Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutTB Minutes 1979-01-29 TOWN OF ITHACA TOWN BOARD MEETING January 29 , 1979 - 5 : 30 p . m . At an Adjourned Meeting of the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca , Tompkins County , New York , held at the Town Offices at 126 East Seneca Street , Ithaca , New York , on the 29th day of January , 1979 , at 5 : 30 p . m . , there were PRESENT : Noel Desch , Supervisor Andrew W . McElwee , Councilman Victor Del Rosso , Councilman Robert N . Powers , Councilman Catherine Valentino , Councilwoman Shirley Raffensperger , Councilwoman Gust L . Freeman , Councilman ALSO PRESENT : James V . Buyoucos , Town Attorney Lawrence P . Fabbroni , Town Engineer / Building Inspector Robert W . Bonnell , Assistant to the Town Engineer Beverly Livesay , County Representative Loran Marion , County Representative David Jennings , Town of Ithaca Representative on Tompkins County Youth Bureau Board Willis Hilker , Developer Ronald T . Cortland , 503A Etna Road Brian Ellsworth , 152 Honness Lane Representatives of the Media : Philip Lerman , Ithaca Journal Jay Schneider , WHCU Joel Tallmadge , WTKO News RE - PAINTING OF SAPSUCKER WOODS ROAD AND DANBY ROAD WATER TANKS — RESOLUTION NO . 61 1979 Motion by Supervisor Desch , seconded by Councilman McElwee , RESOLVED , that this Town Board hereby authorizes the release of advertisements for bids on the repainting of the interior and exterior of the Sapsucker Woods Road and Danby Road water tanks . ( Raffensperger , McElwee , Powers , Freeman , and Desch voting Aye . Nays - none . Valentino and Del Rosso not yet present for this vote . ) STONE QUARRY ROAD WATER SERVICE Supervisor Desch reported that Mr . Fabbroni has worked out an alignment of the proposed water line that minimizes the possi - bility of encountering rock . It is intended at the Town Board meeting of February 12 , 1979 to set a date for a public hearing on this project . FEASIBILITY STUDY ON TOWN HALL IMPROVEMENTS - °' Supervisor Desch reported that the Town has in hand three proposals for Town Hall improvements feasibility study . He appoint - ed a committee of three - - Councilmen Powers and McElwee , and him- self to study these proposals and make a recommendation to the full Board on February 12 , 1979 . REFUND REQUEST - RESOLUTION NO . 7 - 1979 Supervisor Desch reported that a request had been received from Robert W . Andree , President of R . W . " Gusher " Andree , for consideration of a refund for water service for the period October 1 , 1978 through December 31 , 1978 . In view of the fact that the water Town Board Minutes . . "` 2 - January 29 , 1979 service was for less than two weeks , the Board was inclined to make this refund . However , the Board felt that a more definitive policy should beset to 'handle such requests in the future . Super - visor Desch noted that the Bolton Point Water Commission is at this time preparing a set of Rules and Regulations which will cover ser - vice connections . Until that policy is formally adopted , however , he felt the Board should proceed with the refund requested by Mr . Andree . Motion by Supervisor ' Desch , seconded by Councilman Powers , RESOLVED , that $ 18 . .58 be refunded to R . W . " Gusher " Andree for service account # 169 - 015343 , on East Hill Plaza , for the period October 1 , 1978 through December 31 , 1978 , the service having only been installed on December 18 , 19780 ( Powers , Raffensperger , Valentino , Del Rosso , Freeman and Desch voting Aye . McElwee - Nay ) TAX EXEMPTION - CITY OWNED PROPERTY IN THE TOWN OF ITHACA - RESOLUTION NO . 8 , 1979 Supervisor Desch reported that on March 10 , 1975 , the Town Board passed a resolution which provided for a tax exemption on City owned land in the Town providing the City reciprocated with regard to the Town Hall . Last year , the City resolved to support the Town ' s request for special State legislation with regard to the Town Hall . The Supervisor recommended that in recognition of the City ' s action the Town Board should proceed to grant the exemption on City property with water and park related uses . (' He noted that it appears that the Real Estate Law does not permit the Town to exempt the City from County and School Taxes . It would be up to the City to pursue this aspect of the matter . ) Supervisor Desch said that even though the State Legisla - ture has not yet acted on the Town ' s bill , he believed it in the best interests of the total community to formally proceed with the exemption . Motion by Councilman McElwee , seconded by Councilman Powers , WHEREAS , the Town of Ithaca appreciates the support ex - pressed by City of Ithaca Common Council on April 5 , 1978 , on the matter of the tax exemption