HomeMy WebLinkAbout2022-07-14TB 7-14-22
Page 1 of 8
TOWN OF DRYDEN
TOWN BOARD MEETING
July 14, 2022
Zoom Hybrid
Present: Supervisor Jason Leifer, Cl Daniel Lamb,
Cl Loren Sparling, Cl Leonardo Vargas-Mendez
Absent: Cl James Skaley
Elected Officials: Bambi L. Avery, Town Clerk
Rick Young, Highway/DPW Superintendent
Other Town Staff: Ray Burger, Planning Director
Cassie Byrnes, Secretary to Supervisor
Amanda Anderson, Bookkeeper
Supv Leifer opened the meeting at 6:00 p.m.
RESOLUTION #111 (2022) – APPROVE ABSTRACT #7
Supv Leifer offered the following resolution and asked for its adoption:
RESOLVED, that this Town Board hereby approves Abstract #7, as audited, general
vouchers #512 through #625 ($905,639.14) and TA vouchers #30 through #33 ($5,654.11),
totaling $911,293.25.
2nd Cl Lamb
Roll Call Vote Cl Sparling Yes
Cl Vargas-Mendez Yes
Cl Lamb Yes
Supv Leifer Yes
PUBLIC HEARING
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT APPLICATION
BROADBAND PROJECT
Supv Leifer opened the public hearing at 6:04 p.m. and displayed the slides provided by
the town’s consultant (attached). The town is applying for funding to help build the Varna
section of the Dryden Fiber Project. The first step is to hold a public hearing to allow the town
to apply. The town is applying for $300,000 toward the broadband improvements in the
hamlet of Varna. The consultant utilized the results of the income survey used for the water
and sewer projects in Varna. This is yet another grant for the town to draw from and the town
has to match what is received, so we would receive $300,000 in funding and have to match
that. The grant received from the Appalachian Regional Commission money will go toward the
backbone, so this funding would go toward the fiber off the backbone to serve Varna. The
application is due July 29. A successful application will help serve Varna sooner. A second
public hearing is required later in the process. There were no comments from public. The
hearing was left open.
COUNTY UPDATE
TB 7-14-22
Page 2 of 8
Mike Lane announced the county has filled two positions under the County
Administrator. Bridget Nugent will be one of the deputy county administrators. Norma Jayne
will be the budget director. .
The Etna bridge is under construction. It will be a new two-lane bridge across Fall
Creek in the hamlet of Etna.
The county is beginning budget work. Over the summer, the County Administrator
brings together her proposed budget for consideration by the legislature. She starts by meeting
with department heads and looking at their proposed budgets and wish lists. The legislature is
very interested in things like green initiatives and sustainability, electric vehicles and those
kinds of things.
The facilities committee has been discussing the properties the county owns in the 400
block of Tioga Street in Ithaca. There was a vote in committee to deconstruct the old dental
building. The cost of converting that to serviceable office space because of the change of use
would have cost over two million dollars. The cost to deconstruct is about $150,000.00 The
other property (red house at 405 N Tioga) is a historic house and it would be very expensive to
convert that to offices. The committee will discuss f urther.
The airport is still functioning as best it can. They are about to lose flights from
American.
The Human Services Building on State Street has been a cause of concern because of
the number of violent incidents (mostly outside the building) that have alarmed the employees
and the clients visiting the buildings. The County Administrator is recommending installing a
magnetometer to make sure no one entering has a weapon and hiring deputies to provide
security in the building. There have been shootings and knifings on State Street and they are a
large concern.
The recovery act community grant program was delayed by a change in the regulations
at the federal level and legal opinions about how the funding could be used. The county found
out that they are more restricted by the way they chose to use the funding, so they have
reversed their decision to use those federal funds as an income reduction, freeing up money in
capital reserves to use for the program. The revised regulations at federal level are less
onerous than what they thought they would be, so they will now use the federal money for the
grant program. They expect the program to launch in the near future.
