HomeMy WebLinkAboutPB Minutes 1966-06-14 Z
TOWN of ITHACA
PLANNING BOARD MINIJTES
JUNE 14 , 1966
A meeting of the Town of Ithaca Planning Board was held at the Town
Offices , 108 East Green Street , City of Ithaca at 7 . 30 P * Ma on Tuesday ,
June 14 , 1966 ,
Members of the Board present were . Chairman Desch , Elmer Phillips ,
John Vasse , James Lacy , Walter Wiggins , Walter Schwan , and Richard
Perry
Also present were . William Lower , Loraine Copeland , Robert Bruce and
Loran Mariono
The minutes of the April meeting were read and approved The minutes
of the May meeting were approved after the following correction : It
was added to the minutes that Leonard Liberman requested this Board to
take action to correct the lack of screening in front of the Cayuga
Heights plant and also -to take action to correct the unsightly nature
of the rock fill along Route 13
SAVEY SUB-DIVISION
• There was a request to approve three additional lots on the west side
of Coddington Road for building perraitso Mro Desch stated that he had
spoken to Mr4 Liguori , who stated that as far as the Health Department
is concerned , they are willing to review , on an individual basis , build»
ing permits for three additional houses and to authorize the Zoning
Officer to issue building permits for three lots subject to Health
Department approval of each individual loco Mr � William Bd Kerr , Town
Supervisor , had concurred with this Upon motion by Mro Phillips ,
seconded by Mrl> Vasse , and carried by unanimous vote , it was moved that
the Zoning Officer be authorized to issue building permits forthe
above Lots ( 318 , 322 , 324 Coddington Road ) °
DREW SUB-DIVISION
Chairman Desch read a letter from Attorney Armand Adams concerning the
Board ' s original decision , following, a. public hearing , to increase the
size of Lot S in the above sub - division at the expense of Lot 6 , ma'swing
it more suitable for placing a house on. same Recently , the opportunity
has come to sell Lot 6 , but the prospective purchaser will not buy the
lot unless the piece of land which increased Lot 8 is included with
Lot 6a The developer is recommending that Tot 0 be increased , but not
by way of decreasing Lot 6 due to the fact that Lot 69 if decreased ,
would have a. topographical problem The plan submitted by the developer
would permit development of individual sever systems as the 30 , 000
• minimum requirement is meta Upon motion by Mru Wiggins , seconded by
Mro Vasse , and carried by unanimous vote , it was moved that the Board
grant prelimina-i"j approval of the ;yap as amendede
Planning Board Minutes June 14 , 1.966 Page 2
• WILLIAM LOWER 9 ET14 STREET RZTENSION
Mro Lower has entered into a contract to purchase property on Elm
Street on West Hill which he proposes to develop as a subdivision Mr ,
bower was represented by Mr -4 Walter Wiggins who submitted two preliminary
plans which were prepared by Mr Niederkorn and showed two alternative
road laymiouts
It was painted out that the Health Department sees some problems in
this area with respect t• o sewers , and they may approve only every other
lot until pub:? ic sewer comes into this area. , It is anticipated that
within two years there will be public water and sewer in this area
.4 The only other complication is that the proposed road which is shown
running Tn' ^lest Haven is across lands within the New York State Electric
Gas Corps right of way However , Mr , Wiggins stated that there would
be sufficient room within the right of way for the proposed road Mr �
Brice , a resident from the area , stated that he was concerned with the
proposed road coming too close to his house ., Mrd Wiggins also pointed
out that the right of way for high tension lines restricts construction of
a dwelling , but they do not restrict how the land will be used under the
lines ; he also stated that if the road cannot be built here , an alternative
route will be found
John Vasse stated that the main cont� ern of the neighbors should be the
• quality of the construtition to which Mr � Wiggins replied that there Is no
intent to build minimum houses in this proposed subdivision
The following facts were presented : The lots meet minimum standard of
15 , 000 sqn fte ; 2 ) This is an. R - 15 zone * 3 ) The conceived prices of the
dwellings to be erected will be approximately 825 , 000 per dwel '.1ingp and
4 ) The subdivision is 450 feet in widtho.
