION OF A CITY NATURAL AREAS
COMMISSION
WHEREAS, the City of Ithaca has several natural areas, and will
soon be acquiring several more by alienation or purchase, and
WHEREAS, these areas, open to the public, will require subtle and
knowledgeable management, and
WHEREAS, the skills required for natural areas management are quite
different than those required for parks, and
WHEREAS, the Parks Commission already has a great deal of
responsibility overseeing our 19 maintained parks, and
WHEREAS, our natural areas as well as our parks are important
/ resource3for the residents of the City of Ithaca and our growing
tourist industry; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, That the City of Ithaca form a Natural Areas Commission
to advise the Department ) and Board of Public Works in the
management of natural areas such as the Six Mile Creek Wildflower
Preserve, Fuerte6 Bird Sanctuary, Ithaca Falls Area, the Festival
`Lands, Negundo Woods, and certain creekside areas, and be it
further
RESOLVED, That thi committee wi thcorporate committee now
working in the these ar- : as the Six Mile Creek Advisory
Committee, Circle Greenwayl a hade Tree Advisory Committee and
such others as may be ,f,6rmed to a. on new acquired areas .
l'
DRAFT
RESOLUTION CONCERNING THE FORMATION OF A CITY NATURAL AREAS
COMMISSION
WHEREAS, the City of Ithaca has several natural areas, and will
soon be acquiring several more by alienation or purchase, and
WHEREAS, these areas, open to the public, will require subtle and
knowledgeable management, and
WHEREAS, the skills required for natural areas management are quite
different than those required for parks, and
WHEREAS, the Parks Commission already has a great deal of
responsibility overseeing our 19 maintained parks, and
WHEREAS, our natural areas as well as our parks are important
resources for the residents of the City of Ithaca and our growing
tourist industry; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, That the City of Ithaca form a Natural Areas Commission
to advise the Department and Board of Public Works in the
management of natural areas such as the Six Mile Creek Wildflowe j
Preserve, Fuertes Bird Sanctuary, Ithaca Falls Area, the Fes, 1..u,v,.,.,.4
Negundo Woods, and certain creekside areas, and, be it further
RESOLVED, That this Commission will incorporate
Committees now working in these areas such as the Six-'Mile Creek
Advisory Committee, Circle Greenway, 12:1=g====6"teee and Shade
Tree Advisory Committee. G,i,cer Jzcdv o [e/2Qi -)7,7 . de,
042/ /cry , / cvez; yyS ,� - ,
___74 W � `
��l.4
iii i' i 0.• %e hi-71 A., W XI zzi,4v
N / �Z(J Gam. / ter Gvr' e I Cy
„7400 eon a,,i / 4i 6.e e-e. - kT L
�2x cr�u r. c�2- - - • .�-1' 4171-14.4t
�4 1,.:1j "I 440141 diXt.frf evrS.Q kot lea- 4.3114 to- /7-,A, ,aa it c4Jd pt
r
Comments :
This Commission i §.. dg ,igned to
1 ) maker'\gge eral policy concerning natural areas and 2 ) provide
a forum for the member committees in which "the right hand will
know what the left hand is doing" .
It will work through the DPW and report to BPW and CC .
ri
This Commission will be a "twin" of the Parks Commission , both being
concerned about City open green space ; it would have the same
organization concerned committee representatives and individuals .
TheCommiittees would not lose their identity and their expertise
would be available to the Commission . These Committees would be :
Six Mile Creek Advisory Committee
Conservation Advisory Committee
\ Fall Creek Planning Committee
` Shade Tree Committee
The Chairs of the two Commissions or their representatives would
work together ,on common problems .
Six Mile Creek Advisory Committee
Minutes of March 9, 1995
Present: Rick Farrel, Jill Tripp, Andy , Bill Dress, Peter Fortunato, Beth
Mulholland,
Nancy Ramage, Dan Hoffman, John Johnson
Land Acquisition Update
John led a discussion of the Public Works Water and Sewer Proposed guidelines for
acquisition and protection of land in the city's watershed.
Six Mile Creek will forward it's list to BPW and the Planning Committee
Gorge Ranger
Beth and Peter will do the initial review of applications and make recommendations to
the committee.
6 Mile Creek Maintenance
Since Circle Greenway is now part of the Parks Commission, Beth will do
maintenance for one year. We need an apprentice to work with her this year and take
it over next year. We agreed that we will conduct the Spring Wild Flower Walk. We
may want to involve the city environmental committees. Beth reported that Adam had
accompanied her on a gorge walk and maintenance tasks had been done. If we are to
do anything with Handicapped access, the DAC needs to be involved. Adam is
making a new bulletin board.
Natural Areas Proposal
We will vote on the proposal for this commission at our April meeting.
Van Etta Upgrade
There was a consensus we would proceed with the benches.
April 10, 1995 Agenda
Gorgre Ranger
Natural Areas Commission
Plant Fair (May 13, 1995
Beth's Report
SIX MILE CREEK COMMITTEE
MINUTES FROM
MAY 8, 1995
PRESENT: Bill Dress, Jill Tripp, Peter Fortunato, Richard Fisher,
Andy Hillman, Beca Harber, Marjorie Olds, Beth
Mulholland, John Johnson, Ed Hart (dropped in for last
part of meeting)
Ranger Interviews :
Beth and Peter reported that Pamela Johnson and Allison
Wilson were selected from over 60 applicants for the
Gorge Ranger position(s) . They will begin patrolling the
Gorge for the Memorial Day weekend.
Land Acquisition:
Doug Foster reported that there has been no action on the
Baker and Pakala properties that this committee
recommended as having a high priority for acquisition by
the city. (See attached resolution sent to the Mayor) .
Doug also reported that the Six Mile Creek land
identified for substitute park land will be on hold at
least until the state budget is passed. Then, it will
take another 1 - 2 years for the federal conversion
process to be completed.
The committee requested a memo be sent to the Mayor to
follow up on the Baker and Pakala properties.
Bike Meeting
Peter and Andy reported that they met with the Cayuga
Mountain Bike Club, and that they would find out if the
club members would hand out bike trail maps at Six Mile
Creek. Andy is trying to install "No Biking" signs in
the gorge. Andy will also find out about the possibility
of bike enforcement fines .
Beth' s Report
Adam, Andy and Beth took a walk through thee gorge and
noted bank erosion. Andy will check on this and report
to the committee and talk to George in the town.
Beth reported that we are looking at options for
memorials -- possibility a bike rack near the parking
lot.
Beth reminded members of the May 13th plant sale.
RESOLUTION CONCERNING THE FORMATION OF A CITY NATURAL AREAS
COMMISSION
WHEREAS, the City of Ithaca has several natural areas, and will
soon be acquiring several more by alienation or purchase, and
WHEREAS, these areas, open to the public, will require subtle and
knowledgeable management, and
WHEREAS, the skills required for natural areas management are quite
different than those required for parks, and
WHEREAS, the Parks Commission has all it can handle in dealing with
our 19 maintained parks, and
WHEREAS, our natural areas as well as our parks are important
resources for our growing tourism industry; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, That the `City of Ithaca form a Natural Areas Commission
to advise in the anagement of these important open spaces .
YT1+n
• (Ca
The Six Mile Creek Advisory Committee passed a resolution
recommending that a Natural Area Commission be established. The
Commission would be designed to make recommendations regarding
general policy concerning natural areas .
2 ) Provide a forum for the member to share information about the
management of our natural areas .
It will work through the DPW and report to the Board of Public
Works and Common Council.
