Press Alt + R to read the document text or Alt + P to download or print.
This document contains no pages.
HomeMy WebLinkAboutTB Minutes 1996-02-12 FINAL -
Town of Ithaca
Town Board Meeting
February 12 , 1996
5 : 30 P . M .
At a regular meeting of the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca ,
Tompkins Country , New York held at the Town Hall , 126 East Seneca
Street , Ithaca , New York there were present :
PRESENT : Catherine Valentino , Supervisor; John P . Wolff ,
Councilman ; David Klein , Councilman ; Carolyn Grigorov ,
Councilwoman ; Mary Russell , Councilwoman , Ed Conley , Councilman ,
EXCUSED : Ellen Harrison , Councilwoman .
ALSO PRESENT : John Barney , Attorney for the Town ; Joan Lent
Noteboom , Town Clerk/Director of Administrative Services ; Daniel
Walker , Director of Engineering ; Fred Noteboom , Highway/ Parks
Superintendent ; Andrew Frost , Director of Building and Zoning ;
Jonathan Kanter , Director of Planning .
go
OTHERS PRESENT. Jason Peter , 206 Pennsylvania Ave . ; Audrey M .
Lowe , 136 Snyder Hill Road ; M . Vehovec , 28 - 07 Hasbrouck Apts . ;
Kristina Bartlett , Ithaca Journal ; John Yntema , 993 Danby road ;
Mark Macera , 115 S . Quarry St . ; Nancy Krook , 113 Pine Tree Road ;
Elizabeth Cain ,, Freeville , NY ; Margie Rumsey , Buttermilk Falls Rd . ;
Virginia Bryant , 115 S . Quarry St . ; Barbara Thuesen , 201 Hampton
Road ; David Carlson , T . C . Planning Dept . ; Jim Hanson , T . C . Planning
Department ; Gail Eddy , Ithaca ; Stephen Eddy , Ithaca ; Doria Higgins ,
2 Hillcrest Dr . ; Robert Lama , 409 Warren P1 . ; Ernest Hardy , 215
Enfield Falls Rd . ; H . Brown , 324 Richard P1 . ; Peter Voorhees ,
WHCY /WYXL Radio .
Call To Order : The Supervisor called the meeting to order at 5 : 30
p . m . , and led the assemblage in the Pledge of Allegiance .
Agenda Item No .. 18 will be moved to the beginning of the meeting as
there are persons wishing to speak regarding the new town hall and
have other meetings to attend .
There will be an additional Agenda Item No . 1 which is a budget
amendment . Agenda Item No . 14 - s has been deleted .
Agenda Item No . 7 - PERSONS TO BE HEARD :
Barbara Theusen , 201 Hampton Road , Ithaca - I was very involved
with the petition for the referendum and would like to thank all of
you who have been willing to serve on the Town Board for us .
Regardless of your party affiliation , you have been elected to
represent all of us and have accepted a fiduciary responsibility to
manage our money carefully . We feel we have a responsibility to
communicate our concerns to you as the Board . I believe State Law
requires a referendum be held if taxpayers money is being used to
build a Town Hall or to dispose of real property . Certainly going
I
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
into debt requires input from people who supply the money . We
understand State Law also stipulates the Town Hall should be in the
Town it represents . In 1964 a waiver was granted to the Town of
Ithaca by the New York State Legislature and apparently that waiver
can or cannot apply . We are asking for fiscal accountability and
common sense from not only the Town Board members but staff as
well .
The referendum called for by the petition was very specific as to
the resolution which was passed in December 1995 which included the
site and debt incurred . If the site is no longer available then a
referendum on the December 1995 resolution is moot . The referendum
again called for by the petition was specific to the December 1995
resolution . The recent survey is a good effort however it was also
confusing as people did not know which resolution was referenced
and objected to being asked how they were going to vote . CLARITAS
or American Demographics ' research shows that in this community our
population turns over every two years . This means that every four
years , we do not know two thirds of the people here . Understanding
this explains why there seems to be so much confusion . New people
do not know the history and what has happened in the past . People
ask if the turn over includes students and yes it does but students
may vote also The fact is very important and the historical
perspective is lacking . Most people confuse the Town with the r
City . In 1964 it may have made sense to locate the Town Hall in
the center of the City however is this true today ? If so , do not
take good property off the tax rolls for a government building or
go into debt .
Mary Russell , Town Councilwoman was quoted in the paper as trying
to follow the 1990 survey however with this being 1996 that plan
may not represent the preference of the people today . It is
frustrating to have to say the same thing over and over again but
the demographic fact makes it a constant necessity to explain to
the voters .
The OBGYN owners have a right to do what they wish with their
property . Someone should ask why another valuable business is
moving outside the City . Town taxpayers need to pay for borrowing
the voting machines and the election inspectors for the March 12th
referendum . While we feel that spending up to $ 5 , 000 is better
than spending money on a bad site and going into debt at $ 500 , 000
plus interest we ask you to please not waste any more money if the
option on the site has expired . Put the egos and special interests
out of this issue .
Tim Ciaschi , 124 Woolf Lane , Ithaca - I want the Board to know we
appreciate the time and effort afforded this issue . The biggest
thing I heard while passing petitions was that the taxpayers do not
mind a new building . They want something that will work for the
2
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
Town and the 'Gown deserves one . They want financial responsibility
and the Board needs to be held accountable .
If you went to build a house and went to a bank , they would give
you what you could support and that is all the taxpayers are
asking . Spend what you can support and not exceed the budget . I
received a call from the Mayor of the City regarding the
discussions the Town has had with the City on the annex building .
It was a great idea and I also thought the same thing three weeks
ago when we last met . Everyone together , centrally located and at
a good price . The Mayor got a feeling the staff members did not
like this idea . We are the taxpayers and who has the say , staff or
us ? The Board is supposed to be looking out for us , the taxpayer
and I do not believe this is asking alot . If the municipalities
got together , it would be recognized throughout the nation , it
would be great , the City Hall and Town Hall in one location . The
taxpayers only see spend , spend , spend and it hurts .
Councilwoman Grigorov - We thought it was a great idea a couple of
years ago when it was suggested to us . We studied the
possibilities and found out it did not meet our needs .
Mr . Ciaschi - *What would be the draw back other than parking ?
Supervisor Valentino - I do not want to get into a long discussion
regarding the annex however we did study it and looked at it very
1 closely . Contrary to what the paper said I had three long meetings
with Mayor Cohen and it was not a quick decision . It was not just
staff pressure but a thorough research on the annex and the
problems we would encounter there . Now that we have the referendum
coming up on March 12 we need to focus on making sure everything
gets heard on both sides fairly , honestly and openly . People are
divided on this issue and we need to listen to all sides .
Nancy Krook , Pine Tree Road , Ithaca - I would like to thank you for
this opportunity to have this discussion with you . I believe one
disadvantage the site on Court Street has is it is very expensive
considering there is not really a market for it . Another concern
I have is the safety aspect of the location when late meetings are
held . I wonder if it is lighted enough and that would worry me not
only for those attending the meetings but for the workers as well .
It would help us if we were aware of some other sites the Town is
considering however I know this would be difficult as the prices
would go up if one were aware of the interest . It is my
understanding this does not have to go to a referendum if the site
on Court Street were abandoned , is that correct ?
Councilman Klein - Yes , that is correct . The resolution the Board
passed was specifically for that site at that price .
1
3
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
Mrs . Krook - Then if the Town Board decides to go for another site ,
the referendum would not be in affect , is this correct ?
Councilwoman Grigorov - The referendum applies only to that site .
Mrs . Krook - I come from a larger city in Maryland where we have
volunteer fire departments . I know this sounds odd however it
shocks me when I see the fire trucks going to fires in Ithaca where
there is one person on the truck and that is the driver . I get
upset when I realize there is money we need to spend on fire
personnel , one without volunteers or adequate staff . We are
running the fire department as we would have 25 years ago where
there were no tall buildings at Cornell or in our area . We have to
think of the money which will be spent sooner or later on mutual
fire protection for our growing community . We need to put our
priorities into public safety first .
Agenda Item No . 18 - Consider Resolution Setting Date for
Referendum Related to the Acquisition of a New Town Hall and
Establish Polling Places and Procedures Related To Same
Mr . Barney - The site is still available to us at this time and
will be held available until after the referendum .
Mrs . Noteboom - The Election Inspectors have been confirmed to
serve as of today as indicated in Section 5 of the resolution .
Mrs . Noteboom - I would like to suggest an amendment to the
resolution . On page 3 , regarding registered voters , Shari
Zifchock , Commissioner of the Board of Elections , has asked the
registration date for eligible voters be the 25 day deadline from
the 12th of March which would make it February 16th and would
accept a postmark on the 16th .
. Absentee ballots and military ballots shall be issued upon
application 7 days prior to the March 12th date . The Board of
Elections is helping us arrange for the printing of all the
necessary documents done but my office will be the one which will
accept the absentee and military ballot applications and send them .
On March 12th the results of the election will be returned to me as
Town Clerk and I will personally pick up the results from each
polling place and return to the Town Hall and place them in the
vault . We would then have them witnessed for the count the next
morning .
Councilman Klein - Then you will not be tallying that night ?
Mrs . Noteboom - It would be up to the Town Board as to whether
they would want us to .
4
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
Mr . Barney - The results would be available from the machines ,
however , you would not have results from the absentee ballots .
Mrs . Noteboom - We have borrowed four machines from the City of
Ithaca and they will not be charging us for the use of those
machines . The reason we needed to borrow the machines is we have
a Primary on March 7 , 1996 and Election Law requires the machines
to be sealed for 15 days after the election . We would not have
enough machines to accommodate the Special Election due to the
primary .
Supervisor Valentino - This is a resolution which meets the
requirements which are set by law .
Mr . Barney - The Election Law , by its terms , simply applies to
General or Special Elections which are working on Statewide
propositions or Primaries . They do not really talk about Special
Elections for Towns on special propositions therefore we have tried
to follow the language and the requirements of the law in so far as
we think it applies to special elections . I have made a number of
calls to Counsel ' s Office in Albany and they have not been
returned .
Supervisor Valentino - We have been very careful in trying to
comply with the various laws . There has been a lot of discussion
in the community and hopefully the only clear answer we will get is
the result from this going to a referendum .
Mrs . Noteboom - Based upon the numbers we had in the last
Gubernatorial Election , there will be four districts voting at
BOLES , three districts voting at the Ellis Hollow Elderly Housing
and four districts voting at the Veteran Volunteer Fireman ' s which
will be advertised . We will have two machines available at the
BOCES location as the numbers are higher but will only use one
unless the second is necessary .
Supervisor Valentino - We will need to be sure to get the
information out so people will know which polling place they will
be voting at . The only thing we are voting on is to set a date for
the special referendum and setting rules and regulations for going
forward with the referendum .
Resolution No . 24 : Motion made by Councilwoman Grigorov , seconded
by Councilman Wolff authorizing and setting date for a special
election of the Town of Ithaca for the purpose of voting by ballot
on the proposition as set forth in the attached resolution as
amended .
A Roll Call Vote on the resolution resulted as follows :
5
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilwoman
Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley , aye . Carried unanimously .
Councilman Wolff - Some , people in the Town received a letter and
survey from Councilman Klein , Councilwoman Russell and myself
seeking information from various residents regarding this issue .
I want to make it clear this was something I proposed , with the
help of Councilman Klein and Councilwoman Russell . We do not speak
for the Town in any capacity outside of the fact that we are Town
Board members and we are only soliciting feedback about it . This
is not something which was paid for by taxpayers money nor was it
something the Town Board formally sanctioned and we are hopeful the
information we received will help us in our deliberations . The 317
people we sent the surveys to were selected entirely at random and
I do have the results available for anyone who would like to see
them . ( See attached )
Supervisor Valentino - It will be an interesting month for all of
us to do the best we can and get our points of view out to the
public , to help people get to the polls , and to try to get a large
turn out . I would like to thank the people who have taken the time
to pass the petitions and help us get the information we have
received so far .
Councilman Conley - Had I been at the last meeting when the vote
was taken regarding this issue , I ' would have joined the. two former
Town representatives in voting against the proposed site . I do
believe we could build a project that would fulfill all of our
needs without sacrificing any of them . We had a needs assessment
done and I think we had compromised that assessment as we
progressed in the OBGYN project . I would not have supported that
project or that location . I would have supported looking for other
alternatives and I would lean heavily towards building a project in
the Town of Ithaca and not in the City , which would meet the needs
of all of us and make it easier for us to expand if necessary .
With the OBGYN project , we have no where to go . As our staff has
indicated , we could make it work and I think we should build a
project which meets our needs and allows for any future expansion .
I do not support this particular project and I wanted to make that
a part of the record .
Mr . Ciaschi - I would like to address Councilman Wolff . The survey
which was sent was rather biased . I could send out a survey as
well and could probably get 5501 either way I wanted the results to
go . I did not see any mention about cost or tax increases . People
are cost conscious .
6
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
Agenda Item No . 6a - Report of Tompkins County Board of
Representatives :
Tim Joseph , T . C . Board of Representatives - At our last meeting a
resolution was passed asking for state legislation which would
allow us to place the solid waste annual fee on the property tax
bills as a part of the regular tax bill and not as an enclosure .
We have the support of the state senators and assemblyman as well
on this issue . It would appear as a separate item on the bill
however be included in the total tax amount .
Councilwoman Grigorov - Is the site for the DSS building subject to
a permissive :referendum?
Mr . Joseph - No it is not . We have been asked that many times as
a result of your present referendum . Not only is it not subject to
a referendum but not allowed as well . I do not know what the
difference is .
Mr . Wolff - Does the County have any jurisdiction regarding the
NYSEG issue we! will be discussing this evening . I have heard rumors
certain members of the County have acted on this issue and I am
curious to know if in fact there has been any action .
Mr . Joseph - There has not been any I am aware of . Some Board
members have paid attention to it and are interested in it and if
anything is happening it would be on the Health and Environmental
Quality Committee . The only thing which could happen would be the
County Board passing a resolution expressing an opinion .
Acrenda Item No 3 - Reports of Town Officials :
Supervisor Valentino - Does any one have anything they would like
to report which was not included in their packets ?
a . Town Supervisor - See attached . I would like to make a
correction on my report . Where I talk about the Town books being
closed the first week in February and stated the process has always
taken until mid May , I would like it noted that is should have read
March .
b . Director of Engineering - See attached . The Forest Home Bridge
project has gotten a lot of fast breaking non news . At the time I
did my report: there was not much difference however we have
received a revised cost estimate which brought the total project
costs closer to the original . With the Federal monies and the
County ' s budgE! t range it is not exceeding our budget and is now
running around $ 35 , 000 to $ 36 , 000 for the Town contribution for the
structure plus approximately $ 30 , 000 for utility relocations which
is in the range we had budgeted for . I still have not seen a
7
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
document from the State indicating the ISTEA monies are guaranteed
to us and we are going under the assumption we will be receiving
the funds . There were a few minor revisions to the design which
were suggested when the work group met .
At present , the drawings which we have reviewed and with a few
minor comments have been transmitted to the State for their review
and the Federal agency for their review . This process should not
take more than 30 days . Once the response has been received the
County could then submit it for bid . If all goes well , we could
have a project under way by the summer and have it constructed
during the months of June , July and August . That window gets
tighter and tighter as there is about a 90 day process to let a
contract with the County .
