HomeMy WebLinkAbout1993 Proceedings1993 PROCEEDINGS
Tompkins County
Board of
Representatives
TOMPKINS COUNTY
NEW YORK
ROBERT I. WATROS, Chair
Ithaca, New York
CATHERINE COVERT, Clerk
Ithaca, New York
State of New York
County of Tompkins
Tompkins County Board of Representatives
ss:
In pursuance of the authority conferred by Section 211 of the County Law, I do hereby certify that the copy of
the Proceedings of the Tompkins County Board of Representatives of the County of Tompkins, New York, for
the year 1993, contained in this volume is true and correct.
CATHERINE COVERT
Clerk of the Board of Representatives
TOMPKINS COUNTY BOARD OF REPRESENTATIVES
1993 Standing Committees
Budget and Administration
Mary G. Call, Chairman
Daniel Winch, Vice Chairman
Frank P. Proto
Barbara Mink
Eric Lerner
James Mason
Stuart Stein
Phil Shurtleff (At -Large)
Health and Education
Frank P. Proto, Chairman
Charles Evans, Vice Chairman
Donald Culligan
Phil Shurtleff
Nancy Schuler
Human Services
Barbara Mink, Chairman
Beverly Livesay, Vice Chairman
Charles Evans
Tim Joseph
Mary G. Call
Personnel
Charles Evans, Chairman
Beveryly Livesay, Vice Chairman
Thomas Todd
1993 Special Committees
Article 18 Task Force
Thomas Todd, Chairman
Benjamin Bucko, Vice Chairman
Nelson Roth
Roger Rector
Planning
Stuart Stein, Chairman
Frank P. Proto, Vice Chairman
Tim Joseph
Barbara Mink
Nancy Schuler
Public Safety
James Mason, Chairman
Nancy Schuler, Vice Chairman
Phil Shurtleff
Eric Lerner
Tim Joseph
Public Works and Construction
Management
Daniel Winch, Chairman
Thomas Todd, Vice Chairman
Donald Culligan
Stuart Stein
James Mason
Solid Waste and Resource
Management
Eric Lerner, Chairman
Mary G. Call, Vice Chairman
Thomas Todd
Beverly Livesay
Charles V. Evans
Fiscal Affairs
Thomas Todd, Chairman
Mary G. Call, Vice Chairman
Stuart Stein
Margaret Dill
Andrew Lavigne
January 5, 1993
Organization Meeting
Pursuant to Section 151 of County Law, Section 2.04 of the Charter and Code, Rule I of the Rules
of the Board and the date established by Resolution No. 369 adopted by the Board on November 17,
1992, the Board of Representatives convened at its chambers in the Courthouse in the City of Ithaca, New
York, on Tuesday, January 5, 1993 at 5:30 p.m. and was called to order by Catherine L. Covert, Clerk of
the Board.
Members and guests participated in the Pledge of Allegiance.
Present: 15 Representatives. Representative Culligan was excused from the meeting at 7:05 p.m.
prior to the adoption of Resolution No. 4.
City of Ithaca:
District No.
District No.
District No.
District No.
District No.
Towns:
1 - Eric J. Lerner, 504 South Plain Street
2 - Donald J. Culligan, 627 Hudson Street
3 - Stuart W. Stein, 11 Cornell Walk
4 - Nancy B. Schuler, 110 Ferris Place
5 - Barbara Mink, 614 North Cayuga Street
District No. 6 - Thomas L. Todd, 847 Davis Road, Lansing
District No. 7 - Frank P. Proto, 2585 Slaterville Road, Slaterville Springs
District No. 8 - Daniel M. Winch, 310 Burdge Hill Road, Newfield
District No. 9 - Phil Shurtleff, Box 129, Groton
District No. 10 - Mary G. Call, 108 Comstock Road, Ithaca
District No. 11 - Beverly E. Livesay, 147 Snyder Hill Road, Ithaca
District No. 12 - Deborah F. Dietrich, 221 DuBois Road, Ithaca
District No. 13 - Charles V. Evans, 819 Snyder Hill Road, Ithaca
District No. 14 - Robert I. Watros, 14 Evergreen Street, Box 72, Dryden
District No. 15 - James A. Mason, 102 Larchmont Drive, Trumansburg
Mrs. Covert announced that the first order of business was the election of a temporary chairman.
Mr. Evans nominated Mr. Proto as temporary chairman, seconded by Mr. Todd. After hearing no more
nominations, it was adopted by voice vote to close nominations. A voice vote resulted as follows for
temporary chairman: Ayes - 15, Noes - 0. Adopted. Mr. Proto took the chair as temporary chairman.
The next order of business was the election of a permanent chairman and nominations were
opened. Mrs. Call nominated Robert I. Watros as permanent chairman, seconded by Mr. Evans. Mr.
Lerner nominated Barbara Mink as permanent chairman, seconded by Mrs. Livesay. It was Moved by
Mr. Stein seconded by Mr. Lerner, and unanimously adopted by voice vote, to close nominations.
Ms. Mink, Representative, District No. 5, stated that it is a honor to be nominated chair of the
Board because she has been nominated by someone whose intelligence and energy she has come to rely
on in the three years since they were elected to this Board and she respects the work this Board does for
the community and appreciates the different perspectives the various members bring: Ms. Mink stated
that if elected chair, she would want to reinforce the direction the Board has been heading in, in terms of
being flexible when necessary, having the courage to reassess positions if there is a better option, and
having the sense to know when to stay the course. She would also like to increase communication with
the public by focusing on broadcasting committee meetings and issues forums. She stated that it is
important to have sensed our limitations as part-time legislators and also our strength as policy makers for
today and the future, to make efficient and sensible decisions on a variety of complicated issues.
3
January 5, 1993
The following is the vote for permanent chairman by show of hands: Robert I. Watros - 8
(Representatives Call, Evans, Mason, Proto, Shurtleff, Todd, Watros and Winch); Barbara Mink - 7
(Representatives Culligan, Dietrich, Lerner, Livesay, Mink, Schuler, and Stein). Robert I. Watros took
the chair as permanent chairman. Mrs. Dietrich requested the record show a unanimous vote for the
election of permanent chairman.
Nominations were opened for vice chairman. Mr. Stein nominated Mr. Lerner as vice chairman,
seconded by Ms. Mink. Mr. Todd nominated Mr. Mason as vice chairman, seconded by Mrs. Call. After
hearing no more nominations, it was adopted by voice vote to close nominations. The following is the
vote for vice chairman by a show of hands: Eric J. Lerner - 7 (Representatives Culligan, Dietrich, Lerner,
Livesay, Mink, Schuler, and Stein); James A. Mason - 8 (Representatives Call, Evans, Mason, Proto,
Shurtleff, Todd, Watros, and Winch). Mr. Mason was elected vice chairman. Mr. Stein asked that the
record show a unanimous vote for the election of vice chairman.
Chairman Watros reflected on 1992 and said he hopes 1993 will be better. Mr. Watros announced
that he will retire from GTE on January 8 and will give additional effort to see that this Board performs to
the best possible grade. Chairman Watros requested Board members to meet with him in the next week to
establish the various committees.
It was Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote, to
approve the minutes of December 15, 1992 as corrected.
Under privilege of the floor, Betsy Darlington, City of Ithaca, spoke concerning the resolution on
the agenda entitled Resolution Determining Significance Pursuant to SEQRA and Authorization for the
Issuance of a Negative Declaration - Execution of Purchase Option Agreement with Thorntree Hill
Associates. Ms. Darlington questioned the SEQR action on this resolution and stated that she believes a
coordinated review needs to be completed prior to the adoption of this resolution. Ms. Darlington urged
the Board to delay action on this resolution.
Under privilege of the floor, James Myers, CSEA member, spoke concerning employee safety and
expressed support for the placement of an armed guard at the Biggs complex, metal detectors being
installed and one entrance into the building.
Under privilege of the floor, Carol Usefara, Biggs complex employee, spoke concerning employee
safety and expressed opposition to an armed guard being stationed at the Biggs complex.
Under privilege of the floor, Penny Calderazzo, Economic Opportunity Corporation employee,
spoke concerning employee safety and expressed opposition to an armed guard being stationed at the
Biggs complex. Ms. Calderazzo stated that there are several workers at the complex who do not want an
armed guard at the site and filed a petition with the Board opposing this. She stated that she believes this
would create a negative attitude and would be stressful to worker -client relationships.
Under privilege of the floor, Mrs. Schuler, Representative, District No. 4, stated that on September
21, 1992 Mrs. Dietrich, Representative, District No. 12, was sworn in as New York State Association of
Counties (NYSAC) President -Elect.
Under privilege of the floor, Mr. Winch, Representative, District No. 14, stated that in his years of
public service he does not recall going through a fiscal crisis as publicly as this Board did in 1992. He
believes this Board has worked very well together trying to meet the needs of its citizens as best as it
could. Mr. Winch thanked Mr. Heyman, County Administrator, and Kathy West, Deputy County
Administrator, for assisting in the budget process.
Mr. Proto, Chairman, Health and Education Committee, recalled accomplishments Tompkins
County achieved in 1992. He made reference to the inoculation of over 12,000 school children, a well
4
January 5, 1993
educated public on rabies, successful Tompkins Cortland Community College negotiations, the Youth
Bureau being the recipient of the Eleanor Roosevelt award and the Ithaca Tompkins Transit Center. Mr.
Proto reported that the Health and Education Committee met on December 29 and had a discussion with
representatives from the Multicultural Resource Center. He stated that the Committee heard a positive
report on the PCAP program.
Ms. Mink, Chairman, Human Services Committee, reported that the Committee met this morning
and discussed security issues at the Biggs complex. She stated that Mary Pat Dolan, Commissioner of
Social Services, updated the Committee on security measures being taken at the complex. Ms. Mink
stated the Committee will attend an Employee Council meeting to discuss this issue.
Mr. Mason, Chairman, Public Safety Committee, reported that he has met with representatives of
ACT -UP and believes the issues which they have concerns about are being addressed. He stated that
ACT -UP is reviewing the policy on HIV and AIDS at the Tompkins County Jail and will schedule a
follow-up meeting when their review is completed. The next Committee meeting will be January 7.
Ms. Mink, Public Information Committee, reported that the Committee is trying to emphasize on
more current issues and asked for additional ideas and input.
Mr. Winch, Chairman, Public Works and Construction Management Committee, reported the
traffic light has been installed at the East Hill safety improvement project. Mr. Winch stated that Mr.
Nicholas, Airport Manager, has received a signed agreement from US Air. The next Committee meeting
will be January 6.
Mr. Todd, Chairman, Article 18 Task Force, reported that the Committee will meet January 7 at
8:30 a.m.
Mr. Todd, Chairman, Fiscal Affairs Committee, reported that the Committee will meet January 7 at
10:30 a.m.
Mrs. Livesay, Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, thanked the
members of the Committee for their work in 1992. Mrs. Livesay reported on a letter she received from
Cargill stating that they have no interest in contracting with Tompkins County to put solid waste in the
salt mines. Mrs. Livesay distributed information on household waste collection costs and also a draft of
items to be discussed at the January 12 meeting with the haulers. She requested comments be submitted
to her as soon as possible. She stated that she will request an executive session to discuss litigation. Mrs.
Livesay stated that the Procurement Committee for the Recycling and Solid Waste Center is looking into
members visiting facilities that have been built by the two proposers that Tompkins County is evaluating.
The next Committee meeting will be January 14.
Mrs. Call, Chairman, Budget and Administration Committee, reported that the Committee met
prior to the Board meeting and will meet again January 8 at noon. Mrs. Call stated that staff is working
very hard in their efforts to simplify the proposed solid waste management fee.
Mrs. Eckstrom, Solid Waste Manager, spoke of the goal for the restructured fee. She stated that
the goal of the fee is to seek the funds to operate the recycling program and the Recycling and Solid
Waste Center. Mr. Stein, Representative, District No. 3, stated that although this fee will relate to a
household or property, it is a fee not based on the amount of garbage people will throw away. Mrs. Call
stated that the overall budget for solid waste is down from 1992. Mrs. Call stated that the proposed fee
will leave a shortfall in the budget of $800,000 which the Comptroller will most likely ask the Board to
identify a source of revenue.
5
January 5, 1993
Chairman Watros reported that a letter has been sent to the Chamber of Commerce in regard to the
privatization of the handling of solid waste. The Chamber has organized a committee and a response is
expected in sixty days.
Mr. Heyman, County Administrator, reported that offices will be moving to the Old Jail soon.
Mr. Mulvey, County Attorney, had no report.
On motion of the appropriate committee chairmen and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by
voice vote, the following resolutions were added to the agenda:
Resolution in Memoriam - Schuyler County
Resolution Determining Significance Pursuant to SEQRA and Authorization for the Issuance of a
Negative Declaration - Execution of Purchase Option Agreement with Thorntree Hill Associates
Award of Bids - New Terminal Project - Tompkins County Airport
Chairman Watros gave Mrs. Call, Chairman, Budget and Administration Committee, permission to
withdraw from the agenda the resolution entitled Authorization to Provide Funds to Assist in the
Acquisition, Construction and Equipping of a 120 Bed Nursing Home Facility - Reconstruction Home,
Inc.
Chairman Watros gave the appropriate committee chairmen permission to withdraw from the
agenda with final committee action being affirmed:
CA001-93 - Authorizing Amendment to Parking Rates -Tompkins County Airport
CA002-93 - Authorizing a License to Enter
CA003-93 - Award of Bid - Snow Plow with Wing and Hopper Spreader
RESOLUTION NO. 1 - PURCHASE OF PROPERTY - LANDFILL NEIGHBORHOOD
PROTECTION PROGRAM
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 13, Noes -
2 (Representatives Culligan and Todd). Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the County
Administrator is directed to execute a purchase agreement for property now belonging to Charles Elrod,
Town of Dryden, Tax Parcel No. 40-1-26.2, notwithstanding Resolution Nos. 319 or 379 of 1992,
suspending the Landfill Neighborhood Protection Program, said purchase being for the sum of $65,000.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 2 - RESOLUTION DETERMINING SIGNIFICANCE PURSUANT TO
SEQRA AND AUTHORIZATION FOR THE ISSUANCE OF A
NEGATIVE DECLARATION EXECUTION OF PURCHASE OPTION
AGREEMENT WITH THORNTREE HILL ASSOCIATES
(Reconsidered and adopted later in meeting)
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Todd. Mr. Mulvey, County Attorney, stated that he has
reviewed this matter with the City of Ithaca Attorney. He stated that Tompkins County is complying with
SEQR by furnishing an Environmental Assessment Form. Mrs. Schuler felt that even though the SEQR
action is in compliance with the State's threshold, that it would also be appropriate to comply with the
City of Ithaca's threshold. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 15, Noes - 0. Adopted. This
resolution was reconsidered later in the meeting.
6
January 5, 1993
WHEREAS, the Board of Representatives is contemplating the execution of a purchase option
agreement with Thorntree Hill Associates with regard to two parcels of real property on Elmira Road in
the City of Ithaca, and
WHEREAS, the execution of such agreements involves no physical improvements or alterations
that would change the use, appearance or condition of any natural resource or structure, and
WHEREAS, the Board of Representatives has determined that this action is Unlisted for the
purpose of the environmental review process under SEQRA, and
WHEREAS, the Board of Representatives has reviewed a draft Short Environmental Assessment
Form, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That this Board
finds the execution of the aforesaid Purchase Option Agreement will not have a significant effect on the
environment requiring the preparation of an environmental impact statement,
RESOLVED, further, That the Chairman of the Board of Representatives and/or his designee is
authorized to file and circulate such determination according to law and to execute such other
documentation as may be necessary.
SEQR ACTION: TYPE I OR UNLISTED
(DETERMINATIONS OR FINDINGS
INCLUDED HEREIN)
RESOLUTION NO. 3 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE AGREEMENT - THORNTREE HILL
ASSOCIATES (Amended by Resolution No. 200 of 1993 and Res. No. 48 of
1994)
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mrs. Livesay, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
RESOLVED, That the County Administrator is directed to execute a purchase option agreement
with Thorntree Hill Associates of Fayetteville, New York dated December 9, 1992, which agreement
authorizes sale of two (2) parcels of real property on Elmira Road, Ithaca, New York, being a portion of
City of Ithaca Tax Parcel No. 126-1-2 together with a narrow strip of land measuring approximately 20
feet by 673 feet adjoining, for $225,000,
RESOLVED, further, That in the event the purchase option agreement is exercised, the County
Administrator is directed to execute a deed conveying said property to Thorntree Hill Associates or to
another party officially designated by Thorntree Hill Associates.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
Representative Culligan was excused from the meeting at 7:05 p.m.
RESOLUTION NO. 4 - BLANKET AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE REAL ESTATE LISTING
AGREEMENTS, PURCHASE AGREEMENTS AND DEEDS (Amended
by Resolution No. 317 of 1995)
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the County
Administrator is authorized to execute real estate listing agreements pursuant to the County's contract
with Patterson Real Estate and is authorized to bring resolutions authorizing purchase agreements and
deeds directly to the Board of Representatives without review by any committee in order to convey
property acquired by Tompkins County through foreclosure and through the Landfill Neighborhood
Protection Program,
7
January 5, 1993
RESOLVED, further, That with respect to 1992 foreclosed properties only, the County
Administrator is authorized to execute listing agreements effective April 1, 1993, but that in future years
those agreements may be authorized immediately after foreclosure by Tompkins County, provided that
written notice is provided to parties whose properties are in foreclosure that this will take place,
RESOLVED, further, That when the County Administrator is able to determine that a foreclosed
property is occupied by the owner of record at the time taxes became delinquent, that no listing agreement
may be signed until specifically authorized by the Budget and Administration Committee and that said
Committee shall provide said authorization only when it is determined that no reasonable efforts are being
made by the owner of record to secure sufficient funds to re -purchase the property,
RESOLVED, further, That all deeds of conveyance by Tompkins County of foreclosed properties
shall be quitclaim deeds, and all deeds conveying the properties purchased through the Landfill
Neighborhood Protection Program shall be warranty deeds if so authorized by the County Attorney.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 5 - CHARGING THE SOLID WASTE AND RESOURCE MANAGEMENT
COMMITTEE WITH DEVELOPING ALTERNATE PLANS FOR
FINANCING RECYCLING
Moved by Mrs. Livesay, seconded by Mr. Lerner. Mr. Proto requested the record show that this
will not be the only option explored. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 14, Noes - 0, Excused - 1
(Representative Culligan). Adopted.
WHEREAS, collection and marketing of recyclables will cost County residents more than $1.5
million in 1993, and
WHEREAS, many County residents are uncertain whether present financing plans are distributing
costs fairly, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, That
the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee is charged with continuing to research methods
for financing County recycling activities after 1993 and developing alternate plans among which shall be
a plan under which the County would charge a per -container fee for collection and processing of
recyclables.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 6 - APPROVAL FOR PURSUIT OF CONTRACT BETWEEN NEW YORK
STATE DIVISION OF PROBATION AND CORRECTIONAL
ALTERNATIVES AND THE ALCOHOLISM COUNCI L OF
TOMPKINS COUNTY, INC.
Moved by Mr. Mason, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, the current Alternatives to Incarceration Service Plan (for contract year July 1, 1992
through June 30, 1993) does not make use of $5,242 (five thousand, two hundred and forty-two dollars)
of the total amount originally allocated to Tompkins County by the New York State Division of Probation
and Correctional Alternatives (NYSDPCA) for the provision of programs which provide alternatives to
incarceration, and
WHEREAS the Alcoholism Council of Tompkins County, Inc., a private, not-for-profit
organization, has submitted a "New Programmatic Proposal" which would become part of the above-
mentioned Alternatives to Incarceration Service plan (for contract year July 1, 1992 through June 30,
1993). Said proposal providing for the staffing necessary to deliver up to four (4) hours per week of on -
8
January 5, 1993
site alcohol evaluations of defendants detained at the Tompkins County Public Safety Building, so as to
assist in expediting the court processing of such cases, and
WHEREAS, the New York State Division of Probation and Correctional Alternatives is willing to
reimburse the Alcoholism Council of Tompkins County, Inc. for the cost of said proposal (up to the limit
of $5,242) at the rate of 100 percent for the duration of the Updated Service Plan year based upon: (1) the
amount of cash credit earned by Tompkins County, (2) the high percentage (59.3%) of admissions to the
jail for which alcohol use is involved, and (3) the desires of the Criminal Justice Advisory/Alternatives to
Incarceration Board, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Safety Committee, That the "New Programmatic
Proposal" submitted by the Alcoholism Council of Tompkins County, Inc., be approved as a modification
to the current Alternatives to Incarceration Service Plan Update for the contract year July 1, 1992 through
June 30, 1993, contingent upon: a) a 100 percent rate of reimbursement from the NYSDPCA to the
Alcoholism Council of Tompkins County, Inc.: and b) no further cost to Tompkins County; and c) the
ability of the NYSDPCA to effect a contract with the Alcoholism Council of Tompkins County, Inc.
which is separate and distinct from the current contract with the Tompkins County Probation Depai lnient
(State Contract #C920133, Local Contract #PROB92-005).
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 7 - ACCEPTANCE OF GRANT AND BUDGET ADJUSTMENT -
HEALTHY HEART PROGRAM
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, the County of Tompkins has submitted a request for a grant of funds from the New
York State Department of Health as approved on November 17, 1992 (CA091-92) for the development of
a community campaign to promote Tobacco Free Awareness Week (January 24 - January 30, 1993), now
therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education and Budget and Administration
Committees, That Tompkins County hereby accept said grant,
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller be and is hereby authorized and directed to make the
following adjustment on his books:
APPROPRIATION:
A4021.4330
.4332
.4402
.4333
.4452
.4465
Printing/Copying
Books/Publications
Legal Advertising
Promotional Supplies
Postage
Job Nec. Travel & Training
$1,170
2,907
200
617
50
56
REVENUE:
A4021.3401 State Aid $5,000
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator is hereby authorized to sign any and all
agreements necessary to complete this project.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 8 - TOMPKINS CORTLAND COMMUNITY COLLEGE AMENDED
STATE FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE FOR 1991-92
9
January 5, 1993
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, Ciaschi, Dietershagen, Little and Mickelson, Certified Public Accountants (CPA's),
has completed an audit of the Tompkins Cortland Community College financial records for the period
September 1, 1992 through August 31, 1992, and
WHEREAS, the State Annual Financial Report for 1991-92 has been submitted and approved with
expenditures and revenues totaling $11,357,310, and
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County sponsor contribution to the 1991-92 fiscal year did not change,
and
WHEREAS, 1991-92 actual State Aid calculation was higher than originally budgeted, and
WHEREAS, the college's 1991-92 surplus of $154,491 included additional State Aid of
$43,200.65, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education and Budget and Administration
Committees, That the State financial assistance for Tompkins Cortland Community College in 1991-92
be increased to $3,764,190.65 from the original budgeted level of $3,720,990,
RESOLVED, further, That the State of New York pay Tompkins Cortland Community College the
amended State financial assistance of $43,200.65 for the year,
RESOLVED, further, That this Resolution shall become effective upon the adoption of a
concurrent resolution by the Cortland County Legislature.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 9 - AUDIT OF FINAL PAYMENT - CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT
AND VALUE ENGINEERING (PRE -CONSTRUCTION PHASE) -
CIMINELLI-COWPER
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Stein. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes -
14, Noes - 0, Excused - 1 (Representative Culligan). Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the following claim against the County of Tompkins, be and hereby is audited by the Board of
Representatives:
Vendor Payment Request Account No. Amount
Ciminelli-Cowper 5 (Final) 5610.9239 $1,750
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller be and hereby is authorized and directed to pay said
claim from Account No. 5610.9239.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 10 - AUTHORIZATION OF DETOUR - ROUTE 96
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Mason, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, the New York State Depailnient of Transportation proposes to replace the Route 96
bridges over Jenny Creek (BIN 1035020) to Taughannock Creek (BIN 1035030), located in the Town of
Ulysses, Tompkins County, and
WHEREAS, in conformance with Section 42 of the New York State Highway Law, the New York
State Department of Transportation proposes to utilize the following roads and streets as detours during
the period of construction. Vehicle traffic, excluding trucks, will be detoured from Route 96, easterly
10
January 5, 1993
along Taughannock Park Road then southerly along Jacksonville Road to its intersection with Route 96,
and
WHEREAS, the New York State Department of Transportation will provide traffic control devices
and make improvements prior to construction and repairs when necessary to the above-mentioned roads
to make them adequate to handle additional detour traffic, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the Board of Representatives of the County of Tompkins does hereby authorize the New York State
Department of Transportation to utilize the above-mentioned roads as detours and maintain traffic on
them in accordance with Subsection 619 of its Standard Specifications during the period of construction,
RESOLVED, further, That the County of Tompkins will continue to provide snow and ice control
for the above-mentioned roads and streets,
RESOLVED, further, That the Clerk of this Board is hereby directed to transmit three (3) certified
copies of this resolution to the State Department of Transportation.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 11 - AUTHORIZING A PUBLIC HEARING - AIRPORT LEASE
AGREEMENT WITH US AIR
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That a public hearing be held by the Board of Representatives on Tuesday, January 19, 1993 at 5:30
o'clock in the evening thereof at Board Chambers of the Tompkins County Courthouse, 320 North Tioga
Street, Ithaca, New York concerning a proposed lease agreement with US Air at the Tompkins County
Airport. At such time and place all persons interested in the subject matter will be hard concerning the
same,
RESOLVED, further, That the Clerk of the Board is hereby authorized and directed to place proper
notice of such public hearing in the official newspaper of the County.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 12 - AWARD OF BIDS - NEW TERMINAL PROJECT - TOMPKINS
COUNTY AIRPORT
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Proto. James Kazda, Sr. Civil Engineer, reported that
since the December 15, 1992 Board meeting Triangle Steel and CNY have withdrawn bids. He stated
that the County Attorney made a determination based on New York State Construction Law that the
County can go with the second bidder if the first bidder withdraws their bid. He said that he believes the
cost to delay the project would justify the additional cost of going with these bids. Mr. Stein,
Representative, District No. 3, stated that the funds coming to the County to build this terminal come
from a fund dedicated to this and may not be used for other purposes such as reducing the property tax
levy. If Tompkins County does not use these funds they will be used somewhere else. Mr. Nicholas,
Airport Manager stated that the additional cost incurred by awarding to the second lowest bidder will be
taken care of by US Air.
It was the consensus of the Board to separate out Fergusson Electric. A voice vote on the
resolution exempting Fergusson Electric resulted as follows: Ayes - 13, Noes - 1 (Representative Lerner),
Excused -1 Representative Culligan). Adopted.
11
January 5, 1993
Mr. Winch, Chairman, Public Works and Construction Management Committee, stated that the
County has concerns in awarding an electrical bid for this project to Fergusson Electric of Connecticut
due to alleged violations at the State Fairgrounds and at the Cornell Vet School in regard to
apprenticeship training and overtime. County staff has contacted the New York State Department of
Labor. The Department has told the County that these are alleged violations which are under
investigation.
Chairman Watros declared recess from 7:47 p.m. - 7:55 p.m. It was Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded
by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members present, to enter into executive
session at 7:55 p.m. to discuss Airport Litigation. The meeting returned to open session at 8:15 p.m.
It was Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mrs. Call, to award the bid for electrical work to
Fergusson Electric of Plainville, CT in the amount of $699,400. A roll call vote resulted as follows:
Ayes - 9, Noes - 5 (Representatives Dietrich, Lerner, Mink, Schuler and Stein), Excused - 1
(Representative Culligan). Adopted.
WHEREAS, the Division of Purchasing and Central Services has duly advertised for bids in
accordance with specifications as approved by Airport Construction Committee, the Federal Aviation
Administration (FAA), and the New York State Depai tiuent of Transportation (NYSDOT), and
WHEREAS, bids were received an publicly opened and read on August 17 and August 18, 1992,
now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Airport Construction and Capital Program Committees,
That the bids for the New Terminal Project be awarded as follows, subject to agreement by the FAA and
NYSDOT and subject also to funding commitments being received from the FAA, NYSDOT and the
Airlines:
Site Work, Paving and - Hartman Development of Macedon, NY
Utilities in the amount of $1,723,749
General Construction - Daniel J. Lynch of Endwell, NY
in the amount of $2,170,000
Heating, Ventilation and - J & K Plumbing and Heating of Binghamton, NY
Air Conditioning in the amount of $763,000
Electrical - Fergusson Electric of Plainville, CT
in the amount of $699,400
Structural Steel - Raulli & Sons, Inc. of Syracuse, NY
in the amount of $635,000
Plumbing and Fire - ABL Plumbing and Heating of Syracuse, NY
Protection in the amount of $206,640
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator is hereby authorized to execute contracts
with these firms to implement these bids,
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller is hereby authorized to borrow monies until
reimbursement is received from the FAA, NYSDOT, PFC's and the Airlines for this project,
RESOLVED, further, That any remaining budgeted funds be allocated for miscellaneous project
expense, staff services, construction testing and change orders,
RESOLVED, further, That a project contingency of ten percent be established, funds being
available in Account No. 5610.9239 and the County Administrator be authorized to sign future change
orders up to the contingency amount,
RESOLVED, further, That the county, as Lead Agency in this Type I action under the SEQR
process, has completed a Full Environmental Assessment, has reviewed the assessment with all involved
and interested parties, has findings to same, and has determined that the assessment did not identify any
significant unmitigable impacts as identified in the project.
SEQR ACTION: TYPE I OR UNLISTED
(DETERMINATIONS OF FINDINGS INCLUDED HEREIN)
12
January 5, 1993
RESOLUTION NO. 13 - RESOLUTION IN MEMORIAM - SCHUYLER COUNTY
Moved by Ms. Mink and seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, the Schuyler County on October 15, 1992 experienced the tragic murders of four
members of its Department of Social Services staff, and
WHEREAS, the lives of these county staff were taken in the course of their assigned duties in the
support collection unit of the Department of Social Services at Watkins Glen, the county seat of Schuyler
County, and
WHEREAS, the entire Schuyler County community grieves the loss of these exemplary staff
members as a result of a senseless and wanton act of violence committed by a disturbed individual who
thereafter took his own life by gun shot, and
WHEREAS, the victims' families, their co-workers and friends continue to mourn their deaths, it is
now an appropriate time to remember each of these dedicated county staff in this period of sorrow - and
commit that all concerned work together to prevent such senseless acts in the future, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, That the Tompkins County Board of Representatives pauses to remember the four
women killed in Schuyler County on, October 15, 1992 while serving the citizens of the county and the
clients of the Department of Social Services:
Phyllis K. Caslin, a Support Unit Investigator. She had
worked for the County for 18 years and was the mother of
three grown children.
Florence A. Pike, the Support Unit Supervisor. She had worked for
the County since 1972, was married and had three grown children.
Denise Miller Van Amburg, an Account Clerk who worked for the
County for two years. She was married and had two young children.
Nancy J. Wheeler, a Senior Account Clerk. She had worked for the
County for eight years, was married and had three grown children.
RESOLVED, further, That Tompkins County residents be aware that the Schuyler County
Legislature has established a fund entitled the "Schuyler County Workers Memorial Fund" to assist
families of the victims and that contributions can be made by payment to "Schuyler County Treasurer -
Memorial Fund" and sent to Schuyler Treasurer, 105 Ninth Street, Watkins Glen, NY 14891,
RESOLVED, further, That a copy of this resolution be forwarded to the Schuyler County
Legislature Chairman and to the New York State Association of Counties.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 14 - RESOLUTION OF RESPECT - HONORABLE FREDERICK G.
MARCHAM
Moved by Mrs. Call and seconded by Mr. Todd, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, the Honorable Frederick George Marcham was known throughout Tompkins County
for both civic and academic diligence and integrity, and
WHEREAS, he first brought his many skills to the position of Mayor of the Village of Cayuga
Heights in 1956, and
WHEREAS, he continued to serve in that capacity for 32 years, the longest tenure of a village
mayor in New York State, and
WHEREAS, he entered all intermunicipal activities with honesty, humor and wisdom, and all of
Tompkins County benIfitted from these traits, now therefore be it
13
January 5, 1993
RESOLVED, unanimously by this Board, That the members thereof express their appreciation for
the many contributions made to the community by him and extend their sympathy and sincere
condolences to the family of Frederick G. Marcham,
RESOLVED, further, That the Clerk of the Board forward a certified copy of the resolution to the
family of Frederick G. Marcham and to the Village of Cayuga Heights.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
It was Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mrs. Livesay, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to reconsider Resolution No. 2 entitled Resolution Determining Significance Pursuant
to SEQR and Authorization for the Issuance of a Negative Declaration - Execution of Purchase Option
Agreement with Thorntree Hill Associates.
Mr. Stein, Representative, District No. 3 questioned the SEQR action on this resolution and
referred to a section of the State SEQR Law read by Ms. Darlington under privilege of the floor. Mr.
Mulvey, County Attorney, assured the Board that this is an unlisted action and does not require a full
environmental assessment because it is under 100 acres.
A voice vote on the resolution following reconsideration resulted as follows: Ayes - 12, Noes - 2
(Representatives Schuler and Stein), Excused - 1 (Representative Culligan). Adopted.
RESOLUTION NO. 404 - BLANKET AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE REAL ESTATE
LISTING AGREEMENTS, PURCHASE AGREEMENTS AND
DEEDS
Resolution No. 404 of 1992 was Tabled indefinitely. A revised version was adopted as Resolution
No. 4 of 1993.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the County
Administrator is authorized to execute real estate listing agreements pursuant to the County's contract real
estate broker, purchase agreements, and deeds in order to convey property acquired by Tompkins County
through foreclosure and through the Landfill Neighborhood Protection Program,
RESOLVED, further, That with respect to 1992 foreclosed properties only, the County
Administrator is authorized to execute listing agreements effective April 1, 1993, but that in future years
those agreements may be authorized immediately after foreclosure by Tompkins County, provided that
written notice is provided to parties whose properties are in foreclosure that this will take place,
RESOLVED, further, That when the County Administrator is able to determine that a foreclosed
property is occupied by the owner of record at the time taxes became delinquent, that no listing agreement
may be signed until specifically authorized by the Budget and Administration Committee and that said
Committee shall provide said authorization only when it is determined that no reasonable efforts are being
made by the owner of record to secure sufficient funds to re -purchase the property,
RESOLVED, further, That all deeds of conveyance by Tompkins County of foreclosed properties
shall be quitclaim deeds, and all deeds conveying the properties purchased through the Landfill
Neighborhood Protection Program shall be warranty deeds if so authorized by the County Attorney.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
On motion of the appropriate committee chairmen and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by
voice vote by members present, the following appointments were made to various advisory boards:
Fire, Disaster and EMS Advisory Board
Terms expire December 31, 1995
14
January 5, 1993
Chris Burris - Town of Lansing Delegate representative
Dennis Griffin - Town of Lansing Alternate representative
Landfill Neighborhood Protection Committee
Term expires December 31, 1995
Nancy Ten Kate - Town of Dryden representative
Service Delivery Area/Private Industry Council
Arlene Chase - Business sector representative
It was Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to enter into executive session at 8:29 p.m. to discuss litigation and personnel matters.
The meeting returned to open session at 9:01 p.m.
It was Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to confirm the County Administrators recommendation to appoint Brenda Vassalotti to
the position of Acting Public Health Director.
On motion, the meeting adjourned at 9:02 p.m.
15
January 12, 1993
Special Board Meeting
Chairman Watros called the meeting to order at 5:30 p.m.
Members and guests participated in the Pledge of Allegiance.
Present: 13 Representatives. Excused: 2 (Representatives Shurtleff and Winch, Representative
Mink was excused at 6:55 p.m. and Representative Dietrich was excused at 7:07 p.m.)
Mrs. Livesay, Chair, Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, requested that the
haulers be invited to sit amongst Board members and to be included in the discussion.
RESOLUTION NO. 15 - RESOLUTION OF INTENT TO INSURE CONTROL OF SOLID
WASTE HAULING
Moved by Mrs. Livesay and seconded by Mrs. Call.
The haulers introduced themselves: Doug Brown - Doug's Trash Removal; Rick Ferrel, Assistant
Superintendent, City of Ithaca; Bob Formeck, Vice President, Superior; Joseph Micilcavage, President,
Superior Disposal Services.
1. Discussion of past operational problems - hauler perspective, County perspective.
Chairman Watros stated that the purpose of this meeting was to discuss this Resolution and give
an opportunity for discussion between the Board members, staff and the haulers.
Mr. Micilcavage asked that the Board clarify the purpose of the Resolution in terms of the
problems with the existing system and how to improve it and make it less costly for the citizens.
Mrs. Livesay stated that the purpose of the resolution is to answer concerns of the Board about
problems that the County has in terms of not being able to insure that the revenues the County needs to
operate programs come to the County. She also stated that the present system has revenues collected by
haulers associated with picking up and hauling of trash, and that members of this Board feel the. County
cannot afford to lose any more dollars, therefore, need to have assurance of this income. The purpose of
the resolution is to ask staff to explore all possibilities to determine if there may be more ways to insure
revenues.
Mr. Micilcavage responded that he thought this was insured through the Flow Control Law.
Mrs. Livesay stated that after the adoption of the Law, the County lost months of revenues but
there would be no discussion on grievance issues at this meeting.
Mr. Proto stated that the County is looking to insure cash flow and to insure that that the trash is
not being taken out of the County.
Mrs. Livesay reported that Barbara Eckstrom, Solid Waste Manager, expects that all waste
generated in Tompkins County is not leaving Tompkins County.
Mr. Brown stated that no one is taking trash out of the County.
Mr. Lerner added that the issue of compliance or non-compliance of the Flow Control Law is not
the only thing that the resolution is intending to address and that there has been problems with some
16
January 12, 1993
haulers in delivering waste to the County and failing to pay when required or not at all. Mr. Lerner also
added that the County is paying about $ 30,000 a year in expenses in processing the paperwork to
monitor on which haulers are dropping off garbage and who is or is not paying for their disposal fee. Mr.
Lerner feels that there is a way to simplify this process. He restated that there is a need for the County to
think about consolidating the separate hauling and payment systems. Mr. Lerner stated the there also
needs to be discussion on ways the County can minimize the cost of trash collection for all residents.
Mr. Stein asked the haulers to discuss any problems that exist now so that the Board can focus on
solving these problems in order to assure the County residents that there will not be problems in the
future, similar to those in the past.
Mr. Brown reassured the Board that the haulers have a good working relationship with the County
and that there is no problem paying $95/ton disposal fee. Mr. Brown went on to say that the problem
arose when the County asked the haulers to pay the $145 a ton fee.
Ms. Mink questioned Mr. Ferrel asking if the City had a problem paying the $145/ton fee and if
this was the cause for running up their debts.
Mr. Ferrel answered saying that the City had an excess amount of money before the increased fees
and used the excess money to fund the following year and that when the price went up to $145 a ton the
City could not pay.
Mrs. Livesay explained that the County did not ask the haulers to pay $145/ton, the citizens of the
County are the ones who were to pay for the disposal of their trash and if there is a problem with this
system then it needs to be discussed.
Mr. Brown stated that because of the problems of residents over stuffing bags, haulers are the ones
who pay the price in the long run.
Mrs. Livesay stated that she felt it was Mr. Brown's opinion that it doesn't work well for the
haulers to collect the fees, therefore, there needs to be another system.
Mr. Culligan stated that the system compensates itself due to some residents understuffing and that
this makes up for those who overstuff their garbage bags. Mr. Culligan suggested that special trash bags
be purchased that will break if stuffed over a certain weight. He requested that the first option in the
resolution include trashbags.
Mrs. Livesay accepted Mr. Culligan's suggestion as a friendly amendment and stated that the
information could be gathered upon request.
Mr. Micilcavage stated that Superior does not have a problem with the $95/ton disposal fee.
Mrs. Livesay replied that the committee has been working on other ways of collecting the disposal
fee, and that the County residents will be paying this year to make up for the deficit. Mrs. Livesay
restated that the haulers can not decide what the County's costs are just as the County can not decide the
haulers' cost. Mrs. Livesay stated that the County has lowered the tipping fee to $95/ton and now there
needs to be another way to make up the loss of revenue due to lowering the fee. This is the proposed
annual fee that the County is discussing. Mrs. Livesay commented that there is a feeling of concern
about paying this fee, some people are saying that they would rather pay it in the disposal cost in the
trash tag.
17
January 12, 1993
Mr. Stein stated that the City of Ithaca's garbage is left at the curbside if it is over 35 pounds and
asked the haulers why can't the haulers do the same.
Mr. Ferrel explained that the City assesses the resident a penalty fee if the bags are over weight.
Mr. Culligan stated that the haulers need to all have the same rules of operation.
Mr. Micilcavage stated that the City of Ithaca's system is different and that they are not in
competition, thus, having the option to leave the garbage and not worry about losing business to someone
else.
Mr. Mason stressed that if everyone continues to haul within the County, the haulers stand a better
chance of not losing business by leaving the garbage if over weight.
Mr. Lerner stated that Mr. Micilcavage is apparently suggesting that municipal collection is
superior to private collection because competition creates extra costs.
Mr. Brown commented that the County made the haulers the middleman on the budget. He stated
that the City can leave their garbage because they have scales. Mr. Brown stated that the higher the rate
is, the less garbage there is to pick up because people are resorting to burning their trash. Mr. Brown
explained that Brown's Trash has started a recycling project and said that customers are burning their
trash in order to decrease the amount of trash needed to be picked up. Mr. Brown stated that the "system
is doomed to fail".
Mrs. Livesay replied to Mr. Brown's statement stating that the County made the haulers the
middleman to collect the fee. She said that it was the haulers' choice at that time to collect the fee. Mrs.
Livesay stated that maybe the haulers wish not to be the middleman any longer.
Mr. Brown replied that at $95/ton that there is no problem.
Mr. Lerner stated it was his opinion that it's not that Mr. Brown does not want to be the
middleman but that the haulers do not want to be the enforcer on the weight of the bags.
Mr. Brown replied that the $95/ton is not a problem and that neighboring counties are decreasing
their fee to $70/ton and that the County needs to explain the fee and provide a breakdown. Mr. Brown
stated that recycling needs to be done separately. Mr. Brown said that he feels that County residents
should pay a fee for recycling that is separate from the disposal fee.
Mrs. Eckstrom clarified that the revenues versus expenses is equal and the better the County gets
at recycling the higher the disposal costs will be. She explained that people could pay less even if the low
price is higher than it is at present.
Mr. Todd stated that when the disposal fee went up, the incentive to reduce trash increased.
Mr. Lerner replied that for every ton of material that gets diverted from disposal into recycling,
from the point of view of the County, the material that is sent out for disposal generates the $95 By
recycling, the County receives nothing, therefore, by recycling, the County is undermining its' budget
which then hinders a revenue stream set up for recycling. Therefore, Mr. Lerner believes this needs to be
dealt with.
18
January 12, 1993
Mr. Proto referred to the guidelines set for discussion at this meeting, Item No. 1 regarding past
operational problems and asked the haulers if there were anymore problems (besides the fee) that the
County needs to be made aware of.
Mr. Brown replied that he had no problems and that the landfill was easily accessible, best kept
and run as well as the transfer station and that up until last year he has no problems.
Mr. Micilcavage replied that Superior has a good working relationship with Mrs. Eckstrom and
Mr. Squires and even though there are still some problems with Flow Control, overall everything is fine.
Mr. Ferrel stated that he felt the location of the landfill was convenient.
Mr. Culligan commented that with composting there is a decrease in garbage waste and that
Cornell will be handling a great volume of composting and asked Mrs. Eckstrom how she foresees
composting on the County level.
Mrs. Eckstrom stated that there is a charge for composting on a per ton basis and that the Solid
Waste Department is working jointly with Cornell and the City of Ithaca on a composting facility. She
stated that the Director will consider examining the co -collection of composting and trash. She stated
that the County has the capabilities of reducing residents' cost of collecting both.
2. What relationship should or needs to exist between County government and the haulers? What
do haulers need? What does County government need?
Mr. Stein stated that the components of the haulers' role needs to be a guarantee of assurance of
long-term stability between the haulers and the County.
Mr. Micilcavage replied that Superior wants stability also but they too need assurance that they are
doing business with the County without fear of going out of business due to possible implementation of a
municipal collection system. He stated that their relationship with the County is excellent at this time and
that they are complying with the transfer station regulations and that they do not foresee going anywhere
else. Mr. Micilcavage stated that Superior wants to do business in the County.
Mrs. Livesay stated her concerns of difference of opinion that people would rather pay it all on the
disposal fee on their trash tag and that the Board needs to try to resolve the difference between what the
public needs and what the haulers need to stay in business in order for the County to meet expenses.
Mr. Micilcavage stated that his customers are happy with the system and that the only way to get a
clear understanding of what people want is possibly through a referendum.
Mrs. Livesay stated that some people expressed they do not want to pay the annual fee that there
needs to be some other way to collect for the revenues. She felt they need to reconsider the collection
fees to satisfy the residents.
Mr. Micilcavage stated that his company has explained the recycling system to their customers and
are not experiencing any problems.
Mrs. Livesay commented that the fee is not directly related to how much one recycles.
Mr. Brown replied that he identified the annual fee as a recycling fee and explained to his
customers that it was a recycling fee. Mr. Brown stated that he felt the County needs to explain the
system.
19
January 12, 1993
Mrs. Call stated that in order to absorb the costs, the County needs to have an additional fee source
and that the Solid Waste Committee is working on revising a plan for a recycling fee.
Mr. Proto stated that he feels the haulers want to be part of the decision-making process and
expressed the need to keep communication open.
3. Distribute chart on costs - Hauling and County program breakdown and assessment of fees -
Discussion
Mrs. Eckstrom briefly explained the purpose of the Recycling and Disposal charts and they are
designed to show the average amount and cost of waste disposal and recycling per household. She also
explained the charts outline the waste and cost per pound per household for waste collection. She stated
that the goal is to refine the system of collection no matter what the material is in order to strivefor low
cost and provide a degree of service that people are satisfied with. Mrs. Eckstrom referred to the
brochure What We're Paying and Why explaining that the recycling fee is assessed for services being
provided and for the opportunity to access recycling service in this County.
Mrs. Dietrich suggested that the haulers consider bi-weekly disposal collection.
Mr. Watros referred to the handout stating that the County has a $7.5 million expense relative to
waste issues and with the present plan with the haulers, it only generates about $4.3 million in revenue
and the County is in need of an additional $3.2 million in order to balance the budget.
4. How should we handle collection of waste, recyclables, etc., in a cost effective reliable manner
that enables County government to collect the revenues needed for the operation of the
programs and maximizes the ability of local haulers to remain in business?
Ms. Mink asked the haulers what they felt would be the most cost effective way is to handle
garbage.
Mr. Ferrel stated that the City's circumstances are different than the other haulers being that the
City is non profit, and he feels that the haulers are entitled to make a profit.
Ms. Mink stated that the County is focusing on obtaining the best price for residents.
Mr. Culligan suggested that municipalities place their bin out every two weeks in order to cut
costs.
Mrs. Eckstrom stated that the villages do not need pick up every week versus the cities who need
pick up every week. There is a need to examine a more cost effective system.
Ms. Mink asked Mrs. Eckstrom what the reaction would be if the County put garbage disposal out
to bid.
Mr. Micilcavage stated that Superior likes the system the way it is, but he felt that if the County
decides to have municipal collection, then Superior will need to accept it.
Mr. Brown stated that he is happy with the system now, and said the public has informed him that
they too are happy with the present system.
20
January 12, 1993
Mr. Lerner explained that he feels there may not be a cost savings by eliminating the drop-off
centers, but by having curbside collection of paper, there is less volume at the drop-off centers.
Mrs. Eckstrom stated that the drop-off centers cost more now because they collect less material
and there are fixed costs. Mrs. Eckstrom stated that she feels the costs for handling mixed paper is
inefficient and there is a need to explore this further and examine the options.
Mrs. Livesay stated that some of the public has conveyed to her that they feel there is a need for
more alternatives in choosing a hauler. She restated that the some of the public has also questioned
whether costs may be higher due to various haulers driving greater miles to pick up a small amount of
bags.
Thomas Corey, member, Chamber of Commerce Board of Directors, reported that a sub-
committee is in the process of preparing a report for the Board of Representatives. He said the committee
is conducting an analysis based upon the guidelines Chairman Watros provided with a break down of the
areas that County government is involved in pertaining to solid waste disposal. Mr. Corey reported that
the committee has collected about 50 comments from businesses in Tompkins County regarding their
feelings towards the proposed solid waste fee. He stated that there are some major concerns by large
manufacturing businesses regarding the implementation of this fee. Mr. Corey requested that Mrs. Call
provide the Chamber with a copy of the changes in guidelines prepared by the Budget and
Administration Committee upon completion.
Mrs. Call stated that she received copies of the comments from these businesses that Mr. Corey
was referring to and would provide him with the new guidelines upon completion.
Ms. Mink was excused from the meeting at 6:55 p.m.
Mr. Evans stated that he would like to consider the possibility of charging by volume versus
weight and requested that an analysis be done.
It was moved by Mr. Evans, seconded by Mr. Proto to amend the resolution as follows: Item No.
7, "The County examine the volume method of charging for waste". A voice vote resulted as follows:
Ayes - 12, Noes - 0, Excused - 3 (Representatives Mink, Shurtleff and Winch). Motion carried.
A voice vote resulted on the resolution as amended as follows: Ayes - 12, Noes - 0, Excused - 3
(Representatives Mink, Shurtleff and Winch). Adopted.
WHEREAS, some citizens and members of this Board have requested that County government
exercise more control over garbage collection services in the County, and
WHEREAS, a number of options exist for County government to prevent abuses by more closely
regulating the trash hauling businesses, including:
1) The County selling trashtags or trashbags, and/or
2) The County buying and operating trash vehicles, and/or
3) The County putting trash collection out to bid as a exclusive County
provided service, and/or
4) The County assisting municipalities in providing trash collection
service to residents, and/or
5) The County franchising trash hauling districts, and/or
6) The County operating its own collection service in competition with
the private sector, and/or
7) The County examine the volume method of charging for waste, now therefore be it
21
January 12, 1993
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, That
the County Attorney and County Administrator be directed to prepare a report and a plan that would
determine all the steps necessary to insure sufficient County control over all refuse hauling not provided
by municipalities, to guarantee the revenues and overall integrity of the Tompkins County Solid Waste
Management program,
RESOLVED, further, That said report shall be presented to the Board by March 31, 1993.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
Mrs. Call announced that there will be a public informational discussion on the proposed annual
fee tomorrow evening, January 13, 1993.
Mrs. Livesay thanked the haulers and Board members for meeting this evening.
Chairman Watros declared recess from 7:07 p.m. - 7:17 p.m. Mrs. Dietrich was excused at 7:07
p.m.
It was moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mrs. Livesay and unanimously adopted by voice vote to
enter into executive session to discuss possible litigation. An executive session was held at 7:17 p.m.
The meeting returned to open session at 7:48 pm.
On motion, the meeting was adjourned at 7:48 p.m.
22
January 19, 1993
Regular Meeting
Public Hearing
Chairman Watros called the public hearing to order at 5:30 concerning a proposed lease
agreement for US Air at the Tompkins County Airport. Chairman Watros asked if any one wished to
speak? No one wished to speak and the public hearing was closed at 5:30 p.m.
Members and guests participated in the Pledge of Allegiance.
Present: 14 Representatives. Excused: 1 (Representative Dietrich).
It was Moved by Mr. Evans, seconded by Mrs. Call, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to approve the minutes of January 5, 1993, as corrected.
Chairman Watros read a proclamation declaring January 25, 1993, as Dr. John W. Hirshfield day
in recognition of his immeasurable contribution to health care in the community..
Chairman Watros announced that the 1993 list of committee assignments and responsibilities is
complete and available in the Board office. Chairman Watros announced the appointment of Beverly E.
Livesay as Intergovernmental Representative. Mrs. Livesay will assist the Chairman of the Board in the
affairs with relationships with both levels of government in Tompkins County as well as County
governments across the State. She will also assist the Board in its relationships throughout Tompkins
County as well as County governments across the State. She will also assist with issues at the State and
Federal level impacting our government such as legislative/mandate relief as well as other legislative
issues.
Under privilege of the floor, Donald Barber, Chairman, Environmental Management Council,
spoke concerning the proposed solid waste annual fee. Mr. Barber expressed opposition to the word
recycling being included in the title of this fee. He believes that by naming this a recycling fee, people
would be discouraged from recycling.
Under privilege of the floor, Mrs. Call, Representative, District No. 10, thanked Mrs. Livesay,
Representative, District No. 11, for her work as Chairman of the Solid Waste and Resource Management
Committee during a very difficult and stressful time in dealing with solid waste.
Under privilege of the floor, Mrs. Schuler, Representative, District No. 4, stated that Congressman
Maurice Hinchey has also expressed concern with the proposed solid waste annual fee including the word
recycling in its title. Mrs. Call, Chairman, Budget and Administration Committee, announced that the
title to the proposed fee has been changed and will not include the word recycling. Mrs. Schuler thanked
the Committee for changing the title of this fee.
Chairman Watros declared recess from 5:47 p.m. - 5:49 p.m. It was Moved by Mr. Evans,
seconded by Mrs. Livesay, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members present, to enter into
executive session at 5:49 p.m. to discuss the Procurement process for the Central Processing Facility. The
meeting returned to open session at 6:13 p.m.
Mr. Proto, Chairman, Health and Education Committee, reported on activities of the Board of
Health. Mr. Proto stated that the Board did not adopt the changes to the Sanitary Code as proposed by the
State of New York. Mr. Proto reported that the Health Department has begun lead screening and that
approximately 85 children have been tested and screened. Mr. Proto announced that the Health
Department is no longer issuing permits for open burning. These permits must now be obtained through
the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation.
23
January 19, 1993
Mr. Proto, Vice Chairman, Planning Committee, reported that the Committee met January 11. The
Advisory Board on Affordable Housing report was approved by the Committee. Mr. Proto stated that
Dwight Mengel, Transportation Planner, gave the Committee a presentation on the Ithaca Tompkins
Transportation Commission. Mr. Proto made mention of the Ithaca calendar of events produced by the
Convention and Visitors' Bureau.
Ms. Mink, Chairman, Human Services Committee, reported on the security situation at the Biggs
complex. Ms. Mink stated that following a meeting with the Public Safety Committee and Mary Pat
Dolan, Commissioner of Social Services, there is armed security personnel at the site. This will be on an
interim basis until a long range decision is made. She reported on a series of open forum meetings with
employees and tenants of Biggs A (see Employee Council report later in meeting). Ms. Mink made
reference to a recent article written by Jay Tokasz at the Ithaca Journal which reflected the situation
accurately. Ms. Mink restated the security measures already in effect at the Biggs complex. She stated
that she would like for the Committee to continue to meet in 1993 on the first Thursday of the month at
10:00 a.m. in 1993.
Ms. Mink, Public Information Committee, reported on a panel discussion concerning solid waste
that will air on January 21. She stated that the Committee would like to hold an issues forum and if
anyone has ideas they would like aired or discussed to let the Committee know.
Mr. Mason, Chairman, Public Safety Committee, reported that the Committee met on January 7.
Mr. Mason reported that the Committee heard an extensive report from the Civilian Review Board for the
Sheriffs Department. He stated that 11 of 14 complaints have been resolved. Mr. Mason announced that
Darryl Avery, formerly of Schuyler County, now holds the position of Undersheriff. He stated that
Gordon Stevens, formerly of Chemung County, now holds the position of Corrections Administrator.
Mr. Winch, Chairman, Public Works and Construction Management Committee, reported that
Committee business is reflected on the agenda. Mr. Winch read the following statement concerning
Fergusson Electric:
"Fergusson Electric has had charges and allegations presented to them and to the Department of
Labor. The Depaitinent of Labor has been investigating these since our bid opening in late August.
Some allegations have been negotiated and settled by mutual agreement."
"We in Tompkins County plan to have our Airport project, as we do all projects, carried out in an
appropriate, legal fashion. We have gone through the bid process in a fashion that is consistent with
Public Construction Project Rules and Laws. An allegation is not a finding. It is our desire to have a
safe, legal, beautiful project that all residents in Tompkins County can be proud of -- the way all projects
have been run by the Department of Public Works, specific project committees such as the Airport
Development and Construction Committee, and the Board of Representatives during my tenure as
Chairman of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee."
"To that end our staff in Public Works, our construction manager, Ciminelli-Cowper, and our
County Attorney have been keeping abreast of this investigation since August. 'What are our plans in
Tompkins County?' We plan to have our construction manager, Ciminelli-Cowper, our Public Works
staff in cooperation with the Department of Labor, and the FAA if appropriate, review certified payrolls
prior to any payment for each of the contractors working on the project. These payments are usually
presented to the Committee monthly. I plan to have a copy of these certified payrolls on file in the Board
of Representatives for the duration of the project for representatives and the public to review."
Mr. Todd, Chairman, Fiscal Affairs Committee, stated that the Committee met on January 7 and 14
and began review on the proposed fiscal plan. Assemblyman Luster attended the January 14 meeting to
discuss the State takeover of Medicaid and sales tax.
24
January 19, 1993
Mr. Todd, Chairman, Article 18 Task Force, reported the Committee met January 7. Chairman
Watros and representatives of the Advisory Board on Indigent Representation were present at this
meeting. The Committee will meet again January 22.
Mrs. Livesay, Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, reported that the
Committee met January 14 and had a presentation on out of County disposal alternatives. The Committee
discussed out of County alternatives and also had a presentation from representatives from Seneca
Meadows. Mrs. Livesay stated that the Department of Environmental Conservation has made comments
on the Solid Waste Management Plan. She said now is the time for Corrections. The Solid Waste
Management Advisory Committee is working on some changes. Mrs. Livesay asked for comments and
suggestions to be submitted to the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee. Mrs. Livesay
reported that the Committee has accepted the 1993 Projected Recycling and Waste Disposal Cost
Analysis which demonstrates that the cost to the public per ton for recyclables is substantially less than
the cost to the public per ton for disposal. Mrs. Livesay reported on the status of the landfill closure grant
and stated that the grant still has not been signed by the State. She stated that Barbara Eckstrom, Solid
Waste Manager, will be reviewing the possibility of waste being accepted at local recycling drop-off
centers.
Mr. Lerner, Representative, District No. 1, stated that as Chairman of the Solid Waste and
Resource Management Committee in 1993, he will try to address serious concerns that have been raised
pertaining to solid waste. Mr. Lerner stated that in 1993 he would like the Committee to focus on
stability. Mr. Lerner listed the following eight categories he would like to address in 1993: 1) process
issues, 2) DR -7, 3) moving forward with the Central Processing Facility, 4) balance budget, 5)
privatization, 6) regulations of hauling, 7) illegal dumping and 8) public information.
Mrs. Call, Chairman, Budget and Administration Committee, reported that the Committee met
January 8. The Committee had a discussion on the assessment appeals process. Staff will review two
sections in the County Charter to see if the local and County appeals process can be combined. Mrs. Call
reported on progress with the proposed Solid Waste Annual Fee and stated that the proposed fee would be
due in August. She said there would be an appeals process and that the proposed fee may be changed in
1994. She briefly reviewed the recommendations in terms of cost and categories for this proposed fee.
Mr. Heyman, County Administrator, reported on activities of the Employee Safety and Health
Committee. Mr. Heyman requested that 1993 committee chairmen try to schedule committee meetings
five days prior to the Budget and Administration Committee meeting date. Mr. Heyman stated that an
open house for the Old Jail which has been converted into County office space will be announced at a
later time.
Cheryl Nelson, Chairman, Employee Council, reported that the Council met with the Human
Services Committee on January 6. It was decided that the Biggs A Security Committee would conduct a
series of open forum meetings with the employees and tenants in Biggs A. Following these meetings, a
recommendation will be sent to the Human Services Committee for consideration and action. Mrs.
Nelson thanked members of the Board for attending this meeting on January 6 and taking interest in
County employees.
Mr. Mulvey, County Attorney, stated that the monthly report for his office has been submitted to
the Board office. Mr. Mulvey reported on the successful outcome of a litigation case.
Chairman Watros gave the appropriate committee chairmen permission to withdraw from the
agenda the resolution entitled Authorization to Hire Above Midpoint - Sheriffs Department.
Chairman Watros gave the appropriate committee chairmen permission to withdraw from the
agenda the following resolutions with final committee action being affirmed:
25
January 19, 1993
CA004-93 - Approval of Contract with Town Of Caroline
CA005-93 - Renewal of Contract with Carlson Associates
CA006-93 - Approval of Contract with Better Housing for Tompkins County
CA007-93 - Approval of Contract with Davidson -Peterson Associates
CA008-93 - Authorization to Contract - Department of Social Services
CA009-93 - Acceptance of Award, Authorization to Execute Contracts and Budget Adjustment —
Breast Health Partnership — Health Department
CA010-93 - Authorization to Submit a Grant Proposal - Healthy Heart Program
CA011-93 - Award of Bid - Refuse Removal
CA012-93 - Reclassification of Position - Bridge Mechanic - Public Works
CA013-93 - Award of Bid - 1993 County Vehicles
CA014-93 - Amendment of Resolution No. CA085-92 - Award of Bid - Computer Software
RESOLUTION NO. 16 - DISSOLUTION OF THE ADVISORY BOARD ON AFFORDABLE
HOUSING
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, the Board of Representatives established the Tompkins County Advisory Board on
Affordable Housing, by Resolution No. 312 of October 10, 1989 in order to advise the Board of
Representatives on matters related to the provision of affordable housing, and
WHEREAS, the Advisory Board has prepared and presented to the Board of Representatives its
final report, entitled A Chronicle of Achievements and Recommendations, and
WHEREAS, the Advisory Board has fulfilled its charge by the Board of Representatives and
recommends the dissolution of the Advisory Board, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the Tompkins County
Advisory Board on Affordable Housing is hereby dissolved,
RESOLVED, further, That the Board of Representatives extends its appreciation and admiration to
all members to the Advisory Board, past and present, for their many hours of work on behalf of the Board
of Representatives, the County and its residents, and that the Chairman write a letter of appreciation to the
members of the Advisory Board.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 17 - AUTHORIZATION TO CONVEY PROPERTY OBTAINED BY
FORECLOSURE
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
RESOLVED, That the County Administrator is authorized to execute a quit claim deed conveying
Town of Caroline Tax Parcel No. 30-1-8 to Charles T. McDonald for the sum of $29,000.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 18 - CHANGE ORDER NO. 1 - TRANSFER AND HAULING OF
RECYCLABLE MATERIALS
Moved by Mrs. Livesay, seconded by Mr. Lerner, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
26
January 19, 1993
WHEREAS, the following change order in relation to Resolution No. 333 of 1991 has been
reviewed and approved by the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee:
Change Order No. 1 - Superior Disposal Service, Inc. shall be
required to compact all recyclable plastics to be hauled to a
County designated market. The compaction ratio for the densified
plastic shall be a minimum of 4 to 1. Superior Disposal shall be
authorized to charge $300 per month for this service which shall
result in a significant net savings to the County due to decreased
hauling costs, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, That
the County Administrator be and is hereby authorized to sign said change order on behalf of the County.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 19 - CHANGE ORDER NO. 2 - CURBSIDE COLLECTION OF
RECYCLABLE MATERIALS
Moved by Mrs. Livesay, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, the following change order in relation to Resolution No. 256 of 1991 has been
reviewed and approved by the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee:
Change Order No. 2 - Superior Disposal Service, Inc. shall be
authorized to collect curbside recyclable materials from
commercial establishments as specified by the County. This
service shall be provided to businesses which set out recyclable
materials equivalent to individual residential set -out quantities.
Superior Disposal Service, Inc. shall be paid the same per unit
cost ($14.04) unit/year as specified in the contract for the
residential curbside service. In addition, Superior Disposal
Service, Inc. shall be authorized to collect curbside recyclable
materials from residential and commercial units, as specified by
the County, within the City of Ithaca's collection service. The
cost for these services shall be the same cost ($14.04/unit/year)
as specified in the contract, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, That
the County Administrator be and is hereby authorized to sign said change order on behalf of the County.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 20 - TO AMEND RESOLUTION NO. 30 OF FEBRUARY 18, 1992 -
DETERMINATION AND CERTIFICATION OF COUNTY
CLERK'S ALLOWANCE - ANNUAL EXPENSES FOR
ADMINISTERING MORTGAGE TAX (Amended by Res. No. 374 of
1993)
Moved by Mr. Mason, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 262 of the Tax Law, recording officers are entitled to receive all
their necessary expenses for purposes of administering mortgage taxes in their offices on approval and
allowance by the State Tax Commission, and
27
January 19, 1993
WHEREAS, the State Tax Commission, by resolution duly adopted July 1, 1946, did determine
that such mortgage tax expenses be approved at the amount certified to the State Tax Commission by the
County Board of Representatives provided it is a reasonable and necessary allowance for such expenses,
and
WHEREAS, the County Clerk has conducted a cost analysis and has recommended that the
allowance for mortgage tax expenses be increased from $31,619 per annum to $33,508 per annum, now
therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Safety and Budget and Administration
Committees, That the sum of $33,508 per annum be and the same hereby is, determined as a reasonable
and necessary allowance of the Tompkins County Clerk, the recording officer of the County of Tompkins,
for the hire of clerks and assistants and other expenses to assist in the administration of the mortgage
recording tax law in her office, and that said sum of $33,508 is hereby certified to the State Tax
Commission as the reasonable and necessary allowance for such expenses,
RESOLVED, further, That the Clerk of the Board of Representatives is hereby directed to send a
certified copy of this resolution, with her original signature thereon, to the State Tax Commission,
RESOLVED, further, That this resolution shall take effect immediately.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 21 - APPROVAL OF AIRPORT LEASE AGREEMENT WITH US AIR -
NEW TERMINAL PROJECT
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, a public hearing was duly advertised and held on the 19th day of January, 1993,
regarding the contract with US Air to occupy the new terminal building, at which public hearing all
persons wishing to address the Board on this subject had an opportunity to speak, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the County Administrator is hereby authorized and directed to execute a contract on behalf of the
County with US Air.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 22 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE A GRANT AGREEMENT WITH
NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
(NYSDOT) - AIRPORT ACCESS CONTROL SECURITY SYSTEM
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Stein, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, The County has received a grant offer from the New York State Depai tnient of
Transportation (NYSDOT) in the amount of $10,800 towards the cost of the Airport Access Control
Security System, and
WHEREAS, the budget for said project is as follows:
FAA Share Account No. 5610.4592 $ 129,600
NYSDOT Share Account No. 5610.3592 $ 10,800
Local Share Account No. 5610.5031 $ 3,600
Total Project Cost Account No. 5610.9239 $ 144,000
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Airport Construction Committee, That the NYSDOT
grant offer in the amount of $10,800 be and hereby is accepted and that the County Administrator is
authorized to execute the required documents.
28
January 19, 1993
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 23 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE A GRANT AGREEMENT WITH
NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
(NYSDOT) - NEW TERMINAL PROJECT (TOMPKINS COUNTY
AIRPORT)
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, The County has received a grant offer from the New York State Depaitment of
Transportation (NYSDOT) in the amount of $ 248,105 towards the cost of constructing the New
Terminal, and
WHEREAS, the budget for said project is as follows:
FAA Share Account No. 5610.4592 $ 1,488,632
NYSDOT Share Account No. 5610.3592 $ 248,105
Local Share Account No. 5610.5031 $ 2,932,293
(PFCs, Airlines, Future Entitlement Funds)
Total Project Cost Account No. 5610.9239 $ 4,669,030
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Airport Construction Committee, That the NYSDOT
grant offer in the amount of $ 248,105 be and hereby is accepted and that the County Administrator is
authorized to execute the required documents.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE I
(FINDING OF NO SIGNIFICANT IMPACT)
RESOLUTION NO. 24 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE A GRANT AGREEMENT WITH
NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
(NYSDOT) - NEW TERMINAL RAMP AND ACCESS ROAD
(TOMPKINS COUNTY AIRPORT)
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Stein, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, The County has received a grant offer from the New York State Department of
Transportation (NYSDOT) in the amount of $ 156,000 towards the cost of constructing the New Terminal
Ramp and Access Road, and
WHEREAS, the budget for said project is as follows:
FAA Share Account No. 5610.4592 $ 2,808,000
NYSDOT Share Account No. 5610.3592 $ 156,000
Local Share Account No. 5610.5031 $ 1,113,499
(PFCs, Airlines, Future Entitlement Funds)
Total Project Cost Account No. 5610.9239 $ 4,077,499
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Airport Construction Committee, That the NYSDOT
grant offer in the amount of $ 156,000 be and hereby is accepted and that the County Administrator is
authorized to execute the required documents.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE I
(FINDING OF NO SIGNIFICANT IMPACT)
29
January 19, 1993
RESOLUTION NO. 25 - AUTHORIZING AN INCREASE IN CONTRACT FEE AND BUDGET
ADJUSTMENT - AIRLINE NEGOTIATIONS - TOMPKINS COUNTY
AIRPORT
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Culligan, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, a contract for $ 52,000 was executed on August 13, 1991 with Aviation Planning
Associates Inc., of Cincinnati, Ohio for services in connection with a cost center structure review, an
airline rates and charges analysis and airline negotiations for the new terminal project, and
WHEREAS, an increase of $ 8,000 to a total of $ 60,000 was authorized by the Public Works and
Construction Management and Airport Construction Committees on September 23, 1992 for creation of a
formal Airline Agreement, which was not part of the original Scope of Services, and
WHEREAS, the contract negotiations have become protracted because of the difficult economic
times within the airline industry, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management and Airport
Construction Committees, That the contract with Aviation Planning Associates Inc. be increased from $
60,000 to an amount not to exceed $ 72,000 to finalize negotiations and produce the final agreement,
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller is hereby authorized to transfer said additional amount
of $12,000 from the Airport Fund Balance to Construction Account No. HV5610.9239 to meet the cost of
this contract.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 26 - DEMAND FOR RESTITUTION BY STATE AND FOR ACTION BY
GOVERNOR RE: NEW YORK STATE POLICE CONDUCT
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Ms. Mink, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, the County of Tompkins has incurred and become charged with certain expenses
which would not have been incurred but for the intentional misconduct of certain officers of the New
York State Police and but for the negligence in the supervision of said officers by superior officers of the
New York State Police, and
WHEREAS, a Special Prosecutor has been appointed by the Tompkins County Court to investigate
and prosecute David L. Harding and Robert Lishansky on the basis of an alleged conflict of interest or
appearance of impropriety presented by the defendant' previous working relationship with the District
Attorney, and
WHEREAS, said Special Prosecutor has been required to participate in substantial efforts to
review evidence in cases that may be related to a conspiracy or on-going criminal scheme which has
ranged across several counties in this area, at substantial cost to the County of Tompkins, and
WHEREAS, it is patently unfair and inappropriate for the taxpayers of this County to absorb the
expenses directly attributable to the intentional misconduct of State officers and attributable to lax and
negligent supervision of same, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the
Chairman of the Board is hereby authorized to demand restitution from the State of New York for all
expenses arising from the investigation, prosecution and defense of former State Police officers David L.
Harding and Robert Lishansky and for all County expenses related to the prosecution and defense of
Shirley Kinge and Mark Prentice,
RESOLVED, further, That the Chairman of the Board is hereby authorized to request the Governor
of the State of New York to require the Attorney General to investigate the alleged commission of any
indictable offenses in relation to any matters connected with the New York State Police, and to prosecute
the person(s) believed to have committed the same, and any crime or offense arising out of such
30
January 19, 1993
investigation or prosecution or both, including but not limited to appearing before and presenting all such
matters to a grand jury, all pursuant to Section 63, subdivision 3 of the Executive Law of the State of New
York.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 27 - DELEGATING TO THE COUNTY COMPTROLLER OF THE
COUNTY OF TOMPKINS, NEW YORK, THE POWER TO
AUTHORIZE THE ISSUANCE OF AND TO SELL $4,000,000
REVENUE ANTICIPATION NOTES OF SAID COUNTY IN
ANTICIPATION OF THE RECEIPT OF STATE AID DURING THE
FISCAL YEAR OF SAID COUNTY COMMENCING JANUARY 1,
1993
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 14,
Noes - 0, Excused - 1 (Representative Culligan). Adopted.
RESOLVED, by the Board of Representatives of the County of Tompkins, New York as follows:
Section 1. The power to authorize the issuance of and to sell $4,000,000 revenue anticipation
notes of the County of Tompkins, New York, including renewals thereof, in anticipation of the receipt of
State Aid due said County during the fiscal year of said County commencing January 1, 1993, is hereby
delegated to the County Comptroller, the chief fiscal officer of such County. Such notes shall be of such
terms, for and contents, and shall be sold in such manner as may be determined by County Comptroller,
consistent with the provisions of the Local Finance Law.
Section 2. This resolution shall take effect immediately.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 28 - AUTHORIZING A PUBLIC HEARING ON PROPOSED LOCAL LAW
NO. 1 OF 1993 - AUTHORIZATION TO ESTABLISH AN ANNUAL
SOLID WASTE FEE FOR REAL PROPERTY IN TOMPKINS
COUNTY
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Mason, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That a public
hearing be held before the Board of Representatives at Board Chambers of the Tompkins County
Courthouse, 320 North Tioga Street, Ithaca, New York, on Tuesday, February 2, 1993 at 5:30 o'clock in
the evening thereof on proposed Local Law No. 1 of 1993 concerning Authorization to Establish an
Annual Solid Waste Fee for Real Property in Tompkins County. At such time and place, all persons
interested in the subject will be heard concerning the same,
RESOLVED, further, That the Clerk of the Board is hereby authorized and directed to place proper
notice of such public hearing in the official newspaper of the County.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 29 - REFINANCING OF ONE-HALF OF CAPITAL COSTS OF CERTAIN
FACILITIES FOR TOMPKINS CORTLAND COMMUNITY
COLLEGE (Rescinded by Motion 2/16/93)
31
January 19, 1993
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, authority is required from the Board of Trustees of Tompkins Cortland Community
College to execute and deliver an agreement by and among the Dormitory Authority of the State of New
York (the "Authority"), the Counties of Tompkins and Cortland (the "Local Sponsors") and Tompkins
Cortland Community College ("The Community College") pertaining, among other matters, to the
proposed Authority refinancing of the State's 50 percent share of the capital costs of certain facilities for
Tompkins Cortland Community College (herein and in the Agreement referred to as the "Project"), now
therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the Board of
Trustees of Tompkins Cortland Community College hereby approves the form and content of the
Agreement subject to approval of the form and content of the Agreement by Tompkins and Cortland
Counties' Departments of Law, and approval as to the content by the Office of the Comptroller of
Tompkins County and the Office of the Treasurer of Cortland County,
RESOLVED, further, That the President of Tompkins Cortland Community College (who is duly
qualified so to act) is hereby authorized on behalf of the Board of Trustees of Tompkins Cortland
Community College, to execute and deliver the Agreement to the Authority, subject to prior approval as
to form by Tompkins and Cortland Counties' Departments of Law and approval as to content by the
Office of the Comptroller of Tompkins County and the Office of the Treasurer of Cortland County with
such nonsubstantive changes in terms of form as the President of Tompkins Cortland Community College
shall constitute conclusive evidence of the approval of the Board of Trustees,
RESOLVED, further, That the President of Tompkins Cortland Community College (who is duly
qualified so to act) is hereby authorized, on behalf of the Board of Trustees of Tompkins Cortland
Community College to execute and deliver all necessary or appropriate documents, certificates and
agreements and to furnish all information requested by the Authority in connection with the College,
including the furnishing of information required pursuant to the provisions of the Agreement, and
necessary to prepare an official Statement to be used in connection with the sale of bonds.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 30 - BUDGET ADJUSTMENTS AND APPROPRIATIONS - VARIOUS
DEPARTMENTS
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Winch. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes -
13, Noes - 1 (Representative Lerner), Excused - 1 (Representative Culligan). Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the County
Comptroller be authorized to make the following budget adjustment on his books:
BUDGET ADJUSTMENTS
L Fund Library
Revenue: L7410.2770 Unclassified Revenues $(22,998)
Appropriations: L7410.1900 Library Personal Services $(16,160)
.4300 Supplies and Materials (1,800)
.4405 Contractual Expenses (3,652)
.8830 Social Security (1,386)
Sheriff
Revenue: A3110.2625 Forfeiture of Crime Proceed $ 7,215
Appropriations: A3110.2221 Safety Equipment $ 6,915
.4347 Ammunition $ 300
32
January 19, 1993
RESOLVED, further, That the Chairman of the Board of Representatives be and hereby is
authorized and directed to execute any contracts necessary to convey these funds.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
On motion of the appropriate committee chairmen and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by
voice vote by members present, the following appointments were made to various advisory boards:
Community Affirmative Action
Term expires December 31, 1993
Mary G. Call - Board member
Criminal Justice Advisory/Alternatives to Incarceration Board
Terms expire December 31, 1995
Merton Wallenbeck - Town Justice representative
Nancy Schuler - Board member
Soil and Water Conservation District
Terms expire December 31, 1993
Daniel M. Winch - Board member
Deborah F. Dietrich - Board member
Southern Tier East Regional Planning Development Board
Term expires December 31, 1993
Beverly E. Livesay - Board member
Advisory Board on Tourism Development
Terms expire December 31, 1994
Stuart Stein - Board member
Barbara Mink - Board member
On motion, the meeting adjourned at 8:45 p.m.
33
February 2, 1993
Regular Meeting
Public Hearing
Chairman Watros called the public hearing to order at 5:30 p.m. concerning proposed Local Law
No. 1 of 1993 - Authorizing the Establishment of an Annual Solid Waste Fee for Real Property.
Chairman Watros asked if anyone wished to speak?
Gary Lindenbaum, Business Manager of the Ithaca City School District, spoke about the proposed
tipping charges. He expressed the School's concern of how much this will cost. He said the School
District is going into a difficult budgetary period. He stated the School District has taken efforts to reduce
its waste and cut down on their costs.
Rich Weiss, Business Manager, TST BOCES, and representing other school districts, expressed
concern with the cost to the Districts with the proposed fee imposed. He said he also understands that
Cornell University, Ithaca College and Tompkins Cortland Community College have a separate billing
structure under the proposal. On behalf of the school districts, he is requesting the same billing structure.
He also would like to request a meeting with the County to discuss a fee schedule that is appropriate.
Charles Breckheimer, Ithaca School District Teacher, spoke about the waste reduction program in
the schools. He felt that there would be less incentive to recycle and that this proposed fee would send
the wrong message to the kids.
Beverly Baker, South Geneva Street, said Tompkins County residents have been encouraged to
recycle but are now being penalized with this proposed fee. She asked that the Board postpone this for a
few weeks. She also requested the Board wait until the Chamber of Commerce responds to the requests
of the Board.
Phil Barden, Town of Caroline, spoke in opposition of the annual fee proposal and feels the
County should keep the trash tag system and let the people who make the garbage pay for it.
Susan Centini, Owner of Centini's Restaurant, said she has been recycling for years and also
composting. She feels it is unfair to the small businesses to impose the proposed fee.
Helen Morgan, Mobile Home Park resident, spoke in opposition of the proposed fee and asked
why she would be charged the same amount a mobile home with four or five people living in it. She said
judging by footage is a wrong idea for setting the fee schedule.
Allen Akers, Trumansburg Road, said the County should get out of the garbage business. He
spoke in opposition of the proposed annual fee and expressed his concern about people with fixed
incomes and asked how they would come up with the money when taxes keep going up and others costs
increase.
John Novarr, Property Owner in City of Ithaca and Town of Ithaca, spoke in opposition and about
the inequities on the proposed fee schedule. He said he owns apartments that he rents to students and
spoke about his costs compared to Ithaca College. He asked how vacancies would be handled.
Richard Westfall, City of Ithaca, spoke in opposition of the proposed fee and stated that he
believes people should pay for what they use. He does not think that a person should get charged
according to the size of their residence.
Tim Foote, Town of Groton, spoke in opposition to the proposed fee and expressed concern for the
taxpayers because of so much tax exempt property in Tompkins County.
34
February 2, 1993
Richard Sponable, Newfield, spoke in opposition to the proposed fee and said the County should
get out of the trash business.
John Parmelee, Old Port Harbor Restaurant, spoke in opposition to the proposed fee and expressed
his dissatisfaction in the way solid waste is handled by the County. He stated that he is a customer of
Superior Disposal and referred to how is charges have increased.
Herb Wiegandt, Cayuga Heights, spoke in opposition to the proposed fee and stated that he does
not believe the way the proposed fee will be charged is equitable. He feels that it would be difficult but
charges could be assessed in a more systematical way.
Dan Quest, City of Ithaca, spoke in opposition to the proposed fee and asked if the taxpayers will
have to pay for the haulers going out of business. Mr. Quest said that he believes haulers with
outstanding debts to the County should have to pay.
Ida Poole, Tompkins County senior citizen, spoke in opposition to the proposed fee and stated that
she feels discriminated against because she is a single person. She asked that the Board think about the
single person living in Tompkins County.
Mrs. Call, Chairman, Budget and Administration Committee, read a statement submitted by
Andrew Bower, Triphammer Road, in opposition to the proposed fee.
Mrs. Call, Chairman, Budget and Administration Committee, stated that she received verbal
comments from Bert Hillard, Town of Lansing, in which Mr. Hillard expressed opposition to the
proposed fee and asked that the Board delay action on this. Mr. Hillard asked that public meetings
throughout the County be held for discussion on all solid waste issues. Mrs. Call referred this request to
Mr. Lerner, Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee.
Mr. Stein, Representative, District No. 3, voiced concerns he received by a Tompkins County
resident in opposition to the proposed fee.
Mr. Shurtleff, Representative, District No. 9, called attention to correspondence from Walpole Real
Estate of Groton in which opposition was expressed to the proposed fee. The letter voices a concern that
the proposed fee charged to schools will be passed on to businesses in the community.
Chairman Watros read a letter from Noel Desch, Chairman, County Affairs Committee, Chamber
of Commerce, which stated that it is the consensus of the committee that the latest formula used to assess
the proposed fee represents a vast improvement over the fee proposed in the fall and is in close balance
with the intent of the law and the revenue needs of the County.
Chairman Watros closed the public hearing at 6:05 p.m.
Members and guests participated in the Pledge of Allegiance.
Present: 15 Representatives.
RESOLUTION NO. 31 - RESOLUTION DETERMINING SIGNIFICANCE PURSUANT TO
SEQRA AND AUTHORIZATION FOR THE ISSUANCE OF A
NEGATIVE DECLARATION
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Lerner. Mr. Lerner said that the solid waste program is
paying for past, present and future programs including costs at the proposed DR -7 site and closure and
maintenance of old landfills by complying with the Department of Environmental Conservation
regulations. These costs also include paying for current disposal and recycling operations.
35
February 2, 1993
Mr. Lerner stated that the County has to recoup revenues lost due to the haulers disposing of waste out of
County resulting in a one million dollar deficit. Mr. Lerner stated that the County has tried to find a fair
way of distributing these costs. He said he would like to eliminate the proposed annual fee in 1994.
Mr. Mason stated that the County is not in the solid waste business as the public has perceived. He
said over 80 percent of money is spent on contracts to the private sector. He also said the County has to
comply with New York State mandates.
Ms. Mink stated that people have asked why not pay for this proposed annual fee through property
tax. Mr. Lerner said that those exempt from paying real property tax would also be exempt from paying
this proposed fee.
Mrs. Schuler asked if the policy under SEQRA had been examined by the Environmental
Management Council (EMC). Mrs. Call said it was reviewed by the EMC and read a letter from Robert
Mulvey, County Attorney.
A voice vote resulted as follows on the resolution: Ayes - 15, Noes - 0. Adopted.
WHEREAS, the Board is contemplating the adoption of a local law establishing an annual fee for
solid waste management to be imposed upon the owners of real property in Tompkins County, who are
the generators of solid waste and the users of the County's solid waste facilities and programs, and
WHEREAS, the adoption of such a local law involves no physical improvements or alterations that
would change the use, appearance or condition of any natural resource or structure, and
WHEREAS, the Board believes that the adoption of the local law is a Type II Action, it has
nonetheless reviewed it as though it was an unlisted action for purposes of the environmental review
process under SEQRA, and
WHEREAS, the Board and Budget and Administration Committee have reviewed drafts of the
proposed local law and the Short Environmental Assessment Form, including the Determination of
Significance dated November 1992, and the proposed Negative Declaration, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That this Board
finds the enactment of the proposed law regarding the annual solid waste management fee will not have a
significant effect on the environment requiring the preparation of an environmental impact statement,
RESOLVED, further, That the Chairman of the Board and/or his designee is authorized to file and
circulate the Negative Declaration provided according to law and execute such other documentation as
may be necessary.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(DETERMINATIONS AND FINDINGS
MADE CONCURRENTLY HEREWITH)
RESOLUTION NO. 32 - ADOPTION OF LOCAL LAW NO. 1 OF 1993 - AUTHORIZING THE
ESTABLISHMENT OF AN ANNUAL SOLID WASTE FEE FOR REAL
PROPERTY IN TOMPKINS COUNTY
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Lerner. Mr. Culligan felt the County should pursue a
special benefit district and pay for these costs with additional sales tax revenues.
It was Moved by Mr. Shurtleff, seconded by Mrs. Dietrich, to postpone the resolution until the first
meeting in March to obtain a few more answers. Mrs. Call reminded the Board that a resolution was
passed in December to adopt this proposed fee by February 2 and it was also recommended by the
Comptroller that the proposed fee be adopted by the end of February. Mr. Squires, Comptroller, stated
that the Board authorized borrowed money and that he will be going to market in February or March. He
stated that if the Board voted this proposed fee down, the Board would have to decide how to balance the
budget in 1993. Mrs. Schuler spoke of her concern with voting on a subject following a public hearing.
36
February 2, 1993
Mrs. Call said a public hearing was held in December and the Board responded to concerns raised at the
hearing resulting in action being delayed.
Chairman Watros said that these people that will now assume the burden of the proposed fee should also
enjoy a reduction in the hauling costs because of the rollback of the tipping fee. Mr. Mason questioned if
passing the law resolved the Comptroller's concern mentioned above. At this time, Mr. Shurtleff
withdrew his motion to postpone.
It was moved Mrs. Dietrich, seconded by Ms. Mink, that this local law shall sunset on December
31, 1993. Mr. Mulvey, County Attorney ruled Mrs. Dietrich's motion as illegal because it is considered a
substantive change in the law and the Board would not be allowed to vote this evening and an additional
public hearing would have to be held.
A roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 10, Noes - 5 (Representatives Culligan, Proto, Schuler,
Shurtleff and Stein). Adopted.
WHEREAS, a public hearing was held before the Board of Representatives on February 2, 1993 to
hear all persons interested in proposed Local Law No. 1 of 1993, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That said
proposed Local Law No. 1 of 1993 Authorizing the Establishment of an Annual Solid Waste Fee for Real
Property in Tompkins County is adopted,
RESOLVED, further, That this local law be reviewed in conjunction with Resolution No. 5 of
1993, Charging the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee with Developing Alternate Plans
for Paying for Recycling with recommendations to be made by September 1, 1993 in time for formulation
of 1994 Budget,
RESOLVED, further, That the Clerk of the Board publish in the official newspaper of Tompkins
County a notice of adoption containing a synopsis of said local law, and shall within five (5) days file one
certified copy in the office of the County Clerk and three (3) certified copies in the office of the Secretary
of State.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 33 - ESTABLISHING A UNIT CHARGE FOR THE 1993 ANNUAL SOLID
WASTE FEE (Amended by Res. No. 127 of 1993)
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Winch. Mrs. Dietrich suggested a delay in this resolution so
the equity issues with school districts may be addressed. Mr. Squires stressed the importance of the
budget being balanced and said that if the fee were to be cut, a source would need to be identified to
replace any reduction in revenue this would cause. Mrs. Call responded to comments made during the
public hearing. She explained how the fee would apply to tax exempt properties; she said that almost all
of the cost budgeted for the Landstrom Landfill is mandated by the Department of Environmental
Conservation; she replied that to a comment made comparing residential costs to costs of the colleges and
said that colleges are not getting curbside recycling service; she stated that the proposed fee is based on
information that the County Assessment Department has and that the County does not have a breakdown
of how many people reside in each household; she stated that a portion of this fee will go towards
curbside recycling. Barbara Eckstrom, Solid Waste Manager, stated that recycling costs money even
though it is cheaper right now than disposal. Mr. Stein expressed his concern that once this resolution is
passed, it is unlikely that questions will be resolved.
It was Moved by Ms. Mink, seconded by Mrs. Dietrich, to postpone the vote on this rate schedule
until the February 16, 1993 Board meeting. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 14, Noes - 1
(Representative Call). Motion carried. Mrs. Call said questions concerning school districts and the
Hospital would be answered.
37
February 2, 1993
It was Moved by Mrs. Dietrich, seconded by Mr. Mason, and unanimously adopted by voice vote,
to add to the agenda the resolutions entitled Resolution of Intent to Reconsider Local Law No. 1 of 1993
on or Before December 31, 1993.
RESOLUTION NO. 34 - RESOLUTION OF INTENT TO RECONSIDER LOCAL LAW NO. 1
OF 1993 ON OR BEFORE DECEMBER 31, 1993
Moved by Mrs. Dietrich, seconded by Mr. Mason, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, Local Law No. 1 of 1993 was necessitated by serious Tompkins County fiscal
problems and the lowering of the County tipping fee, and
WHEREAS, this Local Law deviates from the user fee method of raising revenue as typified by the
Tompkins County trash tag system, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, That it is the intent of the Board of Representatives to reconsider this Law on or
before December 31, 1993.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
Chairman Watros declared recess from 7:26 to 7:35 p.m.
It was Moved by Mr. Evans, seconded by Mr. Stein, and unanimously adopted by voice vote, to
approve the minutes of January 19, 1993 as corrected.
Chairman Watros called attention to a letter on each member's desk authorizing the Comptroller to
reduce each Board members salary $158 from their paycheck. The letter should be returned to the Clerk
of the Board.
Under privilege of the floor, Yvonne Bartlett, Tompkins County Depaitiiient of Social Services
employee, stated that she feels employee safety is very important and that she is in support of a metal
detector and an armed security guard being stationed at the Biggs complex.
Under privilege of the floor, Margaret Marks, Schuyler County resident and employee of
Tompkins County Department of Social Services, spoke concerning employee safety at the Biggs
complex. She stated that a metal detector and armed guards need to be in place for her to feel secure at
work.
Under privilege of the floor, Sharon Prezioso McLaughlin, Tompkins County Department of
Social Services employee, spoke concerning employee safety at the Biggs complex. Ms. McLaughlin
spoke in favor of a metal detector and armed guards at the site. Ms. McLaughlin also stated that she
believes the carpeting at Social Services contains a chemical which makes her ill.
Under privilege of the floor, Hiroshi Takashima, Tompkins County Department of Social Services
employee, stated that he is concerned about the security issue at the Biggs complex. He spoke in favor of
a metal detector and armed guards at the site and stated that employee safety is a basic need.
Under privilege of the floor, Mel Bartlett, husband of a Tompkins County Depaitnient of Social
Services employee and vendor who has worked with Tompkins County, stated that he is in support of an
armed guard and a metal detector at the Biggs site so that he can feel safe when entering the building and
also feel his wife is safe at work. He asked that the Board not take this issue lightly.
Chairman Watros gave the appropriate committee chairman permission to withdraw from the
agenda the resolution entitled Approval of Issuance of Bonds - Reconstruction Home.
38
February 2, 1993
On motion of the appropriate committee chairmen and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by
voice vote, the following resolutions were added to the agenda:
Authorization to Execute Easement - 122 Commercial Avenue - Solid Waste Office Building
Implementation of Security Plan - Biggs A
RESOLUTION NO. 35 - IMPLEMENTATION OF SECURITY PLAN - BIGGS A
Moved by Ms. Mink, seconded by Mr. Evans. Ms. Mink stated that this issue has been taken very
seriously. It has been discussed by employees through the Employee Council. The Human Services
Committee and the Budget and Administration Committees passed this plan as a result of several sources.
Ms. Mink explained that the plan involved including the limitation of only three entrances to the building,
buzzers to allow entrance and security guards on site. Ted Merritt, Senior Investigator, Social Services
Department, spoke to the issue and stated that all employees must work together and take some
responsibility in security. Mr. Merritt stated that doors which will not be used as entrances to the building
will still permit emergency exiting. Cheryl Nelson, Chair, Employee Council, thanked the Human
Services Committee for getting involved in this issue and stated that she thinks that some of the steps that
are in this proposal are very good. She stressed the importance of constant communication among
everyone. Mr. Lerner requested that Mr. Heyman, County Administrator, look into the issue raised
concerning the carpeting at the Biggs complex.
A voice vote resulted as follows on the resolution: Ayes - 15, Noes - 0. Adopted.
WHEREAS, it is the intention of the Board to provide a safe and secure environment for all its
employees, and
WHEREAS, discussions of options for a plan for providing increased security at Biggs A have
taken place at the Biggs A Security Committee, among the directors and department heads within the
building, at Employee Forums which were joint efforts of the Employee Council and the Community
Dispute Resolution Center, and staff of the Depai lnient of Social Services, and
WHEREAS, a recommended security plan has been brought forward which addresses the
substantive recommendations of those deliberations, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Human Services and Budget and Administration
Committees, That the authorization is hereby given to the Department of Social Services to begin
implementing the security plan as detailed on the memo from Mary Pat Dolan, Commissioner of the
Department of Social Services, dated February 1, 1993,
RESOLVED, further, That the Board has directed that the security system be put in place as
quickly as possible and be notified immediately of any delays,
RESOLVED, further, That the Biggs Security Committee, in conjunction with the Employee
Council and the department heads within the building, conduct an all employee survey between August
and November of 1993 to obtain employee feedback on the implementation of the plan and to provide this
feedback to the directors and members of the Board.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 36 - AUDIT OF FINAL PAYMENT - OLD JAIL RENOVATION - FRED H.
THOMAS ASSOC.
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mrs. Dietrich. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes
- 15, Noes - 0. Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the following claim against the County of Tompkins be and hereby is audited by the Board of
Representatives:
39
February 2, 1993
Vendor Payment Request Account Amount
Fred H. Thomas Assoc. 17 (Final) HV3151.9239 $3,575
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller be and hereby is authorized and directed to pay said
claim from Account No. HV3151.9239.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 37 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE EASEMENT - 122 COMMERCIAL
AVENUE - SOLID WASTE OFFICE BUILDING
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Todd. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 14, Noes -
1 (Representative Proto). Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the County Administrator is hereby authorized to execute an easement which allows NYSEG the
right to extend electric along County property on Commercial Avenue in the City of Ithaca.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
It was Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, to amend the Rules of the Board by
dispensing with committee reports this evening. Following discussion, Mrs. Call withdrew her
amendment.
Mr. Proto, Chairman, Health and Education Committee, reported that the Committee endorsed a
plan adopted by the Infant Mortality Review Board. He reported on lead screening and stated that the
Health Department is applying for a grant for $15,000. Mrs. Schuler reported that BOCES will be
holding a Fay's Drug Quiz show on February 4.
Mr. Evans, Chairman, Personnel Committee, reported that the Committee met January 28. The
Committee will be working on the evaluations of the four employees who report to the Board and will try
to develop a mechanism to receive more input from members of the Board. Mr. Evans stated that the
Committee will also be concentrating on the search for two depai lnuent heads within the County.
Ms. Mink, Chairman, Human Services Committee, reported on security issues at the Biggs
complex earlier in the meeting.
Ms. Mink, Public Information Committee, reminded committee chairmen that on February 9 at
1:30 p.m. interviews will be held to discuss goals for 1993. There will also be a call-in talk show
concerning health care reform at 7:00 p.m. that evening.
Mr. Mason, Chairman, Public Safety Committee, reported that the positions of transport officers to
cut down on the amount of overtime by road patrolmen which the County was considering must be
created as civil service positions. Mr. Mason reported on the latest proposal in Albany concerning county
Departments of Probation. He stated that a consideration is being made to eliminate funding to all
probation depar tiuents within the State of New York.
Mrs. Dietrich, Chairman, Planning Committee, reported that the Committee will meet February 11
at noon. Mrs. Dietrich reported on her visit to Washington, D.C. in which she observed the presidential
inauguration and attended the festivities.
Mr. Winch, Chairman, Public Works and Construction Management Committee, reported that the
Tompkins County Airport logo will be changed to make it more up-to-date. He reported on the progress
40
February 2, 1993
of County offices moving into the Old Jail. Mr. Winch stated that all business for the Ithaca Tompkins
Transit Center has been completed. The next Committee meeting will be February 3 at noon.
Mr. Todd Chairman, Fiscal Affairs Committee, reported that the Committee met last week and will
meet again February 3 at 10:30 a.m.
Mr. Todd, Chairman, Article 18 Task Force, submitted a report to the Board with the following
recommendations: 1. The Board of Representatives proceed with the two local laws recommended in the
Program Development 1993 Plan and 2. The Board of Representatives request the Public Safety
Committee to meet with the Advisory Board on Indigent Representation leadership and administrator and
have regular reports on the progress of implementation of the improvements specified in the Program
Development 1993 document. The Task Force recommends to the County Board that the matter be
reviewed by July 30 by the Article 18 Task Force for evaluation of progress of implementation of the
improvements specified in the Program Development 1993 document. Mr. Todd and Mrs. Dietrich
thanked Roger Rector, Nelson Roth, Benjamin Bucko, Marilyn Ray and Ingrid Olsen-Tjensvold for the
time and effort they each have contributed to the Article 18 Task Force.
Chairman Watros requested the Fiscal Affairs Committee to develop a recommendation for the
salaries of the Board of Representatives for the 1994-1997 term.
Mr. Lerner, Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, reported that there will
be a presentation by the Chamber of Commerce on the prioritization of solid waste at the Sheraton on
February 11 at 10 a.m. Mr. Lerner stated that Barbara Eckstrom is working on reducing the amount of
money the County spends on consultants. He requested that Board members let him know what
information is needed by them to make an informative decision on the Recycling and Solid Waste Center.
Mr. Lerner stated that he will be working on the restructuring of advisory committees in the area of solid
waste. The next committee meeting will be February 11 at noon.
Mrs. Livesay, Intergovernmental Representative, had no report.
Mrs. Call, Chairman, Budget and Administration Committee, reported that the next Committee
meeting will be February 9 at noon.
Mr. Heyman, County Administrator, reported on a meeting which he attended in Albany. Some
highlights were funding to Probation departments as Mr. Mason mentioned in his Public Safety report and
also a slight increase in CHIPS funding from last year. He reported on a personal care cap proposal that
would greatly affect New York City. He also stated that New York State DSS is increasing their
estimated Medicaid costs 18.5 percent. Mr. Heyman noted that there is a very strong trend away from
foster care and towards the use of preventative services.
Mr. Mulvey, County Attorney, stated that the monthly report for his office has been submitted to
the Board for review.
Mr. Squires, Comptroller, reported on sales tax proceeds thru December 22, 1992 and stated that
although there was an increase, he sees no sign of a great economic recovery by Tompkins County.
Chairman Watros announced the following appointments with the Board's confirmation to the
various boards (appointments are for one-year terms):
Tompkins County Area Development Corporation Board of Directors
Deborah Dietrich - Tompkins County representative
James Hanson, Jr. (Ex -officio) - Tompkins County representative
Capital Program Committee
41
February 2, 1993
Daniel Winch - Chairman
Thomas Todd
Donald Culligan
Stuart Stein
James Mason
Chamber of Commerce
Robert I. Watros
Frank P. Proto, Alternate
Emergency Medical Services Committee
James A. Mason
Extension Service
Charles Evans
Finger Lakes Association
Donald Culligan, Delegate
James A. Mason, Alternate
Local Advisory Board of Assessment Review
Villages: Cayuga Heights - Mary G. Call
Dryden - Robert Watros
Freeville - Robert Watros
Groton - Phil Shurtleff
Lansing - Mary G. Call
Trumansburg - James A. Mason
Towns: Caroline and Danby - Frank P. Proto
Enfield and Newfield - Daniel Winch
Groton - Phil Shurtleff
Dryden - Robert Watros and Charles Evans
Ithaca - Mary G. Call, Beverly Livesay and Deborah Dietrich
Lansing - Thomas Todd
Ulysses - James A. Mason
City of Ithaca - Nancy Schuler
On motion of the appropriate committee chairmen and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by
voice vote, the following appointments were made to various advisory boards:
Tompkins Community Hospital Board of Directors
Term expires April 30, 1996
Frank P. Proto - Board member
Community Mental Health Services Board
Terms expire December 31, 1993
Joanie Groome
Cynthia Syversten
Term expires December 31, 1995
Dr. Robert Ballard
Office for the Aging Advisory Committee
Term expires December 31, 1995
John Efroymson
42
February 2, 1993
Service Delivery Area/Private Industry Council
Term expires December 31, 1995
Virginia Bryant - Private sector alternate representative
Tompkins County Youth Board
Term expires December 31, 1995
Andra Benson - Town of Lansing representative
John Gaines - Town of Groton representative
On motion, the meeting adjourned at 8:55 p.m.
43
February 16, 1993
Regular Meeting
Chairman Watros called the meeting to order at 5:30 p.m. and stated that he would prefer to
adjourn the meeting at 7 p.m. due to weather conditions.
Members and guests participated in the Pledge of Allegiance.
Present: 13 Representatives. Excused: 2 (Representatives Dietrich and Shurtleff).
It was Moved by Mr. Culligan, seconded by Mr. Todd, to approve the minutes of January 12 as
corrected and February 2, 1993, as submitted.
