Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutTB Minutes 2021-10-18 Meeting of the Ithaca Town Board October 18, 2021 at 5:30 p.m. This meeting will be held virtually and broadcast via our o..u.'1�u .e L i.nk.. and LC)Q I for your convenience. If you are planning to address the Board, please join via ZOOM and consider shifting to YouTube for the remainder of the meeting. AGENDA 1. Call to order and pledge of allegiance 2. Persons to be heard 3. Approval of BP 2022 Wage Scale and Employee Wages 4. Approval of Town Employee Wages 5. Public Hearing regarding the Preliminary 2022 Town of Ithaca Budget a. Consider any changes b. Consider adoption 6. Amabel requests for change in building permit fee and refund of penalty costs 7. Consider approval and authorization for the Supervisor to sign the 2022 Amendment to the Municipal Cooperative Agreement—Health Consortium 8. Discuss Short Term Rentals draft legislation 9. Consent Agenda a.A pproval of Town of Ithaca Abstract b. Approval of sale of Surplus Items c.A pproval of permanent appoint(s) 10. Report of Town Officials Maplewood Refund request I LA djourn TOWN OF ITHACA AFFIDAVIT OF POSTING AND PUBLICATION 1, Becky Jordan, being duly sworn, say that I am the Deputy Town Clerk of the Town of Ithaca, Tompkins County, New York; that the following notice has been duly posted on the sign board of the Town Clerk of' the Town of Ithaca and the notice has been duly published in the official newspaper, Ithaca Journal: ADVERTISEMENT/NOTICE NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE OF ESTOPPEL NOTICE OF ADOPTION OF PUBLIC INTEREST ORDER 9 2022 Preliminary Budget Location of Sign Board Used for Posting: Town of Ithaca Town Clerk's Office Public Hearing Notice 215 North 'I Street The Ithaca Town Board will hold a public hearing on Ithaca NY 14850 the 2022 Preliminary Budg- e et on the meeting Of Octo- ber Is, 2021 which begins at 5:30 m, for the pur- pose otp hearing public Town website at www.town,ith e ---—------------------ comments. The meeting f will be held via Zoom and broadcast on the Town' YouTubeLive channel. Date of Posting: October 13,2021 Links to both are on the web calendar and aV,d, Date of Publication: October 13, 2021 post.d to the own Website. Meeting 10 989109585241. Paulette Rosa Town Clerk 1 0/13/2021 Becky Jord Deputy To Aerk STATE OF NEW YORK) COUNTY OF TOMPKINS) SS: TOWN OF ITHACA) Sworn to and subscribed before me this 13"' day of October 2021, ........... Notary Public DE R"MLEY NO PUBLIC,nATE OF NEW YORK Rees mfion No.OIKE6025073 Quhfi6d in SCHUYLER Couni) Coaunission Expirts MAY 1 20--3 TOWN OF ITHACA AFFIDAVIT OF POSTING AND PUBLICATION 1, Paulette Rosa, being duly sworn, say that I am the Town Clerk of the Town of Ithaca, Tompkins County, New York; that the following notice has been duly posted on the sign board of the Town Clerk of the Town of Ithaca and the notice has been duly published in the official newspaper, Ithaca Journal: ADVERTISEMENT/NOTICE NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE OF ESTOPPEL NOTICE OF ADOPTION 0 2022 Town Budget and Salaries for Elected Officials Location of Sign Board Used for Posting: Town Clerk's Office 215 North Tioga Street Ithaca, NY 14850 Town website at www,townithaca,,ny.us Date of sting: October 21,2021 Date u do tober 21, 2021 A Paulette Rosa Town Clerk STATE OF NEW YORK) COUNTY OF TOMPKINS) SS: TOWN OF ITHACA) Sworn to and subscribed before me this 2 1"day of October 202 1. Town of Ithaca Notice of Adoption The Ithaca Town Board adopted the 2022 Town Budget at its meeting of October I 2021, Notar Pu The Budget is available for review on the Town website or at the Town Clerk's offli during normal business hours. BECKY L. JORDAN The 2022 salaries for the elected officials are: NOTARY PUBUC-S TAT E OF NEWYORK TOWN SUPERVISOR S 76,818 (Paid Biweekly) No. OIJ06166381 Crown Supervisor pay and 800/6 percent of Supervisor's Administrative Function pay) Quolified in ToMpkins county DEPUTY TOWN SUPERVISOR $26,448(Paid B 1wee kly)(Board Member pay and 20% percent of Supervisor's Administrative Function Pay) any Commission Explies Aptil 28, 20iq TOWN BOARD MEMBER(5) S 15,973 Each(Paid Biweekly) TOWN JUSTICE(2) $26,523 Each(Paid Biweekly) Paulette Rosa Town Clerk 10/21/21,, Meeting of the Ithaca Town Board October 18, 2021 This meeting was held virtually and broadcast via our YouTube Link and ZOOM due to Gov. Hotchul's Executive Order suspending certain requirements of Open Meetings Law in response to COVID 19 pandemic. MINUTES Board Members Present: Rod Howe, Supervisor; Members Eric Levine(6pm), Rich DePaolo, Bill Goodman, Tee-Ann Hunter, Pat Leary and Pamela Bleiwas Staff Present: Susan Brock, Attorney for the Town; Judy Drake, Director of Human Resources; Marty Moseley, Director of Code Enforcement; Susan Ritter, Director of Planning; Paulette Rosa, Town Clerk; Joe Slater, Director of Public Works; Donna Shaw, Director of Finance; and Dan Thaete, Director of Engineering 1. Call to order and pledge of allegiance—Mr. Howe opened the meeting at 5:33p.m. 2. Persons to be heard -None Added item—Authorization to establish a line of credit Mr. Howe stated that the resolution was sent earlier and asked if there were any questions. There were none. TB Resolution 2021 — 133: Authorization for the Town of Ithaca to open a Line of Credit Account at Tompkins Trust Company and for the Supervisor to sign a Letter of Credit for NYSEG on behalf of the Town Board Whereas the Finance Manager has determined a need for the establishment of an account at Tompkins Trust Company and associated Line of Credit required by NYSEG for the Streetlight Replacement/Ownership Project, and Whereas NYSEG requires an irrevocable letter of credit and Tompkins Trust Company requires a resolution from the Town Board designating the person(s) authorized to sign said Letter of Credit, now therefore be it Resolved that the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca hereby approves and authorizes the establishment of a line of credit not to exceed $60,000.00 and designates and authorizes the Rod Howe, Town Supervisor or Deputy Town Supervisor William Goodman, to execute the necessary documents to establish the account and sign the Letter of Credit. Moved: Rich DePaolo Seconded: Pat Leary TB 2021-10-18 (Filed 11/1) Pg. 1 Vote: ayes—DePaolo, Leary, Hunter, Goodman, Howe and Bleiwas 3. Approval of BP 2022 Wage Scale and Employee Wages There were no questions or comments. TB Resolution 2021-134: Ratify Southern Cayuga Lake Intermunicipal Water Commission 2022 Wage Scale and Employee Wages Whereas, the Commission on October 7, 2021, approved the 2022 Wage Scale and Wages for all Commission staff, now, therefore,be Resolved, the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca does hereby ratify approval of the 2022 Wage Scale and Wages for all Commission staff as filed in the Human Resources Office. Moved: Pamela Bleiwas Seconded: Rod Howe Vote: ayes—Bleiwas, Howe, Hunter, Leary, Goodman and DePaolo 4. Approval of Town Employee Wages There were no questions or comments. TB Resolution 2021-135: Approval of 2022 Employee Wages Whereas, the governing Town Board of the Town of Ithaca has reviewed the proposed wages for the Town of Ithaca non-collective bargaining employees for the year 2022,utilizing the 2.5%wage scales approved by the Town Board August 9, 2021; and Whereas, the Town Board has reviewed the wages established by the collective bargaining agreement with the Public Works unit represented by Teamsters Local 