HomeMy WebLinkAboutTB Correspondence 2012�� �� r��
� �r� �� TOWN OF ITHACA
,. a,
�� ,��� :��� 215 NORTH TIOGA STREET, ITHACA, N.Y. 14850
��' www.town.ithaca.ny.us
CORRESPONDENCE LISTING
January 9, 2012
P/ease review the following correspondence and indicate, by placing your initials in the right hand column
adjacent to the correspondence that you wish to receive a copy. We can forward a copy to you via e-mail or
make a hard copy. P/ease indicate your preference next to your name at the bottom of this form.
Correspondence — Item Please place your
initials here if you wish
to receive a co
1. Letter from Guy Krogh re Ethics Law updates
2. Letter from NYSERDA re site visit and description of energy saving
suggestions
3. Letter from TCAD re PILOT from Ithaca Beer/Nut Brown Realty
4. email from Tamrie Oliver re development in the southwest neighborhood
5. email exchange with Leon Zaharis re TOI snow plowing machinery
6. Letter from Diana Graser, NYS DOT, re denial of speed limit reduction
request, Hayts Road
7. Letter from MEGA re 2011 bid results
7a. Letter to Kate Supron, V Cayuga Heights, re deer culling notification
7b. Letter from Guy Krogh to Peter Littman re Montessori deed (executed)
7b. Letter from Rec Partnership re start of new 5-year contract in 2013
8. Letter from TCHD re 2012 changes to the onsite sewage treatment system
program
9. SPCA report for November 2011
10. November pog Control Officer and Municipal Shelter inspection reports
11. Liquor license renewal application, Moakley House
11.a. Sustainable Tompkins recognition
12. Letter from TCCOG to Joe Martens, NYSDEC, re comments from public
hearing on revised SGEIS
13. Letter from Henrik Dullea re redistricting
14. NYSAOT resolutions
15. Time Warner Cable new ricin for cable acka es
16. Lakeview Mental Health Services 2010 Annual Re ort
17. FI er re Tom kins Count A ricultural Summit
18. Notice from Division of Environmental Remediation re " oin Pa erless"
19. FreshDirt Ithaca magazine, Fall 2011
�� �� r��
� �r� �� TOWN OF ITHACA
,. a,
�� ,��� :��� 215 NORTH TIOGA STREET, ITHACA, N.Y. 14850
��' www.town.ithaca.ny.us
CORRESPONDENCE LISTING
January 23, 2012
P/ease review the following correspondence and indicate, by placing your initials in the right hand column
adjacent to the correspondence that you wish to receive a copy. We can forward a copy to you via e-mail or
make a hard copy. P/ease indicate your preference next to your name at the bottom of this form.
Correspondence — Item Please place your
initials here if you wish
to receive a co
1. Letter from NYMIR re 2012 capital return check
2. Letter from Linda Caughey to Toby Millman re sidewalk sidewalk on
Mitchell Street, Belle Sherman Cottages
3. Letter to LGRMIF reviewers re support for shared records management
project with County
4. Dog seizure report, December 2011
5. NYS DEC, Division of Water, re FEMA Flood Insurance Rate Maps and
"New Levee Approach in Development"
6. No Farms No Food Rally
�
��q,����
J��� � �c�, `�
�� vJ
�,o�,a .
January 5, 2012
Mr. Toby Millman
Agora Homes
25 East Elizabeth Street
Skaneateles, NY 131 S2
Subject: Belle Sherman Cottages, Mitchell St. Sidewalk
Dear Toby,
I hoped the coxistruction crew would fill in the sidewalk area along
Mitchell Street for the winter, but it has not happened. This is a busy
sidewalk area (going to & from Belle Sherman School, the bike path, and
the P&C shopping area}, and there is no sidewalk on the other side of
Mitchell Street.
Due to the lack of sidewalk, people walk along the road. A"rise" in
� Mitchell Street there can prevent drivers seeing someone walking in the
road. With a moderate snow fall, people will be forced father out inta the
road.
I do NOT want to see someone hit by a car, especially c}uldren walking
aiong there. The Town of Ithaca said you don't need to provide a
sidewallc, but the County owns that road Please see if you, the Town and
the County can temporarily fill or brid�gans. and open the walk to
pedestrians even if it is not shoveled.
Sincerely,
:,
r `• j ' ./
�. ..:.��-r
Linda Caughey
125 Pearl Street
Ithaca, NY 14850
PS. Someone came and added some black plastic to the Wortb. Street end
of the properiy. Thank you. Hopefully that will help with water & mud.
Cc: Don Lampman, Couniy Highway Dept., 170 Bostwick Rd.
,/ Susan Brock, Town Lawyer, 215 N. Tioga St.
T��� �� ���i'1�4��
215 N. Ti��a �tr��t, Itha�a, �J'.�'. 1485�
WWW.�(7W]1.1�hi1C'�i.�Yj�'.115
Ta+�rn Supervis�ar (6t�7� �i3-1iC�, �xt 1�5 ; 6,if ������-��:,i_� t z rc�...w;1r��wr �,r�.�,a_��;
TCJ'WN CLE�iK (6d7) 273-1i21 PUBLIC WC)RKS (�iDi) 273-q656 ENGIN��Fi4NG (607j �73-17�7
p�a��c�iN� (�o,� ���-1�a� �arvin�� ��oz) ��a-1��s
�ax qso�} 2�s-7Taa
.��1[l�.taiC)' %, �(��?
�i�1Q,t', ��"'sll�I"(:}I"1
l�+'1f4y"C:)1"
ViVlw��� c�l' �'G�yu�,�=� �-��i�l�is, NC�aa�c6���c7i 1-���1�
��(-i F-l�inwl����v Rca�a�f
��f�rtc��.1"��' 1��5t1
�Gckl' �il�'C)I' �11�71'()G7:
At it�; rT�e;i�tir�� I���:�T�b�o. �'�C�, ?()1 V tk�� Itt�t�c��'T"c���i� I3c�xGr�i he��r�l I'�-c�n7 �� n�ul�k�c�r af'tc�wn
r�;�icii�e�r� vuhc> ��1-L cc���c���i��c:i �k�c���t ��i1'c:ty i�:�«c� �•c:l�st�;c3 t�y t11� Vill�z�� c�f Cr�}�ti��a H�i�11t�;
cl��.r� ���lli��� }�l�i��. �CiZ�,y wkGztc:c� tl�zu tl�c�y wisll�r� tc� �uvc�icl tJy� ��i•c��� i�� �'ay�.�g�� 1�Iei���ts
�rl��i-e �;ht��>tii�� ��i� ���r i�; �al�trt���cl tca Ct�ke ��l���e:.
,��>>q" A(�tc��� c�L�e �c>r�5i�3���xxt�c��, iN�e'C'����r�� �«��r-c� ti�+k�ci tf���t l�:c�zlt��ct yc��� tc� �•�;cg����t tl���� �vl��:►� tl�G
�irezt� �ant� tigt�€: 6�c��u��e� r�f'the c:�aClin� �7�a��'�tu�i� a1Ma� ki�t�wvr� tk��tt tk��;Villa�;� �`c7r�t�tc:t tli�
Tc7+,���, i➢�r�a�i��t7 r�7� c7�' �]�ar Tcav��i� C1��'1�:, tc� �;17rire t17at ii�Gt�r-fl7�ttii��r� wc.� t���tt �v� c���n t��� t��ttec.
���-c��a�zz-e� tc� a�s`r5� c:7�arz,���ic�erltti witt� �k�ei�- cc�i7c;�rc��;. I h:r�c�w �.v� w1�41r•e ���G �ca��l E�f t�7eNt�N��1
cc�c��aer�ti���i te� �,�tiet� �ct•ve; ik�c r•c�;ic��:,nt�; s�l` l�c�th tl�� Villa�� arrcE 'H"awt�.
Th�r1�k yc}�� i�c�z� yc�tii• ata���tican tc:� ch�� trr��tt�,c• �►�7c1 �le�ts�, �c�t ii1 to�.�ch ii�yt�u 1-r�xve; any
c{G���;c�c�1��.
.�it�or�c�rc�l}�,
„ � „�.,.w-�°_;,�
��,,��.�,. �. ......
�'� �,;
H�rl����t .M. �n������rT� ,
TcSwt� Sta����-v�scar�
CC:.: It11t�c�� T"�aw�� 134a��r�
I'a��l�:tt� rI'�r•willi��;��, �["c�wzl C.le;��k
��ar;���c�� ����'Q�rmn�e��.�ux�e�����
,�',�cs�d'el���rrr
f%€al�ec�� ��carr¢ii
Iut�i��,rre�es�7rr��uw�rtt�R C���g�wa,�ar,tive
f��^I[Mt�c>aas}�ip5 .1de%ititar
Ftt�o°oa�77 C"er�,�b�t;r
P�'i:cr i'e�e��src�`erad
Il7<�i7;:rl�� F3Wau'�er'
tiia�be,ew iscar
'1'uw��ri �a4��"ttr�<��irr�
� r�. �,� ��" � � ��� �� �`� �a; °� w �� � �� �� �, � �� � �., �� ��� � � � m�� � ���: � � u �� ��� aa� � � �� ��
1SII 4C;rtic� :�ire�t, Alh,arrv, iVc4a Ycark 12?(l7
ti I�.�'(,�i.7;w? • I c��, ? I fC,�a(,S,Ia7�<;, . e���-��.��}-°irriM�.€�s��
��
�
f��-. @-Ic��b 9���m��«�a�, Sir�a���vis�at• .I���tt���y ?(?, ?ll l?
��'UWII �7�, Ct�1c�Ci�
2 I � 1�°'."1'�c��� �treet
1CI���a, �11' 14��i)
t7ea�' `;u��eo•vi�c��• E;n�tt���rt:
����'�r`��r�•�;""� .I.P�is lct�tu�� is tcr �k�rllc�w ��a��s �vit7� y�r7u ¢����t�r�ciir7� tl��� ��Q �'� ct��ait�d rekurn cEicck �,vk�ic��7 y�ri� w�aalld
,��r�r�� v�c[���,�aet �G�v�; r��c�iw�c� fi•��n 'N'Y�u1IF� �n,jr�st tl�c ��ast fe�tiv �ays. F`���• �lt����s�t �Il �albm• r��e�nE�a�i°�„ tl�is i� ���e
�� �v�,r
C�i f aaf�t'uhi"a�'.S �`4lil'i�'i i1Ct@l�lc�� ['1"k�it'���I71,Cf'll' IIl il C&3�)1T8� C"�`[IWIi"0 [3C'G7�,1"i8111 w4"�'liC�'1 IS ��5��"1�i�C� C171"al'� ��1��� if7 ti'1�
c:atc;9c����1 c�istri�i�ition fl,�c:n�..
St�t^r�i:^dtrra-
txG��c,��1ay��tr�MiQUs��� �`.�� ���h���it af th�; �3cras��i a���i'Gc�v��r���crrs �n�' a��r "wl��riici��l t1.ssaci��iorr ������rtn�rs, C a��t�t����9 t�
5��r�v�-4i�c,� tzil:r; 11�is c>pperrC�,ii�ity kt� t�iar�k y<�u fi�r �•c;o7�wir��; witl� NYMC12 I�r ��nc�tf7ci- y�;ar, �inci
"I"�xwvri ufE3rrotiwlb,�r��Y�c+��r
k�rarti��al�a•ly ic�a� ya��Gtr anG�a�ic�ip�lot�}�"� �c�r7�sg�s77�iri� I�aya�t�y a�i� ct:�n�»7i��d�rcnt t��� c���n� prr�����i7�.
,�c�.5 a' �'r�s�a"ra"c��ra7
a�,�k�� t..z7y�,7c M��nici�a�l �cac��r�a�riric�ra c7�i this sc�il� c7i�ly �vcarl::s rvla�n itt; ����r�tdciK�z�t7ts {��rc� tcr �triy the
y,��,�.��raty� C'¢��?u t:s�f��cc�.ia�c,»� �;)i7'a�ca� . , �
c,c�a�rs�. �?w'� ����: �`��r-���rr4�tc tc� I��w�� s�a rnt��y �����nt��;z•s ��ha� 1���ec r�c;mKtin�.ej aa- r�taa¢-i�ed tc� us
n.�;�c��t'[r�,��:r�y���� �nd, in �cr dai«,�, c�r�xl�l�;cl �dYMI[t to �«e��ee�i in its t��dssicn� tc� dErc cle�r°ce tN�at it ��a�.
�:,� xar��^�l� fts�cia�c:s+�:�
Car�inc�ilrna��.
C(M\�Wl'1 ��T�C:'N�!I�f
WroJlie7a�r l 17t^n��t�,}�
�"a��a�n�}� Ti�c�o�,GA�a"c�r
��t�c�alrsari� C'rr��ra�it�y
I'catx°t� s�t ��a y�•a.
�'illa��;�; �a3srnui:�trtaia�a-
Villr�tMc; aff�I'lcia�;��'7kv"sPl�e
SG�o7<ir;t 4?rat�vk:s:d
�wtt}�e,rui.w�xr
1lrorwst ��at I�ai}y}i4a;Mo�t
Ju�hx� t ��Pai�atu
Sup�� s v�a�ear
'7"aa�vaa caf�'aetn�dt�t�a
��,erovxe,i� n�t ,.�f�
i����,a��� t � 'a'�;�����
[ �wuxa�tituat d'�+uctty
fC�rrr N�a�a4lcr
[ o�d,T+�au t�,7 i�irsl� �wi�,x�:�����tuunt
C el,y arC��ir�ta7li�t
�i�t "�ta �se�
� ntitii�ta��five t.)t�ice�
..I�(?Ct (.,l'��'l1Y'll}f
l �< <�rrtrwcr 1)arc�r��+c�r.
A Pti.a^Wirr C����rwd��»-�4
ker.r�sr�C�r�dlrr kertyo�nir.aA���.
At �1Y�1��CT, w� ���a���i�st�m��d �r�ci ���r��:iti�te t�l7e �iiiii�;�iltm�5 t��eor�� l�rc��l I�i���et5� ch�lle����c�1 }�y
a� ���a����rt� tax �a�zp� ����� � ve�y c�i�k'�c��lt �c�nor7�7��. L'3y sla�r�ir�� styr��� �f �ur k�a�rQ� w��T� ��ai��� �n
r���n���ia�� yQur �rr��e�1�y� ar��d c���ralty ir�rs���•ar7ce r��u�ds„ tiv�e I�€�p� ��� f7av� I�e�}aec��l p�r•�rvicle
sc�na�: sa����] n����strr� t�f"r`r�1i�f dBtLse }���t �ew yr:ars. "w�r'c lc�c�k f<>�'���ard tcr clair�� <;z7 �`car ���ar�}�
111QC'� �'i�11'S CC7 C(DGT1C.
�i,s �l�vG�y�, I la�a&� f�rr���Grt�c9 tu ��:ci�1� �,r y�cakii�� �vitEi rp�G�i�y' ul"����r�i a���>tt�; tl�e lix�� �h�i� y��r•.
���d ��N��rse, c6c�r�"t hcsit�it� t� pick u�� r��� Frfion� ��i�d �r�Cl ��t ���y tirr��; i1'y�a�i s�� z� ��ral�lei�1
wkl�r� vc��� t}irr7k �ve c��rro ���l�a c�r iira�r�c�v� cu�a.c sc��vic� tc� �,�c>u err t�r�y wu��y.
_�!���''„✓ ( 0"N� �}� y0 ��1,�� � / / � .� ^ "".M:� �— -` '
W� ,
_..� � �, � � i �
' r �/ � ,
�� �
� � `' � �' �,a: ',� �"'��i't �.' ,��.� �j`�r � � � � ,� 4., '�� ��
r� ,f ,
•�� � � .
,r , � � � .. �.
.� , � , ,. a
,
� u_. _.��, � ;, � �
�r
/ �w -� � � r_ . `' _._ �' , '�
� e,-k: V 1 I l� I`1 �%ll C` � "'" / �� f
,� /'
�F ' � ' ��-,�y .,"0 �w_ � `"��.:�_
�
l�;xecr�tiv�� L�irc C�<�r � °',�°������ � �"��....�-i,1, �."',�� i�✓ -.._
� , i
� � F
� �
., . _
�" ,.,� �
� „... �, J ,/
� ��,,.-�,r„��, �`� �.. ^ �� �,��,�`` '��°' � r�� a,� �^- y �� � �"��"� � /�, tJ-��
;
r � � �
�' � - , �
& ..
. , � + , ���
� ;
�',,� °� r � I C „"'Y'"Y �. '�,, � (� �. _ �.�
� '" � � �. . � - �' ��,�r,
a � �'��^� � �� � � ,'`� �� .�r d.
i �� j I
"y! �h �
� i .0 ' �r�,s���.�j�E.`��"..� ;f�y at�; a
� � ��1C7�14�.i1"�;1� S7'V:
� �1
` .a
:^P.s.rr>c iertiraaa +x) 7eriaras
�i i�i
(� i
�M /
�l � %;'/
NYMIR +nr�s �ta�tcd er��ire �t�ar� 18 years �go by th� three state�,ride mur�icip�l asst�ciations — the NYS
Canferen�e af Mayc��s, thue Assaciati�n af Cc�ut�ties ar�d the Assa��iation af Toenrn5 — as a way ta pratect
rmaac�icipalities from the fiscaP� ur7certaanties of �he traditior�al insua��nce m�rket�lace. It �r�av�r prc�vi'des
rnur��cipal ins�aran�e cr�verage fr�� r�rar� th�rr 650 It�c�l �av�rnmer�ts all �ccc�ss th� St�tie.
At its Ncave�nlaer �(��8 u��eetir�g, tE�e NYMIR Br�ard of Gav�rn�ars began a�ar�,gr�m by which N'YN91E� wcau�ld
share a pt�rti'oru qf the R��i�raca�`s c�irrer�t surpla�s b�sed u�c�n the �rrr�uu�t af ir�iti�l capbta� ccar�tributic�rti
each s�abscrib�r�g rnemka�r- ra�ust rr7ake tc� th� Reciprt�cal. �'his annual dis�riba�tican g�aes ��a each r-r��mb�r
�uhich h�s camplet�d i�s f�ve y�ar ca��taliz�tion obligati�n ar�d ren�vu�d �✓ith N'Yf�91� �ar �nather tv�relve
mo�th period. N�fN1IR remains t'he lar��st1 rr�ast suec�ssful exampl� �f r�unicipa� ccraperatit�n anywhere
in hJevv Y�rk S��te, and this capit�l ret�rn pr��marru is ane �r�y in v,rhich we can recc�gniz� th� I�y�lty ar�d
cc,��rrri:trr��nt vuhiew� are the eornerstar�es �af any s�acc�ssful ca��er�tive v�r�ttare. It is a testamer�ti t� the
f�r�a�cial stren�th a� a�r prngram a�cf tr the r�sk maraagement praeRices of �ach �f crur Icayal, Ic�ng te�rm
merrob�r�.
Th%s is yoGar seco�rd ar�nual distribution in th� amrunt c�f��,415.6C�
The d�cis�c�n yr��� muni�ipa�ity r�rade t� jc��r� with fella�nr S�bscrib�rs and c�ar�trr�l ya�r awn d�estiny �h,�n
it cornes tca p�r�perty �r7d cas�alfiy irrsu�ance h�s prc�ven to kae a v�my wise cane. �l�+le are pl��sed to
recognize and salute that fcare�ight ar�d' fortitude as wre corati��u� t� sl�are vvi�h a�ar rner�berst67e fruits o�
th�ir Icrngs�amdar�g comcnitme�t �o r�isk management and tr �nrarkir�� wi�h tt��ir �elirw loc�l g�ver�me��ts
t� provide th�� v�ry best of ins�.a�-ance c�verage �t a� �rric� that is preddc�table for ya�r b�sd�ets �n�d
�ultirnately ber�efuts your taxpayers.
n
TOWN OF ITHACA
215 N. Tioga Street, Ithaca, N.Y. 14850
www.town.ithaca.ny.us
Paulette Terwilliger, Town Clerk Phone: (607) 273-1721 Debra DeAugistine, Deputy Town Clerk
pterwilliger�town.ithaca.ny.us Fax: (607) 273-5854 ddeaugistineC�town.ithaca.ny.us
LETTER OF SUPPORT/PARTICIPATION
Dear LGRMIF Reviewers,
The Town of Ithaca is excited to partner with Tompkins County and the
Tompkins County Clerk's Office in the development of a shared electronic
records management system funded by a 2012 – 2013 Shared Services grant
from the NYS Archives through the Local Government Records Management
Improvement Fund.
We affirm our active participation in the design and testing of the system using
the Town Board Minutes record series and our expectation of a successful
program that will result from the project.
�'�+ If, as expected, the pilot program is successful and fiscally feasible in the future,
the Town anticipates entering into a long-term commitment with the County to
provide host senrices for a shared electronic records management system
involving more record series.
.�—
Paulette Terwilliger
Town Clerk
January 24, 2012
n
� �n� // �
,����. �"�: `�`�r�r°i1 �� It���c� ,' ,
�� � � �fii�g� �� ��"�� � x ' r
I� ���� �.'�'. `� 4��� �� �� ��,. ��' ��� �� �
��
, ��ti � ,, �°�
��
�F :� �.
",�t�i:f' , , _
A *` �i, '' N ^ � " � ; � '. . MM � , � .
Y M d�' ; � "" . ! ii�
/' �M �iY I � �,�:. Vi M � .... , w i!I � r .� � '�R �. +/, `41 `� 1R i � re, ,�:w * ..
,�: �! � ! :� 'IAI �. :.A! . �M � � AV � � 'iM• :� � � �: '�M
y� AI IY r
Gi
� f� '� .#1 � 811 � � F +il� ` .�r ;�,y ' ' yp � +M" '�; <�
��� ..'! , :I�' �� ,9!" �, , 1� �� ,+! � �.91 �
� � i! � N1 , 9f: � � X/ II #� ,.: 11i' � 1� ,
M *
M ,: � '� � :. � I M' , �, �
# � �
:. ! ��:i! :qR.�' aY, ' �; ��� ��:A1, � � " �:�
�. � .... " �: � �` �",.. ,. A� ��:. ,: � ,.+4 ru .: � .: M � � !',. . r ., .�Y..
� #t �I sF:. 1F. �
� �:� � M .� � ...,
� �
.:',. �, � �. ,� � :'.
�M y,
. ,� ar� �.; 1�, # �. w
I' ,f .j L"� �,� ,.a�-
}
. : �
�.. � �,, � . � �.. i
M •
� �•..
� r« I
(, ,:?' :;". ��.,
�, � • � • - �► • • � � � •
M -,r;� • � .s.. � � * . ,� �..
"'- +�- . � r�� . � « • - • •�
s - - • ' „ : - • ,, � • w ,, • - s � • •
� • - � •� r . • u� �+� sr• • �
" • . � . �, • . � • a - ! +� ,. � +r
r .� r- • • +� • " � •. -• • •^� -�
�r . • +M �e I� ' r �"' .. • • +� �M - � �
11 • . .. �M « 4 � � M '" � �
..� � �, � ,� �.. �.. �� . �M i
' • � i "" �
� � M � � �� Y� a1 ~� �I � ! � �I . A� �11 . � �11� M � �MM . �.� �I •
�1 �IF 1/ f� � !A. !I � �. .� A� �I . �I �I � .i
* ^', • "' A. � i ,� • ,. • " N '" w
"'� t ! �. • . • — . •
� , '�
� y �I 411 „` 11 tlM • • •" •
M � � � � f w M � �M � N M�` � • #
�.+M, 1Y ,i �Il . . � a . . � w.n � '� .� � � � . �. �i .�, � . � wf . � r � �' � , A�
111 !'
y/ �. � . �� � '� �� �I . A11 �� � eY . � +I ,,. .A� i �,.. ��. � �,�..
�S N�" 'll� �1 1I ♦ �'.�II� # � 'M.
fI � T � �sF � � � #1� � � '�li 'I11 �....� aV' � � �� �
V � ! � ..� � � � � ` .� .. � � .. � . .� �. '� �� �. . �
�. �, � � L .w a � 1R. ., r1 f � �Y' aR f�� Mh Mlw. 1! ��� . � �� A! .�. t. � � � .
� � � f r �� �w, M �!' AI � �. � � � � iV � �M' � .M/.
i. � �tlr. � .a: � � , yl� i. r � r .we �. ` a r. y�. �.Y ,.. �I4 . �� .Yl �., 1 . ' �1� . . . � � �.
�� w �� ��n �ir ��'
« • � � M
�
2 D�3
A common sense recommendation seems simple and straight
forward. It centers on just three important concerns:
(1 } Is there a real need now and over the next five years for more
two-family dwellings near Ithaca College? The Town of Ithaca
seems to have more than its share of unsold homes, so why do
we need more? In addition, Ithaca College is building more
student housing on its campus and most college students
would prefer to be on campus than to be living off campus.
Where is the current and future need for more gray cookie-
cuttercubes?
(2) Does the proposed project enhance or detract from the natural
beauty of the surrounding area, especially the Ithaca College
Wetlands and the natural field and protected parts of 346
Coddington Road? I have walked around this area for more
than 35-years and it is cherished land to many residents,
biology professors, and the unique wildlife there. It is also a
� living laboratory for college students on the wonders of nature
that surround the Wetlands of Ithaca College.
(3) Since we live in a community to each other and none of us is
more important than another, the Town needs to weigh the
rights of residents as well as those of property owners. From
my perspective, the Town has weighed in with the property
owners and has left the long-term residents out in the cold.
As the saying goes, "Money Talks,� but sometimes it talks too
loudly. I do not believe the Ithaca property owners are on food
stamps quite yet, but many residents have decided to leave our
town because of quality of life issues. In economics, there is
an interesting term called, �Creative Destruction," coined by a
famous British economist that applies. In short, it simply
means that individuals and corporations become so powerful
and successful that the seeds of success breed the seeds of
destruction. Most Ithaca Town residents would like it to happen
now!
�
�,, My last point is tied in with part (3), but it needs special
attention. "Property ownership" means different things. Some
arrogant and self-centered property owners believe that their
actions are none of the business of others because they hold
the property deed and are thus free to do what they can get
away with under our liberal and broken zoning laws. Town
Board Members need to remind such individuals that we all
tenants on planet earth with a limited time to live our lives. In
the march of time, we all are udust in the wind," and the big
bank accounts and all these wonderFul buildings will be left
behind for future generations to cope with.
In summary, Ithaca town residents hope that our zoning
leaders can raise the bar on the current zoning restrictions and
put an end to the mindless destruction currently going on. This
is a threat to every Town resident and a threat to the Wetlands
of Ithaca College. Your action is needed now!
r�
Sincerely,
::�o�r'`�`'�/ '
,
Louis R. Munch
214 Northview Wes#
Ithaca, NY 14850
cc: Fred Willcox, Chair of the Planning Board
Rich Depaolo, Chair of the Planning Committee
Bruce Bates, Director of Code Enforcement
�
3�3
������
� `' ` ;'. � ' ��` ' I W 1/ 1 V 'V �
� � ������
18 21 G.1 � kMk. T���� i7�r��lr ��hC��iC�, PkJ.4`. 14�54
��_., .�..
��"�r �,��'"� �w�.tc�wn.������c;�.�7y.�.z;�
Towrr Superv¢scrr (6Q7j 2J3-�72�, Ext 1�5 : 6-9E-avr�rr��Ar�C��tra�^ra.otY��ru�.r�y.�u.�
TrJV'trN CLER�t (�(77� 273-1 i?1 PU�L9C W4E�KS (6f17) �7�-1656 �NGBNEERi�I� (607} 273-1747
��ptvr�ir�� (s��r� z��-��a�r zca�i��v� �sa�� 2��-����
FAX (6�?7) �73-1704
F�}�1 Glul["�` �', ?f� � �;
L,41,L�1ti {�. �l6'T1t;}1�
? ] 4 T�lc�rtl���i�w W��;t
iti��Yc��, �!'�'' 1��5C�
C►ea�- I"�`�,. M��nc;l�:
I��in ��cat �is���r�e� �vitka ��a��ela r.�f wl���t �F��u ���rvc �aic1 �rx ycr�ri�.➢�►c���r�c•y 3�J`�, lett:��-. T��e c�•���
�,i' �t��cl�;��t I�ca��sir�� t�t'c�t�� tl��: k��74�r�el�t�'i�� t7i' ca��r- twc� lc��;��1 aa�l�vc�c��itie� ����� f�cee7 �►r� i�:�tae 1�crt°
��,c£�c�c�;. �"17� �y}ac� c��� ��c��a�ii�� �>i�ir�� h�ri�t c�n i'c:rrr7�ylv������k ,�1v�rntiic �r��c� I��mr��1i �?.veu�ue i�
l���hly �ii�;Gi��pc�ic�tAn�.
We ���•c vrc�s�kir�� l���t�cl tc� cc�r���al�ce c���r �ta�c���t��l cc7r71}�a•el�c:,i��iwe p1���7.'�''ith a ncw 1�YG�i�a ia�
�,➢�cL w� r�aay he ��blc tc� iru�titute:. �� laa�ttc�a� tyI�� c.y9� zc��iit7� a��ci �7��Mt7�i��; ��rcl-�itect�x�•4aV
�.: �i�t�cl�tt°ci;� �u�c] l�tiil�in� �;I.tu�cfl���'�:, tl��ii will �'Ls�rIG in �i�,ttt�n c��usi���. �,'+1e ar�e �tlyr� lcaraltiia� at
tl�� cc-�c�c� �viaici� ����°���ic th�, ty��c: c�f' �t��cIl�;��t t���tisi��� t8�;:�t i� :�c� �����lt��ac�tiGFe. "1 ha� s�id, t61��-e
��rc ti�lway�; t�7c�:;e i�� tl7e �:c�'�����t�►�i�4y wtxc� �vi91 �c�k ��r��i I'�ncl way5 tca �kirC th� 1aw. Y'cru z����y
l7c inte�-c�;tc�cl t�� ka�c�w f1��tl w� rccc;ntlyf cahtaair��c� �� c:c�►�vi�ti�ai� ���au�ttia rr ht�ilci��• �vlyc� i-ente��
t�,� r3�c���c st��c�c��t� �t��,�t �a8ic�����d ��x��i���� c��ci�. �r'�t, v�6llx��.j�.�d� �� ��a��1nG� (�c�rce, w�e l�ra�re li�n�t�d
4�hility tca �u�•�ue a��cl }�t�c7����ite vic�l��t��i��;.
MaSt r;<�»���NGxix�t5 we ��t i��wi4d tl�ai ti�e; "I'��vw�� ca�� �kB��►c�i'�; le►w� txre tc�c� 5tr•ict. tn i��ct �hei�c
��r� sc�ve�•c a�e�i��ic%ic���s ��r� wl�4�t ��a�t��ici�a<tBiCi�� G�;tr� ea�l't��•�:e. 4'+/c; c��n hCt�te t�4�C c��re c�r11 ���i�el
�� c��a�;-1�ta�l�i�y hc����;�, ��t�t lt€�����r�� i� t�� �� "1'�at�uaily'= is v�rtu�illy ir��g�c�w�il��e. Yo�a �����c ���t�t
"..,khc:, Tcav�e� l�c�� �✓ci�l�cc� iry will� tk�� ����c���c°��t;y c�wr�c:rti ar�d l���s 9c1�9 t.l�� lc7n�;-t��-Qn r�si�ients
��uC ir� t11� cE�lci.'' (�['1��� tf�c: ��r�]���r-ty c�w�1�i`s cxe�� �h� It����-tet��77 n���itlertt�;. Atxci, �tr�de�' law,
w�. �;at� ��c�t c(e���°ivc tl�er7r cai� ��ll v�:il���. c>f tl��:i�- ����c��7e.��ty (tfj��t i� �� "t�kin ;,. ��nciel� �t�e la�a).
�3z�l�aM��.i�7� t�ll tl�r�at ra��t m� r� vc�•y �9if`l'ic;talt �aC�l'icy a��G�ttct•. Nc�r�c:��l�Gl���, w� ��a�e �c�ii�� to t��y
4tr�c3 w� ��i�pr'eci�al� y�acr�` �t��rrc:at•t i�c�i° t�i�t�Lr• �;a�ir7c������6�; �itE�in tE�c "I`c���n.
S'ri7ceb��:1}�,
�� � ��
�, ,��w��� ���„ . _ .._._
� �� I�� `��;r°t .I. �€�r�r��a��� ��
T�arn��� ,5ia����°vrsca�' �;�
C�C�': I�c•e�l �v`i�c�c�x
a����
i�icl� I�e��a�al��
13r�.ace C�tttc�4
Tt�'W �I t� F I TH,�C�A►
215 �l. Tic�g� Street, I�hac�, 6�.Y. 14�5�
W W W.1:C) 4l�'tl . 9 i�7 wi L�1.11 �r' . l�l �i
T�awm Superviso� (607) 273-1721, Ext 125 ; f iC:ric. rn<aR7�t �c��rru.ithk�c;rs.o� .t,��
TC)WN CLERK (607) 273-1721 PUBLIG W�Fif�,S (6�7) 273-16�a6 ��JC=II��CFiNGV�a (6q7) 273-1747
��,�n�rvir�� �so�' 27�-�T�� zcrn�sna� �sc��r� 2��-����
�,ax (soa) � �a-7 �a�
���7I`U'c1Il'�' �, ��' � ��.
�i1V4'. �' j�i�}i�'I'
I�i4 Si���tibu���� D��ive
it9�a�.a, NY 14850
Dc;.td� iwlr°. Pyt�:f��,r;
I a��� in full �i�,C-ee���c:.a�t wit�� y�a�r �e;xati����nt5 ir� yAc��i�� J����uary �(), 2()12 lctta:��. �JJ�aY• "T°��wn
fii°� cQ�n�i�aet �c��ts Glr-e ��a� c�f cc��ut�-��1. �ui� 1G�1°��st yin�Cc fai9l ev�.��g� }�����' i� ����ici tca t���. �C"iCy
o�� �tha�ci Fir�; De��Q�rt����;i�t. 'I'lr�it'S wl�y° �u}�ret� I�ti�5tt���ec1 c�i�d'i�� ���; Tc�°we7 5�i���r°vi:,���' 1 c'e;_
n��c�ti��te� p�i�� ��i��e c�c�t�ka��act, a�c�ltici,��, t6��; c�vei-}�c���9 c;lu������� '�5()>(�(��l y�cz� �,rc����• (,'�?�d:},(J�(:�
c�vtr` tl�� lii�i� �i� th� �c�nt:raei). I K11;��� �li�cc�va:r•�cl tl�r�t Cla�:, f���-� [��;���ro�t��a�i�i w���; �ir�� u���c�ivi���
t��11 c�•eclit l'ca7• tlz�, Cc�rn�;ll ��t��c�i���itic�i� lc� rt��irgic�i����l ���°viccs. Th�it h4�� �c���e:�i ��c� ���icliti�l���l
�� 25,()Of? tc�taU crve�- tl��; past � y�:���-�.
I-Ic��,�rer��cr, 1 z'����ir..�El th��t t�ac��� ;��iviT��4 v���.�°c:�iq�,t d� ti�av�r� }���yr���:�lt. "C�ru4, tk�e Tc�rw°z�
�r;�a�li�f��c� tt�� �lc� 1-lcac F�ir� Cc�r��x�litt�;e ia� �?(� l t) t�� :�ta�r•t �hc �art�G��;:� c��� f'i��cli�1� ���u�°t� r�7c�c°e
��►���ta�rcti�G ��xvi�1��;. �V� ��rc 1���ak:i��� ��t a�l c�}�tic�r7s, ���tc;l�Meii�a�� ���Icli��� vc�luni�.�;��ti �c� the:. �a�rici
f�.�z•e�, ��c�i�z�,� ���c;� tica ��c�l�r��t��c� fa�.�alkc�'�, �t�ntt•acCi�`��; w�Fetk7 ��kl�c�� 1'irc ����:�ai-����r�nt� 6}�tai.
1����•�icc• t�ze Tc���n, c�;t��hli:�Y7ic�� �� n�.��r, irtc��.,�e,r�c�c��t 1`ic°c cic��cxt•t����:�7t d`c:��° tl�c 'I�c�w�i„ �tc;. �+.:�
y�rti �i�ay h�ave re�tl ir� th� Cthac�t Ti�iacw, �uc. f��tv� ��t�t �tlti�tc�� i"<711�;�s; ��n ��c�tic�. Chrlt it r7�tt�t.
i7�c�r�: :�efi�ic�i��ly �:�t��icle:�• dt�; r�5��c����il�ility° �c� t8��; �c�r�r�j�����ity� �c� }��:1� t��uc7c1 ��it�c anc�
c���ug��ency se�-wficcs ��a����c:cti�r�. T e�;i�z�:acitc tl��it <� I'�zi�� <�i��c�u��t wvc�talcl 1��. `� l,(�()�,t��0 ���:r
}a�.�r•, ��1t��c����6� tl��ut ���xc��ir�t i� ��i�l�l�ely l��:c���a:;� �'������� 1i �c]�aic�ik���t�,s c���nly `�7l � (�f)C� 1-�e:��
ye�a��.
Qve�- ti�e ��a.�� y�;ar• I�;�«t��: aihc��.Nc tl��� 1'i4�4�� �1�t�ll�.���e a����a�t6�ly �ot�7 C�{�a�c�l}Rfi7 }�ctcr�c�r�
wli��� al�te ��a� �a7��yac• ��ricl t���ve 1����tc� thc �;Gu��c ct�nvc���;�►tit�x� v���tk� l��c° r�c:w �a�u��������, .`aaFaelte;
Mye°ich.. T"B�G Tc�wv�7 Bc�zlt°r� �;� c�et�rr7�ir7ed tc� si.l��titG�na�tlilly e��ci�rc:e c>�N�• f�i��� �n�ci c,���cr�yc,��cy
l�rt�t�ctic��1 c:��:�1� a�1� wcl�:c�t�ac�5 any ��nc1 �z�l a�ic���. ��1�����k �j���a 1'a:�n� tE�kir�� �1��; tir��c tca �x��e'css
�ra��r ����apc7a�t t�c,i• i���l�.�c����; �i tt��: c����� tca t��c `C�c-rw��.
�0.I1C'�'B"�.� j°,
���
�� �w,����.
�,mu�%��,, �1"��G'1"C .�. �17bC71i11
Tc����n S�i�err�is�r°
� ���� � ��"�" ��"� � �� � � � � � � � ��'"�"" � �� �� � '�" � �
ir��r��r�, C�Ic:vr �`,���1� �"""�°�""�� � ;
�,�� �
�'� � � � � i°:� i_,� f r I,- 1
�.�a� i t
�� !
�
� � �� �
: � �._�� �
"�"�: ������� T�u�rn B��re� - . ....
��t���� F+��M�st F�c���t� C�r����°����������: r���uci�I��c���.
���1����:tm P�t����a�� ��� ��e��ac� ��a��d Lir��it c�ra J�ac�� �`�11s ���c� ta� �5 1"��"�-I
��t�a ��b�T►��x-� :i+�, �I���
���wcl�s�� is �z ��ti�gc�� ������� l�� �C� ��c�sic�����s c�� �'c����� �-��x��� i�� ��a�p��•� �f � r������ ��
�µ��lu�c �:l�t� s���� lir�it c�n ��,��� ��11� F�c��c� �� [t��+c�, ���nr Y�a�r�, f����� �� �F'�-1 �� �� �1�I-I..
T�°�e at��c�7�c� p����ia�� c�����1� ��au�ti��� t����c��as d'c�r �l�i� �°��ta�st. �n �!�������i�ti��,���1 i� ��
r°�d�z��e ����c� �� �I�� �'�r�st �i�r��� ���t�+��� c�f J�c�� ➢��a�ls R��� �ah�e�•� t����� ar� �h��� r����tlyr
il�st�t��ci ����fi�: �;a1ir���a� ���tic��°��. fi� 2� �tPT-� s��e��� 1�����: �ra�tl� �.�r�c�a������ d�~iv��•� t� t� a�a��
�� a �.�at������r���� ���-���r�v�t��ac� s�3��c� �hra��h tl�� ����� t��l�s (��s��ad ��s���di��� r���
������ ����t��, �l�us re��catx� �r�i�� �r�� �r�a�s�a���� ��n�.�i i���.r������ s�ff�t� ��� ����� t�����e��s.
V'�'� ��c���� ���� It�z��� Tca�� �o��ci �v�ifl b� ��.���p�����cv� +�� �hi� p�t��x��� ara�i �������� �ar��4
��ee�u�si �;���°���1� ���� r����ss�r�r i����� ��'a���-c�v�� �r�� ��:fii��a. �V"� r°�s���cti'��1�� re��l�s� t����
�h� ���r�� ��%:��ra��i+�c��� �W�c�i�t r�� t��i� p������c���. ,��e�itia�����9�, it ��at,�l� b� ��►�l�.�f��l �� ��t�o�
�,rl'iera �^a� �ha�lc� ��p��t � r�s�ao���� ��d wr��i��� �r��r�t����er���� �r��i�y �rill r�s�c���e� ta �s.
,n���.
I�'t��� '�'cr�r� �cr���i h�s q���c�li�r��� �l�a��� t:��� �a��itica�, i� is wv�l�;c��� �� �.�a���t�ct rr�� �t tl�e
F�r°���: I-Ic����� �t��i� ���eitm��� ����:��e�e� flx� ��� f�c�t�r of �lais I�t�er r�t� �z� ���r ��t4s�z�r�1 cc�����ct
�r��'cwrrn�ticr�� �:��s+� i���cic���r� l��l��nr.
�'h�ar�l� �ac� �`��� �r��ir s�:��a�.���µ� af �"��M��t �-ic���� i�� �:1��� r�a��att���. t�'� ����� �'�r�r�r�� t�a �i����ir��
fr��� �ra�� �� �r+��,a� �a��li��t c+�r�v�������e.
�i�a����l�r,
T"��-��� 1'�. ����i,������
F°����i����, r������: ���r-��c� �x������a�°��-���x�: �����i��ti��z� (�"���.�}
�,� F�����y� €�t�i�r�,
�t�a�a, �iY �.4•��D
��7-�5'i�11.��
���2�r��°r��ll.�t��
C�c:
.ia��a i������r, T���a��c�i��� ��a�i ����icl��!t:, �°l��i��
f"l�:r�:��is�� �,�����l��b��„��•, ��c� I������da���t, �'I-���
.��°i ���r����, ��c��°���r��, �'I-�l�
�i�����a ��ry���s "�'�������r°���p �°�-�I�
i� 11^*at�/.����I� i ir,�it��° a ��u'�A"a.:.��.�'ri�.uW7W'tl��19t(a,.od��S����luN7C,%;qd4f����'"�4'�7o191fi'Ih
PETITION TO REDUCE SPEED LIMIT ON JUDD FALLS ROAD TO 25 MPH
Presented to the Town Board, Town of Ithaca
�
Whereas the Town of Ithaca has recently installed a number of traffic calming
features, including stone pillars, lampposts, curbing, and three speed tables along
Judd Falls Road between our hamlet's southern boundary and the road's
termination at Forest Home Drive, and
Whereas each of the new speed tables is accompanied by a warning sign and an
advisory speed sign marked at 20 mph, and
Whereas the posted speed limit for that section of road is 30 mph, as it was
before the installation of the traffic calming features, and
Whereas the average vehicle speed has decreased signi�icantly subsequent to the
installation of the traffic calming features, according to a survey conducted by the
Town of Ithaca in Spring 2011, and
Whereas the 10 mph difference between the posted speed limit and the advisory
speed encourages drivers to speed back up again after having slowed for each of
the three speed tables in that short section, increasing the Ievels of braking noise, �
engine noise, and exhaust, and
Whereas that section of road is thickly settled and heavily used by pedestrians
and bicyclists, and
Vllhereas that section of road serves as a major thoroughfare for commuters to
and from Cornell University, and also as a pass-through route connecting
Northeast Ithaca with points south, and
Whereas the Forest Home Traffic Calming Plan calls for all roads in the hamlet to
have a speed limit of 25 mph, and
Whereas the posted limit on the adjoining Forest Home Drive is already 25 mph,
We, the undersigned residents of the Hamlet of Forest Home, Town of Ithaca,
County oi Tompkins, State of New York, respectfully request that the speed limit
on Judd Falls Road between the intersection with Plantations Road and the
intersection with Forest Home Drive be changed from 30 mph to 25 mph, and
that the existing 3U mph signs be replaced with signs reflecting the new limit. �,.,�
��' � �' ' u /�; 4;G ; �- l $ � �� I ? b �''t, i !; ��a
� .
l���v� ��tr�r f"���t�r� �n J�a��� ��ai�� 1�c��c��� wi��w�cr� E'r��u� ��7�� �sc��tl��.
, ���,.,.
`C���a �,•lc���ky ����c,�;c� r�awc.1-f���>�°lt ����c���' i.a,�l����� v���r�r��c� �r����� �li�� :�caaAti�.
PETITION TO REDUCE SPEED LIMIT ON JUDD FALLS ROAD TO 25 MPH
�
Presented to the Town Board, Town of Ithaca
# Name Address Signature
�- " �a �,,, •�o o c� 1 I � � �� ,,.� � �; �
� �tw �e. �'j•iv�o c � �,
� l,1� Z. ,`�. C��--=��. k i v i/rc �7+� �— �:•r i��--= c' '�
� L C f�� f'1 r�.c�' �, �• L' �� t-� :� �-�
� '' U`c��c VU � I o k'c�.ti � � i�,�.e.� �
�
�
F'E�'i"T�1�1� `I'� ]k�.1�i)UCE �P'�F� I��t�i'�" fJ�1 ��.�L l� �'.�i�L� �?�A� "C"�b �� �1��
Z'an���r�tec� ti:a� ����� '1'e�vvt� l�a����r�, '�"c�r�i� ��' It�z���
� ## � f�����c i, �1cl�lr�es� ���nat�.�r��
� __...�� ._.....
r -.__ ....�.- ... , � ,
� ., _ . _ �..,.,._. .. w .. � _� 'R
� w y � 2 ,? ^'{� f
, G � p _
��,' C��,�,� � � � '... �, '� � i� a �✓^ ��' � '� �,� uJ" r �.r �'+� ° d ��+ " d �"'R., � �4 � C � . n t �k � �' p � �"i µ, ^ ¢ �,
_. � �
.. ..._ ... �. .. _�._. .... ......... . .__... .., _.... . ._. __ ..�.. _. " __N r_. � _.
� �
.. � � p � fr�
� °� ,..rl � � �w�,� � �� y� ° �� �" k 4 �,y�. �d v�^ �O �. �� � +� �+" �� d � k � 6� � �,.. �%�,,� d � �� r' A d �s°`�' _ . �..,
� � � .. � � w d � � h"� m�✓� � �"5 q� � 'I� ......�.�� . > .. . _
f „ � � W ,y
„ q
� . W , ... � � '��
� y°'
q� ». d� I r� „7 d i '.v J+^'r"i �
' I � � +.�.., '��` Q ,� � W � � � +§"'�° � � � `'� _.. � � � �"" �
..�_,.i _..._..._ ._...... . i� .. .. .— tl
..' ��`. �
r� � �� � � �.... � ,
...� .��� _ . _ . . "� � � _.�.� �._. � ``�� _ � � ?�'��.- .. �.,�� � ��_�� �� �._�� � _ r....� ��� �« �., y� � � ��,�,.
._ w ; � ,,,✓� ; � ,,, ��' - � , ���.
/ � � � � � �,.m.
. ' I, �
i A � � ��d..:, p� � •,� u� � .,�""d �� 7 ��-"_ ° .S (j � � .�_.� ___.—� "�..� .. �"'x� � %'��'r� � i f
� � � � �' ��r
._ _ ...._� ._. � �
, � � , �.�
��..d_� � w '. "�„ �w. _� � ��.._..°.._� .�.....,,_ 4..E...._� �.��._..�,��i.�" a ``.r �r_ �" �. � �,�..��F,--����----�-�.`,���,,,;,''
: � � , n.. �� � � � ._.r _, � , � ,..-
, � r � �+
�, "_
� �, � �. � �,� '�� � � � � r �i. _ , "�,� � �__,w � , o w �t � i'g k � ��� r^ _ , , � r " ..� .._ x��
�. • � t
.. � f, ,.
�� ...._� � �, �... ._ ��..w . , __
_,..
i � m _ .._.. . �..._...._ ._ _.. —_ � �... •
_.....,..___.......
�
� .. � _ _ �, , �
�. �
i / � � '� _��� �� �" .. �. i�,� �"�'.� 1.�„'�� �° � "" � �°.. � �`� �" � � ��
, . �� __ ;.� �:�
�",� : � , � � . „�
. ..�, � �" � �� � .�� � �
� � �d �� �� � �� � ��� ,��...� ��`�,�z� �� �� ' �
""�" _.�... �-,H.-
. .. _.—__
._ ._.�__ ,
r
'� ��" � Y:.�. ` s� :__ __........_ �.� _ '_ V � � . a � 4 � � � , � .
� �. .. � ? _ e_ , � �. �, _.._...... _..__._._ �
�
'�e� � � � ,,. l � ��.. � ,I� w�., �d � � � 4. � � Cr�;, �, � °'�
� �.,, �,�
_ _.�.. ._ _. .,._, .n . _
�° ✓p �. ��_"k.... �.�..�, �. �.� ��_�_�. �l � ��" � h�+.. ��+ �`"_.__-��� � ��',�p"p���
� I � g / +,� �
� � � . ��
� mm � .f ti..✓' W`" B� ('� � � . � � � � d �I' � ��� �p°�'
.. ° -.�._. �..... m ._._._......_ _.__ _ _____.. ,... , .___ ,
� � � � �.d �' :""' n.."_ �.,o" •,
7 � � ".b'& �a � •�,� L al. C < ���
�'.�r_,.."� � �-. _�rwo: `��� _m::m� > � �, �. � � � � � �� .
.. _ _._. ..�_
� I ^ / p
�
��C�r � i�` �� Wi F� ( 8,... ��� "rr �� � (� � ° W � ��i �"1 f'� � a� � �(' �-d
a� l_ .._e _.m..._ ._._.� � _�____ ____________n � _____..:._
w` .._.�_ y..._°:1 d.. ..... •,:�... _( .�.......,4,., � "..,..,..,, ^ �°o "�"_.. �__�...� ° ! '�� „_.��
...... � C .,. �
:� _� � � � *� __
�
�' _ � �..��� �....m���� �.�� �:......� __ ��. �. . � � �, w�.��,�;�� �� �,� � �. ��.��� __�
.
� � , , ..
� �,� �
� �
� a � � + „a . 7 ��a� �-_._ d''r"���.,_ .�?f" ��:�' f t�:_�.1 d" �
I.. �" �m _. . ..__ _, ti .. . _ .
�x �)
E...MN".'��� 1�' .� �.aP � .�.;...� �"_�hr'�.'J'�J., g, ° / 4 {w:
� � r �� , _ _ , ...... ._.. ..�.., ... _�._
I ° � �" ' s �r C o. ,
� ..�'_. h.....__.1 ._ �. _ � r. '� �� .. � � � � � .� ........ � � _'��� �Am�,J � �i^ � �, r::..'1� Qd,'.p ..
i
� . ..,_. ...., ..
/" � _. " —
�_ i� � �.� �. E� � � .� �
:` ;� ° � J' ; � I�"�,� u:.,� �`�`'�,r e'�„,.,�ti �, .
��� �������
� � k
, � ,�
�� ,��� � ...�w �����;..�,
_.. _..... � .� ,_ _.�� �,.� •,
„�, �,.� @, � .....� • . � � � � ,.
�_/� � 4
�� r r"�.,.� ,/'& � .m..._�."'�:=_._____._
a�"�. � � � �.�w.� ,
VyY� � _ � �___ .___ ...
�� � „�� ''� �,I , ' „'1' _���
a
. . „ ,��.s-^-. �° "�
� a
,��c..„�,.�,.. �.,. � .... �� ����a. g� �u..,,��w....�.�
d N„ �
_..... .. µ .."�/. � .,._..5.. �,m�":_, � _
�.�r ,� _ . ��-.-� ,�,� �- .� �,�.. ,� �.
�������,,,
�'E'I"�fiIC��1"� "�'�i R�Dp�:,I�E ����;� L���'�' �1°� �t��� ���i��.� ���.�I� '�"� 2� �'1��-�
i'�-��c�t��e.�ci �c:a th� Tc��r�� 1���t�c�, '1"��vv�� c�� It:9��c�
PETITIOAT TO REDUCE SPEED LIMIT ON JUDD FALLS ROAD TO 25 MPH
Presented to the Town Board, Town of Ithaca �
# Name Address Signature
3d ��(Z M. S Guc � c� s� A �
F"'�
�
�,
/'�1
PETITION TU REDUCE SPEED LIMIT ON JUDD FALLS ROAD TO 2 S MPH
Presented to the Town Board, Town of Ithaca
� ��. ,
� '- ' , , , . ► .� , .
