HomeMy WebLinkAboutPWC Minutes 2010-01-26 ti*
TOWN OF ITHACA
Public Works Committee
January 26, 2010
Present: Rich DePaolo,Chair; Bill Goodman;Jim Weber; and Mike Smith
The meeting began at 10:00 a.m.
The minutes from the December 1, 2009,meeting were approved.
Setting Meeting Dates and Time
Rich DePaolo said that he would like to have the meeting held for an hour and half
instead of one hour. Susan Riha told Rich the best times for her to meeting would be
Monday and Friday.
The Committee decided to hold the meeting on the fourth Monday of the month at
10:30 to noon. After April, we will have to reassess because of Susan's schedule at
Cornell. The meeting dates will be February 22, March 22, and April 26 so far.
Setting Goals and Meeting Format
Jim Weber said that he would like to have staff here only when they are needed to help
with discussions. Rich agreed. Rich also wants to have agendas sent out at least one
week in advance of the meeting. Rich said that he would like to have as much
information sent to him electronically;Bill Goodman agreed. Staff will start scanning
documents to be sent to Committee members.
Rich felt that issues and projects should be reviewed by the Public Works Committee
before going to the full Town Board. The Committee agreed.
Mike Smith asked if he should continue to come to the meetings. Rich said he would
talk to Jonathan about this,but he felt it was good to have someone from the Planning
Department represented.
Ulysses Water Meter Building
Jim explained that the Town provides water to the Town of Ulysses. In the past, the
Town of Ulysses has disputed the billing and meter readings. The Town of Ithaca has
been losing approximately$10,000 a quarter.
r
1
0,14 rks Committee Minutes,January 26,2010 Page 2
0'4 Jim explained that the past Town Supervisor in Ulysses felt the problem was the Town
of Ithaca's and would not pay for the overage in water charges. They now have a new
Supervisor, so this problem might go away. Jim didn't feel the Town of Ithaca should
rely on this happening. We need to fix the problem.
The Town has designed a new building that would house two meters. One meter
would read the water going to the Town of Ulysses and the other would read the water
coming back to the Town of Ithaca. This will solve most of the problems. The building
would be 20' x 12',contact has been made with property owner and he identified
concerns with visual impacts. We could increase the landscaping to hide the building
more. The building would be in the Town of Ithaca.
Jim explained that when this design was being planned,cost estimated to be $60,000.
Both Town's would pay half. The revised cost will be more like $125,000. The Town
staff will talk to the Town of Ulysses to see if they are willing to pay half the$125,000.
He felt that even if they didn't,we would still get$30,000.
Rich asked if we needed both meters. Jim explained that we do,but there are other
meters that could be use. Those meters are more for high volume water flows.
Rich asked why water comes back into the Town of Ithaca. Jim explained that it serves
houses on Trumansburg Road, Woolf Lane area, down to Indian Creek Road.
Bill was concerned that the Town has not tried to recoup the money from the Town of
Ulysses. Jim said that staff sat down and figured out the differences and billed the
Town of Ulysses. Jim indicated this took quite a bit of staff time. The Committee
decided this should be discussed at a study session. Jim said that we can't really prove
it's the water on the Ulysses side.
Rich asked how soon the building and meters could be in place. Jim said it could be up
this summer. We have an easement that we would need to get.
Jim said we would like to move ahead. Rich asked if the Town has a Memorandum of
Understanding with the Town of Ulysses. Jim said it was verbal at this time. Jim felt
the next step was to meet with the Town of Ulysses. The extra money the Town will
have to pay will need to work on be approved by the Town Board.
Jim said that staff is working on redoing our department's capital projects list for 2010.
He would like to be able to both this project and the Remington PRV.
Remington Road PRV
Jim explained that,as can be seen by the picture, this space is a Confined Space. When
1
Public Works Committee Minutes,January 26,2010 Page 3
there is a confined space, at last three people are need to be there; one going down the
hole, one monitoring the air quality from above, and one supervising. We wanted to
get away from confined spaces, so we proposed putting a building on the property.
This project would reduce risked to staff.
The owner,Mr. Rogers,wanted the Town to buy the whole property to put in the
building. We decided to redesign the PRV pit to keep it in the existing easement. We
will rebuild it underground,but it will have steps down to it and there will be a floor.
We will still have to get a temporary construction easement from Mr. Rogers.
Jim explained that the valve is working but very old and needs to be replaced. This
project will also help when the Town replaces the East Shore Drive water main. During
construction of East Shore Drive water main project, the PRV on Remington Road will
be used more extensively.
Jim said that the project should cost around$200,000 and that money was included in
the capital project for East Shore Drive water main. Because the money is in the East
Shore Drive project and the East Shore Drive water main will not be constructed until
2011,we will need to go to the Town Board for the redistribution of money for this year.