317; now, therefore, be it Resolved, the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca does hereby approve the said wages for the non- collective bargaining employees and collective bargaining employees for 2022, as filed in the Human Resources Office. Moved: Pamela Bleiwas Seconded: Bill Goodman Vote: ayes—Bleiwas, Goodman, Howe, Hunter, Leary, and DePaolo 5. Public Hearing regarding the Preliminary 2022 Town of Ithaca Budget Mr. Howe opened the public hearing at 5:38 p.m. there was no one wishing to address the board and the hearing was closed. TB 2021-10-18 (Filed 11/1) Pg. 2 Mr. Howe thanked Ms. Shaw and the Budget Committee for their work on the budget and noted that there is a 3-page summary at the beginning which has a great summary. This year's budget will actually decrease about 3.43% from last year, or about $900K; the tax levy will decrease by $46K. This is due to the increased taxable assessed value of town properties, up a bit from last year about 1.9%. We are staying under the 2% tax cap and the typical house, $300K, will have a 1.27% increase at about$25.30 per 1,000. TB Resolution 2021 - 136: Adoption of the Town of Ithaca 2022 Budget Whereas the Town Board held a public hearing on Monday, October 18, 2021, to hear comments regarding the 2022 Preliminary Budget, and Whereas the Town Board discussed, reviewed, and made any changes properly put forth and voted upon to the 2022 Preliminary Budget, now therefore be it Resolved that the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca hereby approves and adopts the 2022 Preliminary Budget as the Final 2022 Town of Ithaca Budget. Moved: Rich DePaolo Seconded: Tee-Ann Hunter Vote: ayes—DePaolo, Hunter, Bleiwas, Leary, Goodman and Howe 6. Amabel requests for change in building permit fee and refund of penalty costs Mr. Moseley gave an overview, stating that Ms. Cosentini has requested a change in the building permit fee structure for her development houses and a refund of the penalty fee assessed due to her starting work without a permit. He referred the Board to his memo. The applicant was informed that work should not begin prior to the issuance of a permit. The building permit fee is $1,400 and when work was started, the additional "building without a permit fee"was charged, which is $100 or 50% of the original permit fee. The applicant has also requested a reduction in the permit fee because she feels the inspections are repetitive given the nature of the buildings and the four models she is using. We did do a search and there does not seem to be any precedent for that type of reduction. At this point, the Department has conducted 14 inspections, including plan overview, and we anticipate an additional 10 inspections for a total of 24, which on average are 1 hour long. The $1,400 fee divided by the 24 inspections comes to $58, which does not include the 70+ emails the inspector has dealt with up to this point, or the time I have spent on this, as well as other town staff. TB 2021-10-18 (Filed 11/1) Pg. 3 Mr. Howe added that this has been a very difficult development with issues along the way and the town has worked very closely with her and others to address issues as they have come up to the best of our ability, and I think we have been a good partner. Mr. DePaolo asked if there is anything related to the review of replica homes that would reduce the amount of time involved in inspections and review. Mr. Moseley responded that the process is the same no matter what except for possibly the plan review is a little shorter,but they do allow for variations in these models we still need to review them. The inspection process is the same; each one has to be set and different installations as well as the foundations. He did not think there is any difference. Mr. DePaolo asked if the homes were staged in such a way as to allow for a site visit to cover multiple homes, instead of multiple site visits, would that make a difference, and do we know if that is her plan? Mr. Moseley responded that we have only one building permit and he was not sure what the process is going to be for the next or the future. Mr. DePaolo stated that this always comes to the recoupment of staff time and if the estimation is that time is not going to be significantly reduced by virtue of these homes being similar or somewhat identical, then we would have to deny the request. Mr. Moseley added that he could not see any significant reduction in time is similar developments recently such as the Belle Sherman Cottages and Maplewood. Both had multiples of similar buildings or what is called modular construction, and there was no significant reduction in staff inspections and time involved. Mr. DePaolo asked if these permit prices were a surprise because she seems to be making this request as if it were a surprise to her or is this something that should have been known and figured into the construction costs. Mr. Moseley responded that she is aware of the Code Fee Schedule as she has worked in the town before, it is posted online as well as in the permit application process. Permit fees are based on the cost of the project. Mr. Howe turned to the $1,400 penalty levied on her, and where did that come from. Mr. Moseley stated that we had not issued the permit to her when she started the foundation. She was also told not to begin work prior to the issuance of the permit. We were in the process of issuing it, but it had not been issued and we had warned her not to start work. She requested an inspection before the permit was issued, and at that point in time, it was evident that she had started several times and we had warned her that if you start work, it is a double permit fee. Mr. Howe noted that there is no resolution proposed;just wanted to know whether this was something you wanted to consider, we could draft a resolution. TB 2021-10-18 (Filed 11/1) Pg. 4 Mr. Goodman asked, as far as the penalty, isn't a foundation only permit a way to begin some work while a permit is processing and did she ask for one? Mr. Moseley responded that she did not, and we were in the process, about 3 days out, from issuing her the building permit for the first home, when she started foundation work, that was the work that was started that triggered the additional fee. Mr. Goodman asked what the $2,400 fee is she is referencing in her emailed request. Mr. Moseley said he would assume she is factoring in the other permitting fees such as an external plumbing permit and any other permits she may need for each home. Mr. Thaete spoke, saying that Engineering recently went through a calculation of the external plumbing permit and although only one or two site visits may be needed, there is a lot of plan review and behind the scenes work. Ms. Cosentini started the sewer lateral work for this home before she had obtained that permit also and we did not charge her the double fee for that action. We overlooked it and just verball "slapped"her on the wrist kind of thing, and then she went ahead and put the pipes in the ground before she had a permit. Mr. Goodman asked if the base permit is $1,400, what is the price range of the homes. Mr. Moseley responded the fee of$1,400 is based on a price range of$100K- $35OK, construction costs, and she listed a $200K range for price. Mr. Goodman stated that he feels the town under charges in a lot of these pyramid type fees because there are lots of costs associated with people going out for inspections other than the time of actual inspection; benefits, vehicles, administrative, and