Chairman Watros announced the resignation of Representative Dietrich from the Board effective
March 11, 1993. Mr. Watros stated the Board wishes her well in her endeavors. Chairman Watros
announced that until a chairman is announced, Mr. Proto will act in his capacity as Vice Chairman of the
Planning Committee.
Under privilege of the floor, Rich Weiss, T -S -T BOCES; thanked the Board for the opportunity to
speak at a meeting set up with representatives of school district and members of the Board to discuss the
annual fee. Mr. Weiss stated that his complaint with the proposed rate schedule revolves around equity.
He stated that he now believes that the schools will not be charged fairly when compared to
municipalities under the revised fee schedule.
On motion of the appropriate committee chairmen and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by
voice vote by members present, the following resolutions were added to the agenda:
- Abolition and Creation of Positions and Budget Transfer - Sheriffs Department
- Approval of Proposed Agreement - Dormitory Authority of New York State and Tompkins
Cortland Community College
Chairman Watros gave the appropriate committee chairmen permission to withdraw from the
agenda the following resolutions with final committee action being affirmed:
CA015-93 - Reclassification of Position - Staff Development Coordinator - Department of Social
Services
CA016-93 - Authorizing the Youth Bureau to Apply for Gannett Foundation Grant to Publish
Pocket Guide to Youth Services
CA017-93 - Authority to Contract - Department of Social Services
CA018-93 - Award of Contract - Inspection Services for Construction of Aircraft Ramp and
Taxiway Connectors - New Terminal Project
CA019-93 - Authorization to Execute Contract - R.W. Beck and Associates - Milliken Station
Improvements
RESOLUTION NO. 38 - APPROVAL OF BAIL PROGRAM ENHANCEMENT FUNDING -
OFFENDER AID AND RESTORATION
Moved by Mr. Mason, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, Offender Aid and Restoration (OAR) of Tompkins County was unable to maintain its
1990 and 1991 level of bail loans during 1992 because of reduced funding and dropped from 50 loans per
year to 42, and
WHEREAS, OAR loans in 1990 and 1991 saved Tompkins County 3,600 jail days each year for
OAR bailees who did not receive jail sentences, an average of 90 days saved per bail, and
44
February 16, 1993
WHEREAS, given the crowded conditions in the jail in 1990 and 1991, OAR thereby saved the
County between $200,000 and $360,000 each year in boarding out costs, and
WHEREAS, jail admissions in 1992 continued at the 1990 rate of about 80 per month, and OAR
had a waiting list for bail loans throughout 1992 and expects similar demand in 1993, and
WHEREAS, Tompkins County has specified that new funding is to be made available only to
programs that cost the same or less than the program saves the County, and
WHEREAS, OAR could expand its bail program to provide a minimum of 12 additional bails in
1993 by adding .2FTE to the Bail Fund Coordinator's time for expanded services, and .2FTE to the
Executive Director's time for service back-up and expanding the bail fund, which at 90 days saved on the
average per bail, would save 1230 jail days, and
WHEREAS, these 1,230 jail days saved would either save Tompkins County $65,190 at the
estimated $53 per day cost of keeping inmates in the jail, or save $123,000 or more for boarding inmates
out and transporting them, for a cost to the County of $12,600 and,
WHEREAS, OAR could assist in further reducing the jail population by facilitating substance
abuse evaluations of inmates in the jail, in cooperation with defense counsel, as part of alternatives to
incarceration sentence proposals, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Safety and Budget and Administration
Committees, That the Comptroller shall appropriate $12,600 from A1990 Contingent Fund to
A6310.4597 for OAR Bail Program Enhancement, including substance abuse treatment referrals, and
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator is directed to execute a contract amendment
to convey these funds.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 39 - AUTHORIZING A PUBLIC HEARING ON PROPOSED LOCAL LAW
NO. 2 OF 1993 - AMENDING LOCAL LAW NO. 7 OF 1990 -
PROVIDING FOR AMENDMENTS TO THE TOMPKINS COUNTY
CHARTER AND CODE
Moved by Ms. Mink, seconded by Mr. Lerner, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Human Services and Budget and Administration
Committees, That a public hearing be held before the Board of Representatives at Board Chambers of the
Tompkins County Courthouse, 320 North Tioga Street, Ithaca New York on Tuesday, March 2, 1993 at
5:30 p.m. in the evening thereof concerning proposed Local Law No. 2 of 1993 - Providing for
Amendments to the Tompkins County Charter and Code - Youth Bureau - Section 22.02 - Youth Board;
Composition; Term; Powers and Duties. At such time and place all persons interested in the subject
matter will be heard concerning the same,
RESOLVED, further, That the Clerk of the Board is hereby authorized and directed to place proper
notice of such public hearing in the official newspaper of the County.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 40 - AUDIT OF FINAL PAYMENT - INTERIM COMPOST FACILITY -
RICHARDSON BROTHERS ELECTRICAL CONTRACTORS, INC.
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Todd. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes -
13, Noes - 0, Excused: 2 (Representatives Dietrich and Shurtleff). Adopted.
45
February 16, 1993
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the following claim against the County of Tompkins, be and hereby is audited by the Board of
Representatives:
Vendor Payment Request Account No. Amount
Richardson Brothers
Electrical Contractors, Inc. 5 (Final) HH8162.9263 $2,000
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller be and hereby is authorized and directed to pay said
claim from Account No. HH8162.9263.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 41 - AUDIT OF FINAL PAYMENT - PUBLIC TRANSIT FACILITY -
POSTLER AND JAECKLE
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Stein. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes -
13, Noes - 0, Excused - 2 (Representatives Dietrich and Shurtleff). Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the following claim against the County of Tompkins, be and hereby is audited by the Board of
Representatives:
Vendor Payment Request Account No. Amount
Postler and Jaeckle 14 (Final) HA5630.4400 $11,618
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller be and hereby is authorized and directed to pay said
claim from Account No. HA5630.4400.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 42 - AUDIT OF FINAL PAYMENT - PUBLIC TRANSIT FACILITY -
PANKO ELECTRICAL AND MAINT., INC.
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Culligan. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes -
13, Noes - 0, Excused - 2 (Representatives Dietrich and Shurtleff). Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the following claim against the County of Tompkins, be and hereby is audited by the Board of
Representatives:
Vendor Payment Request Account No. Amount
Panko Elect. and Main., Inc. 11 (Final) HA5630.4400 $18,179.85
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller be and hereby is authorized and directed to pay said
claim from Account No. HA5630.4400.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 43 - APPROVAL OF SALE PRIOR TO AUCTION - COUNTY OWNED
PROPERTY ACQUIRED THROUGH TAX FORECLOSURE - TOWN
OF CAROLINE
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
46
February 16, 1993
WHEREAS, by tax foreclosure proceedings of 1992, the County acquired parcel 12.-2-7 in the
Town of Caroline, and
WHEREAS, prior to auction of said property, the County Administrator wishes to sell same for the
total amount due for taxes, penalties, interest and expenses, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the sale of
parcel no. 12.-2-7 to C.D. and Roberta Woodman of 6 Elm Street, Brooktondale, New York for the
amount of taxes, penalties, interest and expenses due, be and the same hereby is confirmed and the
County Administrator is directed to execute a quitclaim deed to the aforesaid property.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 44 - APPROVAL OF SALE PRIOR TO AUCTION - COUNTY OWNED
PROPERTY ACQUIRED THROUGH TAX FORECLOSURE - TOWN
OF GROTON
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, by tax foreclosure proceedings of 1992, the County acquired parcel 20.-1-27.7 in the
Town of Groton, and
WHEREAS, prior to auction of said property, the County Administrator wishes to sell same for the
total amount due for taxes, penalties, interest and expenses, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the sale of
parcel no. 20.-1-27.7 to Sheila A. Dawson and Pauline C. Ayers of 681 Old Stage Road, Groton, New
York for the amount of taxes, penalties, interest and expenses due, be and the same hereby is confirmed
and the County Administrator is directed to execute a quitclaim deed to the aforesaid property.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 45 - AUTHORIZATION TO CHARGE -BACK SPECIAL ASSESSMENT
CHARGES TO TOWNS OF DRYDEN AND ITHACA
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Mason, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, three parcels within the Town of Dryden and one parcel within the Town of Ithaca are
assessed to the State of New York and fall under the guidelines of Section 19 of the Public Lands Law,
and
WHEREAS, in order to collect special assessments against these parcels, a certain process, which
is outlined in Section 19, must be followed, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That due to the
State's assertion that this process has not been followed by the Town of Dryden or the Town of Ithaca for
certain periods in time between 1972 and 1991, and the subsequent refusal by the State to reimburse the
County for these charges, the following special assessment charges in the amount of $1,291.79 be charged
back to the Town of Dryden for the tax year 1990:
42.-1-31.5 $ 755.01
42.-1-34.1 74.40
43.-2-3.1 462.38
RESOLVED, further, That the following special assessment charges be charged back to the Town
of Ithaca for the tax years 1972-77 and 1981-91 in the amount of $5,986.58:
38.-3-16 $ 5,986.58
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
47
February 16, 1993
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 46 - CORRECTION OF TAX ROLLS - 1992 AND 1993 - CITY OF ITHACA
(WESTERN UNION)
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Ms. Mink, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, this Board is informed that an error has been made in the 1992 and 1993 tax roll for
the City of Ithaca; namely parcel 648.8-6-1 assessed to Western Union, was erroneously charged for real
property which had been previously removed, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the entry on
the tax rolls be corrected,
RESOLVED, further, That the total tax for 1992 and 1993 be corrected to -0-,
RESOLVED, further, That the tax collector for the City of Ithaca and the Budget and Finance
office are directed to correct the tax rolls,
RESOLVED, further, That the amount of $362.48 be charged back to the County of Tompkins
($184.79 for 1992 and $177.69 for 1993).
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 47 - APPORTIONMENT OF DOG MONIES
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, the County Administrator has surplus monies in the Dog Fund for apportionment,
pursuant to Section III of the Agriculture and Markets Law, in the amount of $12,838, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the County
Administrator be and hereby is directed to pay the several towns in the County and the City of Ithaca the
amount set forth below as apportioned and approved by this Board:
Remitting Amount Seventy-five percent of
Municipality Remitted: Surplus Apportioned
Caroline 619.21 605.70
Danby 404.94 396.10
Dryden 2,299.45 2,249.25
Enfield 307.07 300.37
Groton 1,114.64 1,090.31
Ithaca 809.79 792.11
Lansing 1,463.97 1,432.01
Newfield 1,162.25 1,136.88
Ulysses 805.68 788.09
City 856.37 837.68
TOTALS 9,843.37 9,628.50
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 48 - APPROVAL OF ISSUANCE OF BONDS - RECONSTRUCTION
HOME
48
February 16, 1993
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 13,
Noes - 0, Excused - 2 (Representatives Dietrich and Shurtleff). Adopted.
BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF REPRESENTATIVES OF TOMPKINS COUNTY,
NEW YORK, AS FOLLOWS:
WHEREAS, Reconstruction Home, Inc., a New York not-for-profit corporation (the "Borrower"),
has requested that Tompkins Health Care Corporation (THCC) provide funds to assist the Borrower in
paying certain costs for the acquisition, construction and equipping of a 120 bed nursing home facility
(the "Project"), and
WHEREAS, the THCC is authorized to approve the issuance of revenue bonds, notes or other
obligations in the approximate amount of $3,500,000 (the "Bonds") for such purposes by Rev. Rul. 63-20
issued by the Internal Revenue Service, and
WHEREAS, pursuant to the requirements of Rev. Rul. 63-20 the County has previously agreed to
take title to the Project at the maturity of the Bonds issued to finance the Project, and
WHEREAS, the County intends to approve the issuance of revenue bonds by THCC to provide
funds for the making of a loan secured by a mortgage for the acquisition, construction and equipping of
such facility, which mortgage will be insured by the Federal Housing Administration, and
WHEREAS, by Resolution Nos. 164, 276 and 277 of 1985, the Board of Representatives did
authorize the Tompkins Health Care Corporation to act on behalf of the County of Tompkins as an
instrumentality to provide health care facilities for persons within the jurisdictional area of the County,
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED as follows:
1. At the request of the Borrower (1) the law firm of Peck, Shaffer & Williams, Attorneys,
Cincinnati, Ohio, is hereby appointed Bond Counsel in connection with the issuance of the bonds, and is
authorized to prepare the legal documents necessary therefore and (2) First Albany Corporation is hereby
appointed as placement agent to facilitate the placement of the Bonds.
2. This resolution is intended to be relied upon by the Borrower, which expects to complete
permanent financing of the Project as soon as possible.
3. The Board of Representatives will enact the necessary resolutions to proceed with approval of
the issuance of the Bonds, in one or more series, provided that the payment of the principal, interest, and
premium (if any) on the Bonds Shall be made solely from moneys realized from the Borrower. The
Bonds shall have such terms as shall be approved by the Borrower, the Tompkins County Board of
Representatives, the THCC, First Albany Corporation, and Bond Counsel, and the THCC will cause the
Bonds to be delivered to First Albany Corporation against payment therefore, and will cooperate to the
fullest extent in consummating the transaction.
4. This resolution is an affirmative official action of the Tompkins County Board of
Representatives toward the issuance of the Bonds as contemplated herein in accordance with the purposes
of Federal laws.
5. This resolution is expressly contingent upon the fact that the securities issued by the THCC
shall not constitute a debt of the County of Tompkins and shall in no way effect the borrowing capacity of
the County.
6. This Board of Representatives hereby finds and determines that all formal actions of this Board
of Representatives concerning and relating to the adoption of this resolution were adopted in an open
meeting of this Board of Representatives, and that all deliberations of this Board of Representatives and
of any of its committees that resulted in such formal action, were in meetings open to the public, in
compliance with all legal requirements, and the rules of this Board of Representatives in accordance
therewith.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 49 - BUDGET ADJUSTMENTS AND APPROPRIATIONS - VARIOUS
DEPARTMENTS
49
February 16, 1993
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Mason. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes -
13, Noes - 0, Excused - 2 (Representatives Dietrich and Shurtleff). Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education, Human Services, Planning and
Budget and Administration Committees, That the County Comptroller be authorized to make the
following budget adjustment on his books:
BUDGET ADJUSTMENTS
Job Training
Revenue: CD6290.4735 Special Training & $ 120
Employment Project
CD6290.4425 Service Contracts
Appropriation:
Mental Health
Revenue:
Appropriation:
Office for Aging
Revenue:
Appropriation:
Revenue:
Appropriation:
Revenue:
Appropriation:
Revenue:
Appropriation:
Revenue:
Appropriation:
Planning
Revenue:
Appropriation:
Revenue:
Appropriation:
Public Health
Revenue:
Appropriation:
Revenue:
A4235.2770
A4235.4400
A6777.3803
A6777.4491
A6780.3803
A6780.4465
A6782.8303
A6782.4302
.4465
.4466
A6783.4772
A6783.4491
A6789.3803
A6789.4465
A8023.4939
A8023.4465
.4466
CD8686.4989
CD8686.1671
.1701
.4302
.4402
.4452
.4465
.8830
.8840
.8870
A4010.3401
A4010.2210
.2211
.2212
.4302
.4315
.4330
.4442
.4452
.4472
.4901
A4011.3411
Unclassified Revenues
Alcohol Council
Revenue
Subcontractor
Revenue
Job -Necessitated Travel
Revenue
Supplies
Job -Necessitated Travel
Job -Related Travel
Revenue
Subcontractor
Revenue
Job -Necessitated Travel
Urban Transportation
Job -Necessitated Travel
Job -Related Travel
HUD Rehabilitation Grant
Secretary
Admin. Spec. Coor.
Office Supplies
Legal Advertising
Postage
Job Necessitated Travel
Social Security
Worker's Compensation
Unemployment Insurance
PHW State Aid
Equipment - Other
Equipment - Chairs
Equipment - Desks
Office Supplies
Nursing Supplies
Printing
PSF
Postage
Telephone
Micro -computer
State Aid IHAP Grant
50
$ 120
$(26,500)
$(26,500)
$ 7,364
$ 7,364
$ 161
$ 161
$ 137
$ 16
$ 72
$ 49
$ 169
$ 169
$ 99
$ 99
$ 2,011
$ 1,011
$ 1,000
$ 2,375
$ 40
$ 539
$ 417
$ 284
$ 200
$ 739
$ 140
$ 8
$ 8
$ 4,789
$ 333
$ 112
$ 244
$ 250
$ 800
$ 250
$ 1,950
$ 200
$ 400
$ 250
$ 811
Appropriation:
Youth Bureau
Revenue:
Appropriation:
APPROPRIATION:
District Attorney
FROM:
TO:
A4011.4465
.4466
A7026.3836
A7026.4589
February 16, 1993
Job -Necessitated Travel
Job -Related Travel
Red Cross Management
Red Cross Management
A1990 Contingent Fund
A1166.4400 Special Prosecutors
$ 611
$ 200
$ 2,000
$ 2,000
$ 10,578
$ 10,578
RESOLVED, further, That the Chairman of the Board be and hereby is authorized and directed to
execute any contracts necessary to convey these funds.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 50 - ABOLITION AND CREATION OF POSITIONS AND BUDGET
TRANSFER - SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Safety and Budget and Administration
Committees, That four (4) positions of Deputy Sheriff Transport Officers (32/428), labor grade II,
competitive class, at twenty-five percent (25%) full-time equivalency be abolished,
RESOLVED, further, That four (4) positions of Corrections Officer (32/406), labor grade II,
competitive class, at one hundred percent (100%) full-time equivalency be created,
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller is hereby authorized to transfer such funds between
personal services sub -accounts as necessary in order to maintain proper balances:
FROM: A3150.1904 Jail - Overtime $ 25,000
A3110.1904 Sheriff - Overtime 20,000
A3110.1419 Sheriff - Deputy (bgt err.) 29,830
A3110.1428 Sheriff - Dep. Sh. Trans. Offr. 29,000
A3110.8830 Sheriff - Social Security 5,800
A3110.8840 Sheriff - Worker's Comp. 1,655
A3110.8870 Sheriff - Unemployment 473
$ 111,758
TO: A3150.1406 Jail -
A3150.8810 Jail -
A3150.8830 Jail -
A3150.8840 Jail -
A3150.8860 Jail -
A3150.8870 Jail -
A3150.4340 Jail -
Correction Officer
Retirement
Social Security
Worker's Comp.
Health Insurance
Unemployment
Clothing
$ 84,592
2,086
4,559
1,251
15,912
358
3,000
$111,758
RESOLVED, further, That target spending in accordance with the Fiscal Plan for Tompkins
County Sheriffs Department is hereby reduced from $1,946,600 to $1,859,842.
RESOLVED further, That the County Administrator and the Public Safety Committee are charged
with finalizing an implementation plan regulating the use of overtime in the Sheriffs Department.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
51
February 16, 1993
It was Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to add to the agenda Resolution No. 29 - Refinancing of One-half of Capital Costs of
Certain Facilities for Tompkins Cortland Community College.
It was Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to rescind Resolution No. 29 of 1993 entitled Refinancing of One-half of Capital Costs
of Certain Facilities for Tompkins Cortland Community College.
RESOLUTION NO. 51 - APPROVAL OF PROPOSED AGREEMENT - DORMITORY
AUTHORITY OF NEW YORK STATE AND TOMPKINS
CORTLAND COMMUNITY COLLEGE
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County Board of Representatives (the "Local Sponsor") hereby finds
and determines that, pursuant to the provisions of Article 126 of the Education law, the Local Sponsor has
established [Tompkins Cortland] (the "Community College") in and for the County of Tompkins; has
provided for the refinancing of not exceeding one-half of the amount of the capital costs of certain
facilities (herein and in the Agreement, each as hereinafter defined, collectively called the "Project") and
has authorized the Dormitory Authority of the State of New York (the "Authority") to provide for the
refinancing of not to exceed one-half of the amount of the capital costs of the Project by the issuance of
its bonds ( the "Bonds"), and in furtherance thereof and after discussion of the provisions of the proposed
Agreement, wishes to approve the form and substance of the proposed Agreement among the Local
Sponsor, the Authority and the Community College pertaining, among other matters, to said proposed
Authority refinancing of one-half of the capital costs of said Project and to grant approval to the Board of
Trustees of the Community College to execute and deliver the Agreement.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, by the Tompkins County Board of Representatives as
follows:
Section 1. The form and substance of a proposed agreement, by and among the Local Sponsor, the
Authority and the Community College (the "Agreement"), in substantially the form presented to this
Legislature prior to this meeting, is hereby approved.
Section 2. The Chairman of the Tompkins County Board of Representatives, is hereby authorized,
on behalf of the Local Sponsor, to execute and deliver the Agreement to the Authority, with such non -
substantive changes in terms and form as said Chairman of the Tompkins County Board of
Representatives, shall approve. The execution thereof by said Chairman shall constitute conclusive
evidence of the approval of the Local Sponsor.
Section 3. The Local Sponsor also hereby grants approval to the Board of Trustees of the
Community College to authorize the approval of, and to execute and deliver the Agreement to the
Authority, and the Local Sponsor knows of no regulation or limitation which has been established and
prescribed by the State University of New York which would prohibit the Board of Trustees of the
Community College from executing the Agreement and carrying out the provisions thereof.
Section 4. The Local Sponsor hereby grants approval to the Board of Trustees of the Community
College to do all things necessary and proper to effectuate the construction of the Project in accordance
with the provisions of the Agreement.
Section 5. The Local Sponsor hereby represents that it presently intends to continue its operation
of the Community College, and does not intend to substantially reduce or "cut back" it's operations. The
Local Sponsor further represents that its fiscal and economic situation is such that it will be able to
continue, in the foreseeable future, its financial support for the Community College.
Section 6. The Local Sponsor hereby authorizes the said Chairman of the Tompkins County Board
of Representatives of the Local Sponsor, (who is duly qualified to so act) to execute and deliver all
necessary or appropriate documents and to furnish all information requested by the Authority in
connection with the Local Sponsor, including the furnishing of information required pursuant to the
provisions of the Agreement.
52
February 16, 1993
Section 7. The Local Sponsor hereby authorizes the Dormitory Authority to construct the facility
on its behalf and authorizes the said Chairman, of Local Sponsor, (who is duly qualified to so act) to
execute and deliver all documents necessary or desirable in connection with construction of the Project by
the Authority.
Section 8. The said Chairman of the Local Sponsor agrees to provide to the Tompkins County
Board of Representatives monthly status reports with respect to design and construction of the project,
and the reports will be delivered in person to and reviewed by the Health and Education Committee.
Section 9. A certified copy of this resolution shall be forwarded to the Chairman of the Tompkins
County Board of Representatives and Office of the Tompkins County Comptroller, Commissioner of the
Depaitment of Environment and Planning, County Attorney, President of Tompkins Cortland, and
Executive Director - Dormitory Authority of the State of New York.
Section 10. This Resolution shall take effect immediately.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
Ms. Mink asked for authorization to let Board members who are ill cast proxy votes. Chairman
Watros requested the County Attorney to pursue this request.
It was Moved Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans, to hold an executive session to discuss
negotiations and contract negotiations. An executive session was held at 6:05 p.m. and returned to open
session at 6:35 p.m.
Mr. Lerner, Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, stated that he would
like to schedule a special Board meeting on March 30 to discuss options on the Recycling and Solid
Waste Center, to put the proposed DR -7 landfill site on hold and to follow-up on solid waste
privatization. Mr. Lerner stated that he would like the Board to develop a long-term solid waste financing
program. Chairman Watros agreed to the special meeting and said the Clerk of the Board will send a
notice to Board members and media.
Chairman Watros appointed the following members to serve on an ad-hoc Solid Waste Finance
Committee:
Eric Lerner, Chairman
Mary Call
Thomas Todd
Ed Cope
Chairman Watros stated that the Committee is charged to develop a long-range solid waste finance
plan by year-end. Mr. Lerner stated that he hopes to bring a resolution forward to set criteria and
perimeters of this plan.
It was Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Mason, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to lift Resolution No. 33 of 1993 from the Table.
RESOLUTION NO. 33 - ESTABLISHING A UNIT CHARGE FOR THE 1993 ANNUAL SOLID
WASTE FEE (Amended by Resolution No. 127 of 1993)
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Mason. Mrs. Call, Chairman of the Budget and
Administration Committee, reviewed the discussion and actions that took place at the committee meeting
prior to the Board meeting.
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Winch, to approve option G proposed rates and options:
Residential - $52.00; Apartments - $0.056; Warehouses/Recreation - $0.0270; Other - $0.0500; Other
53
February 16, 1993
(schools) - $0.0000; Local Government - $0.0000; Colleges - $280,233. A roll call vote resulted as
follows on the amendment: Ayes - 9 (Representatives Call, Evans, Lerner, Livesay, Mason, Mink, Todd,
Winch and Watros); Noes - 4 (Representatives Culligan, Proto, Schuler and Stein); Excused - 2
(Representatives Dietrich and Shurtleff). Motion carried.
A roll call vote resulted as follows on the resolution as amended: Ayes - 9 (Representatives Call,
Evans, Lerner, Livesay, Mason, Mink, Todd, Winch and Watros); Noes - 4 (Representatives Culligan,
Proto, Schuler and Stein); Excused - 2 (Representatives Dietrich and Shurtleff). Resolution adopted as
amended.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the Unit Charge
for the 1993 Annual Solid Waste Fee hereby be established at $52.00 per Billing Unit,
RESOLVED, further, That the Schedule of Rates of real property for the purpose of this fee shall be as
follows on ATTACHMENT A:
ATTACHMENT A: SCHEDULE OF RATES
Property Class "Used as" Code
(A)
Single family residences 210, 240, 250, 260, 280.
Mobile homes 270, 271, 416.
Churches
Unit Charge: One Billing Unit per church or living unit
Z32
(B)
Two family residences all 220's,
and other residences with two living units
Unit Charge: Two Billing Units, except if verified as owner -occupied and used as a single unit dwelling,
the charge is one Billing Unit.
(C) Multi -unit residences:
3 or more units 230
Apartments: Any number of units on a commercial site A01 thru A07
Rooming houses B06
Unit Charge: One Billing Unit per 928.5714 square feet of floor area
(D) Colleges:
Unit Charge:
All tax exempt parcels owned by these colleges.
Tompkins -Cortland Community College
Cornell University
Ithaca College
189.6 Billing Units
4,682.4 Billing Units
517.1 Billing Units
(E)
Recreation and Warehouses (except row storage)
Recreation All K's, ZO1 thru
Z11, Z19 thru Z26
Warehouses FO1 thru F04, F06, F07,
F08, F10, F11
Unit Charge: One Billing Unit per 1925.9259 square feet of floor area
(F) All Other: All property classes and "used as" codes not listed elsewhere in a specific category.
Unit Charge: One Billing Unit per 1040.0000 square feet of floor area
(G)
No fee assessed: Row storage F05
54
February 16, 1993
Non -contributive area Z98
Local government -- all tax-exempt parcels owned by the city, towns and villages within Tompkins
County.
Public schools: All tax-exempt parcels owned by taxing school entities within Tompkins County
Z29
Unit Charge: Zero Billing Units
Note: The Annual Solid Waste Fee does not apply to unimproved property.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
Mr. Proto, Chairman, Health and Education Committee, reported on cases of meat containing
bacteria and stated that the Health Department has appropriate procedures prescribed so that people will
not pick up this bacteria.
Mr. Proto, Vice Chairman, Planning Committee, reported on rural ridership and stated that the
County can project $42 million in upstate funding.
Mr. Mason, Chairman, Public Safety Committee, reported that the Committee continues to work
with ACT -UP and the Sheriffs Deparlruent on the HIV policy and recommendations for the policy.
On motion of the appropriate committee chairmen and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by
voice vote by members present, the following appointments were made to various advisory boards:
County Board of Assessment Review
Term expires December 31, 1995
Robert C. Herrick
Family Court Advisory Council
Term expires December 31, 1993
William Cornell - Law Enforcement representative
Regional Forest Practice Board
Term expires December 31, 1993
Daniel Winch - Board Member
Advisory Board on Tourism Development
Terms expires December 31, 1994
Margaret Hobbie - Arts Organization representative
Solid Waste Management Advisory Committee
Term expires December 31, 1994
Penny Calderazzo - Consumer representative
On motion, the meeting adjourned at 6:59 p.m.
55
March 2, 1993
Regular Meeting
Public Hearing
Chairman Watros called the public hearing to order at 5:31 p.m. concerning proposed Local Law
No. 2 of 1993 - Amending Local Law No. 7 of 1990 - Providing for Amendments to the Tompkins
County Charter and Code - Youth Bureau - Section 22.02 - Youth Board; Composition; Term; Powers
and Duties.
Chairman Watros asked if anyone wished to speak?
Mr. Shurtleff, Representative, District No. 9, asked what the local law meant?
Ms. Zahler, Youth Bureau Director, said it raises the membership from four (4) to six (6) youth
members.
No one else wished to speak and Chairman Watros closed the public hearing at 5:33 p.m.
Members and guests participated in the Pledge of Allegiance.
Present: 13 Representatives. Excused: 2 (Representatives Call and Dietrich and Representative
Evans was excused at 7:05 p.m.).
It was Moved by Ms. Mink, seconded by Mrs. Livesay, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to approve the minutes of the February 16, 1993 meeting as submitted.
Chairman Watros read a proclamation and presented it to Irene Stein, Office for the Aging
Director, declaring March 7 - 13, 1993 as Employ the Older Worker Week in Tompkins County.
Chairman Watros read a second proclamation and presented it to Ann -Marie Tutton, Assistant
Vice President of Marketing, Tompkins County Trust Company, declaring March 22 - 28, 1993 as
Community Banking Week in Tompkins County.
Mr. Proto, Chairman, Health and Education Committee, said the committee met February 23. The
committee reviewed the dental care program and said the Groton Health Center is taking the lead in the
program. Mr. Deluca, Commissioner of Mental Health, updated the committee on the status of forensic
care being provided at the Jail and the extra cost that may be incurred by the County. Mr. Proto stated
that Mr. Deluca is working with Gordon Stevens, Jail Administrator, towards identifying the population at
the Jail to see if all the individuals who receive this type of treatment really need it. The committee
approved the Birches proposal for Willard Psychiatric Center. Mr. Stein, Representative, District No. 3,
reported on the short-range plan program the community college is undertaking. The plan is for three to
four years. A consultant was hired and will be looking at the building and grounds. Staff, students and
community groups are also involved with the program. Mr. Proto said Board members should have
received an invitation for the community college's budget session on February 26 which sets a stage for
what the college will be requesting. Mr. Proto reported on the lead screening grant and stated the County
hopes to receive 1993-94 funding. The next committee meeting will be March 30. Mr. Culligan, Liaison,
Tompkins County Public Library, reported that Nancy McGinnis has been appointed Acting Public
Library Director. Mr. Culligan announced a vacancy on the Library Board of Trustees.
Mr. Evans, Chairman, Personnel Committee, reported that the committee met February 25. The
committee expects to interview candidates for the position of Commissioner of Personnel on March 15
and 16. Mr. Evans stated that the position of Public Health Director has been advertised. The next
committee meeting will be April 1.
56
March 2, 1993
Ms. Mink, Chairman, Human Services Committee, reported that the committee met this morning.
Ms. Mink stated that a timeline has been proposed for the various security measures being taken at the
Biggs complex. She commended Nancy Zahler for the awards ceremony held March 1 in tribute to
volunteers on the Youth Board and youth commissions throughout the County. She stated that the
committee heard a report from Theda Zimrot, Human Rights Director, who stated that the number of
complaints has risen dramatically. Ms. Mink updated that Board on the status on the streamlining process
of having a human services center.
Mr. Mason, Chairman, Public Safety Committee, reported that the committee will meet on March
4 and will be discussing a resolution concerning the implementation of an overtime regulation plan for the
Sheriffs Department.
Mr. Proto, Vice Chairman, Planning Committee, reported that the committee met prior to the
Board meeting to discuss the resolution on the agenda addressing the Dryden Dam project. The next
committee meeting will be March 11.
Mr. Winch, Chairman, Public Works and Construction Management Committee, reported on a
food composting project at Attica, New York. Mr. Winch reported that the Governor has proposed a
seven percent increase in CHIPS funding for 1993-94. He said that the committee reviewed rules for the
Airport logo contest. He reported that an open house for the Old Jail and the new Planning Department
will be held on Saturday, March 13. Mr. Winch updated the Board on the status of the elevator in the
Mental Health Facility. He apologized for people not being able to use the sixth floor conference room
and stated that he believes the problem has been taken care of. He will continue to monitor the situation.
Mr. Winch reported on the groundbreaking ceremony for the new terminal at the Tompkins County
Airport and stated that the ceremony went well and work has started.
Mr. Todd, Chairman, Article 18 Task Force, stated that he will request an executive session to
discuss a personnel matter.
Mr. Todd, Chairman, Fiscal Affairs Committee, reported that the Committee met on February 17.
He stated that many items are on hold until the County sees how Albany will handle the County's sales
tax request.
Chairman Watros stated that it is imperative that this Board be prepared to take action on March 30
on solid waste issues. He stated it is important that items which Mr. Lerner will report on in his
committee report be moved forward with a fully informed Board of Representatives.
Mr. Lerner, Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, reminded the Board
that there will be a special Board meeting on March 30 to address solid waste issues. Mr. Lerner
distributed a draft summary of each resolution that will appear on the agenda that evening. The
resolutions will address the following:
1. The Solid Waste and Recycling Center - this resolution will authorize final negotiations with
vendor(s) for the Center. The resolution will also reiterate the criteria for justifying the project.
2. DR -7 - this resolution will affirm that the policy of the Board of Representatives is to abandon
plans for a balefill at DR -7. It will identify the major deadlines and tasks to be completed and
will direct staff to proceed.
3. Preparing for taking bids for transportation and waste disposal - this resolution will direct staff to
prepare a plan and schedule for a procurement process for long term transportation and disposal
of solid waste.
4. Regulation of waste collection - this resolution will direct staff to work out schedules and
deadlines for a six point plan to regulate waste collection.
5. Privatization - this resolution will approve a Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee
report on privatization.
57
March 2, 1993
6. Finance and fairness - this resolution will set goals and priorities for developing a long term plan
for solid waste finance by late summer.
Mrs. Livesay, Intergovernmental Representative, reported on meeting of Tompkins County
municipal officials which she attended. Mrs. Livesay stated that she met with City of Ithaca
representatives to discuss sales tax. She said that she has been reviewing several pieces of State
legislation relating to the Education of Handicapped Children, mandate relief and the proposed State
takeover of Medicaid. She stated that she will attend the New York State Association of Counties
conference next week.
Mr. Winch, Vice Chairman, Budget and Administration Committee, reported on a meeting held
prior to the Board meeting to discuss sharing the cost of security with the unified court system.
Mr. Heyman, County Administrator, had no report.
Mr. Mulvey, County Attorney, reported on the status of Rubbish Removal litigation.
Chairman Watros gave the appropriate committee chairmen permission to withdraw the following
resolutions from the agenda:
Authorizing Supplementary Agreement No. 1 for Design of Aircraft Ramp and Taxiway
Connector - New Terminal Project - Tompkins County Airport
Environmental Management Council Election of New Chair
It was Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Mason, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to add to the agenda the resolution entitled Authorization to Execute Contract - Marc
Immerman, M.D. - Jail Medical Services.
It was Moved by Ms. Mink, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to add to the agenda the resolution entitled Award of Bid - Security Access System -
Biggs Building A.
Chairman Watros gave the appropriate committee chairmen permission to withdraw from the
agenda with final committee action being affirmed:
CA020-93 - Award of Bid - Lease - Purchase of Truck with Snowplow - Buildings and Grounds
CA021-93 - Contract with Town of Enfield for Small Cities Grant Services
CA022-93 - Contract with New York State Council on the Arts for Trumansburg Main Street
Study
CA023-93 - Award of Bid - Security Access System - Biggs Building A
RESOLUTION NO. 52 - ADOPTION OF LOCAL LAW NO. 2 OF 1993 - AMENDING LOCAL
LAW NO. 7 OF 1990 - PROVIDING FOR AMENDMENTS TO THE
TOMPKINS COUNTY CHARTER AND CODE - YOUTH BUREAU -
SECTION 22.02 - YOUTH BOARD; COMPOSITION; TERM;
POWERS AND DUTIES
Moved by Ms. Mink, seconded Mrs. Livesay, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, a public hearing was held before the Board of Representatives on March 2, 1993 to
hear all persons interested in proposed Local Law No. 2 of 1993, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Human Services and Budget and Administration
Committees, That said proposed Local Law No. 2 of 1993 - Amending Local Law No. 7 of 1990 -
58
March 2, 1993
Providing for Amendments to the Tompkins County Charter and Code - Youth Bureau - Section 22.02 -
Youth Board; Composition; Term; Powers and Duties is adopted,
RESOLVED, further, That the Clerk of the Board publish in the official newspaper of Tompkins
County a notice of adoption containing a synopsis of said local law, and shall within five (5) days file one
certified copy in the office of the County Clerk and three (3) certified copies in the office of the Secretary
of State.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 53 - AMENDING THE BYLAWS OF THE TOMPKINS COUNTY YOUTH
BOARD
Moved by Ms. Mink, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, the Youth Board has revised its bylaws to reflect changes in membership made in the
Charter and Code and to improve the advisory board's ability to recommend comprehensive plans and
programs to promote youth development and prevent crime and delinquency, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Human Services Committee, That the bylaws of the
Tompkins County Youth Board on file in the Clerk of the Board's office are hereby approved as amended.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 54 - ENDORSEMENT OF "BIRCHES PROPOSAL"
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, demographic projections show a dramatic increase in numbers of elderly in Tompkins
County and the region as well as in the nation as a whole, and
WHEREAS, increasing number of elderly will require treatment for mental illness and various
dementias as well as physical conditions, and
WHEREAS, Willard Psychiatric Center has developed an outstanding holistic program for gero-
psychiatric patients, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education Committee, That the Tompkins
County Board of Representatives endorses the "Birches Proposal" for a regional Gero-psychiatric Center
at Willard Psychiatric Center,
RESOLVED, further, That the County Board of Representatives urges the appropriate members of
the State Depaitments of Mental Health, Health, Social Services and Aging to work together to coordinate
services for elderly psycho -geriatric patients suffering from Alzheimer's disease and organic brain
syndrome so that all such individuals are appropriately placed and served.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 55 - URGING STATE TAKEOVER OF MEDICAID PROGRAM
Moved by Mr. Todd, seconded by Mr. Stein. Following discussion, a voice vote resulted as
follows: Ayes - 11, Noes - 2 (Representatives Lerner and Proto), Excused - 2 (Representatives Call and
Dietrich). Adopted.
59
March 2, 1993
WHEREAS, New York is one of the few states in the country which mandates that counties and
the City of New York (localities) pay a local Medicaid share, which now costs localities $3.3 billion a
year with a growth factor of 14% per annum, and
WHEREAS, this Medicaid mandate requires localities to dedicate an increasingly larger portion of
their local taxes for the State Medicaid program thereby imposing a back breaking burden on local tax
payers, and
WHEREAS, it is imperative that localities obtain immediate relief from this unbridled growth in
the Medicaid program by enactment of effective Medicaid cost-containment, and
WHEREAS, local Medicaid relief must include the immediate acceleration, statutory expansion,
and State assumption of the Managed Care Program, and
WHEREAS, local Medicaid relief must also include the State assumption of the administrative
costs of the Medicaid program, and
WHEREAS, local Medicaid relief must also include a State takeover of the Medicaid program, and
WHEREAS, each phase of a State takeover of the local Medicaid program should include a hold
harmless clause to ensure that each locality benefits from the State takeover plan, and
WHEREAS, counties no longer have the fiscal resources to support the local Medicaid share by
reliance on continual property tax increases and sales tax increases, and a State takeover of Medicaid
would enable counties to administer other necessary local programs in an equitable and productive
fashion, and
WHEREAS, the New York State Association of Counties has made Medicaid takeover its
NUMBER ONE MANDATE RELIEF PRIORITY FOR 1993 and is advocating that Medicaid takeover
be enacted into law concurrent with the adoption of the 1993-94 State budget, and
WHEREAS, Tompkins County now wishes to express its support for State Medicaid takeover in
accordance with the above recitals and such State takeover be enacted into law on or before March 31,
1993, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Fiscal Affairs Committee, That Tompkins County
supports a phases -in State takeover of the Medicaid program which shall include as a minimum: (1)
enactment of structural Medicaid cost-containment, (2) assumption of local Medicaid managed care, (3)
responsibility for all Medicaid administrative costs, (4) incur all growth in the Medicaid program by
1997, and (5) all additional Medicaid takeover relief agreed to by the Governor, Senate and Assembly,
RESOLVED, further, That copies of this Resolution be submitted to Governor Mario M. Cuomo,
Senate Majority Leader Ralph J. Marino, Assembly Speaker Saul Weprin, and all members of the New
York State Legislature, as well as any and all other persons, organizations, and agencies deemed
necessary and proper.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 56 - AWARD OF BID - OFFICE PANEL SYSTEM - OLD JAIL
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Culligan, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, the Division of Purchasing and Central Services has duly advertised for bids for an
Office Panel System - Old Jail, and
WHEREAS, nine (9) bids were received and duly opened on Thursday, February 11, 1993, and
WHEREAS, the low bid received by B. Milligan Contracting of Oswego, NY, be rejected as not
equivalent, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the bid received by B. Milligan Contracting of Oswego, NY, be accepted as the lowest responsible
bidder with a bid as follows:
Office #1 - Personnel $ 3,546
Office #2 - County Attorney's $ 3,826
Office #3 - Budget and Finance $ 2,536
60
Alternatives:
March 2, 1993
Office #4&5 - Purchasing $ 5,366
TOTAL $15,274
Alternate #1
Alternate #2
Alternate #3
Alternate #4
Alternate #5
Alternate #6
TOTAL
$ 685
$ 685
$ 685
$ 1,839
$ 1,839
$ 1,568
$ 7,301
RESOLVED, further, That funds shall be available in the Capital Account No. HV3151.9239 or
through individual department budgets.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 57 - CREATION OF POSITION AND BUDGET TRANSFER - DIVISION
OF BUDGET AND FINANCE (Amended by Resolution No. 84 of 1993)
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Mason, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That one full time
position of Administrative Assistant, (62-326), labor grade XII, be created in the Division of Budget and
Finance effective March 8, 1993 for a period not to exceed ninety (90) days,
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller is hereby directed to make the following budget
transfer:
FROM: A1310.4452 Postage $ 8,600
TO: A1310.1326 Administrative Assistant $ 8,000
A1310.8830 Social Security $ 600
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 58 - FEDERAL SECTION 18 OPERATING ASSISTANCE GRANT
APPLICATION FOR TOMTRAN RURAL TRANSIT
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, Section 18 of the Federal Transit Act of 1964, as amended, provides for the payment
of federal assistance for public transportation in rural and small urban places through a formal grant
program administered by the New York State Department of Transportation, and
WHEREAS, TOMTRAN rural routes are operated by CU Transit, Inc., and Tioga Transport, Inc.,
and provides fixed -route, open -to -the -public transportation service in Tompkins County, and
WHEREAS, the New York State Department of Transportation informed the County that
TOMTRAN is eligible for $59,000 in operating assistance for the 1993 calendar year, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the County Administrator or
his designee be authorized to execute and submit a Federal Section 18 an operating assistance application
to the New York State Department of Transportation in the amount of $59,000 for the calendar year of
1993.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
61
March 2, 1993
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 59 - CONTRACT WITH NEW YORK STATE COUNCIL ON THE ARTS
FOR LANSING TOWN CENTER STUDY
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Todd, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, Tompkins County won a grant from the New York State Council on the Arts on
behalf of the Town of Lansing to perform a Town Center for the Town, and
WHEREAS, the County Planning Department, in conjunction with the Town of Lansing Planning
Board, will administer the grant on behalf of the Town of Lansing, and
WHEREAS, the County will receive $2,500 from the New York State Council on the Arts for this
study, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, That the County Administrator be authorized to sign a contract with the New York
State Council on the Arts,
RESOLVED, That the money received be deposited in revenue account A7010.2770 (Arts
Contract State Aid) and be budgeted in A7010.4442 (Professional Service Fees) by the County
Comptroller.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 60 - CAPITAL PROJECT - AMEND RESOLUTION NO. 322 DATED
OCTOBER 5, 1992, TO APPROVE INITIATION OF LEGAL
PROCEEDINGS FOR EMINENT DOMAIN AS PART OF
PURCHASE AGREEMENTS FOR ACQUISITION OF FLOOD
EASEMENTS FOR VIRGIL CREEK P.L. 566 WATERSHED
PROJECT (DRYDEN DAM PROJECT)
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, the landowners and the municipalities have agreed to a negotiated settlement in lieu
of eminent domain proceedings, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That Resolution No. 322 dated
October 5, 1992, is amended to reflect a payment schedule of $500/acre for lands previously identified as
being in the 10 year flood event and $300/acre for lands identified as being in flood events greater than 10
years up to the 100 year flood event as defined by the top of the proposed dam structure,
RESOLVED, further, That additional survey work as agreed to in negotiations will locate the
approximate easement boundary on either side of Virgil Creek at the County line and in accordance with
agreed metes and bounds survey for Cortland County parcels 144-01-6 and 135.00-1-43,
RESOLVED, further, That in the event that any landowner should for any reason refuse this
negotiated agreement, that eminent domain proceedings may commence as specified in Resolution No.
322.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 61 - ESTABLISHMENT OF CONTRACT WITH COMMUNITY ARTS
PARTNERSHIP FOR ADVISORY BOARD ON TOURISM
DEVELOPMENT ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICE
62
March 2, 1993
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, the Advisory Board on Tourism Development (ABTD) has seen the need for an
administrative location for its staff person and operation, and
WHEREAS, the Community Arts Partnership of Tompkins County (CAP) has space available at a
rate deemed reasonable to the ABTD, and
WHEREAS, the CAP will also provide administrative services such as paying the ABTD staff
salaries and benefits, installing appropriate office equipment and providing suitable space, and
WHEREAS, the CAP shall voucher the County monthly in advance for all fixed expenses, and
variable expenses shall be billed on a monthly basis as incurred, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, That the County Administrator or his designee be authorized to sign a contract with
the Community Arts Partnership to provide the aforementioned devices at a maximum cost of $18,247.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 62 - APPROVAL OF COMMUNITY ARTS PARTNERSHIP WORLD OF
ART PLAN
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Ms. Mink, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, the Community Arts Partnership has successfully demonstrated the potential of its
World of Art plan, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That $4500 be provided as interim
support for the first quarter of the 1993 World of Art plan.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 63 - APPROVAL OF FUNDING FOR DEWITT MALL TICKET CENTER
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Ms. Mink, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, the Dewitt Mall Ticket center has continued to provide a service for tourists and
residents alike, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the Advisory Board on
Tourism Development shall fund the Ticket Center at $8000.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 64 - APPROVAL OF COMMUNITY ARTS PARTNERSHIP (CAP)
GENERAL SUPPORT
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
'members present.
WHEREAS, CAP has participated considerably in the administration of Advisory Board on
Tourism Development (ABTD) projects such as the tourism grants program, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the ABTD shall provide
$7,000 in general support to the Community Arts Partnership.
63
March 2, 1993
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 65 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE CONTRACT - MARC
IMMERMAN, M.D. - JAIL MEDICAL SERVICES
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Mason, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present. Mr. Evans was excused prior to the vote on the resolution.
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County Health Depai tuient is charged with providing inmate medical
services at the Tompkins County Public Safety Building, and
WHEREAS, Marc Immerman, M.D. is qualified to provide medical services to inmates and
oversee the medical services at the facility, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education Committee, That the County
Administrator is authorized to execute a contract with Marc Immerman, M.D. to provide inmate medical
services at the Tompkins County Public Safety Building,
RESOLVED, further, That funding for this service is provided to the Health Depai tment by the
Sheriffs Department, said funds to be expended from A4150.4442, Professional Service Fees.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
Under unfinished business, Chairman Watros requested a decision be made on the course of action
to be taken concerning the sales tax legislation. Discussion followed regarding the County
Administrator's projected 1994 Tompkins County real property tax levy:
The 1993 real property tax levy is $15,582,600. If the local share of five mandated items increases
at the same rate as the last five years, this will add $1,617,064 to the levy. If the cost of living increase
for all optional items is added to the levy and this increase is 4.1 percent, this will add $720,000 to the
levy. If the County receives 50 percent of the proceeds of the fourth cent of local sales taxes, and if sales
tax proceeds grow by one percent, the impact on the levy will be $787,442. The total levy based on the
above would be $18,704,106 (+20%).
If the County receives 75 percent of the proceeds of the fourth cent of local sales taxes the impact
on the levy will be ($1,148,391). The total levy based on this would be $16,768,273 (+7.6%).
If the fourth cent of local sales taxes were permitted to lapse, the impact on the levy would be
$4,659,109. The total levy based on this would be 22,575,773 (+44.9%).
Mr. Mulvey, County Attorney, stated that he has been informed by Assemblyman Luster that the
Ways and Means Committee of the New York State Legislature has a general policy that they will not
enact legislation for additional sales tax unless there is an agreement on how this sales tax will be spent.
Mr. Todd, Chairman, Fiscal Affairs Committee, stated that the Committee has discussed this and believes
that the County made a sound fiscal attempt to solve problems in rocky economic times. Mr. Todd said
that he would not support the City of Ithaca's request for an additional amount of the County's sales tax.
Ms. Mink, Representative, District No. 5, stated that she feels the City is doing what it has been told it can
do. Mrs. Livesay, Representative, District No. 11, suggested the Board consider sharing services with the
City of Ithaca.
It was Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, to add to the agenda the resolution entitled
Authorizing Negotiations with the City of Ithaca Regarding Disposition of Sales Tax. A voice vote
resulted as follows: Ayes - 10, Noes - 2 (Representatives Mason and Todd), Excused - 3 (Representatives
Call, Dietrich and Evans). Motion Carried.
64
March 2, 1993
RESOLUTION NO. 66 - AUTHORIZING NEGOTIATIONS WITH THE CITY OF ITHACA
REGARDING DISPOSITION OF SALES TAX
It was Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mr. Proto. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 10,
Noes - 2 (Representatives Todd and Winch), Excused - 3 (Representatives Call, Dietrich and Evans).
Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Sales Tax Negotiating Committee, That the Committee is
hereby authorized to continue negotiations with the City of Ithaca regarding disposition of sales tax.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
Chairman Watros announced the appointment of Stuart Stein as Planning Committee Chairman.
Mr. Stein will replace Representative Dietrich who has resigned effective March 11, 1993.
Chairman Watros announced the appointments of Scott Craver and Peggy Calderazzo to the Solid
Waste Finance Subcommittee.
On motion of the appropriate committee chairmen and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by
voice vote by members present, the following appointments were made to various advisory boards:
Environmental Management Council
Term expires December 31, 1993
Herb Engman - Chairman
Human Rights Commission
Terms expire December 31, 1995
Susan Beal
Lyn Greenspan
Solid Waste Management Advisory Committee
Term expires December 31, 1993
Eric Lerner - County Board member
Term expires December 31, 1995
Edward Cope - Environmental Management Council representative
Chairman Watros declared recess from 7:50 p.m. to 7:55 p.m.
It was Moved by Ms. Mink, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to enter into executive session at 7:56 p.m. to discuss personnel matters and litigation.
The meeting returned to open session at 8:20 p.m.
On motion the meeting adjourned at 8:20 p.m.
65
March 16, 1993
Regular Meeting
Chairman Watros called the meeting to order at 5:30 p.m.
Members and guests participated in the Pledge of Allegiance.
Present: 14 Representatives. Excused: 1 (Representative Shurtleff arrived at 5:45 p.m.).
Chairman Watros recognized and welcomed Tim J. Joseph, Representative, District No. 12.
It was Moved by Mr. Evans, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to approve the minutes of March 2, 1993 as submitted.
Mr. Winch announced the appointment of Grant and Marie Musser as the Keepers of the Newfield
Covered Bridge for 1993.
Chairman Watros read a proclamation declaring March 16 - 22, 1993 as Red Cross Week in
Tompkins County and presented it to Chuck Nocera of the Red Cross.
Under privilege of the floor, Ernest Bury, Valley Road, Ithaca, addressed his concerns with
municipal solid waste and asked for plans to be frozen on the Central Processing Facility.
Under privilege of the floor, Jeannine Kirby, Supervisor, Town of Lansing, stated that she is
opposed to the City of Ithaca receiving any additional sales tax revenue other than what was originally
agreed upon.
Under privilege of the floor Mr. Winch, Representative, District No. 8, thanked Public Works staff,
road crews and grounds crews for their work during the blizzard. He sated that it will take the rest of the
week to finish cleaning up.
Under privilege of the floor, Mr. Mason, Representative, District No. 15, also extended his
appreciation to the Fire, Disaster and EMS personnel for their work during the blizzard. He reported on
the New York State Association of Counties (NYSAC) and New York State Supervisors and County
Legislators Association (NYSSCLA) conference. He said it was a very productive session and copies of
resolutions adopted by NYSAC are on file with the Clerk of the Board.
Mr. Lerner responded to some of Mr. Bury's concerns regarding recycling of newspapers and flow
control.
Mr. Proto, Chairman, Health and Education Committee, reported that the annual Hospital meeting
will be April 15. He stated that due to weather conditions, the Health Fair at Pyramid Mall was cancelled.
He reported that the Convenient Care Center has had in excess of 17,000 visits.
Mr. Evans, Chairman, Personnel Committee, reported that the Committee met briefly before the
Board meeting. He stated that interviews with candidates for the position of Director of Personnel were
cancelled due to the weather and will be rescheduled.
Ms. Mink, Chairman, Human Services Committee, stated the next Committee meeting will be
April 8.
Mr. Mason, Chairman, Public Safety Committee, reported that the Committee met March 4 and
Committee actions are reflected on the agenda. He stated that the Committee received correspondence
from Judith VanAllen, Offender Aid and Restoration, regarding difficulties with the bail program. Some
concerns are papers and bail funds not being returned in a timely manner following cases being resolved.
66
March 16, 1993
Mr. Mason stated that it was not appropriate for the County Attorney to assist because OAR is an outside
agency and County money is not involved.
Mr. Stein, Chairman, Planning Committee, stated that the Committee met today. Mr. Stein
welcomed Representative Joseph. Mr. Stein reported on the Small Cities program and stated that a
housing grant application for the Town of Enfield has been resubmitted. He stated that the Metropolitan
Planning Organization has appointed a Director. The Town of Ithaca has requested staff assistance from
the County Planning Depat tnient.
Mr. Winch, Chairman, Public Works and Construction Management Committee, reported on an
accident a County snowplow was in during the blizzard. He stated that during the blizzard there was
minimal breakdown of equipment. Robert Nicholas, Airport Manager filed his 1992 annual report. Mr.
Winch reported that the Airport Terminal project has been delayed due to frozen ground.
Mr. Todd, Chairman, Fiscal Affairs Committee, reported that there has been ongoing discussion
with Mary Pat Dolan, Commissioner, on how the Department of Social Services fits into the fiscal plan.
A review of the fiscal plan has been postponed until negotiations with the City of Ithaca concerning sales
tax is resolved. The Committee has been discussing salaries for Board of Representatives members for
the term 1994-1997. The Committee will be discussing the establishment of a task force to consolidate
police agencies and decentralize highway services. The Committee is also preparing preliminary work on
conducting a survey like last year.
Mr. Lerner, Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, stated that the plan is
still to have six resolutions on the March 30 Special Board meeting agenda. He said the Committee will
meet March 18 to discuss the six proposed resolutions and backup material will be available. The next
meeting of the justification of the Central Processing Facility is March 23.
Mrs. Livesay, Intergovernmental Representative, also reported on the New York State Association
of Counties and New York State Supervisors and County Legislators Association conference and agreed
it went very well. She stated that she attended the business meeting of Supervisors and Legislators and
stated that they also adopted a packet of resolutions. Mrs. Livesay reported that she has been involved in
negotiations on sales tax with the City of Ithaca. Mrs. Livesay stated that Monroe and Nassau County are
suing the State for mandate funding and recommended that Tompkins County not get involved.
Mrs. Call, Chairman, Budget and Administration Committee, reported that the Committee met
March 9 and discussed changing the Assessment Review process, however, the Committee voted not to
proceed. She stated that the Committee met briefly to clarify a form being used for the Solid Waste Fee.
Mrs. Call said that any questions concerning the Fee should be directed to the Budget and Finance office.
She stated that Cathy Covert, Clerk of the Board, updated the Committee on the status of the Board
proceedings. The next Committee meeting will be April 13.
Mr. Heyman, County Administrator, reported on employee health concerns at the Biggs complex.
He reported that he is awaiting comments from the court system concerning security for the Courthouse.
He reported on worker's compensation and insurance offerings by PENCO and a reciprocal among New
York State municipalities at the New York State Association of Counties and New York State
Supervisors and County Legislators Association conference.
Mrs. Nelson, Chair, Employee Council, reported that the Council met March 3 and stated that the
tasks the Council are working on will be charted in the next issue of the County Corridors. She stated that
the Council will be looking at ways to improve communications among all employees. She said the
Council supports Resolution No. 13 in memoriam to Schuyler County. The next meeting will be April 7
in the SADD Conference room.
67
March 16, 1993
On motion of the appropriate committee chairmen and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by
voice vote, the following resolutions were added to the agenda:
Amendment of Resolution No. 57 of 1993 - Creation of Position and Budget Transfer - Division
of Budget and Finance
Amendment of Resolution No. 359 of 1992 - Request for Authorization to Increase Local Sales
Tax
Authorizing Execution of Agreements for Aquatic Vegetation Control Program Narrative and
Budget for NYSFY 1992-93
Budget Adjustment for Aquatic Vegetation Weed Control
Decrease in Hours and Creation of Positions - Planning Department
Authorization to Execute Agreement with City of Ithaca - Sales Tax Distribution
Chairman Watros gave the appropriate committee chairmen permission to withdraw from the
agenda the following resolutions:
Approval of Convention and Visitors Bureau 1993 Budget
A Resolution Authorizing the Issuance of $5,100,000 Serial Bonds of the County of Tompkins,
New York to Pay the County's Share of the Cost of the Construction of Improvements at the
Tompkins County Airport
Authorization to Increase Hours - Director of Weights and Measures
A Resolution Authorizing the Issuance of $363,801 Serial Bonds of the County of Tompkins,
New York to Pay the Costs of Various Objects or Purposes
Chairman Watros gave the appropriate committee chairmen permission to withdraw from the
agenda the following resolutions with final committee action being affirmed:
CA024-93 - Implementation of Overtime Regulation Plan - Tompkins County Sheriff
CA025-93 - Acceptance of Grant and Budget Adjustment - Healthy Heart
CA026-93 - Authorizing Supplementary Agreement No. 1 With C & S Engineers, Inc. for Design
of Aircraft Ramp and Taxiway Connector - New Terminal Project - Tompkins County
Airport
CA027-93 - Award of Bid - Road Materials and Highway Services (Mr. Proto stated that he would
be submitting a letter stating a conflict of interest and would request an abstention
from any vote on this resolution)
CA028-93 - Budget Adjustments and Appropriations - Various Depaitnients
CA029-93 - Authorization to Execute Contract with Tompkins County Trust Company
CA030-93 - Award of Bid - Office Furniture
CA031-93 - Reclassification of Position - Youth Bureau
CA032-93 - Reclassification of Positions - Public Works
CA033a-93 - Authorization to Accept Funds from NYSACHO - Immunization Coalition - Health
Department
RESOLUTION NO. 67 - PERSONAL EMERGENCY RESPONSE SYSTEM RENTAL AND
SERVICE FEES
Moved by Mrs. Livesay, seconded by Mrs. Call, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County Board of Representatives by Resolution No. 420 of October 18,
1991, has authorized a rent and service charge schedule for Personal Emergency Response System
(PERS) users, and
WHEREAS, on recommendation of the PERS Advisory Board, that the Board of Representatives
accept and adopt the revised schedule, now therefore be it
68
March 16, 1993
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Human Services Committee, That the Board of
Representatives accepts and adopts the following revised fee schedule:
If you live alone:
Equipment Service Total
Monthly Income: Rental: Charge: Charge:
Less than $541 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00
541 - 690 2.50 .50 3.00
691 - 800 5.00 1.25 6.25
801 - 1,000 7.50 1.90 9.40
1,001 - 1,500 10.00 2.50 12.50
1,501 - 2,000 20.00 5.00 25.00
2,001 - up 25.00 6.25 31.25
If you live with a spouse:
Equipment Service Total
Monthly Income: Rental: Charge: Charge:
Less than $774 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00
744 - 925 2.50 .50 3.00
926 - 1,100 5.00 1.25 6.25
1,101 - 1,300 7.50 1.90 9.40
1,301 - 1,800 10.00 2.50 12.50
1,801 - 2,300 20.00 5.00 25.00
2,301 - up 25.00 6.25 31.25
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 68 - POLICY REGARDING PAYMENT OF COSTS FOR SPACE IN
COUNTY BUILDINGS
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Fiscal Affairs and Public Works and Construction
Management Committees, That effective immediately any new or increased occupancy of space in any
County building must at a minimum be paid for in full by the user department, agency or company. The
full cost of such occupancy shall be as determined in the Buildings and Grounds Cost Report prepared by
Jack Venesky, CPA (Certified Public Accountant), or any successor means of determining costs as
established by the Public Works and Construction Management Committee of this Board,
RESOLVED, further, That all other practices with respect to charging for space in County
buildings shall be unaffected by this resolution.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 69 - AWARD OF BID - OFFICE FURNITURE SOLID WASTE OFFICE
BUILDING
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mrs. Livesay. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 14,
Noes - 1 (Representative Proto). Adopted.
WHEREAS, the Division of Purchasing and Central Services has duly advertised for office
furniture for use by various County departments, and
69
March 16, 1993
WHEREAS, eight (8) bids were received and publicly opened on February 26, 1993, now therefore
be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Solid Waste Construction Committee and the Public
Works Construction Management Committee, That the bid of Batty & Hoyt Inc. of Syracuse, New York
be rejected as they do not meet minimum specifications,
RESOLVED, further, That the bids of RACE Office Equipment Co., Inc. of Ithaca, New York for
carts and storage cabinets, and MDI, Inc. of Syracuse, New York for all HON and Bevis items be rejected
as they do not meet minimum specifications,
RESOLVED, further, That the bid be awarded in the following configuration:
Syracuse Office Environments
Syracuse, New York: $6,889.60
T.G. Miller's Sons Paper Co.
Ithaca, New York: $255.63
RACE Office Equipment Co., Inc.
Ithaca, New York: $5,902.29
Ithaca Office Equipment
Ithaca, New York: $992.74
Hummels Office Equipment Co., Inc.
Herkimer, New York: $5,508.99
Desks/Returns
File Cabinets
Secretarial Task Chairs
HON Side Chairs
Storage Cabinets (24" deep)
Grolen Computer Furniture
Chairmats
Stylex Chairs
Magazine Wall Rack
Map Cabinets
Bevis Computer Furniture
Folding/Utility Tables
Wood Bookcases
Global Stacking Chairs
Miscellaneous Tables/Stands
RESOLVED, further That the percentage discounts be awarded in the following configuration:
Syracuse Office Environments
Syracuse, New York
HON Desks
HON Files
HON Seating
50.1%
50.1%
50.1%
Hummels Office Equipment Co., Inc. BEVIS Computer Furniture 55%
Herkimer, New York
BEVI S Panels 55%
RESOLVED, further, That the Department of Public Works be authorized to execute this award on
behalf of the County in accordance with the terms and specifications outlined within the bid
specifications, funds to be provided from Capital Account HH8167.9239.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 70 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE A GRANT AGREEMENT WITH
FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION (FAA) - NEW SNOW
PLOW - TOMPKINS COUNTY AIRPORT
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
70
March 16, 1993
WHEREAS, the County has received a grant offer from the Federal Aviation Administration
(FAA) in the amount of $191,671 towards the cost of purchasing a new airport snow plow, and
WHEREAS, the budget for said project is as follows:
FAA Share (90%) Account No. HT5610.4592 $ 191,671
NYSDOT Share (5%) Account No. HT5610.3592 10,648
Local Share (5%) Account No. HT5610.5031 10,649
(PFC's)
Total Cost Account No. HT5610.2200 $ 212,968
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the FAA grant offer in the amount of $191,671 be and hereby is accepted and that the County
Administrator is authorized to execute the required documents.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 71 - AWARD OF BID - AIRCRAFT RAMP AND TAXIWAY CONNECTOR
- TOMPKINS COUNTY AIRPORT
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, the Division of Purchasing and Central Services has duly advertised for bids for
construction of an aircraft ramp and taxiway connector at the Tompkins County Airport in accordance
with specifications as approved by the Airport Construction Committee, the Federal Aviation
Administration (FAA), and the New York State Department of Transportation (NYSDOT), and
WHEREAS, five (5) bids were received and publicly opened and read on February 18, 1993, now
therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Airport Construction and Public Works and Construction
Management Committees, That the bid for construction of an aircraft ramp and taxiway connector be
awarded to Suit-kote Corporation of Cortland, New York as being the lowest responsible bidder in the
amount of $2,377,331.95, subject to agreement by the FAA and NYSDOT,
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator is hereby authorized to execute a contract
with Suit-kote to implement this bid,
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller is hereby authorized to borrow monies until
reimbursement is received from the FAA, NYSDOT, and airport revenues for this project, and that the
funding sources shall be as follows:
FAA Share (90%) Account No. HU5610.4592 $2,139.598
NYSDOT Share (5%) .3592 118,867
Local Share (5%) .2831 118,867
Total Account No. HU5610.9239 $2,377,332
RESOLVED, further, That a project contingency of ten percent be established, funds being
available in Account No. HU5610.9239 and the County Administrator be authorized to sign future change
orders up to the project contingency amount.
SEQR ACTION: TYPE I
(NEGATIVE DECLARATION ON FILE)
RESOLUTION NO. 72 - CORRECTION OF TAX ROLL - CITY OF ITHACA - ITHACA
URBAN RENEWAL AGENCY
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, this Board is informed that an error has been made in the 1993 tax roll for the City of
Ithaca, namely parcel 43-2-1.3 assessed to Ithaca Urban Renewal, an exemption having been omitted,
now therefore be it
71
March 16, 1993
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the entry on
the tax roll be corrected,
RESOLVED, further, That the total tax for the parcel be changed from $967.40 to $ -0-,
RESOLVED, further, That the tax collector for the City of Ithaca is hereby authorized and directed
to correct the 1993 tax roll,
RESOLVED, further, That the amount of $967.40 be charged back.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 73 - A RESOLUTION CALLING A PUBLIC HEARING ON THE
ISSUANCE OF SERIAL BONDS BY THE COUNTY OF
TOMPKINS, NEW YORK TO PAY THE COST OF VARIOUS
IMPROVEMENTS AT THE TOMPKINS COUNTY
AIRPORT IN AND FOR SAID COUNTY
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Mason. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 14, Noes
- 1 (Representative Lerner). Adopted.
WHEREAS, the County of Tompkins, New York, proposes the issuance of serial bonds (the
"Bonds") of said County to pay the County's share of the cost of various improvements at the Tompkins
County Airport in said County, including the construction of a new terminal building, access roads,
parking lots, ramp/taxiway and T -hangers including original furnishings, equipment, machinery,
apparatus and related incidental improvements and expenses in connection therewith, and
WHEREAS, the Bonds and any bond anticipation notes issued in anticipation thereof may be
"private activity" bonds within the meaning of Section 141 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 (the
Code"), and
WHEREAS, Section 147(f) of the Code requires that bonds or notes which are "private activity"
bonds within the meaning of Section 141 of the Code be approved by the governmental unit issuing such
bonds or notes after a public hearing following reasonable public notice, in order for interest on the bonds
or notes to be excludable from gross income for federal income tax purposes, and
WHEREAS, the Board of Representatives now desires to call a public hearing on the issuance of
the Bonds and any bond anticipation notes issued in anticipation of said Bonds, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, by the Board of Representatives of the County of Tompkins, New York, as follows:
Section 1. A public hearing will be held at the Tompkins County Courthouse, in Board Chambers,
in Ithaca, New York, in said County on April 6, 1993, at 5:30 o'clock p.m. Prevailing Time, on the
question of whether serial bonds, and bond anticipation notes issued in anticipation thereof, should be
issued by the County of Tompkins, New York, to finance the County's share of the cost of various
improvements at the Tompkins County Airport in said County, including the construction of a new
terminal building, access roads, parking lots, ramp/taxiway and T -hangers including original furnishings,
equipment, machinery, apparatus and related incidental improvements and expenses in connection
therewith, and to hear all persons interested in the subject thereof, concerning the same, and to take such
action thereon as is required or authorized by law.
Section 2. The Clerk of the Board of Representatives is hereby authorized and directed to cause a
copy of the Notice of Public Hearing hereinafter provided to be published once in the Ithaca Journal, the
newspaper hereby designated as the official newspaper for this purpose and one having general
circulation in, and available to residents of, the County, such publication to be made not less than 14 days
before the date designated for the hearing. The Clerk of the Board of Representatives is hereby further
authorized and directed to cause a copy of such Notice of Public Hearing to be posted in such places as
the Clerk of the Board of Representatives customarily posts similar notices of public meetings of the
Board of Representatives of the County of Tompkins, such posting to be done not less than 14 days
before the date designated for the hearing.
Section 3. The notice of public hearing shall be in substantially the following form:
72
March 16, 1993
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Board of Representatives of the County of Tompkins, New
York will meet at the Tompkins County Courthouse, in Board chambers, in Ithaca, New York, in said
County, on April 6, 1993, at 5:30 o'clock p.m., Prevailing Time, for the purpose of conducting a public
hearing on the question of whether serial bonds, and anticipation notes issued in anticipation thereof,
should be issued by the County of Tompkins, New York, to pay the County's share of the cost of various
improvements at the Tompkins County Airport in said County, including the construction of a new
terminal building, access roads, parking lots, ramp/taxiway and T -hangers including original furnishings,
equipment, machinery, apparatus and related incidental improvements and expenses in connection
therewith. The maximum aggregate face amount of the serial bonds, or bond anticipation notes issued in
anticipation thereof, to be issued with respect to such improvements will not exceed $5,100,000. The
maximum estimated cost of the improvements is $5,100,000, of which obligations of the County, not to
exceed $5,100,000, will be issued. It is anticipated that bond anticipation notes in the aggregate amount
of $5,100,000 will be issued prior to the issuance of serial bonds. The County is the owner and operates
the Tompkins County Airport.
At said public hearing the Board of Representatives will hear all persons interested in this subject
matter.
Dated: Ithaca, New York BY ORDER OF THE BOARD OF REPRESENTATIVES
March 31, 1993 OF THE COUNTY OF TOMPKINS, NEW YORK
By Catherine Covert
Clerk, Board of Representatives
Section 4. This resolution shall take effect immediately.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 74 - AUTHORIZING A PUBLIC HEARING ON PROPOSED LOCAL LAW
NO. c OF 1993 - SCANNER ACCURACY LAW
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans. It was Moved by Ms. Mink, seconded by Mrs.
Schuler, to add the following Resolved: "Resolved, further, That a public hearing also be held concerning
the proposed Item Pricing local law of 1991." Mr. Mason asked if a representative who did not vote on
the prevailing side could bring back an item for reconsideration. Mr. Mulvey, County Attorney, felt that
since it is beyond a year it could be brought back.
It was Moved by Mr. Mason, seconded Mr. Proto, to Table amendment and main motion for
County Attorney to research whether it is a motion to reconsider.
A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 8 (Representatives Call, Culligan, Lerner, Mason, Proto,
Todd, Winch and Watros), Noes - 7 (Representatives Evans, Joseph, Livesay, Mink, Schuler, Shurtleff
and Stein). Motion to Table carried.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That a public
hearing be held before the Board of Representatives at Board Chambers of the Tompkins County
Courthouse, 320 North Tioga Street, Ithaca New York on Tuesday, April 6, 1993 at 5:30 p.m. in the
evening thereof concerning proposed Local Law No. c of 1993 - Scanner Accuracy Law. At such time
and place all persons interested in the subject matter will be heard concerning the same,
RESOLVED, further, That the Clerk of the Board is hereby authorized and directed to place proper
notice of such public hearing in the official newspaper of the County.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
73
March 16, 1993
RESOLUTION NO. 75 - APPROVAL OF SALE PRIOR TO AUCTION - COUNTY OWNED
PROPERTY ACQUIRED THROUGH TAX FORECLOSURE - TOWN
OF CAROLINE
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, by tax foreclosure proceedings of 1992, the County acquired parcel 18.-1-22 in the
Town of Caroline, and
WHEREAS, prior to auction of said property, the County Administrator wishes to sell same for the
total amount due for taxes, penalties, interest and expenses, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the sale of
parcel no. 18.-1-22 to Robert and Thea White of 3437 Slaterville Road, Brooktondale, New York, for the
amount of taxes, penalties, interest and expenses due, be and the same hereby is confirmed and the
County Administrator is directed to execute a quitclaim deed to the aforesaid property.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 76 - AMENDMENT OF RESOLUTION NO. 370 OF 1992 - ESTABLISHING
1993 MEETING DATES
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Lerner, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That Resolution
No. 370 of 1992 - Establishing 1993 Meeting Dates, be amended by rescheduling the April 5, 1993 Board
meeting to April 6, 1993 at 5:30 p.m. in Board Chambers.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 77 - INCREASE HOURS TEMPORARILY - CLERK OF THE BOARD
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the positions
of Clerk of the Board and Deputy Clerk increase their hours from 35 to 40 per week up to 90 days,
effective March 15, 1993.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 78 - APPROVAL OF FINGER LAKES ASSOCIATION 1993 BUDGET
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mr. Culligan, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, the Finger Lakes Association has submitted its annual budget for review by the
ABTD (Advisory Board on Tourism Development), now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the Finger Lakes Association
shall receive up to 7.6 percent of the 1993 Occupancy Tax revenues, which is projected to amount to
$31,920,
RESOLVED, further, That the Finger Lakes Association shall provide as soon as possible its 1992
year to date actual financial statement and a written revised 1993 budget reflecting the $31,920 cap.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
74
March 16, 1993
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 79 - BUDGET FOR HUD ADMINISTRATION
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, Tompkins County received a $400,000 grant from the U.S. Department of Housing
and Urban Development as part of the Small Cities Community Development Block Grant program, and
WHEREAS, the County has administered this grant to perform housing rehabilitation work in the
Town of Caroline, and
WHEREAS, the work to be performed as part of this grant will continue into 1993, now therefore
be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the County Comptroller be
authorized to place monies into the CD8686 (HUD Administration) accounts as follows:
Revenue:
.4989 HUD Rehabilitation Grant $126,020.00
Expenses:
.1243 Planning Committee 300.00
.1701 Admin. Spec. Coor. 703.92
$1,003.92
.4302 Office Supplies
.4402 Legal Advertisement
.4442 Professional Service Fees
.4452 Postage
.4465 Job Necessitated Travel
.4491 Sub Contracts
149.09
250.00
9,003.58
100.00
437.20
114,978.41
$124,918.28
.8830 Social Security 76.80
.8840 Workers Compensation 10.50
.8870 Unemployment Compens. 10.50
$97.80
RESOLVED, further, That the County Comptroller or his designee be authorized to draw down
funds for HUD as needed.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 80 - APPROVAL OF CONTRACT WITH FINGER LAKES FIREWOOD
FOR FORESTRY PROGRAM
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County Forestry Program has identified an opportunity to generate
additional revenue by the selective cutting of timber not previously designated by the timber bid, and
WHEREAS, Finger Lakes Firewood of Candor, New York, wishes to contract with the County to
harvest said timber, and
WHEREAS, the contract will allow the County forest to be maintained in proper environmental
condition, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the County Administrator or
his designee be authorized to enter into an agreement with Finger Lakes Firewood for the harvest of
timber,
75
March 16, 1993
RESOLVED, further, That the County Comptroller be authorized to deposit revenues received in
Account No. A8710.2652 (Sale of Forestry Products).
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 81 - CAROLINE HUD GRANT ADMINISTRATION
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, the Town of Caroline received a $400,000 grant from the U.S. Department of
Housing and Urban Development (HUD) in September 1992, and
WHEREAS, the Town has contracted with Tompkins County in order to administer and execute
this grant, and
WHEREAS, the County has sub -contracted with Better Housing for Tompkins County and Carlson
Associates of Cooperstown,'N.Y., to provide administrative services, and
WHEREAS, the Planning Depail,nent has the ability to provide these administrative services on
behalf of the town, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the County Comptroller is
authorized to place the funds received in account CD8687 (HUD Local Administration) as follows:
Revenue:
.4989 Local Income $395,000.00
Expenses:
.1243 Commissioner of Planning 5,309.00
.1701 Administrative Specialist Coordinator 2,832.00
.1671 Secretary 559.00
$8,700.00
.4302 Office Supplies
.4402 Legal Advertising
.4442 Professional Service Fees
.4452 Postage
.4465 Job Necessitated Travel and Training
.4491 Sub Contracts
.8830 Social Security
.8840 Workers Compensation
.8860 Health Insurance
.8870 Unemployment Insurance
570.00
750.00
22,000.00
200.00
800.00
360,000.00
$384,320.00
653.00
25.00
1,251.00
51.00
$1,980.00
TOTAL $395,000.00
RESOLVED, further, That the Administrative Coordinator of the Planning Department be
authorized to draw money on behalf of the Town of Caroline.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 82 - AUTHORIZING EXECUTION OF AGREEMENTS FOR AQUATIC
VEGETATION CONTROL PROGRAM NARRATIVE AND BUDGET
FOR NYSFY 1992-93
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mr. Winch, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
76
March 16, 1993
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County Board of Representatives has authorized by Resolution No.
219, dated July 15, 1992, and subsequent memorandum of understanding with the Finger Lakes
Association, Inc., the expenditure of monies from New York State Department of Environmental
Conservation (NYSDEC) Aquatic Vegetation Control Program Grant for New York State Fiscal Year
1992-93 pending and in accordance with the program narrative reviewed and approved by NYSDEC, and
WHEREAS, the pending contract with NYSDEC provides full State funding for all parts of the
program narrative, and
WHEREAS, the NYSDEC has approved the program narrative content and budget, and
WHEREAS, the program narrative attached to said contract identifies Cornell University as the
principle contractor for work in progress and that this continuity is in the best interests of the County in
order to accomplish the tasks defined in the program narrative, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the County Administrator is
hereby authorized to execute an Agreement with Cornell University to perform certain tasks defined in
the program narrative.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 83 - BUDGET ADJUSTMENT FOR AQUATIC VEGETATION WEED
CONTROL
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mr. Joseph, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, Tompkins County has received grants from the State of New York for the Aquatic
Vegetation Control Program (Account No. A8022), and
WHEREAS, the County has been unable to complete the grants from the years 1989-90 and 1990-
91 due to weather and other problems, and
WHEREAS, the County has requested that the Planning Department bring forward previous year's
monies through a budget adjustment in order to spend previous year's funds, and
WHEREAS, the County is required to spend 1989-90 and 1990-91 State Fiscal Year funds by
March 31, 1993 in order to receive retainage for these program years, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the following amounts be
brought forward to be spent before March 31, 1993:
1989-90 Aquatic Vegetation Control
.2230 Computer Software $ 297.40
Total for year $ 297.40
1990-91 Aquatic Vegetation Weed Control
.2230 Computer Software
.4302 Office Supplies
.4442 Professional Service Fees (Cornell University)
Total for year
1991-92 Aquatic Vegetation Weed Control
Revenue
.3959 State Aid
Expenditure
.2206 Computer Equipment
.2230 Computer Software
.2720 Previous Year's Encumbrance
.4302 Office Supplies
.4314 Computer Supplies
.4425 Service Contracts
$ 750.00
$ 98.98
$ 914.60
$1,763.58
$18,725.00
$ 425.00
$ 1,075.00
$14,247.05
$ 63.21
$ 150.00
$ 6,585.30
77
.4442 Professional Service Fees
.4447 Printing
.4452 Postage
.4465 Job Necessitated Travel
.4700 Previous Year's Encumbrance
March 16, 1993
$ 1,805.72
$ 350.00
$ 21.75
$ 600.00
$ 1,235.72
RESOLVED, further, That the County Comptroller be authorized to make the necessary
adjustments to the Aquatic Vegetation Control Program Account (A8022) as indicated above.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 84 - AMENDMENT OF RESOLUTION NO. 57 OF 1993 - CREATION OF
POSITION AND BUDGET TRANSFER - DIVISION OF BUDGET AND
FINANCE
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That Resolution
No. 57 of 1993 be amended that effective March 15, 1993 one full time position of Administrative
Assistant, (62-326), labor grade XII, be created in the Clerk of the Board's office for a period not to
exceed ninety days,
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller is hereby directed to make the following budget
transfer:
FROM: A1310.4452 Postage $ 8,600
TO: A1040.1326 Administrative Assistant $ 8,000
A1040.8830 Social Security $ 600
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 85 - DECREASE IN HOURS AND CREATION OF POSITIONS -
PLANNING DEPARTMENT
Moved by Mr. Evans, seconded by Mr. Mason, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning and Personnel Committees, That the position of
Planning Specialist (11/564), labor grade K(11), competitive class be decreased in hours from 35 to 17.5
hours per week effective immediately,
RESOLVED, further, That one position of Geographic Information System Technician (08/713),
labor grade H(08), competitive class and one position of Geographic Information System Analyst
(13/714), labor grade M(13), competitive class be created effective immediately,
RESOLVED, further, That monies have been budgeted in HG 1355.9239 (Assessment Mapping
Capitol Improvement Program) to fund these positions for 1993.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 86 - DISTRIBUTION OF SALES TAX (POSTPONED — CONSIDERED
MUTE)
Moved by Mr. Todd, seconded by Mr. Proto. Following a brief discussion, it was Moved by Mr.
Shurtleff, seconded by Mrs. Livesay, and unanimously adopted by voice vote, to Table this resolution
until all arguments have been heard on the proposed sales tax resolutions.
78
March 16, 1993
WHEREAS, the Board of Representatives had adopted Resolution No. 15 of 1992 requesting
enabling legislation for the State of New York for the imposition of an additional one -percent sales tax
upon the expiration of the current enabling legislation, and
WHEREAS, said resolution seeks a division of proceeds with the City of Ithaca consistent with the
current division, and
WHEREAS, the Common Council of the City of Ithaca has adopted a resolution stating its intent
to thwart such state enabling legislation unless the City of Ithaca is granted a significantly higher
allocation of such proceeds, and
WHEREAS, the Common Council proposed to make such demand under its perceived right of pre -
exemption, and
WHEREAS, there is no such right of preemption in either constitutional, statutory or case law, and
WHEREAS, the Common Council's statement of intent is based solely upon a policy alleged to
have been adopted by the Ways and Means Committee of the New York State Assembly, which policy
purports to deny such enabling legislation to a county unless there is an agreement with a city within such
county regarding the division of proceeds, and
WHEREAS, the Board of Representatives initially sought the additional sales tax authorization due
to a critical fiscal situation exacerbated in part by increasing state mandated programs and escalating solid
waste responsibilities, and only after extensive cost-cutting measures, and
WHEREAS, the division of proceed proposed by the City would result in an estimated 20 per cent
increase in County property taxes and would, therefore, thwart the Board of Representatives long-term
fiscal plan to ease the burden of state -mandated programs upon property tax -payers, and
WHEREAS, the Common Council's threat to kill the County's enabling legislation altogether,
would result in a forty-four percent County property tax increase, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, That this Board of Representatives hereby urges the City Council to accept the
Board of Representative's Resolution, and in the form submitted to state legislation.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 87 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE AGREEMENT WITH CITY OF
ITHACA - SALES TAX DISTRIBUTION
Moved by Ms. Mink, seconded by Mrs. Schuler. Ms. Mink offered the following amendments to the
agreement between the County of Tompkins and City of Ithaca:
1. a. Replace the wording "consumer price index (CPI -U, Northeast)..." in the last sentence on
pages 3 and 4 in paragraph 4 with ... "total of sales tax revenues generated from sales attributed to the
City of Ithaca, as determined by adjusted quarterly reports generated by the New York State Department
of Taxation and Finance, for the twelve months ending October 31, 1994, and the denominator of which
is the equivalent total of sales tax revenues for the period ending October 31, 1993".
b. Replace the wording "consumer price index..." in paragraph 5 on page 4 with ... "total of
sales tax revenues as measured as per paragraph 4 of this agreement for the period ending October 31,
1995 and the denominator of which is the equivalent total of sales tax revenues for the period ending
October 31, 1993".
2. Delete on page 3, paragraph 2, "the City Prosecutor Office" and on page 4, paragraph 7,
"$50,000.00 for the City Prosecutor's Office". Change the figure for funding human service agencies to
$190,000.00 instead of $180,000.00.
3. Delete the following wording in paragraph 8 on pages 5 and 6: "Similarly, it is understood and
agreed that the City's agreement to support said proposed legislation is conditioned upon and in
consideration of receiving such payments from the County and that nothing in this agreement or in the
City's support for this proposed legislation shall be construed to imply the City's support for future similar
legislation".
It was stated that this is also an agreement to sit down with the City of Ithaca to discuss the
consolidation of some services.
79
March 16, 1993
A brief discussion followed concerning the County Administrator's handout on sales tax split.
Mrs. Call stated that she has a problem with the part in this agreement that addresses funding to the
Human Services Coalition. She stated that by the City not funding the Human Services Coalition, it will
no longer be a coalition. Ms. Mink stated that people in the Coalition consider the service agencies as the
coalition rather than the funding sources.
Mr. Todd, stated that he believes the City of Ithaca is trying to force the County to go along with
this agreement and if the Ways and Means Committee of the Assembly are willing to give preemptive
rights, then the towns could have come to the County with the same thing.
Mr. Winch stated that he believes there needs to be more negotiating and more intermunicipal
cooperation and believes areas should not be limited to youth development and human services.
Mr. Proto stated that he is disappointed at the stress this issue has caused and feels it is unfortunate
that the City is in such a financial situation that they need this. Mr. Proto expressed concern for giving
the City this amount of money without anything to show for it.
Mr. Watros stated that as a member of the negotiating team, he spent a lot of time with City
officials and negotiated in the best interest of Tompkins County. He stated that the City Common
Council agreed to reduce their original request of $960,000 to $825,000. Mr. Watros expressed concern
over the sunset clause and stated the County may have to negotiate again. Mr. Watros expressed concern
for the equity issue with the towns. He stated that being proposed by preemptive rights is that an
additional $1 million of the additional one cent sales tax revenue go to the City. He stated that there has
been no discussion at this point to cut in towns for their equal share. He stated that it might be
appropriate when you look at the economics, to say that the towns have been done a disservice by the
proposed negotiated settlement. He stated that he feels it is in the best interest of the public for discussion
on the consolidation of services to continue.
Mr. Mason expressed concern for residents of towns and villages paying more for certain services
than City residents.
It was Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote, to
Table this resolution until all arguments have been heard on the proposed sales tax resolutions.
RESOLUTION NO. 88 - AMENDMENT OF RESOLUTION NO. 359 OF 1992 - REQUEST FOR
AUTHORIZATION TO INCREASE LOCAL SALES TAX
(POSTPONED — CONSIDERED MUTE)
Moved by Mr. Watros, seconded by Mrs. Call. Chairman Watros said that this resolution shares
with the towns and raises property taxes twenty percent. Discussion followed at length concerning the
handout provided by Mr. Heyman, County Administrator, which describes the outlook for a property tax
increase in 1994. According to Mr. Heyman, in 1994 a property tax increase of approximately seven
percent is expected. If the Board chooses to adopt the proposed agreement with the City of Ithaca, the
property tax increase would be approximately 13-14 percent. If the Board were to choose to share the
proposed additional amount with the towns, the property tax increase would be approximately twenty
percent.
It was Moved by Mrs. Schuler, seconded by Mr. Stein, and unanimously adopted by voice vote, to
Table this resolution until all arguments have been heard on the proposed sales tax resolutions.
RESOLVED, That Resolution No. 359 of 1992 be amended as follows: the figure: "75 percent" is
amended to read 50 percent; the figure "25 percent" is amended to read 50 percent.
80
March 16, 1993
RESOLVED, further, That this Board commits itself to continue to work with representatives of
the City of Ithaca toward consolidation of service delivery in manner that benefits all the residents of
Tompkins County.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
It was Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, and unanimously adopted by voice vote, to
lift from the Table the following resolution. A roll call vote resulted as follows on the resolution: Ayes -
8 (Representatives Culligan, Joseph, Lerner, Livesay, Mink, Schuler, Shurtleff and Stein); Noes - 7
(Representatives Call, Evans, Mason, Proto, Todd, Winch and Watros). Resolution Adopted.
RESOLUTION NO. 87 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE AGREEMENT WITH CITY OF
ITHACA - SALES TAX DISTRIBUTION
WHEREAS, the City of Ithaca is a part of Tompkins County and persons owning real property
situate in the City of Ithaca pay not only City taxes to the City, but also pay County taxes to the County,
and
WHEREAS, the City also provides certain services which benefit not only City residents, but also
benefit residents of the County who reside outside the City limits, including but not limited to transit
services, police protection, roads and bridges, parks and recreation, etc,. and
WHEREAS, the City also provides certain services, including but not limited to transit, roads and
bridges, criminal prosecution, youth development and recreation mainstreaming services, etc. which are
paid for out of the city's general funds, while similar services provided in the towns and villages in
Tompkins county are paid wholly or partially for out of the County general funds to which City residents
contribute, and
WHEREAS, the County wishes to obtain the City's support for proposed New York State
legislation which would authorize the County to charge up to a total sales tax of four percent, in addition
to the four percent which is imposed by the State of New York, which legislation would specifically
provide with respect to that portion of the final one percent which is generated from sales occurring
within the City of Ithaca, that it would be divided between the City and County with the City's receiving
25 percent of that one percent and the County's receiving 75 percent of that one percent, and
WHEREAS, based on adjusted sales tax reports for 1992 as provided by the New York State
Division of Taxation and Finance, and assuming continued inflation in the amount of three percent per
year, it is estimated by the City of Ithaca that the difference between the City's receiving 50 percent of
that one percent and receiving 25 percent of that one percent exceeds $975,000 for the calendar year
1994, and
WHEREAS, the City believes it should receive 50 percent of the additional one percent sales tax in
order to be able to meet its responsibilities without imposing undue adverse property tax impacts on the
property owners in the City, and
WHEREAS, the City wishes to further the spirit of cooperation between the City and the County,
now therefore be it
RESOLVED, That the Chairman of the Board is hereby authorized to enter into an agreement with
the City of Ithaca regarding the City's support for proposed legislation authorizing the County to charge
an additional one percent sales tax for a total sales tax of four percent in addition to the four percent
imposed by the State of New York, with that portion to be divided between the County and the City so
that the City receives 25 percent of that one percent and the County receives 75 percent of that one
percent,
RESOLVED, further, That the City of Ithaca's support of such legislation is provided in
consideration of the County of Tompkins' agreement to provide payment of certain sums to the City of
Ithaca for services which the City provides, as outlined in said agreement, such sum to total $825,000 in
1994 and to be adjusted in subsequent years for inflation.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
81
March 16, 1993
RESOLUTION NO. 89 - RESOLUTION OF APPRECIATION - DEBORAH F. DIETRICH
Moved by Mrs. Livesay and unanimously seconded and adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, the Honorable Deborah F. Dietrich was elected to serve as a member of the Board of
Representatives with a term commencing January 1, 1986, and
WHEREAS, during her tenure as a member of this Board, Mrs. Dietrich displayed leadership and
commitment in her role as Chairman of the Planning Committee from 1991 to the present, and
WHEREAS, Mrs. Dietrich also served as a dedicated member on the Health Committee, Human
Services Committee, Public Safety and Corrections Committee, Construction Management Committee,
Planning and Economic Development Committee, Public Works and Construction Management
Committee and Budget and Administration Committee, and
WHEREAS, Mrs. Dietrich also actively served on the following special committees: Management
Compensation, Mental Health Facility Planning, Reapportionment and Article 18 Task Force, and was
liaison to several advisory boards, and
WHEREAS, she was a member of the Tompkins County Area Development and the Industrial
Development Agency, and
WHEREAS, while a member of this Board, she served on the staff of the Speaker of the New York
State Assembly and was in a unique position to serve both the Speaker and county governments by her
understanding of the roles and needs of each, and
WHEREAS, Mrs. Dietrich distinguished herself and Tompkins County by being elected President
Elect of the New York State Association of Counties, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, That the Tompkins County Board of Representatives appreciates Deborah F.
Dietrich for her service to Tompkins County and wishes her well as she serves yet another level of
government as a member of the staff of our new Congressman and in all other endeavors she may pursue
in future years.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
Chairman Watros announced the following appointments:
Tompkins County Area Development - annual appointment
Stuart Stein - Tompkins County representative
Local Advisory Board of Assessment Review - annual appointment
Tim J. Joseph - Town of Ithaca representative
Chairman Watros also announced the following 1993 reassignments of standing committees:
Human Services Committee
Tim J. Joseph
Planning Committee
Tim J. Joseph
Public Safety Committee
Tim J. Joseph
On motion of the appropriate committee chairmen and duly seconded and unanimously adopted
by voice vote, the following appointments were made to various advisory boards:
82
March 16, 1993
Environmental Management Council
Term expires December 31, 1993
Susan Hajda Brock - At -large representative
Criminal Justice Advisory/Alternatives to Incarceration Board
Term expires December 31, 1993
Marilyn Ray - At -large representative
Soil and Water Conservation District
Term expires December 31, 1994
Raymond Aasen - Farm Bureau representative
Advisory Board on Tourism Development
Term expires December 31, 1993
Jill Hartz - Arts Organization representative
On motion the meeting adjourned at 8:48 p.m.
83
March 30, 1993
Special Board Meeting
Chairman Watros called the meeting to order at 5:30 p.m.
Members and guests participated in the Pledge of Allegiance.
Present: 12 Representatives. Excused: 3 (Representatives Call, Culligan and Todd and
Representative Schuler was excused at 6:36 p.m.).
Chairman Watros stated the purpose of the meeting was to discuss and take action on solid waste
issues.
Under privilege of the floor, Ed Cope, Town of Caroline and Solid Waste Management Advisory
Committee (SWAC) Chair, said he had personal comments and that a member from SWAC will speak as
the representative of that group. He stated his opposition to the resolution on the agenda concerning DR -
7 abandonment. He felt the County should keep communications open with the Department of
Environmental Conservation (DEC) concerning the permit until the site becomes economically feasible.
Under privilege of the floor, Dooley Kiefer, representative of Solid Waste Management Advisory
Committee (SWAC), stated the committee's opinions on the following resolutions: supports proceeding
with the development of the Central Processing Facility project; supports proposed decision to continue
out -of -county disposal in the near term and to abandon the development of the DR -7 site; supports the
steps to improve the hauler collection process and recommends the development of contingency plans as
an alternate and that county -level hauler franchising be explored as an option; and supports the goals of
the solid waste financing resolution, however, would recommend that the intentions of financing the solid
waste management program, a statement of the need for equitable treatment of and clear economic cues
for potential users of the solid waste management program's services, and a statement of revenue sources
being explored and the desirability of relating funding sources to the specific waste services to be funded
be included. She also urged the Board to approve a resolution concerning the County's intentions to
remove hazardous materials from the waste stream which SWAC approved.
Under privilege of the floor, Ernest Bury, Valley Road, said there are many ways the County can
manage solid waste. There is no state mandate that says the County needs to be so involved in solid
waste. He spoke about United States Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit, overturning flow control and also
spoke in opposition to proceeding with the Central Processing Facility project.
Under privilege of the floor, Amari Meader, Town of Dryden, spoke in support of the resolution to
abandon the DR -7 site and thanked the Board for observing citizens rights and keeping the door open.
Under privilege of the floor, Herb Engman, Town of Danby and Environmental Management
Council Chair, said economics may change and feels the County should get another landfill site. He
believes people have a right to know where a landfill may be sited.
Under privilege of the floor, Nancy Ten Kate, Town of Dryden, said that if DR -7 continues to be a
prospective site then the property protection program would have to stay in affect which costs money.
She also thanked the Board for listening and spoke in support of the resolution to abandon DR -7.
Under privilege of the floor, Noel Desch, Chair of Chamber of Commerce County Affairs
Committee, thanked the Board for inviting the Chamber and opportunity to participate in the process and
making information available. He asked the Board to table the resolution to proceed with the Central
Processing Facility (CPF) and to look at short-term and long-term options. The following are three
specific questions concerning the CPF project:
1. Why spend 150 per square foot for the facility?
2. Why is County planning to pay $250,000 in taxes for the facility?
84
March 30, 1993
3. Why pay the landscaping for 12 acres of land?
Under privilege of the floor, Dan Collins, Chamber of Commerce, said the County Affairs
Committee is not comfortable with the direction the County is taken with the Central Processing Facility
(CPF) project. The Committee feels that advanced technology will change, i.e. fly ash, and believes there
are interim steps that could be taken.
Under privilege of the floor, Scott Craver, County Affairs Committee member, stated that the
decision to move forward with the Central Processing Facility should hinge on its ability to decrease the
cost of the County's recycling program. He stated that he has reviewed the tables regarding the tonnage
of recyclables that were prepared by the County and believes more studies need to be done.
Under privilege of the floor, Thomas Bonn, 131 1/2 Cambridge Place and member of Citizens
Advisory Committee and former resident of Etna, felt it would be unfair to the neighbors and residents in
that area if DR -7 continued to be a potential site. He spoke in support of the resolution to abandon DR -7.
Chairman Watros stated that at this point in the meeting he would turn the meeting over to Mr.
Lerner, Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, and that comments from the
public would only be allowed from Mr. Noel Desch, Chairman of the Chamber of Commerce's County
Affairs Committee.
Mr. Lerner stated that it has been three months since his Chairmanship of the Solid Waste and
Resource Management Committee began and stated that there has been a lot of time and work with
preparing reports and developing information for this meeting. He thanked Board members, the Chamber
of Commerce, members of Solid Waste Advisory Committees and staff.
Mr. Lerner asked Assistant County Attorney, Jonathan Wood, to address the impact of flow control
legislation being overturned by Federal courts in the State of Mississippi. Mr. Wood stated that the
decision is not binding in New York State. The second Court of Appeals which is the Federal Court and
would bind New York State has never addressed that issue. At the moment the vast majority of State
courts have upheld this law. Mr. Wood stated that at some time the law may go to the Supreme Courts
but stated that the effect of that is somewhat overstated. He stated that if the law were overturned it
would not mean that Tompkins County should not build a central processing facility; it would mean that
the County would have to find other means of financing at least in part by another way. At the moment
Tompkins County does not face that issue because flow control is currently legal in New York State and
if a time came when flow control became illegal, the County would at that time reevaluate how it finances
its facilities. Mr. Wood stated that if the flow control law were overturned it does not mean that it would
make any County facility useless. Mrs. Eckstrom stated that she is confident at this point in time that
there is compliance with Flow Control in Tompkins County.
On motion of the appropriate committee chairman and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by
voice vote by members present, the following resolution was added to the agenda:
Reaffirmation of Intent to Continue Toward Elimination of Household Hazardous Waste from the
Waste Stream
Chairman Watros gave the appropriate committee chairman permission to withdraw from the
agenda the following resolution with final committee action being affirmed:
CA33b-93 - Authorization to Execute a Six Month Contract Extension with Superior Disposal, Inc.
for the Transfer and Hauling of Recyclable Materials
85
March 30, 1993
RESOLUTION NO. 90 RECYCLING AND SOLID WASTE CENTER - ACCEPTING
PROJECT JUSTIFICATION, CONSTITUTING A NEGOTIATING
TEAM AND AUTHORIZING THE CONCLUSION OF
NEGOTIATIONS
Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mrs. Livesay.
Mr. Lerner referred Board members and public to page four of the report entitled The Purpose and
Features of the Tompkins County Recycling and Solid Waste Center. Mr. Lerner explained that the
intention of the central processing facility is to end up with a solid waste program that costs less each year
than it would without the facility. The purpose of the Facility is to bring the County's costs down. Mr.
Lerner discussed how costs were itemized (see page four of report) and showed the total annual savings
of the project. Following discussion, Mr. Lerner stated in response to the Chamber of Commerce's
question concerning sales tax, that the Facility will be a privatized operation and would be subject to
property tax including County tax. Mr. Heyman noted that the bonds for the project could be tax exempt.
Mr. Lerner stated that it is estimated that in 1995 having the Facility operating will mean that the County's
solid waste budget will be approximately $150,000 less than it would be under the current plan. He stated
that by moving forward with this project he sees a Facility that makes the County's solid waste program
much more stable, flexible and adaptable to changing circumstances.
Representative Schuler was excused from the meeting at this time.
Mr. Lerner introduced Mr. John Kowalchak, Director of the Division of Solid Waste for Broome
County who thanked the Board for inviting him. Mr. Kowalchak responded to questions raised by
members of the Board and stated that although Broome County was used in a comparison with Tompkins
County by the Chamber of Commerce, Broome County is very different. He stated that there is a great
difference in the counties of demographics, public policies in solid waste management, economic
conditions, social attitudes and politics. Mrs. Eckstrom asked Mr. Kowalchak questions which evolved
from a meeting between Chairman Watros and the County Affairs Committee on
March 29, 1993. She asked Mr. Kowalchak to answer why Broome County's cost of landfill closure is
listed as $2,807,000 yet their budget reflects $800,000. Mr. Kowalchak stated that this figure includes a
set aside; in 1989 Broome County developed an enterprise fund which had incorporated to it funds for
both closure and long term maintenance which are within 35 percent. Therefore, this amount includes a
set aside amount. Mr. Kowalchak stated the $1.1 million cost for Broome County's recycling facility
does not include debt calculations and he also stated that this is not a waste transfer facility or drop off-
center. Discussion followed concerning trends and what the market trends are expected to be for
recyclables.
A roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 9, Noes - 2 (Representatives Proto and Shurtleff),
Excused - 4 (Representatives Call, Culligan, Schuler and Todd). Adopted.
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County Board of Representatives by Resolution No. 505 dated
December 17, 1991, authorized the publication of a final Request for Proposals ("RFP") for the design,
construction, acceptance testing and operation of the Tompkins County Recycling and Solid Waste Center
("Facility"), formerly the Central Processing Facility, and accepted findings related to the substantive
elements of comments received in the relation to the draft RFP in connection therewith, and
WHEREAS, the Board of Representatives by Resolution No. 348 dated October 20, 1992 accepted
the recommendation of the Evaluation Team to designate as preferred proposers for negotiations CRlnc.
and Resource Recycling Technologies (RRT), authorized the issuance of an amended Request for
Proposals to said proposers reflecting cost saving measures requested by the Board and authorized and
directed the Evaluation Team to continue to negotiate with either of said proposers, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, That
the Board of Representatives reaffirms and accepts the Facility Justification Report prepared by the Solid
86
March 30, 1993
Waste Manager and desires to conclude the procurement process as promptly as possible, and declares
the continued procurement and development of the Facility to be in the public interest,
RESOLVED, further, That the Board of Representatives reaffirms its agreement with the City of
Ithaca as stated in Resolution No. 77 dated February 19, 1991,
RESOLVED, further, That the Board of Representatives reaffirms its goals
to minimize the long term cost of solid waste handling through:
a) maximum flexibility for disposal, recycling and reuse,
b) minimum cost of facility development,
c) maximum recycling and reuse revenue,
d) optimum balance between public and private participation
RESOLVED, further, That the Board of Representatives hereby authorizes the Chair of the Board
of Representatives to appoint a final negotiating Committee and negotiators,
RESOLVED, further, That the Negotiating Team be authorized and directed to conclude
negotiations with CRInc. and Resource Recycling Technologies, Inc. (RRT), taking into account cost
saving measures previously requested by this Board of Representatives and as set forth in its Resolution
No. 348, dated October 20, 1992 subject to a) the requirements of the State Environmental Quality
Review Act, and b) the need, if any, to modify or amend the existing Part 360 permits for the Facility
issued by the Department o -f Environmental Conservation, all of which conditions may be specified as
conditions precedent to the County's obligation to perform under the Service Agreement.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 91 - ABANDONMENT OF THE TOMPKINS COUNTY PROPOSED
LANDFILL SITE: DR -7
Moved by Mr. Evans, seconded by Mr. Lerner.
Mr. Lerner addressed this resolution stating that the County has spent countless hours and dollars
and it is not by any means a trivial decision to reverse course like this. He stated that a great deal of the
controversy over Tompkins County building a landfill has revolved around the site itself and whether DR -
7 is a viable site. He stated that after all this time the Committee's main reason for adopting this
resolution does not reflect feelings about the site but rather in the past several years the market for waste
disposal, particularly the market for landfilling has changed significantly. In 1986 there was a severe
shortage of landfill space in New York State and relatively recently imposed regulations by the
Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) that severely constrained the operation of old-style
landfills. These constraints rapidly caused old-style landfills to go out of business in the following years.
In 1986 it was not possible to predict what the situation was going to be several years down the line. The
County has learned several things since that time: building landfills that comply with DEC regulations
are a tremendously expensive proposition, there are tremendous economies of scale to be achieved by
building big landfills, and that if a County is most concerned with their per ton cost for waste disposal,
these costs would be a lot lower if capital costs are spread over far more tons than Tompkins County
produces. Therefore, when Tompkins County made a commitment in 1987 to build a landfill that would
take waste from only one County and a landfill that would only operate for twenty years a limitation was
put on the amount of waste that landfill was going to take. It is now more economical for Tompkins
County to take waste where the per ton cost of disposal is lower even taking into consideration the cost of
transportation.
Mr. Mason stated that he feels adoption of the proposed resolution has been a long time coming,
however disagrees with the wording in the last RESOLVED. He believes the wording is unfair and
would pose as a threat to everyone else in Tompkins County. Mr. Proto stated that the Board may
abandon this site now and a future Board may reverse this decision in the future.
87
March 30, 1993
It was Moved by Mr. Mason, seconded by Mr. Proto, to amend the resolution adding a final
Resolved as follows: "RESOLVED, further, That Tompkins County hereby abandons in -County
landfilling and the staff is directed to continue scrutinizing other landfill options in the County". Mrs.
Eckstrom explained that the DEC would not approve Tompkins County's Solid Waste Management Plan
if the County abandoned the possibility of looking for a landfill site in this County. They want the
County to generally look for in -county landfilling, they find it unacceptable for a county to say that they
are not going to put a landfill in their County. There was discussion by members of the Board concerning
revisiting this resolution if circumstances were to change at some point in the future. It was the consensus
of the Board that this issue could be reconsidered in the future if a Board chose to. Chairman Watros
gave Mr. Mason permission to withdraw the above -stated amendment and Mr. Proto to withdraw his
second.
Mr. Lerner stated that it is not cost effective in 1993 for the Board to choose to build a landfill in
Tompkins County, however, in 1987 it would have been impossible for a Board to predict good bid price
in 1993 and any responsible Board member in 1987 should have voted for Tompkins County to have a
landfill. He stated that no action being taken this evening should be taken as a criticism for what the
Board did in 1987 with regard to planning to build a landfill.
Mr. Winch thanked the public for their comments. Mr. Winch stated that he believes in
economies of scale and because there are large landfills that are available to take our trash and thinks that
it will be economically sound to contract with those landfills. He stated that he doesn't foresee Tompkins
County ever finding a several thousand acre site to construct a large landfill that will support this County
as well as other counties. Mr. Winch offered concern for future liability of the County if there were to be
a major disaster to occur in a landfill that Tompkins County delivers to.
A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 11, Noes - 0, Excused -4 (Representatives Call, Culligan,
Schuler and Todd). Adopted.
WHEREAS, Resolution No. 334 of December 7, 1987, selected the landfill site known as DR -7 in
the Town of Dryden, which DR -7 is the subject of an application for a permit to construct a sanitary
landfill pending before the New York State Depaitment of Environmental Conservation (NYSDEC), and
WHEREAS, the existence of federally protected wetlands required site facilities to be reconfigured
and required a supplemental Final Environmental Impact Statement (FEIS) to be prepared and submitted,
and
WHEREAS, such reconfiguration of facilities at the site would increase the cost of constructing
and operating a landfill at DR -7 when compared to other solid waste disposal alternatives, and
WHEREAS, the County is holding the Neighborhood Protection Program in abeyance pending the
final decision on the disposal method, thus removing the protection without the elimination of the
perceived risks of the development of DR -7, and
WHEREAS, the Administrative Law Judge presiding over the Tompkins County permit hearings
has recently requested a comprehensive update on the status of the County's application which has been
held in abeyance, and
WHEREAS, the County has experienced great success in its recycling programs, resulting in
significant reductions in the size of the waste stream and reducing the amount of solid waste to be
disposed of, and
WHEREAS, the County Board's commitment to limit the life of a landfill at the DR -7 site to 20
years reduces its economic viability. Recently constructed landfills are having serious financial problems
paying their operating expenses due to the decreased waste stream and the existence of excess landfill
capacity statewide, and
WHEREAS, excess landfill capacity exists at this time both in New York State and regionally, and
waste disposal by Tompkins County can make use of the excess capacity in an environmentally
responsible manner and at a reasonable cost to County users, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, by the Tompkins County Board of Representatives as follows That:
88
March 30, 1993
1. The present application for a permit to construct a landfill at the DR -7 site be withdrawn from
further consideration by the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation.
2. The County terminate any further plans to site, construct, or operate any Solid Waste
Management facility on the DR -7 site in the Town of Dryden.
3. County staff be directed to revise the County's Draft Solid Waste Management Plan to reflect
this change from County landfilling at the DR -7 landfill site to more economical alternatives for disposal.
4. The DR -7 Property Value Protection component of the Neighborhood Protection Program be
terminated immediately.
5. The Citizens Advisory Committee for the landfill at the DR -7 site be disbanded, at a date
chosen by that committee, with our thanks and appreciation.
6. All other activities related to DR -7 be completed and a final financial report be issued by June
29, 1993.
RESOLVED, further, That the Capital Budget be amended to reflect this resolution,
RESOLVED, further, That Tompkins County is not abandoning in -county landfilling or any other
waste disposal option and the staff is directed to continue scrutinizing disposal options for the County.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 92 - AUTHORIZING THE PREPARATION OF PLAN AND SCHEDULE
FOR TRANSPORTATION AND DISPOSAL OF SOLID WASTE
Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mr. Evans. Mr. Lerner said that this resolution basically states
that if Tompkins County is not building a landfill to dispose of its garbage, the County needs to develop a
procurement process for disposal sites and this allows the Solid Waste Division to move forward in the
bid process. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 11, Noes - 0, Excused - 4 (Representatives Call,
Culligan, Schuler and Todd). Adopted.
WHEREAS, Tompkins County is a "Planning Unit" pursuant to Section 27-0107 of the
Environmental Conservation Law and is responsible for planning for the disposal of solid waste generated
in the County, and
WHEREAS, the County currently has contracts with Waste Management of New York, Inc. for the
transportation and disposal of its solid waste at the Modern Trash Removal of York, Inc. Landfill in York,
Pennsylvania, and
WHEREAS, these contracts with Waste Management of New York, Inc. terminate on October 31,
1993, unless extended by the County for a six month period, and
WHEREAS, the County has terminated plans to site a landfill at DR -7 in Dryden, now therefore be
it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, That
the Solid Waste Manager is directed to prepare a plan and schedule by June 29, 1993 for a procurement
process for long-term transportation and disposal of solid waste.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
Chairman Watros declared recess from 7:52 to 8:00 p.m.
RESOLUTION NO. 93 - REGULATING WASTE COLLECTION
Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mr. Evans. Mr. Lerner stated that Tompkins County has had
major problems with trash collection in Tompkins County and the intent of this resolution is to solve the
problem and close loopholes the County has been experiencing in the trash collection area. He believes
this will address and solve those problems. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes 11, Noes - 0, Excused
- 4 (Representatives Call, Culligan, Schuler and Todd). Adopted.
89
March 30, 1993
WHEREAS, Resolution No. 15 of January 12, 1993 called for "a report and a plan that would
determine all the steps necessary to insure sufficient County control over all refuse hauling not provided
by municipalities, to guarantee the revenues and overall integrity of the Tompkins County Solid Waste
Management program" by March 31, 1993, and
WHEREAS, some private trash haulers violated the county's flow control law and illegally
deprived the county of revenues, and
WHEREAS, inadequate flow control enforcement is unfair to haulers who respect the law, and to
county residents, and
WHEREAS, flow control enforcement mechanisms already include investigation, criminal
penalties, license suspension and in some cases consent orders, and
WHEREAS, county record keeping and billing procedures for the disposal fee need to be
substantially enhanced by a software upgrade and integration of data bases, and
WHEREAS, some haulers failed to pay transfer station bills, or failed to pay promptly, and
WHEREAS, consumers in some municipalities pay far more for trash collection services than in
other municipalities, and
WHEREAS, buying sheets of 6 or 12 trashtags at once is a hardship for many county residents, and
WHEREAS, some residents have been denied refunds on previous year's trashtags, and
WHEREAS, the Board of Representatives intends to make every reasonable effort to preserve free
enterprise in trash collection, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, That
the Solid Waste Manager and County Attorney shall (by June 29, 1993) prepare a budget and
recommendation on how best to improve enforcement of the flow control law, and to satisfy the board
that the law is being consistently complied with,
RESOLVED, further, That the County Comptroller and the Solid Waste Manager shall (by June
29, 1993) recommend a plan for requiring pre -payment or security for use of transfer station services
according to the following guidelines:
a) Present arrangements shall continue unchanged for Tompkins County municipalities.
b) All other permitted or licensed haulers delivering material to the transfer station must either pay
before tipping or provide adequate security (e.g. a bond, letter of credit or security deposit to
guarantee payment). The County shall not offer unsecured credit to any private hauler.
c) Adequate notice will be given to the public and to regular users of the transfer station before
changes in payment requirements are implemented.
RESOLVED, further, That the Solid Waste Manager and the County Comptroller shall (by June
29, 1993) recommend a plan on how to integrate transfer station record keeping and billing in order to
improve efficiency and to accommodate the above recommendations,
RESOLVED, further, That the County Attorney and the Solid Waste Manager shall (by June 29,
1993) prepare a recommendation on how to revise and improve the County's trashtag law (Local Law No.
10 of 1990). The proposed revisions shall include the requirement that single trashtags be sold to the
public on request at least one location, the requirement that residents be permitted to claim a refund from
the hauler on any trashtag until 90 days after its expiration date, and any other needed changes in the 1-aw,
RESOLVED, further, That the Solid Waste Manager shall (by June 29, 1993) prepare a report comparing
the arrangements made by municipalities for residential trash collection, and their effects on the costs to
residents. The report shall highlight the fact that County residents pay less for trash collection in
municipalities that put trash collection out for bid. The County shall encourage all towns and villages to
reduce collection costs through private sector bidding or other methods. The report shall be distributed to
all municipal governments with an offer of Solid Waste Division staff advice to any municipal
government that wishes to explore reducing trash collection costs for their residents.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
90
March 30, 1993
RESOLUTION NO. 94 - THANKING THE CHAMBER OF COMMERCE FOR ITS REPORT
ON PRIVATIZATION AND ACCEPTING THE SOLID WASTE AND
RESOURCE MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE'S REPORT ON
PRIVATIZATION
Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mr. Proto. Mr. Lerner referred the Chamber of Commerce's
report and stated that many of the items suggested in the report are already being done. He also referred
to a chart incorporated into the report comparing solid waste costs with several counties and stated that
this was published in today's edition of the Ithaca Journal. He stated that at the present time Tompkins
County is doing about average or somewhat better than other New York State counties and believes that
in five years Tompkins County will be in a much better situation once the central processing facility and
composting facility is on line. Chairman Watros thanked the Chamber of Commerce for devoting a lot of
time to this issue. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 11, Noes - 0, Excused - 4
(Representatives Call, Culligan, Schuler and Todd). Adopted.
WHEREAS, Resolution No. 408 of 1992 authorized the Chair of the Board to ask the Chamber of
Commerce for advice on privatization options in the county solid waste program, and
WHEREAS, Chair Watros' letter of December 12, 1992 asked for that advice, and
WHEREAS, the Chamber of Commerce's County Affairs Committee presented its
recommendations of February 11, 1993, in a report entitled "A Chamber of Commerce Report on Private
Sector Alternatives for Solid Waste Management", and
WHEREAS, the County Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee has prepared a report
of privatization options, taking into account and responding to the Chamber's recommendations, now
therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, That
the Board of Representatives expresses its sincere thanks to the Chamber of Commerce, and to the
members of the County Affairs Committee,
RESOLVED, further, That the Board of Representatives accepts the Solid Waste and Resource
Management Committee's report,
RESOLVED, further, That the Solid Waste Manager is directed to proceed with implementing the
recommendations in the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee's report, and to report to the
Board on progress by June 29, 1993.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
Stable
RECOMMENDED CRITERIA FOR SOLID WASTE FINANCE SYSTEM
Balances budget for foreseeable future
Stable revenue source for fixed costs
Tonnage based revenue for tonnage based costs
Multiple revenue streams
Predictable costs for public
Readily adaptable to changing circumstances
Protects Environment
Low incentive to dump or burn illegally
High incentive to recycle
High incentive to reduce and reuse
Fair
Lower costs for those least able to pay
Lower costs for those who use system least
Public perception of fairness
91
March 30, 1993
Tax exempt entities pay fair share
Easy to implement
Low start up costs
Low fee collection costs
Easy to understand - little public education required
Convenient to public
Easy to enforce
Difficult for haulers to cheat
Difficult for public to cheat
Low incentive to cheat
Low costs
Reduce expenses wherever possible
Maximize revenue from grants
Costs to public income tax deductible
No sales tax on fee payment
RESOLUTION NO. 95 - ESTABLISHING CRITERIA FOR SOLID WASTE FINANCE
Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Ms. Mink.
Mr. Lerner stated that the point of asking the Board to adopt this resolution is to try to get the
Board and the public to understand the complexities of the issues the County is facing. He said the
County for many years has paid the cost of solid waste through the property tax and that meant that the
tax exempt entities did not pay and that there were many drawbacks. The Board then began to fund
through the tipping fee as an incentive to recycle and reduce and unfortunately found out that it was an
incentive to illegally dump solid waste. The County found that when the tipping fee began to run high the
County experienced problems with the public and the haulers. In 1992 the Board explored options of
financing solid waste that avoided the property tax and disposal fee, thus, adopted the Solid Waste Annual
Fee. The County has heard from the public that this is an unpopular fee that is unfair. Mr. Lerner stated
that he cannot promise the Annual Fee will be eliminated in 1994 but hopes that another method of
charging for solid waste will be found that is as fair as possible to everyone. Mr. Stein expressed
appreciation on behalf of the Board to all advisory groups, staff and public for all their input and work on
solid waste matters. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 11, Noes - 0, Excused - 4 (Representatives
Call, Culligan, Schuler and Todd). Adopted.
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County Board of Representatives wishes to establish a funding plan for
the county's solid waste program that will meet the needs of County residents for years to come, and
WHEREAS, the Board is grateful for and wishes to continue the important work begun by the
Finance Subcommittee of the Solid Waste Advisory Committee, and
WHEREAS, the Board recognizes that every tax or fee has advantages and drawbacks, and
WHEREAS, the Board recognizes that many conflicting considerations must be taken into account
to develop a balanced plan, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, That
the plan should combine multiple revenue streams to maximize the following criteria:
The financing plan must be stable, environmentally benign, fair, easy to understand, easy to
implement, easy to enforce, and with costs as low as possible (detailed criteria list attached),
RESOLVED, further, that the Ad Hoc Solid Waste Finance Committee is directed to develop a
plan to fund the County solid waste program for at least five years, beginning with the 1994 County
budget,
92
March 30, 1993
RESOLVED, further, That current realities and future trends be recognized and incorporated into
the financing plan, so that it is a flexible one that requires minimal adjustment.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 96 - REAFFIRMATION OF INTENT TO CONTINUE TOWARD
ELIMINATION OF HOUSEHOLD HAZARDOUS WASTE FROM
THE WASTE STREAM
Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, the existence of toxic or hazardous materials in the solid waste stream poses a
potential danger to the workers who collect, haul, and/or sort trash, and
WHEREAS, such materials also constitute a threat to the environment, and
WHEREAS, such materials, if burned, contribute to air pollution, and if landfilled, make the
leachate dangerous, and
WHEREAS, any landfill may eventually leak, and
WHEREAS, eliminating from the waste stream as many environmentally harmful items as possible
makes our waste more marketable and any landfill safer, and
WHEREAS, it is possible to separate such materials at the source of generation and/or at a transfer
station or processing facility, and
WHEREAS, full provision has not yet been made in the Solid Waste Program for disposal of
household hazardous waste, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, That
Tompkins County reaffirms its intent to continue to work toward elimination of household hazardous
waste and other toxic and hazardous materials from its waste stream.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
On motion of the appropriate committee chairman and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by
voice vote by members present, the following appointments were made to various advisory boards:
Hillview Road Landfill Citizens Advisory Committee
Term expires December 31, 1993
Beverly E. Livesay - County Board member
Term expires December 31, 1995
Frank P. Proto - Town of Danby representative
Chairman Watros appointed the following Central Processing Facility Negotiating Committee:
Eric Lerner, Chairman
Beverly Livesay
Daniel Winch
Thomas Todd
Stuart Stein
Scott Heyman
William Mobbs
Barbara Eckstrom
Chairman Watros arranged that the following four members of the Central Processing Facility
Negotiating Committee meet with the vendors at the table to discuss the terms and conditions of
contracts:
Beverly Livesay
Daniel Winch
Scott Heyman
Barbara Eckstrom
93
March 30, 1993
Chairman Watros declared recess from 8:42 to 8:48 p.m.
It was Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mrs. Livesay, and unanimously adopted by voice vote
by members present, to enter into an executive session at 8:48 p.m. to discuss contractual negotiations.
The meeting returned to open session at 8:57 p.m.
On motion, the meeting adjourned at 8:57 p.m.
94
April 6, 1993
Regular Meeting
Public Hearing
Chairman Watros called the public hearing to order at 5:30 p.m. concerning the Issuance of Serial
Bonds by the County of Tompkins, New York to Pay the Cost of Various Improvements at the Tompkins
County Airport for Said County.
Chairman Watros asked if anyone wished to speak? No one wished to speak and the public
hearing was closed at 5:31 p.m.
Members and guests participated in the Pledge of Allegiance.
Present: 9 Representatives. Representative Livesay arrived at 5:34 p.m. Excused: 4
(Representatives Culligan, Schuler, Shurtleff and Todd).
It was Moved by Mr. Evans, seconded by Mr. Stein, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present to approve the minutes of the March 16, 1993 Board meeting as submitted.
Mr. Hanson, Planning Commissioner, introduced David Boyd, the new MPO Planning Director.
Chairman Watros read a proclamation concerning the retirement of Marjorie Boykin, an employee
of the Tompkins County Health Department.
Under privilege of the floor, David Corsi, Store Manager, Wegmans, spoke in support of the
proposed scanner accuracy law but in opposition to the proposed item pricing law. He said a benefit of
the scanner accuracy law is it provides a faster checkout.
Under privilege of the floor, Eric Lerner, Representative, District No. 1, spoke of his experience at
a grocery store over the weekend. He said the computers were down and he had about $90 worth of
groceries. It took approximately 30 minutes to checkout and stated that item pricing would have
prevented this.
Under privilege of the floor, Beverly Livesay, Representative, District No. 11, said a constituent
complained to her about a product without a record of price and that the person had to locate a clerk to
find the price of the product.
Mr. Evans, Member, Health and Education Committee, said the committee met March 30 and
reviewed Municipal Health Plan revisions pertaining to Health Department. The committee also
reviewed the budget of the Job Training Program and expects $300,000 in the next fiscal year rather than
the $100,000 now being received. Questions were asked about a report concerning the Job Training
Program. Chairman Watros requested a report be scheduled and presented to the Board.
Mr. Evans, Chairman, Personnel Committee, said the committee met April 1 and approved a
number of reclassifications. Interviews for the Commissioner of Personnel have been scheduled for the
week of April 26th.
Ms. Mink, Chairman, Human Services Committee, said the committee will meet April 8. The
committee will hear from the Human Services Coalition Director and several agency heads on shifting of
funds with the County taking over. The committee will also hear a progress report concerning the
building study allegedly due to the illness of several employees at Biggs A.
Mr. Mason, Chairman of the Public Safety Committee, said the committee met April 1 and
discussed an Alternatives to Incarceration proposal with Alcoholism Council. He said the Computer Aid
95
April 6, 1993
Dispatch system is near completion. He also spoke about a New York State Association of Counties
Alert concerning state aid for Probation services. The result is a reduction from 33 percent to 18.84
percent and will be a net loss of approximately $121,000 for Tompkins County.
Mr. Stein, Chairman, Planning Committee, said the committee met just before the Board meeting
and approved several resolutions which are reflected on the agenda. The committee discussed contracts
for services with municipalities. The committee also had discussions with staff regarding an economic
stimulus package that if passed would have a positive impact on Tompkins County. He reported on the
water quality and community development block grant program and stated there may be funds in those
programs that Tompkins County would be eligible to receive. He attended a Community Program Grant
Board meeting. These grants are being put to good use to people who need to improve living conditions.
Mr. Winch, Chairman, Public Works and Construction Management Committee, said most of the
committee's business is reflected on the agenda. The committee approved several Request for Proposals
(RFP's) for various shops at the Airport: the gift shop, restaurant, contract for advertising within the
Airport and vending machine contracts. He said the Airport Construction Committee will be meeting
tomorrow at noon. He reported on the rededication ceremony for the Old Jail. He asked that the
statement attached by Martha Preston, Chairperson, Ithaca Landmarks Preservation Commission, be
entered into the record.
Mr. Lerner, Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, said the committee has
not met. The next meeting is April 8 at noon.
Mrs. Livesay, member of SWAG (Solid Waste Advisory Group), said the committee is now
accepting comments concerning the Solid Waste Management Plan.
Mrs. Livesay, Intergovernmental Relations, reported on a meeting organized by her and Chairman
Watros to discuss City, County sales tax agreement and implications for County municipalities. The
meeting is scheduled for April 21, 1993 at 7:30 p.m. in the Old Jail Conference Room.
Mrs. Call, Chairman, Budget and Administration Committee, said the committee has not met. The
next meeting is April 13. The committee will be reviewing several proposed Administrative Manual
Policy amendments. The committee is also looking for people interested in serving on the Solid Waste
Annual Fee Appeal Board.
Ms. West, Deputy County Administrator, said she did not have a report.
Mr. Mulvey, County Attorney, said his written report is on file. Mr. Stein asked about the current
status on ethics. Mr. Mulvey said the completed forms are now kept on file in the Board office and the
deadline to file is May 15.
On motion of the appropriate committee chairmen and duly seconded and adopted by voice vote by
members present, the following resolutions were added to the agenda:
- Award of Bid - T -Hangars - Airport
- Authorization to Execute a Contract with the Alcoholism Council
- To Urge the State Senate and Assembly to Restore Aid for Probation Services to 33 Percent
- Authorization to Apply for Grant from New York State Council on the Arts (NYSCA) for
Historic Preservation
Chairman Watros gave the appropriate committee chairmen permission to withdraw from the
agenda the following resolutions with final committee action being affirmed:
CA034-93 - Authorization to Execute Contracts — David Meinz, M.S., R.D. and Cheri Dygert —
96
April 6, 1993
Healthy Heart Program
CA035-93 - Pedestrian Bridge Over Salmon Creek in Myers
CA036-93 - Route 79 Detour
CA037-93 - Route 34B Detour
CA038-93 - Memorandum of Understanding - Depar tment of Environmental Conservation
and Highway Division
CA039-93- Award of Bid - Gas for County Vehicles
CA040-93 - Reclassification of Position - Senior Account Clerk to Secretary - Mental Health
RESOLUTION NO. 97 - AUTHORIZATION FOR FIVE-YEAR SERVICE CONTRACTS -
CHILDREN WITH SPECIAL CARE NEEDS (Amended by
Resolution No. 217 of 1993)
Moved by Mr. Evans, seconded by Ms. Mink, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County Health Department is responsible for securing service '
providers for the provision of services to preschool children with handicapping conditions pursuant to
Section 4410 of the New York State Education Law, and
WHEREAS, the Department requests that said contracts be approved for a five year period and
that an addendum will be processed as rates need to be updated, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education Committee, That the County
Administrator is authorized to execute five-year agreements with all service providers as identified by the
Health Department.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 98 - AUTHORIZATION TO SIGN CONTRACT WITH CRAWFORD AND
STEARNS, ARCHITECTS - TRUMANSBURG MAIN STREET
DESIGN STUDY
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mr. Mason, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, Tompkins County received a grant from the New York Council on the Arts to
complete a Main Street Study for the Village of Trumansburg, and
WHEREAS, Tompkins County had hired Crawford and Stearns, Architects, for the first year of the
Study and had successfully completed the work program, and
WHEREAS, Tompkins County wishes Crawford and Stearns to complete the work necessary for
the grant, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the County contract with
Crawford and Stearns, Architects, for an amount not to exceed $5,980, for professional services necessary
to complete the grant,
RESOLVED, further, That the County Comptroller be authorized to pay the contract amount of
account A7010.4442 (Professional Service Fees).
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 99 - CLARIFICATION OF EMPLOYMENT STATUS - POSITION OF
ITHACA-TOMPKINS TRANSPORTATION COUNCIL PLANNING
DIRECTOR
97
April 6, 1993
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mr. Joseph, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, this position was created in the management group of County employees but the
Ithaca -Tompkins Transportation Council has independent authority under Federal regulations over the
position, and therefore, the employment status of the position needs clarification, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning and Personnel Committees, That the position of
Ithaca -Tompkins Transportation Council Planning Director shall be entitled to the terms and conditions of
employment established by this Board for management employees unless otherwise recommended by the
Council and established by this Board of Representatives.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 100 - APPOINTMENT TO THE INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT AGENCY
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mrs. Call, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, Section 856 of the General Municipal Law authorized that the Board of
Representatives designate the members of the Industrial Development Agency by resolution, now
therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That Daniel Collins of New York
State Electric and Gas be appointed to the Tompkins County Industrial Development Agency to serve at
the pleasure of the Board, effective immediately, in the place and stead of Deborah F. Dietrich,
RESOLVED, further, That the Clerk of the Board be and hereby is authorized and directed to file with
the Secretary of State a Certificate of Appointment.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 101 - APPROVAL OF CONTRACT FOR NEW YORK CANAL SYSTEM
WORK WITH SOUTHERN TIER EAST REGIONAL PLANNING
DEVELOPMENT BOARD
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Ms. Mink, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, Tompkins County is part of the New York State Barge Canal System through the
connection of Cayuga Lake with the Barge Canal, and
WHEREAS, the State of New York has contracted with Regional Planning Boards throughout the
State to provide mapping and data collection services in support of this study, and
WHEREAS, the Southern Tier East Regional Planning Development Board has expressed an
interest in sub -contracting this work to the Tompkins County Planning Depai tinent, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the County Administrator or
his designee be authorized a contract in the amount of $5,000 between the County and the Southern Tier
East Regional Planning Development Board,
RESOLVED, further, That the County Comptroller be authorized to deposit money received in the
A8020.2770 (unclassified revenues) account.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
98
April 6, 1993
RESOLUTION NO. 102 AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE A SUB -CONTRACT BETWEEN
TOMPKINS COUNTY PLANNING DEPARTMENT AND
DAVIDSON-PETERSON ASSOCIATES FOR WORK ON THE
TOMPKINS COUNTY TOURISM STUDY
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Ms. Mink, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County Advisory Board on Tourism Development selected Davidson -
Peterson Associates of York, Maine to complete the Tompkins County Tourism Study, and
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County Board of Representatives has approved the proposal of
Davidson -Peterson Associates, and
WHEREAS, as part of their proposal, Davidson -Peterson Associates wishes to sub -contract a
potion of the contractual work to the Tompkins County Planning Department, and
WHEREAS, the Planning Department has the technical capability to complete such work in a
timely and efficient manner, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the County Administrator or
his designee be authorized to execute a contract in the amount of $5,000 between Tompkins County and
Davidson -Peterson Associates,
RESOLVED, further, That the County Comptroller be authorized to deposit funds received in
Account No. A8020.2770 (unclassified revenues).
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 103 - AUTHORIZATION TO SIGN CONTRACT WITH TOWN OF
ITHACA FOR PLANNING SERVICES
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mrs. Livesay, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County Planning Department has a Circuit Rider program to provide
enhanced planning services for local municipalities, and
WHEREAS, the Town of Ithaca has requested the assistance of the Tompkins County Planning
Depai tinent to perform planning services in the areas of development review, SEQR and CAC work on
behalf of the Town, and
WHEREAS, the Town of Ithaca Planning Department has authorized the expenditure of funds for
these services not to exceed $3,459.75 for these services, and
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County Planning Depai lucent has the technical capability to provide the
services listed to the Town of Ithaca in a competent and efficient manner, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Department, That the County Administrator or
his designee be authorized to sign a contract with the Town of Ithaca not to exceed $3,459,75 for planning
services,
RESOLVED, further, That the County Comptroller be authorized to deposit funds received in
Account No. A8020.2770 (unclassified revenues).
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 104 - SUPPORT OF ECONOMIC ADVISORY BOARD FOR NEW YORK
STATE REGIONAL ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT PARTNERSHIP
PROGRAM (REDS) APPLICATION
99
April 6, 1993
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mr. Joseph, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County Economic Advisory Board has developed Phase One of the
Overall Economic Development Strategy, and
WHEREAS, the database which was developed has been extremely useful to a variety of public
and private actors throughout the County, and
WHEREAS, Phases II and III of the strategy cannot be completed without the assistance of the
New York State Department of Economic Development Regional Economic Development Partnership
Program (REDS), now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the Tompkins County Board
of Representatives supports the development of an application by Tompkins County Area Development
(TCAD) to the New York State Dept tnient of Economic Development for funding of Phases II and III of
the Overall Economic Development Strategy.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 105 - AUDIT OF FINAL PAYMENT - TOMPKINS COUNTY INTERIM
TRANSFER FACILITY - MCPHERSON BUILDERS, INC.
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Mason, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the following claim against the County of Tompkins, be and hereby is audited by the Board of
Representatives:
Vendor Payment Request Account No. Amount
McPherson Builders, Inc. 6 (Final) HH8162.9263 $3,713.26
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller be and hereby is authorized and directed to pay said
claim from Account No. HH8165.9239.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 106 - AUTHORIZING SUPPLEMENTARY AGREEMENT NO. 3 FOR
WETLANDS DESIGN SERVICES TO COMPENSATE FOR
FILLED WETLANDS IN RUNWAY EXTENSION PROJECT -
TOMPKINS COUNTY AIRPORT
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mrs. Call, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, the United States Army Corps of Engineers, in consideration of its approval to fill
existing wetlands in the runway extension area, requires the County to compensate for the taking of these
wetlands by creating a four -acre wetland at an approved site, and
WHEREAS, under Supplementary Agreement No. 2 the wetlands Compensation Study has defined
the extent of required design services necessary for this wetlands creation, and
WHEREAS, the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) has agreed that this design work should
be a supplement to the existing design contract for the runway extension and that said FAA will provide
the necessary funds to meet the federal share, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management and Budget
and Administration Committees, That said supplementary agreement for $15,530 be approved and that
the County Administrator be hereby authorized to execute said supplementary agreement with C&S
100
April 6, 1993
Engineers, Inc. subject to approval by the FAA and the New York State Department of Transportation
(NYSDOT), and that the budget appropriations shall be as follows:
FAA Share (90%) Account No. HX5698.4592 $13,977
NYSDOT Share (5%) Account No. HX5698.3592 776
County Share (PFC's) (5%) Account No. HX5698.5031 777
Total Account No. HX5698.9213 $15,530
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller be authorized to advance funds until FAA, NYSDOT
and Passenger Facility Charge (PFC) reimbursement is received.
SEQR ACTION: TYPE I
(NEGATIVE DECLARATION ON FILE)
RESOLUTION NO. 107 - PUBLIC UTILITIES EASEMENTS - AIRPORT TERMINAL
PROJECT
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Mason, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the County Administrator is hereby authorized to execute easements allowing New York State
Electric and Gas (NYSEG), New York Telephone and Southern Cayuga Lake Intermunicipal Water
Commission the right to extend and/or maintain public utilities along and/or through County property at
the Airport in the Village of Lansing.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 108 - A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE ISSUANCE OF $5,100,000
SERIAL BONDS OF THE COUNTY OF TOMPKINS, NEW YORK
TO PAY THE COUNTY'S SHARE OF THE COST OF THE
CONSTRUCTION OF IMPROVEMENTS AT THE TOMPKINS
COUNTY AIRPORT (Reconsidered and Adopted 4/20/93)
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Mason. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 8
(Representatives Call, Evans, Livesay, Mason, Mink, Stein, Winch and Watros); Noes - 2
(Representatives Joseph and Lerner); Excused - 5 (Representatives Culligan, Proto, Schuler, Shurtleff and
Todd). Resolution Lost. (Further research revealed the resolution required two-thirds vote pursuant to
Local Finance Law; the vote was incorrectly announced at meeting.)
RESOLUTION NO. 109 - A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE ISSUANCE OF $363,801
SERIAL BONDS OF THE COUNTY OF TOMPKINS, NEW YORK
TO PAY THE COST OF VARIOUS OBJECTS OR PURPOSES
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans. A short roll call vote resulted as follows (two-thirds
required): Ayes - 10 (Representatives Call, Evans, Joseph, Lerner, Livesay, Mason, Mink, Stein, Winch
and Watros); Noes — 0; Excused - 5 (Representatives Culligan, Proto, Schuler, Shurtleff and Todd).
Adopted.
WHEREAS, all conditions precedent to the financing of the capital projects hereinafter described,
including compliance with the provisions of the State Environmental Quality Review Act, have been
performed, and
WHEREAS, it is now desired to authorize the financing of such capital projects, now therefore be
101
April 6, 1993
RESOLVED, by the Board of Representatives of the County of Tompkins, New York, as follows:
Section 1. For the specific objects or purposes of paying the cost of the capital projects specified
in Section 2 hereof, there are hereby authorized to be issued $363,801 serial bonds of the County of
Tompkins, New York, pursuant to the provisions of the Local Finance Law.
Section 2. The capital projects in and for the County of Tompkins, New York, for which such
serial bonds shall be expended and the maximum estimated cost of each of such capital projects are as
follows:
a). The preparation of assessment maps required for the digitalization
of the County's tax maps to conform the County's tax maps to State
standards, at a maximum estimated cost of $154,801;
b). The preparation of grid coordinate mapping, including funding of a
generic impact statement in connection therewith, at a maximum
estimated cost of $134,000; and
c). The purchase and installation of a fire/EMS computer aided dispatch
system, at a maximum estimated cost of $75,000.
Section 3. The plan for financing of each of the specific objects or purposes set forth in Section 2
hereof shall consist of the issuance of the serial bonds of said County authorized to be issued pursuant to
this bond resolution, which serial bonds shall be apportioned among the objects or purposes described in
Section 2 hereof in accordance with the maximum estimated cost of each.
Section 4. It is hereby determined that the period of probable usefulness of the aforesaid
preparation of assessment maps is ten years, pursuant to subdivision 44 of paragraph a of Section 11.00 of
the Local Finance Law, that the period of probable usefulness of the preparation of grid coordinate
mapping if five years pursuant to subdivision 62 of paragraph a of Section 11.00 of the Local Finance
Law, and the the period of probable usefulness of the aforesaid purchase and installation of a fire/EMS
computer aided dispatch system is ten years, pursuant to subdivision 25 of paragraph a of Section 11.00
of the Local Finance Law.
Section 5. Subject to the provisions of the Local Finance Law, the power to authorize the issuance
of and to sell bond anticipation notes in anticipation of the issuance and sale of the serial bonds herein
authorized, including renewals of such notes, is hereby delegated to the County Comptroller, the chief
fiscal officer. Such notes shall be of such terms, form and contents, and shall be sold in such manner, as
may be prescribed by,said County Comptroller, consistent with the provisions of the Local Finance Law.
Section 6. The faith and credit of said County of Tompkins, New York, are hereby irrevocably
pledged for the payment of the principal of and interest on such obligations as the same respectively
become due and payable. An annual appropriation shall be made in each year sufficient to pay the
principal of and interest on such obligations becoming due and payable in such year. There shall annually
be levied on all the taxable real property of said County a tax sufficient to pay the principal of and interest
on such obligations as the same become due and payable.
Section 7. Such bonds shall be in fully registered form and shall be signed in the name of the
County of Tompkins, New York by the manual or facsimile signature of the County Comptroller and a
facsimile of the corporate seal shall be imprinted thereon and attested by the manual of facsimile
signature of the County Clerk.
Section 8. The powers and duties of advertising such bonds for sale, conducting the sale and
awarding the bonds, are hereby delegated to the County Comptroller, who shall advertise such bonds for
sale, conduct the sale, and award the bonds in such manner as he or she shall deem best for the interests of
the County; provided, however, that in the exercise of these delegated powers, he or she shall comply
fully with the provisions of the Local Finance Law and any order or rule of the State Comptroller
applicable to the sale of municipal bonds. The receipt of the County Comptroller shall be a full
acquittance to the purchaser of such bonds, who shall not be obligated to see to the application of the
purchase money.
Section 9. All other matters, except as provided herein relating to such bonds, including
prescribing whether manual or facsimile signatures shall appear on said bonds, prescribing the method for
the recording of ownership of said bonds, appointing the fiscal agent or agents for said bonds, providing
for the printing and delivery of said bonds (and if said bonds are to be executed in the name of the County
by the facsimile signature of the County Comptroller and, providing for the manual countersignature of a
102
April 6, 1993
fiscal agent or of a designated official of the County), the date, denominations, maturities and interest
payment dates, place or places of payment, and also including the consolidation with other issues, shall be
determined by the County Comptroller. It is hereby determined that it is to the financial advantage of the
County not to impose and collect from registered owners of such serial bonds any charges for mailing,
shipping and insuring bonds transferred or exchanged by the fiscal agent, and, accordingly, pursuant to
paragraph c of Section 70.00 of the Local Finance Law, no such charges shall be so collected by the fiscal
agent. Such bonds shall contain substantially the recital of validity clause provided for in Section 52.00
of the Local Finance Law and shall otherwise be in such form and contain such recitals in addition to
those required by Section 52.00 of the Local Finance Law, as the County Comptroller shall determine.
Section 10. The validity of such bonds and bond anticipation notes may be contested only if:
1). Such obligations are authorized for an object or purpose for which said County is not
authorized to expend money, or
2). The provisions of law which should be complied with at the date of publication of this
resolution are not substantially complied with.
and an action, suit or proceeding contesting such validity is commenced within twenty days after the date
of such publication, or
3). Such obligations are authorized in violation of the provisions of the Constitution.
Section 11. This resolution shall constitute a statement of official intent for purposes of Treasury
Regulations Section 1.103-18(f). Other than as specified in this resolution, no monies are, or are
reasonably expected to be, reserved, allocated on a long-term basis, or otherwise set aside with respect to
the permanent funding of the object or purpose described herein.
Section 12. This resolution, which takes effect immediately, shall be published in full in the Ithaca
Journal, which is hereby designated as the official newspaper of such County, for purposes of this bond
resolution, together with a notice of the Clerk of the Board of Representatives in substantially the form
provided in Section 81.00 of the Local Finance Law.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 110 - AWARD OF BID - SURPLUS T -HANGARS - AIRPORT
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mrs. Call, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, two (2) sets of used T -hangars at the Airport need to be removed to clear the way for
construction, and
WHEREAS, it is important that one of the sets be removed by May 3, 1993, in order that
construction not be held up, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the Director of Purchasing and Central Services be authorized to solicit bids for removal of said T -
hangars,
RESOLVED, further, That the Director be authorized to award the bid for removal of said T -
hangars to the highest responsible bidder,
RESOLVED, further, That the Airport Division be authorized to implement this bid on behalf of
the County.
SEQR ACTION: TYPE I OR UNLISTED
(DETERMINATIONS OR FINDINGS INCLUDED HEREIN) NEW TERMINAL REPORTS FILED
RESOLUTION NO. 111 - AUTHORIZATION TO APPLY FOR GRANT FROM NEW YORK
STATE COUNCIL ON THE ARTS (NYSCA) FOR HISTORIC
PRESERVATION
103
April 6, 1993
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, Tompkins County has done previous work to catalogue historically significant places
and areas in the County, and
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County and Historic Ithaca have been working together on a process to
update the previously collected material, and
WHEREAS, the County Planning Department has identified NYSCA funds as a source to facilitate
the updating of this material, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the County is authorized to
apply for a NYSCA grant not to exceed $10,000 for historic preservation purposes,
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator or his designee is authorized to sign the
application on behalf of the County.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 112 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE A CONTRACT WITH THE
ALCOHOLISM COUNCIL
Moved by Mr. Mason, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Safety and Budget and Administration
Committees, That the County Administrator is hereby authorized to execute a contract with the
Alcoholism Council,
RESOLVED, further, That the source of funding is unallocated ATI funds from 1992-93 Division
of Probation and Correctional Alternatives, not to exceed $5,242,
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller is hereby authorized and directed to make the
following budget adjustment on his books:
Appropriation: 3143.4442 Alternatives to Incarceration Other $5,242
Revenue: 3143.3389 Other Public Safety $5,242
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 113 - TO URGE THE STATE SENATE AND ASSEMBLY TO RESTORE
STATE AID FOR PROBATION SERVICES TO 33 PERCENT
Moved by Mr. Mason, seconded by Mr. Lerner, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, passage of the budget by the New York State Senate and Assembly translates to a
reduction in state aid for Probation services from 33 percent to 18.84 percent, and
WHEREAS, the net loss to Tompkins County amounts to approximately $121,000 in state aid, and
WHEREAS, this loss will result in a reduction of Probation staff, a curtailment in the Probation
Department's ability to protect the community, a reduction in Alternative to Incarceration programming,
and a cramping of the Probation Depal tnient's abilities to perform its mandated functions, and
WHEREAS, the cost of retaining Probation services at their current level, if absorbed by the
County, would represent a hefty and unfair tax burden to the citizens of Tompkins County, now therefore
be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Safety Committee, That the New York State
Senate and Assembly be urged to restore Probation funding to 33 percent, as going below that percentage
is less than tolerable,
104
April 6, 1993
RESOLVED, further, That the Governor of New York State be urged to support that restoration,
RESOLVED, further, That the Clerk of the Tompkins County Board of Representatives is hereby
directed to send certified copies of this resolution, with her original signature thereon, to Senators Kuhl
and Seward, Assemblyman Luster and Governor Cuomo.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
It was Moved by Ms. Mink, seconded by Mrs. Livesay, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to lift Resolution No. 74 from the Table.
RESOLUTION NO. 74 - AUTHORIZING A PUBLIC HEARING ON PROPOSED LOCAL LAW
NO. c OF 1993 - SCANNER ACCURACY LAW
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans. Ms. Mink withdrew her motion to add the following
RESOLVED: "RESOLVED, further, That a public hearing also be held before the Board of
Representatives at Board Chambers of the Tompkins County Courthouse, 320 North Tioga Street, Ithaca
New York on Tuesday, April 20, 1993 at 5:30 p.m. in the evening thereof concerning the proposed Item
Pricing Local Law of 1991. At such time and place all persons interested in the subject matter will be
heard concerning the same." A voice vote resulted as follows on the resolution: Ayes - 10
(Representatives Call, Evans, Joseph, Lerner, Livesay, Mason, Mink, Stein, Winch and Watros); Noes —
0; Excused - 5 (Representatives Culligan, Proto, Schuler, Shurtleff and Todd). Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That a public
hearing be held before the Board of Representatives at Board Chambers of the Tompkins County
Courthouse, 320 North Tioga Street, Ithaca New York on Tuesday, April 20, 1993 at 5:30 p.m. in the
evening thereof concerning proposed Local Law No. c of 1993 - Scanner Accuracy Law. At such time
and place all persons interested in the subject matter will be heard concerning the same,
RESOLVED, further, That the Clerk of the Board is hereby authorized and directed to place proper
notice of such public hearing in the official newspaper of the County.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
On motion of the appropriate committee chairmen and duly seconded and adopted by voice vote by
members present, the following appointments were made to the various advisory boards:
Tompkins County Youth Board
Term expires December 31, 1993
John J. Sincebaugh - representing Town of Newfield
Family Court Advisory Council
Term expires December 31, 1995
Joanne M. Miner - at -large representative
On motion, the meeting adjourned at 6:42 p.m.
"OLD JAIL RE -DEDICATION
MARCH 30, 1993
REMARKS OF MARTHA PRESTON,
CHAIRPERSON, ITHACA LANDMARKS PRESERVATION COMMISSION
105
April 6, 1993
This is an absolute pleasure for the Ithaca Landmarks Preservation Commission! To witness such a
wonderful transformation within this historic edifice is an exciting moment for every member of the
Commission, as well as every citizen of our county! It is also an excellent example of the cooperative
efforts between the county, this city, and the Landmarks Commission, of which we are especially
appreciative. This handsome building, originally erected in 1933, has succeeded in this adaptive reuse
though excellent design, sensitive planning, and acute attention to detail. It is interesting to imagine what
J. Lakin Baldridge, the original architect, would think of his County Jail design being reconfigured to
accommodate such efficient and inviting office spaces! I feel certain that he would be impressed!
The original design is an example of Neo -Georgian style, which became popular in the 1930's, primarily
due to the restoration work being done at that time in Williamsburg, Virginia. There are no authentic
Georgian architecture examples in Ithaca, as this style was prevalent from 1700-1780 and Ithaca, of
course, was settled after the colonial period. Many typical Georgian elements are exhibited in the "Old
Jail", such as the pediment with tooth-like dentil molding centered on the front facade, the main doorway
crowned with an ornate broken pediment supported by decorative flattened columns on either side, and
the small paned windows. The use of red brick and stone as primary building materials, and the stone
accents at the corners, known as quoins, are also characteristic of the Georgian style.
The architect, Mr. Baldridge, studied architecture at Cornell, graduating in 1922. He was an assistant
professor in the department the following year, and in 1924 he opened his own architectural office in
Ithaca. Mr. Baldridge designed two other Noe -Georgian building in town: the County Courthouse just
around the corner, erected at the same time as the jail; and the Cayuga Apartments on West Buffalo
Street, opposite DeWittt Park. He also designed several opulent houses in Cayuga Heights, where he
resided. Both the "Old Jail" and the County Courthouse are included in the DeWitt Park Local Historic
District and were listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1971.
The jail and courthouse was Mr. Baldridge's last commission in Ithaca, for having inherited a substantial
amount of National Steel Corporation stock in 1931 and with the deepening Depression, he felt that he
should not take work away from those who needed it more. Mr. Baldridge then moved to Bermuda, built
himself a home, and became a deep sea fisherman.
Every resident of this county, whether they consider themselves an advocate or historic preservation or
not, should feel proud that the County officials chose to revitalize an existing building within the city to
accommodate their need for office space, ultimately saving taxpayers' money and enhancing the
appearance and vitality of Downtown Ithaca.
On a personal note, in 1933 when this building was originally constructed, my grandfather was a
businessman here in Ithaca. He may have watched the construction of the jail and courthouse, as he lived
only three blocks away. It gives me great pride and a sense of awe when I think that the County has now
given this handsome building a new use while preserving the original historic and architectural character
to be appreciated by generations to come!
106
April 20, 1993
Regular Meeting
Public Hearing
Chairman Watros called the public hearing to order at 5:30 p.m. concerning proposed Local Law
No. c of 1993 - Scanner Accuracy Law (version as adopted by Budget and Administration Committee
March 9, 1993). Chairman Watros asked if anyone wished to speak?
Will Burbank, 132 Glenside Road, Ithaca, spoke in opposition to proposed Local Law No. c of
1993 - Scanner Accuracy Law. Mr. Burbank stated that attention should be focused on the larger
problem which he believes is item pricing.
Rebecca Weber, New York Public Interest Research Group (NYPIRG), spoke in opposition to
proposed Local Law No. c of 1993 - Scanner Accuracy Law. She stated that a similar law has been
considered in several counties throughout New York State and has not been adopted by any to date. She
said that item pricing is the only sure method to guard consumers against wrong prices. Ms. Weber
urged the Board not to adopt this law for the following reasons: the fines proposed in the law are too
low; stores will continue to take in a large amount of money in overcharges; the County would have
problems with enforcement; the law does not include item pricing and the law legalizes being less than
100 percent accurate.
Elizabeth A. Smith, East Shore Drive, Lansing, spoke in opposition to proposed Local Law No. c
of 1993 - Scanner Accuracy Law. Ms. Smith referred to statistics compiled in New York State in regard
to food sales. She urged the Board to not make the public settle for anything less than 100 percent
accuracy.
Ilene Finn, Town of Danby, spoke in opposition to proposed Local Law No. c of 1993 - Scanner
Accuracy Law. She stated that she finds it impossible to remember the price of each item she is buying
by the time she reaches the cashier. She said she feels this proposed law will hurt Tompkins County and
consumers and urged the Board to reconsider item pricing in Tompkins County.
No one else wished to speak and the public hearing was closed at 5:44 p.m.
Members and guests participated in the Pledge of Allegiance.
Present: 15 Representatives. Mr. Stein was excused from the meeting at 7:25 p.m. prior to action
on Resolution No. 124.
It was Moved by Mr. Evans, seconded by Mrs. Call, and unanimously adopted by voice vote, to
approve the minutes of March 30 and April 6, 1993 as submitted.
Catherine Covert, Clerk of the Board, announced that a packet of material concerning Standards of
Conduct for officers and employees of Tompkins County is available upon request.
Chairman Watros read a proclamation declaring the week of May 3-7, 1993 as Public Health
Nursing Week in Tompkins County.
Under privilege of the floor, Paul Bennett, Esq., spoke on behalf of five individuals he is currently
representing in the matter of the alleged sick building syndrome at the Department of Social Services.
He stated that he is frustrated with the progress the County has made in helping to resolve the complaints
of his clients. Mr. Bennett also commented on the procedure the County uses for employees filing for
107
April 20, 1993
workman's compensation and stated that some of his clients are not able to get workman's compensation
and may have to apply for public assistance themselves.
Under privilege of the floor, Catherine Brady, Ithaca College student, spoke in opposition to
proposed Local Law No. c of 1993 - Scanner Accuracy Law. Ms. Brady stated that she lives on a tight
budget and believes it is unfair to consumers to not have item pricing. Ms. Brady stated that consumers
would be cheated if stores were allowed to have anything less than 100 percent accuracy.
Under privilege of the floor, Yvonne Bartlett, Department of Social Services employee, spoke
concerning the alleged sick building syndrome at the Department of Social Services. Ms. Bartlett stated
that she has been out of work since March 1, 1993 and does not receive any disability of workman's
compensation.
Under privilege of the floor, Mrs. Call, Chairman, Budget and Administration Committee, stated
that a resolution to adopt proposed Local Law No. c of 1993 - Scanner Accuracy Law is not on the
agenda because the County Attorney is reviewing it and if any changes are made to the law, another
public hearing will be called.
Under privilege of the floor, Ms. Mink, Representative, District No. 5, stated that the proposed
Scanner Accuracy Law would not protect consumers and would undercut possible item pricing
legislation. She said item pricing is the only way for consumers to really know what they are paying.
She said that fifteen counties around the State have adopted item pricing and stated she would still like to
see item pricing in Tompkins County.
Under privilege of the floor, Mr. Lerner, Representative, District No. 1, spoke concerning
proposed Local Law No. c of 1993 - Scanner Accuracy Law. Mr. Lerner stated that scanner accuracy is
not a substitute for item pricing and that these are two different laws. He stated that he does not agree
that the County should accept any less than 100 percent accuracy, the fines should be increased and a
requirement to make the law self -policing should be included in the law. He said that he will introduce
amendments to the proposed Law under consideration.
Under privilege of the floor, Mrs. Livesay, Representative, District No. 11, spoke concerning
proposed Local Law No. c of 1993 - Scanner Accuracy Law. She stated that she agrees with Mr. Lerner
but believes that both scanner accuracy and item pricing should be included in the same law. Mrs.
Livesay recommended that a task force be created to see what is needed.
Mr. Proto, Chairman, Health and Education Committee, reported that the next phase from the
Board of Health regarding the Sanitary Code is underway. He stated that the Health Department has not
received the last quarter reimbursement from the State in the amount of $200,000. Mr. Proto reported
that Tompkins Cortland Community College has embarked on an energy conservation program which is
projected to save $894,000 over a ten year period. He stated that graduation at the College will be on
May 27. Mr. Proto reported that articles will continue to appear in the newspaper concerning rabies and
lyme disease as the season is approaching.
Mr. Evans, Chairman, Personnel Committee, reported that the Committee met yesterday and
interviewed candidates for the position of Commissioner of Personnel. The next Committee meeting will
be April 29 at 8 a.m. in the Old Jail conference room.
Ms. Mink, Chairman, Human Services Committee, reported that the Committee met on April 8
and discussed how the City of Ithaca and County sales tax agreement will affect human services
agencies. Ms. Mink expressed concern concerning the alleged sick building syndrome situation at the
Department of Social Services. She stated that steps are being taken to assess the air quality in the
108
April 20, 1993
building and to see what can and should be done to the building. She stated that the Committee and the
Board are taking the problem very seriously. Mr. Proto stated that after receiving a complaint about the
building in February, Health Depai tment staff were in the building that day to assess the concerns that
were expressed. Mr. Heyman, County Administrator, reported that the Employee Safety Committee
made testing County buildings a top priority. Professionals from Central New York Office of Safety and
Health are guiding the County in this process. Mr. Heyman stated that the County is fully prepared to
make reasonable accommodations to its employees.
Mr. Mason, Chairman, Public Safety Committee, stated that dialogue with State representatives
continues concerning cuts to the Probation Department. Mr. Mason reported that the position of Jail
Administrator has been highly successful and that Mr. Gordon Stevens, Jail Administrator, has earned his
salary a couple of times over. Mr. Mason stated that at the present time the County is not boarding in
prisoners.
Mr. Stein, Chairman, Planning Committee, stated that the next Committee meeting will be April
27 at 9:00 a.m. in the Old Jail Conference Room.
Mr. Winch, Chairman, Public Works and Construction Management Committee, apologized for
the inconvenience and stated that the elevator in the Annex building will soon be operational. Mr. Winch
stated that the Airport project is moving forward.
Mr. Todd, Chairman, Fiscal Affairs Committee, reported that the Committee met on April 15 with
Senator Seward in attendance. Mr. Todd expects to have a fiscal plan proposal for the Board to consider
in May. The next Committee meeting will be April 22 at 9:30 a.m.
Mr. Lerner, Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, reported that the
Committee met on April 8 and will meet again on April 22. Mr. Lerner called attention to an April 2
letter from James Dwyer, Consulting Attorney for Tompkins County, stating that the permit application
for DR -7 has been withdrawn. Mr. Lerner reported that Barbara Eckstrom has been asked to speak at the
April 28 Legislative Commission on Waste. She will be making a presentation on the success of
Tompkins County waste reduction programs. Mr. Lerner stated that the site of the Recycling and Solid
Waste Center has not been affected by the recent flooding conditions.
Mrs. Livesay, Intergovernmental Representative, reported that she, Ms. Mink and Chairman
Watros will be meeting on April 21 with representatives from the City to see if we need one committee
or three committees to follow-up with specific items in the recent sales tax agreement. Mrs. Livesay
referred to a meeting she attended at Cornell University to discuss contracts with Hyrdo Quebec and
stated that she will be following-up on that issue. Mrs. Livesay stated that she is also following various
legislative bills and will be bringing them to the appropriate committees.
Mrs. Livesay, member, Greater Ithaca Activities Board, reported that a performance will be given
on April 29 - May 1 in the GIAC gymnasium that was written by Carol Kammen and suggested that
members of the Board may wish to attend.
Mrs. Call, Chairman, Budget and Administration Committee, reported that the Committee met
April 13 and discussed the informal appeals process for the Annual Solid Waste Fee. She stated that the
Appeal Board still needs to be appointed and would like that Board appointed in May. Mrs. Call stated
that after review by Bond Counsel, the County was informed that a two-thirds vote is required for
Resolution No. 108, therefore, this resolution is on the agenda to be reconsidered this evening. Mrs. Call
stated that Mr. Squires, Comptroller, has submitted the year-end budget close out report. She stated that
the Community Affirmative Action Committee has met twice without quorum and will be put on hold
until after the new Personnel Commissioner is appointed.
109
April 20, 1993
Mr. Heyman, County Administrator, reported that he is working on rescheduling another open
house for the Old Jail which was canceled due to weather conditions.
Ms. Nelson, Chair, Employee Council, reported that the regular council meeting was held on April
7. The highlight of the meeting was the passing of of the performance review policy that has been an
ongoing project of the Professional Growth and Development Committee. This policy was approved by
the Department Heads on April 12th and requires the action of the Board to make it final. She
commended the Committee and Department Heads that helped get this policy written in a form
acceptable by all.
Mr. Wood, Assistant County Attorney, stated that the monthly report from the County Attorney's
office will be submitted.
On motion of the appropriate committee chairmen and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by
voice vote, the following resolutions were added to the agenda:
Abolish, Create, Increase of Hours of Positions - Board of Representatives
Approval of Sale - County Owned Property Acquired Through Tax Foreclosure - Town of Enfield
Chairman Watros gave the appropriate committee chairman permission to withdraw from the
agenda the following resolution:
Authorization to contract with Task Force for Battered Women - Depai lment of Social Services
Chairman Watros gave the appropriate committee chairmen permission to withdraw from the
agenda the following resolutions with final committee action being affirmed:
CA041-93 - Authorization to Contract - Mike O'Neil - Department of Social Services
CA042-93 - Authorization to Submit Grant Proposal - Children with Special Care Needs
CA043-93 - Budget Adjustments and Appropriations - Various Departments (Amended by
Resolution No. CA054-93)
CA044-93 - Reclassification of Position - Senior Welfare Investigator - Department of Social
Services
CA045-93 - Reclassification of Position - Budget and Finance Supervisor to Budget and Finance
Manager - Budget and Finance
CA046-93 - Reclassification of Position - Senior Account Clerk Typist - Various Departments
CA047-93 - Reclassification of Position - Benefits Manager - Personnel
CA048-93 - Change Order No. 1 - Waste Management of North America, Inc. - Solid Waste
Hauling and Disposal Services
RESOLUTION NO. 114 - AUTHORIZATION TO CONTRACT WITH COMMUNITY HOME
AND HEALTH CARE, INC. TO PROVIDE NON-MEDICAL HOME
HEALTH CARE SERVICES
Moved by Ms. Mink, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, there is a need to utilize all appropriate home care services in the community in the
Expanded In -Home Services to the Elderly Program (EISEP), and
WHEREAS, Community Home and Health Care, Inc. can provide such services, now therefore be
it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Human Services Committee, That the Tompkins County
Office for the Aging be authorized to contract with Community Home and Health Care, Inc. for provision
110
April 20, 1993
of personal care services at the rate of $10.19 per hour for homemaker/personal care and at the rate of
$10.13 per hour for housekeeper/chore services for the period of April 1, 1993 through March 31, 1994.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 115 - URGING SUPPORT FOR STATE ANTI -DISCRIMINATION
LEGISLATION
Moved by Ms. Mink, seconded by Mrs. Call, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, the New York State Assembly has recently adopted legislation prohibiting
discrimination in public accommodation based on sexual orientation, and
WHEREAS, the New York State Senate has not yet introduced a companion bill for the same
purpose, and
WHEREAS, Tompkins County adopted a Fair Practice Law in 1991 and feels such protection
from discrimination should be statewide, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Human Services Committee, That the Board of
Representatives urges the New York State Senate to introduce and adopt the Civil Rights Bill (A1336),
RESOLVED, further, That the a copy of this resolution be sent to the Majority Leader of Senate,
our local Senate representatives, and Assemblymember Steven Sanders, 622 Legislative Office Building,
Albany, New York, 12248.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 116 - REASSIGNMENT OF SPACE IN BIGGS BUILDING A
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mrs. Call, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Human Services, Planning, Public Safety, Public Works
and Construction Management and Budget and Administration Committees, That space in Biggs
Building A is hereby reassigned effective immediately pursuant to maps prepared by the Depaitment of
Planning and dated April 1993.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 108 - A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE ISSUANCE OF $5,100,000
SERIAL BONDS OF THE COUNTY OF TOMPKINS, NEW YORK
TO PAY THE COUNTY'S SHARE OF THE COST OF THE
CONSTRUCTION OF IMPROVEMENTS AT THE TOMPKINS
COUNTY AIRPORT
Moved by Mr. Culligan, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote to
reconsider Resolution No. 108.
It was Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto. Mr. Mason, Representative, District No. 15
stated this is a situation where the project is funded by those who are going to use it and feels this is
important to the community as the Airport generates a great amount of revenue which comes into the
Tompkins County community. Mr. Joseph, Representative, District No. 12, stated that although there is
111
April20, 1993
no cost to the County taxpayer, there is a cost to the State and Federal taxpayer and does not feel that an
airport terminal should be a top priority. Mr. Lerner, Representative, District
No. 1, stated that one reason he is opposed to the project is because of concerns for unforeseen
circumstances which may result in the involvement of property taxes.
A roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 13, Noes - 2 (Representatives Joseph and Lerner).
Adopted.
WHEREAS, all conditions precedent to the financing of the capital projects hereinafter described,
including compliance with the provisions of the State Environmental Quality Review Act, have been
performed, and
WHEREAS, it is now desired to authorize the financing of such capital projects, now therefore be
RESOLVED, by the Board of Representatives of the County of Tompkins, New York, as follows:
Section 1. For the specific objects or purposes or classes of objects or purposes of paying the
County's share of the cost of the following capital improvements at the Tompkins County Airport in said
County, there are hereby authorized to be issued $5,100,000 serial bonds pursuant to the provisions of the
Local Finance Law:
1. The County's share of the cost of the construction of a new terminal
including original equipment, machinery, apparatus and furnishings
required for the purposes for which the terminal building is to be
used and including landscaping and other site improvements and
incidental improvements and expenses in connection therewith, a
specific object or purpose, at a maximum estimated cost of
$3,175,451;
2. The County's share of the cost of the construction of new parking
lots at said Airport, including incidental improvements and expenses
in connection therewith, a class of objects or purposes, at a maximum
estimated cost of $1,015,644;
3. The County's share of the cost of the construction of a new access
road at said Airport, including incidental improvements and expenses
in connection therewith, a specific object or purpose, at a maximum
estimated cost of $109,318;
4. The County's share of the cost of a new ramp/taxiway at said Airport,
including incidental improvements and expenses in connection
therewith, a specific object or purpose, at a maximum estimated cost
of $499,587; and
5. The County's share of the cost of the construction of new T -hangers
at said Airport, including original furnishings, equipment,
machinery, apparatus and incidental improvements and expenses in
connection therewith, a class of objects or purpose, at a maximum
estimated cost of $300,000.
Section 2. The plan for the financing of each of the objects or purposes set forth in Section 1
hereof shall consist of the issuance of the serial bonds of said County authorized to be issued pursuant to
this bond resolution, which serial bonds shall be apportioned among the objects or purposes described in
Section 1 hereof in accordance with the maximum estimated cost of each.
Section 3. It is hereby determined that the period of probable usefulness of the aforesaid
construction of a new terminal is thirty years, pursuant to subdivision 11(a)(1) of paragraph a of Section
11.00 of the Local Finance Law, that the period of probable usefulness of the aforesaid construction of
new parking lots is ten years, pursuant to subdivision 20(f) of paragraph a of Section 11.00 of the Local
Finance Law, that the period of probable usefulness of the aforesaid construction of a new access road is
fifteen years, pursuant to subdivision 20(c) of paragraph a of Section 11.00 of the Local Finance Law,
112
April 20, 1993
that the period of probable usefulness of the aforesaid construction of a new ramp/taxiway is thirty years,
pursuant to subdivision 15 of paragraph a of Section 11.00 of the Local Finance Law and that the period
of probable usefulness of the aforesaid construction of new T -hangers is twenty years, pursuant to
subdivision 17 of paragraph a of Section 11.00 of the Local Finance Law.
Section 4. Subject to the provisions of the Local Finance Law, the power to authorize the issuance
of and to sell bond anticipation notes in anticipation of the issuance and sale of the bonds herein
authorized, including renewals of such notes, is hereby delegated to the County Comptroller, the chief
fiscal officer. Such notes shall be of such terms, form and contents, and shall be sold in such manner, as
may be prescribed by said County Comptroller, consistent with the provisions of the Local Finance Law.
Section 5. The faith and credit of said County of Tompkins, New York are hereby irrevocably
pledged for the payment of the principal of and interest on such obligations as the same respectively
become due and payable. An annual appropriation shall be made in each year sufficient to pay the
principal of and interest on such obligations becoming due and payable in such year. There shall
annually be levied on all the taxable real property of said County a tax sufficient to pay the principal of
and interest on such obligations as the same become due and payable.
Section 6. Such bonds shall be in fully registered form and shall be signed in the name of the
County of Tompkins, New York, by the manual or facsimile signature of the County Comptroller and a
facsimile of the corporate seal shall be imprinted thereon and attested by the manual or facsimile
signature of the County Clerk.
Section 7. The powers and duties of advertising such bonds for sale, conducting the sale and
awarding the bonds, are hereby delegated to the County Comptroller, who shall advertise such bonds for
sale, conduct the sale, and award the bonds in such manner as he shall deem best for the interests of the
County; provided, however, that in the exercise of these delegated powers, he shall comply fully with the
provisions of the Local Finance Law and any order or rule of the State Comptroller applicable to the sale
of municipal bonds. The receipt of the County Comptroller shall be a full acquittance to the purchaser of
such bonds, who shall not be obliged to see to the application of the purchase money.
Section 8. All other matters, except as provided herein relating to such bonds, including
prescribing whether manual or facsimile signatures shall appear on said bonds, prescribing the method
for the recording of ownership of said bonds, appointing the fiscal agent or agents for said bonds,
providing for the printing and delivery of said bonds (and if said bonds are to be executed in the name of
the County by the facsimile signature of the County Comptroller and, providing for the manual
countersignature of a fiscal agent or of a designated official of the County), the date, denominations,
maturities and interest payment dates, place or places of payment, and also including the consolidation
with other issues, shall be determined by the County Comptroller. It is hereby determined that it is to the
financial advantage of the County not to impose and collect from registered owners of such serial bonds
any charges for mailing, shipping and insuring bonds transferred or exchanged by the fiscal agent, and,
accordingly, pursuant to paragraph c of Section 70.00 of the Local Finance Law, no such charges shall
be so collected by the fiscal agent. Such bonds shall contain substantially the recital of validity clause
provided for in section 52.00 of the Local Finance Law and shall otherwise be in such form and contain
such recitals in addition to those required by section 52.00 of the Local Finance Law, as the County
Comptroller shall determine.
Section 9. The validity of such bonds and bond anticipation notes may be contested only if:
1. Such obligations are authorized for an object or purpose for which said County is not
authorized to expend money, or
2. The provisions of law which would be complied with at the date of publication of this
resolution are not substantially complied with, and an action, suit or proceeding contesting such validity
is commenced within twenty days after the date of such publication, or
3. Such obligations are authorized in violation of the provisions of the Constitution.
Section 10. This resolution shall constitute a statement of official intent for purposes of Treasury
Regulations Section 1.103 - 18 (f). Other than as specified in this resolution, no monies are, or are
reasonably expected to be, reserved, allocated on a long-term basis, or otherwise set aside with respect to
the permanent funding of the object or purpose described herein.
113
April 20, 1993
Section 11. This resolution, which takes effect immediately, shall be published in full in the
Ithaca Journal, which is hereby designated as the official newspaper of such County, for purposes of this
bond resolution, together with a notice of the Clerk of the Board of Representatives in substantially the
form provided in Section 81.00 of the Local Finance Law.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 117 - AUTHORIZATION TO PAY SPECIAL PROSECUTOR -
HARDING/LISHANSKY
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Ms. Mink, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That pursuant to
the approval of the Honorable Betty D. Friedlander, the County Administrator be and hereby is directed
to issue an interim payment to Attorney Nelson Roth for professional services and disbursements as
Special Prosecutor in regard to People vs. David L. Harding, People vs. Robert Lishansky, in the sum of
$10,577.14, and to Joseph O'Brien, Investigator, in the sum of $877.90.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 118 - APPROVAL OF SALE - COUNTY OWNED PROPERTY ACQUIRED
THROUGH TAX FORECLOSURE - TOWN OF DANBY
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, by tax foreclosure proceedings of 1992, the County acquired parcel no. 3.-1-36 in the
Town of Danby, and
WHEREAS, the County Administrator wishes to sell same for the total amount due for taxes,
penalties, interest and expenses, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the sale of
parcel no. 3.-1-36 to Floyd J. O'Grady of 135 Nelson Road, Ithaca, New York of the amount of taxes,
penalties, interest and expenses due, be and the same hereby is confirmed and the County Administrator
is directed to execute a quitclaim deed to the aforesaid property upon receipt of the above -stated amount.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 119 - APPROVAL OF SALE - COUNTY OWNED PROPERTY ACQUIRED
THROUGH TAX FORECLOSURE - TOWN OF ENFIELD
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Winch, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, by tax foreclosure proceedings. of 1992, the County acquired parcel no. 9.-2-20 in the
Town of Enfield, and
WHEREAS, the County Administrator wishes to sell same for the total amount due for taxes,
penalties, interest and expenses, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the sale of
parcel no. 9.-2-20 to Samuel and Anna Supek of Enfield Center Road, Ithaca, New York of the amount of
taxes, penalties, interest and expenses due, be and the same hereby is confirmed and the County
114
April 20, 1993
Administrator is directed to execute a quitclaim deed to the aforesaid property upon receipt of the above -
stated amount.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 120 - INCREASE POSITION FROM 35 HOUR WEEK TO 40 HOUR
WEEK - ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT - MENTAL HEALTH
ADMINISTRATION (GENERAL SUPPORT)
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education and Budget and Administration
Committees, That effective immediately, the position of Administrative Assistant, Mental Health
Administration (General Support) (12-535), weekly hours be increased from 35 to 40 hours. This
position shall be paid according to 40 hour salary schedule,
RESOLVED, further, That no new monies are needed for this change.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 121 - APPROVAL OF SALE PRIOR TO AUCTION - COUNTY OWNED
PROPERTY ACQUIRED THROUGH TAX FORECLOSURE -
TOWN OF DANBY
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, by tax foreclosure proceedings of 1992, the County acquired parcel no. 15.-1-11.4 in
the Town of Danby, and
WHEREAS, prior to auction of said property, the County Administrator wishes to sell same for
the total amount due for taxes, penalties, interest and expenses, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the sale of
parcel no. 15.-1-11.4 to Stephen K. and Tracey M. Blumenthal of Comfort Road, Ithaca, New York for
the amount of taxes, penalties, interest and expenses due, be and the same hereby is confirmed and the
County Administrator is directed to execute a quitclaim deed to the aforesaid property.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 122 - APPROPRIATION FROM CONTINGENT FUND - NEWFIELD
PUBLIC LIBRARY
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Winch. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes -
15, Noes - 0. Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education and Budget and Administration
Committees, That $6,450 be appropriated from the Contingent Fund (A1990) to be used by the Newfield
Public Library in the installation of a Dynix System (Account No. A7410.4521),
RESOLVED, further, That such appropriation increase the target net local share for the Health and
Education Committee and County Government as a whole for 1993 only,
115
April 20, 1993
RESOLVED, further, That the 1994 Fiscal Plan target spending calculation shall not be increased
by the $6,450 authorized by this resolution for the Health and Education Committee, or for the total
County budget.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 123 — ABOLISH AND RECLASSIFY POSITIONS — ASSESSMENT
DEPARTMENT
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Personnel and Budget and Administration Committees,
That the position of Senior Assessor (15/604), labor grade 0 (15), competitive class be abolished
effective immediately,
RESOLVED, further, That positions of Assistant Assessor (12/593), labor grade L (12), be
reclassified to Real Property Appraiser (14/709), labor grade N (14), competitive class, effective
immediately,
RESOLVED, further, That no monies are need to fund these changes in 1993.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE H
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
Representative Stein was excused from the meeting at 7:25 p.m.
RESOLUTION NO. 124 - CREATION OF POSITION - HEALTH AND SAFETY
COORDINATOR - COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR'S OFFICE
(Amended by Resolution No. 224 of 1993)
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Winch, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Personnel and Budget and Administration Committees,
That one position of Health and Safety Coordinator (84/297), management level M (13), competitive
class be created effective immediately,
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller is hereby authorized and directed to make the
following transfer on his book:
From: A1989.4462 Other General Government - Insurance $26,600
To: A1230.1297 Health and Safety Coordinator $16,705
.2201 Calculators 125
.2206 Computers 1,350
.2230 Computer Software 750
.4330 Printing 600
.4332 Books and Publications 300
.4452 Postage 120
.4465 Job Necessitated Travel and Training 450
.4466 Job Related Travel and Training 300
.4472 Telephone 480
.4901 Microcomputer Services 88
.4905 Centrally Distributed Items 282
.8810 Retirement 585
.8830 Social Security 1,237
116
April 20, 1993
.8840 Workers Compensation 48
.8860 Health Insurance 3,080
.8870 Unemployment Insurance 100
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 125 - CREATION OF TEMPORARY POSITION - SOCIAL WELFARE
EXAMINER - DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL SERVICES
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Ms. Mink, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Human Services and Budget and Administration
Committees, That one temporary full-time position of Social Welfare Examiner (11/538), labor grade K
(11), competitive class, be created effective immediately for a period of ninety days,
RESOLVED, further, That no new monies are needed to fund this position at this time.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 126 - AUTHORIZATION TO APPROPRIATE FROM CONTINGENT
FUND - HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSIONER
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Ms. Mink. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 9,
Noes - 5 (Representatives Call, Mason, Todd, Winch and Watros), Excused - 1 (Representative Stein).
Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Human Services Committee (not recommended by the
Budget and Administration Committee or County Administrator per the Fiscal Plan), That the County
Comptroller be authorized to make the following appropriation on his books for in-service retreat for
members of the Human Rights Commission:
Appropriation: A1990 Contingent Fund $300
Revenue: 8040.4466 Job Related Travel and Training $300 .
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 127 — AMENDMENT OF RESOLUTION NO. 33 OF 1993 —
ESTABLISHING A UNIT CHARGE FOR THE 1993 ANNUAL SOLID
WASTE FEE
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Lerner. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes — 11, Noes
— 3 (Representatives Culligan, Proto and Schuler), Excused — 1 (Representative Stein). Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That Resolution
No. 33 — Establishing a Unit Charge for the 1993 Annual Solid Waste Fee shall be amended as follows:
1. Condominiums (Property Class 412) and Cooperatives (Property Class 413) shall be charged
the same rate as single family houses, at $52 per living unit.
2. Single and two family residences which are defined as "commercial" and and classified under
Property Class 411 by the Assessment Department, shall be charged the apartment rate of
117
April 20, 1993
$.056/ square foot, unless they are restricted by local building codes to allow four or fewer
unrelated occupants. Buildings with such a restriction shall be charged $52 per living unit.
3. Churches with a weekly average attendance of twenty or fewer persons will be exempt.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 128 — ABOLISH, CREATE, INCREASE OF HOURS OF POSITIONS —
BOARD OF REPRESENTATIVES
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Personnel and Budget and Administration Committees,
That one position of Stenographic Secretary (60/332), labor grade J(10) Confidential, competitive class,
be abolished effective immediately,
RESOLVED, further, That one position of Keyboard Specialist (55/321), labor grade E(5)
Confidential, competitive class, be created effective immediately,
RESOLVED, further, That the hours of Clerk of the Board of Representatives (88/213) be
increased from 35 to 40 hours effective October 1, 1993 and the hours of the Deputy Clerk be increased
from 35 to 40 hours effective immediately.
RESOLVED, further, That no new monies are needed to fund these changes.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 129 — APPROVAL OF SALE — COUNTY OWNED PROPERTY ACQUIRED
THROUGH TAX FORECLOSURE — TOWN OF ENFIELD
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Winch, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, by tax foreclosure proceedings of 1992, the County acquired parcel no. 9.-2-21.2 in
the Town of Enfield, and
WHEREAS, the County Administrator wishes to sell same for the total amount due for taxes,
penalties, interest and expenses, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the sale of
parcel no. 9.-2-21.2 to Samuel and Anna Supek, of 60 Enfield Center Road East, Ithaca, New York of the
amount of taxes, penalties, interest and expenses due, be and the same hereby is confirmed and the
County Administrator is directed to execute a quitclaim deed to the aforesaid property upon receipt of the
above -stated amount.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 130 — SALARY ADJUSTMENT — SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT (ADOPTED
6/1/93)
Moved by Mr. Evans, seconded by Mr. Mason. It was Moved by Mrs. Schuler, seconded by Mr
Lerner. And unanimously adopted by voice vote by members present, to refer thisresolution to the Public
Safety Committee.
118
April 20, 1993
Ms. Mink, Member, Public Information Committee, announced that there will be a live call-in
discussion on May 11.
On motion of the appropriate committee chairmen and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by
voice vote by members present, the following appointments were made to various advisory boards:
Economic Opportunity Corporation
Term will be determined at a later date
Bruce Bard - Town of Caroline representative
Tompkins County Planning Board
Term expires December 31, 1993
Richard Chase - Town of Enfield representative
Gary Sloan - Village of Lansing representative
Tompkins County Youth Board
Term expires December 31, 1993
Mary Pat Dolan - Department of Social Services representative
Term expires December 31, 1995
Judith Paskin - Town of Enfield representative
Chairman Watros announced that in the near future the Board will be asked to gather prior to a
meeting for a photograph.
Chairman Watros declared recess from 7:58 - 8:08 p.m.
It was Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mrs. Call, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to enter into executive session at 8:08 p.m. to discuss pending litigation.
The following is the motion adopted in executive session:
It was Moved by Mr. Evans, seconded by Ms. Mink, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to authorize James Dwyer and law firm to appeal decision of Supreme Court in the
Landstrom Landfill.
The meeting returned to open session at 8:22 p.m.
On motion, the meeting adjourned at 8:22 p.m.
119
May 4, 1993
Regular Meeting
Chairman Watros called the meeting to order at 5:30 p.m.
Members and guests participated in the Pledge of Allegiance.
Present: 13 Representatives. Excused: 2 (Representatives Culligan and Shurtleff).
It was Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to approve the minutes of April 20, 1993 as corrected.
Chairman Watros presented the following proclamations:
Hospital Week in Tompkins County - May 9-15, 1993
Breast Health Awareness Month in Tompkins County - May, 1993
Public Service Recognition Week in Tompkins County - May 3-9, 1993
Senior Center 50th Anniversary Week in Tompkins County - week of May 9, 1993
Tourism Week in Tompkins County - May 2-8, 1993
Mr. Winch, Chairman, Airport Construction Committee, stated that with the New Terminal project
underway, it was decided that this would be an opportunity to change the logo of the Tompkins County
Airport. He stated that a contest was held with 71 entries received. Mr. Winch thanked US Air and
Continental for the generous donations.
Mr. Nicholas, Airport Manager, stated that when he thought up the idea to change the logo for the
Airport, he hoped for a design that would take Tompkins County into the 21st century. Mr. Nicholas
stated that he approached US Air and Continental for prizes and was surprised to learn that each had
donated two round trip tickets to anywhere in their system. Mr. Nicholas thanked people for entering the
contest and presented the first place prize to Jeffrey Miller and the second place prize to Paul Bradley
Chang as the runner-up. Mr. Nicholas thanked US Air and Continental for donating the prizes.
Mr. Winch, Representative, District No. 8, introduced Laurie Goldstein and Whitney Bozelco,
Ithaca College students working closely with the Physical Plant Operation staff on environmental
management. Ms. Goldstein began her presentation reviewing the history of recycling and waste
management at Ithaca College in 1989. She stated that by 1991, 25 percent of the waste stream had been
reduced. She said that since that time waste reduction efforts have continued to expand and stated that
during that time an on -campus composting facility was created at Ithaca College of which the annual goal
is over 200 tons of food waste. This would bring the College to total reduction of 43 percent of diverted
waste. Ms. Goldstein explained the process, used for food -composting at the College. Ms. Bozelco
explained what is involved in the College's Solid Waste Management Program. She stated that since
implementation of the program, the amount of solid waste being delivered to the landfill has been reduced
by approximately 400 tons. She stated that the composting facility has reduced the amount by another
150-200 tons which brings the College's total tonnage being delivered to the landfill by approximately
600 tons. She stated that the program has benefits for both the College and County. She said that future
program goals include increasing the amount of material being recycled by ten percent which result in
another 100 tons being diverted from the waste stream. The College would also like to increase the
capacity of its food composting facility by another 200 tons per year, and to reduce the amount of waste
in its waste stream by two-thirds by the end of 1994. Ms. Bozelco stated that they would also like to
increase the number of students enrolled in the program.
Mr. Winch thanked Tom Brown, Physical Plant Director, Al Cobane, and Rick Couture, also of
Ithaca College and stated that the County is fortunate to have people to work with on the issue of solid
waste.
120
May 4, 1993
Under privilege of the floor, Mr. Mason, Representative, District No. 15, brought to the Boards'
attention that some municipalities are considering extending their spring clean-up days and may ask the
County to wave charges for C&D (construction and demolition) at the landfill as the County did last year.
Under privilege of the floor, Mr. Lerner, Representative, District No. 1, spoke about a meeting he
attended concerning a project called Ithacanet. The concept is to create local public access computer
telecommunications networks. The model being used is the Cleveland Freenet which has been operating
for eight or nine years. The idea is anyone with a personal computer and a modem either at home or at a
business would be able to call to a central server which would make it possible to have E -Mail,
computerized discussion groups, access to international internet of computer services and other related
services at no charge to the user.
Under privilege of the floor, Mr. Lerner, Representative, District No. 1, stated that he had been
shopping at an Ithaca supermarket and explained an experience which he had in line. He stated that a
customer was arguing with a cashier over the price on the shelf and the scanner. The cashier stated that
he/she could not leave his/her station to check the price on the shelf. The cashier proceeded to void items
as requested by the customer. During a conversation with this cashier, Mr. Lerner was told that a cashier
gets penalized for an excess amount of voids.
Mr. Lerner, Chairman of the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, reported on the
solid waste finance committee appointed by the Chairman of the Board to pursue a finance plan for solid
waste for 1994 and thereafter. He said he would be speaking about the revenue side of solid waste and at
another meeting he will speak about the expense side. He said he would not be addressing recycling
revenues, grants and license and permit fees this evening which have all been subtracted out of the figures
being discussed later. He said there are four potential large sources of revenue for the solid waste
program for 1994:
1. Tipping fee - the per ton charge at the transfer station for waste coming in is currently at $95
per ton. The first decision to be made is how high should the tipping fee be. We need to be aware that
the higher the tipping fee the more potential there is of flow control violations. A higher tipping fee is an
incentive to recycle but is also a stronger incentive to dump illegally, irresponsible burning and violate the
flow control law. We also need to be aware that the more the solid waste program is dependent on the
tipping fee the long-term effect will cause a risk because the program is designed to reduce the tonnage in
future years. If the tonnage decreases every year then the financing is too dependent on tonnage
dependent revenues and will result in a shrinking revenue stream.
2. Annual fee - the perception is that the fee is unfair and is expensive to administer. We are
spending over $100,000 this year administering the fee with sending out the bills and processing the
payments. However after the first year, the amount decreases.
3. Property tax - any solid waste related expenses shifted back to property tax will result in
increases. The Board is already dealing with potential increases for a number of other reasons.
Mr. Lerner stated at this time that in the 1993 and 1994 budget there is approximately $1 million in
expenses for maintenance and closure of old landfills: Caswell, Hillview and DR -7. These expenses are
not related to the current tonnages in solid waste. The Board may wish to pursue the possibility of
including these expenses in the property tax.
4. Recycling fee - may be based on the weight or volume of recycling put out at the curb by a
home or delivered to the recycling center by a business. This may be a disincentive to recycle. In 1994,
13,500 tons of recycling is being budgeted.
121
May 4, 1993
Mr. Lerner distributed and explained a draft outline of solid waste financing options for 1994. It
outlined the 1992 system, six options based on a $120 tipping fee, and two options with lowering the
tipping fee. He stated that the outline is not a proposal for the solution; it is a statement of the problem.
Mrs. Livesay asked if the expense of administering the collection of the recycling and the logistics
of opening the recycling center were discussed. Mr. Lerner said no but the logistics of access to the
recycling center will be reviewed in the next couple of months.
Mr. Proto asked if the approximate cost of the Central Processing Facility with the bonding has
been reflected in the $6 million total solid waste budget. Mr. Lerner said the debt service is included.
Mr. Proto also asked if there was an optimum and/or not so optimum tipping fee.
Ms. Mink spoke about option C-1 but suggested changing the annual fee to recycling fee. Mr.
Lerner said landfill closure is also included in the $45 annual fee and that it does not only include
recycling costs. He said this year and if the Board continues with the annual fee next year it would
include landfill closure costs (approximately $1 million) and recycling expenses. She asked if the landfill
closure costs could be included in the property tax instead. Mrs. Call agreed.
Mr. Stein said he was concerned with the household fee because of the changed rules established
several years ago; you pay for what you make. He said he preferred the recycling fee over the annual fee
because a person has some options to control their costs. He feels the recycling fee is incentive to
purchase recyclable material as where the household fee removes that incentive. He stated his preference
is a combination of a recycling fee and a tipping fee.
Mrs. Livesay cautioned against calling the annual fee a recycling fee. The annual fee includes
more than recycling expenses. The fee also includes landfill closure and maintenance.
Mr. Lerner stated that the collection mechanism by which the County decides to acquire needed
revenue is what he is primarily concerned with at this time. If the County should choose to adopt a
recycling fee, the revenue would reflect the volume or weight of recyclables brought in, which would still
fall far short of the needed revenue. If the annual fee mechanism is used, the County could determine the
amount of revenue needed and establish a fee that could yield the needed revenue.
Mr. Joseph referred to B-1 in the draft outline of Solid Waste Financing Options and asked what an
11.3 percent property tax increase would translate to in a dollar amount. Mr. Heyman stated that an
average single-family homeowner would pay approximately an additional $46 per year based on a
$100,000 home. Mr. Joseph stated that the adoption of an annual fee would have less impact on property
owners than a property tax increase because the fee includes not-for-profit agencies and tax-exempt
properties.
Mr. Lerner concluded the discussion by asking Board members to submit questions and comments
in writing.
Mr. Proto, Chairman, Health and Education Committee, reported that the Committee met April 27
and had a presentation on the status of the Job Training Council. It was decided at that meeting to revive
Kris Deluca -Beach's proposal regarding the addition of a service coordinator for the County. He stated
that the Committee received an update from the Healthy Heart program on the school lunch program. He
stated that Suzanne Stopen, Director, Children with Special Needs Program, attended the meeting and
gave a presentation on that program. Mr. Proto said that the six month report regarding the Dental
Hygienist in -school program was placed on desks this evening. On April 29 he attended, along with
Chairman Watros, a meeting in Cortland of the Nine County Regional Body at which the topic was rabies
and how it affects Upstate New York. He said that Tompkins Cortland Community College will be using
the former McCurdy's building downtown. The next Committee meeting will be May 25.
122
May 4, 1993
Mr. Evans, Chairman, Personnel Committee, stated that the Committee met on April 29 and
completed the development of a questionnaire to gather input from the Board on the evaluation of each of
the four employees which report to the Board. Comments and suggestions will be solicited for this from
Board members. Mr. Evans stated that the initial interview process for the position of Commissioner of
Personnel has been completed. The next Committee meeting will be April 27 at 8 a.m.
Ms. Mink, Chairman, Human Services Committee, stated that the Committee met this morning and
heard from the Office for the Aging on pending legislation that would provide a central access point for
users of long-term health care. She stated that more information on this will follow. Nancy Zahler,
Youth Bureau Director, updated the Committee on several issues including the number of clients served
and their demographic configurations since the County took over Youth Bureau funding in 1988. She
stated that there has been a 65 percent increase in the number of youth served, 20 percent more youth
served from the rural area. Ms. Mink stated that the walk-through survey at the Depaitment of Social
Services will be held next week and stated that the results of surveys will be available near the end of the
month. She reported that the security system implementation at the building is going well and is ahead of
schedule.
Ms. Mink, Public Information Committee, stated that a live call-in and panel discussion will be
held on May 11 at 7 p.m. to discuss item pricing/scanner accuracy.
Mr. Mason, Chairman, Public Safety Committee, reported on a letter of appreciation Jack Miller,
Fire, Disaster and EMS Coordinator, received from Chief Gunderson of the Aurora Fire Depallinent
concerning a major fire on March 25 in Aurora and thanking Tompkins County their help and for sharing
its truck mounted cascade system at the fire scene. Mr. Mason stated that the Public Safety Committee
meeting scheduled for May 6 has been rescheduled for May 14 at noon.
Mr. Stein, Chairman, Planning Committee, reported on the situation with cooperation with Cornell
University and the community having to do with the sale of goods and services at the campus. He stated
that he attended a meeting yesterday and reviewed the new rules and regulations that were instituted a
year ago and stated that there is a new mood of cooperation and it seems that the problems the County
was facing a few years ago have been solved. Mr. Stein reported that the Planning Depaitment has begun
the process of developing a vision plan/comprehensive plan for the County which will be a one to three
year process. He stated that an ad-hoc committee has been created to make recommendations to the
County.
Mr. Winch, Chairman, Public Works and Construction Management Committee, made mention
that he has been receiving questions and comments concerning what the economic impact of the storm
and flood has been on the County's infrastructure. He stated that Tompkins County did not receive as
much damage as some surrounding counties. Mr. Winch stated that staff is compiling information on
this and it will be available soon.
Mr. Todd, Chairman, Fiscal Affairs Committee, stated that the Committee met on April 28 and
completed work on the Fiscal Plan and forwarded it to the Budget and Administration Committee for its
next meeting along with a recommendation for Board members' salaries. He stated that a statement of
purpose for the County was advanced through the Fiscal Affairs Committee and will be sent to employees
and the public for comment before bringing it to this Board. The Committee also discussed whether
another community survey will be conducted. The next Committee meeting will be May 13 at 10:30 a.m.
Mr. Lerner, Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, said the Committee
met on April 22. He mentioned that a copy of the resolution adopted by the Board on March 30
authorizing the negotiating committee to go forward with the Central Processing Facility was sent to each
of the vendors. A meeting has been scheduled for May 11 and 12 with these vendors. He stated that a
meeting was held today with the sub -committee looking at expanding the markets for the County's
recyclables.
123
May 4, 1993
Mrs. Livesay, Intergovernmental Representative, reported that she and Chairman Watros met with
town supervisors and village mayors on April 21 and discussed the recent sales tax agreement with the
City. She stated that they were pleased that they were invited to this meeting and that the meeting went
well. She reported on the issue of low-level radioactive waste which is severely impacting Cortland
County.
Mrs. Call, Chairman, Budget and Administration Committee, stated that the next Committee
meeting will be May 10 at 11:30 a.m. at which time they will be discussing the proposed Scanner
Accuracy Law. Mrs. Call stated that Mr. Squires, Comptroller, gave an update on sales tax proceeds
received for the first quarter of 1993 and stated that the County received approximately 25 percent of
budget estimate which he feels is a positive sign.
Mr. Heyman, County Administrator, stated that the Director of Data Processing has announced he
will be retiring at the end of this month. He stated that Kathy West, Deputy County Administrator, Mr.
Lerner and Mr. Evans have agreed to serve on a selection committee for this position. He stated that Pat
Nowalkowski will serve on an interim basis as Acting Director effective June 1. Mr. Heyman also
announced the retirement of Joyce Musson, Executive Assistant to the County Administrator.
Mr. Mulvey, County Attorney, stated that he has submitted his monthly report to the Board office.
He stated that Rubbish Removal has paid their debt in full to the County and are now being served at the
transfer station on a cash basis.
Chairman Watros updated the Board on the consolidation of services with the City. He stated that
he and Mayor Nichols will release a memo tomorrow listing the committees that have been established
and the charge to its members. He also stated that there was a meeting held on April 30 relative to the
flooding conditions in Tompkins County. The meeting was attended by Representative Livesay, Mr.
Heyman, County Administrator, Mr. Miller, Fire and Disaster Coordinator, and a representative from
Assemblyman Luster's office. Following contact with the State, it was concluded that the County has
done everything possible to set in place the ability for those who were impacted to apply for funds
through FEMA or the Small business Administration to get some relief.
On motion of the appropriate committee chairman and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by
voice vote by members present, the following resolution was added to the agenda:
Creation of Position - Assistant Airport Operations Technician - Public Works
Chairman Watros gave the appropriate committee chairman permission to withdraw from the
agenda the following resolution:
Approval of Visitors Survey Committee Expense Account
Chairman Watros gave the appropriate committee chairmen permission to withdraw from the
agenda the following resolutions with final committee action being affirmed:
CA049-93 - Award of Contract - PCAP Software
CA050-93 - Authorization to Execute Contracts - Various Labs - PCAP
CA051-93 - Authorization to Execute Contracts - Photosynthesis Productions - Healthy Heart
Program
CA052-93 - Reclassification of Position - Account Clerk Typist to Senior Account Clerk Typist —
Mental Health Department
124
May 4, 1993
RESOLUTION NO. 130(a) - AUTHORIZING THE ISSUANCE OF CERTAIN BONDS BY THE
TOMPKINS COUNTY INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT AGENCY
AND PLEDGING NON-INTERFERENCE WITH THE RIGHTS OF
THE HOLDERS OF THE BONDS
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mrs. Call. Following a brief discussion a voice vote resulted as
follows: Ayes - 13, Noes - 0, Excused - 2 (Representatives Culligan and Shurtleff). Adopted.
WHEREAS, pursuant to Title I of Article 18-A of the General Municipal Law of the State of New
York (hereinafter referred to as the "State") and Chapter 535 of the Laws of 1971 of the State
(collectively known as the "Act"), the County Board of Representatives of Tompkins County ("the
Board") has heretofore appointed the Chairman and members of the Tompkins County Industrial
Development Agency (the "IDA") and has duly caused to be filed in the office of the Secretary of State
the certificates required by Section 856 of the General Municipal Law, and
WHEREAS, the County has been advised by the IDA that the IDA proposes to issue, contingent
upon the adoption of this resolution, its Civic Facility Revenue Bonds (Glenwood Handicapped Services,
Inc. Facility) in an aggregate principal amount sufficient to pay substantially all of the cost of acquiring,
constructing, renovating and equipping the below described facility (the "Facility"), presently estimated to
be up to $2,000,000 (the "Bonds"), and
WHEREAS, the Facility shall consist of the acquisition, construction and equipping of
approximately 10,000 square foot facility adjacent to the existing facility of Glenwood Handicapped
Services, Inc., at 21 Wilkens Road, Ithaca, New York and the renovation and equipping of such existing
facility, and
WHEREAS, the Facility shall be leased with an option to purchase by the IDA to Glenwood
Handicapped Services, Inc. (the "Company"), and
WHEREAS, it is the intent of the IDA that interest on the Bonds qualify for exemption from
Federal income taxation pursuant to Section 145 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended (the
"Code"), and
WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 147 (f) of the Code, interest on the Bonds will not qualify for
exemption from Federal income taxation unless the issuance of the Bonds is approved by the Board after
a public hearing to consider both the issuance of the Bonds and the nature and location of the Facility has
been conducted following reasonable public notice, and
WHEREAS, such public hearing has been duly held and a report of such hearing has been made
available to each member of the Board prior to this meeting, and
WHEREAS, Section 870 of the General Municipal Law of the State specifically provides that
neither the Bonds nor any other obligation of the IDA shall be a debt of the County nor shall the County
be liable thereon, and
WHEREAS, Section 870 of the General Municipal Law of the State, the Board desires to pledge to
and agree with the purchasers and holders of the Bonds that the County will not limit or alter rights and
remedies of the holders of the Bonds, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That for the sole purpose of
qualifying the interest payable on the Bonds for exemption from Federal income taxation pursuant to the
provisions of Section 144 of the Code, the Board, as the elected legislative body of the County hereby
approves the issuance by the IDA of the Bonds, provided that the Bonds, and the premium (if any) and
interest thereon, shall be special obligations of the IDA and shall never be a debt of the State or any
political subdivision thereof, including without limitation, the County and neither the State nor any
political subdivision thereof, including, without limitation, the County, shall be liable thereon,
RESOLVED, further, That in order to induce and encourage the purchase and enhance the
marketability of the Bonds, the County, pursuant to the authorization set forth in Section 868 of the
General Municipal Law, does hereby pledge to and agree with the holders of the Bonds, when, as and if
issued by the IDA, that the County will not limit or alter the rights vested in the IDA pursuant to the Act
to acquire, hold, lease, maintain and sell the Facility, to establish and collect rentals, fees, installments of
purchase price and other charges, therefrom, to pledge such rentals, fees, installments of purchase price
and other charges, to grant a security interest in the Facility and to fulfill the terms of any agreements
125
May 4, 1993
made by the IDA with the holders of such Bonds nor in anyway impair the rights and remedies of the
holders of such Bonds, until such Bonds, together with the interest thereon, with interest on any unpaid
installments of interest and all costs and expenses in connection with any action or proceeding by or on
behalf of the holders of the Bonds, are fully met and discharged,
RESOLVED, further, That this resolution shall be deemed to be made for the benefit of the
holders, from time to time, of the Bonds and shall constitute a contract between the County and the
holders of the Bonds,
RESOLVED, further, That this resolution, once recommended by the Planning Committee and
approved by the Board, shall take effect immediately.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 131 - CONTINUED SUPPORT FOR COMMUNITY ARTS PARTNERSHIP
"WORLD OF ART" PLAN
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, the Community Arts Partnership (C.A.P.) has demonstrated the potential of its World
of Art marketing plan, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the Advisory Board on
Tourism Development shall provide C.A.P. with $3,500 in additional support.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 132 - AUTHORIZATION TO HOLD A PUBLIC HEARING ON SMALL
CITIES APPLICATION AND COMPREHENSIVE HOUSING
AFFORDABILITY STRATEGY (CHAS)
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Ms. Mink, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, Tompkins County is considering submitting an application to the United States
Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) for a Small Cities Community Development
Block Grant (CDBG), and
WHEREAS, a public hearing is required for the application and the Comprehensive Housing
Affordability Strategy (CHAS) for the County which is required in order for the application to be
submitted, and
WHEREAS, it is desirable to have the public hearing during the month of May in order to have
approval to file the application before the deadline approaches, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the Tompkins County Board
of Representatives will hold a public hearing on the CDBG application and CHAS on Tuesday, May 18,
1993 at 5:30 p.m. in the evening thereof in Board Chambers of the Tompkins County Courthouse, 320
North Tioga Street, Ithaca, New York. At such time and place all persons interested in the subject matter
will be heard concerning the same,
RESOLVED, further, That the Clerk of the Board is hereby authorized and directed to place proper
notice of such public hearing in the official newspaper of the County.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
126
May 4, 1993
RESOLUTION NO. 133 - AGREEMENT FOR CIRCUIT RIDER PLANNING SERVICES WITH
THE TOWN OF GROTON
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, the Town of Groton has requested assistance from the County Planning Depai tnient
for the completion of its Master Plan, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the County Administrator or
his designee be authorized to sign a contract with Groton in an amount of $3,904 for Planning Services
and $900 for newsletter production to be paid to the County,
RESOLVED, further, That monies from the contract be deposited in Account No. A8020.2770
(unclassified revenues).