Winthrop Drive Parking Concerns
The Public Works Department has received, several times, requests from a resident on
Winthrop Drive regarding parking and dropping off or picking up kids for school.
There is a crosswalk at the curve on Winthrop. There is a crossing guard,but they are
not able to "police" vehicles there.
Jim explained that he has researched this with Susan Brock,Town Attorney. We would
need to have the local law changed to read "No Stopping". No Standing means that
vehicles can be parked there but not idling. No Parking means vehicles cannot park
there. No Stopping means vehicle cannot park or idle.
Rich asked how far Jim felt the no stopping should be. Jim felt it should be 75' on both
sides of the crosswalk and both sides of the street. Rich asked if it would be only certain
times, and Jim said all the time.
There was a brief discussion regarding Dewitt Middle School changing the traffic
pattern in their parking lot. This may or may not help with parents dropping
off/picking up students on Winthrop Drive.
We should move ahead with this.
r
Public Works Committee Minutes,January 26,2010 Page 4
Hanshaw Road Walkway
Jim explained that the Hanshaw Road Walkway project is part of the 2010 Capital Plan.
This consists of building a walkway on Hanshaw Road in conjunction with Tompkins
County rebuilding Hanshaw Road. The Town has agreed to funding parts of the
walkway project which would go from the Village of Cayuga Heights line to Salem at a
cost of$70,000. Tompkins County would build the platform and the Town would put
in the concrete. Tompkins County has delayed construction of this project until 2011.
Tompkins County would like the Town to pay$55,000 for design work on a walkway
from Salem Drive to Sapsucker Woods Road. The Town needs to decide if we want to
fund that. There would be an additional cost of$5,000 for rights-of-way accusation.
These costs would include design work for cuts and fills along Hanshaw Road
properties. Appraisals would also need to be done. Jim explained that if the Town
decides not to do this design work, that it would greatly change the scope of Tompkins
County's design work.
Rich felt that it seemed like a lot of money for such a short length of walkway to design.
Jim explained that it would cost an additional$70,000 to construct the walkway from
Salem Drive to Sapsucker Woods Road.
Jim informed the Committee that in 2006, the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca passed
a resolution committing to the walkway from the Village of Cayuga Heights to Salem
Drive, and that they would consider extending the walkway to Sapsucker Woods Road.
Rich said that he would like to defer this until Susan Riha was able to be at the meeting.
He also felt that because the new development proposed in the area has not been
decided yet, that this should wait. Rich asked what savings the Town would see if the
design was done now. Jim figured it would be approximately $15,000.
Jim explained that the approved Capital Budget for this project is $163,000 plus. He has
not fully identified what all the costs are for,but we know that$70,000 would be for
construction of the walkway from the Village to Salem Drive. If the Town uses
approximately$60,000 for the design and rights-of-way work, there would be
approximately$33,000 remaining. If construction of the walkway from Salem Drive to
Sapsucker Woods Road would approximately$60,000,we would have a shortfall of
approximately $27,000.
Jim went on to explain that there is a handout that indicated that Cornell University
would split the costs from Salem Drive to Sapsucker woods Road 50/50 if the project
was expanded. This would reduce what the cost to the Town would be. We will talk to
Cornell and see if they will split the costs 50/50.
Public Works Committee Minutes,January 26,2010 Page 5
Mike Smith explained that the Town is working on a design called Bluegrass Trail. This
trail would go from Cornell University campus and connect to the Hanshaw Road
walkway. If the walkway was extended to Sapsucker Woods Road this could lead to
walkways to the Ornithology Lab. The Committee discussed that the extension on
Hanshaw Road could be done in conjunction with the Bluegrass Trail.
Bill felt that if Cornell University did go with the 50/50 cost split,the Town should do
the design work now. This would have to go to the Town Board to get the money.
The Committee had concerned about what the residents on Hanshaw Road wanted in
terms of a walkway extension. It was contentious at the beginning, so we are not totally
sure.
The Committee discussed the problems Tompkins County is having with Coddington
Road reconstruction. The County wanted rights-of-way to be 3 rods on all of
Coddington Road, and the Courts said no,they would have to go with each individual
parcels right-of-way.
Jim believes that Hanshaw Road would not have that problem as the plans show it as
deeded rights-of-way.
Public Works Projects and Priorities for 2010
The Committee received a list of the Public Works Department's projects and priorities
for 2010. This is more for information. This Committee will look more at policies than
oversee projects.
Bill asked about the clay fields at the Valentino field (Tutelo Park). Jim explained that
there were some drainage issues and that we wanted to upgrade it to meet the
specifications/standards for Cal-Ripkin ball.