1
�
SIX MILE CREEK COMMITTEE
MINUTES OF
JUNE 12, 1995
PRESENT: John Johnson, Dan Hoffman, Jack Booker, Marjorie Olds,
Andy Hillman, Beth Mulholland, Dick Fischer,
Rick Gray
OTHERS PRESENT: Pam Johnson, Elissa Wolfson, Becca Herbor, Ed Hart
1) - Group Membership - Because of plans for "Natural Areas
Commission" re-appointments for Six Mile Creek are not
up-to-date. (Fortunato, Ramage only members) . John will
submit a list to the Mayor for re-appointments so
"vacancies" will be filled.
2 ) - Gorge Ranger Report - Discussion re limits, public
access beyond Potter ' s Falls, signage to help enforce
that (signs are now gone) . Andy Hillman to confer with
Chuck Baker about where trails should end. Beth
Mulholland to check committee minutes about this subject.
Erosion near original water pipes and along upper trail
between 30 and 60 ' foot dams was discussed. Trash and
recycleables were discussed. General feeling was to
encourage policy for "carry-in, carry-out" . Marjorie
Olds and Elissa Wolfson will do some research and
assessment about other resources, alternatives, patterns
in other public areas re trash/recyclable management and
report at next meeting. Tree walk led on 6/10 by E.
Wolfson.
3) - City Forester Report - Signs about flower preserve and
usage have been put up. Cayuga Mountainbike personnel
willing to help with public education. Some discussion
about having signs further in on `Rec Way' so that a list
of "DON' TS" is not the first thing that greets users of
`Rec Way' . Andy will talk with George Frantz, Town of
Ithaca about this .
4) - Land acquisition resolution directed to Mayor in memo,
urging response ASAP. Discussion, clarification of land
parcels under consideration, and various funds available.
John Johnson will clarify, update this info, and give it
to Dan Hoffman and Marjorie Olds of the land acquisition
sub-committee.
5 ) - Need for sub-committees - per Beth Mulholland, "Site
Maintenance" Committee - John Booker, Ed Hart volunteered
to assist; "Publicity" - Andy Hillman, Dan Hoffman;
"Land Acquisition" - Dan Hoffman, Marjorie Olds;
"Signage" , Ad Hoc "Trash" - Elissa Wolfson, Marjorie
Olds .
6) - Beth Mulholland - Update re wildflower walk; tree walk;
need for new bulletin board at parking lot (Beth
graciously made $400 . available from her award from
Tompkins County Trust for this project) . Andy Hillman,
Elissa Wolfson will be checking various sources re
bulletin board design, labor. Also, Andy will send
thanks to City of Ithaca Bicycle Advisory Council in
Journal ' s `Darts and Laurels ' , for listing 6-mile creek
as `No Bike ' area. Tree memorial/thanks for Adam Carmen
to be discussed, handled by Beth Mulholland and Andy
Hillman.
7 ) - Memorial benches discussed. Sunday, June 25, 10 a.m.
meeting, Van Natta' s Pond, to meet with families, discuss
options and details . Letter re meeting to be sent to all
interested parties .
8) - Memo about formation of Natural Areas commission was sent
to all interested parties and committees to elicit
comments, feedback.
9 ) - The committee passed and forwarded to the Town of Ithaca
the following resolution regarding the proposed
conservation district for the Six Mile Creek valley:
"RESOLVED, That the Six Mile Creek Advisory Committee
requests that the Town of Ithaca include the undeveloped
properties off Pearsall Place as part of the proposed
conservation district for the Six Mile Creek valley. "
10) - Next meeting July 10 at 5 : 00 p.m. at SIX MILE CREEK VAN
ATTA' S POND PARKING LOT.
JJ/cjh
§ 113-3 SIX MILE CREEK COMMITTEE § 113-4
§ 113-3. Membership;terms.
A. The Committee shall consist of nine (9) voting members.
The Mayor shall appoint one (1) member from each of
the following entities: the Common Council, the Board of
Public Works, the City Conservation Advisory Council,
Circle Greenway and the Town of Ithaca Conservation .o
Advisory Board. In addition, the Mayor, subject to the
approval of the Common Council, shall appoint four (4)
members from the public, all of whom shall have a
• scientific, environmental and/or civic interest in the Six
Mile Creek Natural Area. At least six(6)members of the
Committee shall be residents of the City of Ithaca.
B. In addition, the Assistant Superintendent for Water and
Sewer, the Chief Operator of the City Water Filtration
• Plant, the City Forester, the Gorge Ranger and the
Director of Planning and Development (or his/her
designee) shall serve as nonvoting ex officio members of
the Committee.
( C. All terms shall be for a maximum period of three (3)
`: years (although reappointment is allowed). Members
•
representing city or town boards or committees shall
initially be appointed for a term ending December 31,
1994, but shall be replaced if their service on said Board
or committee ends. Of the four(4)initial representatives
from the public, two (2) shall be appointed for a term
ending December 31, 1994, one (1) for a term ending
December 31, 1995, and one (1) for a term ending
December 31, 1996. Subsequently, each seat shall be
filled for a three-year term.
•
§ 113-4. Officers.
The Officers of the Committee shall be a Chairperson, a Vice
•
Chairperson and a Secretary, all of whom shall be elected by
the Committee.
11303 4-25-94
SIX MILE CREEK COMMITTEE
ACQUISITION OF BAKER AND PAKALA PROPERTIES
WHEREAS, Common Council passed a resolution that provided $200,000 for the
year 1989 and intended to include additional amounts during subsequent years Ito
acquire property in order to preserve the Six Mile Creek Gorge natural area, and
WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 6-C of the General Municipal Law of the State of
New York, Capitol Reserve Fund No. 26 was established for the purpose of land
acquisition in Six Mile Creek Watershed, and
WHEREAS, it is imperative that the city acquire rim and buffer property to
protect the gorge ecosystem, and
WHEREAS, several of the gorge properties are for sale, and
WHEREAS, the Baker Property, bordering Route 79 on East Hill and next
Commonlandjis strategically important, and
WHEREAS the Pakala Property, located on South Hill with steep slops and
exceptional landscaping, is threatened by encroaching development from Hudson
Street and is used by mountain bikers from the Recreation Way, and
WHEREAS, The Six Mile Creek Advisory Committee, The Conservation
Advisory Committee, and Circle Greenway, identified the Baker and Pakala
Properties as two of the highest priority properties for the city to acquire, and
WHEREAS, the city has received current appraisal of these properties, now
therefore be it
RESOLVED, that the city proceed with immediate acquisition of the Baker and
Pakala Properties
SIX MILE CREEK ADVISORY COMMITTEE
MINUTES FROM MEETING OF
JULY 10, 1995
PRESENT: John Johnson, Beth Mulholland, Dan Hoffman, Becca Harber,
Marjorie Olds, Peter Fortunato, Nancy Ramage, John Booker
ALSO PRESENT: Chuck Baker (DPW) , Elissa Wolfson (Gorge Ranger)
I . Approval of the Minutes of the June 12, 1995 meeting.
II . Membership Terms - Discussion
Circle Greenway is no longer a separate entity; it
is now part of the Parks Commission.
Marjorie Olds - public
Beth Mulholland - public
Nancy Ramage - public
Peter Fortunato - public
Jack Booker - adjunct - City of Ithaca
John Johnson - Common Council
Jill Tripp - Board of Public Works
Dan Hoffman - Conservation Advisory Council
Bill Dress - Adjunct - Town of Ithaca
Richard Fischer - Town of Ithaca
Move to amend by-laws to eliminate "Circle Greenway" ,
Thus, the Mayor will be appointing five members from the
public.