� � :. ..: ► ��„ �,� S ����. ►L. �!it
��I.0 .a 1.'I �I.iii��� ' ' � �L'/ll��
��� ! , , .� ' � 1 i. / �. /
�� ������ �, � i � `,� / ; �' �'1 r '� / �' I
�•
��.� /.7� �,./� � �1 1 / �.
-.�I�L , . . r, , ��'l� �_�
� .�:, ,� !� 1 '' �...� • • . 1 . +1 3 �<< �. - �.,._:...
� _ i4 . . �, !��r�v���
� � . .. . .��
m � . � .� •� � ... t,� _.� r�- --
�'�.���i ' h / � �r � . � %
■
■
■ _
■
■
■
■- '-
■
■
■
■
■ -
■
�� � � ; � � , ,�. � �, , �, , � � � �. �, � ,� �� � �, �, . �, � a ;
� . � �
____- -_... _...� __ .. .. ....__.._.
_.__ _ .. _ .... .... _ ..._.._...___� ......._ ____ _ . _�_...____._____
# N�rr►e � A�dx't�ss So���attar�
___w .._ � __..___ � ..�_
, , .....___.____.__ _... ...,. ._ . _._
����r� • r � o � �.. a . ,r
t` �.„�_., � u mm ,; �.�.� JM� ��",��� �`"�_t���� � � �r°� ,t
d,.� fl� q A C � "'P � f.
.....____,. ._� _ ��,�„w
. i'�
�.,. k Y d*;N��....._........__..._. _.�.W_........___�_. � ��o�k�,� � ' ����..�.,
�r� �' A f�� ; � � ��
/
� � � � '�,� � _
_�, w ?.0 "�y�� r + p ���2p'� � )'`Y . �.a �"�r� � ^�' �'" ��
..._._.....,.. .__ � _.._...._. � �� °� �
r---_ _--� . ,�-°"�`7�' �- . ,,�� � .,
.r ..............�...�,_, .w_.w...�...m,........_....._.._._�.�.�._._....._._,�....__......__.._..._. ..r. .........a _..,m.,_._._. _..�_.__.._... _____.,...,.....,_, .�..w,.,..�_� .._---. .
— i -.�.,__..__ . . � ... . . . ............_.� ,
__.__
....._w.... I, ._. � , ..�....... ..._.__... ......._�._.�._.._w_......�_.._w ................ ..._...,.__......_....� _�__._.._w_ � �...�.,.__ . :.�.mm_.���..�_^____ �.� ,.
w .._.......,..........___.......____.._.___._.. ._,._.
_..�_.. ,_......_.�...,...,_.___........_._.. ............._....., .. _.__...,....,_w.....__._�.�..._.....
, ,.,.._ ....... .. .......m_,._. .
`.W�-.. _. i��...... _ ,.... ...._._.._ ..__........__`-� _..._._._ m__..�
_.___�
W. ----- � . _.._...__. _._. ............. __ .__...W.. .�.. -- u ... .._ .._ �-_�__.�. � _.__._. _.__ ._......_..._ _.._._ _._...
� � � � ,u; y ; ,�, � ; � �, �; ; r ,N �, � �� �
� '�
.._. .. _ __ __.... __��___�___ �_.. ...._.w�..._�._.�_. _..__.._ ____.________
� i�t����e Aeldr°�ss Si�;�1��t�a��t�
____..__. � __�. _ ._._.....�..._.� .._._� ,
�f� I M _. _______ _._ _. ..._. .._ _._ __ ___._
� � � � _ �
� , , ,i t
, � r
(� `'
� � ��` �' � , � �� ���� � 1(� ' , ".� � N � a: �: ....._.....
�� �
.... __.. � ..�. � .. ��__�__ � -��� �
F _ _ _ _, .
,
;,�
_ .� W � _. � �
�--� . , ���,° �,� 7'�1�: � f�,���.- �-�'�.
,
,
__._... � . _ . _ .. ...__ _._..__._ u�_ _...._.m_ .._�._
� _..�.��. �.� _._...._ .� __... _ _.�___ ..._..�._.w..
� :� � �P ��� � b���� � u� � ��� �� '�� �. � `� ��' � �-�� �' ��� — � � � ��
_ ____.._ ��__.,_ � �'�
. .....w _._.._______—____ _.�_____.�. _ _. _ _._ �
. _ !- V
/ � � �.��. _._�. :._ � F � c � �,
� �- l �.__.-_- �. �� _
_....._ .��___.. � ._ � ��� ��_..e._..._�..._���____-�_ :_..�:_ .__ ..... _ . __.._._ _ .,�e_
R
___.. LL -� /�` '
P � � �,,r"� (Z, �r Cl� �� � � �" �1Y�I 1 �. � � 1�r-�, �b.� � �.J G�, " �t,a.�"�.���..� l l.. �._� .1����'
�_. .... _._.._.. _.._._..� w_.�-
i____-- ......___._._____.__.._...w._ �._ �_,..,_._ _..._...._..__.__...._.W__ .._.�...._.._. _._. _..._..�__.__...._...__._._..�.�.____
� s
.—_l_ __ ....w_ _....m .___..__._
_.._... .... _. .._...... �_._. �.— --_.._....__.w__w_..�
_... .�--- -- w� �.
� -- --
......_........ �.__ ____.. .... I
_._...__..._....� _._.....1.._..._. �_w �___—_._. ._..____.._..____ _ _._
__ m _ _ _...... __ .__. _.�._ �..�.. �
....___.__ .__......__.. ��._.._..__ _..__.-_-- _...._.._.__
i
____.._ _ ....... _ ......_...__._--- ,....._..__ _t._.__..____....�._......m. ....._.._ __`___
i...._ ._..._,_._ _._.___.. .._...____..._..__
__ _._ .. _,_._ _ . � .— . ......_ _�. _____ ___... _ _� _—_l_._. � . m m_._.___.. � ____...._._._._.
I...._.. _ __.... __..__ _ ____------ -
�
.______. T .._...._.___ ._.�.._ ._ ___.._- �
_..._._....._._._—V �___ _._....._—_ ____._._.W �,�.... _ �. . .__--- ------ -----_ �
........ _ ._I�_. ..... .......__ ___ _�___ .m... _____ _.._.._...__1._.__----_ __.____ �_ ... __ _ _ . _..... . . .._ ... ..._ . _. ._ ..._.. _ . ___....__ _...._.... _. _.._
PETITION TO REDUCE SPEED LIMIT ON jUDD FALLS ROAD TO 25 MPH
Presented to the Town Board, Town of Ithaca ,*�►�
# Name Address Signature
D ' �_R�ht �� � � �� �,� ,�,
�
r
, � �
s� �'a S� -� 3 � �; �� � -
.
z 5 r�. ��. �
3 � t.a �.�+i" 'o! �r �r.+^ c.! />i- ..1 a v-� . �. (a�'
s� ��d�,.' .
� w
�
�
i" � f; �' '!j;^ i r"U �'r1 �,,� k, f r et -J �! � } � J � � A f�
� � �
� �+Ja�-n� ��d��ss Si�r��t�zr��
��� � -��. ��� ,���.� �� ��� C�. �`��, �" ����� .
��'�. � �. � ,� ,✓� �.
� �w
�w
�r ��,� , �� � ti � �� .
� �
„ '6,!
� �
_ ,� �" ..
�
�' � �� �����„�� r� �� ��� � ° ��� A� � � ,� p �� .�.��� � �r�,����� .. .� ��, 4���1�,� �" a� � � ����°� �� � �� ,� �� w� � ,.
� � .� .�.�� � � � : �^��' � ,�.. m... ...�
�
�° � �' /�,�'�
,�a � �� a ���° ��" r��; ~ - I `�'�''� .. �� � ( "� � � ai ' ''"�,-/ �� t�a , b � �".. �,""��✓��.'�� � � ��� ��
-
�, ..m._ � . � '.
� ,� " �Y
. . � �_.�' ° • - w.
�
,�
T � . � r ,, a
' �-,� �. ' _
�
�"�� a ` '�. � x +� w 1�� , d� Ld. �w�� ( H � � �rG "�° " 4. -�
.
�" � , r .;� • �,'��;
�� � r =
ri ,
"-c. � `. .� �d, ; � �,
.
, ,. . �
J r'� � �,. , � ��� � ,,�' ��',�, �� i�. , w.a.�a.v a �.P �. !✓ ,�'��� r � �,,;� � � �.
d� H' v � r
� �� �L� �
_� r � �-r �fi'� w
� �^
�y� �.a'�'"4_, � �,k��^"�"`��,�,�.., � "rm� � r a�� �a L�^�' Z�d. ,✓q�""�.�' ���,. ""'� „�,.�.�„��.�
� :....., ��
ua.. ,�^-- � .. ,.
� �� .� s .�:� , , f�'�,p',�v4^7 �„-G� g/i','� °"�,�,��°�^` � �"�'��'�;� �/�� �. h'.�;�,. „��,�,,.,„�...�,„�"�,...,.
�� �
�� .., -. J ,/'�� k�..�
. � �*Pr �� m �- my� ..
�� �. �"�� "� Y"P�+r ` � � ��, � � r" r f r�� � � � C �� Lm��✓s,� � ; � ,�a�"f` ; �;�„'°�. ( d d.�"! ; �,,�"� � a < d �� �e' d.�� �" �
�'
� � ��., � �
. ---,✓,
� �'t � rv" r � �� �n �r s r�� �' �'�� ✓' "�+`� ,���""��,
� �..� " �,� � � � ., � �:' �r P` ' �"r� �` �, ° 'r ,..»,�""
� �° C ��' �. � � � l �., � � '� . ��.r � �� � �.w�.�°
_.n _, � w.. _
.._.�`N . �. ,- , . , .
r,--��
._
. _. � � � .. �
�^ � ,�� � .�,C �,_. � �' ,.� r' ���,,� �c'a �� �'`,���' �.� �'� �� �� � ` �°� � ��' _..
, � ��
.
_.._ � w„
���,��'r� •--�n� /� .. � :.,-. � ,,,.`� : —a,. � __�� ��
..M z
•,.w --�
, , �'
. �.
� ^� � r �� ` ��. �: U _ a r �� - / r� � � .s� z�`�.�"� � ,f .�„ "'� ,���_& ��-;, �"� l"" �� � � . ...� �� ; -��._.
, .�
M ��
,
,. •� ,� . ✓" �'
, �,
,
�� �/ 1' �r� � ✓ .� , � �' , ,..,�. :.. ,� P�✓ t. ! ��r"� ., x n ^-� ` ; �vna� "z- A �` i q r ti �
.
) ' , �,. (, , , .. , ". .. . � .,...
�- . , . Q,
� �
7
l
y+ ^ � ,,�- � i �
�
w n , � �
�-� t '� ',�,sm��, y '� $ � ti i r � �.� �', ���/r r ,� ,,!xt� �..�,,.»,� � ,......,,...� ��,��'� d �a
„ ..,,.., ,. ,_ � ✓ C / �-w...
, , , - ,.....
� �
� � ..Sl�l�p'�,.. „ �i... ., f„._,. '�u , "� '^ 'w y ,"! Y 'J':, ;%; , J �F� . .__
w
rv
,„ �.,
�. R.:,w ..._ d � ��.w..,�,.�,2...._ a. p . ., � , y/ � '. / 5 r , �k ,7 ,u r&'...�,� �. . _ ._...
a p, �-;^^� ,r^� m._
!'�e ?t,,pg I� " � � ��� W�� ,'� � ,. �� ��
f,� f .W,� {;3 er'y ��.., � �� `�(." C'1. � �"Y. ° � 1.�..w. " � k ` tri�:'� j4. "� �� � �' r
o- t .�
w
<, __a-���� . . � � ��+
# Y � ��
: , . � ,
; "'�
� "�..L' ,� �_. q� i I � �m' I �' ""� � � ub " ,, +�. � ,j��, ._
. �j
,� - f �;.('� 4° �` l l". 4 sC�w"� 1 '4 �,_ _" �� �.., ���._.. r ; �
��..��...� r `'"-'., t_ fl
,� ���
,.,..,..... .,✓
I��_______--
;e...�,
� 1_...: .mm ...ma
� ��N'�t�`� �„,� �`��� ��r�, irr����rr� �`���tr� i c�c.�<� ��rr�.r.r��rr��c��l�c.�r��f A c:���c��rsf�r�� /r���rdt.rf�
��,�,we�, . ���,�,� �m,���a,� "� � � ��U��� �n,�,��� �.�����,��,�,�,w��,�,� � y����,,,u ���.��.,�. � �.,���,.. �� �.���,.� „ x,,.�� r����r
,��,��Y,�,,.
�:,,, ���, ��u,�nw�e �����„�
l�'et��-Ga����y 1 _">, � U 1 �
l l�:r-�� l;a��;��a����, ���7��:r����c7�.
�Ca���� c�l`it1�f�Gi�.
? 1 � T�1. "I i����i `�t.
It��ac�t. �1�r' ] 4i���)
�,��_�,: : �`�
L)ear Mi�TyI:>i����i��i�: ,.
� � �� ��. �;��h� ��"�
�[ r � i r��+
� � u , . , ::;,���,,
1 jlis� ����inta:� i�� t��}t� t� i�1t�r�7�r�t �c� ����ci a ���zc;k latil �;ir���t'� "fl�t��z�l� �`c�u., :t:crt� �pa�;�tl�it�� ��� ��wr�i��il
zz����717�r� t�i` G�1�.�1:) N��,-� �'"�.��-1�: C`l�is� 14 �vltict7 tiv�� ��•i�itccl Iil�ci��� YGtsti v„r�:�.�: fc��� t�t�t- [c�e�zl
�car��;r�t�tl��it °�+��;tiic�i�. G�ur clt��� �77c�t�1��l�s s��sc�l��; �r�r`y l���l�ly �al'il�t�i�' �a��etin�:;y w�'i11� lc����l 1cL�clet�s i�t
tl�i; Itl-�cl��:r �l�-c:��. '�'eaa:ir cc�i�v�;�����tit��ls �lel���;c� tl��r7� �c:� �t1dc:�-st���acl tl�� ��c�l�;s t1�at lcat;�al l�a��c;r-s �31�z��,
�I�e: c:�7�x1'l�a��=�� w4�u 1��r;�, ��t7cl kl�c: �3ttit•il���t�s tl���t I��lp nl��c 1c�crxl I���cll�rs s�a���;:�:�k`Gzl. �11����k }�c,�i f:c�i-
�7��p�����: �i� u�c��ai��� t����t ���.>ja;cti�,��;.
���e�il�, ��x����t��:c:i��t� yo��r c�14fii:�r�t� tc> 1�c, ��itl1 c7�u• �;➢<t�s ����,���l��a�5 iY�t�t ��I�i�;r�7c�c7n. I l�c�pa� �luia c;��je�y�:ci
���c�tiz�� c���c cl��s:� m1�en�hc��� ��� ���;�1— thc� �-i���r°�:;ci7t s4��7�c; cal�th� C,c:;t �����i l�ri�,l7i�tit ir� c�cu• ��c�cl
��i��i <:��,���ic�alta��•��I �x�ci�ast�-�,-, �mra�:i �I�e z�z:��<�l cc�xa�z���nL7itic�:� t�a�y� �z�•� ��Kla-t ��[�. I Ic�c7k Cc��-4����rc� tca tl-�e
pc�ssibi�i��,' c>l'•��c�r•�i�7� r�uifl� �c��� ���,�cx���. I1�xtiV ti��t�, 1��;�t �.��i�17�:,:; f��a• 4� �g�f�. ����c��,����lc;, wi��cl
pr�c�cl�7cti�r� �-�e��a• ���7�;�c1.
�i���e��ly°,
�"�k-,G .��"�s��.�. ��
t..aY`r`y V��a� �)�V��11�, P��➢�
I;�c:c�atiM c C.)ir��:tc7r, I�I;�I� Z�1���� Yc-�rk
�"����a�rlc����a• t�,�urp,tir 6�� — �1�i2 � 22(1 1�i7�k���r t�cl. � 1C6���e��s, i`4;c��s� 1''tr��l<. 1 ��'�7;?a—����CI�C � '14.°l���R(�oi7i.� (i4?i � ���+`ry i��ID&7'� � (�f� � (�d)i E "rrr,:l_'��°7(7
'�lc�w�:� `u't�� &k';��rl`�.° t "�°Il,°s'yt rrf ,��;r�ic�t�ltti�re^ �aa�dWl Ldit° `�t��t�r���.��, ��k C:ara�i7��11 I.Ji�ti^,�i�u��,itv
I�rli��.i /��'t���t� lJ>Mrtr�31�+.�7�'ti; �
p"�:1��9t�� Lf I:�;�'�)R:�` �P�� I�F?\�L�;1�U�.5 /�:t��_7 ��:I��:I�LU.�"I"tJ��.�:;:� C)�� ��'�1�i:IC:,?�.' I�I4t��? Ti�:�tJ1���:J�
(5e:ts I�ts�r�ecticans crt7 �ts�verst.:iide)
�c�� �/�/�� — �2/���/1�
d ..e..._ c��� C�am� Y .._... �
��A � �
i��,���r: e��fEn�i�����w.� S r� ue ����m�r & H' �a�� �7�a . �,
��
1 y���c: [� 7�'mre I�)����artr7rre;i7t � I�ira: C'�a�a ���n�� ❑�3c�ncur�l�.�1t hswr��iata�n
T�iY:� kns�ars�nce; fl7�F�c. f�n�e Ccrde #r �ifknru�vn)_ . �__,_ C�csta�tty^ �l��re fl,c,rc���ccH `�'��_ �? �M_,.._.
C�Il� �I1S
l�l��rrtc:� r�f��ire L7�,,trsct �,a F'ire I'rateclsan I)tstrm�i "V�Alicrr. L��c�tcil (Il`AF�raSicak�lc} C�. i.. C7f ��.�"ic�C �
��lciress: 1 � 4 C� �'rumans�aurc� �c� .
.� __ __m___ ��_________._ �_.__. __._---.._.__.. .
t;ity,�"cj�jrriF��illa�c:_. �� hc�z�ci ,�I�w 5'�z'k Zit' 1 4 8�i Q-1 3°� 4
nt.,r. �t.rr�s��r.:r�s rr�� r�r�s tz�r�c��t�r° r�t�:�T ��: F�c7tr�rrar.t� �rca �t� r��:�,tt�_4Tr� r7r��.i.,n�r
r'r�rce�r�r ,�r�<)t1r��'
7:3alancs:: AS C) �`C / 1/ 1 1 96%'8dY21 ............... �_ 1���31 , Qf�
R�v�nues: (I'l��asc: list i�r�rviduaAly�, if�}axa�ic�kalc:)
�°arc��;n Fire Cnsuraanc�
�t�er I�.evenues:.
Int:e�es�
�a��N
ntal �teverr�ses 1�i�'80�?.....
'I`�ti�i Bak'a�c� and Tzev�nwcs
�x�a�ndin�r�s;
�9�et�.ng M�a1s ;� 1 , 265. �0
:�
CQm�any �'�nctic��s 6� 8. �a
Han�rarium� 7�t�.�Q
,� 4, 843. f70
�
�
� 1 � '� . (7 (i
�
'i't�2;�1 Ex�acnditures 1 �P8�24_.e........._..
Ciasid�nee AS C) � 1 2/� 1 f 1 1 1 GP8n29 ...............
Aw��ds
T�ues
i�a sce:�l�na�as
� �,���.aa
� �C1 � 7�5. �CJ
_
� .. 11
� ��
1� 1t
� 3,�Q�.O(�
�; 1 �, 986. C1�
t��"t:�D
LCrt�� � C� T:� . G1�C�c7Ci �T�` . ccrtify tli��t tlzis re�o�t is Ks ts�rc arad accuratc
t_. .—_._..._.e_ _
. ._� .� _----
at,xtc.p77E�;r�t c�f thc reucrr�i�a�� �u§ ex�rtriitu:�e^��y cr('F��arci�;�ra Fire I�r��sa��a pret���iu�s�s ��r,tk�� Sssc�7 ycar cnc➢c:c�' t��C . 31 , � C� "� �
"' f/
/ �b � �f
C�I�Elr1i'LII'C�: � . %' � � �L �T�lr.'�t'"1, ' � . .
� "
,,-
,, , ____._...
�....L.._, -._.�_._.T.��.W_.. „_.....,.._.,___�____
q� fi�
�rl0.t�t:� r����'C�.w�Y. ����.
__� ......... ....._..�.
("�"e;➢cg�9rcraa�. tJurar�.�crj 6 l� 7�- 2 7 2 6 Z 3�
���ea�e rrr�r� r.�;�.�c}�-t �cr:
C)�'�acc o1�tk��: ���it�: �on�r�trc�l�e:��
T��t� Ivla��a�;c;��l�zit L�ni1 St l�..t�-C;
11�1 St�ttie; �1��a;t
,� il�any NY 1?23 �r-C1�C� l
r, �i fi� � �
M i X� � � � � �r. � . �' ` �
f�.Jw�. ��'�u?��',�..� ���",��.�V�,��'�'�Tu.T� ���� �� ����'���ir .. .�.,"� �uti.i�a�� ���...�t.� ..`'•."�.
� �� � 4.._ � �:�" f .
1`S�rGa� �i"�'s�tity: C°��cn r�"��- r�- C° �"' .� C'' r"✓��l ��,;�, o~� �,/ �
_��,
Ty�re: �'ir� �7epartna�nt �Fir� �ss���p��ay 13�s��;wo�ca�� .Asscsciatia
F"rre i)istrict i:C� f� �i�' ka�c��v�x} Ccauuty "�hcrc �,o�at�d � �':l . -�. 7 `' � ^ ,;�i F
�
t^�arn� 4f�'ir� �7ist�act ar F�r� T"c�rtectimn L)a�tr'rct'6�Ti��r� L�ca�ed (y�'Ap�li�al��e) ��9 ��,! ,�`+ �y .. ,,�:;� 1 c;s� ��.`�,,
�y , � __„ s
Adr�r�ss: /° �.� ,� �'.i ✓"'� 'j G.� ,:�-
��l�rwc�.: (�� af 1,+1P1 T�:.
lt�vcntacs: i^ar�i�n C°cr� Tx�sa.aranc� Pcem�ums�
5�ra�ce: (pl�as� list s��t�ky�
.. �, �� . �
;�" C:`�=�__�_r:� � a r� ..,L p~7� � `'� c�1` "'i�`' �' �%
�....�,W� � _�.„.� .,
�
Tn�r�sC r�t7 investtteent af �aa-�i� ric�:
� cat�l t�evecau�s:
"1"�r��P i�el�rrc� and &�.�vc�rrta��:
�xp�a�ditur�:
��I�,� t��d� �,�r �`��� a ^ ���"'� ���pc�
���.. a��� <�� � � �° r"� ri �'e � � ,�`�
� w�
�"���1 � ��� r �,���i c:a. r"B � � �." . r`i �' e:' X ~-
� � 'a�'t j�;��. r'r ^� , r.�, c: � �°� ��c. � �S
$
�r
� � _� �..... �. G:` �."a
�.�
� '� � ��' �x �,"?
� � �' ,��� �3 ��
�IP i �� ¢��.��� `- � x."�,..� �^�' �
.�?,.Mc���,iT
� �=�. �'�� ;�� � � � C��"�..)
� "��� :�' '�'� �;?� '' G' C-�.
� e� �'N. � � "_I M� C"J t�:�
-------r �
T�t�i E�p�xyc�civr�cs: � ,����� �a�'�'��w : �.��i
�alanc� ��s �af i�F3l'fl ] ) � c,� � "�' �`.S"'�y'" .- r'��'„�
__, ,, /
E ��. C���P s~"t �� C.'.. ��.. ��.', -^y �� c�r�ify th�tk ttais x�gacrct is �¢a~u� r;uzd �c�urmt� stat�m�nt nf`t�ue r�+renuc� an+� e �ita�r� �rf
Fc�r�agta Fnr� �n�as�nc� prerenirsna� fe�r the cal�nd�r y�aar �nd�s121� i 1.
(Si,gna�rar��:
("1'eEep}7catrc
d� F ';✓ �-- �� ,i' �',�' �-�-�
� �" ft�
.E'�Y.l'Y1,'l�G,ln�.ds� L4+.Lsl'�V'i!i.l.. LNA'1 I�.L' W@:eA19.,11"�e�� �17�l.P L"+t�w.��k.'Y�A, A 7J�'k.Cti7 V'�� �'&�;�A{aY�lY d' J.l'L,L:a ��AV�3��&"6a"�I'W&..i'+. l.��bif"�l�AA�.U�iTt��.F.7i
f:�ce �r��t�~�ctinns rrn ��wex�:�,� �a�c��) r'"",,,.
�'or~ tl��: cs�l�mu�l�a�r y���r Jssr�u�r'w� 1, 2�i 1- I}c�e�t�uta�ur� 3$,, 2�11'I �>�
�M �
.���, �
� � ;
�aM,�.,e�q�»�k3r.��: �rr� �tr.rrrt��t�����.��c�i�u�r�w�iD'f'G�'�° . � r� I.1.����a���. �+4�: Q �
4 •
• �
�+f��rn� ��f C.,�t�i ��. � '� ~ � � � � 7 � ` �� � ��� �> �
'�' •' r•e1")� art��Y c�.__�L�!�9'1....�: 1�.'�...Y.��wC��!�k�.�m� ��'�'�" k�~.., rr��+ �µ / ,,,
-- � ��.�� r,..�, � F
_ �
- �^ x � �
T' i�: l�isd.rau� �17 �d^ �ifiknowrX�_4:� �7� yC"� f��' ( ) r�---_��t�-��.(,�a nty 'rNl�er-� I,�cat�d ,...__.e � I.�.C�L__..1����[ � t /�ssuciai�it'rt� t�✓,f � � ,� �"���"�
�F�rra�� ti�9 1 �ru l�rstric� err T�dre T�r•a�ts:cticria t7w��ri�t "Wlr�rc ].,�r�„�t�:ci (1'fA lica lc _ �� ,/ .� � l ��,,,��,� __ , "�
�.Cl.�.0 _���'���-�_�.��'/Ca LC1C�., '.,s �,�. ' , . .._...___.....__ ___m__.. 7 ✓�
�� } �.����"�a �_ �:� t� ,� ✓ r�� �u�' `
r�������: _�' �, � ��r��� k� .,e
_ �_ .._ ____
{..9��"I��,��UW�'S�`�I�.�el�.'"C�•��.._ ^-��1 f'"� l. �� " �' p �...."
..w
�,... m._ _e . _ .________�.._.._� � ___.__�.__m. __._� �`_ x.a� ,......._ ���
���i��1�;: ��� �>s t���i,�:
�2a;w�;¢attu.s: t�ar�i��r I�dru Cnsuranc�. I'r�iniurns:
5c�uece� (pleaselist:�c:�s<ri��CulY)
1c�tcrest srsa i�zu�;simcnt �rC'I�crr°ee�rr I�ir�:
,�"�," -Cot�al l�cve;raucs:
°Cc�4ra! I�'�1�na;� aa.r7�i �ever�ues:
� xp�� °
a�j�tG�a���: -_ /
�.�'����d����,��1.�.�?���_ ������' � �"�p�,� � ��? � ��..M�.. �___�_
a
,P �__ 1
..�.. � .'.'> c�l f �,"�a �:� � f �"�, ���,�%�S" ��". �°r��?.. �� h �� < �
�
�_ �_�_____�� �___..._
� � � �. �: � .� � ��� �.� � � �.� �� ������,�, �W�z. < r1_�� ���., ... � �� � �� �� �.�_
.i.r,�i�tl iix��rotr.r��it����a���:
13�s�€�a�e� (srs at� � 2�13 tf 11 j
�,�c��r�r
� �'',2.. a �.���
� � � ��
�* � _ ..� .
� �� �"�
,�- � tl
� ��'� �� �3 _._
$ �l G �f � C.J
f r /�
I �``� A�'�(.;��✓7 �-- � r"��"��d`ti �/r'�. ccrCA1'y tl�al t9ai�; ��c�c�c-a is a cav�: �ns� a�c�c��,•s�t� y�s�tc�ris;zit caf'tl��; rc;ven�m�;s trca�l c:x���tzaiitt��•us cyt'
]ynrei��r ��tm� irrsu �rrcc p��miuYns ferr khc; uatlen��t��� yu��rcmc�ec� 2a1 t..
(Si r:atr��-r; :..__�r_�-9� �r'] ' � , �`� ���✓�'�.. �'��� `�' �'_ � . .
/ �r
� � �'_::�� )_.. _..-- ------ _ i.9.atic) i �'� �z,% fi°��� �..
,� � „a ,�° s ...y �/
('l�ele;�k�c�at� Ntsiv�[�c.c`)...__ �..m " ��'R��_ G?;r�_.�..� .__.._.__,. ._..,_,.,_,.,._ _..,....._.,_. __ .�.�
����s� �;� �i� f�� €��° . ��� �c� c��� �c�: ���µ���`kt�C��j�����µ,t�����;�.r��,����
�'��: ��.�-4�6-�14�a
i�Cfi�� m�tl-�� 5��tc C:;c���tr��l�r
T�ivisi�� r��'Lc��.�l C:,c�v�ru�r����t ar�r� �ic}xe��1 Acc���u��t;�k�ili�y
�ata 3�[��a��n�ea�t �.6�w1, 1 �-�-G
1 I tl �tatt St.
�14aai�y �i`r` 12,23G-�Q4�(11
"I eleph��a�: 51 �-�"i4�4fa 1 �
:�/��/,�-
�
� %
i i - �� , , � ", , ��
� � s � / � � �� �_
.
�/ i i � i r i�.� �:�
� , � , J � � � �/
� � ,
11 1 ' /
/ / I •'V // �' !
! � ��� , i / � i - i �► i
/
� i/i�� , � I �` /� ,� /
� d' / !' �' � � ,% '� '% . .� / / /
� � r � � � � � !� �
. �� � ` �
�� . �,,, � /�
► /' / 1 / ` ,
,,� ; / �� �
� � I � ' ,' . �
/' � / /' , / �./ !' i� / ,/. ' � /
► � '/ i �' � �
, � . ♦
� . i �� � �i��i � / ! � �
� �" / / �� �
',// � I�;� i , /
.•
/ �� �
,� � �
�
0
�
N�� ERIC LEVINE
674 CODDINGTaN RDAD
ITHACA, N�J YORK LL1850
DEAR MR� LEVINE;
CREETINGS AND SALUTATIQNS�
Nl�CH 18, 2012
1028 ELLIS H4LLOW ROAD APTS, 208
ITHACA, �iE4�f YORK Ltl$50
�
I WAM' TO APOLOGIZE AGAIN FOR DISTURBING YOI�R HOUSEHOI.D AT
NIGHT, A LITTl.E WHILE AGO� I REGRET IT� A COf�INATION QF GRADUATE
WORK AND PRAYER SOMEi'IMES LEAVES ME LESS THAN AWARE OF THE
CLOCK� PLFASE TElL YOUR WIFE FOR ME, WILL YOU? THANKS�
�,"`� _ _
LISTEN. THE ITNACA OFFICE OF THE F,B.I� HAS NO LEGAL OPINION�
NO OBJECTION,TO PUTCII�G A GLASS aF HYDROFRACKING LIQUTA ON
A TCNJN BOARD OR ANY OTHER TABLE AIVD LOOKI NG AT IT �
I THINK THAT IF FOLKS COULD RUN Tl-IIS SUBSTANCE BY 'fHEIR PRESENT AWARENES:
OF THEIR MEDICAL CQNDITiONS� THEY WOULD PROBABLY HAVE A GOOD
IDEA WHAT WOULD HAPPEN. ONE CAN SMELL IT, RUN A DROP PAST THE TQi�iGt1E,
PUT A LITTLE ON THE SKIN RE: ALLERGIES- YOU IWOW, IT NEmN'T.
BE A BIG DEAL� I WOI�LD LIKE TO (3IVE THIS TO YOU TO FURTHER�
I AM VERY BUSY RIGHT Nfl4V. AND I DON'T FEEL INSPIRED ABOUT
THIS. MY METHOD AS A TEACHER IS TO FIND THE GUY I THINK WIl1 HAVE
7HE INSIDE TOUCH ABOUT THINGS, YOU IWOW. THE RIGHT APPROACH�
THAT SEEMS TO DO THE TRICK.
IT OCCURED TO ME Tf-!AT YOU MIGHT WAM' TO SllGGEST SCQOPING �UT DECLI-
VITIES, LITfLE Fi�LES, IN THE SUBROCK F�R THE BEPOSIT Q�' THE
FRACKING LIQUID� IT CQULD JUST SIT THERE UNTIL SOMEONE GOT
�..\ A GQOD IDEA ABaUT I T� I' M SURE THAT TODAY' S BLAST I PdG TECF�pV I QUES
WOULD BE UP TO IT.
2
I WOULD LIKE TO STATE THAT SOME OF THESE IDE4S COME TO
YOU COUSRTESY OF THE LQRD, WHO HAS HAD INPUT INTO THESE CONSIDERATIONS,
AND OF THE PRODIlCT OF THE STUDY OF THE CULTIIRAL ANTHROPQL.OGIST
DR, CARLOS CASTENF�A. ALSO� THERE HAS BEEN IP�PUT IXTENSIVELY
FROM THE SPIRIT, ALSO CALLm, IF THIS IS CORRECT, THE HOLY
SPIRIT� I CALL TNEM CREW�
TEiA�'VK YIX! FOR YOU EFFaRT� GOOD LUCK�
SUSAN BEELER�
�,\
-,�
��
�—. � _
,
_�,
;
� /.'
(
�
!�. ____,�
�
�1
Page� of �
2 Z
Paulette Terwilliger
� From: Eric Levine [elevinetown@gmail.com]
Sent: Friday, March 23, 2012 9:24 AM
To: Paulette Terwilliger
Cc: Herb Engman; Bill Goodman; PLearyContact; RDepaoloContact; THunterContact;
NHorwitzContact
n
n
Subject: Letter fram Susan Beeler
Attachments: beeler.pdf
Paulette,
Attached please find correspondence from a resident named Susan Beeler.
To provide some context, around early November she called my house about 10 times. I listened
to her at length a few times, mainly about Hydrofracking. Other times my wife took messages or
she left several long messages in a row on my answering machine. Mainly about a need to
investigate hydrofracking fluid. To be clear about what she wanted, I asked her to write a letter.
I do not believe I heard from her again, but I did receive the attached letter in the mail yesterday.
Eric
Eric S. Levine, Esq.
Councilperson; Town of Ithaca
215 North Tioga Street
Ithaca, New York 14850
3/23/2012
CARL F. FORD, P.E.
REGIONAL DIRECTOR
Ms. Paulette Terwilliger
Town Clerk, Town of Ithaca
215 North Tioga Street
Ithaca, New York 14850
Dear Ms. Terwilliger:
STATE OF NEW YDRK
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
REGIDN 3
333 EAST WASHINGTON STREET
SYRACUSE, NY 132U2
www.dot.ny.gov
JOAN MCDONALD
COMMISSIONER
March 21, 2012
RE: REQUEST FOR LOWER SPEED
LIMIT ON NDD FALLS ROAD
� Thank you for yow March 14 letter and getition requesting a lower speed limit on Judd Fa11s
Road beteen Plantatioa Roadand Forest Home Drive.
A formal investigation will be conducted at the subject location. Please be aware that our review
requires sufficient field investigation and analysis to assure a proper response. Upon completion of the
investigatioq you will be notified of the results and our determination.
To carry out the Deparhnent's initiative to be more responsive to our customers, we encourage
you to submit any information which may be helpful in our investigation. This may include petitions,
letters from the public, accident ciata, maps, etc. This informa.tion should be submitted to my office at the
above address.
We request that you use the revised TE 9a form (attaclted) for future speed limit requests on local
(Town and County) highways. Tite only change is elimination of "Gentlemen:" from the salutation.
�our interest in this ma.tter is �reatly appre�iated.
Very truly yours,
�(��`.G2�'�'c� p`t''- ..i��I/
DIANA L. GRASER, P. E.
Regional Traffic Engineer
�''� Attachment
cc: C. Nelson, Interim Highway Manager, Tompkins County Highway Division
H. J. Engman, Supervisor, Town of Ithaca
P. C. Stein, County Legislator, District 11
����������� ���'����� � �������� ����������
1 i� �'ast7�rick Fia�cl, Itl��.c�„ f�Y �E ��5�
co�-���-���a
��x ���-���-����
N�ai�c1� 1 �, 2(� 1 "?
t���tr7t�a C�. �irKis�a', I'�
I�Y�I:)��C..
'I'ra�7s}}ariali�a� �}�stcr�� (���ci-cttio��s Eia�r:��cc�'
333 I�ast i�lielsl�ia���r��� Sti-cet
��,rl"ekG1lS1�", ��Y� ]. 77{�'7
�2c;: ����;e�i LirlLit ��eciuest
I�ca�: �w1s. Cir���sr��',
����� '.N �:� ����
��y a�:: !�:.��.����,
l'I�u�s� ���ci �a�c:l�as�:,cl r� r•�c{.�zcsi fc�r � t�eci�cce�.� s��c�c:r:1 li���iti c��� ,P��c1il fj��ll� ��c7��c1, i�i t11�
l-iaii�li;t cal� lyc�rest I-Ic�n��, in t11c r1��v�7 c��' Ifl�trc�t. �l�h� �z����t�c�����i��tu �1'l�' �)a G�atc1 I�escal��ti�i7
,��,,,, ����c� s�rl�at��ittc;ci �aaa� y��:�r r��Fi��v ���ci acti�ail.
E�l���sc ���a �ac�� Ia�sit��te Ca cozltact ���e, at (Ci(�7� 27�WC��()f), il� [�.<�c� assi�t ��irtl��r ���
�'�'1i,1,1" Cj�,1:t;1"i171a1�1f1�11.
��l�l�,�:1`f���°, �� ,
i ,r�_"��� �� �/',' �„ ,rd� �
f k ,�'P r��«�,.r';y,F`�� /"°� � ��.,�� °Y�� �'-,.��. „.,,
�,,� '�-4 � C .
r�
�.,�1C4"�� � �SCll�li
Ia1t�;�°i�n 1-li��ti�v�.�y 1�r14rt�i���;r
Iv;�ac��s���-cs
�,,,�� cc �,��/t� r;cl�;lc�sui��s
I'a�al�fit� Ta;r�viili�er, itfi�xc�� "I,c��v�� C.lc�i-l�
�� ��, �r�Gy�r�� ����r
����,�1���� � � ��°� �
� ��„����,���
��� ' � ����� � �@�� �� ��
Ipn�puuW�ro � �.,� N6'�� IW ���� ,
TV"�3T'C}1 �3.,?f}l�
Su�a�rvvs��r-1 C�a�f�c�Y-� I=;n�rn�in
"I"c�wn c�1'I�11�tca, I�PY
2l5 ?�lcartll �I"ic���z �tr��;t
It��ac�, N�'" 'I �$�5Q)
�e: I`ir�tc� Wurrze�• Ccat�fe Ir�ternat Restr�ec•tar�-in�,,
C)e�r Saa�aervisr��• I:sr��r�����:
t�7r7� wl-itixi� tca �c�vise; y�c�u c�#"at� Ns�t�t•��al z�estt•a�ctu�•ia�� k�y "l�in�� "�v"ar���t�r C;��h1G Ir��;. (""�"WC") inwolv��� ti7�
c2�l�lc Ii'a��ck�is�c in yt��tr �r]mi�r�tinity. ,As yatt ai�ay �n�w, k-v� t�}�t'i•at� t���t' c���1�;, �yStGn�s il�tr�iaa�,�}� v�t�ic�us
i�lc�ircGt, rullc�lly-c�}��r�rec� saa�isi:diaries, ir�c;lu�in� `I`oo�l� W��rr�ea• 6;a�t�E�t��in'��e:r�t-11c�uar��e,/i�e�E�o��se
Pa►•tr���sl���, tl�c ���•a��chise-B���la�c�• f'ar tt�e s�ste�7� s��•v�ir��; ye,��r cc�emr��rianit}�. Ie� o�•c����� tc, �strcan�l�r�e aur
c�r�anizati�a�7, �vc s�rc a�n�c�-t��kir�� a�i intcrr��l rcai-�ani���tica�� (tl7e: "'C'�-�t����ctit�n") v,�kacrcby. our e�ble
r��a�.a-�tiot�s r✓rFill 1��: c����eli��cta,c� �l�r�aa�ll� s�ven re�ic�nal c,ntities r���i,�;�teci tra sirro�plifjr on�ra��eme��t rep�artir��,�
ar�d ca-e��te. � an��i�� �c�7���z}�}�ically ��atir��nal s�1-uc�tur�:�. IJpc��� c;c�r��p�l�;t�i�i� c��'tB�c; ��I��.raa��acti���, tB�e ]c�ca➢ s�xst�.n�a
�r�d frar�ck�is� s��•vit��, yjc�ur carnir��anit}r will b� l��;Ec� t�v "1"im� "�v"a�-r7e;a° C'ahlc 1`»��7rtlle:ast �.I.�, an it�dir�c�,
wh�lly-E�w�r��ci 5���l��iciiE�ry e��"�i`VV`C.
,������, ��Ml� "I�r���i�:,z��;ti�ea w��il� ��c�� resu1t ir� a tr•ansfer a�'c�c�nt�-c�l .-. "I��.�w`G will �-�t�ir� �tltira���t� a�W���;�r�}�ip ar��
rt7��r1a��;�����r�t� a�tt9��urrity �v��• tk�e c�bl�e syst�t� itq }�c�ta�• c��r�t7��t�r�ity. "1��"h�s intea_�nal "�'r�a���action wi19 k��ve
a��c�l�tle.ly rtc� i��p�t��t c�e� the c�l�➢e s��t�Tn rn your cr�r�-�r����nity, it� �����r•atic�r�s c�r ���a�• lt�c�1 5ta�� Qr
n�a�ia��;ment, anc{ �«��e iuoll cc����:in��e tc� do L�u�ine5s a5 "l�it��: W��r��rer C;at�l�;. In �aai-lic��lar, tB�e�4e ruill be no
c6��t��t; i�� e���r �:urn�ni��t�ent t4� �rc�vitl� �aur custornex•s +�vith tfye bc;st r���ri�;ty ��crc� c�uaality i�� ert�te��laii�n�ent and
infc�rri�aticro sc;rwic�s, ta11 clt cc�rn��etitive rates �vitl� c;�.celler�t cw��;t��i���:a- c�ir��. 1`��trur�iBl}�, Titne Warr�er C�&alc
Nr�rt6�ef�st t.,l..G wvill cc�r�ti�7ue tc� cc�a-�ply w�th �ll tra�icl�is� tc°eJ7�s �ro�r� cc�t�c�iticans aa�r� l�� suhjec:t tca all
�a��lic�alalt; q��4v.
'C�'(1c� "1�.r��►�;��cti<7�r dr�e:s� ncrt rer��aire ar�y ����ia�7 c���► ���sr p��-t�. Si7c�ulcl y��L� I��vc�� �c�y c�ue:�tic�ns r���rding �1��c
"�Nwa��sa�;tic�r�, }alc:d�s� cc�a�t��t Nn� a:t ro�My.wl�eEan('u�t���ca��le;.��7�n �ar S t�-f�4()-�Sl��,
We G�r�,�k f'car���ara� t��r ca�ntix�a�iru� �r���• lo��� a��d ��autuaVla bc����:�i��ic:i�1 r�l�t�ic�nslli��� wvitl7 y���a� cr���r���u7��ty.
�in�;crc:�ly,
�'ST41I�'��d��lti�i�:lt C:'�13t.�; F*GC'.
����. ��.�
. ..�-
I�e,�-y Wl�cl��n
li��;ic�nal `v'ic� f'r-�5'rcl�rnt
„nure�.mm.,
F'�t�� � �i� 2
P'��M�fit� T�rvuil�ig�r
_. _ _
����v�„
Franrm: H�rb �ragm�n
fier�t» Tuesday, Yvl�rch �7„ �C�12 8:5Ci AI"��
i"o: Pau��tte Te�vwiiliger
�u�j+�ct: FW; I���r.�ngman
Hert�ert �. �nc�rr����
�ca�n ��p�rviscar
�"awn cai 8th�ca
2%� Nar#h �'icaga atr��t
lih�ca, '�+1�` fi4E�5�1
(6�J7"j 2i3-� 7�1 f�x�. 12�
Fro�rr�. n�a�anc� phway [�a'r�dta:m�u�g���ya�a�o-.cc�m]
Ser�t: �larud�y, March 2:6, 201� 1�:�4 PM
i'�: N�rb En�rr7�n
Sub�e�lk: �e� I�ear.Eng�nar�
I tl�ank yo�u frr yaur re�pc�r�d. I�ir�d �f I�rr�w th� f�ndin� wauld be ihe pr�blem. q kc�o�w
a�c�u� E�Ouae�ras� I��n�, not t�o �rrany peapl� waGk �r r��n th�t vr�ay. B�rt I hr�pe in th� future
tt�a� �� as in cc�rr�r��un�ty c�n b�ild e�p th� s�d� waPk an �Nar��n F�d ta�r�rd ��rm��ll.
N thar�k ycru again f�ar yaur inforrrratac�r�.
������r�,.
�Kaaaro�: �lerb �c�c�m�n rHEngra�a��town.ithaca,r�y.usa
70: maung phway cm�ung45�yahcro.corn>
Cc: F��ulette �`��wi9li�er eP�"erwilligerQ#ow�,ithac�.�y.u��
�ent: �Ilar�day„ I�larch ��, �01 � �:Q4 AM
S�a�ject: RC: f���ar.�ngm�r��
C�e�r C�fl��a��rc� f�hw�y:
I st��r�� y�aur c�rc�cerra �t�aud the lack esf a sid�w��k 1'�'car�a �ar�r�����+ ��a�rg i�d'a�re� to C�rnell. I also liwe �ar7
��rrer� f�c��e:� �.r�d r��l� �r�cl run ti�er� every vw���. �'� h��+e ��anned �.i� off-ra�d v<+�Ikw��,y frc�r� N����sk���r
alo�g Blue�r�ss f��n� (� ��rnell farr� ra��� t� I��s&�r��a�4� ���rt�ner�ts, l�ut we hav� nat �o�r7� kl�ae �ur�c�s �c�
budCd i�. Tt7� T�+�rr� �rf Ithac� can r��t r�is� en�rugr� g� ��xe� tc> �.r�aild sic�e�^ralks e�n it� owwnr r�r� als� r7e�d
�a�,risic�� s�ur��s. Th� s��lewalk alc�r�g `�l�rr�a� �raa�r� N�ra�l��w tcr th� Tcr^�r� lin� c�c��t �Irr��st � I��f� r°nilli�ar�
cloll�rs. It u��� u��u�u�liy �xpensiv� beca�se iC ha� a per°r���k�6� surface, �ut �ve� the sia�lpl��t �walk�r�y i�
�cr�Cl}/.
TI'u�r�k yc��i expr�ss�rt� yr�ur s�.r�apart faar a sici�vv�lk. !�� vviN� c�ar�ki�ta� ica s��k ��si�c�An� t� buil�i �.�r��..
H�rk� �r7�rr��r�
hf�rl��r� J. �r��rn�r�r
1C'�+nrn ����r�rviscar
Tc��rr� �,f Ith�c�
215 V�caril� Ti€��� �1r�c�t.
Itt��c;�a„ (��IY� 1���3��1
��a�� ���-� ��� �x�. � ��
„�s���„
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _
Fr��ra: ���a�r�g �hvw�y [mailta;r���n��5�y�l7�rr�,��a��r��'
��ntn G�lancl'ay, f��r�h 26, 2�12 11:45 �1N1
1"�. I�I�p'b Er�c�rn�r�
�3/'? �3i�f)1')
_ t Page 2 of 2
Subject: Dear.Engman
Dear, Herb Engman
My name is Maung Phway. I am from Town of Ithaca , NY . I live on Warren Road . I am writing
this letter to let you know that the street that I live in does not have a sidewalk. Some how
there is a new sidewalk starting from the intersection of Warren road and Hanshaw going
toward rout 13. But if you go to Cornell from the intersection of Warren Road and Hanshaw
there is no sidewalk. I see a lot of people walking all the time to Cornell and up toward the
Hanshaw. When I see the people walking on the side of the road, where there is no sidewalk, I
get worry and it seem like is not safe and I personally think that we should have a sidewalk
Warren Road that going to toward Cornell. I am concem about the side walk on Warren Road
because that is where I live and I myself also walk on that road. I seen how people drive. I do
concem about my safety and other people safety.
Sincerely: ^
Maung Phway
�"1
3/28/2012
�r ..
� . � � ���' . .
21 � P'�'�. Tlt��� �tr��ir Ith���, C`�.�Y'. 14�3 aCe
L'v'W W.4�C�VV11.i1�1i�C�1.1i�.8.1�
Tpw,�,rn Sup��r�v�sar (G�37) 2�73•17�1, Ext 125 �&-iG=rro�r�� �o�`�?aP�caw�rr iiVira�°���.g�y ai��� �
T�wrv ��,��r< �sca�� ��:�-�,�1 r�uguc wca��s �soa� ���-�s�s �r��ira���irvc (�a�� z��-1a��
����r�r�A�� C�a�� 2��-1�a� zc�r�ir�� (so�� 2a�-17s�
EA�X (6Q7) �7�-17Q4
�rt1'C�] ��), ��� � �
���Y�-�r A�1�� ��a��t�x��.
Su.a�����ai�;c:�r, "T'c����� c�d' Lryc�cr�.
�� 9::at5t N1��i1� �aCrc�;t
I7ry���i1, T�`r' 1 �faS3
�����r ut�l�ic�y ,�t�aa:
"4�Jil:l�c:���l 4� ����.�;ti��� 1c� eliaa����5 tl�� iss��� c7f thc: use c�fY �l�c Towr� c.��` �lh�r��� scw�r 1i�7e;� t.�7
�r•ar�s��7it'l,c�vvia c:�l� I:)r�c:l�.o� s�wr:��c: ���ic� ���c��a�� �zi1y fu.artll��• �i�r��� frc��r� at��'Iryuw�1 c�i' C��°yck���,
1�i���Fc� u4�.ci t11s� ir�1'c��°i7�4tti��1 aC r��y cii�}7s.����� tc� c������c �l�e �ttacl�c:ci t�ill�t��.
�s yc��i cd��� �c:�: l�y �i�►� i�a�c;�c�5c��i e--r���bil ts�reji�, I lx�ave l�eet� tryim� t�a ��c�c�lve tt�i� r���xtt�er °�i��c��
etC 1�:t��C �'''������:�f, '�(�&C).
i']c�rrs� i-����ia. �a�iyi�r��til. ��rit.17i�1 I'i�t�ty-1�iuc� �1�ty;�. �ftc:�- �a��5t �a}r����l�l is t'c;�civc:,cl l wc�t�lci lil��.
t�� t71c:�t �c� E1a�;i:Lrh� '�?(.)1 �� i�t���;;.
�iia�c� ly,
�� �s � �
� �� �
. . , �� � �� ..�.Wa�.
��' I �;�•��a;rt ,P. E;��,�,z������ ,,
"q'�:>�,���a St����et�vu�;c���- ��
� � ��� � � ���� �
�15 �J. Ti�ga �tr��t, Ithaca, �J.�". 14�5�i
www.t�>wn.itI��Ga.ny.l:xs
'9"+awn S�pervis�r �6(i�7) �73-172�'4, Fxt 125 N-GF'r��cw� a���� �a��wr9 k�N��a���.i,�y �p;s�
TC.iWhJ C��RK �6d7� 273-172� PllBLIC'�dONKS (�4i7j 2'73-165G ENGINE�f�INC (C�CD7� 273-1747
��_.ar�r�A�� (�r�r� �r�-������ z���an��� �sa�� 2, a-��sa
�=,�x ��a, ) 27�-1 �oa
� .� � � � . . � .. �i ��. rw . w„ ! . . r � . � '�, � M . � � r r � a
BeCaw �s s�mm�riz�d th;e b�blinr� fic�r �ise af the Tc�v�rr� c�f Ithaca s�vuer� lines far
carrvey�e�ce of T'�wru �af C�ryden s�vvag� to treatmer�t pl'ants.
�rr der Hill Raac� P"er� rine �Ioll�w ��wer Distri��
17 �nits � 2�Q g�aQk�r�r�/day (es�imat�c�� �C 365 day� � 1,241,0�0 gallc�w�s/yr
1,�41,�Q0 gal �ivided I�y 1�O,a�l� = 1',�.41
12.41 � $�CJ110C1,OG�� �al = $744�,�C1ly�
�744.��J/yr X 15 y�ars �1996-�411 � - $11,16�
��1 � rate adj�sted' �c�r ir�fiatic�n ��511 C��,00� g�l = ��055
TC)TAL �12,2�4
���,�,,
�apsucker'�ao�'s �oad
First year 45 �uni�s � �� �lur�it =
E#�
45 units ���7� gaA/day (estir��:te�� X�55 day�s = 32,85�,C�C�� �alJyr
32,���7,�(7(� g�) duvi��d by i�G�,OC10 = 32.�5
�2.85 X �6� _ �19i�/yr
$19711yr � 3� years = �6�,�7�.