Rich was concerned that we are paying for these changes. Jim will get the specifications
on this. Jim said it would take about one week to rebuild.
Bill asked what I&I meant. Jim explained that it means infiltration and inflows in the
sewer lines.
Rich asked Jim why gravel shoulders had to be constructed. They break apart,
materials go into the ditches, and grass grows up in them. Jim explained that the
shoulders support the road asphalt from deteriorating. Other materials that can be
used would be pavement, curbing, or gutter pans. These materials make the road way
seem wider.
,
Public Works Committee Minutes,January 26,2010 Page 6
Rich asked what the lasting value of shoulder is. Jim said that people drive on it;if it
was grass, there would be ruts. Jim explained that shoulders also help with the Town's
liability. Rich would like to go on a tour of the Town with Jim. Jim explained that
putting shoulders on roads is not unique to the Town; it is a national practice. Rich
wondered if there was any measure of shoulders really working.
The Committee decided that#8 (and other items for discussion) on the agenda should
stay there.
The Committee discussed Forest Home Drive Phase 1 and where it was at. Jim
informed the Committee that New York State is reviewing this plans. Rich wanted to
review it again to make sure the key elements were in place. This needs to be done
soon as the State already has it. Rich said that he is hearing that there are differences
between what some people believed the plan was and what is on paper. Jim explained
that the Home Owners Association was happy with the plan. There where some issues
with the speed tables not being detailed enough.
The meeting was adjourned at 10:45 a.m.
ghk
.
Yr .
-/ : .
•
•
NOTE
l� GRID I ____-. _ ALL UNDERGROUND UTILITIES ARE APPROXIMATE �N OF 1 py�
NORTH : tT%>\
\ AS OWSRASDEE 0A LANSOFESNTSPSEORA7A�`` GIULIPNO JRF LUCPTELLI ' ' \\\ •yn -O�l��
\\`� Tn•33-3-19, _ l I,�
•'�"G-, ' C°'�Ji,� 'pl 635/B¢5 �iy `I�
e ,` ENC/NEER'S SEAL
,° 4y
ev �'� - `i.71,,,\(.Are ^ .
) ,,
``, S` •
A, ``may, \\ (Q' ``� �Y// �°(y -
•
\\ -` p Jq`� ° 70WN OF ULYSSES_
`C7 musc.ru�s_o1. .\-
%',1: c / .`` _-- \ TOWN OF I THACA
1'") ADELL G3 D ` Q zip
l'I 6- L -2. a . . N/F o CO.�o
*JP'
...6' {may] ,, '</ ki — q\� 2 In.-�
�/� \ / • ?a�f ; 4y� \4 6I ULIPNO JR.. —I
Q / ® : a \- LU6PTELLI I� rCOHy
(tea (/�,] m z3-1 a L7 J m
q• ^/�� L \°. .Y \�✓ ..a r•rW�� tram 635/805 �� •�:
o t W
^� . \C.S.
Z Q W
- FEATURE SYMBOL • G >.. _ =2
tA'Y'
MITT MG Q^ ifs On y ]p� 1�S p Q
V.1 n •• \'S\p3\�`�C t �
PILE Y/LIGHT / p
'MI MAW ``A v • `� \` NL vrs/uvs
v m WOE O \ \ +�+14 : CD,
-Logo TrtEs, • l O kb//
_ GIG LOC —O— `6 ` / \ Y \ RAYS 22 mm SNLLYr
RAMO EIELTRc —Lvo— 20 0 20 40, 60 5� /�% \ 1LS0 A�i9 .
!UM IMAM —or -. - �+ '.°w 1'=20'
•
NfREAO TELEROE '—or — `p O •P \ SCALE VERY
' SIG Y/POSTS ana S c a I e 1 " = 2 0 ' / • NOT TO.SCALE
. : CID 1 ILL
•
W11)1
•
•
•
W /
444
co
•
•
p
m
CO
m
O
N
A N
NOF1T.,
p-*/_ 9
t 0,NOTES 4'SPRING
ALL FLANGE BY FLANGE FLOW CHECK VALVE 8.X4.
FITTINGS 125• TYPICAL 8'X4' REDUCER
REDUCER 8°- 80.B 8' - 90' 4'TURBINE METER & STRAINER \ BENDBEND_II�. B *IIILY31)
"
1.1II1w
,' '.��,In ••i,I*' IAII''!I II'
VALVE 4'SPOOL PIECE / VAAVEE ENGINEER'S SEAL
PRESSURE GAGE 1
0-300 P.S.I. i1 i'!) 8 PIECE SPOOL 8'SPOOL rol V PRESSURE GAGE
A � / \ • • •• / PIECE\ fI 0-300 P.S.I.
fPMEmII\IIImP• - . is 9III'`II—ii ..