on the Town Hall , and WHEREAS , the Town believes it in the best interest of both the City and the Town to grant the City of Ithaca a tax exemption on City properties in the Town that are used as elements of the City water and park systems , NOW ., THEREFORE , BE IT RESOLVED . That the Town of Ithaca does hereby grant an exemption from the payment of Town levied real estate taxes on the following City - owned properties located in the Town so long as these properties are used by the City for water supply system purposes : 6 - 18 - 2 - 11 902 East Shore Drive 6 - 26 - 5 - 6 Trumansburg Road 6 - 54 - 2 - 21 Pearsall Place Rear 6 - 55 - 1 - 1 Slaterville Road 6 - 63 - 2 - 15 Maple Avenue The exemption does not include relief from special assess - ments such as fire , water and sewer " taxes and benefit assessments . ( Raffensperger , Valentino , Powers , Del Rosso , McElwee , Freeman , and Desch voting Aye . Nays - none ) ° Town Board Minutes - 3 - January 29 , 1979 PEARL S . MILLER ESTATE Town Attoeney Buyoucos distributed to the Board members a proposed resolution in this matter . He said if the Board passes this resolution , the lands which lie under the existing buildings , to the extent they encroach on the right of way , shall be deemed to be leased to the owners of the Miller parcel for so long as the building or buildings stand , and if the buildings are destroyed or removed , then the lease shall cease . It is a permanent lease so long as the building stands . Councilwoman Raffensperger inquired whether the proposed resolution solves the problems of the attorneys involved and the problems of the people who intend to buy the property . Mr . Buyoucos said it does . Motion by Councilman Freeman ; seconded by Councilman McElwee , WHEREAS , the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca has made the following findings and determinations . A . The Estate of Pearl S . Miller is the owner of a parcel of land in the Town of Ithaca known as 235 Forest Home Drive , being tax parcel # 66 - 4 - 11 , more particularly shown on the survey map there - of made by Thomas G . Miller , P . E . , dated June 26 , 1972 , amended June 12 , 1978 , and being the parcel conveyed by Christopher Lindley to Pearl S . Miller by deed dated August 14 , 1960 , recorded in Liber 431 of Deeds at page 123 ( herein referred to as the Miller parcel ) . A copy of said map is attached hereto . Be It appears that a portion of the dwelling may encroach on the Town highway known as Forest Home Drive . C . Any encroachment has apparently continued uninter - ruptedly since the erection of the dwelling house now on the Miller parcel . D . The representative for the owner of the Miller parcel has appeared before the Town Board , alleging financial hardship because of apparent unmarketability of title created by any such encroachment and has asserted a claim that the Town ' s jurisdiction in the highway extends only to the travelled portions and has re - quested the Town to abandon any claim the Town may have to any land lying southerly of the paved portion of the highway . E . A public hearing was held at the Town Hall on December 11 , 1978 , at 5 : 30 p . m . , following a notice published in the ITHACA JOURNAL on December 1 , 1978 , by order of the Town Board . Ross J . Guglielmino , of Rochester , New York , attorney for the owner , and David Tyler , attorney for the contract purchaser of the Miller parcel and Robert J . Hines , attorney , of Ithaca , New York , for Chester Pond , the owner of the . parcel directly opposite on the northerly side of Forest Home Drive ( tax parcel 66 - 3 - 16 ) , appeared . No one objected to the granting of a permanent lease . F . The Town Engineer has reported to the Town Board that he foresees no practical difficulties or impairment of the Town ' s ability to maintain the rest of Forest Home Drive if the encroachments are permitted to continue and he recommends such action . The Town Highway Superintendent recommends such action . NOW , THEREFORE , IT IS RESOLVED AS FOLLOWS : Section I . The Town of Ithaca grees to grant to the owners of the Miller parcel , as described above , herein also referred to as LESSEES ( their successors , distributees and assigns ) W ' p 7 (o u j o 0 1 y uj J Q CIE N S � � ZY° • < �' mow . , Qf � y s s� S s .� • ° ; � u) ppp a 1�01 o o d UL Ay Opy 1 co 7. o .� r O - _ b r _ J a Z d- W o W in 0 � r4 -' Q � O Z ) 5 La � � O -j o ci n. o t-- ° Z ° w N 4 a_ o w � ~ o d Z wok 4 � v Q Q_ C- w ° DL O o u1 0 uj cx. 0 H vl a, Z F- epS. N. CL, Z � sgs o . 