C , Town Highway Superintendent - See attached . A group of Town
staff went to a CEMO and FEMA Conference explaining the process we
need to go through in order for the Town to receive the State aid .
We will not have the definitive numbers until the inspectors come
from CEMO and inspect the individual sites and make a determination
on which sites will be covered . If the work is contracted out , as
would be the case with Sand Bank Road , CEMO would not question the
need and therefore the Town would be eligible for the maximum
amount , if the site is approved .
Supervisor Valentino - Do we have an estimate of the damage has
been on Sand Bank Road ?
Mr . Noteboom - At this point our estimate is approximately $ 579 , 500
total for all sites with Sand Bank Road alone at $ 429 , 000 .
d . Director of Planning - See attached . The Northeast Connector
Study Group met with a State representative in attendance . He
reiterated the State is willing to participate in the study both
financially and with staff . Part of the reason for the study group
is to scope out the project and obtain a good cost estimate on what
will be involved . The study should be broad based which would look
at the needs of the Northeast sub area as a context of the whole
regional transportation need . Updated traffic data would be needed
and suggestions on road alignment for a north - south connector road ,
if appropriate . Other recommendations for mitigating measures
would be submitted to address the transportation problems which the
residential neighborhoods are experiencing .
Councilwoman Grigorov - Is Cayuga Vista planning to increase the
number of dwellings on the site ?
Mr . Kanter - The overall numbers would be reduced down from their
original approved townhouse development . Only 12 units have been
built out of an approved 32 units . The subdivision is to allow a
8
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
realignment of the buildings over the entire lot . There would be
some good aspects in that there would be more room to work around
some of the wetlands and other site constraints . The original
layout did not take in to consideration some of the site
constraints as well as it could have .
e . Director of Building and Zoning - See attached .
f . Town Clerk. - See attached .
g . Assistant Budget Officer - See attached .
Agenda Item No . 4 - Report of Town Committees .
Councilman Wolff - You have all received information regarding the
NYSEG pipeline issue which summarizes the status . NYSEG is
planning to develop a pipeline however some residents in the Danby ,
Caroline area have raised some concerns . The reason this has
become an issue to the Town of Ithaca is that the process of which
they have raised their concerns has not been met as set forth by
the Public Service Commission . Mr . Brian Eden has been one of the
persons involved in this issue and is here to make himself
available for questions .
The proposal I: am introducing is not a statement regarding the
actual issues involved but more or less a statement about the
process itself . I believe the Town has an interest in showing a
fair process to all citizens and what may happen to Caroline or
Danby citizens is of interest to Town residents as well .
There is currently a petition filed for a re - hearing before the
Public Service Commission asking the Commission to reopen the
issue . This will allow those residents who have not had a chance to
speak on the issue to raise their concerns to insure them their
needs and other issues have been taken into consideration before
any final plans to build the pipeline are approved . The resolution .
before you recognizes and supports the citizens , efforts .
If NYSEG has a :Legitimate need for this pipeline , if the quality of
life of the residents is not threatened in any way and there are no
legitimate concerns , or other issues we should not be worried
about , then certainly it would not hurt to reopen the hearings .
Councilwoman Valentino - I thought I had read they were going to
have more hearings on this issue .
Brian Eden , Citizens Environmental Coalition - The petition for a
re - hearing has not been heard due to time constraints . I am working
with people along the pipeline route to avail them the opportunity
to comment for the first time on the project . They have only been
9
TBM 2 / 12/ 96
given the opportunity to speak on the routing issue and never able
to comment on the need for the project itself . My main concern is
we get the Commission to reconsider the petition . We had thirty
days to file the petition after a decision was made and we did not
know there was a decision impending as it was done in Albany and
did not involve any local parties . We were completely unaware of
the process which was taking place in Albany . The evidentiary
hearing was held on July 21 , 1995 and no one on the eastline route
was represented at that hearing . No one with any interest other
than the PSC staff and NYSEG commented on the issue of public need .
Why we are addressing the Town of Ithaca , even though you are
slightly affected , was we did not want to leave anyone out of the
process . There may be someone in the Town of Ithaca concerned
about this project and since the PSC has passed over reviewing this
project the last four months , even though we had thirty days , they
have taken four months . The project construction has been
continuing in this process with millions of dollars already spent .
It will become moot by the time we get to hearing unless we can
find some way to get to get their attention . The Town of Caroline
passed a resolution , the Town of Danby is considering one this
evening , The Environmental Management Council has passed a
resolution , the Government Operations Committee of the County Board
heard the resolution today in hopes of making the agenda for their
February 20th meeting . This is our way of getting their attention
and moving this issue . We cannot appeal nor do we have any legal
rights until they make a decision . The PSC has taken four months
and are not subject to any time requirements other than to be
reasonable . Now whether four months is reasonable for this fairly
simple petition is another question and has allowed construction to
continue . We are concerned the longer the Commission does not
decide , there will be very little to talk about .
Councilman Wolff - I have spoken with other elected officials and
although there is no specific authority the County has , Frank Proto
has been very interested in this issue as it is his constituency
which is affected not to mention his home . He has communicated
that one of the things elected representatives could do would be to
write a letter to John F . O ' Mara , Chair of the PSC , expressing your
concerns as an elected official to insure the process remain the
way it is intended to .
Resolution No , 16 : Motion made by Councilman Wolff , seconded by
Councilwoman Russell that the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca
strongly urges the Public Service Commission to approve the
petition for rehearing on the issue of public need so that
interested residents may have an opportunity to provide relevant
testimony .
Councilwoman Russell - As a Coddington Road resident in the area
the pipeline will pass through and although it will not affect my
10
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
property , I am . concerned about this issue as well as some of my
neighbors . There are four other major gas transportation lines in
our neighborhood and therefore safety is a big issue . The tap into
the CNG line will be located in the Town of Ithaca and we should be
aware of these issues .
In the NYSEG application , I noted that in the section where it
talks about the Town of Ithaca , NYSEG was requesting a waiver from
our Town Zoning Ordinance noting that they were unreasonably
restrictive . What is the status of this waiver request and what do
we know about it .
Mr . Frost , Town of Ithaca Zoning Officer - I would hope as the
Zoning Officer I would know however I am not aware of anything . I
did receive a call from NYSEG around November 1995 inquiring about
the zoning in the area . It was the Towns determination , in
looking at the plan at the time , there were two parcels involved .
Councilwoman Grigorov - Who would be authorized to grant the
waiver ?
Mr . Frost - Ii° there were such an exemption , i . e . variance , it
would be authorized by the Zoning Board . The R - 30 Zone , which is
the area in question , would allow NYSEG to install the pipeline as
the ordinance is written . Possibly the waiver request is something
which is incorporated in all applications .
Attorney Barney - It seems to me the Zoning Ordinance would not
prohibit them from running the pipeline .
Councilman Klein - In the memo they claim since it is a main
transmission facility it is prohibited .
Mr . Frost - Who is the memo written to ?
Councilwoman Russell - It is the NYSEG - Seneca Lake Storage
Application dated March 1995 .
Councilwoman Grigorov - The whole thing was not addressed to the
Town at all . It. was included in the application to someone else .
Mr . Eden - They have not been certified for the route as yet so any
sort of request to the Town would come after the certification .
The good news for the Town is they will probably certify another
route which will go around the Town .
Attorney Barney - Does the PSC have the power to set aside local
zoning regulations ? It sounds like they are applying to the PSC
for the waiver . The PSC is a regulatory commission .
11
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
Mr . Frost - This is a public utility purpose . Reading an R - 15 zone ,
it seems to be a permitted use .
Attorney Barney - They are maintaining in the application this is
such a major transmission facility , it may not be construed as a
general public utility use .
Mr . Frost - I have had no questions posed to me formally on the
issue .
Mr . Kanter - Normally one would get an interpretation from the Code
Enforcement Officer before requesting a waiver .
Mr . Frost - So it is clear , we typically ask the applicant to write
a letter proposing what they want and we would respond in writing .
Councilman Wolff - I would like to amend a part of the resolution .
In the 7th WHEREAS , strike words " in November " .
A vote on the resolution resulted as follows :
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilwoman
Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley , aye . Carried unanimously .
Councilman Klein - I assume the Town Clerk will send this to the
PSC ?
Supervisor Valentino - Councilman Wolff will make sure copies of
the resolution will be distributed to the respective persons .
Is there anything we should follow up on with regard to the PSC
request for waiver ?
Mr . Frost - I find it incredible . If I knew where or who to write
to I would be happy to contact them . It seems obvious from the
application someone had a copy of our Zoning Ordinance as they cite
various sections . Our ordinance does not require special approvals
for utilities , it just says if a building is constructed , there
needs to be building set backs . It seems to be a permitted use .
Councilwoman Russell - What about the fact they are going to build
a structure where the tap into the CNG line goes ?
Mr . Frost - It seems to be something which is permitted as long as
the building set backs are met .
Attorney Barney - I would hesitate to render an opinion without
doing some research and looking at it more closely . What we might
ask Mr . Frost to do is write a letter to the President of NYSEG .
12
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
indicating our, awareness of a request for a waiver from the Town of
Ithaca Zoning Ordinance and we have yet to be notified .
Mr . Walker - There is a local community contact person who has been
handling this issue . We have the name and address of the person in
our office .
Supervisor Valentino - We will postpone agenda item no . 4 until
after the public hearing .
Agenda Item No 8 PUBLIC HEARING - To Consider a " LOCAL LAW
PROVIDING FOR ADDITIONAL LEVELS OF INCOME ELIGIBILITY FOR THE
PARTIAL TAX EXEM TION FOR REAL PROPERTY OWNED BY PERSONS WITH
LIMITED INCOMES WHO ARE 65 YEARS OF AGE OR OVER " :
The Supervisor- opened the public hearing at 6 : 30 p . m . The Town
Clerk had proof of posting and publication .
As no one from the public came forward wishing to be heard during
the public hearing , the Supervisor closed the public hearing at
6 : 39 p . m .
Agenda Item No , 9 Consider SEOR Related to a " LOCAL LAW PROVIDING
FOR ADDITIONAIJ LEVELS OF INCOME ELIGIBILITY FOR THE PARTIAL TAX
EXEMPTION FOR REAL PROPERTY OWNED BY PERSONS WITH LIMITED INCOMES
WHO ARE 65 YEP..RS OF AGE OR OVER " :
Resolution No . 18 : Motion made by Councilman Klein , seconded by
Councilman Wolff making a negative determination of environmental
significance in accordance with the New York State Environmental
Quality Review Act for the above referenced action as proposed and
neither a Full. Environmental Assessment form nor an Environmental
Impact Statement will be required .
A vote on the resolution resulted as follows :
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilwoman
Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley , aye . Carried unanimously .
Agenda Item No 10 Consider Enactment of a " LOCAL LAW PROVIDING
FOR ADDITIONA LEVELS OF INCOME ELIGIBILITY FOR THE PARTIAL TAX
EXEMPTION FOR - REAL PROPERTY OWNED BY PERSONS WITH LIMITED INCOMES
WHO ARE 65 YEP.RS OF AGE OR OVER " :
Resolution No . 19 : Motion made by Councilman Conley , seconded by
Councilwoman Grigorov enacting Local Law No . 1 / 1996 a " Local Law
Providing for additional levels of income eligibility for the
partial tax exemption for real property owned by persons with
limited incomes who are 65 years of age or over " .
13
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
Supervisor Valentino - I will sign a Certificate of Necessity prior
to the vote .
Councilman Conley - Why before we vote ?
Attorney Barney - It is a mechanism which shortens the period the
Town Board must receive a copy of the proposed local law .
Normally , this local law would need to be " placed on the Town
Boards desk " at least 10 days prior to the Town Board meeting .
A Roll Call vote on the resolution resulted as follows :
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilwoman
Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley , aye . Carried unanimously .
RESUMED - Agenda Item No . 4 Report of Town Committees :
Councilwoman Russell , Recreation Partnership - I attended my first
meeting and was involved with their budget process . There were
discussions regarding whether fees charged were appropriate and
cost comparisons are being done with other towns .
Councilman Klein - Councilman Wolff and I , as the Interviewing
Committee for the Ethics Board , met with Laura McClellan and Max
Penske last thursday . They are fine citizens and we believe they
will serve us well .
Agenda Item No . 5 - Review of Correspondence :
a . James and Phyllis Baker , New Town Hall - No discussion .
b . NYSDOT Route 366 at Judd Falls Road , Tower Road and Caldwell
Road :
Councilman Klein - If they close the north leg of Judd Falls
Road , it will force much more traffic over to Caldwell Road
which is presently in very poor shape . I am not sure that is
such a good idea .
Mr . Noteboom - When they close the leg on Judd Falls Road they
intend to open Campus Road and Tower Road .
Mr . Walker - The proposal is that Cornell has offered to give
the Town of Ithaca a portion of their road system . Cornell has
proposed , at some point , the Town might consider taking over
portions of Campus Road and Tower Road in return for abandoning
a section of Judd Falls Road .
14
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
Supervisor Valentino postponed further discussion of correspondence
until after agenda item no . 11 , public hearing .
Actenda Item No 11 - PUBLIC HEARING • To Consider Application on
Behalf of the Town of Ithaca by Tompkins County for a Small Cities
Community DevE��loiment Block Grant :
The Supervisor opened the public hearing at 6 : 45 p . m . The Town
Clerk had proof of posting and publication .
RESUMED - Agenda Item No 5 - Review of Correspondence :
Councilman Klein - This was written to Cornell from the State ,
therefore , what is our position on this ?
Mr , Noteboom - Concerns regarding the road is ' we would be taking on
more roadway and you will see they are not in the best of shape .
They appear to have base problems however it is not that much
additional road .
Mr . Kanter - This was discussed at the Cornell / Town of Ithaca
Transportation Committee meeting over a month ago . The State has
contacted Bill Wendt , from Cornell , on this issue . It was
indicated the State would like to come talk to the Town and
interested parties to pursue the proposal . I believe we will have
a State presentation on the agenda for the March meeting . If any
Town Board members are interested , please feel free to attend that
meeting .
Mr . Noteboom - Perhaps the Town Attorney could clarify what the
procedure is for shutting off a piece of Town road .
Attorney Barney - You would abandon a portion of the road . The
abandoning process is fairly lengthy .
Mr . Kanter - It was discussed in two parts . One is the desire to
change the signalization at the intersection of Judd Falls and
Route 366 . If that were done then perhaps it could be pursued as
to whether or not closing a portion of Judd Falls Road would be
appropriate .
Councilman Klein - Would this affect traffic in Forest Home as
well ?
Mr . Noteboom - I am sure it would not affect quantity at all . It
my possibly alleviate some as it would be a nuisance and they might
just stay away .
Councilman Klein - Then I think that would throw traffic to
Caldwell Road .
15
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
Mr . Walker - We would need to look at the traffic counts . Most of
the traffic coming through Forest Home is using Cornell as a
destination .
Supervisor Valentino - I sat in the committee ' s first meeting and
they are looking carefully at this issue . The letter is in essence
the first stage of the process .
Mr . Walker - The Northeast Connector study needs to be completed
before we do any highway changes . That would be my recommendation .
Agenda Item No 11 - RESUMED PUBLIC HEARING • To Consider
Application on Behalf of the Town of Ithaca by Tompkins County for
a Small Cities Community Development Block Grant •
Mr . Kanter - I would like to introduce Jim Hanson , T . C .