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 134 - ACCEPTANCE OF FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION
(FAA) GRANT OFFER - TOMPKINS COUNTY AIRPORT - NEW
TERMINAL PROJECT (PHASE 2)
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Todd, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, the FAA has made a grant offer for Federal assistance in connection with the
construction of the New Terminal Project, and
WHEREAS, said grant offer is from FY 93 Airport Improvement Program (AIP) Entitlement
Funds, representing the remaining eligible areas of the new terminal and designated as a Phase 2 grant,
now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the grant offer of $88,883 is hereby accepted and the County Administrator is authorized to execute
the grant agreement.
SEQR ACTION: TYPE I
(NEGATIVE DECLARATION ON FILE)
RESOLUTION NO. 135 - CREATION OF POSITION - ASSESSMENT DEPARTMENT
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Personnel and Budget and Administration Committees,
That one position of Real Property Appraiser Trainee (11/710), labor grade K (11), competitive class, be
created effective April 20, 1993.
RESOLVED, further, That no new monies are need to fund this change in 1993.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 136 - CREATION OF POSITION - ASSISTANT AIRPORT OPERATIONS
TECHNICIAN
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto. There was discussion on whether this was intended
to be a temporary position, therefore, it was suggested that a time -frame be included in this resolution. It
127
May 4, 1993
was Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present, to amend the resolution adding the following: "RESOLVED, further, That this position shall
exist through August 31, 1993". A voice vote on the resolution as amended resulted as follows: Ayes -
13, Noes - 0, Excused - 2 (Representatives Culligan and Shurtleff). Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works, Personnel and Budget and Administration
Committees, That one position of Assistant Airport Operations Technician (07/847), labor grade G (7),
competitive class, be created effective immediately,
RESOLVED, further, That no new monies are needed to fund this change in 1993,
RESOLVED, further, That this position shall exist through August 31, 1993.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
On motion of the appropriate committee chairmen and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by
voice vote by members present, the following appointments were made to various advisory boards:
Agricultural and Farmland Protection Board
Terms expire December 31, 1993
Laurie Todd - Farmer representative
David Hardie - Agri -Business representative
Frank P. Proto - County representative
Terms expire December 31, 1994
Mary Beth Holub - Farmer representative
Donald Barber - Land Preservation representative
Terms expire December 31, 1995
Roger Gleason - Farmer representative
George Holmes - Farmer representative
Office for the Aging Advisory Committee
Term expires December 31, 1995
Willard Daetsch
Economic Opportunity Corporation
Patricia Driscoll - Town of Ithaca representative
Barbara Barry - Town of Lansing representative
Environmental Management Council
Term expires December 31, 1993
Ronald M. Beloin - Town of Enfield representative
Tompkins County Youth Board
Term expires December 31, 1993
Charles V. Evans - County representative
Terms expires December 31, 1995
Ronald Simpson - Town of Ithaca representative
Debbie Fitzpatrick - Town of Danby representative
Anthony B. Deluca - Mental Health representative
Chairman Watros announced that there will be a Flag Day parade and if anyone is interested to
contact him.
Chairman Watros declared recess from 7:48 - 7:55 p.m.
128
May 4, 1993
On motion and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members present, that an
executive session be held to discuss a personnel matter. An executive session was held from 7:55 p.m. to
8:05 p.m.
On motion, the meeting adjourned at 8:05 p.m.
129
May 18, 1993
Regular Meeting
Public Hearing
Chairman Watros called the public hearing to order at 5:30 p.m. concerning the Small Cities
Community Development Block Grant Application and Comprehensive Housing Affordability Strategy
(CHAS). Chairman Watros asked if anyone wished to speak?
James Hanson, Planning Commissioner, spoke concerning the Small Cities Community Block
Grant Program and the Comprehensive Housing Affordability Strategy. He stated that in the past the
County has been successful in obtaining funds for the Town of Caroline to rehabilitate low to moderate
income housing. The Town of Enfield was also assisted in completing an application for funds for
housing rehabilitation. Mr. Hanson introduced David Carlson, Consultant, who gave a brief overview of
the Small Cities program. Mr. Carlson stated that the program has been in existence since 1978 and is an
annual funding competition run through the Department of Housing and Urban Development. This year
approximately 200 communities across New York State applied with approximately 75 applications being
accepted. This year Tompkins County is looking at a County -sponsored home -ownership program that
would be available Countywide which the Planning Deparinient feels is much needed in the County. Karl
Heck, Administrative Coordinator, updated the Board on meetings that have been held with lending
institutions, stating that five have made preliminary commitments to the program. He stated that a survey
was completed of potential applicants to the program which showed a strong level of interest. Based on
several sources of information, it is the opinion of the Department that this is a much needed program in
Tompkins County.
No one else wished to speak and Chairman Watros closed the public hearing at 5:55 p.m.
Members and guests participated in the Pledge of Allegiance.
Present: 15 Representatives.
It was Moved by Mr. Evans, seconded by Ms. Mink, and unanimously adopted by voice vote to
approve the minutes of May 4, 1993 as corrected.
Chairman Watros presented a proclamation to Betsy Crane, Executive Director of Planned
Parenthood, declaring the week of May 17 to be Planned Parenthood 25th Anniversary Week in
Tompkins County.
Chairman Watros presented a proclamation to Marilyn Strassberg, Aging Services Specialist for
the Office for the Aging, declaring the month of May, 1993 to be Older Americans Month in Tompkins
County.
Under privilege of the floor, Lars Washburn, Forest Home Drive, spoke concerning the resolution
on the agenda entitled Responsibility for County Bridges on Town Highways. Mr. Washburn urged the
Board to table or not support this resolution and continue with the intention to rebuild the Forest Home
Bridge.
Chairman Watros noted that the above-mentioned resolution will be withdrawn from the agenda.
Under privilege of the floor, Mr. Culligan, Representative, District No. 2, displayed a picture he
took of a closed landfill site in the San Francisco Bay area. He stated that there are several businesses
very close to the site. He stated that his point is that if landfills are closed correctly, it is not a waste of
land.
130
May 18, 1993
Under privilege of the floor, Mrs. Schuler, Representative, District No. 4, announced that the
week of May 17 is Try -transit week. She also expressed concern that a AAA publication listing tourist
events for the summer only included one Tompkins County event.
Mr. Proto, Chairman, Health and Education Committee, reported that there will be a luncheon on
April 21 at Tompkins Cortland Community College to review their proposed budget. He said that Irene
Stein, Office for the Aging Director, will attend the next Health and Education Committee meeting to
discuss a proposal to create a centralized local access system for long term care services. The next
Committee meeting will be May 25. Mr. Culligan reported that he attended the groundbreaking
ceremony for the Reconstruction Home and stated that this will be another good addition to downtown
Ithaca.
Mr. Evans, Chairman, Personnel Committee, reported that the Committee has not met since the
last Board meeting. There will be a meeting on May 20 at noon to start the interview process for the
Public Health Director. The next Committee meeting will be May 24 at which time interviews will take
place with the finalists for the position of Personnel Commissioner. Mr. Evans distributed evaluation
forms for the four employees who report to the Board. He asked for comments on the form be submitted.
Ms. Mink, Chairman, Human Services Committee, reported that she attended the Biggs A
Environmental Review Task Force meeting as a follow-up to the walk through that was done. She stated
that a preliminary report is not completed at this time but questions were formalized which focused on
issues of ventilation and composition of materials in the building. She reported on a meeting held with
the working group from the City to consolidate human services and stated that the meeting was very
productive.
Mr. Mason, Chairman, Public Safety Committee, reported that the committee met on May 14 at
noon and primarily discussed the Sheriffs Department needs assessment. Mr. Mason made reference to a
report on the Department prepared by Deputy County Administrator, Kathy West. Mr. Mason stated that
a motion to release the report to the public failed at the Committee meeting. However, since that time, a
press release has been issued by the Deputy Sheriffs Association and he felt that with concurrence by the
committee, it would be appropriate to release the report at this time. Mr. Mason expressed outrage at the
press release issued by the Deputy Sheriffs Association and stated that the report addressed issues that the
Committee asked it to. He stated that the Committee met prior to the Board meeting and discussed an
Alternatives to Incarceration proposal. He stated that the proposal will reduce the population of the Jail
and possibly allow the County to board prisoners in and reduces the chances of boarding prisoners out.
Mr. Evans, Chairman, Community Mental Health Services Board, stated that the Community Mental
Health Services Board approves and recommends this proposal.
Mr. Stein, Chairman, Planning Committee, stated that the committee met this morning and had a
report from Harry Missirian, Deputy Commissioner of Planning, on the County's response to the
American Disability Act. Mr. Stein stated that the Committee also heard a brief review of a five-year
plan for the Transit system. He announced that Mary Smith, Environmental Management Coordinator,
and Jeanne Barrett, Circuit Rider for the Planning Department, had accepted other positions and will be
leaving the Planning Depaitnient. There will be a special committee meeting on June 3.
Mr. Winch, Chairman, Public Works and Construction Management Committee, reported on
damages and the economic impact of Blizzard '93. Mr. Winch stated the County would incur cost
overruns as a result of erosion and sedimentation caused by the weather and would have a major impact
on the work the Public Works Department has planned for County roads this summer.
Mr. Stein, Representative, District No. 3, spoke to the resolution intended for withdrawal on the
agenda entitled Responsibility for County Bridges on Town Highways. He stated that he believes this
resolution needs to deal with the needs of communities in the County on an individual basis. He feels
131
May 18, 1993
those towns who cannot afford to take care of bridges in their communities should be helped more than
those towns who can afford it.
Mr. Todd, Chairman, Fiscal Affairs Committee, stated that the committee met May 13 and
discussed a means of allocating some funds, separate from the Contingent Fund, to be set aside and
distributed based on priorities. There was a discussion on what would be considered a priority and the
process by which a department would receive funds. There was concern expressed by Mr. Joseph, Mr.
Stein and Mrs. Livesay over an application process being used to apply for these funds. Mr. Todd stated
that the committee will continue to work on this and stated that the committee hopes to have a fiscal plan
available in June. Mr. Lerner stated that if the Fiscal Affairs Committee should decide to conduct a
community survey, he would like the full Board to review the survey before it goes to the public. The
next meeting is May 27, 1993.
Mr. Lerner, Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, reported that the
Committee met May 13. He reported that the Negotiating Committee for the Recycling and Solid Waste
Center has met with the vendors and will meet again next week. He stated that there is continued
discussion in the area of solid waste financing and he will give a discussion at length on this subject at the
June 1 Board meeting. He stated that Mrs. Livesay is chairing a sub -committee of the Solid Waste and
Resource Management Committee which is working on revisions to the Solid Waste Management Plan.
The target is to have final approval of revisions to the Plan before the end of 1993. He reminded Board
members that Marcal will have a tree planting ceremony at the Recycling and Solid Waste Center and all
are welcome to attend.
Mrs. Livesay, Intergovernmental Representative, stated that she will be distributing a packet of
pending legislative resolutions to Board members so that committees can review these and possibly act on
them June 1.
Mrs. Call, Chairman, Budget and Administration Committee, stated that the committee met May
10 and reviewed Administrative policies and will continue work on this in June. She stated that the
committee received the first quarter financial report and stated that she feels the Fiscal Plan was
absolutely necessary and that it is working. She reported that the proposed Scanner Accuracy Law was
tabled indefinitely at that meeting. The next committee meeting will be June 7 at 11:30 a.m.
Mr. Heyman, County Administrator, reported that he will be submitting a reorganization structure
for his office which will result in a cost savings. He stated that a video on total quality management is
available for Board members, Department Heads and any staff that would like to watch.
Cheryl Nelson, Chair, Employee Council, reported that the committee met on May 5 and discussed
whether it is alright for employees to speak to Board members. She stated that the committee was asked
to develop a list of questions or concerns that employees might have for candidates for the position of
Personnel Commissioner. She stated that the next meeting will be June 2 at 9 a.m. at the Ithaca Tompkins
Transit Center.
Mr. Mulvey, County Attorney, reported that he intends to have a report and recommendation in
June on the status of the Collins' bankruptcy matter.
On motion of the appropriate committee chairman and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by
voice vote the followingresolution was added to the agenda:
Support of Assembly Bill 2384 Pertaining to Collection of Sales Tax at Cornell's Statler Hotel
Chairman Watros gave the appropriate committee chairman permission to withdraw from the
agenda, the following resolutions:
132
May 18, 1993
Authorizing a Public Hearing - Lease Agreement with the Federal Aviation Administration
(FAA) - Land at the Tompkins County Airport Used for a Visual Approach Slope Indicator
(VASI) Air Navigation Aid
Responsibility for County Bridges on Town Highways
Chairman Watros gave the appropriate committee chairmen permission to withdraw from the
agenda the following resolutions with final committee action being affirmed:
CA053-93 - Budget Adjustments and Appropriations - Various Departments
CA054-93 - Amendment of Resolution No. CA043-93 - Budget Adjustments and Appropriations
- Various Departments
CA055-93 - Authorization to Contract - Task Force for Battered Women - Depaitiiient of Social
Services
RESOLUTION NO. 137 AUTHORIZATION TO APPLY FOR U.S. DEPARTMENT OF
HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT FUNDS FOR SMALL
CITIES COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT
PROGRAM
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, Tompkins County is eligible to apply for U.S. Department of Housing and Urban
Development Funds for Small Cities Community Development (HUD) funds through its Small Cities
Community Development Block Grant (SCCDBG) program, and
WHEREAS, the County has an application which meets the eligibility requirements to receive
funds through the SCCDBG program, and
WHEREAS, the County has held the required public hearing for the application before final Board
of Representatives approval, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the County Planning
Department is authorized to complete an application to HUD for SCCDBG funding,
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator or his designee is authorized to sign the
application on behalf of the Board.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 138 - AWARD OF BID - RUNWAY 14 EXTENSION AND PARALLEL
TAXIWAY - TOMPKINS COUNTY AIRPORT
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Culligan, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, the Division of Purchasing and Central Services has duly advertised for bids to
construct an extension to Runway 14 and parallel taxiway, together with a new mandated signage
program and wetlands compensation, in accordance with specifications as approved by the Public Works
and Construction Management Committee, the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), and the New
York State Department of Transportation (NYSDOT), and
WHEREAS, three bids were received and publicly opened and read on April, 28, 1993, now
therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction management Committee,
That the bid for construction of the runway extension be awarded to Chemung Contracting Corporation of
Pine City (nr. Elmira , New York as being the lowest responsible bidder in the amount of $3,274,587,
subject to agreement by the FAA and NYSDOT,
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator is hereby authorized to execute a contract
with Chemung Contracting Corporation to implement this bid,
133
May 18, 1993
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller is hereby authorized to borrow monies until
reimbursement is received from the FAA, NYSDOT, and Passenger Facility Charges (PFC's), and that the
funding sources shall be as follows:
FAA Share (90%) Account No. HU5610.4592 $2,947,128
NYSDOT Share (5%) .3592 163,729
PFC's Share (5%) .2831 163,730
Total Account No. HU5610.9239 $3,274,587
RESOLVED, further, That a project contingency of ten percent be established, funds being
available in Account No. HU5610.9239 and the County Administrator be authorized to sign future change
orders up to the project contingency amount.
SEQR ACTION: TYPE I
(NEGATIVE DECLARATION ON FILE)
RESOLUTION NO. 139 - AWARD OF BID - CONSTRUCTION OF THE NEW T -HANGARS -
TOMPKINS COUNTY AIRPORT
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Todd, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, the Division of Purchasing and Central Services has duly advertised for bids for the
construction of the new T -Hangars at the Tompkins County Airport, and
WHEREAS, bids were received for the two (2) contracts and publicly opened on Friday, May 14,
1993, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the bid be awarded as follows:
CONTRACT DESCRIPTION CONTRACTOR AWARD AMOUNT
General Construction Daniel J. Lynch $292,800
Endwell, New York
Electrical John Rogers Electrical $ 24,686
Binghamton, New York
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator or his designee be and hereby is authorized
to execute agreements on behalf of Tompkins County for the implementation of these bids,
RESOLVED, further, That the project contingency of ten (10) percent of the contracts total be
allocated for miscellaneous project expenses, staff services, and change orders not to exceed $82,514,
RESOLVED, further, That all funds for said project are available in the Capital`Account.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 140 - AUTHORIZING SUPPLEMENTARY AGREEMENT NO. 2 WITH
C&S ENGINEERS, INC. FOR DESIGN OF AIRCRAFT RAMP AND
TAXIWAY CONNECTOR - SERVICES IN CONNECTION WITH
ACQUISITION OF A NEW STATE POLLUTANT DISCHARGE
ELIMINATION SYSTEM (SPDES) DISCHARGE PERMIT
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, there are changes to the Airport's drainage pattern brought about by the New
Terminal Project and the runway extension, and
WHEREAS, the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) requires a
modification to the State Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (SPDES) permit, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management and Budget
and Administration Committees, That a supplementary agreement for $7,626 with C&S Engineers, Inc.
be hereby approved and that the County Administrator be authorized to execute said supplementary
134
May 18, 1993
agreement, subject to approval by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) and New York State
Depai tuient of Transportation (NYSDOT), and that the funding sources shall be as follows:
FAA Share (90%) Account No. 5610.4592 $6,863
NYSDOT Share (5%) Account No. 5610.3592 381
PFC's (5%) Account No. 5610.5031 382
Total Account No. 5610.9239 $7,626
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller be authorized to borrow monies until reimbursement is
received from the FAA, NYSDOT and Passenger Facility Charges (PFC's).
SEQR ACTION: TYPE I
(NEGATIVE DECLARATION ON FILE)
RESOLUTION NO. 141 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE LEASE AGREEMENT WITH
ODYSSEY RESEARCH ASSOCIATES, 1992-1994
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Stein, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the County Administrator is directed to execute a lease agreement with Odyssey Research
Associates for the years of 1992, 1993 and 1994.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 142 - AWARD OF BID - BUFFALO ROAD BRIDGE REPLACEMENT
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote. There was
discussion concerning the extraordinary cost of replacing this bridge. Mr. Mobbs, Commissioner of
Public Works, stated that the cost is offset by other bridges costing less to replace. Mrs. Livesay inquired
about the schedule for maintenance of bridges including maintenance of the Forest Home bridge. Mr.
Mobbs stated that maintenance of the bridge has not been scheduled because the issue of ownership of the
bridge has yet to be resolved. Chairman Watros requested the Committee to resolve this issue at the next
Board meeting.
WHEREAS, the Division of Purchasing and Central Services has duly advertised for bids for
Buffalo Road Bridge Replacement, and
WHEREAS, seven (7) bids were received and duly opened April 29, 1993, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the bid be awarded to G. DeVincentis Construction of Binghamton, New York as the lowest
responsible bidder with a base bid of $364,821.20,
RESOLVED, further, That the Department of Public Works be and hereby is authorized to execute
an agreement on behalf of Tompkins County,
RESOLVED, further, That the Commissioner of Public Works be and hereby is authorized to
execute project change orders up to $35,000,
RESOLVED, further, That all funds for said project are available in the 5110.4411.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 143 - CREATION OF POSITION - KEYBOARD SPECIALIST -
TEMPORARY - PCAP
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
135
May 18, 1993
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education and Budget and Administration
Committees, That one position of Keyboard Specialist (05/507), labor grade E, competitive class, be
created for a period not to exceed seven weeks in 1993,
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller is hereby authorized and directed to make the
following transfer on his books:
FROM: 4023.2214 Office Furnishings $ 533
.2222 Communication Equipment 700
.4402 Legal Advertising 934
TO: 4023.1507 Keyboard Specialist $ 2,167
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 144 - 1994 HUMAN SERVICES COALITION BUDGET REVIEW
GUIDELINES
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Ms. Mink, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, the Board of Representatives desires Tompkins County funds for health and human
service agencies that are not included in County departmental budgets nor reviewed by any County
department heads to be allocated in a manner that best meets the needs for these services, and
WHEREAS, the Human Services Coalition is established and funded in part by Tompkins County
to provide an objective overview of health and human service needs and provisions based on expert
analysis, and
WHEREAS, it is expected that the Human Services Coalition will strive to optimize the use of
available funds for the delivery of services in Tompkins County and advocate for new services for which
a need has been determined, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Human Services and Budget and Administration
Committees, That the Human Services Coalition is requested, pursuant to the 1992 contract with
Tompkins County, to recommend to the Board of Representatives, no later than September 1, 1993, a
minimum of $209,536 plus the inflation increment specified in the 1993-94 Fiscal Plan. The Human
Services Coalition may recommend additional funding to address the needs of human services in the
County. These recommendations may be treated as special requests by the County,
RESOLVED, further, That the following process shall be used by the Coalition in its review of
requests for the funding:
1. The Coalition may recommend funding for a portion of a request;
2. The Coalition is not required to recommend expenditure of all of the funds allocated by the
County;
3. By September 1, 1993, the Human Services Coalition shall present the results of its review of
all requests within the dollar allocation as established by the Board of Representatives;
4. Special situations shall be referred, to the Chairman of the Budget and Administration
Committee before the Coalition begins its review process;
5. The Coalition may discontinue its review of any agency application; in the event this occurs, the
Board of Representatives shall be notified and all documentation shall be provided by the Coalition of
its reasons for taking such action;
6. Funding applications must state the benefits to be derived from implementation of the program
and the specific goals of the program;
7. If, during the review process, a program does not meet the minimum standards established by
the Human Services Coalition, the Coalition may consider recommending conditional funding. The
Coalition will recommend the conditions of the funding.
8. If any agency decides not to offer a service, or the Human Services coalition determines during
the review process that a provider is no longer able to offer the service, but the need for the service is
still found to be high, the Human Services Coalition may request that money be encumbered for that
136
May 18, 1993
service, subject to final review and recommendation by the Human Services Coalition to the Human
Services Committee.
9. If any program, previously reviewed through the Human Services Coalition process, is to be
reviewed through any other County process in 1993, the 1993 dollars attached to the program will be part
of the review process.
RESOLVED, further, That the Coalition will use as the basis for allocation of funds the following
criteria:
1. Severity of the need that the program identifies and addresses in Tompkins County;
2. Financial need of the client population;
3. Effect on the Tompkins County community if the service is not available or is available at a
reduced level;
4. Agency's organizational ability to deliver proposed services and meet the needs of clients;
5. Effectiveness of agency planning, and management of fiscal and personnel resources;
6. Agency financial need, including needs caused by cost of living increases;
Where necessary, the Coalition's recommendations shall also take note of problems concerning
duplication of service or countywide service delivery, though these should not be scored among the above
criteria in the evaluation instrument,
RESOLVED, further, That in its 1994 Work Plan, the Coalition will continue a systematic review
of all agencies receiving health or human service grant funding from Tompkins County. This review
shall evaluate efficiency of agency administration and effectiveness of service delivery. The Coalition
shall make a recommendation to the appropriate program committee and the Budget and Administration
Committee for recommending to the Board of Representatives by December 1, 1993 a plan for this
review and specific actions to be taken in 1994,
RESOLVED, further, That the Human Services Committee in coordination with the Human
Services Coalition is asked to continue exploration of multi-year funding and other areas, as part of
looking at the entire funding review process,
RESOLVED, further, That the Human Services Coalition take the lead in helping agencies find
ways to consolidate common costs, like administrative services, space, etc.,
RESOLVED, further, That at the close of the review process, the Coalition shall conduct an annual
written survey of the agencies, soliciting feedback, suggestions and constructive criticism on the review
process and the activities of the Coalition, and that a summary of the results of this survey shall be
distributed to the agencies and to the Human Services Committee,
RESOLVED, further, That the Human Services Coalition will evaluate and update its plan to
reduce the total time and money agencies must spend on local review by funders for the 1994 funding
cycle and continue to reduce time and money agencies spend on review in the future.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 145 - REFUND OF ELECTION EXPENSE PAYMENTS
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, during 1992 the County Comptroller billed the municipalities for their share of
election expenses, and
WHEREAS, subsequent to this billing the State Comptroller issued an opinion advising that
election expense chargebacks by county government were not fully authorized by the Election Law, and
WHEREAS, the majority of municipalities within the County have advised that they would not
remit payment on election expense billings because of the New York State Comptroller's opinion, and
WHEREAS, the Towns of Caroline and Danby have paid their 1992 election expense charges and
have now requested that their payments be refunded, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the
Comptroller is hereby authorized to refund 1992 election expense payments remitted by the Towns of
Caroline and Danby.
137
May 18, 1993
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 146 - ESTABLISHING BOARD MEMBER SALARIES - 1994-1997
(Amended by R.365 of 1993)
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Shurtleff. Mrs. Call stated that the Budget and
Administration Committee discussed this resolution at length and decided to bring it to the full Board for
discussion.
Mr. Shurtleff stated that he feels strongly that by setting Board members salaries too low, it
discriminates against the lower income segment of the population that may wish to be on the Board. It
was Moved by Mr. Shurtleff, seconded by Ms. Mink, to increase Board salaries to $10,000 each year for
the four year period. Mrs. Livesay suggested an average of $10,000 over the four year period and
maintaining an annual increase.
Mr. Culligan stated that he feels this amendment is aimed at the working person and the only way
this would work, a lot of things would have to change because working people cannot attend committee
and other meetings that are scheduled during the work day. Mrs. Livesay stated that she disagreed with
this statement because she feels meeting times are scheduled to meet the needs of committee members.
Mr. Lerner stated that he feels the point trying to be made by Mr. Shurtleff is that there are several people
in the community who would make very good Board members but cannot afford to maintain a full-time
job and serve on the Board. By having a reasonable Board salary, combined with income from a part-
time job, an individual may be less burdened financially which would allow them to serve.
Mr. Stein stated that he sees the difference between the original proposal and the amendment
totaling $2,800 for four years for each Board member. He stated that although he believes the issue is
valid, an increase of this amount would not make a difference.
Mr. Culligan and Mr. Evans cautioned against increasing Board salaries too much because the
current CSEA contract will expire at the end of the year and it may send a message to employees that
would make negotiations more difficult in the Fall. Mr. Evans stated that he does not feel the argument
that the increase proposed in the amendment will make a difference in attracting the public is valid
because it is only a slight increase.
Mr. Joseph stated that the issue of getting paid for time spent working on Board activities is very
important to him. He stated that he quit a half-time position in order to take on the responsibilities
associated with serving and relies on being compensated with at least a half-time salary.
Mr. Todd stated that he looks at this job as public service and thinks that to attract a larger group of
candidates, committee and other meetings will have to be held in the evening as they were in the past.
Mr. Todd stated that this Board has to set an example of prudence for Tompkins County Government and
taxpayers.
It was Moved by Mr. Todd, seconded by Mr. Winch, to amend the amendment by substituting the
following salaries, and leaving in place the Chairman receiving a salary of 1.5 percent above Board
members:
RESOLVED, on minority recommendation of the Fiscal Affairs Committee, That the annual salary
for the members of the Board of Representatives is hereby established as follows:
Effective January 1, 1994 $ 8,450
Effective January 1, 1995 8,600
Effective January 1, 1996 8,750
138
May 18, 1993
Effective January 1, 1997 8,900
Mr. Proto stated that there is something to be said for being paid what is fair and sees a different
perception amongst Board members. However, he does not think that the dollar amount that is being
disputed will make a difference.
Mrs. Call stated that the Board should consider the perception the public will have if the salary
increases by a large percentage. She expressed caution due to it soon being negotiation time and also
referred the cost of living increase that will be built into the Fiscal Plan and will govern the budget
increases.
A roll call vote on the amendment to the amendment resulted as follows: Ayes - 5
(Representatives Culligan, Evans, Proto, Todd and Winch), Noes - 10 (Representatives Call, Joseph,
Lerner, Livesay, Mason, Mink, Schuler, Shurtleff, Stein and Watros). Motion Lost.
A roll call vote on the amendment resulted as follows: Ayes - 6 (Representatives Joseph, Lerner,
Livesay, Mink, Schuler and Shurtleff), Noes - 9 (Representatives Call, Culligan, Evans, Mason, Proto,
Stein, Todd, Watros and Winch). Motion Lost.
A roll call vote on the original resolution resulted as follows: Ayes - 10 (Representatives Call,
Joseph, Lerner, Livesay, Mason, Mink, Schuler, Shurtleff, Stein and Watros), Noes - 5 (Representatives
Culligan, Evans, Proto, Todd and Winch). Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Fiscal Affairs and Budget and Administration
Committees, That the annual salary for the members of the Board of Representatives is hereby established
as follows:
Effective January 1, 1994 $ 8,650
Effective January 1, 1995 9,050
Effective January 1, 1996 9,500
Effective January 1, 1997 10,000
RESOLVED, further, That the annual salary for the Board of Representatives Chairman is hereby
established as follows:
Effective January 1, 1994 $ 12,975
Effective January 1, 1995 13,575
Effective January 1, 1996 14,250
Effective January 1, 1997 15,000
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 147 - CHANGE ORDER NO. 3 - MALCOLM PIRNIE - TOMPKINS
COUNTY RECYCLING AND SOLID WASTE CENTER
Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mr. Evans. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 14, Noes
- 1 (Representative Proto). Adopted.
WHEREAS, the following Change Order relative to Resolution No. 91 dated March 17, 1991 was
approved by the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee:
Change Order No. 3 - Malcolm Pirnie and its sub -consultants, shall be authorized to provide
contract negotiations with the performed vendors for the Recycling and Solid Waste Center.
now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, That
the county is authorized to execute said Change Order in an amount not to exceed $11,500 to be funded
from Account No. HH8167.9269.
139
May 18, 1993
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 148 - AWARD OF BID - TELEVISION EQUIPMENT
Moved by Ms. Mink, seconded by Mr. Mason. Following a brief discussion, Mr. Lerner called the
question. A voice vote on calling the question resulted as follows: Ayes - 14, Noes - 1 (Representative
Proto). Motion carried. A voice vote resulted as follows on the resolution: Ayes - 13, Noes - 2
(Representatives Proto and Todd). Adopted.
WHEREAS, the Division of Purchasing and Central Services has duly advertised for bids for the
purchase of television equipment, and
WHEREAS, two (2) bids were received and publicly opened on May 13, 1993, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Information Committee, That the bid be awarded
in the following configuration:
For Purchase Only Including Operation Manuals:
Advance Video System Panasonic AG -455U $3,170.00
Owego, New York S -VHS Camcorders
JVC TM-1400SU 14" $ 599.00
Color Monitor
For Purchase and Installation, Including Operation Manuals:
VIDEOSOUND of Ithaca, Inc. Telex Audiocom $1,853.13
Ithaca, New York Intercom
Bogen Tripods $ 814.35
Panasonic WJ-MX50 $4,427.50
Digital Video Mixer
FOR.A Digital Time $3,456.25
Base Corrector
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator be authorized to implement this bid on behalf
of Tompkins County, funds to be provided from Account No. AA1989.4906.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 149 - SUPPORT OF ASSEMBLY BILL 2384 PERTAINING TO
COLLECTION OF SALES TAX AT CORNELL'S STATLER
HOTEL
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the Tompkins County Board
of Representatives supports Assembly Bill 2384 which, in essence requires that an educational institution
which operates a hotel of one hundred or more rooms collect sales tax from its customers who do not
qualify for a sales tax exemption pursuant to section 1116(A) of the New York State Tax Law,
RESOLVED, further, That the Tompkins County Board of Representatives requests that a
companion bill be introduced in the New York State Senate by Senators Seward and Kuhl,
RESOLVED, further, That this resolution be forwarded to Senators Seward and Kuhl and
Assemblyman Luster.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
Chairman Watros declared recess from 9:07 p.m. to 9:13 p.m.
140
May 18, 1993
It was Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote, to
enter into executive session at 9:13 p.m. to discuss a personnel matter. The meeting returned to open
session at 9:25 p.m.
On motion of the appropriate committee chairmen and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by
voice vote, the following appointments were made to various advisory boards:
Soil and Water Conservation District
Term expires December 31, 1993
Tim Joseph - County Board member
Solid Waste Annual Fee Appeals Board
Terms effective for 1993 only
Edward Cope
Andy Lavigne
On motion, the meeting adjourned at 9:26 p.m.
141
June 1, 1993
Regular Meeting
Vice Chairman Mason called the meeting to order at 5:30 p.m.
Members and guests participated in the Pledge of Allegiance.
Present: 14 Representatives. Excused: 1 (Chairman Watros).
The minutes of May 18, 1993 were approved as corrected.
Vice Chairman Mason read a proclamation declaring the week of June 4-11, 1993 as
Manufacturing week in Tompkins County.
Under privilege of the floor, James Ellis, Department of Social Services employee, stated that he
recently has been diagnosed with Sick Building Syndrome. He stated that he feels that relocating
employees to different areas in the building does not take care of the problem. He stated that he believes
the building is causing him to be very sick and that it is a very serious situation which he hopes will be
taken care of immediately.
Under privilege of the floor, Yvonne Bartlett, Depai lment of Social Services employee, spoke
concerning the Sick Building Syndrome. Ms. Bartlett stated that she has heard there is a proposal to take
all the workers who suffer from Sick Building Syndrome and put them in a separate room and do only
paperwork. She stated that she is opposed to any idea that does not allow the workers to interview clients
as she was trained to do. Ms. Bartlett stated that she does not feel all necessary steps are being taken.
Under privilege of the floor, Duane Bonowitz, spoke in support of the resolution on the agenda
entitled Urging New York State Government to Consider Alternatives to Land Disposal of Low Level
Radioactive Wastes. Mr. Bonowitz spoke concerning pollution and stated that every dump site that has
been built to date has suffered leakage with cleanup costs that run into billions of dollars. Mr. Bonowitz
urged the adoption of this resolution.
Under privilege of the floor, Betty Bonowitz, spoke in support of the resolution on the agenda
entitled Urging New York State Government to Consider Alternatives to Land Disposal of Low Level
Radioactive Wastes. Mrs. Bonowitz stated that her family has a camp on Lake Ontario and has been told
that they need to limit eating fish from the Lake to once a week due to possible contamination of Low
Level Radioactive Wastes. Mrs. Bonowitz stated that an informational meeting will be held at the
Cortland County Office Building on June 3 to discuss this issue.
Under privilege of the floor, Dooley Kiefer, 629 Highland Road, Ithaca, spoke concerning the
resolution on the agenda entitled Urging New York State Government to Consider Alternatives to Land
Disposal of Low Level Radioactive Wastes. Ms. Kiefer stated that she feels New York State should
segregate waste by hazardous life and any monitored retrievable storage makes sense for at least the next
twenty years as some redefining of low level radioactive waste may be redefined as high level. Ms.
Kiefer stated that she supports this resolution and urged its adoption.
Under privilege of the floor, Joel Rabinowitz, Elm Street, Groton, stated he is sympathetic to those
who spoke concerning Sick Building Syndrome. He spoke in support of the resolution on the agenda
entitled Urging New York State Government to Consider Alternatives to Land Disposal of Low Level
Radioactive Wastes. Mr. Rabinowitz stated he feels this is relevant to Tompkins County because of the
following reasons: self interest, it is a State issue of great significance, this is a rural issue which focuses
on rural upstate New York areas, the possibility exists that a federalized disposal site could be made into a
centralized low level radioactive waste site and this is a regional issue.
142
June 1, 1993
Under privilege of the floor, Dana Paul, Lansing, spoke in support of the resolution on the agenda
entitled Urging New York State Government to Consider Alternatives to Land Disposal of Low Level
Radioactive Wastes and asked that Tompkins County lead the way in the responsible handling of low
level radioactive waste.
Under privilege of the floor, Dorothy Pomponio, Elm Street Groton, spoke in support of the
resolution on the agenda entitled Urging New York State Government to Consider Alternatives to Land
Disposal of Low Level Radioactive Wastes. Ms. Pomponio spoke of a successful on site storage program
operating in Ontario County. She stated that any low level radioactive site in New York State risks being
federalized.
Under privilege of the floor, Rebecca Vallely, Groton, stated that she would like to receive a
breakdown of recycling costs for Tompkins County.
Under privilege of the floor, Mrs. Livesay, Intergovernmental Representative, introduced Denise
Cotie Hopkins, Cortland County. Mrs. Livesay commended Cortland County for creating within their
Planning Department an office and staff whose job it has been to gather and disseminate information on
the complicated and little understood subject of low level radioactive waste.
Ms. Hopkins expressed her support for the passage of the resolution on the agenda entitled Urging
New York State Government to Consider Alternatives to Land Disposal of Low Level Radioactive
Wastes and stated that she is impressed by Tompkins County residents being so well informed on this
issue. She stated that Cortland County has tried to make it known that this is an issue which affects
everyone and through studies in Cortland County they have come to learn of radioactive uses in medial
and research applications. They have also studied the role the nuclear power companies play in the
generation of the waste. She stated that there will be much activity on this issue at the State Legislative
session before the end of July. She said the resolution proposed by Tompkins County will go to other
counties such as Erie, Cattaraugus, Allegheny, Cortland and the City of Buffalo and that Tompkins
County is not alone in this issue. One possible solution to the problem could be storage at point of
generation. Ms. Cotie Hopkins described the storage process for low level and high-level radioactive
waste and how the disposal process is handled. She said that if the on-site storage proposal was chosen it
could help our medical and academic generators from being thrown into a crisis.
Under privilege of the floor, Mr. Lerner, Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management
Committee, responded to Ms. Vallely's request for information on the breakdown of recycling costs. Mr.
Lerner stated that this is being worked on and should be available by the June 29 Special Board meeting.
Under privilege of the floor, Ms. Mink, Chair, Human Services Committee, responded to
comments made under privilege of the floor pertaining to the Sick Building Syndrome situation at the
Department of Social Services. She stated that a packet of information was sent to Ms. Bartlett today
which answers most of the questions she had asked for. Ms. Mink stated that she attended a Task Force
meeting on this issue on May 17 and it seemed clear to her that positive steps were being taken to break
down the questions that were raised including the writing of a physician's note to get the proprietary
information on the carpets, glues, etc. She stated from her point of view the Human Services Committee
and the Board of Representatives are well aware of the situation and are doing their best to oversee a
rapid conclusion to this situation.
Under privilege of the floor, Mr. Winch, Representative, District No. 8, expressed his appreciation
to Denise Cotie Hopkins for educating the people of New York State on the issue of radioactive waste.
Mr. Winch also stated that he feels this should be a business expense and generators should take care of
their of own waste.
143
June 1, 1993
Under privilege of the floor, Vice Chairman Mason announced that Sheriff Emery Guest
underwent bypass surgery today and word was received prior to the Board meeting that the prognosis
looks well. On behalf of the Board, Mr. Mason expressed sincere get well wishes to Sheriff Guest.
Mr. Proto, Chairman, Health and Education Committee, stated that Mr. Evans, Vice Chairman,
attended the Tompkins Cortland Community College graduation ceremony. Mr. Evans stated that the
ceremony was very impressive and referred to the accomplishment of a disabled graduate who will be
going on to Cornell University. Mr. Evans said that he is proud to represent a County which offers such
opportunity. Mr. Proto stated he attended a formal reception in Cortland County for the 133 Spanish
students that have arrived from Madrid that are enrolled in TC3. He stated that this program will generate
approximately $230,000 for the College this year. He reported that the Committee met May 25 and had a
very extensive presentation from Cooperative Extension pertaining the Women's Financial Management
Program that Cooperative Extension is supporting. He stated that the Lead Program has accepted a
$40,000 grant. Mr. Proto also said that the County. will be re -endorsing the Community Mental Health
Resources Bill and urging the Legislature to give a portion of savings from the Bill to communities which
the deinstitutionalized mental health clients are placed. He reported that the Mental Health Department
may be faced with a shortfall of State funding in its budget of $220,000 but stated that due to federal
salary enhancement funds and economies in the Department the Department may be able to meet its
budget. The next Committee meeting will be June 29.
Mr. Evans, Chairman, Personnel Committee, reported that the Personnel Committee met May 27
and discussed the freedom of speech rights for employees. Mr. Mulvey, County Attorney, will be
preparing a policy on this which will be forwarded to the Employee Council then to the CSEA for
comment. He stated that the final employee evaluation form for the four employees which report to the
Board are in each member's box. He asked that these be returned by the next Board meeting. He reported
that the appointment of the Commissioner of Personnel will be made by Mr. Heyman, County
Administrator, at the appropriate time in the meeting and also reported that the selection process has
begun for the Public Health Director.
Ms. Mink, Chair, Human Services Committee, reported that the Committee met this morning and
had a presentation from Jeff Curtis, Director of the Child Care Consortium of Cornell University on
developing a public/private partnership on funding services for childcare in the County. The Committee
received positive reports on consolidation of human services and youth services and should meet its July
1 deadline.
Mr. Stein, Chairman, Planning Committee, reported that a special Committee meeting will be held
on June 3. He reported that the New York Thruway Authority has taken over the Barge Canal and a
process has begun which is aimed at development for economic purposes and assisting the communities
along the Canal on various types of economic activity. There will be a meeting in June which is aimed at
informing the public on this issue.
Mr. Winch, Chairman, Public Works and Construction Management Committee, reported that
Committee business is reflected on the agenda.
Mr. Todd, Chairman, Fiscal Affairs Committee, reported that the Committee met on May 26 and
discussed having a community survey this year and stated that the Committee has not made any decisions
at this time. Mr. Heyman, County Administrator, reported on the May 27 Fiscal Affairs Committee
meeting which Mr. Todd was excused. He stated the Committee made a recommendation on the Fiscal
Plan for 1994 which does include a pool of priorities money. The procedure for allocating these has not
yet been established. The Plan has been forwarded to the June 7 Budget and Administration Committee
meeting. The next Committee meeting will be June 9 at 2 p.m.
Mr. Lerner, Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, reported that the
Committee met on May 27. The Negotiating Committee on the Central Processing Facility had its last
144
June 1, 1993
meeting and voted unanimously by members present to enter into a contract with CRInc. as the preferred
vendor for the Central Processing Facility. A final phase of negotiations will begin and will follow by
action at the June 29 special Board meeting. Mr. Lerner reported on a article in the Ithaca Journal
concerning illegal dumping of solid waste. He stated that the article did not include that Tompkins
County has identified illegal dumping as a priority for the second quarter.
A public information program on illegal dumping will be telecast on June 22 at 7 p.m. and June 24 at 9
p.m. He reported on a constitutional challenge to flow control laws which have been brought to the
Boards' attention. These challenges revolve around the interstate commerce clause. Jonathan Wood,
Assistant County Attorney, pointed out that flow control laws which requires waste to enter a landfill
would have a different legal status than trash which comes to a transfer station.
Mrs. Schuler, Vice Chairman, Public Safety Committee, reported that the Committee met on May
14 and May 18 and discussed the report prepared by Deputy County Administrator Kathy West on needs
assessment for the Sheriffs Department. The Committee will meet again June 3 at noon.
Mrs. Livesay, Intergovernmental Representative, brought to the attention of the Board a memo
placed on desks from the Healthy Heart program which supports the proposed resolution on the agenda
entitled In Support of Dedicated Fund from Cigarette Sales Tax.
Mrs. Call, Chairman, Budget and Administration Committee, reported that the next Committee
meeting will be June 7 at 11:30. She stated that she will ask for the Rules of the Board to be waived this
evening to allow an appointment to be made.
Mr. Heyman, County Administrator, reported on that copies of a video on total quality
management will be available from the Clerk of the Board for Board members to watch. He reported on a
workshop that will be held at Cornell University on this subject at 8 a.m. on June 11.
Vice Chairman Mason reported that Mr. Mulvey, County Attorney, was excused from the meeting
to attend court and that the monthly activities report from his Depaitnient has been submitted.
Vice Chairman Mason gave the appropriate committee chairman permission to withdraw from the
agenda the following resolutions:
Ownership of Downstream Forest Home Bridge
Authorizing Second Addendum - Lease Agreement with Taughannock Aviation Corporation —
Tompkins County Airport
Authorizing an Easement for NYSEG - Location of Power Transformer - Tompkins County
Airport
On motion of the appropriate committee chairman and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by
voice vote by members present, the following resolution was added to the agenda:
Salary Adjustment - Sheriffs Department
Vice Chairman Mason gave the appropriate committee chairmen permission to withdraw from the
agenda the following resolutions with final committee action being affirmed:
CA056-93 - Authorization to Sign Contract for Provision of Circuit Rider Services for the Village
of Lansing
CA057-93 - Authorizing a Third Addendum to the Contract with Egner and Associates for Design
Development and Construction Documents for the New Terminal Project
CA058-93 - Authorization to Contract with the Human Services Coalition to Provide a Bathroom
Safety Education Program to Seniors
145
June 1, 1993
CA059-93 - Authorization to Execute Contract - Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Central New York
- Public Health and Mental Health
CA060-93 - Authorization to Execute Contracts - Various Colleges/Universities - Health
Department
RESOLUTION NO. 150 - SUPPORT OF STATE LEGISLATION A7948 AND S4674
(GOVERNOR'S PROGRAM BILL 153)
Moved by Ms. Mink, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, the current long term care system in the County and across the State is fragmented,
confusing, and not cost effective, and
WHEREAS, State Legislature Bills S4674 and A7958 create local centralized access reform to
address these problems, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education and Human Services Committees,
That the Tompkins County Board of Representatives supports this legislation and urges its passage in the
Legislature.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 151 - URGING NEW YORK STATE GOVERNMENT TO CONSIDER
ALTERNATIVES TO LAND DISPOSAL OF LOW LEVEL
RADIOACTIVE WASTES
Moved by Mrs. Livesay, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, no state in the nation has licensed and opened a centralized disposal facility for low-
level radioactive waste (LLRW) since the 1985 Low Level Radioactive Waste Policy Amendments Act of
the federal government was passed, and
WHEREAS, the "take title" provisions of said Act were found to be unconstitutional by the U.S.
Supreme Court when challenged by New York State and the states thus were relieved of the onerous
command of the "shall be responsible" provisions, and
WHEREAS, in 1989 the Congressional Office of Technology Assessment found that LLRW
volumes had declined by half since 1980, and were predicted to decline by half again by 1993, and
although a dozen LLRW disposal facilities were slated for development, a reduced number of facilities
could easily handle the nation's LLRW, and
WHEREAS, a LLRW disposal facility in New York State risks becoming federalized as a national
repository for other states and the federal government if it is the first state to open such a facility, and
WHEREAS, the NYS LLRW Siting Commission on May 11, 1993, declared by resolution that
there are no preferred sites at this time for locating a facility in New York State and will recommence site
selection once a disposal method is chosen, which means potential sites may be found in any county
including Tompkins, and
WHEREAS, 98 percent of the LLRW that would be placed in a centralized disposal facility over
the 30 to 60 year projected life of a facility when measured by radioactivity will be produced by nuclear
electric generating facilities, and
WHEREAS, medical and academic institutions generating LLRW will produce less than one
percent of the waste over the projected life of the facility when measured by radioactivity, and
WHEREAS, aboveground, monitored, retrievable storage is the preferred management method for
LLRW since no technology for land burial that can effectively isolate LLRW over its entire hazardous life
has been successfully implemented, and
146
June 1, 1993
WHEREAS, a draft report dated April 28, 1993, of the study conducted by New York State Energy
Research Development Authority (NYSERDA) on the ability of New York's generators to store their own
waste on-site has found that of the six nuclear electric generating facilities, five have the capability of
storing wastes produced over the next twenty years or more and the sixth, ten years or more, now
therefore be it
RESOLVED, That the Tompkins County Board of Representatives urges the State of New York to
consider alternatives to the development of a large-scale centralized low-level radioactive waste disposal
facility for the disposal of all LLRW; that storage at the point of generation by the nuclear electric
generating facilities is the most sensible means of managing their low-level radioactive waste at this time;
that waste generated by hospitals, research centers, universities and similar institutions should be stored
on-site for decay to the maximum extent possible and that only for such generators with inadequate
storage space who have already implemented waste reduction and segregation practices, the State should
develop space at a State-owned and operated nuclear electric generating facility for aboveground,
monitored, waste -retrievable storage,
RESOLVED, further, That this Board supports State legislation that incorporates each of the
foregoing components,
RESOLVED, further, That copies of this resolution be sent to Assemblyman Luster, Senators
Seward and Kuhl, Governor Cuomo, New York State Supervisors and County Legislators Association
and the New York State Association of Counties.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 152 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE A GRANT AGREEMENT WITH
THE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION (FAA) FOR
RUNWAY EXTENSION PROJECT - TOMPKINS COUNTY
AIRPORT
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, the County has received a grant offer from the Federal Aviation Administration
(FAA) in the amount of $3,442,000 (Discretionary Funding) towards the cost of the Runway Extension
project which includes mandatory signage and wetlands compensation programs, and
WHEREAS, the budget for said project is as follows:
FAA Share (90%) Account No. 5698.4592 $3,442,000
NYSDOT Share (5%) Account No. 5698.3592 191,222
PFC's (5%) Account No. 5698.5031 191,222
Total Account No. 5698.9213 $3,824,444
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the FAA grant offer in the amount of $3,442,000 be and hereby is accepted and that the County
Administrator is authorized to execute the required documents.
SEQR ACTION: TYPE I
(Negative Declaration on File)
RESOLUTION NO. 153 - AUTHORIZING A CONTRACT WITH THE FEDERAL AVIATION
ADMINISTRATION (FAA) - LEASE OF AIRPORT LAND FOR
VISUAL APPROACH SLOPE INDICATOR (VASI)
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Culligan, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
147
June 1, 1993
WHEREAS, the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) wishes to renew its lease agreement with
the County for land occupied by a Visual Approach Slope Indicator (VASI) navigation aid for Runway 14
at the Tompkins County Airport together with the right of access and egress to the site for the purpose of
repair and maintenance, and
WHEREAS, the lease shall be for one year beginning October 1, 1992 until September 30, 1993
and shall be automatically renewable until September 30, 2007, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That said lease agreement is approved and the County Administrator is hereby authorized and directed to
execute said lease agreement on behalf of the County with the FAA for one year, renewable annually for
fifteen (15 years, expiring on September 30, 2007).
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 154 - AWARD OF CONTRACT - CONTRACT ADMINISTRATION AND
INSPECTION SERVICES FOR RUNWAY EXTENSION PROJECT -
TOMPKINS COUNTY AIRPORT
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Todd. Mr. Stein stated that he sees this as a lot of money
to be spent on overseeing the construction of a runway. Mr. Todd stated that although he does not
disagree with Mr. Stein, he does not feel qualified to judge Calocerninos and Spina. Mr. Nicholas,
Airport Manager, stated that the Federal Aviation recognizes a cap of ten percent and stated that this is
not just pouring concrete, it requires a large amount of testing and sampling. Following discussion, a
voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 9 (Representatives Call, Culligan, Evans, Livesay, Mason, Proto,
Shurtleff, Todd and Winch), Noes - 5 (Representatives Joseph, Lerner, Mink, Schuler and Stein), Excused
- 1 (Chairman Watros). Adopted.
WHEREAS, a Request for Qualification (RFQ) was issued to the six airport consulting engineers
most proximate to the Airport, in accordance with the procedures outlined in Federal Aviation
Administration (FAA) Advisory Circular No. 150/5100-14B, with two (2) of these firms submitting
qualifications, and
WHEREAS, after using evaluation criteria outlined in said Advisory Circular, the Public Works
and Construction Management Committee has selected the firm of Calocerinos and Spina Engineers as
being the best qualified to complete the task, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the County Administrator be and hereby is authorized to execute a contract with said Calocerinos
and Spina Engineers for an amount not to exceed $319,952 subject to approval by the FAA and New
York State Depai lment of Transportation (NYSDOT) and that the budget for the inspection be as follows:
FAA Share (90%) Account No. 5698.4592 $287,956
NYSDOT Share (5%) Account No. 5698.3592 $ 15,998
PFC Share (5%) Account No. 5698.2831 $ 15,998
Total Account No. 5698.9239 $319,952
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller is hereby authorized to advance monies for these
services until reimbursement is received from FAA, NYSDOT and from Passenger Facility Charges.
SEQR ACTION: Type I
(Negative Declaration on File)
RESOLUTION NO. 155 - AUTHORIZATION TO CONVEY REAL PROPERTY
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Shurtleff, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
148
June 1, 1993
RESOLVED, That the County Administrator is directed to execute a purchase agreement and deed
conveying Town of Groton Tax Parcel No. 14-1-25 to Martin and Linda LePage of Groton, New York.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 156 - ENDORSEMENT OF THE NEW YORK STATE ASSEMBLY BILL
NO. 6382 AND SENATE BILL NO. 4021 EXTENDING
AUTHORIZATION TO THE COUNTY OF TOMPKINS TO
INCREASE THE RATE OF SALES AND COMPENSATING USE
TAXES
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Ms. Mink. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 13,
Noes - 1 (Representative Proto), Excused - 1 (Chairman Watros). Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That pursuant to
Article IX of the Constitution of the State of New York, the County of Tompkins requests the enactment
of Assembly Bill No. 6382 and Senate Bill No. 4021 endorsing "An ACT to amend the tax law, in
relation to extending authorization to the County of Tompkins to increase the rate of sales and
compensating use taxes",
RESOLVED, further, That the appropriate officials are authorized to execute and submit Home
Rule forms requesting passage of the above State legislation.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 157 - APPROPRIATION FROM CONTINGENT FUND - COORDINATED
COMMUNITY CORRECTIONS PROGRAM PROPOSAL -
ALCOHOLISM COUNCIL
Moved by Mrs. Schuler, seconded by Mr. Joseph. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes
- 14, Noes - 0, Excused - 1 (Chairman Watros). Adopted.
WHEREAS, the Alcoholism Council of Tompkins County proposes to expand the intensive
Outpatient Treatment Program of its clinic to provide assessment, case management, referral and
treatment services as an alternative to incarceration for criminal offenders who have alcohol problems,
and
WHEREAS, the Public Safety Committee at its May 18 meeting supported the proposal as an
opportunity for its participants to reduce the likelihood of future criminal behavior and thus incarceration,
and
WHEREAS, research regarding treatment of persons involved in the criminal justice system reveal
an 80 percent reduction in recidivism, and
WHEREAS, the Criminal Justice Advisory/Alternatives to Incarceration Board on March 29, 1993
unanimously supported and recommended to the Public Safety Committee by members present this
proposal, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Safety and Budget and Administration
Committees, That the Comptroller is directed to appropriate $20,700 from A1990, Contingent Fund, to
3143.4442, Alternatives to Incarceration (Alcoholism Council), to fund the Coordinated Community
Corrections Program proposal, said funding to cover costs for the June 1993 - December 1993 time
period,
RESOLVED, further, That this appropriation increases the Fiscal Plan target for the Public Safety
Committee for 1993 by $20,700, but does not increase the 1994 target for that Committee by the same
amount.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
149
June 1, 1993
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 158 - APPROPRIATION FROM CONTINGENT FUND - ALCOHOLISM
COUNCIL'S 1993-1994 SERVICE PLAN
Moved by Mrs. Schuler seconded by Mr. Lerner. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes -
14, Noes - 0, Excused - 1 (Chairman Watros). Adopted.
WHEREAS, the Alcoholism Council's 1993-1994 Service Plan will provide for needed alcohol
evaluations to inmates at the County Jail, and
WHEREAS, funding for this purpose from Division of Probation and Correctional Alternatives to
Tompkins County has been reduced to $2,379 from the original $5,504, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Safety and Budget and Administration
Committees, That the Comptroller is directed to appropriate $3,125 from A1990, Contingent Fund, to
3143.4442, Alternatives to Incarceration (Alcoholism Council), to make up the difference,
RESOLVED, further, That this appropriation increases the Fiscal Plan target for the Public Safety
Committee for 1993 by $3,125, but does not increase the 1994 target for that Committee by the same
amount.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 159 URGING THE NEW YORK STATE LEGISLATURE AND
GOVERNOR TO ENACT AND IMPLEMENT THE
COMMUNITY MENTAL HEALTH RESOURCES BILL
(S2020,A4239)
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County Board of Representatives, by Resolution No. 311 of 1992
supported legislation that would ensure the transfer of savings derived from the shift of mental health
patients from state institutions to community programs to pay for those programs, and
WHEREAS, A4239 has been introduced in the Assembly and S2020 has been introduced in the
Senate and this legislation outlines a plan for the transfer of funds from state psychiatric hospitals to a
dedicated fund to be used exclusively to support local community mental health services, now therefore
be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education Committee, That the Tompkins
County Board of Representatives reaffirms Resolution No. 311 and urges the passage and implementation
of the aforementioned bills,
RESOLVED, further, That copies of this resolution be sent to Assemblyman Luster, Senators
Seward and Kuhl, Governor Cuomo, New York State Supervisors and County Legislators Association
and the New York State Association of Counties.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 160 - IN SUPPORT OF A DEDICATED FUND FROM TOBACCO TAXES
Moved by Mrs. Livesay, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
150
June 1, 1993
WHEREAS, tobacco kills more New Yorkers than alcohol, cocaine, crack, heroin, homocide,
suicide, car accidents, fires and AIDS combined, and
WHEREAS, tobacco is the leading cause of heart disease and is the single most preventable cause
of chronic disease, and
WHEREAS, the Surgeon General of the United States has determined that smoking cigarettes
leads to such diseases as cancer and emphysema, and is associated with low birth weight babies and many
expensive related problems, and
WHEREAS, environmental tobacco smoke is responsible for an increased risk of asthma and other
respiratory diseases, especially in children, as well as lung and other cancers and heart attacks, and
WHEREAS, the Surgeon General of the United States has reported that over 50,000 non-smoking
Americans die each year from other peoples smoke, and
WHEREAS, environmental smoke has been classified as a Class A carcinogen by the
Environmental Protection Agency, and
WHEREAS, tobacco use costs the State more than $6 billion per year, or $4.33 per pack, in direct
and indirect health care, with county governments bearing an additional share, and
WHEREAS, New York's current excise tax of $.39 does not begin to cover the health costs that
smoking poses on New York and its counties, and
WHEREAS, New York State has raised the tax on cigarettes sold in the State of New York by
$1.70 a carton, which makes a total tax of $.56 per pack, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, That the Tompkins County Board of Representatives is in support of a dedicated
fund derived from tobacco taxes to be used for funding health agencies and for education programs aimed
at reducing tobacco usage by youths,
RESOLVED, further, That copies of this resolution be sent to Assemblyman Luster, Senators
Seward and Kuhl, Governor Cuomo, New York State Supervisors and County Legislators Association
and the New York State Association of Counties.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 130 - SALARY ADJUSTMENT - SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT
Moved by Mr. Evans, seconded by Mrs. Livesay. Mr. Lerner stated that he has concerns with this
resolution because it is his understanding that the employee affected by this is not a member of the
Deputy Sheriffs' Association and that the Memorandum of Understanding does not apply. He also
expressed concern that this goes directly against the Reclassification/Pay Equity Study this Board
conducted approximately two years ago. The Study assigned points to identified factors in job
descriptions of which supervision was one of the largest factors taken into account. One of the primary
focuses of the Study was to eliminate possible gender and racial bias in the County's classification system.
It is his opinion that to take a particular job which is traditionally a male job and pay it more than the
reclassification system takes away from the avoidance of bias that the County spent endless time and
money in order to eliminate. Mr. Heyman, County Administrator, stated that while the Memorandum of
Understanding with the Deputy Sheriffs' Association does not apply to this position, and while he does
not disagree with comments made by Mr. Lerner, but if there are going to be cases of supervisors making
substantially less than those they supervise, a systematic approach needs to be taken. Mr. Evans stated
that he feels this resolution should be adopted and that the issue should be discussed at the next
negotiation session with the Deputy Sheriffs' Association. Vice Chairman Mason granted Mr. Winch's
request to abstain from voting on this resolution due to a family conflict.
A roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 11, Noes - 2 (Representatives Lerner and Mink),
Abstention - 1 (Representative Winch), Excused - 1 (Chairman Watros). Adopted.
WHEREAS, a Memorandum of Understanding has been signed with the Tompkins County
Sheriffs' Association which results in all promoted employees moving to working rate effective March 1,
151
June 1, 1993
1993 and subordinate staff will receive an increase in salary above the current management salary level of
a supervising management employee, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Personnel Committee, That the resolution of the
Personnel Committee of April 1, 1993 adjusting the salary of a management staff employee is hereby
affirmed.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
It was Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to waive the Rules of the Board to allow appointments to be made to the Solid Waste
Annual Fee Appeals Board.
On motion of the appropriate committee chairmen and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by
voice vote by members present, the following appointments were made to various advisory boards:
Solid Waste Annual Fee Appeals Board Appointments — 1993 only
Martha Preston - Delegate
Robert Sweet - Alternate
Tompkins Cortland Community College Board of Trustees
Term expires June 30, 2002
William J. Raynor
Economic Opportunity Corporation Board of Directors
Term expires March 31, 1995
Thomas Lange - Village of Trumansburg representative
It was Moved by Mr. Evans, seconded by Mrs. Call, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to confirm the County Administrator's appointment of Anita Fitzpatrick to the position
of Personnel Commissioner for a six year term.
Vice Chairman Mason declared recess from 7:49 p.m. to 8:56 p.m.
At this point in the meeting Vice Chairman Mason turned the meeting over to Mr. Lerner,
Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee. Mr. Lerner distributed a written summary
on solid waste expenses and stated that this would give a detailed outline of where and how money is
spent on solid waste. He stated that the goal of the Program is to manage the County's solid waste in a
manner that is environmentally sound, cost-effective, socially responsible and safe. Mr. Lerner expressed
his thanks to Mrs. Eckstrom, Solid Waste Manager, and other staff for their work on this project. He
stated that figures in his report reflect preliminary 1994 budget figures, which has not yet been reviewed
by the Solid Waste Manager, County Administrator, or the Solid Waste and Resource Management
Committee. Mr. Lerner reviewed the following areas of expense to the County in his presentation:
Disposal
Purpose - to provide for the transfer and disposal of waste from the Hillview Interim Transfer
Station and enforcement of local laws governing disposal and recycling activities. Major activities
include transfer, transportation, disposal, law enforcement and public information.
Recycling
Purpose - to divert materials from the waste stream to be reused or remanufactured into usable
products rather than being disposed of. Major activities include handling, transportation, marketing and
public information.
152
June 1, 1993
Waste Reduction, Collection and Related Programs
Purpose - to reduce the quantity or toxicity of solid waste entering the solid waste system. Major
activities include waste reduction programs, waste assessments, composting, residential curbside
collection, drop-off center collection, household hazardous waste management.
Old Landfills
Purpose - to provide for the proper closure construction of the Hillview Road Landfill, post -closure
maintenance of Hillview and Caswell landfills and debt service payments for the proposed DR -7 landfill
which will not be constructed. Major activities include closure, monitoring and maintenance, leachate
hauling and disposal and DR -7 debt service.
Mr. Lerner's written summary contained information on each staff position within the Solid Waste
Division and a brief description of responsibilities assigned to each position. He stated that he feels the
program has the needed amount of staff positions at this time.
Mr. Lerner stated that actual expenses are approximately $6.7 million which has to be paid for by
some combination of tipping fees, property taxes, annual fee or another source of revenue. He pointed
out that a major portion of the budget is devoted to bringing down the cost of disposal.
The following chart is a brief summary of information contained in Mr. Lerner's report:
Estimated Portion of
Program Sub Program Total Budget
Disposal Waste Transfer 3.9%
* waste transfer personnel
Transportation 14.8%
* transport to landfill
Disposal 23.1%
* landfill fees
Public Information .2%
Law Enforcement .8%
* flow control, illegal dumping
mandatory recycling, trash tags
Recycling Handling 2.8%
* temporary recycling transfer
Transportation 5.1%
* hauling to markets
Public Information and Marketing .4%
Administration Management 6.4%
* Solid Waste Manager and staff
* office building debt service
* Annual Fee administration
Old Landfills Hillview and Caswell Closure
* debt service
Maintenance and Monitoring
Leachate Disposal
* leachate hauling
DR -7 Debt Service
6.7%
1.7%
2.7%
1.0%
Waste Interim Composting Operations 4.2%
Reduction * compost materials, debt service,
compost fees
153
June 1, 1993
Recycling Collection 8.8%
* City of Ithaca, Superior Disposal
Drop -Off Centers 3.9%
* drop-off pick-up and supervision
Waste Reduction 1.3%
* organic waste collection, home composting,
Cooperative Extension,
Environmental shopper
Waste Assessments 1.8%
Household Hazardous Waste Management .3%
* notes and included major cost items
Facility Development (Capital Projects not yet in service)
Recycling and Solid Waste Center
Recycling Portion
Disposal Portion
4.9%
5.3
The preliminary 1994 budget outlined in the report for the Solid Waste Division also includes
revenues from license and permit fees, sale of Recyclables, sale of Bins, compost Fees and NYSERDA
Grants.
Mr. Lerner stated that the expense outlined in the chart reflects that of the interim Hillview Road
composting operations but mentioned that staff is working on developing a full scale composting facility
which would take restaurant and supermarket food waste and possible other compost materials.
Mr. Stein asked what the impact on the budget would be when the Recycling and Solid Waste
Center is on-line? Mr. Lerner stated that it is expected that revenues will be increased for the recycling
program as the amount of waste transfer, handling and transportation of waste will be reduced as well as
the tonnage of reyclables are expected to increase. Mr. Lerner stated the cost benefit of building the
Recycling and Solid Waste Center will be discussed at the special Board meeting on June 29.
Following a brief discussion, Mr. Lerner concluded his presentation stating that answers to several
questions raised would be available at the June 29 Special Board meeting.
On motion, the meeting adjourned at 8:42 p.m.
154
June 15, 1993
Regular Meeting
Chairman Watros called the meeting to order at 5:30 p.m.
Members and guests participated in the Pledge of Allegiance.
Present: 14 Representatives. Excused: 1 (Representative Stein).
It was Moved by Mr. Evans, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to approve the minutes of June 1, 1993 as submitted.
Chairman Watros welcomed students from the Montessori School.
Under privilege of the floor, Paul Bennett, an Ithaca Attorney representing five employees of the
Depailinent of Social Services alleging to have sick building syndrome, expressed his concerns and
frustration for his clients who are out of work and are not receiving any compensation. He stated that to
date he has not seen a concrete proposal put forth by the County showing its plans for accommodating
these people. He also stated that he feels the County, as an employer, has a responsibility to its
employees to provide a safe working environment.
Under privilege of the floor, Yvonne Bartlett, Depaitment of Social Services employee, spoke
concerning sick building syndrome. Ms. Bartlett displayed a bag containing several medications which
she states she is currently taking. Ms. Bartlett stated that she has permanent damage as a result of
multiple chemical sensitivities. She again requested copies of information on the Biggs A building. She
made available a video tape of a CNN television program which addresses problems with carpeting.
Under privilege of the floor, James Ellis, Department of Social Services employee, spoke
concerning sick building syndrome. Mr. Ellis submitted a request to waive the 25 cent per copy fee that
has been requested for copies of committee and Board minutes. Mr. Ellis expressed his disagreement
with an article in the Ithaca Journal in which Representative Mink was quoted in which she stated that it
was standard procedure to strip floors and paint rooms when people are moved. Mr. Ellis requested the
Board to expedite any request that is made to resolve this issue and to work with the employees so that
they may return to work.
Under privilege of the floor, Mel Bartlett, husband of Yvonne Bartlett who is a Depailnient of
Social Services employee, stated that he feels the situation at the Biggs complex is being handled poorly.
Mr. Bartlett stated that his wife is sick because she worked in the building for a year and a half. He
expressed frustration with the lack of progress being made to solve the problem.
Under privilege of the floor, Margaret Marks, Department of Social Services employee, spoke
concerning sick building syndrome. She expressed her frustration in obtaining information on the Biggs
A building and requested the Boards' assistance in obtaining all necessary building material data sheets.
Ms. Marks also expressed concern for the resolution being added to the agenda authorizing the hiring of
four temporary Social Welfare Examiners. She stated that she wants and needs to work and would like to
see a plan put into affect that would return workers to work who are allegedly affected by sick building
syndrome.
Under privilege of the floor, Mr. Proto, Representative, District No. 7, asked for the status of the
Biggs A building situation and requests made by individuals for information.
Ms. Mink, Chair, Human Services Committee, reported on the situation at the Biggs A building.
She responded to comments made concerning a quote published in the Ithaca Journal. She stated that the
article published in the Ithaca Journal was a summarization and left out important statements. Those
comments concerning the striping of floors and painting of rooms were made on information she had been
155
June 15, 1993
given. She stated that it is important to recognize there are two separate issues that need to be addressed:
building safety and specific problems of the workers. She stated that her immediate concern is that steps
are being taken to make the Biggs building a safe building. Ms. Dolan, Commissioner of Social Services,
updated the Board on the status of bringing employees back to work. She stated that bringing these
people back to work require the employees, counsel, physicians, the County Attorney and the Personnel
Commissioner to work together to find a location in the building or a location in another building that
would meet the requirements of the employees. She stated that she hopes to enter into the necessary
discussions with the employees, their counsel and physicians soon so that these people may return to
work. Commissioner Dolan addressed the resolution being added to the agenda entitled Creation of
Positions - Department of Social Services and stated that the Department is not processing cases
according to the required timelines and, therefore, additional staff is needed to handle the backlog of
work. The proposed positions do not affect the status of the positions of those out of work. Mr. Heyman,
County Administrator, stated that the requests for information by Ms. Bartlett have been voluminous.
He stated that the requests are being assembled as quickly as possible. Mr. Heyman stated that the
County does not have disability coverage although it was offered and was turned down at the last two
bargaining sessions with the Civil Service Employees Associations.
Mr. Proto, Vice Chairman, Planning Committee, reported that the Committee reviewed an
amendment to the Hotel Room Occupancy Tax Law. He stated that the Planning Department has put
together a spreadsheet of 82 separate projects the Depaitment is involved in. Mr. Proto suggested that
anyone interested in Long Range Planning obtain a copy of the schematic prepared by Joan Jurkowich on
how this is going to operate. He reported that Joseph Daley will serve as Chairman and Judith
Vandermark will serve as Vice Chair of the Advisory Board on Tourism Development for the remainder
of 1993. The next Committee meeting will be June 17.
Mr. Proto, Chairman, Health and Education Committee, stated that the Committee will meet June
29. He reported on an advisory committee meeting which he attended on children with special care needs
which centered around what the State is going to do for these children.
Mr. Evans, Chairman, Personnel Committee, stated that the Committee has not met since the last
meeting and will meet on June 24. He updated the Board on the status of the search for a Public Health
Director and a Data Processing Director. Mr. Evans welcomed Anita Fitzpatrick who recently was
appointed Personnel Commissioner.
Ms. Mink, Chair, Human Services Committee, reported on the consolidation of human services
with the City of Ithaca and stated that the City voted unanimously at their meeting to support the
proposed nine point agreement. Ms. Mink also updated on the Board on the status of a building to house
human service agencies downtown and stated that Mr. Missirian, Deputy Planning Commissioner, will be
asked to work on this with the City. She stated that the Department of Social Services is to be
congratulated for being the recipient of two grants from New York State which total $112,000. The next
Committee meeting will be July 6 at 2:30 p.m.
Mr. Mason, Chairman, Public Safety Committee, reported that the Committee has met twice since
the last Board meeting and have again discussed the Needs Assessment Study for the Sheriff's
Department. He stated that the discussion has been quite productive and stated that the Committee has
learned a great deal including what has precipitated some of the overtime. He stated that out of a total of
27 positions on road patrols, there are twenty in Deputy positions and seven in Sergeant positions. He
stated that at the present time there are four Deputies out on disability or workman's compensation claims.
Mr. Mason stated that several steps are being taken to resolve these problems.
Mr. Winch, Chairman, Public Works and Construction Management Committee, stated that as a
part of the negotiating team for the Central Processing Facility he has voiced a lot of concerns about the
process and the type of building the County is getting into. However, he recently visited a facility
designed by CRInc. in Maryland and many of his concerns were answered after seeing this facility. He
156
June 15, 1993
stated that on May 20 he was honored to represent the Board at the annual Historic Ithaca Dinner which
presented Tompkins County with an award for their sensitive adaptation of the Old Jail to a modern office
building. Mr. Winch complimented Mr. Mobbs, Commissioner of Public Works, and his staff for their
fine work.
Mr. Todd, Chairman, Fiscal Affairs Committee, stated that the Committee met June 9 and have
advanced the Fiscal Plan to the Budget and Administration Committee. He stated that the emergency
pool proposal has been withdrawn from the Plan by the Committee because it is felt additional work and
discussion is needed.
Mr. Lerner, Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, reported that the
Supreme Court for the United States has just accepted for review an appeal of flow control law in
Clarkstown, New York located in Rockland County. He stated that it has been pointed out by Assistant
County Attorney, Jonathan Wood, that this case is very similar to Tompkins County and will be a very
firm and final decision on flow control for Tompkins County. He stated that the sub -committee of the
Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee which is dealing with developing new markets for
Tompkins County recyclables is going to be having a presentation on July 22 at 2 p.m. in the Old Jail
Conference Room. He reported that Solid Waste Office staff have moved to their new location in the
Solid Waste Office Building on Commercial Avenue. Mr. Lerner reminded the Board that a Special
Board meeting to discuss solid waste issues will be held on June 29.
Mrs. Livesay, Intergovernmental Representative, reported that she was invited to attend a meeting
in Elmira, New York where the Secretary of State and her representatives were in attendance and
discussed with local officials some of the Governor's proposals for relieving the property tax. She said
the main thing that they were looking for was to give more information on the proposals and to get
reaction and feedback from local officials.
Mrs. Call, Chairman, Budget and Administration Committee, reported that the Committee met on
June 9 and set a tentative budget schedule. She stated that Representative Shurtleff proposed an
exemption for the Annual Fee for those with an income lower than $5,200 and stated that while the
concept is interesting, the process is too far along to implement this exemption in 1993. Mrs. Call stated
that the Annual Fee Appeals Board has been very active and are doing a very good job. She reported that
the Blue Cross/Blue Shield contract which normally expires on July 1 has been extended for 18 months so
that it can be on the same basis as the County's fiscal basis. The next Committee meeting will be July 6.
Mr. Heyman, County Administrator, reported that in addition to the investigations going on at
Biggs, the ventilation systems in all County buildings are going to be checked. He reported on a meeting
he attended with other County Administrators concerning county organization. Mr. Heyman reported that
Kathleen Drew, Secretary to the Commissioner of Social Services will be transferring to the position of
Secretary to the County Administrator. He stated that the County's request to extend the eight percent
sales tax was approved by the Senate for a period of two years. Kathy West, Deputy County
Administrator, reported on a conference she attended on June 11 at Cornell University where a report was
given on the University's wide commitment to quality improvement and the progress they've made in the
first year. She stated that representatives from the City of Ithaca, Challenge Industries, Special Children's
Center and Ithaca Childcare Center were also in attendance.
Cheryl Nelson, Chair, Employee Council, stated that the Council met on June 2 at which time
updates were given from the various standing committees of the Council. She reported that the Council is
in the process of revising its bylaws, is working on an informational sheet reminding employees of the
professional image that should be portrayed by County employees, is working on the third edition of
"OH" which will soon be released and is working on a County employee directory of depaitiuents'
employees with names and publishable phone numbers. Ms. Nelson also stated that Employee Council
elections should be taking place in August. Ms. Nelson stated that as the County gets into total quality
157
June 15, 1993
management that she hopes there will be a partnership between the County and its employees. The next
Council meeting will be July 7 at 9 a.m. in the Mental Health Building.
Mr. Mulvey, County Attorney, reported on the status of the costs of the Special Prosecutor and
other expenses incurred in the Harding/Lishansky cases.
Chairman Watros reported that members of the Board will be receiving notification of a meeting
which is scheduled for June 21 at noon at Tompkins Cortland Community College. He stated the subject
of this meeting will be a review of the five year Master Plan for the College of which all Board members
are asked to participate in. Mr. Watros stated that a decision will be made soon relative to this which
carries a significant financial obligation to the College's sponsors. He stated that it is important that the
leadership of both Cortland and Tompkins County be informed as to what is being proposed as part of the
Master Plan.
On motion of the appropriate committee chairmen and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by
voice vote by members present, the following resolutions were added to the agenda:
Reaffirmation to Commitment to Establish Priorities for County Services
Authorizing a Public Hearing on Proposed Local Law No. 3 of 1993 - Concerning the Revision
and Updating of the Tag System for the Collection of Solid Waste
Creation of Positions - Department of Social Services
Chairman Watros gave the appropriate committee chairman permission to withdraw from the
agenda the resolution entitled Authorizing a Public Hearing on Proposed Local Law No. d of 1993 -
Amendment of Local Law No. 1 of 1991 - Tompkins County Hotel Room Occupancy Tax Law.
Chairman Watros gave the appropriate committee chairmen permission to withdraw from the
agenda the following resolutions with final committee action being affirmed:
CA061-93 - Authorization Intermunicipal Agreement Between Tompkins County and Cortland
County - Public Transportation Services
CA062-93 - Authorization Intermunicipal Agreement Between Tompkins County and Tioga
County - Public Transportation Services
CA063-93 - Authorization Intermunicipal Agreement Between Tompkins County and Chemung
County - Public Transportation Services
CA064-93 - Budget Adjustments and Appropriations - Various Departments
CA065-93 - Authorization to Contract - Foodnet - Depaitnient of Social Services
CA066-93 - Reclassification of Position - Executive Assistant to the County Administrator to
Secretary to the County Administrator
RESOLUTION NO. 161 - APPROVAL OF CITY AND REGIONAL PLANNING PROGRAM
STUDENTS FOR SUMMER INTERNSHIPS
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Ms. Mink, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County Planning Department has need for summer students to
complete portions of the Department's Work Program, and
WHEREAS, the Department wishes to hire three students from the Cornell University, City and
Regional Planning (CRP) program to fill these roles during the summer months, and
WHEREAS, the Depai intent has funding for one intern in the Planning Depai lnient, one in the
Aquatic Vegetation Control Program and one in TOMTRAN, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning and Personnel Committees, That the Department
be authorized to hire three students for 10 weeks at 20 hours per week at a total cost of $2,600,
158
June 15, 1993
RESOLVED, further, That the County Comptroller be authorized to charge TOMTRAN account
A5630.1053 $850, Planning account A8020.1053 $750 and Aquatic account A8022.4425 $1,000.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 162 - ACCEPTANCE OF 1991 FEDERAL SECTION 18 CAPITAL GRANT -
SMALL BUS PROJECT
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, the County of Tompkins submitted a request for a grant of funds to the New York
State Department of Transportation and the Federal Transit Administration, pursuant to Section 18 of the
Federal Transit Act of 1964, as amended, for a project to purchase two (2) passenger transit buses to be
used in the TOMTRAN Rural Transit System, (PIN 3798.09.306), and
WHEREAS, the budget for the project is as follows:
Federal Section 18 $100,800
New York State 12,600
Tompkins County 12,600
Total $126,000
, and
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County share is encumbered from the 1992 TOMTRAN Budget, now
therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the Tompkins County Board
of Representatives authorizes the County Administrator or designee to sign:
1. Any and all agreements between the County of Tompkins and the State of New York for the
above named project (Contract No. C002203)
2. Any and all agreements between the County of Tompkins and any third party subcontractors
necessary to complete the project, if appropriate
3. Any municipality/vendor contracts for the purchase of vehicles and/or equipment
RESOLVED, further, That the County of Tompkins certifies in this resolution that the local share
of $12,600 is committed to this project form the 1992 TOMTRAN Budget,
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller is authorized to adjust the 1993 TOMTRAN Budget
revenues and appropriations to account for the receipt and expenditure of Federal and State funds for the
proj ect:
Appropriation: A5630.2231 Vehicles $113,400
Revenues: A5630.3594 State Aid $ 12,600
A5630.4594 Federal Aid $100,800
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 163 - AUTHORIZATION TO APPLY FOR FEDERAL SECTION 18
OPERATING ASSISTANCE GRANT FOR TOMTRAN - 1993
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mrs. Schuler. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes -
14, Noes - 0, Excused - 1 (Representative Stein). Adopted.
WHEREAS, the County of Tompkins is submitting a request for a grant of funds to the New York
State Depai tilient of Transportation and the United States Depai lment of Transportation, pursuant to
Section 18 of the Federal Transit Act of 1964 as amended, for a project to provide for public mass
transportation service for Ithaca, Dryden, Caroline, Danby, Newfield, Ulysses, Lansing and Groton, to be
159
June 15, 1993
operated by Cornell University (CU) Transit, Inc. and Tioga Transport, Inc. in the amount of $59,000 for
the 1993 fiscal year, and
WHEREAS, the County of Tompkins and the State of New York have entered into a continuing
agreement for a ten year period which authorizes the undertaking of the project and payment of the
federal share, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the Board of Representatives
authorizes the County Administrator or designee to act on behalf of the County of Tompkins to sign the
annual grant application and to progress and complete the above named project,
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator or designee is authorized to sign any
contracts or agreements between the County of Tompkins and any third party subcontractor necessary to
complete the project.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 164 - AUTHORIZATION OF 1993 FEDERAL SECTION 9 CAPITAL
GRANT - BUS AND FAREBOX PROJECT
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mrs. Schuler. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes -
14, Noes - 0, Excused - 1 (Representative Stein). Adopted.
WHEREAS, the Secretary of the United States Depal twent of Transportation is authorized to make
grants for mass transportation projects pursuant to the Federal Transit Act of 1964, as amended, and
WHEREAS, the County of Tompkins is the designated recipient of Section 9 urban transit funds
and will apply on behalf of the City of Ithaca and other transit providers to receive and use said funds, and
WHEREAS, the County of Tompkins desires to submit a request for a grant of funds to the New
York State Department of Transportation and the Federal Transit Administration, pursuant to Section 9 of
the Federal Transit Act of 1964, as amended, for a project to purchase two (2) 35 foot passenger transit
buses (City of Ithaca) and 29 fareboxes to be used in TOMTRAN, CU Transit and Ithaca Transit bus
fleets, and
WHEREAS, the budget for the project is as follows:
Federal Section 9 $480,000
New York State 60,000
Tompkins County 50,500
Cornell University 9,500
Total $600,000
WHEREAS, the project was approved by the Ithaca -Tompkins County Transportation Council and
is included on the 1993 Transportation Improvement Program, as amended, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the Tompkins County Board
of Representatives authorizes the County Administrator(or designee) to execute and file an application on
behalf of the County of Tompkins with the United States Depal lnient of Transportation and the New
York State Department of Transportation to aid in financing; the capital project pursuant to Section 9 of
the Federal Transit Act of 1964, as amended,
RESOLVED, further, That the County of Tompkins acknowledges the County share of the project
($50,500) to be appropriated in the 1994 budget,
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator (or designee) is authorized to execute grant
agreements on behalf of the County of Tompkins with the United States Depailnient of Transportation
and the New York State Dep.'tment of Transportation to aid in financing the capital project.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
160
June 15, 1993
RESOLUTION NO. 165 - A JOINT COMMITTEE TO STUDY AND SPECIFY METHODS BY
WHICH CITY AND COUNTY SERVICES FOR TRANSIT MAY BE
CONSOLIDATED
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Ms. Mink, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County Legislature has initiated an agreement dated March 18, 1993
between the City and the County to share certain sales tax revenues, and
WHEREAS, the City and County wish to develop mechanisms for more efficient consolidation of
services to be provided by the City and the County, and
WHEREAS, the City and County agreed to establish joint committees for the purpose of
specifying methods by which City and County services for Transit may be consolidated and costs
allocated among County residents, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That an Ithaca/Tompkins County
Transit Coordination Committee be established to study and make recommendations to the County
Legislature and City Council on both the immediate measures that can be undertaken to improve
efficiency of Transit operations as well as identify long-term objectives for consolidation of all Transit
services,
RESOLVED, further, That the Ithaca/Tompkins County Transit Coordination Committee include
the Mayor of the City of Ithaca, Chairperson of Tompkins County Board of Representatives, Chairperson
of County Planning Committee, Chairperson of Ithaca Tompkins Transit Center Operation Committee,
Chairperson of County Fiscal Affairs Committee, Vice -Chair Person of City Board of Public Works who
shall meet and appoint a chairperson, and will be served by a technical advisory group including, Director
of Cornell University Transit Servicers, Tompkins County Planning Commissioner, Director of Ithaca
Tompkins County Transportation Council, Transit Supervisor of Ithaca Transit, City Public Works
Commissioner, and County Public Works Commissioner.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 166 - AUTHORIZING A PUBLIC HEARING - SECOND ADDENDUM TO
LEASE AGREEMENT WITH TAUGHANNOCK AVIATION
CORPORATION - FUEL FARM FOR TOMPKINS COUNTY
AIRPORT
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Culligan, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That a public hearing be held by the Board of Representatives on Tuesday, July 13, 1993 at 5:30 o'clock
in the evening thereof at Board Chambers of the Tompkins County Courthouse, 320 North Tioga Street,
Ithaca, New York concerning a proposed second addendum to a lease agreement with Taughannock
Aviation Corporation at the Tompkins County Airport. At such time and place all persons interested in
the subject matter will be heard concerning the same,
RESOLVED, further, That the Clerk of the Board is hereby authorized and directed to place proper
notice of such public hearing in the official newspaper of the County.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 167 - AUDIT OF FINAL PAYMENT - IVERSON CONSTRUCTION -
PUBLIC TRANSIT FACILITY
161
June 15, 1993
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mrs. Call. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes -
14, Noes - 0, Excused - 1 (Representative Stein). Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the following claim against the County of Tompkins, be and hereby is audited by the Board of
Representatives:
Vendor Payment Request Account No. Amount
Iverson Construction 17 HA5630.4400 $50,000
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller be and hereby is authorized and directed to release
retainage from Account No. HA5630.4400.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 168 - AUDIT OF FINAL PAYMENT - J & K PLUMBING AND HEATING
CO., INC. - PUBLIC TRANSIT FACILITY
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Mason. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes -
14, Noes - 0, Excused - 1 (Representative Stein). Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the following claim against the County of Tompkins, be and hereby is audited by the Board of
Representatives:
Vendor Payment Request Account No. Amount
J&K Plumbing & Heating 12 (Final) HA5630.4400 $29,814
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller be and hereby is authorized and directed to pay said
claim from Account No. HA5630.4400.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 169 - ABOLISH PLANNING SPECIALIST POSITION — PLANNING
DEPARTMENT
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the position of Planning
Specialist (11/564), labor grade K(11) competitive class be abolished effective June 18, 1993.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 170 - CREATION OF POSITIONS - TRANSPORTATION ANALYST,
DATA COLLECTOR, KEYBOARD SPECIALIST - PLANNING
DEPARTMENT (MPO)
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning, Personnel, and Budget and Administration
Committees, That the following positions be created effective immediately:
One Transportation Analyst (13/676), labor grade M(13), competitive class
One Keyboard Specialist (05/507), labor grade E(5), competitive class
162
June 15, 1993
One Data Collector (07/535), labor grade G(7), competitive class
All positions are also subject to the approval of the Ithaca -Tompkins County Transportation
Council Policy Committee,
RESOLVED, further, That sufficient monies are budgeted in the 1993 MPO budget for these
positions and related costs, will be continued as long as MPO money is available.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 171 - APPORTIONMENT OF MORTGAGE TAX
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Shurtleff, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, the County Clerk and the County Administrator have presented their report
concerning mortgage tax receipts for the period from October 1, 1992 through March 31, 1993, pursuant
to Section 261 of the Tax Law, and the same have been apportioned to the various municipalities thereto,
now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the
apportionment as presented for said period from October 1, 1992 through March 31, 1993 be and hereby
is approved:
Municipality Amount Total
Town of Caroline $ 14,488.89
Town of Danby 18,295.89
Dryden: Town $ 93,944.92 101,694.87
Village 6,377.28
Village of Freeville 1,372.67
Town of Enfield 14,741.77
Groton: Town 18,641.62 23,000.64
Village 4,359.02
City of Ithaca 122,150.46
Town of Ithaca 108,073.43 128,302.16
Village of Cayuga Heights 20,228.73
Lansing: Town 99,271.42 125,031.25
Village 25,759.83
Town of Newfield 28,870.68
Ulysses: Town 28,065.78 31,997.90
Trumansburg 3,932.12
Total $608,574.51
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 172 - AUTHORIZING A PUBLIC HEARING ON PROPOSED LOCAL LAW
NO. 4 OF 1993 - AMENDING LOCAL LAW NO. 7 OF 1990 -
PROVIDING FOR AMENDMENTS TO THE CHARTER AND CODE
- ARTICLE 5 - FINANCIAL PROCEDURES AND CONTROLS -
SECTION 5.06 - PUBLIC HEARING
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That a public
hearing be held before the Board of Representatives at Board Chambers of the Tompkins County
163
June 15, 1993
Courthouse, 320 North Tioga Street, Ithaca, New York on Tuesday, July 13, 1993 at 5:30 o'clock in the
evening thereof on proposed Local Law No. 4 of 1993 Amending Local Law No. 7 of 1990 - Providing
for Amendments to the Charter and Code - Article 5 - Financial Procedures and Controls. At such time
and place all persons interested in the subject matter will be heard concerning the same,
RESOLVED, further, That the Clerk of the Board is hereby authorized and directed to place proper
notice of such public hearing in the official newspaper of the County.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 173 - ADOPTION OF FISCAL PLAN FOR TOMPKINS COUNTY
GOVERNMENT
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Todd. It was Moved by Mr. Todd, seconded by Mr. Winch,
to amend number 3, paragraph C: "The target net local share and the allocation of unallocated revenues to
the eight (8) categories of the County budget for 1994 shall be calculated as follows: Two thirds of the
increase (if any) in projected unallocated revenues for 1994 as compared to 1993 as budgeted shall be
allocated to the eight (8) categories of the County budget. An amount equal to two thirds of the rate of
inflation for the previous 12 months according to figures available in July 1993 from the U.S. Bureau of
Labor Statistics, All Urban Wage Earners Index, shall be added to the target net local share for the eight
(8) categories of the County budget. An amount equal to one third of the projected increase in
unallocated revenues plus an amount equal to one third of the rate of inflation referenced above multiplied
by the total net local share for all optional areas of the County budget shall be set aside to be allocated by
the application process for these funds shall be recommended upon by the Fiscal Affairs and Budget and
Administration Committees in time for action by the County Board in July 1993." by substituting the
language with the following: "During the preparation of the 1994 budget, net local share for the eight (8)
categories of the County budget listed above shall not increase in the recommendations of the County
Administrator nor the budget review committees of this Board by a percentage rate greater than the rate of
inflation according to the figures available in July 1993 from the United States Bureau of Labor Statistics,
all Urban Wage Earners Index, for the most recent available twelve (12) month period." and add the
following RESOLVED: "RESOLVED, further, That in any instance when a request is made for funding
in excess of the guidelines in this Plan, the request shall provide information that specifically addresses
each of the following:
a) The strength of public support for addressing the particular need;
b) Appropriateness of County government involvement in addressing the
need, and the desirability of addressing the need through the use of
public or private resources;
c) Severity of the need for the service;
d) Probability of success of meeting the need based on the management
strength and approach of the provider department or agency;
e) An inventory of other existing public and private services available
to meet the need to determine the extent of unmet needs and the mix
of prevention, intervention, remediation, and regulatory services
needed;
f) Number, dispersion, and demographic characteristics of those
experiencing the need, and
g) Potential impact of the program on the budgets of other County
departments.
Some discussion followed regarding the establishment of priorities.
It was Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Joseph, to amend the amendment to add the word
"perceived" before the word "need" in a -f above. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 6
(Representatives Culligan, Evans, Joseph, Proto, Shurtleff and Watros); Noes - 8 (Representatives Call,
164
June 15, 1993
Lerner, Livesay, Mason, Mink, Schuler, Todd and Winch); Excused - 1 (Representative Stein). Motion
Lost.
It was Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Joseph, to separate the motion above and vote on
each section (substitution and additional RESOLVED). A voice vote resulted as follows on the motion to
separate: Ayes - 11, Noes - 3 (Representatives Evans, Mink and Todd), Excused - 1 (Representative
Stein). Adopted.
A voice vote resulted as follows on the motion to substitute number 3, paragraph C: Ayes - 13,
Noes - 1 (Representative Joseph), Excused - 1 (Representative Stein). Adopted.
It was Moved by Mr. Proto to add the wording from Resolution No. 180 at the end of the last
paragraph. Motion failed for lack of a second.
A voice vote resulted as follows on the motion to add the above RESOLVED: Ayes - 12, Noes - 2
(Representatives Mason and Proto), Excused - 1 (Representative Stein). Adopted.
A voice vote resulted as follows on the resolution as amended: Ayes - 14, Noes - 0, Excused - 1
(Representative Stein). Resolution adopted as amended.
WHEREAS, this Board of Representatives adopted and later amended a Fiscal Plan for Tompkins
County government for 1992 and 1993, and wishes to amend and clarify said Plan and extend it to cover
1993 and 1994, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Fiscal Affairs and Budget and Administration
Committees, That the following Fiscal Plan for Tompkins County government is hereby adopted to be in
effect from the date of adoption to December 31, 1994,
STATEMENT OF PURPOSE
The purpose of this Plan is to maintain a sound and stable fiscal position for County government,
to address the problems created by unfunded or under -funded mandates, and to restrain net local spending
while minimizing negative impacts on services wanted and needed by the residents of Tompkins County.
1. FUND BALANCE STABILITY
Definition: An unrestricted Fund Balance consists of any funds in the possession of a
governmental body which have not been appropriated (approved for spending) or reserved for any
purpose. Existence of an unrestricted Fund Balance enables municipalities to respond to unforeseen
negative events and to "level out" the impact of those events on taxpayers, service delivery recipients and
employees.
For purposes of this resolution, the following are not included in the unrestricted Fund Balance:
Retirement Reserves; Construction Funds; Health Premium Reserve; and the Self -Insurance Reserve.
Target: The target unrestricted Fund Balance for Tompkins County government is established by
this Fiscal Plan to be 5 percent of total annual expenditures, net of Interfund expenditures and
construction expenditures paid with borrowed funds. The unrestricted Fund Balance includes all County
Fund Balances except the Airport Fund. (The Airport Fund is maintained, in compliance with Federal
Aviation Administration regulations, only for Airport contingencies.)
The County Comptroller is charged with monitoring expenditures and revenues throughout County
government and with reporting to the Budget and Administration Committee and the County
Administrator during May, July and monthly thereafter with respect to any projected shortfalls or
surpluses at year-end. The County Administrator shall recommend to the Budget and Administration
Committee appropriate action based on this report.
165
June 15, 1993
2. UNFUNDED AND UNDERFUNDED MANDATES
Net local expenditures for Education of Handicapped Children; Legal Defense of Indigents
(payments to attorneys only); Social Services; Jail personal services, fringe benefit and professional
services costs; and costs of County students attending other community colleges shall be calculated
separately from the remainder of the County budget and shall be fully described and explained to the
public at least yearly. These strict legal mandates, imposed in every case by the federal government,
state government, the courts, or all three, shall not be included in spending targets in #3 below.
Education of Handicapped Children: This Board and the appropriate
committee shall monitor the work authorized during 1992 to occur in 1993
in the Public Health and Social Services Depaitments aimed at increasing
the number of handicapped children in the least restrictive environment,
to their benefit and with the result of reducing costs. These two
departments are charged with reporting at least quarterly to the Health
and Education Committee on the status of this initiative.
Jail Operations: In its actions in connection with the 1993 budget in
the Probation Department, this Board demonstrated its commitment to
reducing the population of the Tompkins County Jail without unreasonably
endangering the safety of this community. This Board directs the Public
Safety Committee and the County Administrator to consult with the Sheriff
of Tompkins County to develop recommendations that will ensure that the
boarding out of prisoners to other counties is kept to an absolute
minimum, that the transport of imprisoned persons to New York State
Psychiatric Hospitals is reviewed carefully for medical appropriateness,
and that the opportunities for boarding in of prisoners from other
counties are maximized. In addition the Public Safety Committee is
charged with continuing to work with the Criminal Justice
Advisory/Alternatives to Incarceration Board to develop alternatives to
the use of the Tompkins County Jail that are appropriate.
Legal Defense of Indigents: Upon receipt of a recommendation from the
Article 18 Task Force established in 1992 by this Board, this Board shall
authorize any changes in the current method of ensuring the provision of
effective counsel to indigent persons in criminal and family matters. By
this resolution this Board directs that a charge be developed to the
oversight body established or continued as a result of the above action
to pay serious attention to this Board's desire to ensure that reasonable
steps are taken that will prevent the assignment of attorneys to persons
who are not indigent, that will maximize appropriate co -payments by
defended persons, and that will ensure that payments to attorneys are
accurate and appropriate.
Social Services: This Board continues its support of initiatives
undertaken by the New York State Association of Counties to reform the
provision of social services and the proposal of the Governor of the State
of New York, supported by the New York State Association of Counties,
that the State of New York accept all fiscal responsibility for
provision of medical assistance to indigent persons, until that is done,
the Public Health Department shall emphasize preventive health care
programs that improve public health and reduce County Medicaid costs.
Community College Chargebacks: The cost to Tompkins County for Tompkins
166
June 15, 1993
County students to attend community colleges in other New York State
counties must by law be paid to the college that the student attends.
The County encourages Tompkins Cortland Community College to continue to
exercise its best efforts to minimize these chargebacks by attracting as
many Tompkins County and other students to the Community College as
possible.
3. STABILIZATION OF NET LOCAL SPENDING
A. All expenditures and revenues in the remainder of the Tompkins County budget shall be
divided into the categories of community services, education, general government support, health, human
services, public safety, public works (includes solid waste) and capital. The last shall include debt
service.
B. The Target Net Local Share for 1993 for all of the above -listed areas of the County budget
shall be considered to be the figure indicated on a document prepared by the Deputy County
Administrator entitled 1993/1994 Fiscal Plan Target Net Local Share Calculation and dated April 23,
1993.
Clarification: "Net Local Share" as used in this resolution means total spending authority of each
department or account as listed in the above- referenced document prepared by the Deputy County
Administrator, after applicable departmental revenues and pro rata share of unallocated revenues have
been subtracted. A result of this is that if total estimated unallocated revenues in 1994 increase, the Net
Local Share for all County spending will increase by that amount. In the event that estimated proceeds of
unallocated revenues decrease, the Net Local Share for all County spending will decrease by that amount.
See, in addition, the provisions of #4 below which will have the effect of reducing target net local
shares of depai tiiients and agencies when so specified by the Board of Representatives.
C. During the preparation of the 1994 budget, net local share for the eight (8) categories of the
County budget listed above shall not increase in the recommendations of the County Administrator nor
the budget review committees of this Board by a percentage rate greater than the rate of inflation
according to the figures available in July 1993 from the United States Bureau of Labor Statistics, all
Urban Wage Earners Index, for the most recent available (12) month period.
D. Program committees of this Board are authorized to approve two-year (1993 and 1994)
spending plans that meet the overall requirements of this resolution and of the 1992 Fiscal Plan.
E. The Net Local Share established for Tompkins Cortland Community College under this
resolution shall refer to the total sponsor share appropriated by Tompkins and Cortland Counties together.
For example, if the rate of inflation defined above is determined in July 1993 to be 3 percent, and the net
impact of unallocated revenues does not increase or decrease the net local share for the Community
College (total Tompkins and Cortland appropriation of new money) would increase at 3 percent above the
College's previous year budget. In the event that the Tompkins County share of student enrollments at the
College increased or decreased from the previous year's level, however, the Tompkins County target
would be increased or decreased by the dollar amount resulting from that shift.
4. CONTINGENT FUND
It is the intention of this resolution that departments and agencies must accommodate unexpected
expenditures with their own previously appropriated funds. This Board will not entertain favorably
requests for Contingent Fund appropriations except in the most extreme circumstances.
Departments may request Contingent Fund appropriations for expenditures from personal services
and fringe benefit accounts for terminal pay and replacement staff costs that, during a fiscal year, exceed
25 percent of the department's 1992 budget reduction obligation.
167
June 15, 1993
Whenever there occurs a request, recommendation, or action appropriating funds from the
Contingent Fund or from any Fund Balance, it must be specified whether the appropriation increases the
target net local share of the department or agency receiving the funds, and whether any increase in the
*target net local share increases the overall target for County government as a whole, or whether, in the
alternative, these funds will be subtracted pro rata from the target net local share for all depai tnients and
agencies for the ensuing fiscal year.
Whenever there is a request, recommendation or action in connection with the budget that results
in net local spending in excess of the targets in this Fiscal Plan, the party requesting, recommending or
acting, must specify in writing the source of funds to pay for said spending.
5. RE -APPROPRIATION OF UNSPENT FUNDS FROM PREVIOUS YEAR'S RESOLUTION
Resolution No. 339 of 1992, outlining a procedure for re -appropriation of unspent funds from
previous years, is reaffirmed in its entirety.