III . Gorge Ranger Report
a. Three Walks
Wildflower Tree Walk Bird Walk
Possible future activities :
Night Hike
Gorge Day
Park History
Pond and Stream Life
b. Swimming increased at 30 foot dam;
Jumping from brick tower - dismantle?
Safety at 30 foot dam is a concern;
Recommend removal of hanging door - Elissa to talk
to Andy Hillman and Chuck Baker and bring
recommendation to August 14th meeting;
lean-to habitated?
c. Trash - Gorge Ranger will talk to Jim Kelly
regarding recycling and trash.
1 . Marjorie Olds will check with Andy Hillman
regarding a sign that reads : "Take Only Pictures
Leave Only Footprints" .
2 . Second trash can? Needs to be replaced.
3 . Check with Andy Hillman regarding emptying trash
cans more regularly and more often.
4 . Gorge Ranger will check with Jim Kelly regarding
recycling and will report to the committee at the
August 14 meeting.
d. Can we get rusty rolls of wire fencing and metal
posts that are in the ravine at Potter ' s Falls
pulled out and removed?
e. Dan Karig - Slide Specialist - Committee
recommended John Johnson call Larry Fabbroni to
include Dan Karig in discussion regarding how to
deal with this area.
f . Better trail blazing system/ well-used trails need
to be better marked to keep people on the trails .
g. There is no "Poison Ivy" signage up. Beth
Mulholland has provided sign before for this .
h. John Johnson will check with Andy Hillman regarding
the status of Gorge signage and ask him to make a
report at the August 14 meeting.
John Johnson will check with Andy Hillman regarding
a sign that reads : "Public Trail Ends Here" at or
above Potter ' s Falls .
Andy to report to committee at the August meeting
regarding where the trail ends and signage.
1 . Gorge Day Plans? The Gorge Ranger will check
with Andy Hillman regarding Gorge Day plans;
2 . Signage on post below bulletin board?
Signage on trash can?
Parking Lot Exit dangerous?
Need "Dangerous Driveway" sign on Giles Street;
Need vegetation cut;
Change Exit grade;
John Johnson will contact Dan Cole, Highway
Engineer.
2
IV. Subcommittee Reports
Site Maintenance
1 . Beth needs City Forester and Streets and Facilities to do
underlying work. Example: Town of Ithaca plants need to
be planted.
2 . Need information about Gorge Day.
3 . Bumpers in parking lot need to be secured.
Bulletin Board
The Bulletin Board subcommittee will report on their
recommendations after they visit the Plantations,
Headquarters, and the Wildflower Preserve and talked with
Andy Hillman.
Memorials
John Johnson, Nancy Ramage and Beth Mulholland will meet at
the Van Atta Dam on July 16 at 10 : 00 a.m.
Signage
Committee members reported that "No Bikes" signs are not up.
Andy will report at the August meeting from original list of
designated spots for signage.
V. Proposed Conservation District
Chuck Baker advised that it is in the city' s best interest to
beware of restrictions placed on the city' s water system.
VI . Land Acquisition
No action has been taken on the Pakala property. John
Schroeder was to be at the meeting to report on the progress
to bring the sale about.
John Johnson will meet with the Mayor next week regarding this
matter.
VII . Chair of Committee
Dan Hoffman has agreed to assume the Chairmanship of the Six
Mile Advisory Committee.
JJ/cjh
3
-Q,)4 76AA
)-,,09 i'' -vvi )-0/Yv)
„,c?,,, -,,r4 Vvi7 ?i° pcfMr"\
..-----)_o .,fora 6-9'. 07/41),
, v' Uo 1 ��G f lJ
,.,,nom d +1 g }
r I"'., � \--
I
ItY4 pvvo-gt),111q -a)1 11
O CO C
1
\ ''' 1
? >
1
\ 1
\ Cyr "
\, lt) - / - i
1 .1
V 6) .\ -
7
S,`0C N ___, _ /
N
00
\
0
G
Proposed Policy on Memorials for the 6-Mile Creek Gorge
Suggested by Nancy Ramage
for the Gorge Committee meeting of 8/14/95
The Six-Mile Creek Gorge Committee has been discussing
memorials at least since the meeting of January 1994 . In one of
the meetings in 1994, we agreed to limit any kind of memorial to
the entrance area, before the beginning of the wooded path; and
to limit the number of benches to no more than three. We had
also discussed, but not decided on, the possibility of a plaque
or "memorial board" of some kind, with the on-going addition of
the names of persons honored by a substantial donation to the
maintenance and up-keep of the gorge area.
The question has now come up of "a rock and a tree" [the
rock marked with a plaque honoring a deceased person] as an
alternative, or additional, way of setting up a memorial .
I suggest that we need to be very careful about increasing
the number of markers, both because the place could start to look
like a cemetery, and because the space we are talking about is
really quite small and could quickly start to look cluttered. I
also think it is crucial to maintain and preserve the "wild"
character of Van Natta's Dam and the walks that proceed from it.
I recommend staying with our original (and carefully thought-out)
plan of accepting no more than three memorial benches; and I am
very dubious about the "memorial plaque, " which I think could
open the way for people who give money to feel they should be
able to make changes in the gorge appearance. I also think the
plaque itself could be ugly, and an intrusion on the wild
character of the entrance area.
In the interest of having something tangible to discuss, I
attach a proposed sketch of where we might put these benches (or,
as an alternative, a "rock and a tree") . Whatever it is, we have
agreed that it should be substantial, so as to minimize
vandalism.
I also believe we should decide what we would find
acceptable (i.e. what material and style of bench; what type of
rock and/or tree) , and offer only the agreed proposal to the
donors, who might opt for this if they wish.
wiLoFLovivfc_
7 v/fA < 0c Nile! (°( Z (< .
•
worrocAlvo
}
,
tack dvet
shad
6
/2 :(57' 2- 411■:,,,, ' . ' ._ .. . _ . ,
Lo usr -
/e `(
1
�.. , , .. •
. Es . - - - ,. _ _. . . _____ V -A -cv�-r, rA ts;
, . ,,_ . _ .
----- - , 4-- -i ,+ t.
SLic
Q
D
.p-
I
• - Ra 0 N° .
I
i
IN ymew - - a
ji) riz , --.....,,6;1Vi 1-A■ o
Bl la. teAcrS z • t ' BuLt_E,z t tv 13oisre2 p
Bum p¢vS 80)44 peYS 1 •.- El
,:.,, 113 f
. -
•
. . , ..% . • 0_ _
, rAl z .. ,1„1---(7... .
Ia . (7-77
VA-10 NA7Th !s .l'7Okm vnc3lePrQz r .
14AtlJDICAPPE,0 SUteRacc.zs , (ro EX r 0 m EOu - : WoOOg "'1i'o t -
Fie ST te.pc ,`f pc:Ace)
Cout tviEmotzt , L)
a
a
1V w l3ULC.Ertw ( or 12D 131M 1<3 MitS1 & U.S
i ED _ - - -� 0 r - 1--�-. -- - i - - -
�. l3gT�.c1�£
�eKc t�T u-_.
13E Qct-1. S ?
MF.M.cltAL., TP£IS ?
- f
t
—_ - Iz x E , T
`\.3 3
• • t
-0 0 IA T - t. 4-1 ri
yn N C
0.) Z vt$ - . r‘qz 7---ITI La r
, - a -_ `� y
rft
c. -,-1 .„
, , -4 , 6
t- Pp t a-
to ..g :?). 7r
C G
14
1,
z r ir __r•
_ __, 1 , : , , ...., L . . .