Commissioner of Planning .
Mr . Hanson - We feel this will be a great partnership for the
County and the Town to be involved in . The grant is a HUD Small
Cities Community Development Block Grant and is for economic
development for low and moderate income wage earners . The purpose
is to provide low interest loan assistance to companies to business
in Tompkins County . The assistance will be secured debt requiring
the borrower to justify proposed interest and loan terms . They
must meet HUD criteria for providing employment for low and
moderate income families . The Tompkins County Economic Development
Program is interested in job creation , including equipment , fixed
assets construction , working capital and other projects which will
create jobs and employment opportunities . Loan assistance must be
paid in full through the terms and conditions though the terms are
flexible based on the nature of the project . The funds will be
repaid to Tompkins County and the proceeds are used to make
additional loans to businesses in the County .
We have a specific project in mind at this time . AXIOHM , which is
a point of sale printer manufacturer , will be provided with loan
assistance to maintain and expand their operations at the Ithaca
facility .
The Tompkins County revolving loan fund for economic development
was created in 1995 through funding from two small cities projects .
Loans have been granted to JAMEX Inc . , a manufacturer of coin
operated copier and fax equipment . As repayments are made to the
fund , additional loans will be made and that money will not be
repaid to HUD but will be put back into a revolving loan fund .
This is the first of two hearings . Tonight , we are supplying you
with the background of the process . There will be a second hearing
the Town will hold to discuss the specifics of the program . At
16
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
this point my staff and the County consultant David Carlson have
been meeting with the AXIOHM officials to put together the
proposal .
As no one from the public wished to speak , the Supervisor closed
the public hearing at 6 : 55 p . m .
Agenda Item No 12 - Set Public Hearing Date to Consider the Second
Phase of the Application on Behalf of the Town of Ithaca bx
Tompkins county for a Small Cities Community Development Block
Grant .
Resolution No .., 20 : Motion made by Councilman Klein , seconded by
Councilman Wolff authorizing and directing the Town Clerk to
advertise for a public hearing to be held at the regular meeting of
the Town Board on March 11 , 1996 at 6 : 45 p . m . , in order that the
Town Board may meet the HUD requirements for the public
participation process involved in applying for the Small Cities
Community Development Block Grant .
A vote on the resolution resulted as follows :
Supervisor Valentino , aye , Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilwoman
Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley , aye . Carried unanimously .
Agenda Item No 5 - RESUMED - Review of Correspondence :
Councilman Klein - I assume the meeting will be coordinated with
Fred and Jon at some point .
d . Yervant Terzian , Flooding -
Mr . Noteboom - Mr . Terzian contends there is a driveway
pipe which is too small and that the intersection floods .
It is slightly backed up from a small driveway pipe
and with this particular storm event there was
more water than normal . There is an ongoing problem in
that area however .
Councilman Klein - By addressing the retention pond , that
should relieve the problem to some extent . Has the Town
responded Supervisor to Mr . Terzian ' s and Ms . Macera ' s
P P
letters ?
Supervisor Valentino - I will respond to them .
17
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
Agenda item No 6 - Consider Acceptance of the 1995 Annual Reports
of Town Officials :
Resolution No . 17 : Motion made by Councilwoman Grigorov , seconded
by Councilman Conley accepting and approving for permanent filing
the 1995 Annual Reports of the Town of Ithaca Officials as listed
in the attached resolution .
Supervisor Valentino - I would like to thank the staff for working
so hard in getting these reports to us in such a timely manner . It
is very much appreciated .
A vote on the resolution resulted as follows :
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilwoman
Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley , aye . Carried unanimously .
Agenda Item No 15 - Consider 1996 Resolution of the Association of
Towns of the State of New York
Resolution No . 22 : Motion made by councilman Wolff , seconded by
Councilwoman Russell provisionally approving the Association of
Towns 1996 Resolutions , but hereby instructs the town ' s Delegate ,
Catherine Valentino and Alternate Delegate , Carolyn Grigorov to
exercise discretion in voting based upon any information that may
be provided during the floor discussions of the resolutions at the
Association of Towns Annual Meeting February 18 to February 21 ,
1996 .
A vote on the resolution resulted as follows :
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilwoman
Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley , aye . Carried unanimously .
Agenda Item No . 13 - 7 : 00 P M PRESENTATION • Saddlewood Farms :
Supervisor Valentino - You received in your board packets some
background concerning Saddlewood Farms ,
Pam Gleichman , Landmark America - You have some highlights before
you outlining the project . In the packet , there is a site plan ,
photographs of other developments we have done , summaries of the
market studies done in Ithaca , environmental studies done on the
site and marketing and management plan .
Landmark America was started 18 years ago and I am the sole
stockholder of the company . We initially began building affordable
housing and have since become diversified in other projects . We
18
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
have an asset 'management company located in 50 states and in Puerto
Rico . We manage single family houses for a number of third
parties , such as the RTC , banks , FDIC , HUD . That company manages
large portfolios of single family houses and places them with
affordable buyers . We have a number of properties such as
Saddlewood Farms located in approximately 12 states and have
developed a lot of downtown urban properties due to our focus in
historic pre :o) ervation . We recently completed the Exchange
Building , in d'.owntown Memphis . It was vacant for approximately 17
years and we converted the building in to 202 apartments . You
might be familiar with the building as it was shown at the
beginning of the movie " The Firm " . The book and movie were written
about a firm located in this building . We managed to save some of
the architectural details of a marble entry way and ballroom . The
apartments are a mix of affordable housing , at about $ 400 - $ 450
per month rent up to $ 1500 per month for the higher end market rate
apartments . We did something similar in downtown Portland however
this was a new construction development . This building is a 17
story building which is at 70a market rate with monthly rent going
as high as $ 24: 00 per month with 30 % affordable apartments at $ 450
per month .
We have also done a number of social service oriented projects , and
have been involved with historic preservation . We look at what the
need is and work very closely with communities .
We looked at approximately 10 locations in New York State and did
some preliminary market studies , and ultimately selected three
communities we felt met our development target . In Ithaca , we
observed there was a strong market for apartments , primarily
because of the impact of the colleges . The apartments available
were very expensive and did not give a lot of amenities in return
and at the same time there was a very strong desire for quality of
life in the community . In looking for an ideal location to combine
these types of demands we identified through Bob Lama , a number of
sites and selected Mr . Eddy ' s site as the most appropriate for what
we wanted to accomplish . What we identified was a place we could
have views , southern exposure for the gain of the sunlight and at
the same time having enough open space to be able to develop a
green area and put back 25 % to 3011 of the land in to trees and
plantings .
Ms . Gleichman went on to explain the proposed project design .
Our plans are such that we are welcoming any input anyone might
have regarding the project . When we met with Supervisor Valentino ,
Candace Cornell and Jon Kante r a couple of weeks ago ,,
there were
some suggestions made and have incorporated those suggestions in
the proposal .
The rents will range from approximately $ 395 per month to $ 950 per
19
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
month .
Councilman Conley - I live in a project with the units about that
size . What provisions are there for a second or perhaps a third
car in the garage area ?
Ms . Gleichman - In front of each garage there is an additional
parking place and then across the drive is some additional parking
for either visitors or a third car . Our experience is there is
usually one car with maybe 20 %w who have two cars .
Councilman Conley - These units are for working families ? Working
families in this area usually have at least two cars .
Ms . Gleichman - We allow two parking places for each unit .
Councilman Wolff - What does the 50o refer to ?
Ms . Gleichman - It refers to 50 0s of median income . That is what
the rent is . The median income is determined by County .
Councilman Wolff - If the market rate is slightly higher , who would
cover the costs ?
Ms . Gleichman - The market rate ; ones paying the $ 750 - $ 950 per
month .
Councilman Wolff - How would you insure low income units are filled
in an equal manner in proportion to the market rate ?
Ms . Gleichman - We designate at the beginning what percentage will
be at the affordable rate the rest would then be at the market
rate .
Councilman Wolff - So individual units are pre - selected to be
affordable . What Federal or State programs are you able to take
advantage of ?
Ms . Gleichman - There is no Federal or State money however we will
get tax credits on the property . It is a one time designation then
the credits are received over a period of time .
Councilwoman Russell - Could you briefly describe your market
research and who you think your market is for this type of housing ?
Ms . Gleichman - Mr . Kanter has the full market study available if
anyone would like to review it . The market study was conducted
approximately three months ago by Kuntz & Sollinger , a reputable
fine which does market studies for apartment complexes . They study
the entire demographics of the community , where they work , how much
20
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
money they make , rental rates , a broad range of information is
gathered . We are not targeting nor are we renting to students .
Our target market are people who work in the community . We are
looking at single family , typical users . We expect a big target
to be the " empty nesters " , we will have the young couples just
starting out and we will get professionals . We always are getting
school teachers , lawyers , doctors , the whole gambit that for some
reason someone! does not want to own a home . The market is a
variety of folks looking for this quality of development and want
service . They have a higher demand for service . We ill have full
time staff , security people , and others available to meet their
needs .
Councilwoman Russell - My concern is the " town house market " . Some
of the apartment complexes have had trouble filling vacancies . I
am concerned if there really is a market for this . Are we really
servicing town residents with this and not competing in a
detrimental way with other developments already here ?
Ms . Gleichman -- Kuntz & Sollinger said there was a very grave need
for additional market rate and affordable housing in Ithaca . They
are only allowed to do their market studies to draw from the
community . There is nothing that does what we are doing in so far
as community living and quality of life product we are designing .
The people we would attract would be people who would not live in
a townhouse or would not want to live close to the universities .
Again , we are able to offer reasonable rents . I do not think we
would compete with anyone next to the colleges as we are not
looking for students to be our tenants .
Councilman Klein - On the 5001 to 600W median income , what is that
number ?
Mr . Kanter - I believe the median income for the County is
approximately 034 , 000 for a family of four .
. Councilman Klein - So about 250s of their gross income .
Ms . Gleichman -• These rents include utilities .
Councilman Klein - In the market study , there was a similar project
that has come :before us . It appeared the market study for that
project was dome by a computer and someone entering a bunch of
numbers . It sounds like your consultant has done a more thorough
job .
Ms . Gleichman - He was here and spent some time here however that
is not to say you cannot look at data and extrapolate a market
study . Kuntz &: Sallinger will not give a report unless they have
spent time in the community .
21
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
Councilman Klein - Do you know what the geographical area was they
covered ?
Ms . Gleichman - I do not believe they were allowed to go out of the
county .
Councilman Klein - I believe we are all in support of affordable
housing however I would be a little skeptical if they went to the
far corners of the County and said yes there are a lot of lower
I
ncome people here that would fit your model .
On the summary sheet , I do not understand where he says the market
for the proposed 125 market units is very deep however the proposed
upper segments under consideration should not be utilized in order
to properly target the product . I do not understand what he is
saying there . As a board we are looking at a number of proposals .
I would say to myself can this community absorb anymore ?
Councilwoman Grigorov - It looks like a very good company which
would provide affordable housing . I like the idea of combining
affordable with market rate housing as well . Our problem , as I see
it , is the location in an area which we had planned to keep
agricultural , as indicated in the Comprehensive Plan . What other
sites might be available ?
Ms . Gleichmann - The way it encumbers an existing neighborhood , we
sought out a location which would not be in everyone ' s back yard ,
which could be buffered from the neighbors , and also accessible to
shopping and schools . We wanted to be able to allow enough space
to dedicate a " green " area , which is something we want to make
clear in order to generate some vitality to the land . The
topography of a lot of the sites does not allow for a project like
this . The way this is set up now , there is one property on the
site which goes around the area . The neighbors do not seem to have
a problem with the project and it would be an enhancement to the
land we saw .
From a zoning point of view , one small corner is an R - 15 and a
small portion on the top .
Mr . Kanter - Approximately 10 . 5 acres of the property is zoned R - 15
and the remainder is agricultural .
Ms . Gleichman - To the north it is R - 15 , the east R - 15 , and across
the street is R - 30 . The problem with this property in terms of
agricultural land due to the houses which will eventually surround
it as well as the zoning prohibiting animals on the land . It would
be restricted by the 1000 ft , setback requirement in either
direction . Spraying would be prohibited and the result would be
difficult when you have a piece cut in to a residential zone . When
22
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
we looked at the land we felt it would a logical place for an
extension and cut off . Our plan was to cluster as close to the R -
15 area to the east and to the north , then putting as much as 25 %
to 30 % of the site as a buffer towards the agricultural area with
plantings .
People who haN►e come down Mecklenburg Road have seen the views
from Lansing to Danby and it is really spectacular . It is
something which adds to the value of the units especially with a
patio with that view .
Mr . Eddy - I am the farmer you are talking about when you say you
want this land to remain agricultural . My brother and I have dairy
farms on Bostwick Road , south of this project . The people who
previously owned our property went bankrupt and we eventually
purchased it from the County . We work very hard , do not have
stocks or bonds , and have invested everything we have in the farm
itself . I am 65 years old and my brother is ill . We bought this
farm with the idea of using it as a feeder farm . After we bought
the farm , we had to sell the homes as we could not afford the
taxes , insurances , and the like . We farmed the land and put hay
and corn in to feed our dairy cows . The price of milk went from
$ 14 to $ 10 . 50 thus we could not make any money . The cows have been
gone about 8 years and I cannot properly farm this land . The big
half of the farm land is owned by EcoVillage and this half we are
talking about would be too small to farm now . EcoVillage residents
are against sprays and concerned about the environment . In 1989 I
became poisoned with some spray and became very ill .
Pam Gleichman is the person I would like to see go ahead with this
project . Why this is zoned differently is due to us selling parts
of the land to different people . There is presently water and
sewer available to the property as well .
Part of the planning idea was that at some point in time the Town
would like to have another road which would go around and back to
Bundy . Candace and John asked if we could designate the 50 or 60
foot right of way which would be needed to put that type of road in
and this is what we propose .
Mr . Walker - Right now the water is on West haven Road with the
pressure zone it serves ending about where the roadway is . To move
up the hill , the pressure zone would require an additional storage
tank and pumping station .
Councilwoman Russell - Is there any precedent for a developer to
put in their own pressure tank ?
Mr . Walker - Yes . It has been done before and they are doing that
at EcoVillage .. The health Department and I get a little
23
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
uncomfortable with a large number of users on a private water
system . What could eventually happen is at some point in time ,
when the system no longer is adequate , the Town would be asked to
extend the water or sewer supply . We do have some weaknesses on
West Hill as there is not enough storage . We are serving all of
West Hill including the hospital and the Biggs Complex through a 6 "
line which is very old so we have to look at some improvements in
that area soon .
Any water supply for this proposed project would require Town Board
approval . There could be mutual benefits which could be attained
by jointly doing Town improvements along with new development
improvements .
Ms . Gleichman - We budget a certain amount then negotiations with
the Town would occur . It would be a give and take situation as to
what would have the greatest long term benefit .
Mr . Walker - That portion of the Town also abuts the City and they
have areas which are in need of reinforcement as well . We are in
the process of working with the City on their master plan for water
and infrastructure in the future . There are a lot of opportunities
there .
Councilwoman Grigorov - Would the roads you have proposed be
private ?
Ms . Gleichman - Yes . We would maintain the road with the Town ' s
long term right of way .
Supervisor Valentino - This is an issue for the Town to consider as
a rezoning . This is not a public hearing this evening .