Chairman Desch stated that he was concerned about the final, layout
that would come out of this as far as topography is concerned Before
preliminary approval can be given. , he would life to see the use of these
lots as far as topography is concerned
Chairman. Desch also stated that; the Board has reviewed. the proposed
subdivision plan favorably in principles but the requirements of the
subdivision ordinance and the means of developing the entire subdivision
as it relates to egress from public highways must be clarified before
preliminary approval. can be. given , The general lay - out is accepted
provided -the access roads can be developed in a ma.rner satisfactory to
the Boars?
JOHN MARION SDTERVILLE R04..:.a , PINE TREE PLOAD SUB - DIVISION
M) - Marion appeared befor ethe Board requesting a deletion of one lot
from the approved subdivision pla.nr• Mr � Perry moved that the plan be
amended and this lot be removed from same - Mrd Wiggins seconded the
' motion which was carried by =unanimous vate � Mry Desch also requested
that Mr " Marlon submit to this Board a subdivision. plan for the
proposed subdivision on Snyder Hili Road
Planning Board Minutes - June 14 , 1966 Page 3
IORAIu MARION - NORTH�AdEST CE"ZEyERY ASSOCIATION
• Mrc. Marion stcated that it has become necessary to extend the cemetery
and sell lots in order to maintain the same o Dr o Goth has indicated
that he might sell some property to the cemetery • However , this would
require all of the general funds of the association , and it would also
be necessary to borrow money - Mru and Mrso Freer have offered to donate
a section of 5 acres located at the corner of Hayts Road and Trumansburg
Road
MrQ Marion stated -that he would like to give his board ( NoWe Cemetery
Assn ° ) an answer at its next meeting as to whether these 5 acres would haul-
to be rezoned. in order to permit a cemetery in this R �15 zone NIr
Wiggins stated. that there are two alternatives in this matter : 1 ) Amend
the Zoning Ordinanceso
s 2 ) Rezone the areas
Upon motion by Mrd Phillips , seconded by Mro Schwan and carried by
unanimous vote , it was moved that R ~ 15 be amended to add to Use
Regulations to include cemetery and the building and structures incident
thereto , but only upon special approval of the Board of Appeals •
STA.TERVILLE ROAD - MANDEVILLE REQUEST FOR COMMERCIAL ZONE
Mr � ?Mandeville had submitted a sketch to Chairman Desch of his property
and indicated that he would like to have this area re - zoned commercial °
However , Jt was the unanimous .feeling of the members of the Board that
they are against re - zoning due to the rise of the laud for ingress and-
egress
ndegress to and from the property
REPORT ON PARKS
Chairman Desch and Mro Schwan are going to meet at another time with
reference to the parks which Mro Lucenti has proposed to deed over to the
Town
REPORT ON TOWN BOARD MEETING
Chairman Desch stated that it was resolved to extend the water and
sewer districts on South Hill , and that progress is going ahead on same
LAKE SEAL DIVISION - BUILDING DEMOLITION
It wa.s pointed out to the Planning Board that there is a building in
the bake Seal :Division area. which is only partially demolished Upon
motion by Mrs Wiggins , seconded by Mro Perry and carried by unanimous votF
it- was roved that .-he Board suggest to the Zoning Officer that he contact
the people involved and inform thew that this constitutes a violation of
the Zoning Ordinance =
REQUEST OF K.EN GARDINER TO ATTEND MEETING
Mro Phillips suggested to the Board that Mro Ken Gardiner attend a meet ®
Ing in order to point out the facts with respect to plans for adjacent
areas and also point out =a-arious matters to the board with respect to
what has been dome throughout the state as far as pooling counties , with
an expert to help the development of the particular areav The members
of the Board were in favor of this sugr eation �
Pl arming Board Minutes - June 14• , 19bb 'age 4
This meet atg wa.s ad j ourneU at 9 * 35 P * 14
Respectfully submitted ,
Cheryl So Beninati
Secretary