HomeMy WebLinkAboutComp Plan Chapter 2 Goals and Recommendations
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 9
CHAPTER 2
GOALS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 10
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 11
GOALS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Goals are broad statements that form the foundation of the Comprehensive Plan. Recommendations are more
specific policies, programs, projects, and mechanisms that direct action toward achieving the goals. The goals and
recommendations represent the values and priorities of the community, and serve as a guide for evaluating future
planning decisions.
Goals and recommendations are organized into 11 policy areas:
Land Use and Development (LU)
Housing and Neighborhoods (HN)
Natural Resources and Environment (NR)
Energy and Climate Protection (EC)
Agriculture (AG)
Recreation (RE)
Historical Resources (HR)
Transportation (TR)
Municipal Services and Infrastructure (MS)
Community Services (CS)
Economic Development (ED)
The goals and recommendations of this plan are intended to shape the Town in a way that will result in a vibrant,
healthy, sustainable, and even more livable community with attractive, walkable, and socially inclusive
neighborhoods, open scenic vistas, preserved natural and agricultural areas, thriving educational and cultural
institutions, a modern transportation infrastructure that accommodates all users, a prosperous and diverse
population, and a distinct sense of place. Goals and policies are based on best contemporary planning practice,
Smart Growth principles, and the collective vision of the larger community.
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 12
2.1 Land use and development
The Town of Ithaca is committed to establishing land use practices that promote a strong sense of place for its
residents. Land use and development practices provide the foundation for how a Town grows and changes, and
molds the community’s quality of life, character, and sense of place. The Town’s land use and development goals
anticipate a Smart Growth approach, encouraging pedestrian- and transit-oriented development by establishing
walkable, mixed use residential, office, and commercial areas that are connected by a multimodal transportation
system. These new areas will be interweaved with the Town’s existing conventional suburban neighborhoods,
commercial enterprises, and employment centers, and establish architectural standards in commercial, office, and
industrial areas to promote community identity. The Town is committed to protecting and preserving open space,
agricultural lands, and sensitive
environmental lands from additional
development. The Smart Growth approach
will support an enhanced quality of life for
Town residents, and will put into practice
the Town’s commitment to reduce energy
consumption and to meet its climate
protection and housing diversity goals.
An additional goal is to create new
institutional zoning for Cornell University,
Ithaca College, and other area institutions.
The intention of this new zoning is to
provide the institutions with the flexibility to
plan and develop their facilities, while
ensuring that surrounding areas are
protected from negative impacts such as
traffic, overshadowing buildings, noise, other
externalities from laboratory and research
facilities, and from expansion of
institutional uses into residential areas.
Goals and recommendations
Goal LU‐1: Shape and improve the quality of the built environment by focusing growth to provide for the
needs of Town residents while fostering a balanced mix of agricultural, open space and recreational,
residential, commercial, institutional, and office/industrial uses.
LU-1-A Avoid sprawl by focusing and promoting development in areas where adequate infrastructure and
services already exist or can be easily upgraded.
LU-1-B Preserve and protect lands that contain: steep slopes; Federal, State, or locally designated wetlands;
environmentally important areas such as quality wildlife or plant habitat; forests and woodlots;
agriculture; and areas listed on the inventory of Scenic Resources.
LU-1-C Limit intrusion of non-agricultural uses into agricultural and conservation areas. Buffer farms from
neighboring development.
Stapleton, Denver, Colorado (DT)
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 13
LU-1-D Limit low density residential uses to areas that have limited or no value as agricultural or conservation
areas, and which are also not anticipated to be served by public sewer and water.
LU-1-E Require development to take the form of cluster subdivision (also known as conservation subdivision) in
environmentally, agriculturally, and visually sensitive areas.
LU-1-F Establish more intensively developed mixed use neighborhood centers near large employers on East Hill
and South Hill.
LU-1-G Establish new mixed use neighborhoods in areas where they can be supported due to proximity to
utilities and adequate transportation networks.
LU-1-H Limit the acreage of land zoned for commercial and industrial uses in the Town to only the amount
realistically needed to meet current and future demand. Discourage strip commercial zoning and
speculative rezoning.
LU-1-I Restrict frontage (“strip”) residential development.
LU-1-J Redevelop or retrofit aging or abandoned industrial or commercial sites as mixed use, pedestrian-
oriented development.
LU-1-K Ensure that development is sensitive to the community’s scenic views (as identified in the Town’s Scenic
Resources Inventory).
Goal LU‐2: Create, reinforce, and respect a strong sense of place through the form of the built environment.
LU-2-A Adopt architectural design requirements to promote high quality, human-scaled architecture. Encourage
construction of efficient and environmentally sustainable buildings with a timeless visual appeal.
LU-2-B Implement site planning requirements to promote human-scale development and social connectivity, and
to discourage less attractive and less enduring alternatives (such as vehicle-oriented development where
parking visually dominates the site).
LU-2-C Establish standards for landscaping and screening.
LU-2-D Revise sign requirements to ensure that the Town continues to be protected from visual pollution that
results from excessive and inappropriate signs and clutter, while still providing adequate flexibility for
agritourism and special community events. Ensure that sign regulations conform to current legal
doctrine.
See also: NR-2-D (tree preservation)
Goal LU‐3: Maintain and enhance the established character and sense of community of existing
neighborhoods.
LU-3-A Ensure that new development and uses in existing neighborhoods are compatible with the established
character and scale of development.
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 14
LU-3-B Encourage infill development and redevelopment opportunities that take full advantage of the existing
infrastructure, yet respect the established character and scale of the built environment.
LU-3-C Establish new and additional systems of communication between Town government and neighborhoods
to ensure early awareness of and input into the Town’s decision-making process regarding proposed
developments and land use changes.
LU-3-D Work with neighborhood groups to determine important characteristics of their community; maintain
and enhance these characteristics.
LU-3-E Encourage private initiatives to maintain or improve neighborhoods (such as neighborhood cleanups,
tree plantings, supervision and maintenance of play areas, and adopt-a-park and adopt-a-road
programs).
LU-3-F Work with the City of Ithaca and other adjacent municipalities to connect and enhance the existing
neighborhoods that cross municipal boundaries.
See also: RE-1-B (provision of parks and trails), TR-2-A (road design, speed, and traffic calming)
Goal LU‐4: Require that new development in designated areas on the Future Land Use map take the form of
traditional neighborhood development (TND).
LU-4-A Scale new neighborhoods to be within a 5- to 10-minute walk (¼ to ½ mile) from a common destination.
Define the edges of neighborhoods, but also provide for easy access to open space.
LU-4-B Promote a wide cross-section of uses, densities, and building types in new neighborhoods. Site more
intensive uses closer to a common destination; intensity and density generally should decrease with
distance from the common destination.
LU-4-C Require new neighborhoods to contain a mix of uses and recreation spaces that support the daily needs
of residents. Locate mixed uses in the appropriate areas and in suitable building types.
LU-4-D Ensure that a variety of housing types and prices are provided that support a broad range of household
types, sizes, lifestyles, life stages, and household incomes in new neighborhoods.
LU-4-E In new neighborhoods, require that civic uses be located in areas of high public visibility, prominence,
and accessibility.
LU-4-F Scale blocks to accommodate a variety of building types and to encourage walking.
LU-4-G Site building types of like scale, massing, and uses to face one another on a given street. Face primary
building entrances towards streets, open courtyards, or public spaces such as parks or plazas.
LU-4-H Incorporate suitable sustainable development practices such as light imprint development, low impact
development, and alternative energy production in the design and construction of new neighborhoods.
LU-4-I Consider neighborhood identification and branding programs including gateway features, special
signage, public art installations, and other features, to reinforce the identity and character of existing and
new neighborhoods in the Town.
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 15
See also: TR-2-G (street design following traditional neighborhood development principles), TR-6-A (Complete
Streets)
Goal LU‐5: Recognize in the planning process the presence and character of Cornell University, Ithaca
College, Cayuga Medical Center, and other large institutions.
LU-5-A Implement institutional zoning to recognize and accommodate the unique land uses and built
environment at colleges and universities. The intentions are: to allow institutions the flexibility to plan
and develop their facilities; to promote best planning practice for institutional sites; and to protect the
character of surrounding areas. Consider institutional zoning for other large institutions.
LU-5-B Work with Cornell University, Ithaca College, Cayuga Medical Center, and other large institutions to
ensure that their development plans conform to the Town Comprehensive Plan, while supporting the
missions of their institutions.
Goal LU‐6: Use contemporary, effective tools that reflect best current planning practice to guide the form of
the Town's built and natural environments.
LU-6-A Adopt a new zoning code that includes all aspects of land use and development regulations that are now
located throughout the Town code into one document. Consider a unified development code.