Ernest Hardy , Retired , Land Use Specialist for State of New York -
I wanted to point out a couple of things . One is when you look at
farming areas , the real signal that things will remain strong is
when a farm passes from one generation to the next . As you drive
along Mecklenburg Road , there are no farms which have passed from
one generation to the next . The degree of agricultural strength is
certainly not strong in this area . Sooner or later there will be
another use for this kind of property no matter what decision this
Board makes . The slope is very good for the project and it is
identified in the soil bulletin as being adequate for dairy farm
crops however as we have heard , there is no dairy farm left and I
do not expect there ever will be . It is excellent soil for housing
as well which is also indicated in the soil bulletin . Typically
the soils are dry in the summer months and if no irrigation water
is available all farming activities are under stress in the summer
months .
24
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
The area is essentially surrounded by housing now and no matter
which way you go , with the exception directly to the south off the
road , there i. s no other territory around which is not already
committed to housing of one form or another .
Supervisor Valentino - Should we have this on our agenda for the
next meeting to consider the rezoning ?
Mr . Kanter - The next step in the process would be to obtain a
petition to rE' zone the property and an application .
Attorney BarnE�y - Then the issue would be referred to the Planning
Board for consideration , if this Board is willing to entertain the
rezoning issue . If not , there would be no point in referring the
issue to the Planning Board .
Mr . Kanter - There is a development review application .
Acrenda Item Nc> 9 14 - Consent Items :
Councilman Klein - I have some questions on item 14 - k and 14 - r .
Supervisor Valentino - We will pull those items and discuss later .
Resolution No . 21 : Motion made by Councilwoman Grigorov , seconded
by Councilwoman Russell approving and/ or adopting the Consent
Agenda items numbers 14 ( a ) through 14 ( 1 ) , 14 ( m) - 14 ( q ) , 14 ( t ) - 14 ( aa )
as presented ; items 14 ( k ) and 14 ( r ) are approved as amended . Item
14 ( s ) is removed from consideration .
A vote on the resolution resulted as follows :
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilwoman
Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley , aye . Carried unanimously .
Councilman Klein - I was under the impression Holly Beermann
resigned from the Youth Commission ?
Supervisor Valentino - That was from the Youth Bureau Board .
Councilman Klein - Then there is another name in the resolution
which is not complete .
Mrs . Noteboom - The Commission bylaws stipulate that one of the
Board members must be appointed as a representative . They will be
reviewing the bylaws for revision however at this time we must
abide by those bylaws .
25
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
Supervisor Valentino - I am looking for a volunteer . For tonight
we should get Holly Beermann appointed as she will assume the
responsibilities of the chair .
Councilman Klein - Should we then strike " Council
Supervisor Valentino - Yes , for now .
Councilman Klein - I do not understand why Sally Alario ' s title is
Account Clerk Typist . I thought she was the Assistant Budget
Officer and I thought $ 37 , 000 for an Account Clerk Typist does not
seem to be the right description .
Mrs . Noteboom - I will try to explain it as best I can .
Attorney Barney - This should be discussed in Executive Session .
If you begin to talk about specific employees then it should be
done in Executive Session .
Councilman Klein - The salary is public knowledge .
Attorney Barney - Yes the salary is public information however the
reason this is done this way may or may not be .
Supervisor Valentino - It is actually Civil Service .
Mrs . Noteboom - There is no Civil Service title for Assistant
Budget Officer . The only test she could take which would qualify
her closely as possible to the work she performs on a day to day
basis was Principal Account Clerk Typist . That is the title of the
exam she took .
Supervisor Valentino - It was also the non - competitive exam .
Mrs . Noteboom - She was the only one which took the promotional
exam for that title .
Councilman Klein - That is crazy . It just does not make any sense .
Supervisor Valentino - A lot of the Civil Service does not make a
lot of sense to us but in order to have her in the system and have
that job , this is the way it worked out with Civil Service . I can
tell you Civil Service is happy with us and we have made it work .
Councilman Klein - In other words , the exam fits her position ? She
has a lot of responsibilities and the title seems to be totally off
the wall .
Supervisor Valentino - None of the Civil Service exams fit exactly
what people do .
26
I
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
Councilman Klein - Is this State ? Could we ask them to change the
title ?
Mrs . Noteboom - They will not do it . We have asked them to do it
on several other titles and they said absolutely not . They did say
we could name people what ever we want internally but for Civil
Service purposes these are the titles we must use .
Supervisor Valentino - In house , she is the Assistant Budget
Director , for Civil Service she is a Principal Account Clerk
Typist .
Councilman Klein - It does not make any sense to me which is why I
raised the question . Let ' s hope it does not set a precedent for
future typists .
Mrs . Noteboom - This is the highest level of Civil Service for a
Principal Account Clerk . The typist does not come in to play .
This is more of an accounting position .
Councilwoman Russell - This is the highest level of salary for that
position ?
Supervisor Valentino - No . The salaries we put on our positions
are internal to us . The County has nothing to do with the salaries
we apply to any job title or classification . That is an in - house
decision for us . We set up our own classification last year .
Mrs . Noteboom - The three testing . levels they would have for
municipal accounting offices are Account Clerk , Senior Account
Clerk/ Typist , and Principal Account Clerk / Typist . We already have
one individual classified as an Account Clerk/ Typist . One is a
Senior Account Clerk and Sally took the promotional exam to be the
Principal Account / Typist .
Resolution No . 21 ( a ) : Adopting the said minutes as the official
minutes of the Ithaca Town Board for the regular meeting held
December 11 , 1995 , December 29 , 1995 and January 8 , 19960
Resolution No . 21 ( b ) : Authorizing the payment of said vouchers as
numbered and listed for the Town of Ithaca .
. in the attached 1995
Resolution No . 21 ( c ) Approving and adopting
budget amendments .
Resolution No . 21 ( d ) : Approving and adopting the said report as
the official Quarterly Investment Report for the Town of Ithaca for
the period October 1 , 1995 through December 31 , 19950
27
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
Resolution No . 21 ( e ) : Approving and adopting the said report as
the official 1995 Annual Investment Report of the Town of Ithaca .
Resolution No . 21 ( f ) - 1 : Authorizing the payment of said vouchers
as listed .
Resolution No , 21 ( f ) - 2 : Authorizing the attached Southern Cayuga
Lake Intermunicipal Water Commission Year End Closing Transfers to
the 1995 Operating Budget .
Resolution No . 21 ( g ) : Approving and authorizing the attendance of
Sally Alario at the GFOA Annual Conference at a cost not to exceed
$ 600 . 00 .
Resolution No . 21 ( h ) : Approving the attendance of Andrew Frost at
the Finger Lakes Building Officials 1996 Educational Conference at
a cost of $ 407 . 00 .
Resolution No . 21 ( i ) Authorizing the Town of Ithaca Spring brush
and leaf pick up starting April 15 , 1996 and commencing until
completed .
Resolution No 21 ( 1 ) • Ratifying the approval of attendance of
Robert Strosnider and Timothy Eighmey to the Annual Cornell
Turfgrass Management Short Course at a cost not to exceed $ 800 . 00
for each person attending .
Resolution No , 21 ( k ) : Appointing Holly Beermann to serve as the
Town of Ithaca Representative on the Joint Youth Commission for a
term of office commencing immediately through December 31 , 1997 .
Resolution No . 21 ( 1 ) : Appointing Phillip P . Zarriello to serve as
Chair of the Town of ithaca Conservation Board for the term of
January 1 , 1996 through December 31 , 1996 ,
Resolution No . 21 ( m ) : Appointing Lois Levitan and Melinda Boyar to
serve on the Town of Ithaca Conservation Board for the terms
January 1 , 1996 through December 31 , 19970
Resolution No . 21 ( n ) : Appointing Laura McClellan and Max Pensky as
member of the Town of Ithaca Ethics Board for terms of offices of
February 12 , 1996 through December 31 , 1999 and February 12 , 1996
through December 31 , 2000 respectively .
Resolution No . 21 ( 0 ) : Appointing Phillip P . Zarriello to serve as
the Town of Ithaca representative on the Tompkins County
Environmental Management Council for the term January 1 , 1996
through December 31 , 1996 .
28
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
Resolution No . 21 Appointing Councilman John Wolff as a member
of the Town of Ithaca Data Processing Committee for the year 1996 .
Resolution No . 21 Ratifying the appointment of Suzanne Bordoni
as Court Clerk: at $ 9 . 95 per hour for 15 hours per week .
Resolution No . 21 ( r ) : Appointing Sally Alario to the position of
regular full time Principal Account Clerk Typist effective
retroactive to the civil service notification from Tompkins County
Personnel , dated January 4 , 1996 .
Resolution No . 21 ( t ) : Appointing Richard Tenkate , Motor Equipment
Operator effective February 12 , 1996 with an 8 week probationary
period ending April 8 , 1996 .
Resolution No . 21 ( u ) : Approving the creation of additional job
classifications as indicated in the attached resolution .
Resolution No . 21 ( v ) : Establishing the duties and responsibilities
of the Deputy Town Clerk ' s of the Town of ithaca to be the same as
prescribed in Town Law and General Municipal Law for the Town Clerk
in the absence! of the Town Clerk .
Resolution No . 21 w Adopting the Revised Drug and Alcohol Policy
for the Town of Ithaca .
Resolution No , 21 ( x ) : Approving participation in the Cornell
University CIV'ITAS Work Study Program for the year 1996 at a cost
not to exceed $ 4 , 000 . 000
Resolution No . 21 ( y ) : Authorizing and approving a water bill
refund of $ 36 . 91 on account T - 1432 located at 1430 ha.nshaw Rod to
Robert Silver .
Resolution No . 21 ( z ) Authorizing reimbursement of $ 1. 17 . 04 to Mr .
Kenny Wells for the expenses he incurred to correct a sewer lateral
blockage .
Resolution No . 21 ( aa ) Approving the quarterly payment of $ 1 , 474
to the Coddington Rod Community Center .
Agenda Item No 20 Consider Setting Public Hearing Date to
Deliberate Modification of the SLUR and Extension of Time for
Construction for Ithacare :
Mr . Kanter - The Planning Board adopted the statement of findings
for the Ithacare Environmental Impact Statement at their January
23rd meeting . On February 6th , the Planning Board approved a
preliminary site plan or a variation of the building from the
original proposal , called Alternative B - 3 . In order to carry the
29
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
alternative to final site plan approval , it is necessary to modify
the SLUR that was . applied to the Ithacare site back in early 1994 .
That is why the public hearing is needed and with the Planning
Boards preliminary approval of the site plan , they recommended
modifying the SLUR . The second part is there was a January 13 ,
1994 Town Board resolution which indicated if construction had not
substantially commenced by February 1 , 1996 , the entire SLUR should
be revisited to determine whether it is still appropriate for the
site and area .
Attorney Barney - The need for the public hearing is needed for
modifying the SLUR however I do not believe a public hearing is
needed on the resolution whether or not you choose to extend the
construction time per the resolution of 1994 .
Mr . Kanter - If it is decided to continue the SLUR , I believe that
would require rewording the SLUD provision ,
Attorney Barney - At the time the SLUR was adopted there was some
discussion of making an automatic sunset provision in the SLUR
language itself . I resisted that as you are supposed to rezone and
zone and according to the Comprehensive Plan this was something
that is not automatically if it is used for some other use . It was
inconsistent with the fact that the Town is supposed to be
functioning under a Comprehensive Plan . There was a separate
resolution passed which says we will take another look at it and if
we do not like what we see or if the project is not completed at
that point the Town might want to consider rezoning .
That is a resolution and as such only requires another resolution
without a public hearing . If the Town approves a modification of
the SLUR the Town would implicitly approve the extension of the
time to do the construction . None of us at the time anticipated a
years worth of litigation which has ultimately caused the process
to be slowed down considerably . I do not care if the public
hearing is held or not however I am not sure you want to invite
comments on that particular issue . That would be a Board decision .
I would recommend a public hearing only on the modification of the
SLUR .
Resolution No . 26 : Motion made by Councilman Klein , seconded by
Councilman Conley authorizing and directing the Town Clerk to
advertise for a public hearing to be held at the regular meeting of
the Town Board on March 11 , 1996 at 7 : 00 p . m . in order that the
Town Board may consider modification of the Ithacare SLUR .
A vote on the resolution resulted as follows :
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilwoman
Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
30
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
Councilman Conley , aye . Carried unanimously .
Agenda Item No 16 - Consider Ap-po ;ntment of Acting Deputy
Supervisor During Absence of Town Supervisor and Deputy Supervisor :
Resolution No , 23 : Motion made by Councilman Wolff , seconded by
Councilwoman Russell appointing Councilman Klein as Acting Deputy
Town Supervisor for the period of February 18 to February 21 , 1996
during the absence of the Town Supervisor and Deputy Supervisor and
be it further Councilman Klein shall be empowered with all duties
and responsibilities as may be imposed as Deputy Town Supervisor by
Town Law , General Municipal Law , and Public Officers law and
further authorized to sign checks on behalf of the Town of Ithaca
and the Southern Cayuga Lake Intermunicipal Water Commission .
Councilman Klein - I will need to come in and sign a signature card
then , correct -'
Mrs . Noteboom - My understanding is as long as the bank receives a
copy of this resolution that will not be necessary .
Attorney Barney - In that case I would recommend adding a specific
RESOLVED , authorizing Councilman Klein to sign checks on behalf of
the Town of Ithaca and the Southern Cayuga Lake Intermunicipal
Water Commission .
A vote on the amended resolution resulted as follows :
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilwoman
Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley , aye . Carried unanimously .
Supervisor Valentino - When we did the resolution for the
Association of Towns , there was also one designating me as the
delegate and Councilwoman Grigorov as the alternate delegate .
Mrs . Noteboom - We did that last month . This resolution
provisionally approves the resolutions and authorizes you to vote
in that manner on behalf of the Town .
Agenda Item No 17 Consider Setting Work Session Date to Discuss
1996 Priorities Work Plan :
Supervisor Valentino - Every year when we get around to talking
about the priorities for the year and trying to get our work
schedule done we have a whole Town Board Meeting where we spend a
great deal of time working on those issues and not being able to
think about our priorities and setting realistic expectations of
what we can achieve . I would like to suggest setting a working
session Board Meeting on March 4 , 1996 at 5 : 30 p . m . We will
31
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
advertise it as a Work Session for our 1996 Priorities Work Plan .
A_crenda Item No . 19 - Consider Setting Public Hearing Date for
Capital Project Related to the SCLIWC Master meter Agreement and
possible Bonding for Same :
Mr . Walker - The plans have been completed and the agreement re -
drafted . The cost to the Town has gone up to about $ 105 , 000 due to
some added contingencies and engineering costs . The net cost to
the Town will be the same at approximately $ 85 , 000 .
Mrs . Noteboom - $ 82 , 945 , right ?
Mr . Walker - One of the Commissioners had not had an opportunity to
review the revised agreement with their attorney so they deferred
approval until the next meeting . All the other Commissioners were
in favor .
Resolution No . 25 : Motion made by Councilman Klein , seconded by
Councilwoman Russell authorizing and directing the Town Clerk to
advertise for a public hearing to be held at the regular meeting of
the Town Board on March 11 , 1996 at 6 : 30 p . m . in order that the
Town Board may consider an agreement for a capital project with the
Southern Cayuga Lake Intermunicipal Water Commission for the
installation of master meters on transmission lines , issuance of
bonds for the same and execution of an agreement to participate in
such project , all at a
$ 100 , 0000 maximum cost to the Town of Ithaca of
A vote on the amended resolution resulted as follows :
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilwoman
Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley , aye . Carried unanimously .