DISCUSSION/ACTION ITEMS
Etna Cemetery Association - The board has received a request for assistance from
Etna Cemetery (attached). Cynthia Marquis, President of Etna Cemetery Association, said the
cemetery was established in 1853. They have been working closely with the Division of
Cemeteries to identify monuments that are leaning and need repair. They have met with
people who do monument restorations and have the necessary criteria for them to submit a
proposal for repair. The State will fund and oversee the repairs.
Mowing is difficult due to sunken graves and uneven terrain. They would like topsoil to
fill areas as necessary, seed, and fertilizer. They have six people on the board and a couple of
volunteers to help with mowing and weeding. They would like to continue to keep the cemetery
in good working order, but it is more than they can manage with little funds and no grave sites
to be sold. They met with a local landscaper to rough out those costs.
TB 7-14-22
Page 3 of 8
C Marquis met with Supervisor Leifer and Highway Superintendent Rick Young and
discussed what the town could do to help. They would like help getting the graves level so they
can continue the mowing, repair the driveway, and trim up the trees, so that when the repairs
are being made to the monuments they can readily access the stones. Those are immediate
needs.
The fence surrounding the cemetery needs repair. Some trees have fallen on the fence
and portions are missing. She will meet with R Young on Tuesday to look the site over.
They would like help so they can continue to care for the cemetery until they run out of
volunteers. It would then be in better shape if and when the town needs to take it over.
There are five lots that have been purchased and not filled (to the best of their
knowledge). There are some records, but they are incomplete. There are 124 monuments
there with about a dozen that have fallen over. They did raise enough money to pay for
materials for a new sign and someone donated their time to create it.
R Young said the town could help them keep going until they no longer function. The
board agrees it would be a good thing for the town to help.
Dryden Fiber purchases - Supv Leifer said the town has an opportunity to purchase a
used equipment cabinet/shelter for the broadband project for a total cost, with shipping and
installation, of $29,995.00. Netegrity has located a refurbished router for $8,500.00.
RESOLUTION #112 (2022) – APPROVE PURCHASE OF CABINET FOR DRYDEN FIBER
Supv Leifer offered the following resolution and asked for its adoption:
Whereas, Dryden Fiber needs to purchase a fibrebond concrete shelter, and
Whereas, our consultant with Hunt Engineers was able to find a used shelter at a lower
cost and available at this time from Tower Direct,
Therefore, be it resolved that this Town Board hereby approves the purchase of a
fibrebond concrete shelter for $29,995.00 which includes shipping and use of a crane for
installation.
2nd Cl Vargas-Mendez
Roll Call Vote Cl Sparling Yes
Cl Vargas-Mendez Yes
Cl Lamb Yes
Supv Leifer Yes
RESOLUTION #113 (2022) – APPROVE PURCHASE OF CISCO ROUTER FOR
DRYDEN FIBER
Supv Leifer offered the following resolution and asked for its adoption:
Whereas, Dryden Fiber needs to purchase a refurbished Cisco Router and installation
for the router,
Therefore, be it resolved, that this Town Board hereby approves the purchase of
refurbished Cisco Router with installation for $8,500.00.
2nd Cl Lamb
TB 7-14-22
Page 4 of 8
Roll Call Vote Cl Sparling Yes
Cl Vargas-Mendez Yes
Cl Lamb Yes
Supv Leifer Yes
Hunt Phase 2 Agreement - The agreement with Hunt Engineers previously approved
contained incorrect dates. Those have been corrected in the new document. The previous
resolution will be rescinded and a new one adopted.
Resolution #114 (2022) Rescinding Resolution #98 of 2022, adopted on May 19, 2022
Authorizing Agreement with Hunt Engineers
Whereas, at a regular meeting of the Town Board of the Town of Dryden, held on May
19, 2022, the Town Board adopted the following resolution:
Resolution #98 of 2022 which approved an agreement dated May 18, 2022 with Hunt
Engineers for consulting and design service for Phase 2 of the Town’s Fiber to the Home
deployment and authorized the Town Supervisor to execute, and
Whereas, after this resolution was approved, it was discovered that the dates (January
2022 to January 2023) on the approved agreement were incorrect. The work covered by this
agreement has already been completed, now, therefore be it
RESOLVED, that the Town Board of the town of Dryden hereby rescinds resolution #98
of 2022, effective immediately.