LU-6-B Require a form- or transect-based zoning code to guide the development (where appropriate) of new
neighborhoods and the redevelopment and retrofitting (where appropriate) of existing neighborhoods.
Consider including form-based regulations in a larger zoning or unified development code.
LU-6-C Adopt new subdivision regulations that are suited to a growing community with a diverse range of land
use patterns and physical environments. Consider including subdivision regulations into a larger unified
development code.
LU-6-D Review, revise, and add to as needed, all of the Town’s development standards to ensure that they reflect
current best planning practices and legal doctrine. Remove or revise standards that are barriers to
implementing this Comprehensive Plan.
LU-6-E Revise the zoning code to implement a simplified and more logical categorization of zoning districts,
permitted uses, and siting requirements.
LU-6-F Ensure that all land use regulations are written in clear, plain, and consistent language that will be easily
understood by all users, including laypeople. Use tables, charts and illustrations where possible.
LU-6-G Review the Comprehensive Plan and all land use regulations on a regular basis, to keep ahead of
emerging land use trends, best planning practice, and potential legal issues.
LU-6-H Work closely with adjacent municipalities, Tompkins County, Tompkins County Council of
Governments (TCCOG), Ithaca-Tompkins County Transportation Council (ITCTC), and other
appropriate regional agencies and organizations regarding land use planning and development decisions.
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 16
2.2 Housing and neighborhoods
A cornerstone of a community’s quality of life is its housing and neighborhood opportunities. Citizens desire safe,
secure, high-quality housing and neighborhoods. Although housing in the Town is largely a function of the private
sector, the Town is responsible for assuring that housing provides for affordability and diversity, including special
needs and multigenerational needs.
The Town of Ithaca is committed to fostering
neighborhoods that are livable, affordable,
walkable, transit-oriented, and sustainable.
To meet that commitment, the Town’s
housing and neighborhood goals include a
Smart Growth approach, which encourages
more density, diversity, and mixed uses in
existing neighborhoods.
The Smart Growth approach also promotes
efficient, mixed use development with a
variety of housing types, sizes, and prices that
provide for a diversity of incomes, ages, and
household types. Complementary services
should be interspersed within new housing
developments. Development will be located
near and connected to existing multimodal
transportation facilities (e.g. pedestrian and
bicycle facilities, trails, and public transport)
and employment centers. New residential
mixed use development will be constructed with respect for and preservation of the natural features of any proposed
development site. Finally, new development will be encouraged to locate within target areas designated as
appropriate for such development.
The housing goals also include promoting Universal Design for seniors and those who want to age in place, and
adopting a multi-pronged approach to increase the supply of housing that is affordable to median income residents.
While the supply of housing geared to low income residents has increased in recent years, housing affordable to
residents in the median income range continues to be in short supply.
Goals and recommendations
See also: LU-1-B (protection of sensitive lands), LU-1-E (cluster/conservation development on sensitive lands), NR-2-
D (tree preservation), EC-2-B (green building standards), EC-2-C (energy code)
Goal HN‐1: Promote the availability of diverse, high‐quality, affordable, and attractive residential
neighborhoods.
HN-1-A Ensure that adequate amounts of suitable land in appropriate locations are zoned to meet the Town’s
share of regional housing needs.
Commonland Community
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 17
HN-1-B Focus new housing development closer to the City and in areas where public transit is available.
Designate locations for new housing that will connect with the Town’s existing and future planned
neighborhoods, parks, trails, and transportation system.
HN-1-C Explore future locations for senior housing that are located conveniently to commercial and professional
services and public transit routes. Include both moderately priced units and market rate options for
seniors. Encourage mixed-age housing and housing that accommodates Universal Design/Aging in
Place principles in all developments.
See also: LU-1-F, LU-1-G (new mixed use neighborhood areas), LU-4-D (housing variety), HN-2-B (zoning and
housing options)
Goal HN‐2: Encourage a balanced blend of high‐quality housing opportunities, including moderately priced
housing to provide a range of prices to accommodate the local workforce.
HN-2-A Require developers to provide a certain percentage of residential development as moderately priced
housing affordable to households in the median income range (80% to 120% of Tompkins County
median household income), and/or consider using density bonuses and other modifications of
development standards (e.g., raise maximum building heights) to encourage developers to create
moderately priced housing units. Moderately priced units should be indistinguishable in appearance and
functionality from other housing and should not be isolated from other housing.
HN-2-B Modify the Town’s Zoning Code to allow smaller lot sizes and encourage smaller residential units and
other strategies in residentially zoned areas to provide housing options that will not preclude moderately
priced housing.
HN-2-C Consider pursuing legal or other mechanisms to ensure that affordable and moderately priced housing
remains affordable over the long term, while allowing opportunities for owners to take a modest
advantage of increased equity. Strategies might include: zoning regulations; housing trusts; deed
restrictions; internal subsidies of lower priced units by higher priced units within private developments;
or other mechanisms that allow a reasonable profit as property changes hands, while keeping the resale
price below market rate.
HN-2-D Continue working with the major employers in the Town, including Cornell University and Ithaca
College, to promote housing opportunities for their employees near their places of employment.
Continue working with Cornell University on their commitment in the Cornell/Community Housing
Initiatives program to fund housing programs and projects that will support moderately priced housing
opportunities in the Town.
HN-2-E Seek grants from Federal, State, and other agencies and foundations to fund housing that are affordable
to those at or below moderate income ranges and also use strategies that do not depend primarily on
Federal or State subsidies, means testing, or third-party agency involvement.
HN-2-F Consider establishment of a housing trust fund or land bank that could be used to support housing
projects in the Town that are affordable to families at or below median income. Consider ways that the
Town can help provide funds to decrease development costs (density bonuses, assistance with
infrastructure, housing trust fund programs, etc.).
See also: LU-4-D (housing variety in new neighborhoods)
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 18
2.3 Natural resources and environment
The Town of Ithaca is enriched by a wide
diversity of natural features and open space.
The abundance of woods, waterfalls, gorges,
open fields and meadows, and lakeshore
contribute greatly to the quality of life in the
Town and serve as important habitat for
plants and wildlife. Residents value the
Town’s natural areas and scenic resources.
Ninety five percent of the respondents in the
2009 Resident’s Survey stated that their
quality of life was enhanced by the existence
of natural areas; 91% stated the same for
scenic views. However, our extraordinary
natural heritage is challenged by changes to
the landscape caused by development
affecting the viability of the natural areas,
water quality, and the Town’s scenic beauty.
The Town of Ithaca is committed to the
preservation and growth of diverse natural
areas throughout the Town. The Town
recognizes that natural areas need to be identified, designed, and preserved with an eye towards richness and diversity
in native animal life, native plant life, and ecological communities. Sufficient land must be set aside for the range of
needs of the specific native species that live in that ecosystem, with well-planned interconnecting natural corridors to
allow for the natural migration of the flora and fauna. Natural areas should be developed with the needs of the
plants and animals that inhabit them taking priority. We must ensure that these areas, features that attracted many of
the Town's residents to move here in the first place, are also vibrant for future generations to enjoy.
Although the Town has achieved many of the goals in the 1993 Comprehensive Plan aimed at open space and natural
resource protection, most notably the adoption of a Park, Recreation and Open Space Plan, there are still more
challenges and work to be done if we are maintain the character and quality of life as it relates to the natural
environment.
Goals and recommendations
Goal NR‐1: Identify and target natural and environmental resources for preservation and protection.
NR-1-A Inventory, identity, and comprehensively map the Town’s natural areas and open spaces, including
riparian areas, gorges, biological corridors, forest cover, steep slopes, ecological communities, wetlands,
wildlife habitats, etc. Expand the Town’s knowledge of its valuable resources beyond basic existing land
use information and known Unique Natural Area boundaries. Maintain and update the inventory over
time.
Coy Glen Creek
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 19
NR-1-B Establish criteria and a mechanism for classifying the significance and importance of natural areas and
habitat types. Include rarity as a consideration as well as high-quality common habitat/plant
communities/ecosystems, such as those especially large and contiguous, isolated from human activities,
old, or lacking harmful invasive species, or those providing connections between other important
habitats.
NR-1-C Update the 1997 Park, Recreation and Open Space Plan to reflect new or expanded natural areas or
open space targeted for protection (through purchase, easements, conservation zoning, etc.) subsequent
to the inventory and classification process described above. Include possible new planning approaches
and necessary funding mechanisms.
NR-1-D Identify and designate additional natural and/or scenic resource areas that warrant Critical
Environmental Area designation as a way to highlight them and to ensure that environmental impacts of
proposed development will be thoroughly assessed.
Goal NR‐2: Protect open space with appropriate land use regulations and development strategies.