Mr . Walker - We have done more descriptive work on the project and
I know some have had questions on it and I have reviewed it with
Councilman Klein . We have photos of all the sites and information
on the buildings . If anyone has questions , I will be glad to
discuss them with you .
Agenda Item No 21 - Discussion of the Six Mile Creek Conservation
District :
Mr . Kanter - Based on discussions with Supervisor Valentino , our
intent this evening is to provide the Board with materials and
information to enable you to review the status of the proposal . We
will have a more in depth discussion on the issue at the March 11 ,
1996 Town Board meeting .
32
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
This has gone through approximately a year and a half of
discussions through various committees . Those discussions resulted
in a joint meeting of the Planning Committee and the Codes and
Ordinances Cormnittee in December 1995 to try and work out the
details of the proposal . The draft you have before you is the
culmination of the year and a half ' s work and the consensus for a
new zoning district , which would cover the majority of the Six Mile
Creek Valley . There is a boundary map with the materials . One of
the issues discussed throughout the process not resolved at
present , is where the boundary , particularly on the Coddington Road
side , should be . There are two alternate proposals on the map and
one of the things the Town Board can give some direction on . Once
the Town Board has a chance to discuss them , it will then be
forwarded to the Planning Board for the public hearing process .
Councilwoman Grigorov - Two of us on the Planning Committee have
a conflict of :interest and therefore we will not be voting on this
I
ssue .
Supervisor Valentino . - We should be prepared to discuss this issue
at the March 11 , 1996 meeting .
Councilwoman G-rigorov - Bear in mind this is our first proposed
conservation zone and we are preparing to do others . I would like
this to be as acceptable as possible to the people .
Mr . Kanter - Would it be appropriate to send this proposal out in
its current form to the public affected in that area ?
Supervisor Valentino - Yes . The more we keep the people informed ,
the better .
Acrenda Item N :) 22 Consider AloAroval of Agreement with NYS
Department of Transportation To Provide Federal Emergency Relief :
Mr . Noteboom - This is in reference to Stone Quarry Road , which is
on our federal highway system . The Federal Government will
reimburse us 1008 on the repair of that road estimated at
approximately $ 30 , 000 .
If we go over the $ 30 , 000 we would need to negotiate another
agreement with NYSDOT . The revenue account should be changed on
the original resolution to DB4589 . 000 which is a separate revenue
account for FEMA aid .
Mrs . Noteboom - Isn ' t the FEMA Aid the Federal Aid ?
Mr . Noteboom - Yes . But this is an agreement with New York State .
Mr . Noteboom - That is correct however it will be coming from the
33
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
Federal Government .
Attorney Barney - I would like to see added a sentence authorizing
the Town Supervisor to make changes in the agreement as necessary
before the agreement is executed .
Resolution No . 27 : Motion made by Councilwoman Grigorov , seconded
Supervisor Valentino approving the execution of the agreement as
amended , between the FHWA and the Town of Ithaca for emergency
relief funds for Stone Quarry Road in substantially the form
submitted to this meeting with such changes therein as the Town
Supervisor may approve .
A vote on the amended resolution resulted as follows :
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilwoman
Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley , aye . Carried unanimously .
Agenda Item No 23 - Consider R guest to NYS D 8artment of Parks
and Historic Preservation to Consolidate Tax Parcels :
Mr . Walker - As we have been going through the benefit assessment
process , we noticed that Buttermilk Falls and Treman State Park
have two parcels . Within the Town of Ithaca , 12 tax parcels for
Treman State Park are all exempt out of 35 parcels . This has led
to some confusion when assigning benefit assessment units as it is
all one entity we are sending the bills to however the water
services are on different tax parcels . Each time we bill an exempt
parcel for a special district we need to send the State special
notification over and above the tax bill . If we could consolidate
these parcels in to one , only one notification would need to be
sent to the State .
I spoke with Jessie Miller , Engineer for the State Parks in
Trumansburg , who indicated there should not be a problem with
consolidating the parcels . A written request from the Town Board
would be in order prior to his notifying Albany of our intent .
We may end up with a couple of tax parcels due to the properties
crossing tax parcel boundaries . Treman should not be a problem as
they are located within Section 34 however Buttermilk Falls is
located within several boundaries . I will check with the T . C .
Assessment Office to see how they wish to handle this . We can
extend parcels across parcel boundary maps . What we ultimately
would like to do is reduce the number of parcels as much as
possible .
Resolution No . 28 : Motion made by Supervisor Valentino , seconded
by Councilwoman Grigorov authorizing the Town Supervisor to request
34
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
that the NYS Department of Parks and Historic Preservation consider
consolidating contiguous tax parcels within the State Park
boundaries into a single tax parcel for each of the said parks .
A vote on the amended resolution resulted as follows :
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilwoman
Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley , aye . Carried unanimously .
Agenda Item No . 24 - Consider Aparoval to Rebuild Puma House at
Christopher Circle :
Mr . Walker - The pump house gained notoriety last year when we
began to clear the area . The pump station there presently is a
concrete block: building which is over 30 years old and in poor
condition . What we are proposing is a pole type structure , wood
frame and vinyl siding with insulation incorporated in to it . This
is a maintenance item we have been looking at for some time . The
reason it is coming before this Board is we have a quote from a
contractor for $ 11 , 700 to rebuild . We obtained three quotes from
different contractors with this one $ 5 , 000 less than the others . I
am asking for authorization from this board . No SEQR is required
as this is a :reconstruction project ; maintenance of an existing
structure .
Mr . Walker went on to explain the various repairs to be done to the
building .
Councilman Klein ON This should enhance the area .
Resolution No . 29 : Motion made by Councilman Klein , seconded by
Councilwoman Russell authorizing the expenditure of $ 11 , 770 and
accepting the proposal by Richard Lobdell Construction to provide
the said repairs to the Christopher Circle Water Tank and Pump
Station .
A vote on the :resolution resulted as follows :
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilwoman
Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley , aye . Carried unanimously .
Agenda Item No . 25 - Consider Approval of By - Laws for the County
Cable Commission :
Councilman Wolff - There are two resolutions before you . One is
the approval of` the by - laws of the Intermunicipal Cable Commission
of Tompkins County . The other is to specifically authorize the
Commission to negotiate on the Town of Ithaca ' s behalf and to
35
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
develop a model franchise agreement .
Many of the municipal franchise agreements are expiring and rather
than go through the process of individually making a franchise
agreement with each one there is something to be gained if
municipalities got together and negotiated with Time Warner Cable
to insure cable services are equally beneficial for all residents
of Tompkins County ,
Time Warner has not been cooperative with this Commission however .
They claim they are not specifically authorized to negotiate on our
behalf therefore we have the resolution before you authorizing the
Commission to negotiate on the municipalities ' behalf . Approval of
such resolution would not undermine our ability as a Town to reject
or approve what ever it is this T . C . Intermunicipal Cable
Commission recommends .
Attorney Barney - We went over these by - laws some time ago and
raised a number of issues . I see that many of the issues which
were raised at that time have not been addressed . Some of things
are relatively minor . Other areas I was and still am concerned
about is in the area of financing . The budget process is out of
synch with the Town ' s budget process so they will determine how
much the municipality will pay . The Town of Ithaca will be one of
the bigger payers and as such the budget they have does not come up
until the fourth quarter . You may be doing a budget at a time when
you will not know what your obligation is for this franchise .
Supervisor Valentino - We can get the budget numbers a head of time
however .
Councilman Klein - It is not that much money we are talking about .
Attorney Barney - You are agreeing to be levied whatever they levy .
There is no ceiling on what you will pay .
Supervisor Valentino - There is a ceiling of approximately $ 750 .
Attorney Barney - There is no limit they can charge you as I
recall from reading it .
Supervisor Valentino - I have some other questions regarding the
financing . In section D , where is states " such budget levy and any
amendments to either must be approved by a majority vote of the
total number of municipal representatives . No vote on a .proposed
budget levy may take place without one months prior notice of all
municipal representatives " . Wouldn ' t we as a Town Board have to
vote and approve any monies we would levy ?
Attorney Barney - If you are entering into an agreement you are
36
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
agreeing to be bound by these bylaws . The SCLIWC is a typical
example . We are agreeing to pay in advance and what ever the
budget commission assesses us . There are some limits on what can
happen .
Supervisor Valentino - Also in section 13 , on additional parties
they state " the commission may require that a municipality make a
reasonable contribution to expenses of the commission " .
Attorney Barney - Is there any room for modifying this agreement or
is it a take it or leave it situation ?
Supervisor Valentino - The last time I met with them it was a take
it or leave it situation however they may have changed their minds
since then .
Councilman Wolff - In the few meetings I have attended the issue
of changing the by - laws has not been mentioned at all . The issue
has been more focused on the .current draft of the franchise
agreement . There is an interest in having this Board approve the
other resolution due to time frames and Time Warner Cable is very
interested in getting this process under way . They seem to be
making an effort to deal with this commission in a legitimate way .
We do need to authorize that part at this time . It would not be a
problem to wait on approving the by - laws until I have had an
opportunity tc look into it further . I spoke with the Supervisor
recently and my understanding was we would be able to address the
other issues later . If that is not the case and there are enough
concerns raised we do not enter in to an agreement under the false
assumption that we will not have an opportunity to modify it .
Supervisor Valentino - We know what we are going to pay for the
first year as it is written in the agreement , so we could join .
Attorney Barney - Then you are committed to next year as it takes
one years notice to get out from under it . Once you join you know
you are committed for at least two years .
Councilman Klein - I would think all of the municipalities would be
as concerned about the expenses as we are .
Supervisor Valentino - The only ones who have not signed are
Freeville , Groton , Town of Ithaca and Danby .
Attorney Barney - Our firm represents Danby and Groton .
Supervisor Valentino - I agree with Councilman Wolff in that we
should show our " intent " to negotiate as a group . I would hope they
would take that as a show of good faith we are going to join as
soon as we resolve the concerns .
37
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
Attorney Barney - This Board could authorize payment however I
would wait until the by - laws concerns are addressed .
Councilman Wolff - I should have the issue resolved by the next
Town Board meeting .
Attorney Barney - The other thing which came up in previous
discussions was the interests of the various municipalities are not
exactly parallel . If you are a rural community usually the
paramount interest in the franchise is the expansion of the service
to as many people over as large an area as possible . The Town of
Ithaca ' s interest is not necessarily the same and would be more
concerned about public access . Is the model franchise going to
cover all kinds of concerns .
Councilman Wolff - They are trying to develop it in order for them
to address issues as much as possible . There is a type of
understanding among the municipalities that there are certain
things which will not be necessary . The real purpose of it is to
address those concerns which are shared . It might not be a perfect
process but in the interest of getting as much as we can out of it
there is a willingness to accommodate and compromise .
A base model franchise which each municipality would have an
addendum to has been discussed as well .
Supervisor Valentino - They are early in the process however that
has been discussed from the beginning .
Attorney Barney - The whole thing is up in the air since the
recently signed the deregulation bill .
Supervisor Valentino - The last time I spoke with Attorney Kent , we
went over the franchise and could not see where anything had
changed which would make us want to expedite a franchise agreement .
Time Warner is more interested and could be to our advantage for
negotiations .
Attorney Barney - What is the term of the agreement they are
proposing .
Supervisor Valentino - They still want a long term agreement .
Attorney Barney - It would not be in the best interest of the Town
to enter into any long term agreement at this time .
Councilman Wolff - I will move the resolution authorizing the
Tompkins County Intermunicipal Cable Television Commission to
negotiate a cable franchise agreement for the Town of Ithaca and
will withdraw the other resolution from consideration at this time .
38
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
Resolution No , 30 : Motion made by Councilman Wolff , seconded by
Councilman Conley authorizing the Tompkins County Intermunicipal
Cable Television Commission to negotiate with Time Warner Cable the
renewal of the Town ; s cable franchise , including conducting such
public hearings as the Commission deems appropriate , Reserving
however to the Town the ultimate approval , disapproval or amendment
of the franchise agreement so negotiated and further that the
Commission is authorized to obtain from Time Warner on behalf of
the Town such information as the Commission deems appropriate , and
this resolution shall be deemed specific instruction and direction
of the Town to Time Warner to provide such information as the
Commission as agent of the Town may request .
A vote on the resolution resulted as follows :
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilwoman
Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley , aye . Carried unanimously .
Additional Agenda Item No . 1 - 1996 Budget Amendments :
Mrs . Noteboom - The Town Board passed a resolution in October 1995
agreeing to pay $ 1 , 950 to the SPCA for cat control . This amount
was never encumbered to be paid in 1995 . We did not however have
a contract signed with them until after January 1996 . We need to
pay this amount at this time and it is not included in the 1996
budget thus requiring a budget amendment .
The second is the County informed us last year during the budget
process they would no longer be charging us for election expenses
and would add that amount to our tax warrant and charge it as a
" pennies " levy to the taxpayers . We did not budget this year for
this expense as it was to be levied on the warrant . We need more
money for the :special election . This is the first of what could be
two or three more transfer requests to cover the special election .
Councilman Klein - Why are you only asking for $ 500 ?
Mrs . Noteboom -• At this time , the quote we have from the printer to
print the supplies is $ 370 . We have budgeted for the inspectors
and custodians so I am hoping the postage and other necessities we
will need will only put us up to approximately $ 500 . We can come
back and ask for another budget amendment .
Councilman Klein - What about notices and mailings ?
Mrs . Noteboom - I hope the mailings will be covered and the
absentee and military ballots will be covered with $ 130 and the
notices I will use the press as much as possible as public
39
i
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
information notices and editorials to avoid any added expenses .
Councilman Klein - What if we want to do a mailing piece ?
Mrs . Noteboom - I will do one " official " notice .
Councilman Klein - In order to inform everyone about the project
one of the things we need to do is send out a newsletter on the
referendum and on the project .
Mrs . Noteboom - We had decided it would go in the newsletter and we
do have monies budgeted for a newsletter .
Councilman Klein - And will the newsletter go out before March
11th ?
Mrs . Noteboom - I doubt it . There is no way my department and I
are going to prepare for the referendum and do a newsletter . It
would be impossible .
Councilman Klein - Assuming Councilman Wolff and other interested
Councilpersons would put together a question and answer piece to
send out , we would have to send this out under the Town auspices .
Mrs . Noteboom - Then we would need more monies .
Councilwoman Grigorov - We have to do something . There has been
nothing available at the front desk .
Mrs . Noteboom - That is not true . We have had the schematic design
available .
Councilwoman Grigorov - The receptionist does not know about it
then . I asked her what she gives people when they ask about the
new town hall and she said we really do not have anything .
Mrs . Noteboom - We have been giving the schematic design out to
interested persons .
Supervisor Valentino - People have come to get copies and have had
communications with them . Most items were things to look at and
there was a summary they could take with them .
Councilwoman Grigorov - I was really surprised when she said there
was nothing .
Councilman Klein - We need to send something out to the residents
of the Town informing them with a factual description of the
project .
40 46
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
Mrs . Noteboom - I was hoping my fellow department heads would help
figure out the contents of the newsletter . We now have a listing
of all taxpayers in the Town from the tax roll and are able to make
labels from that listing . This was one good thing which came out of
the tax bill problems we had this year .