�a� 2 r�.te adju�stec�' fc�r inflatiar� �8� X 32.8� = 2�9�
T�T�L $65,864�
'"' � � ` '� *r 1�:
>��,��,,,
,. '
��.., `
,�������
�'rc��rn: f�ary ,Ann Surr�r�er [su��rviscarC�dryd�n.r�y.us)
a�r�t: FricCay, M�rcl� �9, 2t712 6:�6 P�PN
�Pa: H'�rb �ngmap�
Subj�ct: FiE: dryden sew�r a�reernents
m,��w�,,
Y�t�� � �71 �,`"
�-n �
,..,� �
� f��a�d ote, �1�� C���� ��a����� l���t�a°. �'c�ll, �°ar�c�18�� � ��sr�t������ ��°��r �����a�e� ���� �+�r�
c�"� ���fi ry�h��� ���-� i°� �� ��.
. ,.
�rrc�rn. �ierb Engman [rr�ailto:�l��gman�te�wn.itt�aca.my.us]
S�r�t: NVanday, March 05, 201� 3;33 6�M
Tca: Mary An�� Sumn�r
�ubj�r.�: �1N: drydea� sew�r agr°een�en�s
f-9i„ fUO�ry Anri. Nca�u t17at e�ec�iat�s �nc� the I�:wsust are, over f��° th� tir�7� beir�g, @�ca�t tcr �ur��e t17e setive�
line� u�se i�su�. It i� clasing �� or7 twc� y�ars si�r�� I��.u��ci �his issci�, �c� uw� neec� �� c�ne�t. ,Alt�rn�t�v���, I
���� j�as� ���d a bill ta� yq�a. I�I�a�� C�t rr�� kne�v+� sarc7� rJ�te� r�rl�a�� yc��.a ar� f'r�� sr �c� c�r� �et this �es�lue�.
I�9ar7y tl�;�nks.
��
�i��'faer� ,�. Ee�gi�arr
Town Su�a�rviscar
Tr�u�r� crf Ith�ca
��� �Vartl� Tiag� �treet
btfr���„ (�Y 14.��C�
��c��)� ���-� a�� ��t. 12�
�ra�nn. �la,�y An� S�arnner [c��ilt�:sup�rv��ar�dryd�r�.ny.�sJ
!�er�t: N9ao���y, Maccf� i4, 2011 3:2�1 P�1
i�a. hC�rb Engrr�ar�
�ubject: f�E: dryd�r� sewe�- �gr�em�n�
R�c�r�t�y retired frc�m T 4� M'�ill�r. 94nows rrrore abaut our wat�r �r�c9 �evw�r th�n �nyt�ne else.
aei�t fr�am rr�y �'Jfndaws Mabile phc�n�
�rc�rrd: He�L� Er�gman �H�rug�nai� c�, �awvi�.ith�c�.ny.us>
,�uen�. Mc�ncla�, �t�rch 1�, 2(��.1 9:�4 AP�1
�'�a; �'lary Ar�n 5urrrner �sl��ervis�i°�d�der�.ny.u�>
��������: ��, d�yd�n sew�r agr��r��nts
�'U'I��� is I���vr� �c.a�n�i��
6-i���l�
,,��,m, pw.1����a�r� ,.9. Er7�m�n
Tnw�rr� ��.w��erarisar'
�"��,rr� c�� ItP��.c�
:�/2�;�J'��) l "�
l'a�� '? ��1 i
��'� �Jar-fh Ti�ga �1r��t
Vtl��c�, t�Y 1485C�
(�CS�7�� ���-1721 Ext. i ��
_. _ _ ����M,
�r+�m: NEary Anr� Surnm�r [r�rail�a:superuisar@dr�rd���.ny.us]
��I"1�: �t'I�d'�, �af"Ch, �. ir �Ld �. � �. �� ��'0'�
�tA; ��►'�i ��1�111��1
�ub�+��t: RE: dryd'en s�wer �gre�rr�en�s
�I����l;�l� i5„ I'v� I�ast r���r �7�����s. l I°���1 ����cc �r�a>�r�r i��r°�a���� C����� ��atr��rr�. 11"e���� 9cacr@�ir�� fr�r it. If I c��m7°�� ��i��c� it: r���x�t
�w��E<, I°II t�l� �� G����,r� ���;�i�7.
��rmrt�: H�rb Engm�n [r�raiBtQ:H�r�g,�nan�t�awn.itf�ac�.��y.us]
Ser�t: `Wec�r�e5day, ]��r�u�ry �.2, 20i1 9��4 AM
it�: Mary e4r�n Sumner
�'ubject: F'�/�l: dryder� sew�r° agr�ernerrts
Ua�ci rr�arnirug, f'��ry �,r�K�. 8�m fc,llo��r�g up ar-� tl�� sew�r �greemer�ts I r-n��7tic�n��i �tia yau I�st ��9N. Can yc�u
sur��est sc�rr�� �l�te� iPi tr�e r�ext cc�upa'e af �+�ek� wh�c� we cs�u�d r�re�Q ��uc� �rir���r� nc�tes'? '4�Ue s�rr�u��i r�ak� ��ar�
vw� h�ave tl�� sar�e fi��ts. E-I�v� yr� �e�� ��[e tcr find � e�rpy of the ag,reer7l�rrt ir¢an� 19i8 can����-r�u�g i�r�
aa�a�ucke�° ��rods are� d�ve�c��r��nt? �h�nk�.
�d��ka
H�rL�er-t J. �ngt����
�a�r� .�u��rvasc�r
Tt�vwru c�� Ith�ca
�15 N'�rrth Tiog� St�'��t
I�h�.c�, �lY 14�3 ac�
��e��� ���-� ��� �x�. � ��
�ram: Herb Engtt�a�n
,��n�: Tuesday, Septelnber 28, 2��Q 4.35 PM
T`ca: °I�ryden Su��rviscan•�
�ubje+��: �E: cEryt�en sew�r ac�ceem�nts
�hnr�k� ��ar g�tti€�� baca� �cs a��, f�ar�r a�r��, �r7� �x,tu�4wcar� r�as �up°viv��% � f�w� c�����c��s„ � �e� ��err�e �re�ks u�ra��'t
o��tt�r.
�i e a�b
k-#�r��rk J'. Cnc�r�n�r�r
�iYc�vw+�t �u��rvisor�
ia�vr�� c�t It6°raca
2� .5 f�c�rC�7 Ta�g� �'tr��t
li'���a�;�, NY 1'��50
���r� ���-���� ��t. ���
�'rtart�: C7ryder� Su��rv#soa° [r���i�t�:superviss�r(c�dr��i���.e�y.us]
��r�t; Tu�s�P�y, 5e�ate���b�� ��, ?�l� 1�?:17 PP�
�'ca; �ier�� En�rnan
�w�L�j���: f��: ciry�i��� s�vu�r ac�r•e�in�n,ts
&�-���r`���
:;l?1:�f`7i�&?
�'��;�; ��c�i ��
��� ���".
h"r�'�� �u��'�0<g�°����� ir�u��c� i��t�. �a����� o��°ut�z �a �:�����-�It� i��c���� �r����@<s.
�+�„, �G�J�`"��' .�`��,�Jrfi�
�,
Frc��: H��-� Er�grr7au� [rn�ilt€a:6'�EngrnanC���wn,ith��ca.r�y.us]
Se�rt: M�r�day, �uga�st ��, ��110 3:�3 PGu1
i'�: Dryc��r� Sup�rvisa�
�ubj�ct: FI�I: dryden sewtirer �gr��r�ents
�"I�ry Ar�r�, R a��d' r�en�ion�cJ t� y€au� t�ra� �h��-� a�� sorr�e la�se ���c�s ta th� sc��r�r ����er���ts ta�tr���r� tY�� Tc��vras
�+� �m�ra�e� �r7c� lthac�. Ther� �r� a nurnb�r caf re�id�nc�� in ihe -C"avu�r �f N�ryder� th��� h�ve th��r s��r��� ��u��d
thr�rugh fc�w�r� �af Nthac� s���r �m�7es rr�ostly t� i�7e '��ql�.�e ca� ��:yu�a �leights �r�ati��rrot pl�rlt. As y�r� c�n ��� i�
c�n� �� tih� �t���x7mer�t�, {a�.yt���r�ts v�r�re to h��e i��er� rnacl� tt� t��� T�a�r� e,i Ith�cc�„ b�t have n�t be�r�. Th� a�tC�er
�tt�ch�n�c�i �r�di��t�s an intenti�ar� i� s�i u� �.n�t�r�r �c�r�ement, buf th�u� v�as n�v�r dca��, f+�?ill s�r��4 i� a separat�
�-mail �r°7 �tda�h¢ment +�iii��� is ��r�i �af tf�� r��;�n� cs�unty-�ide ��w�r�� �r�� vv�t�r sia.idy �vhich inrJic�t�s C�ryderi's
r���rall us� �af 9tl��c�'s 1i�1�.5s.
1°�cr�al'ci I"r�e taa s�� u� � rr7��kir7�, ��rhap� �dtR� ycau�r staff ���d �nG�re, ta� ���c�ss ir�far�rnat��rr �re I��t�� migl�t �av� ��tc�
t� det�rrr�irte next �t�eps. 'U'aPl���, r�i�k�t that I�� perssi�i�e far yo��'� � I��,k f�au�a�rc� tc� w�ar&�ing au� this i�s�a� �itk� yc��a.
f�erb
Herk��r� ,J. �n��n�n
T(7�4`Ei �ll�i�P"Vl�CJi
Tar�r� caf I'thac�
�15 �Ic�r�k� Tic�c�� St��e�t.
Ithac�, I�Y i 4�5p
�ea�} ���--� ��� ��t. � ��
�.���,�.
_ _. _ _. _ __ .. __ . _ . .._
Frc�m: neb�a DeAuc�istir�e
��nt: T�esd�y, July 20, �O1C� 8:32 AM
"To: F�erEr Er�grr��n
�ark,wj�c�. dryden sewer agreemer�ts
�--Ierb,
�ler� t�ey ar�.
3/2�1��) 7 �
V
V
�
A
W
H
�
v 3 �,�v� o
t�. v� ca Q aJ ta. ,y� i
� � f-� u � W � LI '�
•b ¢1 �. �" +-'L" � bpA � cC
OC'� a� 'G `n Q�,'1 � G
� w, sr y 6� •� y i ea
FQ ,�c p.� � p" � a� "�.�., �
� �
�.L"i�'u V O �� C•�
�°��a.�����.�
v
�� �'�a:' w�� �
�o���.N°�.���°
�
O'� ' � Z o p� v�
� N � .� y rn -� cC
vvb��a�vo�g
.v z � � � �� � o � o
y'� ���� °�' o � � �
�� ��•¢'o,� �c7�c��
psy.� '�c � Q .,� 'O 'O � � �+
O � v, ��°� m N a�i
O. '�' � �' �L" � G � � �„
N y. O" ',�' O� v��, fn �
O �
���'' A. O++ a� ca
�iR�i� �P. p C'i�.�
:.
�
0
L
�
u
C � L O
�
� G► i = � O > Z
'u a p � � �
QW� ,n c s� � `� i Li'v ro � � �
� � Q C V � � r (d � � yyj � tA 'q p
�� L u a Q'c � i � � c o��^
y � ; m'� a V � � ° +' . .� �� M
` �` 3 � � � � o �u o � � `gNW
� d C � � � � � V �• w O a � E n'^
Z= Gl 0 O i p � .� C O � �+ = r
Q � � C � � � � _ � � Q N
V H o � u � U V
F' � N O
�
7
�
c
�
�
l0
�
�
Q
�
i
N
O
N
N
L
a�
u �
�
d ?
'u y
d
� O
u �
C �
.�
� Ec
id
a c
•V AN
•� L
7
Y �
� .L
Z oc
� �
Z
�
O
>
�
c
d
L �
d C
Ol �
L �
c o
O .o
Y
fV .�
N �
N
� L
lC �
� u
% y
� '�
� �
N
� V
o a
m
Y �y
A C
C �
c
ro "
0 V �
O � �
O
f+1
� � �
A
7 Q �
0 N �
V � ';
� R
_ y
� a� �
C � �
�� � �3
E O �'
� E �
�
�
2 �
C
0
V
�
�
d
;
�
Gl
�
u
N
.n
7
H
,c
�
�
d
a"
�0
v � •�
c
y y C
i�=' L �
o aZ
H
C N N
0 p �
.� � �
� ' Z
�
y v
ar3 O �
o +� a�i
a b
3 � O
t
u
10 � tq
��
i 3
` � '�o
10 L
L � �L
� IO^ �
N V �
�
C
O
V
'9
Gl
T�
.�
C
N
.�
L
.`�o
.L
V
�
7
�
L
b
W
�
�C
G
V
A
O
>
.—
♦+
'.c3
N
�
L
a
L
�
O
�
.� �
M '
� `�
V ,G.
V
� �C
3
°> E
� �
�
•� �
� �
L �
a L
d �
L �
�
N y�
Q1 •
� �
a c
� v
ld y
�
� n-
� h
� �
~ Z
O
N
N
N
a
�
� �
`=�( � � m � �
W O p �a �� 0 G� J
Y E�` � y�1'Q' H�G! O^D ��' pp
Y � � � � � !;i ^y — n C � ��
t`°^� ��' ai'c ai°i �Uv+ �
� c � a � � G � � �, m � r
�a`oau ���� ��r�
c-�oo 8a$;;� 'uSV•-
Y e
O; w.G C Lb� C C�! L Y �7 u
��Cs��V $'Cu��P��t
P i� � � � � �� d p � L �r
��v�°m 3.� ��'�u � � d �`;
2 3� ao�L �o-� A�' � a�i �vbi
�°Y�"�?„��p� �c.�-
N u� l.t� p� bpL � G" d
Z���Y ���dN ,L��� ��y.pC
=ZN ��d= I �Lp,py��� =n �O
�n� � �.;0�� � � � � o
Oy °�°�,� �+ �Z ` �?vi� w d �
!4 Z v ..
d' `�i � 3 c td aC � O���p[ O> Y
LL C v� d T� LL h Vl v� U i-L Vf Q D
�
�
c
a
.�
v
�
N
d
�
3
N
i'�
C
b
G.
E
u
Ld
c
N
�
10
c
bC
C
L
�
Gl
�
�
u
�
L
W
C
0
a
�e
�
�
a
c
�N
7
�
� C
L •y
O �
7 L�
N F�
d
N
c
0
d
L
�
�
^
�
�
v�
�
6:�
�
�°
.;
N
N
0
�
�
� �
00 y
C
'c d
�
� a"i
O '0
`� C
A�
� y
41 y
u -o
d �
C �
�
e�a O
i y
a
�
� E
� �
� L
� O
� �
v
O
C
�
3
�
�
a
d
d
Y
>
L
ld
�
�
'O
c
/.�d
C
Q
�,
Y
L
w
a�
.O
.�
�
c
A
�
�
�
c
.�
L
�
07
Y
y
'0
a�
L
N
C
.�
a�
iro
�
C
'�
�
�
c
�
'��"
n
�
Gr,Y
G
C.?
�
�
O
C
�
Q
p
(3.�
C
u
�
C�
� �
W � �, �.
�
�
�. � � � ,� �
� c� � .,
� " �- ..,
� � � c� � � � �
� ,�, � � .� �. � �.
� � � � � � ��
..�
,�; '"� :� V "a.
G"` "� � 41
�
�� n� �
;g � � .� � � a.
�, w� ,„� � "M o o �
a�i c� - °1 Q1 �-0 v3 ,� � � � 4
'�.'" � e.'�n r� i- ess k`^ .� p_ F� iu c
�
'a°' �. a 6 'a, � .� � � � CY
x „� � m s.' � � � �'-a � � �r
� . .� � �u' ',� >, ° �° Q �
� � � � � � � � Q � o �
„ c�.w � cu - � � ' � � ,c `.�
.� � � � ^y a�
u,
� � � o p � � o Cti �
o. a� w a� o>� � c�' ��+
�, >: � � -� � � '� '� �, `�, L �
p,. � �„ � t? tao � ��. '"' °� ,� �::
� o-�°""�. � e �w� �
�
?. '� ''' }�,� ZJ t�'n. � ,� y�,� • � 6? Cl �
� � O � � .,� 9l � N ,�GTQ C � .L C
i Q� c�tl ��'L' Cp � L •� P
„,� � Ci q y.. «.� tit" � r iW � v_�
� � [Y1 V) � � 'yt � � � �
Y— � u �� tu � � � i � �," u�i � �
� � d � ..:. °; � U Q c �au �
i �" al.y2�F� � �� ���
� �
.c t ) m .c �—
�.. 3 cui a: O�"" � a� �.' �, ao
a °'�'�� �s� � ��
(� s � � ti 4"J a� � `�0 w Q -!� � �r
+n �" m� � � L ci d � `� � "� � in
��a��.+a-�"�-o�-�a�o�� � �a
C?^� o cC3' 3 3`� ° O$.,� �
GG �y � c � cC �y �y u ,�, t� n ,� �
W�. Pv N O lL� . t�f� 41 `��. v..+r U
T"]�+e Itl�ac�
;���,�
.�� rr��dic�
A GANNETT CC3MfzA.NY
f li�rl� 1=:c1�sr�aFi
.i.c>�vn crf Ithacz�
2 C> i�c7rt�i 7'ic���t Sta•c�t
Ith�c.�i, N'1' 14�3C1
I)ctar 11er�1�:
5hq.5��ra���n I�I. �o�$r���r
('ra.s�i�:�� �bt ��� f�'�al�laa�Yl��e�.,e
fi�)il) ��7, ���7
Y�ru r����y 1����e� rc�ar� t����' fi-�,��t-��t��,e s��i��y a��7 �,E�,r3iae�cl�ti�, r��ril � 8 t��l�c�t:i� K� ale�rv Itl��ca� J��zr�iti�l �ri����ri�SCi«r7 an������� �r�c�l c�tl���� �h��rr�L�;
w��l7�c17 4vi:. �v�i11 i4t�ra��s�� i��'�rly� M�yf. K�t���v�ir�r� yyaa�r 7•cale �s �� c�i���r7��ta��ii'y ke.�c�c¢-. I�+�d�i�t�,cl ��u��i tcr I���a�- di�-cct�1y I�a•r��t��� r��i�: ���c��zt ��c�wti�
tlo� .Ic���x•nal es clra�cr`„;it��:
Fwir�t, si����ethis�� t'I�4st'� a�arlr cl�h�i7,gin�: 1'ri��C i� r���t ����ir�� a�v�y�. �C,k�� l�h���ca .143e��-nal �vi18 cCariCi�7i��^, tc7 l�c p��k�lisl�ecd, ir�rl� �rr �as��er, a��c�
ci�C��v�r���l to ��e��vs �i�s�l�rs r��tcl ChaLnsaEicls cat�h��c���s �:�vcry ��iay.
5�cc���cl, �vc a��c cx�7<�nc�in� cattr cli�ita) oflirir��4. '1'I�e iCl��tetijc��anyEal'.cca�a� i+�ill t�e ���7d�tt�ci ng��r�: Ii-ec��ies�Cly� t�s r���c:eC b�•��ikizi� eie�vs �ti�ci
��v�rav��: of c�r�a����i�it�,' s�e�^�•s �n��i sg�c��°t:�. 4Ve �w ill 11ak�e x�eew� di�;it��l pi�t,clxr�ts: .���as rlesi;�e7�:ci Ic3�� i��� ik�hc�n� Kz�i�3 tk�� �nc�r�id, �iricl ��
��e,��� c�E�tt��a�tii�ec� �w��k�sil�: t4�at iC'�eI a�7c1 ua�l��r t�b��t �aser�s �uill r�n�ijr�y. /�r�c1 ��tar e�-N�e���s��aF��:9• w�+ill �:��r71ia�r��� ta ��"avit�lc t� �aa�.�e��--�I�k�;
�xp��:ricr�ce Ior o��Nir�� Ea�et•s.
.I`I�ircl, crn �Il tl�esc� �;17������ly, wc� �r� r�t�F�7r��a�ii�� ��ur c�ver�a��:� tc� �a('9'c�� ��rG7re� ��fi w✓hat Chu cr:r�t��a����¢�iCy tald ��s, �thr�i���lr r•�ti��rc�h z�1�t� l�ocus
�r���p5, are t�7�io• ���at`�itrriiies f'or. cc�v�era��; N�7�;t�V tttax��,�, pt�l�lic spEs�ciii�� r�vncl ���w� al����ut Cl��e �rr��r� 9�f�ur��s residents cic� t�a ii�ti}���rc�ve t��e�
���mirtt��nit'y. ,�,x7d �wG �uil� r���7�a up� c�ur �t�t�i���itre��7ea7t tc� irt-�deptlt a���r[c:h��d'a�; ��•eCaaris, ln�al ����7rt:� ���a�e� let�ii7� tl��t� c��rnn��t�riiky 1�¢7c��tin� at��a�rt
,��,� �
la� cMtrac�r-c3ii�aa��,� a��ts, r�ti-�,atic�ii�l anci �;uYttaN��il �:tiFcnis ii� thc Itl7�tc�� �ai�c�a.
C�'��etrtl�, wr�e �re �;��7�r��ir7� ��u��• laiusir�ess rrr�c��l. k�������� r7����o7y� ��e�ars, �v� Il��ti�c ���iv€�r� o�c�a cear7tea�fi �r������ry�, ii-��, o��� tl�� W`�:Y�. P�r}a��}�s ll��s ���c[�
�s�n�� �� �3c���de �a��; i� ���,.r I���ar��er c�r�es. C.i���rix�� f�c�r����t�r•c1, [�ull ar�c��:��s to itl�arcajt��r�7�1.e�as�� ���rrci cae�e �tl�er �li��it�l ���p��c3G��,t�s ����il'I rcr�uire a
si�bbscri�7liva�. Cc�alsui�te�'s �vi18 s��it�se�ril�t 2�� �7�u� c�r�r��4>rrt ��1c1 ti�e�� c�<a�rs� r� ���•ct"�e-reci fa�etl�ac�Gl c�t�cl�;li����r�y:
__.
•� f'��Lill di�iCal ry�c�s4 f'r��r t��ulti�lc cievic�;� k���c���rser�, t�hl�t txr�c9 sn�i�i-Cpk�c�n� -- �vi11 hc ti f�:z�tairc �aia19 su@�sca•i��ti�r7�.
+ I'ri���t cleli�+c,i`v �w^il� �ie aff�r�:�i in ft'�Gu� e�rt����: [;vei�•y cl�t�r +,vc }����t�li�l�, a�n��eekcn�l ct�mL7�iiata�ri t�f I���r•ici�y �i�Cl �,�tt���c1�y; Sat�ir-d�rv
r�a��ly, �i��, d'rar• bprc��� �����o }�a•�l�'em� t��eiR�� ��rervs �t�cl in�'ari7���t��«rb �aurel}r ir� tl7e� cii�it'al �;���:c, ns� �ri¢�t d�:liv�ry Git all.
• S4abscriptirar� �>ris:srt� r��i1l' var-y� ac�c�rciir��r tc> tl7c ci�li���ta� c��aiic��� t� tiXG��scr°ik�ei° cl�c�t�5c°�. C;ui-r���t sul�scrihe�4 �ir�� rc�ccivi���= 1ctC����
t�uAlia�ia�t� c3eiails tal"tlxc Hi��v �ari��i�+y=.
I�6���Sc k��o��� that i�rrrr-Sub�c�•ika�;t�s 3vill stbd� t�� arl�l� ic� access tlic Jc��¢rn4i1"s 1r«meE�a�e a���l cc�rtr��in �atlicr 4e�ttarc;s. Gtr�c9 �e�ila liave de�p�r•
a��Ci:.:z.7 ��.:�lGii ;ii'ii"tl�il ii7 eY �HI�aV.it.`+.� ¢ILalYli)�l" t?f SY(lClti:�4. f#t.i�il:l' l�dill 111711�.� d:�74`�� 4V1�� 17E: �1VE`il "1f�74:� l)�7��'7l?[`ll.ltlll.�" �Cb SII�'1a`CV"1[)4'.�..
b��e ��l�i� c�ci �7a���cli�eic�y ��trt�7n�, Qa�eal r�ewsp�E7r�r f�c�K� � loi�g t�ine Ct� c�ix�c, ev��� as c��n� i�e�cus ifat�:�t sl�itl� i�cswarcl ��rr���t�ic�ii�� ���d
c�3tiliv�:ri��� N���re i-�i����rrt �.c.�i���:r�it ���itll ��reat�r I��r•�c�ti�er�cy� crn �ll dtiyii��l pl�t�cr��i��s. We r��ccl tu cr�t�hi°s�ce �ur futt�rG @7�^s�c saiae� s�ow.
��r�rc� 1�s1�.s, c��ar rr���ii<r��ii7� �+�it�at� aiti�1 ��n�r�r�9 r��trt�����,�r, �r�d 1 lac�ti� tiv��t�&�'�i L�c� l��a��a��,� t�a ������i�:� ����arselv�s ��ailal�l� �c� t�ilk a�rc���n Q�n-
�I�<��°��c:� �t�e� w��l��at tk7a�}� rr��:���rr to ��s, tc� y��.� <�M��I tca Che c�a�r�r��ita��ity. 4�"� jc7ir� v��r i7v a in�i�t��il 41�si�-e t� r���.�ke �I'"ar�����h:in� Ccr�i¢��Cy ��rcate;r
�al;ac;t t�o l�vc, ����N�k ai74� �s��t����. 'T'I��ar7k y�csu f��r• yc'�t�er sGr���acrr�t.
:�ir7u�rely�,
,�� ""�«,�� ���.��.�,�,_
,����I��rrntiaia }3c�dncr
(�7�ffie:�:�; P,C'��;�_?J^b-��'�����° � : k�ar�d�tc d����u;'car�p�u���tit.�����i�.��..�
1�'� l�'�."c�:>t � , � ,.d, itl-�-�c:.�r, f��.��' „� .��;�:.�
.J t c,d't: �: `a`� Y r. Fi^ V � 3
Paul�tt� T�rwilli er
��� ��,.rc►on:
.�@11t:
�6Ci:
�c:
��abje�t:
[ ) c,� r� .t. ."�i r . E I :i. i� �~ � .r. :
�I�r% Engman
Wedne�d'ay, AprA� �5, 201� 6:11 PM
�. /`i. �1��1�f
�usan �iitter; P�ulette Terwilli�er
�E: Bell� Sherr��n �"Cc�tt�g�s„
T�.-;��n'1� ci� ;�rc:��c�� ��ri.k_��u rttu.a�;l� c�a� ���s�asu�t:: �r�u }tav� ,,r.�1�c�>c�. I3e;fr>r+� 1 re�ei.v�+��3 yc�ur. rct�..�.�;�Zc�� :t
wra;rl.k�� �r_c�rr� '1"own HI�7w.l. t:r.� t�}�� s�_i;� t.c� ;,�e i�l-ic� t:i.:�:�st hau:sr,� �a�a �:;lc�s�. :[, i�<>o, was ;�r k�_i� takarr
������c;k by 1:,1��� �isu�l. .i.m�7<:�c;te af ttyc� trr�ti.7�. inl� u..�rr�c*r.sto�ci i..��t�� 1;h� c��;ir��:l.c��ment wac�til,Cl l�e; �s
cic�nse; as f.;l�e� :au:r��c�unci.i.r��_� n�ic]hk�r�r}z��cac� ar�d r��c�y��t� a�3.t rr�a:��-c�r ��ut se.��:i.r�r� the si.c�c� c�C t_h�
l�a�xt.��7� i�c�c•a�.t°'c:� �P�e ma�r�:t- =>f.�r��t ,��wcer;; ar�e�.
C:7�.zz: Pl�r�ria.r�c� E�����c3 �n�c:�c� t:t�� de�,t:�.i.c`vaa7s �:c�rYc�=�°t�irrc� t:h� �3c��rbv_�s��rnent �rL�i I h,�ve �I�txat:rMcl yaur
..
ti„e�zrtretien�5 wa.f�k� th� [�a.rc��:t.c>.r. of E�'lr�nr�irac} k:c� �I��rrc� ��r:ith l:hr_ r-:l�t�a�.r c�f t:h�w �':8��ar�riiat� 1:3t:�����. I
9�c���c� �h�t: ]��ra�:i.�capa.rar� r:��rcl c�th�a= iqtia.l� p.��<:��ion� c.��ri .�;a�t�c�r7 1.17e* :i_��p���wt:; E>.G� l:&��y l�au ac�:-; a:�.l c����t: twc�
� ht�; ��.rc,c 1:.. ':b'h�nk yc�u 1`.'ra�r yc�ur i����=�r�k��:�e�k.
fIE>r@��rt tiJ. E?ri�����an
'1"cacar7 Su�cxx�v:i;�-�r_
7:"c:awn af Ii:�����;�a
r'1`� ��rtNi '1°:i_ryc�G� � t����
:1t�}r�ra, �JY' 7..!�E3��C�
( �i i) 7 � �' 7 :3 —1 "1 �? � � x t . 1 :�a `:;
,��..�nm�suw�i,.,.
----t?ric�i.x��x:l. ���c�sw7r�c�c;-----
,�'���btct: C. 1'�. B1:L�ber (rrti�i B t:c>:c:r�i7�31�C�c::c'�t:'ra�:�.] .eciM,a�
;7e��it: ��r�_cl<:.�y, �1�ril 2(:D, �(�7.? �! : `��4:1 l:a�ti
"I"ca: k-I���k� Fa��c;�a��ar�
.:]��k�� �ct� : ��r u_ 1_� � h�rrn�;:rti "�'c�t �:�ye � ��
(R�/:-',G.1/'4'k�_�') �')��� d;�r�
��: r� c�rcta n ,
F.:i<:�a ric� <: r-e� icic:r�t: c�r: R�c�rr�Lc;y Im�r�n�, I rc�r�ta1�r��ly w�:�l.�: tc� my ��i �c::c c�r� t;h� �:ca7�rr�11
�.:�rn��u� k;,y rtti��➢.:i.rig �a;�c� rafM t�87e r�� 9�k—�:�:.—#;rai� �>�afy�b }���t"w.r�en Elcar�nr.-as� L�r�+; �� l�a�l�: ��v�sr�ur�.
��e�:;:c�r��_r7c';l.y, I�7�r� Lc,r��:r5c� f:-c7x�wr:aa:ci caifi�lz s�rn� <:i7�t.:i.e:i���i_tiae� ,:�c�rzru,��rx:i.zr�,; t�6��� cl�v�;1.c-��.>rr;r�rx�m� �lc�rqc�
t��i.t�c:tmell :,��r�.�Gm=�; ���ri.. ��=a��t� �T ° � , ar�—c.a1l.r;c� [:��.1.1e � �` �
` .� ;-��r a-c�.l.�xi_.:�.n tc� �:��rc "' : �'t��ss.ni��rt �.att,arc��'".
�].�-�;7, u��<.�ri s�c:�.i�rc;� 1����: ��.�..,t� ,:��aa�h "c,r�t:t�:�c:��=:,", �t :l.(Di, 1�1a�.1.� St_�.�t�t. (why r.�a_.�;}t r.;r.>tt�tas��r�
wit:l�f �7a�y.1.c� l:v��r�i�ie?! ), 4: h,�ve b���r�r .;�k�rc��'9��d l_t��,�t, s�t.���h �� 2— rd;:��rr-�y (�rlus at��:i_c, w.a.l_t��r 1'i.a�1.�.—s�.z.�ec:�
w�.r���c���rsj �l.r•ta�;��iar� �~��a1.c;� k�a� te;rTrr��ci �"ca�t_��r��"' !... �nci i�a:r:i„}7erarre.rr.r�, t�}Y�at i.� c;�c::at.��u ��e
�a].r��w��c� �c,� �:�.<a.�p t� I�?if.e::�t�:1_1 Stre�c;t: (t;�Yr� a�r� e.:�iz:��-rc�� &��ine� vri_th�ia� �'� fc�r�t �� ��.}�f` ;:>:ame:3���a�1k�
w:i.�kt ra�z �>c��:a;h �an ti'a� T�d::.tw��h�il—St,rc�e�t: c���crs�.z'e:: t:c� �am�llc�rGt�c� �i�� �����t��r�rsrinc� .zz�;��r���t,.
`d'}�3r ��rese�at4;€; is �s�ar�t;,i.[��.:l.y t�i�f_a_c.�:�i.�br� ��nc�xr lt�y��c�inr.� ta�r ��Lc7rac� f�.i�c�k�c->:li.l. k:�'c>�t� ��.�1.��, :��r�rrm�n
:�-���•,k��c}�.1., ��''.�a.r�tpc�.r�s� � ""; �:�ny�a�n° c���� Q�t..
� l.i.rx�� i� in«,r�aclg.�:�.1� L�aL :�,t.�c:l�a ��c*vr9.n��rn�rrh� �;c�ial.a�l ]��:3vtix k��e�cr <ar.;���,g�k:ee� lay i:t�r, f�aw�7.
k��,��rr�. Ct. w.�..�.:1 r�rt� c.������t:: :�,���rv� ��:,� �� l.a�,:7�.ii'Lz�� ��r��e�+a�r�r�i�1"` �:.a, M:.Y�a�� �r�v.i��<armrrtc��rat ,�l
t,,}���artsic��P�f..;.r'3t�i�>:.a� t��:f �,t c;+��r't���in l e�i�:.,.�1 <�d.ma.ri� .;t:x:'rrtw.:i�a�. ,.
;u�+1IDiNNp,
G: n c:l _i .����> e:a ca :i. ra f� ar� � ri P: ,
C:br.r7��:��.:i.t�:; �1. I1.i.��ac;:r., J��.
LL
s,�uu�;n„ �,��1"1� ��, �Q 1 �
"T"��'�Il�a��� It M�y Gc���uct•r�,
/ i , ., ! i,.� ,. ��
'� „
As a�x iz�te��� �t N9e����;��r� �ta�ll�y Stnitl� i3a�-��ey as rr��11 as �t �urre��t stu¢�e�lt �t C��-nel1
[.J��iw�e�•sity, i at�� wt•iti��� tc� La���C:c tny 41�it�iaz�s cic4l�• i°e��z�°clii�s� t�e �rc��c�st;c� i�7ct•c�asc c�f �1��
r7�it�it��un� w�rag� ir�7 �I��t�����alcii�s �c��znty�.
�laile I fully sGa���ac�rt tl��: incs•ea,�e ii� li��u��� w4��e !<�r Ei�ll-Cin�c ec����l�ay�:c;s, c�r• tl�c�s�;
�w���-�i�a� tc� su��p�x-t t}�cx��s�lv�;s, 1 h�elieve tl�as ���z�a`c���e i�1 �-e:c��ii�-ec� d�✓a�;e �:vill k�arr� tr ��eg�ative
�.fif�.c�t upc�i� studc�lts seel<i���; �� l�txt-�iin� �xpc�ri�����: fz�c���i ir7tet-�xsl�i�s inar� tl�aal �� ?���y�:��ccle.
Ma��y stuc�c��ts �a��t•ti�;a��utc a�� a���e�-�sl�i}7s irr t]�is ��-�:a i�� carcier t� g;�i�� �x�a�a:��u•c: tc� �iffcrcnt
ir�c�l�stri�s whilc tl�cy ai•� �tiHl i�� :�cl7a�a1. Tltias ca��able:s ��5 tc� ���lve a rnc�rc �ve1�-rc��a��cic�t� �can�aii-��
ex�acc�ie:i�u� ti��t �c���r����.i�����ts c���r- cla�sraca�r� ec�u���ic�z�. `vV��il� str.rclents alsa �,rc7rk f���• ar� a�zc:c�i�e,
tk�� ���e�s o� "i�ter��s" a�•u rx���cl� l�;�s t��a�� t}7c�se: wc��-kin�; t�� s�������art t8x�;ii- r��st c�fi livit�r�.
Frc�in a��ei°�c�i���l st�i��3�a�ri�t, tny i�7�.�r��e �c��s tu��r��z-�ls �aod a�7� �i11s, v�Fl��le 1-rc�usiz-r� ��i7d
e��ls�atic���s ar� c�vc�•�c� �y i��y ��arerlt�, l�ai�s ai�rci �'o�•��ell. `�'}�r� lesscr ii�corz�e i� ��ci�,yu�te ferr
�tu�ict�t�, �v1�c�sc n7�i�� }�ur}�tasc� af w�c�rkin� i� r�rc�t tc., �;tic}����]rt thc,l�s��v�s �i�at i•atl��,r tca �;�t �vcark
c��:��cri�;r�c� betare �r��i�x��tii��; ti•�ai�7 �c1�ae�I.
�n �ct•ass tlzc �c���rr�i ix�c;reczse ia� tl�e �nini�7�ta��-y wa�;�; wc��zld causc i�1e�c�� �7at��� tl��n �ood for
���rciet�ts sucl� �s ��nys�.lf, �rrl�ca arc� cyclical az�d te���E�ca�•a�-y e;r�r�lc�yees. "�`l�is u�c;�-c;a�� �n c��st for o�r
c�rl��rlcr��rs ��^�atulct k�c: ����rcl�t�sc�n�c �c�c� wnuld ca�i:�c tl�c: lc�a��sta.iic3ii�� int�;�-a� ���-c��;�-��in �at I�1�raca's
Pvt�r�c�n S��nley S��aitl� Bz��-��c�;� ���c� ��aa��y ��l��c- �lac�e�� tc� a�l�a�� t��ei�- �c�ors tc� :�kt�ci�;���s. �tuc�e��ts in
tui-�� �vc�uld lc�sc o�ut o�x a ct•i�ic��( Ie�ri�i�lg �;���c�-rcr��c; �l���t ti�rill ]�c;l�� them ir-� tl�� 1i�t�ir•e:.
C)rtc� a�ai��, I F'��l�y si��r�aac•t ai� increasc ��� t1�G ��ir�i�7�az�n ��ra�;e tc� ac�jus� �a7 cc�st �1 li�ffr�� itz
Tc�ml�kins Cc�u�-�ty, k�ut �aT�ly i`a7• c��ar�-i��►te�-�� ei��pl�ymc,��t. It i� ll�ese e����al�}�ec;s il�a� ar-c� �aliin� f�i�
kl�� ia�ct�eas� in w��� �°��t���a- tl�an �9�e i�����i�� p�c����E�lat�ican. l� �,�r��.�1c� �pra}�c�se a.�� �xw���tie�aa f�ra��
ca��playc��e��t �,c,sxtic,��� �al��l�e� �:� "i��tcrd�s", so t�1�� r�� c�r� �c�ntiifl�tre �o lcar�a �vk�il�; tl�c��� ti��at 1�►av�
le�itia���te �xee� f��r tl�e. wr��;c� ins�rcas� arc al��c tca lz��vc it.
��oulc� bc h�����y t�� ���ak witl�� s�caz�le���e a-�g;�ircli��� tl�c�se c�ar���s ��t�c1 s��oul� ��:�y
c�cc�in���e,i�c���:�c�i� bc t�l�c�� i��tc� 4�c�a�.i��t, assr'st in az�y w�ay {�c��sil�1�,-
�ax-fln �e�a�•cls,
�
�,,�,e��..._._ "�� ,�'
At�is���� C��opt•�t�...
C�c�rt1e,11 "�CJt�iversi�y � C°l��ss t�i`?()13
�i)5.5�"�.�1�Q � ��79� ec,cc��°��cl�.cct�i
,,��u��, C�c�ll��;e ot A.z-�s &; Scicr�cc;�) G�ve,r��r-�ent, �c:ca��c����ic�s
Ivic�l�,ax� St��nlcy 5���it1� l�arn�y —�r�tc;n7 t� Ar-��alc1 �. Sc�i���E�i-tz
�y!ry;�i.IWYbL.ug
I'rr�;e ]_ c�� 2
P��N�t�e Terwillic�er
Frcamu: Rich DePaalc� [rd�richde�aQl�.�aen�
a�r�t: W�dn�sday, F�pril 25, 2CP1 � 11:46 r`�M
Tca: F"aul�tte Terwilliger
Subj�ct: Fw: Fie: Ciel�r,�are &��ckawrr�inna 6��ilraad corridcar b�tween Germari �r�ss Fic�. �nd �urns Rd.
�'rlr�lc�tt��
'�'fi�: z���;5:;���e ���;lc�w i� l�ee��� fc�r-w<xrc9�;c1 i"�ac� ���(:�li�, cc7����li��ne� �aur}�c�seS.
fZici�
-------�ri�i�aai Pv'ie;s�it��__.._..__
�'rc7r�r: dZicl7 I�cPr��lca
'T��: .Ber�r��iy �rus�r
Gc� I���yc;y Mclsk� ,�I��Y�;i7�r�r��i`t��wn.i1l�K�c���.��y.us, T3�oc,cla�r�r�n ii)tc�w�a.itl�r�cr�.d�y.aa:�
��rl�j�;ct.� ��e;: I�c���w�►r� �� L���ck��w�i►�t3�Y Y��xils�na� c�rr�dpr l�ct.wvcc�� �'J�r�x���rz �"�•c�:;s 1�.c�. s�r7c1
�3eu'�i:� Rcl,
�ic;��t: 25 1'���t. �12. lf):35t1»�
Je:r-���a7ys
�o���„���,.�
�T'l�� cc�c-�-iclr�i� ��� c�ucsli�ar� l�a� t�acc�l tl:�� s�al�j��t C�1'�a�c�E��-�i���/�ii5c�ss:�i�ar� 1��c• sc:���7c t�r�1c� r1c�w�r. 1'lle
'�"��vi� �;Gi���ar���is k17� ide4x ad cat�;r�c3ii1� te��. Sc,��zt�� f�il9 �ec trriil, �1'1��:��e l�s« l��;crti c�a�r�fclurn�l�le
cliscu��i��� ��ta�aut tlii� �y tl�c 'I°c�wa� ��t� �;��rolir�� �3���rc1 �rnc� th� �'�wr� ��t: Iil���c�� I'ula�ic Wo���Cs
��nc� "9,�-��il� �c�x7�tni�teccs. ,�,s y��u �:vc�e�lc� cx���:c�, t1�e.re �Mre �c�tr�e resi�E�.t�t� �t1c�r��; ���e ca��ridc�r
�r��t� tai°c ��fa��r�.1�er��i�rc r�t��aiat tE�c ic1L��.
.�:� t��r ��� I�az� c9ctcr���ii�e, yo�i ��c(GaG�fly l�v�; ir� t9�� "T€�wn r�f I�ryd�rt, T��i����t yt�ru ct�r����ct.
Su���;��vi;�c�i° Nit�l�y Ax�r� Su'�ia�e� z���c� rrl:��� c:carrt��ct 'Iry�wc� ot CErr€�linc �����cr�vi�;t�r, i��an l3�lr�ic��,
��r7c[ I�cL7�il:y S�u�7�;rvisbr, 1�ta��ai,�6c l�'r�cac��;�10��. 1�� c�rcler tc� extce�c3 it7�; lr�xil, ��t 1cs��;t 3 E���cl
latassil�ly � r7y��r�aci���lilie�, N�'ST��, irilc� nu�trocrcaus �c5�clt;�a1.4 wc��alcl l���vc tc� �c�c��r�:r�rtc.
r�c� Kt���rver �c��ar c��ic;�Kiat� ��ccific4illy, I c;<Nr� ��r�t <�c�visc ytyu car� f7ta�v {tyr ��1�ctG�cr iC i� pac7�sil�lc
tca ��t) "���c;ri��i5��r�n' �c� util��e; tl�� cc�rp�ic3c�r.
[��t�� i'carw����cii»�, ia��r r��;�t���5e; tx� "1"���uar c��` I1l���c;�� �Su��Q�visc,r �-{�rt� ��;rti�m�tr� ���icl Crc�u�7ciper�c�a�
13i11 Gc�c�clat3it��, ��s I3iC1 i� c.urrca�tl�� �:'974tfla� t�f t�ur k't�l�lic �4't�rk4 ��rici `�'r��i�s ��¢L�����t1t;c�.
l3c�t ��c��;�za�cls,
����, ______..C���i��i��s►l M�cs�tia��:-------
�"'1"(71�1: .�GI"r1fi1�' ��1`Li;��C
'I'«: I�l��i'cit>l� cr t�w���.itl���c��.r��P.��
C'r�.: I���sc;y Me9ski
4/�Ci/2():�,�
Page 2 of 2
Subject: Delaware & Lackawanna Railroad corridor between German Cross Rd. and �
Burns Rd. '
Sent: 25 Apr'12 8:44am
Rich,
I got your email address from the Ithaca Town Board website as a point
of contact for Public Works. I am hoping you can help me out, or at
least get me to the right person to get some help.
My fiancee and I live on German Cross Rd. in Ithaca/Dryden. We are
avid hikers and have discovered an overgrown corridor between German
Cross Rd. and Bur�s Rd. that I beiieve is part of the Delaware &
Lackawanna Railroad corridor. We would like to clear a little brush
from this trail so that we can use it to hike between our home and the
South Hill Recreation Way. We are trying to find out what we need to
do to get permission to do this. Could you provide us with some
direction? Any assistance would be appreciated. Thank you for your
time.
Jeramy Kruser
25 German Cross Rd.
Ithaca NY 14850
607-257-6589
4/26/2012
w.
�"�
'I'own lioard
Herb Engman, Supervisor
Bill Goodman, Deputy Supervisor
Rich UePaolo, N'ahmin I-iorwitz
'Te:�-Ann Hunter, Pat i��ary, and Eric Levine
M�y 2, 2012
l t 1 Blackstone Avenuc
ithaca, New York 1485U
(607) 257-2U57
Codes and Ordinance Committee
Bili Gaodman, Chair
Evg Hoffman, .Bill Kin�, Pat Leary
Eric Levine, and Fred T. Willcox III
Tawn af lthaca
21 S Narth Tioga Street
Ithaca, New York 14850
Dear Members of the Town Board and Members af the Cades and Ordinance Committee:
I write concerning zoning at l 10 Blackstone Avenue. Construction there raises a zoning issue geater than just
the one site. Unless you correct the situation I am atsout to describe, I believe that developers will have a
precedent that will alter our neighborhood zoning and in sitnilar neighborhoods within the Town.
The property at 110 Blackstone Avenue has two separate buildings, both of which continue to be worked on.
Our neighborhoad is designated as a"Medium Density Residential Zone." As you know, Section 901, Article
IX ("Medium Density Residential Zones") of the "Zoning Ordinance" states that buildings in our neighbarhood
�"�hust either be "a one-family dwelling" or a"two family dwelling." In both cases, the term "dwelling" is
singular.
I believe that the buildings do not yualify as a single two-family dwelling. Yet the owner has rented an
apartment in the two-story building located in the front yard, closest to Blackstone Avenue, while living in the
two-story building at the rear of the property.
I have enclosed photographs of the two structures at 110 Blackstone Avenue, along with a map.
Earlier this year, I contacted Bruce Bates by phone. Mr. Bates informed me that the Town initially granted
these two structures the status of a single home suitable for two families, on the basis of a roofed �walkway with
a dirt floor that stretches between the two buildings. This walkway does not connect the buildings with doors,
and it stops short of the main house, a building that is on the western side of the property. There is only one
short beam that extends flimsily from the roof of the walkway to connect to the northeast comer of the main
house. In order to use the walkway, people must step outside. The owner, Marc Messing, has occasiona.ily
parked one of his cazs under the walkway, a cleaz indication of how this walkway is not closed off.
I believe that the eastem building with its renta.l unit is in violation of the provisions of Article IX, Section 906,
paragraph 5, which states that an Accessory Building "may not occupy any open space other than a rear yard."
The eastern building is in the front yard and is the building closest to Blackstone Avenue. The location of the
eastern building in front of the main dwelling shauld also negate the passibility of a special permit from the
Board of Appeals, because a variance for an Accessory Building {Section 904) can only be applied to build.ings
�cated behi.nd a main builtling.
A
I am concerned that ifdevelopers se� that all they have to do is build two separate buildings and then stretch a
rooted walkway between them, th� result will make a moc.kery of the ~r..oning in our area and in the Town. l.f
1 l0 Bl��ckstone remains as an unr�;�;ulateci "single twafamily dwelling" and becomes a new stanc�ard, nur
n�ighborhaod and ather neighborhocxis in the Town mighi now faU under what might be termed a new �
"walkway rufe," under ihe tiction that the a dirt walkway with a roof transforms two buildings into a sin�le
dwelting. 7'he effect will be a defacto rezoning.
In January 24l 2, the owner,lVlarc Messing, be�an renting out the second story apartment in the eastern building
ta a male Cornell graduate student. �Iis family cantinues to reside in the western building farthest from
Blackstone Avenue. This second-story apartment was originally used by Mr. Messing and his family {his
spUuse and two sons) while the second building was being constructed. Thus the two large, sta.nd-alone
buildings are built on iwa separate foundations erected at two separate times.
Frnm the time Mr. Messing purchased the property and showed me his architectural drawings, all this
consiruction stretched over several years. � was assured by Mr. Messing that, once the larger building was
completed, he int�nded to use the second-story apartment as his office. His family referred to the apartment in
the eastern building as "the clubhouse." Mr. Messing �ave me his assurances because I clearly expressed my
concern that any rental would be a violation of zoning. Had I known what would develop, I would have
appealed #he situaiion imrnediately, even before the completion of one of the buildings.
I am asking the board to declare that these two dwellings are in fact two separate houses and that they do not
Qualify as a sin�le dwelling — that is, that these two buildings do not constitute a two-family single structure.
1 am also requesting that the owner of 110 Blackstane, Marc Messing, be directed to terminate the rental of the
apartment in the eastern building at 110 Blackstone and to agree in writing that the eastem building cannot be
rented at any time. 1 alsa request that Mr. Messing's statement clarifying the issue be added to any and all /"1
documentation kept by the Town so that future buyers will realize that the property is not a single two-family
dwelling.
C have attached an appendix to review other deta.ils of the circumstances behind this issue.
Thank you for taking the time to read this letter and the accompanying appendix and photographs.
I would be grateful if you woutd respond in writing. I would also be willing to discuss this matter with you.
Sincerely,
Robert W. Venables
�
2
s'
�
APPENDIX: 11U Blackstune Avenue
�'HU'TOGRAPHS.
As the attached photographs demonstrate, both buildings at I 10 Blackstane are twastnries hi�;h. The first,
which now cantains a rental, is located at the eastern en.d of the praperty closest to Blackstone. The second
building is another lar�e two-stary bailding at the western end of the property.
The eastern huilding with its current rental apartment has a garage door facing Blackstone Avenue and thus may
be rebarded as an accessory buildin� under Article iX, Sectian 946, paragraph 5, "Accessory Buildings."
�lowever, this paragraph states that a gara�;e is detined as "nat over one story." The two-story eastern buildrn�;
is abviously more than a garage. The apartment on the second story is an open, large loft-style residence
equipped with a camplete kitchen and toilet facilities. Thus the eastern building is so large it is a"regular"
home.
T��:E NEfCHBORHUOD,
Virtually all the properties in our immediate neighbort�ood are half-acres — our neighhorhood being at the
souihern end of Blackstone, south qf Hanshaw, and east-west all along Roat Street. The future development of
all these neighborhood properties will be affected if the eastern building at 110 Blackstone includes a separate,
income-generatin� buildin�.
If the Zoning Ordinance is not enforced at 110 Blackstone, it will also set a legal precedent that developers
throughout the Town of lthaca are sure to use to circumvent the Town's zones for specific neighborhoods. The
developers could then build two or more structures, connect them with a dirt walkway with a roof, and call the
�complex a single structwe.
Finally, by comparison, I would like to add that our own properiy at 111 Blackstone is a rectangular half-acre,
running north-south along Blackstone between Hanshaw Road and Roat Stree�. Our home is placed on the
southem quarter acre, at the corner of Blackstone and Roat Street. But the other quarter acre to the north of our
hom� is open lawn and faces the two buildings at 110 Blackstone. This quarter-acre is adjacent to Blackstone
Avenue's sources of sewer, gas, and electrical power.
If my family built an exact replica of the two-story eastern building that now exists at 110 Blackstone, and if we
attached a roofed walkway with a dirt floor, would the Town of Ithaca regard that complex as a single structure
suitable for two families? Especially if, prior to beginning construction, I did not go through the formal
application to the Board of Appeals for a specific permit?
Thank you for considering the issues raised in this appendix.
3
�����c :� �f l
Pa�ul+�tt� Tervvr�ltrger
�ram: �'ust�n C7o�abs [�rd "(...�jrd,c�m]
��nt: M�nday, P+�ay (li, 2a12 1:�0 P'M
To: Pau�ette `ferwilli'ger
SwbjeCt: [http:/ialnvepresjecks.com� �treet swe�ping alc��rg 'Warr�n F4aad, Hanshaw, and Fcarest Hame speed
bu�rnps
[ lcllc�! �'w�� �� I'lli� stercle��t 1ivi��� io� i�lc�rtta��4t Ith��c��. I�;cat������at� �c� c��r��i��,as eack� �3<�y ��i�t ��icycl�: c�r
t�u�; z�rlci l�;kve <t fc;au �,������a��:a��t� <�N���azi ���c��l rc�e��i cc�r�c�li��c�►a�;.
l. ��ic3� rt�y l�ike uy� W�brr��� ��c�r�ci whc;s°e th�; ru�l�r1�er �icl�;�°��lk w�r�i� x-a�ce:a�R�y an�t<�lY�ri.