8e ! w y . L'a Ur z ? Otis ° 7o • � a ,y m a Z o Q o �- 3 oc 4:j7 v d �4TdnAmia. ► s z �+ v Y = � Lo acv J W Q Q a Q r ► a111 - `,y u 3 a w a• 6n n ul a to W nz p � iv d a Lu LTV tU .;�' t'Y y d > z la Ld co o qT Ul 4 3 O < O = Q Y a p \ W w Joe Yv M . // • - .R �• m t W 2 4w > q O R m < \ Q at T - O � W X • b Z O O o < y Oo = w0 le O o u O a? t V v i s w < u O Town Board Minutes - 4 - January 29 , 1979 a lease to maintain the existing building and appurtenances in their present location as shown on the survey map referred to above , but subject to the provisions set forth in the following Sections . Section II . A portion of the dwelling may encroach on the Town highway known as Forest Home Drive . Section III . It is not intended that this grant of a lease shall convey to the Lessees a permanent title to that por - tion of Forest Home Drive which may be occupied by , or may lie under , the building , nor shall this resolution or the grant of the lease to the Lessees be deemed to be an abandonement by the Town of such title as it may now have in such portion of the said highway , but it is intended that the lease shall be perpetual for so long as the present building stands . Section IV . The Town recognizes that the acceptance of this lease by the Lessees shall be without prejudice to the rights of the Lessees to assert that the right of way is limited to the paved portion of the highway and that the Lessees reserve any and all other rights they may have with respect to the leased lands and/or the lands claimed by the Town to lie within the right of way for the highway . Section V . The Lessees shall maintain and pay for adequate public liability insurance in the amount of at least 100 / 300 / 50 thousand dollars , insuring both the Town and Lessees against any liability , loss or damage which may result by reason of the maintenance of the building and appurtenances in their present location . Section VI . Neither this resolution nor the execution and delivery of a lease pursuant thereto shall be deemed in any way , or in any degree , a waiver by the Town of any rights which it may have in all the remaining portion of Forest Home Drive , i . e . , that portion of said highway which lies beyond the bound - aries of the - subject property and the Town reserves all rights , titles , interests and claims in such remaining portion of Forest Home Drive , and all rights it may have at any time to assert and maintain the full width of the right of way which the Town lawfully has over such remaining portion of Forest Home Drive . Section VII . The Supervisor is authorized , with the assistance of the Town Attorney , the Town Engineer , and the Highway Superintendent to cause to be prepared and to execute a lease in recordable form . Such lease shall contain such pro - visions as he deems appropriate to carry this resolution into effect and to protect and preserve the respective interests and rights of the Town . Without limiting the broad discretion granted to the Supervisor as aforesaid , such lease shall contain suitable provisions for the upkeep and maintenance of the building so that it will not become a hazard to the public using the highway , and for the termination of the lease in the event that the building is destroyed , removed or abandoned and such provisions , if any , as the Supervisor may require for payment to the Town of expenses incurred in connection with this matter , and any additional matters relating to the insurance required ,. above . ( McElwee , Powers , Raffensperger , Freeman , Del Rosso , Valentino , and Desch voting Aye . Nays _ none ) Town Board Minutes - 5 - January 29 , 1979 REPORT OF COUNTY REPRESENTATIVE Loran Marion . " It was my intention tonight to thank the members of this Board for my appointment to the County Board of Rerpesentatives . After four regular meetings , nine committee meetings , two meetings that I am not sure what they were all about , I still thank the Board for my appointment . " Mr . Marion reported that the County Board of Representa - tives has now come to a conclusion on the ambulance service . Ambulance service will be provided at no cost to the County and at no cost to the hospital . He said he believed they now had an agreement that the ambulance services can live with . Mr . Marion said that this agreement has in large part been reached due to the work of Gust Freeman ' s committee which brought all of the pertinent information to the Board of Representatives and they pulled it all together . Supervisor Desch thanked Mr . Marion for his report . He said he could speak for the Town Board , that it is pleased that the County will administer the service , that the five involved municipalities felt the County should administer the service rather than have a fragmented agreement . He commended the County on listening to the concerns of the municipalities and moving quickly to achieve a reasonably comprehensive agreement . The