NR-2-A Establish buffer areas between development activities and large contiguous protected areas such as
Buttermilk State Park, Robert H. Treman State Park, Eldridge Wilderness, Land Trust preserves (e.g.,
Lick Brook Nature Preserve) and Cornell University natural areas.
NR-2-B Focus development to within targeted areas to protect against habitat fragmentation.
NR-2-C Develop regulations for timber harvesting activities of a certain scale; such regulations should require the
submission of a sustainable forest management plan that includes preservation of enough healthy,
diverse species for an ongoing forest.
NR-2-D Adopt standards for tree preservation, clearing, and replanting for development activities. Provide
incentives for maintaining healthy, diverse species of trees. Require a tree inventory,
replacement/planting plans, and construction standards to protect retained trees.
NR-2-E Continue to ensure protection of Unique Natural Areas through the development review process and its
associated environmental assessment (State Environmental Quality Reviews), conservation zoning, and
other mechanisms.
See also: LU-1-B (protection of sensitive lands), LU-1-E (cluster/conservation development on sensitive lands), LU-
2-C (landscaping standards)
Goal NR‐3: Acquire or assist in the acquisition of open space throughout the Town.
NR-3-A Partner with existing and future nature conservation groups on establishing permanent protection of
environmentally sensitive areas in the Town.
NR-3-B Use funding mechanisms such as the Purchase of Development Rights (PDR) or fee-simple land
purchase to acquire or preserve important natural areas or open space.
NR-3-C Encourage private property owners to establish conservation easements to protect environmentally
sensitive lands and open space. Encourage land owners to donate to the Town or other entities, such as a
land trust, environmentally important lands.
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 20
Goal NR‐4: Support private and intermunicipal efforts to protect wildlife and open space.
NR-4-A Promote incentives such as the Wildlife Habitat Incentives Program (WHIP), to encourage development
or improvement of fish and wildlife habitat. [Note: The USDA Natural Resource Conservation Service
administers WHIP and provides technical and financial assistance to landowners for the development of
upland, wetland, aquatic, and other types of wildlife habitat].
NR-4-B Support and collaborate on intermunicipal/regional efforts to develop protection plans for contiguous
expansive areas of natural resources that extend beyond municipal boundaries. Such areas might
include wildlife habitat, biological corridors, Cayuga Lake and other lakes and streams, wetlands, mature
forests, and other important mixed ecosystems (e.g., the Emerald Necklace effort led by the Finger Lakes
Land Trust).
Goal NR‐5: Support and actively engage in efforts to control the threat of invasive species.
NR-5-A Manually remove invasive species and where necessary allow the judicous use of herbicides and
pesticides on Town-owned land following Integrated Pest Management (IPM) Program standards and
tree harvesting, as needed. Develop management plans for invasive species on Town-owned lands.
Monitor trends in invasive plants growing along Town roadways and on Town-owned property.
Proactively plan for the consequences of a Town-wide invasive insect infestation and the resulting
damage to trees and forests
NR-5-B Encourage use of native diverse landscaping which includes a variety of plant species.
NR-5-C Educate residents (through the Town newsletter, informational displays at Town facilities, brochures,
etc.) about invasive species found in the Town or those likely to spread into the Town. Include how to
identify these species, what can be done to prevent their spread, and what should be done if they are
found. Include hands-on removal programs as appropriate.
Goal NR‐6: Protect water resources and seek to improve water quality.
NR-6-A Incorporate low impact development, light imprint development, and green infrastructure standards to
reduce the amount of impervious surfaces and offsite stormwater runoff.
NR-6-B Continue to support water quality testing and evaluation of major streams and Cayuga Lake to ensure
protection of our area’s water bodies.
NR-6-C Monitor regulations, policies, and practices to ensure the health of Cayuga Lake and its value as a
natural resource.
NR-6-D Maintain Cayuga Lake as a natural area capable of supporting a diverse and healthy ecosystem and as a
source of potable water.
NR-6-E Acknowledge the “impaired water quality” designation and listing of the southern end of Cayuga Lake
by the NYS Department of Environmental Conservation, and strive to improve water quality through
policy making.
NR-6-F Oppose using the waste water treatment plants to receive and handle large volumes of industrial or other
hazardous waste products.
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 21
NR-6-G Continue to help support and participate in organizations like the Cayuga Lake Watershed
Intermunicipal Organization and the Stormwater Coalition of Tompkins County to share resources;
work cooperatively with other municipalities to protect Cayuga Lake.
NR-6-H Establish regulatory mechanisms to protect wetlands; place particular attention on those wetlands that
are not currently addressed by State or Federal wetland protection laws.
NR-6-I Reevaluate methods and policies related to the maintenance of roadside ditches, including decisions
related to the closing/piping of ditches. [Note: Ditches are the dominant conveyor of stormwater and
their role in water quality and stormwater runoff is a critical consideration.] Educate members of the
public on the need to take responsibility for the care and maintenance of ditches on their property.
See also: RE-1-C (Cayuga Lake access), MS-4-A (stormwater management plan, stormwater-related laws)
Goal NR‐7: Preserve scenic resources that contribute to the Town’s unique character.
NR-7-A Finalize the Scenic Resource Inventory and Analysis Report which identifies, catalogues, and provides
analyses of the Town’s significant scenic areas.
NR-7-B Pursue protection of critical scenic resources by purchasing lands or acquiring conservation easements.
NR-7-C Adopt development standards intended to protect scenic resources.
NR-7-D Promote the appreciation of scenic resources through education by developing scenic overlooks and
educational signage in parks, neighborhoods, and public spaces. Construct overlooks and signage in
such a way that they are an enhancement and amenity to neighborhoods and other locations.
See also: LU-4-I (neighborhood branding)
Goal NR‐8: Protect existing air resources and maintain the air quality for the health and safety of Town
residents.
NR-8-A Consider enacting regulations that address and reduce air quality impacts from outdoor wood burning.
Such regulations might include: building permits for installation of outdoor wood boilers; setbacks from
neighboring properties; prohibited use in residential zones; and mandated seasonal-only use.
NR-8-B Enact regulation to limit the cumulative air quality impacts from industrial, diesel, or other similar
operations.
NR-8-C Explore adopting a motor vehicle idling law.
Goal NR‐9: Protect neighborhoods from noise disturbances and pollution including the cumulative impacts
of noise.
NR-9-A Prevent noise pollution through ongoing enforcement of community noise regulations.
NR-9-B Establish performance and design standards to address and reduce effects of noise pollution.
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 22
2.4 Energy and climate protection
The Town of Ithaca is committed to protecting and
enhancing its economic, environmental and
community resources, to benefit future generations
while at the same time addressing the needs of today.
The Town Board has endorsed sustainability and
climate protection as overarching principles to guide
long-term decision-making; elements of these
principles are infused throughout this Comprehensive
Plan.
The guiding principles for the Town’s sustainability
efforts are as follows:
The Town leads by example through integrating
energy efficiency, sustainability, and climate
protection into its daily operations.
The Town enacts and implements policies and
regulations that integrate sustainability and
climate protection into building and construction
practices and land use planning.
The Town engages in partnerships that strengthen
sustainability efforts internally and community-
wide.
The Town provides education and outreach to its
constituents to promote sustainable practices,
energy efficiency, and conservation, and to
encourage public participation.
The transition to a more sustainable future for the Town of Ithaca goes beyond the work of government. Residents,
business owners, and organizations each have a part to play in creating the community we aspire to live in. Though
the Town government cannot do it alone, it will provide leadership to the community as we move forward. The long-
term goals articulated here support the guiding principles and provide a framework to advise future decision-making
and policy development. The actions that accompany these goals are specific activities to be implemented to achieve
the long-term goals.
Goals and recommendations
Goal EC‐1: Incorporate sustainability and climate protection into long‐term planning.
EC-1-A Institutionalize sustainability in Town operations. Consider continuing a sustainability position and
creating an internal sustainability committee. Distribute sustainability-related tasks to existing staff as
necessary.
EC-1-B Conduct greenhouse gas (GHG) inventories at regular intervals to assess emissions from government
operations and from the community at large. Streamline and facilitate data collection.
Residential wind turbine, Town of Ulysses
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 23
EC-1-C Implement the Government Energy Action Plan 2011 to achieve a 30% reduction in GHG emissions
from government operations by 2020. Update the Energy Action Plan (EAP) on a regular basis and
consider incorporating long-term actions in future Plans to meet the existing goal of reducing
government GHG emissions 80% by 2050.
EC-1-D Set short- and long-term goals for community-wide GHG emissions reductions. Develop and implement
a Community EAP to meet reduction goals, and update Plan on a regular basis. Maintain a citizen
committee to advise on the implementation and update of the community EAP and other sustainability-
related issues.