Mr . Walker - We do have a summary sheet from the architect we could
incorporate in the newsletter .
Councilman Klein - It has to go to all voters and not taxpayers .
Mrs . Noteboom - This would give us every tax parcel however which
is every residential property in the Town . If we go with the voter
registration :List for the Town it takes a great deal of time
crossing out the duplicate households .
Councilwoman Grigorov - What is the relationship between the number
of voters and the number of households ?
Mrs . Noteboom - There are about 4700 households and about 7 , 563
registered voters from the last election .
Attorney Barney - This includes a number of tenants as well .
Councilman Klein - Will it be sufficient enough to send it just to
the tax parcels ?
Councilman Wolff - There is a way to do it electronically . If we
have the data I could load it in my database and ask it to check
addresses and eliminate the duplicates .
Councilman Klein - Is it on a diskette ?
Mrs . Noteboom - Not at the moment . The Board of Elections nor the
Assessment Office sell it . We have asked them and that is why we
have not had it up until this point . The County has not been
cooperative is supplying us that information . The other thing I
was thinking of would be a half page ad in the Ithaca Journal
showing statistical and other information .
Councilman Klein - It is very important we get a newsletter out as
that could answer a lot of questions residents might have .
Mrs . Noteboom - Since the staff is supposed to be unbiased and to
follow directions from the Town Board , we could give the residents
a factual sheer. .
orney Barney - By law that is all you can give them .
41
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
Supervisor Valentino - We have to be very careful what we do give
them .
Councilwoman Grigorov - Wouldn ' t the ad in the paper be the same
thing ?
Mrs . Noteboom - The ad would show what it looks like , the location ,
square footage , number of offices and the cost and the amount to be
bonded without any questions and answers . You just want to say
these are the facts and this is what you will be voting on .
Councilman Klein - Have you seen the questionnaire we mailed out
recently ? Maybe the Attorney for the Town could read that to
determine if we could use that . I would like the Board to approve
some expenditure of funds unless we can take it out of newsletter
funds , to do a newsletter mailing as soon as possible .
Mrs . Noteboom - I would rather get a better handle on the cost
before we appropriate more than $ 500 .
Councilman Klein - Do you think the Board should formally approve
a mailing ?
Mr . Walker - You have the election supplies which is one thing . I
do not think you want to put the Town Board information into the
election supply line item in the budget .
Councilman Klein - Can we authorize the Town Clerk to prepare a
special newsletter to inform Town residents about the upcoming
referendum?
Mrs . Noteboom - That might be the only thing which would be on it
Resolution No . 32 : Motion made by Councilwoman Grigorov , seconded
by Councilwoman Russell approving and authorizing 1996 budget
amendments to increase A3520 . 400 Animal Control by $ 1 , 959 . 00 ,
increase A14509401 election Supplies $ 500 . 00 and decrease A1990 . 400
Contingent Account by $ 2 , 459 . 00 .
A vote on the resolution resulted as follows :
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilwoman
Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley , aye . Carried unanimously .
Supervisor Valentino - We should take the funds for this special
newsletter from the newsletter line . This will just be a special
newsletter .
42
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
Additional Acgenda Item No 2 - Informational Newsletter -
Referendum New Town Hall :
Councilwoman Grigorov - An explanation as to why we need a new Town
Hall should be explained in the newsletter as well .
Supervisor Valentino - We should review it before we mail it out to
insure we have not violated any law .
Mr . Walker - We could include the summary the architects did a
little over a 44,rear ago . I clearly states the number of people we
have serving the public in Town Hall and the amount of space needed
for that servilce . That is the basis for this whole project . If
use the needs :summary as a lead in and then the description of the
proposal as it came from the architect and the floor plans , that
should cover what it is we are proposing .
Councilman Klein - We should try and include some of the drawings
and then a fairly distilled fact sheet .
Attorney Barney - The piece sent out by David , John and Mary is too
much on the proponent side . The newsletter should be a little more
neutral .
Supervisor Valentino - We need to be sure we stay within the law .
We need to supply residents with only the facts .
Resolution No . 33 : Motion made by Councilman Klein , seconded by
Councilman Conley authorizing and directing the Town Clerk to
prepare and dio" tribute an informational newsletter regarding the
proposal and referendum for the new Town Hall to the residents of
the Town of Ithaca prior to the Special Election to be held on
March 12 , 1996 .
A vote on the resolution resulted as follows :
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilwoman
Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley , aye . Carried unanimously .
Councilman Wolff - I would like to make a recommendation that we
have some sort of public forum and debate with perhaps journalists
and media representatives and panelists to discuss the pros and
cons of the project . We could invite public input and comments on
the issue .
Councilman Klein - We could try the Public Access Television
station possibly .
43
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
Agenda Item No . 27 - Consider Contract with Westinghouse Electric
Corporation to Remove and Dispose of Electrical Transformers at
Pearsall Place Pump Station :
Resolution No . 31 : Motion made by Councilman Wolff , seconded by
Councilman Conley authorizing the expenditure of a maximum of
$ 4 , 000 for the removal of the said electrical equipment and accepts
the proposal by Westinghouse Electric Corporation to remove and
properly dispose of the said equipment for the estimated cost of
$ 3 , 350 .
A vote on the resolution resulted as follows :
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilwoman
Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley , aye . Carried unanimously .
The Town Board took a 15 minute break at 9 : 15 p . m .
The Town Board resumed at 9 : 24 p . m .
Agenda Item No . 26 - EXECUTIVE SESSION :
Motion made by Supervisor Valentino , seconded by Councilwoman
Grigorov to move in to Executive Session to discuss personnel and
potential litigation . Carried unanimously . The Board began
Executive Session at 9 : 24 p . m .
Motion made by Councilman Wolff , seconded by Councilwoman Russell
to resume regular session . Carried unanimously . The Board resumed
regular session at 10 : 22 p . m .
As a result of the Executive Session the following resolutions were
passed .
Attorney Barney - I would like to request a resolution be passed by
this Board authorizing the Town Attorney to institute the
proceedings for an injunction against the individual discussed in
Executive Session .
Resolution No . 34 : Motion made by Councilman Wolff , seconded by
Councilman Conley authorizing and directing the Attorney for the
Town to institute the proceedings for an injunction against the
individual discussed during the Executive Session .
A vote on the resolution resulted as follows :
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilwoman
Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff , aye ; Councilman Klein , abstain ( due
to possible conflict of interest ) ; Councilman Conley , aye . Carried
44
TBM 2 / 12 / 96
unanimously .
Resolution N•o . 35 : Motion made by Councilwoman Grigorov , seconded
by Councilman Wolff authorizing and directing the Town Supervisor
to enter into an agreement of settlement of any claims whatsoever
for unemployment compensation or otherwise with the individual
employee discussed in Executive Session .
A vote on the resolution resulted as follows :
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilwoman
Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley , abstain . Carried unanimously .
Agenda Item No . 29 - Adjournment :
As there wa :; no further business to come before the Town Board a
motion was made by Councilman Wolff , seconded by councilwoman
Russell to ELdjourn . Carried Unanimously ,
The Supervisor adjourned the meeting at 10 : 20 p . m .
Respectfully submitted ,
()' oan Lent Noteboom
Town Clerk/ Director of
Administrative Services
* * * Next Regular Meeting - March 11 , 1996 @ 5 : 30 p . m .
* * * Minutes 'Cranscribed by Betty F . Poole
45
OF 1 T�
F TOWN OF ITHACA
1 126 EAST SENECA STREET , ITHACA , N . Y . 14850
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273- 1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No . 3
Resolution to Urge the Public Service Commission to Rehear
Issue of Need for Proposed NYSEG Pipeline
Resolution No . 16
WHEREAS , New York State Electric and Gas Corporation (NYSEG ) on March 14 ,
1995 filed an application for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public
Need for the Seneca Lake Storage Project and Gas Transmissions Facilities ; and
WHEREAS , the prime route for the east line of the transmission facilities passes
through the town affecting two (2 ) land parcels in the Town of Ithaca ; and
WHEREAS , a Metering and Regulating station would be located in the Town at the
junction of the CNG line ; and
WHEREAS , on February 21 , 1995 , NYSEG mailed a notice to parties it identified as
interested in thEl project stating that "the proposal will be subject to extensive analysis
and a series of public hearings " and "after the hearings are concluded , the PSC will
decide whether the proposed facilities should be built . . . " , and
WHEREAS , NYSEG filed a motion on March 14 , 1995 to bifurcate the required PSC
review of the project into two phases , Phase 1 of which would address the Salt Cavern
Storage Facility , the west pipeline routing , and the "public need " for the project , with
Phase 2 addressing the routing of the gas line from the Town of Ithaca to the Town of
Union ( in Broome County) ; and
WHEREAS , Administrative Law Judge Jeffrey Stockholm approved the "unopposed"
motion to bifurcate the proceedings on May 8 , 1995 ; and
WHEREAS , the public statement hearings on the east line routing were held after
the official record on the issue of public need had been closed , denying affected
residents the opportunity to testify on this issue ; and
TB Res . # 16/ 1996
Page 2 .
WHEREAS , Chapter 272 of the laws of the State of New York , 1970 , creating the
Article VII review process for such transmission facilities sets forth in Section 1 of this
Chapter the legislative intent as follows : "the legislature hereby declares that it shall be
the purpose of this act to provide a forum for the expeditious resolution of all matters
concerning the location of. . . gas transmission facilities . . . in a single proceeding to which
access will be open to citizen groups , municipalities , and other public agencies to
enable them to participate in these decisions" ; and
WHEREAS , the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca believes that affected residents
have been denied their due process rights pursuant to Article VII of the public service
law; now therefore be it
RESOLVED , that the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca strongly urges the Public
Service Commission to approve the petition for rehearing on the issue of public need
so that interested residents may have an opportunity to provide relevant testimony.
MOVED : Councilman Wolff SECONDED : Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff , aye . Motion
carried unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
CFlp
TOWN OF ITHACA
' 126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA , N . Y . 14850
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273- 1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item 6
Town Officials 1995 Annual Reports
Resolution No. 17
WHEREAS , the following Town of Ithaca Officials have presented their 1995 Annual
Reports to the Town Board for their review and approval ; and
WHEREAS , the Town Board has reviewed and accepted the said 1995 Annual
Reports; now therefore be it
RESOLVED , that the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca does hereby accept and
approve for permanent filing the 1995 Annual Reports of the following town of Ithaca
Officials .
HIGHWAY SUPERINTENDENT
DIRECTOR OF ENGINEERING
DIRECTOR OF PLANNING
DIRECTOR OF BUILDING AND ZONING
HUMAN RESOURCE SPECIALIST
ASSISTANT BUDGET OFFICER
MOVED : Councilwoman Grigorov
SECONDED : Councilman Conley
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov, aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley , aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff, aye . Carried
unanimously.
DATED : February 12, 1996
0"" -k qLt
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
4� OF I r
F _ TOWN OF ITHACA
�- 126 EAST SENECA STREET , ITHACA, N . Y . 14850
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273- 1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No, 9
SEAR: Local Law Providing for Additional Levels
of Income Eligibility for the Partial Tax Exemption
for Real Property Owned by Persons with Limited
Incomes Who are 65 Years of Age or Over
Resolution No . 18
WHEREAS , this action is the adoption of a local law providing for additional levels
of income eligibility for the partial tax exemption for real property owned by persons
with limited incomes who are 65 years of age or over; and
WHEREAS , this is an unlisted action for which the Town of Ithaca Town Board is
legislatively determined to act as Lead Agency in environmental review with respect to
the enactment of local laws ; and
WHEREAS , the Town Board , at a public hearing held on February 12 , 1996 , has
reviewed and accepted as adequate the Short Environmental Assessment Form , Parts I
and II for this action ;
RESOLVED , that the Town of Ithaca Town Board hereby makes a negative
determination of environmental significance in accordance with the New York State
Environmental Quality Review Act for the above referenced action as proposed and ,
therefore , neither a Full Environmental Assessment Form , nor an Environmental Impact
Statement will be required .
MOVED : Councilman Klein SECONDED : Councilman Wolff
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff , aye . Motion
carried unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
Q" L - M&"'
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
i
OF 1p
_ TOWN OF ITHACA
126 EAST SENECA STREET , ITHACA , N . Y. 14850
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273- 1704
Town Board Meeting 2/ 12/96
Agenda Item No . 10
Enactment Local Law = Additional Levels of Income Eligibility
Persons With Limited Incomes 65 Years of Age or Older .
Resolution No , 19
WHEREAS , the properly advertise public hearing has been held to consider a ,
LOCAL LAW PROVIDING FOR ADDITIONAL LEVELS OF INCOME ELIGIBILITY FOR
THE PARTIAL TAX EXEMPTION FOR REAL PROPERTY OWNED BY PERSONS
WITH LIMITED INCOMES WHO ARE 65 YEARS OF AGE OR OVER now therefore
be it
RESOLVED , the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca does hereby enact Local Law
No . 1 /1996 a , "LOCAL LAW PROVIDING FOR ADDITIONAL LEVELS OF INCOME
ELIGIBILITY FOR THE PARTIAL TAX EXEMPTION FOR REAL PROPERTY OWNED
BY PERSONS WITH LIMITED INCOMES WHO ARE 65 YEARS OF AGE OR OVER
and be it further
RESOLVED , the Town Clerk is hereby authorized and directed to advertise and file
the said local law as required by Town Law.
MOVED : Councilman Conley SECONDED : Councilwoman Grigorov ..
Roll Call Vote : Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov, aye ; Councilman
Klein , aye ; Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff,
aye . Carried unanimously .
DATED : February 12 , 1996
Q"" - la�
/ .QAc4ir►�
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
4� OFIp
_ TOWN OF ITHACA
IL 21 126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA, N . Y. 14850
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273-1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No . 12
Authorization to Hold Public Hearing Second Phase
1996 Small Cities Community Development Block Grant Application
Resolution No , 20
WHEREAS , the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca has expressed interest in having
Tompkins County prepare a Small Cities Community Development Block Grant (CDBG)
application on behalf of the Town of Ithaca by hold the first of two public hearings
related to the said application on February 12 , 1996 ; and
WHEREAS , it is* necessary that the Town of Ithaca conduct two public hearings to
meet the HUD public participation process involved in applying for the CDBG funds;
now therefore be it
RESOLVED , that the Town Clerk is hereby authorized and directed to advertise for
a public hearing to be held at the regular meeting of the Town Board on March 11 ,
1996 , at 6 : 45 p. m . , in order that the Town Board may meet the HUD requirements for
the public participation process involved in applying for the Small Cities Community
Development Block Grant .
MOVED : Councilman Klein
SECONDED : Councilman Wolff
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov, aye; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye; Councilman Wolff, aye . Carried
unanimously.
DATED: February 12 , 1996
C 1� js�,� r
loan Lent Nateboom , Town Clerk
4� OF 1p
TOWN OF ITHACA
126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA , N . Y. 14850
� Y
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273-1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No , 14(a)= 14 (aa)
Consent Agenda Items
Resolution No . 21 (a) -21 (r) , 21 (t)-21 (aa)
BE IT RESOLVED , that the Town Board of the Town of It ca hereby ap �oves
and/or adopts the Consent Agenda Item resolutions number a) througl1l' 1) ,
14(m ) - 14(q) , 14(1:) - 14 (aa) as presented ; items 14 (k) and 14 (r) are approved as
amended . Item 614 (s) is removed from consideration .