RESOLVED, further, That in any instance when a request is made for funding in excess of the
guidelines in this Plan, the request shall provide information that specifically addresses each of the
following:
a) The strength of public support for addressing the particular need;
b) Appropriateness of County government involvement in addressing the need, and the desirability
of addressing the need through the use of public or private resources;
c) Severity of the need for the service;
d) Probability of success of meeting the need based on the management strength and approach of
the provider department or agency;
e) An inventory of other existing public and private services available to meet the need to
determine the extent of unmet needs and the mix of prevention, intervention, remediation, and regulatory
services needed;
f) Number, dispersion, and demographic characteristics of those experiencing the need, and
g) Potential impact of the program on the budgets of other County depai tments.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 174 - ADOPTION OF ADDITIONS, REVISIONS AND DELETIONS -
ADMINISTRATIVE MANUAL POLICIES
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the
following Administrative Manual policies be and hereby are adopted:
01-38 Software
01-39 Commitment to Serving the Public Without Discrimination
03-01 Benefits for Management Staff
03-02 Benefits for Confidential Staff
RESOLVED, further, That the following revised Administrative Manual policies be and hereby are
adopted:
01-06 Public Access to Records
01-09 Petty Cash Funds
01-10 Contracts
01-15 State Aid Reimbursement
01-17 Work-study Programs
01-22 Risk Management and Safety
168
June 15, 1993
01-27 Sale of County Publications
01-28 County -owned Vehicles
02-04 Processing New Employees
02-10 Outside Employment
03-05 Health Insurance
03-07 Moving Expenses Reimbursement
04-02 Overtime Compensation, Compensatory Time Off and Discretionary Time Off
04-06 Compensation Plans
04-07 Paychecks
04-13 Starting Salaries
05-01 Departmental Operations Report
05-02 Budget Approval Process
05-04 Transfer of Funds, Budget Adjustments, Appropriations
06-07 Bidding Procedures
06-09 County -owned Buildings, Equipment and Furniture
06-10 Equipment Rental
RESOLVED, further, That the following Administrative Manual policies be and hereby are
deleted:
03-14 Drawing of Earned Credits Upon Retirement
06-05 Purchase of Unbudgeted Equipment
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 175 - CREATION OF POSITIONS - DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL
SERVICES
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation Human Services and Budget and Administration Committees,
That four (4) full-time positions of Social Welfare Examiner (11/538), labor grade K (11), competitive
class, be created immediately. The positions will be reviewed quarterly for need based on staffing levels
and caseload changes,
RESOLVED, further, That no new monies are needed during 1993 to fund these positions and
associated equipment costs (desks, chairs, telephones).
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 176 - TOMPKINS COUNTY FIRE/EMS SERVICE "COMPUTER AIDED
DISPATCH"
Moved by Mr. Mason, seconded by Mrs. Call, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, the State Legislature has appropriated in the 1992-93 State Budget in Legislative
Member Item C933186, an amount of $36,000, and
WHEREAS, these funds were set aside for a Computer Aided Dispatch Upgrade of software,
hardware for alarm reporting for Tompkins County, and
WHEREAS, the funds are available through the New York State Office of Fire Prevention and
Control to Tompkins County, and
WHEREAS, there are no needed County matching funds required, now therefore be it
169
June 15, 1993
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Safety Committee, That the County Administrator
be and hereby is authorized and directed to sign such Project Agreement as may be required to secure
such funds.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 177 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE AGREEMENT WITH NEW YORK
STATE OFFICE OF PARKS, RECREATION AND HISTORIC
PRESERVATION AND APPROPRIATION FROM CONTINGENT
FUND (Rescinded by Resolution No. 211 of 1993)
Moved by Mr. Mason, seconded by Mr. Lerner, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, Tompkins county executed an agreement with the New York State Office of Parks,
Recreation and Historic Preservation in 1980, providing for rental payments in compensation for the use
of land on Connecticut Hill in connection with the Emergency Communications System owned and
operated by Tompkins County, and
WHEREAS, payments under that agreement have never been made pending further agreement
between the County and New York State Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation with
respect to the appropriate means of payment, and
WHEREAS, agreement has not been reached on the appropriate means of payment, now therefore
be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Safety and Budget and Administration
Committees, That the Comptroller is directed to appropriate $38,121 from Account A1990, Contingent
Fund, to Account A3410.4432, Depaitwent of Fire, Disaster and Emergency Medical Services Rental,
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator is directed to execute a cooperative
agreement with the New York State Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation, providing for
rental payment in the amount of $1,150 per month for land on Connecticut Hill as described above,
RESOLVED, further, That all payments under this agreement shall be credited to the Solid Waste
Division in compensation for solid waste charges (per -ton fee and solid waste user fee) levied by
Tompkins County on the New York State Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation,
RESOLVED, further, That this appropriation increases the target local spending for the Public
Safety Committee for 1993 and thereafter but not increase the total local spending for County government
as a whole beyond 1993.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 178 - RESOLUTION OF COMMENDATION TO THE COMMUNITY OF
NE WFIELD
Moved by Mr. Mason, seconded by Mr. Winch, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, in an effort to improve its community public safety and response, and
WHEREAS, in cooperation the Newfield Town Board, Newfield Fire Depai tiuent, Newfield Post
Office and Newfield resident, Charles Mosher; have completed the first Town wide naming of all private
and public roads, and
WHEREAS, this system will give every private and public road a different and united road name
and this will also assign a house number to each resident in the Town, and
WHEREAS, this will assure Tompkins County Emergency Dispatch Center a correct address for
its new Computer Aided Dispatch operation, and
170
June 15, 1993
WHEREAS, by this great effort in the Town of Newfield, it will speed the delivery of emergency
services to all its residents and this impressive effort by the Town and its residents to improve quality of
life, and
WHEREAS, this shows that a community by working together, has resources and skills available
to handle in a professional manner, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of Public Safety Committee, That the Tompkins County Board
of Representatives congratulates and commends all those organizations and individuals in this most
important and impressive effort.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 179 - AUTHORIZATION FOR PUBLIC HEARING - TOMPKINS
CORTLAND COMMUNITY COLLEGE OPERATING AND
CAPITAL BUDGETS - 1993-94
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Shurtleff, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education Committee, That a public hearing
be held on Tuesday, July 13, 1993, at 5:30 o'clock in the evening thereof in Board Chambers of the
Tompkins County Courthouse, 320 North Tioga Street, Ithaca, New York concerning the 1993-94
operating and capital budget request for Tompkins Cortland Community College. At such time and place
all persons interested in the subject matter will be heard concerning the same,
RESOLVED, further, That the Clerk of the Board be and hereby is directed to place such notice of
public hearing in the official newspaper of Tompkins County.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
It was Moved by Mr. Todd, seconded by Mr. Mason, to refer Resolution No. 180 entitled
"Resolution of Commitment to Establishing Priorities for County Services" to Committee. A voice vote
resulted as follows: Ayes - 5 (Representatives Lerner, Livesay, Mason, Schuler and Todd); Noes - 9
(Representatives Call, Culligan, Evans, Joseph, Mink, Proto, Shurtleff, Winch and Watros); Excused - 1
(Representative Stein). Motion Lost.
RESOLUTION NO. 180 - RESOLUTION OF COMMITMENT TO ESTABLISHING
PRIORITIES FOR COUNTY SERVICES
Moved by Mr. Todd, seconded by Mrs. Call, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, this Board has adopted a second Fiscal Plan covering the Calendar years 1993 and
1994, and
WHEREAS, this Plan makes no distinction among the various programs and departments of
County government but allocates the same percentage funding increase to each, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Fiscal Affairs Committee, That this Board recommits
itself to establishing a method of setting priorities among County programs and departments which
priorities reflect the values and goals of the community as a whole,
RESOLVED, further, That the Fiscal Affairs Committee, and/or its successor Committee are
charged with working with the County Administrator to ensure adequate staff support for this purpose and
with recommending a process for establishment of priorities in time for adoption by this Board during the .
current calendar year so that a newly -elected Board may review and, if desired, amend this process
171
June 15, 1993
sufficiently early in 1994 so that it may be implemented in connection with adoption of the 1995 County
Budget and Capital Program.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 181 - AUTHORIZING A PUBLIC HEARING ON PROPOSED LOCAL LAW
NO. 3 OF 1993 - CONCERNING THE REVISION AND UPDATING
OF THE TAG SYSTEM FOR THE COLLECTION OF SOLID
WASTE
Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mr. Todd, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, That
a public hearing be held before the Board of Representatives at Board Chambers of the Tompkins County
Courthouse, 320 North Tioga Street, Ithaca, New York at a Special Meeting Tuesday, June 29, 1993 at
5:30 o'clock in the evening thereof concerning proposed Local Law No. 3 of 1993 - Concerning the
Revision and Updating of the Tag System for the Collection of Solid Waste,
RESOLVED, further, That the Clerk of the Board is hereby authorized and directed to place proper
notice of such public hearing in the official newspaper of the County.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
Some discussion followed concerning Resolution No. 175 entitled "Creation of Positions -
Department of Social Services". Mrs. Call referred to a document from Mary Pat Dolan which was
discussed at the Human Services Committee.
It was Moved by Mr. Mason, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to appoint Benjamin Darden to the Advisory Board on Indigent Representation for a
term which expires December 31, 1995.
Chairman Watros declared recess at 8:32 p.m. The meeting reconvened at 8:43 p.m.
It was Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mrs. Call, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to enter executive session to discuss contract negotiations, personnel matter and
litigation. An executive session was held from 8:43 p.m. to 9:29 p.m.
On motion, the meeting adjourned at 9:29 p.m.
172
June 29, 1993
Special Meeting
Catherine Covert, Clerk of the Board, called the meeting to order at 5:30 p.m. Mrs. Covert stated
that Mr. Watros, Chairman of the Board, and Mr. Mason, Vice Chairman of the Board, have been
excused from the meeting. Mrs. Covert stated that pursuant to the Rules of the Board the first order of
business would be the election of a chairman pro tem. Mr. Lerner nominated Mr. Stein chairman pro
tem, seconded by Ms. Mink. Mr. Proto nominated Mr. Culligan chairman pro tem, seconded by Mr.
Evans. Mr. Culligan declined the nomination. After hearing no more nominations, it was Moved by
Mrs. Livesay, seconded by Mr. Lerner, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members present, to
close nominations. Following a voice vote, it was unanimously adopted by a show of hands by members
present to elect Mr. Stein Chairman pro tem.
Mr. Stein called the public hearing to order at 5:34 p.m. concerning proposed Local Law No. 3 of
1993 - Repealing Local Law No. 10 of 1990 and Revising and Updating the Tag System for the
Collection of Solid Waste.
Mr. Stein asked if any one wished to speak? No one wished to speak and the public hearing was
closed at 5:43 p.m.
Members and guests participated in the Pledge of Allegiance.
Present: 11 Representatives. Excused: 4 (Representatives Call, Mason, Shurtleff and Watros).
Under privilege of the floor, James Ellis, Department of Social Services employee, spoke
concerning sick building syndrome. Mr. Ellis stated that he has been out of work since June 2, 1993.
Mr. Ellis thanked the Board for helping to expedite some of the paperwork that employees have
requested and stated that some progress has been made in getting the requested infolination. Mr. Ellis
also stated that people are still sick and that the problems with the building continue to exist.
Under privilege of the floor, Margaret Marks, Department of Social Services employee, spoke
concerning sick building syndrome. She said that she has been out of work since March 9, 1993 and does
not receive any compensation or any type of income for her disability. Ms. Marks thanked the Board for
responding to requests for information she made at the Board meeting on June 15, 1993. She stated that
although all of her requests for infolination haven't been received, she was appreciative of the recent
progress.
Under privilege of the floor, Yvonne Bartlett, Department of Social Services employee, spoke
concerning sick building syndrome. Ms. Bartlett stated that she has been out of work since March 1,
1993 and does not receive any compensation or any type of income for her disability. She stated that the
Seneca County Department of Social Services has denied her request for assistance because her husband
owns a fire truck valued at $10,000. Ms. Bartlett stated that she feels the Board is becoming more aware
of the situation at the Biggs complex but feels there is more that needs to be looked into.
Under privilege of the floor, Vicki Ellis, spouse of James Ellis who is a Department of Social
Services employee, spoke concerning sick building syndrome. Mrs. Ellis explained to the Board
problems her husband has which are believed to be caused by sick building syndrome and the effects the
situation has had on their family. She said that her husband would like to return to work and asked that
an safe environment be provided so that these people can return to their jobs.
Under privilege of the floor, Chrissy Bartlett, daughter of Yvonne Bartlett who is a Department of
Social Services employee, stated that she has been helping others at home who are affected by sick
building syndrome. She stated that her mother is very sick and not able to do things that she use to do.
173
June 29, 1993
Under privilege of the floor, Claudia Cinquanti, Department of Social Services employee, spoke
concerning sick building syndrome. Ms. Cinquanti stated that she has developed multiple chemical
sensitivities as a result of the carpeting adhesives and other chemicals used in the Biggs complex. Ms.
Cinquanti stated that as a single parent, she depends on her income and would like to return to a safe
working environment.
Under privilege of the floor, Henry Vaughan, Chan man of the Neighborhood Advisory Committee
for the Commercial Avenue Central Processing Facility, spoke concerning the proposed central
processing facility. Mr. Vaughan stated that it is the opinion of the Advisory Committee that the location
is still one of high risk. He said that although they do not recommend the location of the facility, the
Committee is committed to working with the County to minimize the impact. Mr. Vaughan asked that
the Board support the funding for installation of an observation deck at the facility. He stated that this
would be a way to ensure the County would be under public scrutiny to keep the area clean and also used
as be an educational tool for school children and the public.
Under privilege of the floor, Ernest Bury, Valley Road, Ithaca, spoke concerning the recent
Chamber of Commerce forum at which other counties discussed the handling of solid waste. Mr. Bury
stated that it is his opinion that Tompkins County is spending too much money on the handling of solid
waste.
Under privilege of the floor, H. Taraszkiewicz, Hanshaw Road, Ithaca, spoke concerning the Solid
Waste Annual Fee. Mr. Taraszkiewicz stated that he is in the process of circulating a survey to be
presented to the Board in opposition to this fee.
Under privilege of the floor, Ms. Mink, Representative, District No. 5, responded to comments
made during privilege of the floor concerning the situation at the Biggs complex. She stated that a
meeting was held recently and felt the meeting went very well. She reported on the high level of activity
on this subject and stated several requests for information have been answered. She stated that a plan
should soon be ready that addresses accommodations for people to return to work in the building. Ms.
Mink expressed an apology on behalf of the County for it taking so long to get this level of activity.
Under privilege of the floor, Mr. Joseph, Representative, District No. 12, spoke concerning health
care in America and recent attempts to promote versions of health care care programs by advertising on
television. He stated that television stations were refusing to run these advertisements because the
station didn't want to offend the insurance industry or risk their advertisers. He stated that the he feels
the debate over a national health plan is not only being dominated by special interests but being censored
by them as well.
It was Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to add to the agenda the resolution entitled Charging the Ad Hoc Committee on Solid
Waste Finance with Developing Alternative Financing Options.
RESOLUTION NO. 182 - AUTHORIZING A PUBLIC HEARING - VARIOUS CONCESSIONS -
TOMPKINS COUNTY AIRPORT
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That a public hearing be held by the Board of Representatives on Tuesday, July 13, 1993 at 5:30 o'clock
in the evening thereof at Board Chambers of the Tompkins County Courthouse, 320 North Tioga Street,
Ithaca, New York concerning contracts for Advertising Services, Automated Teller Machine (ATM),
174
June 29, 1993
Rental Cars, Telephones, and the combined Restaurant/Bar, Gift Shop and Vending Machine concession.
At such time and place all persons interested in the subject matter will be heard concerning the same,
RESOLVED, further, That the Clerk of the Board is hereby authorized and directed to place
proper notice of such public hearing in the official newspaper of the County.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
At this point in the meeting, Mr. Stein stated that the remainder of the meeting would focus on
solid waste issues and asked to Mr. Lerner, Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management
Committee to lead the discussion.
RESOLUTION NO. 183 - ADOPTION OF LOCAL LAW NO. 3 OF 1993 - REPEALING LOCAL
LAW NO. 10 OF 1990 AND REVISING AND UPDATING THE TAG
SYSTEM FOR THE COLLECTION OF SOLID WASTE
Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mr. Todd. Mr. Lerner stated that on March 30, 1993 the
Board adopted a resolution calling for a five -point plan for better regulations on private trash haulers. He
stated that this Local Law differs from the existing Trash Tag Law because it will require the haulers to
make single trash tags available to customers and at the end of the year haulers will be required to offer
refunds for expired tags within 90 days of expiration date of the tag. The Law also requires for the
hauler's tag to stipulate the County and the haulers cost. He stated that the original Law was adopted
prior to the Flow Control Local Law and the proposed Law will be consistent with the Flow Control
Law. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 10, Noes - 1 (Representative Proto), Excused - 4
(Representatives Call, Mason, Shurtleff and Watros). Adopted.
WHEREAS, a public hearing has been held before the Board of Representatives on June 29, 1993
to hear all person interested in proposed Local Law No. 3 of 1993, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, That
said proposed Local Law No. 3 of 1993 repealing Local Law No. 10 of 1990 and revising and updating
the Tag System for the collection of solid waste be and hereby is adopted,
RESOLVED, further, That the Clerk of the Board publish in the official newspaper of Tompkins
County a notice of adoption containing a synopsis of said Local Law, and shall within five (5) days file
one certified copy in the office of the County Clerk and three (3) certified copies in the office of the
Secretary of State.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
Mr. Lerner introduced the Flow Control Recommendation Report. He referred to problems that
occurred last year with commercial trash haulers taking trash out of the County which resulted in the
County's Solid Waste Division not receiving anticipated revenues of approximately one million dollars.
The Board voted on March 30 for the Solid Waste Manager and the County Attorney's office to prepare
recommendations on how to improve the enforcement of the Flow Control Law. Mr. Lerner reviewed the
following recommendations:
1, Hauler License and Revocation/Suspension: The report states that the licensing
revocation/suspension section (Section 8) of Local Law No. 3 of 1992 (Flow Control Law) contains
ambiguities regarding when a license can be revoked or suspended. Section 8 does not make it clear that
a violation of the Flow Control Law is sufficient reason to suspend or revoke a license. The Law should
be amended to give the County Solid Waste Division the authority to suspend a license immediately
when a violation occurs and prior to conducting
175
June 29, 1993
a hearing. The threat of revoking a hauler's license is a better deterrent than issuing appearance tickets.
By taking this action, the County will be closing an existing loophole. Mr. Todd stated that he feels the
County should act quickly because there is potential for abuse and said he thinks haulers should be
assured that if their license is suspended they will get a hearing.
2. Add an Additional Part-time Enforcement Staff Position: There has not been enough staff time
to follow-up on complaints about possible Flow Control violations. The Solid Waste Division looked
into contracting with the Sheriffs Department, contracting with a private investigator and expanding staff
in the Solid Waste Division. Mr. Lerner stated that it was found that the most inexpensive and cost
effective way would be the hiring of a half-time position at an annual cost of $12,000. Mr. Proto asked
how creating another position in the Solid Waste Division would fit into the County's Fiscal Plan for
1994. Mr. Lerner stated that the Fiscal Plan only applies to programs in departments that are funded with
unallocated revenues from property or sales tax. Mr. Proto stated that it is important for the public to
know that these are not tax generated dollars. Mr. Proto referred to when the Sheriffs Department
handled illegal dumping and asked what the cost difference would be when handled through the Solid
Waste Division. Mr. Lerner stated that the salary for a Solid Waste Assistant is substantially less than
that of a Sheriffs Deputy but can do the very same job in terms of enforcing flow control.
3. Disposal Time Limits: this would impose a time limit of 72 hours from the time trash is picked
up and delivered to the transfer facility. This would assist investigative staff in tracking down violators
of the Flow Control Law. Mr. Proto asked if this had been discussed with the haulers. Mrs. Eckstrom
stated that it had been preliminarily discussed with them and that she felt that 72 hours was a sufficient
time. Mr. Stein suggested separating the issue of should there be a time limit and what that time limit
should be. Mr. Lerner stated that this is an area that needs further discussion and will be researched more
before the Board votes on a revised law. Mr. Winch stated that if a time limit were imposed, he would
hope the law would allow provisions for mechanical breakdowns. It was the consensus of the Board that
a time limit should be pursued.
4. Enforcement Designee: This gives the Solid Waste Division the authority to issue appearance
tickets to violators of the Flow Control Law.
5. Federal Constitutional Issues: The Assistant County Attorney should follow federal
constitutional issues related to flow control and advise the Board accordingly when the County's Flow
Control law is affected.
At this point in the meeting, Mr. Lerner reviewed with the Board the proposed Transfer Facility
Payment Plan. He stated that there have been problems with delinquent accounts, unpaid bills and
inconvenient payment methods. The proposed plan will reduce the County's financial risk substantially
and streamline County accounting practices and provide the required financial security. The following
steps are recommended by the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee:
1. Accepting credit cards at the transfer station for fees up to $1,000. This will simplify most
transactions and reduce the large sums of cash handled at the transfer station. Mr. Lerner stated that the
Solid Waste Division will be working with the State Comptroller's office on this.
2. Continue the present prepayment coupon system and implement a punch card prepayment
system. Punch cards would be sold by fixed dollar denomination amounts and change could be paid/or
returned as cash at the gate.
3. Extend credit privileges only to accounts that have average monthly charges of more than
$1,000. Accounts which do not prepay would be required to guarantee payment by providing a bond
equal to two months billings. Municipalities would not be required to guarantee payment provided their
accounts are maintained on a current basis.
176
June 29, 1993
Mr. Lerner stated that in the past there have been some problems with how the County tracked
accounts at the Transfer Station. He said current billing procedures are cumbersome and require manual
verification of account billings to facility user's permit numbers and that no easy access to account
history is maintained. He introduced the Report entitled Tompkins County Transfer Station Billing
Procedures and System Software Recommendation Report. The recommendations of the report are as
follows:
1. Software: The County should purchase accounting software during the interim period until the
Recycling and Solid Waste Center is on line. The estimated cost to upgrade the accounting software in
1993 would be approximately $600.
2. Billing and Accounting Procedures: The billing and accounting responsibility should be
transferred to the Solid Waste Division in 1994. This will enhance and streamline the billing process and
be less expensive for the County. The Comptroller would retain responsibility for auditing and
confirmation of accurate procedures. Mr. Lerner stated that at this time the Solid Waste Division is
paying the salary for a Sr. Account Clerk in the Comptroller's office. Mr. Culligan stated that it is
important that both the Comptroller's office and the Solid Waste office know what is going on and feels
there should be a guide for person who will be handling these accounts to alert the Comptroller's office of
any problems.
Mr. Lerner stated that included with the agenda is an update on the status of negotiations on the
Tompkins County Recycling and Solid Waste Center with New England CR Inc. He stated that the
information has been carefully put together so that it can be released and discussed in public session. He
stated that the original Request for Proposals for the Recycling and Solid Waste Center called for a
public convenience area designed to accommodate 100 cars a day. He stated that the volumes of traffic
at the Willow Avenue facility have gone way above 100 cars a day. He stated that the County has asked
CR Inc. to redesign the public area to accommodate 400 cars a day.
Mr. Evans stated that discussed in the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee was the
possibility that the when the County goes to full curbside collection of recycling that the rural drop-off
centers will be closed in the rural areas. Mr. Evans asked how this would affect the Recycling and Solid
Waste Center. Mr. Lerner stated that drop-off centers would be closed only if all things taken there could
be picked up at the curbside so the average homeowner would not need to go to a drop-off center. For
those with larger volumes i.e. small business, they would go to the hauler base at the Recycling and Solid
Waste Center rather than the public convenience area.
It was the consensus of the Board to negotiate for the larger public convenience area. Mr. Proto
stated that he wanted reassurance that a decision to close the rural drop-off centers has not been made at
this point. Mr. Lerner stated that this subject has not had a full Committee discussion at this point and
that no decision has been made at this time to close these centers.
3. Future Billings at the Recycling and Solid Waste Center: There are several criteria that will
guide the selection for billing procedures at the Recycling and Solid Waste Center including integrated
accounts, user customizing, flexible data handling and report generation, access to system from remote
location and multi-level security.
Mr. Lerner stated that the Neighborhood Advisory Committee for the Commercial Avenue Central
Processing Facility has forcefully recommended that there be a public observation area at the Facility for
school children, interested tourists or members of the public. This would be an educational tool so that
work being done at the facility could be seen by the public and could also be used as a means for the
public to scrutinize the facility. He stated that this would increase the overall price of the Facility by
more than $150,000 but less than $200,000. Mr. Lerner asked for the Boards' guidance on this.
177
June 29, 1993
There was discussion on the cost of this including the high cost of installing an elevator and
possible ways to reduce the cost. Mr. Proto asked that if the Board decided not to move forward with the
observation area at this time what the cost would be of adding it at a later date. Mrs. Eckstrom, Solid
Waste Manager, stated that it would be difficult and much more costly at a later time. Mr. Lerner
suggested that at this time have the contract include the observation area with the following stipulations:
That in the next two weeks the Committee look into ways to bring the cost down and allow to have the
observation area removed from the contract easily if the Board so decided. Mrs. Livesay and Mr. Winch
stated that they feel the use of the area as an educational tool would be a benefit. Mr. Todd stated that as
Liaison to the Neighborhood Advisory Committee for the Commercial Avenue Central Processing
Facility, he believes this item is important to them and plans to support it. Mr. Joseph stated that he
believes in the points made on this issue but is concerned with other programs in the County that need
additional funding. Mr. Stein stated that if this is going to be done, it should be done in a way that is safe
and attractive and will get a lot of use. It was the consensus of the Board to move forward and to look
into this much more carefully.
Mr. Lerner presented the preliminary Solid Waste budget for 1994 with slight revisions to the one
presented at the June 1, 1993 Board meeting. He also presented a chart on Solid Waste Capital Projects
and Debt Service. Mr. Lerner cautioned members against using earlier inaccurate drafts of this report
and stated that the report dated June 29, 1993 contains the most current and accurate figures available at
this time.
Mr. Lerner stated that in February Chairman Watros appointed an Ad Hoc Committee on Solid
Waste Finance and reported that although everyone would like to eliminate the Solid Waste Annual Fee
in 1994, it is not clear that it is possible. He stated that if the Board approves a renewed Annual Fee for
1994, he would expect significant improvements to be made in that fee. He stated that the fee could be
improved by the way apai tâ–ºnents are handled and stated that negotiations have begun with the Colleges to
insure they pay their fair share. He stated that he would also like to see a better way to handle an annual
fee with low income families. Mr. Lerner stated that he feels that if there is going to be an annual fee, all
of the unfairness cannot be eliminated and the fee shouldn't represent too large of a portion of the Solid
Waste budget. He would prefer to cut the fee in half if it cannot be eliminated in 1994.
RESOLUTION NO. 184 - CHARGING THE AD HOC COMMITTEE ON SOLID WASTE
FINANCE WITH DEVELOPING ALTERNATIVE FINANCING
OPTIONS
Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mr. Evans. He presented and explained the Table entitled
Solid Waste Financing Options for 1994. He said that if the tipping fee in 1994 is going to be less than
$192 per ton, the difference has to be accounted for. He thinks that a fee for recycling service is an
interesting option but not practical for 1994. The only options for 1994 are the property tax, an annual
fee or a combination of both. There was discussion on the various financing combinations as presented
in the Table.
Mr. Proto asked what the highest level the tipping fee could be. Mr. Lerner stated that the highest
tipping fee that has been suggested has been $120.
Mr. Stein declared recess at 7:47 p.m. The meeting reconvened at 7:51 p.m.
Mr. Lerner stated that the Board should keep in mind that the higher the tipping fee, the greater of
a chance for non-compliance of the Flow Control Law. Mr. Proto stated that he would like a financing
option developed at a relatively higher tipping fee. A voice vote on the resolution resulted as follows:
Ayes - 11, Noes - 0, Excused - 4 (Representatives Call, Mason, Shurtleff and Watros). Adopted.
178
June 29, 1993
WHEREAS, Resolution No. 95 of March 30, 1993 charged the Ad Hoc Committee on Solid Waste
Finance with developing a plan to finance county solid waste services for 1994 and thereafter, with
priority given to the following criteria: Stable, Fair, Protects the Environment, Easy to Implement, Easy
to Enforce and Low in Cost, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Solid Waste Resource Management Committee, That the
Ad Hoc Committee on Solid Waste Finance is further charged with the following by the August 10 Board
meeting:
1. Divide the Solid Waste Division budget into the following programs, and any others that are
necessary:
Management
Disposal
Recyclable Collection
Recycling
Composting
Waste Reduction
Old Landfills
Facility Development
2. Identify dedicated revenue streams for each of these programs, including license and permit
fees, sale of equipment, marketing of recyclables, and grants.
3. Establish a sludge tipping fee at the interim composting facility that comes as close as possible
to paying for all interim composting program costs, plus an appropriate share of management costs.
4. Include appropriate debt service costs across programs appropriately.
5. Distribute management costs across programs appropriately.
6. Recommend a way of funding the balance of each program, choosing from among the tipping
fee, property tax and the annual solid waste fee.
7. Develop alternate plans that include both relatively higher and lower tipping fees.
8. Develop alternate plans that include or exclude property tax as a funding source.
9. Report on projected solid waste budgets through 1998, describing the impact of those
projections on each alternate plan.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
Mr. Todd urged the Board to review the tables and charts presented very carefully. He
commended Mr. Lerner and staff for the time and work they put into these charts.
Mrs. Livesay, Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management Sub -Committee on the
Tompkins County Solid Waste Management Plan, reported that revisions to the Plan began three months
ago and involves revising the Plan to conform to policy changes made by this Board. The comments
received from the public last year on the Draft Plan also need to be incorporated. The Depaitnient of
Environmental Conservation (DEC) has also commented on the Plan with what they would like to see
more of or done in a different way with responses being prepared by staff. She stated that the draft of
these responses along with the DEC comments are available in the Board office and asked for comments
on the Plan to be submitted as soon as possible. She stated that the SEQR process on the Plan also needs
to be completed. It is expected that the Plan will receive final approval at the end of December.
Mrs. Livesay, Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management Sub -Committee on illegal
dumping and open burning, stated that the committee will be reviewing existing laws, regulations and
codes in order to make recommendations on the Sanitary Code which the Health Depal tment is in the
process of revising now. She stated that an issue has arisen concerning illegal dumping and whether the
investigator should pick up the trash. The Committee will be looking into this. Mrs. Eckstrom, Solid
Waste Manager, reported that there is a video tape on illegal dumping available for viewing.
179
June 29, 1993
Mr. Evans, member, Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, reported that on March
30 the Board adopted a resolution to abandon the proposed DR -7 landfill site and as a result the Landfill
Neighborhood Protection Committee will be disbanding. He said that there is still some clean-up work
that needs to be done at DR -7 and Ken Thompson, Assistant Solid Waste Manager, will be negotiating
with the DEC on the most economical ways to do this. Mr. Evans stated that included in agenda packets
are bid schedules for the hauling and disposal of solid waste.
Mr. Lerner stated that he is chairing a subcommittee on recycling markets. This committee looks
at ways for the County to encourage support and catalyze the creation or expansion of private sector
businesses to take parts of the solid waste stream in a way that will make a more profitable business for
the private sector. On July 22 at 2 p.m. at the Sheraton Inn there will be presentation from the New
York State Depai tinent of Economic Developments Office of Recycling on how to develop local markets
for recyclables.
Mr. Lerner stated that the Solid Waste Division has been moving forward with developing a full
scale composting facility and more information will follow in the coming months.
Mr. Lerner extended his thanks to staff and advisory committee members for their work on
preparing information for this meeting.
On motion, the meeting adjourned at 8:37 p.m.
180
July 13, 1993
Regular Meeting
Public Hearings
Chairman Watros called the first public hearing to order at 5:30 p.m. concerning the 1993-94
Operating and Capital Budget request for Tompkins Cortland Community College. Chairman Watros
asked if anyone wished to speak?
Dr. Eduardo Marti, President, Tompkins Cortland Community College, stated that the proposed
budget represents a 3.2 percent increase to the County's contribution.
Debbie Payne, Newfield resident and Tompkins Cortland Community College Graduate, expressed
her appreciation and support of the Pace Program at the College. Ms. Payne urged the Board to support
the Master Plan proposed by the College.
Melissa Edmunds, Tompkins Cortland Community College Graduate, expressed her appreciation
for the College and thanked the Board for its support of the College.
Rebecca Vallely, Groton resident and Tompkins Cortland Community College Graduate, stated
that she is in full support of the College's budget and proposed Master Plan.
No one else wished to speak and the public hearing was closed at 5:37 p.m.
Chairman Watros called the second public hearing to order at 5:37 p.m. concerning proposed Local
Law No. 4 of 1993 - Amending Local Law No. 7 of 1990 - Providing for Amendments to the Charter and
Code - Article 5 - Financial Procedures and Controls.
Chairman Watros asked if anyone wished to speak? No one wished to speak and the public
hearing was closed at 5:39 p.m.
Chairman Watros called the third public hearing to order at 5:39 p.m. concerning a proposed
Second Addendum to a Lease Agreement with Taughannock Aviation Corporation - Fuel Farm for
Tompkins County Airport.
Chairman Watros asked if anyone wished to speak? No one wished to speak and the public
hearing was closed at 5:40 p.m.
Chairman Watros called the fourth public hearing to order at 5:40 p.m. concerning Award of
Contracts - Airport Concessions II - ATM, Pay Telephone and Car Rental.
Chairman Watros asked if the anyone wished to speak? No one wished to speak and the public
hearing was closed at 5:41 p.m.
Members and guests participated in the Pledge of Allegiance.
Present: 15 Representatives.
It was Moved by Mrs. Schuler, seconded by Mr. Joseph, and unanimously adopted by voice vote,
to approve the minutes of June 15, 1993 as corrected.
David Squires, Comptroller, introduced Jerry Mickelson of Ciaschi, Dietershagen, Little and
Mickelson. Mr. Mickelson gave the Board a brief update on. the 1992 Financial Audit of Tompkins
County. He stated that the Audit is broken down into various facets, including a financial review and
review of the County's internal accounting structure which covers administrative and fiscal policies over
the areas of purchases, accounts payable, cash disbursements, payroll, revenue and cash receipts, data
181
July 13, 1993
processing functions and other areas. Mr. Mickelson stated that the County has a budget of $62 million
which is to be administered to the operating fund and in addition to that is $12 million in special revenue
funds which are also administered. There is also a debt service of a approximately $6 million. He stated
that the financial implications are that the County must have very adequate systems of controls, checks
and balances. He said they feel the County's system of internal accounting is very adequate and that the
County's compliance with laws and regulations is adequate and is described in the prepared report.
Chairman Watros updated the Board on the current status of indoor air complaints at Biggs A. He
stated that five proposals were presented to those individuals who are currently unable to work that are
intended to allow them to safely return to work. A meeting is scheduled for July 14 for those individuals
and their representatives to discuss these proposals. At a joint meeting of the Public Works and
Construction Management, Human Services, and Health and Education Committees there was a
consensus that a determination be made as quickly as possible about a capital project that would fully
modernize air handling in Biggs A. Mr. Watros stated that all requests for information received prior to
last week have been responded to and additional requests have been received this week and all but one
will be answered within a very short time. A request for time card copies dating back several years will
be provided but may take a little time. He stated that the Employee Safety and Health Coordinator is
expected to be hired and on staff by next week and stated that there is a resolution on the agenda which
authorizes the hiring of Judy Crawford, a Certified Industrial Hygienist, to conduct any testing deemed
advisable. Mr. Watros said that Greg Siwinski's preliminary report has been received and sent to
individuals and their attorneys. There is nothing in the report to which the County has any objection and
expects that County to follow through on all of its recommendations in an expedited way for the benefit
of everyone in the building.
Under privilege of the floor, Herb Engman, Chairman, Environmental Management Council, spoke
concerning the Tompkins County Recycling and Solid Waste Center, stating that among various solid
waste advisory committees there has been support for this facility. He stated that it is seen as an
opportunity to have flexibility in the County's recycling and solid waste disposal plans. He expressed
support for the proposed viewing platform at the Facility and urged the Board to support it as well.
Under privilege of the floor, Barbara Blanchard, City of Ithaca Councilperson, spoke concerning
the proposed contract for the Tompkins County Recycling and Solid Waste Center. She stated that her
• background as a professional Planner has allowed her to work in the solid waste field in a number of
capacities over the past several years. Ms. Blanchard asked that the Board postpone a decision on the
contract for the Tompkins County Recycling and Solid Waste Center until the Supreme Court has
determined whether or not you can control the flow of solid waste to that facility.
Under privilege of the floor, Ernest Bury, Valley Road, Ithaca, spoke concerning the Tompkins
County Reclining and Solid Waste Center and expressed his opinion that recycling is regressive and very
expensive. He stated that there are other investments that would be better for the environment.
Under privilege of the floor, Paul Bennett, Hook Place, Ithaca, and a non-smoker, spoke
concerning the policy of no smoking at the Tompkins County Public Safety Building. He stated that
incarceration is very stressful to individuals and having a no smoking policy at the Public Safety Building
makes inmates more aggressive. Mr. Bennett asked that the Board reconsider the policy and try to
accommodate the inmates in a way that would not be of great cost to the County.
Under privilege of the floor, Ann Rider, Political Action Chairman of the Civil Service Employees
Association, Local 855, spoke concerning the resolution on the agenda entitled Authority to Contract -
Judy Crawford, Certified Industrial Hygienist. Ms. Rider read a letter written by David Chase, CSEA
President, in which it was stated that CSEA does not approve of this resolution and feels the hiring of an
additional industrial hygienist would be a duplication of services already being provided by Mr. Greg
Siwinski.
182
July 13, 1993
Under privilege of the floor, Judith Van Allen, Director of Offender Aid and Restoration (OAR),
spoke concerning smoking in the Tompkins County. Public Safety Building. She stated that the Agency
works in the Jail and does advocating services for the inmates. Ms. Van Allen made reference to a
petition signed by inmates which requests County policy to be changed to allow smoking at the Jail in a
way that would protect the rights of non-smokers. She stated that by not being allowed to smoke, there is
increased stress and tension and urged the Board to reconsider this policy.
Under privilege of the floor, Coert Bonthius, Tompkins -Cortland Labor Coalition Coordinator,
spoke in support of the resolution on the agenda entitled Urging the Labor Commissioner to Appoint a
Wage Board. Mr. Bonthius stated that the Coalition believes that Tompkins County is severely impacted
by minimum wage jobs and stated that a person who makes minimum wage ($4.25 per hour) is living in
poverty. He stated that a person cannot live on this wage without government assistance.
Under privilege of the floor, Margaret Marks, Department of Social Services employee, spoke
concerning indoor air quality at Biggs A. Ms. Marks stated that Mr. Ellis was very emotional at the June
29, 1993 Board meeting because he has been put under a great amount of stress as a result of the situation
at Biggs A. Ms. Marks stated that it takes 6-18 months for a Social Welfare Examiner to become
proficient at their job and stated that it would serve the County's best interests to return these experienced
workers to their positions.
Under privilege of the floor, Yvonne Bartlett, Department of Social Services employee, spoke
concerning indoor air quality at Biggs A. Mrs. Bartlett stated that she is still out of work and does not
receive any compensation. Mrs. Bartlett stated that she feels there is no plan for the employees who are
out of work to return to their positions.
Under privilege of the floor, Mel Bartlett, husband of Yvonne Bartlett who is a Department of
Social Services employee, expressed his frustration over the situation at Biggs A. Mr. Bartlett disputed
the reference made that his wife is "allegedly sick". He urged the Board to facilitate their efforts in
dealing with this issue.
Under privilege of the floor, James Ellis, Department of Social Services employee, spoke
concerning indoor air quality at Biggs A. Mr. Ellis stated that it is time for the County to move forward
quickly with recommendations made by Greg Siwinski and make the building a safe working
environment.
Under privilege of the floor, Margaret Kirchgessner, Human Rights Commission employee, spoke
concerning indoor air quality at Biggs A. Mrs. Kirchgessner stated that she has been out of work since
June 23 and said the problem has gone beyond the Department of Social Services. She stated that the
Human Rights Commission is also located in the Biggs building and referred to venting problems in her
department. Mrs. Kirchgessner stated that she feels communication between the Administration and
employees needs to improve.
Under privilege of the floor, Barbara Mahoney, Department of Social Services employee, spoke
concerning indoor air quality at Biggs A. She stated that she also suffers from sick building syndrome.
She stressed the urgency for finding a safe workplace for employees.
Under privilege of the floor, Kathy Leinthall, Probation Director, spoke in opposition to the
resolution on the agenda entitled Calling for a Plan to End the Smoking Ban in the Living Areas of the
Tompkins County Jail. Ms. Leinthall stated that ending the smoking ban in the Jail would create several
problems which would include the number of classifications in the Jail. She explained the number of
ways in which these classifications could increase.
Under privilege of the floor, Gordon Stevens, Corrections Administrator, spoke concerning the
resolution on the agenda entitled Calling for a Plan to End the Smoking Ban in the Living Areas of the
183
July 13, 1993
Tompkins County Jail. Mr. Stevens stated that he is responsible for listening to concerns of the inmates
and correction officers and stated that in keeping good faith with them he brought this item to the Board
for consideration.
Dr. Marti, President, Tompkins Cortland Community College, began discussion on the proposed
Master Plan for the College stating that a requirement of the State University of New York asks the
College to prepare a Plan which represents what the needs of the College will be in the near future. He
stated that the Master Plan would accommodate the needs of the College for the next five years. Dr.
Marti stated that the Plan includes several projects but if a project is not contained in the Plan, it cannot be
funded by the State University of New York. However, if a project is contained in the Plan, it does not
have to be funded. He said that the building has been in existence since 1974 and the College has never
asked Tompkins County for Capital dollars, but needs to now because the building is getting older and the
projects larger. For example, the roof on the campus needs to be replaced and classrooms expanded. The
College is looking to the future to see where the College wants to be.
Dr. Marti explained that the College is asking Tompkins County to fund projects which total
$2,166,000. The amount does not have to be paid all at once, it can be accomplished on a project to
project basis or the County could decide to issue a bond. The College would receive a total of $8,689,000
towards the proposed Master Plan when combined with the shares of Cortland County and the State
University of New York. He stated that the first time the College will come to Tompkins County and ask
for money will be in June, 1994 after the State budget has been adopted. Dr. Marti concluded his
presentation by thanking the Board for Tompkins County's past and continued support of the College.
Chairman Watros thanked Dr. Marti for responding to concerns that have been raised relative to
the proposed Master Plan. He stated that he believes it will be received on much better terms than the
original proposal.
On motion of the appropriate committee chairmen and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by
voice vote, the following resolutions were added to the agenda:
Authorizing SEQRA Compliance for Execution of a Service Agreement in Connection with the
Applications for the Required Permit and any Modification of the Permit with the Department
of Environmental Conservation
Authorization to Contract, Continuation of Pace Program through Contract between Tompkins
Cortland Community College and Tompkins County Department of Social Services
Endorsing Tompkins Cortland Community College Facilities Master Plan and Approving
Expansion and Renovation of Tompkins Cortland Community College Facilities Subject to
State Approval and Funding
Approval of Amendments of Employee Council Bylaws
Chairman Watros gave the appropriate committee chairmen permission to withdraw from the agenda
the following resolutions:
Establishment of Fee Schedule for Sale of Voter Registration Listings and Computerized Data
Files
Award of Contract for Hillview Well Replacement and Confirmatory Investigation
Transfer Station Billing Procedures
Transfer Facility Payment Plan
Flow Control Enforcement
Authorizing Contract with ServRite for Provision of Restaurant/Bar, Gift Shop and Vending
Services - Tompkins County Airport
Chairman Watros gave the appropriate committee chairmen permission to withdraw from the
agenda the following resolutions with final committee action being affirmed:
184
July 13, 1993
CA067-93 - Authorization to Execute Contract - Brigid Kernan Terry, Occupational Therapist and
Terry Hoppenrath, Physical Therapist
CA068-93 - Approval of Funding for C.A.P./C.V.B. Joint Marketing Plan
CA069-93 - Authorization to Contract, Continuation of Pace Program through Contract between
Tompkins Cortland Community College and Tompkins County Department of Social Services
CA070-93 - Authorization to Contract with the Senior Citizens Council to Expand their Ability to
Carry Out the Health Insurance Counseling Program
CA071-93 - Authorization to Contract with Gadabout Transportation Services, Inc. to Provide
Transportation to Senior Citizens
RESOLUTION NO. 185 - ENDORSING TOMPKINS CORTLAND COMMUNITY COLLEGE
FACILITIES MASTER PLAN AND APPROVING EXPANSION AND
RENOVATION OF TOMPKINS CORTLAND COMMUNITY
COLLEGE FACILITIES SUBJECT TO STATE APPROVAL AND
FUNDING
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Evans. Mr. Stein stated that this is a very fine institution
and one that Tompkins County can be proud of. He also stated that he has received several letters of
support for this Plan including letters from Borg Warner, Citizens Savings Bank and Therm, and stated
that it does not make sense when the Board is asked to support something and at budget time is asked to
cut the budget. However, Mr. Stein stated he will vote in favor of this. Mr. Culligan stated that he served
on the committee in the 1960's which selected the site for the College and would support this. Mr. Winch
stated that the age of the Facility warrants the upgrade to code and preserving the existing building and
campus. He stated that he believes the changes in the proposed Master Plan will permit adjustments to
the programs that the College provides. He complimented the College on its efforts towards energy
efficiency. Mr. Proto stated that some of the businesses who have supported the proposed Master Plan
employ graduates of the college and also stated that Tompkins Cortland Community College is the only
place where some of the County's residents can further their education. Mr. Proto, on behalf of the Health
and Education Committee and the Board, thanked the College for its service to the community.
Chairman Watros stated that if adopted, the resolution would be subject to its form by the County
Attorney. Chairman Watros thanked Dr. Marti and other staff members of the College for bringing forth
to the Board the information presented on the proposed Master Plan. A voice vote resulted as follows:
Ayes - 15, Noes - 0. Adopted.
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County Board of Representatives and the Cortland County Legislature
as sponsors of Tompkins Cortland Community College, recognize the need for building space
modifications within the Tompkins Cortland Community College campus to address the enrollment
increases experienced during recent years and further recognizes the need to make certain improvements
to existing facilities on campus to bring them into code compliance, improve their efficiency and to
extend their useful lives, and
WHEREAS, the College entered into an agreement with the firms Thomas Associates and
Saratoga Associates "to expand and refine the Facility Master Plan previously completed by the College,
to re-evaluate enrollment and space projections, to closely scrutinize the condition of existing campus
facilities and to focus on and clearly define those campus renovations or improvements which are most
essential to the College's mission", and
WHEREAS, the comprehensive Facilities Master Plan has been completed under guidance and
direction of County and College officials and in consultation with the .State. University of New York
(SUNY) Office of Capital Facilities producing a revised Facilities Master Plan that will guide the College
and its sponsors in ensuring the integrity of the physical plant and in providing for the programmatic
needs of the college, and
WHEREAS, Phase I of the project identifies health and safety projects, handicapped access, code
compliance, work related to the preservation of the physical structure, and the creation of additional
instructional space necessary to accommodate increased enrollment as well as enrollment in courses
requiring special laboratories, and
185
July 13, 1993
WHEREAS, Thomas Associates and Saratoga Associates have estimated that all costs related to
phase I of the Master Plan are not likely to exceed $8,689,572 one half of which would be funded by New
York State and one half by the Counties of Tompkins and Cortland, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, That the Board of Representative does hereby approve the Tompkins Cortland
Community College Facilities Master Plan,
RESOLVED, further, That subject to the approval of said Master Plan by the State and the
appropriation of 50 percent State funding, this Board of Representatives does hereby approve the
undertaking of Phase I of the Master Plan and the appropriation of the Tompkins County portion of the 50
percent of the local sponsor share,
RESOLVED, further, That Tompkins Cortland Community College submits to the State
appropriate applications and information necessary for approval of the Facilities Master Plan and funding
of Phase I,
RESOLVED, further, That certified copies of this Resolution be sent to the Cortland County
Legislature, the Board of Trustees of Tompkins Cortland Community College, the Board of Trustees of
the State University of New York, and the State University Construction Fund,
RESOLVED, further, That this resolution shall become effective upon adoption of a concurrent
resolution by the Cortland County Legislature.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 186 - MODIFICATION OF THE 1992-93 OPERATING BUDGET -
TOMPKINS CORTLAND COMMUNITY COLLEGE
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, the Board of Trustees, Tompkins and Cortland Counties, and State University of New
York have previously approved the 1992-93 Operating Budget for Tompkins Cortland Community
College, and
WHEREAS, the College will expand its summer program and will exceed its original budget, and
the reallocation of funds in various departments is necessary to meet increased demands per the 1992-93
Modified Budget, and
WHEREAS, the total revenue and total expenditures will be increased by $202,450 to a modified
level of $12,209,238, and
WHEREAS, the local sponsor share will not be affected by the modification, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education and Budget and Administration
Committees, That the Board of Representatives approve the 1992-93 Modified Operating Budget.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OF TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 187 - ADOPTION OF 1993-94 OPERATING BUDGET - TOMPKINS
CORTLAND COMMUNITY COLLEGE
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, a proposed operating budget for Tompkins Cortland Community College for the
fiscal year. September 1, 1993 through August 31, 1994 has been presented to the Board of
Representatives of the County of Tompkins pursuant to County Law and Section 6306 of the Education
Law, and
WHEREAS, the Board of Representatives has conducted a public hearing on said proposed budget
on the 13th day of July, 1993, now therefore be it
186
July 13, 1993
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education and the Budget and Administration
Committees, That said proposed 1993-94 operating budget in the amount of $13,301,917 of which the
sponsoring community contribution is in the amount of $2,601,937 be and the same hereby is approved,
RESOLVED, further, That the Board of Representatives of Tompkins County includes in the 1994
Tompkins County Budget an amount to be determined pursuant to the approved plan for said College in
effect as of September 1, 1993 and that the amount when determined be raised by taxation in the County
of Tompkins in the fiscal year 1994,
RESOLVED, further, That this resolution shall become effective upon the adoption of a concurrent
resolution by the Cortland County Legislature.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 188 - ADOPT 1993-94 CAPITAL BUDGET - TOMPKINS CORTLAND
COMMUNITY COLLEGE
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Culligan, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, the Board of Trustees of Tompkins Cortland Community College has presented to
this Legislature a Tentative Capital Budget for fiscal year 1993-94, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education and Budget and Administration
Committees, That said 1993-94 Capital Budget in the amount of $118,000 of which the sponsoring
community contribution is in the amount of $59,000 to be funded by out -of -county chargebacks be and
the same hereby is approved and adopted,
RESOLVED, further, That the sponsoring community contribution shall be paid from the capital
construction account to be maintained by Tompkins Cortland Community College,
RESOLVED, further, That this resolution shall become effective upon adoption of a concurrent
resolution by the Cortland County Legislature.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
Following adoption of the resolutions concerning Tompkins Cortland Community College, Dr.
Marti, President, thanked the Board for the support given by Tompkins County.
Chairman Watros declared recess at 8:00 p.m. The meeting reconvened at 8:08 p.m.
Chairman Watros began discussion by recognizing Mr. Lerner, Chairman of the Solid Waste and
Resource Management Committee and Mr. Winch and Mrs. Livesay as members of the Negotiating Team
for their work in developing and negotiating the proposed contract for the Tompkins County Recycling
and Solid Waste Center.
Chairman Watros stated that a letter to the Board dated July 12, 1993 was received from Mark
Goldfarb, President of the Tompkins County Rental Housing Association. The letter stated that the
Association is concerned about the expenditure of this project and urged the Board to table any decisions
regarding solid waste disposal until other alternatives are explored.
Mr. Lerner stated that it has been a long process to bring the Board to this point and thanked Mrs.
Eckstrom, Solid Waste Manager, Solid Waste Division staff and the Negotiating Team for their work on
this project. He stated that two packets of information have been distributed entitled "Tompkins County
Recycling and Solid Waste Center Project Summary" and "The Purpose and Features of the Tompkins
County Recycling and Solid Waste Center - A Report of the Solid Waste and Resource Management
Committee". Mr. Lerner described the proposal by stating that this is the systematic, business -like, long-
term way to bring down costs of the solid waste program and protect the environment at the same time.
187
July 13, 1993
Mr. Lerner stated that the concept of the Facility is to have one central location that virtually all of
the waste in Tompkins County comes to where it can be sorted, processed, transferred and shipped to the
appropriate destination. This would exclude material going to the interim composting facility. The point
of the Facility is to make the process as simple and efficient as possible. Mr. Lerner explained the
process of waste and recyclables entering and leaving the facility. He stated that the proposed contract to
CR Inc. guarantees the County that at least five percent of the waste material that goes in will go out as
recyclables. It is the responsibility of CR Inc. to remove contaminated waste from the stream before
recyclables are delivered to market.
Mr. Lerner explained solid waste finances, stating that increasingly in the 1990's recyclables are
commodities that are traded on the commodities markets. By teaming up with CR Inc. in a partnership,
Tompkins County will be able to take advantage of CR Inc.'s national and international markets that are
dealing in much vaster quantities and Tompkins County will receive advantages of huge volumes at
wholesale prices. He stated that the 1995 projection is that Tompkins County's cost for disposal will be
approximately $70 per ton and recycling $0-$10 per ton. The total waste stream for Tompkins County
right now is in the neighborhood of 60,000 tons per year. The proposed agreement .with CR Inc., a
money -saver for Tompkins County and an incentive for both CR Inc. and the County to bring the cost
down through maximum recycling.
He stated the proposed Facility is designed to save residents and the government of Tompkins
County money through maximum and aggressive recycling. Mr. Lerner referred to the report entitled
"The Purpose and Features of the Tompkins County Recycling and Solid Waste Center - A Report of the
Solid Waste Resource Management Committee" and explained Table I - Comparison of Annual Solid
Waste and Recycling Budget Projections (1995) which estimates a cost savings with Recycling and Solid
Waste Center in 1995 of $728,389. In addition, reduced transportation costs to transfer station will save
haulers approximately $150,000 annually who can pass the savings on to their customers.
Mr. Lerner updated the Board on the status of Flow Control and the possibility of the Law being
overturned by the Supreme Court. He stated that in the worst case scenario if the Law were overturned,
Tompkins County would have to lower the tipping fee and raise the revenue some place else but there is
no minimum tonnage with the proposed contract with CR Inc. and Tompkins County would not suffer a
significant loss. He feels that Flow Control will be upheld with the Supreme Court siding with
municipalities statewide.
RESOLUTION NO. 189 - AWARDING A CONTRACT FOR THE DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION,
ACCEPTANCE TESTING AND OPERATION OF THE TOMPKINS
COUNTY RECYCLING AND SOLID WASTE CENTER PURSUANT
TO GENERAL MUNICIPAL LAW SECTION 120-W AND
AUTHORIZING AND DIRECTING THE PUBLICATION OF
NOTICE OF SUCH AWARD
Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mrs. Livesay. There was discussion concerning the need for
an observation deck at the Facility. It was Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mrs. Livesay, and
unanimously adopted by voice vote to postpone action on this resolution until action has been taken on
Resolution No. 190.
A lengthy discussion followed concerning the possibility of eliminating rural drop off centers. Mr.
Lerner stated that once that the Facility is operating, it is expected that everything going to the Facility
will be picked up at the curbside. He stated that a decision to close rural drop off centers has not been
made.
At this point in the meeting, Mr. Lerner introduced Mr. Dick Kattar, President of CR Inc. who in
turn introduced members of the CR Inc. team. Mr. Kattar gave a brief overview of his company and its
operations stating that the companies technology is far above others in the world. Mr. Kattar stated that a
188
July 13, 1993
local construction manager has been hired for construction of the Facility. Following a presentation on
the physical layout of the proposed facility, a brief question and answer session concluded the
presentation.
RESOLUTION NO. 190 - AUTHORIZING SEQRA COMPLIANCE FOR EXECUTION OF A
SERVICE AGREEMENT IN CONNECTION WITH THE
APPLICATIONS FOR THE REQUIRED PERMIT AND ANY
MODIFICATION OF THE PERMIT WITH THE DEPARTMENT OF
ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION
Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mrs. Livesay. A roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 14,
Noes - 1 (Representative Shurtleff). Adopted.
WHEREAS, pursuant to the State Environmental Quality Review Act, ECL Section 8-0101, et sec
(SEQR) and implementing regulations, 6NYCRR Part 617 this Board of Representatives has reviewed the
potential environmental impacts resulting from the adoption of Resolution No. 186 and has analyzed and
identified areas of environmental concern to determine if the action may have a significant effect on the
environment, and
WHEREAS, this Board of Representatives, as the sole agency maintaining any discretionary
approvals regarding the adoption of Resolution No. 186, is the only involved agency for environmental
quality review of its adoption in accordance with SEQRA, and
WHEREAS, Resolution No. 186 awards a contract for the design, construction, acceptance testing
and operation of the Tompkins County Recycling and Solid Waste Center which is expressly conditioned
upon compliance by the County with the requirements of SEQRA and the need, if any, to modify or
amend any permits, and
WHEREAS, the County has applied for an obtained a permit in connection with the Recycling and
Solid Waste Center, prepared a final environmental impact statement and adopted a Findings Statement in
connection therewith, and
WHEREAS, the County may seek a modification of its permit and intends to comply with SEQRA
and assess the environmental impact of any modification in connection with any application for a DEC
permit modification, and
WHEREAS, any potential environmental impacts of Resolution No. 186 have been addressed in
the SEQRA process in connection with the permit application and will be further addressed in connection
with any application for a modification of the permit, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, That
consideration and compliance with SEQRA for the execution of the service agreement has occurred in
connection with the application for a permit and shall further occur upon submission of any permit
modification with DEC and that the service agreement authorized by Resolution No. 186 is contingent
upon such SEQRA compliance and obtaining approval of any required permit modification.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 189 - AWARDING A CONTRACT FOR THE DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION,
ACCEPTANCE TESTING AND OPERATION OF THE TOMPKINS
COUNTY RECYCLING AND SOLID WASTE CENTER PURSUANT
TO GENERAL MUNICIPAL LAW SECTION 120-W AND
AUTHORIZING AND DIRECTING THE PUBLICATION OF
NOTICE OF SUCH AWARD
Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mrs. Livesay. A roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes 13,
Noes - 2 (Representatives Proto and Shurtleff). Adopted.
189
July 13, 1993
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County Board of Representatives by Resolution No. 505 dated
December 17, 1991, authorized the publication of a final Request for Proposals ("RFP") for the design,
construction, acceptance testing and operation of the Tompkins County Recycling and Solid Waste Center
("Facility"), formerly the Central Processing Facility, and accepted the findings related to the substantive
elements of comments received in relation to the draft RFP in connection therewith, and
WHEREAS, this Board of Representatives by Resolution No. 348 dated October 20, 1992
accepted the recommendation of the County's Evaluation Team to designate as preferred proposers for
negotiations New England CR Inc. ("CR Inc.") and Resource Recycling Technologies ("RRT"),
authorized the issuance of an amended Request for Proposals to said proposers reflecting cost saving
measures requested by this Board, and authorized and directed the Evaluation Team to continue to
negotiate with either of said proposers, and
WHEREAS, this Board of Representatives by Resolution No. 90 dated March 30, 1993, reaffirmed
and accepted the Facility Justification Report prepared by the Solid Waste Manager, declared the
continued procurement and development for the Facility to be in the public interest, reaffirmed its
agreement with the City of Ithaca as stated in Resolution No. 77 dated February 19, 1991, reaffirmed its
goal to minimize long term costs of solid waste handling, authorized the Chair of this Board to appoint a
Negotiating Committee and Negotiators and authorized and directed the Negotiating Committee to
conclude negotiations with either CR Inc. or RRT on the basis of cost saving measures set forth in
Resolution No. 348 and subject to the requirements of the State Environmental Quality Review Act and
the need, if any, to modify or amend existing Part 360 Permits for the Facility, and
WHEREAS, the Negotiating Committee and Negotiators have evaluated revised proposals
submitted by both CR Inc. and RRT in response to the amended RFP and met independently on May 12,
1993 with each of the proposers to discuss and clarify their revised proposals, and
WHEREAS, the Negotiating Committee and Negotiators received and further evaluated written
responses and clarification dated May 18, 1993, submitted by each proposer following those meetings,
and
WHEREAS, the Negotiating Committee accepted the recommendation of the Solid Waste
Manager, in conjunction with County's technical, legal, financial an risk management advisors
(collectively "County Consultants") as well as appropriate County staff, to designate CR Inc. as the
preferred proposer to negotiate, for consideration by this Board, the terms of a recommended service
agreement providing for the design, construction, acceptance testing and operation of the Facility, which
recommendation is memorialized in a report dated June 18, 1993, a copy of which has been made
available to this Board, and
WHEREAS, the Negotiators, in conjunction with the Solid Waste Manager and County
Consultants have negotiated and prepared, in a series of negotiating sessions with CR Inc., the substance
of a preferred service agreement including attached technical schedules, (together "Service Agreement")
subject only to agreement on final language revisions, which Service Agreement has been made available
to this Board, and
WHEREAS, this Board has determined that it is in the public interest to award a contract to CR
Inc. on the basis of overall Facility costs and anticipated revenues and such other factors as Facility
design, system reliability, energy efficiency, compatibility with source separation and other recycling
systems and environmental protection, together with such other factors as are specified in the RFP, as
amended, and
WHEREAS, the County has determined that and award to CR Inc. does not require the adoption of
particularized findings referred to in General Municipal Law Section 120-w(4)(e)(4) because of all
responsive proposals received by the County, the total proposal submitted by CR Inc. for the Facility
provides the lowest net cost to the County, and
WHEREAS, this Board wishes to authorize the Clerk of this Board to publish notice of such award
in accordance with General Municipal Law Section 120-w(6), now therefore be it
RESOLVED, That the County Administrator is authorized and directed to execute a Service
Agreement with CR Inc., providing for the design, construction and acceptance testing of the Facility for
the Fixed Construction Price of $5,646,439 inclusive of a public viewing platform valued at $141,901 and
operation of the Facility for the Operations and Maintenance Fee described in said Service Agreement on
the basis of the determination by this Board that (a) CR Inc. is the most responsible proposer having
190
July 13, 1993
submitted the most responsive proposal to the RFP, as amended, and (b) of all proposals received from
responsible proposers, CR Inc.'s total proposal, as negotiated, will provide the lowest net cost to the
County, subject to such final language revisions as the Chairman of this Board determines to be in the
public interest,
RESOLVED, further, That the rights, obligations and liabilities of the County pursuant to said
Service Agreement shall be and hereby are made expressly subject to satisfaction of each of the
conditions precedent described at Article III thereof including, without limitation, compliance by the
County with the requirements of the State Environmental Quality Review Act and the need, if any, to
modify or amend the existing Part 360 Permits for the Facility issued by the Depaitment of
Environmental Conservation, unless such conditions are waived by the County in its sole discretion
pursuant to said Article III,
RESOLVED, further, That the validity of the Service Agreement and the procedures relating to its
award may be contested only if:
(1) such action, suit or proceeding is commenced within sixty (60) days after the date of
publication of such official action, and
(2) such award or procedure was not authorized pursuant to General Municipal Law Section 120-
w, or
(3) any of the provisions of General Municipal Law Section 120-w which should be complied with
at the date of the publication of such official action have not been substantially complied with, or
(4) a conflict of interest can be shown in the manner in which the Service Agreement was awarded,
RESOLVED, further, That the Clerk of the Board is hereby authorized and directed to publish
notice of the official action of the County awarding the Service Agreement in accordance with General
Municipal Law Section 120-w (6)(b),
RESOLVED, further, That a budget of $350,000 be established for miscellaneous project
expenses, staff service, consulting and project support activities provided that no portion of such budget
shall be allocated to CR Inc.
SEQR ACTION: SEE RESOLUTION NO. 190 DATED JULY 13, 1993
Chairman Watros declared recess at 9:32 p.m. The meeting reconvened at 9:38 p.m.
RESOLUTION NO. 191 - AWARD OF CONTRACT - AIRPORT CONCESSIONS II - ATM, PAY
TELEPHONE AND CAR REPAIR
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Culligan, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, a public hearing was duly advertised and held before the Board of Representatives
this 13th day of July, 1993, to hear all persons interested in the proposals, and
WHEREAS, the Division of Purchasing and Central Services has duly advertised for proposals for
Airport Concessions II - ATM Machine, Pay Telephone and Car Repair, and
WHEREAS, proposals were received and duly opened May 28, 1993, and
WHEREAS, no proposals were received for Car Repair, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the proposals be awarded as follows:
ATM Machine Citizens Savings Bank
Ithaca, NY
Millicom Services Co.
Brooklyn, NY
Administrator be and hereby is authorized to execute
Pay Telephone Services
RESOLVED, further, That the County
agreements on behalf of Tompkins County.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
191
July 13, 1993
RESOLUTION NO. 192 AUTHORIZING SECOND ADDENDUM - LEASE AGREEMENT
WITH TAUGHANNOCK AVIATION CORPORATION -
TOMPKINS COUNTY AIRPORT
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Todd, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, US Air and Taughannock Aviation Corporation (TAC) wish to cease operations at the
existing fueling facility and remove underground tanks contained therein in order to comply with EPA
and New York State environmental regulations, and
WHEREAS, TAC wishes to build a new fuel facility at another site within Tompkins County
Airport and install aboveground tanks, and
WHEREAS, TAC also wishes to return leased land for which it no longer has a use, and
WHEREAS, a public hearing was duly advertised and held this 13th day of July, 1993 and all
persons wishing to address the Board on this subject have had the opportunity to do so, now therefore be
it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the County Administrator be and hereby is authorized to execute a second addendum agreement with
TAC to incorporate said changes,
RESOLVED, further, That in order to allow TAC to amortize the costs of building the new fuel
farm, the second addendum agreement be extended beyond the term of the original agreement for ten (10)
years, until December 31, 2005.
SEQR ACTION: UNLISTED
(NEGATIVE DECLARATION ON FILE)
RESOLUTION NO. 193 - AUTHORIZING CONTRACTS WITH AVIS RENT A CAR SYSTEM
INC. AND THE HERTZ CORPORATION FOR PROVISION OF
RENTAL CAR SERVICES - TOMPKINS COUNTY AIRPORT
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Culligan, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, a request for proposals for the operation of rental car concessions at the Tompkins
County Airport has been duly advertised and two proposals were timely received, and
WHEREAS, a public hearing was duly advertised and held this 13th day of July, 1993, and all
persons wishing to address the Board on this subject have had the opportunity to do so, now therefore be
it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the proposals submitted by Avis Rent A Car System Inc. and The Hertz Corporation be accepted and
the County Administrator be and hereby is authorized and directed to execute contracts with same for a
period of five (5) years, commencing from the opening date of the new terminal.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 194 - AUTHORIZING CONTRACT WITH INTERSPACE AIRPORT
ADVERTISING FOR PROVISION OF ADVERTISING SERVICES
- TOMPKINS COUNTY AIRPORT
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Shurtleff, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, a request for proposals (RFP) for the operation of an Advertising Concession at the
Tompkins County Airport has been duly advertised and no proposals were timely received, and
192
July 13, 1993
WHEREAS, negotiations have been ongoing with Interspace Airport Advertising who expressed
an interest in providing this service on different terms than were specified in the RFP, and satisfactory
terms have been mutually agreed, and
WHEREAS, a public hearing was duly advertised and held this 13th day of July, 1993, and all
persons wishing to address the Board on this subject have had the opportunity to do so, now therefore be
it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That a contract be signed with Interspace Airport Advertising and the County Administrator be and
hereby is authorized and directed to execute said contract with Interspace Airport Advertising for a period
of ten (10) years, commencing from the opening date of the new terminal.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 195 - ROUTE 90 DETOUR
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Todd, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, the New York State Depai Intent of Transportation proposes to replace two (2) box
culverts on New York State Route 90 between the Town of Genoa and Creek Road in Cayuga County,
and
WHEREAS, in conformance with Section 42 of the New York State Highway Law, the New York
State Depai tment of Transportation proposes to utilize the following Tompkins County road as a detour
during the construction period: CR154 (Locke Road), and,
WHEREAS, the New York State Department of Transportation will provide traffic control devices
and make improvements or repairs when necessary to the above-mentioned road to make it adequate to
handle additional detour traffic, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the Board of Representatives of the County of Tompkins does hereby authorize the New York State
Department of Transportation to utilize the above mentioned road as a detour for approximately sixty (60)
days during the period of May 1, 1994 - October 1, 1994 or during the period of May 1, 1995 - October 1,
1995 for construction,
RESOLVED, further, That the County of Tompkins will continue to provide routine maintenance
on the above mentioned road, including snow and ice control,
RESOLVED, further, That the Clerk of the Board of Representatives is hereby directed to transmit
three (3) certified copies of this resolution to the State Department of Transportation.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 196 AUTHORIZING A CONTRACT WITH AVIATION PLANNING
ASSOCIATES IN CONNECTION WITH PROVISION OF A
COMPUTER SOFTWARE PACKAGE, TRAINING, AND OTHER
FINANCIAL SERVICES TO ALLOW FOR ONGOING
CALCULATION OF ANNUAL AIRLINE RATES AND CHARGES
- TOMPKINS COUNTY AIRPORT
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Shurtleff, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, the new Airline -Airport Use and Lease Agreement calls for the proposed schedule of
rates and charges to be made available to the Airlines no later than ninety days prior to the end of each
fiscal year, and
WHEREAS, Aviation Planning Associates are able to reduce the necessary formulas and
calculations to a software package which can be used by airport staff in the future, and
193
July 13, 1993
WHEREAS, Aviation Planning Associates will provide said software, training, assist with the first
year's calculations and help with the presentation of the calculations to the Airlines, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the firm of Aviation Planning Associates, Inc. be retained to provide said software and services on a
time and expenses basis for an amount not to exceed $12,000 and that the County Administrator be and
hereby is authorized to execute a contract with said firm,
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller is hereby authorized to transfer $12,000 from the
Airport Fund Balance to Construction Account No. HU5610.4442 to meet the cost of this contract.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 197 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE A GRANT AGREEMENT WITH
NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
(NYSDOT) - PURCHASE OF NEW SNOW PLOW
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Shurtleff, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, the County has received a grant offer from the New York State Depailment of
Transportation (NYSDOT) in the amount of $10,648.40 towards the cost of buying a new snow plow, and
WHEREAS, the budget for said snow plow is as follows:
FAA Share Account No. HT 5610.4592 $ 191,671.20
NYSDOT Share Account No. HT 5610.3592 $ 10,648.40
Local Share (PFC) Account No. HT 5610.5031 $ 10,648.40
Total Cost Account No. HT 5610.2200 $ 212,968.00
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the NYSDOT grant offer in the amount of $10,648.40 be and hereby is accepted and that the County
Administrator is authorized to execute the required documents.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 198 - ESTABLISHING FUNDING FOR CRASH, FIRE, RESCUE (CFR)
EXPANSION - DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION AND RUNWAY
OVERLAY DESIGN
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Mason, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, the County has received notice that the Crash, Fire, Rescue (CFR) Expansion -
Design and Construction and Engineering Design for the Runway 14/32 Overlay is fundable up to a total
Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) share of $386,869, State share of $21,493 and local share (PFCs)
of $21,493, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the budget for these projects be established at $429,855,
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller is authorized to borrow monies until reimbursement is
received from the FAA, New York State Department of Transportation (NYSDOT) and PFCs.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 199 - PAVING AUTHORIZATION (Rescinded by R.235 of 1993)
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Mason. There was discussion on the current lawsuit
against the State which has jeopardized dedicated CHIPS funding and whether the County should
194
July 13, 1993
continue its paving program this summer. William Mobbs, Public Works Commissioner, updated the
Board on the status of the lawsuit and funding. He stated that neighboring counties are continuing with
paving programs. Mr. Lerner stated there is $800,000 at risk if this funding is not received. Mr. Mobbs
stated that this resolution, if adopted, would authorize the program to commence paving as originally
planned. Mr. Todd stated that the $800,000 may have an impact of adding this to the County's 1994
budget twice, once to pay for the revenue not received in 1993 and again for paving to be done in 1994.
Mr. Mason stated this has come at a very bad time because of the severity of damages to roads
caused by the past winter. He stated that if the resolution is adopted, a message should be sent to
representatives in Albany that the County expects dedicated highway funds to be restored. Mr. Winch
stated that the Board needs to give direction in addressing the State on the impact this is having on
municipalities throughout the State.
It was Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Ms. Mink to add the following Resolved: "RESOLVED,
further, That should the current lawsuit result in the loss of $801,000 for CHIPS funds, that the Highway
Division shall cease further operations and return to the Board for guidance." A substitute was offered to
the amendment to replace $801,000 with $400,000. It was Moved by Mr. Lerner to refer this issue to the
Budget and Administration Committee. Motion failed for lack of a second. Following discussion, it was
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Lerner, to refer this issue to the Budget and Administration and
Public Works and Construction Management Committee. Mr. Stein stated that referring this to a
committee would not stop paving operations. The Public Works Department was approved to do
$800,000 worth of paving in 1993 and unless instructed otherwise, they are authorized to continue. At
this point the motion made by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Lerner, was withdrawn.
Discussion followed concerning the County's infrastructure and the importance in taking care of it.
It was Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mr. Shurtleff, to amend the substituted amendment to read as
follows: "RESOLVED, further, That when the Highway Department has spent a total of $250,000 in
anticipated CHIPS funds, the Highway Division shall cease operations and return to the Board for
Guidance, RESOLVED, further, That this issue be sent to the Public Works and Construction
Management and Budget and Administration Committees for review and to the Board for further action."
Ms. Mink stated that she was not prepared at this time to vote on something that could result in a
property tax increase. Mrs. Livesay stated that she feels the State Legislature has some obligation to
come up with money and more public awareness is needed.
Chairman Watros called the question. Mr. Mason challenged the ruling of the Chairman. A roll
call vote resulted as follows: Ayes 13, Noes - 1 (Representative Lerner). The Chairman does not vote.
The ruling of the Chairman was not sustained.
Mr. Mason stressed the impact the winter has had on County roads and stated that if these roads are
not taken care of it is possible they will not exist next year. Mr. Winch stated that the Depai lment has
already spent $100,000 as authorized by the Public Works and Construction Management Committee. It
was clarified that his amendment would authorize an additional $150,000 to the $100,000 previously
authorized by the Committee.
A roll call vote on the amendment to the substituted amendment resulted as follows: Ayes - 11,
Noes - 4 (Representatives Mason, Proto, Todd and Watros). Amendment Carried.
A roll call vote on the resolution as amended resulted as follows: Ayes - 14, Noes - 1
(Representative Lerner). Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the Highway Division is instructed to continue paving immediately as scheduled.
195
July 13, 1993
RESOLVED, further, That when the Highway Depaitment has spent a total of $250,000 in
anticipated CHIPS funds, the Highway Division shall cease operations and return to the Board for
guidance,
RESOLVED, further, That this issue be sent to the Public Works and Construction Management
and Budget and Administration Committees for review and to the Board for further Board action.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 200 AMENDMENT OF RESOLUTION NO. 3 OF 1993 -
AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE AGREEMENT -
THORNTREE HILL ASSOCIATES (Amended by Res. No. 48 of
1994)
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Culligan, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, Resolution No. 3 of 1993 directed the County Administrator to execute an agreement
with Thorntree Hill Associates of Fayetteville, New York giving a purchase option on County property on
the Elmira Road in Ithaca, New York, and
WHEREAS, Thorntree Hill Associates has requested an extension of the expiration date of said
agreement in order to provide time for completion of all reviews required by the City of Ithaca in
connection with the development of said parcel, now therefore be it,
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the County Administrator is directed to execute an amendment to said agreement extending its
expiration date to June 30, 1994.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 201 - A RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING THE ISSUANCE OF AN
ADDITIONAL $100,000 SERIAL BONDS OF THE COUNTY OF
TOMPKINS, NEW YORK, TO PAY ADDITIONAL COSTS OF
THE COUNTY'S SHARE OF THE COST OF THE
CONSTRUCTION OF NEW T -HANGARS AT THE TOMPKINS
COUNTY AIRPORT IN AND FOR SAID COUNTY
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Mason. A roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 15,
Noes - 0. Adopted.
WHEREAS, all conditions precedent to the financing of the capital project hereinafter described,
including compliance with the provisions of the State Environment Quality Review Act, have been
performed; and
WHEREAS, by bond resolution dated April 20, 1993, the Board of Representatives of the County
of Tompkins, New York (the "County"), authorized, among other projects, the issuance of $300,000 serial
bonds of said County to pay the County's share of the cost of the construction of new T -Hangars,
including original furnishings, equipment, machinery, apparatus and incidental improvements and
expenses in connection therewith at the Tompkins County Airport in and for said County; and
WHEREAS, it has now been determined that the maximum estimated cost of such project is
$400,000, and increase of $100,000 over that previously authorized; and
WHEREAS, it is now desired to authorize the issuance of an additional $100,000 serial bonds of
said County for such purpose; NOW THEREFORE
BE IT RESOLVED, by the Board of Representatives of the County of Tompkins, New York as
follows:
196
July 13, 1993
Section 1. For the class of objects or purposes of paying additional costs of the County's share of
the cost of the construction of new T -Hangars, including original furnishings, equipment, machinery,
apparatus and incidental improvements and expenses in connection therewith at the Tompkins County
Airport, in and for the County of Tompkins, New York, there are hereby authorized to be issued an
additional $100,000 serial bonds of said County, pursuant to the provisions of the Local Finance Law.
Section 2. It is hereby determined that the maximum estimated cost of such class of objects or
purposes is now determined to be $400,000, and that the plan for the financing thereof is as follows:
a. By the issuance of the $300,000 serial bonds of said County authorized to be issued pursuant to
bond resolution dated April 20, 1993;
b. By the issuance of the additional $100,000 serial bonds of said County authorized to be issued
pursuant to this bond resolution.
Section 3. It is hereby determined that the period of probable usefulness of the aforesaid class of
objects of purposes is twenty years, pursuant to subdivision 17 of paragraph a of Section 11.00 of the
Local Finance Law. No bond anticipation notes have heretofore been issued for said class of objects or
purposes.
Section 4. Subject to the provisions of the Local Finance Law, the power to authorize the issuance
of and to sell bond anticipation notes in anticipation of the issuance and sale of the bonds herein
authorized, including renewals of such notes, is hereby delegated to the County Comptroller, the chief
fiscal officer. Such notes shall be of such terms, form and contents, and shall be sold in such manner, as
may be prescribed by said County Comptroller, consistent with the provisions of the Local Finance Law.
Section 5. The faith and credit of said County of Tompkins, New York, are hereby irrevocably
pledged for the payment of the principal of and interest on such obligations as the same respectively
become due and payable. An annual appropriation shall be made in each year sufficient to pay the
principal of and interest on such obligations becoming due and payable in such year. There shall annually
be levied on all the taxable real property of said County a tax sufficient to pay the principal of and interest
on such obligations as the same become due and payable.
Section 6. Such bonds shall be in fully registered form and shall be signed in the name of the
County of Tompkins, New York, by the manual or facsimile signature of the County Comptroller and a
facsimile of the corporate seal shall be imprinted or impressed thereon and attested by the manual or
facsimile signature of the County Clerk.
Section 7. The powers and duties of advertising such bonds for sale, conducting the sale and
awarding the bonds, are hereby delegated to the County Comptroller, who shall advertise such bonds for
sale, conduct the sale, and award the bonds in such manner as he shall deem best for the interests of the
County; provided, however, that in the exercise of these delegated powers, he shall comply fully with the
provisions of the Local Finance Law and any order or rule of the State Comptroller applicable to the sale
of municipal bonds. The receipt of the County Comptroller shall be a full acquittance to the purchaser of
such bonds, who shall not be obliged to see to the application of the purchase money.
Section 8. All other matters, except as provided herein relating to such bonds, including
prescribing whether manual or facsimile signatures shall appear on said bonds, prescribing the method for
the recording of ownership of said bonds, appointing the fiscal agent or agents for said bonds, providing
for the printing and delivery of said bonds (and if said bonds are to be executed in the name of the County
by the facsimile signature of the County Comptroller and, providing for the manual countersignature of a
fiscal agent or of a designated official of the County), the date, denominations, maturities and interest
payment dates, place or places of payment, and also including the consolidation with other issues, shall be
determined by the County Comptroller. It is hereby determined that it is to the financial advantage of the
County not to impose and collect from registered owners of such serial bonds any charges for mailing,
shipping and insuring bonds transferred or exchanged by the fiscal agent, and, accordingly, pursuant to
paragraph c of Section 70.00 of the Local Finance Law, no such charges shall be so collected by the fiscal
agent. Such bonds shall contain substantially the recital of validity clause provided for in section 52.00 of
the Local Finance Law and shall otherwise be in such form and contain such recitals in addition to those
required by section 52.00 of the Local Finance Law, as the County Comptroller shall determine.
Section 9. The validity of such bonds and bond anticipation notes may be contested only if:
1) Such obligations are authorized for an object or purpose for which said County is not
authorized to expend money, or
197
July 13, 1993
2) The provisions of law which should be complied with at the date of publication of this
resolution are not substantially complied with, and an action, suit or proceeding contesting such validity is
commenced within twenty days after the date of such publication, or
3) Such obligations are authorized in violation of the provisions of the Constitution.
Section 10. This resolution shall constitute a statement of official intent for purposes of Treasury
Regulations Section 1.103 - 18(0. Other than as specified in this resolution, no monies are, or are
reasonably expected to be, reserved, allocated on a long-term basis, or otherwise set aside with respect to
the permanent funding of the object or purpose described herein.
Section 11. This resolution, which takes effect immediately, shall be published in full in the Ithaca
Journal, which is hereby designated as the official newspaper of such County, for purposes of this bond
resolution, together with a notice of the Clerk of the Board of Representatives in substantially the form
provided in Section 81.00 of the Local Finance Law.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 202 - ADOPTION OF LOCAL LAW NO. 4 OF 1993 - AMENDING LOCAL
LAW NO. 7 OF 1990 - PROVIDING FOR AMENDMENTS TO THE
TOMPKINS COUNTY CHARTER AND CODE - ARTICLE 5 -
FINANCIAL PROCEDURES AND CONTROLS - SECTION 5.06 -
PUBLIC HEARING
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Ms. Mink, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, a public hearing was held before the Board of Representatives on July 13, 1993 to hear
all persons interested in proposed Local Law No. 4 of 1993, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committees, That said proposed
Local Law No. 4 of 1993 - Amending Local Law No. 7 of 1990 - Providing for Amendments to the
Tompkins County Charter and Code - Article 5 - Financial Procedures and Controls is adopted,
RESOLVED, further, That the Clerk of the Board publish in the official newspaper of Tompkins
County a notice of adoption containing a synopsis of said local law, and shall within five (5) days file one
certified copy in the office of the County Clerk and three (3) certified copies in the office of the Secretary
of State.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 203 - ADVERTISE PUBLIC HEARING ON 1994 TOMPKINS COUNTY
BUDGET AND CAPITAL PROGRAM
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Todd, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the Clerk of
the Board of Representatives is directed to publish a notice of public hearing, said notice to appear in the
official newspaper of Tompkins County, said hearing to be conducted in the Chambers of the Tompkins
County Board of Representatives at 320 North Tioga Street, Ithaca, New York at 7:00 p.m. on November
30, 1993 for the purpose of hearing all persons interested in the 1994 Tompkins County Budget and
Capital Program as required by Section 5.06 of the Tompkins County Charter and Code.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
198
July 13, 1993
RESOLUTION NO. 204 - CREATION OF POSITIONS, REQUEST FROM CONTINGENT
FUND AND BUDGET ADJUSTMENT - CHILDREN WITH
SPECIAL CARE NEEDS - EARLY INTERVENTION PROGRAM
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans. A short roll vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 15,
Noes - 0. Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education and Budget and Administration
Committees, That the following positions be created effective July 19, 1993:
1-50% time Sr. Account Clerk Typist (09/529), labor grade I, competitive class
1 -County Clinical Nurse II (15/703), labor grade 0, competitive class
RESOLVED, further, That one position of County Clinical Nurse II, (15/703), labor grade 0,
competitive class, be created effective October 1, 1993, and
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller is hereby authorized and directed to make the
following budget adjustments and appropriations on his books:
Revenue: 1990.4400 Contingent Fund $ 20,981
4047.3401 State Aid 13,298
Appropriation:
4047.1529 Sr. Account Clerk Typist $ 4,488
.1703 County Clinical Nurse II 20,183
.2211 Chairs 390
.2212 Desks/Bookcases 191
.2213 File Cabinets 378
.4462 Insurance 120
.4465 Job Necessitated Travel/Training 300
.8830 Social Security 1,889
.8840 Workers Comp. 376
.8860 Health Insurance 5,816
.8870 Unemployment 148
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 205 - EXTENSION OF POSITION - ASSISTANT SOLID WASTE
ENGINEER - PUBLIC WORKS
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Lerner, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Solid Waste and Resource Management and Budget and
Administration Committees, That one position of Assistant Solid Waste Engineer (10/845), labor grade J,
competitive class, be extended through December 31, 1993. The position was created by Resolution No.
250 of 1992 on a temporary basis for one (1) year,
RESOLVED, further, That no new monies are needed to fund this extension of position through
1993.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 206 - APPROVING THE ISSUANCE OF TOMPKINS HEALTH CARE
CORPORATION OBLIGATIONS
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto. A roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 15, Noes
- 0. Adopted.
199
July 13, 1993
WHEREAS, the County of Tompkins, New York, (the "County") desires to assist Tompkins
Health Care Corporation (the "Issuer") to provide a 40 -bed addition to an existing 80 -bed nursing home
facility in New York, and
WHEREAS, said County determined it to be in its best interest to approve the formation of the
Issuer as a charitable, non -stock non-profit corporation to act for the public purpose as set forth in
Revenue Ruling 63-20 to provide for the acquisition and construction and financing therefor, of nursing
home facilities therefor to be developed by the Issuer, and to cooperate with the Department of Housing
and Urban Development of the United States of America ("HUD"), and
WHEREAS, the County will take title to said Issuer upon completion of the project financing as
required by Internal Revenue Service Revenue Ruling 63-20, and
WHEREAS, the County has previously reviewed the Articles of Incorporation, the Certificate of
Amendment thereof and By -Laws for the Issuer, as filed with he Secretary of State of New York (the
"State"), and has reviewed certain other documents listed below prepared and presented to this meeting
with regard to the proposed issuance of the Issuer's $3,205,000 aggregate principal amount Mortgage
Revenue Bonds, Series 1993A (FHA Insured Mortgage Loan -- Reconstruction Home, Inc. Project)
simultaneously issued with its $165,000 aggregate principal amount of Taxable Subordinated Revenue
Bonds, Series 1993B Bonds (Reconstruction Home, Inc. Project) (the "Series 1993B Bonds")
(collectively, the "Bonds") to be issued for the purpose of providing funds to finance the acquisition and
construction of the Project, and
WHEREAS, there has been submitted to this meeting the proposed form of the following
documents relating to the financing of the Project:
1. Supplemental Loan Agreement (the "Supplemental Loan Agreement") between the Issuer and
Reconstruction Home, Inc. (the "Owner") pursuant to which the Owner will use the proceeds of the
Bonds to purchase the Project site and to fund the costs of construction as work progresses;
2. Trust Indenture (the "Indenture") between the Issuer and Manufacturers & Traders Trust
Company, Buffalo, New York, as trustee (the "Trustee") pursuant to which the Issuer's Bonds are issued
and secured to provide funds with which the Issuer will finance the acquisition and construction of the
Project;
3. The Official Statement from the Issuer and Owner (the "Official Statement"), and
4. Tax Regulatory Agreement among the Issuer, the Owner and the Trustee.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the County of Tompkins, New York, a body
corporate and politic, a lawful quorum of which is duly assembled, as follows:
Section 1. That it is hereby determined to be proper to approve the issuance of the Issuer's
obligations therefor, to be conveyed to this County at the completion of the Project financing.
Section 2. That the County has been presented with a Bond Resolution of the Issuer including
provisions for the issuance and sale thereof, and hereby approves the Resolution as well as the form of
Supplemental Loan Agreement, form of Bonds, form of Indenture, form of Official Statement, and form
of Tax Regulatory Agreement, all presented to this meeting, and all other documents necessary and
proper to carry out all the purposes herein and therein.
Section 3. That the Directors of the Issuer have been issued a Certificate of Incorporation by the
Secretary of State, and the County authorizes and approves the issuance, sale and delivery of the Bonds of
said Issuer pursuant to the applicable laws of the State, the encumbrance of any interests in real estate so
acquired by said Issuer for the purpose of acquiring and constructing said nursing home and health
facilities.
Section 4. That the Bonds of the Issuer shall not constitute a debt of this County, or the State nor
affect the borrowing capacity of Tompkins County.
Section 5. That this County hereby agrees to accept the fee title to the Project at the earlier of the
time of dissolution of the Issuer or upon payment of the Bonds in full. The County further agrees that the
Issuer shall grant to the County an option to purchase the Project at any time while the Bonds are
outstanding for an amount sufficient to redeem the amount of Bonds outstanding.
Section 6. That the providing of nursing home facilities in and for the County is in the public
interest of the citizens of the County, and is a proper public purpose, and this County desires to cooperate
with agencies of the Federal Government and other public bodies to fulfill such public purposes.
200
July 13, 1993
Section 7. That the prior lawful acts of the Issuer in authorizing, issuing and selling the Bonds
secured by the Indenture are approved.
Section 8. If any section, paragraph or provision of this Resolution shall be held to be invalid or
unenforceable for any reason, the invalidity or unenforceability of such section, paragraph of provision
shall not affect any of the remaining provisions of this Resolution.
Section 9. All resolutions and orders or parts thereon in conflict herewith are, to the extent of such
conflict, thereby repealed.
Section 10. That it is found and determined that all formal actions of this County concerning and
relating to the adoption of this Resolution were adopted in an open meeting of this County, and that all
deliberations of this County and of its committees that resulted in such formal actions were in meetings
open to the public, in compliance with all legal requirements.
RESOLVED, further, That this resolution shall be in full force and effect from and after its passage
in accordance with the regulations of this County.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 207 - AUTHORIZATION FOR TOMPKINS COUNTY PUBLIC LIBRARY
TO BE INCLUDED IN COUNTY INSURANCE COVERAGES AND
IN THE COUNTY'S SELF INSURANCE AND RISK
MANAGEMENT PROGRAM
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Lerner, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the
Tompkins County Public Library is authorized to participate in Tompkins County's Insurance and Risk
Management Program and specifically that insurance coverage for personal injury and property damage
carried by the County shall be extended to include the Library and that the Library shall in turn pay its pro
rata share of premiums on such coverage and of the charge for Risk Management and Safety Services,
RESOLVED, further, That any payments for claims handling or claims payouts that would be paid
for a County department from the Self Insurance Reserve Fund shall be paid on behalf of the Library,
RESOLVED, further, That as is the case with County Departments, any insurance determined to be
needed only for the Library shall be charged to and paid directly by the Library.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 208 - BUDGET ADJUSTMENTS AND APPROPRIATIONS - VARIOUS
DEPARTMENTS
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Ms. Mink. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 15,
Noes - 0. Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education, Public Works, Public Safety, Human
Services, and Budget and Administration Committees, That the County Comptroller be authorized to
make the following budget adjustments on his books:
BUDGET ADJUSTMENTS
Employment & Training
Revenue: CD6290.4735 Special Trng/Employment Project $10,764
Appropriation: CD6290.1051 JTPA Participant $ 5,000
.1507 Keyboard Specialist 3,000
.4424 Equipment Rental 2,052
.8830 Social Security 612
.8840 Workers Compensation 100
201
Office for the Aging
Revenue: A6782.2705
Appropriation: A6782.4332
APPROPRIATIONS
Public Works - Airport
Revenue: B0909.0000
Appropriation: B9616.4400
B5610.4442
Appropriations from 1992 Surplus
Purchasing & Central Services
A0599.0000
A1345.2204
Revenue:
Appropriation:
Youth Bureau
Revenue:
Appropriation:
A0599.0000
A7026.4576
Revenue: A0599.0000
Appropriation: A7026.4608
A7020.4400
Revenue: A0599.0000
Appropriation: A7026.4620
A7026.4655
A7026.4670
Public Works
Revenue: A0599.0000
Appropriation: A1490.2230
A1490.2206
Stop -DWI
Revenue: A0599.0000
Appropriation: A4250.2206
BUDGET TRANSFERS
Budget & Finance
July 13, 1993
Gifts & Donations
Books/Publications
Airport Fund Balance
Debt Service Contribution
Prof. Services Acct.
1992 Surplus Funds
Copying Equipment
1992 Surplus Funds
DCC -Teen Preg/Parenting Program
1992 Surplus Funds
1. Youth Mini Grants
2. Program Expenses
1992 Surplus Funds
Town of Danby
Village of Groton
Town of Lansing
1992 Surplus Funds
Computer Software
Computer Hardware
1992 Surplus Funds
Computer Equipment
$ 104
104
$ 38,176
$ 26,176
12,000
$ 544
$ 544
$ 11,700
$ 11,700
$ 4,000
$ 2,000
$ 2,000
$ 6,800
$ 4,830
$ 1,934
$ 36
$ 2,327
$ 1,300
$ 1,027
$ 2,010
$ 2,010
A1310.4422 Equipment $ 25
A1310.4402 Advertising $ 25
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administration be and hereby is authorized to execute the
necessary contracts to convey these funds.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 209 - AUTHORIZATION TO SIGN ELECTRONIC TRANSFER OF FUNDS
AGREEMENT
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the County
Administrator be and hereby is authorized to sign for electronic transfer for the County of Tompkins and
to delegate this authority to the Deputy County Administrator,
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator be and hereby is authorized to sign an
agreement with the Tompkins County Trust Company for the execution of electronic transfers and to
delegate this authority to the Deputy County Administrator.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
202
July 13, 1993
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 210 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE CONTRACT - BUCK
ENVIRONMENTAL LABORATORIES, INC. - LANDFILL
ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING - HILLVIEW ROAD
LANDFILL
Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, the Solid Waste Division has duly advertised for proposals for environmental
monitoring for Hillview Road Landfill, and
WHEREAS, eleven (11) proposals were received on Wednesday, July 29, 1992 and subsequently
evaluated, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee,
That the County Administrator be and hereby is authorized to execute a contract with Buck
Environmental Labs, Inc. of Cortland, New York, to perform environmental monitoring at Hillview Road
Landfill at a cost not to exceed $24,646 from funds allocated for such services in 8160.4442 operational
budget, professional services account,
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator is authorized to execute change orders up to
a total of ten percent (10%) of the contract value.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 211 - RESCISSION OF RESOLUTION NO. 177 OF 1993 -
AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE AGREEMENT WITH NEW
YORK STATE OFFICE OF PARKS, RECREATION AND
HISTORIC PRESERVATION AND APPROPRIATION FROM
CONTINGENT FUND
Moved by Mr. Mason, seconded by Mrs. Schuler. Chairman Watros granted Mr. Stein
permission to abstain from voting on this resolution because of a relationship he has with the State parks.
A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 14, Noes - 0, Abstentions - 1 (Representative Stein). Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Safety and Budget and Administration
Committees, That Resolution No. 177 of 1993 is hereby rescinded.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 212 - CALLING FOR A PLAN TO END THE SMOKING BAN IN THE
LIVING AREAS OF THE TOMPKINS COUNTY JAIL
Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mr. Joseph. Mr. Lerner stated that being incarcerated is an
extremely stressful experience. This resolution doesn't change the current policy, it authorizes the County
Administrator and Jail Administrator to do research to see what would be involved in changing the policy.
Mr. Mason spoke adamantly against this resolution and stated that he would rather see monies spent on
programs to help people quit smoking. Mrs. Livesay stated that passage of this resolution would be a
breach of faith with County employees who have negotiated for this. Mrs. Livesay distributed and
commented on two articles written by the American Medical Society. Following continued discussion, a
roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 5 (Representatives Joseph, Lerner, Mink, Shurtleff and Stein),
Noes - 10 (Representatives Call, Culligan, Evans, Livesay, Mason, Proto, Schuler, Todd, Watros and
Winch). Resolution Lost.
203
July 13, 1993
WHEREAS, smoking is now prohibited in all areas of the Tompkins County Public Safety
Building. Enforcing the smoking ban in the Jail results in additional County expenses. Prisoners found
with tobacco must be prosecuted for possession of jail contraband, resulting in costs for investigation,
prosecution, and in some cases, additional jail time, and
WHEREAS, involuntary withdrawal from smoking is a hardship on the residents of the facility,
many of whom are detained pre-trial and are presumed innocent. Many prisoners become irritable,
aggressive, and in some cases violent, which is a threat to other prisoners and jail staff. Prisoners who are
angry and stressed when they are released from jail are at greater risk of acting violently and committing
crimes in the community, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Safety Committee, That the County
Administrator is hereby charged with working in cooperation with the Jail Administrator to develop a
plan to permit smoking in living areas of the Jail. The plan should involve the least possible cost to the
County and should protect the right of non-smokers. The plan shall be provided to the Public Safety
Committee no later than September 2, 1993.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 213 - PROMOTING THE USE OF ALTERNATIVES TO
INCARCERATION THAT REDUCE JAIL COSTS AND
PROTECT COMMUNITY SAFETY
Moved by Mr. Mason, seconded by Mr. Lerner. Following a lengthy discussion, it was Moved
by Mr. Culligan, seconded by Mr. Evans, to Table this resolution. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes
- 5 (Representatives Culligan, Evans, Mason, Proto and Winch), Noes - 10 (Representatives Call, Joseph,
Lerner, Livesay, Mink, Schuler, Shurtleff, Stein, Todd and Watros). Motion Lost.
A roll call vote on the resolution resulted as follows: Ayes - 10 (Representatives Call, Joseph,
Lerner, Livesay, Mink, Schuler, Shurtleff, Stein, Todd and Watros), Noes - 5 (Representatives Culligan,
Evans, Mason, Proto and Watros). Adopted.
WHEREAS, the mandated costs of holding sentenced prisoners and pre-trial detainees in the
County Jail are a burden to County taxpayers for which there is no State aid. The total appropriations of
the Jail in 1993 are $1,487,399, and
WHEREAS, when the Jail is full, it costs $65-95 per person per day to board them in another
facility. The total cost to Tompkins County of board -outs in 1992 was $64,927, and
WHEREAS, when the Jail is full, it is not possible to generate revenue by boarding in excess
prisoners from other facilities, and
WHEREAS, thoughtfully designed and carefully implemented alternatives to incarceration
programs can prevent crime and reduce jail costs, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Safety Committee, That the heads of the
following County departments shall each prepare a written plan for that department's programs that affect
the Jail: Mental Health Department, Public Health Department, Youth Bureau, Assigned Counsel
Department, Probation Department and the Social Services Depai lnient. Each plan shall be submitted to
the Public Safety Committee and to the Criminal Justice Advisory/Alternatives to Incarceration Board, as
well as the appropriate program committee no later than October 7, 1993,
RESOLVED, further, That the Board of Representatives requests that the Sheriff's Depailwent
and the District Attorney's office also prepare written plans that identify ways in which the respective
Departments can help reduce incarceration time,
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator shall prepare a monthly report on Jail
expenses,
RESOLVED, further, That the Chairman of the Board of Representatives is authorized to write
letters to all County, City, Town and Village Judges, all police agencies and District Attorney,
204
July 13, 1993
highlighting the costs of the Jail and encouraging optimum use of existing alternative to incarceration
programs.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 214 - AUTHORITY TO CONTRACT - JUDY CRAWFORD, CERTIFIED
INDUSTRIAL HYGIENIST
Moved by Ms. Mink, seconded by Mrs. Call. Mr. Heyman, County Administrator, stated that
these are not duties that could be performed by the Health and Safety Coordinator. Ms. Mink, Chair,
Human Services Committee, stated that it is her understanding that this person is being hired for her
technical expertise to help clean up the Biggs building and follow through with Greg Siwinski's
recommendations. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 15, Noes - 0. Adopted.
WHEREAS, the Department of Social Services is in need of technical assistance as it evaluates
and implements the results of the Air Quality study which is on-going at Biggs Building A, and
WHEREAS, Ms. Crawford has the qualifications and experience to provide this technical
assistance to the Department, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Human Services Committee, That the County
Administrator is authorized to execute an agreement with Ms. Judy Crawford, Certified Industrial
Hygienist, for the period of July 1, 1993 to December 31, 1993 and that the total amount of this
agreement shall not exceed $4,000.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 215 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE CONTRACT - COOPERATIVE
EXTENSION - LEAD GRANT
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, the New York State Department of Health has made additional funding available for
the Lead Screening Grant, and
WHEREAS, Cooperative Extension of Tompkins County is interested in working with the Health
Depattment on outreach and educational activities for the Lead Program, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education Committee, That the County
Administrator is authorized to execute a contract with Cooperative Extension for services as outlined by
the department,
RESOLVED, further, That funding for this project is 100 percent state funded to be budget
adjusted with other changes as approved by New York State Depai tcuent of Health.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 216 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE MULTI-YEAR CONTRACT -
JACK VENESKY, C.P.A. - CHHA MEDICARE AND MEDICAID
COST REPORT
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Shurtleff, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County Health Department is required to file a Medicare and
Medicaid Cost Report for the Certified Home Health Agency, and
205
July 13, 1993
WHEREAS, Jack Venesky, C.P.A. has provided accounting services for the past five years, now
therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education Committee, That the County
Administrator is authorized to execute contracts with Jack Venesky, C.P.A. for the reporting years of
1993 and 1994.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 217 AMENDMENT OF RESOLUTION NO. 97 OF 1993 -
AUTHORIZATION FOR FIVE YEAR SERVICE CONTRACTS
- CHILDREN WITH SPECIAL CARE NEEDS
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education Committee, That the Public
Health Director or designee is authorized to execute contracts in compliance with County policy for
professional services for the Early Intervention Program and the 3-5 year old Education of the
Handicapped Program.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 218 - URGING THE LABOR COMMISSIONER TO APPOINT A WAGE
BOARD (Adopted September 7, 1993)
Moved by Mr. Joseph, seconded by Mr. Lerner. Chairman Watros stated that he could not see
how this resolution would help New York State to create jobs. Mr. Joseph stated that he brought this
resolution forth as an Individual Representative. He stated that he was not sure there was an appropriate
committee to review this. It was Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, and unanimously
adopted by voice vote, to refer this resolution to the Planning Committee.
