HomeMy WebLinkAboutPlan Appendix B 05 Energy and Climate Protection
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan B‐76
B.5 Energy and climate protection
Climate change is one of the most
urgent, pressing issues faced by the global
community. According to the
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change
(IPCC), global GHG emissions resulting
from human activities have grown since pre-
industrial times, with an increase of 70%
between 1970 and 2004. The IPCC is the
leading international body for the assessment
of climate change. Thousands of scientists
from all over the world contribute to the work
of the IPCC on a voluntary basis. Since
1750, global atmospheric concentrations of
greenhouse gases have significantly increased
as a result of human activities, and now far
exceed pre-industrial values. Most of the
observed increase in global average
temperatures since the mid-20th century is
very likely due to the observed increase in anthropogenic (human-made) GHG concentrations. Although the Earth’s
climate has changed throughout history, never before have we seen such significant disruptions to the systems that
make life on Earth possible.
According to the IPCC, human influences have:
“Very likely contributed to sea level rise during the latter half of the 20th century.”
“Likely contributed to changes in wind patterns, affecting extra-tropical storm tracks and temperature patterns.”
“Likely increased temperatures of extreme hot nights, cold nights and cold days.”
“More likely than not increased risk of heat waves, area affected by drought since the 1970s and frequency of
heavy precipitation events.”
(Source: https://www.ipcc-wg1.unibe.ch/publications/wg1-ar4/faq/wg1_faq-2.1.html)
With its April 2009 resolution to participate in the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation
“Climate Smart Communities Initiative,” the Ithaca Town Board recognized that climate change is a threat not only
globally, but also locally, and likely to affect our water supply, food sources, infrastructure, sensitive ecosystems,
economy, and quality of life. The Town Board resolved to promote sustainability, reduce greenhouse gas (GHG)
emissions, and adapt to climate change by implementing the following strategies:
Reduce GHG emissions from Town operations and in the community.
• Gather data on current GHG emissions from Town operations, as well as throughout the Town at large.
• Set GHG emissions reduction goals for Town operations.
• Develop and implement an Energy Action Plan to decrease Town government’s energy demand and achieve
reduction goals.
• Pursue renewable energy sources at Town government facilities.
Reduce solid waste generation and disposal and enhance recycling strategies in Town government facilities as
well as throughout the Town.
Implement land use planning that supports Smart Growth principles and GHG emissions reductions.
Assess risks and develop a climate adaptation plan for Town operations and within the Town at large.
Concentration of greenhouse gases: 0 AD to 2005 AD
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan B‐77
As the first step in the process, the Government Operations GHG Emissions Inventory was initiated to assist the
Town in understanding the scope and nature of the challenges we face in reducing our impacts. Completed in April
2011 using 2009 data, the inventory revealed the largest sources of emissions and the most expensive energy
consumers within Town buildings, fleet, and infrastructure:
GHG emissions and energy costs by sector
Fleet
23%
Employee commute
3%Buildings
6%
Streetlights
and signals
3%
Water
45%
Wastewater
20%
GHG emissions
Wastewater
27%
Water
45%
Streetlights
and signals
3%
Buildings
6%
Employee commute
12%
Fleet
7%
Energy costs
The above figure illustrates the proportion of GHG emissions resulting from the Town of Ithaca’s government
operations, broken down into six sectors.42 Water treatment is by far the largest source of emissions in the Town,
comprising nearly half of the total emissions. The vehicle fleet and wastewater treatment facility are also significant
contributors to overall emissions in the Town’s operations. The figure also illustrates the costs associated with
powering, heating, cooling, and fueling the Town’s operations. This reveals that water treatment, wastewater
treatment, employee commute43 and vehicle fleet are the biggest expenses for the Town when it comes to energy. The
conclusions drawn from these data inform our next steps and prioritize actions. The biggest opportunities to save
money and reduce emissions are clearly within the water treatment, wastewater treatment and vehicle fleet sectors.
Efforts focused in these areas will yield the greatest return on any investment, whether through energy efficiency
upgrades, alternative fuel usage, renewable energy installation, or energy conservation policies.