Uax�'c7t°ti�arti�ztt;ly, �itl� ciry-lik�; saat`r���t��uctur� cc��e5 �tt tt�;cci i"c��• za��ci��t��t�����:� th�t� cie�es7�'t ��crn tra
������rac;t��. ����;cifi�i�;<�11y, tl�� ia�4l��ll��tia��� t��' �I�G �;ic�ew�i�k l�ri� ����<�a�:c1 �x tr��� f'c�r rc�r�d cicl���►:;, �r,�l�c;��; G�
r�<1tur�zl 51�wvulci�.�� �sec� �a� all��w c��;�y��is tc� le;�v�. tlx� �•c��zc�. "C'9�� �l�ca�alcic�- c�6't7c�rtl�t�����c�ci `�4't���rcit [�a�ci
rs �z w�:�z c�f ,�T-��vel a��c3 w<�rroci �'r��m cir�vc;w<ays, l��oken �;la�;:�, �l��cl ����I�c�����rc; tl�rrt is I�c���arcJc��z� t��
t�icyc;li�l.�, Wi�l t��i� cvcr �ct �,1cai7e�i ���a`?
2. I�I�4x�;e r��aE�ve �-�t�n���<��� tl�� ri�l�t w�Gxy �Xncl n�e��e t11c :�I����aldc�� ���(�e ���Y�1 wi�3c �r1�7����j �°c��.
w;.al�i��� r�r l��ki�3g. I r�c�i�"t �;e� t� �:c�����a�llli��� rue�cZ f��r t� �ic��;w�r��l}� t1�Glt e��ts intc� p����le'�; yti���c��;--ju�d
cicr�ll u�� tl�c; c;�istin� �;h���lcj�r ��� tla��t ��c� c���� �W<�I1�. ��lc�n� (1ie; rc�ac� rvitl�c��it tr��a��iryg c�vee ��ll t8ae;
rut�.
3, "1"lie; Y���rc:;t 6-��7►iyc :����cel l���r����*� ��r�; St� infur'idit��i�. C�r� CY��; ��1��, �v�:r� c�1 lr�tiu s��;e��, �:��t�;�c:����r5
��,����r�
ar�; tc�:�5�ci a�-c�l���c�. �y c��• is c���it�; �ar�c:c�i�llc�t�able c�v�r tl�c:�� at �a��t �� cc�i�7}a➢etc stc�}�. I 17�x�1 �c> c�r�iv�
t7�y �,��•t��ri�tyd tc� £��� ear�pc�irtl�atLr�t �►i't�r �lic il�t� �i rr���jt�i° i�tjury <►r�c� it wc�5 ��Ity�ic�tfly }7car�i5l7i¢r�; 1'tar
lacar ��g ���<�vcrse thc ��cecl l�wm���;. �"v� �c;c�l re��r-cncl cfrr �:c�l��;;ic�r�w f�r�t�rz� cirivers �l���rry�air��, tI�c;ir
t�r-crkc:�; Ia�.���i�e tl�e 4p�ec� �7ur����5 ��r�c1 �;c���a� a��e���--�iai4s�s witl� l�ic�y�;l��;t� �ii7ci �c�lcstri����s ci��e ��a 1���
c�l�e}�c; ����nt� crc��tcc3 17y tljc n�irr°c�wi��� cai� t97e �•�acl, rI 9�c c��rl>� ['�����c c����5 <�n�l l�ike� tc��;ctl�er �nrl�c;i�.
tl�r�� ��t���;rwisc ��c�ulcl 1������ �r�f� latei-t�l �}�G�ce, �i»cj kl��° li�;i�t�; f���� ��n cyesc�re ��a�c3 vvt��t� c�f'
elc�t�•ic�ty ��t ��i�;l�t. "G�'h}� cax� ���°ll� ��icl ��c� c��7� try �c�w�F�:r�r�� fh�; :�}a��ci li���it a»cl ui�Ccar•cir��, iC v��itl� ���
���fi��r"? W��y ���u�t l�un��s�c:cl4 ��1���ac;1V-�7����T1���� ic�]�CS, �������y ca� �I�c�za� a�rce7"t e�F�57 c�ri�^ir1�, 8�c
��ll���i�:a�ly ����zi�hecl �C� c�l- � ti�n�s ���c�� cl�ly j�rst t+� ��t t�a sctic�c�1 c�r vvc�rk`? Th���; c�17:�t����cti¢�r�4 ��r�.
�a�����fe �:���ci �.�netl�ic°��� adr�cl �lxc��al c1 ��c�v�;r l�tave �ce�� ir�st<�]l�� i�lc�ri� �� lr��n�it rc�ute.
51'7/2C� 1 �
�������
�! ��
� ;,,; a � ;; ' °�a" � � � � � � � � � i�, "�..i �
f i� 21
"����", ��� ����� 2� � N. �i��� ��reet, Ithac�a, �."Y. 1485a
ww�r.tc�w��.��hac�.r�y.t��
Tcrwr7 S��p�rvisor (6'07) 273-1721, Ext 125 ;��l�o��im��r„c��,r��ae�Am�.ot9i�a��.rc�v��a�
TOVVN CL�R{i (6a7) 273«1721 PUBLNC WQRKS (60i) 273-166F� ENCICVEERIN� (fr07) 273-17�7
PLANNIhJG (6�7) 27�-1747 ZC3NIN'G (6CY7) 273-1783
FAX {607) 273-1704
r • !
K�ndr� Liddicc�at, M�, �TF�S
Adju�ct �ectur�r
Recre�ti�n, Parks, �nd L�ei��are �tudi�s
StJNY Corkland
22'I4 Prc�f�ssu�¢��I S�tudies B�eildi�ug
Cc�rkland, C�Y � ��45
��^. r• �.
Th� c�oemb�rs af th� Tc��ner� Boa�d �vc�udd Iip�� tca a�k �c�u to �xter�d ta yau�
st�n�'ents a�r thar�k� fc�r t�re fir�e wark fih�y �ud �on � r�cre�tian s�rvey far the
���,�...
Towvn �af Ithaca. �81 as��cts of the �rc��ect fram surv�;y design, th��ugh d�t�
coNle��ic�n and ara�lysns, ta pr�s��rtatir�n af iindir�gs �nd r�c�m�n�ndatic�ns were
doo�� in � p�crf�ssional ar�d timeYy m�ren�r. dt as � trib�te to yat�r I��d�rshrp and
StJNX �ortlar�c� th�t th� �tudents wer� so w�ll p�rep��e�'. 4N� P���k fc�rw�rd to
rec�ivi�g� yc�ur forral r�p�rt �nd ir�cQ�parating wh�t we h�ve ke�rn�d 6nto our
recre�tdao� �lar�niing.
Th� �`c�wn is fo�k�rnat� t� s�h�re its cc�r-�munity with ir�s�itutican� ca� hagh�r
educ�;�ic�r�. P'artr��rshMps with st�d�c�ts �rrd ��achers fr�m t�w�s� nnstit�atic�ns c�n
be �fi real b�r�efit �o �as all. N€�p�fulBy yc��r s��dents have gairw�d a� nnu�� fram
tfi�� �xperien�e as t�ue Tawr� �ras. Th�nk y�u f�ar y��r r�ilfingness t�a share yc�ur
�xp�r�i�� wi�h us �r�d' w� Ia�k faru+e�r� to vvarkinc� w�th Cortl�nd stud�nts on futur�
pr�jects.
Sir�ce��ly,
��N" ��
� �,�� � �:... __..._..,..�...�, _ ��w�.__�. _..
�H rb��t �I. � r�ar� ���
Tc�vtr� �e�p isor
Page 1 of 2
Paulette Terwilliger
�' From: Justin Dobbs [jrd@jrd.com]
Sent: Thursday, May 10, 2012 2:12 PM
To: Herb Engman
Cc: Paulette Terwilliger; Bill Goodman; E Levine; IVHorwitzContact; PLearyContact; RDepaoloContact;
THunterContact
Subject: Re: [http://aliveprojects.com] Street sweeping along Warren Road, Hanshaw, and Forest Home speed
bumps
Hi Herb!
The sidewalk along Warren was constructed as part of the national Safe Routes to
School program. These walks are designed to enable school child�en a safe way to
get to school by foot or bike. You have pointed out an apparent negative
cansequence of the required curbing — the accumulation of some material washed
onto the road via driveways. I have drawn the attention of both the County highway
department (the owner of the road) and the Town Public Works Department (the
Town maintains the sidewalk). Unfortunately neither the County nor Town has the
type of street sweeper often seen in the City. I'll check the road way to see the extent
of the problem and see what can be done.
That issue is common to all streets with standard curUs. Naturallunimproved shoulders are "self-
cleaning" to a point, which is why city street sweeping programs generally involve only curbed
streets. To maintain safety, the Town needs to find a way to periodically maintain streets once
curbs are installed, or Uetter yet, come up with a design that allows for passive debris removal. I
� appreciate your checking into this--I recently got a flat tire along there and I know another
student who has recently too. Road Uike tires are highly vulnerable to damage from rocks and
glass shards. Once a month would probably be more than adequate. I use Warren Road and the
Northeast Ithaca Walkway only to avoid the poor pavement conditions on Hanshaw.
Hanshaw is also a County road and it will make the design decisions based on
standards �et by the funding sources (mainly NYS). The sidewalk along Hanshaw
will connect with the Warren Road sidewalk (thus enabling even more children to
walk or bike to school), with the Village of Cayuga Heights (thus gi�ing residents the
option of walking into the village for services), and with the various side streets in
the Northeast (thus giving families the apportunity to walk safely both for recreation
and commuting purposes). It is not appropriate for children to be walking and biking
on an unpratected shoulder. The Town conducted a neighborhood discussion of the
walkway several years ago and there was overwhelming positive support for a
sidewalk from Cayuga Heights to Sapsucker Woods Road.
I had assumed (perhaps erroneously), given abrupt change in pavement condition right at the
Town of Dryden border, that the Town was involved in maintenance decisions. What I meant
was that deteriorated infrastructure should Ue repaired Uefore more is added, if a choice is to be
made between the two. Of course children deserve a safe route to school--I don't think anyone
would contest that. While not a full substitute for a walk along Hanshaw, the addition of a
parallel pedestrian cut-through from the end of Birchwood Drive or Birchwood Drive N over to
Sapsucker Woods Road would yieid a safer route through the family-oriented and highly
walkable Salem Drive neighborhood, provide access to route 31 for Sapsucker Woods Road
� residents, and enhance access to the nature preserve. Has anyone approached Mr. Lucente about
this?
Kids riding bikes on the sidewalk along the sidewalk on Hanshaw sounds like trouble unless all
5/11/2012
Page 2 of 2
the shrubbery is removed on an ongoing basis to provide a clear view from driveways.
The Forest Home entrance features and speed tables were designed and supported by the �
Forest Home Improvement Association after all other measures failed. The plans were
incorporated into the Town's Transportation Plan and constructed when state and federal
monies became available. The Town does not have a police force and the County Sheriff had
little success controlling unsafe speed and running of stop signs in the neighborhood.
Towns in New York State do not have the power to set speed limits and the County and state
had lowered them as much as they deemed feasible. Had the commuters passing through
been more respectful of the residential neighborhood the expense and inconvenience of the
measures taken would have been unnecessary. A post-construction survey taken of Forest
Home residents showed that over SQ% were very pleased with the results and thought the
effort worthwhile. ( have suggested to Cornell for years that it cou[d help the situatian by
diverting campus traffic onto Cradit Lane and making it more difficult to continue into Forest
Home. While there is agreement in concept, Cornell has been unwilling to make the changes.
No doubt Forest Hame residents would love to make all through-trips as time-consuming and miserable
as possible. However, antagonistic methods are counterproductive in that they create obstructions for
the vast majority of the road's users and displace traffic to other areas rather than truly mitigating its
impact. Cornell probably objects to the idea of thousands of additional car trips past the undergraduate
dorms and through pedestrian-dense central campus. TCAT route 31 eliminates hundreds of car trips
per day through Forest Horne and deserves more support than it seems to receive from Forest Home
residents, as evidenced by the responses to last year's survey. A broader survey of all stakeholders and
not just Forest Home residents would yield very different responses and possibly some innovative ideas.
I frequently see Cornell's officers camped around Forest Home and the adjacent county roads and had
assumed that they were cooperating with the adjacent communities. Sounds like that's not the case--a �,,,�
shame, because I'm sure Forest Home could benefit from a cut of the tic3cet revenue.
Thanks for respond to my e-mail. Your perspective is helpful and I appreciate your time.
Respectfully,
Justin Dobbs
�
�.
5/11/2012
- - • �-��,� �� ��:-;�,.E F{�.H; � �,g -- ��a � j�•� .� � � ���
uu.., a�:.'u .; �_ '/T�
�€�;� � `� 2��,� ___�-�/'�,a.C,c�� f /6 l � �-1 `Z 8'�
� 'rowrv oi- rr i�E;cn ���,t� 1 v� ��- �� r�
TUWN CLENK /
D ��v yy�� r 7 %G�- � K.�� �2�
�
. `v.� ��
� �' 8 �,� .o r `'� ��
�1 oa�n �- d � � ,
...�. �� _9
� � �, � �-c� U� � r � v�.� � �t
v /�` �y��%�'r��-� . r
I u� �a. �s
�- a v�� �G� Q
-�� v C�Y� �� G�5 �- ,,,.r-
-hf s ; , e � � � � f ��
yL p�.s �Lu-�/ �2i � GG' Ge-Y �
���n �, �� � t ��
/. � � ��a U � �� I 5 � �L �Uv
� / �. � .
�, � �� �� -� �
� �� , 1 �
I Yc C�''�ce s �� � L`'� � �a � �'� � Z � , ,
<
� ;,� �, s s �v �cz �
�-cv�s � �av�
� � �� �
� . .
��� - � ` � o n �, G� y � ���� a- .
,-� v I � /2 � `�G� � 7� ,
5 � � t��
�.�� o�� rn����� a
� �� � ��� �
�� � �
�
������ d�s � / �-�— ah �
`�t�, a tiP/ f 6
�C;c. 5 �- � � � C� ��
� ,�
� � � (,t !/I'1 p�S Y G �l �
D/ S� � c� -�l ft. GQ S �
1�1Zd l�� %Z � .
F �G, �/� � `L Q� � / i' C� i% � � � / !� L��
Ce N G` C� �,G J� v'�. GL G ,
U � , S �-�-� � y ���; �
1;�, �I� �� , �
�v'� � , �- yIOJS .
. , 1,��5 �� `� /Z ! � � �' �s �
(�ol� �� � � � /� /�IGL 5 �
� ,� !.e s �S
` Gr,Y t°1�� f.2 5! 12 � lL °�—, S G Lc p 0`
�lZr � � e����- � `��� �` v
� -� � ! � �-s l
�� r
� �y oc�� c� � .�
C'J/'I'd'� �' aT�`'�% r
� �
J t
'� �,,� d t� o t^- Y� Q� I h �,� Z S
�--�'� y .� , �
s� l��j' � j%l ��ti'� � �� %��� �� G� �! 5 � C� vt ,
( � �
Cn����
%�a� � � a �� �� �
� c��l1 c�.. 1'JLo y t..� ��cr-j'L
`�'� a-�/ � � !�
C�� �5�
�-��� ��� �v�v ��,•..
� ,c /� 1
'C�12-Ut� �y � `/ � ��i � �Z.c-f
�J
�
. �� f �"�- �—''" �
a =�J�
C� a ?J �,� �-�-� o � �'
^
�
�����"�
� ; r� ,�� � �� ,
�,������,,
���� �� �T�i�►�,�
���Y��, �, ,,,,,,,,,��� � 2� 5�9. Ti��� ��r��t, Itha�a, N.`r'. 14�350
�� '��� w�wr�v.tc�wn.i�l���;�.�iy.�,�s
Tawr� S���aervisar (�D7} 273-�721, Ext 125 ; rl�r� r�r��m��k,r��rcu.it�i��ca ny.�i��
T�7WN' GLERK (6p7) 273-1721 PUBLIC Wt}RKS (fad?j 273-1656 ENGINEERING (607) 273-1747
PL/�,NNINC� (607j 273-174i ZC7NING (607) 273-1783
FAX (C��17j 273-17t14
�'V`Ti��' ��, �(� � �
Rc���re�`t �V. V���at�lc;�
l 1 I �31��ckstc���� �w��;nci�:
ICI�ac��, I�fY � ��S(�
I�e,��r Mi•. Vci�a��le:�:
"C"k�aa�k yc��a i'c��� yc��.ix� ]c;tt��- c�t� ��zy '? tc� kl�� ']"c���m �3c:rax�c� r���l ��1�cr T�"ow°��. �f Itl��ac� c��ii�i�als,
Yc��i �arcavic�c�c� �,x'Gat ita�c�r��r��tic��� tl���t a��rrYcla; c1r�c�utssit�e�s tivitll "�"c�w�� s��ff �nd ai����n�; I�cr�rcl
i�1c�n�acr•5 ��r�n�luctfvc�.
,�,�,„,. VV� �3�;a-c�e t11�1t t17� �v�c���e;L-ty ix� c�lr�.5ti�-�c� i�; �►r���s�z�l. Cv�:n tltic��i�h �'o4vn law a1�c�r�s a
sc;c��r7c14k���% ������a�t���r�i�t �v1��;7�a; �l�ui°� is a�arimat•y rc:sadcn��:, tl�is �l-�•ai�r�;ernei�t is ccrtai�ly t�c�t
iy�ical. f-[c�wcv�.r, we; c�ti� ��c�t ��r�c� ��i�y �act�t��1 vac�latic�n c�ti Tc�w�z �c�c�e. It is �sea�•fly
�n��a�as��%Ce, tc� �vrit�. ]E�:w� tll�rt �:c�ve�° �►11 c�ve��t��aluti�;s ��i�c� ti��is ��g�e�rs to be an�.
Y�a�.t I���ve; c!<:]i�c a y�►-vic;� 1ay ��l�.rtit��, r.�� t1a tl�i:� �;xttin��l€� �iritf we �vrlll �tter��pt tc� �:vuic#
{��Zc�tl��.r sfi-�ail��r 5it�.��tkic��� f��r�r�a c1�v�;lc��it��. 1-lc��ve;v�;��, wc cai� nr�t ta@ce at�y actiol� a�c�i�l�fi
t���:� fl�at�ti�:tu14�Y- prc�p�r-ty.
Sinc,�.t°c;ly,
�
� � a���
w..
�° w
� ,, .������,_w. _
. ��.�
�
c.r�e�-t .�. �'`�17ir����a
�'�����t� �t�p�v�s���
Pub���rks
Catn�lai:nt Fe�rm
��_.�_�..��,...�....�_.�.�_..,�.,�._.,��,,_�..�..._,__
-�,.. - -.. ,� .� _ �. .. ...� �, �... _ �. _ �. .. .�. �
u�a�»,� _ �
� Ta b� �iYi�c� ��� ��r ���i Tak��� r
r i
� L7�i�': .�� �'1221.�: � G'. � tJ �Cl����. ��jA: � �
� t
� �
a �azr��l�iz�t N�n��: _ �_ ���-��, .Address: �I'._ �iv��..! �
a ��
� e
a — �
I �'�3oa�e Pht�x-��: � '%� �' (� d�' �a � A
�+Taz�C P�a�ne:
� I'zo�r�er�r; �'.:S � ��s u.{�' �,� f' �C..�15 P�NN 1..s1N� ht t� PK6 . ,S i � � �
i� � i �1'-q �'�� �'�a.r"-,$ �c�r-1G.�';�t a
� .�'cZ.... �f���l� c��i �y`c��s a� �. r��r�r�'_�....t�s�..���.��_�� �..,,_�'� �
I a� '�,�a�5 �r� c�s c�,rs �,� �pa�-lc�d r�" ��- �.� --f� �srrr�er,�, r�'� t��s;�,;�'
� ,-�. �
� � � .����c.� �1�_�.v� �r���r...��..�..�� �� ���.-� �
�� � ��r� w,�
r �'!t � Y"! .:5�, �"'�'�'� ``� �" �p �aJ �"1 ! /'� i '�'i' ct."t7 .�t� `P/'y C3 � a✓* ,� � ,v� ' ` Y�' t� �'S "��` -'�Ci �
� -..��..�� �___�'��i n w_ _�,�,,�,,. �..."�,�� `"� � r
° ����'�' CC�77�17r^l . ,�� �..° Gu't./ _"`"7 k� — - _��.�� .�..e�.�.._.—f'�-..."�� ,
J � ..,
� l� �.:4` .��_�!�'M �� �/`Yt�./t �'rra�'n '}iJ � ��` C.111 �� +��. � C,�� ,
° °�'���•e `��7 ��'��.��_..�.£�Gc..l.. �L
� f 1 ��' ,� �'r� ►� �? �`h Z? ..�'��ti.,► ,� n�a `r . ���� �7 ���'�µ�c_ _
�- _ ..._ _ ._. _ ' .. _ .. � _ ._. _ .._ .. .,,.. _ .,.. _ �.., ,� .� _ .�. � ,_. _ .�.,.. �. ..�.. .. � .�
To �e �xliecl ix� �y Su�u+�rv���r
��y�y
�ric�xity: _�. ��.) �n��:r��ncy c��, (�) Re�u�ar Assigz�cci to� �(
� �lz�c�: Irtax af cc �Nnr�'c ���c�e�• ya���s t�a b� ���ze�����t�.
j �ol�cfi���di���y�,��i���ec�€c��'ersa�i....,._,�__,____.._.�..._�_.._.e_.._.__.�...__�,�_._..___�____,�.�.�,_�
: I
� _l\.��'i)1'�%�l,L� _. . �A � �� P4 , re
� � 1
j �tn lr� �c c��ai�a: �:c�uipir��nL: 1VT�t��.�ia1;�: �
� �
� � _.�. __ �.�' �- �.�+�`�� �.��C'Z�_�_.��a��.� �
" � i
! �� c�'--��-� _�.���.���..._�E'�� �f? l� -1 a�' �� '
,
'��_ � C
. .�µ_-�-��-�-,-�.-�_...�......�,.._______,.....___...._____..�__..___.�__�,.__.._.,.,.___.__�.......�...____.,�,'s
,,�,,,,.
CARL �. �`C�RC3� P.E.
REGI+��fAL C�1Ft�.CTC7R
�✓1r, T��er��rt E��;�taaa.
�u��rvr��r, "C�r�r� c���:tlaaca
2 � 5 �carth `�'c��a Stre�et
ltl�aca, �f�wr �sl�atk 1485�1
���r'�Vtir. �i��;nian:
,,
�� ��"�r
�` `"�4t"'
� �''A .�
���` *'F
f p ��A 4 vl.b.6i19� .. ..
a � �.,
� "'�' • " `�"`' ` ,�
. i i
� � � �
�� �
wM ••
J11i1� �7, ��� G
JOAN 1+�GDCMC�ALt�
COM�VUSSIC7Q��R
1�.�;: l'�1RI�I1'�� 1��i F��JUTI� 7�
,����,,e
T�tis� �s i�� r���r�rrs� t+a y���' 1'��lay 31 e-��ai1 t�r} b���a�t �a�'Nfa�col� Tht�rnas re�ar�in�
p�r�i�� c��a i�.c���te 7� near the ��rnrr�anl�r�d�. � tiarra��l in�esti�aticrn wi11 �e caradut�ted at �he
subj�;�t l��atran. W� r�a�rm�il�y respect th� wish�s� c�f�C'c�wri �trd "V�l���;e c�f`f�ici�ls r����c�in�;
�arki�� restr�ctic�r�s, but tt�er� �r� co�rs���aenc�s that m�.ast l�c t�ken �nta crrns�d�r�tio�►. A nc�
parki�� r�s�rict��t� ap�l��s tc� a11 �r�h�cles. Pr°���it�itin� �aar�k���,� cac� th�s sectic��� af Rc��te 7� �rill
rem«�ve p�rkec� c�.rs frar� th� �houl�er, t��at i� �zl� �lso �r<���ik��� resid�nts fr�rr� parki�� in frc�r�t aE'
t��'tr h�¢�ne�. This r�aill likel� �e a�t i��ue vratk► �re� r-�;;i�ent� t��t the �a� rr��st b� r���i:y tca
�dcir���.
I'1��� ��nsid�r tfl�� aba�ae ar�d ad�is� �fi}�� �"�wwn �;� ir� %�or ofa pa.r�i��; r�st�ic�ic�� a�qd
�he �a}��arca�imat�. lir��ts desire�. Yc�ur it�te���i in tltis �a�atter is �r��t�y ap�reciat�d.
V�ry truly yc�ur:s,
/ /
k � � � �
��, �������f ✓° �f.,��'r� �,��_.� �d.,.�"" .�w�l,��'�.,...-
17I A:1`� �, I.�. GR.��:F�, F. E.
�.��;ic�nal 7'raf�i� En�ineer
„����,,.
C�,RL �. 1=b�C�, F�,�..
REGtE7N'l�,L DIR'�CTaR
,i l..
4 � ,� �
rr � 4
��k�, ti����r
� Y��YM %e�.
} �,.; wF
�d
A',�;V'�'tYb1P,'� ," '
��f'i�{... �� �`e��r/v ����.
C:��I'A�l�"�t�1�C'JT f�� �'"F�A�15iC,)'R1'P;T�k�'�'
f�CGIa�J �
3�3 �AST'Wti�,�"�SH'IP��T�IV STRE��"
�Y�F�CU��, I�Y 132a�
�n�^r.dat.m+�.gav
.1tzr�� fi, 2(i��
ivts. T��br-� �t�ttca», �la��a��r
C���aa�c�t��at�d C�tnrr�uenity I�.��i€��r�:ts �,�sc�ci�tia�i
�. O. �c�x 694
Iti�ac�,l�Jew 'Y'c���k 14#�S ]
�tear I�s. �t�ttan:
iy
�'' r ' d
/ . y %i
YI I ��Nd.,l ����
w4 , / V
0 ��.,d� ! (w/ .�.� 1 � �~�i���
,�QAN i�,C[�Uh�Af.f�
CUMVPvNISSIC)hl�R
ii�=�: P,hIt.i�il�T� d�N �,.Q�U"I"C 79
Tl��nlr ya�u far y����' Ju���; I��tt��• ��qu�stit��; ��a�r�i�a� prat��l�itac�n c�n l�.c�uie 7� at th� I�t�is
L,aa��, �nfir��rc� t�a Cart7tra�n��nci ('c��a�mut�'tt:y. W� rc�c��itl� i�itiat�cl ��e �nv�sti�;�t��r� �,t �his
I�c�tior� i�l res�acat��e tc� � l�ttet• ��•a��� Ilk�ac�a �'c�wx� ��p���vist��' I�er�r��t Es����a��. "Y"c�u�- c�nce�-ns
will l�e ��ket� i��i:� s�cat�s�ci�;a-E�t,i��� c�ur�3n�; �ur� is��ve�ti�;�tic�r�. Upan co�n}alet�ai� c�fth� irrv�sti���ie�r�,
y�u vv�11 ��e ��cati�ied ca�'th� res�Alt.s �tad our ti�t�rr��in�tic��r. P�e�se b� �wa�-e that aur r�vi��+
r�cpuii•es ��f�ic:i�nt ��1� irav�sti��tac�n �r�d «��lalysis tc� �ss�.��-� a�arop�r r�spai�se.
�a�ar ixate��csti �a� tl�is r��tt�r i , �re��l� ����a-eci�ter�.
V�ry ir�z�y y�urs,
������ '��:�. ����,���m�� ���`
���°�� �,W ����'"����
�7A�.� �.,. ��.����, �. �.
I�,�,�,�r�r��l 'I'r�ific �,n�;ineer
��: �-�. �I. �;���t������, �'a,����e���vi�+���, ..�'r�wt� taf" [t�1��.��x �,� ..�.m. _ .a����
s�.iz-�y'
Commonland Community Residents Association
c% Debra Statton, Manager
�! PO Box 694
Ithaca, New York 14851
June 1, 2012
Diana Graser
333 East Washington Street
Syracuse, New York 13202
Dear Ms. Graser,
I am writing to you at the recammendation of Fred Morrison of the state Highway
Department, with whom I spoke two days ago about the new, dangerous situation at the
Lois Lane entrance to Commonland Community on Route 79 in Ithaca.
Commonland abuts the Six Mile Creek Natural Area and the Upper and Lower
Reservoirs, which draw people from far and wide for nude gay bathing and cliff jumping.
Googling eitlzer of these phrases results in glowing testimonials from swimmers across
the state who flock to the Reservoirs.
As a result, Penny Lane in Commonland in recent years has been overwhelmed with
�"`� swimmers' cars parking at the head of the trail into the gorge, to the goint where 75% of
the 118 residents on the road petitioned the Town of Ithaca to ban parking on the road
May-September yearly. The petition was approved and signs were posted May 1, and
since then hundreds of cars each warm afternoon have moved from Penny Lane onto the
shoulders of Route 79 just outside Commonland.
I am writing to ask for signage to protect the entrance to Commonland because the cars park
so close to the entrance that residents cannot see to pull out onto Route 79, a very busv road
with a 45 mile/hour speed limit there. The parked cars not only cut off visibility but block the
bus stop nearby so that the TCAT bus cannot pull over to pick up riders. Residents aze very
worried about the likelihood of an accident there any day now.
Is it possible to get signage banning parking for 50 feet either side of the Commonland
entrance at Lois Lane? This would keep the bus stop there open as well.
I appreciate your consideration of this request.
Sincerely,
Debra Statton
r""� Manager
607-277-1368
fih�ftl� uef� ivec�;
tY � Iw��lllty
�uN o � zo�2
ro: CL�--�,C
Ex � s7�N 6 c�s�
�,2�,�y
1�w�./" � I'V � 1� I 1� i"'i �.✓ /"+►
�15 �J. Tiag� Stre�t, �th�ca, �J.1r'. 14��C�
�,�ww.tt�w��.it�,aca.ny.us
To�wrr Sup�rvisor (�a7) 273-1721, Ext 125 , N�En�ir�aru�)rr��+r�.ui9i a� ��:o?y..�i;�
TQWPJ CLERK (fiQ7} 2,73-1721 F'UBLIC VW�F�KS (6�7) �73-1658 E�JGIi�EERB�VG (6t}7} 273-1747
��.,�r�Nir�� ��a�) z�3-1 aa7 zor�inaG Cso�� 2��-� �ss
��x �sca�7 2�s-� �a�+
.l�zn�. 1 1, 2012
Ms. Jc��c7 Lcar��;sclo�f
15() �ifl1c� T"re� C���cl
�t�tklc;��, t`�1�'' 1 ���(�
L7e��i- I�l;�. I.t�fll�;sdo�-f�:.
Thank ����i fr�r �c��ar lc:ttc�r' r��;�uY-cii��� �7'rzi�fic c�t� �'�r�G °Tree I���ac�. I'ic7c: �I c-�.c� Rc����6 is �t Ce��tt�ty
���a��c�, s�7 � l�ave t�aken �l�c� lit�c�7•ty �t`����si��,� yc�ur let:tet• al�����; t�� Nf����t��t� I�€��aez-ts�at�, Cllair
r�t t17� C`��utlty L��isl�zt��7•c�.
"44"�; in t�1� 1 r�wvi� l�e���- cro1`c�����:c;�-s�� �l�c�e�t i��cre�a�ec�l t�-af�fic f��c��t� Gal� dr�•�;��:� caf�t➢��: rE'ow�� ��
�t��4�ca. It sccrns tc� be +��Zc� c�f tl��, �l�.�r�tiv�s o�`tl�e �r►a�l�.st,, l��zi �:c�n��7-����ci �:c�-���c��l�ic �r�r�v�1�
�„�„�, t�1't��c itl��t��� a��;�. Tlze "i"tnv�l c�t�c;� r�c�t l��zv�; t���. c-i�;�7t te� z-�st�-ic;t tr��dck r}d������ c�ther ty�ae af
tr��ftic fg-c�i�i tl�� ���l�li� �•c�aciw�ay�. �����us�: c�fcaud- unir.�u� �;e,c��;r�����y, ��xitl� �;c�iµ��;s a�sd ste�p
l�ills, ���ic�iti�rial c°o�c�s �e��xl 1�a�l�ly u��like:ly� At ���c Tc��vn l�:�xc➢ vv� ar•c t�•yi��� t� ��iti�;at�
i11�; �t�c�hl�:tn� r��r�tl� a fc�ctas �m irrcrc�iwecl �lc�r�sity c�f`cicve����t��rt;ttt iHl_�u:;t u�'t���✓ al-�as c��`�1��
"I��a4v�� sca t17at bus s�rvic�;, ��,falkw��y:� ar�cl ���fe k�i�i1��; �;�il tac irn�r-c�v�;d.
�vVc; �c��e; uw����lly �a�er l� su�7f�c�rt �-�.c��ic�;c� �;��c��i lii-�it� ��n� d��l��;c� t�-��1'ii� �aln�i�7� incas��re�,
My u,tt�ci�r��an�iiil� is �lyt�t tk�cr•c� i:� a��c;titio�� c�it`eul�atin� ii� thc Pin� Tr�� Rcaac�
7��i�l���c�i•��cacad, T l�clieve tl�c'f'��wa� ��r�ei C oua�ty will bc s���apc�r•Civ� �3t7c1 wr11 �a�k klaat tl�e
Stt�tc; (w��ich k7a5 tl�G aittl��:�r��y lc� �c�l�ttrcal s�j�Lei liinits) reci���;e tl�t� �;�ie.c;�] limit can [?inc� T�'e�.
������c�.
"�w-'i <��-� c��,�:r to 11�:��r• c�f an� c�t}��:t• ��r�;��..�ti��1s tc, irn�Il•c�v� tl��. c���4r14iy �a�'li��; i1� c���r
r��;i�,���cal-��ac�c�s.
`��z�ccrcly,
1-��Y-l�crt J. Ea��7na1�
.I..c7wr� S�a�����vi�p��.
�9���v..
{ y 7 yi
k�,,::r� ( °d � . I .�° �,.E"'�.1Y?
liJk.� ���'i�`�k6laN,�X 4� �,.e�.lf�a,
r I„t.�..a... _nt'�o �) �. .<x. �� .F(�i
J�ne 11, 2t�12
Tc�+�rrro Of Ithaca
2�S Narfi�O Tira�� 5treefi
Ith�aca, New �carVc 1485(�
Attn: Tovvn Clerk
�.
b �"4,. �' �.
a `"y
�l
�,{
6�RP � � j
s
/ � "
� . J^� i
(.) .. �l
i � �,
"" �, (, I' r` ` ,, ,� �'
� �r
(''
i
PV9y ru�r-�e is Ficrbert Nfa�tin and P Foave prope�lty t��� I r�,rill b�e p��at�in� up �car sa�l� uan Sr�u�h Hifl a� t��c erud
of Per�n�ylv�ni� Avenue and Ker�daN�' A,uenu� io� the tc�vun of Itl�a�a. All utiGitnes are �Ir�eady available and'
the pr�p�wty is access6ble. I have encNased a m�p with th�e pr�pertie� h�ghligt�ted in €�range.
Vnterest�d praspects �c�r the purchas� aF fihe prr�pe�y have been R�an Ror�suale c�f M��rit�ge P�rk
Townhcauses, ar�d Orl�mdra Ia�c�v�INi wvho �wns numerr�aas erther praap�cties in th� area. �ic�th p�rt"r�s hav�
,���„�°< v�riced 1�he�ur ���once�rrrs ta me �ru regarc�s ta th�� prabler�os ar�d unar�swec�ed qu�est�or�s t'�ey �re havara� with
the ��vxrn. 5om� �rf their co�ncerns ar-e: v�riUl they be ab�e to nbt�in t�e roe�cessa� bu�iading perrm�ts for
develapmerat, wifd the tav�+n ��►ild the prapased �dd"uti�n tm Peransyfvania Avenue ar +ruwll perr-�issican b�
giver� te� th� dewel�p�r tca ea�tenr� the rc�ad a� their cflst?
I wurauld appreciate a lett�r frorru the tae�rrt o� Ithaca answerin� th� above questions an�V a�ferin� �ny
curc���k in�armatiern th�y w�uld h�ve on the develapr�ent �af this area. Tl�os wa�ld gr�atly assi�t r�e in
praviding the prosp�ctave b��y�ers with a�sw�rs pr�ar ta therr� ma&car�g me an �ffer� ar�d savir�g a�c�t c�f
unnecessary ca�lls te� �h� tawn c��F���, d h�ve already d6sca�ssed Chis m�tter vwith Bru�� B�tes 6n t�u� office
and �n+�u�d dee�ly appareciate ar�y ccansEdera�i�n yc�u car� off�ee �a me c�ru tho� mat�er. �eel fr�e tc� ccantaaci
me sht��ld yau hav� ar�y furt�rer q�a�stir�ns. I earr be �-eached �t (6�7) 272-A�773
Thank yau in advance.
Respe�tft,ulVy,
��W�' ��'� �"��.v"��+��. R �w , ..,.�"
�
i�Q�]E'C"t 1�1/YI�6'CICI
�r,�UMNY�N��..
�t
4'L� v
��
�� ��
�ti' �
s �
�S,
r
�`�a
��. �
� �a
r �`� � � � �
� `' s `":�;. ,."�
5`� ���
� ;�E g�
� �'`
f� ����W � ��I
��
c.x'a � ����" f �
�, T' r � f�%�
`.�� � �ht ca`� / fI� i�/� d/ /
t+" ��,1 �i� � � �i 1
� / �%� /ii %/%//%/r�
ta �' �� / i// �/�i����f
`� � �ii/
��� rl � �� 1��/i/�%�ria / i j� j%
� ''� � i �i/� Gi ��i � i
+n s' �} '� � �/�j/iji� j !�%%/o/O%%//� ,
� �"t �,.. , � �i/ ��/„ � �a
❑�
323 s
c� � �
12 fi' s
�
C� J(� � � _'i -'1
c r �
�21 s
r
m `�
� �
� �, .. � � �
�� �
,, �
Q �/,/////i�>i/� ;e �ii���i%%%f' �
�,--� ,�, ir,�� �//�J ;�J ,,;;% � � -�
� h � � !���p � i � � �i i /,9 / ,.
s,c�t+ � "W %��l ��ff 1���� l�/�!/l��%//(/lt���� � t'' I ����%%n���//������ �
[ h Ol �%f %/i/ i / i �� � /�%///��/�i'J//��
: /r ,�io/,ifif �J/ / i�,/ �% D%�
� ��������/� � � ��%/////////ri/oI%i/%/pi/i%�� ;
/ f/l� ��� i /// //
,' I �%� ��i�m �%/i//J � ., � i i ii %
� � IG/i/�r//%/ � // ��%�
°� 1/1////////%%/i�� i -
�r ��'��ii � �
�,� , / ` � / j%//////�/%/r�%�//%!/f`i% f/ ;
(� `n � t �Fio%%ii/%/`�%%%�//%j� ' � . .i =
� � b J i i i /� '/I/////%/,/��/li///%/�/////
z4 � � i %i�%%�i/%%%�'�/��i � � I �ii // � i� � �
�`+✓ � � � r�J,�� � �9 iii/�i��l � ,�- l�%i%i/i���/%��� � ..�:
�'v M 1 1 , � ii '
��� ,v � �� ,�.. �, �/%/iii/%�'�%l�/Or�i ,
�, ,liijri/f�/B �i//O/////%%%/% r � �j�,�' �ii���/
��� ' �,� � ✓�Ir`/1lriii�//%��//////�/�/rr�l%:
L `x ; i / / �///��%%iii "�"l3da! �� �� _
Ly "���� % � � , � % �� �� r���0�%� <;
�/�/%/%i%r����/���%//'�j H `, /f f �%y � %//; /� ��
N , ,� _ �„� <,, r � ��ii /,
�y /`r%���ii����������i%%%O/,� -; �2a s
,
� ,�" > G c�� �? � ��% �i�ii�pf%///'�ifo,%i/�'�ii �%i _.
p�
t"''� � �7 %i ��� �� � ,i o/,��i i !l'i���; �
m �
� � '�5(J s cr� � �' �r
. +�� � � �, c�
ca ^v '�n �^"% '.
.5�;,��I[ � � _"..�.__.... . . ..
. �a __""__""_' � *-
� (� -'-`_- T-�a
a�� r7
� � � T
ery
� � c�u
��l1 uy C'___.._Q'�--.-_------ 121 5 rv
r.
�
5 B�' n
d79 � 1, 24 : � �,
�'� � _-_ ----� �;`---� --�- ,
�ay -�-^-- �;
C7 ,�, � � �" ,�v J
� � s ��
� ���c - � �20 �
� ��
� � P�C7 53.-'h'.a �
w �c--
c� � 113s 12(1s
a
xz
`'' �€"r �' �C�! �, � v,
i � �,. v�i r`" � '^`-�� � �,,,� � C'�J
C`tiJ `^ s'� �� '�" ------"------
N � G'F`( i� � v qC� � �,
Ql v ;u
� � th � 4 ff� ,�'� � „°' ? � � •-
"� . , � ..,..,
FOREST HOME IMPROVEMENT ASSOCIATION
Ithaca, New York
To: Ithaca Town Board
From: Forest Home Improvement Association
Subject: Fraposal for a small parlc in Forest Home
Date: June 12, 2012
The Forest Home Improvement Association (FHIA) is pleased to submit a proposal in
support oE a small parlt at the intersection of Forest Home Drive and Pleasant Grove Road.
Our understanding is that the Cornell Plantations is interested in leasing the vacant land at
this locaCion to the Town of Ithaca. Forest Home endorses the concept of the lease, and is
enthusiastic about creating a small park in that location.
Forest Home residents have a variety of ideas and visions for the proposed park—some of
which are touched on very briefly in the propasal. The breadth and number of ideas
residents submitted to the FHIA clearly demonstrates a high level of support for creating a
small park.
With submission of this proposal, the FHIA envisions two interrelated next steps:
• First, we hope the Town of Ifihaca will seriously explore the possibility of leasing the
land under discussion from the Cornell Plantations.
�'^` • Secondly, assuming the lease happens, we hope the Town of Ithaca will engage the
residents of Forest Home in creative conversation and discussion about features
�
desired in the small park. The FH[A is more than willing to support an opportunity
for community feedback and discussion with the Town by circulating
announcements, securing a venue for discussion, etc.
Thank you for considering our proposal as you explore possible lease of the Cornell
Plantations land. Forest Home is fully supportive of Eurther investigation and development
of a park. Please feel free to contact us at foresthomenews@gmail.com if we can answer
questions or provide additional information.
Regards
Teresa Craighead, President, FHIA
Cc
Christina Leuenberger, Vice-President, FHIA
Ari Lavine, Secretary, FHIA
William Arms, Treasurer, FHIA
Jon Miller, Immediate Past President, FHIA
www.fhia.or� I forasthomanews@�mai[.com
Proposal for Forest Home Park
Praposal: Accept a long-term lease from the Cornell Plantations for the vacant parcel at the intersection
of Pleasant Grove Rd. and Forest Home Dr., and create a small park there.
Batkground: At the October 2011 Forest Home Improvement Association Annual Meeting, Ithaca Town
Supervisor and Forest Home resident Herb Engman indicated that Cornell Plantations is interested in
offering a long-term lease to the Town of Ithaca for the vacant land at the corner of Forest Home Drive
and Pleasant Grove Road. Herb indicated a Forest Home proposal for using the land might usefully
contribute to the Town's thinking about whether or not to accept the lease from Cornell.
Accordingly, a working group from Forest Home came up with several ideas for how the community
might use the parcel. Subsequently, Herb told us that it would be best if Forest Home put forth a single
concept, to make it easier for the Town to consider the lease offer. A basic proposal was prepared and
offered to the community of Forest Home for comment. The proposal offered to the Town, below,
attempts to balance and be inclusive of a variety of community comments that reflect the many
approaches and uses individuals envision.
Proposed concept: Create a small park with these features:
/"�
• Benches situated to enjoy a view of the creek and also placed in other locations. �
• A break in the existing fence to make it clear that the area is intended for use.
• Natural, native, low-maintenance landscaping.*
• Paths.*
• An open area for occasional Forest Home gatherings.* Note: because there are concerns about
the impact of Stream Setback legislation on maintaining an open area that requires mowing and
because we need to balance the need for an open area with naturalistic plantings, careful
decisions about type of grass(es) and discussion about mowing �s. not mowing is suggested.
• Attention to accessibility for wheelchairs, strollers, and people who use aids like walkers and
c�nes: at least some benches situated so that a wheelchair or stroller can be roll up next to
them.
*Landscaping, path materials, and open-area materials and maintenance plans should satisfy a variety of
interests: accessibility; views; a naturalistic, low-maintenance setting and the flexi6ility to use the park
for gatherings, play, gardening and walking as well as for individual enjoyment and as a wildlife habitat.
Next step: Because the proposed small park has sparked interest among Forest Home residents and
because there are a variety of visions, Forest Home requests design consultations with the Town in the
event a park is approved for the parcel. The Forest Home Improvement Association is available to assist ^
in scheduling community comment and conversation sessions with Town designers. ,
u.,
,,,,,Y�,� ��., �,�.. .,� �� ' ,.w. � . ' �.
�,���,,, �. �� ,� �����:���
_.�..� ������ � � ,��
I"; F�,": da'f. I F' I E:. ��� f- l.! 6J 1. t�. L"; �^, V":; I,:; C'::i I,.Y P�J'T,'i h a f' `..:�
Et GO "'.�v k tl•�! L 3 i'.,� C:I ��� °a 4..R 0._u"�.�, h��# "k" �S
11'��)l'��'��fi�fl���`�"1� A(.`('()l,l"�'T��N'�w�',., ��.1�;�7(��i�" ��i"�
A1't"�.Ji'�i'�1+C� r�,Cxit[�A�+;�)-�.rl'(.�;�t 1'�tt9CvY�;���Pl�l�,`�
.Itli�� fl<�, 2()1'�
`T�h�, `�"���;�_�� t�l�� Iti�7aca w��t�ci t�f�l�ic�� ��l �+t4itr i."��ii���rc�'Ilc:�e.
B��r���cl.� �ri�.l�r��ti�e C'cat��•t ���'������a�
�"��"�; 1�{�v�: ���1-fc��-m�cl tJi� }3ro�;�c1����L� �r���r��er��C�:ti ii� tl�� ri��tr���ed s�;1�u�lail�, r�11�c1� ��'�t-�
"""'"� a�.���c�c� tc� k�e' 11-�� �'�a��r� ��l` CtI�K�c�<� a��ci �)lfi��; i��' �t�zl� C'c7i�7�3tr-call�:r I3ure��u ��r1'.1e,t�ti�e C`�atr��t I•'t�r7�1.
s��l�l�° ��� �r:��i�t vc�t� ��iti� i�c�����:t tr� �llc� �a�c�7����ti��;x ��ecu�°ci� c�l'tl�� "Cryu�;�� .T�d�,ti��ti ��i' C17�:, '1"iya��n ��1.
Itllt�c;�l ���z� ti�i: ti��t�t� L7�c.l��( ➢��ce:¢lah�.�� ?�, �"(7� 1. �I�l��:� �;a�c�Q�{��t��Gl�t tc� al��,l� t���r�eci-u��aci��
��"'", ������"' ��r�a�;�.����ir���; ������ ���rt:�m�i�7��i il� ��c��a�ciatic�: ��it�z s�t�x�-���[t�.��ci� ��t�:�l�li�l���i ls}�� t17� ��a��ric���� ta�:�ti��ttc e:�l,
(:ec•ii�i��:l �'�a&�lic� ��ccc>�xa������t�. T�t�e s���'ficici�c� c�1` t���: prcic�cl�i���5 i� sc�l�l�� tl��: �•es�c�rlsil�ility� ��!'
tl�� s�a��ii�cc� lxs�rs cal` tl�� c��°}�r�r't. 4�'car��ec1G«���ly, wu �a�scic� tx�� z��.���•�:s���t�itic�n r�:.<�Tarcii��� tl�e;
`� �uf'l�c.i�r��v c�fr tl7e ����c���;cltzr��4 ci�:;�;r•il��c� �ytk���� �'��t• tl�� ���t�•�a�a:�� t�l• �n-1�ie1� 1��i� a'c��c:>rt 11��� ��c��t1
r-e:c��ac:�;t�c� c>r• I:c��� ��a�ti� �fiher ���u-pc���.
(:}��r ����c�a:cc�u�•�:; r�r�cl ��nciilzt7�; ��:���: 5�����x���.�r-il��i c�a� r��� tr�tG�cl�cc� �7���a�. a�l�sc� ��ttac;l���� i5 ��
sa:�t���1�wu��' i71���cti��it�� i`c7r tla� "i.�a����� J�d:�tici::;.
���
��,'c ����'c: nc7t �i���rtt���.� ���. �l�cl �lri! ��c�i. �7�t�lc�t•t�1 �ar� Af�t�lit. tl�� c��j�ctiv� �ai`E�I�ic1l ti�s:��i��i 1��.
tl�e �:r0��°�5�;ii;��1 c,i���� �7���r�ic��a �ao� �1��: ���e�:ifi�.�ci Ll�i��i�nc,. �i��cc:�lue�t:�, c]r it��»�;. r��:c.°c�rcli3�<�1�°. r�c c:i�>
����
ixt:�t ���ar�:�:� �t��:h �r�7 o��i��ic:?��. l l��il ��c: ��r:,a•li�r�:�i�ci �zaI�iiti��i�tt@ ����r�c:�:citares, t��l7li- r7aa�tt�r� zni{�ht k��r�°�
cc3»i� tc� c�l�r rrltc��ti�ji� tl�r�t �vc��il�1 har'�: f��a:�� t•�����aRt�c� ic� �%t�tb.
,yp,�� .l"➢7i� r�}ac�ri i� ini�n�l�c� salcl� l«r t��e ir�� �1:� thc :��7�cifi�cl �rs�t';� �i�t�°cl ;;tk�c7��e �r���i �17ut:ilcl
ru�� l7� i��;l�:l I�y tl�c��c: �r.�llca 17���� ��r7t �z����u�cl tc� �hc ��1���c���It���c:5 ��z�c� t�fll,:�i� r�;��c�»si��ilit�� f���• �17�.
stt(��i�ii:�t�:� cr�'tl�� �,�'t��:�;dtk¢��:� f�c�r t17a�iz- ��r�r����cr5�5.
. � . �
� �"� � ��� ���. � � �
� �
� �
'ti�i��s•�����,a �%�al9��r {� ('a�.. I.I..P
��l�,N B���a��,� 8��a�fl����m� `aC�rc�°��, ��o.a.g�:c ��J:� �<� C�f�;>r��:�z �✓Ta�i���� �k�a�rtr�9:
�d�utaw:.�a, I�Cr�v�wr��r'�rg-��, :I����'���i'N �'«�-�I���a�l, I�l�c��vv��'�e�fl�lc 1:�C�1��;
uwr��r
c���"7-�l� "�.::awa() / �,Q:D"7-,?7:'�-��,:� r�' ('�°`�,t�:) fi(�J_"l.��a-C�Oi,'i / �i�;1-.7 �fi,..(��9�� (�=<r.,�� ��r��r�,�+'.�c..s:�+°z��a�-��t�a�st�l�;�°u�.r:c�s�'a
� PROCEDURES:
TOWN OF ITHACA
AGREED UPON PRQCEDURES
l. Reviewed monthly bank reconciliations for unusual items and tied monthly checkbook
,., balances to bank statements.
2. Traced reconciling items appearing on period ending bank reconciliations to supporting
,� documentation.
�
�.,
�
3. Tested the daily receipts journal for mathematical accuracy.
4. Traced total fines, surcharges and miscellaneous fees to monthly report issued to New York
. Staxe Comptroller's Office.
S. Reviewed the monthly reports issued to the New York State Comptroller's Office for timely
filing.
6. Traced a sample of receipts from the cash receipts journal to the supporting receipt book
noiing proper dates, names and amownts.
7. Traced a sample of receipt transactions to the Office of State Comptroller� s Office by Justice
Court Fund monthly report_
�
8. Reviewed a sample of invoices from the New York State Connptroller's Office and payments
to the Town of Ithaca Chief Fiscal Officer by examining daily surnmary, cancelled checks,
^ and invoices.
9. Tra.ced a sample of tickets issued through the daily receipts journal, Justice Court Fund
"'' Report, carbon receipt and deposit slips.
10. Reviewed the bail account receipts and disbursements folder tracing a sample to bank
'� statements noting proper dates and amounts.
11. Traced a sample of bail amounts received to defendant file noting a carbon receipt and traced
`�" return or forfeiture of bond to corresponding check.
12. Traced a sample of three percent poundage amount on returned bauil money to cancelled
'� checks submitted to Town of Ithaca account.
