HomeMy WebLinkAbout2001-10-23TB 10 -23 -01
TOWN OF DRYDEN
TOWN BOARD MEETBVG
October 23, 2001
Board Members Present: Supv Mark Varvayanis, Cl Ronald Beck, Cl Thomas Hatfield,
Cl Charles Hatfield, Cl Deborah Grantham
Other Elected Officials: Bambi L. Hollenbeck, Town Clerk
Jack Bush, Highway Superintendent
Other Town Staff: Dianne McFall
Mark Sutton
Supv Varvayanis explained that revenues included sales tax, interest, etc; everything
except property taxes. 1.6 million was received in sales tax revenues last year.
CI T Hatfield with respect to salaries elected officials stated that he had reviewed the
survey prepared for the Town of Lansing and it reinforced his thinking: I'm very much a
believer that: wages are not necessarily an incentive, but I also believe very strongly that they
can be a disincentive. I would like to see our Town Board members, starting next January 1
receive a compensation equal to $5,000 per year per person. I think this is one of the few years
that we can make this kind of a change seeing how two of us are not seeking reelection. So we
are not going to be in a position where people can say well, you're just: putting money in your
own pocket. Ron, you and I haven't talked about that at any length, but I was hoping that you
might agree that that might be something we ought to look at. I think it is a disincentive when
you look at the amount of work and the number of hearings. I don't think it's an incentive, but
I think it does make a difference. I feel quite strongly about that personally.
Cl Beck - The way I calculate it, I think a councilperson is going to have to spend twenty
plus hours a month and he ought to be making $15 or so, and that comes up to $3,600
annually, which is a fair amount less than what you had. But I still think it's a. bare minimum
and there are some tunes of the year when if you are doing your job properly as a councilm
person you can put in a heck of a lot more and especially if you are active on some of the other
committees, town committees or county -wide things.
Cl T Hatfield stated that in comparison to what other Towns the same size are paying,
Dryden is low for the Supervisor's salary, and that a minimum ought to be $1,000 per month
because of the amount of work involved. Lansing is paying its Supervisor $20,000 and Ithaca
is paying $32,000. Dryden currently pays $7,700. Dryden is the largest Town in the County
and he would like to see the salary at no less than $12,000. With these increases and some
reductions previously discussed in other lines, this would mean a total increase of $15,000 in
the budget.
Cl T Hatfield - I think this budget that Mark
approach. The 25% reduction in sales tax certainly
anybody that has a major answer to that, whether t
15% or 35 1/o. We don't know. I think it's prudent to
time we're in, there's a little bit of recession started,
any higher is criticall
has presented us is a pretty balanced
could be questioned. I don't think there is
he 25% is right or whether it should be
be expecting less. Also I think given the
for us to keep town taxes at least not going
Page 1 of 4
0
W
e
TB 10 -234)1
Cl T Hatfield noted that: the Highway Superintendent had made a good argument for a
look at the high%vay department: wages, and that needs to be.addressed. The Town has 96
• miles of road and these guys are doing a great job. He stated that when he looks at ghat
Dryden is paying; its Highway Superintendent and Deputy versus other communities, he
believes there is the same inequity.
Cl
T Hatfield - I've
been through the budget
in a great amount
of detail and those are
really the
major issues
that I saw that jumped out.
(Cl T Hatfield left
the meeting.)
The board discussed the wages for board members and town supervisor. Supv
Varvayanis stated that it was difficult to find people to run for office, but he wasn't sure an
increase would be much incentive. Cl C Hatfield stated that Nve'd been fortunate in the past to
find people to run, but perhaps it was time to get realistic. Cl Beck stated that $5,000 for
board members and $12,000 for the Supervisor was more than he had figured, but that it
wouldn't be a lesser job as time goes on. After further discussion, the board decided to raise
the compensation for board members to $5,000 each per year and $12,000 for the Supervisor.
Salaries for Highway Superintendent and Deputy Highway Superintendent were then
discussed using the survey prepared for the Town of Lansing by AMTFK Human Resource
Consultants and a survey done by the Deputy Highway Superintendent which was based on a
sampling of like towns provided by NYS DOT. Jack Bush has asked for a 5% increase and
asked the board to consider paying for family medical insurance. Cl Beck stated he had
considered 10% plus the health insurance. Cl C Hatfield remarked that the Highway
Department is the most organized it has been since he's been on the board and though both
the Highway Superintendent and his Deputy are relatively neuv, they need to paid
comparatively for what they are doing and he states that he does not feel it is a huge increase.