other costs. He said he was not inclined to reduce the permit fee to a flat $600 per home as requested. As for the penalty was known and is there to stop people from getting started before they have a permit and there is a foundation permit only she could have availed herself of and she did not. Ms. Bleiwas stated that the town's P&O Committee and the staff is very thorough in determining fees and they answer a lot of questions from committee members in determining and evaluating the rates. She said she was not inclined to reduce a fee just for asking and she did not see a good cause shown to do so. Ms. Hunter said she agreed with Ms. Bleiwas but asked for clarification that the $200 was the construction cost, not the sale of the home cost. Mr. Moseley agreed, saying the application states $200K for the house and Mr. Howe added that he believes they are being marketed and sold for around $300K or more. Ms. Leary said she agrees with the other statements and does not see a reason to move forward. TB 2021-10-18 (Filed 11/1) Pg. 5 Mr. DePaolo asked about the penalty; saying she seems to be saying she was under the impression that she could go forward and made a point in her email that she had been given an indication that the issuance of the permit was imminent and that there were no obstacles between point a and b. He asked if this was a case of her being asked to remedy something and she didn't and went ahead anyway. Mr. Moseley responded that that conversation was concerning a State DOT permit for the southern end connection, and I told her there shouldn't be an issue now and we can proceed with the permit, but she needed to check with the inspector assigned to the project to see where they were in the review process of the building permit. Mr. DePaolo stated that as usual, it is more complicated than as presented. The consensus of the board was no action was necessary and the fee schedule is researched, discussed and set. 7. Consider approval and authorization for the Supervisor to sign the 2022 Amendment to the Municipal Cooperative Agreement—Health Consortium Ms. Drake stated that this is an annual requirement under the bylaws of the Consortium and we are adding four additional municipalities in 2022. TB Resolution 2021 -137: Approval of the 2022 Amendments to the Municipal Cooperative Agreement for the Greater Tompkins County Municipal Health Insurance Consortium Whereas, the Town of Ithaca is a Participant in the Greater Tompkins County Municipal Health Insurance Consortium (the "Consortium"), a municipal cooperative organized under Article 47 of the New York Insurance Law, and Whereas, the municipal participants in the Consortium, including this body, have approved and executed a certain Municipal Cooperation Agreement(the "Agreement"; effective date of October 1, 2010), and Whereas, Article 47 of the New York Insurance Law and the rules and regulations of the New York State Department of Financial Services set forth certain requirements for governance of municipal cooperatives that offer self-insured municipal cooperative health insurance plans, and Whereas, the Agreement sets forth in Section Q2 that continuation of the Consortium under the terms and conditions of the Agreement, or any amendments or restatements thereto, shall be subject to Board review and upon acceptance of any new Participant hereafter, and Whereas, by motion 001-2021 the Consortium's Board of Directors recommends approval of the 2022 Amended Agreement, and Whereas, the Municipal Cooperative Agreement requires any amendments be presented to each participant municipality for review and adoption by its municipal board, and TB 2021-10-18 (Filed 11/1) Pg. 6 Whereas,the Town of Ithaca is in receipt of the proposed amended Agreement and has determined that it is in the best interest of its constituents who are served by the Consortium to amend the Agreement as set forth in the attached 2022 Amended Municipal Cooperative Agreements, now therefore be Resolved, that the Ithaca Town Board hereby authorizes the Town Supervisor to sign the 2022 Municipal Cooperative Agreements of the Greater Tompkins County Municipal Health Insurance Consortium, and Resolved, further, that the Town Clerk of the Town of Ithaca is hereby authorized to execute this Resolution to indicate its approval, transmit a copy thereof to the Board of Directors of the Greater Tompkins County Municipal Health Insurance Consortium, and take any other such actions as may be required by law. Moved: Tee-Ann Hunter Seconded: Pamela Bleiwas Vote: ayes—Hunter, Bleiwas, Howe, Goodman, Leary, Levine and DePaolo 8. Consent Agenda TB Resolution 2021 - 138: Consent Agenda Resolved,that the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca hereby approves and/or adopts the following Consent Agenda items: a. Approval of Town of Ithaca Abstract b. Approval of Sale of Surplus Items c. Approval of Permanent Appoint(s) Moved: Tee-Ann Hunter Seconded: Eric Levine Vote: ayes—Hunter, Levine, Goodman, Leary, DePaolo, Howe and Bleiwas TB Resolution 2021 -138a: Town of Ithaca Abstract No. 20 for FY-2021 Resolved that the governing Town Board hereby authorizes the payment the audited vouchers indicated: VOUCHER NOS. 1161 - 1203 General Fund Town Wide 59,935.14 General Fund Part-Town 100.00 Highway Fund Town Wide DA 376.73 Highway Fund Part Town DB 19,308.00 Water Fund 12,279.39 Sewer Fund 651.89 Risk Retention Fund 179.10 TB 2021-10-18 (Filed 11/1) Pg. 7 Forest Home Lighting District 36.60 Glenside Lighting District 10.93 Renwick Heights Lighting District 18.25 Eastwood Commons Lighting District 25.57 Clover Lane Lighting District 3.42 Winner's Circle Lighting District 5.09 Burlei h Drive Lighting District 11.93 West Haven Road Lighting District 46.48 Coddin ton Road Lighting District 27.47 TOTAL 93,015.99 TB Resolution 2021 -138b: Sale of Surplus Items Whereas, a municipal online auction is held from time to time hosted by RTI auctions located in Geneseo, NY, and Whereas, certain items have become surplus/no longer needed by the Town, and Whereas, the Town wishes to put the following surplus equipment in an online auction in November: • (2) Heil Air Conditioner Units Model#N4A360GHC300 • (1) 1997 Champion Motor Grader(Fleet# 37) • (1) 2004 SECA Trailer Mounted Sewer Jet (Fleet# 74) • (1) 2011 Ford Escape (Fleet# 30) • (1) 2018 Quality Steel Trailer(Fleet#T8) • (1) 2005 Wells Cargo Enclosed Trailer (Fleet#T9) • (1) 2011 Ford F-150 w/ Survey Box (Fleet#23) • (1) 2016 Gradeall Excavator(Fleet#48) • (1) 2016 Salt Dogg SHPE3000 Salt Spreader Now therefore be it; Resolved, that the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca hereby declares said above-described equipment to be surplus and no longer needed by the Town; and be it further Resolved,that the items listed above be placed in the auction with the proceeds from the sale going into the appropriate funds. TB Resolution 2021 -138c: Approve Permanent Appointment of Director of Code Enforcement and Electrical and Code Enforcement Officer Whereas, Martin Moseley was provisionally appointed as the Director of Code Enforcement, effective December 28, 2019, and Jessica Hull was provisionally appointed as an Electrical and TB 2021-10-18 (Filed 11/1) Pg. 8 Code Enforcement Officer, effective October 15, 2019, both pending the next civil service exam for their title; and Whereas, the Tompkins County Civil Service office has provided the certificate of eligible listing for the said titles and Martin Moseley and Jessica Hull were reachable candidates; now, therefore be it Resolved, the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca does hereby approve the appointment of Martin Moseley to the position of Director of Code Enforcement with no change in current compensation or benefits,retro-active to September 28, 2021, with an eight (8) week promotional probationary period applies with no further action by the Town Board if there is successful completion of the probationary period as determined by the Town Supervisor; and be it further Resolved, the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca does hereby approve appointment of Jessica Hull to the position of Electrical and Code Enforcement Officer with no change in current compensation or benefits,retro-active to September 28, 2021, with a twenty-six (26)week probationary period applies with no further action by the Town Board if there is successful completion of the probationary period as determined by the Director of Code Enforcement. 