MOVED: Councilwoman Grigorov
SECONDED : Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov, aye ; tCouncilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff, aye. Carried
unanimously.
DATED: February 12 , 1996
c,ofC AVcll-vim
foanLent Noteboom , Town Clerk
4� ofIp
F 9 TOWN OF ITHACA
126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA , N . Y . 14850
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273-1704
Town Board Meeting 2/ 12/96
Agenda Item No . 14 (a)
Town Board Meeting Minutes
Resolution No. 21 (a)
WHEREAS , the Town Clerk has presented the Town Board meeting minutes for the
regular meeting held on December 11 , 1995 , the close out meeting held December 29 ,
1995 , and for the regular meeting held January 8 , 1996 to the Town Board for their
review and approval ; and
WHEREAS , the Town Board has reviewed the said minutes and approved them as
written ; now therefore be it
RESOLVED , the Town Board does hereby adopt the said minutes as the official
minutes of the Ithaca Town Board for the regular meeting held December 11 , 19959
December 29 , 11395 , and January 8 , 1996 .
MOVED : Councilwoman Grigorov
SECONDED : Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff, aye . Carried
unanimously.
DATED: February 12 , 1996
Joan Lent NotE!boom , Town Clerk
OF 1p
_ _ 9 TOWN OF ITHACA
1 126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA , N . Y. 14850
Y
Ov-
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273- 1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No . 14 (b)
Town of Ithaca Warrants
Resolution No , 21 (b)
WHEREAS , the following numbered vouchers have been presented to the Ithaca
Town Board for approval of payment ; and
WHEREAS , said vouchers have been audited for payment by said Town Board ; now
therefore be it
RESOLVED , that the Ithaca Town Board hereby authorizes the payment of said
vouchers .
General Townwide -Vouchers : No . 3 , $20 , 103. 50 ; No . 4 , $23 , 679 . 55 ; No . 5 , No . 685-68 ,
$ 10 , 358 , 14 ; No . 6=63 , No . 685-687 , $31 , 364 , 77 ,
General Outside Village Vouchers : No . 2 , $ 17 , 506 . 41 ; No . 3 , $204 . 12 ; No . 4 ,
$ 14 , 102 . 34; No . 5 , $4, 429 . 54; No . 6-32 , $7 , 286 . 27 ; No . 280 , $334 . 08 .
Highway Vouchers : No . 1 , $ 17 , 926 . 21 ; No . 2 , $ 16 , 722 . 64 ; No . 3 , $5 , 041 . 60 ; No . 375 ,
$306 .24 ; No . 443 , $27 , 068081 .
Lighting District Vouchers : No . 3 , $82 . 47 ; No . 1 , 2 , 4 , $596 . 15 .
Water District Vouchers : No . 1 , $64 , 560 . 63 ; No . 2 , $ 1 , 145 . 83 ; No . 3 , $ 1 , 512 . 57 ; No. 4 ,
$ 130 . 03 ; No . 51814 , No . 226 , $26 , 064. 84 ; No . 225 , $27 . 840
Sewer District Vouchers : No . 1 , $58 , 830 . 00 ; No . 2 , $ 1 , 144 . 46 ; No . 3 , $ 1 , 605 . 20 ; No . 4 ,
$ 100 . 82 ; No . 5•• 18 , $8 , 316. 72 ; No . 191 , $27 . 840
Capital Projects : No . 46 , $$ 11634 . 97 .
MOVED : Councilwoman Grigorov
SECONDED : Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov, aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley , aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff, aye. Carried
unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
4� OF 1 P�
9 TOWN OF ITHACA
126 EAST SENECA STREET , ITHACA , N . Y. 14850
� Y
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273- 1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No, 14©
1995 Budget Amendments
Resolution No . 21 ©
WHEREAS , there were certain expenditures that are now over extended in the 1995
budget; and
WHEREAS , it was necessary to make the proper budget amendments prior to
closing the 1995 books; now therefore be it
RESOLVED , that the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca hereby approves and
adopts the attached 1995 budget amendments .
MOVED: Councilwoman Grigorov
SECONDED : Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov, aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye; Councilman Wolff , aye. Motion
carried unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
1995 BUDGET AMENDMENTS - WATER FUND
F83409480 Trans & Distr CE 91 , 030 . 53
F8340 . 470 Trans & Distr CE 42 , 166 . 68
F8350 . 472 Common Wtr Supp 311 , 269 . 72
F599 Appropriated FB 48 , 070 . 75
492 , 537 . 68
F8350 . 472 Common Wtr Supply 102 , 690945
F8350 . 473 Common Wtr Supply 29 , 776 . 10
F9010 . 800 State Retirement 148 . 32
F9055 . 800 Disability 9 . 78
F9710 . 610 Serial Bond Prin 255 , 174 . 30
F9710 . 710 Serial Bond Int 56 , 095 . 42
F99010900 I / F Transfer 48 . 643 . 31
492 , 537 . 68
1995 BUDGET AMENDMENTS - SEWER FUND
G8120 . 480 Trans & Distr CE 1 , 108 . 03
G8120 . 200 Trans & Distr E 949 . 93
G9010 . 800 St . Retirement 148 . 32
G9055 . 800 Disability 9 , 78
1 , 108 . 03
1995 BUDGET AMENDMENTS - LIGHTING DISTRICTS
SL2404 Int . \ Earn E . wood Com 422990
SL2407 Int . \ Earn Burleigh 10080
SL2409 Int . \ Earn Cod Rd 280 . 98
714 . 68
SL5182 . 404 E . wood Commons 422 . 90
SL5182 . 407 Burleigh Drive 10 . 80
SL5182 . 409 Coddington Rd . 280 , 98
714 . 68
1995 BUDGET AMENDMENTS - CAPITAL PROJECTS
H5730 Proceeds of Oblig . 108 , 354 . 56
H5031 I / F Trans 572956
108 , 927 . 12
H8120 . 221 Inlet Valley 41 . 20
H8120 . 225 W . Haven Rd 14 , 477 . 42
H9901 . 900 I / F Trans 93 , 835 . 94
H8340 . 225 Troy / Cod Rd 572 . 56
108 , 927 . 12
1995 BUDGET AMENDMENTS - GENERAL TOWNWIDE FUND
ACCOUNT NAME DEBIT CREDIT
A1110 . 100 Justice PS 91217 . 37
A1110 . 403 Justice CE . 901e56
A1330 . 100 Tax Collection PS 487 . 44
A1340 . 400 Budget Officer CE 378 . 66
A1410 . 100 Town Clerk PS 2 , 205 . 10
A1430 . 100 Personnel PS 7 , 011 . 48
A1430 . 400 Personnel CE 7 . 46
A1620 . 100 Buildings PS 108 . 50
A1670 . 411 Shared Services CE 21084 . 06
A5010 . 200 Hwy . Superintendent E 318979
A5132 . 200 Hwy . Garage E 7 . 00
A5132 . 412 Hwy . Garage CE 1 , 819 . 84
A7140 . 401 Cod . Rd . Com Ctr CE 467 . 00
A7320 . 404 Youth Recreation CE 5 , 152 . 12
30 , 166 . 38
A1990 . 400 Contingency 10 , 048 . 09
A1330 . 400 Tax Collection CE 2 , 340 . 00
A1420 . 400 Attorney CE 1 , 000 . 00
A1450 . 403 Election Chg CE 16 , 778 . 29
30 , 166 . 38
1995 BUDGET AMENDMENTS - GENERAL OUTSIDE VILLAGE
B1990 . 400 Contingency 161281 . 42
B1420e400 Attorney CE 71871 . 73
B8010 . 100 Zoning PS 5 , 303 . 07
B80209100 Planning PS 1 , 487 . 65
B9010 . 800 St . Retirement 11385 . 13
B9055 . 800 Disability 233 . 84
16 , 281 . 42
1995 BUDGET AMENDMENTS - HIGHWAY FUND
DB5142 . 102 Snow Removal PS 8 , 710 . 00
DB9060 . 800 Medical Ins 12 . 43
8 , 722 . 43
DB5142 . 452 Snow Removal CE 8 , 556 . 51
DB9040e800 Workers Comp 15 . 08
DB9055 . 800 Disability 150 . 84
8 , 722 . 43
4zyOFlp
9 TOWN OF ITHACA
21 4$ 126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA , N . Y. 14850
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273-1704
Town Board Meeting 2/ 12/96
Agenda Item No , 14 (d)
Quarterly Investment Report, 10/1 /95 - 12/31 /95
Resolution No . 21 (d)
WHEREAS , the Quarterly Investment Report for the months October 1 , 1995
through December 31 , 1995 has been presented to the Town Board for their review,
now therefore be it
RESOLVED, that the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca hereby approves and
adopts the said report as the official Quarterly Investment Report for the Town of Ithaca
for the period October 1 , 1995 through December 31 , 1995 ,
MOVED : Councilwoman Grigorov
SECONDED: Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye; Councilman Wolff , aye . Carried
unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
4� OF1r
_ 9 TOWN OF ITHACA
04}. 126 EAST SENECA STREET , ITHACA, N . Y . 14850
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-5035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273- 1704
Town Board Meeting 2/ 12/96
Agenda Item No . 14 (e)
1995 Annual Investment Report
Resolution No . 21 (e)
WHEREAS , the 1995 Annual Investment Report of the Town of Ithaca has been
presented to the Town Board for their review; and
WHEREAS , the Town Board has discussed and reviewed the said report; now
therefore be it
RESOLVED , that the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca does hereby approve and
adopt the said report as the official 1995 Annual Investment Report of the Town of
Ithaca .
MOVED: Councilwoman Grigorov
SECONDED : 000ncilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye; Councilman Wolff , aye . Carried
unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
fly OF Ir
a TOWN OF ITHACA
126 EAST SENECA STREET , ITHACA , N .Y . 14850
� Y
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273-1704
Town Board Meeting 2/ 12/96
Agenda Item No . 14 (f) , ( 1 )
Bolton Point Warrants
Resolution No . 21 (f) , 1
WHEREAS , the following numbered vouchers have been presented to the Ithaca
Town Board for approval of payment; and
WHEREAS , said vouchers have been audited for payment by said Town Board ; now
therefore be it
RESOLVED , that the Town Board hereby authorizes the payment of said vouchers .
i
Operating Fund Vouchers : No . 830-9031 $54 , 693 . 530
MOVED : Councilwoman Grigorov
SECONDED : Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff , aye . Carried
unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
Joa Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
4� OFIp
F a TOWN OF IPTHACA
126 EAST SENECA STREET , ITHACA , N . Y . 14850
� Y
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273-1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No . 14 (f) , (2)
Bolton Point Budget Year End Closing Transfers
1995 Operating Budget
Resolution No . 21 (f) , 2
BE IT RESOLVED , the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca does hereby authorize
the attached Southern Cayuga Lake Intermunicipal Water Commission Year End
Closing Transfers to the 1995 Operating Budget .
MOVED: Councilwoman Grigorov
SECONDED: Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov, aye; Councilman Klein , aye;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff, aye . Carried
unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
Lanz Irz: q?, 6
Joan Lent NOtElboom , Town Clerk
FEE- 12- 1 'l 11 : 4 .3 FRIUM SCl at 30LTON POINT TO 27.31704 P801
Southern Cayuga Lake
lntermunicipai Water Commission
Year End Closing Transiefs
t0 the
1995 Operating Budget
Trani Appropriation Lines
Amount From Une To Line
$1 ,200 .00 8310.460 In4-4ouse Training 8310.405 Auditor Attanol
i
$325, 00 8310.410 Office Supplies 8310.411 Printing and Postage
$216.00 831 0.410 Office Supplies 8310.437 Data Processing
$1 , 100600 8340. 102 Dist. Overtime ILS40. 101 Dist. Persona! Svc,
$60.00 8340.201 Dist. Equipment 8340.212 ToolVil p. Pw4; a Supplies
$1 .607.100 OCAO . 800 Health lnsurwice X10,800 State Retirement
9320 . 101 qfr, 4
Fax Nof2 7671 Fe�as�
7b ' From
Ip
?Rena 3 ?bane K �
rax * ra,c r, I
Jill
�7 Vim .
TOTAL R , 131
�zy OF 1T�
F a TOWN OF ITHACA
21 04� 126 EAST SENECA STREET , ITHACA , N . Y. 14850
Y
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273- 8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273- 1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda No . 14 (g)
Attendance GFOA Conference
Resolution No . 21 (g)
WHEREAS , the Government Finance Officers' Association is holding its Annual
Conference in Albany, March 27-29 , 1996 and
WHEREAS , this conference gives valuable information on investment options and
risks , financial reporting , GASB updates , and more ; and
WHEREAS , the Principal Account Clerk Typist wishes to attend this conference as
she feels it will increase her knowledge of accounting practices ; now therefore be it
RESOLVED , the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca does hereby approve and
authorize the attendance of Sally Alario at the GFOA Annual Conference , March 27-
29 , 1996 at a cost not to exceed $600 . 00 and to be charged to account A13400400 .
MOVED : Councilwoman Grigorov
SECONDED : Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov, aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff, aye. Carried
unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
OF 1p
TOWN OF ITHACA
126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA , N . Y. 14850
� Y
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273-1704
Town Board Meeting 2/ 12/96
Agenda Item No . 14(h )
Building Inspector/Zoning Enforcement Officer
Conference Attendance
Resolution No . 21 (0 )
WHEREAS , Andrew Frost , Building/Inspector Zoning Enforcement Officer has
requested that he attend a four day conference entitled , " Finger Lakes Building
Officials 1996 Educational Conference" , at the Marriott Thruway Hotel , Rochester, New
York from March 25 through March 28 , 1996 at a cost of $407 . 00 ; and
WHEREAS , attendance at this seminar will be beneficial in the performance of Mr.
Frost' s duties as Building Inspector/Zoning Enforcement Officer. It is also a New York
State requirement for continuing education and training ; now therefore be it
RESOLVED , that the Town of Ithaca Town Board hereby approves the attendance
Buildin onin
to be paid from
' r at a cost of $407 . 00 , 92 9
of Andrew Frost at said seminar p
Department Account No . B8010 . 4031
MOVED : Councilwoman Grigorov
SECONDED: Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye;
Councilman Conley, aye; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff, aye . Carried
unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
4� OF 1p
TOWN OF ITHACA
,p� n
Oil 4� 126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA, N . Y . 14850
A Y
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
- FAX (607) 273-1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No , 14(I )
Annual Cornell Turfgrass Management Short Course
Resolution No . 21 (1 )
WHEREAS , Robert (Jerry) Strosnider and Timothy Eighmey are employed by the
Town of Ithaca and attended the Eleventh Annual Cornell Turfgrass Management Short
Course at Cornell University; and
WHEREAS , the Highway Superintendent and the Park and Open Space Manager
felt attendance at this course benefitted the Town by _ expanding Mr. Strosnider's and
Mr. Eighmey's abilities within their job classification ; and
WHEREAS , the Cornell Turfgrass Management Short Course ran for two weeks
starting on January 8 , 1996 , with a fee of $600 . 00 for each person attending ; now
therefore be it
RESOLVED , that the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca does hereby ratify the
approval of attendance of Robert Strosnider and Timothy Eighmey to the above said
course through Cornell University; and be it further
RESOLVED , that the cost of attending the said seminar shall be expended from
account B7140 . 402 , and shall not exceed $800 . 00 for each person attending including
meals and travel expenses .