M} -�t to 1 - :3 K ` • 7 _" "C 7,- .-. Ili!. > c r0 5 Obi+ > -1 a__. (To
- -0
- . .4); g ■ ' . c '' r-q, . en
_ . ,.., , -, .
z.a O M M
•. ? 71
9171.6141 . . . . ,4.
t 0 Q
,... th f_'_' CI') C
Z st
M c-
a p R 2 ::, k.., ■-r 1:. It
R t zt", s ,t. w
N
. 1.-,r.-13,1-t4 . ,
i . , �o '
3
' T ' • . . _ _... r"--). ri ri • . • ' ' :fa tr
b
,, . , ,._.„ (A „ .__, . ,, --,- G. , r-e r- 3 F6 g" M Q ^t $ g � % ` � C ip
17,1 a:
N •-r•43 —'1 A ,.. , z tza V6 ijj k'-- I V' la "Z ,
omt, � ,n _ _ � � -- -�, - � mt:,--;:
__ ________H__, __ 4 ,;, , i , - , , - , , , ,
0cx, MGLZ CreEE« avcLr, GOW22 PICT g. 2vr p. 2
1 ;
U,S� T• �LL ti' 4' eetwitvG V ., fociiNI'IN6S f tvlPr1Nr£NAt\JC, -'
QIahD;GE .
.Tie.Aus crot`J. coo urey , -►uTic(PAT tOki .13taiSEI;vffTc01V,
I 1 ! .. S iGty Z., LA ST
I 1 CA LL , ,
I Q PEEN : . amortivou) nnerosin PrCMUST `Dtco NIP eSsc1ou:
City of Ithaca
Parks Commission
Memorandum
To: Mayor Nichols, John Johnson, Board of Public Works
From: JoAnn Cornish , Chair, City of Ithaca Parks Commission
Date: July 23, 1995
Re: Natural Areas Commission
At the July 11, 1995 meeting of the Parks Commission, the Resolution
Concerning the Formation of a Natural Areas Commission was discussed at
length. By a unanimous decision, the forming of a Natural Areas Commission was
agreed upon with the following suggested changes to the resolution.
Whereas#1, accepted as written.
Whereas#2 should read: Whereas, these areas, open to the public, will require
knowledgeable management, and (eliminate the words subtle and).
Whereas#3 should read: Whereas, the skills required for natural areas
management are different than those required for parks, and (eliminate the word
quite).
Eliminate the Whereas#4 entirely.
Whereas#5 should read: Whereas, our natural areas are important resources;
now, therefore, be it(eliminate the words as well as our parks and for our
growing tourism industry).
Resolved, accepted as written.
Add: Be it Further Resolved, that the Six Mlle Creek Advisory Committee be
disolved and incorporated into the Natural Areas Commission.
Please direct any comments or questions to me at 273-1747.
RESOLUTION CONCERNING THE FORMATION OF A CITY NATURAL AREAS
COMMISSION
WHEREAS, the City of Ithaca has several natural areas, and will
soon be acquiring several more by alienation or purchase, and
WHEREAS, these areas, open to the public, will require •e. -
knowledgeable management, and
WHEREAS, the skills required for natural areas management are quitta
different than those required for parks, and
WHEREAS, our natural areas are important
resources . now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, That the City of Ithaca form a Natural Areas Commission
to advise in the management of these important open spaces .
ant Pi it -4,y-,Le„. A_LvLo Yh•ct-6
S/V t4 e & :i8r)/v�o( y Net" GQ-t a f,eGe
14 -/-z) u A/7
Six Mile Creek Gorge Advisory Committee Minutes
Meeting,September 11, 1995
Present: Dan Hoffman, chair;Jack Booker,Andy Hillman, Beth Mulholland, Nancy
Ramage, and Elissa Wolfson.
[Note: as we lacked a quorum, no formal decisions were made.]
Ranger and City Forestor Reports [made by Elissa Wolfson]:
See Ranger Report, attached. In addition, Andy Hillman reported that the bulletin
board construction is underway and should be ready by October 15.
Meeting Length and Time:
Those present recommend that our future meetings begin at 5:15 and last for one
and a half hours. [Due to Columbus Day, next month's meeting will be
postponed for one week, to October 16.]
Beth Mulholland reported:
An informal hedge will be planted at the Giles St entrance between the parking lot
and the grassy spot near the pond, where 2 benches will be placed.
There is a plan for several people to work with a potato hook to bring growth back
to the verges of the upper road, where so much road construction has taken place.
Several of us volunteered to help.
A suggestion has been made to add a"sheep gate" at the Giles St. path next to the
lagoons. All committee members should please check the entrance before the
next meeting, when this item will be discussed again.
Property acquisition:
There was discussion of the SM-08 property near Burns Road. All present were
in favor of attempting to buy that property, as well as additional property along
the tributary that leads to the 6 Mile Creek in that area.
Benches:
All present recommend the purchase of bench model 24 in the available
catalogues. Andy Hillman will check on sustainable yield redwood vs. recyclable
plastic wood.
Tree planting: A\wil be planted in the gorge in honor of Adam Carman's long service.
Enforcement of rules:
Dan Hoffman reported on a meeting that he and Andy Hillman had with the
Police Chief. There was considerable discussion of a Rochester policy of signage
at the water supply area, and how that might work for the 6 Mile Creek area.
Regarding signage: George Frantz suggests we need more on the South Hill side
of the gorge.
The problems at Commonlands continue; a fence or hedge may be needed as well
as further signage.
Natural Areas Commission: On hold for the moment.
DPW Access Road
This will eventually connect to the Commonland access road. There are no plans
to take the road down to the 30 foot dam.
Minutes taken by Nancy Ramage
u e 0 -- x M t C C. A d v ,
Update: News from the Gorge 9/11/95
-60' and 30' dam have been at their lowest on several
occasions--approximately 3 feet below the dam crest at 60'
on 9/8. Duly reported to Water Treatment Plant.
-Continued reports from visitors of bee/wasp stings,
resulting from walking into nests along trails
-Trash accumulation continues to be kept under control by
DPW pickups.
-Fall wildflowers are out in full force; there is much
interest among visitors for a Fall Wildflower Walk, which
Beth is planning. It would be a good idea to set the date as
soon as possible for maximum publicity purposes.
-Incidents of swimming at 30' dam have decreased with the
cooler weather; but similar incidence levels should be
expected to recur next summer, particularly if weather and
strategies remain unchanged. We have been fortunate in
having no injuries or deaths occur in the gorge throughout
this summer.
-Biking has increased, also probably due to cooler weather
and widening of upper trail. Andy has arranged with Cayuga
Mountain Bike Club to post bikers at entryways, perhaps next
weekend, to speak with other bikers as they enter and hand
out brochures to them.
-There will be a meeting of the Carpenters Union tomorrow;
they will then give Andy an estimate of expenses expected
for a new bulletin board.
-Ranger Bob Drabicky's apprehension of the man he caught
} exposing himself in the gorge, and his subsequent report to
police, has resulted in an arrest of that man.
-DPW has protected wooden briges at Wildflower Preserve
entrance with sealant.
-Other DPW workers, accompanied by Ranger Elissa Wolfson,
removed several large metal scraps from the gorge on 9/8 ;
the four rusted rolls of fencing and barbed wire remain,
posing an eyesore and potential heath hazard and liability
issue. Stickers are still obscuring several gorge signs, and
other faded and blank signs still await removal.
-Ranger Elissa Wolfson has filmed various gorge features,
problems and activities with a camcorder; could be basis for
publicity video on Six Mile Creek for viewing by general
public.