9. Discuss Short Term Rentals draft legislation Mr. Goodman gave an overview, saying that the Committee met again last week and also talked to Counsel about a number of issues, which we will most likely go into closed session to report to the full board about. The Committee discussed the purpose clause and adding an amortization provision for implementation so people could have extra time to recoup some of the investment they have made expecting to be able to utilize short term rental income. We also discussed the enforcement provisions and penalty sections, which will mirror the penalty guidelines in other sections of the Town Code. The goal tonight is to decide what number to put in for the days limitation and the lakefront residential restrictions for the majority of the board so the final draft can be presented at the November meeting and a public hearing scheduled for December. Lakefront residential was at 120 days to start because the committee felt that was the summer months in total then to 150 which seemed to be about 5 months to recoup the costs of owning and maintaining a lakefront home. Discussion followed, with some members saying that it is unfair to allow some owners such a significant number of days over others, especially since the lakefront properties are significantly more expensive and the perception is that people who are more well off get more. TB 2021-10-18 (Filed 11/1) Pg. 9 Non-committee members stated their concerns, mostly around lakefront rentals which are historical, way before the concept of Air BNB's and is a known factor for anyone purchasing a lakefront property up front. The economic drivers and support provided by renters to the community and county as a whole outweighs the limited number of complaints in the zone. The lakefront residential is comprised of approximately 120 residences with maybe 60-70 used as short term rentals. Mr. Howe suggested moving to the discussion regarding the request for Water Sewer Billing reduction from Utility Advisors for Maplewood so Public Works staff could leave the meeting prior to a closed session. Item 10 Report of Town Officials Maplewood billing request. Mr. Howe explained that the Public Works Committee reviewed the data, history and request and recommended no refund based on that information. The system is private, at the choice of the developers and the leak was on the private side and not addressed in a timely fashion by them after notifications by Bolton Point and assistance from Bolton Point in locating the general area of the leak. The Board concurred with the Public Works Committee recommendation and took no further action at this time. Short Term Rentals continued Closed Session to seek the advice of counsel, moved by Mr. Goodman, seconded by Ms. Hunter at 6:34 p.m.; unanimous. Reenter open session at 6:40 p.m. moved by Ms. Hunter, seconded by Mr. Goodman, unanimous. The Board discussed various numbers for Lakefront residential and Mr. Goodman will work through the notes and make a change to the draft that will either be approved or changed at the next full session. The next item centered on the "one permit per owner" and the restrictions that entailed if someone had a"regular"rental and wanted a short term for a period of time, which would not be allowed. Changes to accommodate certain scenarios with little overall impact were discussed. Clarifications on hosted and unhosted rentals were discussed and the legislation will be drafted for discussion and action at the November meeting. It was noted that some residents have questioned whether board members acting on this legislation should be conflicted out of the discussion. Each member stated whether they owned TB 2021-10-18 (Filed 11/1) Pg. 10 rental property, which some did,but none engaged in short term rentals, and so there is not conflict. The Board was not unanimous in support of the stated draft outline, but the Committee felt they had spent three plus years researching and discussing many scenarios, and the draft needed to come to a vote. Mr. DePaolo added that a survey was sent to the lakefront owners and those responses factored into the draft legislation. 10. Adjourn Meeting was adjourned upon motion by Mr. Goodman, seconded by Mr. Howe at 6:58 p.m. SubmittedUy Paulette Rosa, Town Clerk TB 2021-10-18 (Filed 11/1) pi?, U a O v o .F to p p 0) O o C ) C ) r =O V � o o L 00 () O CA N NT N C) .m Z O O O O O O O O N COW ~ W a a a a a a a o a Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q N 0TM 0 C L. -a 0� 0 � r V W co W W W } 0) 0 J J J 0 W 0 Q 0 LO 0 Q CO E N X U- 3 m j �O _ ca Q N to °)z U d CD 0 � ) � a Z�Z E � D a _ � � �' Q C L co -0 r_ N c0 O Rj H ca ca N (6 N N OLLC) Q ti c CD E LO N I� O Q Z .C� J N 0) N >, N Q N � � � � O L TT ^ U) CV a: r r ii X OQ O -C C)3 Z �' 0° °' Ca x O — a) C'o CD O -0Q W N co O o0 N 4- � .� Co J C) J M M E N O f- > m CD It C ) X o0 C'o .�� (D J co co N N N I� U-) Ch W (D C'o 3: CD } a) Q cC -C C L cC p0) _O co z 0- z io LL L U) W > 'o Q a o z U = (D� O Oc � a� (D � J = Jto � = Z � Z > W Q } } U o m U m m c O O O o z z z - 7t WEE O > O � Oa J O �Q Z oo Z . Z ' OJZ W Q CV) Q m Z �n � c CN U U O Q W Q J6 Z Zn ou O Z OcCO N ° °a m a (D w o O o oo co Z >, ° C "J W a) W X W WW O U) Gi >" W "o LL o W 0) a = o = o 0) T 0 _ E N CO O E > E CQ caO O O O O N O N p 0 O 4) N I N N N a N pp O p O C) U) ++ C ) C ) (D C ) C ) N N N N N O O r ,O r— O 00 O O 0'),O O O O O :F+ 1- 00 C ) N m 0 (D r— O 00 00 00 m O) V Mo M M o o Co Ro �o Mo �o �o �o N N N N N N N N N N a N N N N N N N N N N a 0 C) C) C:) (13 C) 0 0 � OC) 0 00 It 0 U-) C) 7a3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0) w w w ui w w ui w w w ui w > > > > > > > > > > > > o (13 w (1) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 U) a a IL a a IL a a a- a- o- CO) n C14 - < a- IL a a IL a a a IL aQ < < < < < < < < < < < < C14 CD >U) w w E ui w w ui w w w ui w C)4) 0- CD a: 0 0 0 L 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 r 0) W 00 - : �e z co U) -C> U) U) U) U) U) U) U) U) U) 13 U) 13 13 75; 13 13 75; 13 13 13 75; 75 E 0 z 70 0 w < c E (6 0) LO 13 Z > Q 0000000 < E 00 0 0 0Ja: C)L C4 0) 0) E CD 0) 3: ::(c4' 2 0 0 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) Q > > > > > > Fn -0 c 0) = C = C = = = - L a) 0 0 (1) 0 .