HomeMy WebLinkAbout2011-09-08-STB Town of Ulysses
Special Board Meeting
September 8 , 2011
Present : Supervisor Roxanne Marino ; Councilpersons Kevin Romer, David Kerness,
Lucia Tyler and Elizabeth Thomas ; Highway Superintendent James Meeker; Deputy
Clerk Patricia Halloran.
1 Truck Purchase
Mr. Meeker explained the opportunity and condition of the truck he would like to
purchase from the Town of Ithaca for $20,000 . He feels this is very good opportunity.
Mr. Meeker explained the advantage of used over new.
The Board discussed this and Ms . Marino moved, seconded by Ms . Tyler the following:
BE IT RESOLVED that the Town Board of the Town of Ulysses approve the
purchase of the 2000 Volvo single-action truck with plow equipment, dump
box/spreader unit from the Town of Ithaca in the amount of $20, 000.
Ms . Marino aye
Ms . Tyler aye
Ms . Thomas aye
Mr. Romer aye
Mr. Kerness aye
Adopted
Mr. Meeker will require a letter from the Supervisor approving the purchase of this truck
addressed to the Town of Ithaca to be delivered by September 9, 2011 .
Amend 2003 Water Agreement
Ms . Marino said that the Town Board, in the resolution agreeing to pay the Town of
Ithaca for the outstanding water bills, that we also agreed to work on a joint committee
with the Town of Ithaca to amend the 2003 Water Agreement, specifically to share the
cost of the un-accounted for water. The Town of Ithaca' s supervisor emailed Ms . Marino
and said that they have their three people ready to meet. Ms. Marino said that she, Mr.
Austic and Michael Boggs, WD3 Water Commissioner will participate.
Agenda Items for September 13, 2011
Ms. Marino introduced a Resolution/Local Law to override the State of New York
mandated tax cap that she will present at the Regular Town Board meeting on the
September 13 `h
Ms . Marino reviewed with the Board a spreadsheet she prepared to help the Board
understand the budget figures for the Fire/EMS services .
Ms . Marino moved, seconded by Ms . Thomas the following resolution: * * The following
resolution is the corrected resolution to be sent to the Village of Trumansburg.
RESOLUTION TO RESOLVE PROVISION OF EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT
SERVICES WITH THE VILLAGE OF TRUMANSBURG FOR THE YEAR 2012
WHEREAS the Village of Trumansburg severed the ambulance service from the Fire
Protection District (FPD) as of as of April 11 , 2011 and created the new Trumansburg
Emergency Medical Services Department (TEMSD) ; and
WHEREAS on June 13 , 2011 the Village of Trumansburg adopted an EMS Billing
Policy requiring all patients within the Village limits to be billed for emergency medical
Town of Ulysses — Special Board Meeting 2
9/8/2011
services in order to reduce the amount of municipal funding needed to run the TEMSD ;
and
WHEREAS the above changes to the Village of Trumansburg EMS service and the
timing of the above actions and subsequent availability of information necessary to form
an Ambulance District under the procedures of Town Law did not allow the Town of
Ulysses the option of creating an Ambulance District with an ad valorem tax levy to pay
for an EMS contract in 2012 , and
WHEREASithis leaves the Town of Ulysses with the following, limited options for EMS
service in the 2012 budget year:
a) Contract with the Village (TEMSD) for Town-wide service which by NYS
law must include the Village, and would require the following :
• The Town to accept the current policies and charges with no official way to
amend them as all agree will be necessary over the coming 1 — 2 years,
• OR the Village to agree formally to work with the Town in a cooperative
and meaningful way to develop a shared decision-making structure to
review and amend the policies and charges, which the two municipalities
have thus far not been able to negotiate, and
• A change from 2011 in distribution of financing of the EMS with taxes
such that the total tax rate to Town residents (outside the Village) residents
would increase by —p11 % for 2012 . Funds for a Town-wide contract can
only be raised in the General Fund, resulting in a large overall increase in
the town-wide tax levy. This would require a local Town law to override
the newly enacted NYS tax cap law.
b) Request that the Village structure provision of EMS in two ways for 2012 , and
Provide an ambulance service as part of the Fire District Protection District in
addition to the TEMSD, as proposed by the TEMSD attorney Brad Pinsky
(8/29/ 11 meeting) as feasible. The Town (outside the Village) could then
contract for both EMS and fire protection in 2012 as part of the Fire ,
Protection District, as is currently done . With this option:
• Taxes for Town (outside the Village) residents would stay relatively level
for 2012 , as the cost would be raised with an ad valorem FPD tax as in
2011 .
• Patients receiving ambulance service originating in the Village would be
billed for ambulance service by the TEMSD in 2012 ; patients receiving
service originating in the Town of Ulysses would not.
c) Take no action, with the following consequences :
• There would be no contract for EMS services in the Town (outside the
Village) , and as such no taxes raised for EMS in 2012 .
• Residents would still call 911 in emergencies, and the closest available in-
service ambulance would be dispatched; all patients would be charged for
the service at the billing rates of the provider.
• Service in the northern part of Ulysses will likely be negatively affected,
due to longer response times.
• The Village (and any other Towns contracting with the TEMSD) would
need to pay more for EMS in 2012 and the long-term sustainability of the
TEMSD could be jeopardized, as the Town of Ulysses contract currently
supports 48% of the EMS budget.