These data guided the Town Board in setting emissions reduction targets for both the long- and short-terms, and
provided the foundation for the Energy Action Plan. The Town Board considered actions already planned, and
weighed the impacts of proposed actions before coming to agreement on ambitious, yet achievable emissions
reduction targets. Recognizing that all sectors of the community, especially the local government, must accept
responsibility for their share of reducing emissions and the risks associated with climate change, the Town Board
endorsed the following GHG emissions reduction goals for its government operations:
80% reduction below 2009 levels by 2050
30% reduction below 2009 levels by 2020
The 2020 Energy Action Plan, which is available for download on the Town of Ithaca’s website, was adopted by the
Town Board in October 2011 and provides a clear roadmap of the activities and measures that should be
42 The wastewater treatment facility, which is an intermunicipal system, entered into a 20‐year energy performance contract in 2010 and
will undergo significant improvements starting in 2011 to lower energy costs, and emissions over the long term.
43 Employee commute is not considered an expense to the Town, but is included in the inventory because local governments often have
opportunities to reduce emissions associated with employee commuting, such as encouraging and incentivizing alternatives to driving
to work alone.
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan B‐78
implemented to achieve GHG emissions reduction goals. A summary of these recommended measures by sector,
and their contribution towards the interim reduction target is as follows:
Water treatment
Energy efficiency improvements to water treatment system
Promote water conservation practices amongst residents
Wastewater treatment
Energy efficiency improvements to wastewater treatment facility
Energy efficiency improvements to wastewater pumping stations
Vehicle fleet
Use biodiesel (B20) as fuel source for vehicles
Limit idling of heavy duty trucks and other vehicles
Reduce vehicle fleet mileage
Optimize fleet and vehicle size
Maintain and repair vehicles regularly
Buildings and facilities
“Lights out” policy (electricity conservation)
Increase chiller efficiency
Efficient lighting retrofits
Energy efficient computer hardware (computers, printers, monitors)
Reflective roofing
HVAC fan upgrades
Increase boiler efficiency
Municipal green building policy
Streetlights and traffic signals
Replace streetlights with efficient lamps
Evaluate lighting districts and remove unnecessary lights
Install LED lamps in town-owned lights
Renewables
Purchase 10% of electricity from Renewable Energy Certificates (REC’s)
Solar power purchase agreement
Given that government operations constitute only 2% of the Town of Ithaca’s community-wide emissions, the Town
of Ithaca determined that it was critical to complete a Community GHG Emissions Inventory. The inventory details
emissions:
The following chart illustrates the proportion of total town-wide community GHG emissions associated with the
various sectors. Transportation is by far the single largest source of emissions within the Town of Ithaca (44% of
total emissions). Buildings, however, when combined from the Residential, Commercial, and Industrial sectors are
responsible for more than half of total emissions (53%). The Town can use this information to engage the public in
an effort similar to the Town’s to develop GHG emissions reduction goals, and to develop and implement an Energy
Action Plan. These data also have important implications for the Town’s land use planning and policy development,
given the authority the Town has to regulate and guide future development. With 97% of Townwide emissions
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan B‐79
coming from transportation and buildings, the Town can adopt policies and implement programs to reduce vehicle
miles traveled and automobile dependence, create more walkable, livable neighborhoods, require greener, more
efficient buildings, and promote energy conservation amongst residents.
GHG emissions by sector | Town of Ithaca
Waste
2%
Transportation
44%
Industrial
4%
Government
32%
Residential
17%
Agriculture
1%
Robust data, ambitious goals, and well-articulated plans can only go so far in helping the Town achieve its energy and
sustainability objectives over the long-term. Without a centralized sustainability department or permanent staff
devoted to energy and climate change programs and projects, it is essential that the Town identify who will be
responsible for carrying out specific energy and climate change actions to meet the goals, and that the Town devote
resources to these areas. In addition to devoted staff time and resources to carry out the energy and climate change
goals, actions, and plans, the Town should also take the lead in establishing an Energy Action Committee. This
committee should be comprised of local community members and experts, and should guide the implementation of
the Town’s energy, climate change, and sustainability plans, goals, and actions. Critical to the success of these stated
goals is a commitment to tracking and evaluating the outcomes of various action items and goals to ensure
effectiveness and clarify the best path forward. Once the Town has identified responsible departments and individuals
for each goal and their related actions, those point people will report annually to the Town Board on their progress. It
is anticipated that the goals and actions will evolve continuously over the years, and the annual report can serve as an
opportunity to check in, reevaluate, and add or omit focus areas to reflect the needs and interests of the Town.