- 0 C: 0 0 C 0 C: 0 C: 0 C 0 c T m (/) (n-F a U) -U) i= -U) -U) to :t-- to :t-- U) :t-- U) :tf (n :t-- co wC C C C C 'F V) 0 o CN as 0 Lo - 0.) C) 0 0') C) r- (.0 0 0 0 C LO 1- Y) rl- -0 -0 75 00 aI -J C:) Cj c C) CD C) -0 C) 'D C) 70 CD _0 C) -0 0 0 Z 04 M 'It CD C: CD (.0 - co "00 (D co co CD CD co 0 0 o- c c0 c0 'D C.0 r CL L) U) z m U)cp < m N O0) 0 to m -0 E E E E E E E co 0') > -U) E - - - I C4 C,4 m CN co V- cn " "t " T " LO t CL AW co (a I CL I I (a m m m (a m CN Q _j c� L6 4 v) m :t E v) L6 0- 4 .CDE1. -= 1. (a .. m .. m .. m I. (a I. M 00 --- C) CD C- CD CD CD c CD �c CD �c CD c CD c- mUl)' c.D -- I- m (a I co M [1- CD 0 [,- m (a m m m m (a m C: U- - 2 -t-- 2 -t-- 2 -L-- ) -Z Z z z .- 2 z C: -0 C: c c C: C: c c U- Z) m Z)C) z .2(D (D 0 0 (D 0> (D o (D o t8 o :t,- (D :t,- (D (D 0 0 0 0 0 Z (D - Z -T Z > Z > Z Z > z > z > z > z > z > z > 0 - -1 CD CD CD - CD CD CD CD CD_j 0 -1 CD - C: m o N o N o o N -j CD -j N o CN o CN o (N ON N 0 m D 0 0 ol 04- 0 0 E 0 m 0 0 0 D 0 0 0 0 0 0 ' 0 C) . C) () F- C) U F- () F- 0 F- 0 F- U F- () F- C) f- 0 E >, C) 0 0 co C) 0 0 0 co 0 m C) m 0 co 0 co 2 - CD CD CD CD z U) -0 Z Lo Z (C:D:) Z cc DD Z CD z z CD z CD z z z z < 5, E < r- < < < CD < CD < CD < CD < CD < CD < CD < CD U) a) CD CD CD CD CD CD CD CD CD CD m 0) 0) m 0) m 0) 0) 0) m 0- UU)U) < U0 0 0 U U UUU U4) z E m z U) Z_ Z Z Z Z T -U) D T U) D T U) -0 -0 -0 -0 -0 < < < < < < < < :3 < < < < :3 w E w w ui w w ui w w w uj w M 40- r M m (00000 CN C"L 04 U) CN U) C\l U) 04 U) CN En C\l U) 04 U) 04 U) CN U) C\l U) 04 U) 4) C:) c: U) C) c CD c CD c C) c C:) c: CD c C) c C) c: C:) c: CD c C) c CN 04 CN C\l 04 LO U') LO LO U') U') LO LO LO Z LO LB LO cx tz: cz: cz: ZZ: cz: ZZ ZZ: cz: cz: ZZ C: 0 Q 0 0 Q 0 0 Q Q 0 0 0 00 0) C) C14 co I- V) (D 1- 00 0) M m CD CD C) CD CS (S 8 CD CD C) co CY) It C? C? C? 04 C14 04 C\l C14 04 C\l C14 C14 04 C\l C14 C:) C) C) CD CD CD CD CD CD CD CD CD 04 C14 04 C\l C14 04 C\l C14 C14 04 C\l CNJ a 0 C) O Lri Cli C\l 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 w ui w w ui w w w ui w w UJ > > > > > > > > > > > > 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 a- IL a a a IL a a I L CO) C14 CL a- a- a- a- a- a- a- a- a- CL IL Q < < < < < < < < < < < < U) C14 0 -C Q 0 0 U) U) W ui w w ui w w w ui 4) Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z z z _j U) 0- 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 (D (D -j 0) F--- F--- F-- F-- < < UJ o a U) U) U) U) U) U) U) U) U) 13 13 v c 13 75; 13 13 75; 75 75 75 73 0 0 7; 0 It E E E E E E E E E 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 CL cm 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Q 0) CD 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) m IL > > 0 ce) Q �= 0 Q .0 o C: o c o c o C: o c o o •C: o •C: 0 m • • • • >, >, X W) U) t- U) t- (1) :tt U) t- U) :tf (1) (1) U) -a —c >1 ' oo 0 ,t CO m C/) CL 4) C,4 o 0 C14 0 C) 0 00 0 (.0 0 It 0 C,4 0 co (.0 CD [I- CL [I- _j C:) 70 C) _0 70 70 C) _0 C) 70 C) 70 CD 'D CY) 0 CN CD w .C- I " 4- o 0 Z (.0 C: to C It C NT C: Il- C It C It C: NT C: 4- C14 0 0 r M C CO CO Cfl CO CO Cfl CO CO Ch L 00 -2 U U) 00 o Lo E E ,t c,) C.4 E E C) E E 0) co LO E CL C4 CD V- V- " , - I E Lo 06 0) 4-0 (a m m (a m m "M CD I U) Q LO 0- 4 CL A CL C; 0- A CL A CL A 0- co 0- w (a (a m m (a m m m C� C� CD CD CD CD CD CD CD CD E co CD co U-) I'- [-- C'4 U') (a m m ca m m m 0 0 2 E U) 2 tc-f: -LC-- -tC-- -LC-- -tC-- C: C: z U) (D )0 0 (D 0 (D 0 (D 0 (D 0 (D 0 (D 0 (D 0 U) c z > z > z > z > z > z > z > z > q_- z CD CD CD CD CD CD CD CD 0 0 o o o o o o o o U) 0 0 O = 0 0 O = 0 0 0) E 0 0 0 F- F- U F- F- U F- 0 U) U) >1 0 z CD z CD z CD z CD z CD z CD z CD z CD CD C) CD CD C) CD CD CD Z z (.0 < CD < C) < CD < CD < C) < CD < CD < CD 0 E < (D 0) 0') m m 0) m 0) 0) (D 4� CN (D It z z z z C- z C- z I-- z I-- z 0) z C,4 T U) D T U) D T T — 00 4) z tt- — F-- LL y LL m 0 CD < M < < D M D M< < < < < =5 0 0 47 U) < CD W UJ W W UJ W W W 0 10 0 y w uj cy) m CD "M Ln q (D 0) 0 (a W (a m m (a m m m U) C-4 C.4 -V) C,4 C-4 C.4 -V) C,4 C,4 >- 4 C- C\, E E 0 C14 0) C\, 0) 4) C:) c: CD c C) c C:) c: CD c C) c C) c: CDC CD 0 C14 0 C) 0 CD 0 CD of z 4.0 C14 C*4 C14 C14 C\l O U') LO LO U') LO CD Lo 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0') 0') m 0') 0') 0') m 0') 0� C: CC: cc: cz: CC: cc: cz: cz: C: cc: cz: C: C) C14 co V) (D 1- 00 0) C) , Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q C14 C\l C? -'4- 1-C? C?I:T C14 C\l C14 C14 C\l C14 C14 C14 C\l C14 C14 C\l C:) CD C) C) CD CD CD CD CD CD CD CD C14 C\l C14 C14 C\l C14 C14 C14 C\l C14 C14 C\l a O .r+ O N O .F U1 p p � Op 6 0) O O O rn o c O O U O 0) CDm O U m O O O Q- N OD M L OC y W CD U ui CD W ui W W W ui W M > a 6 > > O > > > > > > .� Oc: z z °, O z O E O O O O .`� O O /� 0. F r A LL L z z O CL z CL o- CL a a C O CL a N aY w W ° a w a 0 a a a a � a a o Q ° a a Q a Q � Q Q Q Q o Q Q N LEli (n o 0- (1) O O a' o p o U) o U) w U) W J J J O J J o Z z Z Z J J J a J J J a U O O 7�; Y 75 13 Q- 75 73 U) o 0 � o (a =5 2 (a U) (a O > N � M a 06 J OL xO It �Q 21) o 0 -00 o� p/i cm u) L w O N >L w 0) U O w -p L U) m Z z UO L_ to nco U O m U Q �O a) -a = o = to ( ULuj -U) cU) 0 ) (ofir r �+ -O M C a rn 0') (aM CO � � tia J cy) ptO oO Q Z � U) Z ^ � Q O p U) � Op N O •C •1 O N 3 ii■ co o _ M L Y 00 N o0 O ?� O O Q ° C6 � OO LA N O � O M m LO O � M NL a r cN CD 'p co CO f- o 7 W 0?F— cV C z O > mo OD O ( OO J f- o M (Y) C MZ � C\J C CO INN W c 1 O E � Q' z = o L o '0 L L ° N L L W W �. H O a N a 0 fl Z o J N > o > z > z O •� J '� c ° Q �c J ��- ac) o O a m m o J O O .J O Q Y Z ° oo > o Q0 m a Q O N Q O O U Q O Q O Q ° U O J J L N o a U U = Z , CL -0 z >, W Q Z Z U '� ~ J x J >aci O ° ~ og N � 2 WU Q °° 0 -Q O oO M X WX ui -oI c o oW . ° z c o ui w Oo oz O ° O -UW D cWoo A w 0 o o = JLJ F5 o � 0) U 0) ui — W o 0 mO o o c L E N O N rn N •L N cn N N O N O N O N O NO I NO Y NO U) O p O O O O U) O O O O F- N N N N N N N N N N N N Q 0 = O 0 = O O 0 = N N = N = co M N O N O N O N ,O O� Q o) 4 o) Q O O 4 O Q O O 4 O Q O Q O O 4 = V V V V V V V V V V V V O y y y H y y H y y y H y :r+ N M N In 0 (D OD O) O N D M N N N N N N N N M co M M O O O O O O O O O O O O N N N N N N N N N N N N Q O O O O O O O O O O O O N N N N N N N N N N N N a O O o v o p oo C) C) .Q O C) O C:) o - 1- 6 o C)to 0 0 °:0 O O O M C U C) CD � ° cI i � aoo o CD ° U NT c6 M N U N 0 0 C to CD (D CD (D CD (D C� C� pp 'Fz Z z N Z_ O z O z z O Z_ Z_ U) C) o(l) 0 w 0 w 0 0 0� 0 0 ' c r N Z Z -° Z IL a Z Z a Z Z Q o N W W = W W W CL ui W a W ui Z -a o a a a Q a Q -i�l a a Q a a00 -C CN U s- Q = to V LLJ W > > T c G) Z Z Z z z z } o y Q Q Q ° Q W H D 75 Q z ° - U- -0 -CN O O J "p 2i L r C C) tC O N N i >, X O i( a> —� Y c o +� c ca N uiL O > U CB Qj ,a � N c6 C� CU tll U s] U V) ,�A-A co O Rf cLo x N E u72 0 E E Q N CU W — U) Q QLn S O E 4) ti ~ 1- > O f— CD o0 � M ti CV O ti J O O CD LT N N O CDO Q Z N LO � N N p N — ■� v- Z � O •C � 3 O N U m Rf O t O N 'p CD O L CD N O C E O O Lo �_ N co N L6 j N p O� 00 N 0 •L � N N N OrO U Q 00 co .Q .� Q ■� N J i (6 Q Cn N Cfl 0 O m CD CO CD U M � � CD M � O M � -0 (b M 'F O - co co CD � CD 's= N S- M � O CO 0 CD M ca � N � � U) W p 4- 0. E Z W z o w c( H O ° .� o O c a W 75 ° z z Q N LL c p F •3 a U W UJ E W W D > > z = 70 ° j � -C wm ao � < n CL C� C� � zo U a O c 4- 0 N (D (� U z z = N °O - �_ W -pa W (2) Z CN� z z O O N M c W > � ° > � -C 7E � 3 O O � Nz J > J s g 46 � a) a } .� a a z z a � O (� Q tC ° Q J V Up J J O Q Q 5 c N p L j N U) w ° Z O Z O) U) Z Z O o C� _ UU O U W p W 0) W W p H 0- � a� io ~ W c O � - Z 0) O � z �° X p U m X X p W T W c U a U) .