SIX MILE CREEK ADVISORY COMMITTEE
Minutes
August 14, 1995
COMMITTEE PRESENT: Dick Fischer, Peter Fortunato, Dan Hoffman,
John Johnson, Beth Mulholland, Marjorie Olds, Nancy Ramage.
OTHERS PRESENT: Ed Hart; Andy Hillman (City Forester) ; John
Schroeder (Planning Committee) ; Pam Johnson, Elissa Wolfson
& Bob Drabicki (Gorge Rangers) ; Nancy Goody, Carl & May
Warren, Greg Bell and other neighbors not introduced.
COMMITTEE ABSENT: Jill Tripp, Jack Booker.
1. Election of Officers. Dan Hoffman was elected unanimously as
the new Chairperson. Nancy Ramage was elected as Vice Chair, and
Beth Mulholland as Secretary.
2. Minutes of July 10, 1995. Add to Section III.g: " . . .but it
has not been effective. " Minutes approved as amended.
3. Concerns of Neighbors. Several citizens who live near the
Six Mile Creek Natural Area addressed the Committee with concerns
about increased problems of late night entry into the area, loud
music and other noise, firecrackers, fires, drinking, etc. They
believe much of the late night access is from the Commonland
entrance. (There are no restrictions on parking on Penny Lane, a
Town road. ) These issues will be taken up later in the meeting.
4. Land Acquisition. John Schroeder, Chairperson of Common
Council's Planning Committee, provided an update of City actions
regarding land protection in the Six Mile Creek area. A new,
multi-color map, dated August 11, 1995 and produced by Doug
Foster of the Planning Dept, was distributed.
a. Proposed Substitute Parkland. To replace parkland on
Inlet Island that is being "alienated, " City has designated
5 parcels adjacent to watershed (all downstream of 60-ft
dam) which it hopes to acquire. All have been appraised and
State has approved the substitution. City recently wrote
letters to affected landowners; none appears opposed
(although a sixth owner did rebuff the City) . If
successful, this will provide a buffer above the pipeline
access road, to a point above the "rim" of the valley, and
will secure the largest unprotected parcel on the south side
of the Creek below the Recreation Way (Grigorov) .
b. Purchases from General Fund Account CP-292 (so-called
Water & Sewer monies) . In 1988, Common Council transferred
about $200,000 in surplus monies from the Water & Sewer Fund
to a capital account for Six Mile Creek land acquisition.
Board of Public Works says this money should be spent only
for land that affects water supply (ie. , upstream of 60-ft
dam) . BPW has identified 8 parcels for purchase or easement
protection. Most of this property is upstream of Burns
Road.
Six Mile Creek Advisory Committee Page 2 of 3
Minutes - August 14, 1995
c. Purchases from Remainder of Account CP-292 . Council
recently placed other funds (about $100,000) in this
account, which have no relationship to the Water & Sewer
Fund. The Planning Dept has designated 3 parcels on the
south side of the Creek (Apgar, Sincebaugh & Farrell) for
purchase with these funds; in addition, the Planning
Committee has directed City staff to negotiate and acquire
the Somero-Pakkala parcel below the Recreation Way. (This
property is now for sale, and has been cited as a top-
priority acquisition for years. ) Owners and City are still
thousands of dollars apart on value of this parcel. (Town
has not answered question of whether parcel has legal road
access across Rec Way. )
Dan asked whether City has option on any of the properties,
including proposed substitute parkland. Answer is no. Could
City reach agreement with Town regarding "early warning" if any
development of parcels is proposed? John (and Greg Bell, who is
on Town Planning Board) said they would speak to Town Supervisor
and get back to Dan on this.
5. Memorials. Beth's and Nancy's proposals discussed. Some
confusion exists over what was agreed to in the past. Most
believe we approved 3 memorial benches in area before "entry
rocks" to Wildflower Walk, but were not more specific about
locations. Apparently, there are now 5 people who want memorial
benches, and others who want to donate a tree with a plaque.
Some are concerned that requests for memorials will be endless,
and that the "natural" feel of the area will be diminished.
PROPOSAL was made to approve three memorial benches, in the
following locations: two between the parking area and the Creek
(downstream of footbridge closest to Creek) and one upstream of
same footbridge, just inside triangular mowed path. Design to be
approved by Committee at a future meeting. APPROVED 5-0-1.
6. DPW Access Road. Andy provided an update of work on the
road. John J. asked for a sketch of the planned route; Andy will
see if Larry Fabbroni can provide one. Special concerns voiced
if plan is to take the road beyond the Commonland access road or
to develop a road down to the lower reservoir. What would be the
purpose of the latter?
7. Trail Maintenance. Some very inelegant cutting of vegetation
occurred along the first section of the Wildflower Walk. DPW did
it to make room for vehicle to carry in plantings. Beth and Andy
will try to make sure this doesn't happen again.
Peter shared Mary Gilliland's letter to Town concerning very
over-zealous cutting of wildflowers (twice! ) along Recreation
Way. PROPOSAL: That Committee endorse concerns expressed in Mary
Gilliland's letter and ask Chairperson to write letter in support
to the Town. APPROVED unanimously.
Six Mile Creek Advisory Committee Page 3 of 3
Minutes - August 14, 1995
8. Regulations & Enforcement. John J. and others met with
Police Chief, who said City police cannot act beyond the City
boundaries (ie. , upstream of Van Natta's parking lot) . Chief
suggested we work with Sheriff's Dept on enforcement; said he
would help. Gorge Rangers report that usage of lower reservoir
area is "way up" this summer, that it's apparently "fashionable"
among young people. Also, the fact that there have been no
arrests or injuries lately make swimming/diving more popular.
Dan suggested a nighttime "curfew" as in City parks (eg. ,
between midnight and 6 AM) to discourage and/or prosecute late
night users. Could also prohibit late night parking in Van
Natta's parking lot. Bob (a former police officer) said State
laws against swimming in watershed are clear; enforceability of
other City"rules" is less clear. Also, police/deputies need to
know how to get to trouble spots (they've gotten lost in the
past) . Some want a late night "bust" to occur this season.
Dan said problem is complex, and that it may not be possible
to take legal action right away; suggested that Committee make
this a high priority over the winter and have a comprehensive
plan and strategy in place before next summer. Dan will speak to
Town Supervisor to discuss possible Town or joint City/Town
actions.
9. Gorge Rangers' Reports. Pam, who has resigned, submitted a
report and talked about her experiences and frustrations. Elissa
also submitted a report, and pointed out that on the bright side,
there have been no serious injuries in the Six Mile Creek area
this year, despite increased use. Bob mentioned that if it is
decided that there should be patrols at night, he is available.
10. City Forester's Report. Andy expressed great appreciation
for the work of the Gorge Rangers. Tree crew removed fallen tree
that was blocking trail above 30-ft dam. "Bumpers" in parking
lot are now secured by steel rods. Plantings have been done in
various places to discourage trail bikers. City police will try
to patrol parking lot more frequently. Carpenters' union is ready
to build new bulletin board. (Nancy and Marjorie will submit
photos of Plantations model to Dan; if they appear OK, he will
submit them to Andy so construction can begin ASAP. )
Adjournment
Notes by Marjorie Olds & Peter Fortunato
Transcribed & Edited by Dan Hoffman
SIX MILE CREEK ADVISORY COMMITTEE
October 16, 1995
Committee/Present: Elizabeth Mulholland, Jack Booker, Marjorie
Olds, Nancy Ramage, Dan Hoffman, Dick Fischer, Peter Fortunato.
