HomeMy WebLinkAboutPB Minutes 1959-11-04 - A
i VAM3ad�
A 1v%I,NLW# S OF THEE PLANNING BOARD OF T& TO101 OF ITHACA
Piaccs Town Barns 7 : 30 Wo
Presents Ligoari o Wiggins , Brus1m , Phillips, Vasso g is ion o I'arrry
1 ) Minutes of the 0atober 21st fc®ting tiara areas and app' ovedo
2 ) Nro and Nr1io 1sighmay whoa are interested in purchasing the Joseph Macconrasl. l
property known as SunnGables for a restaurant such as the one nou operated at
Taughsannock F s :inn , and their real estate agents Vero Darns Sara and Jr . .
appeared, The Eighaneys asked for a rezoning of nir&3 Soros of land aurrounding
they Sunny Gables building plus four acres located to this Northeast of tl:o praeazant
Placconnell lands . The Eighboys stated that their operation would pria5a,'?ril
fine food service but that there ;could be a<a service bar. Service will run to
about 8 :30 or ( 9s (30 P ,Mv Yro Eigbwy was willing to Comply with aamy rtason:ablre
conditions which . the Planning Board might want to imieso tai insure tho prev, -3rt
residential character of the: entire neighborhood, Ywo DaGriffg a reoi, d.nt of
the area In questlono spoke concerning the future development of the area . He
iitated that there area now fifteen residences. in the area end abont 14.5 good Nome
-� site' s for future development , The question of the operation of a restauscnt.
under control of the iiigbmeya3 was not thought of as being anythxx\g but dasaia.rable ,
bud should such as restaurant prove to be 16a3s9 than the financial 'success no°d
contemplated and it became necessary to sell the operations a now owner raight not
be willing to . lives up to the high standards which the Eigbmeya described , 1&�.,
Burns pointo d . au that all larger properties arca as problem because thein u is
so limited'. He stated that if this large property were converted into apartment
use the structure might not be as desirable the the n. ighborhood as a fi=
restaurant , lire Colas spoke on behalf a t the Ithaca Savings Land Loan �!scociat 'ion
stating that change to commercial operation' in as residential area generally has
adverse effects or nearby residential property value . Yr . Cole pointed out that
although the present use is intended to be of the highest q;aaali.tY 0 6utu�ae nese
might not live up to this standard. He :stated that neiglaberbood valuee are not
as stable where com iereial use of a neighboring preparty has been aU elejed ,
Everyone present wished a means could be found sto aWol.ve the problem of fihding
as suitable use for the _ property , It was pointed oat that any hardship variances
azre the business of the Zoning Board of Appeal s . After mach, discussion the
following resolution was offered by Phillips :
RESOLVED : that although the request of H. S . Ei tzey and John Bur-ass to rezone
the property riow balonging to Joseph McConnell rrcez resiaGntiaal to commercial
seems reasonable for the proposed use , other co-mmarciaal uses mght not bean the
beat interests of the neighborhood and therefore this Board takes no action
toward rezoning the property frGm its present residential use and clascif icaation .
Seconded by Marion = Passedo
3 ) Ar . Haller appa9ered with to proposed road-waad system for the Haller subdivision
which coordinated the Stuart Carpenter Earl. Carpenter cubdiv' ision and the Dorhald
Barnett property which adjoinA the .taller property , IAIr . Hallex cants the three
s •lis s;.gtro�WS�vc,. <€ a'�a. �,F1S3d.s ,, ,�, :"3ior.. o oa,m. luw �. o,�a by
°E30 7 _ [ ' F» i n ' + ''1t^i`•O• tap tt., s v I c a b f a i d° f 3f1 A �cl � f r c d
• }v •D : that
q.,/L�,'i;a � lG�p » �y� ' y, kie ic. ' r e p /0�•� Is o} .� r� i;��:_ �i yy ler fronting of
(d � Eby
,�,Ji,""aot be �_Pi VGgic� * a 6s'en� divil. long On cointdirt on JLw��:F. o hrr" aubda4 �u i b��. 'g n of eJ£heze
s f.S°i' .y. ,'16 GnVa xd �.• ^4 ice' *t V JLF14t r�.a 4> ^ 5^ ) ^i for z � fi Yi�� q
c u '€3f3i s shown on sir,$ ve icy jJ � stun, o 7 c
' eAti PC Ir ,e ' dated September C .95; aTcta J b ; " dm' Crandall . and that p vupor
culverts shall.ll. be installecd u d.eyz "Vi efueJ g`Oo td �`ed on t?' ay mare cJnsuructed , and
q,
a�an
tth'�N water likles of pr° opaai sp n ^'z �-''jc,att. P.ns aaahElil, f:3 xtended eoi 81. 1 Ya �3xree bloc:
Secaoneded o-.JyH° Wf.9.gnjlLns .'`a .2 tis-sed
w ..
:{ The ] at. ciC$t :K;t i ids"s. o?1as to tllle Zoning Crcli -naxx . e made by the ZLsF3ing Gc-mmmittoe
wore submit-teal to tha u£'?E'i. 4d' A Joint int mee ing to discuss tha s°E�S�. �jE'✓�."� F7�. � �3 ta3Q
ZcniriE Bowed of Appeals and the, `fioajn Board was oCheduled for 'November 18th or 19tao
5 ) Rosclutim v ` hillrmg.> RESCL IVED: that Coy . Idemazz be invited to submitplu
for his proposed bus . n. ess dIstmriet at tha corner of Judd ~ai3,s R a. 6. and MUIt shall
Street , Lo be acted on as quiCkly as possible aftw passap of the -revised Lo:aing
Crd.i¢ziance a 11 3
� c-% cc.r.C�C=� CT by 'd . vis « o Pass-ado
Mseztingr adjourned ,
Ban V . Boynton
d
�' x' ♦ ��.. 1�'L/ G� 1 r 4' i �,
� , ,
♦ ll `s
�'` ro If I .we III
f ' jaeIt : i / /•1.�- t n , t - �'c,, 1��"'zr" r , ,
x1. I
SI c zr y
it i.� n --r d y , N * . , l.f
t ' _ ' " o ` t♦ L. s{' 4 I. I`I e _t' moi. {
�4z
a� ,
i t _ ' w Cjl
--# i L It . I I I l , . . I . L �,I -I4I'l , - I
,
/ C � - Il I- I.