^ 13. Identified year-end cash balances and determined if any funds should be remitted to New
York State.
'�'g
�
�
-2-
�
�
�
� FINDINGS:
1. All procedures listed above were performed for both Justices.
�-+ 2. As a result of our procedures we noted one receipt we could not locate support for among
those we examined for Justice Klein. Alternative procedures were performed to verify
that the associated funds were properly collected and deposited. Following alternative
�-+ procedures, we were satisfied that receipts are properly recorded.
3. We noted that the months of April and December had not been reconciled for the Bail and
�'+ Regular bank accounts for Justice Klein. This was brought to the attention of the clerk who
performed the December reconciliations during fieldwork. We reviewed the completed
December reconciliations and were satisfied they had been done correctly.
�
4. We noted a duplicate check and voided check error in the regular account register for 3ustice
Kiein. Check #1105 had been recorded as void, but we noted that the next two checks had
''' been recorded with a duplicate check number of #1106 and the voided check #1105 was not
present in the records. Per our review of the canceled checks on the bank statement, it was
discovered that one of the duplicate checks in�the register was #1105 and that the voided line
'�' item for #1105 in the register was incorrect.
5. We noted deposits for Justice Salk that had not been deposited within 72 hours due to the
'^'�' clerk being on vacation. Deposits for December 19`t' - 22"d were deposited on December 30,
2011.
�' 6. We noted one instance where the supporting documenta�ion for a receipt was labeled with a
duplicate receipt number for Justice Salk. The receipt was filed in the correct place in the
�
records for the actual receipt number.
-3-
�,
�
�
�
r,
r�
.^ r\
TOWN OF ITHACA
SUMMARY OF TOWN COURT ACTIVITY
Judge Judge
Klein Sa1k
CASES:
Nunriber of cases closed 1,809 788
Number of cases open 2,026 1,97I
Arrai�nent for other courts 14 25
Charges transferred to couniy court 10 11
TOTAL CASES 3,859 2,795
FINES AND FEES:
Criminal, motor vehicle $ 98,575 $ 47,365
Surcharges � 85,800 48,900
Civil 2,335 2,885
Bail poundage I35 120
ITHACA TOWN COURT COLLECTIONS $ 186,845 $ 99,2%�
BAIL RECEIVED $ 14,325 $ 12,�$�
�
CASH BALANCES:
Regular
r•, Bail
�
r�
n.�
P�1
�1
AGGREGATE NEW YORK STATE
JU5"�'ICE COURT REMITTANCE
$ 15,225 $ 9,200
5,215 11,315
$ 20,440 $ 20,515
$ 286,11�
-4- �
�
CONSTANCE BRUCE
878 Highland Road, [thaca, NY 14850
Tel: 607-592-5307
Bruce Bates
Director, Town Code Enforcement
Town Hall
215 North Tioga St
Ithaca, NY 14850
June 25, 2012
Dear Mr. Bates,
I am writing tc inquire about the applicability of the Town of Ithaca Noise
Ordinance to activities at the training and shooting range off Burns Road
maintained by the City of ithaca. Activities take place there at
unpredictable times, and regularly disturb the peace, quiet and enjoyment
of the surrounding Coddington Road neighborhood.
^ For example, on June 7�h, at around 10:30 AM, the firing of semi-automatic
weapons could be heard very loudly across the creek at 915 Coddington
Road, a property under sales contract. The semi-automatic gunfire went on
for 45 minutes or so, and was very disruptive and bewildering.
Making matters worse, when the City of Ithaca Police Department was
called to inquire about the allowed use and the schedule of the shooting
range, the caller was rebuffed and told that the City maintained no
schedule and that police officers and their designees could use the range
at any time, at their own discretion.
The Coddington Road area in the immediate vicinity of the shooting range
is zoned for low-density residential use and, as far as I can tell is protected
against noise nuisance by the Town of Ithaca Noise Ordinance. Constant
firing of guns echoing through the valley is a real nuisance. Moreover, in
the absence of any known schedule, the unpredictable nature of these
shooting episodes is upsetting and dismaying. The unexpected firing of
semi-automatic weapons for any period of time, let alone 45 minutes,
further devalues the quality of life for people who reside in a residential
neighborhood. ,
We called the Ithaca Police and the County Sheriff's office to find out more
� about the shooting range and what was going on there on the morning of
June 7th. While both confirmed that the shooting range is indeed made
available to Tompkins County law enforcement entities on a schedule
maintained by a coordinator within the City of Ithaca's police department,
neither was able to provide written documentation of the actual schedule
and regulations regarding the use of the shooting facility.
Given the noise produced by semi-automatic weapons, shouldn't the police
be required by the Town of Ithaca Noise Ordinance to acquire a noise
permit?
Over the years, the sound of gunfire could be heard periodically. While a
nuisance, we tolerated it in large part because of its occasional nature.
But, the incident on June 7th was particularly upsetting, and made much
worse by the lack of any information from the City regarding standards of
usage.
I look forward to hearing from you. Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
Constance Bruce
Cc: Paulette Terwilliger, Clerk, Town of Ithaca (Distribution all Town Reps)
Herb Engman, Supervisor, Town of Ithaca
Peter Stein, Tompkins County Legislature
Ari Lavine, Attorney, City of Ithaca
Edward Vallely, Police Chief, City of Ithaca
Kenneth Lansing, Sheriff, Tompkins County
� � �
P.C�. C3cr�: 35 • F�i°1will�, I"���wv Y��r•� �3�32 *(�3f1f)) 72�-�)�5'�� + I�t�x (315) 6��`�-�:31.1.
.iuly l0, `�G�12
�ra �t�7t��1 �': [:f��'�
���r. H�r•U 1:;���;r���rt�
Tc�wI� c��' Itk��tc�
21 � �'���til� "p"i���w� �t�•�.ei
It1�ac�, T�1�w Yc�i-1. 1��5f�
Re; Tii��� `wt���i-���,r C',�l�le �luclzt
I��;ar ��a�a�x'vi�;��t• I:�i��.n��n,
�1s yo�:� l���c�vv, �,��c'��� l��en l�irud by tl��, ,l'c�w�� t� ��r�:c�c•�1� �zn ����ciit c�f'yc�tirr cab1G t��evisie���
fi��nclzi�e Ka�;r�c�i3zc:nt ��vitl� T�t��� W���i��7•. (�r� May a, ?f�l?, we s���t � ls�ttut� t<a "["ir��e �Nartz�r
C���ble, r����►e�cit��, 6ia���acial i���c��•���a�t�c��� a�c;l�rted �e� �i•��r�ck�is� f:��; p�yi���nt� �i�t�ci� tca �1�e To��fa�u caf°
Ttl��c� �l�lr�z7�, tl�e p�st six ��e�31•�,. '�"� 1�4��re �°ecei��c�l f�°��i7c:��i�;c, fe� �a}�i���rrt c���czi �r�rx�i•in� t1�e timc;
}��r-i�d ii•���i .�1�7�wi1 ?�O6 tl�r�ru�,l� i�fi�a-cfl� ?f112. °��c�'�F� �•�;vi�vve�i �he ia���ar���atic��� ('i-oa1�t `I'in�r�
G�lai•r�er ��e�c1 t11is l�tter caiitains �� :����a����<i�-,� �fTour i�i�cii���s> c;c��lsi�ter7t ��it:f� c���a� ��}��t��;
�r���ver��tic�al ca�'�<�z�li�;r tc��a}r.
,��ry��y>. F'iz°st, a lit�le� l��zcl��rc��u7ci fln:#`ca�-li��:�ti���� z��;�<�:r•c.�in� fi�zzac9�i5�: i�a;s. L9ncie�� f�:�i�c4�l l��w, �x��a�xici�r�llitic:5
a�•e allca�7ecl tc7 cl��:��•�� t�•��a�c;l�ise l:� c5 ��1� tie� a m�l�ci�x��rt�� ��f� S�/� c7f` �r�ss i•ev�;����e�. 1-Ic����.vcr, j��st �y
i�7��aort�nt �s i17�. �crce¢ata�e is h�r� tl�c� tc�rz�� "�re�ss I��v�.��u��" �s def�n��. °I`@�c�z•� ��r� €enr�a h�a�ic
types a#`i•cvcr�uc� tl�at ar� el��;ik�l� 1`c�r i��cGusian i� t]�e, calc;t�l��tic�i� of�rc��s �•�:uc;��t�cs — sub�eritae�-
r�ve��ue �rr� a�c���-4����sei��bc�r �-ewt������. �L�k�scribcz• �-cvG���a�,, G�;� tl�� i��a�aL iz�pdi�;�, is r�-��de la� �9'
c,l�ar�c�� tl��t :�l���w aip c��l sti�sefl-i&i�z•s' ����r��ll�ly� �il�s. 1"�c�77-�inhscri��r i-�vr�rl�x� i� �7��de r.ip e�1:'
i��ec�rnc� `t`i���e; W���-ne:�• znal�:c,s fi�cnlx �i��; ca��et•atic�n t�1� tl�c; cable s}��tcnz in t1�c; "1`rawt� tli�t ci�es cxc�t.
shc�w ��}� c��� sul��;c�,il�e�� bills. 1,I�e lw�rca ��iaiz� cca��z�aca��cdi�Cs c�1` tl�is typc L�9'r�;vc1����. ar-c; inr�z�cy ���tzc�c
f'�-c�i�7 t1�� s��la r�1`lc�cal acl��ert��i��r� �����i ii:.�� dcrx�F�c3 fx•cai�l st�l�� c�l� l�cai��e; Sl�ra����in� ri�tw��k�,
TI�c;��efc�i��, tE'j� ma�ir��tzt�� all�i��ti�%l�c (i�<�z�c��ise fe.�; ��Pc��rlcl l�L �('�'� c�I'��lfl 5lib�c�•ik���• �i�d ���rxa-
subsc�ibei• �„�.v�;���re �Zl��c�e ii�c�tn th�: ��t°cx�i�ip�-� c�fica��lc tcl�:vi�;i��r� ��itl�i�� tlar, "I'c��.�Fn.
�1tl�a�i�la tl����� i5 a�ca �•e:��zi��e�a����t tc� i�����rc�se ���y c4��le �i•����cl�ise f�e, f�dc,l��rl 1��v� ancl I�ublic
Scr�vicc �`,�����nissi�a� (�'SC) rulc4 ac�cl���ss i0�� �iiii�iT���rr�� �cc��ai�-ei���nts if'a dreal�c�l�i�� Iee is
i���posec�, [.Ja�c��;�- l'SC' rules tl�ttz� �ov�.r��ci tl�e Taw��'s currc;rat i:raa�ck�isc� ��r•c��:���Li�t, if'�� I'rancl�as�
i'�e �,r�s ir���ca:;c�c�, it h�d ta ����aly t�� <�t le�5t all r�;��il<�r, �•�c:��rrit7� �r�a�z�tl�1}F �l�a����;s c��� �ul�sc�-iY��:�-
ta�11s. fW�cic�c��r➢ l�a,v �i1s� �llat�,��t;, ��l�f�c�ru��� it c�ca�s n�at r�cl�.aix-�, ��lalc cc�z��������i�� tc� �����;s tl�rc��:z�;l�
�r�r�e��i�e f��� tcs sti�l�scr•iE�e�•:� z��; <� s���<z��at� li1�e it���� t��� tl��,ir- n�c�t�tl���r lai�l. �°caa. �zll iait���ts aa�ci
p�sT-�sas��, i1"a m����iea�<�Pity ia����c�;�r�� �r c;a1��e lrai�c;hi��; 1'�c�, ik7��t ���: �,��ill �.��: ���:��� c,x� to
s�a�.�sc��ibc,�•� 4�:� a��cc�ir��ia�� aa�����l�ly cl����°��, Aflsc�, �r�nt�•t�r°y t�, �vl�at Tir���; W��rr��r• wvtat�ld lil�e:
c��rer•yoi�� tca �7Gli�°v�, fr��al�l�isc 1��;s ��re a�c�t a t��. 7�i 1��� ���ici-1�)90's tl�is ����ct iss�l� w�s rc�vi�;wc�c�
ir7 ��cicral cc�tt�-t, w�ritl� R}7� ca�art st��ti���; tlaa� fi-a���l�i5� 1�e;s �vGz•e; jl�st a ca5� c��� c�c�'s��� l���sii��s:� �cac�
�;,abl� c��i7}����aicti __ z•e�zt for ���;�:�s a�� <ii7c� use c�f����i.a��ici�a��l c�i�l7ts oi'��a�F. 'I�I��s i� r��`��a�ai•t��1t,
t�eca���e tax��; ca��r�c7t be i��c���dc�ci iz-� Al�� e��leul�tic�e� �>f'�rc��� ��c��erlu�s. �.ltl�t�u�;l� tE7c��r cc���lcl jt��i
�,s� ���si9y h��v� ����;rl Y�2�zi1t �7�to �h� c����al�� rate s�i•a�ci1��•e, �.�tl�%� ccaz�7��ani�� �'��x�.��;h7i 1ta��, ai�d ����ag�, t�l��
ri�l�t tc� Itxal�e 9c°�x��cl�ise fe�s a�se�����°��t�; li��e iteln a�� tk��:17i�1.
r'"�
2
In addition to the Time Warner data, we've reviewed a copy of the Town's franchise agreement,
which was approved by the PSC May 29, 2003 and is scheduled to expire on May 29, 2013.
Therefore, the entire period reviewed was governed by the current franchise agreement.
Section 18 of the franchise agreement calls for quarterly payments of 3% of Gross Revenues,
which Section 1(j} of the agreement defines as follows:
"Gross Revenues" means all revenues net of franchise fees and PEG access monies
actually received by and paid to Time Warner Cable by subscribers residing within the
Municipality for Cable Television Service purchased by subscribers on a regular,
recu.rring monthly basis.
Although this definition seems fairly straightforward, the language actually excludes a
significant portion of allowable revenue, without actually saying it specifically. For instance, use
of the phrase "paid to Time Warner Cable by subscribers" effectively eliminates all non-
subscriber revenue (advertising and home shopping fees) from gross revenues. Likewise, the
phrase "purchased by subscribers on a regular, recurring monthly basis" means that revenue from
installations, late fees, and pay-per-view movies and events is also excluded. Whether the Town
was aware of these revenue exclusions or not, they were allowable under State and Federal
regulations. However, the attempt to exclude franchise fees from gross revenues — through use
of the phrase "net of franchise fees" — was against PSC rules at the time of your franchise
�"`� renewal. In fact, the PSC pointed out the error to Time Warner in their Order Approving
Renewal (issued 5/29/03) stating:
First, the definition of "Gross Revenues" in Section 1(j) of the agreement, which
defines gross revenues as "all revenues net of franchise fees", is not consistent with our
rules. Section 595.1(0) of our rules requires that the revenue base not be less than the
revenues received directly from subscribers for any cable services purchased on a
regular, recurring monthly basis. Therefore, our approval will be expressly conditioned
upon striking from the renewal agreement "net of franchise fees" in Section 1(j).
In reviewing franchise fee payment information, it is clear that Time Warner ignored PSC r�iles
and the PSC Order and excluded franchise fees collected from subscribers each month from the
calculation of gross revenues. This depressed the actual value of gross revenues and resulted in
an underpayment of franchise fees to the Town. Although this error has most likely caused
underpayments all the way back to 2003, the statute of limitations prevents us from recouping
those underpayments beyond the past six years. From Apri12006 through March 2012, we
would estimate the underpayment to be $15,602.74 (spreadsheet enclosed). In addition, Section
18(d) of the franchise agreement calls for Time Warner to pay interest on the underpaid amount
at the rate of 9% per annum, which would add an additional $5,000+ to the amount owed.
Correction of this error will result in increased franchise fee revenues of approximately $3,000
annually through the remaining term of your current agreement.
f''1 This problem is fairly widespread amongst municipalities with Time Warner Cable franchise
agreements. In fact, dozens of the municipalities we've worked with on this issue were involved
in a complaint process before the PSC. In May of 2006, the PSC ruled in the municipalities'
favor, stating that Time Warner did owe money for past underpayment of franchise fees in
circumstances exactly like yours.
r"1
3
I also want to point out that since these underpaid amounts would have been passed through to
subscribers had franchise fees been handled properly in the first place, you should be aware that
Time Wamer's response will be to exercise their right to pass through the underpaid franchise
fee amounts they now pay the Town as a result of any claim that is filed. Given that the Town
had 3,302 subscribers {as of 3/12) we would estimate the impact of the temporary pass through
to be about 39 cents a month over a period of one year. Although they could simply apologize
and waive the pass through, Time Warner's strategy has been to use the pass through as a way to
discourage municipalities from enforcing their agreements and demanding that the proper
amounts be paid.
At this point it isn't really a matter of whether the Town wants franchise fees passed through to
subscribers, once a franchise fee is included in your franchise agreement that is inevitable.
However, given that the error was caused by Time Warner, you'd obviously prefer that none of
these amounts be passed through at this time — a sentiment that we will make clear to Time
Warner when filing the claim.
Our review has also identified two other issues that I want to bring to your attention. First,
Section 18{d) of your agreement specifies that Time Warner will pay a late payment charge of
1.5% on any franchise fee payment that is not made on or before 60 days after the end of each
quarter. According to Time Warner documentation, the 2"d Quarter 2009 franchise fee payment,
�'►� which was due by August 29, 2009, was not issued until September 2, 2009. The late payment
charge should have been $328.23 and we'll request that Time Warner make that payment or
provide proof that it was already made.
The other issue involves a somewhat mysterious deduction to Basic Service revenues in January,
February, and March of 2007. During those three months the Time Warner data shows that
revenues were reduced by $121,467.36 on a line called "Revenue Shaze." We know of no valid
reason for that deduction and have asked Time Warner's Accounting Department for an
explanation. If they don't have a valid reason for the deduction, this would represent another
potential underpayment of $3,644.02 plus interest. We'll continue to pursue this issue with Time
Warner and keep you informed of developments.
I want to make clear that this enforcement action will not raise the franchise fee, it will simply
require its accurate payment under the terms of your current franchise agreement as it was
approved by the PSC. Likewise it will have no impact on cable rates, which are set through an
entirely different process. In accordance with the directions you provided in our phone
conversation of earlier today, we will file a claim with Time Warner to recover the underpaid
amounts owed the Town. I'll copy you on all relevant correspondence with Time Warner Cable.
Please feel free to contact me at any time with questions regarding this matter.
Since y,
� "
�c ae . aton
Partner
Spreadsheet Enclosed
Town of Ithaca Underpaid Franchise Fees
�
1) Underpayment due to exclusion of franchise fees from gross revenues in violation of
PSC Ord�r Approving Renewal.
Fran Fee 3% Running Cumulative Revenue
Month Interest Payment Underpay Interest Total Interest Quarter
April-06 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
May-Q6 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
June-06 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
July-Q6 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 $0.00
August-Q6 9.00% $19,384.06 $581.52 $4.36 $585.88 $4.36 2nd Q 2006
September-06 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $4.39 $590.28 $8.76
October-06 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $4.43 $594.70 $13.18
November-06 9.00% $18,582.60 $557.48 $8.64 $1,160.82 $21.82 3rd Q 2006
December-06 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $8.71 $1,169.53 $30.53
January-07 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $8.77 $1,178.30 $39.30
February-07 9.OQ°/a $22,340.42 $670.21 $13.86 $1,862.38 $53.17 4th Q 2006
March-07 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $13.97 $1,876.35 $67.13
April-07 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $14.07 $1,890.42 $81.21
May-07 9.00% $18,220.03 $546.60 $18.28 $2,455.30 $99.48 1st Q 2007
June-07 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $18.41 $2,473.71 $117.90
July-07 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $18.55 $2,492.26 $136.45
August-07 9.00% $20,560.15 $616.80 $23.32 $3,132.39 $159.77 2nd Q 2007
September-07 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $23.49 $3,155.88 $183.26
,�.^ October-07 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $23.67 $3,179.55 $206.93
November-07 9.00% $19,844.29 $595.33 $28,31 $3,803.19 $235.24 3rd Q 2007
December-07 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $28.52 $3,831.71 $263.77
January-08 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $28.74 $3,860.45 $292.50
February-08 9.00% $23,470.54 $704.12 $34.23 $4,598.80 $326.74 4th Q 2007
March-08 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $34.49 $4,633.29 $361.23
Ap�il-08 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $34.75 $4,668.04 $395.98
May-08 9.00% $22,608.46 $678.25 $40.10 $5,386.39 $436.08 1st Q 2008
June-08 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $40.40 $5,426.79 $476.47
July-08 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $40.70 $5,467.49 $517.18
August-08 9.00% $21,286.90 $638.61 $45.80 $6,151.89 $562.97 211d Q 2008
September-08 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $46.14 $6,198.03 $609.11
October-08 9.00% $0.00 $a.oa $46.49 $6,244.52 $655.60
November-08 9.00% $20,139.89 $604.20 $51.37 $6,900.08 $706.96 3rd Q 2008
December-08 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 �51.75 $6,951.83 $758.71
January-09 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $52.14 $7,003.97 $810.85
February-09 9.00% $23,466.00 $703.98 $57.81 $7,765.76 $868.66 4th Q 2008
March-09 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $58.24 $7,824.00 $926.90
April-09 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $58.68 $7,882.68 $985.58
May-09 9.00% $22,934.99 $688.05 $64.28 $8,635.01 $1,049.86 1st Q 2009
June-09 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $64.76 $8,699.78 $1,114.63
July-09 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $65.25 $8,765.02 $1,179.87
August-09 9.00% $21,882.16 $656.46 $70.66 $9,492.15 $1,250.54 2nd Q 2009
September-09 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $71.19 $9,563.34 $1,321.73
October-09 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $71.73 $9,635.07 $1,393.45
� November-09 9.Q0% $20,950.65 $628.52 $76.98 $10,340.56 $1,470.43 3rd Q 2009
December-09 9.Q0% $0.00 $0.00 $77.55 $10,418.12 $1,547.98
January-10 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $78.14 $10,48625 $1,626.12
February-10 9.00% $23,886.70 $716.90 $84.10 $11,297.25 $1,710.22 4th Q 2009
March-10 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $84.73 $11,381.98 $1,794.95
Fran Fee 3% Running Cumulative Revenue
Month Interest Payment Underpay Interest Total Interest Quarter
April-10 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $85.36 $11,467.35 $9,880.31
May-10 9.00% $24,068.90 $722.07 $91.42 $12,280.83 $1,971.73 1st Q 2010
June-10 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $92.11 $12,372.94 $2,063.84
July-10 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $92.80 $12,465.74 $2,156.64
August-10 9.00% $22,398.85 $671.97 $98.53 $13,23624 $2,255.17 2nd Q 2010
September-10 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $9927 �13,335.51 $2,354.44
October-10 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $100.02 $13,435.52 $2,454.46
November-10 9.00% $21,006.14 $630.18 $105.49 $14,171.20 $2,559.95 3rd Q 2010
December-10 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $106.28 $14,277.48 $2,666.23
January-11 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $107.08 �14,384.57 $2,773.31
February-11 9.00% $22,990.74 $689.72 $113.06 $15,187.34 $2,886.37 4th Q 2010
March-11 9.00% $a.oa $0.00 $113.91 $15,30125 $3,000.28
April-11 9.00% $0.00 $0,00 $114.76 $15,416.01 $3,115.04
May-11 9.00% $22,912.63 $687.38 $120.7$ $16,224.16 $3,235.81 1st Q 2011
June-11 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $121.68 $16,345.84 $3,357.49
July-11 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $122.59 $16,468.44 $3,480.09
August-11 9.00% $21,766.87 $653.01 $128.41 $17,249.86 $3,608.50 2nd Q 2011
September-11 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $129.37 $17,379.23 $3,737.87
October-11 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $130.34 $17,509.57 $3,868.22
November-11 9.00% $20,678.23 $620.35 $135.97 $18,265.80 $4,004.19 3rd Q 2011
December-11 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $136.99 $18,402.89 $4,141.18
January-12 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $138.02 $18,540.91 $4,279.21
February-12 9.00% $22,403.57 $672.11 $144.10 $19,357.12 $4,423.30 4th Q 2011
March-12 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $145.18 $19,502.29 $4,568.48
�,.� April-12 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $14627 $19,648.56 $4,714.75
May-12 9.00% $22,297.67 $668.93 �152.38 $20,469.87 $4,867.13 1st Q 2012
June-12 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $153.52 $2Q,623.40 $5,020.65
July-12 9.00% $0.00 $0.00 $154.68 $20,778.07 $5,175.33
Totals: $15,602.74 Underpaid Franchise Fees 8l06 to present
$5,175.33 Interest
$20,778.07 TotalOwed
Twelve Month Pass Through to Subscribers:
3,302 subs (as of 3/12)
$0.39 per month
2) Late Payment Charge
$21,882.16 2nd Q 2009 franchise fee payment issued 9/2/09 - Past the due date
Amount Due: $328.23
Section 18(d) of the franchise agreement specifies a 1.5% late payment charge for all franchise fee payments
that are not made on or before the due date of 60 days from the end of each calendar quarter.
3) Potential Underpayment due to "Revenue Share" deduction in 1st Q 2007
� Revenue Share Deduction: $121,467.36
3% Underpayment: $3,644.02 plus interest
Have requested TVIlC Accounting to provide explanation for revenue deduction.
T� V 1i � �� IT����
215 �,I. Tioga Street, I�haca, 6J.Y. �l �g5�
w�w.tawrl.itl��c�.ny.us
Town 5up�rvis�r (6Q7� 27'�-172'1i, Ext 12� ,�i�i�ei. r���r� c�ai�awru,oroto rrc � r,u,y:.i:sw�
��rrvN c�E�� �so�� 2�a-��2� ��suc wa�w�s ��t�7� 2�s-�sss ��i�or��E��r�� ��oa� 2��-��ra�r
PL�ah��1�dV� (807) 2i3-1747 Zf�1�9NG (6�77) 27'3-ti7�3
FAX (6d7} 2"i�-1704
,��,iy 1Q, �C11�
Kevirr I. McL�ughCirr
b�egion�l C�irector
Southern Ti�r Regi�nal �ffic�
Stat� t�ffic� Building, Raom � Sa8
44 Hawbey Skr��t
Binghamton, �JX 13901-4�53
��: �m�rsan �edevelopment Project
2Q12 Econc�r�ai� D�uelo9�m�c�t Geant fi�ppl�catic�n
a��r Kevn�:
It's no se�ret tl�at when � factary cYases, a part af a community'S saul ��es wi#h �t. �his vwas the
case wh�rr Emerscan decid�d ta cease pr+�duction �t r�ts Pt�aca plank, and it h�s stood vacant and
,���,��,,, distressir�gly Quiet �an our south hill far to� 6c�r�g. ��ing�r�g that almr�st o�e mil[ir�n squ�re f�et c�f
spae� back to l�f� is of crit6c�l impartanc� i� bath the ��awr� �and tFr� SQ�.itherr� Tier Regi��, �n�! �
loca9l develaper has steppeci fprw�rd with a�alar� �ta m�ke that happ��.
I�m writcr�� t� expr�ss my and tl�e "�awn pf Ithaea's strong su}apa�°t fwr l�av�d Lubin's prrpos�d
redev�lapm�nt of the shuttered Em�rsan� f�ctc�ry, �his prcaject will bring up ta 1,�i�Q j�bs back to
th� c�mmunity while prnvading much needed housar�g far its citize�s.
We believe that his request f�r �4t�fl,QOa in eca�omic develc�pm�nen� f�ndin� �hraugh th�: CFF�
des�rves th� �dvt�c�cy ca6 thre Scru#hern Tier I�egaonal �our��il �nd its sut�s�q�rent �pprov�l �t tl��
st�te I�v�l, Ti he �se crf prc�gr�m funds in fu�rtheran�e of t�ris peaject is warr�nt�d and r�pr�sents
uvhat we see as a goc�d ir�vestmerrt in the fuk�r�e ca# Ch� r�giorr.
Mr. Lubin ir�tend� tc� lever�ge the requested �tate �undin� wiik� $1.6 mill'�ion �f his awn morrey av�r�
t�� n�xt ye�r ta get the nece�s�ary enuiro�mental kesting dane �nd to ��o the planning �nd prepare
t�e �equisite dcac�meniat�an to c�et t�is projec� movii�g forwar�. The s�ale af this ur�de�taking
req�.�ires khat a�� parkies pr�ceed with eyes wid� np��, and this due dilig�nce pre��ess is c�-ikic�l �o
makinc� khat possibl�. This Is � cl��r irrst�nce �vhere � sm�ll ir�veskment �f 5tate fu�rds can yieAd a
Fauge re�ur�.
�i�� Tnwn af Ith�ca is ce�rr�mitted �a seeing this project m�ve fanrvard„ a�rd we ur�� �h� CQur�cil t�a
suy�pc�rt this gr�rrk request.
Sincer ly,
�� �--�.._..
�b rk J. Engm
Tc�v�rn ��pe�vis
STA�"� �7�' N�iN YCif�l4 — t��PARTM�NT UF TRANSP�t�RT�TI(�N
TF�,�F�iC A,t�� �A�E�4" QIVISIQN
N�7PC� Ci� t)RDE�
ST191]�Y NC1.: 3�12�Jk�4$
FI�.�: 50.12-Lra�.
i�t�c��: c
/
�4, i1._.J
�"H� C7�I�AI�T11fi�PVT" QF T`RANSF'C3R�AfiC��B HAS �"IL�C� AN C38�L��R WfTH �"Ff� ��CRFTARY OF 'STATE WH�f��BY:
��CTG�N: `�'15d.1� SI.JBC�I'V1SION: (ar�} �ARA�RAf'H: f )
J� �HE LEPARTMENT'S REGI�ImmATI(7N IS (X ) AL�DED () AME�J��D to rea�i �s �aal�nws: ( j R�PEA,'�ED
25 M9P�i at7 Juddl Falls Rc��d, a t+�wstn highway, betweerw Forest Fdcam� i�riwe a�c� Pla�t�#atians Roaci, �
d�star��e a€ D.3� miCe.
�'he abave ord�er wiOA b� effect�we upan the ins�aflat`ron, rnadificati�aa� c�r rem�rval esf the n�cessary tra�frc ccrr�tr�c�a devic�(s�
r�quir�:d' by and ccar�formiir�� ka the St�4e f'�anu�al of Unifc�rm Tr�ffic Cor�trcal! �dev'rces.
,���w�,,,�,
�N� � �d
July 1Ci, 2q"12_ ._._._ ___.._....... AP&'RC7VEt� BY ��w�.� �,TyM�+.,.a�. rv,�w�,Ww'��k;..:'.�,, C��qi�arra� Traf�c Encafnee�
(f3AT�� (51��AT�J�E) �TPTLE)
r �
4Jrcfer est�b@ishes a 25 MP"�fi sp��d zan� on the aka�ue described �eetiorr �f Judd 1=alls N�aad.
C+��J'��'Y: �Tamp�ci�rs
c��rH�� ����,��a a,c-riarvs � x � rvc�r��
c�.: t � ���r�r
( 1 vi��a��
.WWw.,.��:�����X ) YC)'1��d
(X ) C(JUP�TY SI�P�'
�w��
DLG:J'6u1L.
TE �e (1Lii�38)
( } SHEf�IFF
�X ) SiAT� Pt�LICF
( ) PERMJTTE�
L{�CAL9TY: l�c�wr� of Itii�c�
C 1 w���,crty:
( X ) pthaca� �'alice Depk.
( X) Fi��;IC)hl �3) TRAFFIG EN'�G1hJEEf;
( } �THER _
_�_
„a������v,,
�,��� �. �=�a�t�, R.�.
REGIC7NAl. GtIRECTt7�t
I'v�s. l�at�pettc Tea-wiili�;c�-
T��t� �le:r-k, Ta�n�n c,�' Itt�aca
2l 5 I�1��°C�� 'T'i�a�a ���-eet
Itl7aca, I'�c°�v `�'�ar� I4�5(�
1'�eat` ]�!ls. "I'�e�-vailIager:
+J 1 fi5 I�. V'� ��� I V'Rfry.
C./�'d—�1Z�IVY��IY� V� C 1:'1.1""10\Y�1—�d��ri W YVIY
!�ry+� �y fi4�VCAJ�M �
J��J�3 �M�?� WYd7'1�t7�f 1�4VY�7 q+.JIV� � 1 1'�r.�� 1
s���,cus�, r�r � ��a;�
v�w�v.dat.r�y.gav
Juty ] �, 2a12
� � / � �, �
�
°�, �.�1P�d�� �,����' E�"G—F��� a�
� �•+,A.�.�., .......
.�a�r� r�cD�r��tz�
CC7Mh�1�5SPQh��R
�.L: R�Qi.�L�;°T T'�[�. L�IV�'�I�. ���'��I�
L,lM['I' +C)l'� JU1:�T� F�LI:��.,5 �2.(���
"Cl�is is a fi.a�-��ter a-es}�a��se tc� ya�ar 1VTa�•cia � 4 l�tier re���sti►7�; a lower s�aeed lirnit ��� Jirc�c�
F�11s 120��1 b�tweei� I'�aaat��ic�ns l�.caad arncl l�ar•cst I-lor��� I��-irre. t���ar tr��t; �c��irro���-s h�ve
�c�r����let�c� �����r ����i��v �i't��is 1'ac�ti+a� and c��ti�et-'��i���d t}��t a s�a��ci Ix�it �a�`2� l'�[�l�t �vc�uYd t�e
�:��rc�}�r��te. `T'l�e o�f'ici�i car-�ier a�t��ar�zi��� t�7c Hc��vcr s��ced �i���it �wil� �`a�lavr. LJ�c�rt rec�:i}a�t nfih�e
�ffie�al e����l��r•, tl�c Tcaw�� ��za� i�a�tall tla� si�;ni�r� ���cessa�-y tc� i���ple�a�en� t��� �S Mt�i-� s�a��d �irti�it.
cc
�'c�car i��t�r•est it� ti�is �����t�r• h�s l�e+��� �;r•e��ly a�g�a-ec}�tc;c�.
�Iery tt•taly y��,�t-s,
� �^� � a������"���°���. � ��w`���'�"�� ��,� �p��ar
� p„)�rv
fl Y`�n�wa ��F�'�4 ���.�m �d'"�Y�"'�a� 5� �"�h�
r��%�ra� L. c�l�:n�r:�, T�. �;,
Re;�i�ri�l �1'���T-i� �:r��;ii�eer
C. �1�1�scaa�, Ir�tiea�i�n T-�i�l�vw��f l�ar���;���, 'I'o�r���l�ins +�c�u��ty 1-�ig�]c�aay I7fuisic�r�
�E-���. �I. L���€��y�a�, ���ac��-�isr�r•, '�'t�w� c��` l���P���ca �..�_ r���
�?. �. �t�in, Cc�unty Z,��islatar, �is��`i�t 1 i
������
4 �` ���"f� �'�' I�TH,��%�► ��
�� ..a*�� �� � �
,�;,�� �, ,jY �1 � N'. Ti��a it��et, Ith�ca, h!.'�'. 148�Q�
�"��R������
��, .���- ww�.�c��fi��,i�l����.ny.us
Paulette T��kliic��;r, Tawr� C@crG� Pk�prae; (6t�7� 27�-1721 Debr� [7�A,uc�istin�, C7�pu€y Tnvwn CI�r4c
pterwi�ligerr�tawn.i&h�ca.r�y.us Fax: (6�7) 273-�854 ddea�s�isiine�atawn.ithaca.ny.us
�i " , ,
i _ .
J�ly 13, �C?12 ° ���` � �
� _ ..rv ' ._ , _ C C' ���
� ii
:. �
�, ,
,
•�M , � ,�.. � � _ ��. . � ..� � � C�
� ? � fl� k `
w V d � ,.� . "......._,...
, -- . �. „�, � � d �� a ......P
��. 6��. A'.,. t,. �; c � a w
�<
" `";
T"a whom it r��y car���rn,
�`he Tar,vr� nf It�r��� I��� b�:er� a�� activ� parfiicup�r�fi �n ihe multi-jurisdi��iar�al
�ff�arts to c�mplet� tB�e Bla�k Diarn�nd Trail and �p�n thos amazir�� f��ility far
p�bfic use.
T�� 7owr� of It�aca Ns �u�ly ��rppc�rtiv� crf th� 2�1�2 C+ans�rlid�ted Fu�dir�c.,�
,��p�ica�ion fc�r t�� Bl�;ck C�i�cr�ar�� Trial beis�g p�ep�red and s�bmit��d by
T�ar�pR�ins �aunty �u�d ar�tici��tes budc�etor�g '���,C7�0 i� t�wn l�bar and
ec�uiprr�er�t to be c�edic��e� f�rr trail cons�ructmar� �s a cc�n�rib�td�n tov+aar�s th�e
I�c�E r-�atch for t�e �r�nt.
�hc��rld }rc�u have �r�y qu�stiorrs, pCe�se f��l �r�� tc� cc�r�ta�t me.
I�egard�,
,
r r �
� � � !
� /`� �_,�— --..,,...
-' �
� � r �er� J�'< ����
�Tc�v�n �� � p�rves�� �
� �� ��M� � �,
� ,�oo�„u
���� ���
��� �
���a �.
I��'�, �'u° �� �"��� �°� � � �I�'�
� ���.i�- t r"�i.���C� l �. tlo:� °� N,< <r 1�ta��ti �� � �;rrr��°^zsit�t.y 1'i'r�-°r -krn
,���,�m,,.
7,/1.�,�1.�
H�:.�.� ��:rq�r�7��c7
Tc���ra ��a���rvi�;car
�"1 � N.'I"ica�a �t.
I�:I���c���� 1�"�" "1.��5�
r�)ceaa�� i�a�. I:°��a�;n��a��,
I�v�a�.��c� J�I�c ir� ���ll yc��a �ac�� ��•�a��fi�l e�� ar� �t. C�.aya.��„f� S�ici���� C`�:��w t}��,� ���-c�t7���t r�������z��;�
c7�Y��11 t'�a�t� f�r� cc�n����r�i�;� �rv��e:��� ��:� l���c� �a r�a��j��r f7��cs�� ��v��t��z1 �����l�s ���c� ��i� � lat� ���rrc�4�y.
'l'�ie�y �a�r� ve�r� �:d���ir�� catzc:l vc�r�r ���l��ftPl in r�':�c��vir�� ���ar- �:��l�r����:a.
�... .,,
�ir�c������, �"s� �
� � �� -''
�� � �.. � ��,� �"" � ,,..
�, �._ �
�. � , �,�..� l. �
Sla��l�a �. ['�r��y, 1�",t�.C.�.I�:.
��i��ain�:�tr<;tt�t.
�����-a����u�� ���.�� � � , �, ��. r P,.�
I�';��J''df�llV'�9.",r��f��f3�C.��d4� �0.C.)�.I"Il�814,% �,.iW6 r4F!"��� I 0� �rC1T.��"�.f��A1� I�" ��i'F,��'�3.C}3�3 I�"MW"Ja�°.C;.Fw'R"I„JC.;hPi9CJi;:;a�:6�7��� j� fPV4fr'tK�C�:A�.Y�k�C�I�FCVQPG,��i tl"„���P�1
�
�,� avl a---
Dear Route 79 Resident:
The Town has received a number of complaints from homeowners who live along
Route 79 about the cars parked on the roadside by people walking down to Six Mile
Creek. Some of these cars are parked so that the homeowners have difficulty seeing
oncoming traffic as they try to pull out of their driveways.
As you may be aware, last year the Town Board passed a No Parking ordinance
for Penny Lane (effective May 1 to September 30) because of the Common Land
residents' concerns about some of the people accessing Second Dam who were disrupting
the neighborhood with their actions and the trash they left behind.
Because Raute 79 is a State highway, the Town cannot post No Parking signs
there, but we have contacted the State Dept. of Transportation and they are willing to post
the stretch of road (both sides) from the City/Town border all the way east to Pine Tree
Road. At the Town Board meeting on July 9, the Board discussed what parameters to ask
the State to set on the No Parking limitation. We are considering asking for a ban on
parking from 10 AM until8 PM, between May 1 and September 30.
Before requesting the State to prepare and install signs to that effect, we wanted to
give you a chance to let us know what you think. Please contact me (by email or phone)
� in the next two weeks if you have any questions or comments about the No Parking
proposal for Route 79 and I will bring your ideas to the whole Board for consideration.
We will be discussing this at our next Board meeting on Monday, August 13. Thank you.
Sincerely yours,
William D. Goodman, Town Board
Deputy Town Supervisor
BGoodman(cr�town.ithaca.nv.us
607-273-1747, ext. 128
�
„�s���,,,�.
���� �� �Z����
215 N. Ti��� S�ree�, Ithac�, N.Y'. 1485�1
www.�own.ill��t�r�.t7y.tts
��� � �
��.v� � �� ��
,��� �
T¢�wn SupervVsar (6t�7) 273-�721, �xt 125 ; HEr�t�ri�i7 i tavvn.itk�a�;amrey,.�a,s,
TQ'�lVN �L�,RK (fit)7) 273-1721 F'U�L�G 4VC?RkCS (6Q7} 273-1�5� E�IC�I�lE�R9NC (CCl7J Z73-�747
f'L.�.h1NIf�G (64�?j 273-� ��7 ZC7N1(VG (GC77) 273-�7E43
FA7� (6G7� 273-17G��i
f-"1,1.14,�L1S� � , ��� l !
1����. �ic�lacrt fl"�I��rti�7
] �D l��r�cic�ll .�,.v��-�uc
It���xc��, i'J4' 1 ��5�)
Dear �vla�. Nl��i-kcr�:
1 lir��«��;1�e�cz tr}fin�; �c� �;�t}le;i� i��ic���r�����ic�ri at�c� 1�c71<� r��c:ctir��,� ic� �et tl�a� ���15�;e�e;r,s �c� y�uz-
�,�ic��tic7��s cc���t�lir7ce� i�� yc�i�r l�tCc;r� c��`J�ia�c 1�. Lll�fc���tk�rtii���l� �vcat�k �c���c�, ��K�c�,����c�ns ac�cl �1�rc
lc�i��;-t������ ���ck c�f �.l�c�ity ui`tli�: ;�ituaCi���� (�a��� ���ackL ii rl cc���ti»aai���; ciile��a����,. �a� �ciciiti�77.
tca tl-�� i�;;u�:;� �ak.ctlit�ccl i�� yca���` ��ttca- is t}7c c��.icstic?t� c�{`catiW�l�r�stl��a c�Et11� ��rat�.��tic�l stc�t;�t
�i�cl/c�r a ei�l�i-c�i'-w�y tc� �i�iilcl �� �Rrc;c�t. �l �-€:vi�vrr cat'i17a� �lu� �r�c�i�att�s ���� l�i;�tc�o�i+�sa�
pos�t'r�¢� a�f^k1�� "1'c�w�rE� lias �caY��; k�L�wi tl��zk tl�e s�rcct �vc�«Ic� l���ve kc� bc: la��ilk �7��iv��te;ly ta
Town �t����GGz��cls l�cf`c�re td��: ri"«woi �c�tzlcl cc�i�sic��t� t�a1cir�� E�vcr i��aiititer��lr��:c�.
5����c� r�u��xc,lw c�i�tl�� 1:�c�usii7g; ciGv�lc����ci ia� tl�e �����c���llo'f'ei�r7�;ylv�i�,iE� �t���;cts i�� �-ccc�-�t }Pe�s°s
11=�4 l�ee�a �ttic�c:t�t k�atasi¢��, � c��it�����c;E��i��iv� scalt��i�a� ��4a�cicl kaave 4c� i¢��lt��l� It1�ac��
�'c��]��,�;. I l���ve; cc���t��ct�c� }�c;x�5�r����,1 tl7�r�� tc� 1���;i►� c� �c�r�v�i•�ation a��e��at 1�:'�� rc.�le <1nc1
r��sr�c�rYsilai9ity. �,ftcr tE7at i��iki��l c�t��7t��ct I�vo�r�ci k7�al��; t� �;�t �11 p�¢-ti�s tc�>�ctl��i� tdJ �a➢�rr ta
�?I-O�l1C�lVC 4:C)Lll'fi�:,.
L�tely wvc; 1�;��fc l7ces� [���kr�y� �lt �Zc�-v �1��;th�cl;� «f'�t�lvira�; ik�c }�t-�l�lcr��5 �al�r:�Yl i��c� ��rt��ct�ti��
�n t1�7c� Ta��,�r�l ��rit�� c�iff�c���lt �l�v�:lu������c�iti k���-rici-� l'rk� ������am':�. [�� �tl�ez- w�:7a�c➢�, I���i��7�lc �rc
1�uztiJc �t�aci� 4c�i���: ��r-c��;r-�ss i�� �cicir�c:;si��� t��� situatic;�», �a�rt �.�c ���� c�c�t 4�t �� :;�:�I��k%c�r7 yc�t.
T17a��1<� yr�i� ic�rr yc�t�i� �atie,i�ce. ��r�cl S l�c��ae tc� �;c�t 1.����k ��� yc�u i��uch �z�ca�-e ������G����tly ��� tl�e
i�i.�k��t-�~.
aiz�cc�°c(y,
HLr���-t .�. �::z�����u�z�
Tc��.vza ����a�;r-vi����-
I �../ � � '�.J � I I � /� �.�5 �
2'p 5� N. Tic�ga ��re�et, Ith�ca, N.Y. �14�5�
'V4'��'W.tt7b'Vt�.lt�1e8C��.�7�'.Y1S
Tcarnrn Supervisar (�Q7) 27;�-1721, �xt 125 ; F9C�a7�,a:ira(ra)t�r�r�i�u.ikf��caa,,�o�y i.o�="
T�WN CLERI< {�i�ti) 273-1721 f'4JBLI�C Wf�F2KS (CC)i� 273-155F EIVGINE�FtING (6Q7) 273-1747
PI�ANNING (6Q7) �7�-1i4i ZC7NING (GQ7� 273-1783
�AX (6�7j 2?3-� 704
A�agust 7, �01 �
Ed Nlarx
Ccar�missi�ner �� Plann�rug
Yorr�r�kin� �c�unty C�ep�rim�nt af F'lanning
�21 �:ast Gou�rt �t�e�t
Ith�ca, �JY 1 ��50
� ` �. M il 1 • �
I�r�n pl�a��d tc� �nd�rse th� �ffcar�s af Tam�k�ns Cc�unty tc� �b�ain fu�r��d'rn�
t8�r��gh the 2�12 N�w Yar�k d�ivisAa� af �Vcaucsir�� �rr�d Camm�nity k�er����k
,��"��,�°� ��r�am�ar�ity a�v�l�p�rren� �back Gr�nt Proe�r�m t� c��r��inue the Cc��ant�y�'s
H�rra�awn�r�hip Prograrrr.
In the �c�wr� �af Ith�c� u�r� hav� h�d 4� h�u��eholds be��fit from th� v�4u�ble
rr��arCg�g� a��istan�e p��agr�m and R hav� ���rr a very p�sotiv� irrMpa�t on a��r
cc�mm�r�ity. M�n�y ir�dividuafs, in�ludir�� a numb�r af �"owr� rf Ith�c� rnid�f��-
irucam� employe��, h�ve tr�nd rr�e �hey car�nat �ff�a�d t� purchase � hc�rn�� in the
Ta�vr� of Ith�c�. This typ� c�f �ragram i� �ss�n�ial tc� rn�intainir�g div�rsity w��l�irn
�he Tawn. I am pC��s�d tha;t �etter �9�usang far T�rr�pkirt�s Couc�ty wiCl p�ay � rale
in th� praj�ct if furrded. �e h�v� had � very pc��itFve ex�errence �+ith th�t
rargand��tuac�.
1 st�-angly h�pe that Tampk'rns C��n�ty's �u�r��ing ��plic�tican wilN b� I�a�ked up�n
fiavor�bly.
I� I��n be �f �u�ther �s�i�tan�e, pl�a�� da n�t hesitate tc� c�ntact m�.
Sic�c�r�fy,
�
N rb�rt J. � an
Tc�wn ��a�� ��ar
moms�u�,,,,.
�g:�'� ��ni��r
�, � r�.
f_,i��r.c�er�a��c�r� C'����y�e, ���c�:r~trr�err.fis
L,irac,l�r�r7�cr.r� G`r���c 1I
��or�ziJt�r Vi(lccc��€-.� c,t Ithc�ccx
�'a��a.cc;�r.z Vicw /1��c;a.r-trr�crr�z.ts
.��.1 �"��r•��s C::o�r�., lt,i°�c,�.ca 1 ����C?
CaG�7-.2� c1-.I CIC+� f�r•�`cra:: GUi-2�u-�2��3
.I1AJ,AJ7Y .L "i.7qll�l`-1.1��....1 r��l./
���;
�' '� �lil i
���,�;:� ���° ����ti��
i C7V�N C�f 9.iI�f4C�4
,�.tt�ta�t 22, 2(71r�
�
To 1'�w�Z c�f If:����c;�:
Th�: �:iti:��j�s c�f` i.�ir�cle�z�a��.�� Crcc,.l� sl�.rtecl t��c e���lca;�ce� ��tit.i�a�-�. '1"h�y ���-e verY
carrc:ei•i��cl i.h��i: t:1�c; c��t:a-��.�:�at:e �.3f�i �'c���1�e i� c�t��c:� Cc�:dzift;r Driv�. is very c1tz�-1� �a�
a�a�l�t. I l�ave ���atccl str�et ligh�� cc�r�aia�� tt}a ti�c l�i1l �.�t cv��-y �t.l�ei- uti�ity �c�lc. I�:
��a�7c�Lr-s t� ane;.„ �f yaL1 ia�i:����1� tl-�c ne:xxt li�lzt it: v�vi11 &�e� �:�t tl-�e ��.l�c>v� c�c;�c;ril�t;c�
111�i:T':;f':'C;�1�711.
„1'pi9'�N'ro?4ni,
'UiWitll ���•��it�c� �l7() ��csic:lc��t� at tl�c ��z�ca��cx-t;y, �!isitcars ��i�c� i��u,r�� �;�rcic:�� t7T���c, �rr
fe�1 t.1��� ����u1c:3 kae � rnr;�,j�]r ka�nc�it 1a� t:he c,.��rnra��ani�}�. F'IeascS 1Vc�r�i.�;rc, c>�.:tz.
unr.�f�"i�:icil a;�lcira�; fc7r 1i�i� li�;l-�t. �1e z-c;s�c�;tf��;�lly r�c�u�s� tlic� t���v�-� tca �aac�l� i�7t� t1��;
�ossyl�ilitiy �af iaa��:a.11Ilrag; �a sta�etli�;iat to rr�txl��: lhi;� �t��f:�z�5�c,tica��i ��Fer tc� �„c,t in ��.rtrl
aut s�f �;�t x�z�;��t.,
'I`h���7.1� yc�� ia� Gi�:�vaa�c� �:caz- :Yr��.z�- r:��:��chfi�l ct��a��.r:3ca at,ic�i�.
.9
4.�a� �� y� a
. N f i� ] �
� �
f �i py' y(/'.,
���,,. �'( ,� -..»,� ��N' . I . r �� 1d F ��....
41 4
1'v��st� c:�.� �. F�tc1��x-c1
Cani �r� Rc�iJtvy 1''r�c��:aez-ty IVt.�:r��gcz�
Lincie;i.r��r�n C;�-c��al� I
L1T3C;�C;1"1174:tI"k {.1"C f'I�; ��
L,i��c��rrr���z� G�-c�c:��� ITI
�c�:i�jfc,r- Vflll���c �t TL1�G�c�r
� PETITtON �-,
STREET LIGHT/TRAFFIC LIGHT AT INTERSECTION OF
,
ROUTE 79 WEST CONIFER DRIVE
� �� t�(�U �n �� `�=a � �r-�,� C-� ;
� 1� 1 C�0 L� ti�`�.� C.�l�st ��,h'C.�-4
T he signatures be low represent t he resi dents o f Conifer Village
and Linderman, Creek. Without the benefit of a street
�, -,: �. ^ -- � .i ;: .. , ;� r - : �,:
lig�t/tr.;��fic;�igh��; the above captioned infiersection is creating a
.� �� , _
dangerous driving situation. We are presenting this request to
the Town of Ithaca for due consideration with regard to this
serious matter. �a ;n�� ���- � ��r-e-��1� ��1� cx-� -�nn�,rt,v�
� �� � � �
� 1;`�, �,� �� .
0
�
ry
N
�
� �
�
_�---��..� d3::.---- a�. ----�_ _ __..__ __---- - ----
---- ---
, �--- � - � - �.._.
. ------ �
-- ` ' --- �-� C, - /t� �- - , -�c.�rt? �---------- � 8 '�._'-- 3----. _ ------------------- _ _---.. _ .___._ _ ._. _- _ _ ___ ._ ----
_z L ---� - ��.��t----G�,�� �a__ --- 3
. � ___- __ _ � — _ -- __ _ -- ---
_ _ _ _--- --. -- -- - . _
--z3 - --�- -__--- � `:� ���- _- -----� 0 6 � (_-__ __ -_ __---
. ---- -- _ _ _ __ -------
.
z'�- - ` . - - --- - -----_. _ ----- ----c�6 .I__. _ _ _--- - -- _- - -- ---------- -
�. . � �
_-- - ---
_z� — - o
--- — ---- ----_�___. _ .. . ._ --- --
----------�_._.._.._.___ ..-----.- -
� � �
_.. _. . _ ._ __ . ___
_. _
.___
�
Z�P - --- -Q-v ��k� .._ _ -� __ �.c,� a�- -- --,� �?_L, __ �.- _ _ - --- _ . _ _ _ - _ _. . . .