EC-1-E Maintain membership in ICLEI-Local Governments for Sustainability for continued access to climate
action planning tools, technical assistance, training, and networking.
See also: LU-4 (mixed use/traditional neighborhood development), LU-6 (best planning practice)
Goal EC‐2: Reduce energy consumption and GHG emissions in buildings and infrastructure.
EC-2-A Consider using policy instruments and regulations to reduce energy use in existing buildings. For
example, building owners could be mandated or encouraged to perform energy audits and energy
efficiency improvements, and to track energy usage.
EC-2-B Consider adopting a building code to require all new construction projects and major renovations to
incorporate green building techniques and achieve specific energy efficiency standards.
EC-2-C Partner with local organizations and businesses to create, promote and maintain incentives, financing
options, and education and outreach campaigns that support energy efficiency in new and existing
buildings. These products could be marketed to building owners, tenants, developers, builders, code
enforcement officers, and other populations.
EC-2-D Ensure municipal buildings and facilities act as a model of good energy efficient practices. Track energy
usage on a regular basis. Conduct energy audits and implement recommended upgrades. Adopt a green
building policy for all major renovations and new construction projects. Provide education for
employees about behavior change to reduce energy use.
EC-2-E When replacing lamps in municipal streetlights and traffic signals, investigate use of LED lamps or other
high-efficiency equipment. When specifying replacement technologies, take into account the full life
cycle costs, including energy and maintenance costs. Also take into account the spectrum of light
produced, and its effect on visibility and aesthetics and the health of humans and wildlife. Encourage
NYSEG to improve the efficiency of the streetlights it controls.
Goal EC‐3: Reduce energy consumption and GHG emissions related to the treatment and distribution of
water and wastewater.
EC-3-A Conduct comprehensive energy audits of municipal water and wastewater treatment facilities and
infrastructure, and implement recommended upgrades. When replacing equipment, use the most energy
efficient equipment that is economically viable when taking into account full life cycle costs. Explore
other changes to the water supply system in order to improve overall efficiency.
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 24
EC-3-B Work with Southern Cayuga Lake Intermunicipal Water Commission (also known as Bolton Point) to
establish a water rate structure that incentivizes consumers to reduce usage.
EC-3-C Develop and implement an education and outreach program to encourage water conservation and
efficiency community-wide. Consider using policy instruments and regulations as well.
Goal EC‐4: Reduce energy consumption and GHG emissions in the transportation sector.
EC-4-A Partner with local organizations and businesses to support programs that educate residents, businesses
and Town government employees about cleaner operating and more efficient vehicles and vehicle use.
EC-4-B Adopt a municipal green fleet policy that: includes a vehicle replacement plan that specifies vehicles that
are smaller, more energy efficient, and well-maintained; reduces vehicle miles traveled by Town
government vehicles through greater efficiency, planning, and cooperation; and reduces idling in
municipal vehicles.
See also: LU-4-A (pedestrian sheds), LU-4-B (mixed uses in new neighborhoods), TR-2-G (street design following
TND principles), TR-6-A (Complete Streets), TR-6-B (neighborhood design and automobile dependence), TR-7-B
(automobile dependency)
Goal EC‐5: Encourage and facilitate the production and use of renewable energy.
EC-5-A Adopt renewable energy goals for the community and for government operations, to guide decision-
making (e.g. meet a certain percentage of the Town government’s energy needs with renewable energy
sources by 2025).
EC-5-B Revise Town regulations to facilitate local renewable energy production and use (e.g. revise Town Code,
streamline the permit process, reduce permit fees).
EC-5-C Work with other municipalities, local utility companies, businesses and organizations to develop
financial incentives for the installation and use of renewable energy systems. Explore models for
community-owned renewables.
EC-5-D Partner with local organizations and businesses to support programs that provide resources and
information on renewable energy technologies, installation, and financing.
EC-5-E Generate renewable electricity on Town property. Consider integrating renewable technologies in all
new Town buildings and significant renovations; address this early on in the planning process. Consider
using power purchase agreements (PPAs) or lease agreements to make solar photovoltaic installations on
Town property more economically viable. Consider installing biomass systems when replacing boilers.
EC-5-F Consider the purchase of renewable energy credits (RECs) to offset a portion of GHG emissions related
to Town government electricity usage until Town-operated renewable systems can be installed.
Encourage residents and businesses to purchase RECs.
Goal EC‐6: Reduce GHG emissions related to waste generation and purchasing.
EC-6-A Adopt a waste reduction policy for municipal operations to strengthen existing practices, and consider
implementing a compost program in Town facilities.
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 25
EC-6-B Partner with local organizations and businesses (e.g. Tompkins County Solid Waste and Finger Lakes
ReUse) to support programs that encourage Town residents and businesses to reduce, reuse, recycle, and
compost.
EC-6-C Work in cooperation with other municipalities to eliminate duplicate recycling, reuse, and composting
services.
EC-6-D Adopt a sustainable purchasing policy for Town operations that calls for the procurement of products
and services that have a reduced negative impact on human health and the environment as compared
with their conventional counterparts, and are sourced from or provided by locally owned businesses
when possible and legally permitted. Encourage local businesses to consider similar policies.
See also: CS-4-A (waste management and curbside composting), CS-4-B (demolition material reuse and recycling),
CS-4-C (promote recycling and solid waste center)
Goal EC‐7: Build a resilient community by preparing for and adapting to the unavoidable impacts and costs
of climate change.
EC-7-A Work with the Tompkins County Planning Department and other municipalities in the County to
develop a county-wide climate change adaptation plan. Develop a climate change adaptation plan that
provides specificity under the County-wide framework to prepare for the impacts and costs of climate
change within the Town of Ithaca.
EC-7-B Adopt new or modify existing policies so that the anticipated effects of climate change are considered
when changes are made to Town infrastructure (e.g. increase the height of bridges over waterways and
of pipe diameters of culverts and other stormwater conveyance systems).
EC-7-C Require the planting of street shade trees in appropriate areas to counteract the urban heat island effect
of parking lots and roads.
See also: LU-2-C (landscaping standards), NR-2-D (tree preservation), AG-3-B (community gardens)
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 26
2.5 Agriculture
Agriculture in the Town of Ithaca is
very diverse. Agricultural enterprises
include dairy, vineyard and winery,
direct-marketed produce (via area
farmers markets, u-pick operations,
and roadside stands), field crops,
forest crops, landscaping and nursery
stock, Christmas trees, greenhouses,
horses, beef, chickens, fiber, corn-
maze sound gardens, and
community-supported agricultural
(CSA) operations. There are newly
developing farm operations, farms
20-50 years old, and several
multigenerational farms. Farming in
the Town is concentrated in the
western part of the Town along the
borders of Enfield and Ulysses, and
crosses these boundaries. Portions of South Hill are also actively farmed and Cornell University uses areas of East
Hill for agriculture and agricultural research.
Farmland, and the farmers who work it, make a major contribution to the well-being of all Town residents. In
addition to the direct contribution to the local economy through the production of local products and employment of
workers, local farmers also make significant indirect contributions to the local economy through the purchase of
equipment and supplies, and through the relatively low demands on costly public infrastructure. The rural character,
which is enjoyed by Town residents and is essential to the local tourist industry, is provided largely by local farmers
and State parks. Perhaps most importantly, farmers in the Town of Ithaca have established a tradition of stewardship
of the land and its resources.
Town farmers are committed to continuing farming and to keeping their land in agriculture. The Town needs to have
a proactive approach to keeping agriculture viable and needs to work with farmers on issues that impede their ability
to remain or become more profitable.
The Town of Ithaca Agricultural and Farmland Protection Plan outlines a vision for agriculture in the Town. The
vision statement from the Plan is also the basis for the goals and recommendations that are found below. The
Agricultural and Farmland Protection Plan vision statement declares that:
“The Town of Ithaca recognizes that agriculture is an integral part of the Town’s economy and environment, provides
locally grown food and other agricultural products, and enhances the quality of life for Town residents. The Town
proactively promotes a diversity of farm types; seeks the long-term preservation of the Town’s agricultural land
resources; supports the economic viability of the farming community and the profitability of each farm; values the
local public agricultural research and educational resources; and encourages the general public to understand and
support local agriculture.”
Farm in the West Hill area
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 27
Goals and recommendations
The Town of Ithaca Agricultural and Farmland Protection Plan contains a detailed list of recommendations under
each of the goals listed below. The following recommendations were selected from that expanded list. The first five
goals come directly from the overall Vision Statement for agriculture for the Town. The entire Agricultural and
Farmland Protection Plan is included in Appendix I.
Goal AG‐1: Ensure long‐term protection of agricultural land resources for agriculture, open space, and scenic
resources.