agreement now contains most of the provisions which have evolved from the work of various committees , and contains the best of all the pieces . Supervisor Desch expressed some concern whether the agreement will serve as a long term base for ambulance service , there is no guaran - tee that it will . Mr . Marion stated that that had been discussed at the County Board of Representatives meeting today ( January 29 ) ; that it is hoped that the agreement will be an on - going one , but it will be one which must be renegotiated from year to year . Councilman Freeman expressed some concern over the financial stability of the ambulance ; services in the future . Supervisor Desch said that a year ' s experience will make clearer to all concerned the reliability of the services and the financial stability of the carriers . Mr . Marion said that as a member of the Committee involved with the ambulance service proglem , he felt . . . . " we were fortunate to come up with this type of agreement when we had so little to offer the ambulance services . I was delighted with it and members of the Board of Representatives were delighted with it . " He hoped that concerns about financial stability and responsibility would turn out to be unfounded . PERSONS TO BE HEARD Mr . Willis Hilker asked the Town Board to give consideration to the problem of developers and subdividers who are required to install water and sewer pipes , and roads , at their own expense , and yet are required to pay the annual water and sewer benefit charge for debt reduction . He said this seems like a double charge to the developers in the Town . He said he realized a secondary problem arises in how the charge should be handled when the property is transferred from the developers to new owners . Are such owners then in a different position than any other taxpayer ? Supervisor Desch said the Town Board would give serious thought to the problem , but the Board would also appreciate input from developers as to their cost per lot to extend water and sewer under present day construction costs . Town Board Minutes - 6 - January 29 , 1979 COUNTY YOUTH BUREAU Councilwoman Valentino reported meeting with Mr . David Jennings , Town of Ithaca representative on the Tompkins County Youth Bureau Board , regarding money which is becoming available to the County and to the Town for youth programs for the preven - tion of delinquency . Mr . Jennings described various funding pro - grams which are available - - delinquency prevention , job counseling , career planning , prevention of teen - age pregnancy , arid , hopefully , transportation which is a unique problem in Tompkins County . He noted that a new directory of programs available in Tompkins County has been published by the Human Services Coalition , and recommended that the Town purchase one ( $ 1 . 50 ) . Supervisor Desch said he would include in the April news - letter a request for input with regard to youth needs in Tompkins County . He recommended that if the County Youth Bureau is develop - ing a proposal on transportation , or any other program , the Town should be consulted during the latter part of the conceptual stage so the Bureau might have the benefit of the Town ' s view . Mr . Jennings noted that for the moment , at least , the State guidelines do not generally allow for funding of transportation . That would be a matter of changing State law , so it will not be something which will develop rapidly . Councilwoman Valentino said that since the State does not now allow matching funds for transportation , she had recom- mended to the County Youth Bureau that they study that and have the Association of Towns make a recommendation to the State in support of some kind of transportation funds . Councilman Freeman suggested that perhaps the question should be directed to the Tompkins County Transit Commission for study . REPORT OF TRANSIT COMMITTEE Councilman Freeman said that the Tompkins County Transit Commission is studying such things as Rt . 13 , public transit , truck - ing on South Hill access , East - Ithaca recreation , County -wide trans - portation bottlenecks , inventory of transportation studies in Tompkins County , financial resources , exchange of highways with New York State DOT , Rt . 