WHEREAS, Section 653 of the New York State Labor Law provides that "The Commissioner
shall have power on his own motion to cause an investigation to be made of the wages being paid to
persons employed in any occupation or occupations to ascertain whether the minimum wages established
in accordance with the provisions of this article are sufficient to provide adequate maintenance and to
protect the health of the persons employed in such occupation or occupations. The Commissioner shall,
on the petition of fifty or more residents of the State engaged in or affected by an occupation or
occupations sought to be investigated, cause such an investigation of such occupation or occupations to be
conducted. If, on the basis of information in his possession with or without such an investigation, the
Commissioner is of the opinion that any substantial number of persons employed in any occupation or
occupations are receiving wages insufficient to provide adequate maintenance and to protect their health,
he shall appoint a wage board to inquire into and report and recommend adequate minimum wages and
regulations for employees in such occupation or occupations," and
WHEREAS, a petition meeting the requirements of this law has been delivered to the Labor
Commissioner, and
WHEREAS, the Commissioner, John Hudacs, has stated in a meeting with members of the
Campaign for a Liveable Minimum Wage that he believes the minimum wage to be inadequate, now
therefore be it
RESOLVED, That the Tompkins County Board of Representatives urges the Labor
Commissioner to act promptly to appoint a wage board in compliance with New York State Labor Law,
RESOLVED, further, That a copy of this resolution be forwarded to Labor Commissioner John
Hudacs and Governor Mario Cuomo, Assemblymen Marty Luster and Frank Babaro and State Senators
James Seward and John R. Kuhl, Jr.
206
July 13, 1993
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 219 - APPROVAL OF AMENDMENTS - EMPLOYEE COUNCIL BYLAWS
Moved by Mr. Evans, seconded by Ms. Mink, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
RESOLVED, on the recommendation of the Personnel Committee, That amendments to the
bylaws of the Employee Council are approved as amended,
RESOLVED, further, That a copy of the bylaws as amended are on file with the Clerk of the
Board.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
It was Moved by Mr. Mason, seconded by Mr. Lerner, and unanimously adopted by voice vote, to
amend the Rules of the Board and waive reports of standing and special committees at this meeting.
Mr. Winch, Chairman, Public Works and Construction Management Committee, updated the
Board on the status of the Forest Home Bridge and pedestrian walkway. He stated that he expects a
resolution to be placed on the Public Works and Construction Management Committee agenda to take
ownership of the Bridge.
Ms. Mink, Chair, Human Services Committee, announced that the next meeting of the Human
Services Committee will be August 3 at 2:30 p.m.
Mr. Proto, Representative, District No. 7, reported on work being done to the Buffalo Hill Road
Bridge and stated that Public Works staff is working to restore a break that has occurred in the flow of
water from artesian wells. He said that Liz Cameron of the Public Works Department is the contact
person on this project.
Cheryl Nelson, Chair, Employee Council, submitted a written reported dated July 13, 1993 on
activities of the Council.
Mr. Heyman, County Administrator, announced the appointment of Alice Cole to the position of
Public Health Director for a six-year term. It was Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Evans, and
unanimously adopted by voice vote, to confirm this appointment.
On motion, the meeting adjourned at 11:38 p.m.
207
August 10, 1993
Regular Meeting
Chairman Watros called the meeting to order at 5:30 p.m.
Members and guests participated in the Pledge of Allegiance.
Present: 13 Representatives. Excused: 2 (Representatives Joseph and Mink).
It was Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to approve the minutes of June 29, 1993 as submitted.
Mr. Proto, Chairman, Health and Education Committee, introduced Theresa Lyzko, Marketing
Media Specialist at the Health Depai tanent. Ms. Lyzko distributed a press release and began a videotape
presentation on the Healthy Heart Program entitled Five -a -day.
Under privilege of the floor, Margaret Marks, Department of Social Services employee, spoke
concerning air quality at the Biggs building. Ms. Marks stated that she has been out of work since March
9, 1993. Ms. Marks distributed a document entitled "Chemicals in New Carpets Pose Potential Health
Hazard" released from the New York State Attorney General's Department of Law. Ms. Marks
commented on options for employees to return to work and submitted a letter from her physician, Dr.
James M. Miller. Ms. Marks submitted a letter from herself to Commissioner Dolan, Anita Fitzpatrick
and James Kazda concerning the physicians being informed about options to return the employees to
work.
Under privilege of the floor, James Ellis, Department of Social Services employee, spoke
concerning air quality at the Biggs building. Mr. Ellis stated that he feels he has experienced
discrimination since he has become ill. He asked that the County prepare space for the employees to
return to work and allow physicians to look at that space when it is ready. He expressed his opposition
with the presence of armed guards at meetings with administrators to discuss the situation. Mr. Ellis
urged that action be taken to resolve this situation immediately.
Under privilege of the floor, Yvonne Bartlett, Dein" tnient of Social Services employee, spoke
concerning air quality at the Biggs building. She requested that privilege of the floor be held at the
beginning of Board meetings to accommodate those who are ill. Ms. Bartlett expressed frustration with
administrators within the County and asked for the Board to research health complaints that may have
been reported.
Under privilege of the floor, Chrissy Dawson, daughter of Yvonne Bartlett who is a Department of
Social Services employee, recited a poem concerning the air quality situation at the Biggs A building.
Under privilege of the floor, Claudia Cinquanti, Department of Social Services employee, spoke
concerning air quality at the Biggs building. She stated that she has been out of work since April 4, 1993
since diagnosed with multiple chemical sensitivities. Ms. Cinquanti asked for the status of carpets being
removed and repairs to the heating system.
Under privilege of the floor, Sharon Prezioso McLaughlin, Department of Social Services
employee, spoke concerning air quality at the Biggs building. Ms. Prezioso McLaughlin referred to a
petition submitted in 1986 to the Commissioner of Social Services and the Personnel Commissioner. She
stated that as an employee and taxpayer of Tompkins County, she feels that her best interests should be
looked out for.
208
August 10, 1993
Anita Fitzpatrick, Commissioner of Personnel, updated the Board on the status of the air quality
situation at the Biggs building and actions taken since the last Board meeting. She stated that there was a
meeting June 22 with five employees who are currently out ill and their attorneys. There was another
meeting on July 14 which two of the employees attended. Four proposals developed by James Kazda,
Senior Civil Engineer from the Public Works Department, on possible space. The employees who were
present at that meeting did have some objections to those spaces but the options were pursued. In mid
July another space in the Biggs building known as the "B" wing was located and a letter was sent to the
five employees and their physicians outlining the space and asked for the comments by August 9. At this
time, no response has been received. On August 5 there were three meetings held in the Biggs complex
for all employees and occupants of the Biggs building. She explained options for receiving the
information provided in that meeting that were made available to those employees who were not able to
attend. Ms. Fitzpatrick distributed copies of the indoor air quality master activity schedule.
Mr. Lerner asked for the status of the removal or relocation of carbonless forms. Mr. Culligan
suggested that a downtown satellite office space be considered for the Department of Social Services.
Mr. Evans stated that following a walk through the Biggs building, he believes there is a poor flow of air
in the building. He stated that he feels the employees should be returned to work as soon as possible and
the building should be fixed or converted to a space for storage as soon as possible.
Mr. Proto, Chairman, Health and Education Committee, reported that the Committee met July 29
and stated that the PCAP program is going to be re-evaluated later this summer. He reported that the
environmental health fees with two revisions will be presented to the Board for action next month. He
reported that a proposal for AIDS testing by the County will discussed at the Committee meeting in
August. He said that the Health Department application to the State to be a health department for 1992
and also 1993 has not yet been approved. The next Committee meeting will be August 31.
Mr. Evans, Chairman, Personnel Committee, reported that the Committee met August 6. He stated
that the Committee will meet each Thursday at 8 a.m. to discuss evaluations of the four employees
reporting to the Board.
Mr. Evans, Vice Chairman, Human Services Committee, reported that the Committee heard a
report from Irene Stein, Office for the Aging Director, on the Personal Emergency Response Program.
He stated that the intermunicipal consolidation committee on human services has completed its work and
submitted reports to Chairman Watros and Mayor Benjamin Nichols. He stated that there is another
committee working on recreation services. He reported that the annual report for the Tompkins County
Youth Bureau is on file in the Board office.
Mr. Mason, Chairman, Public Safety Committee, reported that the Committee met August 5 and
had a discussion at length on the relationship that George Junior Republic has with Tompkins County.
Mr. Mason reported that Emery Guest, Tompkins County Sheriff, returned to work on August 9. He
stated that the Committee heard a report from Jack Miller, Fire, Disaster and EMS Coordinator, on
problems with the EMS training program. The Committee discussed the possibility of revising the
boarding -in rates at the Tompkins County Jail. After consideration, the Committee decided not to change
the existing $75 per day fee which seems to be competitive with other upstate counties. Mr. Stevens,
Corrections Administrator, reported to the Committee that following the installation of an additional
shower at the Public Safety Building, he expects the temporary variance will be removed and the
Building will be allowed to increase the population to 72 beds. The Committee discussed at length the
proposed business manager position at the Sheriffs Depaitanent. The next Committee meeting will be
September 2.
Mr. Stein, Chairman, Planning Committee, reported that the Committee met July 15 and
committee business is reflected on the agenda. The next Committee meeting will be August 19.
209
August 10, 1993
Mr. Winch, Chairman, Public Works and Construction Management Committee, reported on the
shortfall in the Buildings and Grounds Department as the 1994 budget grows closer and commented that
there are departments/agencies that do not pay rent to the County which Buildings and Grounds are
required to maintain. He stated that he sees the approximate cost of $133,900 to be one which Buildings
and Grounds can not absorb. Mr. Winch reported on the Buffalo Hill Road bridge. He stated that a
second public information meeting with residents and the town supervisor concerning the loss or
reduction of water pressure in homes located near the bridge. Since July 21 the County has been
providing water to approximately one dozen homes through tankers that are placed on the site. He stated
that while trying to resolve this problem, the Depai lnient has kept communications open with the
residents. Mr. Winch reported on the progress of construction at the new Airport terminal and stated that
all of the steel is up and the roof is going on. He reported that work is expected to begin in mid August
on the Forest Home footbridge. Mr. Winch also reported that TOMTRAN will be moving from the
Planning Depai tnient to the Public Works Department. Mr. Proto, Representative, District No. 7,
thanked Public Works staff for working to restore water to residents living in the Buffalo Hill Road
Bridge vicinity.
Mr. Todd, Chairman, Fiscal Affairs Committee, reported that the Committee met July 14 and
expects to have a detailed report on the first sixth months of 1993 in September.
Mr. Lerner, Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, reported that the Solid
Waste Finance Committee met last week and stated that there are three pieces of the solid waste finance
that needs to be completed so the committee has divided into three subcommittees and expects to have a
proposal for the Board to vote on at the end of September. He stated that the committee is working on
negotiations with the colleges concerning paying their fair share if there is an annual fee for 1994. He
also reported that a subcommittee is working on what changes need to be made in 1994 to the annual
solid waste fee to remove unfairness of the fee. He stated that discussions with the City of Ithaca has
taken place on the site plan review for the Tompkins County Recycling and Solid Waste Center are going
well.
Mr. Lerner stated that the Tompkins County recycling program now handles newspaper,
cardboard, glass, mixed plastics, scrap metal cans, and mixed paper, each of which must be processed
and marketed differently. He distributed a report to the Board which summarized recycling operations
and costs for each commodity and indicated how the Recycling and Solid Waste Center will reduce costs
and increase revenues.
Mrs. Call, Chairman, Budget and Administration Committee, thanked Mr. Winch for Chairing the
Committee meeting on August 3 in her absence. She stated that the Committee reviewed the sales tax
report for the second quarter of 1993 and it looks on track. David Squires, Comptroller, however, urged
cautious interpretation of the report. At the meeting the Committee began discussion on possible ways to
improve the Solid Waste Annual Fee. Mrs. Call made reference to correspondence from Mr. Squires
dated July 21 in which he listed Tompkins Cortland Community College, the Sheriffs Depaitiuent and
Jail, the Highway Department (i.e. CHIPS funding), the Depai lnient of Social Services - Aid to
Dependent Children as areas of concern. Mr. Squires advised that the Contingent Fund can not handle
these costs. Mrs. Call stated that the budget process will begin in September.
Mr. Heyman, County Administrator, distributed a report listing items with timelines for activities
planned to improve indoor air quality as prepared by Anita Fitzpatrick, Commissioner of Personnel.
Mr. Mulvey, County Attorney, updated the Board on the status on the status of the Collins'
bankruptcy case. He stated that he will be preparing a report for the Board on tax assessment lawsuits
which are voluminous.
210
August 10, 1993
Cheryl Nelson, Chair, Employee Council, reported on Council activities and stated that elections for
new officers will take place in September.
Chairman Watros declared recess at 7:42 p.m. The meeting reconvened at 7:45 p.m. It was
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present to enter into executive session at 7:45 p.m. to discuss appointments and contract negotiations.
The meeting returned to open session at 8:38 p.m.
Chairman Watros gave Mrs. Call permission to withdraw from the agenda, the resolution entitled
Creation of Position and Budget Adjustment.
On motion of the appropriate committee chairman and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by
voice vote by members present, the resolution entitled Authorization to Execute Purchase Agreement and
Deed was added to the agenda.
Chairman Watros gave the appropriate committee chairmen permission to withdraw from the
agenda the following resolutions with final committee action being affirmed:
CA072-93 - Authorizing an Agreement - Michelle Lovejoy - County Attorney
CA073-93 - Award of Bid - Printing Services - Purchasing and Central Services
CA074-73 - 1994 Tourism Promotion Agency Designation
CA075-93 - Award of Bid - Surplus Bus - Tomtran
CA076-93 - Renewal of Contract with Planning/Environmental Research Associates for
Trumansburg Main Street Study
CA077-93 - Authorization for County Administrator to Enter into Contract with the Convention
and Visitors Bureau
CA078-93 - Reclassification of Position - Public Works - Sanitary Landfill Supervisor to Transfer
Facility Supervisor
CA079-93 - Reclassification of Position - Data Processing - Microcomputer Specialist
CA080-93 - Reclassification of Position - Fire and Disaster - Keyboard Specialist to Secretary
CA081-93 - Authorization to Execute Contracts - Sue Travis, M.S., R.D. and Virginia Raner -
Healthy Heart Program
CA082-93 - Authorization to Execute Contract - Lansing Central Schools - Healthy Heart
Program
CA083-93 - Authorization to Execute Lease Agreements - Health Department Clinics
CA084-93 - Award of Bid - Transportation of Preschool Handicapped Children
RESOLUTION NO. 220 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE PURCHASE AGREEMENT AND
DEED, TOWN OF DANBY TAX PARCEL 18-1-16
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
RESOLVED, That the County Administrator is directed to execute a purchase agreement and deed
conveying Town of Danby Tax Parcel 18-1-16, acquired by tax foreclosure, to Christopher H. Muka for
the sum of $12,000 and to remit to Patterson Real Estate the commission stipulated in the County's
contract with that organization.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
211
August 10, 1993
RESOLUTION NO. 221 - CREATION OF POSITION AND BUDGET ADJUSTMENT -
MENTAL HEALTH
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education and Budget and Administration
Committees, That one (1) position of Account Clerk Typist (06-513), labor grade VI, competitive class
be created, effective immediately,
RESOLVED, further, That the following budget adjustments be made:
APPROPRIATION: 4310.1513 Salaries $8,000
.8810 Retirement 280
.8830 Social Security 480
.8860 Health Insurance 275
$9,035
RESOLVED, further, That no new monies are needed for these appropriations. Monies for this
position are in the current 1993 budgets and are to be charged to: 4311 Mental Health Clinic, 4312
Skylight Club, 4313 CSS, 4315 Satellite Clinic, 4316 ICM, 4606 Mental Health Administration Accounts
and the position has a direct effect on the realization of fee collection that can offset the cost,
RESOLVED, further, That the County Comptroller be and he is hereby authorized and directed to
make said appropriations and budget adjustments on his books.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 222 - CREATION OF POSITION - NURSE PRACTITIONER - HEALTH
DEPARTMENT
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education, Personnel and Budget and
Administration Committees, That one position of Nurse Practitioner, (16/712), labor grade P, competitive
class, be created effective immediately,
RESOLVED, further, That the Department will transfer funds from the allocation in Professional
Service Fees at the time a qualified candidate is hired.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 223 - INCREASE IN HOURS WIC - NUTRITIONISTS AND NUTRITION
AIDE - WIC PROGRAM
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Shurtleff, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, additional funding is available from New York State Department of Health to
increase the hours for the WIC Program Nutritionist positions and the Nutrition Aide positions, now
therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education and Budget and Administration
Committees, That the two positions of WIC Program Nutritionist (12/572), labor grade (L), competitive
class, be increased from 75 percent time to 80 percent time based on a 35 hour work week, effective
212
August 10, 1993
October 1, 1993 and the half-time position of Nutrition Aide (08/524), labor grade (H), competitive class,
be increased from 50 percent time to 70 percent time based on a 35 hour work week, effective October 1,
1993, and one existing full time Nutrition Aide position be filled on a 50 percent time basis, effective
October 1, 1993, and
RESOLVED, further, That these positions remain in existence only as long as there is 100 percent
State funding to reimburse the County for all salary and fringe benefits, and
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller is hereby authorized and directed to make the
following budget adjustment on his books:
APPROPRIATION: A4012.1524 Nutrition Aide $3,391
.1572 WIC Program Nutritionist 658
.8810 Retirement 160
.8830 Social Security 311
.8840 Workers Compensation 103
.8860 Health Insurance 1,107
REVENUE: A4012.4402 WIC Federal Aid $5,730
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 224 - AMENDMENT OF RESOLUTION NO. 124 OF 1993 - CREATION OF
POSITION - COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR'S OFFICE
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, Resolution No. 124 of 1993 created the position of Safety Coordinator (84/297),
Management level M (13), competitive class, in the County Administrator's office and authorized the
Comptroller to make a budget transfer on his books, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education and Budget and Administration
Committees, That Resolution No. 124 of 1993 is amended to provide that the position of Safety
Coordinator is entitled Employee Safety and Health Coordinator and shall be located in the Department
of Public Health, and to provide that the said transfer is deleted and further to provide that the
Comptroller is directed to make the following budget transfer adjustment to his books:
Transfer
From: A1989.4462 Insurance $23,334
To: A1989.4463 Risk Management $23,334
Budget Adjustment
Appropriation: A4013.1297 Employee Health and Safety Coordinator $13,792
.2201 Calculator 125
.2206 Computer 2,003
.2211 Chair 115
.2213 File Cabinet 149
.2230 Computer Software 750
.4302 Office Supplies 300
.4330 Printing 600
.4332 Books/Publications and Training 300
.4452 Postage 120
.4465 Job Necessitated Travel/Training 450
.4466 Job Related Travel/Training 300
.4472 Telephone 480
.4901 Micro -computer Services 88
213
August 10, 1993
.8810 Retirement
.8830 Social Security
.8840 Workers' Compensation
.8860 Health Insurance
.8870 Unemployment Insurance
Revenue: A4013.2770 Unclassified Revenue
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
483
1,055
26
2,115
83
$23,334
RESOLUTION NO. 225 - BUDGET ADJUSTMENTS AND APPROPRIATIONS - VARIOUS
DEPARTMENTS
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 13,
Noes — 0, Excused - 2 (Representatives Joseph and Mink). Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education, Public Safety, Human Services, and
Budget and Administration Committees, That the County Comptroller be authorized to make the
following budget adjustment on his books:
BUDGET ADJUSTMENTS
Job Training
Revenue: A1990.4400 Contingency $ 1,553
Appropriation: A9963.4400 Contribution $ 1,553
Office for the Aging
Revenue:
Appropriation:
Revenue:
Appropriation:
District Attorney
Revenue:
Appropriation:
Public Health
Revenue:
Appropriation:
A6794.3803
A6794.4302
.8810
.8870
.8840
.4465
.4466
.4330
.4472
.4452
.1529
.1559
.8860
.8830
A6793.4772
A6793.4491
State Revenue
Office Supplies
Retirement
Unemployment
Worker's Comp
Travel - Job Necess.
Travel - Job Related
Printing
Telephone
Postage
Salary
Salary
Health Insurance
Social Security
Revenue
Subcontractor
$14,299
$ 100
365
62
31
200
90
200
200
50
574
9,859
1,770
798
$ 617
$ 617
A1165.4999 Non Expendable $10,000
A1990.4400 Contingency $10,000
A4023.1689
A4023.4332
Other Income
Educational Material
$ 2,093
$ 2,093
Revenue: A4010.3401 State Aid $10,539
214
August 10, 1993
Appropriation: A4010.2214 Office Furnishings $ 435
.2230 Computer Software 404
.4315 Nursing Supplies 300
.4330 Printing 300
.4332 Books, Publications 500
.4333 Promotion 500
.4355 Env. Hlth. Supplies 100
.4442 Prof. Service Fees 7,000
.4465 Job Necess. Travel/Trng 1,000
(Healthy Heart)
Revenue: A4021.3401 Public Health State Aid $ 6,495
Appropriation: A4021.2206 Computer Equipment 195
.4302 Office Supplies 200
.4330 Printing 1,000
.4332 Books/Publications 200
.4333 Promotional Supplies 2,000
.4432 Rent 900
.4466 Job Related Travel/Trng 2,000
Mental Health
Revenue: A4329.3493 State Aid $ 261
Appropriation: A4329.4400 Challenge Industries $ 261
Buildings & Grounds
Revenue: A1620.2770 Unclassified Revenue $12,141
Appropriation: A1620.4476 B&G Maintenance/Repairs $12,141
APPROPRIATIONS from 1992 Surplus
Public Works - Highway
Revenue: D0599.0000 Highway Fund Balance $85,102
Appropriation: D5110.4312 Highway Supplies $85,102
Administration
Revenue: A0599.0000 General Fund Balance $77,520
Appropriation: A1311.4400 Program Expense $77,520
Revenue: A0908.0000 Gen. Fund Bal. -Room Tax $34,739
Appropriation: A6475.4400 Program Expense $ 1,346
.4442 Professional Services 33,393
Office for the Aging
Revenue: A0599.0000 General Fund Balance $ 2,527
Appropriation: A6772.2206 Computer Equipment $ 2,527
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator be and hereby is directed to execute any
contracts necessary to convey these funds.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 226 - ADOPTION OF ADDITION AND REVISIONS - ADMINISTRATIVE
MANUAL POLICIES
215
August 10, 1993
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Personnel Committee, That the following Administrative
Manual policy be and is hereby adopted:
02-14 Performance Review
RESOLVED, further, That the following revised Administrative Manual policies be and hereby
are adopted:
02-15 Management Performance Evaluation
04-14 Promotions
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 227 - ESTABLISHMENT OF BOARD POLICY WITH RESPECT TO
RESIDENTS OF FORECLOSED PROPERTY
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the
following policy is hereby adopted with respect to continuing residence of persons occupying properties
foreclosed upon by Tompkins County:
1. The County Administrator is directed to execute lease agreements with persons who occupy
property when it is foreclosed upon by Tompkins County for non-payment of taxes, said lease
agreements to be in a form acceptable to the County Attorney.
2. The County Attorney is authorized to evict from properties foreclosed upon by Tompkins County
all persons who fail for any reason to execute the lease agreement required by No. 1 above, or
who fail for any reason to provide insurance protection documentation that meets the
requirements of the County Attorney.
3. The County Attorney is authorized to evict from properties foreclosed upon by Tompkins County
all persons who refuse to cooperate with the process of showing said properties for prospective
sale by the County's contract real estate broker.
4. The policy previously established by this Board with respect to withholding from prospective
sale all foreclosed properties that are occupied by a former owner who is working with County
officials to repurchase said property for the full amount due on it for back taxes and all other
charges is continued in effect, but the provisions of section No. 1 above shall apply.
5. County staff are directed to provide assistance to former owners who are attempting to
repurchase their homes and to persons who are required to move as a result of this foreclosure
process.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 228 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE PURCHASE AGREEMENT AND
DEED
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
RESOLVED, That the County Administrator is authorized and directed to execute a purchase
agreement and deed conveying Town of Dryden Tax Parcel 40-1-19, obtained through the Landfill
216
August 10, 1993
Neighborhood Protection Program to Steven R. Preheim of McLean, N.Y., for the sum of $60,000, and
that the appropriate commission on this transaction shall be paid to Patterson Real Estate.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 229 - APPROVAL OF APPLICATION FOR APPALACHIAN REGIONAL
COMMISSION (ARC) FUNDS FOR HUMAN SERVICES
COALITION CONSOLIDATION STUDY
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County Human Services Coalition has requested that the Planning
Department prepare an Appalachian Regional Commission (ARC) application for funds to implement
consolidation of services under the Local Government Assistance Demonstration program, and
WHEREAS, the Planning Department has prepared the application on behalf of the County, and
WHEREAS, the County wishes to apply for funds to the Southern Tier East Regional Planning
and Development Board (STERPDB), now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the County Administrator or
his designee be authorized to apply to the Appalachian Regional Commission for funds for the Human
Services Coalition Study.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 230 - AUTHORIZATION TO APPLY FOR A GRANT - THE RURAL NEW
YORK ENVIRONMENTAL ACTION GRANT PROGRAM - USER
MANUAL FOR THE UNIQUE NATURAL AREAS DOCUMENT -
EMC
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, the Environmental Management Council (EMC) has identified a County -wide need
for a manual to instruct users of the Survey of Unique Natural Areas of Tompkins County, and
WHEREAS, the EMC wishes to hire one student to conduct research to prepare and publish the
user manual, and
WHEREAS, the EMC has identified an appropriate grant program, entitled the Rural New York
Environmental Action Grant Program, to which the EMC wishes to apply for funding of this user manual
project, and
WHEREAS, no County money is involved, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the Environmental
Management Council be authorized to apply for the grant, with a total funding request of $4,000.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 231 - APPROVAL OF BYLAWS - HILLVIEW ROAD LANDFILL
CITIZENS ADVISORY COMMITTEE
217
August 10, 1993
Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, That
the bylaws of the Hillview Road Landfill Citizens Advisory Committee be and hereby are approved,
RESOLVED, further, That said bylaws be filed with the Clerk of the Board of Representatives.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 232 - AUTHORIZATION TO ACCEPT GRANTS, CONTRACT WITH THE
NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL SERVICES AND
CREATE POSITIONS - DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL SERVICES
Moved by Mrs. Livesay, seconded by Mr. Evans. Mr. Proto expressed concern for State funding
to continue following the grant period. Mr. Heyman stated that the foster care cottages have saved the
County a great sum of money. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 13, Noes - 0. Excused - 2
(Representatives Joseph and Mink). Adopted.
WHEREAS, the Department of Social Services submitted proposals to New York State
Department of Social Services to fund planning and implementation activities of an intensive home-based
family preservation program and a therapeutic foster boarding home program, and
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County proposals have been accepted and funded at the levels of
$85,108 and $26,962 respectively, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Human Services and Budget and Administration
Committees, That the County Administrator, or his designee, execute a contract with the New York State
Department of Social Services and accept funds totaling $112,070;
RESOLVED, further, That the following positions be created effective September 1, 1993:
One (1) full-time Case Supervisor (16/594) labor grade 16 (P), competitive class
Three (3) full-time Senior Caseworker (15/581) labor grade 15 (0), competitive class
One (1) full-time Youth Care Worker (09/657) labor grade 9 (I), competitive class
One (1) full-time Keyboard Specialist (05/507) labor grade 5 (E), competitive class
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller be and hereby is authorized and directed to make the
following adjustments to his books for 1993:
BUDGET ADJUSTMENT
Revenue: 6010.3610 State Aid $75,973
Appropriation: A6010.1594 Case Supervisor $10,384
.1581 Senior Caseworker 28,320
.1657 Youth Care Worker 6,506
.1507 Keyboard Specialist 5,302
.2206 Computer Equipment 1,975
.2211 Chairs 750
.2212 Desks, Bookcases 1,938
.2213 File Cabinets 266
.2220 Telephones 456
.2230 Software 163
.2231 Vehicles (lease) 2,880
.4302 Supplies 450
.4306 Automobile Supplies 340
.4332 Books and Publications 170
.4424 Equipment Rental 150
.4442 Professional Services 500
218
August 10, 1993
.4466 Job Related Training 400
.8810 Retirement 1,768
.8830 Social Security 3,637
.8840 Workers Compensation 465
.8860 Health Insurance 8,850
.8870 UM 303
Total $75,973
RESOLVED, further, That at the end of the period of the grant this program will continue as long
as total State and Federal funding total 75 percent.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 233 - CITY/COUNTY CONSOLIDATION OF HUMAN SERVICES
FUNDING
Moved by Mrs. Livesay, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, by contract between the City of Ithaca and the County of Tompkins dated March 18,
1993, it was agreed, among other things, that the City would support proposed State legislation
authorizing the County to charge an additional one percent sales tax and that a joint committee would be
established to specify methods to human service agencies may be consolidated and costs allocated more
equitably, and
WHEREAS, meetings between representatives of the City and the County have occurred, and
WHEREAS, the City and the County wish, at this time, to amend and clarify the agreement of
March 18, 1993, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Human Services Committee, That the County
Administrator is directed to execute an agreement with the City of Ithaca providing for a decrease in the
amount of sales tax proceeds to be remitted to the City by the County, and a corresponding increase in
the amount of authorized funding for health and human service agencies through the Human Services
Coalition review process.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 234 - AUTHORIZING CONTRACT WITH SERVRITE FOR PROVISION
OF RESTAURANT/BAR, GIFT SHOP AND VENDING MACHINE
SERVICES - TOMPKINS COUNTY AIRPORT
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Mason, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, a request for proposals (RFP) for the provision of combined Restaurant/Bar, Gift
Shop and Vending Machine Services at the Tompkins County Airport has been duly advertised and one
responsible proposal was timely received, and
WHEREAS, a public hearing was duly advertised and held this 13th day of July, 1993, and all
persons wishing to address the Board on this subject have had the opportunity to do so, now therefore be
it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That a contract be signed with SERVRITE and the County Administrator be and hereby is authorized and
219
August 10, 1993
directed to sign said contract with SERVRITE for a period of ten (10) years, commencing from the
opening date of the new terminal.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 235 - RESCINDING RESOLUTION NO. 199 OF 1993 - PAVING
AUTHORIZATION
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Proto. Mr. Winch reported on the recent lawsuit filed by
Mr. Shotlz of Saratoga County. Mr. Winch reported that a restraining order placed on bonding CHIPS
funds has been reversed. He stated that Tompkins County has been told that it appears these funds will
be received but not as timely as had been expected. Mr. Mobbs, Public Works Commissioner, reported
on a letter received from Wilson Moore, Director of the CHIPS program at the New York State
Department of Transportation, which stated that they remain confident that they will prevail in appellate
court.
Following discussion on the impact the loss of these funds would have on other County
Departments, it was Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Culligan, to amend the resolution and add the
following RESOLVED: RESOLVED, further, That it is not the intention of this Board to require other
County departments to make up for any revenue shortfall this resolution might create. A voice vote on
the amendment resulted as follows: Ayes 12, Noes - 1 (Representative Mason), Excused - 2
(Representatives Joseph and Mink). Motion Carried. A voice vote on the resolution as amended resulted
as follows: Ayes 12, Noes - 1 (Representative Lerner), Excused - 2 (Representatives Joseph and Mink).
Adopted.
WHEREAS, Resolution No. 199 dated July 13, 1993 instructed the Highway Department to cease
operations after expending $250,000 in anticipated CHIPS funds, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management and Budget
and Administration Committees, That Resolution No. 199 of 1993 be rescinded effective immediately,
RESOLVED, further, That it is not the intention of this Board to require other County departments
to make up for any revenue shortfall this resolution might create.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE 11
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 236 - AUTHORIZATION TO AWARD CONTRACTS - CRASH, FIRE,
RESCUE (CFR) EXPANSION
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, Tompkins County authorized to establish a budget for the CFR Expansion on July 13,
1993 by Resolution No. 198 as follows:
TOTAL BUDGET 429,855
FAA Share 386,869
State Share 21,498
Local Share (PFC's) 21,493
, and
WHEREAS, bids were received, publicly opened and read on July 23, 1993, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on the recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management
Committee, That the bids for the CFR Expansion be awarded as follows, subject to agreement by the
220
August 10, 1993
Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) and the New York State Department of Transportation
(NYSDOT) and also subject to funding commitments being received from the FAA and NYSDOT:
General Construction 284,828
Streeter Associates
Elmira, New York
HVAC 77,800
United Plumbing and Heating
Binghamton, New York
Plumbing 30,400
United Plumbing and Heating
Binghamton, New York
Electric 14,600
Ferguson Electric
Ithaca, New York
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator is hereby authorized to execute contracts
with these firms to implement these bids,
RESOLVED, further, That any remaining budgeted funds of $27,083 be allocated for
miscellaneous project expenses, staff services, construction testing and change orders,
• RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator is authorized to execute change orders for up
to ten (10) percent of the contract totals,
RESOLVED, further, That the County of Tompkins has completed the SEQR reports finding this
project to have no significant impacts and a negative declaration has been filed,
RESOLVED, further, That a portion of the work contracted to Streeter Associates ($4,856) will be
funded by insurance as it relates to a repair project on the CFR rather than the CFR expansion.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
(NEGATIVE DECLARATION ON FILE)
RESOLUTION NO. 237 - AWARD OF BID - MULTI-USER FLIGHT INFORMATION
DISPLAY SYSTEM (MUFIDS)
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, the Division of Purchasing and Central Services has duly advertised for bids for
Multi -User Flight Information Display System (MUFIDS), and
WHEREAS, two (2) bids were received and duly opened July 16, 1993, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the bid be awarded to International Display Systems, Inc. of Dayton, Ohio as the lowest responsible
bidder with a base bid of $20,000, and
RESOLVED, further, That a contingency of $5,000 be added to allow for a surge protector, a
maintenance modem, and other equipment that may be necessary to set the system up,
RESOLVED, further, That all funds for said project are available in Account No. HU5610.9239.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 238 - RENTAL FEES FOR NEW T -HANGARS - TOMPKINS COUNTY
AIRPORT
221
August 10, 1993
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Shurtleff. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 12,
Noes - 1 (Representative Proto), Excused - 2 (Representatives Joseph and Mink). Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the rates for the new T -Hangars at Tompkins County Airport are as follows, and will become
effective on the first of the month following beneficial occupancy of said hangars:
Standard T -Hangar $165.00 (Including Utilities Estimate*)
T -Hangar with Storage Area $200.00 (Including Utilities Estimate*)
*There is an estimate of $20.00 to cover the cost of utilities (electricity and water). The County
reserves the right to make an annual adjustment to reflect the cost of providing these services. Provision
has been made to allow for telephone service hook-up but this will have to be arranged by the tenants at
their cost.
RESOLVED, further, That in order to allow for inflation, the rates will be adjusted on the first of
September every year by an amount equal to the percentage change in the Consumer Price Index (CPI)
used by the County for all cities, but in any event the rental fee will be no less than for the previous
twelve month period.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 239 - SHORT-TERM AND LONG-TERM PARKING RATES NEW
TERMINAL - TOMPKINS COUNTY AIRPORT
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Stein, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the rates for the new terminal's short-term and long-term parking lots at Tompkins County Airport
are detailed as follows and will become effective upon beneficial occupancy of the new terminal site:
PROPOSED NEW TERMINAL PARKING RATES
TIME SHORT-TERM LONG-TERM
0 - 1/2 HOUR $ .50 $1.00
1/2 - 1 HOUR $1.00 $1.00
1 - 2 HOURS $2.00 $2.00
2 - 3 HOURS $3.00 $3.00
3 - 4 HOURS $4.00 $4.00
4 - 5 HOURS $5.00 $5.00 (MAX. PER DAY)
5 - 6 HOURS $6.00
6 - 7 HOURS $7.00 (MAX. PER DAY)
MAXIMUM PER WEEK: SHORT-TERM $35.00
LONG-TERM $25.00
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 240 - TOMPKINS COUNTY GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION SYSTEM
(GIS)
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
222
August 10, 1993
WHEREAS, Tompkins County, several municipalities, private institutions, and public
corporations are developing Geographic Information Systems (GIS), and
WHEREAS, significant cost, time, and other resource savings can be realized with a coordinated
approach, and
WHEREAS, the technical, fiscal, and public policy interests need to be coordinated, now therefore
be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Capital Program Committee, That the Board of
Representatives take the lead in establishing a cooperative approach to Geographic Information Systems
in Tompkins County,
RESOLVED, further, That a committee or committees, comprised of technical and lay persons, be
established by the Chairman of the Board to (1) conduct a needs assessment, (2) evaluate computer
equipment and technology for its ability to meet the long range interests in Tompkins County, (3)
consider data provision and maintenance issues, and (4) address other technical, financial and
jurisdictional GIS issues.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE 11
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
On motion of the appropriate committee chairmen and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by
voice vote by members present, the following appointments were made to various advisory boards:
Family Court Advisory Council
Term expires December 31, 1994
Andra Benson - Youth Board representative
Human Rights Commission
Term expires December 31, 1994
Marion Kossack
Term expires December 31, 1995
Anthony A. Poole
Library Board of Trustees
Term expires December 31, 1993
Donald Schnedeker
On motion, the meeting adjourned at 9:50 p.m.
223
September 7, 1993
Regular Meeting
Chairman Watros called the meeting to order at 5:30 p.m.
Members and guests participated in the Pledge of Allegiance.
Present: 14 Representatives. Excused: 1 (Representative Shurtleff).
It was Moved by Mrs. Livesay, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to approve the minutes of July 13, 1993 as submitted.
Under privilege of the floor, Mel Bartlett, Interlaken, New York, spoke in opposition to the
resolution on the agenda entitled Award of Bid - Department of Social Services Furniture. Mr. Bartlett
stated that he believes the bid proposed is irresponsible and does not adhere to Federal regulations. Mr.
Bartlett stated that he feels he is being discriminated against because of his wife, Yvonne Bartlett, suffers
from sick building syndrome, allegedly caused from the Biggs building.
Under privilege of the floor, James Ellis, Department of Social Services employee, stated that trust
needs to be established between the administrators and employees. He expressed frustration at the lack
of progress with preparing a safe work space for the employees to return to work. Mr. Ellis asked that
the County make every attempt to aid them in their medical treatment and to come to a solution to this
problem.
Under privilege of the floor, Margaret Marks, Department of Social Services employee, spoke of
progress that has been made since March. Ms. Marks spoke of financial difficulties and asked the Board
torecommend worker's compensation be granted to employees with an understanding that if later it were
decided that it was not the building that made them sick, they would repay any compensation benefits
received. Ms. Marks stated that she was not notified of the County picnic.
Under privilege of the floor, Yvonne Bartlett, Department of Social Services employee, asked for
the status of water testing that was done in the Biggs building. Mrs. Bartlett also spoke of financial
difficulties and asked that the County pay health insurance premiums for those employees suffering from
sick building syndrome. Mrs. Bartlett also commented on services provided by Tompkins Community
Hospital and stated that she feels mistreated by the Hospital also.
Under privilege of the floor, Chrissy Dawson, daughter of Yvonne Bartlett who is a Department of
Social Services employee, stated that because of financial difficulties, she has not been able to receive
new clothing for this school season.
Under privilege of the floor, Eric Lerner, Representative, District No. 1, stated that he has heard
the County has controverted some or all of the worker's compensation cases for those employees out of
work from the -Biggs building, and would like to know on what basis they were controverted.
Anita Fitzpatrick, Commissioner of Personnel, stated that an area known as the "B wing" has been
renovated and that correspondence was sent to employees who are out ill on August 30. The letter
concluded with an invitation to employees to schedule a meeting or contact her or raise any objections
and no response has been received to date. A follow-up letter was sent September 3 which included an
update and stated that the air purifier units had arrived and had been installed and that air quality testing
was scheduled for September 7. Those results are not yet available. She stated that another meeting has
been scheduled for September 16 at 10 a.m. in the Health Depai lnient conference room. Ms. Fitzpatrick
stated that physicians of employees have also received correspondence and said that a part of the process
in returning employees to work would be approval by their physicians.
224
September 7, 1993
Mr. Proto, Chairman, Health and Education Committee, stated that committee business is reflected
on the agenda. He stated that there will be a proposal presented to the committee next month on HIV
counseling and procedure. Mr. Proto reported that the Health Department received approval for its 1992
and 1993 application for services. He also reported that last quarter reimbursement for the Health
Department from the State for 1992 has been received. Mr. Proto also reported on a shortfall in the
Alcoholism Council's budget as a result of the State changing guidelines.
Mr. Evans, Chairman, Personnel Committee, reported that the committee met September 2. He
reported that the Freedom of Speech policy will be dealt with by a subcommittee of the Employee
Council, three Department Heads, the County Attorney and County Administrator. The first meeting will
be September 9 at 3:30 p.m. He reported that a letter has been received by the CSEA proposing some
tentative dates to begin contract negotiations. The next committee meeting will be September 30 at 8
a.m.
Ms. Mink, Chair, Human Services Committee, reported that the committee met this morning. She
stated that the resolution on the agenda entitled Award of Bid - Department of Social Services Furniture
has been handled exclusively by Purchasing to avoid any conflict of interest with the Depai tment of
Social Services situation. She stated that the committee had a lengthy discussion with the Human Rights
Commissioner on funding for the Multicultural Resource Center. She stated that budget hearings will be
held the first part of October and will be notifying committee members and dep.' huent heads. Ms. Mink
reported on literature that is circulating on a Ku Klux Klan white power march that is scheduled for
September 25 in Auburn. She stated that this is troubling and something that everyone should be aware
of. Mr. Lerner expressed outrage at this march. Mr. Joseph, Human Rights Commission Liaison, invited
and encouraged the attendance of Board members at the annual Commission dinner and awards
ceremony.
Mr. Mason, Chairman, Public Safety Committee, reported that the committee continued discussion
on an administrative aide position in the Sheriffs Department. He stated that the committee heard a
semi-annual update on the Assigned Counsel Program with figures that seemed to be on target. He stated
that the committee met with Judith VanAllen who is asking that the enhanced bail fund program be
renewed in 1994. He stated that the program is well justified. Mr. Mason also reported that the
committee had a discussion with Andrew Mazzella of the Finger Lakes State Park Commission
concerning the tower site on Connecticut Hill which the County uses for its emergency radio
transmission. He stated that the committee approved budget adjustments in the amounts of $36,000 and
$25,000 to be added to the Computer Aided Dispatch System. Mrs. Schuler reported that the Finger
Lakes Runners Club will be having a race on September 19 and is sponsored in part by the STOP -DWI
program.
Mr. Culligan, Representative, District No. 2, stated that two members of his family had recently
been aided by emergency personnel. He expressed his appreciation for the communication network of
emergency services in Tompkins County. He stated that although Tompkins County does not have 911 at
the present time, he feels that Tompkins County has the next best thing.
Mr. Stein, Chairman, Planning Committee, reported that the committee met on August 25 and had
a presentation about the proposed BID (Business Improvement District) for the City of Ithaca. The next
step is a presentation to the Budget and Administration Committee. They will be asking the County, as a
major property owner in the area, for financial participation. Mr. Stein reported that the committee heard
a progress report on long range planning from James Hanson, Planning Commissioner. The next
committee meeting will be September 14 in the Board Room.
Mr. Winch, Chairman, Public Works and Construction Management Committee, updated the
Board on the status of the Buffalo Hill Road Bridge stating that the Bridge reopened today and that there
225
September 7, 1993
are three homes that are still without their own water. He stated that the third public information meeting
for area residents will be held September 9. Mr. Winch reported on the status of construction of the new
Airport Terminal and stated that the project is on schedule. He stated that the bridge on Blackman Hill
Road in Town of Caroline has been closed after inspection by the State. He stated that the bridge was
originally built in 1915 and is co -owned by Tompkins and Tioga Counties. The bridge is scheduled for
repairs in 1994. Mr. Winch stated that the Public Works Department in conjunction with the Town of
Ithaca Public Works Department is making repairs to the Forest Home Footbridge.
Mr. Todd, Chairman, Fiscal Affairs Committee, reported that the committee met on August 21 and
had a presentation from Scott Heyman, County Administrator and Nancy Zahler, Youth Bureau Director,
about a leadership council to improve county government. A special meeting to discuss this item will be
held September 15. The next regular committee meeting will be September 29. Mr. Todd reported that
he has been attending, along with Mr. Stein, Ithaca Tompkins Transit meetings to discuss the
consolidation of transportation services and that progress is being made at a reasonable pace. Chairman
Watros stated that what the County is focusing on now is public perception of a single integrated
transportation system.
Mr. Lerner, Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, reported that the
subcommittee working on revisions to the Solid Waste Management Plan met today and are proceeding
on schedule. He stated that there will be a resolution on the agenda with regard to changes in the design
of the Tompkins County Recycling and Solid Waste Center. He stated that basically, the design has been
made smaller, therefore, the environmental impact made smaller. The resolution being proposed
accommodates those changes. Mr. Lerner reported that the County has received, although slightly
conditional, final approval for the site plan review for the Recycling and Solid Waste Center from the
City of Ithaca.
Mrs. Livesay, Intergovernmental Representative, stated that the County will be looking into the
possibility of pulling together a county -wide cable commission to help municipalities. She stated that she
recently spoke with Martin Luster, New York State Assemblyman, who thinks there may soon be some
action taken on the proposed Medicaid takeover during the legislative session which may be called in
October or November. Chairman Watros encouraged Board members to communicate from
municipalities within their districts to get input on assistance in negotiating franchise agreements with
the cable industry.
Mrs. Call, Chair, Budget and Administration Committee, reported that departmental budget are
due September 15. The next committee meeting will be September 14.
Mr. Heyman, County Administrator, reported that he heard from the State Department of Taxation
and Finance and will be forwarding a resolution to the September 21 Board agenda to enact eight percent
sales tax.
Cheryl Nelson, Chair, Employee Council, reported that the Council met September 1 and she has
been reelected Chair of the Council. Other officers include: Vice Chair - Pat Nowakowski, Secretary -
Leighann Baldwin, Executive Committee - Hiroshi Takashima and Barbara Karaviotis. She reported that
the County Administrator will soon meet with Employee Council representatives who will make up part
of the committee reviewing the Free Speech Policy. She stated that a list of all County conference
rooms, contact person and phone number is being prepared by the Council for distribution.
Mr. Mulvey, County Attorney, stated that the monthly report on activities in the County Attorney's
office has been distributed.
226
September 7, 1993
Mr. Lerner, Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, distributed a packet of
information entitled Outline of Solid Waste Finance Issues. He stated that in his presentation, he would
be explaining what decisions the Solid Waste Finance Committee has reached for financing solid waste
in 1994. Mr. Lerner stated that there have been efforts to cut costs in the Solid Waste Division but there
are severe limits on where the budget can be cut. After all efforts have been made for waste reduction,
composting and recycling, there would still be a budget of almost $7 million. He stated that 90 percent
of the solid waste budget is driven by environmental laws and the State government which the County
has to comply with. There are six major areas of what would be desirable in the finance system:
stability, environmental protection, fairness, easy implementation, easy enforcement and low cost. It is
impossible to have all of these at the same time but the County has to do the best it can. He stated that
alternatives for solid waste finance have both advantages and disadvantages and that the challenge is how
to mix and match them intelligently. He stated that no one likes a property tax increase and it has the
major drawback of not taxing the not-for-profit entities. Mr. Lerner stated the tipping fee is currently set
at $95 per ton. In 1992, the County raised it to $145 per ton which resulted in the problem of flow
control. Finally, the Annual Solid Waste Fee was adopted in an attempt to avoid the not-for-profit
exemption and in an attempt to reduce the cost for the typical homeowner but has produced some
unfairness and also a duplicate administrative process. He believes that in the long run it would be
desirable to eliminate the Annual Solid Waste Fee. He thinks that the County may be able to cut the Fee
in half in 1994 and possibly eliminate it altogether in 1995. He stated that another tool could be a direct
fee for recycling. Mr. Lerner referred to page d-1 in the packet describing financing options for 1994:
Option No. 1 includes a $150 tipping fee, no Annual Fee and a 6.5 percent property tax increase; Option
No. 2 includes a $105 tipping fee, $24 Annual Fee and a 6.5 percent increase in property tax; Option No.
3 includes a $100 tipping fee, a $47 Annual Fee and a zero percent property tax increase for 1994. Mr.
Lerner stated that he supports Option No. 2 and explained his reasons for supporting this option and said
it is his belief that 1994 will be a transitional year because the Recycling and Solid Waste Center will not
yet be open. He stated that the County will have more options once the Center is on line in 1995. Mr.
Todd stated that he endorses Option No. 3 and stated that he thinks the Annual Fee is a user fee and
although the public doesn't like it, they have begun to understand it. The difference between Option No.
2 and Option No. 3 is that there is no property tax increase in Option No. 3 but a higher Annual Fee. Mr.
Todd stated he feels that putting a fee on recycling takes away the incentive to recycle. Mr. Todd also
stated that he feels that tax exempt entities should continue to pay their fair share and that 1995 options
will be open regardless of selection of No. 2 or 3. There was discussion concerning the possibility of
instituting an annual fee for recycling at some point in the future.
Following discussion, Mr. Lerner thanked the Board for their comments and for their seriousness
in approaching this issue.
Chairman Watros declared recess at 7:58 p.m. The meeting reconvened at 8:04 p.m.
It was Moved by Mr. Evans, seconded by Mrs. Call, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to enter into executive session at 8:04 p.m. to discuss litigation, personnel matters and
negotiations with the Deputy Sheriffs' Association.
An executive session was held from 8:04 p.m. to 9:12 p.m.
It was Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Winch, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to add to the agenda the resolution entitled Authorization to Execute Purchase
Agreement and Deed - Town of Enfield.
Chairman Watros gave Ms. Mink, Chair, Human Services Committee, permission to withdraw
from the agenda the resolution entitled Award of Bid - Department of Social Services Furniture.
227
September 7, 1993
Chairman Watros gave the appropriate committee chairman permission to withdraw from the
agenda the following resolutions with final committee action being affirmed:
CA085-93 - Award of Bid - Filters
CA086-93 - Authorization to Execute Agreement - Towns - Snow and Ice
RESOLUTION NO. 241 - RESOLUTION AUTHORIZING A SEQRA DETERMINATION OF
SIGNIFICANCE, FILING OF A NEGATIVE DECLARATION AND
FILING OF AN APPLICATION TO MODIFY THE 1992 DEC PART
360 PERMIT FOR THE RECYCLING AND SOLID WASTE
CENTER
Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, this Board of Representatives by Resolution No. 408 dated December 18, 1989
authorized the filing of a State Environmental Quality Review Act ("SEQRA") Notice of Completion of a
Final Environmental Impact Statement for the Central Processing Facility ("CPF"), now known as the
Recycling and Solid Waste Center which is located on Commercial Avenue in the City of Ithaca, New
York, with a Notice of Completion promulgated thereafter according to law, and
WHEREAS, said Recycling and Solid Waste Center was to include a transfer station including
baling of solid waste for transfer to a proposed sanitary landfill known as Site 31 in the Town of Dryden,
New York and further to include a recycling facility to implement county -wide mandatory recycling, and
WHEREAS, this Board of Representatives by Resolution No. 439 dated December 28, 1989
authorized acceptance and filing of a SEQRA Findings Statement for the Recycling and Solid Waste
Center which was thereafter promulgated according to law, and
WHEREAS, the aforesaid Resolution No. 439 further authorized the filing of an application for a
permit to construct and operate said Recycling and Solid Waste Center with the Department of
Environmental Conservation ("DEC") pursuant to 6 NYCRR Part 360, and
WHEREAS, a DEC permit (No. 7-5007-00032/00001-0) (the "Permit") was issued on April 1,
1991 for a term of ten years, and
WHEREAS, changes have occurred in the County program for waste management, including,
among others, the abandonment of the effort to obtain a DEC Part 360 Permit to construct and operate a
proposed sanitary landfill at Site 31, the closure of the Hillview Road Landfill in May, 1992 and the
resultant export of solid waste from an interim transfer station constructed at the Hillview Road Landfill
which necessitated changes to the Recycling and Solid Waste Center, and
WHEREAS, this Board of Representatives by Resolution No. 505 dated December 17, 1991
authorized a final request for proposals pursuant to General Municipal Law ("GML") Section 120-w for
the design, construction, acceptance testing, and operation of the Recycling and Solid Waste Center, and
WHEREAS, this Board of Representatives by Resolution No. 348 dated October 27, 1992
designated preferred proposers for negotiations and authorized negotiations for a service agreement
pursuant to GML Section 120-w, and
WHEREAS, this Board of Representatives by Resolution No. 189 dated July 13, 1993 awarded a
contract to Container Recovery Inc. (CR Inc.) conditioned upon compliance by the County with SEQRA
for the design, construction, acceptance testing and operation of the Recycling and Solid Waste Center to
CR Inc. which provided, among other things, for downsizing the proposed facility, elimination of the
baling function for solid waste and other changes which would necessitate the filing of an application for
a modification of the Permit pursuant to the Uniform Procedures (6 NYCRR Section 621.13 and Section
621.14) and requires compliance with SEQRA (6 NYCRR Part 617), and
WHEREAS, this Board of Representatives has reviewed a SEQRA Full Environmental
Assessment Form ("FEAF") for the proposed modifications to the Recycling and Solid Waste Center and
a DEC application for a permit modification for said center, and
228
September 7, 1993
WHEREAS, both the FEAF and the application for a permit modification principally address
those changes to the proposal from the previously permitted project by DEC in 1991 following
conclusion of an environmental assessment pursuant to SEQRA filing of findings in 1989, now therefore
be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, That
the action of approving and executing a contract with CR Inc. as described in Resolution No. 93-189
contingent upon SEQRA compliance, and, the action so described in the FEAF which includes the
modification of the Permit for the Recycling and Solid Waste Center to downsize the facility, provide for
private operation thereof and other described changes will not have a significant effect on the
environment and an environmental impact statement need not be prepared,
RESOLVED, further, That the Chairman of the Board of Representatives is hereby authorized on
behalf of the County to file the Negative Declaration dated 1993 as presented to this Board of
Representatives with this Resolution according to law,
RESOLVED, further, That the Chairman of the Board of Representatives is authorized to take any
other lawful action to further the intent hereof, and this Resolution shall take effect upon its acceptance.
SEQR ACTION: TYPE I OR UNLISTED
(DETERMINATION OR FINDINGS
INCLUDED HEREIN) PREVIOUS ACTION
RESOLUTION NO. 242 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE MULTI-YEAR CONTRACTS -
PCAP
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County Health Department has contracts for medical services,
including laboratory, radiology and physician services for PCAP, with various providers, and
WHEREAS, providers and services required do not change drastically from year to year and
addendums are sufficient to handle most changes, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education Committee, That the County
Administrator is authorized to execute contracts with all eligible PCAP providers for a period of five
years, commencing January 1, 1994 and ending December 31, 1999.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 243 - AUTHORIZING CHANGE IN ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH FEES -
1994
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County Board of Health has recommended that the following schedule
of fees charged by the Environmental Health Division be adopted, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education Committee, That the following
schedule of fees is hereby approved for the Health Department to charge for the provision of
Environmental Health permits and services commencing January 1, 1994,
OPERATING OR PERMIT FEES
Food Service Establishments
229
1993 Fee 1/94 Fee
September 7, 1993
High and Medium Risk
Low Risk
Temporary Food Service Establishment
Frozen Desserts
Temporary Residences and Mobile Home Parks
Children's Camps
Swimming Pools/Bathing Beaches
Mass Gatherings (per event day)
$ 120.00
65.00
30.00
25.00
$30+$3 per lot/unit
$ 100.00
$ 150.00
$2000.00
Community Water Systems (with sources) (Part 5, NYSSC)
Up to 25 population
26 to 50
51 to 500
501 to 1000
1000 to 5000
over 5000
Bottled/Bulk Haulers, Ice Plants
$ 35.00
50.00
75.00
225.00
300.00
400.00
150.00
Non -Community Water Systems (with sources) $ 50.00
(Part 5, NYSSC)
Local Public Water System (TCSC) $ 35.00
Sewage Construction Permits (New Construction and Conversions)
Under 1000 gallons per day design
1000 or more gallons per day design
$ 125.00
200.00
Refuse Haulers $ 50.00
+ $10/vehicle
Fee for application received late: $25; Consecutive Lateness: $50.
Note: Fees are additive for all facilities.
$ 120.00
55.00
30.00
25.00
$30+$3 per lot/unit
$ 100.00
$ 150.00
$2000.00
$ 35.00
50.00
75.00
225.00
300.00
400.00
150.00
$ 50.00
$ 35.00
$ 130.00
200.00
no permit
required
Operation permits are generally issued on an annual basis; however, if a multi-year permit is
issued, a 10% reduction of the total fee will be allowed.
PLAN REVIEW FEES
(New Construction or Where Engineering Plans Required)
Food Service Establishments
High and Medium Risk
Low Risk
Mobile Unit
Development Plan Review
(Temporary Residence, MHP,
and Apai li,ient Complex)
(Realty Subdivisions)
1993 Fee
$ 150.00
75.00
50.00
$100 plus $10
per lot/unit
$100 plus $25
per lot
Preliminary Development Review (Where soil testing is required)
$ 150 plus
230
1994 Fee
$ 150.00
75.00
50.00
$100 plus $10
per lot/unit
$100 plus $25
per lot
$ 150 plus
September 7, 1993
Swimming Pools/Bathing Beaches
Up to 5000 square feet
Over 5000 square feet, slide pools, wave pools
Community Water Systems (Part 5, NYSSC)
New source
Distribution (water main)
Cross -Connection Controls -
2" and less, each
over 2", each
$15 per acre $15 per acre
$ 100.00
$ 150.00
$ 75.00
$ 25 plus
$ 10/1,000'
or portion
$ 100.00
$ 150.00
$ 75.00
$ 25 plus
$ 10 each K'
$ 25.00 $ 25.00
50.00 50.00
Non -Community and Local Public Water Systems $ 50.00 $ 50.00
Collector Sewers
DEC Projects and
Health Dept. Projects
Environmental Impact Statement Review
(Where TCHD is Lead Agency)
OTHER
Copies (Cost per page)
Waiver/Variance Request
(Requiring Board of Health action)
Sanitary Codes
$25 + $10/1,000'
or portion
$25 + $10 each K'
As allowed As allowed
by 6NYCRR 617.17 by 6NYCCR 617.17
$ .25
$ .25
25.00 25.00
1.00 1.00
Water Monitoring Sampling
- No exemptions $5.00 + sample cost $5.00 + sample cost
Note: Review fees are additive.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION REQUIRED)
RESOLUTION NO. 244 - APPROVAL OF THE AMENDMENTS TO THE ENVIRONMENTAL
MANAGEMENT COUNCIL BYLAWS
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, the Environmental Management Council (EMC) has found it necessary to amend its
bylaws to reflect structural changes in its organization, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the bylaws of the EMC, dated
March 23, 1993, be approved as amended,
RESOLVED, further, That a copy of the bylaws be filed with the Clerk of the Board of
Representatives.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
231
September 7, 1993
RESOLUTION NO. 245 - AUTHORIZATION OF TOMPKINS COUNTY PLANNING
DEPARTMENT TO ISSUE A CONTRACT - ALLOW LIMITED
TREE CUTTING ON COUNTY FOREST LAND
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Ms. Mink, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County Planning Depai intent (TCPD) has been approached by a local
citizen to cut trees on County forest land, and
WHEREAS, the TCPD has determined that the proposed method of harvest (by hand), and
proposed extent of harvest (area of 21 acres; max. cutting of 200 dead spruce trees; max, tree diameter at
base of 4 inches) will be beneficial to the County forest, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the TCPD be authorized to
issue a contract to Tim Resler, of Ithaca, New York, for a period of one year, commencing on September
10, 1993.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 246 - SOLID WASTE OFFICE/ENTRY TERMINATION OF GENERAL
CONSTRUCTION CONTRACT
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Todd, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the County Administrator is hereby authorized to terminate the contract with Morlando
Construction Enterprises, Inc.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE 11
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY
RESOLUTION NO. 247 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE A GRANT AGREEMENT WITH
THE FEDERAL AVIATION ADMINISTRATION (FAA) FOR AN
EXTENSION TO THE CRASH, FIRE, RESCUE (CFR) BUILDING -
TOMPKINS COUNTY AIRPORT
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, the County has received a grant offer from the Federal Aviation Administration
(FAA) in the amount of $386,869 towards the cost of the Crash, Fire, Rescue (CFR) Building Extension,
and
WHEREAS, the budget for said project is as follows:
FAA Share (90%) Account No. 5698.4592 $386,869.00
NYSDOT (5%) Account No. 5698.3592 21,492.50
PFC's (5%) Account No. 5698.5031 21,492.50
Total Account No. 5698.9213 $429,854.00
232
September 7, 1993
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the FAA grant offer in the amount of $386,869 be and hereby is accepted and that the County
Administrator is authorized to execute the required documents.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 248 - AMENDMENT OF RESOLUTION NO. 239 OF 1991 -
ESTABLISHING HIGHWAY PERMIT FEES
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Culligan, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, Resolution No. 239 of 1991 established Highway Permit fees and directed the
County Superintendent of Highways to charge fees, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That Resolution 239 of 1991 be amended as follows:
11. A. Private/Non-Commercial Driveway
Administrative Fee $25.00
Material (if required) $75.00
Signage (per assembly) (if required) $125.00
RESOLVED, further, That said amendment be effective September 15, 1993.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 249 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE PURCHASE AGREEMENT AND
DEED - TOWN OF ENFIELD
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Winch, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
RESOLVED, That the County Administrator is authorized and directed to execute a purchase
agreement and deed conveying Town of Enfield Tax Parcel No. 16-2-5 and 16-2-2.13 to Jack Allen of
1603 Mecklenburg Road, Ithaca, New York for the sum of five thousand seven hundred ($5,700) dollars,
with the appropriate commission to be paid for Patterson Real Estate according to the County's contract
with that organization.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
It was Moved by Mr. Joseph, seconded by Mr. Lerner, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to lift the following resolution from the Table.
RESOLUTION NO. 218 - URGING THE LABOR COMMISSIONER TO APPOINT A WAGE
BOARD
Moved by Mr. Joseph, seconded by Mr. Lerner, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, Section 653 of the New York State Labor Law provides that "The Commissioner
shall have power on his own motion to cause an investigation to be made of the wages being paid to
233
September 7, 1993
persons employed in any occupation or occupations to ascertain whether the minimum wages established
in accordance with the provisions of this article are sufficient to provide adequate maintenance and to
protect the health of the persons employed in such occupation or occupations. The Commissioner shall,
on the petition of fifty or more residents of the State engaged in or affected by an occupation or
occupations sought to be investigated, cause such an investigation of such occupation or occupations to
be conducted. If, on the basis of information in his possession with or without such an investigation, the
Commissioner is of the opinion that any substantial number of persons employed in any occupation or
occupations are receiving wages insufficient to provide adequate maintenance and to protect their health,
he shall appoint a wage board to inquire into and report and recommend adequate minimum wages and
regulations for employees in such occupation or occupations," and
WHEREAS, a petition meeting the requirements of this law has been delivered to the Labor
Commissioner, and
WHEREAS, the Commissioner, John Hudacs, has stated in a meeting with members of the
Campaign For a Liveable Minimum Wage, that he believes the minimum wage to be inadequate, now
therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the Tompkins County Board
of Representatives urges the Labor Commissioner to act promptly to appoint a wage board in compliance
with New York State Labor Law,
RESOLVED, further, That a copy of this resolution be forwarded to Labor Commissioner John
Hudacs and Governor Mario Cuomo, Assemblymen Martin Luster and Frank Babaro and State Senators
James Seward and John R. Kuhl, Jr.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
On motion of the appropriate committee chairman and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by
voice vote by members present, the following appointments were made to various advisory boards:
Hillview Road Landfill Citizens Advisory Committee
Term expires December 31, 1994
Joel Gagnon
Human Rights Commission
Term expires December 31, 1995
Fred A. Wilcox
Advisory Board on Indigent Representation
Term expires December 31, 1995 •
Emmanuel Cestero
On motion the meeting adjourned at 9:30 p.m.
234
September 21, 1993
Regular Meeting
Chairman Watros called the meeting to order at 5:30 p.m.
Members and guests participated in the Pledge of Allegiance.
Present: 15 Representatives. (Mr. Evans and Mr. Lerner arrived at 5:35 p.m.)
It was Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to approve the minutes of August 10, 1993 as submitted.
Chairman Watros presented a proclamation to Mr. Ed Tenario, Veterans Administration,
proclaiming the week of September 19, 1993 to be P.O.W./M.I.A. Recognition Week in Tompkins
County. Mr. Tenario accepted and thanked the Board for this proclamation on behalf of the veterans of
Tompkins County.
Under privilege of the floor, James Ellis, Department of Social Services employee, spoke
concerning air quality in the Biggs A building. Mr. Ellis stated that he believes the building does not
meet minimum air quality standards and should be closed.
Under privilege of the floor, Margaret Kirchgessner, Human Rights Commission employee, spoke
concerning air quality in the Biggs A building. Ms. Kirchgessner stated that the Biggs building has
approximately 375 people working in it daily and urged the Board to show leadership and resolve the
situation. She stated that she feels accommodations should be made to allow employees suffering from
multiple chemical sensitivities to work from home or create a satellite office.
Under privilege of the floor, Yvonne Bartlett, Department of Social Services employee, spoke
concerning air quality in the Biggs A building. She expressed continued frustration for what she believes
to be a lack of progress on returning employees to work. Ms. Bartlett stated that she has been in contact
with Karl Mount, Vice President of Tompkins Community Hospital, and is requesting that the hospital
not supply heat to the Biggs building. Ms. Bartlett also requested that employees who have been
diagnosed with multiple chemical sensitivities be added as members to the Indoor Air Quality Task
Force.
Under privilege of the floor, Mel Bartlett, Interlaken resident and husband of Yvonne Bartlett,
spoke in opposition to the proposed resolution to award a bid for Department of Social Services
furniture. Mr. Bartlett stated that if the proposed resolution is adopted by the Board he would appeal that
decision.
Under privilege of the floor, Sharon Prezioso McLaughlin, Depai intent of Social Services
employee, submitted a statement requesting relocation to a satellite office which would serve two
purposes: 1. Accommodate disabilities; and 2. Provide a central location as originally planned for
people unable to get to Biggs A. -
Under privilege of the floor, Ernest Bury, Valley Road, Ithaca, spoke concerning the closing of
Triangle Steel and suggested that the County use that location for a recycling center. Mr. Bury stated
that the location of that building is on a rail line and feels the Board should pursue this as a way of
transporting waste.
Under privilege of the floor, Eric Lerner, Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management
Committee, stated that there is a rail line near the Tompkins County Recycling and Solid Waste Center
on Commercial Avenue and if cost effective, the County would pursue that option.
235
September 21, 1993
Mr. Proto, Chairman, Health and Education Committee, reported that the Committee will meet on
September 30 and October 1 to review budgets. He stated that he received from Tompkins Cortland
Community College a schedule for long range planning. Mr. Proto reported that he attended a meeting of
the New York State Archives and Records Administration and stated that he would be assisting local
school districts and fire departments in applying for grants. He stated that Tompkins Community
Hospital with Tompkins Cortland Community College, will be providing a new paramedic training
program. He reported that Planned Parenthood has completed its analysis for the Prenatal Care
Assistance Program Report on Minorities and expects the report to be received by next week.
Mr. Evans, Chairman, Personnel Committee, reported that the Committee met this afternoon to
discuss the beginning of negotiations with CSEA. Negotiations are scheduled for September 24, 27, 28
and 30. The next regular Committee meeting will be September 30 at 8 a.m.
Ms. Mink, Chair, Human Services Committee, reported that the next Committee meeting will be
October 5 and that budget reviews will follow the regular Committee meeting. At this time, Ms. Mink
asked James Kazda, Senior Civil Engineer, Public Works Depai tiuent, to update the Board on
accommodations being made to return employees to work in the Biggs building.
James Kazda, Senior Civil Engineer, Public Works Department, reported on activities that have
taken place in order to make space available for employees out of work. Mr. Kazda updated the Board
on work being done to the building, including but not limited to: carpeting and adhesive has been
removed, ceilings, floor, windows and walls have been washed, air purifiers have been installed, and air
conditioning units have been cleaned and filters replaced. He also informed the Board that a state of the
art HVAC system is being installed in the building. Mr. Kazda spoke of a schedule referred to as the
master plan for implementing improvements at Biggs and other County buildings that was proposed
approximately a month ago and stated that they are still working from that but will need to update it as a
result of comments that were received late from Mr. Siwinski.
Mr. Stein asked Mr. Kazda if Mr. Siwinski has stated that air in the Biggs A building is not safe.
Mr. Kazda stated that "Mr. Siwinski has performed a survey of the employees within the Biggs complex
and that survey identifies that there is a trend of concern within the building, no where has Mr. Siwinski
made any recommendations for us to take any other actions than the actions that we have been taking.
We have been taking actions and we have to follow the protocols which have been established by many
state and national agencies. The protocols that we have been following are consistent with the way other
indoor air quality problems have been identified and have been followed and have been resolved. So, we
are following his guidelines as well as the guidelines of other agencies and he has not identified any need
to take action beyond that." Mr. Kazda referred to the fresh air ventilation standard and stated that he
would be researching code compliance further and will continue to report to the Board.
Mr. Mason, Chairman, Public Safety Committee, stated that the next Committee meeting will be
October 7 at noon at which there will be a brief regular Committee meeting followed by budget reviews.
Mr. Mason reported that he attended the New York State Association of Counties (NYSAC) 69th Annual
Fall Seminar. Mr. Mason reported that he visited the Onondaga County E911 Center and was very
impressed. Mr. Mason stated that he heard from representatives from correction and probation
departments throughout the State at the Conference and reported that twenty facilities are in the process
of expanding their facilities. He said that in 1989 jail populations were at 130 percent of capacity and in
1993 they are at 92 percent capacity. This may be one indication of why expected revenues were not
generated in the past year from boarding prisoners.
Mr. Stein, Chairman, Planning Committee, reported that the Committee met on September 14 and
that business is reflected on the agenda.
236
September 21, 1993
Mr. Winch, Chairman, Public Works and Construction Management Committee, reported that the
Committee met September 13 at the Biggs complex and members of the Committee were given a tour of
the building. Mr. Winch reported on the status of the Forest Home pedestrian bridge and stated that the
bridge is now open. He stated that the Buffalo Hill Road Bridge was open on time and that there are still
two homes experiencing trouble with water systems. He reported that staff of the Department of Public
Works continues to work to resolve this problem.
Mr. Todd, Chairman, Fiscal Affairs Committee, reported that the Committee met on September 15
to discuss a very preliminary program having to do with Total Quality Management. The next meeting
will be September 29.
Mr. Lerner, Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, reported that the
Committee met on September 9. They will meet again on October 28 to review Solid Waste budgets.
Mrs. Livesay, Intergovernmental Representative, reported that she is currently working on
negotiations with the Office of State Parks and has also been researching television cable in Tompkins
County.
Mrs. Call, Chairman, Budget and Administration Committee, reported that the Committee met
September 14 and heard a presentation from people from the City of Ithaca concerning the proposed
B.I.D. (Business Improvement District) and stated that there was not a positive vote to move it forward.
The Committee received a report from Sheila Ferrari, Director of Purchasing and Central Services, on
doing business with preferred sources. Mrs. Call reported that the Committee was updated by Kathy
West, Deputy County Administrator, on the status of payments that have been received for the Solid
Waste Annual Fee. She stated that the next Committee meeting will be October 12 at 5 p.m.
Mrs. Call made special mention of Jeff Vandermark, Department of Public Works employee, who
has by hand, polished the entire railing from the basement to the third floor of the Courthouse. He has
also begun work on the marble throughout the Courthouse. Mrs. Call stated Mr. Vandermark is an
employee who takes pride in his work. Mr. Winch, Chairman, Public Works and Construction
Management Committee, thanked Mrs. Call for her comments and stated that approximately a year and a
half ago, as Chairman of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee, he wrote a letter to
Mr. Vandermark complimenting him on his job performance and how well he maintains the Courthouse
and other County buildings. Other members of the Board also commended Mr. Vandermark on his work
and for being a dedicated employee.
Mr. Heyman, County Administrator, stated that proposed County departmental budget requests
have been placed on Board member's desks. Mr. Heyman reported that he also attended the 69th Annual
New York State Association of Counties Fall Seminar and moderated a panel on Total Quality
Management. Mr. Heyman stated that he is in the process of developing a services brochure which will
contain services information as well as the information provided in the roster prepared by the Clerk of the
Board and in the Local Government Directory prepared by the Planning Department.
Mr. Mulvey, County Attorney, reported that he will submit a list of all active assessment cases to
the Board office for review by Board members. Mr. Mulvey stated that he will ask for an executive
session to update the Board on the status of the Collins bankruptcy case.
On motion of the appropriate committee chairmen and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by
voice vote, the following resolutions were added to the agenda:
Award of Bid - Department of Social Services Furniture
237
September 21, 1993
Authorization to Execute Purchase Agreement and Deed, Town of Lansing Tax Parcel No. 7-1-
11.1 and 11.2
Authorization to File a Grant Application for ISTEA Funding of Newfield Covered Bridge
Preservation and Restoration Project and to enter into an Agreement with New York State
Department of Transportation for Acceptance of Project
Authorization to Settle Action - Usher vs. Mobbs
Chairman Watros gave Mrs. Call, Chair, Budget and Administration Committee, permission to
withdraw from the agenda the resolution entitled Establishing a Per -Ton Fee for Solid Waste in 1994.
On motion of the appropriate committee chairmen and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by
voice vote, the following resolutions were withdrawn from the agenda with final committee action being
affirmed:
CA087-93 - Acceptance of Funds, Authorization to Execute Contract, Budget Adjustment - "89-
313" Funds
CA088-93 - Authorization to Submit Grant Proposal - Healthy Heart
CA089-93 - Approval of Grant for Village of Dryden
CA090-93 - Award of Bid - Office Supplies
CA091-93 - Salary Adjustment - Personnel Department
CA092-93 - Reclassification of Position - County Attorney's Office
RESOLUTION NO. 250 - ESTABLISHING THE PER -TON FEE FOR SOLID WASTE FOR 1994
Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mr. Todd.
Mr. Lerner began discussion stating that the County has a Solid Waste program which has to be
funded in 1994 and included in that funding is a cost of $3 million to landfill waste. This amount does
not include recycling, composting or landfill closure. He stated that the passage of this resolution with
either a $100 or $105 tipping fee commits the Board to a small increase in the tipping fee, continuation of
the Annual Fee, continuing to plan for recycling fees and to no property tax increase going towards solid
waste in 1994. Mr. Lerner stated he feels committee members are all in agreement that the fairest way to
charge for solid waste is through a weight or volume based fee. He said the committee felt that the
tipping fee should be set at a conservative rate to avoid a higher rate of Flow Control and illegal dumping
violators.
Mr: Evans stated that he is prepared to support a higher tipping fee if the Annual Fee were to be
made more fair. Mr. Lerner stated that there has been a lot of complaints about the Solid Waste Annual
Fee and that by raising the tipping fee to $105 it would be possible to have more flexibility in adjusting
fees.
It was Moved by Mr. Joseph, seconded by Mrs. Call, to amend the tipping fee from $100 to $105.
Mr. Todd stated that he would support a tipping fee of $100 and stated that he feels that the higher
the tipping fee, the more of an incentive for haulers to violate Flow Control. He stated that preliminary
figures he has seen show that by raising the tipping fee to $100 there would be a modest reduction in the
Annual Fee.
Mr. Stein stated that he has been opposed to the Annual Fee and is inclined to raise the tipping fee
even higher.
238
September 21, 1993
It was Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mr. Proto, to amend the amendment to a $115 tipping
fee. Mr. Winch stated that he can not support a tipping fee this high because he feels illegal dumping
would increase. Mr. Evans stated that although he is not in favor of the Annual Fee, he feels the majority
of people are paying less than they would if it were on the property tax. Mr. Proto stated that he doesn't
think that raising the tipping fee to $115 will create that much of an adverse reaction and that there will
always be people who will dump illegally. Mr. Lerner stated that if a validation of flow control were
received by the Supreme Court, he would at that time look very seriously at raising the tipping fee. A
vote by show of hands on the motion to amend the amendment resulted as follows: Ayes - 3
(Representatives Evans, Proto and Stein), Noes - 12. Motion Lost.
A vote by show of hands on the amendment to raise the tipping fee to $105 resulted as follows:
Ayes - 10, Noes - 5 (Representatives Schuler, Stein, Shurtleff, Todd and Winch). Motion Carried.
It was Moved by Mr. Joseph, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, to delete the second RESOLVED. Mr.
Lerner stated that the Board should keep in mind that the county is already faced with at least a six
percent property tax increase for 1994. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 5 (Representatives
Joseph, Lerner, Mink, Schuler and Stein), Noes - 10. Motion Lost.
A roll call vote on the resolution as amended resulted as follows: Ayes - 10, Noes - 5
(Representatives Proto, Schuler, Shurtleff, Stein and Winch). Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, That
the per -ton fee for solid waste is hereby increased to $105 effective January 1, 1994,
RESOLVED, further, That it is not the intention of the Board to include any costs of the Solid
Waste or Recycling programs in those portions of the 1994 County budget that would require real
property tax funding,
RESOLVED, further, That this Board authorizes continued examination at the staff and
Committee level of service -based recycling fees not to be implemented before January 1, 1995.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 251 - APPROVAL OF ACCEPTANCE OF LOCAL INITIATIVE MONIES -
SIX MILE CREEK PROJECT (Adopted November 16, 1993)
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mrs. Schuler. Mr. Proto stated that all municipalities are not
informed of this and feels that a meeting of municipal representatives should take place prior to voting to
accept these funds and suggested that this be postponed indefinitely. Mr. Stein stated that he agrees with
Mr. Proto and feels the matter should be resolved before action is taken by this Board. Mrs. Livesay
stated that she would also like more information and Moved to Table this resolution to the October 5,
1993 Board meeting. Motion failed for lack of a second. It was Moved by Mr. Evans, seconded by Mrs.
Schuler, to Table this resolution to the October 19, 1993 Board meeting. A voice vote resulted as
follows: Ayes - 15, Noes - 0. Motion to Table Carried.
RESOLUTION NO. 252 - AUTHORIZATION TO AWARD TOURISM PROMOTION GRANTS
- ADVISORY BOARD ON TOURISM DEVELOPMENT
Moved by Ms. Mink, seconded by Mr. Proto. Mr. Joseph stated that although he believes these
projects are important, he feels there are higher priorities. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 14,
Noes - 1 (Representative Shurtleff). Adopted.
239
September 21, 1993
WHEREAS, the Advisory Board on Tourism Development has responsibility for the review of
grant proposals for tourism related projects in Tompkins County, and
WHEREAS, the Hangar Theatre, Kitchen Theatre, Tompkins County Quilters Guild, and Sacred
Harp Singers have submitted applications for funding from the County through the Advisory Board on
Tourism Development, and
WHEREAS, the Advisory Board on Tourism Development has found the above-mentioned grant
requests to be worthy of funding and appropriate to the mission of the Advisory Board on Tourism
Development, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the following grants be
awarded:
Hangar Theatre $ 6,350
Kitchen Theatre $ 6,000
Tompkins County Quilters Guild $ 5,830
Sacred Harp Singers $ 260
Total $18,440
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 253 - REASSIGNMENT OF SPACE, BIGGS BUILDING A
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mrs. Call, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Human Services, Planning, Public Works and
Construction Management and Budget and Administration Committees, That space now currently vacant
in Biggs Building A is hereby assigned to the Depai tment of Social Services, said space as shown in a
map prepared by the Department of Planning and dated September 1993.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 254 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE A GRANT AGREEMENT WITH
THE NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
- TOMPKINS COUNTY AIRPORT - CONSTRUCT NEW
TERMINAL BUILDING (PHASE 2)
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Culligan, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, the County has received a grant offer from the New York State Department of
Transportation (NYSDOT) in the amount of $7,843 towards the cost of constructing the new terminal
building, it being a Phase 2 grant, and
WHEREAS, the budget for Phase 2 of the new terminal building is as follows:
FAA Share (90.0%)
NYSDOT Share (5.0%)
PFC Share (5.0%)
Account No. 5610.4592 $ 88,883
Account No. 5610.3592 $ 7,843
Account No. 5610.5031 $ 7,842
Total Account No. 5610.2200 $104,568
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the New York State Department of Transportation grant offer in the amount of $7,843 be and
hereby is accepted and that the County Administrator is authorized to execute the required documents.
SEQR ACTION: TYPE I
(NEGATIVE DECLARATION ON FILE)
240
September 21, 1993
RESOLUTION NO. 255 AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE A GRANT AGREEMENT WITH
THE NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
- TOMPKINS COUNTY AIRPORT - EXTEND, MARK, LIGHT AND
GROOVE RUNWAY 14
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, the County has received a grant offer from the New York State Depaitinent of
Transportation (NYSDOT) in the amount of 4191,222.20 towards the cost of extending, marking,
lighting and grooving Runway 14, and
WHEREAS, the budget for the runway extension project is as follows:
FAA Share (90.0%) Account No. 5698.4592 $ 3,442,000.00
NYSDOT Share (5.0%) Account No. 5698.3592 $ 191,222.20
PFC Share (5.0%) Account No. 5698.5031 $ 191,222.20
Total Account No. 5698.2200 $3,824,444.40
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the New York State Department of Transportation grant offer in the amount of $191,222.20 be and
hereby is accepted and that the County Administrator is authorized to execute the required documents.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 256 - AUTHORIZATION FOR QUIT CLAIM DEED - MAIN STREET,
NEWFIELD
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Mason, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee
and the Highway Superintendent with the consent of the Tompkins County Superintendent of Highways,
That certain lands situate in the Town of Newfield, which land is located between the westerly line of
Old Main Street adjacent to property of the People's Baptist Church of Newfield, New York are no
longer needed for public use,
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator is hereby authorized to execute a quit claim
deed to the People's Baptist Church of Newfield, New York in consideration of ONE DOLLAR ($1.00).
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 257 - CREATION OF POSITION - PERSONNEL
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Personnel and Budget and Administration Committees,
That one position of Personnel Assistant (60/333), labor grade J(10) Confidential, competitive class, be
created effective September 1, 1993,
RESOLVED, further, That no new monies are needed to fund this change for 1993.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 258 - CREATE, ABOLISH AND RECLASSIFY POSITIONS - TOMPKINS
CORTLAND COMMUNITY COLLEGE
241
September 21, 1993
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health, Personnel, and Budget and Administration
Committees, That the following positions be created, abolished, and reclassified effective September 1,
1993
CREATE
1 Receptionist/Operator, full-time, labor grade B, competitive class
1 Keyboard Specialist, full-time, labor grade C, competitive class
1 Stenographic Secretary, competitive class, labor grade H
RECLASSIFY
1 Keyboard Specialist, labor grade C to Secretary, labor grade G, both competitive class
ABOLISH
1 Administrative Assistant, labor grade J, competitive class
RESOLVED, further, That no new monies are needed to fund these changes in 1993.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 259 - BUDGET ADJUSTMENTS AND APPROPRIATIONS - VARIOUS
DEPARTMENTS
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Mason. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes -
15, Noes - 0. Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education, Human Services, Public Safety,
Public Works, and Budget and Administration Committees, That the County Comptroller be authorized
to make the following budget adjustments and appropriations on his books:
BUDGET ADJUSTMENTS
Administration
Revenue: A1989.2770
A1620.2770
A1989.4462
A1620.4462
Appropriation:
Fire & EMS
Revenue:
Appropriation:
Revenue:
Appropriation:
Office for the Aging
Revenue:
Appropriation:
Revenue:
Appropriation:
Revenue:
Appropriation:
Revenue:
Unclassified Revenues
Unclassified Revenues
Insurance
Insurance
A3410.3389 State Aid
A3410.2222 Equipment
A3410.3389
A3410.2222
State Aid
Community Equipment
A6795.2705 Gifts & Donations
A6795.4491 Subcontractor
A6776.4772
A6776.4342
Revenue
Food
A6784.4772 Cash -in Lieu
A6784.4342 Food
A6776.4772
$ 4,446
1 ,123
$ 4,446
1,123
$25,000
$25,000
$36,000
$36,000
$ 250
$ 250
$ 397
$ 397
$ 267
$ 267
Revenue $ 397
242
Appropriation:
Revenue:
Appropriation:
Revenue:
Appropriation:
Mental Health
Revenue:
Appropriation:
Revenue:
Appropriation:
Revenue:
Appropriation:
Revenue:
Appropriation:
Social Services
Revenue:
Appropriation:
A6776.4342
A6780.2705
A6780.4491
A6794.3 803
A6794.4302
.1529
.1559
.4330
.4452
.4472
.4465
.4466
.8810
.8830
.8840
.8860
.8870
A4322.3493
A4322.4400
A4329.3494
A4329.4400
A4324.3490
A4324.3499
A4324.4400
A4329.3499
A4329.4400
A6070.2770
3670
4670
A6070.4400
APPROPRIATIONS from 1992 Surplus
Assessment
Revenue: A0599.0000
Appropriation: A1355.2206
A .2211
A .4332
A .4452
A .4466
Revenue: A0599.0000
Appropriation: A1355.2211
September 21, 1993
Food
Gifts & Donations
Subcontractors
State Revenue
Office Supplies
Salary
Salary
Printing
Postage
Telephone
Job Necessitated Travel
Job Related Travel
Retirement
Social Security
Worker's Comp
Health Insurance
Unemployment
OMR/DD OT State Aid
Special Children's Center
OMR/DD 620 State Aid
Challenge Industries
State Aid -Adult Family Support
State Aid-C&Y Support
Mental Health Association
OMH Contract Revenue
Challenge Industries
Unallocated Revenues
State Revenues
Federal Revenues
Purchase of Services
General Fund Balance
Computer Equipment
Chairs
Books, Publications
Postage
Job Related Travel & Training
General Fund Balance
Chairs
243
$ 397
$ 225
$ 225
$(7,149)
$( 50)
( 287)
( 4,929)
( 100)
( 25)
( 100)
( 100)
( 45)
( 182)
( 399)
( 16)
( 885)
( 31)
$ 1,893
$ 1,893
$ 934
$ 934
$ 60
$ 4,000
$ 4,060
$ 953
$ 953
$11,700
$32,175
$53,625
$97,500
$ 5,455
$ 3,400
725
70
500
760
$ 307
$ 307
Youth Bureau
Revenue: A0599.0000
Appropriation: A7020.2212
.2213
A7026.4569
A7020.4442
September 21, 1993
General Fund Balance
Desks, Bookcases, Tables
File Cabinets
FCS: Rural Coordination
Professional Service Fees
APPROPRIATIONS from Contingency Fund
Human Services Coalition
Revenue:
Appropriation:
Data Processing
Revenue:
Appropriation:
A1990.4400
A6310.4561
A1990.4400
A1680.1287
.1638
.8810
.8830
.8840
.8870
$ 7,619
$ 850
150
3,619
3,000
Contingent Fund Balance $ 1,635
Neighborhood Legal Services $ 1,635
Contingent Fund Balance
Director Data Processing
Microcomputer Specialist
Retirement
Social Security
Workers Compensation
Unemployment Insurance
Revenue: A1990.4400 Contingent Fund Balance
Appropriation: A1680.2206 Computer Equipment
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator be and he hereby is authorized to execute
$25,949
$22,363
1,435
0
2,072
79
0
$12,783
$12,783
any contracts necessary to convey these funds.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE 11
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 260 - AUTHORIZATION TO TRANSFER FUNDS AND ENTER INTO A
CONTRACT WITH SYSTEMS EAST FOR SOFTWARE FOR
COUNTY TAX BILL
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the Budget
and Finance Department be authorized to enter into a contract with Systems East of Cortland, NY for the
development of software for a new County tax bill format,
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller is hereby directed to make the following budget
transfer:
FROM: A1311.4400 Program Expense $4,000
TO: A1311.4442 Prof. Service Fee $4,000
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 261 - BUDGET ADJUSTMENT AND APPROPRIATION FROM
CONTINGENCY FUND - SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Mason. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes -
14, Noes - 1 (Representative Culligan). Adopted.
244
September 21, 1993
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Safety, and Budget and Administration
Committees, That the following budget adjustment and budget appropriation be made,
RESOLVED, further, That the 1994 Fiscal Plan target spending calculation shall not be increased
by the $62,718 authorized by this resolution for the Public Safety Committee, or for the total County
budget.
BUDGET ADJUSTMENT
REVENUE
A3110.2770
A3110.3330
APPROPRIATION
A3110.1412
A3110.1419
A3110.8810
A3110.8830
A3110.8840
A3110.8870
Unclassified Revenue
Sec. Costs Court System
$11,000
18,000
Sergeant Deputy Sheriff $ 3,000
Deputy Sheriff 23,529
Retirement 0
Social Security 1,939
Workers Compensation 532
Unemployment 0
TO REFLECT STATE INSURANCE FUND REIMBURSEMENT ANTICIPATED FOR DECEMBER
1992, THROUGH JUNE 30, 1993 WORKERS' COMPENSATION CLAIMS.
BUDGET APPROPRIATION
FROM: A1990.4400
TO: A3110.1412
A3110.1419
A3110.1219
A3110.1906
A3110.8810
A3110.8830
A3110.8840
A3110.8870
Contingency Fund
Sergeant Deputy Sheriff
Deputy Sheriff
Undersheriff
Shift Differential
Retirement
Social Security
Workers Compensation
Unemployment
$60,169
$14,049
29,756
10,419
600
0
4,194
1,151
0
TO REINSTATE FUNDS PAID FOR TERMINAL PAY AND REPLACEMENT PAY BETWEEN
JANUARY 1, 1993 AND JUNE 30, 1993. (Net of Fiscal Plan deductible of $22,350 which represents
25% of the 1992 Fiscal Plan reduction AND $5,253 shortfall in the 1992 year-end balance for this
department.)
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 262 INCREASING TAXES ON SALES AND USES OF TANGIBLE
PERSONAL PROPERTY AND ON CERTAIN SERVICES, AND
ON OCCUPANCY OF HOTEL ROOMS, AMUSEMENT
CHARGES AND CLUB DUES, PURSUANT TO
ARTICLE 29 OF THE TAX LAW OF THE STATE OF NEW
YORK
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Mason. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 13, Noes -
2 (Representatives Proto and Schuler). Adopted.
Be it enacted by the Board of Representatives of the County of Tompkins as follows:
245
September 21, 1993
SECTION I. The first sentence of section two of Resolution No. 256A as enacted in nineteen
hundred sixty-six, as amended, is amended to read as follows:
SECTION 2. Imposition of sales tax.
On and after March first, nineteen hundred and sixty-seven, there is
hereby imposed and there shall be paid a tax of three percent upon,
and for the period commencing December 1, 1992, and ending November
30, 1995, there is hereby imposed and there shall be paid an
additional tax of one percent upon:
SECTION 2. Subdivision (f) of section three of Resolution No. 256A as enacted in nineteen
hundred sixty-six, as amended, is amended to read as follows:
(f) With respect to the additional tax of one percent imposed for the period commencing
December 1, 1992, and ending November 30, 1995, the provisions of subdivisions (a), (b), (c), (d) and (e)
of this section apply, except that for the purposes of this subdivision, all references in said subdivisions
(a), (b), (c) and (d) to an effective date shall be read as referring to December 1, 1992, all references in
said subdivision (a) to the date four months prior to the effective date shall be read as referring to August
1, 1992, and the reference in subdivision (b) to the date immediately preceding the effective date shall be
read as referring to November 30, 1992. Nothing herein shall be deemed to exempt from tax at the rate
in effect prior to December 1, 1992, any transaction which may not be subject to the additional tax
imposed effective on that date.
SECTION 3. Section four of Resolution No. 256A as enacted in nineteen hundred sixty-six, as
amended, is amended to read as follows:
SECTION 4. Imposition of compensating use tax.
(a) Except to the extent that property or services have already been or will be subject to the sales
tax under this enactment, there is hereby imposed on every person a use tax for the use within this taxing
jurisdiction on and after December 1, 1992, except as otherwise exempted under this enactment, (A) of
any tangible personal property purchased at retail, (B) of any tangible personal property (other than
computer software used by the author or other creator) manufactured, processed or assembled by the
user, (i) if items of the same kind of tangible personal property are offered for sale by him in the regular
course of business or (ii), if items are used as such or incorporated into a structure, building or real
property, by a contractor, subcontractor or repairman in erecting structures or buildings, or building on,
or otherwise adding to, altering, improving, maintaining, servicing or repairing real property, property or
land, as the terms real property, property or land are defined in the real property tax law, if items of the
same kind are not offered for sale as such by such contractor, subcontractor or repairman or other user in
the regular course of business, (C) of any of the services described in paragraphs (1), (7) and (8) of
subdivision (c) of section two, (D) of any tangible personal property, however acquired, where not
acquired for purposes of resale, upon which any of the services described under paragraphs (2), (3) and
(7) of subdivision (c) of section two have been performed, (E) of any telephone answering service
described in subdivision (b) of section two and (F) of any computer software written or otherwise created
by the user if the user offers software of a similar kind for sale as such or as a component part of other
property in the regular course of business.
(b) For purposes of clause (A) of subdivision (a) of this section, for the period commencing
December 1, 1992, and ending November 30, 1995, the tax shall be at the rate of four percent, and on and
after December 1, 1995, the tax shall be at the rate of three percent, of the consideration given or
contracted to be given for such property, or for the use of such property, including any charges for
shipping or delivery as described in paragraph three of subdivision (b) of section one, but excluding any
credit for tangible personal property accepted in part payment and intended for resale.
(c) For purposes of subclause (i) of clause (B) of subdivision (a) of this section, for the period
commencing December 1, 1992, and ending November 30, 1995, the tax shall be at a rate of four percent,
and on and after December 1, 1995, the tax shall be at the rate of three percent, of the price at which
items of the same kind of tangible personal property are offered for sale by the user, and the mere
storage, keeping, retention or withdrawal from storage of tangible personal property by the person who
manufactured, processed or assembled such property shall not be deemed a taxable use by him.
246
September 21, 1993
(d) For purposes of subclause (ii) of clause (B) of subdivision (a) of this section, for the period
commencing December 1, 1992, and ending November 30, 1995, the tax shall be at the rate of four
percent, and on and after December 1, 1995, the tax shall be at the rate of three percent, of the
consideration given or contracted to be given for the tangible personal property manufactured, processed
or assembled into the tangible personal property the use of which is subject to tax, including any charges
for shipping or delivery as described in paragraph three of subdivision (b) of section one.
(e) Notwithstanding the foregoing provisions of this section, for purposes of clause (B) of
subdivision (a) of this section, there shall be no tax on any portion of such price which represents the
value added by the user to tangible personal property which he fabricates and installs to the
specifications of an addition or capital improvement to real property, property or land, as the terms real
property, property or land are defined in the real property tax law, over and above the prevailing normal
purchase price prior to such fabrication of such tangible personal property which a manufacturer,
producer or assembler would charge an unrelated contractor who similarly fabricated and installed such
tangible personal property to the specifications of an addition or capital improvement to such real
property, property or land.
(f) For purposes of clauses (C), (D) and (E) of subdivision (a) of this section, for the period
commencing December 1, 1992, and ending November 30, 1995, the tax shall be at the rate of four
percent, and on and after December 1, 1995, the tax shall be at the rate of three percent, of the
consideration given or contracted to be given for the service, including the consideration for any tangible
personal property transferred in conjunction with the performance of the service and also including any
charges for shipping and delivery of the property so transferred and of the tangible personal property
upon which the service was performed as such charges are described in paragraph three of subdivision
(b) of section one.
(g) For purposes of clause (F) of subdivision (a) of this section, for the period commencing
December 1, 1992, and ending November 30, 1995, the tax shall be at the rate of four percent, and on and
after December 1, 1995, the tax shall be at the rate of three percent, of the consideration given or
contracted to be given for the tangible personal property which constitutes the blank medium, such as
disks or tapes, used in conjunction with the software, or for the use of such property, and the mere
storage, keeping, retention or withdrawal from storage of computer software described in such clause (F)
by its author or other creator shall not be deemed a taxable use by such person.
SECTION 4. Subdivision (1) of section 11 of Resolution No. 256A as enacted in nineteen
hundred sixty-six, as amended, is amended to read as follows:
(1)(A) In respect to the use of property used by the purchaser in this County prior to March 1,
1967.
(B) With respect to the additional tax of one percent imposed for the period commencing
December 1, 1992, and ending November 30, 1995, in respect to the use of property used by the
purchaser in this County prior to December 1, 1992.
SECTION 5. This enactment shall take effect on December 1, 1993.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 263 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE PURCHASE AGREEMENT AND
DEED, TOWN OF LANSING TAX PARCEL NO. 7-1-11.1 AND 11.2
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Todd, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
RESOLVED, That the County Administrator is directed to execute a purchase agreement and deed
to convey Tax Parcels No. 7-1-11.1 and 11.2 in the Town of Lansing to Christopher Muka of Newfield
for the sum of $8,000 with the appropriate commission to be paid to Patterson Real Estate.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE If
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
247
September 21, 1993
RESOLUTION NO. 264 - AWARD OF BID - DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL SERVICES (DSS)
FURNITURE
Moved by Ms. Mink, seconded by Mrs. Schuler. The question was called and a voice vote
resulted as follows: Ayes - 13, Noes - 2 (Representatives Schuler and Stein). A voice vote resulted as
follows on the resolution as follows: Ayes - 15, Noes - 0. Adopted.
WHEREAS, the Division of Purchasing and Central Services has duly advertised for the purchase
of various articles of furniture for the Depa' tment of Social Services, and
WHEREAS, three (3) bids were received and publicly opened on August 20, 1993, now therefore
be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Human Services Committee, That the bid be awarded to
Vincent Furniture of Groton, New York being the lowest responsible bidder,
RESOLVED, further, That the Department of Social Services be authorized to implement this bid
on behalf of the County, funds to be provided from various program accounts.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 265 - AUTHORIZATION TO FILE A GRANT APPLICATION FOR ISTEA
FUNDING OF THE NEWFIELD COVERED BRIDGE
PRESERVATION AND RESTORATION PROJECT AND TO ENTER
INTO AN AGREEMENT WITH NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT
OF TRANSPORTATION FOR ACCEPTANCE OF PROJECT
RESPONSIBILITIES AND ASSURANCE OF THE LOCAL SHARE
OF FUNDING
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Evans. Mr. Stein requested he abstain because he served
on the committee that reviewed this at the State level. Mrs. Livesay confirmed with Mr. Winch that this
project does not jeopardize the Forest Home Bridge Project. Mr. Winch said it is not related and that to
the best of his knowledge it does jeopardize the Forest Home Bridge Project. A voice vote resulted as
follows: Ayes - 14, Noes - 0, Abstentions - 1 (Representative Stein). Adopted.
WHEREAS, the Rehabilitation and Restoration of the Newfield Covered Bridge will facilitate the
preservation and continued operation of a historic transportation facility within Tompkins County, have
positive economic impacts on the Town of Newfield and Tompkins County through continued and
enhanced tourism activities and will provide the residents of the Town of Newfield and the greater
Tompkins County area with a greater sense of cultural heritage and local history, and
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County Department of Public Works Highway and Engineering
Divisions intends to file a grant application with the New York State Department of Transportation
(NYSDOT) for the Newfield Covered Bridge Preservation and Restoration Project in the amount of
$280,000 in order to fund the following:
- Abutment and bank stabilization
- New paint, decking and roofing
- Parking lot upgrade and timber guiderail extensions
- Overlook and picnic area(s)
- Pedestrian bridge
- Landscaping
- Survey, design and inspection of the above
248
September 21, 1993
WHEREAS, NYSDOT as part of the application process, requires that Tompkins County accept
responsibility for and/or provide the following:
- Insure public sector support for the project
- Provide assurance for the nonfederal share of the funding and specificity as to when the
nonfederal share will be available
- Assume responsibility for cost increases and cost overruns
- Assume design responsibilities
- Assume inspection and maintenance responsibilities
- Assure necessary environmental compliance
- Assume construction and construction inspection responsibilities
- Assume other responsibilities as may be required
- Enter into a formal agreement with NYSDOT, if the project is chosen for ISTEA funding
WHEREAS, the nonfederal share of the project is 20 percent of the total or $56,000, now
therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the Divisions of Highway and Engineering proceed with the application to NYSDOT for the ISTEA
funding of the Newfield Covered Bridge Preservation and Restoration Project and that the Commissioner
of Public Works be hereby authorized to execute the application,
RESOLVED, further, That the Tompkins County Board of Representatives fully supports this
project and hereby agrees to provide the 20 percent nonfederal share of the project ($56,000), which shall
be part of the normal appropriation for bridges at the time required by the State or Federal Government"
RESOLVED, further, That the funding for the nonfederal share shall be available by January 1,
1994,
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator be hereby authorized to execute the
necessary agreements with NYSDOT for the purposes of providing NYSDOT with assurance of the
availability of the nonfederal share and to formally accept the project responsibilities outlined above.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 266 - AUTHORIZATION TO SETTLE ACTION - USHER VS. MOBBS
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Culligan, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the County Attorney is authorized to settle the action of Usher vs. Mobbs pursuant to negotiations
between Ward Hungerford, Highway Manager and James Fast, buyer of the Usher property, whereby
twenty (20) spruce trees will be furnished and planted by the Department of Public Works to replace
trees to be removed for shoulder improvement,
RESOLVED, further, That the Board of Representatives authorizes the agreement between Ward
Hungerford and James Fast.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
Chairman Watros declared recess at 8:19 p.m. The meeting reconvened at 8:28 p.m.