AG-1-A Continue implementation of the Town’s current agricultural conservation easement acquisition program
(PDR) for appropriate agricultural parcels that have been targeted in the Policies and Procedures Manual
for the Agricultural Land Preservation Program.
AG-1-B Consider enlarging setbacks for non-farm residential dwellings in the agricultural zone to provide spatial
and vegetative buffers between the houses and agricultural activities (such as crop production, animal
pasturage, and hunting).
AG-1-C Require vegetative buffers on non-agricultural land so that farm lands have maximum space and so that
trespassing and movement of pesticides to and from farmlands is prevented and dust control is
enhanced.
AG-1-D Support the Town of Ithaca’s Agricultural Committee.
See also: LU-1-A (infrastructure and development), LU-1-C (farmland encroachment and buffering)
Goal AG‐2: Retain and encourage a diversity of economically viable farm types.
AG-2-A Review and revise regulations pertaining to structures to accommodate farm operations (e.g., sprinkler
law, use of rough-cut timber, property maintenance law).
AG-2-B Encourage shared farm infrastructure development (storage and processing facilities, slaughter and
processing facilities, mobile market, locations for CSA dropoff and pickup, etc.).
Goal AG‐3: Promote the availability of locally grown foods and other agricultural products for all residents,
including limited‐income families.
AG-3-A Accommodate farm stands, year-round farm markets, greenhouses, value-added product operations,
home food production, u-picks, CSA, and agritourism sites.
AG-3-B Require or encourage community gardens in larger new housing developments; provide community
gardens, including raised beds, irrigation water, and other facilities to encourage participation of all
residents, on Town lands and elsewhere.
Goal AG‐4: Encourage public understanding and involvement.
AG-4-A Continue support for agricultural and gardening programs for youth (e.g., community gardens, and 4-H
Clubs).
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 28
AG-4-B Heighten public awareness through the use of the Town’s website, newsletter, and signage regarding
speeding and other traffic issues affecting farmers (e.g., animal and equipment movement).
AG-4-C Encourage household production of food (gardens, orchards, vines, and small food animals such as
rabbits and hens).
AG-4-D Notify applicants for building permits of their adjacency to or location within the Town’s agricultural
zone and the County’s agricultural districts, and provide them with a copy of the right-to-farm law.
Goal AG‐5: Promote wise land use and agricultural waste management.
AG-5-A Encourage ongoing relationships between farmers and resources such as Cornell Cooperative Extension
and Tompkins County Soil and Water Conservation District for farm management and sound farming
practices.
Goal AG‐6: Protect the environment and human and animal health from the negative impacts of large
concentrated animal‐feeding operations (CAFOs).
AG-6-A Lobby State and Federal legislatures to allow towns to regulate CAFOs through local laws and
ordinances.
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 29
2.6 Recreation (parks and trails)
Recreational opportunities are
important to the general health and
welfare of the community.
The Town of Ithaca park and trail
system consists of a wide variety of
types and sizes of facilities. These
facilities include many neighborhood
parks, one developed community
park, four nature preserves, three
multiuse trails, and several
walkways. The existing Town parks
provide a range of recreational
facilities including play structures,
ballfields, playfields, sledding hills,
picnic areas, nature trails, and even a
community garden in one
undeveloped Town park. The
multiuse trails and walkways provide off-street alternatives for joggers, bikers, and walkers, as well as commuting
paths to work, school or shopping.
The Ithaca area is also fortunate in having two large City parks, four State parks, Village parks, and the non-publicly
owned open areas of Cornell University, Ithaca College, and the Finger Lakes Land Trust, as well as numerous other
public and private recreational facilities within or near the Town of Ithaca. Both Buttermilk Falls State Park and
Robert H. Treman State Park are located within the Town of Ithaca.
The recreational needs of the community are considered a priority. The Town has started to develop a network of
parks and trails throughout the community; as the Town continues to grow, it must constantly reassess the
recreational opportunities available for residents now and in the future.
Goals and recommendations
The 1997 Park, Recreation and Open Space Plan outlined goals and objectives regarding the development and
maintenance of the Town’s recreational opportunities. Many of these goals and objectives (or recommendations) are
still relevant to the Town’s future park and trails system, and have been carried over here with additions.
Goal RE‐1: Provide an integrated system of parks, recreational facilities, and open space throughout the
Town, with linkages among trails, parks, nature preserves, stream corridors, and utility rights‐of‐way.
RE-1-A Prepare and adopt an updated Park, Recreation and Open Space Plan, using the 1997 Plan as the
foundation.
RE-1-B Continue to locate and develop a cost-effective and interconnected network of public parks and trails to
provide active and passive recreational opportunities for Town residents. Continue the Town’s support
for the Black Diamond Trail, Gateway Trail, and extension of the South Hill Recreation Way.
Coordinate park and trail development with the efforts of surrounding municipalities.
Eastern Heights Park
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 30
RE-1-C Encourage increased public access to the recreational resources of Cayuga Lake.
RE-1-D Consider future maintenance costs when planning the development of any new parks, trails, or
preserves.
RE-1-E Modify existing subdivision regulations to allow the required 10% reservation of park setasides to be
used in a variety of ways, including preserves, natural areas, or greenways in addition to the currently
allowed small pocket parks or cash contributions. Establish an option for payment in lieu of a park set-
aside, where legally allowed, including a formula for determining a fair payment amount to be held in
reserve for park, open space, and recreational purposes, including the acquisition of property.
RE-1-F Require new parks and common open space to be amassed into meaningful, quality spaces. Require
parks and common open space to be contiguous to the maximum extent practicable, and located where
they are visually and functionally part of the public realm.
Goal RE‐2: Provide recreational opportunities for all Town residents.
RE-2-A Provide recreational opportunities near residents’ homes and workplaces.
RE-2-B Provide recreational activities and programs for Town residents.
RE-2-C Maximize mutually beneficial intermunicipal cooperation and partnerships between the public and
private sectors to deliver high-quality recreational services for Town residents.
RE-2-D Aggressively pursue recreation-oriented grant opportunities.
See also: LU-3-E (private neighborhood improvement initiatives), RE-1-B (provision of parks and trails)
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 31
2.7 Historical resources
The Town of Ithaca has a rich
history with many cultural and
historic resources that contribute to
the life of the community and a sense
of place. The many old stately
buildings of the late 1800s and early
1900s, built in such architectural
styles as Gothic Revival, Federal,
Italian Renaissance and Greek
Revival, are community treasures
and provide visual reminders of our
past. These residences, schools, and
businesses were built during a period
when attention to the aesthetics and
architectural details strengthened the
community character—a trait often
missing in today’s typical
subdivisions and commercial
developments. Historical markers installed throughout the Town denote important landmarks, such as former Native
American settlements, early farmsteads, and water-powered mills that once flourished throughout the Ithaca area.
These connections to our past help us maintain our historical memory; they provide a link to our cultural heritage
and a better understanding of the people and events that shaped the Town’s development.
As the Town grows and changes, the tangible evidence of our history becomes more threatened. The impact of
traffic, utility, and infrastructure changes such as electrical wires, road materials and road widths, incompatible
architecture, fragmented land uses, and other issues need to be evaluated and addressed carefully. Protecting historic
and cultural resources through proactive planning efforts will ensure that the Town maintains and enhances its unique
sense of place for current and future generations.
Goals and recommendations
Goal HR‐1: Preserve, enhance, and promote the Town’s historical resources.
HR-1-A Develop a historic preservation program using the inventory conducted by the Historic Preservation
Planning Workshop at Cornell University and the recommendations outlined in their Final Report for the
Intensive Level Survey (2005).
HR-1-B Explore appropriate mechanisms or incentives to ensure that existing historic buildings, structures, and
resources in the Town are preserved and protected. Explore grant opportunities to assist local residents
in upgrading and improving historic structures that have come under disrepair.
HR-1-C Consider developing and designating a local historic overlay district to protect local historic structures
and sites.
Town Hall
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 32
HR-1-D Explore the benefits of participating as a Certified Local Government (CLG) under the program of the
NYS Office of Parks, Recreation, and Historic Preservation. [Note: To participate in the CLG program,
the Town is required to create and adopt a historic preservation ordinance designed to protect historic
structures].
HR-1-E Work with historic preservation
groups, such as Historic Ithaca,
to coordinate protection of
historic resources.
HR-1-F Ensure continued maintenance
of existing Town-owned
historical markers that are
located throughout the town.
HR-1-G Promote awareness of local
history, including Native
American and other early
settlements and industries.