2nd Cl Lamb
Roll Call Vote Cl Sparling Yes
Cl Vargas-Mendez Yes
Cl Lamb Yes
Supv Leifer Yes
Resolution #115 (2022) Authorizing Agreement with Hunt Engineers
Supv Leifer offered the following resolution and asked for its adoption:
Whereas, the Town Board has rescinded a prior agreement with Hunt Engineers due to
incorrect information, and
Whereas, the updated and current agreement dated June 22, 2022 reflects the correct
term of May 1, 2021 to June 1, 2022, now, therefore be it
RESOLVED, that this Town Board hereby approves an agreement dated June 22, 2022
with Hunt Engineers for consulting and design services for phase 2 of the Town’s Fiber to the
Home deployment, and authorizes the Town Supervisor to execute the same.
2nd Cl Lamb
Roll Call Vote Cl Sparling Yes
Cl Vargas-Mendez Yes
Cl Lamb Yes
Supv Leifer Yes
Schedule Public Hearings for Unsafe Structures – There are properties at 28 Leisure
Lane and 1892 Slaterville Road that are dilapidated, and the Planning Department has deemed
TB 7-14-22
Page 5 of 8
them unsafe. The owners have been issued notices of violation. Board members have received
memorandums on each property. The action tonight is to set a public hearing on the matters.
RESOLUTION #116 (2022) – SCHEDULE PUBLIC HEARING – 28 LEISURE LANE
Supv Leifer offered the following resolution and asked for its adoption:
WHEREAS, on July 13, 2021, the Town Code Enforcement Officer posted the structure
located at 28 Leisure Lane against occupancy as an unsafe structure ; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to a Memorandum dated June 3, 2022, the Town of Dryden Code
Enforcement Office reported its findings and recommendations for repair or demolition of the
structure to the Town Board; and
WHEREAS, the Town Board has considered such report, and has decided to proceed
under Chapter 118-15(F) of the Town Code concerning the repair or demolition of unsafe
structures within the Town;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that in accordance with Chapter 118 of the
Town Code, the Town Board will hold a Public Hearing on August 18, 2022, at 6:05 p.m. to
solicit public input on the issue concerning whether the structure at 28 Leisure Lane can safely
be repaired, and whether it should order the property owner to repair or demolish and remove
the structure; and be it further
RESOLVED that notice of this public hearing shall be served personally on the record
owner of 28 Leisure Lane and its legal counsel, if known, at least 10 days before the date of the
hearing; and be it further
RESOLVED that the Town Clerk is authorized to take such additional and further action
as is necessary to notice the Public Hearing as noted herein; and be it further
RESOLVED that this resolution will take effect immediately.
2nd Cl Lamb
Roll Call Vote Cl Sparling Yes
Cl Vargas-Mendez Yes
Cl Lamb Yes
Supv Leifer Yes
RESOLUTION #117 – SCHEDULE PUBLIC HEARING – 1892 SLATERVILLE ROAD
Supv Leifer offered the following resolution and asked for its adoption:
WHEREAS, on April 11, 2021, the Town Code Enforcement Officer posted the structure
located at 1892 Slaterville Road against occupancy as an unsafe structure; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to a Memorandum dated June 16, 2022, the Town of Dryden Code
Enforcement Office reported its findings and recommendations for repair or demolition of the
structure to the Town Board; and
WHEREAS, the Town Board has considered such report, and has decided to proceed
under Chapter 118-15(F) of the Town Code concerning the repair or demolition of unsafe
structures within the Town;
TB 7-14-22
Page 6 of 8
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that in accordance with Chapter 118 of the
Town Code, the Town Board will hold a Public Hearing on August 18, 2022, at 6:10 p.m. to
solicit public input on the issue concerning whether the structure at 1892 Slaterville Road can
safely be repaired, and whether it should order the property owner to repair or demolish and
remove the structure; and be it further
RESOLVED that notice of this public hearing shall be served personally on the record
owner of 1892 Slaterville Road and its legal counsel, if known, at least 10 days before the date
of the hearing; and be it further
RESOLVED that the Town Clerk is authorized to take such additional and further action
as is necessary to notice the Public Hearing as noted herein; and be it further
RESOLVED that this resolution will take effect immediately.