L t It J / = — ry`js ' f
I.._- , f ^- s .[e 1 - , • �_ t „ B u -- it + ', aiI'Ii G +,{ F r:,• Tx
( F ''f� Ifr
fV�15 /�✓� L„r rl n f� !'ICF. r../ r� $
- �j tY .,. st htac' s
?._____
It
It
t� % iIt II
It II
It II
It II
It II
It II
It II
It II
L tip .{ ¢
L
// �p
tIt-
%
Ill d p ,.. . _L._._._ 4 .._.Y f� �' rT�^J] L�j. ✓'Y• .: ! 4_'V } fes / ��I, Iff ,fin '�' I It} e�;.'' I .1 x t .fi
It
I .i.i t `.9� A� VHw.c.�'�'-� �.fj-�t/A ' \ , `3 �� X1.Y T; ,` / - A . J t.IPI its. (+pT(.'!A"t,b LC✓ •✓Vl t � , 4{'N Ti:ru -!'I 35� . � �4. I I, �., !�' l I.
_- - . - �/ -N._ tl�Lt.N!/�+r"� -_ Jhry_.--aVs., _ _ - _ --_ _ - -- 1 . rQi
1 .
L I
. ' •+ It .:l I .?• ' 1 - •. .' ( _ . . / t -a�-`jq f 1�/F"' .�' Q to , lt*Z f -,— Z...Cr �, ',-. .�. � S• i '. J 6/W� fl 1+- -'y�', `y _ "Lkt
J w M
It I N . 1 ..c. .. . _L t I. r
I
- 'i
- ;;`, Il Qo,I. .� , tAL. -`e.ur - cl-C/ a., ♦"t.:: . At -EeP'fj i pVt C. 6 �'ao .atl t+ M - :r.
.Ilk t; � � -- '=�- -----Y- VJ - I'll �}
1 "' 1 y Yrs - • ,
.p.... ...� 3 n . . _ C. E
Y A
._ .—.... —.. t . ' !'� f� _ _w//' .__ //�� +p... �..— ,,,,,,,,,gyp _ Z
f(j
• - i
.' -. _t 11 V `.
, cl
It
t4 I
i - --- _ - - .- -
:� -
III d7
I ALL f ' .h f i �"` — ._._ cre•a t ..r ..a'er 'f.
lj
A a6� y/
- --- -- - - - - -_ .- -- -- - - - -- -- - - - - - - -- -
It
. ;: 1 N
trite ��`''l ._
�,..,
I
i 1,;,, i
- ___ _-_ _- -- ---- _. . -- - - - - - - - - -- - --
- _ _ __
. t ,';
/'
- - /�
fl
i^
i _. dli /4 vn >� i Wit, �' -�" ,.d 4- -� �; N} AA
_ -.. -_._. - - - - - .. - - - - - � - __ . .
Ilt
1,.
I)
'. I. _ t y
I . ._--_ - • , a
, ; qqqq
Yr �ll.
%
— , a.,..�'
I . IY -- ... . -.. _. _ _ _
Lf � �7V/ �_ . i S _t t,a ._ C y: - V ( "fw nrw /+.S f �j - / F "ti �� _
,
//3
1
_ _
. � 4
1 7 - kzrf
; . P
J �G
— - , _ . ._ — - -._. _ ___— -- -t — -._ .. — _. -- - __ _._ _
N. 1 �•'ritit ir.
- . C, �- ,-w - ..-_.-„'- -�.__— .----- _. . ...-- -- ...._ _. ._. _.-..------.-_.- ---- w. Il------ .- - -._ _-..--.-_- -__-.
t l9 . / .
Ili
�`' —�
-- --”e, '— __� - -- ' F��Jh -----�'.% �! — — ----,7---------- — . -- — — C rY. I . I .
Il
Z i r.lto I.,--. II ,-� t, .&, 0 ,9 11.fd,.4.,,II-�...fI - Y,, /3 ,1, I I I : I," I .
� I 0— I - - - -- - I .�: re, 9. — e ew,�X�tfr, &%.,I&�( ZIW . I I If . , 11I
- I i i/ - �-G%t.. !> %.-.. ..�:_-. ._ - . I------�j"II f (.. w` .1-t�4:t....+r v ' ez./': f _- . v.. C G+ s G'wr"t,o - III t t
_._ ..__— -- --- - _— -- --- -...- - - - -- - -- --- - - ♦ _ .. - -- - --- - - ---
I.
.._____ ___-._ -_�___ . -- --_--�_ __ _.—__-- -__ _ _ _.. - _:__—._— -
tf
/�,.9 � �+ ,ry y,�/ /fes- r
_-.._ '__-.- _ — , k- l y//�L/��/��,�,�-�(/// r t _�7 r/,4P L^+•"� - �-':/ //,1„*''f� CLbl+ v"�4"f� 1 . Aja+
Y// V /J
7 . .
I .`. 5
- I.
_ .. - 1