� w � (A W p Q W W p = pc = _ — > > U N p N p L N p N E N p N N c N N N cn N c6 p 0 O OU OUP O � CD OZ C) o- Op C) O0 C) C: OgU) � N N N N N N N N N N — N Q co = coGNT _ G ti = 1- G 00 M = M = 00 G N p N p N p N p N p N p N p N p N p N p N p m Q O O Q O o) 4 o) Q O o) 4 o) Q a) Q O = V V V V V V V V V V V O y H y H y y H y y y H :r+ V 0 CD Il 00 a) O N co Rj co co co co M co It N O O O O O O O O O O O N N N N N N N N N N N Q O O O O O O O O O O O 04 N 04 N N 04 N N N N N a 0 C�C) C) ■ 0 CD 0) CD LO 00 Z z(D (D z z(D C) 0 0 an Z z z z C14 w ui w w Q CL IL CL r) C14 TM L. 0 0 Q 0 U) U) ry D Z) w 4) z z z (D (D 0 < < w 13 7- y U) 4� 0 0 75 13 IE P) 0 9 CL cm u) (1) C) U) , C4 >Q -C co C, 70 a) 3: , L:l _0 0 U) T U) .(5 (1) — C)) U) (1) co r- () q V) Cl) c) -a 0 c (1) 4) (Y csj) Lr) 0 LO (Y) —J C: r— 0 7a3 4- o 0 Z (13 C14 1-+= 0 0- 70 r E� 0 (D M < E CD 0 U CL CD 0 c0 z m — CY) -0 o Lo M Q E m . T — D 0 co 4 c = D M 2 4 4C2 > c 0 o % O tm - C: 0 < 3: — w b -C 0. E z -0" O .c 2 2 P: 3: 12 U- 2 .4 < 3: x 0 () c > 0 0 z w w E Z U) z U) =- U- W C) O� ui m z > c 0 0 0 -- c U) < 0) > < U) 0 < (-) C: < U) LL Fy , 4) C) < 0 w cc 0 5 LL -J c m >, C) — 0 (D -- 05 w C) Z C� w u w z w '§ Fn -C w (D c C)- 04 CD C14 C14 (1) 4) C:) c CD < c) Z C:) ry 4.0 C14 C\l C14 C14 Ka) QC) o 2�! o a) cy) a) "m a) U-) 2 (D 2 rl- 2 00 I:T It NT I:T It C? C? C? C14 C\l C14 C14 CD CD CD C) C14 C\l C14 C14 r N O N r O r F+ O � r N +�+ O V i Lo CL O M co00 Iq d Cs N co CD co co Lo LO r o O Z O 0 � v � Z V O Lo _ N Q N N m z O Q a Q w 0 O Li w F 0 Q w Q Q w 0 z W z z ry z Z U) O U � O a J CD W Q w Z U j U Q Z w Q < w U O z3: - ~ w w m 0 0� U wU v w J J w dz w CL n O Z) z w > aZF- gQ z O 22WO Q Q C� z O < < Q d w 2 2 O w Z ¢ - J J a lai U w U H a U wJwwmO w �O O w X O z z Q U U o o w w LL = O w W w � � o C) o 0 0 0 V o C) Ci o 0 0 y o o °r° rn o CL N o CL a) 0 0 y Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z Z UWj UWj Z a) W W ui ca W W W ui W W 0 0 W CL CL EL a) a a CL EL a CL J J a r u) O O O L O O O O O O U U O C N N W' 0 '� 3 W' W' 0 06 LO w � C c W W � o O i+ Z Z Q J Z Z J J J Z J J J O r O O o J 0 O -� J J O J J -� o m c 75 75 75 .o c Q 0 -a O a > Q 0 m O U Q O L O O O O W L L N ca VJ O U c _j a-' ca U U — o Z E Q ca L O C: O —J j _0 t0 in CD m � L U) U) �, a > > I..L LOm U)C) J O- '� 00 th C:) 9) 00 00 CO I- C) 0 M M CD � OZ O O O 00 O O (� ,i i co N (n N M N V U N d' U) 06 U ti 0 Co Co aa)) O N— Z (n M N 00 -00 N �i 3 M M 00 N 00 m m CD '� CD co a 00 00 CD CO O 3 Z V N m CO X Co Co U) N N M N N L O W O 0 0 0 70 c o U Q Q L a) C "U a N fl O W E W O U > Q i LO U U- O U (0 co 0 Q Q N 0 X U C Z Z -c Q C) O O o z <La 4- > > a_' C� c (a ° W � U W 0 O O -0 z z 3 z > X z c Z o Z (cl): -I M E � H � =1 a a H ai o a O � J J CL O E } E � } } } ) } > U CD Z c z a) W 3 0 d z O ry 3 z z CL N J D J p w O O a) a o O a o 0 O Q o Q o Q g Q > Q Z E Q = Q c 0 Q Q L c � Q o o U L U 0 ca 0 U_ oo Z - U_ U U -0 W a) W c Z_ c d - H tL U = 0 Li Z Y Z_ G1 JU, 0 C� � � E U Y U 0 � U) U � � � Q U o Q a W ns W W Q W -o W W W O -o Z_ c0 Z c W O _l O _l m a U) ui Q J O a U) J _l O O O ~ U) o U) Q = o W '- W o O = W , O w W x CU ° co � 0 -0 � c a O 0) o "- CL > w 1— 1 '= a) 0 o E Oo o O O O m C) C) C) C) CDIX CD C)C) O IX O O O a) O uj d; N N N N N y N N _ N N N N N c O N N (a N M M }6 M0 M O 0\0 > CO Q•75 � O Cn O M w 0') 0 0') O 0') O 0 cn 0') 0') a) 0') 0 0') O O-) '- p N I- Co Q' 00 " O Q N Q' �T N , Q' O d O Cn (n I- CO ti LO LO co 00 00 N m 00 11- M M Cl) M M M co M t� c� M M M c� O N O N O N O N O N O N O N O N O N O N O N O N o o o o o o o o 0 0 o o o N N N N N N N N N N N N a O C) CD C) C) C) CD CD CD CD CD CDN N N N N N N N N N N N C) (n C) C) 0 C) U) C) -Fo C) C) .- C) C) C) 0C: 0C) C) 0) ch C)C) CD- C) CT C)C) (a) co Cl C14 r C) Qc) C) C-) m E 0) m C) Z Z z z z z z I I m Z z z z z W 0 w w ui w w w w w ui w ca CL CL 2 CL CL CL a) CL CL CL CL CL 4- CL CL 0 cn 0 0 0 0 0 CL m 0 0 0 0 0 CN U) Q o 0 0 0 U) 0 U) U) m 0 � U) UJ c w w ui w Q J z U) z z Z z z z z z (D (D 0 0 (DO 0 0 C� W < 0 w < < E < 73 15 U) m 15 U) 15 3 U) 7 U) U) .C: w E m E _0 0 4- 0 z > 0 W 2 < 2 2 > :s 0) rn < 0 ac ca ca m (13 0 U2: LLco 0 r_ r_ C: >1 7a-) -j _0 -0 CO (n 0 0 0 E Z 0 0) U) C) U) (n m LO LP CN -0 ccf W m z r_ E c) m —CL 0) 4w Y m �o �o ui < C) 7: m 0 L'o = m 0 co E C: -T E C) 0 CO m I:T (D C) 0 It co C\l C) C) LO j,- C-4 E (cor) CD CN C) 0 C14 CY) CL 2 co CN C: < C,4 C'4 CD CD w co (D 0) -0 0) T-- ui C14 0 LU a) . C: co -0 U) c0) .> 4- Cy) Lo 4- co CO >- 0 U) CD 70 C C U) C14 m z C'� "0 cri LO -0 CN 0 Z I C� 4 L? 1. -0 06 m 4 1- co U) co (.0 CD CD -C C) U) LO CY) co CY) 64 E (D CN r-- r-- o r-- 0 co E co Lo w :E- Lo L- _lz 0 0 CL (on) 0 0 0 LO 0 a) T- E 0) U) l< :3 c (14 E 0 = :3 cfl co z z U)0 0 P: C) -C CL < CN 4- m x CL 0 0) 0) a) O� C) D E < < E E V- > > W < V- m 0 ui 0 m F- -i (a CL > W 0 0- CL m z z C: m c W w 70 0 Z x W 0 Z m - z -0 — -,-- — ,-- — 0 W m E O a) UU 0 CL "ci z E (D (D C: C :3 W W z " " w 0 (D o 0 <> .m z o Z Z Z 0 z :3 w Fo '" 0 U) w z 0 0 0 0 0 0 > W 0 w c 0 CL > > C) CD M -0 E U) U CD () C) CD �3 U) 0) 0 C'4 0 C'4 C) C'4 0 0) E < 0 < < < 0 0 < o 0 F- F- (D LL 0 M (D co (D co (D< 0) < U) w D < E < z w -T c, z C:) z CD LL -t LL C: z -j 0) CD P: C) P: CD m w D 0 UJ E 0) F- c F-- CD C) CD CL 0 a 0 x 75 (D 0 m F- a) Z E z < CY) < CF) < 0) >, " 3: x w UJ w C:) O U, w F= ui F= w m Ln U) D i+= T T 4- c C ow 0 -0 C'4 Cj CY) Cj U) Cj < C14 C14 CNJ 0 (3) C:) C) — c) C) p C) 0 C) m C) (,=N) ICN:) c'4 — csj E c:) — 0) !��! 00 C) 0 C) -t 2�! - M2�! 21! 2�! 2�! �C'j 'C) CC'4 a) M CY) = M 75 -,t CO r-- y r-- r-- Q) E OQ u=), cL —m 7 E m M 0 a) 0O M 0 a) 0 M 0 0) (1) 0) c (1) 0) U) 0) (a) a) U) a) U) 0) U) CY) oc) = —0 cy) c ('4 , s Qc) z r < C) r, c 0-) F- , -S (::) -E C,4 co Qc) 0) a) (D co 0) C) C) C) CY) y CY) y CY) y co y m CY) y m v M y v 'IT 6 IT U It C? N O N O N O N O to O N C? N C? N C? N C? to C? N C? C'4 ('4 N N N C'4 C'4 C'4 C'4 N N C'4 C:) 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 CD 0 CD C� 04 C14 04 N CN CN CN CN 04 N CN rn C) 0 C) C) CY) C) rl- 00 C) 00C) vi C) C14 C\T Z z z z z z z z z z z z z w w ui w w w ui w w ui w w w ca CL CL IL CL CL CL IL CL CL IL CL CL CL U) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 CN Q w w ui w w w ui w w ui w w w Z Q 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Co U) U) co co U) U) U) U) U) U) U) U) 7 75 75 75 75 CL _0 C) ry C) C) C) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 E (1) U) U) (1) (1) (1) U) U) (1) (n (n U) C)CD 10 ) CD 0. 00 E r,- E co E m a) I- v) E E m E NE E NE O C) 0 C) 0 C) 0 (14 C) C) 0 C) 0 C) 0 C) 0 C) 0 0 L- co E 2 co2 (o 2 , N (o 2 (D 2 (D 2 (D 2 (D 2 -,1- 2 I U) 0 0) 0) 0) 00 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 1,- 400 T-- 0 C: c c c c c c c — m .> .> 7 4 5: 5; 5; 5: 5: > Im>, c> 6 C: NT = 4- Z -C IT -C or) "t C U-) C: Lr) C CO(D C co C C: co o 0 I C,4 0) co L F "t :t-- 4 4L6 :t-- 4 :tf L6 :t-- 4c; 1. 1. co CD CD C5 =5 " 6 = 6 CD C5 6 C5 C5 6 C5 C5 o [-- " [-- I— 1-- 6 1-- 1-- 1-- [-- I-- I,- 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 co co 0 C: 0 E CL 0) 0 CL E E E E E E E E 0 CL 0- CL CL a 0. .I-- -C ZCL — C — O — (-) I) 000l) Z z z z z z z '15 U) Z) D Z) Z) D D(D (D C: (D -C: (D -C (D 0- -j C) 0 C (D C: (D C (D C (D C (D C: Z Z Z z < Z Z Z Z Z Z Z ;> 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 U) > 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 CD CD C) 0 Z CD CD C) CD CD CD C) N0 C'4 CD 0 CN C) CN C) 00 - C) CN 0 N0 NC) N C) N C) Nz z z z 0) Z E < z z z z z < < M r,--0) < < <--j F- F- F- < F- < ui F- F- F- F- Q F- Q F- 0 ho 0 ho (D ho (D co (D (D (- .