HomeMy WebLinkAboutEnvironmental Review Committee February 13, 1996MEMORANDUM
TO: Candace Cornell, Chairperson and Members of the Town of Ithaca
Planning Board
FROM: Eva Hoffmann, for the Members of the Town of Ithaca Environmental
Review Committee (ERC)
DATE: February 14, 1996
RE: Project No. 9601187, Ithaco Renovations at Axiohm Building
950 Danby Road
The ERC members appreciate the opportunity to review this development proposal
for any possible environmental concerns. Based on the material available to the ERC
at the February 13, 1996 meeting, we have the following comments:
This project involves only interior renovations to an existing building and we see no
negative or positive effects on the environment as a result of this project.
MEMORANDUM
TO: Candace Cornell, Chairperson and Members of the Town of Ithaca
Planning Board
FROM: Eva Hoffmann, for the Members of the Town of Ithaca Environmental
Review Committee (ERC)
DATE: February 14, 1996
RE: Project No. 9601186, Cornell Library Storage Facility,
Palm Road (off Route 366)
The ERC members appreciate the opportunity to review this development proposal
for any possible environmental concerns. Based on the material available to the ERC
at the February 13, 1996 meeting, we have the following comments:
This is a proposal for the existing Library Annex, and although it applies only to the
first of the two anticipated expansions, it would be appropriate to discuss the
possible effects of the second expansion at this time.
The major concerns the ERC has with this proposal revolve around drainage and
erosion during and after construction. The location for the proposed addition lies in
a depression mainly to the east and somewhat to the north of the existing building.
It is surrounded to the north, east and south by large raised areas that appear to be
fill. There is concern that drainage to the building from the surrounding areas be
constructed and directed in such a way as to prevent moisture problems in the
building while at the same time, without creating problems from drainage, erosion
and excessive runoff into the existing and proposed ponds in the area as well as into
Cascadilla Creek.
The drawings, as presented to the ERC, show two different configurations for
parking north' of the Library Annex. Members of the ERC expressed concern with
regards to the amount of fill which will need to be moved as a result of constructing
the parking area and the possible new entrances from Palm Road. In addition, the
question of drainage for the parking lot and entrance drives, both during and after
construction, was raised.
The Town of Ithaca has recently seen plans for the former landfill area south and east
of the Library Annex. The ERC questions the possible soil disturbances and drainage
plans as a result of the proposed Library Annex project and how this project may
affect the plans already approved for the landfill site. The ERC would like to see an
overall plan for how drainage, erosion and runoff will be handled in a coordinated
way with these two projects.
ERC Comments
CU Library Annex Expansion
February 14, 1996
Other questions and concerns of the ERC with regards to this project are:
In view of the fact that so few people are expected to use the expanded
library facility, the ERC questions the need for 20 additional parking
spaces (as indicated on the Site Plan dated January 25, 1996). The
layout on page 4 of the 10/18/95 draft of the Site Design Criteria:
Library Annex Addition, indicates an even larger parking area.
2. The ERC questions the beginning and end of the "major through street"
as mentioned in the text and indicated on page 4 of the 10/18/95 Site
Design Criteria submitted by the applicant.
3. The ERC would like to see photos or similar materials to be able to
determine the visual impact of the building and its additions after
construction and landscaping, especially as they might be seen from the
Cascadilla Creek Recreation Way and from McGowan Woods.
I U CiLVv e u ce C(sVl h u.vL �-PA J-'— 6, d cUe4-, J uj
L -7-
1 gWyt l �[LCt.fctY� fr lY
LVA ! 1, D �`t'INL.t4 f l in [ 1 (J (4t. � ALe-G b.,j 6
e r °h J ti✓ zrncv� C'wL �e.r,`ew d-( Pro'ecis 1Jv, U01197 aa.d `1 6611 e6
( F k C nn e✓kJe r -f 4--P)t V e c,'c -e R.e old 1,du qIk" % 4-D rP rA ew 9�(u s -e
de(ju(O p cv.t,v4 Pro p)s-,ts -r&0 - 44,,,, po,(x," 6�e ei,v,' -o KAti,&"4 i cc;,K co res, Rat,,(
Ke �e a-(-(ai/cy [ce Cit 4o vLS attr kee ,,� &tq eG.
we 1`a.ve Keeo-k,meofS
ifc,-h&xs a -f ftxt'ok„, (3L41['t.11,� � 75-0
l
�/l4L
+Ne NLu rte��-F-,,✓e ar of,,Wve e--F(e67, J-ke ekv:r�-IXk Ela
P r e c'k �, °� 6 0 list w em Lc
r G p h07L 6rpt &,vx ex
E'x MA �� �t S 14 tvQ
L,g�� o C
Sec �t �( � �.� ���� �
1. -1
I
ci [� e
L � a 4.5� �`l�,. �/�I P� o .F�, /� �fi/u. h,`r. �
aed:
vu �ow wn`� t� +, u t1 (,Vk4t Ix
e 6 :9
14 All
wL Kn RA.iL� 74l"[ W1 11Q Q c(
tu`►�� d fes' tel,^ ?
a
34 THE AFFAIR ACT I • Scene 11 35
GAY
Nonsense, my dear chap. You young men don't know what a bad
summer is. Now 'g8'that was a bad summer. That was a summer
and a half, I can tell y6u, I was in Iceland that summer. I was just
getting into the swim of what some critics have been kind enough
to call my great work on the Sagas. Great work—ah, indeed. Mind
you, I've always disclaimed the word "great." I've always said, call
the work distinguished if you like, bu`t,it's not for me to approve of
the higher appellation. However, they insisted. Where was I?