96 improvements , etc . All this material has been put to - gether and taken to the State as part of the County public safety report . Councilman Freeman said that Mr . Fabbroni is to be commended for his part in putting this material together . The next meeting of the Commission is February 21 , 1979 at 7 : 30 p . m . at the County Planning Board Office . It was agreed that Councilman Powers would attend this meeting . REPORT OF CODES AND ORDINANCES COMMITTEE Councilman Powers reported that the Codes and Ordinances Committee a week ago had its first discussion of residential zones . This discussion raised some problems - - percentage density in resi - dential zones and the neighborhood concept . The Committee , he said , has been working from the 1976 draft ordinance as a basis for re - visions . Lengthy discussions have been held . Councilman Powers stated that the Committee members feel that there could be legal problems if specific density percentages with respect to residential zones are established at this time or if neighborhood concepts are firmly established now . The Committee recommends that with respect to the residential zones , the 1968 ordinance should be used as a basis , where possible , and that at some future date the Committee urges the development of some form of a Master Plan which incorporates something on the order of a density or neighborhood concept . Town Board Minutes - 7 - January 29 , 1979 JOINT CITY/TOWN SEWER COMMITTEE Supervisor Desch reported that the last meeting of this Committee had produced the best exchange of views and information regarding the upgrading of the City sewer system ; and that attend - ance by City of Ithaca representatives was better than usual . The Supervisor distributed a draft resolution to be considered for a adoption by the City of Ithaca , Town of Ithaca , and Town of Dryden with regard to the joint construction and maintenance of an expanded sewage treatment facility . Supervisor Desch stated that the City of Ithaca Common Council has authorized the Superintendent of Public Works to apply for a grant to perform the Sewer System Evaluation Survey . The City of Ithaca will not accept that grant , however , until an agree - ment has been worked out with the various municipalities and they agree on a method of paying for the service . DOG CONTROL CONTRACT - RESOLU'TION N0 . 10 , 1979 Supervisor Desch stated that all Board members have received copy of the draft of a contract with the Village of Cayuga Heights and also the proposed contract with the County . He read a proposed resolution in this regard . Councilwoman Valentino said she had nothing to add ; that the Board members have everything in hand , that for the Town of Ithaca it will mean that people who have no way of dealing with dog complaints except to go before the Town Justice , will now have the services of the SPCA who will have the authority , when requested , to pick up an offending dog . The SPCA will be called by the person complaining of a dog . The Agriculture and Markets Law mandates the provision of shelters and dog wardens . The proposed County contract is specifically with the SPCA to maintain shelter , therefore , the Town will not have to maintain a shelter . Motion by Councilman Powers ; seconded by Councilman McElwee , WHEREAS , the Town of Ithaca recognized its responsibility to control dogs in our community through the passage in 1976 of a Local Law , and WHEREAS , the State legislature has recognized the diffi - culty in enforcing local dog control laws because of the archaic fee structure in Article 7 of the Agriculture and Markets Law , and WHEREAS , the State legislature has modified the State law to improve dog enumeration procedures and to provide for local re - tention of license fees to enhance enforcement of local laws and preserve Home Rule , and WHEREAS , the Town Board , following a public hearing on October 16 , 1978 , has increased the license fees in the Town of Ithaca in anticipation of the development of a contract to improve enforcement of Local Law No . 1 ( 1976 ) , and WHEREAS , the Tompkins County Board of Representatives in response to ' the urging of the Tompkins County Municipal Officers ' Association has developed an intermunicipal agreement to provide enforcement coverage consistent with the expressed desires of the Town of Ithaca , NOW , THEREFORE , BE IT RESOLVED : That the Town Supervisor is authorized to execute an agree - ment with the Tompkins County SPCA , the City of Ithaca , and Tompkins County for service as Town of Ithaca Dog Warden to enforce the Town of Ithaca Dog Control Law as provided in the attached draft agreement at a cost to the Town of Ithaca not to exceed $ 6 , 000 , effective retro - active to January 1 , 1979s 1 J7 Town Board Minutes - 8 - January 29 , 1979 BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED : That the Supervisor be authorized to execute a contract with the Village of Cayuga Heights to administer the aforesaid contract on behalf of the Village , including the understanding that fines collected by the Village will be paid to the Town as a reimbursement applied to the Town ' s snare of the County contract ( i . e . $ 6 , 000 ) . ( Raffensperger , Valentino , Powers , Freeman , McElwee , Del Rosso , and Desch voting Aye . Nays - none ) SCHOOL CROSSING - WARREN ROAD RESOLUTION NO . 