HomeMy WebLinkAboutTownBoard_Minutes_20150720Danby Town Board
Minutes of Regular Meeting
July 20, 2015
Present:
Supervisor: Ric Dietrich
Councilpersons: Rebecca Brenner, Leslie Connors, Jim Holahan, Jack Miller
Others Present:
Town Clerk Pamela Goddard
Code Officers CJ Randall
Public Ted Crane, Ronda Roaring, Garry Huddle, Lewis Billington, Michael Casper, Jill
Marie, John Van de Mark
The Danby Town Board Meeting was opened at 7:05pm
Privilege of the Floor
John Van de Mark raised several concerns regarding road repair and property flooding. He expressed
concern on behalf of a resident at 19 Gunderman Road whose home and property has flooded several
times in the past several years. He believes that the problem may be a partial result of an inadequate sluice
pipe/culvert at White Hawk Lane. Dietrich responded that White Hawk Village is aware that the culvert
system under their road requires redesign. An engineering report has been received that supports the
rebuild of the system. Van de Mark also noted an increase in problems after a redesign of the Jennings
Pond dam. Van de Mark asked who would be paying for the damages to this property?
Dietrich responded, describing serious drainage problems and resulting catastrophic losses across the
Town. Danby experienced at least $400,000 worth of damage to infrastructure, not including damage to
private property. This did not meet the FEMA threshold for damage support. Therefore, there is no
funding support for private property repairs. The cost of repairs for Town roads will have to come from
the Town budget. Funding repairs will be a challenge for the upcoming budget cycle. The Town has
written letters to the State to see if aid is available. Dietrich stated that he is meeting with the Highway
Department on reassessing several roads and putting together a plan for triage on the worst damage.
Dietrich noted that Stormwater Management is a top issue in Tompkins County and the Town of
Danby. Efforts are underway to better understand drainage problems and to assess where remediation is
needed. He invited Planner CJ Randall to add information. She described projects underway through the
Stormwater Coalition to understand and address the situation in a holistic manner.
Van de Mark also expressed concerns regarding potholes which have not been fixed in months. He
asked whether the Highway Department budget was sufficient for needed repairs? Dietrich noted that the
Board is not holding up funds for road repairs. He suggested that Van de Mark send a list of specific
concerns to the Highway Department.
Comfort Road, Southern section
Dietrich opened the floor for discussion of a request for a speed reduction on the southern, dirt
portion of Comfort Road. Michael Casper expressed support for the petition to reduce the speed limit and
maintain the rural character of the southern/dirt portion of Comfort Road.
Van de Mark asked why not have a speed limit on the rest of Comfort Road? Dietrich explained that
the Board had previously attempted to have a speed reduction for the entire length of Comfort Road. This
request was denied by the County and State Departments of Transportation. At that time (circa 2013), the
current speed limit (55mph) was found to be appropriate for the road as a whole. Dietrich noted that there
are a number of Town roads, particularly dirt roads, on which speed limits may be reduced. For this
section of road, the Board has a petition in hand.
Lewis Billington expressed support for the request to lower the speed limit to 30mph. He reported a
particular problem with school busses driving too fast on this section of road. He stated that some of the
busses are empty while traveling down Comfort Road. Billington has contacted the school district without
success. Dietrich offered to send a letter to the school district making this request from the Town. He
noted that an increase in traffic and traffic speed is a recognized program.
Councilperson Brenner reported a conversation with Highway Superintendent Seamon. The Highway
Department is in support of lowering the speed on Danby’s dirt roads. Seamon expressed a concern that
enforcement is problematic. Brenner stated that knowing the speeding culprits is good and important. She
further expressed support for speed reduction on Town roads as a general principle, particularly on dirt
roads.
Dietrich noted that enforcement on the state highways has increased, but that there is limited
enforcement on Town roads. There was a general discussion of ways to increase compliance and
enforcement. Dietrich reported conversations with the Sheriff’s Department, requesting increased police
presence on Town roads. Dietrich suggested that the Town might work with the Sheriff’s Department to
prioritize enforcement in different areas of the Town.
Connors presented a draft resolution, based on previous requests for speed reduction on roads and the
points raised in the citizen petition. Clerk Goddard reported, on behalf of the Highway Department, that
the process for review and reduction of speed limits on Town roads has not changed since the time when
speed was reduced on Nelson and Yaple Roads. Connors suggested that this would be an appropriate time
for a review of speed safety on all of the Town roads.
Miller and Holahan asked for clarification as to “why not all of Comfort Road?” Dietrich and
Connors reviewed the history of a previous attempt to reduce the speed on the entire length of Comfort
Road. They suggested that a strategy of speed reduction addressing smaller sections, and focusing on the
Town dirt roads, at this time may be more successful.
Dietrich suggested a special meeting between the Town Board and Highway Department to review
appropriate speed limits on Town roads. This meeting could also address flood devastation and road
maintenance issues. The Board supported this suggestion.