(TO LEWIS)'
Don't tell me!
(Triumphantly)
Eliot! Lewis Eliot! Ha! You see! I've
night, my dear chap. And good-bye
spring. Good-bye till the spring/, ooc
(Assisted by MARTIN and,: FFING
you taped! Well, good -
)u all—good-bye till the
good-bye....
GAY totters out.)
WINSLOW �.+ WINSLOW
In Iceland. \\\ Let us hope that spr' g will be a little late this year.
GAY (He goes 0 t after GAY.)
Precisely. That's where I was, that bitter summer of 'g8. And do
you know what I found when I got there? Why, it was fiftee de- TOM
grees warmer in Rejkjavik than in our unfortunate Cambridge! t.
As soon as they are alone)
(To LEWIS) ewis, I've been wanting to say this all evening. I really do most
Do you mind telling me your name? humbly apologise for—
LEWIS r %(ARTHUR BROWN, the Senior Tutor, hurries in through an inner
I'm Lewis Eliot. per, which leads to the Master's Lodge. BROWN is sixty-three,
plu7n and a bit of a buffer, but shrewd and obstinate. He carries
GAY his gow
Have you any connection with the College?
Q!
LEWIS
I'm a former Fellow.
GAY
I congratulate you. Well, I must be o my way.
(He struggles up.)
I wonder if two of you young men would be kind enough to escor
me to a taxi. :++
(MARTIN and sKEFFINGTON take an arm each.)
Ah, thank you. Thank you indeed.
BROWN N
(Warmly, to L
My dear old friend!
LEWIS
Arthur!
BROWN
Getliffe told me you were here but the Master had the Vice -Chan-
e
""'e You
to dinner, and i was co-opted for coffee. Ah, but it's good to
you In this room again.
lie �Yl��c� ��s
ce
kt 2 G r�m-� vi d' �C (�. fb �e e
(�� s-� &L"r w�f 1 u �.� vU,� G1 Cie 1,'�CL`� a
I r h` �"WS Lowv�e cep �r mv�t '19�s� ew 61n eP�,`v�y 2
1 Ufa^�fiV tl � "-� �,,,/I � 0. 4A-&. &zp- d-,,,✓ tt
4/i tv
CL k -ere �e. C c w cu c� �e en J l� f )JZ
, ciK
_ qs
cG� Ihr/� CGt�c� �►L "� ��iW�h ( fDa�2 L% r�� 'o!`�/SCS
d..IA-. e4l),L�
e..19 -ie `Ib�L i h • a_t,�
,nom,
`un cC `�1 U V L,
D2- ��
32 THE AFFAIR ACT I • Scene Il 33
�M TIN
Thank you, thank you. Ah! Port. There's a drink and a half, if ever
Decembert • twentieth. there was one.
(He drinks.)
WINSLOW
Yes, well, I suppose I sh4ll have to assist, in the French sense, at that Capital.
ceremony. But I'm happy that this time I can't see even this (To LEWIS)
College being so imbecile as to -make a wrong choice. Francis Getliffe
Evill do it very well. Excuse me. Do you mind telling me ur name?
LEWIS
SKEFFINGTON I'm Lewis Eliot.
I seem to remember having heard Arthur Br n's name mentioned.
GAY
WINSLOW Indeed. Hav ou any connection with the ,College?
My dear Skeffington, Arthur Brown's name was mention last time.
Largely, I fear, by Arthur Brown. Is
' a former Fellow.
LEWIS GAY
Getliffe is generally agreed on, is he? I congratulate you. Let me persuade you, Sir, to have a glass of this
excellent wine.
WINSLOW
I've scarcely thought the matter worth conversation. T worthy (To the room at large)
Brown is patently anon -starter by the side of Fran ' Getliffe. I don know whether you realize it, but this is positively my last
appearan gbefore my annual hibernation. Yes, each year I hibernate
GAY for the worst\of the winter. Indeed I do. You won't see me in Col-
lege again till th spring. I am no longer as young as I used to be.
(Who has suddenly woken up) So I retire to my o n inglenook for the winter, and I listen to the
You've forgotten me. great gales roaring ove the Fens and I say to myself, "That's a gale
and a half. I'd rather be here I am than out at sea."
WINSLOW
My dear Gay, had no idea you were planning to stand for the -, TOM
Mastership %% It's damn nearly as bad in the summ these days.
d;+.
GAY
GAY The port. You've missed me out. Where is the y`lhat's that? What does he say?
Mastership? No, no.
Port?MARTIN
Ic,s
1 been a bad y
(The port is passed, and he fills his glass.) summer this year.