11 - 1979 Supervisor Desch reported receiving a letter from Mr . Michael Ouckama , Principal of the Northeast Elementary School , calling attention to problem with crossing guard and speed prob- lems at this location . The Supervisor stated that the crossing guard , for health reasons , has not been in daily attendance at this crossing . There has , however , been support from the Sheriff in his absence . Essen - tially , there are two problems : ( 1 ) reliability of coverage , and ( 2 ) the problem of the speed limit . The PTA have been requested to furnish a stand - by to serve at that location when the regular crossing guard is unable to be on duty . Regarding the speed problem , the school is not on Warren Road , and , therefore , the State Depart - ment of Transportation has been reluctant to reduce the speed limit . After discussion , the Board acted as follows : Motion by Councilman Del Rosso , seconded by Councilman Desch , WHEREAS , the school crosswalk on Warren Road at the southern property lines of the DeWitt Junior High School and B . O . C . E . S . com- plex carries heavy traffic from the northeast area of the Town to these two schools and the Northeast Elementary School with all grades below grade 10 , and WHEREAS , the Town of Ithaca presently employs a crossing guard to supervise children at this school crosswalk , and WHEREAS , the crosswalk is a marked crosswalk , and WHEREAS , there is no traffic control signal , pedestrian overpass or underpass , or highway grade separation appropriate for use by pedestrians crossing the highway involved within the zone or within 450 feet of the near end of the zone , and WHEREAS , the crosswalk is located within a school speed zone permitting the establishment of a school speed limit , and WHEREAS , crossing operations continue to be hazardous at the 85 percentile speed , NOW , THEREFORE , BE IT RESOLVED . That the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca , in accordance with Section 208 . 9 of the Manual of Uniform Traffic Control Devices of the State of New York , requests that a school speed limit of 15 miles per hour be adopted and posted for DeWitt Juniot High School and B . O . C . E . S . on Warren Road . ( Valentino , Freeman , Powers , Del Rosso , Raffensperger , McElwee , and Desch voting Aye . Nays - none ) r Ltq Town Board Minutes - 9 - January 29 , 1979 In addition to the foregoing , the Board recommended that an appropriate traffice device be installed to aid in the enforce - ment of such lower speed limit , if approved . REQUEST FOR REFUND OF WATER AND SEWER BENEFIT ASSESSMENT - EDWARD L . AND LINDA P . KABELAC - RESOLUTION NO . 12 - 1979 The Town Clerk reported that an Application for Refund of Special Water and Sewer Benefit Assessment has been received from Edward L . and Linda P . Kabelac , 1410 Hanshaw Road ( Parcel No . 70 - 11 - 38 ) . The Kabelacs state that the apartment at this location has been remodel - ed and is now part of the living quarters and is no longer rented . It is now solely occupied by immediate family as a single dwelling and has been so occupied since November of 1978 . Motion by Supervisor Desch , seconded by Councilwoman Raffensperger , RESOLVED , that a refund in the amount of $ 52 . 00 for one unit of water benefit assessment and $ 50 . 00 for one unit of sewer benefit assessment , totalling $ 102 . 00 , be made to Edward L . and Linda P . Kabelac , 1410 Hanshaw Road ( Tax Parcel 70 - 11 - 38 ) , due to the re - modeling of the apartment formerly at this location to make it a part of overall living quarters , the premises now being used by immediate family as a single dwelling unit . ( Raffensperger , Valentino , Freeman , McElwee , Del Rosso , Powers , and Desch voting Aye . Nays - none ) EXECUTIVE SESSION - RESOLUTION NO . 13 - 1979 Motion by Supervisor Desch ; seconded by Councilman Powers , RESOLVED , that this Board .will now retire into executive session ( Raffensperger , Valentino , Freeman , McElwee , Powers , Del Rosso , and Desch voting Aye . Nays - none ) In executive session the Board discussed Rumsey - Ithaca ' s new application for a mining permit ; and zoning violations . Following the executive session the Board duly reconvened in open session . ADJOURNMENT - RESOLUTION NO . 14 - 1979 Motion by Supervisor Desch , seconded by Councilman Powers , RESOLVED , that there being no further business to come before the meeting , it is hereby duly adjourned . ( Powers , Freeman , Valentino , Raffensperger , McElwee , Del Rosso , and Desch voting Aye . Nays - None ) The meeting was duly adjourned at 8 : 30 p . m . Edw L . Bergen Town Clerk