--L ---- ----------------�%Yh:vbCl.------------- Z[?�-'=-�------------ ---------
- _. ___ _ --- -----
--.�z.�s--- ------ �==�- ---- .�r`��---- _ .____ . _---- ___ . _.Z��S- �S .. _ _ _- ---_.. _ _ _._ ----_ _ . .
_.._ ... _
_ . .. _ - ------------ _
Z�I_____ le;��--- ��c�.sc,� </(��2-�d'
� - _ -�-- _
- - -- ---
-- . - _ ____. __
, . _ _ --
- � ----- -- J ��.� �...- � 0 4� -- -- -- - ----- - .-- � e-2_� 7_ - -- ---- .
. 3�.------ ___. ---- - � :---- - __ ------- -- --�o� .�- �--_ _ _. __------- __ ----------- ----- --
-------
--�? ---- r __ ------------ -_ _ __----------------.
.
�- -- -- - - - -� _�___ --�----�
. 33__.' � ,.�, � . ��vr+'�- ---
�� �...- -�----- _ ----- _. ------�2,c�b =�--_ _------ -- ----- -- - - -- ---- ---_-------
�-----� _ - �- - _ �_�. _. _ _ _ .. _ _ in��� -�-- __ -- - _ _ ------------ --- _ _ - -
_ ___.
. .3 � -- --- � . _.�-- ---_ ._C._ _ - _ _ __ __ _ _ ---__ _.__ . ._ _..— _f b ��--� --- .- _ . _ -----�----- - - ---- -- - - ._ _ -� -- _ - - ---- _--
3� _ �a+^o�, _�1��e.x-s�a>--�-- _ _ - - _ _ �--- _-� b� - -Ca __ _ ___ _ - - --- -- --- _ _-- -- _ _ __ _.
�?�'"� ' V'Qe.. �-�c.�Js � G�� __- z� � --� . _ _ _ _
.
_---�-�'`c� �,cs�--- — - _ . _---- -- _._ ._ .. _
�. .. a?,t-�.st,.- . _ _ _ . . ._ _. _ __---__ - - _ --c�0 -_----_ __,- _. ___----- _ ___ _-- . .__ __.
-�`�----�r,; 5._��x�:� _ __------__ - - - _ ____._. � d� -�-- ----- - ---------- - - ----
_ _ _ -- -- --
�o �_ � _ 'sn� '�rd��rns_ _ _ _ ad5__-�- _ _-____ _. _ _ _ _ __
� :.
( � . _ _. _. _.___�, os -._ 7 ._. __ _ --- -
.. . : _ _.
_ _ . _ - _. _. . .
_._L(..� _ `_ . _ `__t,� a. - . _._ ���� _ . _ _ _ _ _.__.�_''�e�� � __'�..�_ _. _ _ _ _. - __ ..
. _ _ _ ._ _ _ _. __ _ ----
�.�__-- ._ . .�� G�� ��_x-1 i - --.. _ _ /r�-�_
__ -------- - __. _. . _ _ _ -- _ .
� i��- �
�� � � �. ��e�-L
' .__
. �� __ _ _�.��_.__ ___ _ _.__ _ _ _ . . �d� _ --.�--___ __ __ -. ----_- _-_._ . ._____ _ _ _ __--__.._--
��� -� t
- -- - - ---_ .. __ ___ _ __ _ _ _ _.-- - - - _ - -- _ - ------------
-. _
_ _. �-----...__--- ------
y�__ --- _ _ �,� - ---__ ---��- �__ _
____ -- -- -
-�t�- ---._��,zu____ �_ � .___ _ �.��--� _ _ _
. .__.�;;;� _ ---- --- - ------ --------- ---- _ _ ._ ._---------.-
c�
PETITi�N
STREET LIGHT/TRAFFIC LIGHT AT tNTERSECTIQN �F
ROUTE 791AIEST/COfVIFER DRIVE
. ` '��
�/ �a� 1c � ��� s� L� ► � �-� �� �
� ' �
The signatures below represent the residents of Conifer Village
and Linderman Creek. Without the benefit of a street
light�����it, the above captioned intersection is creating a
dangerous driving situation. We are presenting this request to
the Town of Ithaca for due consideration with regard to this
serious matter.
�i���� G�.C�.�r-�J� �� 0� • 0��0
�
�
s
l�) L-e-�-.�z.�
��,� S� �1 � � � s
r �.
���
� ��������
� �� � � � � w-. �e �v�b�� �-�
�� �``' �� :e�.��,���0 �-r..�
%
����
��,
.
n
�
��.._.����, �-Yi�.
� 1
�> �} ��2. � �-
_. _ ,,,� �
,� �; % � y � ��,'.'� _
, ,
,r=�, � ,•f�►A� �'s�,�'�liAl.,i;�r�,. �.
�-
�� ��- � � '�Z
�
�
�3
�,C` �77� (Itc;v. Zf�SS)
Q"iti�y ����r��9�r �1�5,f7QlC�! �<�paal��t��rr�
,;�mm�nw�...
�i.,�l'.1UI1 L1L'ti
.I.CI V�J Il S
"Y" 1 � �'sl�C S
��������,,
,�'�'�11I'�, (�I� �I�� Y()I�
(��+"l+,I�l+� �fJF T�H]G ST�,T�+: C��l'�'1�(.�L��I�
F1 �! �,�'1�ii'Ar�1 �1i'"��i {� ,
�)i+�l�"�' �'�'�i,"��E1�II:�+I��,
�
i i' • •
+Cf.��1I'��T'Y �a� T+I�MPI����, NE'�VV �'flMR�
PI��+;l'AI�I+�[) AS ()T
����t��n��cr~ �, 2Q�12
F�li'v�'�+I2�� 'T"t): `�t�ace; c�f Ne:w Yt�rk
�fI'�cc c�C' tl�c �t.ule �;c�a7��ikrc�ller
f���,,, l�ireetor, Nl�u�y@�:i���rl T�c�;G��o°clt ����c� SC{��isli��
r"�Ifr�tl L�. :�tnnitll S�aite �fC�ic:� �t�ilclir��
�111���Tty, d>Fe;vw Y��C°lc 1?23fj
u���ro������� �����r��
���.
����'� ��u� �������
�u� ,N
.�..e���^��P�� 6 �f- W f_R�iF��:sd
AC 973 (Rev. 7/85)
Cities under 125,000 gopulation
Counties
Towns
Villages
STATE OF NEW YORK
OFFICE OF THE STATE COMPTROLLER
This is the official debt statement form prescribed by the State Comptroller pursuant to section 141.00
of the Local Finance Law for use by counties, towns, villages and cities having a population of less than
125,000 inhabitants.
THOMAS P. DiNAPOLI
State Comptroller
INSTRUCTIONS
1. STATUTORY REFERENCE. A statutory reference can be found after each itern of indebtedness
to be included and excluded in the debt statement. For example, §135.00 (a)(1) means "subdivision 1�1,
1 of paragraph (a) of section 135A0 of the Local Finance Law". Wherever a reference appears, that ; '
section of the Local Finance Law should be consulted. �
2. DATE OF PREPARATION. This statement must not be prepared more than thirty days previous
to the date of sale of bonds. Local Finance Law, section 109.00.
3. FILING. A debt statement must be filed between three and fifteen days before a municipality sells
any bonds which are required to be sold at public sale. The statement must be �led with the State
Comptroller and a duplicate copy must be filed with the clerk or corresponding officer of the
municipality. It is not necessary to file a copy in the county clerk's office. Lacal Finance Law,
section 109.00.
4. AVERAGE FULL VALUATION OF TAXABLE REAL ESTATE. In computing "Average
Full Valuation of Taxable Real Estate" on page 5, use last completed assessment roll and four
preceding rolls. An assessment roll is one which has been completed, verified and filed by the
assessors and for which a state equalization rate has been finalized. The words "For Fiscal Year
Ending" refer to the year for which taxes have been or will be extended on the assessment roll
rather than the year in which the roll was completed.
�1
Page 1
The amounts to be used in Column 1 should be the amounts shown on such rolls after the hearing of
�,., grievances and the filing of the final completed assessment rolls, regardless of subsequent changes.
In Column 1, include the assessed valuations of special franchises but exclude the assessed
valuations of all exempt properties to the extent they are exempt from general taxation. Full
valuation (Column 3) is determined as follows: Divide the taxable assessed valuations (Column 1)
by the final equalization rate (Column 2) established hy the State Board of Equalization and
Assessment for such valuation. Where boundary changes have occurred and in the case of newly-
created municipalities, see section 2.00 {7}(a) of the Local Finance Law. In the case of counties,
average full valuation is computed by dividing the ta�cable assessed valuations on the last completed
and four preceding assessment rolls for each of the cities and towns therein by the final equalization
rates established for such rolls; provided, however, in a county having a county department of
assessment the state equalization rates established for the cities and towns therein on the basis of the
county roll shall be applied to the appropriate portions of the county roll. The sum of the quotients
thus obtained must then be divided by five.
5. INCLUSIONS. Re item 8, Page 5. Include the respective amounts of all several indebtedness and
allocated or apportioned joint indebtedness contracted or incuned pursuant to Article II, Title 1-A
of the Local Finance Law in relation to a joint service or a joint water, sewage or drainage project.
The amount of joint indebtedness to be so included should not exceed the amount of such
indebtedness allocated and apgortioned to the municipality in the bond or note resolution
authorizing such indebtedness to be contracted.
Joint indebtedness to be included arising out of real property liabilities contract liabilities should
not exceed the amount of such indebtedness required to be allocated and apportioned to the
^ municipality in the agreement of the participating municipalities in relation to such joint service or
project. Where the agreement does not provide for any such allocation or apportionment, or in the
case of involuntary joint indebtedness, the amount to be allocated and apportioned and included in
the debt statement of a participating municipality should be in the same proportion as the full
valuation of the real estate subject to taxation or assessment by such municipality for such joint
service or project bears to the full valuation of the real estate subject to taxation or assessment by
all of the participating municipalities for such joint service or project. See Local Finance Law,
section 15.10. However, if the State Comptroller has issued a certificate allocating and
apportioning such joint indebtedness pursuant to the provisions of section 15.10 of the Local
Finance Law, the amounts so allocated and apportioned by the State Comptroller should be
included in the debt statements of each respective municipality as indebtedness.
1�
6. GROSS JOINT INDEBTEDNESS. The aggregate grass amount of all joint indebtedness
including borrowings, real property liabilities, contract liabilities, judgments, claims, awards and
determinations contracted or incurred and before any apportionment or allocation should be stated
at page 5 of the debt statement.
Page 2
7. EXCLUSIONS:
(1) Item 1, Page 6. Do not include any tax or revenue obligations, or renewals thereof,
which have not been retired within five years after the date such original obligations
were issued.
(2) Item 2, Page 6. Include only obligations issued for objects or purposes other than the
financing of capital improvements and contracted to be redeemed in one of the two fiscal
years immediately succeeding the year of their issue. Do not include bonds, bond
anticipation notes, capital notes, budget notes or obligations which have been issued for
the direct financing of improvements or equipment. Do not include serial bonds of an
issue having a maximum maturity of more than two years.
(3) Item 3, Page 6. Do not include joint or several indebtedness contracted pursuant to
Article II, Title 1-A of the Local Finance Law to finance a joint water project. Such
indebtedness is to be included in Item 14, page 6.
(4) Items 4 and 5, Page 6. Do not include any indebtedness contracted pursuant to Article
II, Title 1-A of the Local Finance Law in relation to a joint service or a joint water,
sewage or drainage project. Such indebtedness is to be included in either item 15 or 16
at page b.
(5) Item 13, Page 6. Include city indebtedness for education purgoses, if any, allocated to
the city school district by the State Comptroller pursuant to section 1 of chapter 831 of
the Laws of 1951.
�
(6) Item 14, Page 6. State the respective amounts of any several indebtedness and the
allocated or apportioned amounts of any joint indebtedness contracted or incurred in
relation to the �nancing of a joint water project pursuant to Article II, Title 1-A of the
Local Finance Law.
(7) Items 15 and 16, Page 6. State the resgective amounts of any several indebtedness and
the allocated or apportioned amounts of any joint indebtedness contracted or incurred in
relation to the financing of a joint service and a joint sewage or drainage project
pursuant to Article II, Title 1-A of the Local Finance Law and excluded pursuant to the
provisions of section 15.20, 123.00 and 124.10 of such law.
8. VERIFICATION. Page 9. This debt statement must be verified by the chief fiscal officer of the
municipality. See definition of the term "chief fiscal officer" in the Local Finance Law, section 2.�0
(5). If a municipality has no chief fiscal officer, then this statement must be verified by the �inance
board.
Page 3
The following is a statement of the Town of Ithaca in the County
�` of Tompkins New York, to contract indebtedness, and is prepared as of Sept 4,
2012, pursuant to Title 8, Article II of the Local Finance Law.
DEBT LIMIT
Counties (except Nassau), cities, towns and villages .........................................
Multiply "Average full valuation" (Page 5), Line 7 by .07
(Nassau County .10)
Total Inclusions (Page 5) ..........
Less: Total Exclusions (Page 6}
Total Net Indebtedness .............
TOTAL NET INDEBTEDNESS
.......................................................
�
�
NET-DEBT CONTRACTING MARGIN
88,126,834
6,112,920
5,171,920
941,000
Debt Limit (Above) ..................................•----....................................... 88,126,834
� Less: Total Net Indebtedness (Above) .......................................................... 941,Q00
Net Debt-Contracting Margin .................................................................... 87,185,834
PERCENTAGE OF DEBT- CONTRACTING POWER EXHAUSTED
�
Divide "Total Net Indebtedness" by "Debt limit" and enter result here
PRQPQSED BOND ISSUE
The amount of bonds proposed to be sold at public sale on Sept 19,
2012, in connection with which this statement is made and filed is ..
The amount of bond anticipation notes heretofore issued in anticipation of the
sale and issuance of such bonds and included at "Borrowings" at Item 1 of
Inclusionsat page 5 is ............................................................................
Page 4
1.07%
2,60Q,000
316,920
STATEMENT OF TOTAL DEBT
AVERAGE FULL VALUATION OF TAXABLE REAL PROPERTY
Note: See Instruction 4, Pnge 1
INCLUSIONS
1. Bonowings. §135.00(a)(1) . ......................
2. Real Property Liabilities. §135.00(a)(2), §142.00 . ...................................
3. Contract Liabilities. §135.�0(a)(3) . .....................................................
4. Cities, Towns and Villages:
Contract Liahilities: Housing Guarantees; Subsidies. §135.00(a)(4},{a)(4-a),{a)(4-b).
5. Cities, Towns and Villages:
State Loans to Certain Housing Authorities and Municipalities. §135.00(a)(5). ....
6. Judgments, Claims, Awards and Determinations. §135.00(a)(6) . ....................
7. Cities, Towns and Villages:
Indebtedness Contracted by Certain District Corporations. §135(a)(7) . .............
8. Indebtedness Contracted or Incurred Pursuant to Artical II, Title 1-A of the Local
Finance Law in relation to a Joint Water, Sewage or Drainage Project:
(See Instruction 5, Page 2.)
(a) Borrowings; Several Indebtedness . ...................................................
(b) Borrowings: Allocated or Apportioned Joint Indebtedness . .......................
(c) Real Property Liabilities . ...............................................................
(d) Contract Liabilities . .....................................................................
(e) Judgments, Claims, Awards and Determinations . ..................................
TotalInclusions ........................................................................
GROSS JOINT INDEBTEDNESS
The aggregate gross amount of all joint indebtedness before apportionment or
allocadonis ......................................................................................
(See instrttction 6, Page 3.)
Page 5
$5,796,Q00.00
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
316,920
0
0
a
$6,112,920.00
$2,600,000
�"1
� �
/�
EXCLUSIONS
1. Tax and Revenuc Obligations. §13G.00(1) . .......................................... $
(See bistrtectio�r 7(a), page 3.)
2. Obligations Issued for other than Capital Improvements. §136.00(1-a). .........
(See Instr�ection 7(b), page 3.)
3. Water Indebtedness. §136.00(2) . ......................................................
(See Instructiori 7(c), page 3.)
4. Indebtedness Contracted for Self-Liquidating Projects. §136.Q0(3) . ..............
(See bas�ruction 7(d), page 3.)(See also, if applicable, caritrac� pa}nnerits (§136.00
(3-a))) and ren�al paymen�s (§13G.00 (3-b)(3-c)))
S. Sewer Indebtedness Contracted on or after January 1, 1962, and prior to January 1,
1994. §136.00(4-a) . .....................................................................
6. Lionds for Pensions. §136.00(4) . ......................................................
7. Cities and Villages with Population of 5,000 or More:
Indebtedness for Housing and Urban Renewal Purposes. §]36.00(8). ..........
(See also, if applicable, indebtedness for ltottsing or ttrban re��ewal purposes
(§136.00(8-a)).
8. Towns and Villages with Population of less than 5,000:
Subsidies or Guarantees for Housing Purposes. §136.00(9) . ....................
9. Assels of Sinking Funds. §136.00(10) . .............................................
�� 10. Refunded and Refunding boods. §]36.00(10-a)(10-b) . ...........................
�"\
11. Cash on Haod for Debts. §136.00(11) . ..............................................
12. Appropriations. §136.00(12) . .........................................................
13. Cities Only:
School Indebtedness. §136.00(13) ...................................................
(See Instructiw� 7(e), page 3)
14. (a) Several Indebtedness Contracted in relation to a joint Water Project § 15.2
(b) Joint lndebtcdncss Contracted for such Purposes . .....................
(See Ir�.strucliai 7{n, page 3.)
15. (a) Several Indebtedness Contracted for a Joinl Service and Excluded Pursuant
to Local Finance Law, §15.20 and §123.Q0 . ...........................
(b) The Apportioned or Allocated A�ount of any such Joint Indebtedness
soexcluded . .......................••••••....................................
(Seelnstra�crioi� 7(g), pnge3.)
16. (a) Several Inelebtedness Contracted for a Joint 3ewage and/or Dainage
Project and Excluded Pu�uant to Local Finance Law, §15.20, §123.00,
And§124.10 . ...............................................................
(b) The Apportioned or Allocated Amounl of any such Joint Indebtedness
soexcluded. ...••• ...........................................................
(See lestrr�c�ia� 7(g), page 3.)
Total Exclusions
Page 6
$0
0
4,784,Q00
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
71,000
0
(a) 0
(b) 31G,920
(a)
ro>
(a)
ro�
0
0
0
0
$5,171,920
SCHEDULE A
PART 1. The foU�wing obligations will be sold at the sale in connection with which this debt statement is filed:
Date Type Amount Object or Purpose
of of to be for which
Authorization Obli akion Sold Authorized
7/13/2Q09 SB $600,000 Road Reconstruction (water system related)
7/27/2012 SB 2,000,000 Water System Improvements
Total....... $2,600,000
PART 2. The following bond anticipation notes have been issued in anticipation of the honds listed in PART 1
above, and are now outstanding.
Date
of Amount Object or Purpose for which Authorized
Note
10/14/2011 BAN $316,920 Road Reconstruction (water system related)
Total ............. $316,920
Tl�e following symbols may be rised: Serial Batds�B; Statutory btstnllment Bonds-SIB; Bond Antrcipation
Note-BAN; CapitalNote-CN; TiixAnticipatiarNote-TAN; RevenrreAnticipationNote-RAN; BudgetNote-BN;
Certificate of ladebtedness-Cl; Sinking Frutd Bards�FB.
Page 7
�
�
��
SCHEDULE B
PART 1. The following abligations are authorized, unissued and will be sold prior to the sale of lhe obligations
listed in 5chedule A, PART 1.
Date Type Amount
of of to be
Authorization Obli ation Issued
NONE $0
..i_ . . . . T ._ . .-.� .. -'1.
� _ •�
v. �. Y 7 `
Total . $0 v!^:r�,_ �r. ,�; �;� n, .. ��: ,...
r�r . ,:,.
PART 2. The following obligations are authorized, unissued and will not be sold prior lo the sale of the
obligations listed in Schedule A, PART 1.
Date Type Amount
of of Remaining
Authorization Obli ation Unissued
NONE $0
Total $0
Page 8
�
VERIFICATION BY CHIEF FISCAL OFFICER
State of New York
ss:
County of TOMPKINS
HEBERT ENGMAN, being duly sworn, deposes and says: That he is the duly selected, qualified,
and acting chief fiscal officer of the TOWN OF ITHACA, COUNTY OF TOMPKINS, New York; that
he prepared and has read the foregoing debt statement amendment and knows the contents thereof; that
the same is true to his own knowledge except as to the matters therein stated to be alleged upon
information and belief, and that as to those matters he believes it to be true.
Subscribed and sworn t before me this �day
of , 20_�.
�^ Signatur
J `
,.,� .,� .� . . �.-
Title
215 North Tioga Street
Ithaca. New York 14850
Notary Pub ic Mail Address
PAULETf'E TERWfLUGER
l�tary PuWic, Sta�e of New l�k
No,otTEetsseo9 VERIFICATION BY FINANCE BOARD
ouetified in rompldns Coimy
CAtrt�ion Exp&es Deoentber 4.20�� Necessary if verifccation is made by chief frscal oJj`'icer
State of New York )
) ss:
Caunty of )
being each duly sworn, depose and say: That they are the duly (elected) (appointed), qualified, and
acting members of the finance board of the in the County of ,
New York; that they prepared and each of them has read the foregoing debt statement and knows the
contents thereof; that the same is true of their own knowledge except as to the matters therein stated to
be alleged upon information and belief; and that as to those matters they believe it to be true.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this day
of
Notary Public
2Q
Page 9
�1
�
/""�
�
������
� ��,, ,, , , ; �� ���� � � � �N�1 �r,l�►
�,�����. ,,,� �� , 2'fl5 IV. Tir�g� ��re�t, Ith��c�, f`�1.Y. 1485a
<,� ' ,i,/ ✓„� ,�
'�"� .,��� "�"w�^"w�'.�1�5�1�t1,1%��iiG�i.�1�.�:15
PauletQe ��rwiPli�er, Tcawn C�erk Ph�ane: (GC17) 273-172`� De�r�a Cie,�l�cegisticr�, D�puat� Tawn Glerk
pterwilVic�er"(�„c�"town.u�haca.r�y.us F�x: (6�7) 27�-5854 cicle�ugisCiru��tcawn�.ith�ca.ny.�€s
[.,ett�ar tc� 13ar�ct Ca��nscl
ST�F�'�#� �7►F 1�EW Y4RK
C'(��.�'N'�"�' i7►F T�Ni�'I�TN�
I, the ����cler�si�n��17'ow� C6�c�-k r�f thc 7`cr�vn a�' it�l���uc�, '�"arn��ri�s C�����t�y, �a�w Yr�t�l�,
�o l�eret�,y cer�ify tl�a� ��le��t �Staten�aem�t cyf said' '['o��°n p�•c���r�c�l �s of` �e�t�ei�r►kae�• 4,
20�2, �v��s �lul;�� �led iru my� c�ffice on #tie ia�°` day caf �;e�teza�t�cr.
l� Wl'1��'E�S W���M�.E()�", � l��ve ha��-cunto sct ���;�� n�l ar�c� aff�xe� t��e se�l r��'s�xid
To���n this 6t°` d��;�° raf �Septenr�kacrw
__. ......_._ ._.__ _...._
FatAlet��. �'er�ti i11i�;er, Ta�^�°n �Clerlc
iprflNN1WN»r, ' ' .,. �
� � =��� ... . .
; ygtlWllY�YRp�a..
,��
�� w, �; i�� �
11 Nh ` . .
� ��.: . .. w .
: r.: � � "`. �..� � � :� ..' r �: : :w � � �..�, * . r`. .` .� � '+`. �. , � i ! � 4�Y�
Tr�ara��r�sb�r� V��a�� I��v� r��at ur����� a�t. At c��r ��� r�e �r� r�a� lc�ng�r �b�'� tr
��r� �c�c ��� pr����rt�°. �h�r�°��ar� rrwe ar� p�at�tcr�g th� �r���r�� �ca �u��icar� ir�
C�ct�b��.
_ �, � � _ � . , � � � , „ � . . ,� # � �, ,�
. +r - s � � ,� . � t , ,� ., . ,� . � - . � . ,� ,� - r � �r �
^� �, � ,� �, � . r� • sr a� +r . ^' � . - , +r . - � � �
�#i�tc��%c Pr�p�r°�a�s h�s d�cNi�u�� �h� �f��r,�m��rcnic�� �as �h�� th�ir ��er�cy is� h��ir��
�nf�i��al�t� i� m��nt�ir�a��� fihe ��stc�r�� ������i�s �r�s�r��l� �r�d�r �6�� ���t�'�
a�,rn�rsE�i�..
� . . ,� � . � � ,� , . . � • r � � � �r �w r �w . .
� � • - - .� �r � s « � �; . �' � • � . , ,� � >
�rap�r�� in tvv� y��rs c��' rr��r�,
'�J� ht��� tf��� th� n��t c�r�r��r� r��Vl ��i�� �h�ar iru��r�s� ►r� th� ��°ap�r�� �i�h �6��
��r�as �� �9�� I��tic�r�al ���9��r� c��F 1-fi�t��ic �I�c�s. "�"e wn�ila ���s +�r� �ol t�r� �i����t�ar�
��v�� p����ir�� �� t@�� hasl�c��~y a°F �8�� �r��erty� th�� e�r� h��� ac��ar�ui�t�d, �s �r�1G �s
�c�t�r�t��0 s�u�c�� ,Nn���di�� �F�� I��taan�l ���is�°�r� ���' d�h���'� ���,r �, ���,�..
"�� �r� �r����ul �c�� t�a� p�ti�r�� a��en�i�ar� ��d ��rrr� t��t �c�� ar�d tFw� Pl�rar�ic�g
�c��rd g��e t�ar�rard ��� e�antinu�n,� pr�s�r��tia� �� i�Vis�cari',c ��ca��er�i�s dn i�h��a.
�ir�c�a����, �
,� , ,.�
, .
��`s � r"`:� ,����'t' ���� �,, �.
�,, �, �,�'r�;� ,.
�,�.-' � ��m� � �,�,�.� �,
�
�
T0: Historic Ithaca
ATT: Dennis Stein , Alphonse Pieper and Board Members
The Chapel had never been rented, and has been vacant since I moved my studio.
Rosalind and I wanted the Chapel to be used as Library and/or Museum-- to serve
an educational purpose regarding the history of the Abolitionist movement in
Ithaca—to pay homage to the bravery, sacrifice , and humanity of Ithaca's
Abolitionists who built the Chapel, dedicating it (as documented) to God and the
Freedom of Man.
We appreciate that the Schoolhouse being rented would help an organization
that took over the property. The rent would help the project we envisioned for
the Chapel.(We had hoped that eventually the Schoolhouse, too, might be open
to the public).
But we do not want the Chapel to be converted to a rental unit .We believe It
,,,r.� defeats the purpose (stated above) for our wanting to donate the property.
We appreciate your informing us that if Historic Ithaca cannot develop and
continue to maintain the buildings, the property might be sold as has been
Historic Ithaca's procedure with other properties , owned for short periods.
Because our vision for this property is not in the foreseeable future of your plans,
we are withdrawing our offer. I believe that Mr.Hinchcliff had already spoken to
you about our position.
Our sincere thanks for your having considered this property.
Rosalind and Salvatore Grippi
�
>1Ca.�4�1' �1Q)�r� � c�vr�7�:��a�;(��r r����il,c.,�>rxi
����. ��� ri�'�/�r�de�'M�.�� v�rvvw.��r����,c�rn
;3r'�� I��ar�,,t Flr�ir�c5 a.)r�ivrry, It9��t����, P�1Y 1�-Il3,'y(�
�"t"t"t� �r�11Cc)JS
�w14� i'OWCI C�i tti'���C�
215 d'�. Ticrs;�l �t�-�c�ti
ith<rc<z, N4T 1�b5(1
Se��t�mk�er lltlt, ��12
I:)c:ar F°reci,
��ldl1 '�"VT'&Tlll� l41 Il1�C)1"171 '�C)ll ��17i, i�tPf'' �() UC1�C)C�S��]] ��C1�St7Cl:il t 1i'f:kltB]S1�i61C1"",S: � tiI17 11I141�7�t �l7 l,()IAlllllll I�l}T i�l"V144', 4"1k�1
tlae'�'ow��a �"It�;��zt T�l<�nm�i�n�; &3az�r<���. IC 9�y���s ��een ����lea;;��r�e t�c�� ;ser��e Yl�c }���c����1� c�f [ti��ca �n�l I l��kv� c�Xljc�}���c� t��i���; ��a�•C �(�
tl�e er��;��ir��;, t�l�c�u�;l�t�f�.�l ��}�rc�a�r,l� t17at t��� �a�rc�l ar7�;�;m�cicr-s.
'1�17as�k yn�r }7ersz>r7r�lly l�c�r y��zr E.�art ir7 a�r�eatia��; a r�s)��cc:tl�rl, c.niiver;�at�ic�i���a➢Iy �:l'aversc, �r�nr� c��t��1i�-��i�i�:i�lff�d fc�rL�z�a t17�zt
��rc�rrzotes t���ls���c��l l<i��tl use a��d sr�wtai�3able fc�resi�;fi1. I wis�� yc�u a11 cc>nCi9��iec1 ��rc�};ress.
Sir��ere�y �'c�u�-�,
�s�w�� �
� � �
, _.
,
_ � ,, �,
, ,,
.
, e,,
-s d� ' �^� �°� �
. 1=.r-i� Va¢��iec�Ivlstti�s
s�d����,:.
�NaREW M. �iLldh+tt�
�cavr,,car��rz
k�E: 2Q1�} ���E��al'�t�on 7rtil
C�e�r Tawr� C�erk,
iy� �� '' x
h ["� '�`" �� S. "`.
� ��� 'ti��`�a�,
a yY`1�"�sN�r��..., $,
Sr�arF �sr �E�v Yc���.
D�PAF2TPs��tVT QF STAT�
�}NE C�M�tEF�CE f �f�Zf�
�� �/�/,45HIR9GTC7N ,�VENIJ�
��_g.a�,�, rvv � ���� -a���
��S/tF; �4. �EF�AL�S
�ec�:E: o a�zv c7F S rar�
/` � , ..
� m ,! ���`"i i
Sep�t�t77E�e� 1.:�, ��11� ,� �""�% � �,� �
� �.
d', � � •
u�.�.dw �E�S �;. � �
.� �l )�` �L� � ,.� / � �'d��'f�;�ti
6'ursuar�t t� Tawr� Law, Sectic��a 11, the Secretary oF St�ze is ecc�uired to �il� w"rtf� yc��ar crffice �n autl�era�ic�ted
stater-�ent e�f tE�� pap�ak��ir�n caf ea�h towr7 whose populatitar7 is 5,0€3(7 crr rrrpr� as shawn in ti�e dec�r�ni�al t=�der�l
censt�s. Encic�sec� ycau wi61 Girid � copy a€ seic6� st�temer�t, fr�ar-r� tf7e Unit�c� 5tat�s Ce�7sus f3�ire�ra, whic#i sfaavors the
?OlQ p��ul�atian �f your tcawr�.
,�����„a.
if you havc �a�y r�uestians, ��Ne�s� calf INilli�rn Sl�arp, f�rinciE�tal �it#c�rney, at (�1�) �74-f�;'�f�.
E��closure
Yc�cirs �ruly,
&���vision caf Lr�c�l �'ave�s7���er�t�
WVW'4^J.UC�S'.NY..CGUW • �:,—I'vOFtIL:INE()(I�fJ�?.�'r.IVY..GQV
,�
�
P"1
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2010
2Q10 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
Total Po ulation
April �, April 1, Po ulation Change
Geographic Area 2000r 2010 Number Percent
lv ew Y orK �JiaiB
New York City
Albany County
Albany city
Bernetown
Bethlehem town
Coeymans town
Cohoes city
Colonie town
Green Island town
Guilderland town
Knox town
New Scotland town
Rensselaerville town
Watervliet city
Westerlo town
Allegany County
Alfred town
Allen town
Alma town
Almond town
Amity town
Andover town
Angelica town
Belfast town
Birdsall town
Bolivar town
Burnstown
Caneadea town
Centerville town
Clarksville town
Cuba town
Friendship town
Genesee town
Granger town
Grove town
Humetown
Independence town
12S,y/6,tS! 1
8,008,686
294,571
94,444
2,853
31,338
8,161
15,607
79,327
2,283
34,045
2,647
8,588
1,915
9,904
3,459
49,927
5,140
462
847
1,604
2,245
1,945
1,411
1,714
268
2,223
1,248
2,694
762
1,146
3,392
1,927
1,803
577
533
1,987
1,074
Page 1 of 43
1 y,37ti,1 UZ
8,175,133
304,204
97,856
2,794
33,656
7,418
16,168
81,591
2,620
35,303
2,692
8,648
1,843
10,254
3,3b1
48,946
5,237
448
842
1,633
2,308
1,830
1,403
1,663
221
2,189
I,180
2,542
822
1,161
3,243
2,004
1,693
538
548
2,071
1,167
4U1,291 2.]
166,447 2.1
9,633
3,412
-59
2,3I8
-743
561
2,264
337
1,258
45
60
-72
350
-98
-981
97
-14
-5
29
63
-115
-8
-51
-47
-34
-68
-152
b0
15
-149
77
-110
-39
15
84
93
3.3
3.6
-2.1
7.4
-9.1
3:6
2.9
14.8
3.7
1.7
Q.7
-3.8
3.5
-2.8
-2.0
1.9
=3.0
-0.6
1.8
2.8
-5.9
-0.6
-3.0
-17.5
-1.5
-5.4
-5.6
7.9
1.3
-4.4
4.0
-6.1
-6.8
2.8
4.2
8.7
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2010
2010 Census: Pu61ic Law 94-171 Data
New Hudson town
Oil Springs Reservation
Rushford town
Scio town
Ward town
Wellsville town
West Almond town
Willing town
Wirt town
Bronx County
Broome County
Barker town
Binghamton city
Binghamton town
Chenango town
Colesville town
Conklin town
Dickinson town
Fenton town
Kirkwood town
Lisle town
Maine town
Nanticoke town
Sanford town
Triangle town
Union town
Vestal town
Windsor town
Cattaraugus County
Atlegany town
Allegany Reservation
Ashford town
Carrollton town
Cattaraugus Reservation
Coldspring town
Conewango town
Dayton town
East Otto town
� 736
0
1,259
1,914
390
'1,678
353
1,371
1,215
1,332,652
200,536
2,738
47,380
4,969
11,454
5,441
5,940
5,335
6,909
5,651
2,707
5,459
1,790
2,477
3,032
56,266
2b,567
6,421
83,955
8,230
1,099
2,223
1,410
0
751
1,732
1,945
1,105
Page 2 of 43
781
1
1,150
1,833
368
7,397
334
1,228
1,111
1,385,108
200,600
2,732
47,376
4,942
11,252
5,232
5,441
5,278
6,674
5,857
2,751
5,377
1,672
2,407
2,946
56,346
28,043
6,274
80,317
8,004
1,020
2,132
1,297
314
663
1,857
1,886
1,062
45
1
-109
-81
-22
-281
-19
-143
-104
52,456
64
-6
-4
-27
-202
-209
-499
-57
-235
206
44
-82
-I18
-70
-86
80
1,476
- l 47
-3,638
-226
-79
-91
-113
314
-88
125
-59
-43
6.1
N/A
-8.7
-4.2
-5.6
-3.7
-5.4
-10.4
=8.6
3:9
0.0
-0.2
o.a
-0.5
-1.8
-3.8
-8.4
-1.1
-3.4
3.6
1.6
-1.5
-6.6
-2.8
-2.8
0.1
5.6
-2.3
-4.3
-2.7
-7.2
-4.1
-8:0
N/A
-11.7
7.2
-3.0
-3.9
�1
�
�'1
�
�'1
�
�
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2010
2010 Census: Public Law 94,171 Data
Total Po ulation
April l, April l, Po ulation Change
Geo ra hic Area 2000� 2014 Number Percent
�uiconv�ue town
Farmersville town
Franklinville town
Freedom town
Great Valley town
Hinsdale town
Humphrey town
Ischua town
Leon town
Little Valley town
Lyndon town
Machias town
Mansiteld town
Napoli town
New Albion town
Oil Springs Reservation
Olean city
Olean town
Otto town
Perrysburg town
Persia town
Portville town
Randolph town
Red House town
Salamanca city
Salamanca town
South Valley town
Yorkshire town
Cayuga County
Auburn city
Aurelius town
Brutus town
Cato town
Conquest town
Fleming town
Genoa town
Ira town
Ledyard town
Locke town
Mentz town
1,"/S 2S
1,028
3,128
2,493
2,145
2,270
721
895
1,380
1,788
661
2,482
800
1,159
2,068
0
15,347
2,029
831
1,771
2,512
3,952
2,681
38
6,097
544
302
4,210
81,961
28,574
2,936
4,777
2,744
1,925
2,647
1,914
2,426
1,832
1,900
2,446
Page 3 of 43
1,598
1,090
2,990
2,405
l ,974
2,168
687
859
1,365
1,740
707
2,375
808
1,248
1,972
0
14,452
1,963
808
1,626
2,404
3,730
2,602
38
5,815
481
264
3,913
80,026
27,687
2,792
4,464
2,537
1,819
2,636
1,935
2,206
1,886
1,951
2,378
-140
62
-138
-88
-1'71
-102
-34
-36
-15
-48
46
-107
8
89
-96
0
-895
-66
-23
-145
-108
-222
-79
0
-282
-63
-38
-297
-1,935
-887
-144
-313
-207
-106
-11
21
-220
54
51
-68
-8.1
6.0
-4.4
-3.5
-8.0
-4.5
-4.7
-4.0
-1.1
-2.7
7.0
-43
1.0
7.7
-4.6
N/A
-5.8
-33
-2.8
-8.2
-4.3
-5.6
-2.9
0.0
-4.6
-11.6
-12.6
-7.1
-2.4
-3.1
-4.9
-6.6
-7.5
-5.5
-0.4
1.1
-9.1
2.9
2.7
-2.8
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2010
2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data .
Total Po ulation
April 1, April l, � Po ulallon Chan e
Geographic Area 2000' 2010 Number Perceat
Montezuma town
Moravia town
Niles town
Owasco town
Scipio town
Sempronius town
Sennett town
Springport town
Sterling town
Summerhill town
Throop town
Venice town
Victory town
Chautauqua County
Arkwright town
Busti town
Carroll town
Cattaraugus Reservation
Charlotte town
Chautatiqua town
Cherry Creek town
Clymer town
Dunkirk city
Dunkirk town
Ellery town
Ellicott town
Ellington town
French Creek town
Gerry town
Hanover town
Harmony town
Jamestown city
Kiantone town
Mina town
North Harmony town
Poland town
Pomfret town
Portland town
Ripley town
Sheridan town
1,431
4,040
1,208
3,755
1,537
893
3,244
2,256
3,432
1,098
1,824
1,286
1,836
139,747
1,126
7,757
3,635
0
1,713
4,666
1,152
1,501
13,131
1,387
4,576
9;280
1,639
935
2,054
7,638
2,339
31,984
1,385
1,176
2,521
2,467
14,703
5,502
2,636
2,584
Page 4 of 43
1,277
3,626
1,194
3,793
1,713
895
3,595
2,367
3,040
1,217
1,990
1,368
1,660
134,905
1,061
7,351
3,524
38
1,729
4,464
1,118
1,698
12,563
1,31 S
4,528
8,714
1,b43
906
1,905
7,127
2,206
31,146
1,350
1,106
2,267
2,356
14,965
4,$27
2,415
2,673
-154
-414
-14
38
176
2
351
111
-392
119
166
82
-176
-4,842
-65
-406
-111
38
16
-202
-34
197
-568
-b9
-48
-566
4
-29
-149
-511
-133
-838
-35
-70
-254
-111
262
-675
-221
89
-10.8
-i a.a
-1.2
1.0
11.5
0.2
10.8
4.9
-11.4
10.8
9.1
6.4
-9.6
-3.5
-5.8
-5.2
-3.1
N/A
0.9
-4.3
-3.0
13.1
-4.3
-5.0
-1.0
-6.1
0.2
-3.1
-7.3
-6.7
-5.7
-2.6
-2.5
-6.0
-10.1
-4.5
1.8
-12.3
-8.4
3.4
�
a
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
. 2000 to 2010 .
P'1 2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
�
�
Geographic Area
Sherman town
Stockton town
Villenova town
Westfield town
Chemung County
Ashland town,
Baldwin town
Big Flats town
Catlin town
Chemung town
Elmira city
Elmira town
Erin town
Horseheads town
Southport town
Van Etten town
Veteran town
Chenango County
Afton town
Bainbridge town
Columbus town
Coventry town
German town
Greene town
Guilford town �
Lincklaen town
McDonough town
New Berlin town
North Norwich town
Norwich city
Norwich town
Otselic town
Oxford town
Pharsalia town
Pitcher town
Plymouth town
Preston town
Sherburne town
Smithville town
Total Po�
April 1,
ZD�a�
1,553
2,331
1,121
5,232
91,072
1,951
853
7,224
2,654
2,665
30,942
7,199
2,058
1.9,557
11,185
1,518
3,266
51,398
2,977
3,441
931
1,589
378
5,729
3,046
4I6
870
2,803
1,966
7,355
3,836
I ,001
3,992
542
848
2,049
928
3,976
1,347
Page 5 of 43
April 1,
2010
1,653
2,248
I,110
4,896
88,830
1,695
832
7,731
2,618
2,563
29,20Q
b,934
1,962
19,485
10,940
1,557
3,313
50,477
2,851
3,308
975
1,655
370
5,604
2,922
396
886
2,682
1,783
7,190
3,998
1,054
3,901
S93
803
1,804
1,044
4,048
1,330
Number
100
-83
-11
-336
-2,242
-256
-21
507
-36
-102
-1,742
-265
-96
-72
-245
39
47
-921
-126
-93
44
66
-8
-125
-124
-20
16
-121
-183
-165
162
53
-91
Sl
-45
-245
116
72
-17
6.4
-3.6
-1.0
-6.4
-2.5
-13.1
-2.5
7.Q
-1.4
-3.8
• -5.6
-3.7
-4.7
-0.4
-2.2
2.6
1.4
-1.8
-4.2
-2.7
4.7
4.2
-2.1
-2.2
-4.1
-4.8
1.8
-4.3
-9.3
-2.2
4.2
5.3
-2.3
9.4
=5.3
-12.0
12.5
1.8
-1.3
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Goverament Areas,
2000 to 2010
2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
�Total Population �"
April l, � April l, Population Change
Geographic Area 2000� 2010 Number Percent
amyrnatown
Clinton County
Altona town
Au Sable town
Beekmantown town
Black Brook town
Champlain town
Chazy town
Clinton town
Dannemora town
Ellenburg town
Mooers town
Peru town
Plattsburgh city
Plattsburgh town
Saranac town
Schuyler Falls town
Columbia County
Ancram town
Austerlitz town
Canaan town
Chatham town
Claverack town
Clermont town
Copake town
Gallatin town
Gerrnantown town
Ghent town
Greengort town
Hillsdale town
Hudson city
Kinderhook town
Livingston town
New Lebanon town
Stockport town
Stuyvesant town
Taghkanic town
1,412i
79,894
3,160
3,O11
5,321
1,660
5,79I
4,186
731
5,150
1,812
3,404
6,364
18,816
11,283
4,077
5,128
63,094
1,513
1,453
1,820
4,249
6,401
1,726
3,278
1,499
2,018
5,276
4,180
1,744
7,524
8,296
3,424
2,454
2,933
2,188
1,118
1,"LtiU
82,128
2,887
3,146
5,545
1,497
5,754
4,284
737
4,898
1,743
3,592
b,998
19,989
11,870
4,007
S,181
63,096
1,573
1,654
1,710
4,128
6,021
1,965
3,615
1,668
1,954
5,402
4,165
1,927
6,713
8,498
3,646
2,3U5
2,815
2,027
1,310
Cortland County 48,599 49,336
Page 6 of 43
-138
2,234
-273
135
224
-163
-37
98
6
-252
-69
188
634
1,173
587
-70
53
2
60
201
-110
-121
-380
239
337
169
-64
126
-15
.183
-511
202
222
-149
-118
-161
192
737
-9.7
2.8
-8.6
4.5
4.2
-9.8
-0.6
2.3
0.8
-4.9
-3.8
5.5
10.0
6.2
5.2
-1.7
1.0
0.0
4.0
13.8
-6.0
-2.8
-5.9
13.8
10.3
I 1.3
-3.2
2.4
-U.4
10.5
-10.8
2.4
6.5
-6.1
-4.0
-7.4
17.2
1.5
�
l'i
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2010
� 2010 Ce�sus:�Public Law 94-171 Data
�Geographic Area
Cincinnatus town
Cortland city
Cortlandville town
Cuyler town
Freetown town
Harford town
Homer town
Lapeer town
Marathon town
Preble town
Scott town
Soion town
Taylor town .
Truxton town
Virgil town
Willet town
� Delaware County
Andes town
Bovina town
Colchester town
Davenport town
Delhi town
Deposit town
Franklin town
Hamden town
Hancock town
� Hatpersfield tavi+n
Kortright town
Masonville town
Meredith town
Middletown town
Roxbury town
Sidney town
Stamford town
Tompkins town
Walton town
� Dutchess County
Amenia town
Beacon city
Totat Po�
April 1,
ZO��r
1,048
l 8,74Q
7,9I9
1,036
789
919
b,3b3
686
2,189
1,582
1,193
1,108
SOfl
1,225
2,288
1,OI4
48,057
1,356
664
2,042
2,774
4,629
1,687
2,621
1,280
3,451
1,603
1,633
1,405
1,588
4,051
2,509
6,109
1,943
1,105
5,607
280,153
4,062
14,805
Page 7 of 43
lation
April l,
201U
1;056
19,204
8,SQ9
980
757
943
6,405
767
1,967
1,393
1,176
1,079
523
1,I33
2,401
1,043
47,980
1,301
633
2,077
2,965
5,117
1,712
2,411
1,323
3,224
1,577
I,b75
1,320
1,529
3,750
2,502
5,774
2,267
1,247
5,576
297,488
4,436
15,541
8
464
590
-56
-32
24
42
81
-222
-189
-17
-29
23
-92
113
29
-77
-SS
-31
35
191
488
25
-210
43
-227
-26
42
-85
-59
-301
-7
-335
324
142
-31
17,335
374
73b
0.8
2.5
7.5
-5.4
-4.1
2.6
0.7
11.8
-10.1
-11.9
-1.4
-2.6
4.6
-7.5
4.9
2.9
�-a.2
-4.1
-4.7
I.7
b.9
10.5
1.5
-S.0
3.4
-6.6
-1.6
2.6
-6.0
-3.7
-7.4
-0.3
-5.5
16.7
12.9
-0.6
6.2
9.2
5.0
. Ta�ble 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2010
2010 Census: Pubiic Law 94-171 Data
Total Population
April 1, April l, Population Change
Geogra hic Area 2000" 2010 Number Percent
Beelanan town
Clinton town
Dover town
East Fishkill town
Fishkill town
Hyde Park town
La Grange town
Milan town
North East town
Pawling town
Pine Plains town
Pleasant Valley town
Poughkeepsie city
Poughkeepsie town
Red Hook town
Rhinebeck town
Stanford town
Union Vale town
Wappinger town
Washington town
Erie County
Alden town
Amherst town �
Aurora town
Boston town
Brant town
Buffalo city
Cattaraugus Reservation
Cheektowaga town
CIarence town
Colden town
Collins town
Concord town
Eden town
Elma town
Evans town
Grand Island town
Hamburg town
Holland town
Lackawanna city
13,698
4,011
8,562
25,588
19,261
20,83?
14,926
2,359
3,002
7,521
2,559
9,Ob3
30,157
42,492
10,394
7,774
3,553
4,521
26,272
4,736
950,265
10,470
116,510
13,996
7,897
1,906
292,648
0
94,019
26,123
3,323
8,307
8,526
8,076
11,304
17,594
18,621
56,261
3,603
19,064
Page S of 43
] 4,621
4,312
8,699
29,029
22,107
21,571
15,730
2,370
3,031.
8,463
2,473
9,b72
32,736
43,341
11,319
7,548
3,823
4,877
27,Q48
4,741
919,040
1 �,865
122,366
13,782
8,023
2,065
261,310
1,833
88,22b
30,673
3,265
6,601
8,494
7,688
11,317
16,356
20,374
56,936
3,401
1$,141
923
301
137
3,441
2,846
734
804
11
29
942
-86
609
2,579
849
925
-226
270
356
776
5
-31,225
395
5,856
-214
126
I59
-31,338
1,833
-5,793
4,550
-58
-1,706
-32
-388
13
-1,238
1,753
675
-202
-923
6:7
7.5
1.6
13.4
I4.8
3.5
5.4
0.5
1.0
12.5
-3.4
6.7
8.6
2.0
8.9
-2.9
7.6
7.9
3.0
0.1
-3.3
3.8
5.0
-1.5
1.6
8.3
-10.7
N/A
-6.2
17.4
-1.7
-20.5
-0.4
-4.8
0.1
-7.0
9.4
1.2
-5.6
-4.8
�"1
r'~1
r"h
�
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2010
2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
Total Population
April 1, April 1, Po ulation Change
Geo ra hic Area 2000r 2010 Number Percent
Lancaster town
Marilta town
Newstead town
North Col[ins town
Orchard Park town
Sardinia town
Tonawanda city
Tonawanda town
Tonawanda Reservation
Wales town
West Seneca town
Essex County
Chesterfield town
Crown Point town
Elizabethtown town
Essex town
Jay town
Keene town
Lewis town
Minerva town
Moriah town
Newcomb town
North Elba town
North Hudson town
St. Armand town
Schroon town
Ticonderoga town
Westport town
Willsboro town
W ilmington town
Franklin County
Bangor town
Bellmont town
Bombay town
Brandon town
Brighton town
Burke town
Chateaugay town
Constable town
39,019
5,709
8,404
3,376
27,635
2,692
16,136
78,155
0
2,960
45,920
38,849
2,409
2,119
1,315
713
2,30b
1,063
1,200
796
4,879
481
8,659
26b
1,321
1,759
5,167
1,3b2
1,903
1,131
51,134
2,147
1,423
1,192
542
1,682
1,359
2,036
1,428
Page 9 of 43
41,604
5,327
8,594
3,523
29,054
2,775
15,130
73,567
34
3,005
44,711
39,370
2,445
2,024
1,163
b71
2;506
1,105
1,382
809
4,798
43b
8,957
240
1,548
1,654
5,042
1,312
2,425
1,253
51,599
2,224
1,434
1,357
577
1,435
1,465
2,155
1,566
2,585
-382
190
147
1,419
83
-1,OOb
-4,588
34
45
-1,209
521
36
-95
-152
-42
240
42
182
13
-81
-45
298
-26
227
-ias
-125
-50
122
122
465
77
11
165
35
-247
lOb
119
138
6.6
-6.7
2.3
4.4
S.I
3.1
-6.2
-5.9
N/A
1.5
-2.6
1.3
1.5
-4.5
-11.6
-5.9
8.7
4.0
15.2
1.6
-1.7
-9.4
3.4
-9.8
17.2
-6.0
-2.4
-3.7
6.4
10.8
0.9
3.6 .