2nd Cl Lamb
Roll Call Vote Cl Sparling Yes
Cl Vargas-Mendez Yes
Cl Lamb Yes
Supv Leifer Yes
Planning Board Recommended Changes to Sign Law – The Planning Board has
passed a resolution recommending that the Town Board modify the town’s sign ordinance to
allow existing, non-conforming billboard signs to be replaced with electronic signs. John Kiefer
explained there are a couple of billboards owned by Park Outdoor in the area of the proposed
rail trail bridge on Route 13. Park Outdoor representative, Paul Simonet, gave the Planning
Board a presentation on electronic signs. Electronic signs are regulated by NYS Department of
Transportation and they talked about what they could be used for. Park Outdoor is very
interested in replacing their conventional billboard signs with electronic signs. The Planning
Board had a lengthy discussion and passed the resolution referred to by a 4 -3 vote. The people
who voted against contributed good ideas, but felt that electronic signs were inappropriate for
Dryden. The resolution is very narrow in scope and allows owners of exis ting non-conforming
billboards to replace them with electronic signage. The owner would have to remove four signs
in order to ask permission to install one electronic sign and they would only be allowed in
commercial/industrial zones.
Comments:
• A reduction in the number of billboards is a good thing.
• Billboards in general are intrusive, so a reduction is good.
• An LED billboard is more noticeable than less bright, conventional billboards.
• Park Outdoor has been provided with the Planning Board’s resoluti on.
• This amendment would not allow these LED billboards by right. They would need special
use permit approval.
• NYS DOT limits the frequency of the changing messages, among other things. The town
could be more specific.
• The town could, in the application process, secure time for town-sponsored content.
R Burger will draft something and ask the town attorney to look into it.
There were no further comments on the CDBG public hearing and Supv Leifer closed
the hearing at 7:09 p.m. The board authorized preparation of an application by the following
resolution:
TB 7-14-22
Page 7 of 8
RESOLUTION #118 (2022) – WITH REFERENCE TO THE PROPOSED TOWN OF DRYDEN,
TOMPKINS COUNTY, NEW YORK, HAMLET OF VARNA BROADBAND IMPROVEMENTS
Supv Leifer offered the following resolution and asked for its adoption:
WHEREAS, a public information meeting was held on July 14, 2022, for the purpose of
identification of community development needs and announcement of the opportunity to apply
for Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) funds: and
WHEREAS, the Town of Dryden engaged qualified engineering to complete an engineering
report for the development of Broadband in the Hamlet of Varna. The report identifies the
proposed infrastructure improvements and the projected costs for residents of the district: and
WHEREAS, affordability for Town residents and property owners is a significant concern
in advancement of the proposed project: and
WHEREAS, the Town is eligible for CDBG funding based on the results o f an income
survey and must submitted a competitive application to obtain CDBG funding.
NOW, THEREFORE, be it RESOLVED as follows:
1. The Town Board authorizes Municipal Solutions to prepare an application for
Community Development Block Grant funds from the NYS Office for Community
Renewal.
2. The Town Board authorizes Supervisor Jason Leifer to execute the application for
Community Development Block Grant funds from the NYS Office for Community
Renewal.
3. This resolution shall take effect immediately.
2nd Cl Lamb
Roll Call Vote Cl Sparling Yes
Cl Vargas-Mendez Yes
Cl Lamb Yes
Supv Leifer Yes
Next week the board will continue the public hearings on videoconferencing for public
bodies and the comprehensive plan amendment that were left open tonight.
Town meetings will continue in the hybrid format.
R Burger will have items related to the boiler replacement at the Ithaca Area Waste
Water Treatment Facility for next week.
The Design Connect group is active again at Cornell University. R Burger said the town
could expect a couple of proposals to move forward with. The fiscal piece is that each funded
project is required to provide a $500 stipend (requires board action). The board will need to
decide on proposals next week and we can put in a couple of applications. Cl Lamb suggested
a proposal for a design of a trail from TC3 to the village.