Ted Crane stated that, given the current condition of both the dirt and paved sections of Comfort
Road, driving 30mph feels fast. He supported requesting a speed reduction to 30mph on the dirt section of
road.
The Board asked Planner Randall to provide some information regarding minimum speeds allowed.
In NYS, a Town can post as low as 30mph, but a lower limit requires action by the State Legislature.
Randall noted that this might be an appropriate time to update the Town of Danby Highway map and
review the design standards on Town roads for the speeds desired in different areas. She stated that there
are ways to slow speed via design.
Ronda Roaring urged the Town to review County roads, such as South Danby Road. in Danby as well
as Town Roads. She reported people driving at excess speed on South Danby Road.
Miller indicated that, while he voted yes, he would prefer to have a speed reduction on all of Comfort
Road.
RESOLUTION NO. 71 OF 2015 - RECOMMENDATION TO REDUCE SPEED LIMIT ON COMFORT ROAD, BETWEEN LIEB
ROAD AND BALD HILL ROAD, TO 30MPH
Whereas, people who live on that section of Comfort Road believe that traffic speed is excessive and do not feel safe
walking or biking on the road, and
Whereas, the community and Town Board believe that Comfort Road, between Lieb Road and Bald Hill Road,has
characteristics that limit visibility and pose safety concerns:
shaded, forested landscape
unpaved, dirt surface, often extremely dusty during dry weather
narrow road width
hidden driveways
much of the section serves as the Finger Lakes Trail, attracting hikers and recreation seekers, and
Whereas, a majority of persons residing on that section of Comfort Road have signed a Petition requesting speed
reduction,
Now, Therefore be it
Resolved, that the Town Board of Danby recommends to the County of Tompkins and the NYSDOT that the speed
limit be reduced from 55mph to 30mph on Comfort Road between Lieb Road and Bald Hill Road.
Moved by Connors, Second by Brenner. The motion passed.
In Favor: Brenner, Connors, Holahan, Miller, Dietrich
Proposed Subdivision and Zoning Changes Update
Planner CJ Randall gave an update on the discussion which took place at the most recent Planning
Board meeting regarding proposed changes to Subdivision and Zoning Local Laws. Randall advised that
administrative subdivision by permit should, “go the way of the Dodo.” She reported that a
recommendation to this effect (that subdivision by permit be removed from the Local Law) was provided
by the Town Attorney and Planners Beeners as well as Planner Randall. The preferred process, according
to NYS Planning law, has all subdivision requests going for review by the Planning Board. This has the
full support of the Danby Planning Board.
Randall described the proposed amended definitions for “Minor and Major Subdivisions.” A minor
subdivision would involved is a one-step plat for a lot line adjustment or financing approval on a phased
project. A major subdivision is a land division of two or more lots, subject to Planning Board review.
Randall said that there will be a very clear procedure for how development applications will be
implemented. The Planning Board agreed that this would be a good process. This process will provide
time and a system for dialogue between the applicant and the Planning Board.
Brenner and other members of the Board expressed support for this revision in the subdivision
practice in Danby. This is the standard process in New York municipalities. Dietrich noted that the the
Town Attorney has been steering Danby in this direction for some time. Holahan asked what needs to take
place for this change to happen? Randall is working on language to amend the Subdivision Regulations. It
is anticipated that this will be available for Planning and Town Board review in August.
Van Woert Road - Recommendation to Abandon
Planner CJ Randall gave an update, referring to comments from the Town Attorney. The Attorney’s
finding is that if a road has not been maintained for six years or more it is, in fact, abandoned. This road
has not been maintained by the Town of Danby in over 20 years. Randall has sent a map, draft resolution,
support documents, and SEQR review to the Town Board. The recommendation is to pass a resolution
restating that this road has been abandoned and formalizing that understanding.
Randall suggested that there is not a time sensitive matter. She will be sending letters to the
surrounding neighbors. The request that this be formally abandoned has come from the adjacent land
owners. So, it is not anticipated that there will be any objection regarding this action.
Aquifer Protection Ordinance/Water Resources Update
The next meeting with Steve Winkley will take place on August 13.
Community Council/Youth Program Report
Brenner reported on observing a summer Youth program with the new DCC program manager, Travis
Judd. This program manager lives in Danby. He has managed programs for the Coddington Community
Center and has an excellent reputation. Brenner joined DCC president Alison Christie and fifteen area
youth for a program with the Cayuga Floating Classroom. Brenner gave the program a very high review.
Gunderman Road PDZ Proposal
Miller asked for an update on the status of the new proposal for Gunderman Road PDZ#10. Dietrich
reported that there will be a meeting with Hall, the Town Attorney, and Planner Randall later this week.
Still waiting for traffic reports, water study, etc. Information will be sent to the Board when it is available.
Adjourn
The meeting was adjourned at 8:08 pm !!!!!!!!
______________________________________
Pamela Goddard, Town Clerk