•
8'GATE •o o — 8'GATE
/ 8'FLANGED SIDE VALVE 'I■IuI®►..nft FII VALVE 8'FLANGED SIDE 02' X 2'BLOCK OUT OUTLET TEE TURBINE METER OUTLET TEE Q Z
g
IN FLOOR SLAB TYPICAL V 0 (/) —
t O VV
FLOW Cr cn
2 2" PIN LUG HOSE -
CAPS W/ CHAINS O _I CO
I"AIR RELIEF ~ CC O
VALVED CC
T
BALL VALVE • LL COI-
' f 2 0 Z Q Lil
..z i ., i
Ai
IMIIIIII—
Illpill 11 11 1 -IL*Aiwa 101 1009 ce....e .•■•lb ••—9 cr I__ ,..0
ICONCRETE FLOOR SLAB CONCRETE FLOOR SLAB
33' STAINLESS STEEL / CORE 10 3/q'STAINLESS STEEL / CORE 10
/ THREADED ROD TYPICAL THREADED ROD TYPICAL
who-n-os f Ti
MO SECT ION A-A `Ir SECT ION B-B `Ir K LI a�+wr
NOF MJ FITTINGS WITH MJ FITTINGS WITH „o,TO SCALE 3
WEDGE ACTION GLANDS TYPICAL WEDGE ACTION GLANDS TYPICAL cif/.0 nc
. , •
, .,......,_ ,
lit
,
t
,4,• 1,7...4,
' -.4' A;,..• .4'
SI?
, „.:.4.• 4.
.. .. ti ..,
. . •
•;•'' ' 4.'8• • 1 4#
•P:i Ca'I • •'• s •'- - 4
a .'e 14;4. . ••• L t
,1!
•I i t.,•• •.1. r•
'' t"1--• 4 , 4
- Av - ) *t• •-•
.. ... _
::_-_-•-:::,•.---_: - - -___ -_-,-_--.4..... - .• .,ti.• , -
. -.-----z: -:•.-- -i -_-- ,,....
. .
- — . .
. .
4'
Alb. --"`"
_ .... -
. . ....
—,....w.lonrf.44,§-1.7.7-,-7 .•',17`.`"!..`•—r•-•.....7.7—:',' —7—F.41.i4.7`• —— 7•—•—•"'••"-" '''' .......................--...........-
P-c)pa5c2,d a/ e — /
le /
NOTE: ALL FLANGE TO FLANGE ‘;4101r"--V' T
F I TFITTINGS 125# TYPICAL y�
IFM
tiF W -c OC
ENIGINEER'S SEAL
4'-0"OPENING
L INK SEAL 1"CAST VENT
„ OR EQUAL N17N RODENT GUANO
INSIILATEO DOUBLE LEAF
ALUMINUM DOOR AND FRAME
Z"PRESSURE RRODEF
BLON-OFF URE ELIENJ
GUARD
2"x 3' SLAB ELEYTADN- 493.Q0'
TEE
C. J -90•
2 B"x 3" �.! Z"GALVANIZED �• GROUND TO SLOPE AMA),
b TEE
1�1 � ]"GATE
�Y. r2'
PE YI TN HANGERS ''! fRON PIT TO RUN-OFF
• VALVE •1\
�J. PflCSSURE REl lEF �Q -B'LATE VE AND FI TONGS
ea 10 TREADS vAl vC ]-METER ,y AS REQUIRED :)!
S lRA1NER ,Y, :�
1. r
_0 1 Q 1 2"BAII 0
B"PRV �: B"PRESSURE / YAL VE J.