Cl Lamb and Cl Sparling have edits to the comp plan. CL Lamb rewrote the broadband
page and there were some errors on the budget page.
TB 7-14-22
Page 8 of 8
Cl Lamb reported that the town has been notified that the Game Farm Road speed limit
was reduced to 45 mph. This may help the county approve the proposed crossing plan.
Freese Road Bridge – CL Lamb said Federal Highway wants to know our preference on
what to do with the old bridge. When the board last met, everyone agreed that the best thing
to do with it is to have the outfit in Indiana take possession of it, restore it and have it placed
somewhere else. It is the least costly alternative. Federal Highway may not agree to that. But
the town’s first priority is to have it removed and we would put in a new single-lane steel
girder, truss style bridge. That would honor our commitment to the Varna community and to
the NYS DOT that we agreed to the lighted signal traffic stops. The next option would be if
Federal Highway does not agree to allow the bridge to leave the area, then we could try to place
both spans at the first washout on the rail trail (the NYSEG washout). We would have to pay to
restore the elements of the bridge that go to the trail and seek additional money (estimated at
$200,000 to repair it appropriately and be sure it is sturdy enough for vehicles to cross). That
would be kind of nice and make people happy to see it there. BridgeNY funding likely cannot
be used for that. The board agrees on these two priorities. Jim Skaley supports this, as well
as David Weinstein. If we can find the money to restore it and have it on the rail trail, that
would be great. It may need to be stored until money to restore it is secured. Barton &
Loguidice will pass the town’s position on to Federal Highway.
Design Connect – The Planning Board has suggested an application for the Design
Connect team to look at the North Street corridor north of the Village and come up with a plan
to rehab and revitalize the area. Craig Anderson said the affordable housing committee is
already looking at the 40 acres off Mott Road. NYS DOT owns the site next to Dryden Mutual
and that will be going up for auction and could be another potential site for housing. The
comp plan directs growth to the village and the updated plan extends all the w ay up North
Road for more housing and commercial development. Design Connect could look at the area
and its possible use for housing and growth. This would help the village and the service
businesses in it.
John Kiefer said he thinks this is a good fit for Design Connect. They could talk with
the village about extension of municipal systems, could look at pedestrian and vehicular
circulation. They could look at the zoning and comment on whether it is adequate or whether
it is limiting for the goals in the comprehensive plan. The comp plan specifically recommends
making it easier for developers to work in the existing population centers.
Design Connect can choose more than one project from the town and the town would
pay $500 per project chosen.
Feeder trails have been talked about and C Anderson said a lot of those will happen by
businesses wanting them. For example, Hopshire has already negotiated with a property
owner across the street for a trail coming through the school property.
The Town Board agreed to pay the associated fee for up to three successful applications
and can vote on it next week.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 7:50 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Bambi L. Avery
Town Clerk
________ __, 2022
Town of Dryden
Community Development Block Grant
Public Hearing
Purpose of Tonight’s Meeting
Community Development Block Grant Program
Announce application opportunity
Discuss potential projects
Enable Public Participation and Input
Meet application process requirements
Listen and Acknowledge Public Input
2022
Community Development Block Grants
Federal $$$$ Budgeted Through US Housing
And Urban Development
Administered In NYS Through the Office of
Community Renewal (OCR) under direction
of the Housing Trust Fund Corporation
(HTFC)
HUD CDBG Program Objective
The program’s primary objective is:
“the development of viable urban communities
by providing decent housing and a suitable
living environment; by expanding economic
opportunities, principally for persons of low
and moderate income (LMI).”
Eligibility Criteria
NYS must ensure that no less than 70% of its CDBG
funds are used for activities that benefit low-and
moderate-income persons
Low -& moderate-income persons are defined as a
member of a household whose income is less than 80%
of the area median income for the household size.
To demonstrate compliance at least 51% of the project
beneficiaries must qualify as low &/or moderate income.