Others Present: City Forester Andy Hillman, Gorge Rangers Elissa
Wolfson and Bob Drabicki, Assistant Superintendent for Water &
Sewer Larry Fabbroni, Becca Harber, Ed Hart, Common Council Member
Rick Gray.
Committee Absent: Jill Tripp, John Johnson.
1. Approval of Minutes:
The Six Mile Creek Advisory Committee ( "Committee" ) approved August
14, 1994 minutes. Committee accepted as accurate the minutes of
the September 11, 1995 meeting, at which no quorum was achieved,
with these modifications: Under "Benches" should read:
"sustainable yield wood" .
2 . City Forester Report:
Sign at Wildflower Trail parking lot is about to be built by
Carpenter's Apprentice Class.
Update provided on downed large Oak tree.
3. Beth Mulholland Field Report:
Report on Upper Path aesthetics in conjunction with Larry Fabbroni:
Work to include raking, road smoothing, vines and groundcovers to
minimize aesthetic damage to wild area.
Issue of the unauthorized bike path by the Town/City line, through
the acid part of the Park, along a very steep area, will be raised
in later agenda.
Discussion of unauthorized campfire site near Commonland entrance.
Someone has left a large trash can or keg; needs to be removed and
area cleaned up. To be "handled" by Beth and Andy.
4. Gorge Rangers Report:
Attached Report delivered and discussed.
Questions raised on vicinity of IPD Shooting Range.
Ranger stopped Youth Bureau from rappelling; Youth Bureau employee
said Department was "exempt" from prohibited activities. Beth and
Dan have recollection that exemption was requested many years ago,
but was not granted. Committee reaffirmed its desire that there be
no rock-climbing/rappelling.
/0. z�
5. Memorials:
The Committee discussed using sustainable wood materials versus
recycled plastic for memorial benches. Sentiment of Committee was
opposed to plastic in this location. City Forester will
investigate whether Victor Stanley Model #24 can be built "in-
house" (by city) using sustainable yield lumber, and what cost
might be.
Next meeting is last opportunity for interested persons to submit
design and material nominations for benches.
6 . Gateway by lagoons on Giles Street:
Committee discussed and declined to endorse George Frantz's
suggestion that the City construct a gateway at this time. Terrain
is problematic; no guarantee this would stop bikes from entering
path at other end.
7 . Barrier/Commonland:
Problems with trespassing in that vicinity discussed. Committee
directed Chair to send recommendation to Board of Public Works to
consider the feasibility of erecting fences or hedges along City
right-of-way as it passes through adjacent yards at Commonland.
8 . DPW Maintenance Road:
Assistant Superintendent for Water & Sewer Larry Fabbroni described
necessity for road construction and entertained recommendations for
lessening aesthetic damage done to wild area. After a landslide in
1993 there were partially collapsed culverts. Larry has ceased
work for consultation with Committee. Future construction will be
coordinated with Committee if possible.
Larry hopes to extend road across ravine to landslide area.
Filling to widen existing path seems preferable to cutting into
unstable slopes. City does not plan to extend road beyond
turnaround on top of flat area above 30 foot reservoir. It may be
possible to discontinue use of Commonland entrance road once this
project is finished.
Larry indicated he is very receptive to restorative suggestions,
including removal of some of early turnarounds, and making all of
the turnarounds less obtrusive. Larry does not want to remove
turnaround near the top of the path going down to the reservoir.
Establishment of an ongoing subcommittee to work with Larry and
report back to Committee every few months?
9 . Land Acquisition:
City is negotiating on purchase of or constructive easement on a
portion of parcel SM-08 (between Burns Road and shore of Upper
Reservoir) . Doug Foster, Planning, heads City team. This parcel
is not part of the substitute parkland package.
Letters have been sent from Doug regarding two other parcels along
Coddington Road side of watershed area, which are part of
substitute parkland package.
The Committee resolved:
IN LIGHT OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL VALUE OF THE PAAKALA PARCEL NOW
UNDER CONSIDERATION BY THE CITY OF ITHACA, THE SIX MILE CREEK
ADVISORY COMMITTEE RECOMMENDS TO THE MAYOR OF THE CITY OF ITHACA:
1. THAT THE CITY CONSIDER A COMPROMISE PURCHASE PRICE, AND/OR THAT
THE CITY APPROACH THE OWNERS OF THE PAAKALA PARCEL AND DISCUSS THE
USE BY OWNERS OF A TAX DEDUCTION FOR CONTRIBUTION OF A PORTION OF
THE PURCHASE PRICE.
2 . THAT THE CITY EXHAUST OTHER STRATEGIES TO MINIMIZE THE
DIFFERENTIAL BETWEEN THE CITY'S OFFER AND THE OWNER'S PURCHASE
PRICE.
3. THAT THE CITY REQUEST A NON-BINDING LEGAL OPINION FROM THE TOWN
OF ITHACA REGARDING ROAD ACCESS FOR THE PARCEL IN QUESTION.
Meeting adjourned around 7:00.
Minutes by Marjorie Z . Olds
"� ;, ''f s N iR
M .;
.„,i �' - ' `yv� � uw b�" � r �,,-�`7'lw"�5 @�"w� rrpk,w°��i4 s � ,, „,,5',.,
R
,� 4 IR” [ 1
tJ
x .x., E h. K
`�a
t Yw«
'ti "j,!►� d iN e p g ' � 'mo _ t•*i.k{:it.q/ a" a Cr ti .s1..:,:,,,,,""; i'° '' } Imo .: � •(Il S { ty r ! € ');''''-'-'4''.:',:s. fsl^ +r . # ''. �T ` . ,,' 1.1:'t t f 4 >Model4:Shown in 4 Y ' y,V St- z Oe2,'-:% r1 F E 4 1, •a , J
' - Model 8and:A gently contoured bench with slight reverse pitch in the
back seat.The Model 8 includes 8 2 X 4 s.Shown in redwood,it
f w is extremely comfortable at moderate cost.
,.. -
c t 4' rT sr irL''
Model 4 Shown in 3 X 4 mahogany
q at +{s1 z Y.�
N t ' r .' �`1., l"1 . a' / ..,-;b , „,:Y t,-te,✓t,-. 4
! x
sfIf` r J e ” ,--i.`+i its�„# v�1
�' +1. ``t� 1 V 1 ' •t 11w,'� +g15 j /7;; T')/} �� a caKrt�' cir' .
Moiiel 4:`Shu ink y A simple flat bench Model 24:A truly graceful traditional bench,shown in redwood,
off1r'ed in thzee wood ,, ,, with optional gull-wing legs,the Model 24 features 4 X 4 slats with
large radius eased edges on top and front slat.Also available:Model
23:Identical to the Model 24,but substituting 3 X...,..._.4 slats
(Far right) — —
Model 18:A square center-post bench
shown in 3 X 4 redwood.See price list for •�, _°�
other thicknesses and species of wood. ) = ' _
t
(Left)
Model 48:A contour bench with 6 interior '�• .
2 X 4 members and outside 4 X 4's. =" - ` -°_:,
(Bottom,far right) ` , s
Model 14:A contoured backless bench, *.'rd r f+ s ?
extremely comfortable and very graceful.
See price list for other wood options.
(Bottom Left)
Model 46:A flat bench made wit114 2 X 4 u
interior slats and outside 4 X 4's. ?-
, ( yal i
.vi. 1 r : 4. 0
ill'
21
SIX MILE CREEK ADVISORY COMMITTEE
MINUTES
NOVEMBER 13, 1995
Committee Present: Jack Booker, Dick Fischer, Peter Fortunato, Dan Hoffman,John Johnson,
Beth Mulholland, Nancy Ramage
Others Present: Ric Dietrich, Outing Youth Program Coordinator, Rick Gray,Common Council
liaison
Committee Absent: Marjorie Olds, Jill Tripp
1. Approval of Minutes: The Six Mile Creek Advisory Committee("Committee")approved
minutes of the 10/16/95 meeting.