REDUCING r
6"SIAP �y 10 TRIOS VALVE 3RE000ING, cfe
^I i: 2�PflV INVERT ELEVATION
YAL YE I85.00' �Y: O�� f1. VAI VE ;: L� O Q
H'CA if 1 IIIN
i - VALVE j
?• ...v,
�•
opf H"xJ"TEE �(L. J"GATE�IQI�� VAL YE ,• % A O +�+
+g — e e;'ri_,'•.a!�k 3':Wit)+t'-4:J+::'OP.. ':e' Y: r.V.i•VAI%�i'7.t:7'•_'r.7+
l"-90•
00
3 TEE3Ell11/121.11 3
12"N/N/NUM REDOING STONE
CC
fN2 NATURAL YASMCD STONE) REI NFORGED CONCRETE O CC CL
r/7R iMi ST/L SEALER
PR VISILAR
1'21 3-xNOCROUT FOR I' Np1 To KALE
ELECTRICAL CONDUIT.ITN
I.1N[SEAL
1101 10 watt
WFE ,:nvo9 SNEE El
MALL NOW
+•.Ir
SALE ARE 3
AOT TO SCALE
G+II A 1LE
REO+HGIONIILN
PROPOSED
LEGENDU D E G ROUNDIC N OF l
FEATURE E1<Ki NYSEG POLE / 1 RDGERSN/F
JOHN B. Z 1 L�N� O.‘..1,
/�ti9
dl L34260 1 8.-1-1 4 1 OpER r` f,
UTILITY POLE I I sue" m \ I SE pR�� D
� is R c - - - M no 111 � �cur VIRE
\J App�Ox,� ,�
FIRE HYDRANT n o o� 1 �i �� 1 �•
C)m 1 �'( \-4
�Kr `(OWATER VALVE (W) 6, ym 1 \ rA 9 .\ `1 il"' 1 \ E I$ T►'S SEAL
( E — - z? r,\1 L _AP_PROXIMATE_co a _ - BASEMENT LINE
IKNE
HATER Litt —W— 0 1 y , Iv,
pp, WITHELEv —� aes1— - EXISTING 12"X8" z. la
TEE TO REMAIN \ la
I ELECTRIC�� 0 — -w-__,' EXISTING 12" 11-
tEL ; / Y
p GATE WATER LINE la
'NE VANES 1
PIPING AND FITTINGS Ilp
V� AS REQUIRED 1A. i1z
, i 1110L-CDP'' 1 \ -r-
(-) r.,C
cli • ! , �//\//
APPROXIMATE _ - IZ
a ` as - EASEMENT LINE l m Q 0
n A� W r- a 0 1Im w ~
rrlc 44�i /� N/F
I o /,b/ ® ROGERS. JOHN B.I 2 LL C 7 O
z I ® T If 8.-1-13.2 1 C3 z
Ir
�--�
1" TAP TO SERVICE I /i // 11m 3 O
HOUSE BELOW. TO BE O W Cr
PLUGGED WHEN DONE / I
/ 1'/4/
jCI1 I
j / j-4rZi /NOTE /! , / - J am wan vs
ALL UNDERGROUND UTILITIES ARE APPROXIMATE / // STRUCTION EASEMENT L,NE !_- -
2miav
AS SHOWN. THIS DRAWING DOES NOT DETERMINE - to 0 10 20 30
EXACT LOCATIONS OF UTILITIES. CONTRACTOR RY CON _ - 3uK£ L1 2
IS RESPONSIBLE
DIG SAFELYO ERVERIFICATIONS
IONSYAND pROpOsE0 TEMPORA --- -=�.--- nt,oQaE
t/D FILE
Scale 1 " = 1 0 ' KM.D
•
•
fF „^ "1 '6 r .r -i "'
t,T ti � �-
V ,
+ ' ` 1-,,- �j 7 ' .« yip 4
i' _ : 1`.
rii.
r
1 OBI
J
::':- - . --::' l'. ..e5
MIII
liPlial
9QA. ' 9'�Y p �., r.
a,4 ��
.,4, Newiiimissi,i N.,...er, ........-="'A--
_:„..1F,
FE �"� ,`
::xf
-
• - 3°`x
r
f�
F
t.:� cCc,
S.r4.
a, it
..
I :.,,
—a—b-A S$-P2--er ---„,),pi cv:-.2)- NI:-Pv14 7--
._,,e/,.. 5 2 tci fo ./6117 --=-a)- 0,9 •
ih, z-111-- 1 )t, )---12 -7-e k''IY5 t -
5- P c?-/--
1 d 1—.g•",s1 f, \its/e,?j, L , -5
c
• f-- ,i 2(
c' (1`
*
- 'I—
* 4.-sss , — $ /410.61110.TMOr' .'-4-'11 ,. ' .h•44 4fiaiht
„.4.-.
• -1,
...
. . , I
S.
,.. *..
il' .. .
, 40
s ,
r .
vi
.„
I . .... t
a '
. _
' t
.. _ .
t
1111
?"•' -
OW
• A. !
" *4 . ,
JP 4-
•
. .
. ,s .
. ,
,••
_...
.. . . ...
•
' 3
. .
1
.. ...
1
....i.
- ... .
- .
„ .
4).
' . I
. - . .
.t di
)1, 1
S.
!441,4 . .I 4.
. -.......1.7.,4....,....to...,- -.1atiotemonlams•.,441sialmarN--...../ ....r
i
rt r ..
