HomeMy WebLinkAboutMN-CIV-1994-03-14 REGULAR MEETING
CIVIL SERVICE COMMISSION
March 14 , 1994
Present: Commissioner Middleton, Commissioner Perko, Bonnie Fiorille (Senior
Stenographer) , Shanna Ducey
Excused: Commissioner Bantuvanis, Valerie Saul (Personnel Administrator)
Commissioner Perko called the meeting to order at 11:00 a.m.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
Commissioner Middleton made a motion to approve the minutes of the February
14, 1994 meeting. Seconded by Commissioner Perko. Motion carried.
DISQUALIFICATION OF POLICE OFFICER CANDIDATE
Bonnie Fiorille explained to the Commission that the Personnel Department had
received evidence that Ms. Ducey had falsified her application for Police
Officer eligible list #68-620 and Police Officer examination #62-321 by
providing a false address to the Civil Service Commission in December 1992
and October 1993 . Ms. Ducey is here to address the Commission regarding this
matter.
Ms. Ducey explained that she was a resident of the City of Ithaca in December
1992 . She stated that she lived with her grandfather (in the City) , until
August of 1993 when she had signed a lease with a friend for an apartment
which was located outside the City of Ithaca from August 1, 1993 - May 31 ,
1994 . This arrangement did not work out and she left this residence to move
back with her grandfather October 1 , 1993 .
Ms. Fiorille explained that the Commission would review the information that
Ms. Ducey presented along with the evidence which was received in executive
session and make a decision as to whether to disqualify her from both Police
Officer eligible list. Commissioner Perko stated that they would inform Ms.
Ducey of their decision.
After lengthy discussion, Commissioner Middleton made a motion to disqualify
Ms. Shanna Ducey from the current Police Officer eligible list #68-620.
Seconded by Commissioner Perko. Motion carried.
Commissioner Perko requested that it be noted in the minutes that a member
of Ms. Ducey's family had previously approached him regarding this matter and
he stated that it would need to be discussed at the Civil Service Commission
meeting.
The Commission deferred voting on the new Police Officer examination #62-
321 until their April 11 meeting so that the full Commission could review the
situation.
34
r1
Civil Service Commission Meeting - March 14 , 1994
Page 2
CONTINUING BUSINESS --
Commissioner Perko made a motion to go into Executive Session. Seconded by
Commissioner Middleton. Motion carried.
APPROVAL OF ROSTER OF CANDIDATES FOR EXAMINATION
Commissioner Middleton made a motion to approve the Roster of Candidates for
examination listed below. Seconded by Commissioner Perko. Motion carried.
Motor Equipment Maintenance Supervisor (OC) #64-354
Motor Equipment Maintenance Supervisor (PROM) #78-451
Senior Community Service Officer (NCP) #78-679
APPROVAL OF PERSONNEL TRANSACTIONS
Commissioner Middleton made a motion to approve the Personnel Transactions
listed below. Seconded by Commissioner Perko. Motion carried:
Permanent Appointment
Phillips, Joanne Principal Account Clerk DPW 02/10/94
Provisional Appointment
Baullantyne, Sandra Dir of Resident Svcs IHA 01/26/94
Fields, Audrey Community Service Ofcr POL 02/07/94 {4
Milks, Joann Typist (PT) ICSD 12/06/93
Perkins, Christian Account Clerk-Typist (PT) ICSD 01/20/94
Temporary Appointment
Mitson, Thomas Bus Driver PT Relief DPW 02/21/94-Indef.
Seasonal Appointment
Berman, Ellen Recreation Attendant YB 01/31/94-06/30/94
Merrill , Jolene Recreation Attendant YB 02/19/94-06/30/94
Verret, Wendy Recreation Attendant YB 02/22/94-06/30/94
Leave of Absence
Lynch, Robert Truck Driver DPW 02/07/94-Indef.
Stark, Susan Bus Driver DPW 02/15/94-02/26/94
Reinstatement
Brown, Barbara Pkg Lot Attendant (PT) DPW 01/31/94
Dickerson, Michael Housing Inspector BLDG 02/04/94
Haring, Margaret Typist (PT) ICSD 01/25/94
Letts, Donald Maintenance Worker DPW 01/31/94
Lynch, Robert Truck Driver DPW 02/21/94
Retired
Tompkins, Ann Tenant Relations Asst IHA 02/04/94
f
Civil Service Commission Meeting - March 14 , 1994
Page 3
Laid Off
Rumsey, Donald Laborer (Seas) DPW 02/11/94
Removed
Smith, Doreen Food Service Helper ICSD 02/18/94
Correction
Smith, Doreen Food Service Helper ICSD 09/09/92
(SUB)
Resigned
Ernisse, Janet Dir of Resident Svcs IHA 02/01/94
Greene, James Recreation Attendant YB 02/18/94
Haring, Margaret , Account Clerk (PT) ICSD 01/25794
Hubbard, Mildred School Crossing Guard POL 01/03/94
Martinie, Derek Teacher Aide ICSD 09/01/93
McKenna, Helen Typist POL 02/02/94
VandeMark, Holly Custodial Worker ICSD 02/11/94
ADDITION OF NAMES TO CONTINUOUS RECRUITMENT ELIGIBLE LIST
Commissioner Middleton made a motion to add the following names to the
Continuous Recruitment Eligible List indicated for a one year period.
Seconded by Commissioner Perko. Motion carried.
Account Clerk-Typist - 20-000b
80 Donna Katzenstein
Clerk - 10-000a
100 Kelly Makinster
97. 2 Joann Milks
95.6 Becki Morgan
92.4 Milagros Gustafson
92 . 4 Holley Seamon
92.4 Fred Muhlsteff
92.4 Linda Eastman
90. 8 Deborah Leach
89. 2 Lynda Davenport
87.6 Colleen Roach
87.6 Barbara Hillick
87 .6 Donna Katzenstein
86 Audrey Fields
84 . 4 Christian Perkins
84 . 4 Diana Taber
84 .4 Geraldine Kilpatrick
82 . 8 Judy Briggs
82.8 Karen McGuire
81. 2 Denise VanEtten
81. 2 Tina McIntyre
.\
Civil Service Commission Meeting - March 14 , 1994
Page 4
Clerk - 10-000a (Continued)
79.6 Tracy Sault
79 .6 Cheryl Spicer
78 Susanne Phytila
74.8 Raymond Bailey
Typist - 10-000b
100 Kelly Makinster
97. 2 Joann Milks
92.4 Milagros Gustafson
92.4 Holley Seamon
92 .4 Fred Muhlsteff
92 .4 Linda Eastman
90 . 8 Deborah Leach
87.6 Colleen Roach
87.6 Barbara Hillick
87.6 Donna Katzenstein
84 .4 Christian Perkins
84.4 Diana Taber
82.8 Karen McGuire
81 . 2 Denise VanEtten
79. 6 Tracy Sault
79.6 Cheryl Spicer
74.8 Raymond Bailey
ESTABLISHMENT OF ELIGIBLE LIST
Commissioner Middleton made a motion to establish the Parts & Supply Manager
(NCP) Examination No. 77-052 for one year. Seconded by Commissioner Perko.
Motion carried.
With no further business, Commissioner Bantuvanis adjourned the meeting at
11 : 55 a.m.
Excused ii � Geer/frY
Ann Bantuvanis, Chairperson Vivian Middleton, Commissioner
Excused
Jahn o, Commissioner Valerie Saul , Personnel Administrator