It was Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mrs. Call, and unanimously adopted by voice vote, to
enter into executive session at 8:28 p.m. to discuss Collins' bankruptcy and three personnel matters. The
meeting returned to open session at 9:25 p.m.
On motion, the meeting adjourned at 9:25 p.m.
249
October 5, 1993
Regular Meeting
Chairman Watros called the meeting to order at 5:30 p.m.
Members and guests participated in the Pledge of Allegiance.
Present: 15 Representatives.
It was Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote, to
approve the minutes of September 7, 1993 as submitted.
Mr. Squires, Comptroller, reported on a constitutional amendment which will appear on the
November ballot. Amendment No. one will specifically affect Tompkins County. It changes the amount
of archaic provisions in the constitution which makes New York State unique. It will allow the ability to
finance capital improvements using low level debt service such as home mortgages. Amendment No.
two affects local governments with sewer debts. This amendment extends the exclusion for another ten
years.
Chairman Watros presented a proclamation to Brian Wilbur, Ithaca City Fire Chief, declaring the
week of October 3 - 9, 1993 as Fire Prevention Week in Tompkins County.
Chairman Watros presented a proclamation to Aurora Valenti, Tompkins County Clerk, declaring
the week of October 10-16, 1993 as Archives Week in Tompkins County.
Under privilege of the floor, Margaret Kirchgessner, Human Rights Commission employee, stated
that she has been out of work from her position since June 23 due to multiple chemical sensitivities. She
thanked Board members for attending a meeting held today on this issue with Dr. Wolfson and Greg
Siwinski. Ms. Kirchgessner requested that she be allowed to work from her home and that a policy be
developed to accommodate employees and members of the public who are affected by chemical barriers.
Under privilege of the floor, Yvonne Bartlett, Depaitnient of Social Services employee, thanked
members of the Board for attending a meeting held today to discuss the air quality situation at the Biggs
complex. Ms. Bartlett apologized for anger expressed at the last Board meeting and hopes that the
employees and administrators can work together towards a resolve to the situation. She stated that she is
willing to share any information she has on the subject with any member of the Board.
Under privilege of the floor, Margaret Marks, Department of Social Services employee, stated that
she appreciates Board members for attending the meeting held today to discuss the air quality situation at
the Biggs complex. Ms. Marks requested that the workman's compensation of the affected employees not
be controverted any longer.
Under privilege of the floor, Claudia Cinquanti, Department of Social Services employee, stated
that on August 13, 1993 she and Sharon Prezioso addressed a letter to Mary Pat Dolan, Commissioner of
Social Services, requesting a written response by August 23 to a request to be relocated to a safe working
environment so that they would be able to return to work. She stated that to date no response has been
received.
Under privilege of the floor, Sharon Prezioso McLaughlin, Department of Social Services
employee, submitted a pack of information she received from the State Attorney General's Office entitled
"Carpets and Indoor Air: What You Should Know".
250
October 5, 1993
Under privilege of the floor, Mel Bartlett, Interlaken, New York, also thanked members of the
Board for attending the meeting held today to discuss air quality in the Biggs building. He stated that he
appreciates the time the Board has taken to listen and try to understand the problems of the employees
who are diagnosed with multiple chemical sensitivities and their families. He stated that it has taken
seven months but sees a common goal trying to be reached.
Under privilege of the floor, Stuart Stein, Representative, District No. 1, stated that he was unable
to attend the meeting of the Chamber of Commerce on September 30. He said he was informed that there
were a number of recommendations made and a report distributed. He suggested that the Board make a
formal response to the report.
Under privilege of the floor, Ms. Mink, Chair, Human Services Committee, stated that the meeting
held today was extremely productive and asked that an update be given to the Board at this time.
James Kazda, Senior Civil Engineer, Public Works Depaitment, apologized for the space not
being available by now and stated that there have been delays in receiving necessary equipment. Mr.
Kazda stated that all repairs that have been requested by Mr. Siwinski and July Crawford, Certified
Industrial Hygienst, have been completed. He responded to questions raised at the last Board meeting
concerning ventilation code compliance and stated that the building is required to have either mechanical
or natural ventilation. The Biggs building has both, therefore, the building is in compliance. He also
reported that required occupancy modifications were made to the building.
James Hanson, Planning Commissioner, stated that his Depattnient was asked this summer to look
at the space study done by the Depaitment a number of years ago. He stated that as well as looking at
that study, the Department has been developing possible alternatives to the current Biggs site. He stated
that there are a number of sites that have been reviewed and cost comparisons are being looked at. Mr.
Hanson stated that specific details would be an item to be discussed in executive session. Mr. Lerner
asked what the cost would be to make the existing Biggs A building useable and a safe working place
without continuing health problems. Mr. Kazda stated that what was presented in the capital program
was a project believed appropriate for the building. That project amounts to approximately $6.4 million.
He stated that the ventilation component contained in that project as not been separated but could be if
the Board wished. Chairman Watros asked if the size of the building was studied. Mr. Hanson stated
that the size including all of the existing tenants was studied. Mr. Watros also asked if a proposal on the
disposition of Biggs A would be prepared and if the impact on Tompkins Community Hospital has been
looked at.
Mr. Watros requested the Planning Committee come back to the Board with a report which
includes the existing proposal, the points made relative to the disposition thereof, and have this
information in a rough form. If it is appropriate at that time, an executive session can be held to discuss
specific sites.
Under privilege of the floor, Mr. Joseph, Representative, District No. 12, spoke concerning E911
and stated that he has been asked by his constituents why inadvertent 911 calls can not be diverted to an
answering point in Tompkins County rather than an operator. It is his understanding that the
Trumansburg Telephone Company does forward these calls but that New York Telephone has chosen not
to. Mr. Mason, Chairman, Public Safety Committee, stated that the Trumansburg Telephone Company
has shown that this can be done and it works out well. He also stated that there are several issues that
need to be resolved with telephone companies and that public education on this subject needs to improve.
Chairman Watros spoke concerning the Tompkins County Human Resource Study conducted and
prepared by the County Tax Committee of the Chamber of Commerce. Mr. Watros stated that he would
like specific committees to pursue the following:
251
October 5, 1993
1. Personnel Committee - to review health care costs and prescription drug co -pay and
deductibles
2. Health and Education Committee - to review home health aid policy of the Health Department
relative to the agencies who give the service and the alleged excessive costs and quality of
care
3. Fiscal Affairs and Budget and Administration Committees - to review organizational structure
of County government
Mr. Watros stated that he would leave the remainder of the document for consideration by any
individual of the Board. Mr. Watros stated that it was important to recognize those individuals who
worked on this report.
Chairman Watros declared recess at 6:48 p.m. The meeting reconvened at 6:50 p.m.
It was Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mrs. Call, and unanimously adopted by voice vote, to
enter into executive session at 6:50 p.m. to discuss contract negotiations, appointments and a personnel
matter. The meeting returned to open session at 8:08 p.m.
Mr. Evans, Chairman, Personnel Committee, reported that contract negotiations are continuing.
Mr. Proto, Chairman, Health and Education Committee, reported that the Committee has met to
review departmental budget requests and requests have exceeded guidelines by $80,000. The Planned
Parenthood African American Study was received and a copy is on file in the Board office. The next
Committee meeting will be October 26.
Ms. Mink, Chair, Human Services Committee, reported that initial departmental budget reviews
were held this morning. The second budget review is scheduled for November 2.
Mr. Mason, Chairman, Public Safety Committee, reported effective September 30 New York State
Police assigned another officer to the satellite office at Biggs to increase coverage on the west side of the
County. The Committee will meet October 7 at noon for a brief Committee meeting and to review
departmental budgets.
Mr. Stein, Chairman, Planning Committee, reported that the Committee will meet October 7 at 9
a.m. to review depai tmental budgets.
Mr. Winch, Chairman, Public Works and Construction Management Committee, reported that the
Committee reviewed capital projects. He updated the Board on the status of construction of the New
Airport Terminal.
Mr. Todd, Chairman, Fiscal Affairs Committee, reported the Committee will meet October 13 at
9:30 a.m. He stated that the Committee has been discussing the resolution on the agenda entitled
Establishment of the Tompkins County Leadership Council and Commitment to an Organizational
Change Initiative to Improve the Efficiency, Effectiveness and Quality of County Services.
Mr. Lerner, Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, reported that he
expects a committee of the whole meeting will be held November 16 to discuss the Solid Waste budget.
Mrs. Livesay, Intergovernmental Representative, reported that there is a meeting October 14 at
Cooperative Extension concerning cable rates and asked that Board members inform municipalities. She
also reported that she continues to work on negotiations with the Office of State Parks.
252
October 5, 1993
Mrs. Call, Chair, Budget and Administration Committee, stated that the next Committee meeting
will be October 12 at 5 p.m.
Mr. Heyman, County Administrator, commented on the Human Resources Study prepared by the
Chamber of Commerce. He reported that the projected increases in mandated costs total approximately
$2.2 million.
Mr. Mulvey, County Attorney, stated that the monthly report on activities undertaken by the
County Attorney's office has been submitted.
Chairman Watros gave Mrs. Call, Chairman, Public Works and Construction Management
Committee, permission to withdraw from the agenda the resolution entitled Authorization to Execute
Purchase Agreement and Quit Claim Deed, Town of Dryden Tax Map Parcel 59-14-36.1.
It was Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Stein, and unanimously adopted by voice vote, to
withdraw from the agenda the following resolutions with final committee action being affirmed:
CA093-93 - Authorization to Execute Consultant Contract - Council for Physical Fitness and
Health in Tompkins County - Healthy Heart Program
CA094-93 - Acceptance of Funds, Authorization to Execute Contract, Budget Adjustment - "89-
313" Funds
CA095-93 - Authorization for Contract with Superior Disposal Service Inc., for Collection of
Recyclables at Tompkins County Airport
RESOLUTION NO. 267 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE A COMMERCIAL AND
INDUSTRIAL HIGH EFFICIENCY RETROFIT PROGRAM
AGREEMENT - TOMPKINS COUNTY PUBLIC LIBRARY
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Culligan, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, New York State Electric and Gas (NYSEG) has undertaken the development and
implementation of a Commercial and Industrial High Efficiency Retrofit Program to enable its
nonresidential customers to reduce their electrical energy costs, and
WHEREAS, NYSEG and the County of Tompkins desire to enter into an agreement to share the
cost of implementing the Program at the Tompkins County Library for the purpose of enabling the
County of Tompkins to reduce its energy usage. The County's $57,924 share of $113,376 will be paid as
a monthly surcharge to the Library's electric bill and should be directly offset by the energy savings, now
therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the Board of Representatives of the County of Tompkins does hereby authorize the County
Administrator to execute a Commercial and Industrial High Energy Retrofit Program Agreement for the
Tompkins County Public Library.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 268 - ESTABLISHMENT OF THE TOMPKINS COUNTY LEADERSHIP
COUNCIL AND COMMITMENT TO AN ORGANIZATIONAL
CHANGE INITIATIVE TO IMPROVE THE EFFICIENCY,
EFFECTIVENESS AND QUALITY OF COUNTY SERVICES
(Adopted November 16, 1993)
253
October 5, 1993
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Todd. Mr. Todd said the Fiscal Affairs Committee
discussed this at length. He encouraged Board members to read the packet of material attached to the
agenda concerning the resolution. Ms. Zahler, Youth Bureau Director, described the information
dispersed to Board members. She said the responsibility of the Leadership Council is to establish
procedures to make this an organization that is driven by planning, clear priorities for budgeting and that
has staff who know what those plans are and see clearly how there particular job is crucial for making
those County and department goals a reality. She described three parts: long-range planning for setting
priorities, staff development and training, and service improvement. Mr. Heyman, County Administrator,
showed a five minute video tape of a group of Public Works employees from the City of Madison,
Wisconsin, who undertook a project to conclude a brush project showing the cost efficiency and service
to the public.
It was Moved by Mr. Todd, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote to
Table this resolution to the November 3, 1993 Board meeting.
RESOLUTION NO. 269 - RESOLUTION OF RESPECT - EDWIN L. CRAWFORD
Moved by Mr. Culligan and unanimously seconded and adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, Edwin L. Crawford passed away, September 27, 1993, and
WHEREAS, Mr. Crawford served the Town of Vestal and the County of Broome as Town
Supervisor and County Executive, and
WHEREAS, being elected to the Supervisor and County Executive positions Mr. Crawford
acquired local grass roots knowledge of the needs of citizens in communities of Upstate New York, and
WHEREAS, he also served as President of the New York State County Government Association
and as President of the National Council of Elected County Executives in the years 1974 to 1976, and
WHEREAS, Mr. Crawford was appointed in 1977 to become the Executive Director of the New
York State Association of Counties, and
WHEREAS, the efforts of Mr. Crawford were always directed towards the betterment of local
government in the counties of New York State, and
WHEREAS, Edwin L. Crawford gave untiringly of his working days to fulfill the lobbying work
and staff leadership needed to enhance village, town, city and county governments, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, unanimously by the Tompkins County Board of Representatives, That the members
on behalf of the citizens of the County thereof express their deep sympathy and most sincere condolences
to the family of Mr. Edwin L. Crawford,
RESOLVED, further, That the Clerk of the Board forward certified copies of this resolution to the
family of Mr. Edwin L. Crawford.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
It was Moved by Mr. Evans, seconded by Mr. Lerner, and unanimously adopted by voice vote, to
appoint Nicholas Wharton to the Tompkins Cortland Community College Board of Trustee for a term
expiring June 30, 1998.
On motion, the meeting adjourned at 8:58 p.m.
254
October 19, 1993
Regular Meeting
Chairman Watros called the meeting to order at 5:30 p.m.
Members and guests participated in the Pledge of Allegiance.
Present: 14 Representatives. Excused: 1 (Representative Schuler).
It was Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to approve the minutes of the September 21, 1993 and October 5, 1993 meetings as
submitted.
Under privilege of the floor, James Ellis, Department of Social Services Employee, said he is a
disabled employee by Biggs Building A and allegedly has "sick building syndrome". He asked about the
status of the safe room and would like to know when he can return to work.
Under privilege of the floor, Yvonne Bartlett, Interlaken resident and Department of Social
Services Employee and allegedly has "sick building syndrome", said she would be put up in a shelter
tonight because she has no electricity, fuel oil or income. She said she is not eligible to receive help from
Seneca County. She also said her immunizations have increased and was notified by Blue Cross/Blue
Shield that she is no longer able to use her prescription card. She expressed her frustration about being
unable to receive public assistance services.
Under privilege of the floor, Sharon Prezioso, Department of Social Services Employee and
allegedly has "sick building syndrome", submitted a statement detailing her experience with an
appointment for an exam with the State Insurance Fund Doctor. She asked that her rights and privileges
guaranteed in the United States Constitution be reinstated in Tompkins County. She also asked that
reports be filed stating any health problems or injuries be reported to the officer to which that department
head has been appointed by.
Under privilege of the floor, Mr. Taraszkiewicz, Hanshaw Road, submitted petitions to the Board
of Representatives protesting the imposition of the Annual Solid Waste Fee. He believes the fee is an
unreasonable tax in that it is not based on the amount of waste or recyclables produced by the subject
properties and it is an unfair and unconstitutional imposition on the taxpayers of this County. He also
believes the fee to be an unreasonable burden on business and property owners. The petition urges the
Tompkins County Board of Representatives to repeal the law.
Under privilege of the floor, James Crawford, Candidate for the Board, District No. 14, said he has
a statement signed by some of the candidates running for the Board asking for reconsideration of the
proposed Solid Waste and Recycling Center. The statement also states that the signed parties feel the
public deserves a thorough examination of the project and solid waste policies. He said his central
purpose for being here is he feels the public has not been convinced or persuaded that the solid waste and
recycling plan is cost effective. The following is a list of questions he asked:
1) What would be the cost in delaying the final approval of the recycling center to the first of the
year and is that a reasonable price to pay to earn the public's confidence and trust?
2) When is construction expected to begin, and would giving the newly seated Board members a
chance to examine the merits of current plans necessarily involve a construction delay, costs or penalties?
3) What would be the effect of flow control being struck down by the Supreme Court and has the
public been apprised of the cost consequences?
4) What is the guiding purpose of the recycling programs --is it cost -avoidance which would lead
to the lowest possible costs for residents, or are there other purposes which compete with cost-
effectiveness?
255
October 19, 1993
5) What is the justification for the cost of the observation platform? Why would a videotape of
the facility not suffice for school uses, and how could anything which cannot be discerned from outside
the facility be of concern to the neighborhood?
6) Would striking the observation platform be a step the Board is willing to take to reestablish the
public's confidence?
Under privilege of the floor, Gerry Angel, 1223 Trumansburg Road and Candidate for the Board,
spoke about the "Tompkins County Resource Study" conducted by the County Tax Committee. He
commended the people who prepared this document. He feels this is an important project and asked that
the Leadership Council be tabled to the first of the year.
Under privilege of the floor, Tammy Andrews, Neighbor of Yvonne Bartlett, said when she got to
know Yvonne, she got to see the illness: "sick building syndrome". She said the illness is
incomprehensible because we do not live with it. She feels it is time to do something and support Ms.
Bartlett and her family.
Under privilege of the floor, Mr. Lerner, Representative, District No. 1, responded to some of the
questions asked by Mr. Crawford. He addressed the impact of the Supreme Court overturning flow
control. He said Tompkins County would have a serious problem to solve but it would be worse without
the recycling center. Flow control helps to finance the solid waste program in the fairest way. Mr.
Lerner addressed the question of whether sufficient explanations to the public of the rationale for the
recycling center have been thoroughly explained. Mr. Lerner stated that a major effort has been made
this year to document what the need for the recycling center is and the economic rationale is. Mr. Lerner
said a proposed document of a six year projection of the entire solid waste budget with the recycling
center included will be available in the next couple weeks. He said he is hoping for a parallel document
showing the same breakout program by program of what the costs would look like without the recycling
center. What it will show is the costs for the overall program will be lower with the recycling center
including capital costs than without the center. Mr. Lerner said he could not answer the question at this
time of what the cost would be for delaying the recycling center project, but could at a later date.
However, he said the Deparnnient of Environmental Conservation (DEC) permits for the temporary
facilities will be expiring and if something to replace them is not in place it will create serious problems.
He addressed the question of whether the purpose of the center is cost avoidance or whether there are
other inconsistent purposes. Mr. Lerner stated that there are other purposes for the facility besides cost
avoidance, but there are no purposes that are inconsistent with cost avoidance. This facility is designed
to dispose of Tompkins County's waste in the most cost-effective way possible that is consistent with
DEC regulations. He also addressed the question about the observation platform. The primary reason
the observation platform is included is because the neighbors of the facility wanted to be able to view the
facility and see for themselves that it is being operated in a clean, safe and responsible way. It is a fringe
benefit to accommodate school children and tourists. He also reiterated that more than half of the cost of
the observation platform is the cost of the handicap access elevator mandated by federal law. He also
answered the question which has been asked several times --why not regionalize the solid waste program?
Mr. Lerner said wherever it is practicable, regionalizing is being done. However, two factors to keep in
mind: 1) a tremendous amount of the cost of the solid waste program is transportation; in the proposed
1994 budget over $2 million is budgeted for trucking costs; and 2) the surrounding counties have a
relatively small population in terms of waste stream and transportation costs would have to be considered
to access the facilities of the next tier of counties consisting of Binghamton, Rochester, Syracuse, etc.
Mr. Lerner also reiterated that DEC regulates how solid waste is disposed throughout New York State.
Until the Hillview Road Landfill was closed, Tompkins County was disposing garbage for about $5 per
ton. Now garbage is disposed of by a lowest bid process for transportation and tipping and the lowest bid
for a DEC permitted facility is about $70 per ton. Anything the County can do to dispose of solid waste
through recycling, composting, and waste reduction brings the cost down. The County is trying to plan
and develop a long-term program and for the next 20 years bring the cost down.
256
October 19, 1993
A lengthy discussion followed regarding the observation platform. Mr. Evans said the request for
the observation platform came from the Neighborhood Advisory Committee for the Central Processing
Facility. Mrs. Livesay stated there are many issues to consider when dealing with solid waste such as the
Solid Waste Management Plan, illegal dumping, open burning, etc. She also addressed the costs for
studying proposals. Mr. Stein reminded the Board that at the time the Board was considering the
observation platform, Mr. Vaughan, Chairman of the Neighborhood Advisory Committee for the Central
Processing Facility, made a strong presentation and a plea to the Board to vote in favor of the observation
platform. Mr. Stein said if the Board proceeds with the consideration of eliminating the observation
platform then Mr. Vaughan should be invited to a Board meeting to make another presentation. Mr.
Proto stated he would like to have Mr. Vaughan attend a Board meeting. Mr. Stein said he would take the
responsibility to invite Mr. Vaughan to a meeting to make comments under privilege of the floor.
Under privilege of the floor, Ms. Mink, Representative, District No. 5, asked for a report on the
status of the "safe" space in the Biggs Building. Ms. Mink stated at the last Board meeting some
questions were raised which involved personnel matters (discussion took place in executive session)
specifically health insurance.
Mr. Heyman, County Administrator, said the answers pertaining to health insurance were
unavailable at this time. He said all the equipment has been installed in the "safe room" and is being
tuned up. Certain tests need to be performed. The target date is October 25. Complainants will be
informed and will be able to contact their physicians about the completed work and receive permission to
return to work. Mr. Mulvey, County Attorney, spoke about the County paying the health insurance for
the employees with "sick building syndrome" allegedly caused by the Biggs Building. He said the
County would have to enact a policy and it would have to be negotiated with the union. He advised the
County cannot target a group of employees.
Mr. Evans, Representative, District No. 13, said he asked Anita Fitzpatrick, Personnel
Commissioner, to provide the Board with the costs of providing full health insurance benefits for
employees on leave due to illness.
Mr. Joseph, Representative, District No. 12, said that Blue Cross/Blue Shield has stated they are
not responsible for the bills because people are applying for Workmen's Compensation and therefore
Workmen's Compensation is responsible for the bills and the people should be not be using the Blue
Cross/Blue Shield cards. Mr. Heyman said he will have the Benefits Manager review this.
Mr. Culligan, Representative, District No. 2, expressed his concern about televising committee
meetings. He said it costs $71 for each committee meeting. He said he would like this decision
rescinded and asked the Public Information Committee to review it.
Cheryl Nelson, Employee Council Chairman, introduced members of the Executive Committee:
Hiroshi Takashima and Barbara Karaviotis and also introduced Leighann Baldwin, Employee Council
Secretary. She said a list of County conference rooms, the capacity of each room, and contact person and
telephone numbers will be available. She said the annual report was dispersed. She also said a revised
policy on public statements is being prepared by the task force. She reported on a resolution passed by
the Council requesting a building occupant survey be done in each building regarding
employee/environmental health. The resolution also requests that a "work at home" policy for employees
be created. The resolution was forwarded to the County's Safety Committee. She also reported on a
recent bus trip to a Buffalo Bills Football game. The trip was very successful.
Mr. Proto, Chairman of the Health and Education Committee, said the committee will be meeting
October 26. The committee will review budget changes, if any, and make a final recommendation
following regular business. He updated the Board on the activities of the Board of Health. He said the
257
October 19, 1993
nursing segment received an applaud on a recent audit. Ninety-four percent of two to three year olds are
immunized. PCAP (Prenatal Care Assistance Program) also received recognition from the State auditor.
For the first time Children with Special Care Needs has reported that nine children have been discharged
since July.
Mr. Evans, Chairman of the Personnel Committee, said the committee has met several times. The
committee discussed questions relative to health insurance and Workmen's Compensation pertaining to
the employees with "sick building syndrome" allegedly caused by the Biggs building. Three rounds of
negotiations have been completed with the blue and white collar units. He said he would like to discuss
at the appropriate time negotiations in executive session. The next meeting is October 28 at 8 a.m.
Ms. Mink, Chair, Human Services Committee, said the next committee meeting is November 2 at
10 a.m. and will complete budget reviews at that time.
Mr. Mason, Chairman, Public Safety Committee, said the committee has also completed budget
reviews except the Sheriffs. The committee will meet November 1 to conclude budget reviews.
Mr. Stein, Chairman of the Planning Committee, said the committee met October 7. The
committee began budget reviews and will meet again October 21 to complete budget reviews and will
receive a presentation on the Biggs study. The Board will receive a presentation on the Biggs study at
the following Board meeting.
Mr. Winch, Chairman, Public Works and Construction Management Committee, said the
committee met and began budget reviews. He announced that the County received $34,600 for the
emergency snow plowing assistance provided through the Federal Emergency Management Agency.
This emergency was declared as a result of the 1993 blizzard. He updated the Board on the asbestos
situation at the Tompkins County Public Library. The Library was temporarily closed until air testing of
materials was performed. The results of the tests were negative and the Library reopened. He updated
the Board on the budget situation for Buildings and Grounds. The Department is experiencing a shortfall
as a result of rented space to the Economic Opportunity Corporation, Tompkins County Employee Day
Care Center, Tompkins County Employee Federal Credit Union, New York State Police, and Ithaca
Town Court. He said he feels the Board needs to reexamine the current policy to provide revenue for
maintaining Buildings and Grounds. The County is not charging for the utilities, cleaning, etc. of this
space and it costs $173,000 annually.
Mr. Todd, Chairman of the Fiscal Affairs Committee, said the committee met October 13. He said
he expects to take action on the material distributed at the previous Board meeting on the proposed
reorganization plan sometimes referred to as "Total Quality Management" in November. He
recommended the Board think about the question raised by Gerry Angel under privilege of the floor
about postponing action on creating a leadership council until a new Board is seated in 1994. He said he
invited Hon. Ronald Dougherty, Chairman of the Tioga County Legislature, to the next committee
meeting to discuss the Council on Government Program.
Mr. Lerner, Chairman of the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, said the
committee met briefly before the Board meeting and approved the resolutions to accept the draft Generic
Environmental Impact Statement and set a public hearing for the Solid Waste Management Plan. The
next meeting is October 28 at 11 a.m. He said on November 16 he will be requesting a committee -of -the -
whole to review the solid waste budget.
Mrs. Livesay, Intergovernmental Representative, updated the Board on the Cable Commission
meeting held October 14 at Cooperative Extension. A staff person from the New York State Cable
Commission was present to discuss cable franchising. She'said she would be pursuing the subject.
258
October 19, 1993
Mrs. Call, Chairman, Budget and Administration Committee, said the committee met October 12
and most of the business is reflected on the agenda. The committee discussed the Financial Disclosure
Form policy. The committee discussed the appeal of the Department of Social Services' furniture and
upheld the Purchasing Depaitment's decision not to rebid. The committee directed the Human Services
Committee to review this since it is the first time to bid used furniture. Some clarifications can be made
in the policy about the bid. The budget reviews have been scheduled. She also spoke about the
memorandum from David Squires, Comptroller, concerning the third quarter financial report.
Mr. Heyman, County Administrator, reported on the meeting with Department Heads concerning
the proposed reorganization plan for Tompkins County.
Mr. Mulvey, County Attorney, said he did not have a report.
On motion of the appropriate committee chairman and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by
voice vote by members present, the following resolutions were added to the agenda:
- Authorization to Execute Purchase Agreement and Quit Claim Deed, Town of Dryden Tax Map
Parcel 59-1-36.1
- Authorization to Execute Purchase Agreement and Deed
It was Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Ms. Mink, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to withdraw the following resolution with final committee action being affirmed:
CA096-93 - Authorization to Contract with the New York State Department of Social Services,
Tompkins Cortland Community College (TC3) and Budget Adjustment - Depaitnient of Social
Services
CA097-93 - Reclassification of Position - Account Clerk Typist to Senior Account Clerk Typist -
Probation Department
RESOLUTION NO. 270 - ACCEPTING THE DRAFT GENERIC ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT
STATEMENT FOR THE TOMPKINS COUNTY SOLID WASTE
MANAGEMENT PLAN
Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mr. Evans. Mrs. Livesay commended the Solid Waste
Division staff for their work in preparing the Solid Waste Management Plan. A voice vote resulted as
follows: Ayes - 14, Noes - 0, Excused - 1 (Representative Schuler). Adopted.
WHEREAS, the County of Tompkins is the lead agency under the New York State Environmental
Quality Review Act ("SEQRA") for the adoption of a Solid Waste Management Plan for Tompkins
County, and
WHEREAS, a Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement ("DGEIS") on the County's Solid
Waste Management Plan was presented to the Board of Representatives, and
WHEREAS, the Board of Representatives have reviewed the DGEIS for the Solid Waste
Management Plan, and
WHEREAS, pursuant to SEQRA it is the responsibility of the lead agency to file a Notice of
Completion of the DGEIS and to provide a public comments period, to be not less than thirty (30) days
from the first filing of the Circulation of Notice of Completion and to hold one or more public hearings to
receive public comment on the DGEIS if it deems such a public hearing is appropriate, now therefore be
it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, That
this Board finds the DGEIS to be satisfactory with respect to its scope, content and adequacy for the
purpose of commencing public review,
259
October 19, 1993
RESOLVED, further, That the Chairman of the Board of the Tompkins County Board of
Representatives is authorized to file a Notice of Completion of the DGEIS and to cause a public
hearing(s) for the purpose of accepting public comment on the DGEIS until ten calendar days following
such public hearing, to publish such notices as may be necessary or desirable and to prepare and present
to the Tompkins County Board of Representatives a Final Generic Environmental Impact Statement and
to take all other actions as may be necessary or desirable to assure the County's compliance with SEQRA
in connection with the adoption of the County's Solid Waste Management Plan.
SEQR ACTION: TYPE I OR UNLISTED
(DETERMINATIONS OR FINDINGS
INCLUDED HEREIN)
RESOLUTION NO. 271 - SETTING THE DATE FOR A PUBLIC HEARING ON THE DRAFT
GENERIC ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT FOR THE
TOMPKINS COUNTY SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT PLAN
Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mrs. Livesay, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, That
this Board .of Representatives shall hold a Public Hearing on a Draft Generic Environmental Impact
Statement, at the Holiday Inn, 222 South Cayuga Street, Ithaca, New York, on November 9, 1993 at 7:30
p.m.,
RESOLVED, further, That the Clerk of the Board of Representatives shall duly publish a notice of
such Public Hearing containing the statements required by law.
SEQR ACTION: TYPE I OR UNLISTED
(DETERMINATIONS OR FINDINGS
INCLUDED HEREIN)
RESOLUTION NO. 272 - AUDIT OF FINAL PAYMENT - OLD JAIL RENOVATION -
EDWARD JOY COMPANY
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Todd. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes -
14, Noes - 0, Excused - 1 (Representative Schuler). Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the following claim against the County of Tompkins, be and hereby is audited by the Board of
Representatives:
Vendor Payment Request Account No. Amount
Edward Joy Company 11 (Final) HV3151.9239 3,304.65
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller be and hereby is authorized and directed to pay said
claim from Account No. HV3151.9239.,
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 273 - CORRECTION OF TAX ROLL TOWN OF LANSING (WESTERN
UNION)
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Todd, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
260
October 19, 1993
WHEREAS, this Board is informed that an error has been made in the 1993 Tax Roll for the Town
of Lansing, namely Parcel 648.8-6-1, assessed to Western Union, was erroneously charged for real
property which had been previously removed, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the entry on
the Tax Roll be corrected,
RESOLVED, further, That the total tax be corrected from $53.99 to $0,
RESOLVED, further, That the Budget and Finance Office is directed to correct the Tax Roll,
RESOLVED, further, That the amount of $53.99 be charged back: $10.82 to the County of
Tompkins; $3.69 to the Town of Lansing; $39.48 to the Lansing School District.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 274 - UNPAID SOLID WASTE ANNUAL FEE
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Lerner. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 13, Noes -
1 (Representative Shurtleff), Excused - 1 (Representative Schuler). Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the Director
of Assessment of the County be and hereby is authorized and directed to add to the respective 1994 tax
rolls the amount of the uncollected Solid Waste Annual Fee remaining unpaid in the Budget and Finance
Office and have not been heretofore relevied on town tax rolls, and that said Solid Waste Annual Fee be
reassessed and relevied on town tax rolls as they are listed on the unpaid list in the Budget and Finance
Office, and that said returned Solid Waste Annual Fee be reassessed and relevied upon the lots and
parcels so returned with 12.0 annual interest in addition thereto.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 275 - INCREASE IN HOURS - HEALTH AND SAFETY COORDINATOR
AND SECRETARY - HEALTH DEPARTMENT
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, additional time is needed for the Health and Safety Coordinator to complete the
required projects and for the Secretary to provide clerical support to the Health and Safety Coordinator,
now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education and Budget and Administration
Committees, That the positions of Health and Safety Coordinator (84/297) and Secretary (09/671), labor
grade I (09), be increased to forty (40) hours per week effective November 1, 1993,
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller is hereby authorized and directed to make the
following budget transfer and adjustment on his books:
From: A4013.1297 Health and Safety Coordinator $323
A1989.4463 Risk Management $445
To: A4013.1671 Secretary $449
A4013.8860 Health Insurance $319
Appropriation: A4013.1671 Secretary $ 83
Revenue: A4013.3401 Public Health Work $ 83
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
261
RESOLUTION NO. 276
October 19, 1993
ENDORSEMENT OF PROPOSED CONSTITUTIONAL
AMENDMENT PROVIDING LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
WITH THE AUTHORITY TO CONTRACT
INDEBTEDNESS MORE EFFECTIVELY FOR FUTURE
CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT REQUIREMENTS
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, two "Blue -Ribbon Commissions" have been impaneled, one by the Governor and one
by the State Comptroller, in the interest of studying existing constitutional restrictions on the issuance of
local governmental debt and making recommendations, and
WHEREAS, both commissions proposed two constitutional amendments, the first would amend
various provisions of Article 8, Section 2 of the State Constitution to provide, as an alternative to the so-
called 50 percent rule method of amortizing principal of indebtedness, a level debt service method of
amortizing both principal and interest on indebtedness; and secondly, a proposed constitutional
amendment which would extend, for another ten-year period, the exclusion of sanitary sewer debt from
the constitutional debt limitation of local government, and
WHEREAS, both constitutional amendments have passed the last two separately -elected State
Legislatures, and now must be approved by the voters of the State of New York this November 2, 1993,
and
WHEREAS, the passage of the two constitutional amendments disclosed herein would provide
local governments with the authority to determine the most affordable and cost effective manner of
financing capital improvements on behalf of their specific constituencies in each instance, now therefore
be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the
Tompkins County Board of Representatives hereby endorses, and recommends approval of both of the
aforementioned constitutional amendments, in the interest of providing local governments with the home -
rule authority to contract indebtedness more effectively for future capital improvement requirements.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 277 - AUTHORIZATION TO INCREASE 1994 FISCAL TARGETS
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice
present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee,
Targets are to be adjusted as follows:
1. Resolution 38 (2/16/93) OAR A6310.4597
Bail Program Enhancement, including substance abuse treatment referrals.
Increase 1993 basis for 1994 Fiscal Target by $12,600.
2. Resolution 122 (4/20/93) NEWFIELD LIBRARY A7410.4521
Installation of a DYNIX System.
Increase 1993 basis for 1994 Fiscal Target by $3,000.
3. Resolution 126 (4/20/93) HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION A8040.4466 - $300
In-service retreat for members of the Human Rights Commission.
262
vote by members
That 1994 Fiscal
October 19, 1993
Increase - 1993 basis for 1994 Fiscal Target.
4. Resolution CA064 (6/15/93) DISTRICT ATTORNEY A1165.4442/.4483
DNA testing and witness fees - $25,500
No increase - 1993 basis for 1994 Fiscal Target.
5. LIBRARY INSURANCE COSTS
Insurance costs for the County will increases in 1994 by $1,906 as a
result of adding the Public Library to the County policy. Since Buildings
and Grounds must pay this premium from their budget, target adjustments
are needed.
Increase 1994 Fiscal Target - BUILDING AND GROUNDS $1,906.
Decrease 1994 Fiscal Target - PUBLIC LIBRARY $1,906.
6. BOARD OF ELECTIONS, Administration A1450
Direct payment by Towns has not occurred.
Increase 1993 basis for 1994 Fiscal Target by $169,096.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 278 - APPOINTMENT OF ELECTION COMMISSIONER FOR 1994-1995
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Tompkins County Republican Committee and Budget
and Administration Committee, That Lee Shurtleff be and hereby is appointed Republican Party
Elections Commissioner for the two-year term commencing January 1, 1994 and ending December 31,
1995.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 279 - RETURNED VILLAGE TAXES
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Mason, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the Director
of Assessment of the County be and hereby is authorized and directed to add to the respective 1994 tax
rolls the amount of the uncollected village taxes returned by the collectors of the various villages to the
County Administrator and remaining unpaid and that have not been heretofore relevied on town tax rolls,
and that said returned village taxes be reassessed and relevied on town tax rolls as they are returned, and
that said returned village taxes be reassessed and relevied upon the lots and parcels so returned with 12.0
percent annual interest in addition thereto.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
263
October 19, 1993
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 280 - RETURNED SCHOOL TAXES
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the Director
of Assessment of the County be and hereby is authorized and directed to add to the respective 1994 tax
rolls the amount of the uncollected school taxes returned by the collectors of the various districts,
exclusive of the City of Ithaca School District, to the County Administrator and remaining unpaid and
that have not been heretofore relevied on town tax rolls and that said returned school taxes be reassessed
and relevied on town tax rolls as they are returned, and that said school taxes returned in 1993 be
reassessed and relevied upon the lots and parcels so returned with 12.0 percent annual interest in addition
thereto.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 281 - ADOPTION OF APPORTIONMENT OF TAXES
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Shurtleff, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the report of
the Budget and Administration Committee be accepted and adopted and that valuation of real property
and franchise for the purposes of general and highway tax levied against the several tax districts of the
County be equalized at full value and determined as therein set forth as the basis for the apportionment
for such general and highway tax levies for the year 1994,
RESOLVED, further, That several amounts therein listed for State tax, County tax for general
county purposes, enterprise fund tax and County highway tax for 1994 against the several towns of the
County and City of Ithaca be assessed against, levied upon and collected from taxable property of the
several towns and City liable therefore.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 282 - ADOPTION OF REGULAR AND SUPPLEMENTAL REPORTS OF
FOOTINGS OF ASSESSMENT ROLLS
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Mason, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the regular
and supplemental report of the footing of assessment rolls be accepted and the figures therein be used as
a basis for the taxation in the several tax districts of the County for the year 1994.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
264
October 19, 1993
SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT OF THE COMMITTEE ON FOOTING
OF ASSESSMENT ROLLS
19 93
TOWNS AND VILLAGES
TOTAL REAL ONLY
EXCLUSIVE OF ALL
EXEMPTIONS -INC.
PUBLIC SERVICE
TOTAL FRANCHISES
REAL PROPERTY AND
FRANCHISE SUBJECT
TO GENERAL AND
HIGHWAY TAX
PENSION EXEMPT
DRYDEN-DRYDEN VILLAGE
-FREEVILLE VILLAGE
TOTAL -INSIDE CORP.
-OUTSIDE CORP.
60,203,154
1,462,315
61,665,469
1,338,346
12,942,650
506,112
13,448,762
1,268,8.50
73,145,804
1,968,427
75,114,231
2,607,196
408,916,609
4,603,702
413,520,311
29,973,091
-TOTALS
482,062,413
6•,572•,129
488,634,542
32,580.,287
GROTON-GROTON VILLAGE
-OUTSIDE CORP.
-TOTALS
47,124,147
759,956
47,884,103
1,524,865
78,848,017
1,569,497
80,417,514
5,253,471
125,972,164
2,329,453
128,301,617
6,778,336
ITHACA-CAYUGA HEIGHTS
-OUTSIDE CORP.
-TOTALS
217,830,320
3,750,899
221,581,219
2,215,680
479,267,223
6,910,772
486,177,995
22,312,935
697,097,543
.10,661,671
707,759,214
24,528,615
LANSING -LANSING VILLAGE
-OUTSIDE CORP.
-TOTALS •
259,198,942
3,734,680
262,933,622
4,619,205
380,648,086
3,400,446
384,048,532
11,618,462
639,847,028
7,135,126
646,982,154
16,237,667
ULYSSES-TRUMANSBURG
-OUTSIDE CORP. .•160,774,304
-TOTALS
52,156,255
1,238,177
53,394,432
945,545
1,729,969
162,504,273
6,416,096
212,930,559
2,968,146
215,898,705
7,361,641
265
October 19, 1993
Report of Committee on Footing of Assessment Rolls
Prepared in 19.q1
To the Board of Representatives of Tompkins County, New York
Your committee reports that it has verified and corrected the footings of the
Assessment Rolls referred to it, as made by the Assessor of Tompkins County and
that the following 1s a correct statement of such footings.
1.
TAX
DISTRICT Acres
2.
Full Value of
Land Exclusive
of Buildings
3.
Full Value of
Real Property
Including Buildings
(Prior to Exemption)
4.
Pension and
Partial Exempt
5.
Special
Franchise
6.
Real Property
of Public
Service'Corp
TONN OF CAROLINE 34,747.
TOWN OF CAROLINE
23
447
200
-
88
260
700
4
016
884
1
666
670
3
118
700
TOWN OF DANBY 33,266
115
28
347
300
101
704
900
108
3
730
121
1
190
415
108
9
565
393
1098. OF DRYDEN 58,286
252
112
539
000
713
458
180
600
521
32
580
287
634
.6
572
129
56
462
100
10W58 OF ENFIELD 22,207
311-
27
865
800
200
91
877
300
029
5
058
464
155
207
681
207
743
2
596
700
TOWN OF GROTON 30,725
28
317
500
126
686
900
6
778
336
TOWN OF GROTON
2
329
453
952
6
063
600
TOWN OP ITHACA 16,293
47
163
063
800
80
705
000
310
54
24
528
615
189
10
661
671
16
625
848
TOWN OF LANSING 37,789
759
146
425
600
581
543
683
900
177
16
237
667
811
7.
135
126
099
112
400
795
TOWN OF NEWFIELD 36,997
219
27
620
900
154
120
846
650
622
4
231
753'
532
2
993
432
050
18
913
263
TOWN OF,ULYSSES 19,818
TOWN OF NEWFIELD
65
605
700
345
216
557
300
7
361
641
'
2
968
146
3
734
900
CITY OF ITHACA 2,940
165
253:
942
900
869
080
800
215
24
611
161.
53
21 .
666
756
162
10
182
218
TOTALS 293,088
080
877
175
700
3
321
879
360
900
129
134
929
318
57
865
005
239
663
517
Dated (109ber 8 19 93
TAX
DISTRICT
7.
Total Taxable Real
and Franchise
Subject to Special
District Taxe
(Total Col. 3-5-6)
8.
Real Property and
Franchise Subject
to GENERAL and
RIGNWAY TAXES
(Col. 7 less Col. 4)
9.
Property Within
Incorp. Villages
Subject to
GENERAL and
HIGHWAY TAXES
10.
Property Outside
' Incorp. Villages
Subject to
GENERAL and
HIGHWAY TAXES
11.
Wholly
Exempt
12.
Grand Total
of Roll
TOWN OF CAROLINE
93
046
070
89
029
186
89
029
186
22
130
040
115
176
110
TOWN OF DANBY
112
460
706
108
730
587
108
730
587
9
252
720
121
713
428
TOWN OF DRYDEN
521
214
829
488
634
542
75y114
231
413
520
311-
144
676
200
665
891
029
TOWN OF ENFIELD
95
155
207
90
096
743
90
096
743
9
490
000
104
645
207
TOWN OF GROTON
135
079
952
128
301
617
47
884
103
80
417
514.
54
531
800
189
611
753
TOWN OP ITHACA
732
287
829
707
759
214
221
581
219
486
177
995
684
811
500
1
417
099
329
TOWN OF LANSING
663
219
821
646
982
154
262
933
622
384
048
532
101
596
050
764
815
871
TOWN OF NEWFIELD
142
753
345
138
521
592
'
138
521
592
22
375
450
165
128
795
TOWN OF ULYSSES
222
260
346
215
898
705
53
394
432
162
504
273',
46
080
000
.
269
340
346
.CITY OF ITHACA
900
929
774
876
318
613
876
318
613
1
176
655
900
2
077
585
674
TOTALS
3
619 407
88j 3
11
490
272 953
111
660
907
607
2
829
365
346,
2
271
599
660
5
891
007
542
266
October 19, 1993
RESOLUTION NO. 283 - RESCISSION OF RESOLUTION NO. 310 OF 1986
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Culligan, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, by Resolution No. 310 of 1986 this Board joined the world community in opposing
apartheid in South Africa and forbade the investment of County taxpayers dollars in banking institutions
that did business with that country, but
WHEREAS, Nelson Mandela has requested and the United Nations General Assembly has
concurred that the time has come to lift sanctions against South Africa in light of progress toward equal
treatment and democracy, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That Resolution
No. 310 of 1986 forbidding the investment of County funds in banks that would not attest to the fact that
they did not do business with South Africa is hereby rescinded.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 284 - NOTICE OF ELECTION BY TOMPKINS COUNTY TO SECURE
WORKER'S COMPENSATION AS A SELF -INSURER
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That Tompkins
County hereby elects to secure Worker's Compensation as a self -insurer effective January 1, 1994,
pursuant to subdivision 3 of section 50 of the Worker's Compensation Law of the State of New York, and
that the County Comptroller and the County Administrator are authorized to execute all documents
necessary to effectuate this change.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 285 - BUDGET ADJUSTMENTS AND APPROPRIATIONS - VARIOUS
DEPARTMENTS
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Ms. Mink. A short roll call resulted as follows: Ayes - 14,
Noes - 0, Excused - 1 (Representative Schuler). Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education, Human Services, Personnel, and
Budget and Administration Committees, That the County Comptroller be authorized to make the
following budget adjustments and appropriations on his books:
BUDGET ADJUSTMENTS
Health
Revenue: A4013.2770 Unclassified Revenues
Appropriation:
Youth Bureau
Revenue:
Appropriation:
A4013.3401
A1989.4463
A7020.2705
A7020.4442
Public Health Work State Aid
Centrally Distributed Items
Gifts/Donations
Prof Svcs/Town of Ithaca
Prof Svcs/Town of Dryden
267
$(23,334)
$ 7,829
$(15,505)
$ 1,550
$ 750
500
Office for the Aging
Revenue: A6785.3803
Appropriation: A6785.1517
.1529
.1215
.2206
.2210
.2230
.2212
.4302
.4430
.4452
.4472
.8810
.8830
.8840
.8860
.8870
.4465
October 19, 1993
Prof Svcs/Village of Lansing
Prof Svcs/Town of Caroline
State Revenue
Salary
Salary
Salary
Computer Equipment
Other Equipment
Computer Software
Table
Supplies
Printing
Postage
Telephone
Retirement
Social Security
Worker's Compensation
Health Insurance
Unemployment Insurance
Job Necessitated Travel and Training
Mental Health
Revenue: A4314.3488 ICM State Aid
Appropriation: A4314.4606 Mental Health Admin.
APPROPRIATIONS from 1992 Surplus
Comptroller
Revenue: A0599.0000 General Fund Balance
Appropriation: A9576.4816 Contribution to Construction
Personnel
Revenue: A0599.0000
Appropriation: A1430.2206
Office for Aging
Revenue: A0599.0000
Appropriation: A6772.2206
.2212
General Fund Balance
Computer Equipment
General Fund Balance
Computer Equipment
Desks and Tables
Administration - Room Tax
Revenue: A0593.0000 Room Tax Fund Balance
Appropriation: A6475.4504 Chamber of Commerce
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator be and hereby is
necessary contracts to convey these funds.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
250
50
$ 3,452
$ 1,835
96
77
212
511
21
12
90
30
8
33
70
153
11
221
12
60
$ 1,200
$ 1,200
$ 18,781
$ 18,781
$ 720
$ 720
$ 665
$ 575
90
$ 59,251
$ 59,251
authorized to execute the
RESOLUTION NO. 286 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE PURCHASE AGREEMENT AND
DEED
268
October 19, 1993
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Mason, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
RESOLVED, That the County Administrator is authorized to execute a purchase agreement and
deed to convey Town of Enfield Tax Parcels 16-2-5 and 16-2-2.13 to Christopher Muka of Newfield,
New York for $6,800.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
It was Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to lift from the Table Resolution No. 251 - Approval of Acceptance of Local Initiative
Monies - Six Mile Creek Project.
It was Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to Table Resolution No. 251 - Approval of Acceptance of Local Initiative Monies - Six
Mile Creek Project to the November 3 Board meeting. (Adopted November 16, 1993)
Chairman Watros declared recess at 7:27 p.m. The meeting reconvened at 7:35 p.m.
It was Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans, and adopted unanimously by voice vote by
members present, to hold an executive session to discuss collective bargaining negotiations and real
estate negotiations. An executive session was held at 7:35 p.m. and returned to open session at 8:09 p.m.
RESOLUTION NO. 287 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE PURCHASE AGREEMENT AND
QUIT CLAIM DEED, TOWN OF DRYDEN TAX MAP PARCEL 59-
1-36.1
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Ms. Mink, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
RESOLVED, That the County Administrator is authorized to execute a purchase agreement and
quit claim deed conveying Town of Dryden tax parcel 59-1-36.1, acquired by the County through 1992
tax foreclosure, to Joseph Tilton of 224 Brookside Lane, Newfield, New York for the sum of five
thousand ($5,000) dollars, with the appropriate commission to be paid to Patterson Real Estate according
to the County's contract with that Agency.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
It was Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to appoint Becky Bilderback to the Tompkins County Planning Board to represent the
Town of Caroline for a term which expires December 31, 1996.
Chairman Watros appointed Charles Evans, Personnel Committee Chairman and Anita Fitzpatrick,
Personnel Commissioner, to serve on the Tompkins Cortland Community College Negotiating
Committee.
On motion the meeting adjourned at 8:15 p.m.
269
November 3, 1993
Regular Meeting
Chairman Watros called the meeting to order at 5:36 p.m.
Chairman Watros, on behalf of the Board, extended condolences to Mr. Hugh Hurlburt on the loss
of his wife, Lois Hurlbut.
Members and guests participated in the Pledge of Allegiance.
Present: 14 Representatives. Excused: 1 (Representative Schuler).
Under privilege of the floor, Claudia Cinquaniti, Department of Social Services Employee, spoke
concerning air quality at Biggs A and expressed frustration at administrators.
Under privilege of the floor, Sharon Prezioso McLaughlin, Department of Social Services
Employee, spoke concerning air quality at Biggs A. She urged the Board to consider a satellite office.
Under privilege of the floor, Yvonne Bartlett, Department of Social Services Employee, spoke
concerning air quality at Biggs A. Ms. Bartlett spoke of financial difficulties and expressed frustration at
Tompkins County administration. Ms. Bartlett stated that she has not refused any accommodations to
return to work. "
Under privilege of the floor, Mamie Kirchgessner, Human Rights Commission Employee, spoke
concerning air quality at Biggs A. Ms. Kirchgessner stated that she feels the County does not fully
understand the disease known as multiple chemical sensitivities. She asked that the Board investigate the
possibility of a satellite office to house sick employees to do their work.
Under privilege of the floor, Ann Rider, Department of Social Services Employee and Chair of the
CSEA Local 855, stated CSEA is eager to join together with the County to work towards total quality
management as well as with other policies of the County.
Under privilege of the floor, Barbara Mahoney, former Depaitment of Social Services Employee,
stated that although she now has another job, she still suffers the effects of multiple chemical sensitivities
which she believes she has as a result of working in Biggs A. Ms. Mahoney urged the Board to better
inform themselves on the disease.
Under Privilege of the floor, Mel Bartlett, husband of Yvonne Bartlett who is a Depaitinent of
Social Services Employee, spoke of financial difficulties his family is facing as a result of his wife not
working. Mr. Bartlett believes there needs to be better communication within the County.
Under privilege of the floor, Henry Vaughan, Chairman, Neighborhood Advisory Committee for
the Commercial Avenue Central Processing Facility, spoke concerning the Tompkins County Recycling
and Solid Waste Center. Mr. Vaughan stated the following points:
1. The Commercial Avenue site is a high-risk location: He stated a primary concern of the
Committee is that the location is a potentially obnoxious facility in a location that is adjacent to some of
the most expensive and tax productive properties in the County.
2. Adequate Funding of Maintenance: He stated that one of the biggest concerns of the
Committee is ensuring continued adequate funding of the operation and maintenance of the Facility. He
stated that the County's original DEIS (Draft Environmental Impact Statement) said that the Facility
would be kept clean by hosing it down daily with hot water. The Committee feels that after approvals
were received, budgetary pressures caused the daily cleaning to be modified to only daily sweepings.
270
November 3, 1993
3. Private vs. Public Operation: While it appears that the selection of CRInc. is a reasonable
choice, the Committee hopes that the contract will contain adequate safeguards for those who must live
near the Facility.
4. The "Observation Platform": The Committee feels to ensure its trust that the Facility will in no
way harm them, that it is a good idea to operate the proposed Facility in a manner that is continuously
exposed to public scrutiny. He also believes that public education about the costs and processes for
handling our waste is an important function and this observation area can be used effectively for that
purpose.
Mr. Vaughan concluded his remarks stating that the businesses located near the Facility pay
approximately $250,000 annually in property taxes and generate about one-third of the County's sales
taxes. If the Facility adversely impacts these businesses, the cost to the County would greatly exceed any
savings that County may realize by eliminating that feature.
Mrs. Livesay stated that the change in the cleaning of the Facility was not a result of budget
pressures. She stated that the dry sweepings will be done as a safety measure.
Ms. Mink, Chair, Human Services Committee, on behalf of members of the Board, expressed the
sympathy and feeling members of the Board have for those who are out of work. She stated that there are
many efforts being made behind the scenes and it is the intention of the Board to return employees to
work.
James Kazda, Senior Civil Engineer for the Public Works Department, stated that he participated
in a walk through of the accommodation space at the Biggs building with Fred Thomas Associates, Greg
Siwinski, and staff. Mr. Kazda stated that equipment has been installed and is properly functioning.
Other minor modifications requested by Mr. Siwinski to be made to the room and surrounding areas of
the building are: insulate windows in the office, remove air conditioner, undercut the door to the office
to provide circulation and put final connections on a water cooler located outside the office. He stated
that these modifications are expected to be completed by the end of the week. At this point a meeting is
to be planned with Mr. Siwinski and employees to see if they are ready to return to the space on Monday.
Mr. Stein, Chairman, Planning Committee, stated that that the air quality problem in the Biggs A
building is a serious and complex issue. He stated that the Public Works and Construction Management
Committee has approved $6.4 million to bring the Biggs A Building heating and ventilation systems up to
standard first class office space. This $6.4 million is to be included in the 1994 Capital Budget to be
voted on at the November 30 budget meeting of the Board. Mr. Stein expressed great concern that the
Board would not have an opportunity to discuss this proposed Capital Project in detail prior to that
meeting, therefore, is bringing the issue up this evening.
Mr. Stein stated that this is a very critical and complex issue. Some of the issues he sees are:
health, initial and long range cost, maintenance and operation costs, service to clientele (which is a
location issue), program issues and the relationship to the community. He stated that by investing $6.4
million, it is his judgment that the County would be making a 25-50 year decision to stay on West Hill
and to have all services provided out of that building. He stated that the study originated in the Human
Services Committee and was brought to the Planning Committee. Ms. Mink, Chair, Human Services
Committee, stated that plans have been underway for a couple of years to fix overdue problems in Biggs.
When people came forward with problems they were experiencing from the building, it focused attention
more sharply on what kind of investment the County would make in that building. She also feels that
investing $6.4 million would make West Hill the "County Campus". She also expressed her support for
services to be brought downtown.
271
November 3, 1993
Mr. Stein stated that after a preliminary report was presented to the Planning Committee which
considered different locations and costs of those locations and was reported on in the newspaper, he
received a phone call from a local private development group who commented that they read the report
and felt some of the figures used were not accurate with ones that have experienced and asked if the
County would be interested in receiving what they felt figures should be. Mr. Stein stated that there were
no negotiations but in the spirit of seeking information, he and others met with this development group
and came away with additional information that helped with the study being presented this evening. Mr.
Stein stated that if there is any other development group or person that has information that they feel
would be useful in helping the County with its deliberations on this subject, the information would be
welcomed with the understanding that this would not be any type of negotiation. At this point he stated
he does not feel he has enough information to spend $6.4 million on the Biggs Building. He feels a study
relating to the issues needs to be undertaken and questions of health and air quality need to be addressed.
Mr. Stein introduced James Hanson, Planning Commissioner, who distributed a preliminary spreadsheet
of costs and revenues for Biggs Building A Options dated November 3, 1993 which contains five options
with projected costs. Those options are as follows:
Option I: Building a four -floor addition to the Mental Health Building, plus a 6 -story addition to
the current parking lot.
Option II: Construction of a six -story, 11,000 square foot building on the site of the current "C"
or Annex building, where Assessment, Central Data Processing and the Board of Elections is located.
These Departments would be located in the new building, as well as the Biggs depai liiients.
Option III: The current Biggs Building A, with a new heating, ventilation and air conditioning
system. The architectural enhancements are not included in the cost of this project.
Option IV: Construction of a privately -developed building to house the Biggs depaltments. The
assumption is made of $100 construction costs per square food and 2/3 County contribution to a new
parking garage and parking maintenance.
Option V. Privately -developed building with the County paying 1/3 of the cost of parking and
parking maintenance.
After an explanation of figures presented in the spreadsheet Board members discussed the various
options and costs. Mr. Proto requested information on the cost of building on the existing Biggs Building
A property. Mrs. Call mentioned that the consolidation of Human Service agencies in the same building
should also be looked at in this process. Mr. Stein concluded the presentation by stating that there were
several good questions raised but not enough information for the Board to make a decision on this subject
at this time.
Mr. Proto, Chairman, Health and Education Committee, reported that the Committee met last
week and completed its budget deliberations. Mr. Proto reported on the recent dedication to Dr. Racker
by the Special. The next Committee meeting will be November 30.
Mr. Evans, Chairman, Personnel Committee, reported that the Committee has not met nor held any
negotiation sessions since the last Board meeting. Children's Center. Mr. Evans stated that the next
Committee meeting will be December 2 at 8 a.m. Mr. Evans stated that he will request an executive
session.
Ms. Mink, Chair, Human Services Committee, reported that the Committee met to review
departmental budgets. She also announced that Joan Bordonet has been awarded the "Service to Youth
Award" by the Tompkins County Youth Board. The next Committee meeting will be December 7.
Mr. Mason, Chairman, Public Safety Committee, reported that the Committee met November 1
and completed its deliberations on departmental budgets. The Committee also discussed with the
Criminal Justice Advisory/Alternatives to Incarceration Board a process for reviewing plans that were
272
November 3, 1993
developed pursuant to a charge given to the Board by resolution. The next Committee meeting will be
December 2.
Mr. Winch, Chairman, Public Works and Construction Management Committee, reported that the
Committee met today and its business is reflected on the agenda. Mr. Winch reported that Airport
construction is moving forward quite well.
Mr. Todd, Fiscal Affairs Committee, reported that he will ask that Resolution No. 268 be left on
the Table until the November 16 Board meeting. He reported on a presentation the Fiscal Affairs
Committee received from Ronald Dougherty, Chairman of the Tioga County Legislature concerning the
Tioga County Council of Government which formed in April, 1991. This Council included
representatives from nine towns and government and explores areas of cooperation between
municipalities. Mr. Todd stated that this has worked to a certain degree in Tioga County.
Mr. Lerner, Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, reported that the
Committee met October 28 to review the proposed 1994 budget for Solid Waste. He stated that a public
hearing concerning the proposed Tompkins County Solid Waste Management Plan will be held
November 9 at 7:30 p.m. at the Holiday Inn. Mr. Lerner stated that he expects the Board to adjourn to a
Committee of the Whole on November 16 to discuss the 1994 Solid Waste budget,. He expects to
receive advisement on this process from Mr. Mulvey, County Attorney, and will circulate copies to
Board members.
Mrs. Call, Chair, Budget and Administration Committee, reported that the Committee has not met
since the last Board meeting. She stated that budget deliberations will begin November 9.
Mr. Heyman, County Administrator, reported that Anita Fitzpatrick, Commissioner of Personnel,
received an award from the Office of Vocational Rehabilitation.
Mr. Mulvey, County Attorney, reported that his monthly report has been filed in the Board office.
On motion of the appropriate committee chairmen and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by
voice vote by members present, the following resolutions were added to the agenda:
Approval of the Annual Implementation Report of the Consolidated Services Plan - Depai tment of
Social Services
Sense of the Board with Respect to the Biggs A Renovation Project
Chairman Watros gave Mrs. Call, Chair, Budget and Administration Committee, permission to
withdraw from the agenda the resolution entitled Increase in Hours - Chief Natural Resources Planner —
Planning.
Chairman Watros gave the appropriate committee chairman permission to withdraw from the
agenda the following resolution with final committee action being affirmed:
CA098-93 - Award of Bid - Composting Bins
RESOLUTION NO. 288 - RESOLUTION TO ACCEPT GRANT - WRAP PROGRAM
Moved by Ms. Mink, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
273
November 3, 1993
WHEREAS, there is a need to improve energy efficiency in the homes of many low income
seniors for reasons of both good health and cost efficiency, and
WHEREAS, the New York State Office for Aging has awarded a grant for such purposes to the
Tompkins County Office for the Aging under its Weatherization Referral and Packaging Program, now
therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Human Services Committee, That the Office for the
Aging be authorized to accept the sum of $3,881,
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller be authorized to make the following budget
adjustments in the 1993 budget:
Account Number Amount
Revenue A6796.3803 State Revenue $3,881
Appropriations A6796.1517 Salary $2,196
A6796.4302 Office Supplies 16
A6796.4330 Printing 58
A6796.4465 Job -Related Travel 216
and Training
A6796.4472 Telephone 67
A6796.8810 Retirement 76
A6796.8830 Social Security 151
A6796.8840 Worker's Comp. 7
A6796.8860 Health Insurance 1,081
A6796.8870 Unemployment 13
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 289 - APPROVAL OF THE ANNUAL IMPLEMENTATION REPORT OF
THE CONSOLIDATED SERVICES PLAN - DEPARTMENT OF
SOCIAL SERVICES
Moved by Ms. Mink, seconded by Mrs. Call. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 14,
Noes - 0, Excused - 1 (Representative Schuler). Adopted.
WHEREAS, the Depaitment has prepared a multi-year Consolidated Services Plan (1991-1994)
which identifies program priorities in the areas of adoption, foster care services for children, preventive
services for children, protective services for adults, protective services for children, and other adult
children and family services, and
WHEREAS, the Consolidated Services Plan requires an annual update on program information be
submitted to the New York State Depaitnient of Social Services, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Human Services Committee, That the 1994 Annual
Implementation Report of the Depait,uent's Consolidated Services Plan be approved and signed by the
Chairman of the Board of Representatives.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 290 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE CONSULTANT CONTRACT -
CULINARY TRAINING OF NUTRITION AMBASSADORS FROM
DIVERSITY CHURCHES IN TOMPKINS COUNTY - HEALTHY
HEART PROGRAM
274
November 3, 1993
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, the Cayuga -Tompkins Healthy Heart Program (CTHHP) has laid plans to work with
the multicultural population through their churches as part of the Five -A -Day campaign and has been told
that the communities that already have Healthy Heart programs will probably not be awarded mini -grant
funding this year, and
WHEREAS, after reviewing our State budget for 1993-1994, the Program has sufficient funds to
carry out the project: Using a local chef to train ten (10) nutrition ambassadors on heart health (from
November 1993 through March 1994), Five -A -Day techniques, and the art of demonstrating cooking so
that resources will be in the five diversity churches to assist in becoming heart healthy churches, now
therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education Committee, That the County
Administrator is authorized to execute a contract with Jay Solomon to carry out the above training,
RESOLVED, further, That there are sufficient funds in Professional Service Fees, A4021.4442 to
complete this project.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 291 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE CONTRACT - GROUP HEALTH
INSURANCE INC. - HEALTH DEPARTMENT
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Shurtleff, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, Group Health Insurance Inc. (GHI) requires a contract in order for the Health
Department Certified Home Health Agency to become a participating provider and receive payments for
services direct, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education Committee, That the County
Administrator is hereby authorized to sign any and all agreements necessary to complete this process.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 292 - AWARD OF BID - PLANT MATERIALS - NEW PASSENGER
TERMINAL - TOMPKINS COUNTY AIRPORT
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, the Division of Purchasing and Central Services has duly advertised the bids for the
Plant Materials for the new Passenger Terminal, and
WHEREAS, four (4) bids were received and publicly opened on Friday, October 15, 1993, now
therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the bid be awarded to Paolangeli Contractors of Ithaca as the lowest responsible bidder with a base
bid of $174,500,
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator is hereby authorized to execute an agreement
with Paolangeli Contractors on behalf of the County,
RESOLVED, further, That the remaining budgeted funds of $40,500 be allocated for
miscellaneous project expense, staff services, construction testing and change orders,
275
November 3, 1993
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator is authorized to execute change orders up to
a total of ten (10) percent of the contract value with funds available from Account No. HU 5610.9239.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 293 - RESOLUTION SUPPORTING ISTEA FUNDING FOR THE
DOWNSTREAM FOREST HOME BRIDGE
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mrs. Livesay. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 13,
Noes - 0, Excused — 1 (Representative Schuler), Abstentions - 1 (Representative Stein). Adopted.
WHEREAS, the downstream bridge at Forest Home Drive over Fall Creek (BIN3047440) needs to
be replaced at an estimated cost of $349,255, and
WHEREAS, the bridge is eligible for listing on the State Register of Historic Places and the
community supports historic restoration or rehabilitation of the structure, and
WHEREAS, replacement of the bridge appears to qualify for funding under the ISTEA
Transportation Enhancement Program which requires a minimum non-federal share of 20 percent, now
therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the Tompkins County Board of Representatives supports this project and hereby agrees to provide
$180,000 in non-federal funds for the project (52 percent) and that these funds will be available starting
January, 1994 if needed,
RESOLVED, further, That the Commissioner of Public Works be and hereby is authorized to
execute an agreement with New York State Department of Transportation (NYSDOT) on behalf of
Tompkins County if the proposal is approved for programming.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 294 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE AGREEMENTS WITH
RESIDENTS OF SLATERVILLE SPRINGS
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present. Chairman Watros asked Mr. Winch to report back to the Board.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the County Administrator is hereby authorized to execute agreements with residents of Slaterville
Springs related to the construction of Buffalo Road over Six Mile Creek (BIN 3209760) and/or related to
well water conditions in the vicinity of said construction project,
RESOLVED, further, That the Public Works and Construction Management Committee shall
review and approve each agreement prior to execution by the County Administrator.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 295 - AUTHORIZING A PUBLIC HEARING ON PROPOSED LOCAL
LAW NO. 5 OF 1993 - AMENDING LOCAL LAW NO. 1 OF 1993 -
AUTHORIZING THE ESTABLISHMENT OF AN ANNUAL FEE
FOR SOLID WASTE FOR REAL PROPERTY IN TOMPKINS
COUNTY
276
November 3, 1993
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Lerner. Discussion followed concerning the mailing date of
the bills. Mrs. Livesay stated that she was unaware the mailing date was changed to August. A voice
vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 14, Noes - 0, Excused - 1 (Representative Schuler). Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That a public
hearing be held before the Board of Representatives at Board Chambers of the Tompkins County
Courthouse, 320 North Tioga Street, Ithaca, New York on Tuesday, December 7, 1993 at 5:30 o'clock in
the evening thereof on proposed Local Law No. 5 of 1993 Amending Local Law No. 1 of 1993 -
Authorizing the Establishment of an Annual Fee for Solid Waste for Real Property in Tompkins County.
At such time and place all persons interested in the subject matter will be heard concerning the same,
RESOLVED, further, That the Clerk of the Board is hereby authorized and directed to place
proper notice of such public hearing in.the official newspaper of the County.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 296 - SENSE OF THE BOARD WITH RESPECT TO THE BIGGS A.
RENOVATION PROJECT
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, Tompkins County is considering a capital program of $6.4 million to renovate the
Biggs A Building, including heating, ventilation and architectural improvements, to bring the building up
to modern air and space quality standards and improve the efficiency of the space of the Biggs A
building, and
WHEREAS, the Planning Committee requested that the Planning Department examine the
potential options to the full renovation to the Biggs A Building, and
WHEREAS, the long-range space needs for many of the depai lnients located in the Biggs A
Building cannot currently be assured, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, That the Planning Committee has recommended that the Capital Program address
only priority problems such as ventilation, thereby limiting the County's cost,
RESOLVED, further, That it is the sense of this Board that a space planning study be undertaken
to review and analyze both the short-term operations needs for the immediate five-year period as well as
analyze the long-term service objectives associated with those agencies in the Biggs complex and that
appropriate funds be allocated for these purposes in the Capital Program,
RESOLVED, further, That it is the sense of this Board that the Capital Program project for Biggs
Building A shall only include sufficient funding to address the ventilation problem identified in that
building.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 251 - APPROVAL OF ACCEPTANCE OF LOCAL INITIATIVE MONIES -
SIX MILE CREEK PROJECT (Adopted November 16, 1993)
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present, to lift this resolution from the Table. It was Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mr. Proto, and
unanimously adopted by voice vote by members present, to postpone this resolution to the November 16,
1993 Board meeting.
277
November 3, 1993
RESOLUTION NO. 268 - ESTABLISHMENT OF THE TOMPKINS COUNTY LEADERSHIP
COUNCIL AND COMMITMENT TO AN ORGANIZATIONAL
CHANGE INITIATIVE TO IMPROVE THE EFFICIENCY,
EFFECTIVENESS AND QUALITY OF COUNTY SERVICES
(Adopted November 16, 1993)
Moved by Mr. Todd, seconded by Mrs. Call, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present, to lift this resolution from the Table. It was Moved by Mr. Todd, seconded by Mrs. Call, and
unanimously adopted by voice vote by members present, to postpone this resolution to the November 16,
1993 Board meeting.
On motion of the appropriate committee chairman and duly seconded any unanimously adopted by
voice vote by members present, the following appointments were made to various advisory boards:
Environmental Management Council
Term expires December 31, 1995
Nancy Ostman - At -large representative
Planning Board
Term expires December 31, 1996
Herbert Engman - Environmental Management Council Representative
Chairman Watros announced that if anyone is interested in participating in the Veteran's Day
Parade November 17, 1993, they should see him.
On motion the meeting adjourned at 8:12 p.m.
278
November 9, 1993
Public Hearing
Solid Waste Management Plan
Holiday Inn, Ithaca, New York
The public hearing was called to order at 7:30 p.m. by Mr. Lerner, Chairman of the Solid Waste
and Resource Management Committee, concerning the draft Solid Waste Management Plan.
Mr. Lerner began by introducing the following people present:
Eric Lerner, Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee
Robert Watros, Chairman, Board of Representatives
Daniel Winch, Representative, District No. 8
Beverly Livesay, Representative, District No. 11
Stuart Stein, Representative, District No. 3
Barbara Blanchard, Representative Elect, District No. 1
Michael Lane, Representative Elect, District No. 14
Barbara Eckstrom, Solid Waste Manager
Kenneth Thompson, Solid Waste Assistant Manager
Thomas Richardson, Recycling Supervisor
Jonathan Wood, Assistant County Attorney
Sharon Conley, Recourse Systems
Catherine Covert, Clerk of the Board
Michelle Pottorff, Deputy Clerk of the Board
Mr. Lerner said the comments made this evening will be incorporated into the Plan and
distributed to the people speaking. There is a thirty (30) day comment period for the draft Generic
Environmental Impact Statement of the Tompkins County Solid Waste Management Plan which begins
October 19 and ends November 23, 1993.
Mr. Lerner continued by giving a background summary of the Plan. It has been several years in
the making. He said he is satisfied that the Plan comes close to being the best that the people of this
County can do to manage solid waste. This is a twenty (20) year Plan. The previous way solid waste
was disposed of is no longer acceptable. Over the last fifteen (15) years the Federal Government and
New York State Government have required by law that localities change the way they dispose of solid
waste due to leachate problems. No one realized ten (10) to fifteen (15) years ago what an expensive and
complex project it was going to be. Solid waste is disposed of in the most environmentally -sound cost-
effective way possible. The challenge is to find ways to dispose of garbage which is in compliance with
laws and regulations and which reduces the cost of garbage within the framework of State mandates.
Mr. Lerner addressed the concerns that have been raised associated with staffing at the Solid
Waste Division. When people wonder about clerical staff in Solid Waste, there is a lot of office work as
well as physical work involved.
It was the County's original intent to build a DEC (Department of Environmental Conservation)
regulated landfill. Tompkins County has abandoned the DR -7 site. The basic plan in Tompkins County
is based on economies of scale. The cost per ton for disposing of solid waste in a Tompkins County
sized landfill would be more expensive than the alternative -- to take bids from the private sector for the
disposal of solid waste. The disposal method has to comply with DEC regulations and State laws.
These bids would include transportation and tipping to a facility location. There is approximately
60,000 tons per year of solid waste to dispose of in Tompkins County. It would cost $1 million at $70
279
November 9, 1993
per ton for disposal. The County has to look at alternative ways to reduce the per ton cost and find long
range ways to dispose of garbage while complying with State mandates.
Tompkins County is building a recycling center where garbage will be sorted and handled in
different ways. Some sorted materials require additional processing making them more marketable and
less expensive to truck. The Recycling Facility is intended to give us maximum capability and
flexibility. There is currently an interim composting facility in Danby and the County is in the process of
developing a larger composting facility. It would be to the County's advantage to be able to compost at a
cost less than transporting. Finally, early stages of developing waste reduction strategies to reduce the
amount of waste include public education, waste exchange programs and a lot of room for creative
thought for cost effectiveness. Another major component includes the closure of landfills in Tompkins
County by the DEC. The County has to comply with DEC regulations in the closure process while
assuming a $1 million cost for the process.
Jonathan Wood, Assistant County Attorney, explained the SEQR (State Environmental Quality
Review) process. He stated that as part of the Solid Waste Management Plan the State requires the
County to comply with the SEQR Act. The draft GEIS (Generic Environmental Impact Statement) is
required by Law to have a public comment period of thirty (30) days. The Law does not necessarily
require a public hearing but the County is conducting a public hearing to allow maximum public
comment. The comment period ends November 23. All substantive comments and their responses will
become part of the final Plan.
Mr. Lerner stated that copies of the sixteen -page Executive Summary is available in addition to
the two-page summary.
Mr. Ernest Bury, 206 Valley Road, Ithaca, stated that he heard the Plan will allow for a lot of
flexibility. He stated every dollar invested in anything represents a dollar of consumption and stated he
is appalled about a $5.6 million contract with CRInc. He views other alternatives for the County to be:
the Triangle Steel Facility which is on the market and is twice as big and is being sold for $.5 million. It
is also on a rail line. Mr. Bury stated by using this facility the County would be "reusing and recycling" a
large facility. The rail line has several important components. Garbage would not have to hauled on
County roads and would not be creating pollution. The sale of recyclables on a rail car is worth $10
more per ton. A second alternative would be for the County to take advantage of a standing offer from a
neighboring county. The offer would allow the County to receive the same price as is listed in the
CRInc. contract. Mr. Bury feels a third issue is the Supreme Court has yet to rule on the flow control
law. Mr. Bury believes the law is unconstitutional and if it is overturned it means it will have a profound
impact on the economics and the only alternative would be to find other sources of revenues. For the
County that other source of income would be through property taxes. Mr. Bury stated he truly hopes the
law will be overturned.
Barbara Blanchard, 316 Brookfield Road, Ithaca, stated she is not generally supportive of the
concepts of the County's Solid Waste Management Plan. She feels the County's approach to solid waste
management is unrealistic and unreasonable philosophy. She is opposed to the placement of the
Tompkins County Recycling and Solid Waste Center at its location as a City of Ithaca Representative.
She commented on a County Committee meeting where discussion took place on State mandates. Ms.
Blanchard questioned the County's interpretation of those mandates. She stated she has concerns with
the finance section of the Plan. She stated she would like to have section 490 of the Real Property Tax
Law amended to include an exemption for special assessments for solid waste improvements and for
which special ad valorem levies and assessments can be imposed. It would be the same process as with
the water improvements and sidewalk improvements without the amendment in the Law. She does not
feel the current legislation can continue. She asked the County to look at the proposal the City of Ithaca
280
November 9, 1993
advanced in 1990 that had to do with the tax law to see if that would provide a more fairer way to finance
the plan.
8 p.m.
No other member of the public wished to comment and the public hearing was declared closed at
281
November 16, 1993
Regular Meeting
Chairman Watros called the meeting to order at 5:30 p.m.
Members and guests participated in the Pledge of Allegiance.
Present: 14 Representatives. (Representative Livesay arrived at 5:35 p.m.). Excused: 1
(Representative Joseph).
It was Moved by Mr. Evans, seconded by Ms. Mink, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to approve the minutes of November 3, 1993.
Chairman Watros presented a proclamation declaring December 1, 1993 as World Aids Day and
the week of November 30 - December 6, 1993 as HIV/AIDS Awareness Week in Tompkins County.
Pat Pryor, Member of the AIDS Work Board of Directors, accepted the proclamation and thanked
the Board for their past and continued support of the efforts of AIDS Work of Tompkins County.
Under privilege of the floor, Ernest Bury, Valley Road, Ithaca, distributed copies of the Tompkins
County Solid Waste Management Plan Executive Summary. Mr. Bury expressed his opinion that he
believes that there are legal problems because the County has not included costs for transportation in the
Plan. Mr. Bury also stated that he does not feel it is cheaper to recycle.
Under privilege of the floor, Mr. Lerner, Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management
Committee, addressed comments made by Mr. Bury concerning legal problems he feel exist in the
proposed Solid Waste Management Plan relating to the transportation of solid waste.
Under privilege of the floor, Mr. Proto, Representative, District No. 7, stated he is perplexed that
the Board has not taken a position on NAFTA (North American Free Trade Agreement). He stated that
he feels the County would greatly benefit by this. Mr. Proto urged members of the Board to express their
opinion and support this as he feels it can only serve to help and enhance Tompkins County.
Under privilege of the floor, Mr. Culligan, Representative, District No. 2, stated that the Ithaca
City School District is now allowing a five-day grace period on the payment of taxes for the medium and
low income. Mr. Culligan requested that the Budget and Administration Committee look into the
legalities of the County giving a four-day grace period.
Members of the Board acknowledged those individuals who have been elected to succeed them in
January.
Mr. Proto, Chairman, Health and Education Committee, reported that Tompkins Cortland
Community College continues to move along the path the Board approved for planning functions. Mr.
Proto also reported on a letter he received from Joseph Pullman, Cortland County Mental Health
Clinician, in which Mr. Pullman described his use of Tompkins County Information and Referral service.
Mention was also made concerning an extension of Tompkins County's catchment area to involve
Cortland County.
Mr. Evans, Chairman, Personnel Committee, reported that the Committee has reached a tentative
agreement with the Blue Collar CSEA (Civil Service Employees Association). He stated that
negotiations continue with the White Collar and Tompkins Cortland Community College. The next
Committee meeting will be December 2.
282
November 16, 1993
Ms. Mink, Chair, Human Services Committee, reported that two employees who have been out of
work with sick building syndrome have returned to work. She stated that she hopes everyone that can
will be back to work soon. The next Committee meeting will be December 7 at 10 a.m.
Mr. Mason, Chairman, Public Safety Committee, reported that the E911 Task Force will meet
tomorrow at the Crash, Fire, Rescue Building at 10:30 a.m. He stated he plans to report back to the
Board at the next meeting as to what direction the County should go.
Mr. Stein, Chairman, Planning Committee, reported that the Committee will meet November 18 at
9:30 a.m.
Mr. Winch, Chairman, Public Works and Construction Management Committee, gave an update
on construction at the Airport. He stated that the weather has allowed a considerable amount of outside
work to be completed and work is on schedule.
Mr. Todd, Chairman, Fiscal Affairs Committee, had no report.
Mr. Lerner, Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, reported that a public
hearing was held on November 9 on the proposed Tompkins County Solid Waste Management Plan and
thanked Board members who were in attendance. Mr. Lerner stated that several solid waste advisory
committee seats will become vacant in January. Mr. Lerner also reported that the Neighborhood
Advisory Committee for the Commercial Avenue Central Processing Facility has developed a draft of a
neighborhood watch plan for Elmira Road which the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee
will be reviewing.
Mrs. Livesay, Intergovernmental Representative, announced that a meeting will be held with
municipal officials to discuss television cable franchise opportunities and illegal dumping of solid waste.
The meeting will be held November 17 at 7:30 p.m. in the Mental Health conference room.
Mrs. Call, Chair, Budget and Administration Committee, reported that the Committee has met
several times since last month and has conducted committee business and budget reviews. Mrs. Call
stated that there is one vacancy on the Community Affirmative Action Advisory Board. Mrs. Call
welcomed Wendy Skinner who will be handling the Ithaca Journal's coverage of governmental affairs.
The next Committee meeting will be December 14.
Mr. Heyman, County Administrator, commented on figures appearing in the budget document
placed on members' desks. Mr. Heyman stated that there will be an information session concerning the
proposed 1994 Tompkins County budget on November 23 at 7 p.m. This session will be telecast live on
channel 53. Cheryl Nelson, Chair, Employee Council, submitted a written statement on the Council's
work for the last month.
Mr. Mulvey, County Attorney, had no report.
Chairman Watros announced that Cornell Cooperative Extension will be conducting an
informational session for elected public officials on November 29 and December 6.
On motion of the appropriate committee chairman and duly seconded and unanimously adopted by
voice vote by members present, the following resolutions were added to the agenda:
Urging the New York State Legislature to Act on Workers' Compensation Reform
Authorization to Execute Agreement with Third Party Administrator for Self Insurance of
Worker's Compensation Claims, Transfer from Departmental Worker's Compensation Claims,
283
November 16, 1993
Transfer from Departmental Worker's Compensation Subaccounts to Worker's Compensation
Insurance Reserve Account, and Authorization to Execute Agreement with Sedgwick James,
Inc., as Broker for Catastrophic Loss Insurance Coverage for Worker's Compensation Claims
Chairman Watros gave the appropriate committee chairmen permission to withdraw from the
agenda the following resolutions with final committee action being affirmed:
CA099-93 - Award of Bid - Copiers - Purchasing and Central Services
CA100-93 - Award of Bid - Food Commodities
RESOLUTION NO. 297 - AUTHORIZATION TO APPLY FOR STATE FUNDING -
DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL SERVICES
Moved by Ms. Mink, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Human Services and Budget and Administration
Committees, That the Department of Social Services is authorized to apply for $23,933 in 100 percent
State funding for providing Energy Services Packaging activities to eligible qualifying households. Such
services shall include identifying energy -vulnerable households, assessment of energy-related needs,
interfacing with community service providers, conservation education efforts, and evaluation and
reporting to New York State Department of Social Services.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 298 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE AGREEMENT - RMSCO, INC.
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the County
Administrator is directed to execute an agreement with RMSCO, Inc. to provide Flexible Benefits
Account Plan Administrative Services from January 1, 1994 to December 31, 1994, at a cost of $6,600
annually.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 299 - AUTHORIZATION FOR COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR TO JOIN
THE AMERICAN SOCIETY FOR QUALITY CONTROL (ASQC)
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the County
Administrator is hereby authorized to join the American Society for Quality Control (ASQC). Funds are
available in Account No. A1989.4903, Centrally Distributed Items, Inservice Education.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
284
November 16, 1993
RESOLUTION NO. 300 - AUTHORIZING AN AMENDMENT TO AGREEMENT — MICHELLE
LOVEJOY - COUNTY ATTORNEY'S OFFICE
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the County
Administrator be authorized to execute an addendum to an agreement with Michelle Lovejoy for the
provision of secretarial and paralegal services to extend Ms. Lovejoy's services through December 31,
1993.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 301 - ADOPTION OF 1994 TOMPKINS COUNTY BUDGET AND
CAPITAL PROGRAM (Adopted December 7, 1993)
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Shurtleff. Mr. Todd, Representative, District No. 6, began
discussion stating he feels that the budget as presented is unacceptable. As a result of the sales tax
agreement, revenues in towns and villages are up and there is no property tax increase expected from the
City of Ithaca. The proposed 1994 Tompkins County budget as presented is $82 million which is a $1.9
million increase from 1993. This equals an 11 percent property tax increase. Mr. Todd stated that he
doesn't believe Tompkins County wants that kind of property tax increase after the County adopted a
sales tax increase. Mr. Todd stated that he intends to move an amendment for an across the board cut
and hopes that the amendment will stimulate debate by the County and the public.
Mr. Stein, Representative, District No. 3, stated that there needs to be discussion on why taxes are
going up. One observation that he sees that may be overlooked is a trend of services being shifted from
municipalities to County government. The County has taken over assessment, youth services, election
costs, the transit system and the County has a public library. Mr. Stein stated that he expects that the
trend will continue for reasons of efficiency and effectivity. However, with these programs comes a cost
the County must absorb. The reason many municipalities are not raising taxes may be attributed to this
trend. He stated that it is important to understand this as part of the debate.
Mrs. Livesay, Representative, District No. 11, stated that the County should be providing services
in the best possible way. She said that it would be wonderful to have a zero percent property tax increase
but it is important to know what would be involved with that decision.
Mr. Todd stated that he recognizes that mandated items cannot be subjected to across the board
cuts. He believes there needs to be prioritizing within departments. One reason he has presented the idea
is to create debate amongst Board members and the public.
Mr. Proto, Representative, District No. 7, stated that Mr. Stein has hit upon an important concern.
He stated that the County needs to look at those services that have been consolidated and see what the
costs have been and if it has reduced the cost for the taxpayer.
Mr. Mason, Representative, District No. 15, stated that as a result of the sales tax agreement the
towns and villages are facing significant tax decreases. He stated that when the County has the
opportunity to apply additional revenues to the tax rate, the tax rate is reduced and is not sure that
municipalities are doing the same.
285
November 16, 1993
Mr. Winch, Representative, District No. 8, stated that what he would like propose is that
depai tinent heads and committee chairmen have discussion on what the impact would be of a zero
percent property tax increase. Mr. Winch stated that the idea is intriguing but doesn't believe that the
ramifications would be acceptable to the people of Tompkins County who are continually asking for
more services.
Mr. Heyman, County Administrator, stated that a $1.9 million cut across the board could be done.
The actions taken would be severe and would include a number of employee layoffs. Mr. Heyman stated
that it has been done in other counties.
Mr. Lerner, Representative, District No. 1, stated the budget that has been recommended does not
restore the fund balance. He feels the fund balance should be restored and will be arguing to do so.
It was Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mrs. Livesay, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to Table this resolution to November 30, 1993.
It was Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to adjourn to a Committee of the Whole at 6:30 p.m. for sixty minutes to discuss and
consider the proposed 1994 Tompkins County Solid Waste budget and five year projection.
It was Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mrs. Call, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, that the Committee rise and report that the Solid Waste budget was duly considered
and will be brought before the Board November 30 for approval. The Chairman of the Solid Waste and
Resource Management Committee did and upon rise and report the same.
The meeting returned to regular session at 7:30 p.m.
Chairman Watros declared recess from 7:30 - 7:36 p.m.
RESOLUTION NO. 302 - IMPLEMENTATION OF 1994 TOMPKINS COUNTY BUDGET
(Adopted December 7, 1993)
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Shurtleff. It was Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr.
Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members present, to Table this resolution to November
30, 1993.
RESOLUTION NO. 303 - INCREASE IN HOURS - CHIEF NATURAL RESOURCES PLANNER
- PLANNING DEPARTMENT
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Stein, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning and Budget and Administration Committees,
That one position of Chief Natural Resources Planner (17/692), labor grade Q(17), competitive class, be
increased from 35 to 40 hours effective October 1 and through December 31, 1993,
RESOLVED, further, That no new monies are needed to fund this change for the balance of 1993.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE 11
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
286
November 16, 1993
RESOLUTION NO. 304 - ESTABLISHING COUNTY EQUALIZATION RATES
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Stein, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, pursuant to Article III, Section 4.05, Subdivision (d) of the Tompkins County Charter
and Code, the Director of Assessment has submitted and recommended the adoption of equalization rates
for all towns in Tompkins County and the City of Ithaca for the assessment rolls filed in 1993 and for the
apportionment of County taxes levied in 1994, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the
following equalization rates be and hereby are adopted:
AGGREGATE ASSESSED AGGREGATE FULL
VALUATION OF TAXABLE COUNTY VALUATION OF TAXABLE
REAL PROPERTY FOR EQUALIZATION REAL PROPERTY FOR
TOWN COUNTY PURPOSES RATE COUNTY PURPOSES
Caroline
Danby
Dryden
Enfield
Groton
Ithaca/Town
Lansing
Newfield
Ulysses
Ithaca/City
$ 88,960,866
108,679,097
488,387,242
90,096,743
128,301,617
707,759,214
645,048,799
138,419,317
215,898,705
876,286,363
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
100.00
100.00
100.00
100.00
100.00
100.00
100.00
100.00
100.00
100.00
RESOLUTION NO. 305 - PRINTING OF TAX RATES
$ 88,960,866
108,679,097
488,387,242
90,096,743
128,301,617
707,759,214
645,048,799
138,419,317
215,898,705
876,286,363
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That after the tax
rates are ascertained for the various towns and the City of Ithaca, the Clerk shall print such rates in the
Proceedings of the Board following budgets of the several towns and City.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 306 - AUTHORIZING PAYMENTS FOR COMMUNITY COLLEGE
OPERATING BUDGET
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, this Board has heretofore and by resolution approved the 1993-94 operating budget
for the Tompkins Cortland Community College and appropriated the necessary funds to pay the
Tompkins County proportionate share of the operating budget of said college, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the County
Administrator be and he hereby is authorized and directed, pursuant to the provisions of the Education
287
November 16, 1993
Law of the State of New York and within the authorization provided by this Board, to pay Tompkins
Cortland Community College an amount up to but not to exceed the Tompkins County budgeted share of
the operating of said college for the fiscal year 1993-94 on the following dates in the following amounts:
January 1, 1994 $ 410,605.00
March 1, 1994 410,605.00
May 1, 1994 410,605.00
July 1, 1994 410,605.00
Total $1,642,420.00
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 307 - TOWN BUDGETS
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Winch, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That there be
levied upon and collected from the taxable property of the several towns of the County and the City of
Ithaca the foregoing sums for the purposes therein named in accordance with budgets adopted by the
several town boards of the County of Tompkins to be filed with the Clerk of the Board, laws of the State
of New York, and the foregoing report and recommendation of the Budget and Administration
Committee,
RESOLVED, further, That said summaries of the budgets of the several towns of the County and
the City of Ithaca be printed in the 1993 proceedings of the Board of Representatives.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 308 - APPROVING COMPLETED TAX ROLLS AND DIRECTING THE
EXECUTING AND DELIVERY OF WARRANTS
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Mason, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, upon the tax rolls of the several towns and City, the several taxes will be extended,
now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the tax rolls
be approved as completed, that the taxes extended upon the rolls in the several amounts extended against
such parcel of property upon the said rolls are hereby determined to be the taxes due thereon as set forth
therein,
RESOLVED, further, That there be annexed to each of said rolls a tax warrant prepared by the
Director of Assessment as provided for in Section 4.05(b) of the Tompkins County Charter and Code,
that such warrants shall be the respective amounts theretofore authorized to be levied upon each of said
rolls, that the several warrants be signed by the Chairman and the Clerk of the Board under seal of the
Board and by the Director of Assessment, that said rolls with said warrants annexed are to be forthwith
delivered to the respective collectors of the several districts of the County.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 309 - DESIGNATION OF NEWSPAPERS
288
November 16, 1993
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Winch, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the official
newspaper for the County of Tompkins for the publication of all local laws, notices and other matters
required by law to be published pursuant to County Law, Article 5, Section 214, Subdivision (2), and
Local Law No. 1 of 1992 be designated from January 1, 1994 to June 30, 1994 as follows:
Ithaca Journal, Ithaca, New York
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 310 - AUTHORIZATION TO SIGN DRAFTS - COUNTY
ADMINISTRATOR
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Winch, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the County
Administrator be and hereby is authorized to sign all drafts of the County of Tompkins and to delegate
this authority to the Deputy County Administrator.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE 11
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 311 - AUTHORIZATION FOR COUNTY COMPTROLLER TO MAKE
YEAR-END TRANSFERS, APPROPRIATIONS AND BUDGET
ADJUSTMENTS AS REQUIRED
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the County
Comptroller be and he hereby is authorized to make year-end transfers, appropriations and budget
adjustments required to clear credit balances from the books at year-end,
RESOLVED, further, That any such additional entries made by the County Comptroller shall be
reported back to the Board of Representatives.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 312 - DATE OF ORGANIZATION MEETING
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans. Mrs. Livesay, Representative, District No. 11,
asked inthe event of an emergency who has the authority to make decisions until a chairman is elected.
Mr. Mulvey, County Attorney, was requested to report back to this Board. A voice vote on the resolution
resulted as follows: Ayes - 14, Noes - 0, Excused - 1 (Representative Joseph). Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That in
accordance with Section 151 of County Law, the organization meeting of the Board of Representatives
shall be held in the Board of Representatives' Chambers of the Tompkins County Courthouse, Ithaca,
New York, on Tuesday, January 4, 1994 at 5:30 o'clock in the evening thereof.
289
November 16, 1993
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 313 - ESTABLISHING 1994 MEETING DATES
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mrs. Livesay, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the 1994
regular meetings of the Tompkins County Board of Representatives are as follows:
Tuesday, January 4, 1994 at 5:30 p.m.
Tuesday, January 18, 1994 at 5:30 p.m.
Tuesday, February 1, 1994 at 5:30 p.m.
Tuesday, February 15, 1994 at 5:30 p.m.
Tuesday, March 1, 1994 at 5:30 p.m.
Tuesday, March 15, 1994 at 5:30 p.m.
Tuesday, April 5, 1994 at 5:30 p.m.
Tuesday, April 19, 1994 at 5:30 p.m.
Tuesday, May 3, 1994 at 5:30 p.m.
Tuesday, May 17, 1994 at 5:30 p.m.
Tuesday, June 7, 1994 at 5:30 p.m.
Tuesday, June 21, 1994 at 5:30 p.m.
Tuesday, July 12, 1994 at 5:30 p.m.
Tuesday, August 9, 1994 at 5:30 p.m.
Tuesday, September 6, 1994 at 5:30 p.m.
Wednesday, September 21, 1994 at 5:30 p.m.
Tuesday, October 4, 1994 at 5:30 p.m.
Tuesday, October 18, 1994 at 5:30 p.m.
Tuesday, November 1, 1994 at 5:30 p.m.
Tuesday, November 15, 1994 at 5:30 p.m.
Tuesday, December 6, 1994 at 5:30 p.m.
Tuesday, December 20, 1994 at 5:30 p.m.
1994 Conferences
March 6 - 8, 1994 - Joint Conference - New York State Supervisors and County
Legislators and New York State Association of Counties
June 12 - 15, 1994 New York State Supervisors and County Legislators
September 18 - 21, 1994 New York State Association of Counties Fall Conference
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 314 - WORKERS' COMPENSATION BUDGET AND APPORTIONMENT —
MUTUAL SELF-INSURANCE PLAN
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Mason, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, the Budget and Administration Committee estimates that the sum of $4,000 will be
required during the year 1994 for the payment of compensation in old and pending cases on behalf of the
290
November 16, 1993
County and participating municipalities under the Mutual Self -Insurance Plan and for the expenses of
administering same, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That there be
raised from the County and participating municipalities in 1993 the total sum of $4,000 the same to be
apportioned to the County and the several participating municipalities in the proportion that their
equalized valuation bears to the aggregate valuation of the County and all participating municipal
corporations as follows:
Municipality
Caroline
Danby
Dryden
Enfield
Groton
Ithaca (Town)
Lansing
Newfield
Ulysses
Ithaca (City)
Dryden (Village)
Freeville (Village)
Groton (Village)
Cayuga Heights (Village)
County of Tompkins
Total
Full Value
Assessed Full Value
88,960,866
108,679,097
488,387,242
90,096,743
128,301,617
707,759,214
645,048,799
138,419,317
215,898,705
876,286,363
61,665,469
13,448,762
47,884,103
221,581,219
3,487,837,963
7,320,255,479
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
Apportionment
48.61
59.39
266.87
49.23
70.11
386.74
352.47
75.64
117.97
478.83
33.70
7.35
26.17
121.08
1,905.86
4,000.00
RESOLUTION NO. 315 - CREATION AND ABOLITION OF POSITIONS - PLANNING
DEPARTMENT
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Stein, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning and Budget and Administration Committees,
That one position of Secretary (09/671), labor grade I (9), competitive class be abolished effective
November 4, 1993,
RESOLVED, further, That one position of Senior Account Clerk Typist (09/529), labor grade I
(9), competitive class, be created effective November 4, 1993,
RESOLVED, further, That no new monies are needed to fund this change.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 316 - INCREASE IN HOURS - VARIOUS POSITIONS - DATA
PROCESSING
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
291
November 16, 1993
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the
following positions be increased from 35 hours per week to 40 hours per week effective November 17,
1993:
Programmer Analyst (13/662), labor grade M, competitive class - one position
Microcomputer Specialist (12/638), labor grade L, competitive class - two positions
Programmer (09/639), labor grade I, competitive class - one position
RESOLVED, further, That the position of Computer Operator/Technician (08/623), labor grade H,
competitive class, be increased from 17.5 to 20.0 hours per week effective November 17, 1993,
RESOLVED, further, That no new monies are needed for the balance of 1993 and this change has
been incorporated into the 1994 proposed budget for the Department.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 317 - APPORTIONMENT OF MORTGAGE TAX
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Stein, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, the County Clerk and the County Administrator have presented their report
concerning mortgage tax receipts for the period from April 1, 1993 through September 30, 1993,
pursuant to Section 261 of the Tax Law, and the same have been apportioned to the various
municipalities thereto, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the
apportionment as presented for said period from April 1, 1993 through September 30, 1993 be and
hereby is approved:
Municipality Amount Total
Town of Caroline $ 24,701.65
Town of Danby 24,252.17
Dryden: Town $114,239.82 123,756.75
Village 7,812.98
Village of Freeville 1,703.95
Town of Enfield 16,605.91
Groton: Town 27,124.73 33,347.65
Village 6,222.92
City of Ithaca 117,301.20
Town of Ithaca 144,150.19 170,902.83
Village of Cayuga Heights 26,752.64
Lansing: Town 107,461.35 134,718.96
Village 27,257.61
Town of Newfield 22,811.62
Ulysses: Town 39,661.87 45,258.35
Trumansburg 5,596.48
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 318 - BUDGET ADJUSTMENTS AND APPROPRIATIONS - VARIOUS
DEPARTMENTS
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
292
November 16, 1993
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education, Human Services, Planning,
Budget and Administration Committees, That the County Comptroller be authorized to make
following budget adjustments and appropriations on his is books:
BUDGET ADJUSTMENTS
Health Department - Healthy Heart
Revenue: A4021.2770
Appropriation: A4021.4302
.4332
.4333
.4330
.4342
Unclassified Revenues
Office Supplies
Books/Publications
Promotional
Printing
Food
Physically Handicapped Children
Revenue: A599
A4046.3446
A4047.3401
Appropriation: A4046.4400
A4046.4400
A4047.4442
Office for the Aging
Revenue: A6796.3803
Appropriation: A6796.1517
.4302
.4330
.4465
.4472
.8810
.8830
.8840
.8860
.8870
Youth Bureau
Revenue: A7020.2705
Appropriation: A7020.4330
Planning
Revenue: A8020.2705
Appropriation: A8020.4442
Purchasing and Central Services
Revenue: A1345.2770
Appropriation: A1345.4413
APPROPRIATIONS
Budget and Finance/Administration
Revenue: A0599.0000
Appropriation: A1230.2206
.2230
A1310.2210
Unappropriated Fund Balance
Care of PH Children
PHW State Aid
Program Expense
Program Expense
Professional Services Fees
State Revenue
Salary
Office Supplies
Printing
Job Related Travel
Telephone
Retirement
Social Security
Worker's Comp.
Health Insurance
Unemployment
Gifts/Donations
Printing
Unclassified Revenue
Professional Service Fees
Unclassified Revenue
Auction Expense
General Fund Balance
Computer Equipment
Computer Software
Other Equipment
293
$ 3,300
400
400
1,000
1,000
500
$ 4,524
5,664
(2,474)
$ 4,524
5,664
(2,474)
$ 3,881
$ 2,196
16
58
216
67
76
151
7
1,081
13
$ 500
$ 500
$ 3,000
$ 3,000
$19,669
$19,669
$ 7,000
$ 5,000
800
1,200
and
the
November 16, 1993
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator be and hereby is authorized to execute the
necessary contracts to convey these funds.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 319 AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE AGREEMENT WITH THIRD
PARTY ADMINISTRATOR FOR SELF INSURANCE OF
WORKER'S COMPENSATION CLAIMS, TRANSFER FROM
DEPARTMENTAL WORKER'S COMPENSATION
SUBACCOUNTS TO WORKER'S COMPENSATION INSURANCE
RESERVE ACCOUNT, AND AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE
AGREEMENT WITH SEDGWICK JAMES, INC., AS BROKER
FOR CATASTROPHIC LOSS INSURANCE COVERAGE FOR
WORKER'S COMPENSATION CLAIMS (Adopted December 7,
1993)
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans. It was Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mrs.