See also: LU-4-I (neighborhood branding)
House in Forest Home neighborhood
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 33
2.8 Transportation
The Town of Ithaca adopted its
Transportation Plan in 2007 which grew
out of recommendations from the 1993
Comprehensive Plan and recognition of the
need for a close look at the Town’s
transportation system. A number of other
transportation studies have been completed
since the 1993 Plan, including the
Northeast Subarea Transportation Study
(NEST, 1999), Forest Home Traffic
Calming Plan (2007), Cornell University
transportation-focused Generic
Environmental Impact Statement (t-GEIS,
2008), and the Route 96 Corridor
Management Study (2009).
It has become clearer than ever that
consideration of the interrelationships
among transportation, land use, housing, and energy consumption are critical to finding the best balance of
sustainable growth and development in the Town. These issues also have to be examined on a regional scale and in
cooperation with other municipalities in the area. A good example is the amount of commuter traffic; approximately
14,000 in-commuters originate from outside of Tompkins County and travel through the Town and City of Ithaca on
a regular basis for work. Important in these efforts is the provision of choices to residents, commuters, and visitors.
Per the mission statement of the Town’s Transportation Plan, the Town is committed to fostering a transportation
system that enhances the quality of life in the Town. The Town, in collaboration with other municipalities and
agencies, can start developing a multimodal transportation system that reduces the dependency on single occupancy
motor vehicles (SOV) through carpooling, ride sharing, and perhaps park-and-ride lots, as well as making it easier for
residents to choose walking, biking, and transit for their routine transportation. Walking, biking, and transit need to
be planned as complete networks so that people see them as viable transportation options for getting to routine
destinations, not just as recreation.
Long-term planning needs to shape development into patterns that make transporting people over large distances less
necessary. Smart Growth zoning will reduce the amount of future sprawl development in our community and help
organize our neighborhoods in a way that makes public transportation feasible. In addition, the Town must
encourage development where it is needed, based upon proximity to employment centers, services and existing
infrastructure—not just where it is inexpensive to build. Minimizing the need for automobile-based transportation is
one of the most sustainable ways to solve our transportation problems. Segmentation of our community, where
home, school, work, and recreation are separated, leads to increased car dependency. Low density housing is difficult
to service with public transportation. Mixed use communities increase the potential for use of all alternatives to SOV
trips.
Changes to land use regulations and the effects of their eventual implementation can take many years. In the
meantime, the Town seeks to establish and implement policies and programs that will facilitate the provision of
alternatives to automobile transportation. These policies, including bicycle and pedestrian facilities in road projects,
facilitating transit access, and promoting alternatives to SOV use, can be developed in the near future and
implemented concurrently as part of road improvements, site development, and future planning studies.
Tompkins Consolidated Area Transit (TCAT) bus, Tower Road
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 34
Goals and recommendations
Goal TR‐1: Develop and maintain a multimodal transportation system that provides for the effective
movement of people and goods.
TR-1-A Develop a transportation system that serves the mobility interests of the Town’s residents and businesses,
while recognizing the interests of through traffic.
TR-1-B Use the Bicycle and Pedestrian Corridor Maps in Volume II - The Appendices of the 2007
Transportation Plan to guide the development of bicycle and pedestrian facilities in the Town.
TR-1-C Assume the costs of construction and maintenance of bicycle and pedestrian facilities that serve a
broader population beyond the adjacent neighborhoods.
TR-1-D Work with other entities to improve the safety, aesthetics, and convenience of walking and bicycle
connections in priority locations in the Town.
TR-1-E Continue to expand and improve the multiuse trail network in the Town and work with Ithaca-Tompkins
County Transportation Council (ITCTC), Tompkins County, and other entities to expand the County-
wide trail network.
TR-1-F Work with TCAT, ITCTC, and major employers, to develop a park-and-ride system.
TR-1-G Consider increasing funding to TCAT to ensure adequate levels of transit service in the Town. Work
with TCAT to improve transit service frequency to underserved areas of the Town and rural areas of the
County.
TR-1-H Continue to provide funding for Gadabout to ensure continued service for senior citizens and the
disabled in the Town.
TR-1-I Encourage use of carpool, vanpool, and car share from the public and private sectors.
TR-1-J Devise traffic demand management strategies to reduce peak hour demand on roadway capacity. Work
with employers to provide incentives to reduce peak hour single occupancy vehicle use.
See also: RE-1-B (park and trail system)
Goal TR‐2: Develop and maintain a transportation system that promotes livable, healthy, and attractive
neighborhoods.
TR-2-A Control traffic speed through road design standards, traffic calming, and reduction of road widths (street
diets). Incorporate low-speed designs along residential and neighborhood streets when they are
reconstructed.
TR-2-B Work to beautify streetscapes, restore roadways to a human scale, and improve the character and
livability of the neighborhoods through which they pass when modifying and rebuilding roads in
residential areas.
TR-2-C Consider the effects of traffic volume on the quality of life in new and existing neighborhoods.
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 35
TR-2-D Use a context sensitive approach for road planning and design. Implement design standards that
consider the purpose of a road, adjacent built and natural environment, and desired character, to ensure
roads are in harmony with their setting. Work with New York State and Tompkins County to apply
context sensitive design solutions when designing roadways.
TR-2-E Work with TCAT to minimize disruptions caused by buses in residential neighborhoods, while
nevertheless providing adequate transit service to the neighborhood.
TR-2-F Address truck traffic patterns that route through residential areas; to do this, work with Tompkins
County, New York State, the City of Ithaca, ITCTC, Cornell, local businesses and other regional
stakeholders to minimize the impacts of truck traffic on residential neighborhoods.
TR-2-G Require roads in new development to follow principles of traditional neighborhood design, with a grid
of streets that provides a high level of connectivity rather than looping streets, permanent cul-de-sacs,
pods, and other elements that make interconnectivity difficult. Where appropriate, require alleys to
provide access to garages and loading areas, and a convenient location for utilities and trash collection.
TR-2-H Require mitigation plans for projects likely to generate significant truck and heavy vehicle traffic, or
require offsite worker parking and equipment staging areas.
Goal TR‐3: Strive to provide a safe transportation system and to prioritize safety and security in the
implementation of every transportation‐related goal.
TR-3-A Continue to evaluate intersections with poor sight distances; make improvements as necessary.
TR-3-B Regularly request crash information from the Department of Motor Vehicles to update the crash
database. Identify hazardous locations and take steps to mitigate problems, including notification to the
owner of the road, if not the Town.
TR-3-C Continue to petition the County and State for speed limit reductions in appropriate locations.
TR-3-D Adopt access management requirements to control access points to the Town's streets. Ensure access
management requirements are compatible with, or where legally permitted, stricter than County and
State standards.
See also: TR-2-A (road design speed and traffic calming), CS-2-B (traffic enforcement)
Goal TR‐4: Effectively maintain the transportation system.
TR-4-A Strive to ensure that sufficient capital resources are available to maintain the transportation system.
TR-4-B Preserve current rights-of-way for the transportation system. Identify and pursue planned rights-of-way
needed to enhance connectivity.
TR-4-C Require developers and subdividers to dedicate rights-of-way and construct portions of proposed
collector roads and extensions that cross or touch their property.
TR-4-D Update the 2007 Transportation Plan periodically to reflect changes within the transportation system
and the consequent evolution of transportation-related problems, needs, and solutions.
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 36
TR-4-E Regularly update the Official Map. [Note: this map shows existing and planned roads, parks, and trails
in the Town.]
TR-4-F Continue to allow the Public Works Department the flexibility to set its own schedule of roadway
improvements, consistent with Highway Expenditure Agreement with the Town Board, practice
preventive maintenance wherever possible to save money over the long term, and operate in an
environmentally sensitive manner.
Goal TR‐5: Coordinate with other local and regional organizations to promote a regionally coordinated
transportation system.
TR-5-A Continue to explore opportunities for increased intermunicipal sharing of facilities, equipment, labor,
knowledge, and expertise.
TR-5-B Support the establishment of community and regional pedestrian and bicycle facilities throughout the
Town and County.
TR-5-C Continue the Town’s strong level of participation in the ITCTC.
TR-5-D Continue to support the findings of Cornell University’s t-GEIS and Transportation Impact Mitigation
Strategies where appropriate. Continue to work closely with Cornell, ITCTC, TCAT, and other entities
in supporting the Cornell/Community Transportation Investment Initiative Program.
Goal TR‐6: Promote future development patterns that reduce the need for and use of automobiles and
which encourage the use of alternative modes of transportation.
TR-6-A Design streets in accordance with Complete Streets principles – built and maintained in a way that
accommodates not only motor vehicles, but also pedestrians of all ages, bicyclists, and public
transportation vehicles.
TR-6-B Design neighborhoods to reduce automobile dependence and to encourage modal shifts to walking,
cycling, and public transportation.