2. Report from the Field: Beth Mulholland reported she had conferred with Larry Fabbroni,
Assistant Superintendent for Water &Sewer, regarding plans to rake the sides of the D.P.W.
maintanence road on the north side of the gorge. Beth and Nancy Ramage volunteered to oversee
the actual operations. Plans also include covering over the gabians in that vicinity with top soil
and encouraging resident flora to overgrow them. Also, Beth informed the Committee of the
Clausen family's generous donations, totalling$3,500 to begin with, in order to memorialize
the efforts and love of their late mother, Edna Clausen, for Six Mile Gorge. One bench will be
dedicated to her and the Committee took into consideration the family's proposal that trees,
perhaps a grove of trees, also be planted as a fitting memorial. In a letter, the City will
formally thank the Clausen family for their generous contributions. Beth will draft the letter
for the Mayor's signature. Dan will consult with the City Controller about safe keeping the
present funds for the Committee's use. At another meeting, the use of the funds will be taken up
in detail.
3. Youth Bureau Activities in the Natural Area: This fall when they were in the area, Youth
Bureau members who were rock climbing and rapelling were told to leave by a gorge ranger,and
that incident precipitated the current issue before the Committee. Dan gave an overview
regarding the Youth Bureau's use of the area for rock climbing and rappelling. Committee
members had been provided copies of minutes from the 10/10/84 meeting of the Board of
Public Works wherein a Resolution grants special permission to the Ithaca Youth Bureau for
such acitivities in the Gorge area; however, it appears that Common Council never officially
acted on the basis of the Resolution. Ric Dietrich spoke about the history of the City Youth
Bureau's presence in the Gorge area: they have made many contributions of labor, for example
recently in the construction of the South Hill Recreation Way. As well,when they engage in rock
climbing or rappelling, they "are not obvious or blatant" in their use of the area, and activities
are always supervised by competent persons. This fall and winter they would like to be in the
area partly as a consequence of their indoor facility being inaccessible. The Commitee discussed
various aspects of the issue and Peter Fortunato was asked by Dan to work with Ric Dietrich on a
proposal to be presented at the December meeting stating precisely what the Youth Bureau is
asking for. Other members were also invited to submit proposals regarding the Committee's
position about this matter.
4. Construction of Memorial Benches: City Forester Andy Hillman, unable to attend today's
meeting, is still researching the choice of wood and the specifications for "in-house"
construction of the benches. Further discussion of the benches was benched, er, tabled until next
1
meeting.
5. Recreation Way Maintenance Practices: Peter Fortunato reported on his conversation with
Assistant Town Planner George Frantz on 11/13/95 ,and gave an account of the meeting that he
and Mary Gilliland and Marjorie Olds had with George last summer. The mowing schedule is
still under discussion;all parties agree that mowing needs to be done judiciously with respect to
the varieties of flowers blooming throughout the year; low impact machinery needs to be used
carefully by skilled people in order to accomplish this; there are plans for more seeding of wild
flowers. Town Parks Manager Rich Schoch is now in charge of the Recreation Way maintenance.
He has experience both as a horticulturalist and planner and is sensitive to the issues at stake,
said George. George will contact Rich Schoch by memo regarding Committee concerns. Peter also
reported on the the Town's plans to post signs during hunting season (announcing "No Hunting"
and "Recreation Way Closed During Hunting Season") and the mixed messages these signs give to
Rec-Way and Gorge users. Peter will confer with the Town attorney about the intended purpose
of these signs.
6. Land Aquisition and Protection: Dan Hoffman gave an update based on his recent contact with
Doug Foster. Common Council's Planning Committee decided not to act on the purchase of a
portion of parcel SMO8 because of the current owner's asking price; the property is on the
market and the City hopes a new owner would be more amenable to protection; in any event, the
City is confident it could stop any attempted development near the reservoir (through eminent
domain,etc.). The City is actively pursuing purchase of parcel SMO3, the Pakala property,
although contact as of late has only been through message machines. The City is not willing to
pay the price asked for all the property in the Walker parcel, SMOG,and so D.P.W. has cut back
on the amount of land they are offering to buy. Discussion ensued regarding the new Mayor and
his new administration in relation to the process of land acquisition: Dan will invite Alan Cohen
to our next meeting so we can introduce him to the importance of this subject.
The meeting adjourned at approximately 6:50 p.m.
Minutes submitted by Peter Fortunato.
2
SIX MILE CREEK ADVISORY COMMITTEE
December 11 , 1995
Committee/Present: Jack Booker, Marjorie Olds, Dan Hoffman, Peter Fortunato,
John Johnson.
Others Present: City Forester Andy Hillman, Ed Hart, City Planner Doug Foster,
Common Council Liaison Rick Gray.
Committee Absent: Beth Mulholland, Nancy Ramage, Dick Fischer, Jill Tripp
1. Approval of Minutes:
The Six Mile Creek Advisory Committee ("Committee") approved the November
13, 1995 minutes with these modifications: Revision made to item #6: deletion of
names of owners of parcels under consideration for acquisition/protection efforts.
2. Update on City's Land Acquisition & Protection Efforts: City Planner Doug
Foster had no significant news to report. Committee hopes to meet with Mayor-
elect Alan Cohen at January meeting to discuss this topic.
3. City Forester Report: Carpenters' Local has two bulletin boards in progress
and expects to complete two memorial benches this winter if authorized.
Andy's crew will begin to clear gorges of trees downed in recent snow and ice
storm.
Beaver Activity Report.
4. Memorial Benches: Committee voted 4-1 to authorize "in-house" construction
of three benches (previously approved) out of lumber from sustainable yield
forest, along lines of"Victor Stanley Model 24" design.
5. Youth Bureau Activities: Ric Dietrich of City's Youth Bureau discussed
Outing Program's request for "exemption" from certain Natural Area
"prohibitions" (particularly rock-climbing). Ric Dietrich and Peter Fortunato
will complete a recommendation for this Committee to offer to Common Council
regarding limited "exemption" for Youth Bureau activities in Natural Area.
Resolution may address concerns such as contribution Youth Bureau has made
and continues to make in Natural Area, City liability when Youth Bureau
activities are undertaken, minimization of public exposure so as to limit "copy
cat" activities by unsupervised public who see Youth Bureau activities, a
provision for notice to Chuck Baker's staff prior to Youth Bureau activities, and
general geographical areas where Youth Bureau activities will be performed,
among other issues.
4. Rec Way: Peter F gave update. He has spoken with Rich Schoch, the Town of
Ithaca Parks Manager, regarding "closing" of Rec Way during hunting season
(which generally ends 12-12-95) Peter will discuss whether Town could prohibit
hunting along Rec Way with Rich Schoch. More discussion regarding posting
and theft of signs along Rec Way.
Peter, John Johnson, Chuck, Andy and MZO will meet 12-28-95 at 100 Renzetti
at 10:00 AM to discuss Rec Way issues. Interested parties invited.
Meeting adjourned around 7:00.
minutes by MZO
, 010
4-�
Ilk SPRING WILDFLOWER EVENTS IN ITHACA AREA 4.
-.. 1995 00,0
APRIL 13 SPRING WILDFLOWERS: FOLKLORE ON THE FOREST FLOOR.