• Town taxes would go down for 2012, but then jump up in 2013 if an
Ambulance District is formed, or if option (a) above is enacted.
And WHEREAS the Ulysses Town Board believes strongly that it is in the best interest
of the residents of the Town including the Village to negotiate and enter into agreements
for municipal cooperation and provision of shared services to maintain the quality and
availability of services within the property tax cap constraints and as resources available
to municipalities shrink in times of financial stress, and
I 1
Town of Ulysses — Special Board Meeting 3
9/8/2011
WHEREAS New York State government encourages such inter-municipal cooperation
and provides specific mechanisms in General Municipal Law for municipalities to adopt
agreements to share services, resources, and the associated costs,
BE IT THEREFORE RESOLVED that the Ulysses Town Board finds that the most
feasible and best overall option for providing ambulance service to town residents for
2012 is (b) above, in conjunction with establishing an Intermunicipal Managing
Cooperative and working toward implementation of a billing policy to offset future costs
to taxpayers .
}
As such, the TOWN OF ULYSSES REQUESTS THAT the Village of Trumansburg
work with the TEMSD attorney to provide a draft contract and cost to the Town for
combined ambulance and fire protection services in the Fire Protection District for FY
2012 .
Due to NYS legal requirements and the timing constraints of the Town budgeting
process, the Town Board needs the contract and cost information by September 27`h at the
latest for inclusion into the Tentative budget, and by October 17th for consideration of
inclusion in the preliminary and final budgets .
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED THAT the Ulysses Town Board requests that the Village
of Trumansburg amend its Inter-Municipal Managing Cooperative Policy for TEMSD
(adopted by the Village Board 8/ 15/2011 ) for contracting municipalities to the text stated
below or other mutually agreed upon language that incorporates the intent of shared
responsibility and decision-making, and that the Village inform the Town of their
decision in this matter at the time of presentation of a 2012 contract for consideration.
An inter-municipal managing cooperative as proposed below will ensure that the voices
of all of the population who fund and are served by this service are heard and will share
the municipal burdens of maintaining this valuable community service. Further, it is a
strong starting point towards a broader inter-municipal cooperation and cost-sharing
agreement for provision of emergency services that will benefit the residents of the Town
of Ulysses / Village of Trumansburg into the future .
For 2013 , the Town is committed to exploring options and details for forming an inter-
municipal shared services agreement for EMS with the Village of Trumansburg that
might include a town-wide contract or the establishment of an Ambulance District.
Further, the Town commits to establishing a billing procedure for funding a portion of the
EMS services and that meets NYS legal requirements .
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
INTER-MUNICIPAL MANAGING COOPERATIVE FOR BILLING POLICIES
& GUIDELINES FOR THE TRUMANSBURG EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT
SERVICES DEPARTMENT.
The Inter-Municipal Managing Cooperative (hereafter "IMMC") shall be an inter-
municipal committee charged with reviewing and making recommendations on the
billing policy, accounting policy, charity policies, fee schedules, and annual budget of the
Trumansburg Emergency Management Services Department (TEMSD) . Daily
operational decisions and oversight of TEMSD performance will be maintained by the
Village of Trumansburg.
The IMMC will consist of representatives from each municipality as they contract with
Trumansburg Emergency Management Service Department for service. Representation
shall be determined by each municipality' s level of use of the Trumansburg TEMSD . The
voting members of the IMMC (assuming continued participation of all 2011
municipalities) shall be : two members from the Village of Trumansburg Board, two
members from the Town of Ulysses Board, and one member each from the Towns of
Covert and Hector Boards, with advisory positions of the TEMSD Manager,
Trumansburg Fire Company EMS Volunteer, and TEMSD Compliance Officer.
Town of Ulysses — Special Board Meeting 4
9/8/2011
All of the discussions and recommendations of the IMMC that address TEMSD policies
and finances shall be open to the public . Discussions pertaining to individual patients or
EMS staff will be confidential . Meetings will be recorded and minutes including
decisions and a brief summary of IMMC discussions taken and maintained by the Village
as a record. Recommendations to the Village Board will be made by majority vote of a
quorum of the seated IMMC members . The rules of procedure of the Committee and the
Committee Chair shall be decided by majority vote of the Committee. IMMC meetings
will be held every 4 months, and additionally as determined by the IMMC as necessary.
Duly passed recommendations of the IMMC will be adopted by the Village Board as
policy unless overturned by a supermajority (4/5 ) vote of such Board, accompanied by a
short statement of findings in support of the decision.
Members serving on this IMMC have a serious role in determining the policies governing
billing, fee schedules and charity policies of emergency services and as such will commit
to reading and understanding all information and communications to adequately address
issues surrounding emergency medical services as they arise.
Ms . Marino aye
Ms . Tyler aye
Ms. Thomas aye
Mr. Romer aye
Mr. Kerness aye
Adopted
Re-cap of Agenda items for the Regular Town Board meeting.
• Budget 2012
• Local Law Tax Override Cap
• Healthcare
• Presentation from Tim Bangs
Hearing no further business, Ms. Marino moves, seconded by Mr. Romer to adjourn the
meeting. Unanimously approved. Meeting adjourned at 10 : 13 p .m.
Respectfully submitted,
Marsha L. Georgia
Ulysses Town Clerk
PH :mlg
I