Median Income –Tompkins County
Tompkins County Median Income is $100,300
Low -& Moderate-Income (LMI) Persons (80% or less of
County Median Income) = $80,150
To demonstrate compliance, at least 51% of the project
beneficiaries must qualify as low &/or moderate income.
An Income Survey or Census Data may be used to
demonstrate eligibility.
The Town completed an income survey in 2021 that
qualifies the Town to seek CDBG funding for this district.
Grant Amounts Available Under CDBG
Annual Competitive Round
Counties, Towns, Cities or Villages Maximum
Public Facilities $ 300,000
Public Infrastructure (water/sewer only & no co-funding) $1,000,000
Public Infrastructure with co-funding in place $1,250,000
Planning $ 50,000
Joint Applications
Public Infrastructure (water/sewer only & no co-funding) $1,500,000
Public Infrastructure with Co-funding in place $1,750,000
CDBG Funding –2022 Round
$20 Million Available
Competitive Rounds Through CFA Portal
Funding Opportunities:
Public Infrastructure -
Drinking Water, Clean Water/Storm Water, Public Works
Repair/Replace existing systems, construct new water or
sewers systems
Expand existing water or sewer systems into previously
unserved areas
Stand alone public works components (streets, parking,
open space, publicly owned utilities)
Note: Funding for stand alone residential water/sewer lateral connections is not available
as part of the CFA –would be funded under the Housing Funding Category.
CDBG Funding –2022 Round
Public Facilities
Construction or renovation of public facilities
Structures to Service/House Special-Needs Populations
Structures to Service/House Senior Services or Child Care
Removal of Architectural Barriers to Improve Handicap Access (existing building only)
Cannot fund buildings used primarily for the general conduct of government
business
CDBG Funding –2022 Round
Public Infrastructure
Public or Private Water Source Development
Water Storage & Distribution
Sanitary Sewer Treatment & Collection
Flood Control & Storm Water Drainage
Municipal Utilities
CDBG Funding –2022 Round
Community Planning
Community Needs Assessments
May focus on one or more of the following:
o Public Infrastructure
o Public Facilities
o Housing &/or Economic Development
Preliminary Engineering Report Development
Goal is to help initiate a planning process that will result in follow-up
implementation plans to address the critical infrastructure needs outlined
in the report.
Community Development Funding –
Non-CFA Open Round Funding
Applications on-going
Economic Development
Assistance to businesses for activities to attract, expand or retain business and jobs for low-
moderate income individuals
51% of all jobs created mut be held by or made available to low-and moderate-income persons
Award Up to $15,000 per job, maximum CDBG award $750,000
Small Business Assistance
Same purpose as above but for businesses with 25 or fewer full-time equivalent employees
Minimum CDBG Assistance $25,000, Maximum CDBG Assistance $100,000
Up to 40% of the total project cost.
Microenterprise
Same purpose as above but for businesses with 5 or fewer full-time equivalent employees
10% Cash Match required
Awards $5,000 to $35,000 per business.
Open Rounds funding applications may be submitted on continual basis. Pre-submission
form is required & if accepted will have 60 days to apply through the CFA portal.
Awards are on a rolling basis.
CDBG General Funding Criteria
Fundamentals -readiness & ability to complete project
Is the project feasible but for (CDGB) investment?
Are all necessary components identified and committed?
Does the applicant have the necessary experience and team members to successfully
complete the investment?
Has NEPA & SEQR been completed?
Can the project be completed within the 2-year CDBG contract timeframe?
Leverage (other funding or local share)
Does the investment leverage significant outside resources such as third-party funds,
local funds and support?
Firm commitment required for projects requesting awards based on co-funding.
Outcomes
Does the investment produce a transformative or priority outcome?
Are there Measures to demonstrate project accomplishments?
CDBG Application Process
Funding Announced & Applications Due on
July 29, 2022 by 4:00 p.m.
Technical assistance is available in development of grant proposals up until
application deadline or submission of application, which ever is first.
Applicants must hold Two public meetings
One completed prior to application submission to announce/discuss CDBG
availability and solicit input on various application alternatives
Second at approximately 75% completion to review the project progress.
More Information At:
http://hcr.ny.gov/community-development-block-grant
Discussion of Potential Project(s)
Questions?