Wayne Gall, Buffalo Museum of Science, Cornell
Plantations Lecture Series . Whetzel Room, 404 Plant
Science Building, Tower Road at 7 : 30 . Free.
Information : 255-3020 .
APRIL 16 TREE FLOWERS with Ruth Yarrow. Cayuga Nature Center
1420 Taughannock Blvd. 3 p.m. , Fee: $2 . 00 .
Information: 273-6260 .
APRIL 22 SEEING AND SKETCHING OUR NATURAL WORLD With John
Weissinger, Sciencenter, 601 First Street. 2 p.m. Members
free, children 4-12 $2 . 75, teens and adults $3 . 75 .
Information 272-0600 .
APRIL 22 EARTH DAY WALK Lime Hollow Nature Center. Gracie Road,
off Route 13, Cortland. 10 a.m. Information: 758-5462 .
APRIL 23 WILDFLOWER TOURS OF SOUTH HILL RECREATIONWAY Special
Walk with Bob Dirig at 12 o ' clock. Other walks every
half hour, 11 til 2 . Sponsored by Town of Ithaca
Conservation Advisory Council . Meet at Hudson Street
entrance, near Renzetti. No fee.
APRIL 23 SIERRA CLUB EARTH DAY HIKE AT ROBERT TREMAN STATE PARK
A 6-mile rugged hike leaving from Shady Corners at 10
a.m. Information: Nick Vandam, 539-9313 .
APRIL 29 THE BIRDS AND THE BEES Experience the birth of Spring.
Cornell Plantations and the Laboratory of Ornithology,
Raylene Ludgate and Margaret Barker. Meet at the
entrance to the Mundy Wildflower Garden, Caldwell Road at
9 : 00 a.m. No fee but call to register, 255-3020 .
APRIL 30 WOODLAND WALK at Baker ' s Acres . New pondside and woods
path and flowers . 1 : 30 til 3: 00 p.m.
MAY 6 NATURE WALK AT THE ETNA PRESERVE Led by Diane Tessaglia,
Russ Charif, Beth Howard and Betsy Darlington. Finger
Lakes Land Trust. Meet at east end of East Hill Plaza at
9 : 30 a.m. or at the Preserve, Route 366 north of 13 .
No fee. Information: 273-0707 .
MAY 6 SPRING WOOD WALKS With Robert Wesley. Cornell
Plantations . Meet at the Headquarters Building, One
Plantations Road at 10 a.m. Fee $30 members, $35 for
others . This Walk repeated May 20 at 10 : 00 and May 14
at 1 : 30. Information: 255-3020 .
MAY 7 SPRING WILDFLOWERS With Susan Lorbeer. Cayuga Nature
Center, 1420 Taughannock Blvd. , 3 p.m. , Fee is $2 . 00 .
Information: 273-6260 .
MAY 7 WETLANDS PROTECTION: A CASE STUDY Nancy Ostman and
Robert Wesley lead a hike through the Malloryville Bog,
Cornell Plantations . Meet at the Headquarters Building,
One Plantation Road at 1 : 30 p.m.and wear knee-high
waterproof boots . Fee is $18 for members, $21 for
others . Information: 255-2407 .
MAY 12 BELLE SHERMAN SCHOOL PLANT SALE A Benefit for the Bryant
Park Civic Association Beautification Committee. Lots of
plants and low prices . 501 Mitchell Street. 6-8 p.m.
Bring a box. Information: 272-6832 .
MAY 13 STEVENSON FOREST PRESERVE NATURE WALK Finger Lakes Land
Trust. Meet at Cass Park Rink parking lot at 9 : 30 a.m.
to carpool, or meet at site, about 1 mile south of Route
327 on Trumbull Corners Road at 10 a.m.
hi r Tie. ►" nA .��i V L. ... maA.
MAY 13 SPRING GARDEN FAIR AND PLANT SALE Cornell Cooperative
Extension and the Master Gardeners, held at Ithaca high
School, Cayuga Street off Route 13 at Stewart Park exit.
9 a.m. til 1 p.m. This year featuring ornamental
grasses . Exhibits, demonstrations, and soil testing.
Wildflowers for sale. Bring boxes .
MAY 14 POND LIFE EXPLORATION Cayuga Nature Center, 1420
Taughannock Blvd. 3 p.m. Wear rubber boots or sneakers .
Fee for non-members $2 . Information: 273-6260 .
MAY 14 SPRING WOODS WALK See May 6th.
MAY 14 MOTHERS' DAY ALONG THE BEAR TRAIL IN UPPER BUTTERMILK
PARK Led by Tony Ingraham, New York State Parks and
Recreation. Meet at the Upper Park Pavilion at 2 p.m.
MAY 20 SPRING WOODS WALK See May 6th.
MAY 20 & BOGOLOGY Led by Marianna Ferdo. Lifelong Learning
JUNE 3 Program at SUNY Cortland. Meet at Lime Hollow Nature
Center, 3091 Gracie Road, off Route 13, Cortland.
1 : 30 p.m. $15 fee for 2 sessions . Telephone information
and registration: ( 607 )753-4214 .
MAY 21 EDIBLE PLANTS . Taught by David Werier. Identification,
gathering and preparation. Cayuga Nature Center, 1420
Taughannock Blvd. , 3 p.m. Fee for non-members $2 . 00 .
MAY 21 SIX MILE CREEK WILDFLOWER PRESERVE, AN ITHACA TREASURE.
Enjoy late Spring flowers in a streamside woodland. One
and one-third miles . 2 p.m. Meet at VanNatta ' s Pond
parking lot off Giles Street at the bridge. No fee.
Children are welcome. Information: 273-4295 .
MAY 27 LIVING HIGH: ALPINE PLANTS OF TURKEY A lecture by Josef
Halda, Czeck Republic. Cornell Plantations . Whetzel
Room, 404 Plant Science Building, Tower Road. 7 : 30 p.m.
Free. Information: 255-3020 .
MAY 28 WHAT' S A WEED? Cayuga Nature Center, 1420 Taughannock
Blvd. 3 p.m. Non-member fee $2 . 00 .
JUNE 3 BOGOLOGY See May 20th.
JUNE 3 DISCOVER LIME HOLLOW: IT' S WILD FOR FLOWERS Led by
Eugene Waldbauer. Lifelong Learning Program, SUNY
Cortland. Lime Hollow Nature Center, 3091 Gracie Road,
Cortland. 8 : 30 a.m. $10 fee. Information: 758-5462 .
JUNE 4 GORGE EXPLORATION With John Chiment and Robert Wesley.
"A class designed for the adventurous" . Cornell
Plantations . Meet at Headquarters Building, One
Plantation Road, at 1 : 30 p.m. Fee for members is $18,
others $21 . Registration Information: 255-3020 .
JUNE 17 STEVENSON FOREST PRESERVE DEDICATION Finger Lakes Land
Trust. Carpool from Cass Park Rink parking lot at 1 : 30
p.m. or meet at site in Enfield, Trumbull Corners Road,
1 mile south of Route 327 . Mike DeMunn will lead a walk
through this old forest.
SIX MILE CREEK WILDFLOWER PRESERVE Off Giles Street at the bridge,
273-4295; and the CORNELL PLANTATIONS MUNDY WILDFLOWER GARDEN off
Caldwell Road in Forest Home, 255-3020, are both open sun-up to
sun-down. No entrance fees . Parking available. Group tours by
previous arrangement.
This calendar prepared by City of Ithaca Six Mile Creek Advisory
Committee. John Johnson, Chair. Information: 273-4295 .