0.8
13.8
6.5
-14.7
7.8
5.8
9.7
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2010
2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
Total Po ulation --
April 1, April 1, Population Chan e
Geographic Area 2000r 2010 Number Percent
ytcxmson town
Duane town
Fort Covington town
Franklin town
Harrietstown town
Malone town
Moira town
St. Regis Mohawk Reservation
Santa Clara town
Tupper Lake town
Waverly town
Westville town
Fulton County
Bleecker town
Broadalbin town
Caroga town
Ephratah town
Gloversville city
Johnstown city
Johnstown town
Mayfield town
Northampton town
Oppenheim town
Perih town
Stratford town
Genesee County
Alabama town
Alexander town
Batavia city
Batavia town
Bergen town
Bethany town
Byron town
Darien town
Elba town
Le Roy town
Oakfield town
Pavilion town
Pembroke town
"/�y
159
1,645
1,197
5,575
14,981
2,857
2,699
395
6,137
1,118
1,823
ss,a��
573
5,070
1,403
1,693
15,391
8,636
7,067
6,432
2,760
1,774
3,638
640
60,370
. 1,881
2,451
16,256
5,915
3,182
1,760
2,493
' 3,061
2,439
7,790
3,203
2,467
4,530
Page 10 of 43
2S"l3
174
1,676
1,140
5,709
14,545
2,934
3,228
345
5,971
1,022
1,819
SS,S31
533
5,260
I ,205
1,682
15,6b5
8,743
7,098
6,495
2,670
1,924
3,646
610
60,079
1,869
2,534
15,465
6,809
3,120
1,765
2,369
3,158
2,370
7,641
3,250
2,495
4,292
84
15
31
-57
134
-436
77
529
-50
-166
-96
-4
454
-40
190
-198
-11
274
107
31
63
-90
150
8
-30
-291
-12
83
-791
894
-62
5
-124
97
-69
-149
47
28
-238
11.4
9.4
1.9
-4.8
2.4
-2.9
2.7
19.6
-12.7
-2.7
-8.6
-0.2
0.8
-7.0
3.7
-14.1
-O.b
1.8
1.2
0.4
1.0
-3.3
8.5
0.2
-4.7
-0.5
-0:6
3.4
-4.9
15.1
-1.9
0.3
-5.0
3.2
-2.8
-1.9
I .5
I.1
-5.3
�
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2010
�►, 2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
TotaI Po ulation
April l, April l, Population Change
Geo ra hic Area 2QOOr 2010 Number Percent
Stafford town 2,409 2,459 50 2.l
Tonawanda Reservation 0 483 483 N/A
n
Greene County
Ashland town
Athens town
Cairo town
Catskill tovm
Coxsackie town
Durham town '
Greenville town
Halcott town
Hunter town
Jewett town
Lexington town
New Baltimore town
Prattsvitle town
Windham town
Hamilton County
Arietta town
Benson town
Hope town
Indian Lake town
Inlet town
Lake Pleasant town
Long Lake town
Morehouse town
Wells town
Herkimer County
Columbia town
Danube town
Fairfield town
Frankfort town
German Flatts town
Herkimer town
Litchfield town
Little Falls city
Little Falls town
Manheim town
48,185
752
3,991
6,317
11,887
8,884
2,592
3,3I6
193
2,717
970
830
3,411
665
1,660
5,377
293
201
392
1,471
406
876
850
151
737
b4,437
1,638
1,098
1,624
7,386
13,629
9,962
1,464
5,193
1,539
3,171
Page 11 of 43
49,221
784
4,089
6,670
11,775
8,918
2,725
3,739
258
2,732
953
805
3,370
700
1,703
4,83b
304
192
403
1,352
333
781
711
86
674
64,519
1,580
1,039
1,627
7,636
13,258
10,175
1,513
4,946
1,587
3,334
1,036
32
98
3S3
-112
34
133
423
65
15
-17
-25
-41
35
43
-541
11
-9
11
-119
-73
-95
-139
-65
-63
82
-58
-59
3
250
-371
213
49
-247
48
163
2.2
4.3
2.5
5.6
-0.9
0.4
5.1
12.8
33.7
0.6
-1.8
-3.0
-1.2
5.3
2.6
-10.1
3.8
-4.5
2.8
-8.1
-18.0
-14.8
-16.4
-43.0
-8.5
0.1
-3.5
-5.4
U.2
3.4
-2.7
2.1
3.3
-4.8
3.1
5.1
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2010
2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
Total Population
April 1, April l, Po ulation Chan e
Geo ra hic Area 2000� 2010 Number Percent
Newport town
Norway town
Ohio town
Russia town
Salisbury town
Schuyler town
Stark town
Warren town
Webb town
Winfield town
Jefferson County
Adams town
Alexandria town
Antwerp town
Brownville town
Cape Vincent town
Champion town
Clayton town
Ellisburg town
Henderson town
Hounsfield town
Le Ray town
Lorraine town
Lymetown
Or[eans town
Pamelia town
Philadelphia•town
Rodman town
Rutland town
Theresa town .
Watertown city
Watertown town
Wilna town
Worth town
Kings County
Lewis County
Croghan town
Denmark town
"1,16y
727
922
2,487
1,953
3,385
7b7
1,133
1,912
2,202
111,738
4,782
4,097
1,793
5,843
3,345
4,3b 1
4,817
3,541
1,377
3,323
19,836
930
2,015
2,465
2,897
2,140
1,147
2,959
2,414
26,705
4,482
6,235
234
2,465,531
26,944
3,163
2,744
Page 12 of 43
"1,3U2
7b2
1,002
2,587
1,958
3,420
757
1,143
1,807
2,086
116,229
5,143
4,061
1,846
6,2b3
2,777
4,494
5,153
3,474
1,360
3,466
21,782
1,037
2,185
2,789
3,160
1,947
l,l7G
3,060
2,905
27,023
4,470
6,427
231
133
35
80
100
5
35
-10
10
-105
-116
4,491
361
-36
53
420
-568
133
336
-67
-17
143
1,946
107
170
324
263
-193
29
101
491
318
-12
192
-3
2,504,700 39,169
27,087 143
3,093 -70
2,860 116
6.1
4.8
8.7
4.0
03
1.0
-13
0.9
-5.5
-5.3
4.0
7.5
�-0.9
3.0
7.2
-17.0
3.0
7.0
-1.9
-1.2
4.3
9.8
11.5
8.4
13.1
9.1
-9.0
2.5
3.4
20.3
1.2
-0.3
3.1
-1.3
1.6
0.5
-2.2
4.2
r"�
�
a
'Y'able 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
� 2000 to 2010 �
2Q10 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
Total Populallon
April l, April l, Population Change
Area 2000r 2010 Number Perc
Diana town
Greig town
Harrisburg town
Lewis town
Leyden town
Lowville town
Lyonsdale town
Martinsburg town
Montague town
New Bremen town
Osceola town
Pinckney town
Turin town
Watson town
West Turin town
Livingston County
!'�' Avon town
Caledonia town
� Conesus town
Geneseo town
Groveland town
Leicester town
Lima town
Livonia town
Mount Morris town
North Dansville town
Nunda town
Ossian town
Portage town
Sparta town
Springwater town
West Sparta town
York town
Maclison County
Brookfeld town
� Cazenovia town
DeRuyter town
Eaton town
Fenner town
1,661
1,367
423
857
1,792
4,551
1,273
1,249
108
2,720
265
319
793
1,985
1,674
64,330
6,443
4,567
2,353
9,654
3,853
2,287
4,541
7,286
4,567
5,738
3,017
751
859
I ,627
2,322
1,244
3,221
69,441
2,403
6,481
1,532
4,826
1,680
Page 13 of 43
1,709
I,199
437
854
1,785
4,982
1,227
1,433
78
2,706
229
329
761
1,881
],524
65,393
7,164
4,255
2,473
10,483
3,249
2,200
4,305
7,809
4,465
5,538
3,064
789
884
1,624
2,439
1,255
3,397
73,442
2,545
7,086
I,589
5,255
1,726
48
-168
14
-3
-7
431
-46
184
-3Q
-14
-36
10
-32
-104
-150
1,063
72I
-312
120
829
-604
-87
-236
523
-102
-200
47
38
25
-3
117
11
176
4,001
142
605
57
429
46
2.9
-12.3
3.3
-0.4
-0.4
9.5
-3.6
14.7
-27.8
-0.5
-13.6
3.1
-4.0
-5.2
-9.0
1.7
11.2
-6.8
5.1
8.6
-15.7
-3.8
-5.2
7.2
-2.2
-3.5
1.6
5.1
2.9
-0.2
5.0
0.9
5.5
5.8
5.9
9.3
3.7
8.9
2.7
Table 2: � Total Population Change for New York Locai Government Areas,
2000 to 2010
2010 Census: Public Law 94-�71 Data
Total Population
April l, April l, � Population Chan e
Geo ra hic Area 2000r 2010 Number Percent
�ieorgetown town
Hamilton town
Lebanon town
Lenox town
Lincoln town
Madison town
Nelson town
Oneida city
Smithfield town
Stockbridge town
Sullivan town
Monroe County
Brighton town
Chili town
Clarkson town
East Rochester town
Gates town
Greece town
Hamlin town
Henrietta town
Irondequoit town
Mendon town
Ogden town
Parma town
Penfield town
Perinton town
Pittsford town
Riga town
Rochester city
Rush town
Sweden town
Webster town
Wheatland town
Montgomery County
Amsterdam city
Amsterdam town
Canajoharie town
Charleston town
Florida town
y46
5,733
1,329
8,665
1,818
2,801
1,964
I 0,987
1,205
2,080
14,991
735,343
35,578
27,638
6,072
6,650
29,275
94,141
9,355
39,029
52,354
8,370
18,495
14,822
34,645 .
46,d94
27,219
5,434
219,782
3,603
� 3,716
37,926
5,149
49,708
18,355
5,820
� 3,797
1,292
2,731
Page 14 of 43
y74
6,690
1,332
9,122
2,012
3,008
] ,980
t 1,393
1,288
2, l 03
15,339
744,344
36,609
28,625
6,736
6,587
28,400
96,495
9,045
42,581
51,692
9,]52
19,856
15,633
36,242
4b,462
29,405
5,590
210,565
3,478
14,175
42,641
4,775
50,219
18,620
5,566
3,730
1,373
2,696
28
957
3
457
194
247
16
406
83
23
348
9,001
1,031
987
664
-63
-875
1,954
-310
3,552
-662
782
1,361
811
1,597
372
2, ] 86
156
-9,217
-125
459
4,715
-374
511
265
-254
-67
81
-35
3.0
16.7
0.2
5.3
14.7
7.4
4.8
3.7
6.9
1.1
2.3
1.2
2.9
3.6
10.9
-0.9
-3.0
2.1
-3.3
9.1
-1.3
9.3
7.4
5.5
4.6
0.8
8.0
2.9
-4.2
-3.5
3.3
l 2.4
-7.3
1.0
1.4
-4.4
-1.8
63
-1.3
Y
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2010
� 2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
I(�eographic Area
Glen town
Minden town
Mohawk town
Palatine town
Root town
St. Johnsville town
Nassau County
Glen Cove city
Hempstead town
Long Beach city
North Hempstead town
Dyster Bay town
New York County
Niagara County
� Cambria town
Hartland town
Lewiston tawn
Lockport city
Lockport town
Newfane town
Niagara town
Niagara Falls city
North Tonawanda city
Pendleton town
Porter town
Royalton town
Somerset town
Tonawanda Reservatian
Tuscarora Nation Reservation
Wheatfield town
Wilson town
�
Oneida County
Annsville town
Augusta town
Ava town
Boonville town
Bridgewater town
Total
April 1,
2000r
2,222
4,202
3,902
3,070
1,752
2,565
1,334,546
26,626
756,165
35,462
220,703
295,590
1;53.7,395
219,844
5,391
4,163
16,240
22,279
19,655
9,657
8,910
55,661
33,262
b,050
6,920
7,710
2,865
0
1,155
14,086
5,840
235,461
2,956
1,966
725
4,572
1,675
Page 15 of 43
April l,
2010
2,507
4,297
3,844
3,240
1,715
2,631
1,339,532
2b,9b4
759,757
33,275
226,322
293,214
1,585,873
216,469
5,839
4,117
16,262
21,165
20,529
9,666
8,378
50,193
31,568
6,397
6,771
7,660
2,662
0
1,152
18,117
5,993
234,878
3,012
2,020
676
4,555
1,522
N
285
95
-58
170
-37
66
4,986
338
3,592
-2,187
5,619
-2,376
48,478
-3,375
448
-46
22
-1,114
874
9
-532
-5,4b8
-1,694
347
-149
-50
-203
0
-3
4,031
153
-583
56
54
-49
-17
-153
12.8
2.3
-1.5
5.5
-2.1
2.6
0.4
1.3
O.S
-6.2
2.5
-0.8
3.2
-1.5
8.3
-1.1
0.1
-5.0
4.4
0.1
-6.0
-9.8
-S.l
5.7
-2.2
-0.6
-7.1
N/A
-0.3
28.6
2.6
-0.2
I.9
2.7
-6.8
-0.4
-9.1
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 io 2010
2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
Total Population
April l, April 1, Po uiation Change
Geo ra hic Area 2000r 2010 Number Percent
Camden town
Deerfield town
Florence town
Floyd town
Forestport town
Kirkland town
Lee town
Marcy town
Marshall town
New Hartford town
Paris town
Remsen town
Rome city
Sangerfield town
Sherrill city
Steuben town
Trenton town
Utica city
Vernon town
Verona town
Vienna town
Western town
Westmore(and town
Whitestown town
Onondaga County
Camillus town
Cicero town
Clay town
De W itt town
Elbridge town
Fabius town
Gedcles town
LaFayette town
Lysander town
Manlius town
Marcellus town
Onondaga town
Onondaga Nation Reservation
Otisco town
Pompey town
5,018
3,909
1,08d
3,869
1,692
10,134
6,875
9,481
2,127
21,289
4,609
1,958
34,950
2,610
3,158
1,172
4,670
60,599
5,324
6,425
5,817
2,029
6,207
18,635
458,336
23,152
27,982
S 8,805
24,942
6,091
1,974
17,740
4,833
19,285
31,872
6,319
21,063
1,473
2,561
6,159
Page 16 of 43
4,934
4,273
1,U25
3,819
1,535
10,315
6,486
8,982
2,131
22,166
4,411
1,929
33,725
2,561
3,071
1,100
4,498
62,235
5,408
6,293
5,440
1,951
6, I 38
18,667
467,026
24,167
31,632
58,206
25,838
5,922
1,964
17,118
4,952
21,759
32,370
6,210
23,101
468
2,541
7,080
� -84
364
-61
-50
-157
181
-389
-499
. 4
877
-198
-29
-1,225
-49
-87
-72
-172
1,636
84
-132
-377
-78
-69
32
8,690
1,015
3,650
-599
896
-169
-10
-b22
119
2,474
498
-109
2,038
-1,005
-20
921
-1.7
9.3
-5.6
-1.3
-9.3
1.8
-5.7
-5.3
0.2
4.1
-4.3
-1.5 �
-3.5
-1.9
-2.8
-6.I
-3.7
2.7
1.6
-2.1
-6.S
-3.8
-1.1
0.2
1.9
4.4
13.0
-1.0
3.6
-2.8
-a.s
-3.5
2.5
12.8
1.6
-1.7
9.7
-68.2
-0.8
I 5.0
r"�
�
r,•"�
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2010
2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
�Geographic Area
Salina town.
Skaneateles town
Spafford town
Syracuse city
Tully town
Van Buren town
Ontario County
Bristol town
Canadice town
Canandaigua city
Canandaigua town
East Bloomfield town
Farmington town
Geneva city
Geneva town
Gorham town
Hopewell town
Manchester town
Naples town .
Phelps town
Richmond town
Seneca town
South Bristol town
Victor town
West Bloomfield town
Orange Couniy . .
Blooming Grove town
Chester town
Cornwall town
Crawford town
Deerpark town
Goshen town
Greenvilie town
Hampton6urgh town
Highlands town
Middletown city
.Minisink town
Monroe town
Montgomery town
Total Po�
April I,
ZO�Or
33,290
7,323
1,661
146,464
2,680
12,6b7
100,224
2,421
1,846
11,418
7,649
3,361
10,585
13,613
3,295
3,776
3,346
9,25 8
2,441
7,009
3,452
2,737
1,645
9,823
2,549
341,371
17,356
12,140
12,310
7,875
7,858
12,913
3,800
4,686
12,482
25,325
3,585
31,407
20,891
Page 17 of 43
Apri11,
2010
33,710
7,209
1,686
145,170
2,738
13,185
107,931
2,315
1,664
10,545
10,020
3,634
11,825
13,261
3,291
4,247
3,747
9,395
2,502
7,072
3,361
2,721
1,590
14,275
2,466
372,813
18,028
11,981
12,b46
9,316
7,901
13,687
4,616
5,561
12,492
28,086
4,490
39,912
22,606
Number
420
-114
25
-1,294
58
518
7,707
-106
-182
-873
2,37I
273
1,240
-352
-4
471
401
137
61
63
-91
-16
-55
4,452
-83
31,442
672
-159
336
1,441
43
774
81b
875
10
2,761
905
8,505
1,715
13
-1.6
1.5
-0.9
2.2
4.I
7.7
-4.4
-9.9
-7.6
31.0
8.1
11.7
-2.6
-0.1
12.5
12.0
1.5
2.5
0.9
-2.6
-0.6
-3.3
453
-3.3
9.2
3.9
-13
2.7
183
0.5
6.0
21.5
18.7
0.1
10.9
25.2
27.1
8.2
Table 2: Total Popuiation Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2010 �
2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
Total Population
Apri11, April 1, Population Change
Geo ra hic Area 2000r 2010 Number Percent
Mount Hope town
Newburgh city
Newburgh town
New Windsor town
Port Jervis city
Tuxedo town
Wallkill town
Warwick town
Wawayanda town
Woodbury town
Orleans County
Albion town
Barre town
Carlton town
Clarendon town
Gaines town
Kendall town
Munay town
Ridgeway town
Shelby town
Yates town
Oswego County
Albion town
Amboy town
Boylston town
Constantia town
Fuiton city
Granby town
Hannibal towri
Hastings town
Mexico town
Minetto town
New Haven town
�rwell town
Oswego city
Oswego town
Palermo town
Parish town
Redfield town
b,b39
28,259
27,571
22,861
8,860
3,334
24,722
30,764
6,273
9,460
44,173
9,409
2,124
2,960
3,392
3,740
2,838
4,892
6,888
5,420
2,510
122,379
2,083
1,312
507
5,143
11,855
7,009
4,957
8,803
5,181
1,663
2,930
1,252
18,096
7,287
3,686
2,694
. 607
Page 18 of 43
7,U 1 t�
28,866
29,801
25,244
8,828
3,624
27,426
32,065
7,266
11,353
42,883
8,468
2,025
2,994
3,648
3,378
2,724
4,988
6,780
5,319
2,559
] 22,109
2,073
1,263
549
4,973
11,896
6,821
4,854
9,450
5,197
1,659
2,856
1,167
18,142
7,984
3,664
2,558
SSQ
37y
607
2,230
2,383
-32
29Q
2,704
1,301
993
1,893
-1,230
-941
-99
34
256
-362
-114
9b
-108
-101
49
-270
-10
-49
42
-170
41
-188
-103
647
lb
-4
-74
-85
46
697
-22
-136
-57
5.7
2.1
8.l
10.4
-0.4
8.7
10.9
4.2
15.8
20.0
-2.9
-10.0
-4.7
1.1
7.5
-9.7
-4.0
2.0
-1.6
-1.9
2.0
-0.2
-0.5
-3.7
8.3
-3.3
0.3
-2.7
-2.1
73
0.3
-0.2
-2.5
-6.8
0.3
9.6
-0.6
-5.0
-9.4
i""'�
�
r"�
�
�
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2010
2010 Census:. Public Law 94-171 Data �
Total Po ulation
. Aprii l, April l, Po ulation Chan e
Geogra hic Area 2000' 2010 Nnmber Percent
�cniana town
Sandy Creek town
Schroeppel town
Scriba town
Volney town
West Monroe town
Williamstown town
Otsego County
Burlington town
Butternuts town
Cherry Valley town
Decatur town
Edmeston town
Exeter town
Hartwick town
Laurens town
Maryland town
Middlefield town
Milford town
Morris town
New Lisbon town
Oneonta city
Oneonta town
Otego town
Otsego town
Pittsfield town
Plainfield town
Richfield town
Roseboom town
Springfield town
Unadilla town
Westford town
Worcester town
Putnam County
Carmel town
Kent town
Patterson town
Philipstown town
Putnam Valley town
J,2SL4
3,863
8,566
7,189
6,094
4,428
1,350
61,672
1,085
1,792
1,268
41Q
1,818
954
2,203
2,398
1,920
2,247
2,938
1,867
1,116
13,292
4,994
3,187
3,899
1,301
982
2,423
684
1,355
4,548
784
2,207
95,745
33,006
14,009
11,306
9,422
10,686
Page 19 of 43
�,% l iS
3,939
8,501
6,840
5,926
4,252
1,277
62,259
�,�ao
1,786
1,223
353
1,826
987
2,110
2,424
1,897
2,114
3,044
1,878
1,114
13,901
5,229
3,115
3,900
1,366
915
2,388
711
1,358
4,392
868
2,220
99,710
34,305
13,507
12,023
9,662
11,809
-lU6
76
-65
-349
-168
-176
-73
587
55
-6
-45
-57
8
33
-93
26
-23
-133
106
11
-2
609
235
-72
1
65
-67
-35
27
3
-156
84
l3
3,965
1,299
-502
717
240
1,123
-1.8
2.0
-0.8
-4.9
-2.8
-4.0
-5.4
1.0
5.1
-0.3
-3.5
-13.9
0.4
3.5
-4.2
1.1
-1.2
-5.9
3.6
0.6
-0.2
4.6
4.7
-23
0.0
5.0
-6.8
-1.4
3.9
0.2
-3.4
10.7
0.6
4.1
3.9
-3.6
6.3
2.5
10.5
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2Q00 to 2010
2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data �
Total Po ulation
April 1, April 1, Population Chan e
Geo ra hic Area 2000� 2010 Numher Percent
Southeast town
Queens County
Rensselaer County
Berlin town
Brunswick town
East Greenbush town
Grafton town
Hoosick town
Nassau town
North Greenbush Eown
Petersburgh town
Pittstown town
Poestenkill town
Rensselaer city
Sand Lake town
Schaghticoke town
Schodack town
Stephentown town
Troy city
Richmond County
Rockland County
Clarkstown town
Haverstraw town
Orangetown town
Ramapo town
Stony Point town
St. Lawrence County
Brasher town
Canton town
CIare town
Clifton town
Colton town
De Kalb town
De Peyster town
Edwards town
Fine town
17,316
2,229,379
152,540
1,901
11,664
15,429
1,987
6,759
4,818
10,815
1,563
5,644
4,044
7,892
7,987
7,456
12,536
2,873
49,172
443,729
286,761
82,056
33,825
47,781
108,852
14,247
111,919
2,337
10,334
112
791
1,453
2,213
936
1,148
1,622
Page 2� of 43
18,404 1,088
2,230,722 1,343
159,429
1,88Q
11,941
16,473
2,130
6,924
4,789
12,075
1,525
5,735
4,530
9,392
8,530
7,679
12,794
2,903
50,129
468,730
311,687
84,187
36,634
49,212
126,595
15,059
111,944
2,512
10,995
105
751
1,451
2,434
998
1,156
1,512
6,889
-21
277
1,044
143
165
-29
1,260
-38
91
486
1,500
543
223
258
30
957
25,001
24,926
2,131
2,809
1,431
17,743
812
25
175
661
-7
-40
-2
221
62
8
-110
6.3
0.1
4.5
-1.1
2.4
6.8
7.2
2.4
-0.6
11.7
-2.4
1.6
12.0
19.0
6.8
3.0
2.1
1.0
1.9
5.6
8.7
2.6
8.3
3.0
16.3
S.7
0.0
7.5
6.4
-6.3
-5.1
-0.1
10.0
6.6
0.7
-6.8
i""�
�
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 201U
� 2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
i'''1
�"`�
� Geographic Area
Fowler town
Gouverneur town
Hammond town
Hermon town
Hopkinton town
Lawrence town
Lisbon town
Louisvilie town
Macomb town
Madrid town
Massena town
Morristown town
Norfolk town
Ogdensburg city
Oswegatchie town
Parishville town
Piercefield town
Pierrepont town
Pitcairn town .
Potsdam town
Rossie town
Russell town
Stockholm town
Waddington town
Saratoga County
Ballston town
Charlton town
Ctifton Park town
Corinth town
Day town
Edinburg town
Galway town
Greenfield town
Hadley town
Halfmoon town
Malta town
Mechanicville city
Milton town
Moreau town
Northumberland town
Total Po�
April l,
ZQO��
2,179
. 7,419
1,209
1,069
I,020
1,545
4,047
- 3,195
846
1,828
13,121
2,050
4,565
12,364
4,370
2,049
305
2,674
783
15,945
785
1,801
3,592
2,212
200,635
8,729
3,958
33,110
6,259
920
1,384
3,589
7,362
1,971
18,359
13,005
5,019
17,103
13,549
4,603
Page 21 of 43
April 1,
2Q10
2,202
�,ass
1,191
1,108
1,077
1,826
4,102
3,145
906
1,735
12,883
1,974
4,668
11,128
4,397
2,153
310
2,589
846
16,041
877
1,856
3,665
2,266
219,607
9,776
4,133
36,705
6,531
856
1,214
3,545
7,775
2,048
2I,535
14,765
5,196
18,575
14,728
5,087
Number
23
-334
=18
39
57
281
55
-50
60
-93
-238
-76
103
-1,236
27
l04
5
-85
63
96
92
55
73
54
18,972
1,047
175
3,595
272
-64
-170
-44
413
77
3,176
1,760
177
1,472
1,179
484
1.1
-4.5
-1.5
3.6
5.6
18.2
1.4
-�.6
7.1
-5.1
-1.8
-3.7
2.3
-10.0
0.6
5.1
1.6
-3.2
8.0
0.6
11.7
3.1
2.0
2.4
9.5
12.0
4.4
10.9
4.3
-7.0
-12.3
-1.2
5.6
3.9
17.3
13.5
3.5
8.6
8.7
10.5
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2010
2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
Geographic Area
Providence town
Saratoga town
Saratoga Springs city
Stillwater town
Waterford town
Wilton town
Schenectady County
Duanesburg town
Glenville town
Niskayuna town
Princetown town
Rotterdam town
Schenectady city
Schoharie County
Blenheim town
Broome town
Carlisle town
Cobleskill town
Conesville town
Esperance town
Fulton town _
Gilboa town
Jefferson town
Middleburgh town
Richmondvill.e town
Schoharie town
Seward town
Sharon town
Summit town
Wright town
Schuyler County
Catharine town
Cayuta town
Dix town
Hector town
Montour town
Orange town
Reading town
Total Po�
April 1,
2040r
1,837
5,114
26,186
7,522
8,515
12,54I
146,551
5,808
28,179
20,295
2,i32
28,316
61,821
31,582
330
959
1,758
6,407
727
2,043
1,493
1,204
1,285
3,S 15
2,412
3,299
1,637
1,843
1,123
1,547
19,222
1,930
545
4,197
4,854
2,446
1,754
1,786
Page 22 of 43
April l,
20�0
1,995
5,674
26,586
8,287
8,423
16,173
154,727
6,122
29,480
21,781
2,115
29,094
66,135
32,749
377
973
1,948
6,625
734
2,076
1,442
1,3Q7
1,410
3,746
2,610
3,245
1,763
1,84b
1,148
1,539
18,343
1,762
SSb
3,864
4,940
2,308
1,609
1,707
N
lation
158
560
40Q
765
-92
3,632
8,176
314
1,301
1,486
-17
778
4,314
1,167
47
14
190
218
7
33
-S 1
103
125
231
198
-94
126
3
25
-8
-879
-168
11
-333
86
-138
-145
-79
8.6
11.0
1.5
10.2
-1.1
29.0
5.6 �
5.4
4.6
7.3
-0.8
2.7
7.0
3.7
14.2
1.5
10.8
3.4
1.0
1.6
-3.4
8.6
9.7
6.6
8.2
-2.8
7.7
0.2
2.2
-0.5
-4.b
-8.7
2.0
-7.9
1.8
-5.6
-8.3
-4.4
�
^
a
Table 2: Total Population Change %r New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2010
� 2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
Tota! Po ulation
April 1, April l, Po ulation Chan e
Geo ra hic. Area 2000r 2010 Number Percent
Tyrone town � 1,710 1,597 -113 -6.6
Seneca County.
Covert town
Fayette town
Geneva city
Junius town
Lodi town
Ovid town
Romulus town
Seneca Falls town
Tyre town
Varick town
Waterloo town
Steuben County
Addison town
� Avoca town
Bath town
Bradford town
Cameron town
Campbell town
Canisteo town
Caton town
Cohocton town
Corning city
Corning town
Dansville town
Erwin town
Fremont town
Greenwood town
Hartsville town
Hornby town
Hornell city
Hornelisville town
Howard town
Jasper town
Lindley town
� Prattsburgh town
Pulteney town
Rathbone town
33,342
2,227
3,643
0
1,3b2
1,478
2,755
2,036
9,347
899
1,729
7,86b
98,728
2,640
2,311
- i2,oss
772
1,034
3,691
3,583
2,097
2,626
10,835
� 6,433
1,977
7,227
964
849
585
1,742
9,149
3,915
1,430
1,270
1,913
2,064
l ,405
1,080
Page 23 of 43
35,251
2,154
3,929
0
1,471
1,550
2,311
4,316
9,040
981
1,857
7,642
98,990
2,595
2,264
12,379
855
945
3,406
3,391
2,179
2,561
11,183
b,270
1,842
8,Q37
1,008
801
609
1,706
8,563
4,151
1,4b7
1,424
1,967
2,085
1,285
1,126
1,909
-73
286
0
109
72
-444
2,280
-307
82
128
-224
262
-45
-47
291
83
-89
-285
-192
82
-6S
348
-163
-135
810
44
-48
24
-36
-586
236
37
154
54
21
-120
4b
5.7
-3.3
7.9
N/A
8.0
4.9
-16.1
112.0
-3.3
9.1
7.4
-2.8
0.3
-1.7
-2.0
2.4
10.8
-8.6
-7.7
-5.4
3.9
-2.5
3.2
-2.5
-6.8
11.2
4.6
-5.7
4.1
-2.1
-6.4
6.0
2.6
12:1
2.8
1.0
-8.5
4.3
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
� 2000 to 2010
2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
Total Po ulation
April l, April l, Po ulation Chan e
Geo ra hic Area 2000� 2010 Number Percent
"1 nurston town
Troupsburg town
Tuscarora town
Urbana town
Wayland town
Wayne town
West Union town
Wheeler town
Woodhu[l town
Suffolk County
Babylon town
Brookhaven town
East Hampton town
Huntington town
Islip town
Poospatuck Reservation
Riverhead town
Shelter Island town
Shinnecock Reservation
Smithtown town
Southampton town
Southold town
Suliivan County
Bethel town
Callicoon tawn
Cochecton town
Delaware town
Fallsburg town
Forestbtargh town
Fremont town
Highland town
Liberty town
Lumberland town
Mamakating town
Neversink town
Rockland town
Thompson town
Tusten town
1,3Uy
1,126
1,400
2,546
4,314
1,167
399
1,263
1,524
1,419,372
212,139
448,239
19,719
195,289
322,435
283
27,b80
2,226
504
115,545
54,714
20,599
73,962
4,364
3,052
1,327
2,720
12,227
831
1,387
2,407
9,638
1,936
11,OU4
3,556
3,913
14,185
1,415
Page 24 of 43
1,35U
1,291
I ,473
2,343
4,102
1,041
312
1,260
1,719
1,493;350
213,603
486,040
21,457
203,264
335,543
324
33,506
2,392
662
l 17,801
Sb,790
21,968
77,547
4,255
3,057
1,372
2,670
12,870
819
1,381
2,530
9,885
2,468
12,085
3,557
3,775
15,308
1,515
41
165
73
-203
-212
-126
-87
-3
195
73,978
1,464
37,801
1,738
7,975
13,108
41
5,826
166
158
2,256
2,076
1,369
3,585
-109
5
4S
-50
643
-12
-6
123
247
532
1,081
1
-138
1,123
100
3.1
14.7
5.2
-8.0
-4.9
-10.8
-21.8
-0.2
12.8
5.2
0.7
8.4
8.8
4.1
4.1
14.5
21.0
7.5
313
2.0
3.8
6.6
4.8
-2.5
a.2
3.4
-1.8
5.3
-I.4
-0.4
S.1
2.6
27.5
9.8
a.o
-3.5
7.9
7.1
/a'�
r"'1
a
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2010
r'''1 _ 2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
�,
�
Geographic Area
Tioga County
Barton town
Berkshire town
Candor town
Newark Valley town
Nichols town
Owego town
Richford town
Spencer town
Tioga town
Tompkins County
Caroline town
Danby town
Dryden town
Enfield town
Groton town
Ithaca city
Ithaca town
Lansing town
Newf eld town
Ulysses town
Ulster County
Denning town
Esopus town
Gardiner town
Hardenburgh town
Hurley town
Kingston city
Kingston town
Lloyd town
Marbletown town
Marlborough town
New Paltz town
Olive town
Plattekill town
Rochester town
Rosendale town
Saugerties town
Shandaken town
Total Po�
April 1,
2Q00`
51,787
9,066
1,36b
5,317
4, l Od
2,583
20,366
1,170
2,979
4,840
96,502
2,912
3,007
13,531
3,370
5,794
28,775
18,709
10,521
5,108
4,775
177,694
511
9,333
5,238
208
6,562
23,478
908
9,93 8
5,854
8,263
12,830
4,579
9,889
7,01 Q
6,345
18,822
3,226
Page 25 of 43
April l,
2010
51,125
8,858
1,412
5,305
3,94b
2,525
19,883
1;172
3,153
4,87 t
101,564
3,282
3,329
14,435
3,512
5,950
30,014
19,930
11,033
5,179
4,900
182,493
551
9,041
5,713
238
6,314
23,893
889
10,863
5,607
8,808
14,003
4,419
10,499
7,3I3
6,075
19,482
3,085
Number
-6b2
-208
46
-12
-154
-58
-483
2
174
31
5,062
370
322
904
142
156
1,239
1,221
512
71
125
4,799
40
-292
475
30
-248
415
-19
925
-247
545
1,173
-160
610
303
-270
660
-141
-1.3
-2.3
3.4
-0.2
-3.8
-2.2
-2.4
0.2
5.8
0.6
5.2
12.7
10.7
6.7
4.2
2.7
4.3
6.5
4.9
1.4
2.6
2.7
7.8
-3.1
9.1
14.4
-3.8
1.8
-2.1
9.3
-4.2
6.6
9.1
-3.5
d.2
4.3
-4.3
3:5
-4.4
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2Q10
2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
Total Population
April 1, April l, Po ulation Change
Geo ra hic Area 2000r 2010 Number Percent
ahawangunk tawn
Utster town
Wawarsing town
Woodstock town
Warren County
Bolton town
Chester town
Glens Falls city
Hague town
Horicon town
Johnsburg town
Lake George town
Lake Luzerne town
Queenslsury town
Stony Creek town
Thurman town
Warrensburg town
Washington County
Argyle town
Cambridge town
Dresden town
Easton town
Fort Ann town
Fort Edward town
Granville town
Greenwich town
`Hampton town
Hartford town
Hebron town
Jackson town
Kingsbury town
Putnam town
Salem town
White Creek town
Whitehall town
12,0"lU
12,526
13,928
6,226
63,303
2,117
3,614
14,354
854
1,479
2,450
3,578
3,219
25,441
743
1,199
4,255
61,042
3,688
2,154
677
2,259
d,417
5,892
6,456
4,896
871
2,277
1,775
1,716
11,171
645
2,702
3,411
4,035
14,332
12,327
13,157
5,884
65,707
2,326
3,355
14,700
699
i,389
2,395
3,515
3,347
27,901
7b7
1,219
4,094
63,216
3,782
2,021
652
2,336
b,194
6,371
6,669
4,942
938
2,269
1,853
1,8Q0
12,671
d09
2,715
3,356
4,042
Wayne County 93,766 � 93,772
Arcadia town 14,889 14,244
Butler town 2,277 2,064
Page 26 of 43
2,312
-199
-771
-342
2,404
209
-259
346
-155
-90
-55
-63
128
2,460
24
24
-161
2,174
94
-133
-25
77
-227
479
213
46
67
-8
78
84
1,500
-36
13
-55
7
6
-645
-213
19.2
-l.b
-5.5
-5.5
3.8
9.9
-7.2
2.4
-18.1
-6.1
-2.2
-1.8
4.0
9.7
3.2
1.7
-3.8
3.6
2.5
-6.2
-3.7
3.4
-3.5
8.1
3.3
0.9
7.7
-0.4
4.4
4.9
13.4
-S.6
0.5
-1.6
a.2
0.0
-4.3
-9.4
/�`�
r""�
6
Ta61e 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2010
r'�, 2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
�"'�
�
Geographic Area
Galen town
Huron town
Lyons town
Macedon town
Marion town
Ontario town
Palmyra town
Rose town
Savannah town
Sodus town
Walworth town
Williamson town
Wolcott town
Westchester County
Bedford town
Cortlandt town
Eastchester town
Greenburgh town
Harrison town
Lewisboro town
Mamaroneck town
Mount Kisco town
Mount Pleasant town
Mount Vernon city
New Castle town
New Rochelle city
North Castle town
North Salem town
Ossining town
Peekskill city
Pelham town
Pound Ridge town
Rye city
Rye fown
Scarsdale town
Somers town
White Plains city
Yonkers city �
Yortctown town
Total
April 1,
2000'
4,439
2,117
5,831
8,688
4,974
9,779
7,672
2,442
1,838
8,949
8,402
6,777
4,b92
923,459
18,133
38,469
31,334
86,831
24,129
12,324
28,967
10,007
43,221
68,381
17,467
72,182
10,849
5,173
36,534
22,441
11,866
4,726
14,953
43,907
17,825
18,346
53,075
196,001
36,318
Page 27 of 43
April 1,
2010
4,290
2,118
5,682
9,148
4,746
10,136
7,975
2,369
1,730
8,384
9,449
b,984
4,453
949, l 13
17,335
41,592
32,363
88,400
27,472
12,411
29, I 56
10,877
43,724
67,292
17,569
77,062
11,841
5,104
37,674
23,583
12,396
5,104
15,720
. 45,928
17,166
20,434
56,853
195,976
36,081
opulation
Number
-149
1
-149
460
-228
357
303
-73
-108
-565
1,Q47
207
-239
25,654
-798
3,123
1,029
1,569
3,343
87
189
870
503
-1,089
102
4,880
992
-69
1,140
1,142
530
378
767
2,021
-b59
2,088
3,778
-25
-237
-3.4
0.0
-2.6
5.3
-4.6
3.7
3.9
-3.0
-5.9
-6.3
12.5
3.1
-5.1
2.8
-4.4
8.1
33
1.8
13.9
0.7
0.7
8.7
1.2
-1.6
0.6
6.8
9.1
-1.3
3.1
5.1
4.S
8.0
5.1
4.6
-3.7
11.4
7.1
0.0
-0.7
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2010
2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data �"�
Total Po ulation -
Apri11, Aprii 1, Po ulation Change
Geo raphic Area 2040r 2010 Number Percent
Wyoming County
Arcade town
Attica town
Bennington town
Castile town
Covington town
Eagle town
Gainesville town
Genesee Falls town
Java town
Middlebury town
Orangeville town
Perry town
Pike town
Sheldon town
Warsaw town
Wethersfield town
Yates County
Barrington town
Benton town
Italy town
Jerusalem town
Middtesex town
Mi[o town
Potter town
Starkey town
Torrey town
Adams village
Addison viElage
Afton village
Airmont village
Akron village
Albany city
Albion vilIage
Alden village
Alexander village
Alexandria Bay village
Alfred village
Allegany village
43,424
4, I 84
7,806
3,349
2,873
1,357
1,194
2,333
460
2,222
1,508
1,301
4,876
1,086
2,561
5,423
891
24,621
1,39b
2,644
1,087
4,525
1,345
7,026
1,830
3,4b5
1,307
1,616
1,797
836
7,799
3,085
94,444
5,992
2,66b
� 481
1,088
3,954
1,882
Page 28 of 43
42,155
4,205
7,702
3,359
2,906
1,232
1,192
2,182
438
2,057
1,441
1,355
4,616
1,114
2,409
5,064
883
25,348
1,681
2,836
1,141
4,469
1,495
7,006
1,865
3,573
1,282
1,775
1,763
822
8,62$
2,868
97,856
6,OSb
2,645
509
1,078
4,174
1,816
-1,269
21
-104
10
33
-125
-2
-151
-22
-165
-67
54
-260
28
-152
-359
-8
727
285
196
54
-Sb
150
-20
35
108
-25
159
-34
-14
829
-217
3,412
64
-61
28
-10
220
-bG
-2.9
0.5
-1.3
0.3
1.1
-9.2
-0.2
-6.5
-4.8
-7.4
-4.4
4.2
-5.3
2.6
-5.9
-6.6
-0.9
3.0
aa.a�
7.4
5.0
-1.2
11.2
-0.3
1.9
3.1
-1.9
9.8
-1.9
-1.7
10.6
-�.a
3.6
1.1
-2.3
5.8
-0.9
5.6
-3.5
�"'`
�'�"1
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2010
�'"� 2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
�,'"�
�
�Geographic Area
Almond village
Altamont village
Altmar village
Ames village
Amityville village
Amsterdam city
Andover village
Angelica village
Angola village
Antwerp village
Arcade village
Ardsley village
Argyle village
Arkport village
Asharoken village
Athens village
Atlantic. Beach village
Attica village
Auburn city
Aurora village
Avoca village
Avon village
Babylon village
Bainbridge village
Baldwinsville �illage
Ballston Spa village
Barker village
Barneveld village
Batavia city
Bath village
Baxter Estates village
Bayville village
Beacon city
Belle Tene village
Bellerose village
Bellport village
Belmont village
Bemus Point village
Bergen village
Binghamton city
Black River village
Total Po�
April l,
200��
461
. 1,755
348
173
9,441
18,355
1,073
903
2,266
716
2,026
4,269
289
832
623
1,695
I,986
2,597
28,574
720
1,030
2,977
12,613
1,365
7,066
5,556
577
332
16,256
5,641
1,006
7,135
14,805
832
1,173
2,363
952
344
1,243
47,380
1,285
Page 29 of 43
April 1,
2010
4b6
I ,720
407
145
9,S23
18,620
1,042
869
2,127
686
2,071
4,452
306
844
654
. 1,6b8
1,891
2,547
27,687
724
94b
3,394
12,166
1,355
7,378
5,409
533
284
15,465
5,786
999
6,669
15,541
792
1,193
2,084
969
364
I,176
47,376
1,348
�
5
-35
59
-28
82
265
-31
-34
-139
-30
45
183
17
12
31
-27
-95
-SO
-887
4
-84
417
-447
-10
312
-147
-44
-48
-791
145
-7
-466
736
-40
20
-279
17
24
-67
-4
63
1.I
-2.0
17.0
-16.2
4.9
1.4
-2.9
-3.8
-6.1
-4.2
2.2
4.3
5.9
1.4
5.0
-1.6
-4.8
-1.9
-3.1
4.6
-8.2
14.0
-3.5
-0.7
4.4
-2.6
-7.6
-14.5
-4.9
2.6
-0.7
-6.5
5.0
-4.8
1.7
-11.8
1.8
7.1
-5.4
0.0
4.9
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2Q10
2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
Total Population
April l, April l, Po utation Chan e
Geogra hic Area 2000� 2010 Number Percent
�siasaeu vuiage
Bloomfield village
Bloomingburg village
Bolivar village
Boonville village
Brewster village
BriarcliffManor village
Bridgewater village
Brightwaters village
Broadalbin village
Brockport village
Brocton village
Bronxville village
Brookville village
Brownville village
Brushton village
Buchanan village
Buffalo city
Burcfett village
Burke village
Caledonia village
Cambridge village
Camden viltage
Camillus village
Canajoharie village
Canandaigua city
Canaseraga village
Canastota village
Candor village
Canisteo village
Canton village
Cape Vincent village
Carthage village
Cassadaga village
Castile vil[age
Castleton-on-Hudson village
Castorland village
Cato village
Catskill village
Cattaraugus village
Cayuga Heights villag�
l,"/ 1 �S
1,267
348
1,173
2, l 38
2,162
7,663
583
3,248
1,411
8,103
1,547
6,543
3,365
1,022
479
2,189
292,648
357
213
2,327
1,925
2,330
1,249
2,262
11,418
584
� 4,425
855
2,336
5,954
760
3,721
676
1,051
1,619
311
601
4,392
1,075
3,738
Page 30 of 43
"1,55:3
I,361
420
1,047
2,072
2,39U
7,867
470
3,103
1,327
8,366
1,486
6,323
3,4b5
1,119
474
2,230
261,310
340
211
2,201
1,870
2,231
1,213
2,229
10,545
550
4,804
851
2,270
6,314
726
3,74?
634
1,015
1,473
351
532
4,081
1,002
3,729
-1b5
94
72
-126
-66
228
204
-113
-145
-84
2b3
-61
-220
100
97
-5
41
-31,338
-17
-2
-126
-S5
-99
-36
-33
-873
-34
3Z9
-4
-66
360
-34
26
-42
-36
-146
40
-69
-311
-73
-9
-6.1
7.4
20.7
-10.7
-3.1
10.5
2.7
-19.4
-4.5
-6.0
3.2
-3.9
-3.4
3.0
9.5
-1.4
1.9
-10.7
-4.8
-0.9
-5.4
-2.9
-4.2
-2.9
-1.5
-7.6
-5.8
S.6
-0.5
-2.8
6.0
-4.5
0.7
-6.2
-3.4
-9.0
12.9
-I1.5
-7.1
-6.8
-0.2
�"1
�1
/"'1
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Loca1 Government Areas,
2000 to 2010.
� 2010 Census: Pu61ic Law 94-171 Data
�
�
Total Po ulation
April 1, April l, Po� ulation Change
Geogra hic Area 2000� � . 2010 Number Percent
�ayuga vtiiage
Cazenovia viliage
Cedarhurst village
Celoron village
Centrai Syuare village
Centre Island village
Champlain village
Chateaugay village
Chatham village
Chaamont village
Cherry Creek village
Cherry Valley village
Cliester village
Chestnut Ridge village
�hittenango village
Churchville village
Clayton village
Clayville village �
Cleveland village
Clifton Springs village
Clinton village
Clyde village
Cobleskill village
Cohocton village
Cohoes city
Cold Brook village
Cold Spring village
Colonie village
Constableville village
Cooperstown village
Copenhagen village
Corfu village
Corinth village
Corning city
Cornwall-on-Hudson village
Cortland city
Cove Neck village
Coxsackie village
Croghan village
Croton-on-Hudson village
Cuba village
S11
2,623
6,177
1,292
1,812
444
1,173
798
1,758
610
551
592
3,494
� 7,839
4,833
1,887
1,821
445
760
2,223
1,951
2,269
4,539
854
15,607
336
1,983
7,916
305
2,032
865
799
2,474
10,835
3,058
18,740
300
2,895
665
7,606
1,633
Page 31 of 43
549
2,835
6,592
1,112
1,848
410
1,101
833
1,770
624
461
520
3,969
7,91 b
5,081
1,961
1,978
350
750
2,12?
1,942
2,093
4,678
838
16,168
329
2,013
7,793
242
1,852
801
709
2,559
11,183
3,018
19,204
286
2,813
618
8,070
1,5.75
38
212
415
-180
36
-34
-72
35
12
14
-90
-72
47S
77
248
74
157
-95
-10
-9b
-9
-17b
139
-16
561
-7
30
-123
-63
-180
-64
-90
85
348
-40
464
-14
-82
-47
464
-58
7.4
8.1
6.7
-13.9
2.0
-7.7
-6.1
4.4
0.7
2.3
-16.3
-12.2
13.6
1.0
5.1
3.9
8.6
-21.3
-1.3
-4.3
-o.s
-7.8
3.1
-1:9
3.6
-2.1
1.5
-1.6
-20.7
-8.9
-7.4
-11.3
3.4
3.2
-1.3
2.5
-4.7
-2.8
-7.1
6.1
-3.6
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2010
2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
Total Po ulation
April 1, April l, Population Chan e
Geo ra hic Area 2440' 2010 Number Percent
llelevan village
Dannemora village
Dansville village
Deferiet village
Delanson village
Delhi village
Depew village
Deposit village
Dering Harbor village
DeRuyter village
Dexter village
Dobbs Ferry village
Dolgeville village
Dresden village
Dryden village
Dundee village
Dunkirk city
Earlville village
East Aurora village
East Hamptan village
East Hills village
East Nassau village
East Randolph village
East Rochester village
East Rockaway village
East Syracuse village
East Williston village
Edwards village
Elba village
Elbridge village
Ellenville village
Ellicottville village
Ellishurg village.
Elmira city
Elmira Heights village
Elmsford vitlage
Endicott village
Esperance village
Evans Mills village
Fabius village
Fair Haven village
1,089
4,129
4,832
309
385
2,583
16,610
1,699
13
533
1,131
10,622
2,164
307
1,838
1,630
13,131
791
6,673
1,334
6,842
571
630
6,650
10,362
3,178
2,503
465
696
1,118
4,008
472
269
30,942
4,170
4,672
I3,013
380
605
355
884
Page 32 of 43
1,089
3,936
4,719
294
377
3,087
15,303
1,6b3
11
558
1,Q52
10,875
2,206
308
1,890
1,725
12,563
872
6,236
1,083
6,955
587
620
6,587
9,818
3,084
2,556
439
676
1,058
4,135
376
244
29,200
4,097
4,664
13,392
345
621
352
745
0
-193
-113
-15
-8
504
-1,307
-36
-2
25
-79
253
42
1
52
35
-568
8I
-437
-251
113
16
-10
-63
-544
-94
53
-26
-20
-60
127
-96
-25
-1,742
-73
-8
379
-3S
16
-3
-139
0.0
-4.7
-2.3
-4.9
-2.1
19.5
-7.9
-2.1
-15.4
4.7
-7.0
2.4
1.9
03
2.8
2.1
-4.3
10.2
-6.5
-18.8 .