Etna Cemetery Association, Est. 1853
℅ Cindy Marquis, President
PO Box 243
Etna, NY 13062
(607) 351-1105
Background:
The Etna Cemetery is located on Route 366 in the hamlet of Etna, NY. It is slightly over 1 acre
in size with a potter’s field to the rear and a lower gated entrance on the southwest end, facing
the road and next to the entrance to the Finger Lakes Land Trust trail.
There are approximately 125 burial lots, most of which have large monuments on them.
Current situation:
The Etna Cemetery is currently being cared for by a Board of Directors consisting of 4 officers
and 4 additional community members. The officers are President: Cindy Marquis; Vice-
President Dan Taylor; Treasurer Jim Graney; and Secretary Casey Washburn. Other involved
community members include Deb McGraw, Jen Sage, Julia Dawson and Mary Dart Blinn to
name a few. However, it is becoming increasingly difficult for us to maintain given the
condition of the property. We are currently working with Brendon Stanton at the Division of
Cemeteries and have identified dangerous monuments in need of repair. On June 9, 2022, I
(Cindy) met with Dean Clamcey of Clamcey’s Monument Restoration to record and measure
the base of the monuments that were approved by the Division of Cemeteries for repair.
Another monument repair company, Hills Monuments have also been given the information for
their bid. We should be receiving both bids shortly and the repairs should be completed either
by late Fall 2022 or early Spring 2023. These repairs will be paid for by New York State.
Because our cemetery is so old; we have many graves that have collapsed and eroded soil
making it difficult to maintain the grounds. The front tree line, behind the stone wall, consisting
of six pin oaks, are in need of trimming and clearing out most of the dead branches. There are
other large trees in the cemetery that also need trimming to make room for the overhead
clearance that is needed for the monument repairs and to allow for safe mowing and burials.
The main entrance needs additional base materials added to make entering the cemetery
easier as well.
Due to the lack of manpower and finances available to do the repairs and maintenance of the
Etna Cemetery, we, the board, are requesting assistance from the Town of Dryden to help
assist with the care and preservation of our cemetery.
-2-
Our current needs:
1)Top Soil
Top soil is needed to fill in the collapsed graves. There are 5 rows of graves in the front portion
of the cemetery. By figuring each area needing soil in the first 2 rows and estimating an
average depth of 6 inches of top soil being needed, we estimate needing 34 yards of topsoil for
this project. Additionally, we would need grass seed and straw to cover the area. Additional
topsoil will be needed in the future to fill 3 more rows of sunken graves.
2) Tree Trimming
In addition to the Pin Oaks described above, there are other trees in the cemetery with low
hanging branches that should have those low branches removed for safety. There are also
several tall trees in the back and to the south side of the cemetery that are leaning badly and
could injure a person or destroy multiple graves should they fall. These should be removed.
3) Entrance repairs
Currently there is stone in the driveway though using highway millings could be a low cost
solution for improving the entrance area of the cemetery.
Our Request:
We have not placed a dollar amount on these repairs because we are requesting materials and
labor be provided by the Town of Dryden. This will allow the Etna Cemetery Board to continue
working with the Division of Cemeteries to maintain the monuments, provide for their repairs,
and also mow and trim the cemetery as needed.
Etna Cemetery Association, Est. 1853
℅ Cindy Marquis, President
PO Box 243
Etna, NY 13062
(607) 351-1105
Estimated cost for maintenance items:
Based on figures from a local landscape business located in the Town of Dryden:
•Mowing and string trimming is $37.45 per 1/4 acre with NO obstacles. We have over 100
obstacles. Estimated cost per time $150.
•Top Soil is $42 per yard so we estimate the value needed at $1428.00
• Grass Seed is $100 for a 50# bag.
• Straw is $7 per bail
• Fertilizer is about $20 per 5000 square feet at Lowe’s
• Tree Trimming is $800 for each pin oak. Trimming low branches on other trees and an
estimate to remove roughly 3 hanging tall leaning trees in the back is significantly more.
• The entrance lane would be no charge other than labor if millings are used instead of stone.