-
r ,
NOTE
I ALL UNDERGROUND UTILITIES ARE APPROXIMATE � NYSEG POLE \ N/F \12V";::(-21-‘-"-
QF lAS SHOWN. THIS DRAWING DOES NOT DETERMINE .J L3402 1 ROGE8. 1-14 B. N EXACT LOCATIONS OF UTILITIES. CONTRACTOR ^IS RESPONSIBLE FOR VERIFICATIONS AND uuU I 1�� t y \ 1MFIp �f t�DCALLING DIG SAFELY NEW YORK (DSNY) gE vZ I 'i 10 11 3 \ pPP1 Ilv,�� 0 �®m 1 /�� F Q�s,m 1 , f ,\ 1 3o•D' 1 w `lt`7rJ , A®�� 1 L- APPROXIMATE 1 [Nci�r[s'suOm _] % 1 4t1SEMENTLINE r13 `EXISTING 12"X8" z \TEE TO REMAIN \ \/ v"�' —r EXISTING 0 I� ��„_
0p / WATER LINE M
-® I \ I4
ti i `Le-let;)
I 91 1 la
m Q
Ilm Li I
11 1 Ittn Q Z
= O
n lit r- EASEMENy LINE a 11 ~
/ Z
� � � ®
I N/F 1
I ® �I OG8.-. JOHN13.2 B.I I—
i a a B.-1-13.2 1
niT
o
I / I I • ocn
I/` l I %l o/ / LEGEND cc
/ / /I FEATURE EXIST 0
a o / / ! UTILITY POLE w.rir�
on 71 / / / GUY WIRE
,� ! / 1 W/MCHOR
c C - - -
`�"� e I / / FIRE HYORNf r/
^~n
cb
4 // I / / WATER VALVE
/ I / ( I ur----- OAT ,:�t,.ov Will rr
/ I EASEMENT TELEPHONE
1 0 0 10 20 30 / Y ERUCT 10% - WATER LIMNE —"� R'>RJr
• • I.
QSED 1EMPORAR 0N5 - wpm LEVATIa1TH —I 495 I— - w[TOERT
WALE
S C C I e 1 = 1 0 ' PROP UNDERGRdIO �T►tr� 1
ELECTRIC ue�— n..m u.
PSSOCIATIONO,r.c Harlin R. McEwen
rt`°A��' ���'� Chairman, IACP Communications and Technology Committee
W Ap \NA o Chief of Police (Ret) - City of Ithaca, NY
t)^ tiAm
a9 ,� FBI Deputy Assistant Director (Ret) - Washington, DC
`� POLICE
—� V-- 422 Winthrop Drive, Ithaca, NY 14850-1739
SINCE 1893
Mobile 607-227-1664 • E-Mail chiefhrm@pubsaf.com • Phone 607-257-1522
December 29, 2009
Mr. Herb Engman
Supervisor, Town of Ithaca
215 North Tioga Street
Ithaca, NY 14850
RE: Dangerous Traffic Conditions near Northeast Elementary School
Dear Herb:
After I met with you on the morning of December 17, 2009, I went back home and
that afternoon saw another example of the daily dangerous condition I have reported. I have
enclosed photos I took on that day.
Today, a car has again lost control on the curve. We were fortunate that school was
not in session and that children were not walking near the crosswalk and the front of my
home. I have attached photos of the tracks of the skidding vehicle and the marks the driver
left in my lawn.
I am hoping that you have already taken steps to get the Town Board to take quick
action to minimize this problem.
Once again I am recommending that the Town enact legislation that would create a
NO STANDING AT ANYTIME zone on both sides of Winthrop Drive near the crosswalk as
I have described in the diagram I submitted.
Thank you for your attention to this matter.
Sinc rely,
43.W142)
Harlin R. McEwen
Winthrop Drive / Northeast School - Parking Hazard — Sept. 22, 2009
x
f , .1("4 4 oc,. sic * -
•
•
r K• :s :•F.-t-x.
, Y j v. ,
._ i. it
.
_ I i 0
atm
I
•
•
t ,
•
41
•
's
--AIM- , _A, o
4. ,.......ii\
4,- ..._ .
.... _......._
,....
ID .3_
..._
.—._
. . _.
6 an
- • 2.,/91)(1 f'
Winthrop Drive / Northeast School - Parking Hazard - April 28, 2009
I ,.� J
.. =x": -
-Ata. a i a l jY f~"
r•
w . ' 1 :. , .:, .,..
ryw:
•1,
. 4
t 4.
t
` '.k..#:. .I.1 ,,•' 'i.
•
''41‘i‘..--':::::""•:: .4"1-::::T r-- -
__
.,. ... - —
_ _
, -,Ammi, ......._ _. __ .. .
,. ,
.,,_ ‘.
" . -.
,....
.........
,....._..„._ ,
,......„....$ _
. . ., , . ........ a _____________
. . ,.. .
-nut
NO . ..._ _ . - -
1
i
,
1 I
Winthrop Drive / Northeast School - Parking Hazard —Sept. 28, 2009
. -
• ,
4.• , .
. . ., .....
, .
. .
I •
• 46 kt. •'
• . •
....s,
•
I..
l':.:''' •
....*/ ..