1.7
2.8
-1.6
-0.9
-5.2
-3.0
2.1
-5.6
-2.9
-5.4
3.2
-20.3
-9.3
-5.6
-1.8
-0.2
2.9
-9.2
2.6
-0.8
-15.7
/�1
/""`
�
r'��
�
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2010
2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
�(=eographic Area
Fairport village
Falconer village
Farmingdale village
Farnham village
Fayetteville village
Fishkill village
Fleischmanns village
Floral Park village
Florida village
Flower Hill village
Fonda vitlage
Forestville viltage
Fort Ann vi[lage
Fort Edward village
Fort Johnson village
Fort Plain village
Frankfort village
Franklin village
Franklinville village
Fredonia village '
Freeport village
Freeville village
Fulton ciry
Fultonville village
Gainesville village
Galway village
Garden City village
�Geneseo village
Geneva city
Gilbertsville village
Glen Cove city
Glen Park village
Glens Falls city
Gloversvil.te city
Goshen village
Gouverneur village
Gowanda viqage
Grand View-on-Hudson village
Granville village
Great Neck Estates village
Great Neck Plaza village
Total Po�
April l,
Z�D�r
5,740
2,540
8,399
322
4,190
1,740
351
15,967
2,589
4,508
810
770
471
3,141
491
2,288
2,537
402
1,855
10,706
43,783
505
11,855
710
304
214
2I ,672
7',579
13,613
375
2G,626
487
14,354
15,391
5,680
4,2b7
2,842
288
2,644
2,756
6,433
Page 33 of 43
April 1,
2014
5,353
2,420
8,189
382
4,373
2,171
351
15,863
2,833
4,665
795
697
484
3,375
490
2,322
2,598
374
1,740
11,230
42,860
520
11,896
784
229
200
22,371
8,031
13,261
399
26,964
502
14,700
15,6b5
5,454
3,949
2,709
285
2,543
2,761
6,707
Nu
-387
-120
-210
60
183
431
0
-104
244
157
-15
-73
13
234
-1
34
bl
-28
-115
524
-923
15
41
74
-75
-14
699
452
-352
24
338
15
346
274
-226
-318
-133�
-3
-101
5
274
-6.7
-4.7
-2.5
18.6
4.4
24.8
0.0
-a.�
9.4
3.5
-1.9
-9.5
2.8
7.4
-0.2
1.5
2.4
-�.a
-6.2
4.9
-2.1
3.0
�.3
10.4
-24.7
-6.5
3.2
6.0
-2.6
6.4
1.3
3.1
2.4
1.8
-4.0
-7.5
-4.7
-1.0
-3.8
0.2
4.3
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2010
2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
Total Population
April 1, April 1, Po ulation Change
Geographic Area 2000r 2010 Number Percent
Cireat Neck village
Green Island village
Greene village
Greenport village
Greenwich village
Greenwood Lake viliage
Groton village
Hagaman village
Hamburg village
Hamilton village
Hammond village
Hammondsport village
Hancock village
Hannibal village
Harriman village
Harrison village
Harrisville village
Hastings-on-Hudson village
Haverstraw village
Head of the Harbor village
Hempstead village
Herkimer village
Hermon village
Herrings village
Heuvelton village
Hewlett Bay Park village
Hewlett Harbor village
Hewlett Neck village
Highland Falls village
Hillburn village
Hilton village
Hobart village
Holland Patent village
Holley village
Homer village
Honeoye Falls village
Hoosick Falls village
Horneil city
Horseheads village
Hudson city
Hudson Falis village
9,538
2,283
l ,701
2,048
1,902
3,411
2,470
1,357
10,110
3,515
302
731
1,189
542
2,268
24,129
653
7,715
10,1 l7
1,447
53,127
7,498
402
129
804
484
1,271
504
3,678
881
5,$76
390
461
1,802
3,392
2,595
3,432
9,149
6,566
7,524
6,922
Page 34 of 43
9,989
2,620
1,580
2,197
1,777
3,154
2,363
1,292
9,409
4,239
280
661
1,03I
555
2,424
27,472
628
7,849
11,910
1,472
53,891
7,743
422
90
714
404
1,263
445
3,900
951
5,886
441
4S8
I,811
3,291
2,G74
3,501
8,563
6,461
6,713
7,281
451
337
-121
149
-125
-257
-107
-65
-701
- � 724
-22
-70
-158
13
156
3,343
-25
134
1,793
25
764
245
20
-39
-90
-80
-8
-59
222
70
10
51
-3
9
-101
79
69
-586
-105
-811
359
4.7
14.8
-7.1
7.3
-6.6
-7.5
-4.3
-4.8
-6.9
20.6
-7.3
-9.6
-13.3
2.4
6.9
13.9
-3.8
1.7
17.7
1.7
1.4
3.3
5.0
-30.2
-11.2
-16.5
-0.6
-11.7
6.0
7.9
4.2
13.1
-0.7
0.5
-3.0
3.0
2.0
-6.4
-1.6
-10.8
5.2
�
�
�"�
�
i"`�
r�'1
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2010
2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data �
�Geographic Area
Hunter village
Huntington Bay village
Ilion village
Interlaken village
Irvington village
Island Park village
Islandia village
Ithaca city
Jamestown city
Jeffersonville village
Johnson City village
Johnstown city
Jordan village
Kaser village
Keeseville village
Kenmore village
Kensington village
Kinderhook village
Kings Point village
Kingston city �
Kiryas Joel village
Lackawanna city
Lacona vil[age
Lake George village
Lake Grove village
Lake Placid village
Lake Success village
Lakewood village
Lancaster village
Lansing village
Larchmont village
Lattingtown village
Laurel Hollow village
Laurens village
Lawrence village
Le Roy village
Leicester village
Lewiston village
Liberty village
Lima village
Limestone village
Total Pop
April l.,
ZDODr
� 486
1,496
8,622
674
6,631
4,732
3,057
28,775
• 31,984
420
15,503
8,636
1,314
3,471
1,850
16,426
1,209
1,287
5,076
23,478
13,138
19,Ob4
614
985
10,241
2,638
, 2,797
3,255
I 1,188
3,417
6,485
1,860
1,933
277
6,522
4,462
462
2,781
4,018
2,459
411
Page 35 of 43
April l,
2010
502
1,425
8,053
602
6,420
4,655
3,335
30,014
31,146
359
-15,174
8,743
1,368
4,724
1,815
15,423
1,161
1,211
5,005
23,893
20,175
18,141
582
906
ll,lb3
2,521
2,934
3,Q02
10,352
3,529
5,864
1,739
l ,952
263
6,483
4,391
468
2,701
4,392
2,139
389
N
lation
16
-71
-569
-72
-211
-77
278
1,239
-838
-61
-329
107
54
1,253
-35
-1,003
-48
-76
-71
415
7,037
-923
-32
-79
922
-117
137
-253
-836
112
-621
-121
19
-14
-39
-71
6
-SO
374
-320
-22
3.3
-4.7
-b.6
-10.7
-3.2
-1.6
9.1
. 4.3
-2.6
-I4.5
-2.1
1.2
4.1
36.1
-1.9
-6.1
-4.0
-5.9
-1.4
1.8
53.6
-4.8
-5.2
-8.0
9.0
-4.4
4.9
-7.8
-7.5
3.3
-9.6
-6.5
1.0
-5.1
-0.6
-1.6
1.3
-2.9
9.3
-13.0
-5.4
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2010
2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
Total Population
ApriI 1, April l, Population Change
Geo ra hic Area 2000r 2010 Number Percent
Lindenhurst village
Lisle village
Little Falls city
Little Valley village
Liverpool village
Livonia village
Lloyd Harbor village
Lockport city
Lodi village
Long Beach city
Lowville village
Lynbrook village
Lyndonville village
Lyons�Falls village
Lyons village
Macedon vil(age
Madison village
Malone village
Malverne village
Mamaroneck village
Manchester village
Manlius village
Mannsville village
Manorhaven village
Marathon village
Marcellus village
Margaretville village
:Massapequa Park viilage
Massena village
Matinecock village
Maybrook village
Mayfield village
Mayville village
McGraw village
Mechanicville city
Medina village
Menands village
Meridian village
Mexico village
Middleburgh village
Middleport village
27,819
302
5,193
1,130
2,505
1,373
3,651
22,279
338
35,462
3,476
19,921
862
591
3,695
1,496
312
6,075
8,938
18,464
1,475
4,819
400
6,138
1,063
1,826
643
17,499
11,209
836
3,084
800
1,756
1,000
5,019
6,415
3,905
350
1,572
1,398
1,917
Pa�e 36 of 43
27,253
320
4,946
1,143
2,347
1,409
3,660
21,165
291
33,275
3,470
l 9,427
838
566
3,619
1,523
305
5,911
8,5I4
18,929
I ,709
4,704
354
6,556
919
1,813
596
17,008
10,936
810
2,958
832
1,711
1,053
5,196
6,065
3,990
309
1,624
1,500
1,840
-566
18
-247
13
-158
36
9
-1,114
-47
-2,187
-6
-494
-24
-25
-76
27
-7
-164
-424
465
234
-115
-46
418
-144
-13
-47
-491
-273
-26
-126
32
-45
53
177
-350
85
-41
52
102
-77
-2.0
6.0
-4.8
1.2
-6.3
2.6
0.2
-5 A
-13.9
-6.2
-0.2.
-2.5
-2.8
-4.2
-2.1
1.8
-2.2
-2.7
-4.7
2.5
15.9
-2.4
-11.5
6.8
-13.5
-0.7
-7.3
-2.8
-2.4
-3.l
-4.1
4.0
-2.6
5.3
3.5
-5.5
2.2
-11.7
3.3
7.3
-4.0
�1
�
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
' Z000 to 2010
r+�, _ � 2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
�
G`
�Geographic Area
Middletown city
Middleville village
Milford village
Mill Neck village
Millbrook village
Millerton village
Millport village
Mineola village
Minoa village
Mohawk village
Monroe village
Montebello village
Montgomery village
Monticello village
Montour Falls village
Moravia village
Morris village'
Morristown village
Morrisville village
Mount Kisca village
Mount Morris vilIage
Mount Vernon city
Munnsville village
Munsey Par[c vi(lage
Muttontown village
Naples village
Nassau village
Nelliston village .
Nelsonville village
New Berlin village
New Hartford village
New Hempstead village
New Hyde Park village
New Paltz village
New Rochelle city
New Square village
New York city
New York Mills village
Newark Valley village
Newark village
Newburgh city
Total Popi
April 1,
Z�DOr
25,325
550
517
825
1,429
925
297
19,234
3,348
2,660
7,780
3,716
3,636
6,532
i,�s�
1,363
591
456
2,148
10,007
3,103
68,381
437
2,632
3,385
1,072
l,lb�
622
565
1,129
1,886
4,836
9,527
6,034
72,182
4,416
8,008,686
3,432
1,071
9,696
28,259
Page 37 of 43
Aprit 1,
2010
28,086
512
415
997
1,452
958
312
18,799
3,449
2,731
8,364
4,526
3,814
6,726
1,711
1,282
583
395
2,199
10,877
2,986
67,292
474
2,693
3,497
1,041
1,133
596
628
1,028
1,847
5, l 32
9,712
6,818
77,062
6,944
8,175, I 33
3,327
997
9,145
28,866
Number
2,761
-38
-102
172
23
33
15
-435
101
71
584
810
178
194
-86
-81
-8
-61
51
870
-117
-1,089
37
61
112
-31
-28
-26
63
-101
-39
296
185
784
4,880
2,528
166,447
-145
-74
-551
607
10.9
-6.9
-19.7
20.8
1.6
3.d
S.1
-2.3
3.0
2.7
7.5
21.8
4.9
3.0
-4.8
-5.9
-1.4
-13.4
2.4
8.7
-3.8
-1.6
8.5
2.3
3.3
-2.9
-2.4
-4.2
11.2
-8.9
-2.1
6.1
1.9
13.0
6.8
57.2
2.1
-3.1
-6.9
-5.7
2.1
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2010
2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
Total Po ulation
April 1, April l, Po ulation Chan e
Geo ra hic Area 2000� 2010 Number Percent
Newport village
Niagara Falls city
Nichols village
Nissequogue village
North Collins village
North Haven village
North Hills village
North Hornell village
North Syracuse village
North Tonawanda city
Northport village
Northville village
Norwich city
Norwood village
Nunda village
Nyack village
Oakfield village
Ocean Beach village
Odessa village
Ogdens6urg city
Old Brookville village
Old Field village
Old Westbury village
Olean city
Oneida Castle village
Oneida city
Oneonta city
Orchard Park village
OrIskany Falls village
Oriskany village
Ossining village
�swego city
Otego village
Otisville village
Ovid village
Owego village
Oxford village
Oyster Bay Cove village
Painted Post village
Palatine Bridge village
Palmyra village
640
55,661
574
1,539
1,079
743
4,301
724
6,862
33,262
7,606
1,139
7,355
1,685
1,330
6,b48
1,805
138
617
12,364
2,167
947
4, l 27
15,347
627
10,987
13,292
3,296
698
1,459
24,043
18,096
I,052
989
612
3,911
1,584
2,258
1,842
712
3,490
Page 38 of 43
640
SO,I93
512
1,749
1,232
833
5,075
778
b,800
31,568
7,401
1,099
7,190
1,657
1,377
b,765
1,813
79
591
11,128
2,134
918
4,671
14,452
625
11,393
13,901
3,246
732
1,400
25,060
18,142
1,010
1,Ob8
602
3,896
1,450
2,197
1,809
737
3,536
0
-5,468
-62
2IA
153
90
774
54
-62
-1,694
-205
-40
-165
-28
47
117
8
-59
-26
-1,236
-33
-29
544
-895
-2
406
609
-50
- 34
-59
1,017
46
-42
79
-10
-15
-134
-61
-33
2S
46
0.0
-9.8
-10.8
13.6
14.2
12.1
18.0
7.5
-0.9
-S.1
-2.7.
-3.5
-2.2
-1.7
3.5
1.8
0.4
-42.8
-4.2
-10.0
-1.5
-3.1
13.2
-5.8
-0.3
3.7
4.6
-1.5
4.9
-4.0
4.2
0.3
-4.0
8.0
-1.6
-0.4
-8.5
-2.7
-1.8
3.5
1.3
^
/A1
�
�
�
Table 2: Total Po�ulation Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2004 to 2010
2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
�Geographic Area
Panama village
Parish village
Patchogue village
Pawling viltage
Peekskill city
Pelham Manor village
Pelham village
Penn Yan village
Perry village
Perrysburg village
Phelps village
Philadelphia village
Philmont village
Phoenix village
Piermont village
Pittsford village
Plandome Heights village
Plandome Manor village
Plandome village
Plattsburgh city
Pleasantville village
Poland village
Pomona village
Poquott village
Port Byron village
Port Chester village
Port Dickinson village
Port Henry village
Port Jefferson village
Port Jervis city
Port Leyden village
Port Washington North village
Portville village
Potsdam village
Poughkeepsie city
Prospect village
Pulaski village
Quogue village
Randolph village �
Ravena village
Red Creek village
Total Po�
April 1,
Z�QQ�
491
507
11,922
2,233
22,441
5,466
. 6,400
5,219
3,949
� 408
1,969
1,519
1,480
2,270
2,615
t ,418
971
838
1,272
18,816
7,172
461
2,727
975
1,297
27,867
1,697
1,152
7,837
8,860
665
2,700
1,024
9,378
30,157
330
2,411
1,026
1,316
3,369
521
Page 39 of 43
lation
April 1,
2010
479
450
11,798
2,347
23,583
5,486
6,910
5,159
3,673
401
1,989
1,252
1,379
2,382
2,510
1,355
1,OQ5
872
1,349
19,989
7,O19
508
3,103
953
1,290
28,967
1,641
1,194
7,750
8,828
672
3,154
1,014
9,428
32,736
29l
2,365
967
1,286
3,268
532
-12
-57
-124
114
1,142
20
510
-60
-276
-7
20
-267
-101
112
-105
-63
34
34
77
1,173
-153
47
376
-22
-7
1,100
-56
42
-87
-32
7
454
-10
50
2,579
-39
-46
-59
-30
-lUl
11
Chan
-2.4
-11.2
-1.0
5.1
5.1
0.4
8.0
-1.1
-7.0
-1.7
1.0
-17.6
-6.8
4.9
-4.0
-4.4
3.5
4.1
6.1
6.2
-2.1
10.2 �
13.8
-2.3
-0.5
3.9
-3:3
3.6
-1.I
-0.4
1.1
16.8
-1.0
0.5
8.6 '
-11.8
-1.9
-5.8
-2.3
-3.0
2.1
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2010
2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
Total Po ulation
April 1, April 1, Po ulation Change
Geo ra hic Area 2000r 2010 Number Percent
Red Hook village
Remsen village
Rensselaer city
Rensselaer Falls village
Rhinebeck village
Richburg village
Richfeld Springs village
Richmondville village
Richville village
Riverside village
Rochester city
Rockville Centre village
Rome city
Roslyn Estates vitlage
Roslyn Harbor village
Roslyn village
Round Lake village
Rouses Point village
RushviIle village
Russell Gardens village
Rye Brook village
Rye city
Sackets Harbor village
SaddIe Rock village
Sag Harbor village
5agaponack village °
Salamanca city
Salem village
Saltaire village
Sands Point village
Sandy Creek village
Saranac Lake village
Saratoga Springs city
Saugerties viltage
Savona village
Scarsdale village
Schaghticoke village
Schenectady city
Schoharie village
Schuylerville village
Scotia village
1,805
531
7,892
337
3,052
448
1,260
786
274
594
219,782
24,568
34,950
1,210
1,025
2,570
604
2,277
621
1,074
8,629
14,953
1,382
791
2,329
6,097
964
43
2,726
755
5,060
26, I 86
3,908
822
17,825
676
61,821
1,030
1,197
7,961
Page 40 of 43
1,96I
508
9,392
332
2,657
450
1,264
918
323
497
210,565
aa,023
33,725
1,251
1,051
2,770
623
2,209
677
945
9,347
15,720
1,450
830
2,169
313
5,815
946
37
2,675
771
s,ao6
26,586
3,971
827
]7,166
592
66,135
922
1,386
7,729
156
-23
1,500
-5
-395
2
4
132
49
-97
-9,217
-545
-1,225
41
26
2Q0
. 19
-68
56
-129
718
767
68
39
-164
N/A
-282
-18
-6
-51
16
346
400
63
5
-659
-84
4,314
-148
t89
-232
8.6
-43
19.0
-1.5
-12.9
0.4
0.3
16.8
17.9
-16.3
-4.2
-2.2
-3.5
3.4
2.5
7.8
3.1
-3.4
9.0
-12.0
8.3
5.1
4.9
4.9
-6.9
N/A
-4.6
-1.9
-14.0
-1.9
2.1
6.8
1.5
1.6
0.6
-3:7
-12.4
7.0
-10.5
15.8
-2.9
�
�
�
/"�
�
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2010
2010 Census: Public Law 94-1.71 Data
� Geographic Area
Scottsville village
Sea Cliffvillage
Seneca Falls village
Sharon Springs vitlage
Sherburne village
Sherman village
Sherrill city ,
Shoreham village
Shortsville village
Sidney village
Silver Creek village
Silver Springs village
Sinclairville village
Skaneateles village
Sleepy Hollow village
Sloan village
Sloatsburg village
Smyrna village
Sodus Point village
Sodus village
Solvay village
South Blooming Grove village a
South Corning viliage
South Dayton village
South Floral Park village
South Glens Falls village
South Nyack village
Southampton village
Speculator. village
Spencer village
Spencerport village
Spring Valley village
Springville village
St. Johnsville village
Stamford village
Stewart Manor village
Stillwater village
Suffern village �
Sylvan Beach village
Syracuse city
Tannersville village
Total Po�
April l,
ZOD�r
2,128
5,066
6,861
547
1,455
714
3,158
420
1,320
4,068
2,896
844
665
2,616
9,212
3,775
3,156
241
1,160
1,735
6,845
1,147
662
1,578
3,368
3,549
3,965
348
731
3,559
24,091
4,249
1,676
1,265
1,935
1,720
10,982
1,071
146,464
456
Page 41 of 43
April l,
2010
2,001
4,995
6,681
558
1,367
730
3,071
531
1,439
� 3,900
2,656
782
588
2,450
9,870
3,661
3,039
213
9Q0
1,819
6,584
3,234
1,145
620
1,764
3,518
3,510
3, T09
324
759
3,601
31;347
4,296
1,732
l,l l9
1,896
1,738
10,723
897
145,170
539
Number
-127
-71
-180
11
-88
16
-87
111
119
-168
-240
-62
-77
-166
658
-I14
-117
-28
-260
84
-261
N/A
-2
-42
186
150
-39
-85b
-24
28
42
7,256
47
56
-146
-39
18
-259
-174
-1,294
83
-6.0
-1.4
-2.6
2.0
-6.0
2.2
-2.8
2b.4
9.0
-4.1
-8.3
-7.3
-11.6
-6.3
7.1
-3.0
-3.7
-11.6
-22.4
4.8
-3.8
N/A
-0.2
-6.3
11.8
4.5
-1.1
-21.6
-6.9
3.8
1.2
30.1
� 1.1
3.3
-11.5
-2.0
1.0
-2.4
-16.2
-0.9
18.2
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
. 2000 to 2010
2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
Total Po ulation
� April 1, April l, Po ulation Change
Geogra hic Area 2000� 2010 Nuraber Percent
"l�arrytown viUage
Theresa village �
Thomaston village
Tivoli village
Tonawanda city
Troy city
Trumansburg village
Tuckahoe village
Tully village �
Tupper Lake village
Turin village
Tuxedo Park village
Unadilla village
Union Springs village
Unionville village
Upper Brnokville village
Upper Nyack village
Utica city.
Valatie village
Valley Falls village
Valley Stream village
Van Etten viqage
Vernon village
Victor village
Victory village
Village of the Branch vil(age
Voorheesville village
Waddington village
Walden village
Walton vilIage
Wampsville village
Wappingers Falls village
Warsaw village �
Warwick village
Washingtonville village
Waterford village
Waterloo village
Watertown city
Waterville village
Watervliet city
Watkins Glen village
11,090
812
2,607
1,163
16,136
49,172
1,778
6,208
924
3,985
263
731
1,125
1,074
536
1,801
1,863
60,599
1,712
491
36,320
581
1,155
2,433
544
1,892
2,775
923
6,289
3,071
561
4,929
3,814
6,404
5,851
2,204
5,176
26,705
1,721
9,9Q4
2,158
Page 42 of 43
11,277
863
2,617
1,118
15,130
50,129
1,797
6,486
873
3,667
232
623
1,128
1,197
612
1,698
2,Q63
62,235
1,819
� 466
37,511
537
1,172
2,696
6os
1,807
2,789
972
6,978
3,088
543
5,522
3,473
6,'131
5,899
1,990
5,171
27,023
1,583
10,254
1,859
187
51
10
-45
-1,006
957
19
278
-51
-318
-31
-108
3
123
76
-103
200
1,636
107
-25
1,191
-44
17
263
61
-85
14
49
689
17
-18
593
-341
327
48
-214
-5
3l8
-138
350
-299
1.7
6.3
0.4
-3.9
-6.2
1.9
1.1
4.5 -
-5.5
-8.0
-11.8
-14.8
0.3
11.5
14.2
-5.7
10.7
2.7
b.3
-5.1
3.3
-7.6
1.5
10.8
11.2
-4.5
0.5
5.3
11.0
0.6
-3.2
12.0
-8.9
5.1
0.8
-9.7
-0.1
1.2
-8.0
3.5
-13.9
�
f'`�
�
�
�'�,
Table 2: Total Population Change for New York Local Government Areas,
2000 to 2010
2010 Census: Public Law 94-171 Data
�Geographic Area
Waverly village
Wayland village
Webster village
Weedsport village
Wellsburg village
Wellsville village
Wesley Hills village
West Carthage village
West Hampton Dunes village
West Haverstraw village
West Winfield village
Westbury village
Westfield village
Westhampton Beach village
White Plains city
Whitehall village
Whitesboro viliage
Whimey Point viliage
Williamsville village
Williston Park village
Wilson village
Windsor village
Wolcott village
Woodbury village a
Woodridge village
Woodsburgh village
Wurtsboro village
Wyoming village
Yonkers city
Yorkville village
`/nnnncYn�im vill�nra
Total Po�
April l,
Z����
4,607
. 1,893
5,216
2,017
631
� 5,171
4,852
2,106
11
10,304
868
14,364
3,481
1,897
53,075
2,667
3,924
981
5,573
7,237
I,213
901
1,712
906
831
1,234
51•3
I96,001
2,b75
t OC?
Apri11,
2010
4,444
1,865
5,399
1,815
58U
4,679
5,628
2,012
SS
10,165
826
15,146
3,224
1,721
56,853
2,614
3,772
964
5,300
�,as�
1,264
916
1,701
10,686
847
778
1,246
434
195,9'16
2,689
t n� c
Number
-163
-28
183
-202
-51
-492
776
-94
44
-139
-42
782
-257
-176
3,778
-53
-152
-17
-273
50
51
15
-11
N/A
-59
-53
12
-79
-25
14
')r1
-3.5
-1.5
3.5
-10.0
-8.1
-9.5
16.0
-4.5
400.0
-1.3
-4.8-
5.4
-7.4
-9.3
7.1
-2.0
-3.9
-1.7
-4.9
a.�
4.2
1.7
-0.6
N/A
-6.5
-6.4
1.0
-15.4
0.0
0.5
/ /
� "I
��� ��i�l �'��i""C'L'�
�'r��.� ��,r.��x„��.��� r��.� NY :�4��i�A
� l , . ,.,�... �„��
f
N k��., a� � i,;u� ��'�� a� � A°� �
� � �p��7f, - �00 �
.� A�� c�J '-8 8�,•�
� � �� � � � t��
� �
���� �
- � s� -
November 14, 2012
Mr. James Weber, Highway Superintendent
Town of Ithaca Public Works Dept.
106 Seven Mile Drive
Ithaca, NY 14850
RE: CR174, Pine Tree Road Bicycle and Pedestrian Paths Project
SEQRA Coordinated Review, Lead Agency Designation
Dear Mr. Weber:
Tompkins Couniy has identified the subject project as an Unlisted Action in regards to the
iVYS Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQRA). As sponsor of this federal aid project,
Tompkins County proposes to senre as Lead Agency for SEQRA caordinated review. A
copy of Part 1 of the short Environmental Assessment Form completed by Tompkins County
for the prajeci is attached.
Please communicate any objections to the County serving as Lead Agency within 30
calendar days of the date of this letter.
Please feel free to contact me to discuss this matter at 607-274-0307 or e-mail at
<jlampman@tompkins-ca.org>.
Sincerely,
�
�
�. 1,�--
.' John R. Lampman, P. .
�'� Associate Civil Engineer
Enclosure
xc: Ed Marx, County Planning
i"1
617.20
� . . Appendix C -
State Envir.onmental�Quality Review
SHORT ENVIR�NMENTAL ASSESSMENT FORM
�, For UNLISTED ACTIONS Only �
PART I- PROJECT INFORMATION To be cam lete� b A licant or Pro'ect S onsor
1. APPLICANT/SPONSOR 2. PROJECT NAME
Tomplcins County • Pine Tree Road Bike & Pedestrian Paths Project
3. RRO,fECT LOCATiON:
Town of Ithaca
Tompkins
4. PRECISE LOCATION (Street address and road f�tersections,•prominent landmarics, ete., or provicle map)
West side of County Road 174, Pine Tree Road, Between NYS Route 366 and Maple Avenue.
5. PROPOSED ACTION IS:
' Q New � Expansion � Madffication/alteration
6. DESCRIBE PROJEC'�BRIEFLY:
Bpild pedestrian path along the west side of the existing county road from and connecting with the East Ithaca Recreation Way aad
extending to Mapie Avenue, and a multi-use path from the East Ithaca Recreation Way to NYS Route 366. Replace one abutment and
superstructure of bridge canying East Ithaca Recreaiion Way over Pine Tree Road.
7. AMOUNT OF LAND AFFECTED:
Inftiallv fl�68 acres
Ultimately 0•68 acres
8. WILL PROP05ED AC'fION COMPLY WITH FXiSTI{�G ZONING OR OTHER EXISTli�G LAND USE RESTRICTIONS?
Q Yes � No If No, describe brie�ly
9. WHAT IS PRESENT LAIVD USE IN VICINITY OF PROJECT?
� Residential � Industrial � Commercial a Agricu{ture � Park/Forest/Open Space � ather
Describe:
Pasture for horses. Roadside slope. Lawn at callege-related building.
10. DOES ACTION INVOLVE A PERMIT APPROVAL, 4R FUNDII�G, NaW OR ULTIMATELY FROM ANY OTHER GOVERNMENTAL AGENCY
(FEDERAL, STATE OR LOCAL)?
� Yes � No . if Yes, list agency(s) name and parmiUapprovals: _
72.
Town of Ithaca (MS4) - Stormwa#er; FHWA & NYSDOT - funding; NYSDOT - detour permit
DOES ANY ASPECT OF THE ACTION HAVE A CURREM'LY VALID PERMIT OR APPROVAL?
� Yes � IVo If Yes, lfst agency(s) name and permit/approvals:
AS A RESULT OF PROPOSED ACTION WILL DCISTING PERMIT/APPROVAL REQUIRE MODIFICATION?
n Yes n No . - �
I CERTIFY THAT THE INFORMATtON PROVIDED ABOVE [S TRUE TO THE BEST OF MY EWOWLEDG� .� �
ApplicanUsponsorname: �ay�.,�kiu�5 �c��.� � S'a}�yy� �,4��t,i�UlAQh Date:
Signature:
!� .�..�
if the a�F'ion is in the Coasial Area, and you are a staf� agency, complete the
CfSastal Assessment Form before proceeding with this assessment
OVER
4
� FOREST HOME IMPROYEMENT ASSOCIATION
Ithaca, New York
November 14, 2012
Mr. Herb Engman, Supervisor
Town of Ithaca
Town Hall:
215 North Tioga St
Ithaca, NY 14850
Dear Herb,
On behalf of the Forest Home Improvement Association (FHIA ), I am pleased to support
the proposal to reduce the speed along Forest Home Drive from the entrance feature to Rte.
3b6 as referenced in your agenda for the 11/19 Town Board meeting.
This portion of Forest Home Drive is a very popular recreational use area. ]oggers, cyclists,
�, and walkers have been traditional users. In addition, Cornell Plantations' visitors enjoy
walking on the edge of the roadway along Fall Creek as part of their arboretum experience.
The area known on Fall Creek as Flat Rock is also a very popular wading area for residents
and visitors alike who park just off Forest Home Drive. Safety is a concern for all these uses
as there are inadequate walkways so most of the recreational use occurs at the edge of the
roadway. Reducing the speed on Forest Home Drive will vasdy improve the situation.
�
After consultation with selected Forest Home Drive residents most lrnowledgeable of this
area, we propose a new speed of 35 MPH.
If FHIA can provide additional information, don't hesitate to contact us.
Sincerely,
/S/
David W, Gross, President
Forest Home Improvement Association
Cc: Bill Goodman, other FHIA officers, Bruce Brittain
www.fhia.org I foresthomenews�mail.com
/f� r�
�� � ��
�� � / M ' p b �� 'tl
��1���,���� �,.��' � �`� ����� ����:��� ����� �����.���������.
���4 "° w ' � � � p� ��v�rnrr�er�i: a�� �+����.ni�y �.e�a���r:�
'"� i�� �� i �^ r r��°" �1L
� u ;., y
�1C�v��1��ac;r 2f�, 201?
I-��:�-��rt 3. F�,���iz���
��"c�wzz ��:y�a�;t°v%��r
T�a�vi� ca�' �t��a�.a
? 1 � I�ic�rt�� Tic��a atre�:t
Itl�c��:a, i°w1'�'` I��SU
T.�e��� H€:s°k7,
;�t��al�e�r F'tsiC�C� Jc�l�nsc�ri
�ICC ��I'4,SSC�CIli.
�������. ���,iu
ItPiic�i. "�:�ea, "t'cark: 14h5:i-?�aC�1
1. li(�I?.'?5;,.z�C�"?'�1
{': �i(17.��'i.75�?
c. fiC17.`��it).�1?2
e. ;��2� mz s.c�n�7 r�B �.�:w______ei a�
wwv�.�xe��,�,t�� �r;��li��rr�S.c�a��ata ll.a*�lt�
� ., .� .,�'
r �. r '�� rr
�"°a8 � � �� � � �..i �� �m ����.
i �; r � � : i r ��f;�;!'�
i� ,`���, ,n,;.;`
���;�° ����e��icau�s ��rre����a��c�e��c�, C",cax�a�e�l LJ��iw�:z�sat}r �tti���c�a-Cs t��� t�c;eluctic��� <�I� a�� r����l� ;���ce� l�mi� tca
;�»,
:35 ����ah, �azt I��r�st I-�c�ir�e I�i-i��� l�•��� E�c�u�� a�a6 intc� t}1c ��a.�n�c�t �a�•c���,�r�, ��,l��a� � 2� ��1�1� is
c:�t���lish�c�.
":C"t��. '`bl��lc� cuz•�es" c��� tl�is stz�ctcl� are � sc��.r�cc c�f �;c�z�ce;���ti fb�- ���c�7Yy, as tl��:,r� is e;�t�;al�av� cr�ssin�
anc� �edestri��� use alc���� t��c: z•ra���l �Znd l��t�vc:c;�� tl�e f'i���tati���s ��•1���°et����, ��1���; the tiz��ii�:� alc�rn� ��`��11
�'r�c�:. We° �r� cc�t�f��ie��t i���t rn���t ��se�•� ���i11 ����reci��c; �lc�����• �1�aiw��.
�I,l��r��4� f�7• y��au�• ��acic�rship c��� this �a•+���t. �:� w°el� �.s tl�e �iai-�fln���a��it�t it��a��ts c�k` �7�vi� }31eal��aa.
`�it���rel�, .�.--��--.._... _ .
�.�--_
� ,�r���,;
,�w:��
�t��alle� T'k�i&i� Ja�����c�i7
�ac� �?zesicl���t
�
,,mx���,,,,.
� P�G, 2��Z
<j'm 6•1 k.»t l��C�neax-rc '
D v�.! �fy,. �l�3 �`'� �, � S 2 ti►�+¢.r.��,,r o�� �Q—a++�+'►'r
��s�i,,r,r�'�+�+. �v�d� ) 1a7� Js�l. �, z�'"c.�,� a�. �n�b.a-'o�
c}z��sw�v �'�''"�s �-'�aw n. f�1 �'�+�'CF� a�n.d► �g Ge r�ci�e�
bvs �+►�css��.d �Pd� �1a[i �a�5 � Py r�r���i+►� -� �-��
�iad•+�raJ �}+rvs Lo�r� ��s7 o w, � fa�' �whi.c�. S�+2Q1 }� y s� Gt�
P� �� ���i�S z�'�'' oo�► rt d1C�gQ.
�4s a�rv'In,,.t-e� r�a�►�r` s� �ysc ,.��� �r�m a�v��
�
b�, i a�t �r,�s'e� � ����.. �-�,„+` �.�d5�+� ��a� -
-- �P+ �l'�'D Q V" i'� l/7.CiDLr ��Ji�Glr �'�(� T/��� 1� 1 i e��
�l-i���g f��� ¢�iti�ow� �t�' c�i"a-m a�r,�-ke, rr.�c� cos�
i�'iCvrl'Gd �={t�' -" bv�"}► � r"�m �s�a� b� o�i�a/ ��''h re�� _
L.�fi�M1'E'i ftyNiK` »1 Sir+'f�strr Cz0?��'1�S ,
t11 D
� � � %��� l /�7J✓r �4[GA � �pvlf'l A �Z�i e��[?J�' yJ'i
,�, r—fra�r1�t�" �,KacP,�. ���TN�• �+d�C-}� �Sr �sc��
��� � ✓'t��''rti }e �u'�rr'''R�ricc o� a�c cb-� �ow n
Pavs�n e�f � �v �' n.a�i%� ir z3 �-,�w ��F �Lus .
�'�'�v�q�tr� .j ,✓/��CC�T'Cv��4 Yt.atVyb�f/Gfytl�v7'St�+t�
T"vT ��G '�ZT ��K �3'✓i�►'� ��rB.r'ISGS �'�1� � b1Gv�1'�
in G�r►sc.r�r$`�,:e+� ���rnR b vs yrtars a��►+�' �
2o�t �� Zol���-syv �a��-u� �kc 2�?,�srot rdct�i .
� �
`��nit. ?�o-K--
V
�en M " �
�� cv�.�.r �zdt .
2� 3- ��31
�
���� �� ������
215 N. Ti��� �tr���, Ith�ca, (�.Y. 1485�►
w��ww�.towt�.i tl���c��.t�y.�t�;
���
� ��.
� ���
��,�� ��� ,�w�
�� ��
T��wn SGrF�er�vis�ar ((307} 273-1i2�1, �xt 12S ; h��l�n r�nar��C�t<'rv+r��.ithac�.rr .u5
��t�wN G���� �sca, � a�:�-1��1 �u�a_ic war��s �cc7�r� 2»-���� � r���rv�:����v� ����� 2�:�-�»a
���_,�r�rvinrc� {�a,� za�-��a� �e��vira� ���r��a �r�-i�s�
��x ��oa� ���-t ���n
1���e;�-��bcr 5, ?(71 "�
ik![r. �I7�i1�e4V 'Lt'�a��
}°ii7�c�° ����h;e� l,el���f `l'ra.sst
2C}'? i�ast Cc��trt Sts•��t
ltli<ac��, I'�iY 14�5�
I.)�G�r .�.��e�y:
i�za�7 ��ra°itiii�; ta �;x�a�-c:s� o�ry s�i�a��c�a�t C`c��� t@�e F�ic��cr I,�Gk��; I_r�ncJ �"r�ci�t'� ��rc���as�,cl C��y�r�Lr 1.,��1��
'��°tales-s6�eci F-'��ot��Cler�a 1�7itiativ�,. i�►t�7 cleli�k�tccl t�� 1sG, wcaa�kin�; �e�itl7 tl7e I.ar�ci 7'a��i�& sari tl��^.
ac���iis�kia�� aC t17� Ci,a�c&4vi�� �7rc7�ar�,rt�° ao�c1 ihc; E�rc7pca�e�l cc�l'lt��icaraitmv� �:�5s�,��rr�crll. �>f' cc:ao��;c;rvs��ir-�r�
p��i��rities �.�it8�ii� t6�� Six i�i9e C;�-c�.k 4���ter�;}�ecl os �c7�tl�tl�ir�� �I���t tivcr��le� lae �rf brcG:�C irat��o���t tc�r th�.
"i"c,tivn ot� ItW�a��r.
�l�l�e "�c�wn af lk���c�� ��;.�s Ixcc�,n ;��i er�thus�astic c�81�i1���r-dxcc�iw ��srr tbtii-e� c.7tt�cr ��rc�jcc�t�, �vit�r t@�c� I�a��r;c�r
Lailecs Lc�r1ci T"r�ixt ��r7c1 I x�ii� L:�rc�ain tp�xit t9�e C'=iyu�a Im,rsk� V�✓4zi�.i:tihr;�l �'rc�tcctiarr wi�l 17� ��ti
stacccs�fLrl �� t�7c��� fti�itiFc� l�e�,�n.
l 1raak f�arv��aa-� t�� wc�rkirr� �vitk� yFa�r ���ai°e i�7 tlf� f�ltrar�c, �t�rc� 1��o�� ��1�Cicl�tccf t�r ��ia��:�caa�t C17i�
��t'c��,�����1.
Si��ce�-�1 �,
-�""�
-l�:r- ��.t�t .1. �.x��r�a�t��
"['�wn �Lu�aer�vi�c,r
��ri ��'�..u� � � ;: �" Ga ` C tl° �� '�'
1 i0 Bostwick F��acf, I�haca, N�" °� 485Q
Gt�7-2%4-03QU
�A>G CC}7-272-g4�9
�ecer�Y�.��r• fa, 2f}i?
L7i�ilix� I,. �'rc��iscr, �'�?
�`�'"S�� 1'
'9'�•a�ls��ai-tatioi� Syst�;�j� ��a�ratic��ls Lr�gi�7e�r
333 �;as� Waslaia��tc��� Si�„e;r;t
�y����,��sc, I�95' 13�()2
IZ�: S��e�ci Lia�lil: ��c�����t
��c,�r ��1s. Ci�������>
Pl���se I'il�ci �r�cl�asec3 � x�ec�ues� f�7t� F� ��c:t���c�cl s�aeeci 1i���[t c��7 }'ii�c: T�•ec I�.a�c�, i�� tlzc
"["c��vz� c�:� �tl�acG�. "("1��; ��r��az•�pri�te �`.E� ��� ����ci ��.�salt�t'rarz ai•� s��l����ittecl r��� yc��X�• i-evrc�v �irtd
,����,, �rc����i.
I'terxse, cl� ���t �7�;sil�lt� tc� Gcaa�tac,i z���;, t�t (C��� ?7�-�3t)t�, if � ca�� as�ast fi�z�ikxe�� i��
y���a- d�tua-�t�iz��itit���.
Si��ccrelYa �
�'Ir �✓��� � � � �• �
�„, � � ;'�/ �
�� � �
�'1 �� r B. � t7-�itl�
�� � �
]-�`i�lYr�aay� I�il��c�c���
Ltzcicasur�s
�""�M� cc u�/o e�.icicrsurus: �'����1c�t� T�i-�v�Il��c1`, It:l�ttuit Tea��r�l Clcri�
�mi7@mWWJ,'�a,,. ,P 43/ �11.
���� ieC;y'CrlrCiJJ3pEi
.1."���� "�''�>��»: 1'�w�"�;�,r«��t��a�n,�_. ��;�a�_.�t�rvc��A: �.��:r::���►�rc�►t;�.��t.
�arwrrt°rm�,t�,� 4�t�r (3t+Rta P"�efst��w'.
'�3:3 C��11�I:�1; �w�ir��tt��� l�l���., Suite Sf�S
LJp�cc�t-�c�alc, I'�i1' 1 ll 553
�516'� 2?i-23OC� (k�(7C'�)j i�1�`�I1���5
(51 �i� 2'?✓-2352 Fc�:�
I7ccc,tzll�er 1 1, ?d� l 2
I�GI"t! I:ri1,�TZ1'r3T1, Sll��1`�'YS�kG
�'QS�,FI1 �� ��,�1c�Ci3
�.' 1 � �. �'iC)�e1 a#1'C�d
Icl���,�;a, N'�' I4�S�)
f��: Re;ccan�m�;r��3�3ai�an� (�r �I'c���,�a c��' Cth.tc�i
C����� M►�. L,�t�a�r�r�r,
l2 M��r� P��r� S�rite 2(�)�
�CY�t�171�, �`*�� � ���):�
�}��c�n�: (� ��) ��?�i-1 171
F�x: (5��) 43�-'1 ].f�2
� ti�vat�lti lik� tc� tla���k ycata Cc�r ��ffi�����i�a� ���c tlacw c��r�trrt��nity Rc� pc:r°f'r���m �n uncicrr�vritin� su�vey af y�ca�cr rnua7ic���ality.
�����,.
Since you �r� �t sul��c��'r�en�; r��cr7�t�c:c� cr['tta�. N�w Yc�rk 1�ttr��ici���Y1 1i7�;�irance �cui}�roc�l, iC is irnper��tio,�c� tN�G�t t6a�: �rt��c;r
tizl�c a�-��;1 G�tt�salit.�r� l�c �ie�+�tc<� tc� �rc�vicitn�; �� s��1c envir-c�nrracnt lor r�f�c�als, e�aaployces ar�c3 �attaers ��rl�o �ise c�r° visit
yuuc• f�ciVities. C:4xrelul ccrr�sic9cr��tio�� �t�c��ol�� k�u �ive�ti Cc� t��etl�c��5 Qf'�,rev�nti��� anci mini��Yizir7g lc���c�s ������ a�:ci�ler�ts,
w}aici� c�aL�lc� resuNt in ta��iily irrj�rr�•y ar�ci �rc����rt�y daz���a��.
�+Ic ���•e �rlet�s�d to �civGs� t��erc z�rr� nc� r�ccn��T7�enci�tic�Y7� at t�iis ti����, Sha�ilc3 yo�a }3�rvc at�y q�.bestic�i�s, }�l���sc f`�el ti-c�� tc�
�;c�aa�ac:� �nc; at 716-f,�37-C�4(}� c�►� t�v�ishc�c;l�(rr`��,�rrr �9�tr'c;�;k.�c.�a��.
Y�iu�s t�M�rly,
��� ����
Thc�tnas '�Jcist�ccQc
S�r�ic�r Lr��s C,c�i�trol S���cur�li�t
Cc;: L�z�st�i•r� Sh�ar� ,�ssocr��t�s
1'v�Ss. S1�<3n�lc�a� Vela�c��aer
I(�1 C�yl��� Strcet -�'.f�. 13€�x 45(D
I�ult�n, T�.D`�' l iOC��
"6'h�sG r�c�is��rre�arGl<'htiu7ns �sr� n¢N t�, he cu�r�so�i�errh! �s sal'nA�}f vir��c�c:ti�yia,�tro�i �7u�;1�1 i�«� �r}�ncr }^+�ixir��r�ty tr�� �rruskid� a� �.�fc env'rr�nrnci�t. T'la� ��ily c��s�ru�anans afyuueton�lmayee� t�rr'e
ir�st�m7�want;�bly� rnore� iiroipctr�aivt und cirm�al��14 fltsroi ��u�t leaus ����r�lrcol �stievt;y��. 1�1e arss�rrnc rii� ruwgt«r�sib�V'ity C'ar'irx��leraren4��u�, Ci�ese eu�o�7ma�end:��rtians. �ei�r i'�r�r��;er�.��zticrris �re ,c�arlely
Por eanclerwri4'irn�t, {ai�a'�aoses.
�����,,,
•�^�
s s � •—
P�Is. ��ul�titt� �,�r�rilli�;�r
T�a�rn �l�:r�, °Tc�w� c��'�tl�a�a
215 P�i. Ti��� air°�et
It9�ac�, I"��w `�"c�rk 1485Q�
� -.
9 �, � �j T
°� � ��
�r sr ��"�.• �' ..
" k1i"Y:IVIIYk ..
��I,��� �� �i�iiu �'`ti✓�.{!�
C�E(�ARTfV9EN�` C)� T�A.G�S�'(�f�TATI�N
l���IC�N �
333'�AS�" WA�HII���"t�GV STI���T
SYRAC�S�, hJY � �2ti2
vvv✓w.dcat.ny.g€zw
Z7�ece����a��' 13, '�012
JC7�hJ M�B�LC1f�A�f)
Ct�t�hMISSIQ�dER
' ' ' � �I � �r �
��
T��a�l� �a� f�r yc�u�- �ee�rnber � 1�tt�ar �rad r�sedent ��a��c�r-� s-et�u�st�n�; � l�wer spe�d lit��►it
an Pin� "�['r�� 6�c��d be��r��t� £�caut� i9 �nd �l�ns ��o11+�w R�r��.
A. fac�aa�l irave�t�,�atic�r� r�all be cc��clu���d at the s�abj��:t lc��atic��n. P"l��se b� ��a�re thafi �ur
r��ge�v r�c�Xxires ��f��ci�nt ��lc� i�v�sii�;�tian and ar��lysis t�a ass���e a pra�aer'-�;��cans�. T�p�t�
co���eti�r�� a���e �t�v�e�ti�ati��, yau wil'1 �a� n�rtifi�� of tt�� r��ults� �nd c�ur d���r��rination.
"�"ca c�trry aut t��e ����aartr���t's in�ti�t��r� tc� b� r�ar� �`�s�car���ve ic� �aur� �us��+rr�ers, r�ve
�n�c�a�ra�e yau t� sudbmi� �,�:y i�7f�rrnatit�� r�al�ic�� r�a� be h��p�ial �n c�iar inv�sti�„�ti�«��. �'h�� n��y
in�ll.ad� 1c�ters fi-�+m p�blic, �cc�d�n� d�t�., r���,ps, etc, This in��r�����t��a�a �hc�u1�3 t�� s�btnitt�d to �r�y
��ce �t tM�e �bc�v� �d�re�s.
"4'r����- ir�t�rest �n this �n�tter �s �r�atly a��preciate�l.
'�J�ry tarul� y�,a�rs,
, �
�� ,
� �
, .�
4 � � �. x
� �r ��.�,��C..,�"� ��'� � � .;,�� . .�� ���,%�.
� � .
T�Ic�NA L. (�..7rR.���`��, I'. E.
�w,,,„ l���ic�a��l "T"ra�ic ����i�a��r
c�: .�ef�'�-�y �rrmi�}�, Tan�pl�ins Caranty �-li,��w�y �ar���;�r, �ri�t��c�a.
H�r�er� �. En�;tna�, "T'c,�n af Tih�c�, °�'�a�v�a �L�perviscar�, rr�lattac�.
I'eieH� �. �t�in, �'�arro�}�kit�� �c�u��� L1e�isl�i�.a�-e, Dist�•i�t 1 i, e�I�tt�ch..
��� �� . �,"y
a �
� � �V"�t����b�� ���`�'�� ��,��i�.",��� �
�
4s)'
��.� �- ��� ... �p�
__ _ _
P �
,.y.�.�.- , .--� ��/'� .�; •.
``� „ �. . � . , :� �
�"
�`'�'°�'"1 �� � _9 t �l '� �.� �``a ���� �� li � „� ��..^�� t ���'� ro ��� �' '�� F"� w"p""� »�`�
�,i�..,.„ � _ _
, �
_ �.��. � � %� � ��'"` _
. � �,
�. �� ����� � � �:� � � �� � ��a � `� ��-- ��.��, � � � ��"�. 4, .� �;��r� � �'� �'�
����� ���a �. � � ���. ��, � �. ��. ����� �'������ &�,�., �'"�.^��, A � `� �:� ��� ����:� . � —�.. <�a.
w
. �m.
� �. .
.
. . ���"4 � � ��� • c ���, �'��. �"�� �� � �� ,� _ _ _.
� �� �
.— w �
-- _ �
,, `�"' ��
� � �
��� � °���' ` �? � � ��
,�,
�
µ.
` �W� �" ' ' �
,�« �� a � �'��. 'a �`��t„�,„ Y a�. _ ,.� _ ... . -"�^ a�,,.
^� . � r �`
, , �
� l��a � � ` p �� � �., �, r �'. ! � �+ "a � •" � k` � �drd �� r � ! ^" m ";� ,�
. ,� � .. �1 �„,,
, ^ ��' �P � � C.'�
, �
�
�.. �,.. �������. �� ���.a�"'"� � ��w.�.�..� ����.2���" �,., �`� "�� � w,.�'� �.° � L��`� �"` _ '��"_ '��.�..„
� .�
��
a
. . ,� � . . . . . . ... .... . . .. ..... . .. .. .. .. . ....... . ...... ._... .....
� � � � x���'� ��� �
� � � � � � r� ���
� 4 , �
� . �,., 4 "� � �+��° �. ��
,p
�
� ' "
� A�.� � m °
�
� �"� � a .� �,�°� �" �" °� �� :,��� � � �
� � �A ���z""'�R`�"��"f. ����
,
,�,Y�, ,. � _ _
.,�. � �,� � �
�,�, ��i.�iC'��'. � �;� � ���e.,.� �'� _ _
. �° � �. �, �.
� .� w�,
U w. . � .
. ... �
g �c��x � � �r .� �,��� .�. �� � .,w �.. � ���..�".:.. �.�;��.. �'� � �� ��.. �
� � �, � �
� � r.
��..�^�x �"� ��"�, � � �'�"".� �� �*"� .
� .
M���
�,"� � ,���, ��« �, _
. � .
� �
�
,�---_
� _.
��,, _
� ��^" � ,. � ~�e...
�� ��,�
_ �� �„�""' � � �....��,�`� ,.�"�
,.�..� � � ,�' r � _
� � �"�"�,^^�,. _,�.�� �� �° ,r
�,�.. �"�""� � . � .,
_ _
� �� ��"�
� �� �
� � ; y,,
%% �� �, ^`%" �1 � N. Tla�a �tre�t, 4t��Ca, N.Y. 14��0
.�... ,��� �a�-� wwvw.t��w��.itl�dic��.r�y.us
Paulett�; T�rwilliger, T�aw� Glerk I�hon�: (6(�7� 27�-1721 a�br� DeAug�stine, Cl�p�fy T`own Cd'erk
�St�rv,+ill�gerC�'tovvn.ithaca,ny.us F�x: (G07)273-5854 cideaugistirrecztawn.iih�c�.ny.�s
l7e:c;�r��l:7ea� ] 1, 2C� C 2
�l1eAt-�rari�l-� C�w�:�-�s
Tc.�rt�}��i��s C:;r>�a�atv r�<�ul
7?� W���-r•�.r� I���
lt�2ac�a, l<]�' � 4�.5�1
t.7e��a• Ms. S[��r�7<rr-icrk�,
1 receiv��� y�>�tr ile�tc r�c��:ic��;ti�t�; in����cr�lt�ti<>r� c�a� r��Qtrri�r�;c �7rc7c��:��� a���l ���1c�}�tic�n ��r���,css�s.
I ilca t�c�� I��a�ia:ll� f<�a��il}� c:c:>tzr¢' i��t�t��r,� �az�ucl C���� �°c�cpaa�st wla�Yu1�3 1��; �e��t r�� k��tut�ilg7 C;��trc�t �lt
fi`c>n�����ins C���ur�ty, 1� ti�c�r�t.�lcl �7�s��am�.
:1s ��lc- .c;� � i1�4�r-�-i��;;� lic,e;��sa, � c�7�� g;iti^� y��t.t t:17� c�tat:Vir1�, 1-,r��t� it i5 c���t }�<��:�ik�l�; tc.> cic� �v1�i1L.
i��cc�7���r�it��� �ri L��i7�i,��; +.vk�i�1-� is �vl�c:r� rh� Tca�-t1�-�l�in:; C;������tY.f �ril is.
T�1�IC �1t'I11;� tailll�y cllly' �C1'vUC1 l)1' C.��+` C�'�',G`�; 1[1 �"�1C �t��ICC' 4)��� Ci1Pl l:S4l.1C' el illkli"Z"1al�f', �li[.'l1S('.
1.3���1� �,t�rri�::� tc� tl�� 1��sai�i-i�i�;� ���v�: t�> lae ��r�s�i�t I��fc�re: �-1-�� �l�r[: ��,�it�z �-ra-c���t ��f i�l�l�tity ����c�
kl�;� wk�ick� �]'t'� is v��-y p���a�ti��t.al�tx �al7c�trt. TI�L y7t�a5r cf��l�txac:>ix �1r�° l�ix-t1� t:s:rxifi�.�Yt�� aat�l
c�riv��-"� lic�a-�sc�:�. 1;ari� c�i�c;lc>wizt�; <i ��+�`c��:l�ur�: tl-tat L�ctail� rl-�� c�tla�:r- ry��e� ��f iciLi-rraf�'rc��ai�>�1
rk�at t,�tr� l7G G���c:�,t�.�l, 1$ �irla��- ���1�-t:y t�o �l�c: �l7<�r-1-i�t�;c� l��i;� lacei-� �xa�a�-rie�� l��:fr�r-c�> l-�r�-�c�� c�f�
��i�sc7l�.it�t�t-� c�Frh�1t �rtW��-ro�p;;�, �itlle:r <t c�����7r-c,� d��.r�� car �x cl�atll �L�-tificr�t�, �nt�st k-��°
��t•c�v�il�ci. Tl�� c'c�st �',f� �� li�c�r-�sc: is ,`�i ��� aa1c1 t@Zc: lic�tlsc i5 �;�,c�L� f��r ��� ciatya.
�'��5 I���i�l al�r��,��, t ka�c��v tl���t th�: L.�7��,��ir-�� C;➢�rks wvull ��c��� �;c5 tc� t1�c j��il tc> iss�i�, �� l�c� i�5� if
C��Att tiv«�s yc�t.rt' ii�te��t'. Ji�sr.ic°�s c�f ila� I'�r�ce; r�r N1,�rr-ia�g�: C.)tf�ic�ei•s tc.> �7ci-fc�r�i�� 47 �ivil e���-��r��c:>t�y
� lY��z�;:;� ��et�u��r� � i 5 �ii-�d � 1 r�� fc�r t1:1� sc,rG�i�:i:.
�is�c��a�ti�y,
� ��� � �.�J, , �. ���
W� ���.� ,,�'
� ��� LL���o �� ���.�
I�'���.�l�t���: T�rwill����