Board discussed the matter of family coverage for the I•Iighway Superintendent. Town
employees are provided with family health coverage, but town policy provides that elected
® officials will be covered individually at no cost, but for family coverage they would have to pay
the difference. Dianne McFall pointed out that the board has always tried to keep the policy
fair to all, and if the board were to pay for family coverage for the Highway Superintendent,
they would have to do it for all other elected officials. The difference between the price of single
coverage and family coverage is about $350 per month. Cl Beck stated that perhaps the policy
should be discussed at another time, and the Board agreed.
Cl C Hatfield suggested raising the Highway Superintendent's salary to $44,000 and he
would purchase the additional family coverage. Cl Grantham stated that he received a big
increase in salary last year so that he could buy the family insurance. Cl Beck stated that was
true, but now we have surveys that indicate the salary is still low. Cl C Hatfield said that last
year they hadn't been on the job too long, but he thinks they are doing the job right and you
need to compensate them for it, and that: in the business field when you get a good man the
only way to keep hire is pay him what he's worth. Jack Bush said that if the board makes
this decision that the salary would be within range and he doesn't see himself asking for any
kind of big; increase next year. Cl C Hatfield stated that the average of the surveys comes out
to $45,000 and that: in general lie hasn't heard anyone say that: the highway department wasn't
doing a good job and they used to hear that a lot.
The Board raised the salary for Highway Superintendent to $46,000 and to $36,000 for
his Deputy.
With respect to the amount budgeted for the ambulance, Supv Varvayanis stated that it
is based on what is happening this year, with a projected $60,000 deficit.
Pag;c 2 of 4
TB 10-23"01
Sewer repairs are necessary on Freese Road (Varna Sewer II, 388 units) and half the
amount was budgeted for this year and half will be budgeted next, total amount being
approximately $55,000.
Cortland Road Sewer appropriations are down because the Town no longer expects the
Village to ask the Town to become part owner of the sewer plant.
Peregrine appropriations are
down because of the
recent sale and dissolution
of a major
part of the subdivision and it will
no
executive session at
longer be necessary
to buy a share in the sewer
plant.
Supv Varvayanis noted that amount for the recreation coordinator was reduced from
$101000 to $5,0001
The rate of pay for the Highway Clerk was increased from $9.50 to $10.32 /hour.
Cl Beck remarked that perhaps the projected sales tax revenues were too conservative,
but it was safer that way.
Changes made in the budget this morning amount to a tax rate increase of about two
cents.
The Board discussed whether to decrease the amount of funds in the budget for
production of the bicentennial book. There has been little progress in the past few years. Cl
Grantham believes it will actually cost less than the $50,000 budgeted to produce the book.
After discussion, the Board decided to leave the amount at $50,000.
Jack Bush stated that the Red Mill Bridge is still on the County's project list and there
is a portion of that expense that will be the Town's responsibility. D McFall staged that has
® been taken into consideration in the budget and there is more than enough money. Cl Beck
said that it was his understanding that the County had not received a, determination from the
State Historical Society. It was noted that the decking on the bridge is in poor condition and
may need to be repaired before the County replaces the bridge.
Cl C Hatfield stated that he thought the budget was well put together.
On motion
of Supv Varvayanis,
seconded
by Cl Beck, and
unanimously carried, the
board moved into
executive session at
9:50 am.
to discuss union
negotiations.
Board moved back to regular session at 10:10 a.m.
RESOLUTION #204 - AUTHORIZE PAY INCREASE FOR HIGHWAY & DPW
Cl Grantham offered the following resolution and asked for its adoption:
RESOLVED, that this Town Board hereby authorizes the Town Supervisor to give a 51/0
increase and a $1,400 performance payment to the Highway and Department of Public Works
employees according to the tentative agreement.
2nd Cl C Hatfield
Roll Call Vote
Cl Beck Yes
Supv Varvayanis Yes
Cl C Hatfield Yes
Cl Grantham Yes
Page 3 of 4
TB 10 -23-01
On motion duly made, seconded and unanimously carried, the meeting was adjourned
at 10:14 a.m.
Respectfully submitted,
400'J�; 411�1
13ambi L. Hollenbeck
Town Clerk
Page 4 of 4