•• • . .
......
I •
A •''I .
P - .1612 • __
I
- p::•• - .......-
.5,e. .. li , ' •
.. • , r
Ir..... . -•
' miiill.
.. I"-------e-."------- ---------"•••••••-------"'""ex _-
- '
,1 ...
. -- •-- • - ' -r- NOM iMir- •I
• ...
. . .
---•--,.....-
: •
- -
6 ' ,
`..
..' '4./4 i'e „iv i_ r
4.
4.• ,. ,
... J...r
• • -
AlLip.... .,.. .4 7-.a.--I • '
. . 4 le
. i',_ 'Ilte II. - ., ' ,. , ;,;..,-. ,. ,74.7-i ..._.-.. -,:.•,.,,r,
-• - --; 2kca.:. _„,„-r• it. 4.*:,--iv-: ,-.2t....__ -_-- -_,/,-.., --"e"..,;&- --.• f•
- , ..VII....... 4 •4- WV. - -f-''-41.0' ..., ,fi ", Ar.,."-- ....- -'--".- -,0410.4
I -, : - •'11-° ii -:Ar - ' -04, .,---c
- -IF,A•
ig-t-857'r;. _ .
...,40)1F.....o.
- - ......"•"."'.'' ...` .
sr.." ...
.'...::-I", ,...:. ', , yia • --.N1,..4. - 411I'''. '%41' • - . ' -
, -''''1:,41K:ii. .N.:,- ._ .i''X 4„.. .",..,,k.,...' - --- •
4
,...,, ,
... ,...
...
4-...
i
— - f i a lir,-- •., .
, .7
. ,
•
...,- —
• in.. ...,.._
......
. .
ilk 4
_ tl,•t
..., *
--F-4
.,11,- A .'..•
...d.
,,......„
M2009 -
Winthrop Drive / Northeast Crosswalk—April 29, 2009
—1.-------- ...PrA
. //' ),' i, , ------
,... iii :',`,, , il,1,4 iv -
t t ,ACK°'
_- , ..' 4. l' L -,...-----7 • . 4 *lit T'
-..... ,.
goo •-., -
. iii 1•1
----:-.Eas __ 34• Me IMMElli-
..". ' . -'' - :--C. — ."''''"':=.7 EMMM■i..4.•,- - .001 MILITI',,,
-
) ..."......: . - .
0,0°' ' :i'''''',..•"*,.. 1. ' .... Mr-P-:.t.. ga,4-4;:44* ii.....
.'• : ...,./,
.- .:.• I """
At.
\
..-•'
""!...
1 : . 4/2912009
;-V‘ ' • "-, it''ff"' . . — .— ---- —
-c.,. . . _
1 L-'''''
• - , - fr , ,
, .•
°.% - '..
, - ,„,k.,: ..t,.„:, ,....
1. J.: " ' 7410. ic. im re twi., rr .,': ,. '64 • ''
It
1 0 -
, ir rin i RI .4)
1.. -':' '., -. 414.0471" ' t•iwallilles. -
....I.,
, 110101101101111010
_ .
..,-....010....—
...... ---.' -----....._
•...
• - -. ' -,
-"a
PSSOCIATIONOF Harlin R. McEwen
:' fir • ro�le s� Chairman, IACP Communications and Technology Committee
_ // en 1� Chief of Police (Ret) City of Ithaca, NY
4IA� �� FBI Deputy Assistant Director (Ret) Washington, DC
. %, POLICE 0I
�N V--• 422 Winthrop Drive, Ithaca, NY 14850-1739
Mobile 607-227-1664 • E-Mail chiefhrm@pubsaf.com • Phone 607-257-1522
December I 7, 2009
Mr. Herb Engman
Supervisor, Town of Ithaca
215 North Tioga Street
Ithaca, NY 14850
RE: Dangerous Traffic Conditions near Northeast Elementary School
Dear Herb:
I want to call your attention to an ongoing and increasing dangerous traffic condition
on Winthrop Drive near the Northeast Elementary School.
Enclosed are photos taken over the past year that will give you an understanding of
the hazard that I am referring to.
I would appreciate your assistance in bringing this to the attention of the Town Board
with a request for action to minimize this problem.
I am recommending that the Town enact legislation that would create a NO
STANDING AT ANYTIME zone on both sides of Winthrop Drive near the crosswalk as
have described in my attached diagram.
Thank you for your attention to this matter.
Sinc rely,
Harlin R. McEwen
!*'''' :OP .,1 t . ,
4004,
\, -- -• i
.ii,
•
(..- _
4,..
-. . -
y. _ . ..,..' •
K r t, v IJ I a1 * Itr -'1 ii
r.