TR-6-C Examine the existing sidewalk and trail system and pursue opportunities to make connections within the
system. Retrofit existing streets with sidewalks and/or bicycle lanes where practical. Explore the
establishment of new multi-use pathways independent of the roadway network that would allow
pedestrian and bicycle mobility away from motor vehicle traffic.
TR-6-D Consider transportation impacts when making land use decisions, and consider land use impacts in
terms of land use patterns, densities, and designated uses when making transportation decisions.
TR-6-E Evaluate parking area requirements to reduce development of excessive pavement and to encourage
multiple uses of paved areas.
TR-6-F Continue to work with TCAT and developers to ensure that new development in the Town is served by
transit where possible; key issues are adequacy of access for buses in site plans, provision of bus stops
and shelters, and route extensions or service enhancements where feasible.
See also: LU-3-A (development scale). LU-4-A (pedestrian sheds)
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 37
Goal TR‐7: Protect the environment, including the significant natural, agricultural, scenic, and historic
resources of the Town, when planning any changes to the transportation system.
TR-7-A Consider the environmental consequences of transportation decisions; minimize negative impacts on the
natural environment whenever reasonable and to the greatest possible degree.
TR-7-B Work to reduce the negative effects of overdependence on motor vehicles, including detriments to open
space and air quality, by reducing the total number of vehicle miles driven, the number of individual
trips, and the average distance and duration of trips.
TR-7-C Assess the need for wildlife crossings.
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 38
2.9 Municipal services and infrastructure
Municipal services and infrastructure
are a vital but frequently less noticed
part of the day-to-day life of the
Town. Having high quality
municipal services and reliable
infrastructure, such as water, sewer,
drainage systems, and roads, are
essential to our community’s quality
of life and sense of safety. Meeting
expectations for existing services and
infrastructure is an ongoing
challenge that requires constant
attention and continued
coordination with local partners.
Costs for improving, expanding, and
maintaining these services and
infrastructure, as well as the facilities
used to plan and carry out these
functions, are ever increasing and
necessitate the implementation of strategies to help control costs. Rising energy costs alone are likely to strain limited
resources and require vigilant attention to incorporating sustainable approaches in the delivery of services and
operation of infrastructure and facilities. This includes concerted efforts to promote, educate, and incentivize the
conservation and wise use of resources by utility and service users.
The expansion of services and infrastructure to meet the needs of our growing community requires careful
consideration. Expanding infrastructure to serve new areas has important fiscal implications and can have profound
effects on the community character. Town land use policies can play a positive role in reducing the need to expand
services and infrastructure. A policy that channels future development into areas with existing services and restricts
new service to planned growth areas can avoid the ill effects of development in which demand is spread out to less
dense areas, creating excessive costs that are ultimately shouldered by all service customers. The availability of
reliable and high-quality services combined with rising energy and material costs are also motivating factors likely to
direct and encourage development to concentrate in designated places.
Meeting the expectations for municipal services requires both short- and long-term planning. Capital planning and
strategic asset management approaches are effective tools to help set goals and to ensure that scarce financial
resources are properly allocated, and that consideration of the community expectations for services are evaluated in
the decision-making process.
The Town is committed to continuing to provide high-quality and reliable services in a sustainable manner for the
safety, comfort, and enjoyment of its residents, business owners, institutions, and visitors.
Town employees providing leaf collection service
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 39
Goals and recommendations
Goal MS‐1: Provide quality and reliable infrastructure and services in a cost‐effective, sustainable,
responsible, and efficient manner – meeting current needs and anticipating needs of the future.
MS-1-A Continually update the five-year capital improvements plan (CIP) for financing the maintenance, repair,
and rehabilitation of existing infrastructure and municipal facilities, as well as the construction of new
infrastructure. [Note: The CIP is an important tool for planning, prioritizing and budgeting of capital
needs for such things as buildings, utility systems, roadways, and heavy equipment.]
MS-1-B Develop and adopt a long-range water and sewer master plan, consistent with the land use goals of the
Comprehensive Plan, for the operation, maintenance, and extension of water distribution and
wastewater collection facilities. The plan will document existing service conditions and identify short-
and long-term water and wastewater servicing strategies and associated capital projects to serve the
developed areas of the Town.
MS-1-C Investigate additional opportunities for shared municipal services with other Tompkins County
municipalities where not precluded by other existing agreements. Where desirable, consolidate
municipal services and/or cooperate with other government agencies to limit the duplication of services
and the costs of providing such services.
MS-1-D Continue to seek and promote additional public and private funding sources for infrastructure
repair/maintenance/development to offset the cost of improvements and construction. Examples might
include bonding for long-term project funding needs and Federal, State, or private grant opportunities.
MS-1-E Continue to work cooperatively on joint projects with the City of Ithaca and Town of Dryden
concerning the Ithaca Area Wastewater Treatment Facility, Cayuga Heights concerning the Cayuga
Heights Waste Water Treatment facility and with the four other members of the Southern Cayuga Lake
Intermuncipal Water Commission on the Bolton Point Water System.
See also: LU-1-A (infrastructure and development).
Goal MS‐2: Maintain, assess, and repair/replace/retrofit/rehabilitate existing public infrastructure, facilities,
equipment, and services.
MS-2-A Monitor and evaluate the water distribution system; assess and evaluate complaints by customers and
annual system maintenance measurements.
MS-2-B Monitor the wastewater collection system by conducting periodic flow measurements within the sewer
system to determine adequate capacities and quantities.
MS-2-C Continue the Town’s proactive maintenance of Town roads, sidewalks, and trails through repair, snow
removal, cleanup, and other appropriate activities, to the service levels identified by the Town Board.
MS-2-D Perform annual pavement condition surveys of Town roads and determine necessary preventive and
corrective maintenance measures to ensure safety and maximize pavement life.
See also: TR-2-H (mitigation plans for construction-related truck/equipment traffic)
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 40
Goal MS‐3: Based on sustainable development principals that are consistent with the Comprehensive Plan,
limit expansion of public infrastructure and services.
MS-3-A Limit extension of infrastructure into areas not designated for intensive development except when
required for public health and safety. Ensure that extensions are consistent with the needs expressed in
the Comprehensive Plan, sustainable development principals, and adopted Town policies or industry
standards.
See also: TR-6-D (transportation impacts in land use decisions)
Goal MS‐4: Ensure the capability of public and private stormwater management infrastructure and facilities
to provide reasonable protection to property and natural systems from flooding and to minimize degradation
to water quality by reducing contaminants in stormwater runoff.
MS-4-A Implement the Town’s Stormwater Management Plan in compliance with New York State Department
of Environmental Conservation (NYSDEC) Phase II Stormwater Regulations. Enforce, administer, and
update as necessary the Town’s Stormwater Management and Erosion and Sediment Control Law.
MS-4-B Maintain and update a comprehensive inventory of public and private stormwater management facilities
and infrastructure; create a program for routine inspections and maintenance. Develop a strategy to
assess infrastructure needs, and to prioritize solutions for the repair, upgrade, and improvement of the
Town’s stormwater infrastructure.
MS-4-C Ensure that landowners protect and maintain privately held stormwater infrastructure and facilities to
established standards. Provide education and outreach programs to inform businesses, homeowner
associations, and residents about the existence, purpose, and maintenance requirements of their
stormwater infrastructure and facilities and the full range of green stormwater management options
available, taking into consideration site specific conditions.
MS-4-D Provide appropriate staffing to enforce provisions of the Stormwater Management and Erosion and
Sedimentation Control Law to ensure compliance with Federal, State and locally adopted programs and
regulations.
MS-4-E Complete a Town-wide urban watershed model for use in assessing existing drainage issues and potential
impacts from proposed new development on the stormwater collection and treatment system.
MS-4-F Establish Town policy that prescribes when and under what circumstances the ownership for stormwater
facilities and infrastructure will become the Town’s responsibility; keep in mind the practicality of long-
term maintenance and operation for certain types of residential developments.
MS-4-G Pursue a permanent and equitable funding mechanism for the administration of the Town’s stormwater
management program. Study options such as inspection and permit fees, forming stormwater
management districts, creating stormwater utilities, etc.
See also: NR-6-A (low impact development)
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 41
2.10 Community services
The community facilities and
services available to Town residents
are important factors in maintaining
and enhancing a high quality of life
in the Town of Ithaca. As
development occurs, the strain on
existing schools, libraries, parks,
emergency services, and local
government functions increases;
these facilities and services often
need to be expanded for new
residents and businesses.
The Town of Ithaca requires and
depends on a variety of public, volunteer, and private services for fire protection, public safety, and police services.
The Town also relies on private services for its public health and educational facilities. It is important to encourage
and maintain high- quality fire protection, public safety, and police services and public health facilities that provide
excellent healthcare options for Town residents.