�) W (D co 0 co 0 m 0 co 0 co (D ED Z_ CD z c, z c, z C:) z uc, z C) z CD z c, z C:) z CD z CD z CD CD P: CD P: CD P: — LO ui -Fa P: CD P: CD P: C) P: CD P: CD P: CD CD CD CD C) o F- P--- () 0) CD CD C) CD CD CD < m < 0) < 0) < 0-) < 7 z < CD < CY) < CY) < m < m < 0) >, w -F w F= ui F= w -F 0 m w < UJ c w -F w j= ui -F w -F w -F w -F= S2 47- U) LL (D L Ln 4- 0 (N N N (N :tf (N (3) NN N N N :tf C'4 :t-- ('4 :t-- C'4 :t-- C) CD CD p p p m b C:) o c) C:) C:) r- r-- I-- r- C) C:) c) C:) c) C:) CD 0') 0') M 0') 0') 0 0') M 0') 0') o) o) o) o) CY) NLO (10 00 a) , r, 00 0-) C:) C'4 C) CD C) C) a) m C) C) C) It I- It It CO M 'T "ZT I- 'T "ZT "ZT R R ca 0 w (a 0 w w (a 0 w (a 0 E w 0 0) w 0 0) 0) w 0 0) w 0 C'4 C'4 a C�j a C'4 a C'4 a C'4 a CJ a C'4 a C�.j a C�j a C'4 a C'4 a C'4 C:) C) CD CD CD CD CD CD CD CD CD C) C) 0- C'4 C\l C\l CNJ CNJ CNJ C\l CNJ CNJ C\l CNJ CNJ CNJ E>, 0M C m C C C) w m C) 00 Z C) C) Lo CL CO C) W a , U) CN 00 < (0 O ui ui O m (n U) z 0 z z z z z Z O z z 3: z Z m w ui w w ui w UJ w w w w CL ca CL a a CL CL CL a CL CL CL a- cis 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o CN Q m o M m U) 0) 0 W w w ui w Z) C E 0 U) Q *� " < 0 0 0 0 0 U) CX. W < W :3 W m CL R C6 U) U) U) U) U) 75- O = X--0 06 75; 73 75; 75 73 75 75 0 4- 75; ui LO > w > 0 z U) 4 < :3 0 0 < CD OC) 0 UJ -C z -C C z U) 4) w U) 0 0 0 0 0 0 .0 U) W 0 U) 0 0 0 0 0 CL.1- Nw > -j U) 0 U) (1) U) U) (1) Q t 0 C) m 0� -0 o " a) CL >- 0 < 06 z 0 = 0 x O LO :t'- Lo > cD E oo E co E �t E c,4 E C14 o C) 0 E r CO-- L LO LO C) U) 0 C) 0 CD 0 CD 0 C) 0 C) 3: c C) C14 �t �= — co co 2 T 2 ,T 2 T 2 -,T 2 00 C) m CD 0) 0) 0) 0) 0) 04 E W E -0 coc) > 00 CY) Lh 400 m > 0)-C C-) C) 4- Im Z 0 U) m cli LO >, 0 CD P E 0 -o c c o N (1) c9 00 E 00 o 0 Z U) C? -, - - - - cli CL I :t-- A :tf x 6 . _j 1. 1 c I c I c 1 0 - . U) -C 1 1. 1. m r_ r-� r-_: 10, cn 6 (n LO 0 "t 64 w U.) c co E ED co Em "0 "0 "0 "0 " co -Q'z) 0 E ro (10 C) LO Fu CL L- D .= 0 0 0 0 0 a -le 0 CL, _0 C, 0 LO 0 0- _0 70 70 70 -0 Z aj (a) CN (3) X T- 070 0 -0 U) -0 -0 CL c 4) 0 C.) 0- (ai m 00 U) Of (2) c C) 0 0) a) 0) 0) 0) 0 a)< CO 3:WE E E E E 0 E ce) :r C: (a m m m M U) It 0) :r En 0. a 0. 0. CL < m 0) c 0 c CD (a m m m (a a) 0) (D C) (a CD Z 0) U) LU cy) -C -C 75; Z 0 -C :tf z o 0 0 0 o 0 m -0 C() 0 m m m m (a " c 0 p: m---C-C 0) 0 z W< 0)— — 0) x (D 0 CL (a 0 (D (D (D (D C: (D C: (D c > 0 z z z m -0 75 -j 0 Z m (a 0 w m 0 o 0 o 0 o 0 o 0 0 0 O� 0 (2) > > > > > 75; 0) C " 0 C) () -C z C) CD CD CD C:) 0 (2) Z) > 0 0 C'4 0 04 0 CN 0 CN 0 C,4 _j (a) -C -0 C) (a M z U) E Z , o Z z z z z z CL < 0 D < < < < 0) 3: 0 X n < F- F- F- F- F- < c U) 0 (a < C J U 0) (D E o (D co (D co (D co (D co (D co LL -0 rn :5 o < (D -C C-)D U) Z Z 20 Z C:) Z CD Z CD Z CD Z C) WX Z Z CL — U) — C:) P: CD P: CD P: CD P: C) 0 P: (a LL C,4 F- C:) CD CD CD C) ui CL < U, < 0-) < CD < 0) < 0) < 0 CO > 0) >1 ui ` E ui ui -F Lu 'i= ui 'i= ui -F 6 -o ui ui 2 x 0 Lo (a m ui :o -0 0 p 0 0 -C m 0 m (n U) En En (n 0 U) C14 a) C\l :tf C14 :tl_ C\l :tl_ C\l :tl_ C14 :tf C,4 3: x C,4 , C,4 m C14 C'4 C) c CD CD C) C) C) C) a) C) C) C) 0) C) c) m 21! N 21! N N N c N = N a) N N CD C) C) C) C) C) C) M CD = 0 CY) CY) C,4 m CNI M CNJ M CSJ M C-4 M 04 M 04 -0 0 04 04 -�5 - - = CL E -cT, CL 0') -M -V) 0') CD m 0') V) 0') :3 w o) w 0') a) 0') w o) o co co ,t u-) (.o r-- u-) m Of v) p , � CN r, 0') r- CN CN CY) CN cr) CY) v � v � Z; � v � I? C'4 C-4 0 04 04 0 04 04 0 C-4 04 0 04 04 0 C'4 C'4 C'4 C'4 C:) C) C) C) C) C) C) C) C) CD CD N CN C14 C\l C*4 CN CN CN CN CN CN = C:) C) C) C) 0 C) C) C) C� U) CO C:) C) C) C) C) C) I- -�e U) c C-) 7R O C4 00 :3 NT Lr) C) a) 0 C\l _0 0(13 4- 0 -0 Eto W Z z z z z z z z 0 z z z w w w w ui w w ui z w ui W C: m CL CL CL CL CL CL CL CL CL IL CL U) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 —(3) 0 0 0 0 C14 Q 0 0 0 CL 0 u U) U) U) U) U) Z) w w U) (3) L. Z) D 0 — -�e D Z) w E 0 o 0 z z z z z z z z Z D- (D o c E 0 (D (D LL 0 0 4) < < < 0 ui -0 < < ."U) 0 CL 7-> U) 75 75 0 U) U) U) ns U) 0 .C: X co x < w Co C: r) 4) ry 0 ce) Co m a) (a U) = — u) U) ca -0 Z C-) U) > C: ai m 2 C: X W —M ca 2 0) CL a) U) m " Z) w E 7E =5 3: m LL co 0 0) a) �Q-) m w Q) .j CD C) 4) cr) LO co co -0 0 06 [,- C�j cy) CD LO 0-) C14 CL C\l CNJ --.:- CD 0') CNJ CNJ NT C\l cr) CN LO co U) CD CO CL(a CC) C14 cy? " -0 0) 4- Im 0) (Y) 0 LO I:T C: c) 0 Z OP Lr) 4-0 0- C,1 4 (Y I (Y I) 0- (1) co C14 co U') co CO co 0 co(Y)E U) oi C6 'T Qc) It CO(D r— COCD .,t F.0 C14 0) co [1- 0)— co E C: 4- 0 IL 0 -C 0 c 0 Z F- (14 0 0 U70 w C: < 0- -C ce) C'4 ry -C CL -C CD 4- w 0 C) 0- 0 CD 0 w U) 0 CY) CD D z c: Ica w 0 z U) 0 U) 0 U) U) CL U) W -d5 C m (D E Z < C: C: U) :3 Z < > < 0 z CL 2 -0 ui 0 > c: CL U) 0 z o M " 3: — a) co U) .C: W z C: CL C) >- -2 c 0 o w U) U) 0 z E W 4- 0) C: c W a w Z 0 _0 - 0 C,4 75 U) > 0 -0 c E 0 -j C M E2 0) Z a) (D 0 < E Z CT P:< 4- < E c:E 0 E < < E < >-2 0 x < c- 0 0 C) (D (D U) < W E (3:' Z 4c-�U) (1) w w E Z C:) U) 4- C) CD 2 7�; 0 C) U) 0 0 0 C:) P: co 0 0 0 0 0) 75; " ui (D W U) < >, o w C,4 1� z -�5 CL w o CL o 0 0 0 ui w (a-j E W CS a) 0- w C: C'4 0 U) UJ " .(n m o �: m m 0) - (a — C14 E 0) 4- CD C14 C,4 C14 m C14 0 C\l C,4 0 C'4 C\J X M 04 C: C\l C 04 M C) C) 0 E C:) C:) 0) C) C) —0 C:) 0) C:) 0) C:) C:) C) C) C < !��! 4- !Z, ._ 21! - 2�! ! C: > cD E — > -0 > > (.0 0) 0) � CNJ E"t — CNJ E C\l -o CNJ 0 CNJ 0 1- 0 1- CO c 00 0 00 0') m 0.) C) a) C,4 C,4 M x 75_ M E c.\] -0:3 c \].4 c? c. c4 E u) -0 0') U) 0') CD 0 0) 0') a) a) 0) M = 0) a) a) 0) m 0 0-) a) m cn 0) 0) T a) co 'I- d U U) C:) 0 C:) Of ':T a- 0-) to , of C\l of 0 1, Of CD (D of o.:E C14 0') C14 co co C14 co C\l co 0') It v C') LO "t v -'4- vZT -'4- v co CY) E o o o o C:) C'4 C'4 C'4 C'4 CZJ C'4 C'4 CJ C'4 N C'4 CD CD CD C) C) C) C) C) C) C) C) 0- C,4 CNJ CNJ CNJ CN CNJ CNJ CN CNJ CN CNJ 0 Z z w w m CL r) A� U) 0 0 CN Q � T- QO 0 Q CL 2 a .SQ � / -0 0 ry 3 \ k U) E 0 Co , < C) 4) C) -0 cc) LO FA co C-4 U) C) m 0 C'� 3: C:) 4- im>- LO C14 0 0 Z U) I U) (D m co -: 0- 0) 'T c E co cn co 0 LO 0) a. > 0 CL '0CL '0(" c: R ry w w CL 0 (D 2 (D Z Z 0 75 n 75 CL E CL -j E -j < C) < z Z 4) w -C w 0 CL w f-- "X0-w -C I-- C14 a) C14 0) CD a) CD 0) U) 21.! U) m cy) C) m a) CD 0) U) cy) mEn 'a) 2 0-) 0') CN CY) NT C'4 C'4 C:) C) 0- C'4 CN r N O N r O r � r (Q N C C� hN CO) 00 C0 Iq c� mT" 4) F- O N � M ti � � N N CD N CO 0 2 Z N U cti 3z � O `O _ N N CD a N Cs Z J z O Q E O z o P: Q< O F Q w w Q w Q z o z ~ ~ O W W z U) U cn OUJ a � uW Q uW Z U Q Z o Q Z S _I H Z (n cow � ow Z � Z OWW E W W W CL J Z U W W J J O Q Z -r Q � Z O U Q W OQ H z < < Q < Z z W LlJ a 2 U 2 W W Z Z Q w W 0 0 0 2 0 O w W _l X W W w a a O z z w3: U 0 o w W U- 0 = 0 0 W w w H H Town of Ithaca 10/1/2021 215 N. Tioga Street Ithaca, NY 14850 Certificates Issued From: 9/1/2021 To: 9/30/2021 Cert. # Date Type Temp SBL Legal Address Inspector Status 2021-0337 9/1/2021 CC 44.-1-14 27 Whitetail Dr DMAGNUSO ISSUED Permit Type: ELECTRICAL ONLY 2021-0295 9/2/2021 CC 44.-1-98 176 Whitetail Dr DMAGNUSO ISSUED Permit Type: ROOFING 2021-0290 9/2/2021 CO 39.-1-1.1 950 Danby Rd DMAGNUSO ISSUED Permit Type: COMMERCIAL RENOVATION/ALT 2019-0523 9/2/2021 CC 31.-2-21.2 681 Five Mile Dr DMAGNUSO ISSUED Permit Type: ELECTRICAL ONLY 2021-0367 9/2/2021 CC 68.-1-9 213-215 Warren Rd MSTONIER ISSUED Permit Type: TEMPORARY MEMBRANE STRU 2020-0512 9/3/2021 CC 60.-1-34.5 1336 SLATERVILLE ROAD MKELLY ISSUED Permit Type: ROOFING 2021-0362 9/3/2021 CO 30.-2-8 506 Five Mile Dr DMAGNUSO ISSUED Permit Type: CHANGE OF USE 2021-0025 9/7/2021 CC X 21.-2-8 1075 TAUGHANNOCK BOU MKELLY ISSUED Permit Type: ELECTRICAL ONLY 2021-0389 9/8/2021 Cert of C X 21.-2-8 1075 Taughannock Blvd JHULL ISSUED Permit Type: ELECTRICAL ONLY 2020-0357 9/9/2021 CO 26.-1-2 156 BUNDY ROAD MKELLY ISSUED Permit Type: SINGLE FAMILY RENOVATION/A 2021-0229 9/9/2021 CO 52.-2-3 130 NORTHVIEW ROAD MKELLY ISSUED Permit Type: SINGLE FAMILY RENOVATION/A 2021-0390 9/10/2021 Cert of C X 24.