Livesay, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members present, to Table this resolution to
November 30, 1993.
RESOLUTION NO. 320 - ESTABLISHING 1994 SOLID WASTE SLUDGE TIPPING FEE
Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Solid Waste and Resource Management and Budget and
Administration Committees, That the per -ton fee for sewage sludge is hereby established at $45 effective
January 1, 1994.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 321 - URGING THE NEW YORK STATE LEGISLATURE TO ACT ON
WORKERS' COMPENSATION REFORM
Moved by Mrs. Livesay, seconded by Mrs. Call, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present.
WHEREAS, laws governing the payment of injured workers in New York State are badly in need
of reform in order effectively to control costs and to better provide protection to workers injured on the
job, and
WHEREAS, the Senate and Assembly have not been able to work out differences and to reach a
compromise, and to pass identical bills, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, That the Tompkins County board of Representatives urges both the Senate and
Assembly to act expeditiously to pass legislation that is badly needed by workers and employers in New
York State.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
294
November 16, 1993
It was Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present to lift from the Table the following resolution:
RESOLUTION NO. 251 - APPROVAL OF ACCEPTANCE OF LOCAL INITIATIVE MONIES -
SIX MILE CREEK PROJECT
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present.
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County Planning Department received $15,000 from the State of New
York as a Local Initiative for the the Six Mile Creek project, and
WHEREAS, this project will serve to benefit the County and various municipalities within, now
therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the Board of Representatives
shall authorize the acceptance of these funds from the State of New York and authorize the County
Administrator to sign any contractual agreements.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
It was Moved by Mr. Todd, seconded by Mrs. Call, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present to lift from the Table the following resolution:
RESOLUTION NO. 268 - ESTABLISHMENT OF THE TOMPKINS COUNTY LEADERSHIP
COUNCIL AND COMMITMENT TO AN ORGANIZATIONAL
CHANGE INITIATIVE TO IMPROVE THE EFFICIENCY,
EFFECTIVENESS, AND QUALITY OF COUNTY SERVICES
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Todd, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members
present. Mr. Lerner was assured that recommendations to the Board of Representatives by the Council
does not preclude items being referred to standing committees.
WHEREAS, the Fiscal Affairs Committee was created by the Chairman of the Board in January,
1992 to address in a systematic, long-term way the fiscal and services problems that were created by
significant spending increases during 1991 associated with the national recession of that year, and
WHEREAS, the Committee was charged with organizing a process that would make it possible for
the Board of Representatives to differentiate among service delivery areas as to their importance and
their funding, and also to advise the Budget and Administration Committee on the development and
implementation of procedures to achieve the financial objectives of the Fiscal Plans of the last two years
with the least negative impact on the delivery of services, and
WHEREAS, the Committee has reviewed the efforts of other public and private organizations to
institute organizational changes to control costs and continuously improve the quality of services, which
efforts are often referred to as "Total Quality Management", and
WHEREAS, such changes for Tompkins County have been endorsed and recommended by the
Employee Council, County Department Heads, and the County Administrator, and
WHEREAS, it is the understanding of this Board in endorsing these changes that their underlying
philosophy includes but is not limited to the following with respect to establishing the direction and
purposes of County government as a whole:
- constancy of purpose, as defined by this Board, for the short and long term;
- a strong focus on service excellence;
- a primary role for service recipients, employees, and taxpayers, in determining the County's goals
and its means for achieving those goals;
295
November 16, 1993
- service delivery that is as close to the people as possible and that empowers the citizens of our
community;
with respect to reorganizing and restructuring, where appropriate, the means by which County staff
strive to carry out the Board's policies:
- a major increase in commitment to education and training for employees;
- a work force that reflects the diversity of the community that it serves;
- greatly improved and enhanced interdepartmental cooperation and collaboration;
- rewards, recognition, and protection from harm for employees who participate in this process,
and;
- a shift in the role of supervisors away from ordering, correcting and mandating, and toward
educating, supporting, and team leadership;
- clarification of roles, responsibilities, and overall organization of the various units of county
government, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Fiscal Affairs and Budget and Administration
Committees, That this Board of Representatives commits itself to an organization -wide effort to review,
restructure, and improve the ways in which it carries out the responsibilities assigned to it by the State of
New York and by the Tompkins County Charter and Code and hereby creates and establishes the
Tompkins County Leadership Council to have primary guidance responsibility over this effort subject
only to review and approval by this Board and assigns to the Council the following charges:
1. RECOMMEND a process that leads to the approval by the Board of Representatives of:
a. A Statement of Purpose for County government as a whole;
b. Goals, Objectives, and Action Plans for County government and each of its programs that are
aligned with that Statement of Purposes; and
c. A budget review and adoption process by the Board of Representatives that results in
funding decisions that reflect purposes and goals of County government as whole.
The Council is authorized and encouraged to apply bold and creative thought to this portion of its
charge and to involve directly members of the public in carrying it out.
2. RECOMMEND AND OVERSEE a reorganization and restructuring wherever appropriate of
the ways by which Tompkins County government carries out its responsibilities based on the principles
commonly referred to as "Total Quality Management".
RESOLVED, further, That the membership of the Leadership Council shall be designated at a
future meeting by this Board and that the Council may establish its own committees and subcommittees
and may appoint the members of these from within and outside its own ranks,
RESOLVED, further, That the Council shall submit its work plan with timetable and all of its
recommendations directly to this Board for its review and shall receive from County staff appropriate
resources to accomplish its charges.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
Chairman Watros commended Mr. Lerner, Chairman, Solid Waste and Resource Management
Committee, and staff for a fine presentation on the proposed 1994 Solid Waste budget. He stated that it
has been defined clearly so the public can receive answers to their questions.
On motion the meeting adjourned at 7:50 p.m. to November 30, 1993.
296
November 30, 1993
Adjourned Board Meeting
Public Hearing
Chairman Watros called the public hearing to order at 7:00 p.m. concerning the proposed 1994
Tompkins County Budget and Capital Program.
Chairman Watros announced that because the legal notice was not published in accordance with
the Charter and Code a vote to adopt the proposed budget will not be taken this evening on the proposed
1994 Tompkins County Budget and Capital Program. The Board will consider a resolution later this
evening to hold a second public hearing December 7, 1993 concerning the same.
Chairman Watros introduced Daniel Winch, Vice Chairman, Budget and Administration
Committee, who read the following statement from Mary Call, Chairman of the Budget and
Administration Committee:
"Good evening. Thank you for coming to the public hearing on the 1994 budget.
This is my last budget. I'll be off the Board so I won't have a part in future discussions. As I
thought about that fact, I thought about the budgets that we have passed in the last twelve years that I've
been on the Board.
Chart. Shows five items, 1982 thru 1994: mandates, public works, human services, public safety
and all others.
This chart reflects four conditions that I call the "eternal verities" of the County budget":
1. Mandated programs continue to increase at a rate of more than twelve percent a year.
2. The economy remains stable and therefore the sales tax and other revenues do not provide a rising
source of income.
3. The majority of citizens want to maintain the level of services now provided by the County.
4. The majority of citizens don't want their taxes to increase.
The chart reflects the four conditions I've outlined but it also shows that:
1. taxes are with us every year
2. all services share in the increased costs and contribute to taxes (Dan, if this is on the chart)
How do you impact this type of chart?
Two simple -- sounding ways are:
1. Increase revenues. Sales tax estimates for 1994 were put in at about the same level as 1993.
No significant new sources of money for general programs have been found.
2. Decrease spending and/or cut back on programs. I'll repeat: I believe the majority of citizens
do not want to drastically cut programs and services.
A third way to impact the chart, perhaps more complex:
3. Prioritize the services that County government provides so that all do not increase at the same
rate, or some are phased out or cut back, or expanded. Devise a way to do this prioritization: do it by a
massive, well-designed, County -wide survey, or do it by TQM (Total Quality Management), or some
other as yet unnamed method.
Somehow, try to achieve this goal: The level of services that the majority of people want the
County to provide, with a lower tax burden. I charge this new, ongoing Board of Representatives with
that goal.
I have not said much about the 1994 budget. This budget, as in years past, reflects very hard work
on the part of depai tiiient heads and agency directors. It reflects many hours of cost containment, choices
for service provision and all the myriad decisions and dedication that bring us to this point: a vote by this
Board on the budget. The work done in the past twelve weeks reflects some real curtailment of service
and much knowledge that a department cannot fulfill its' full mission because there isn't enough money.
My thanks, as always, to the real public servants who helped create the budget.
297
November 30, 1993
Again, I say to the ongoing 1994 Board of Representatives, the 1994 budget unfortunately
continues to reflect the chart and the concepts I outlined earlier. As hard as we worked, my parting
thought is that "it just isn't good enough" we could have done better".
You, my friends, have got to do better.
Chairman Watros asked if anyone wished to speak?
Joe Cassanti, 330 West State Street, said he knows business people who pay a great deal of taxes
and that he is interested in what they have to say.
Ted Wixom, Village of Lansing Mayor, spoke in opposition to an increase in property tax. He
said the Consumer Index shows an average increase of 3.6 percent over the last three years. The
County's proposed tax increase is three times that amount. This tells me that the goods and services
provided by the County have increased in value three times that for such basics as food, clothing,
transportation, medical care and housing. Mandated programs have often been identified as the reason
for substantial increase in this budget. He asked if a budget was presented with a zero percent increase?
He also asked that the Board vote to cap it at a Consumer Price Index rate of inflation or Statewide
average for counties or some other objective figure.
Paul Steiger, East State Street, said he was speaking on his behalf not on behalf of the Chamber of
Commerce Tax Committee. He spoke about an article in the Ithaca Journal stating a settlement was
reached with the Blue Collar Union Contract. His assumption is that it will be a pattern for the general
wage and benefits settlement or contributions to all employees in the County. He said County employees
have a health care benefit that is a richer benefit than any health care in the nation. Employees all over
the nation have been sacrificing give backs in the health care arena for the past five years, but not
Tompkins County employees. Tompkins County employees have a drug card and for $1 can get a
prescription drug without any generic drug restriction. He said his drug card costs him $10 each time.
The average across the nation is $60. County employees also have a $100 deductible in their health plan.
The average is $250 and rising all the time. The tax committee recommended changing that to the
average and if the County had changed it, the savings would have been $.25 million per year. Instead the
County is now locked in for four years. He said this is one more example of the County's unwillingness
to address cost control.
Yvonne Bartlett, Depai t,nent of Social Services Employee, Interlaken, alleges she has "multiple
chemical sensitivities" due to working at Biggs A. She reiterated the schedule of events since being
taken out of work and stated that she still does not have an income. She said the Doctor who diagnosed
her with the alleged disease passed away.
Calvin Criss, Buffalo Street, expressed his concern with the various percentage increases for
General Government Support, human services, public safety, health services, public works and
community service and education.
Mark Finkelstein, 210 Lake Street, said if the County adopts the proposed budget, the total budget
will have increased over 50 percent in four years. He spoke about possible ways to reduce the budget
including the review of mandates. He urged the Board to support the proposed amendment for a zero
percent increase in property taxes being offered by Representative Todd.
Frank Rose, 112 Valleyview Road, said he opposes a property tax increase. He said if he has
calculated correctly, optional costs have risen 44 percent in the last five years including the proposal
being considered this evening, whereas his salary has only increased 18 percent in the last five years.
298
November 30, 1993
Evan Lambrou, Honness Lane, said he also opposes a property tax increase and feels public
employees at all levels of government should not receive a significant salary increase. He also stated the
County should have an incinerator because of the cost of exporting solid waste.
Fred Quinlan, Sun Down Road, Freeville, encouraged the Board to vote in favor of Representative
Todd's proposed amendment for a zero percent property tax increase.
Alan Cohen, 302 East State Street, felt the general public did not have an idea what was going on
with the budget until after the election. He feels the public needs more time to study the figures and
issues. He also recommends long-term planning. He feels a study of mandates should be undertaken and
urged the Board to be responsive.
Mel Bartlett, Husband of Yvonne Bartlett a Department of Social Services Employee, stated that
he doesn't believe his wife receives a lot of benefits from being a County employee. He asked the Board
to look into concerns raised this evening.
Tom Murray, 62 Spring Run Road, Freeville, finds if difficult to maintain business when federal
taxes, Worker's Compensation, County taxes, school taxes, etc. continue to increase. The end result is
less employees working for him which adds to the County budget. It's important to review how the
County is operating and become more efficient. He said he opposes a property tax increase.
Tom Corey, Lee Road, Village of Dryden, mentioned the report by the Tax Committee and said he
was the author of the health insurance portion. He feels the County should reduce the work force. He
referred to the social services increase in personnel and fringe benefits which amounts to $800,000 in
additional costs between 1993 and 1994 representing a 12 percent increase in the cost of personnel, yet
no increase for the aid to independent children and home relief which are the criteria under which social
services are presented. He also referred to a line item for the County Clerk's office. The Department of
Motor Vehicles is no longer renting space. Barbara Mahoney, Hayts Road resident and Department of
Social Services employee, stated she feels government is too expensive. She stated that she is unable to
work in the "clean room" provided for employees in the Biggs building.
Lloyd Mix, Ringwood Road, stated that a lot of changes are needed to be made to the proposed
budget. He feels that alcohol is a major problem and cost contributor in Tompkins County.
Ralph Lapadula, Floral Avenue, spoke in opposition to the proposed 1994 Tompkins County
budget and stated that he feels the budget should have been presented prior to the November election.
Ernest Bury, Valley Road, Ithaca, spoke in opposition to the proposed 1994 Tompkins County
budget and stated that he believes there are very few State mandates on trash.
Beach Stover, Town of Ulysses, spoke in opposition to the proposed 1994 Tompkins County
budget. Mr. Stover stated that his small business is in jeopardy. He also stated that he feels the increases
outlined in the budget are not justified.
Charles Tollman, Richard Place, stated that as a banker, realtor and someone who has been in
finances all his life, finds the proposed 12 percent property tax increase to be unacceptable. He stated
that he believes that this would drive entrepreneurs out of the County and the State.
Allen Akers, Trumansburg Road, spoke in opposition to the proposed 1994 Tompkins County
budget and stated it creates great hardship for those on fixed incomes. He feels during these hard times,
the County should be cutting back.
299
November 30, 1993
Richard Sweet, Hayts Road, spoke in opposition to the proposed 1994 Tompkins County budget.
He stated that as a purchasing agent for the Federal Government, he tries to bend regulations. He stated
Tompkins County needs to try to bend to get the lowest costs possible.
Gerry Angel, Trumansburg Road, spoke in opposition to the proposed 1994 Tompkins County
Budget. He stated that his family tries to evaluate how they spend their money and the County needs to
do the same. He stated that he feels County and its depaitments need to go on a low fat diet and possibly
initiate a pay freeze.
David Stotz, Green Lane, spoke in opposition to the proposed 1994 Tompkins County budget. He
stated that the number one issue is property tax and that there are many people in this community for
which 12 percent is not a small property tax increase. He urged the Board to reduce County costs.
Willard Daetsh, Danby Road, expressed opposition to a property tax increase. Mr. Daetsch stated
that he feels the County should prioritize services because some services are more crucial than others.
Rev. Ted Craig, Pastor, Town of Danby, spoke in opposition to the proposed 1994 Tompkins
County budget. He stated that people have told him that they live from one payday to the next. Mr.
Craig referred to percentages of increase within the last five years in Tompkins County and asked that
Board members remember their title as "Representative".
Lenorre Schwager, Finger Lakes Independence Center, stated that the Center is aid those who are
hearing impaired and teach people about equipment, services and their rights. She stated that FLIC is the
only agency within Tompkins County which offers this service and without additional money the Center
will be forced to turn people away. Ms. Schwager asked that the Board allocate to them the amount
approved by the Human Services Coalition.
Larry Roberts, President of the Board of Directors at the Finger Lakes Independence Center
(FLIC), asked that the Board favorably consider to allocated to them the amount budgeted by the Human
Services Coalition. He stated that the request is in the amount of $3,000. Mr. Roberts reaffirmed the
comments made by the previous speaker.
Mahlea Carlisle, Cliff Street, and member of the Finger Lakes Independence Center, also spoke in
favor the County supporting the Agency. She stated that because she is hearing impaired she knows what
it is like for those who do what services are available. She stated that she feels $3,000 is a small amount
for the education and training of visually impaired people in Tompkins County.
Bernard Goodman, White Park Road, spoke in opposition to the proposed 1994 Tompkins County
budget. Mr. Goodman stated that government needs to understand that it cannot go into people's lives
and take control of them.
Carol Reeves, Linn Street, stated that she is opposed to the proposed 1994 Tompkins County
budget. She said that she has been involved in the City and budget process for eight years and stated she
feels the proposed budget is unacceptable. She said she is grateful for Mr. Todd's proposed amendment.
David Tanner, Horizon Drive, spoke in opposition to the proposed 1994 Tompkins County budget.
He complimented the County on its work, however, questioned how many businesses locally and
nationally can get an eleven percent increase in their cost and how many people receive an eleven percent
increase annually. He asked if the County has looked at ways to cut costs and if the cost of health care
has been raised for workers.
300
November 30, 1993
Jason Fane, South Quarry Street and landlord, spoke in opposition to the proposed 1994 Tompkins
County budget. He stated that people are real concerned about the proposed 12 percent property tax
increase.
Pat Dayton, Owner, Stafford Chevrolet, Dryden, spoke in opposition to the proposed 1994
Tompkins County budget. She stated that the workforce has gone down and it is very expensive to do
business in Tompkins County or New York State because of taxation.
Henry Gagley, Lansing Foodnet, spoke in favor of the proposed 1994 Tompkins County budget
and stated that proposed cuts would result in the loss of the service of meals being delivered to elderly
people and those on the poverty level.
Phyllis Baker, Bostwick Road, spoke in opposition to the proposed 1994 Tompkins County
budget. She stated that Tompkins County residents cannot afford the budget as it has been presented.
She stated that just because you need something it doesn't mean you can afford it.
Mike Durso, Lansing resident and a member if the Chamber of Commerce Legislative Affairs
Committee, spoke in opposition to the proposed 1994 Tompkins County budget and stated a budget with
a 12 percent property tax increase will be supported by the taxpayers this year or next.
Ray Ingraham, Town of Groton resident and small business owner, spoke in opposition to the
proposed 1994 Tompkins County budget. Mr. Ingraham stated that as elected representatives, members
of the Board have to represent the taxpayers and "just say no".
Andy Sciarrabba, Ithaca, spoke in opposition to the proposed 1994 Tompkins County budget. Mr.
Sciarrabba read a statement prepared by Benjamin Curtis, Trumansburg resident, which stated that Mr.
Curtis is opposed to a property tax increase and urged the Board to support the amendment to be
proposed by Representative Todd.
Anna Smith, Town of Ithaca, spoke in opposition to the proposed 1994 Tompkins County budget
and stated she cannot afford another increase in taxes. She stated that she doesn't not approve of the
Board adopting salary increases. Ms. Smith also stated she feels 'garbage costs are too excessive and
agrees with Representative Call that the County has to do better.
Sarah Jones, Enfield Center Road, spoke in opposition to the proposed 1994 Tompkins County
budget and stated that high taxes encourage Ithaca to be town with a very transient population. She
stated that there are other places much cheaper to live and people will move if high taxing continues.
She urged the Board to look at long-term growth in the County.
Ruben Weiner, Hector Street, spoke in opposition to the proposed 1994 Tompkins County budget
and asked what became of the one percent sales that was imposed. Mr. Weiner urged the Board to look
at setting priorities.
H. Taskevitch, Hanshaw Road, spoke in opposition to the proposed 1994 Tompkins County budget
and stated the Board should listen to the people.
Mark Purdy, Mount Pleasant Road resident and a new homeowner, spoke in opposition to the
proposed 1994 Tompkins County budget. Mr. Purdy stated that when he was hired as an supervisor of
the Ithaca of A&P store, he was told to cut costs and the way he did that was to cut expenses. He stated
that he feels the County also needs to cut expenses.
301
November 30, 1993
Carla Marceau, Village of Lansing, spoke in opposition to the proposed 1994 Tompkins County
budget and any property tax increase.
Noel Desch, Town of Ithaca, spoke in opposition to the proposed 1994 Tompkins County budget.
Mr. Desch stated that he feels there are several soft spots in the budget and called on all County
legislators to make changes between now and December 7.
Girard Oberrender, Town of Ithaca, spoke in opposition to the proposed 1994 Tompkins County
budget. Mr. Obberender stated that he feels the County Board should be able to balance the County
budget.
Mary Beth Holub, Town of Newfield resident, spoke in opposition to the proposed 1994
Tompkins County budget and stated that as a farm owner, she is still producing milk at the same price
she did in 1981. She stated that she appreciates Representative Todd's efforts to eliminate a property tax
increase and asked that the Board cut some of the County's many expenses.
Lorraine Gilbert, Town of Danby, spoke in opposition to the proposed 1994 Tompkins County
budget. She stated that she cannot afford another increase in her property taxes.
Ann Zientek, new homeowner in the Town of Newfield, spoke in opposition to the proposed 1994
Tompkins County budget. She asked that the County look into long term planning and see if there is
something in the current proposal that can be modified.
Rocco Lucente, Town of Ithaca, passed amongst the Board members a string and asked that the
Board "Hold the Line on Taxes".
Chairman Watros declared the public hearing to be adjourned at 8:48 p.m.
Mr. Stein, Representative, District No. 1 suggested that Representatives wishing to propose
amendments postpone doing so until December 7, 1993, following the public hearing.
Present: 13 Representatives. Excused: 2 (Representatives Call and Culligan).
It was Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to add the resolution entitled Authorizing a Public Hearing — 1994 Tompkins County
Budget to the agenda.
RESOLUTION NO. 322 — AUTHORIZING A PUBLIC HEARING — 1994 PROPOSED
TOMPKINS COUNTY BUDGET AND CAPITAL PROGRAM
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Evans. It was Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mr.
Lerner, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by members present, to change the time of the public
hearing from 5:30 p.m. to 7:00 p.m. A voice vote on the resolution as amended resulted as follows:
Ayes — 13, Noes — 0, Excused — 2 (Representatives Call and Culligan). Adopted.
WHEREAS, due to an oversight the notice of public hearing on the adoption of the proposed 1994
County Operating Budget and Capital Program was not published on November 20 as required by
Section 5.06 of the Tompkins County Charter and Code, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, That the Clerk of the Board shall cause a notice of public hearing on the same to be
held on December 7, 1993, at 7:00 p.m. in the Board Chambers and that the said proposed Budget and
Capital Program shall be further considered for adoption on that date.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
302
November 30, 1993
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
It was Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote by
members present, to Lift Resolution No. 301 — Adoption of 1994 Tompkins County Budget and Capital
Program, from the Table. It was Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, and unanimously
adopted by voice vote by members present, to Table this resolution to the December 7, 1993, Public
Hearing.
Discussion followed concerning possible budget reductions and the impact that may occur with
County departments. Mr. Heyman, County Administrator, was asked to retrieve a summary of these
projected impacts from County depail,uents.
Mr. Mason, Representative, District No. 15, questioned property tax rates of local municipalities.
He stated following the imposition of a one percent sales tax increase and an agreement with the City of
Ithaca, the City, as well as all municipalities within the County, received revenue from the County and
benefited. He believes this is why property taxes have had very little or no increase for 1994 and the
public needs to be made aware of this. Mr. Mason stated that he feels residents of some municipalities
should be receiving decreases in their property taxes levied by municipalities as a result of the agreement.
Chairman Watros declared recess from 9:10 — 9:18 p.m.
It was Moved by Mr. Evans, seconded by Mr. Todd, and unanimously adopted by voice vote of
members present, to enter into executive session at 9:18 to discuss contract negotiations. The meeting
returned to open session at 9:43 p.m.
On motion the meeting adjourned at 9:43 p.m.
303
December 7, 1993
Regular Meeting
Public Hearing
Chairman Watros called the public hearing to order at 5:30 p.m. concerning proposed Local Law
No. 5 of 1993 - Amending Local Law No. 1 of 1993 - Authorizing the Establishment of an Annual Solid
Waste Fee for Real Property in Tompkins County.
Chairman Watros asked if anyone wished to speak?
Mr. Lerner, Chairman of the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, said the Board
will be voting on extending the proposed annual solid waste fee. He also stated the rates for the fee will
not be established this evening, but will be in the form of a resolution on the December 21, 1993 Board
agenda following a recommendation by the Budget and Administration Committee. He distributed copies
of the recommendations for the annual fee. The present fee per household is $52 and the proposed fee per
household being considered for 1994 is $45. He also discussed other proposed adjustments with the fee
and said that negotiations with the colleges are not complete. He reiterated that there are no property tax
dollars going into the solid waste budget.
Holly Gump, Ringwood Road, Ithaca, stated that the fee may be going down but the service she
receives will remain the same. Her garbage will continue to be picked up bi-weekly.
Ben Curtis, Village of Trumansburg, spoke about his concern with the State Environmental
Quantity Review determination. He feels illegal dumping has a significant impact on the environment.
Another concern he has with the fee is that it is not tax deductible; tax deductions will be forgone.
Mr. Taraskiewicz, Hanshaw Road, spoke about the petitions he filed with the Board on October 17
which opposed the annual solid waste fee. He asked that the law be repealed.
Ernest Bury, Valley Road, stated his short term goal is to recycle everything that meets state
mandates for recycling and his long term goal is to have a zero discharge waste stream; that is no material
going to a landfill. He spoke about the mandatory recycling state law. He also spoke about the cost of
collection and recycling for 1993. He urged the Board to re-examine the morass of what is mandatory
verses what is a goal.
Dooley Kiefer, Highland Road, said she supports the concept of an annual solid waste fee. She
suggested the fee should be based on per capita rather than square footage.
No one else wished to speak and the public hearing was closed at 5:48 p.m.
Members and guests participated in the Pledge of Allegiance.
Present: 15 Representatives.
It was Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote, to
approve the minutes of the November 16, 1993 meeting as submitted.
Under privilege of the floor, Dr. Eduardo Marti, Tompkins Cortland Community College (TC3)
President, said that the public service the Board provides should be recognized. The Board of Trustees
authorized Dr. Marti to present proclamations to the five Board members who are retiring acknowledging
the Board's appreciation for the years of dedicated service with the Tompkins County Board of
Representatives.
304
December 7, 1993
Under privilege of the floor, Peter Meskill, on behalf of the Village of Trumansburg and Mayor
Bennett, presented a proclamation to Representative Mason, District No. 15, for his contribution and
dedicated volunteered fire and ambulance service to the Village of Trumansburg. The proclamation also
declares December 10 as James A. Mason Day.
Chairman Watros proclaimed the week of December 21, 1993 as Health Planning Council Week in
Tompkins County.
Chairman Watros also proclaimed December 8-14, 1993 as Human Rights Week in Tompkins
County and presented the proclamation to Theda Zimrot, Human Rights Director.
Under privilege of the floor, Margaret Marks, Department of Social Services employee, stated that
she returned to work in the Biggs building on November 17. She stated that following her return to the
Biggs building she had to see her physician because of complications. She states she is unable to work in
the room. Ms. Marks also states that she has not received any compensation to date for her illness. She
also spoke of the upcoming Christmas holiday and the financial hardship placed on her family as a result
of her loss of income.
Under privilege of the floor, Claudia Cinquanti, Department of Social Services employee, stated that
she returned to work in the Biggs building against medical advice. She said that since returning she has
had to seek medical attention and was advised to be signed out of work. Ms. Cinquanti requested that she
and others affected by sick building syndrome be allowed to work at a location outside of Biggs. She also
stated that carbonless forms continue to be used in the "clean room".
Under privilege of the floor, Sharon Prezioso McLaughlin, Department of Social Services
employee, stated she feels employees affected with sick building syndrome are being discriminated
against in Biggs Building A. She stated that the employees names have been removed from the telephone
directory for the Department. She stated that she will never regain her health but hopes something can be
done to protect other workers not yet affected.
Under privilege of the floor Barbara Mahoney, Department of Social Services employee, spoke
concerning the effects she has suffered as a result of multiple chemical sensitivities and expressed
concern for clients being interviewed at the Biggs building. Ms. Mahoney submitted for the record a
letter from a person who applied for public assistance in March of 1993 which referred to medical
problems as a result of being in the Biggs building.
Under privilege of the floor, Yvonne Bartlett, Department of Social Services, stated that she has
received notification from the New York State Department of Justice of their rights to sue the County for
damages believed to been caused as a result of working in the Biggs building. Mrs. Bartlett submitted for
the record the following documents:
o Memo from Tricia Eth to Yvonne Bartlett dated December 6, 1993 regarding Yvonne Bartlett
memo of November 23, 1993
o Letter from Yvonne Bartlett to Tricia Eth dated December 7, 1993
o Memo from Mary Pat Dolan to Claudia Cinquanti and Yvonne Bartlett dated December 6, 1993
regarding NCR paper
o Letter from Mary Pat Dolan to Margaret Marks, Yvonne Bartlett and Claudia Cinquanti dated
December 6, 1993 regarding Meeting of November 22, 1993
o Notice of Right to Sue Within 90 Days from the United States Department of Justice to Yvonne
Bartlett regarding EEOC Charge Against Tompkins County Department of Social Services
o Letter from Yvonne Bartlett to Yvonne Bartlett dated December 6, 1993
o CSEA Grievance Form completed by Yvonne Bartlett submitted December 2, 1993
o Letter from Yvonne Bartlett to Tricia Eth, Department of Social Services Supervisor dated
December 6, 1993
305
December 7, 1993
Under privilege of the floor, Phil Shurtleff, Representative, District No. 9, thanked the media for
the coverage on the annual solid waste fee and budget process. He said that at the appropriate time he
would vote for the amendment to reduce the property tax to zero being offered by Representative Todd.
He also expressed his concern with taking action on the 1994 Budget at a location other than Board
Chambers.
Chairman Watros dispensed with committee reports.
Chairman Watros gave Mr. Mason permission to withdraw from the agenda the resolution entitled
Authorizing the County Administrator to Enter into Agreements with New York Telephone Company for
the installation of an Enhanced 911 Telephone System.
It was Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Mason, and unanimously adopted by voice vote to
add to the agenda the resolution entitled Design Review Services - Recycling and Solid Waste Center.
RESOLUTION NO. 323 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE NYSDOH RABIES CONTRACT -
HEALTH DEPARTMENT
Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, the New York State Depai lâ–ºuent of Health has funding available to assist counties in
the reimbursement of rabies expenses, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Health and Education Committee, That the County
Administrator is hereby authorized to sign any and all agreements necessary to participate in this
program.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 324 - RECOMMENDATION TO IMPROVE REPORTING OF
HAZARDOUS MATERIALS INCIDENTS
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Ms. Mink. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 14, Noes -
1 (Representative Shurtleff). Adopted.
WHEREAS, the Air, Water and Waste Committee of the Environmental Management Council
(EMC) has thoroughly reviewed the draft "Tompkins County Emergency Response Plan for Hazardous
Materials Incidents", and
WHEREAS, the EMC supports the Air, Water and Waste Committee's following recommendation
to facilitate responses to hazardous spills:
To increase citizen awareness of the Statewide Hazardous Materials Spills Hotline, the telephone
number should be included on the inside cover of NYNEX or other New York State telephone directories
under "Other Emergency Numbers", and
WHEREAS, there have been hazardous materials incidents in Tompkins County which indicated
the need for greater public awareness of spill reporting procedures, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the Board of Representatives
forward a resolution to the Honorable Thomas C. Jorling, Commissioner, New York State Depai tinent of
Environmental Conservation, requesting that the Statewide Hazardous Materials Spills Hotline telephone
number be added to the "Other Emergency Numbers" section of the New York State Telephone books.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
306
December 7, 1993
RESOLUTION NO. 325 - AMENDMENT OF RESOLUTION NO. 309 OF 1989 - CHANGING
MEMBERSHIP OF ADVISORY BOARD ON TOURISM
DEVELOPMENT
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Ms. Mink.- A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 14, Noes -
1 (Representative Shurtleff). Adopted.
WHEREAS, Resolution No. 309 of October 10, 1989 created an Advisory Board on Tourism
Development, and
WHEREAS, Resolution No. 85 of March 6, 1990 and Resolution No. 136 of April 16, 1991
increased membership of the Advisory Board on Tourism Development, and
WHEREAS, said Advisory Board was to be comprised of the following membership:
3 members representing the Board of Representatives
2 members representing the operators of hotels/motels/inns/restaurants
2 members representing the arts organizations
1 member representing the general business community
1 member representing Cornell University
1 member representing Ithaca College
1 ex -officio member representing the Convention and Visitors' Bureau
1 ex -officio member representing the Community Arts Partnership
, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That Resolution No. 309 of 1989 be
and hereby is amended to add one voting member representing parks/outdoor recreation to the Advisory
Board on Tourism Development.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 326 - RENEWAL - TOMTRAN LANSING/DANBY CONTRACT WITH
TIOGA TRANSPORT, INC.
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Ms. Mink. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 14, Noes -
1 (Representative Shurtleff). Adopted.
WHEREAS, since 1990, Tompkins County has contracted with Tioga Transport, Inc. to operate
public transit service in the Towns of Lansing, Danby, Ithaca and the City of Ithaca (Resolution No. 328
of 1990 and Resolution No. 461 of 1990), and
WHEREAS, Tioga Transport, Inc. has successfully operated said routes under supervision of
Tompkins County, and
WHEREAS, Tioga Transport, Inc. and Tompkins County agree on the following prices:
Price to operate a contractor -owned bus $31.50/hour
Price to operate a County -owned bus $23 .75/hour
with the agreement that the above prices would remain in effect through December 31, 1994, after which
mutually agreed upon rates shall be effective, and
WHEREAS, Tompkins County and Tioga Transport, Inc. desire to renew for a two-year period of
January 1, 1994 to December 31, 1995, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the Tompkins
County Board of Representatives authorizes the County Administrator, or designee, to act on behalf of the
County of Tompkins to execute a contract renewal with Tioga Transport, Inc. for a two year term from
January 1, 1994 to December 31, 1995, with successive renewals as may be desired.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
307
December 7, 1993
RESOLUTION NO. 327 - AUTHORIZING 1994 FEDERAL SECTION 9 PUBLIC TRANSIT
GRANT
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Ms. Mink. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 14, Noes -
1 (Representative Shurtleff). Adopted.
WHEREAS, the Secretary of the United States Department of Transportation is authorized to make
grants for mass transportation projects pursuant to the Federal Transit Act of 1964, as amended, and
WHEREAS, the County of Tompkins is the designated recipient of Section 9 Urban Transit funds
and will apply on behalf of the City of Ithaca and other transit providers to receive and use said funds, and
WHEREAS, the County of Tompkins desires to submit a request for a grant of funds to the New
York State Depalfluent of Transportation and the Federal Transit Administration, pursuant to Section 9 of
the Federal Transit Act of 1964, as amended, in the amount of $384,408, and
WHEREAS, the Federal Section 9 funding will be used as follows: Transit operating assistance -
$244,000, capital projects - $118,480, and transit planning - $21,928, and
WHEREAS, the project was approved by the Ithaca -Tompkins County Transportation Council and
is included on the 1993 Transportation Improvement Program, as amended, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the Tompkins County Board
of Representatives authorizes the County Administrator, or designee, to execute and file and application
on behalf of the County of Tompkins, with the United States Depai tment of Transportation and the New
York State Department of Transportation to aid in financing the 1994 Section 9 Grant,
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator, or designee, is authorized to execute grant
agreements on behalf of the County of Tompkins with the United States Department of Transportation
and the New York State Department of Transportation, and any third party subcontractor necessary to
complete the Project.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 328 - AUTHORIZING 1994 FEDERAL SECTION 18 PUBLIC TRANSIT
GRANT - TOMTRAN
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Ms. Mink. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 14, Noes -
1 (Representative Shurtleff). Adopted.
WHEREAS, the County of Tompkins is submitting a request for a grant of funds to the New York
State Depaitment of Transportation and the United States Department of Transportation, pursuant to
Section 18 of the Federal Transit Act of 1964, as amended, for a Project to provide for public mass
transportation service for TOMTRAN Rural Transit serving the City of Ithaca and Towns of Ithaca,
Dryden, Caroline, Danby, Newfield, Ulysses, Lansing and Groton, to be operated by C.U. (Cornell
University) Transit, Inc. and Tioga Transport, Inc. in the amount of $69,000 for the 1994 fiscal year, and
WHEREAS, the County of Tompkins and the State of New York have entered into a continuing
Agreement for a ten-year period which authorized the undertaking of the Project and payment of the
federal share identified as State Contract C002157, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the Board of Representatives
authorizes the County Administrator, or designee, to act on behalf of the County of Tompkins to sign the
annual grant application and to progress and complete the above named Project,
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator, or designee, is authorized to sign any
contracts or agreements between the County of Tompkins and any third party subcontractor necessary to
complete the Project.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
308
December 7, 1993
RESOLUTION NO. 329 - AUTHORIZING PAYMENT OF FEDERAL TRANSIT FUNDS TO
CITY OF ITHACA
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Ms. Mink. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 14, Noes -
1 (Representative Shurtleff). Adopted.
WHEREAS, Tompkins County and the City of Ithaca approved a supplemental agreement to
designate Tompkins County as the designated recipient of federal transit funds (Resolution Nos. CA101-
92 dated December 7, 1992, pursuant to Federal Transit Act of 1964, as amended, and
WHEREAS, the County, as the designated recipient, is the sole applicant for federal transit funds
for Section 3, 9 and 18 programs, and
WHEREAS, the County applied for Federal Section 9 funds on behalf of the City of Ithaca and the
County for the years of 1992, 1993 and 1994 and desires to pass through FTA funds to the City as they
are received, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the Tompkins County Board
of Representatives authorizes the County Comptroller to make necessary adjustments to the 1993
TOMTRAN Budget A5630.4594 (federal revenue) and A5630.4425 (Appropriations - Contract Services)
to pay the City of Ithaca Federal Section 9 funding for transit operating assistance as follows:
Federal Section 9 Year
$191,357 1992
166,000 1993
Total $357,357
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 330 - REQUEST THE BOARD OF REPRESENTATIVES HOLD A
SPECIAL SESSION ON COMPREHENSIVE PLANNING IN 1994
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Ms. Mink. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 14, Noes -
1 (Representative Shurtleff). Adopted.
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County economy is in a period of change, and
WHEREAS, there will need to be a coordinated approach to respond to this change from local
businesses, institutions, and governments, and
WHEREAS, Tompkins County has an important role to play to foster appropriate economic
development, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the Tompkins County Board
of Representatives devote a special session early in 1994 to discuss the future of Tompkins County's
economy and authorize work on a strategic economic plan as part of the County's comprehensive
planning program,
RESOLVED, further, That the Tompkins County Planning Board recommends that the Board of
Representatives invite to that special session members of the Comprehensive Planning Steering
Committee, Tompkins County Planning Department, Tompkins County Area Development, Chamber of
Commerce, and local municipalities, chambers of commerce and economic development organizations.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 331 - APPROVAL OF CORNELL UNIVERSITY CONTRACT TO
PRODUCE DIGITAL ELEVATION TERRAIN MODEL FOR
TOMPKINS COUNTY
309
December 7, 1993
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Ms. Mink. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 14, Noes -
1 (Representative Shurtleff). Adopted.
WHEREAS, the program narrative supports the development of information on watersheds and
monies exist in the Aquatic Vegetation Control Program (8022) Account to support GIS (Geographic
Information System) activities, and
WHEREAS, the CLEARS Program within the Center for the Environment at Cornell University
has developed procedures to generate digital elevation models based on United States geological seven
and one-half minute topological maps, and
WHEREAS, the aquatic program has need of this information to assist in modeling efforts, and
WHEREAS, other County programs will also benefit from the information including
comprehensive planning, GIS database development, and transportation analysis, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee and on approval of the Board of
Representatives, That the County Administrator is authorized to enter into appropriate agreement(s) with
Cornell University to acquire digital elevation terrain models for Tompkins County at a cost not to exceed
$7,500.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 332 - AUTHORIZATION TO SIGN LICENSE AGREEMENT WITH NEW
YORK STATE ELECTRIC AND GAS (NYSEG)
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Ms. Mink. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 14, Noes -
1 (Representative Shurtleff). Adopted.
WHEREAS, the County, New York State Electric and Gas, City of Ithaca, Town of Ithaca and
Cornell university have been involved in a joint capital program venture to produce a planimetric map for
the County, and
WHEREAS, this project is now nearing completion and the parties are concerned that the
information be maintained and that each of the parties will bear a portion of the responsibility to maintain
this information in a current state, and
WHEREAS, current State, legislation does not permit the County to charge requestors of the
information under the Freedom of Information Act, and
WHEREAS, the parties have collectively agreed that there is a need and interest to be able to cover
costs of maintaining, updating and in addition recover some of the development costs from municipalities
and private concerns not a party to the development costs of the project, and
WHEREAS, the only procedure now available to protect the database from unrestrictive
reproduction and resale is through a license arrangement with New York State Electric and Gas, now
therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee and approval of the Board of
Representatives, That the County Administrator is authorized to enter into an interim license agreement
and that this agreement shall continue pending changes in State legislation or other negotiations which
may alter the need to continue the said arrangement.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 333 - AUTHORIZATION TO AWARD TOURISM PROMOTION GRANTS -
ADVISORY BOARD ON TOURISM DEVELOPMENT
Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Ms. Mink. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 14, Noes -
1 (Representative Shurtleff). Adopted.
310
December 7, 1993
WHEREAS, the Advisory Board on Tourism Development has responsibility for the review of
grant proposals for tourism related projects in Tompkins County, and
WHEREAS, the Dewitt Historical Society, Caroline Bicentennial, Ithaca Opera, Early Music
Association, Farmers Market, Upstairs Gallery, Kitchen Theatre, and the Finger Lakes Bach Festival have
submitted applications for funding from the County through the Advisory Board on Tourism
Development, and
WHEREAS, the Advisory Board on Tourism Development has found the above-mentioned grant
requests to be worthy of funding and appropriate to the mission of the Advisory Board on Tourism
Development, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Planning Committee, That the following grants be
awarded:
Dewitt Historical Society $10,000
Caroline Bicentennial $ 2,000
Ithaca Opera $ 2,000
Early Music Association $ 4,000
Farmers Market $ 5,000
Upstairs Gallery $ 760
Kitchen Theatre $ 6,000
Finger Lakes Bach Festival $ 2,000
Total $31,760
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 334 - AWARD OF CONTRACT - DOWNSTREAM FOREST HOME DRIVE
OVER FALL CREEK BRIDGE REPLACEMENT DESIGN
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Stein. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 13, Noes -
2 (Representatives Proto and Shurtleff). Adopted.
WHEREAS, the Division of Purchasing and Central Services has duly advertised for Proposals for
Downstream Forest Home Drive Over Fall Creek Replacement Design, and
WHEREAS, four (4) proposals were received on October 15, 1993, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the Proposal received from MRB Group of Rochester, New York for $24,830 be and hereby is
accepted,
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator is authorized to execute an agreement with
MRB Group and execute change orders up to the project contingency of $2,430. Funds to be provided in
Account No. D5010.4411.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 335 - AWARD OF BID - WROUGHT IRON BRIDGE TRUSS AND STEEL
GRID DECK
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Stein. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 13, Noes -
2 (Representatives Proto and Shurtleff). Adopted.
WHEREAS, the Division of Purchasing and Central Services has duly advertised for bids for the
sale of one (1) wrought iron bridge truss and steel grid deck, and
WHEREAS, two (2) bids were received and publicly opened and read on Tuesday, November 30,
1993, now therefore be it
311
December 7, 1993
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the bid submitted by Joseph Oliver of Brooktondale, New York be accepted as the highest
responsible bidder with a bid of $519,
RESOLVED, further, That the Public Works Division of Engineering be authorized to implement
this bid on behalf of the County.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 336 - DESIGN REVIEW SERVICES RECYCLING AND SOLID WASTE
CENTER
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Stein. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 13, Noes -
2 (Representatives Proto and Shurtleff). Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the County Administrator be authorized to sign an agreement with Malcolm Pirnie of 2 Corporate
Park Drive, White Plains, New York for Design Review Services for the Recycling and Solid Waste
Center for a total not to exceed $39,820.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 337 - AUDIT OF FINAL PAYMENT - SNYDER ROAD RELOCATION AND
FENCING (CONSTRUCTION) - ORCHARD EARTH AND PIPE
CORPORATION
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Todd. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes -
15, Noes - 0. Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the following claim against the County of Tompkins, be and hereby is audited, by the, Board of
Representatives:
Vendor Payment Request Account No. Amount
Orchard #3 (Final) HX.5698.9213 $66,854.20
Earth and Pipe Construction
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller be and hereby is authorized and directed to pay said
claim from Account No. HX.5698.9213.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 338 - AUDIT OF FINAL PAYMENT - OLD JAIL RENOVATION -
CHRISTA CONSTRUCTION
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mrs. Call. A roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 14,
Noes - 1 (Representative Proto). Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the following claim against the County of Tompkins, be and hereby is audited by the Board of
Representatives:
Vendor Payment Request Account No. Amount
Christa Construction 12 (Final) HV3151.9239 $29,749.95
312
December 7, 1993
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller be and hereby is authorized and directed to pay said
claim from Account No. HV3151.9239.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 339 - AUDIT OF FINAL PAYMENT - COURTHOUSE ANNEX - CHRISTA
CONSTRUCTION
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Stein. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes -
15, Noes - 0. Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the following claim against the County of Tompkins, be and hereby is audited by the Board of
Representatives:
Vendor Payment Request Account No. Amount
Christa Construction 8 (Final) HQ1355.9239 $ 2,850
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller be and hereby is authorized and directed to pay said
claim from Account No. HQ1355.9239.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 340 - AUDIT OF FINAL PAYMENT - COURTHOUSE RENOVATION —
CHRISTA CONSTRUCTION
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Mason. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes -
15, Noes - 0. Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the following claim against the County of Tompkins, be and hereby is audited by the Board of
Representatives:
Vendor Payment Request Account No. Amount
Christa Construction 12 (Final) HQ1620.9239 $29,309.42
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller be and hereby is authorized and directed to pay said
claim from Account No. HQ1620.9239.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 341 - AUDIT OF FINAL PAYMENT - T -HANGARS - DANIEL J. LYNCH,
INC.
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Todd. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes -
15, Noes - 0. Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the following claim against the County of Tompkins, be and hereby is audited by the Board of
Representatives:
Vendor Payment Request Account No. Amount
Daniel J. Lynch, Inc. 5 (Final) HT5612.9239 $15,253.95
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller be and hereby is authorized and directed to pay said
claim from Account No. HT5612.9239.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
313
December 7, 1993
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 342 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE EXTENSION OF SNOW AND ICE
AGREEMENT WITH THE STATE OF NEW YORK
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Culligan, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, the County of Tompkins has heretofore entered into an agreement with the State of
New York pursuant to Section twelve (12) of the Highway Law relating to control of snow and ice on
State Highways in towns and incorporated villages, and
WHEREAS, Section seven (7) and ten (10) of said agreement respectively proved a method of
modifying the map of affected State highways and for annually updating the estimated expenditures, and
WHEREAS, it would be in the best interest of the County to extend said agreement currently set to
expire June 30, 1994 as modified and updated, for an additional one-year period, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That an extension of said snow and ice agreement is hereby authorized for a period of one year from July
1, 1994 through June 30, 1995, and the County Administrator be and hereby is authorized and directed to
execute such extension on behalf of the County.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 343 - AUDIT OF FINAL PAYMENT - SOLID WASTE OFFICE/ENTRY -
PANKO ELECTRICAL AND MAINTENANCE
Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Culligan. A roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 13,
Noes - 2 (Representatives Proto and Shurtleff). Adopted.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Works and Construction Management Committee,
That the following claim against the County of Tompkins, be and hereby is audited by the Board of
Representatives:
Vendor Payment Request Account No. Amount
Panko Electrical and Maint. 13 (Final) HH8167.9239 $1,647.68
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller be and hereby is authorized and directed to pay said
claim from Account No. UE8167.9239.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 344 - ADOPTION OF LOCAL LAW NO. 5 OF 1993 - AMENDING LOCAL
LAW NO. 1 OF 1993 - AUTHORIZING THE ESTABLISHMENT OF
AN ANNUAL SOLID WASTE FEE FOR REAL PROPERTY IN
TOMPKINS COUNTY
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Lerner. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 11, Noes -
4 (Representatives Proto, Schuler, Shurtleff, and Stein). Adopted.
WHEREAS, a public hearing was held before the Board of Representatives on October 5, 1993 to
hear all persons interested in proposed Local Law No. 5 of 1993, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That said proposed
Local Law No. 5 of 1993 - Amending Local Law No. 1 of 1993 - Authorizing the Establishment of an
Annual Fee for Real Property in Tompkins County is adopted,
314
December 7, 1993
RESOLVED, further, That the Clerk of the Board publish in the official newspaper of Tompkins
County a notice of adoption containing a synopsis of said local law, and shall within five (5) days file one
certified copy in the office of the County Clerk and three (3) certified copies in the office of the Secretary
of State.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 345 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE FOURTH AMENDED CONSENT
ORDER WITH THE NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF
ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION
Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, the County of Tompkins (the "County"), Landstrom Gravel Company, Inc., and the
Depai liiient of Environmental Conservation (the "DEC") entered into a Consent Order relative to the
closure of a landfill located on Hillview and Michigan Hollow Roads in the Town of Spencer, Tioga
County, New York and the Town of Danby, Tompkins County, New York, formerly known as the
Landstrom Landfill, and
WHEREAS, by Resolution No. 163 dated June 21, 1988, this Board authorized the Chairman to
execute a second Amended Consent Order with Landstrom Gravel Company, Inc. and the DEC, and
Resolution No. 514 dated December 17, 1991, this Board authorized the Chairman to execute a certain
Third Amended Consent Order, and
WHEREAS, representatives of the DEC and the County have met to negotiate the terms and
conditions of a proposed Fourth Amended Consent Order (Case No. R7-0585-90-12), and
WHEREAS, the proposed action is exempt pursuant to SEQRA 6 NYCRR Section 617.2 (q)(i) as
it involves Civil Enforcement Proceedings, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, That
the Chairman of this Board of Representatives is hereby authorized and directed to execute a Fourth
Amended Consent Order with the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation permitting
the extended use of the Hillview Transfer Facility until March 1, 1995 and the Interim Composting
Facility until December 31, 1994,
RESOLVED, further, That the Chairman of the Board of Representatives is authorized to further
negotiate amendments of said Fourth Amended Consent Order as may be appropriate hereafter under the
circumstances.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 346 - AUTHORIZING A PUBLIC HEARING ON PROPOSED LOCAL LAW
NO. 6 OF 1993 - FLOW CONTROL OF SOLID WASTE AND
HAULERS LICENSING
Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mrs. Call. A voice vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 14, Noes -
1 (Representative Shurtleff). Adopted.
RESOLVED; on recommendation of the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, That
a public hearing be held before the Board of Representatives at Board Chambers of the Tompkins County
Courthouse, 320 North Tioga Street, Ithaca, New York on December 21, 1993 at 5:30 o'clock in the
evening thereof concerning proposed Local Law No. 6 of 1993 - Flow Control of Solid Waste and
Haulers Licensing. At such time and place all persons interested in the subject matter will be heard
concerning the same.
RESOLVED, further, That the Clerk of the Board is hereby authorized and directed to place proper
notice of such public hearing in the official newspaper of the County.
315
December 7, 1993
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 347 - ACCEPTING THE FINAL GENERIC ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT
STATEMENT FOR THE TOMPKINS COUNTY SOLID WASTE
MANAGEMENT PLAN
Moved by Mr. Lerner, seconded by Mrs. Call. A short roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes -
15, Noes - 0. Adopted.
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County Board of Representatives has proposed a Solid Waste
Management Plan to address the current and future solid waste management needs of Tompkins County,
and
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County Board of Representatives is Lead Agency under the New York
State Environmental Quality Review Act ("SEQRA") for the adoption of the County's Solid Waste
Management Plan ("SWMP"), and
WHEREAS, the Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement (DGEIS) was determined
complete by the Tompkins County Board of Representatives in its capacity as Lead Agency on October
19, 1993 and was filed and circulated along with a Notice of Completion of Draft Generic Environmental
Impact Statement (DGEIS) to other involved or interested local and state agencies and the public as
required by the SEQRA Regulations (6 NYCRR Part 617), and
WHEREAS, the Tompkins County Board of Representatives duly noticed public hearing to solicit
comments on the DGEIS from all interested persons, which was held on November 9, 1993 at which time
all members of the public wishing to make statements concerning the DGEIS were heard, and
WHEREAS, a proposed Final Generic Environmental Impact Statement ("FGEIS") has been
prepared which consists of the DGEIS, revisions to the DGEIS, the substantive public comments for the
DGEIS and the responses thereto, together with additional information and data prepared in response to
the public comments received, and
WHEREAS, the members of the Tompkins County Board of Representatives have had an
opportunity to review the public comments received on the DGEIS and the FGEIS for completeness, and
WHEREAS, a finding by the Lead Agency that the FGEIS is complete does not commit the Lead
Agency in its subsequent decision-making capacity to either unconditionally accept, reject or otherwise
approve or disapprove of the SWMP, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Solid Waste and Resource Management Committee, That
the Tompkins County Board of Representatives, as Lead Agency, has determined that the FGEIS for the
SWMP is complete and hereby directs that the FGEIS be filed and circulated as required by the SEQRA
Regulations,
RESOLVED, further, That the FGEIS be made available to the public for consideration and in
order to facilitate such consideration the FGEIS shall be filed at the following locations:
Tompkins County Board of Representatives
320 North Tioga Street
Ithaca, New York 14850
Solid Waste Division
122 Commercial Avenue
Ithaca, New York 14850
RESOLVED, further, That the Tompkins County Board of Representatives authorizes and directs
the Chairman of the Board of Representatives to file a Notice of Completion of the FGEIS, and to take
such other actions as may be necessary and desirable to comply with the SEQRA Regulations.
SEQR ACTION: TYPE I OR UNLISTED
(DETERMINATIONS OR FINDINGS INCLUDED HEREIN)
316
December 7, 1993
RESOLUTION NO. 348 - AMENDMENT OF RESOLUTION NO. 263 OF OCTOBER 22, 1979 -
TOMPKINS COUNTY FAMILY COURT ADVISORY COUNCIL
Moved by Mr. Mason, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, Resolution No. 263 of October 22, 1979 created a Tompkins County Family Court
Advisory Council, now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Safety Committee, That Resolution No. 263 be
and hereby is amended by increasing membership to include a Mental Health Clinic representative for a
three-year term,
RESOLVED, further, That all other items in Resolution No. 263 will remain unchanged.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 349 - AUTHORIZING A PUBLIC HEARING ON PROPOSED LOCAL LAW
NO. 7 OF 1993 - IMPOSING A SURCHARGE ON TELEPHONE
ACCESS LINES TO RAISE REVENUES FOR THE SYSTEM COSTS
ASSOCIATED WITH THE CREATION OF AN ENHANCED 911
EMERGENCY TELEPHONE SYSTEM IN TOMPKINS COUNTY
Moved by Mr. Mason, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Safety Committee, That a public hearing be held
before the Board of Representatives at Board Chambers of the Tompkins County Courthouse, 320 North
Tioga Street, Ithaca, New York on December 21, 1993 at 5:30 o'clock in the evening thereof concerning
proposed Local Law No. 7 of 1993 - Imposing a Surcharge on Telephone Access Lines to Raise Revenues
for the System Costs Associated with the Creation of an Enhanced 911 Emergency Telephone System in
Tompkins County. At such time and place all persons interested in the subject matter will be heard
concerning the same.
RESOLVED, further, That the Clerk of the Board is hereby authorized and directed to place proper
notice of such public hearing in the official newspaper of the County.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
RESOLUTION NO. 350 - AUTHORIZING A PUBLIC HEARING ON PROPOSED LOCAL LAW
NO. 8 OF 1993 - A LOCAL LAW OF THE COUNTY OF TOMPKINS,
STATE OF NEW YORK, REQUIRING SUBMISSION OF ASSIGNED
COUNSEL VOUCHERS FOR PAYMENT WITHIN NINETY DAYS
OF COMPLETION OF SERVICES
Moved by Mr. Mason, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Public Safety Committee, That a public hearing be held
before the Board of Representatives at Board Chambers of the Tompkins County Courthouse, 320 North
Tioga Street, Ithaca, New York on December 21, 1993 at 5:30 o'clock in the evening thereof concerning
proposed Local Law No. 8 of 1993 - A Local Law of the County of Tompkins, State of New York,
Requiring Submission of Assigned Counsel Vouchers for Payment Within Ninety Days of Completion.
At such time and place all persons interested in the subject matter will be heard concerning the same.
RESOLVED, further, That the Clerk of the Board is hereby authorized and directed to place proper
notice of such public hearing in the official newspaper of the County.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
317
December 7, 1993
RESOLUTION NO. 351 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE A CONTRACT WITH FOODNET
Moved by Ms. Mink, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
WHEREAS, the Office for the Aging contracts with Foodnet to provide home delivered meals to
appropriate elderly, and
WHEREAS, Foodnet wishes to initiate an effort in 1994 to request payment for such meals from
those who can afford to do so, and
WHEREAS, no appropriate senior will be denied meal service because of non-payment for meals,
now therefore be it
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Human Services Committee, That the Office for the
Aging, is authorized to execute a contract with Foodnet in the amount of $6,500 to pay salary and fringe
for personnel making the private pay screening assessment.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
It was Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote, to lift
from the Table the following resolution:
RESOLUTION NO. 319 - AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE AGREEMENT WITH THIRD
PARTY ADMINISTRATOR FOR SELF INSURANCE OF
WORKER'S COMPENSATION CLAIMS, TRANSFER FROM
DEPARTMENTAL WORKER'S COMPENSATION SUB -
ACCOUNTS TO WORKER'S COMPENSATION INSURANCE
RESERVE ACCOUNT, AND AUTHORIZATION TO EXECUTE
AGREEMENT WITH SEDGWICK JAMES, INC., AS BROKER
FOR CATASTROPHIC LOSS INSURANCE COVERAGE FOR
WORKER'S COMPENSATION CLAIMS
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote.
RESOLVED, on recommendation of the Budget and Administration Committee, That the County
Administrator is authorized and directed to execute an agreement with RMSCO to provide third party
administrator services in connection with a conversion effective January 1, 1994 to self-insurance for
worker's compensation claims,
RESOLVED, further, That the Comptroller is directed to transfer funds from departmental
worker's compensation subaccounts in the 1994 budget so as to fund fully the reserve for payment of
claims as recommended by said Administrator,
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator is authorized and directed to execute an
amendment to the County's brokerage contract with Sedgwick James of New York, Inc., to broker an
insurance policy for catastrophic losses from worker's compensation claims,
RESOLVED, further, That the County Administrator or designee is authorized to execute all
required documentation in connection with this change to self insurance with catastrophic protection.
SEQR ACTION: EXEMPT OR TYPE II
(NO FURTHER ACTION NECESSARY)
It was Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Evans, and unanimously adopted by voice vote, to
adjourn the meeting and reconvene at Kulp Auditorium, Ithaca High School, at 6:40 p.m.
318
December 7, 1993
Chairman Watros called the public hearing to order at 7:00 p.m. concerning the proposed 1994
Tompkins County Budget and Capital Program.
Chairman Watros opened the public hearing concerning the proposed 1994 Tompkins County
Budget and Capital Program at 7:10 p.m. Mr. Watros introduced Representatives and staff seated on the
stage and. established guidelines for speakers. He stated that every person wishing to speak would have
an opportunity to address the Board for three minutes and asked that there be no applause between
speakers.
Margaret Dill, Executive Director, Human Services Coalition, and Town of Lansing resident,
stated that she felt if it is important to cut taxes, doing so by cutting across the board would result in a
disservice to everyone. She stated that by cutting services, it would be more costly to taxpayers in the
long -run.
Ed Swayze, Information and Referral (I&R) Service of the Human Services Coalition and Lansing
resident, spoke of the increased demand for I&R services and expressed support for other services offered
by the Coalition.
Paul Eberts, Chairman, Economic Opportunity Corporation Board, stated that he felt that generally
when budgets get cut the low income people are the ones who get hurt. Mr. Eberts expressed opposition
to cutting across the board because by doing so, the quality of the community would diminish. He stated
that until people understand problems of human services in the County they won't be able to respond to
the needs of the County. He asked that funding for human services agencies be left in as much tact as
possible.
Lynn Jackier, Drop -In Children's Center, stated that the Center received a huge cut in 1991 and has
been working since that time to get that money back. She stated that the services provided by the Center
is to prevent parents from using other services later. She stated that additional cuts will cause the Center
to deteriorate.
Mary Ann Lapinski, Trumansburg resident, spoke on behalf of the Learning Web. She asked that
the Board not give in to easy decisions and expressed opposition to across the board cuts. She stated she
feels the deterioration of services puts youth at risk.
Judith VanAllen, Director of Offender Aid Restoration, urged the Board not to cut human services
funding. She stated that O.A.R. is an agency run on a very tight budget with a low budget for salaries.
She gave examples of specific budget cuts undertaken by the Agency in 1991, 1992 and 1993.
John Rowley, local Attorney and member of the Criminal Justice Advisory/Alternatives to
Incarceration Board, expressed opposition to any cuts being made to Offender Aid Restoration. He stated
although he does not want to pay higher taxes, he is willing to do so. Mr. Rowley suggested a freeze on
current levels of funding.
Rebecca Snyder, City of Ithaca homeowner, expressed support for funding to the Drop-in
Children's Center. She stated that she feels that service provided by that Agency is important to the
community.
Sally Wesselo, B.O.C.E.S. ESL Program Coordinator, stated that the program is not supported by
Tompkins County but stated that several persons involved in the program use the services of the Drop -In
Children's Center. She urged the Board's support of this Agency.
Tony Poole, member of the Southside Community Center and the Human Rights Commission,
stated that for the past few years the Southside Community Center has received the same allocation from
319
December 7, 1993
the County to operate the community center at Southside. Mr. Poole asked the Board not to subject the
Center to further budget cuts.
Joan Farbman, member of the Child Sexual Abuse and Battered Women's Task Forces, stated that
she feels it takes much longer to repair damage than to cause it and just because services are not
mandated, it does not mean that they are not just as crucial. Ms. Farbman stated that the Task Forces do
their work by Remediation and asked the Board to not cut funding.
Marcia Fort, City of Ithaca resident and Director of a human services agency, said unemployment
is a problem and the need for advocacy and services has not decreased.
David Leahy, Better Housing of Tompkins County and City of Ithaca resident, asked for the Board
to support funding to Better Housing of Tompkins County. He stated that Better Housing helps improve
housing opportunities for lower income families in Tompkins County. The funding received by the
Agency goes to the home repair program. The Agency makes 55-65 emergency and/or health and safety
repairs per year. Another program protects and maintains existing housing structures. He stated that the
funds in excess of $600,000 used by the program are put back into the local economy.
Louise Miller, Director of the Child Sexual Abuse Project, spoke not only as someone who is a
taxpayer but someone who supports human services and feels the agencies are important to the
community.
Krys Cail, Treasurer for the Drop -In Children's Center, spoke in support of the Center and stated
that the Center helps single people on welfare get off welfare. She also stated that she and her husband
own a business in Tompkins County and are not members of the Chamber of Commerce. She feels that
the Chamber does not represent their needs.
Melissa Edmunds, Drop -In Children's Center supporter, urged the Board not to cut funding to the
Center.
Valorie Rockney, Director of Literacy Volunteers, and City of Ithaca resident, stated that she is not
comfortable with programs that don't stay within their budget guidelines and come in over budget. She
stated that Literacy Volunteers is a free and confidential tutoring of basic English and reading skills using
volunteer tutors. Ms. Rockney stated that the Agency receives support from several other sources and in
July laid off three staff members and reduced the number of students they can accept. She said that the
services provided by the Agency are provided by volunteers and are cost effective and cause savings in
the long run.
Tom Vanderzee, Town of Danby resident, spoke on behalf of Cooperative Extension. He stated
that every dollar received by the County can be leveraged to two dollars in matching state and federal
grants. He stated he is opposed to making across the board cuts.
Mike May, Cooperative Extension Board of Directors, stated he is opposed to across the board
cuts. He asked that the Board take time to analyze services. Mr. May said that funding from the County
is needed by the Extension to bring in State and Federal funding.
Dr. Eduardo Marti, President, Tompkins Cortland Community College, stated that he is opposed to
across the board cuts. He asked that if the Board had to reduce the budget, to fund only those who
provide efficient service.
Nancy Spero, Co -Director, AIDS Work of Tompkins County, stated that one person in 250 is
affected with HIV and that AIDS Work receives approximately eight new referrals every month. She
stated that funds received from the County for the last three years totaled $11,000 and with proposed cuts
320
December 7, 1993
they will not be able to provide education that people urgently want and need. Ms. Spero urged the Board
not to cut funds to AIDS Work.
Anita BeLucci, Displaced Homemakers, stated that she once was a recipient of services provided
by Displaced Homemakers and is now volunteering there. She believes the Agency provides a very
worth while service and urged the Board to not cut funds to the Agency.
Joann Miner, member of the Displaced Homemakers Advisory Board and a Town of Lansing
resident, stated she has been a user of services provided by Displaced Homemakers and the care that is
provided by that Agency is less expensive than the cost of care provided by others. She urged the Board
to not cut funds to the Agency.
Ann Roscoe, President, Tompkins County Public Library and Village of Lansing resident, stated
that more people are using the Library and that the number of cardholders has increased by 1,000. Ms.
Roscoe asked that if cuts have to be made that they not be made across the board.
Pat Pryor, member of the AIDS Work Board of Directors, expressed support for funding to AIDS
Work and stated that she does not want her property tax to increase but has never seen a time when the
County has been in so much need of services.
Constance Cook, Member, Tompkins County Public Library Board, stated that the Library has not
recovered from the cuts imposed in 1992 and stated that staff has been reduced and that the Library relies
greatly on help provided by volunteers. She urged the Board to preserve funding to the Library.
Marilyn Kinner, Senior Citizens Council, stated that the Council would be severely affected by
proposed cuts. Ms. Kinner spoke of budget cuts undertaken by the Council in 1991 and urged the Board
not to cut funding to the Council. She also expressed her opposition to cutting across the board.
Phyllis Stout, recipient of services provided by the Office for the Aging, stated that there are three
programs that are vital to the elderly people of Tompkins County: home delivery of meals, in-home
personal care and housekeeping services, and the Personal Emergency Response service. She stated that
these services prevent people from becoming hospitalized which would be at a much greater cost. Ms.
Stout urged the Board not to cut funding to the Office for the Aging.
Susan Hatch, Law Guardian, stated that she has been working for the last twelve years with the
County court system and foster care families. She urged the Board to accept the work of County
departments.
Charlotte Bruce, member Office for the Aging Advisory Committee, stated that the proposed cuts
would result in the loss of 3,400 meals being delivered to the elderly and would result in some not being
able to maintain an independent life in their own home.
Herbert Engman, Town of Danby resident, stated that he is upset with news coverage on the
budget issue. He said a local newspaper claims that the public has spoken. Mr. Engman said he
volunteers over one hundred hours each year volunteering to different causes and gets to see the way that
government operates. He supports the way Tompkins County operates and the budget as presented.
Milt Goldstein, Executive Director, Challenge Industries, stated that proposed cuts would result in
$9,000 being cut in custodial services provided in the Mental Health Facility. Mr. Goldstein urged to the
Board not to cut these services.
Elizabeth Webster, Well Child Clinic, stated that over 3,000 children use well child immunization
clinics within the County. Ms. Webster expressed opposition to any reduction of funding to this program.
321
December 7, 1993
Nancy Lauten, Tompkins County resident, stated that she once was involved in a dangerous
situation and relied on the Task Force for Battered Women to help her. The Task Force and other County
services helped her and her six children and she is not self sufficient and possesses an associates degree.
She stated that she believes by paying a little now, it prevents paying a lot later. She asked the Board to
support services which are preventative.
Calvin Criss, Tompkins County resident, stated he is upset by the number of people that have
spoken in favor of services. He believes all speakers prior to him have been employed by the County.
Mr. Criss stated that the private sector has made reductions in salaries and benefits and asked that benefits
to County employees be reduced. Mr. Criss said he opposes any property tax increase.
Pat Driscoll, Town of Ithaca, stated that she serves on a number of local boards and has been a
resident of Tompkins County all her life. During a recent election campaign she went to over 1,000
homes and spoke to a number of people who stated they can no longer afford to live in Tompkins County.
She stated that cutting funds to human services agencies is an extremely difficult task, however, urged the
Board to adopt the amendment that will be presented by Representative Todd.
Leo Smull, Tompkins County resident, stated he feels that Tompkins is a small county and cannot
afford to have all the programs it currently has. He said he opposes any property tax increase.
William Benjamin, New York State Division of Probation and Correctional Alternatives and
Tompkins County resident, stated that at the October 7, 1993 Public Safety meeting the Committee
approved a budget proposal for the Alcoholism Council for 1994 and due to a clerical error it was
inadvertently left out of the budget. Mr. Benjamin asked that this item be included in the budget. Mr.
Benjamin stated he feels the decisions of this Board for the last four years have lead up to this public
panic. He stated he did not agree with the pay equity study conducted by the County which resulted in
some employees receiving very large raises.
Nancy Wilson, Health Planning Council, asked that the Board not cut the Health Planning Council
position which is currently at 70 percent.
Beverly Snow-Cretser, Executive Director, Alcoholism Council, requested that the budget proposal
for the Council which was approved by the Public Safety Committee on October 7, 1993 be included in
the budget. She stated without the Board continuing to fund the Alternatives to Incarceration program,
there would be overcrowding at the Tompkins County Public Safety building.
Chairman Watros declared recess from 9:00 - 9:08 p.m.
Joanie Groome, Tompkins County resident stated that she believes there are many under -privileged
people who reside in Tompkins County and deserve the services they are receiving. She stated that she
estimates the Recreation Mainstreaming Program would service 30-40 individuals less than are currently
being served if the proposed cuts are made.
Nicole Carrier, City of Ithaca homeowner and Director of Campfire Boys and Girls, expressed
support for human services provided by the County. She stated that she would rather pay higher taxes
than witness the devastation of human services cuts.
Dan Collins, New York State Electric and Gas (NYSEG), stated that in 1946, 46 percent of jobs in
Tompkins County were manufacturing jobs and today eight percent are manufacturing jobs. He stated
that the jobs have been driven out but the cost of doing business in New York State and Tompkins County
has dramatically risen. He stated that the adoption of NAFTA (North American Free Trade Agreement)
makes us look at the global markets. Mr. Collins said that New York State is among the number one
states in the Country on welfare spending. Mr. Collins urged the Board to just say no to New York State
322
December 7, 1993
and mandates, and asked that goals not be confused with mandates. Mr. Collins stated that he feels the
proposed cuts will not result in services being cut.
Michael Theusen, Chamber of Commerce member, read the following proclamation adopted by
the Chamber of Commerce: "RESOLVED: the County Affairs Committee of the Tompkins County
Chamber of Commerce urges the County Board of Representatives to reduce the proposed tax increase of
11.26 percent to a zero percent increase, with said decrease to be based on review of all budget line items,
including mandated services, and to be based on the prioritizing of requested services".
Lynn Glace, Town of Newfield resident, expressed support for services provided by Displaced
Homemakers and the Learning Web.
Barbara Thuesen, Town of Ithaca resident, spoke of hard times people are experiencing and the
burden being put on tax paying citizens. She asked that the County assess its obligation to the taxpayers,
to downsize government and eliminate the duplication of services. Ms. Theusen stated she is opposed to
any property tax increase.
Richard Flaville, City of Ithaca resident, spoke of cuts and what the results would be and stated
that he is willing to pay to. maintain current services.
Will Kone, Tompkins County resident, asked that County government tighten its belt on spending.
He stated he is opposed to any property tax increase.
Jonathan Beck, Tompkins County resident, spoke in support of the Learning Web and stated that
the survival of some agencies depend on funding received by the County and asked that the Board
determines what programs can survive the proposed cuts.
Ron Space, II, Town of Groton resident and member of the Tompkins County Farm Bureau, read a
letter from the Farm Bureau which supports the amendment to be proposed by Representative Todd
calling for no property tax increase in 1994. The letter also called for spending restraints.
Joseph Springer, Ithaca resident, angrily addressed the Board and stated that businesses cannot
pass on an eleven percent increase to its customers and the County shouldn't be able to either. Mr.
Springer expressed his opposition to the proposed budget.
Girard Oberrender, Tompkins County resident, stated that 300 people were laid off in this area in
October and feels County employees should be facing lay offs also. Mr. Oberrender stated that he feels
services should be cut in order to achieve a zero percent property tax increase.
Ted Wixom, Town of Lansing, stated that he is opposed to an increase in property taxes. Mr.
Wixom suggested the next time the Board presents the public with a property tax increase to invite State
representatives to attend the hearing. Mr. Wixom suggested that people voluntarily give financial support
to agencies of their choice.
William Gibson, Town of Ithaca, stated he is opposed to across the board cuts in the County
budget because it could be costly in the long run. He stated he would like to see all services carried out as
efficiently as possible and is not convinced that most people want cuts made in the budget. He asked that
the Board carefully scrutinize and get an early start on the budget next year.
Kim Whetzel, Gaggle Septic Company, spoke of rising costs and stated that the County became his
biggest and toughest competitor when the County got into the business but eventually couldn't be
competitive with his rates. He asked that the not get involved with the private sector. He stated he is
opposed to the proposed budget.
323
December 7, 1993
Ben Curtis, Trumansburg resident, stated that he has a long background working with human
services agencies. Mr. Curtis stated that he is in support of a ten percent across the board cut. He asked
that the County prioritize and evaluate existing programs and to also bring benefits for County employees
into line with other businesses.
Bart Hiliard, Tompkins County resident, asked that the Board investigate and evaluate each and
every program to see if they are really needed and necessary to the population of Tompkins County. He
also questioned if the position of County Administrator is necessary. He stated that New York State
Electric and Gas has had to tighten their belts and that Tompkins County do the same.
Joseph Scherer, Town of Ulysses resident, stated the public has shown its concern over this issue
which is good. He stated he feels the proposed cuts would be costly.
Donna Evershed, Dental Hygienist, stated that the services provided under the dental hygiene
program are preventive and very few people are maintaining preventive dental care these days. She stated
that cuts to this program will cost the County a lot of money in the future.
Ed Seymour, President, Ithaco, Inc., stated that his business is located in Ithaca but he has no
customers in New York State. He feels this is a very expensive place to do business. He asked that the
Board not use mandates as an excuse and that the Board support the amendment to be proposed by
Representative Todd.
Martha Ferger, Village of Dryden, stated that people should have to pay according to their income
and not that the burden should not be placed on property taxes.
Theresa Alt, City of Ithaca resident, spoke of opposition to across the board cuts. She feels that
using that method to reduce spending in County departments presents unfairness as some departments are
hit hard by cuts and some others get off easy.
Tom Murray, Tompkins County resident, stated he is opposed to an increase in property taxes but
believes reductions in the budget should not be made across the board. Mr. Murray requested the Board
to examine tax exempt properties such as local colleges.
Beach Stover, Tompkins County resident, stated he feels the proposed property tax increase will
put small business and entrepreneurs on the endangered species list in Tompkins County. He said many
businesses are closing or leaving New York State and that increasing property taxes only destroy
economic growth in Tompkins County. Mr. Stover urged the Board to adopt a zero percent tax increase.
Lew Gentsch, Lansing, stated that if it weren't for Cornell University and Ithaca College Tompkins
County would be in much worse shape. Mr. Gentsch made some of the following suggestions: eliminate
the position of County Administrator, have department heads report directly to the Board, hire a
professional secretary to be a clearinghouse for the paper flow to and from the Board, and ignore State
mandates. He stated that he is opposed to a property tax increase and across the board cutting to achieve
budget reductions.
Andy Sciarabba, City of Ithaca resident and member of the Chamber of Commerce, stated his
opposition to the proposed 1994 Tompkins County budget and property tax increase. He asked that the
Board respond to suggestions made by the Tax Committee of the Chamber of Commerce. Mr. Sciarraba
stated that he feels mandates are a small portion of the County's overall budget. He expressed support for
the amendment to be presented by Representative Todd and said he feels the County can survive a 10.42
percent across the board cut while maintaining its current level of service.
324
December 7, 1993
Jim Gilmore, business and homeowner in Tompkins County, stated that he relocated to Ithaca in
1989 and stated that he feels the cost of living has increased dramatically. He stated he likes Ithaca and
wants to stay and urged the Board not to increase property taxes.
Sharon Kinnan, Tompkins County resident, stated that she is not an employee of the County and
urged the Board to support funding to the Drop In Children's Center.
Bill Manos, City of Ithaca businessman, expressed opposition to the proposed 1994 Tompkins
County budget. Mr. Manos asked the Board what happens to funds remaining in a departments budget at
the end of a year.
Joel Zumoff, Tompkins County resident, stated that he sees a good argument on both sides of the
issue and spoke of the quality of life in Tompkins County.
Don Schaff, Danby, stated that a ten percent cut is senseless and ineffective. Mr. Schaff asked
about the population of people in Tompkins County receiving services and whether they are long time
residents of Tompkins County or does the County provide such a great array of services, that people are
attracted to Tompkins County for services? Mr. Schaff suggested that recipients of public services be
made to volunteer their time to services.
Mark Finkelstein, City of Ithaca, stated that he is opposed to a property tax increase and urged the
Board to support the amendment to be presented by Representative Todd. Mr. Finkelstein also requested
the Board to reconsider the Tompkins County Recycling and Solid Waste Center on Commercial Avenue.
Tracey Farrell, City of Ithaca, stated that she has determined what the cost to her would be if the
proposed property tax increase were imposed and realized the possible cuts in services would not make a
zero percent property increase favorable to her. She expressed opposition to budget reductions being
achieved by across the board cuts and urged the Board to be careful in making decisions.
Allen Cohen, Tompkins County resident and small business owner, stated that he is opposed to a
property tax increase, however, is not necessarily in favor of the amendment to be presented by
Representative Todd.
Bruno Schickel, Dryden, urged the Board to adopt a zero percent property tax increase. He feels
the downsizing of County departments will improve efficiency and the quality of services.
Terrance Callahan, Southside Community Center Board of Directors, stated that he feels it is
unfortunate as centered around a debate of property tax vs. human services. Mr. Callahan asked that all
people work together to benefit the City and the County.
Richard Evans, Perry City Road, spoke of hardships he has seen placed on Tompkins County
residents as a result of increases in the cost of living. He stated he estimates that property taxes have
increased by 600 percent since 1959. He also spoke of utility companies raising rates and the additional
sales tax imposed in the County.
William Williamee, Enfield, stated that his taxes have gone up by 300 percent since he moved
there 25 years ago. He expressed opposition to the proposed property tax increase.
Phillip Zariello, Town of Ithaca, spoke of property tax increases in the past few years and his
opposition to the proposed budget. He stated that he feels there needs to be more fairness in the budget
process and spoke of increases in his property tax over the past several years. Mr. Zariello asked that
County representatives speak to the State.
325
December 7, 1993
Carol Benjamin, Danby, expressed opposition to the proposed 1994 Tompkins County budget and
a property tax increase. She stated that she feels that government, including that of Tompkins County,
wants to take over running families and raising their children. She feels the responsibility has to be
returned to the parents.
Howard Steiner, Danby, stated he hopes each Board member took the budget home and analyzed it
carefully and if so he believes each Board member has done their job and can vote in good conscientious.
Mabel Baker, small business owner in the Town of Ithaca, stated that she feels a ten percent across
the board cut is not the answer. She suggested salary cuts to managers. She stated she refuses to pay the
recently adopted Solid Waste Annual Fee.
Jean Currie, Newfield resident and President, Dewitt Historical Society, commended members of
the Board for their patience during this budget process. She stated that the proposed 11.2 percent increase
would be about $16 for her. She said it is her understanding that the cuts that are being proposed may
result in layoffs and programs being cut and feels $16 would be worth saving the programs and peoples
j obs.
Sharon Prezioso, Town of Ithaca resident and Department of Social Services employee, stated that
if prices continue to rise, she will not shop in Tompkins County.
H. Taraszkiewicz, Hanshaw Road, urged the Board to oppose any property tax increase.
Gary Jaynes, City of Ithaca, urged the Board to oppose any property tax increase.
Gerry Angel, Trumansburg Road, stated he is opposed to the proposed 1994 Tompkins County
budget. He stated he could, however, support a 2.99 percent cost of living increase if necessary.
There were no other members of the audience who wished to speak. Chairman Watros declared
the public hearing to be closed at 11:20 p.m. and opened discussion by members of the Board.
Mr. Winch, Representative, District No. 8, stated that he has lived in Tompkins County for his
entire life, is employed by Cornell University as a support person, not a faculty member and devotes
much of his free time to public service. Mr. Winch stated that during his nineteen years of public service
this has been his most excruciating experience for him putting together a budget. ,As Chairman of the
Public Works and Construction Management Committee, he has seen the Public Works budget erode for
the past four years more than any other program. Public Works has lived within the guidelines and has
taken the biggest hits. He spoke of the positions the Department stands to lose with proposed cuts after
not filling positions that have become vacant over the last few years. Mr. Winch stated that among his
interests he has a great interest for human services which is what lead him to this Board. Mr. Winch
stated that he is upset by statements of the poor work being performed by County employees. He stated
that the County does have some problem employees but are taking care of those problems. However,
overall he feels the County has many fine people providing very fine services. Mr. Winch referred to
problems of the Buffalo Hill Road Bridge and how County employees spent many hours trying to provide
service to the residents in the effected area. He also recalled the 1993 Blizzard at which the Sheriffs
Department, County and local highway departments worked endless hours to make roads safe for the
public to travel. Mr. Winch also made reference to the Board of Representatives office which has been
reduced from a four to three-person office and commended staff for their work.
Mr. Winch stated there are portions of the budget he is disturbed with and stated that he will begin
tomorrow on working on the 1995 budget. He stated that he will also present two resolutions to be
included on the next Board agenda. The first will address health insurance for Board members. He said
that Board members are part-time employees and should receive benefits equivalent to other part-time
employees, and all Board members should receive equal compensation for their service. Another
326
December 7, 1993
resolution will address the hiring of an independent auditor to investigate all County mandated programs
and report to the Board of Representatives whether we are meeting or exceeding the mandates of the
State.
Ms. Mink, Representative, District No. 5, stated that the public hearing has been an education to
learn where County dollars are spent. She stated that it seems that human service agencies have been
over -represented here this evening and that is because the small amount of money they receive goes a
long way. That also means that small cuts are devastating and the reason volunteers, taxpayers, non -
County employees and people affiliated with agencies which help people in need came out and spoke
tonight are unfortunately putting themselves against people who call themselves true taxpayers and it is
nonsense to call those people lobbyists. It is clear that people do not want higher taxes and when
speaking about taxes they are referring to State, County, local and other taxes. The County Board can
only address County taxes. She also spoke of the opposition to across the board cuts and the need for
prioritizing services. Unfortunately, the County Board can not establish priorities this evening. Thirdly,
she spoke of mandates. She stated she stands by her recent statements which appeared in the Ithaca
Journal. She said that over the last week she has tried to get a sense of what the County is required to
provide and to get to the bottom of the myth that is going around that if the County just said "no" to State
mandates that it could get away with it. She read from a letter from the Acting Commissioner of New
York State Social Services to Tompkins County Commissioner, Mary Pat Dolan in reference to inquiries
the Depaiinient has been receiving various proposals from counties to reduce costs of public assistance.
The letter stated that certain county actions may violate constitutional or statutory requirements and may
result in lawsuits, penalties, high financial penalties, damage awards, and in some instances the personal
liability of county officials. She also stated that Tompkins County is a member of the New York State
Association of Counties and will continue work towards mandate relief. Ms. Mink stated that Tompkins
County has been referred to as the poverty capital and mentioned a survey comparing social services costs
among other counties and Tompkins County was average in comparison. She also stated that she feels the
welfare costs are not too high, but rather wages are too low. Ms. Mink concluded by stating these issues
will not be resolved this evening but are things for people to think about.
Mr. Lerner, Representative, District No. 1, stated that County governments all over New York
State and all over the nation are in crisis. The recession, cuts in Federal and State aid, growing State
mandates and ballooning health care and insurance costs have put immense pressure on local taxpayers.
As a result this Board will hurt some people by cutting services and others by raising taxes. Every path
before the Board is painful and unfair to someone and tests the limits of wisdom to make those decisions
thoughtfully and justly. He stated that across the board funding cuts abandon any attempt to be
thoughtful, just or wise, and opposes them. He stated that many County programs are well planned and
well run and provide essential public services. A major reorganization of County government is long
overdue. In January there will be five new Board members, a new Chairman, new committee chairs and a
new party majority that will build on a system for change. Over the next four years the Board must revise
the budget process from the ground up, develop the tools for prioritization, thoroughly study State
mandates, grants and aid, distinguish between programs which succeed in their goals and those who only
have good intentions, identify programs that save dollars elsewhere, and eliminate red tape and
bureaucracy.
Mr. Todd, Representative, District No. 6, stated that on November 16 he asked for a public debate
on the Tompkins County budget. Mr. Todd thanked Mr. Proto for his support for this debate and
willingness to second the motion. Mr. Todd also thanked Wendy Skinner, Ithaca Journal Reporter, for
initialing and encouraging this public debate concerning the 1994 Tompkins County Budget. The causes
of the budget date back to 1989 when the recession stopped the sales tax revenue from increasing every
year and the yearly additions to the property tax roll dropped to one percent or less. County revenues are
flat as a result of those two items. A letter was received from Tompkins County Comptroller, David
Squires, dated November 24, 1993 showing depletion of the fund balance from 1989 of $3.7 million to
1992 when there was only $.6 million left. The County spent more than it had taken in. On December 1,
1992 Tompkins County's additional one percent sales tax went into effect and the increase will return to
327
December 7, 1993
the County a little of $5 million in 1994 but the County's spending projected in the budget increases about
$7.8 million over 1993. The County's budgets since 1989 have been driven by yearly increases of $1-2
million in mandated costs mostly from New York State and the these problems (the recession and ever
increasing State mandates) are not of the County's making and are beyond the County's control. Mr. Todd
stated that a family or business faced with this kind of dilemma would cut expenditures and that is what
he feels the County should do. The amendment he will present was prepared for him by Scott Heyman,
County Administrator, and will cut across the board to achieve a property tax increase of zero. Mr.
Heyman stated at the November 16 Board meeting this could be done. Mr. Todd stated that he believes if
this unpleasant task is not completed it will be much worse in future years and urged support for the
amendment.
Mr. Proto, Representative, District No. 7, stated that since Representative Todd announced the
amendment he will be proposing, much public debate has been stimulated and thanked everyone for their
input.
Mr. Joseph, Representative, District No. 12, stated that he has spoken to several people concerning
the proposed budget and for the most part people have been a lot more reasonable than they started out to
be. He said that he explained that he does not feel across the board cuts make any sense, not only because
they would hurt important services but because they would fail to cut spending. He said he feels
Representative Todd's proposed amendment will not result in reduced spending but rather a reduced
budget and several departments overspending their budget. He stated that he has promised that following
the adoption of the 1994 budget, he will work on doing the things that it takes to make rational and
reasonable cuts in the budget. He feels that this can be done with some careful thought and planning.
Chairman Watros declared recess from 11:52 - 11:57 p.m.
It was Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Lerner, and unanimously adopted by voice vote, to
lift from the Table the following resolution:
RESOLUTION NO. 301 - ADOPTION OF 1994 TOMPKINS COUNTY BUDGET AND CAPITAL
PROGRAM
Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Mason.
It was Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Culligan, and unanimously adopted by voice vote,
to amend the proposed 1994 Tompkins County Budget as follows: As a result of rental revenue due to
Buildings and Grounds by Solid Waste, Account A1620 "Buildings and Grounds" on page 34 of the 1994
proposed Tompkins County Budget shall be amended to increase A1620 revenues, and decrease A1620
total County cost by $12,860 resulting in a net decrease of the real property tax levy of $12,860.
It was Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Proto, and unanimously adopted by voice vote, to
amend the proposed 1994 Tompkins County Budget as follows: As a result of increased federal aid and a
decrease in insurance premiums, Account A5630 "TOMTRAN" on page 50 of the 1994 proposed
Tompkins County Budget shall be amended to reduce A5630.4000 Contractual, and A5630 total
appropriations by $12,156, and increase A5630 total revenues by $13,621 and decrease total County cost
by $25,777 resulting in a net decrease of the real property tax levy of $25,777.
It was Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Mason, and unanimously adopted by voice vote, to
amend the proposed 1994 Tompkins County Budget as follows: To assume the costs on behalf of the
Town of Newfield from the 1% Sales Tax for Human Service related expenses, Account A6950
"County/Town Program -Transportation" and Account A6951 "County/Town Program -Human Service"
on page 63 of the 1994 proposed Tompkins County Budget shall be amended to increase A6950.4000
Contractual and total Appropriations by $500 for Gadabout with an equal increase in A6950 Revenues
from Sales Tax; increase A6951.4000 Contractual and total Appropriations by $2,000 for Senior Citizens
328
December 7, 1993
Council with an equal increase in A6951 Revenues from Sales Tax; Account A9999 "Unallocated
Revenue" on page 74 shall decrease by $2,500 resulting in a net increase of the real property tax levy of
$2,500.
It was Moved by Mr. Winch, seconded by Mr. Shurtleff, and unanimously adopted by voice vote,
to amend the proposed 1994 Tompkins County Budget as follows: To assume the costs on behalf of the
Village of Groton from the 1% Sales Tax for Human Service related expenses, Account A6950
"County/Town Program -Transportation" on page 63 of the 1994 proposed Tompkins County Budget shall
be amended to increase A6950.4000 Contractual and total Appropriations by $2,500 for Gadabout with an
equal increase in A6950 Revenues from Sales Tax; Account A9999 "Unallocated Revenue" on page 74
shall decrease by $2,500 resulting in a net increase of the real property tax levy of $2,500.
It was Moved by Mrs. Schuler, seconded by Mr. Mason, and unanimously adopted by voice vote,
to amend the proposed 1994 Tompkins County Budget as follows: To provide continued funding for
evaluations and referrals in the Jail and an Intensive Outpatient Program (for assessment, case
management, and treatment of criminal offenders who have alcoholism problems) by the Alcoholism
Council Account A3413 "Alternatives to Incarceration, Other" on page 39 of the proposed 1994
Tompkins County Budget shall be amended to increase A3143.4000 Contractual, A3143 total
appropriations, and A3143 total County cost by $36,512 resulting in a net increase of the real property tax
levy of $36,512.
It was Moved by Mrs. Call, seconded by Mr. Lerner, and unanimously adopted by voice vote, to
amend the proposed 1994 Tompkins County Budget as follows: As a result of a decrease in workers
compensation costs estimated for 1994, the following amendments shall be made:
County Cost
Decrease
Page No. Account/Title (Increase)
28 A1165.8000 District Attorney 617
34 A1620.8000 Buildings and Grounds 6,640
38 A3110.8000 Sheriff 11,195
38 A3150.8000 Jail 9,512
38 A3140.8000 Probation 5,481
41 A4010.8000 Public Health 12,358
41 A4010.3401 Public Health Revenue (4,409)
44 A4047.8000 Children with Special Care Needs 1,075
51 A6010.8000 Social Services 33,077
51 A6010.3610 Social Services Revenue (11,585)
51 A6010.4610 Social Services Revenue ( 9,856)
67 A8020.8000 Planning 552
70 A8040.8000 Human Rights 110
73 A9522.4000 Contr. to Co. Road 25,500
These changes result in a decrease in total County cost of $80,267 resulting in a net decrease in the
real property tax levy of $80,267.
Mr. Shurtleff again disagreed that the Board should vote on the Budget at a different location other
than Board Chambers.
It was Moved by Mr. Todd, seconded by Mr. Proto, to amend the proposed 1994 Tompkins County
Budget as follows: The 1994 proposed Tompkins County Budget is amended to reduce the real property
tax levy from $17,406.415 to $15,713,194, and to reduce the County cost as indicated in said budget for
each and every program and department by 10.01%; not included in this amendment are Social Services
(all accounts); Attorneys for Indigent Persons; Children with Special Care Needs and Education of
Handicapped Children; Jail Personal Services, Benefits, and Professional Services, net of Prisoner
329
December 7, 1993
Boarding revenue; Outside Community Colleges; Southside Community Center, under an agreement with
the City of Ithaca; and Debt Service; additionally, an exception to this shall be Tompkins Cortland
Community College whose budget was previously approved; and further, the County Administrator is
directed to make all necessary revenue adjustments caused by these changes; with the understanding of
the makers of this amendment that the Board of Representatives and its committees shall enact
appropriate budget transfers early in 1994 to correct the changes authorized by this amendment that
cannot be made and shall redistribute the spending reductions necessitated by this amendment at that
time. A roll call vote resulted as follows: Ayes - 3 (Representatives Proto, Shurtleff and Todd), Noes -
12. Motion Lost.
It was Moved by Ms. Mink, seconded by Mr. Stein, amend the proposed 1994 Tompkins County
Budget as follows: The following fiscal target variances (budget busters) reflected in the 1994 Proposed
Budget shall be deleted as follows:
County Cost
Decrease
Page No. Account/Title (Increase)
28 A1165.4000 District Attorney 56,930
38 A3110.4000 Sheriff 56,761
38 A3140.4000 Probation 54,161
55 A6310.4000 Human Services 3,000
67 A8020.4000 Planning 29,514
70 A8730.4000 Human Rights 1,795
71 A8730.4000 Soil and Water Conservation 21,382
These changes result in a decrease in total County cost of $223,543 resulting in a net decrease in the real
property tax levy of $223,543.
Mr. Mason spoke in opposition to the aforementioned amendment. He said if funding is decreased
for the programs in the three departments (District Attorney, Sheriff and Probation) the County would see
later an increase in costs with more people going to court and jail and in other related areas associated
with these programs.
Mr. Lerner spoke in favor of the amendment and Mr. Joseph spoke in opposition.
Mr. Stein feels that the message being sent to depaitments and depaitment heads is that the Board
really did not mean it when it adopted the Fiscal Plan. He stated that the dep.'tments listed above should
all be deleted or remain in the budget, not separate the motion.
Mr. Proto spoke in opposition to the amendment and said now is the chance for the Board to begin
prioritizing.
A roll call vote resulted as follows on the amendment: Ayes - 3 (Representatives Lerner, Mink and
Stein), Noes - 12. Motion Lost.
It was Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Mason, to amend the proposed 1994 Tompkins
Budget as follows: The following fiscal target variances (budget busters) reflected in the 1994 proposed
Budget shall be deleted as follows:
County Cost
Decrease
Page No. Account/Title (Increase)
55 A6310.4000 Human Services 3,000
67 A8020.4000 Planning 29,514
70 A8730.4000 Human Rights 1,795
71 A8730.4000 Soil and Water Conservation 21,382
330
December 7, 1993
These changes result in a decrease in total County cost of $55,691 resulting in a net decrease in the real
property tax levy $55,691. The 1994 proposed Tompkins County Budget is further amended to reduce
the real property tax levy from $17,351,082 to $16,516,657, a 5% increase over the 1993 tax rate, and to
reduce the County cost as indicated in said budget for each and every program and depaithient by 4.95%
of its total, or $834,425; not included in this amendment are Social Services (all accounts); Attorneys for
Indigent Persons; Children with Special Care Needs and Education of Handicapped Children; Jail
Personal Services, Benefits, and Professional Services, net of Prisoner Boarding revenue; Outside
Community Colleges; Southside Community Center, under an agreement with the City of Ithaca; Debt
Service; and Tompkins Cortland Community College whose budget was previously approved; And
further, the County Administrator is directed to make all necessary revenue adjustments caused by these
changes; with the understanding of the makers of this amendment that the Board of Representatives and
its committees shall enact appropriate budget transfers early in 1994 to correct the changes authorized by
this amendment that cannot legally be made and shall redistribute the spending reductions necessitated by
this amendment at that time. Further, amended, that this Board recommends top its successor 1994 Board
that Citizens/Government commissioners be established to develop a community consensus on how best
to analyze and address the patterns that have led to recurring large property tax increases.
Following a brief discussion, a roll call vote resulted as follows on the amendment: Ayes - 6
(Representatives Call, Culligan, Evans, Proto, Shurtleff and Todd); Noes - 9 (Representatives Joseph,
Lerner, Livesay, Mason, Mink, Schuler, Stein, Winch and Watros). Motion Lost.
It was Moved by Ms. Mink, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, to amend the proposed 1994 Tompkins
County Budget as follows: 1) Reduce the property tax to 7.78% or $505,864; 2) Include budget busters
(mentioned above); 3) A 2.99% across the board cut for all County departments. The fiscal plan cap does
not change next year for the departments submitting budget busters.
A roll call vote resulted as follows on the amendment: Ayes - 5 (Representatives Culligan, Mason,
Mink, Schuler and Stein); Noes - 10 (Representatives Call, Evans, Joseph, Lerner, Livesay, Proto,
Shurtleff, Todd, Winch and Watros). Motion Lost.
It was Moved by Mr. Evans, seconded by Mr. Proto, to amend the proposed 1994 Tompkins
County Budget as follows: The 1994 proposed Tompkins County Budget is amended to increase the
property tax 7.57%, not including Budget busters, restore fund balance at 4.1% ($228,726) and reduce the
County cost as indicated in said budget for each and every program and department by 3.05%, not
included in this amendment are Social Services (all accounts); Attorneys for Indigent Persons; Children
with Special Care Needs and Education of Handicapped Children; Jail Personal Services, Benefits, and
Professional Services, net of Prisoner Boarding revenue; Outside Community Colleges; Southside
Community Center, under an agreement with the City of Ithaca; Debt Service; and Tompkins Cortland
Community College whose budget was previously approved; and further, the County Administrator is
directed to make all necessary revenue adjustments caused by these changes; with the understanding of
the makers of this amendment that the Board of Representatives and its committees shall enact
appropriate budget transfers early in 1994 to correct the changes authorized by this amendment that
cannot legally be made and shall redistribute the spending reductions necessitated by this amendment at
that time.
A roll call vote resulted as follows on the amendment: Ayes - 5 (Representatives Culligan, Evans,
Lerner, Schuler and Stein); Noes - 10 (Representatives Call, Joseph, Livesay, Mason, Mink, Proto,
Shurtleff, Todd, Winch and Watros).
It was Moved by Mr. Stein, seconded by Mrs. Schuler, to amend the proposed 1994 Tompkins
County Budget as follows: An 8.8% increase over the 1993 tax rate, by reducing the County cost as
indicated in said budget for each and every program and department by 3.05% of its total, includes budget
busters mentioned above; not included in this amendment are Social Services (all accounts); Attorneys for
331
December 7, 1993
Indigent Persons; Children with Special Care Needs and Education of Handicapped Children; Jail
Personal Services, Benefits, and Professional Services, net of Prisoner Boarding revenue; Outside
Community Colleges; Southside Community Center, under an agreement with the City of Ithaca; Debt
Service; or Tompkins Cortland Community College whose budget was previously approved; And to
provide that all the optional items above shall be reduced an added $235,698, an amount equal to a 1.5%
increase in the 1993 tax rate or 1.41% of optional County costs as above, with this amount to be allocated
to Account A1990.4990, Priority Programs; And to provide that during 1994 this Board and its
committees shall have the authority to recommend that this Board appropriate funding from said Priority
Program account to any County program based on the level of importance to the residents of Tompkins
County. Funds appropriated from the Priority Programs account shall not be consider part of the base
funding of the entities receiving them for purposes of developing the 1994 budget. And further, the
County Administrator is directed to make all necessary revenue adjustments caused by these changes;
with the understanding of the makers of this amendment that the Board of Representatives and its
committees shall enact appropriate budget transfers early in 1994 to correct the changes authorized by this
amendment that cannot legally be made and shall redistribute the spending reductions necessitated by this
amendment at that time. The fiscal plan cap does not change next year for the depth linents submitting
budget busters.
A roll call vote resulted as follows on the amendment: Ayes - 3 (Representatives Mason, Schuler
and Stein), Noes - 12. Motion Lost.
It was Moved by Mr. Proto, seconded by Mr. Todd, to amend the proposed 1994 Tompkins County
Budget as follows: 1) A 5% property tax increase; 2) restore fund balance at 4.1%; 3) budget busters are
included; 4) across the board cuts of 3.99%.
A roll call vote resulted as follows on the amendment: Ayes - 5 (Representatives Culligan, Proto,
Todd, Winch and Watros), Noes - 10. Motion Lost.
It was Moved by Mrs. Livesay, seconded by Mr. Joseph, to call the question. A roll call vote
resulted as follows: Ayes - 3 (Representatives Joseph, Livesay and Stein); Noes - 12. Motion Lost.
It was Moved by Mr. Evans, seconded by Mr. Culligan, to amend the proposed 1994 Tompkins
County Budget as follows: 1) across the board cuts of 3.99%; 2) a 6.3% property tax increase;