•
,' . i
11
i T M
10,4
pi 7.'T .41/rit .. . • 4411tit
f , '' '-'-- ..'' - .
4 4ip„w , +'
•
� i , A. e '411.FullA" '
•
i. .._ «M'"'4. - 4 A,� • .kit -.. .14' I".
u�3 a
i
A "Y r � ililliP. �
tli• •
? '': ''' tc' . Turteloillft II.. .. ' . .,LL'- 1..:.. . •, P.A..,,....,.........•• ,.
�, • A i • ,ail ts! it 1•
•
2.09 ro. Technologies ti -- �. .V'
4411114cG°42gle 111 .
Im . .e}New"York GIS , ti,-
�fi[ Acts 30, a o ' 42°28'27017' N- 7$,c-28 02.92 W. elev ' 971t- Eye alt 1824 ItY
o
I
n
t ��
S
ki
IL
Winthrop Drive School Crossing/Curve December 17, 2009
•
•
ww
I .. t •
k.
air
rams g-
12/17/2009
Winthrop Drive School Crossing/Curve—December 17, 2009
/�,
•
.} ,q,,,r•*.fir_ - I > 1 • '
•
•
. 4
•
f I
....;-- ' ' ' !Atli.' . '.;. • ' . . . • ,.
.,h'S,.'1.101IIIHIBIp Iu;w .un S •
- '
. ,
Winthrop Drive Accident—December 29, 2009
_---
.i),,,,,cii',;;,-,,,,,,;: _----
• • if 1.
`,*•
-7 :44. t N ,P...i ,., .•" 111 rire4; ‘ ,.
' 4,i p • 4 k , . , ,
''• 1:1, ,,,,_ ,
. „..- ?rip, '::-A 0 !!'4;". -,,..' " N. % ' •: ' .' : j
• 1 '., ' •)% .'.. .
v.,
- -- -.- , , NI 7.-. ,0_ • lag I
sui•41161 ' ' ... c.-...... I ' in j_11
- — --i , .. ._ __ •
. _
.. __
-- - - — -- —
_ -
...
..--,..- • _.,
• . . "Fit, ,-„ 3„...ie..... •
. .. . _
. . .
- -,.,,.
7-
-'741
re .•'• .1'. •1..
,...• ....,
J,-'.7."... ...'
',..
._ , ••,,-... _, -, 1 N.ts,,t, . f i .,. .
N._ t, , • 1!ilk , • ... ..,,t.' ..'41
•••••;,., .
'• • : , . ,,,.. : • .. .441t,."1.
- '4. .,.. 1 . 4 ' .4' •Z‘ °Illk :‘ ' !i;44 . .
I
.1 r•-V.-41k, . •Ns... 1 i' - -
_.:• : - • I IP r 4 ' - t,4 i
1111 I -111 11 I j
f -- A
. - j fill
-
• ill' - ,),-...1 1 .4 .:J ig"' I I 61
' . -. ._ ....• -
' •,,,
- :mi I
II i
,.4,..,..,
e_r -
1 1 '''.7" '-;e•'!; " - • .
_. ---
, 'v. -.•-
-1107' • '4, -• - .,..-.-ow.. •z -
--- - • • - - ._
. ..." - --•''IP - - .r. ... •..'-` ee-. - :1 . '''''4.)2:0;3."'""
-,.'. -.1°. :-4.4f4--..,'.7'. •. 4"; . •iy. --. -- "••. AA 114...
• .
- •::.' • . 1.• ...•'-' . . ,
...-- ,: • INSHilit
• ... •
• , * •
Winthrop Drive Accident—December 29, 2009
I
..* AY. ‘,4*% •4\ i
,,
1, -, 1.° Is 1 . z' - ',. .. '• . , ...
, • ..., - - -,., oto, t T ' - '-:0'' ' 't 41 1.
,..i.
• ..,
..gee"
,rt, 0 1111 ll 1 IP! n ! ,
_ -0
,-
.
- ,
1 1.1 II
,,, J liten
male -;..
. I
osamill
•„,. -
.7
''*er'' 2/29/201)9
...._ . -.,...1.p., • .
•
- -
f 1, •
t - '-. . _. .. 4!.
14 ,p ,\-: a •.-.7"'• .
, • .. s,•
, ak• ,„ t ,' : ' ' - '.A; .%
I
.. . e..,
.„. •
,,,P,.." .• q ,,,I:- •4 -48.7,li •
41" '
----
,
- — I -
;._____ -- VII- 1 i . • - a 1. la
11.•
IOW-,
- .---..-low.- ----..-.-
_ -- -
,_....„...
----ak -
...
1110P-5.- Nkrz-- :
--Ilk . .'-e't,.......
---
,
-_ i "•.‘. -..
4041; .
12/29/2009
•
.• .- .