-1-2 181 Iradell Rd JHULL ISSUED Permit Type: ELECTRICAL ONLY 2021-0227 9/10/2021 CC 72.-1-1.134 108 Brandywine Dr JHULL ISSUED Permit Type: ROOFING 2021-0101 9/13/2021 CO 72.-1-1.135 110 Brandywine Dr MSTONIER ISSUED Permit Type: SINGLE FAMILY RENOVATION/A 2020-0548 9/13/2021 CO 44.-2-7.3 161 King Road East DMAGNUSO ISSUED Permit Type: SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE NE 2021-0090 9/13/2021 CO 44.-2-7.3 161 King Road East DMAGNUSO ISSUED Permit Type: FOUNDATION ONLY 2021-0292 9/15/2021 CO 41.-1-30.2 148 Conservatory Dr DMAGNUSO ISSUED Permit Type: COMMERCIAL RENOVATION/ALT Page 1 of 4 Town of Ithaca 10/1/2021 215 N. Tioga Street Ithaca, NY 14850 Certificates Issued From: 9/1/2021 To: 9/30/2021 Cert. # Date Type Temp SBL Legal Address Inspector Status 2021-0292 9/15/2021 CO 41.-1-30.2 148 Conservatory Dr DMAGNUSO ISSUED Permit Type: COMMERCIAL RENOVATION/ALT 2021-0235 9/17/2021 CC 37.-1-6.1 215 King Rd W DMAGNUSO ISSUED Permit Type: ROOFING 2020-0199 9/17/2021 CC 70.-4-6 601 Winston Ct MSTONIER ISSUED Permit Type: HEATING AND COOLING UNIT 2020-0200 9/17/2021 CC 70.-4-4 605 Winston Ct MSTONIER ISSUED Permit Type: HEATING AND COOLING UNIT 2021-0299 9/20/2021 CC 71.-1-56 104 Kay St MSTONIER ISSUED Permit Type: HEATING AND COOLING UNIT 2019-0458 9/20/2021 CC 36.-2-3.47 112 Larisa Ln DMAGNUSO ISSUED Permit Type: POOL AND SPA 2019-0461 9/20/2021 ELECTRI 36.-2-3.47 112 Larisa Ln DMAGNUSO ISSUED Permit Type: ELECTRICAL ONLY 2020-0015 9/21/2021 CO 63.-1-8.1 161 Synchrotron Dr MSTONIER ISSUED Permit Type: COMMERCIAL RENOVATION/ALT 2021-0070 9/21/2021 CC 63.-1-8.1 161 Synchrotron Dr MSTONIER ISSUED Permit Type: ELECTRICAL ONLY 2021-0075 9/21/2021 CC 63.-1-8.1 161 Synchrotron Dr MSTONIER ISSUED Permit Type: ELECTRICAL ONLY 2021-0285 9/21/2021 CC 63.-1-8.1 161 Synchrotron Dr MSTONIER ISSUED Permit Type: ELECTRICAL ONLY 2019-0743 9/21/2021 CC 24.-3-2.1 91-301 Harris B Dates Dr MSTONIER ISSUED Permit Type: COMMERCIAL RENOVATION/ALT 2018-0349 9/21/2021 CO 63.-1-8.1 161 Synchrotron Dr MSTONIER ISSUED Permit Type: COMMERCIAL RENOVATION/ALT 2021-0353 9/21/2021 CC 67.-1-2.1 121 Pleasant Grove Rd MSTONIER ISSUED Permit Type: TEMPORARY MEMBRANE STRU 2021-0345 9/21/2021 CO 22.-2-2.12 9 Orchard Hill Rd JHULL ISSUED Permit Type: SOLAR 2021-0321 9/27/2021 CC 70.-12-13 1419 Hanshaw Rd MSTONIER ISSUED Permit Type: ELECTRICAL ONLY 2021-0320 9/29/2021 CC 24.-3-2.1 101 Harris B Dates Dr MSTONIER ISSUED Permit Type: ELECTRICAL ONLY Page 2 of 4 Town of Ithaca 10/1/2021 215 N. Tioga Street Ithaca, NY 14850 Certificates Issued From: 9/1/2021 To: 9/30/2021 Cert. # Date Type Temp SBL Legal Address Inspector Status 2021-0028 9/29/2021 TCO X 31.-5-1.2 325 Bostwick Rd DMAGNUSO ISSUED Permit Type: SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE NE Page 3 of 4 10/1/2021 Town of Ithaca 215 N. Tioga Street Ithaca, NY 14850 Certificate Report Totals by Type and Status From: 9/1/2021 To: 9/30/2021 Certificate Type Certificate Status Count CC 19 Cert of Compliance - Electrical Only 2 CO 12 ELECTRICAL ONLY CC 1 TCO 1 Total: 35 ISSUED 35 Page 4 of 4 Town of Ithaca 10/1/2021 215 N. Tioga Street Ithaca, NY 14850 Complaints Received Report From: 9/1/2021 To: 9/30/2021 Date Type Tax Parcel # Legal Address Disposition 9/2/2021 LOCAL LAW 70.-4-6 601 Winston Ct OPEN Desc: AC units installed in buildings 606, 608, 610, 612,412 without obtaining permits. 601 and 605 have permits expired on 6/29/2021-failed to renew after two renewal letters sent. Dumpster blocking fire access by building 611. 9/9/2021 FIRE SAFETY VIOLATIONS 101 Harris B Dates Dr OPEN Desc: Steam plant alarm system transmitting fire alarms to alarm co. but the panel is clear upon IFD arrival, 2x. SEE DOCS 9/14/2021 BUILDING WITHOUT A PER 58.-1-23 1427 Slaterville Rd OPEN Desc: House recently had new metal roof installed without a Permit. LS Roofing sign at road. 9/17/2021 BUILDING WITHOUT A PER 26.-4-18 131 Hillcrest Dr OPEN Desc: House appears to be in the stripped for remodeling based on photos online. A BP application was withdrawn previously for similar work. See docucment section 9/17/2021 BUILDING WITHOUT A PER 16.-2-1 7 Renwick Dr OPEN Desc: Observed work being conducted without a permit. 9/17/2021 BUILDING WITHOUT A PER 17.-3-25.12 25 Renwick Heights Rd ABATED Desc: Observation of work without a permit. 9/17/2021 BUILDING WITHOUT A PER 33.-3-8.18 4 Peachtree Ln CLOSED Desc: I was in the neighborhood (14 Peachtree Ln.) following up on a complaint and saw contractors working on a roof without a BP. Top Notch Contracting. I spoke with contractor William Marks who called his boss J.R. and put him on speaker phone. I told J.R to fill out the Application online and pay the double fee this Monday. He said he would do just that. I also spoke with homeowner's daughter Barb Singleton who was sitting on the front porch when I pulled up. 9/20/2021 FIRE SAFETY VIOLATIONS 103 Bundy Rd OPEN Desc: Alarm in Building B. the building has been renumbered, but the fire alarm panel addresses are still old. Finally found the alarm in a small utility room in the interior of the building with an activated smoke head. Attempted to replace the head but it was jammed in its base. Left the system in alarm and silenced Contacted staff. 256-5094. SEE DOCS 9/20/2021 BUILDING WITHOUT A PER 25.-2-19 883 Taughannock Blvd OPEN Desc: Neighbor is reporting that excavating and work around a shared retaining wall has begun. For more info, please see complaint form in document section 9/23/2021 LOCAL LAW 21.-2-16 1045 Taughannock Blvd OPEN Desc: Neighbor reports that a deck is being built and believes it is too close to his property line. We do not have a permit app for the deck. Page 1 of 3 Town of Ithaca 10/1/2021 215 N. Tioga Street Ithaca, NY 14850 Complaints Received Report From: 9/1/2021 To: 9/30/2021 Date Type Tax Parcel # Legal Address Disposition 9/24/2021 PROPERTY MAINTENANCE OPEN Desc: 9/24/2021 ZONING VIOLATION 33.-2-3.1 180 Calkins Rd OPEN Desc: violating the Laws of Home Occupation wit a tarp and parked car (red/burundy) parked accross garage doors. 9/30/2021 BUILDING WITHOUT A PER 33.-1-11 210 Enfield Falls Rd OPEN Desc: Appears work is being done without a permit. Page 2of3 10/1/2021 Town of Ithaca 215 N. Tioga Street Ithaca, NY 14850 Complaints Report From: 9/1/2021 To: 9/30/2021 Totals by Complaint Type & Status ComplaintType Complaint Status Count BUILDING WITHOUT A PERMIT 7 FIRE SAFETY VIOLATIONS 2 LOCAL LAW 2 PROPERTY MAINTENANCE 1 ZONING VIOLATION 1 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Total: 13 ABATED 1 CLOSED 1 OPEN 11 Page 3 of 3 Town of Ithaca 10/1/2021 215 N. Tioga Street Ithaca, NY 14850 Complaints Closed Report From: 9/1/2021 To: 9/30/2021 Date Type Tax Parcel # Legal Address Disposition 9/17/2021 BUILDING WITHOUT A PER 33.-3-8.18 4 Peachtree Ln CLOSED Desc: I was in the neighborhood (14 Peachtree Ln.) following upon a complaint and saw contractors working on a roof without a BP. Top Notch Contracting. I spoke with contractor William Marks who called his boss J.R. and put him on speaker phone. I told J.R to fill out the Application online and pay the double fee this Monday. He said he would do just that. I also spoke with homeowner's daughter Barb Singleton who was sitting on the front porch when I pulled up. Page 1 of 2 10/1/2021 Town of Ithaca 215 N. Tioga Street Ithaca, NY 14850 Complaints Report From: 9/1/2021 To: 9/30/2021 Totals by Complaint Type & Status ComplaintType Complaint Status Count BUILDING WITHOUT A PERMIT 1 Total: 1 CLOSED 1 Page 2 of 2