Quality schools and educational institutions that provide students of all ages with the skills necessary to be successful
and productive are also a critical part of a thriving community. The Town is fortunate to be home to a university, a
college, and a large public school system and a variety of alternative education options and is committed to engaging
students in civic life. Work study, service learning and internship opportunities are consistently offered to students
with staff, board, and committee members providing training and oversight. Secondary school students have
benefited from educational materials developed with the Town to augment their study of government. The Town
welcomes and encourages student engagement in its operations and at public meetings
The Town of Ithaca is committed to assuring that the required public safety, police, and fire services and facilities are
available now and in the future to meet the needs of existing and future Town residents. The Town is also committed
to supporting existing and future public health facilities, schools, and other educational institutions.
Goals and recommendations
Goal CS‐1: Maintain and strive to improve the Town government’s ability to serve its citizens.
CS-1-A Encourage inter- and intramunicipal cooperation and communication to provide high-quality services at
reasonable costs. Continue joint development of mutually beneficial services and facilities and
cooperation with shared equipment with neighboring municipalities and the county.
CS-1-B Ensure that Town residents are well informed in Town matters through continued distribution of the
Town newsletter and regular updates on the Town website.
CS-1-C Ensure that Town officials, boards, committees, and staff are well versed in the goals of the
Comprehensive Plan, and support professional and educational development for all officials and staff to
serve the community well.
Rescue Engine 202, Village of Cayuga Heights (Village FD web site)
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 42
CS-1-D Continue to support public libraries. Explore opportunities for local residents to use libraries at local
educational institutions.
Goal CS‐2: Ensure that fire protection, public safety, and police services in the Town of Ithaca are adequate.
CS-2-A Explore options for an increased presence of public safety officials in the Town.
CS-2-B Partner with existing public safety officials to ensure enforcement of vehicle safety and traffic laws in the
Town.
CS-2-C Explore ways to reduce fire protection costs to residents, such as continuing negotiations for current fire
contracts, establishing a Town-sponsored fire department, and investigating shared services with other
non-partnered municipalities.
CS-2-D Update the Town’s Zoning Code to reflect the most recent fire code regulation changes.
Goal CS‐3: Integrate public school facilities planning with Town land use planning.
CS-3-A Work with the Ithaca City School District so that land can be reserved for schools when planning future
development and so that school facilities will be in harmony with the Town’s vision of future land use.
Goal CS‐4: Minimize the impact of solid waste on Ithaca’s residents, businesses, and the natural
environment.
CS-4-A Continue coordination with the Tompkins County Solid Waste Management Division for the removal
and management of the Town’s solid waste. Implement a townwide program to test residential curbside
composting in partnership with the Tompkins County Solid Waste Management Division.
CS-4-B Explore the option of a construction and demolition ordinance that requires the diversion from landfills
of a proportion of all waste associated with construction, demolition, and renovation projects (e.g.,
shingles, ceramic tiles, sheetrock, toilets/bathtubs/sinks, treated wood, wallboard) either through
recycling or reuse.
CS-4-C Promote use of the newly renovated Recycling and Solid Waste Center to help Tompkins County reach
its goal of diverting 75% of waste from landfills by 2016 and 80% by 2030.
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 43
2.11 Economic development
Economic development is a means of enhancing the
well-being of the community as a whole. It includes
the creation and retention of jobs and support for
workplace practices that promote broad-based
economic prosperity with a focus on alleviating local
poverty.
Local tax policy has minimal effect on the decision by
corporations to locate or remain in a community. The
quality of life, cultural and recreational opportunities,
educated population, and natural attractiveness of the
Ithaca area have consistently been cited as
inducements to live here.
The Town welcomes the creation and growth of
sustainable, locally focused businesses—ones that use
local resources, employ local people, and create
products and services to benefit the local market and
beyond. The Town welcomes businesses that
complement our community character, including
those that take advantage of our farms to create value-
added food products, our natural areas and parks to
bolster tourism, and the high level of education in our
local population to enhance technology and the green
economy.
The Town values its entire labor force and the
employers who respect the right of workers to
organize and bargain collectively.
The Town recognizes the important contributions of our institutional and educational service employers, including
research spinoff companies. The Town acknowledges that our local economic future will be even stronger if it is
supported by a solid base of smaller companies and businesses that are locally owned and operated and which
employ local construction workers and employees. Local businesses create a multiplier effect, in that the profits
derived and the wages earned are likely to be invested locally. And businesses that are committed to the local
economy have a greater stake and interest in the long-term viability of our community. The Town wants to focus on
sustainable businesses that are committed to being part of the community over the long term and not short-term or
extractive industries that create infrastructure demand and lingering costs to the community far beyond the life of the
business.
Maintaining and encouraging job growth is also important to the Town. Our community is fortunate to have a
relatively stable employment base with many well-paying jobs. Yet, we still have many who are underemployed or
who must work more than one job. By continuing to support the creation of quality and diverse job opportunities—
ones that that provide benefits, prospects for advancement, and wages at or above a living wage—the Town can help
to provide employment opportunities for residents across all skill levels and socioeconomic groups.
South Hill Business Campus
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 44
Goals and recommendations
Goal ED‐1: Promote a stable, sustainable, and diverse local economy.
ED-1-A Encourage the continued vitality of existing employers, full employment, wage levels that keep families
out of poverty, and the incorporation of marginalized citizens into the economy.
ED-1-B Foster a positive entrepreneurial environment for business start-up and expansion.
ED-1-C Consider ways to streamline development review, permit processing, and code enforcement within
shorter timeframes; clarify and simplify regulations; eliminate redundant layers of control; and ensure
predictability (also discussed in the Land Use Section, Goal 6).
ED-1-D Support workers in attaining fair labor practices.
ED-1-E Support the mission of the Town’s major public and non-profit institutions which: contribute to a
diversified economy; bring living wage jobs, new activity and capital into the economy; develop and
promote advanced technology; and provide substantial public benefits and needed services to area
residents.
ED-1-F Support artists, arts organizations, and institutions because of: their potential contributions to a healthy
business climate; their role in creating a cultural environment that attracts other living wage employers,
as well as tourists, to the region; and the substantial benefits they provide to the region’s quality of life.
ED-1-G The Town should lead by example by considering the local economic impact of layoffs, attrition, wage
levels, and level of benefits and by giving priority in purchasing and contracting when legal and
practicable to locally based business with positive employment practices.
ED-1-H Work to increase communication among government agencies, businesses, organized labor, institutions,
and other entities that might provide economic opportunities. The aim is to enhance the common
understanding of issues related to employment growth, business competitiveness, public policy goals and
program implementation. Promote partnerships between government and business.
ED-1-I Support agricultural economic development, including a strong agritourism industry, based on the
findings of the Town’s Agricultural and Farmland Protection Plan.
ED-1-J Support sustainable businesses rather than short-term, high-impact extractive industries.
Goal ED‐2: Establish a cohesive and sustainable economic development policy for the Town of Ithaca.
ED-2-A Articulate a socially equitable long-term economic development strategy that builds on local competitive
advantages and promotes environmental stewardship and economic justice.
ED-2-B Participate in a larger, regionally coordinated economic development planning strategy, which includes
businesses, organized labor, institutions, Town officials, officials from neighboring communities, and
area residents.
Town of Ithaca 2014 Comprehensive Plan 45
ED-2-C Engage Tompkins County Area Development (TCAD) in cooperative efforts to develop viable economic
incentives and initiatives tailored to the Town’s unique conditions; adapt TCAD’s major economic goals
to fit the Town’s needs.
ED-2-D Work to reduce poverty by supporting economic development efforts that provide worker training and
recruitment of businesses that offer employees the opportunity to be elevated.
ED-2-E Promote regional industry clusters that will draw on local advantages to access local and wider markets.
ED-2-F Evaluate publicly supported economic development programs and incentives on their long-term benefits
and impacts, including long-term employment at living wages. Give weight towards projects that
practice outstanding site and architectural design, promote redevelopment of brownfields and greyfields,
and do not exacerbate urban sprawl.
ED-2-G Ensure equitable public economic development investments, which prioritize infrastructure and
supportive services that promote the vitality of all local businesses or an industry sector, rather than
individual businesses.
ED-2-H Support tax policies that encourage business development and growth based on the area’s workforce,
economic vitality, natural beauty, cultural attractions, and generally high quality of life, rather than tax
breaks that shift funds from the general public to specific profit-making entities.
ED-2-I Provide funding to nonprofit agencies contracting with the Town that encourages those agencies to
employ staff at or above the living wage.
ED-2-J Actively pursue increased financial support from prominent local tax-exempt institutions to substantially
offset existing and future costs of infrastructure and beneficial services.