MOVED : Councilwoman Grigorov SECONDED : Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff, aye . Carried
unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
4� OF 1p
F 9 TOWN OF ITHACA
' 126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA, N . Y. 14850
�► Y
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273-1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No. 140)
Brush and Leaf Pick Up
Resolution No . 21 (j)
WHEREAS , the Highway Department provides yard refuse disposal services for
Town of Ithaca residents; and
WHEREAS , twice annually the Highway Department collects brush and leaves from
the roadsides ; now therefore be it
RESOLVED , that starting April 15 , 1996 , and commencing until completed , will be
the dates when the Highway Department will pick up brush and bagged leaves for
residents in the Town of Ithaca .
MOVED : Councilwoman Grigorov
SECONDED : Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye; Councilman Wolff, aye . Carried
unanimously.
DATED: February/ 12 , 1996 n
��Arcrirr�.
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
4� OF I T�
a TOWN OF ITHACA
1 126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA, N . Y. 14850
� Y
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273- 1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No. 14(k)
Joint Youth Commission Appointment
Resolution No . 21 (k)
WHEREAS , there exists a vacancy for a Town of Ithaca Representative on the Joint
Youth Commission ; and
WHEREAS , Holly Beermann , Ithaca , New York has expressed an interest in serving
as the Town representative to the said Commission ; and
WHEREAS , -the Operating Guidelines for the Joint Youth Commission require a
member of the Town Board also be appointed to serve on the said Commission ; now
therefore be it
RESOLVED , that the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca hereby appoints Holly
Beermann to serve as the Town of Ithaca Representative on the Joint Youth
Commission for a term of office commencing immediately upon adoption of this
resolution through December 31 , 1997 , and be it further
RESOLVED , the Town Clerk is authorized and directed to forward a certified copy of
this resolution to Holly Beermann , the Joint Youth Commission , and the Tompkins
County Board of Representatives . -
MOVED : Councilwoman Grigorov
SECONDED : Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff , aye . Carried
unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
OF 1 P�
9 TOWN OF ITHACA
4� 126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA , N . Y . 14850
�j ,( o
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273- 1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No , 14 (I)
Appointment of Conservation Board Chair
Resolution No , 21 (1)
BE IT RESOLVED , the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca hereby appoints Phillip P .
Zarriello to serve as Chair of the Town of Ithaca Conservation Board for the term of
January 1 , 1996 through December 31 , 1996 ,
MOVED : Councilwoman Grigorov
SECONDED : Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye;
Councilman Conley , .aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff, aye. Motion
carried unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
OF IV
E a TOWN OF ITHACA
1 126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA, N . Y . 14850
Y
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273- 1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No . 14(m )
Appointment of Conservation Board Members
Resolution No . 21 (m )
BE IT RESOLVED , the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca hereby appoints the following
individuals to serve on the Town of Ithaca Conservation Board for the terms of office
indicated :
Lois Carol Levitan January 1 , 1996 = December 31 , 1997
Melinda G . Boyar January 1 , 1996 - December 31 , 1997
MOVED : Councilwoman Grigorov
SECONDED : Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov, aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye; Councilman Wolff, aye . Motion
carried unanimously.
DATED : Februar/ 12 , 1996
an Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
OFIp
TOWN OF ITHACA
�`_ 4� 126 EAST SENECA STREET , ITHACA , N . Y . 14850
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273-1704
Town Board Meeting 2/ 12/96
Agenda Item No . 14 (n)
Appointments Ethics Board
Resolution No . 21 (n)
WHEREAS , the Interviewing Committee interviewed Laura McClellan and Max
Pensky on February 8 , 1996 for the two vacant positions on the Town of Ithaca Ethics
Board ; and
WHEREAS , the Interviewing Committee has recommended the appointment of Ms .
McClellan and Mr. Pensky to the Ethics Board ; now therefore be it
RESOLVED , the Town Board of the town of Ithaca does hereby appoint Laura
McClellan , 132 Woolf Lane , Ithaca , New York; and Max Pensky, 171 Bundy Road ,
Ithaca , New York as members of the Town of Ithaca Ethics Board for the term of office -
indicated below .
Laura McClellan Term : February 12 , 1996 - December 31 , 1999
Max Pensky Term : February 12 , 1996 - December 31 , 2000
MOVED: Councilwoman Grigorov
SECONDED : Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff, aye . Carried
unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
J., a ,
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
4�y OF Ip
TOWN OF ITHACA
n 4� 126 EAST SENECA STREET , ITHACA, N . Y . 14850
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273-1704
Town Board Meeting 2/ 12/96
Agenda Item No . 14(o)
Appointment of Tompkins County Environmental
Management Council Representative
Resolution No . 21 (o)
BE IT RESOLVED , the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca hereby appoints Phillip P .
Zarriello to serve as the Town of Ithaca representative on the Tompkins County
Environmental Management Council for the term of January 1 , 1996 through December
31 , 1996.
MOVED: Councilwoman Grigorov
SECONDED : Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff, aye . Motion
carried unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
JOCf Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
4� OF 1 P�
F TOWN OF ITHACA
126 EAST SENECA STREET , ITHACA, N . Y. 14850
� Y
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273-1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No. 14(p)
Appointment Data Processing Committee
Resolution No . 21 (p)
WHEREAS , Town Supervisor, Catherine Valentino has determined she will be
unable to attend the Automated Data Processing Committee meetings due to her busy
schedule ; and
WHEREAS , Councilman John Wolff has expressed an interest in being a member of
the said committee because of his interest in computer technology; now therefore be it
RESOLVED , the Town Board does hereby ratify the Town Supervisor' s appointment
of Councilman John Wolff as a member of the Town of Ithaca Data Processing
Committee for the year 1996 .
MOVED : Councilwoman Grigorov
SECONDED : Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff, aye . Carried
unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
a�a� - Ec U�
loan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
OF 1p
F 9 TOWN OF ITHACA
1
126 EAST SENECA STREET , ITHACA , N . Y . 14850
�
� Y
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273-1704
Town Board Meeting 2/ 12/96
Agenda Item No , 14(q)
Appointment Town Justice Court Clerk
Resolution No. 21 (q)
WHEREAS , Raymond Bordoni , Town Justice has appointed Suzanne Bordoni , 400
Teton Court, Ithaca , New York to serve as his Court Clerk retroactive to January 1 ,
1996 ; and
WHEREAS , the position of Court Clerk is an exempt status class position pursuant
to Section 41 of the Civil Service Law , and the Tompkins County Civil Service
Regulations ; and
WHEREAS , in keeping with the said Civil Service Law the Town Board must ratify
the appointment of Mrs . Bordoni as Court Clerk; now therefore be it
RESOLVED , that the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca does hereby ratify the
appointment of Suzanne Bordoni as Court Clerk at $9 . 95 per hour, for 15 hours per
week, charged to account All 10 , 100 , Benefits are limited to the part time status of the
position .
MOVED: Councilwoman Grigorov
SECONDED : Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye; Councilman Wolff , aye. Carried
unanimously .
DATED : February 12 , 1996
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
4� OF I T�
F TOWN OF ITHACA
21 044- 126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA , N . Y. 14850
A Y
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273- 1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No . 14 (r)
Regular Appointment Principal Account Clerk Typist
Resolution No . 21 (r)
WHEREAS , Sally Alario has worked for the Town of Ithaca provisionally as Principal
Account Clerk Typist; and
WHEREAS , Ms . Alario has successfully completed the promotional examination
requirement to be considered a regular full time employee rather than a provisional full
time employee; now therefore be it
RESOLVED , the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca does hereby appoint Sally Alario
to the position of regular full time Principal Account Clerk Typist effective retroactive to
the civil service notification from Tompkins County Personnel , dated January 4, 1996 ;
and be it further
RESOLVED , an eight week probationary period shall apply retroactive to the civil
service notification from Tompkins County Personnel , dated January 4, 1996; and be it
further
RESOLVED , the wage for the said position shall be $37 , 775 . 00 for the year 1996 .
Full time benefits apply .
MOVED : Councilwoman Grigorov
SECONDED : Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye; Councilman Wolff, aye . Carried
unanimously .
DATED : February 12 , 1996
Q." la . x
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
OF 1p
9 TOWN OF ITHACA
� 04� 126 EAST SENECA STREET , ITHACA , N . Y. 14850
W Y
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273-1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No, 14(t)
Appointment Motor Equipment Operator
Resolution No . 21 (t)
WHEREAS , the resignation of a Motor Equipment Operator has left a vacancy in the
Highway Department for the position ; and
WHEREAS , the Highway Superintendent believes there are qualified candidates to
fill this position within the Town of Ithaca Highway Department itself; and
WHEREAS , based upon the recommendation of the Public Works Committee and
the Highway Superintendent, Richard Tenkate possesses the appropriate license ,
skills , and qualifications ; and
WHEREAS , Richard Tenkate has worked for the Town of Ithaca since July 6 , 1993
and has performed his duties as Laborer in an exemplary manner; now therefore be it
RESOLVED , the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca does hereby appoint Richard
Tenkate , Motor Equipment Operator effective February 12 , 1996 , an eight (8) week
probationary period applies ending April 8 , 1996 ; and be it further
RESOLVED , the hourly wage for the said position shall be $9 . 00 per hour. Full time
benefits apply.
MOVED : Councilwoman Grigorov SECONDED : Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff , aye . Carried
unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
r Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
4� OF 1p
F 9 TOWN OF ITHACA
n oS4 126 EAST SENECA STREET , ITHACA , N . Y . 14850
� Y
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273-1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No . 14 (u )
Creation of Additional Civil Service Classifications
Resolution No . 21 ( u )
WHEREAS , Civil Service Law allows for there to be additional vacant Civil Service
Classifications available for certain positions which have a history of high turnover, or
when there is a need to hire persons under unusual circumstances; and
WHEREAS , a study by the Highway Superintendent , Town Clerk/Director of
Administrative Services , and Human Resource Specialist, and upon recommendation of
the Town Supervisor, it is believed the addition of these vacant Civil Service
Classifications would be beneficial to the Town by eliminating unnecessary paperwork,
and eliminating the need for the Town Board to approve the classification for these
positions prior to appointment of the individual ; now therefore be it
RESOLVED , the Town Board does hereby approve the creation of the following
additional job classifications :
(4) Heavy Equipment Operators : Non- competitive class .
(2 ) Motor Equipment Operators : Non- competitive class .
( 1 ) Senior Typist : Competitive Class .
( 1 ) Keyboard Specialist : Competitive class
MOVED : Councilwoman Grigorov SECONDED : Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff, aye . Carried
unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
OF1r
_ TOWN OF ITHACA
2' 126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA , N . Y. 14850
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273-1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No, 14(v)
Assignment Duties and Responsibilities = Deputy Town Clerk' s
Resolution No, 21 (v)
WHEREAS , the Town of Ithaca has requested that the New York State Civil Service
Agency classify the two positions of Deputy Town Clerk as exempt; and
WHEREAS , the Town of Ithaca has been notified by the New York State Civil
Service Agency, through the Tompkins County Personnel Department that the Town
Board must establish the duties and responsibilities of the Deputy Town Clerk's in
order to have those positions considered for exemption under Civil Service ; now
therefore be it
RESOLVED , the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca does hereby ,establish the duties
and responsibilities of the Deputy Town Clerk' s of the Town of Ithaca to be the same as
prescribed in Town Law and General Municipal Law for the Town Clerk, in the absence
of the Town Clerk,
MOVED : Councilwoman Grigorov
SECONDED : Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff, aye . Carried
unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
4jy OF I r�
TOWN OF ITHACA
,t,� 04� 126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA , N . Y. 14850
� Y
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273- 1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No. 14(w)
Adoption Revised Drug and Alcohol Policy
Resolution No . 21 (w)
WHEREAS , the adopted Drug and Alcohol Policy needed some revisions ; and
WHEREAS , the changes have been made under the advisement of the Attorney for
the Town ; now therefore be it
RESOLVED, that the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca adopt this policy as the
revised drug and alcohol policy for the Town of Ithaca.
MOVED: Councilwoman Grigorov
SECONDED : Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov, aye; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff, aye. Motion
carried unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
Joan Lent Noieboom , Town Clerk
i
4� OF 1 T�
TOWN OF ITHACA
1 126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA, N . Y. 14850
� Y
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273-1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No . 14(x)
Participation Cornell CIVITAS Work Study Program
Resolution No . 21 (x)
WHEREAS , the Engineering , Planning , and Highway Departments have budgeted
funds to cover the cost of having student interns and have traditionally participated in
the Cornell University Work Study Programs . to provide students with valuable work
experience while receiving valuable technical support from the students to the Town of
Ithaca; and
WHEREAS , the CIVITAS program provides student interns at a cost to the town of
15 % to 25% of the full employment expense for these students ; now therefore be it
RESOLVED , that the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca does hereby approve
participation in -the Cornell University CIVITAS Work Study Program for the year 1996 ,
at a cost not to exceed $4, 000 . 00 , charged to account A1440. 406 Engineer CIVITAS
Students , and a cost of $720 . 00 transferred from account B8020 . 110 Student Interns ,
and charged to account B8020 . 410 CIVITAS Interns ; and a cost not to exceed
$29100. 00 transferred from account DB5110, 100 Highway General Repair Personnel ,
and charged to account DB5110 . 406 CIVITAS Interns .
MOVED : Councilwoman Grigorov
SECONDED : Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff, aye . Carried
unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
Joan Lent Noleboom , Town Clerk
4zy OF IT�
TOWN. OF IPTHACA
126 EAST SENECA STREET , ITHACA, N .Y. 14850
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273-1704
Town Board Meeting 02/12/96
Agenda Item No. 14(y)
Water Bill Refund
Resolution No . 21 (y)
WHEREAS , Robert Silver sold his home and after a final meter reading there was a
credit balance on his water account , therefore be it
RESOLVED , that the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca does hereby authorize and
approve a water bill refund of $36. 91 on Account #T- 1432 located at 1430 Hanshaw Road
to Robert Silver, PO Box 193 , Woods Hole , Ma, 02543 .
MOVED: Councilwoman Grigorov
SECONDED : Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov, aye; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley , aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff, aye . Motion
carried unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
4� OF ITS .
_ TOWN OF ITHACA
n 126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA, N . Y. 14850
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273-1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No. 14(z)
Sewer Repair Reimbursement
Resolution No . 21 (z)
WHEREAS , the sewer lateral at 723 Five Mile Drive became plugged due to Town
of Ithaca water main construction activities ; and
WHEREAS , the owner, Mr. Kenny Wells , incurred out of pocket costs to correct the
blockage and has requested reimbursement to cover the costs in the amount of
$ 117 . 04 ; now therefore be it
RESOLVED , that the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca does hereby authorize
reimbursement of $117. 04 to Mr. Kenny Wells for the expenses he incurred to correct
the said sewer lateral blockage. Funds to cover the reimbursement are to be expended
from account number F8340. 470 .
MOVED : Councilwoman Grigorov
SECONDED : Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye; Councilman Wolff, aye . Motion
carried unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
4� OF I7V
_ TOWN OF ITHACA
n 4 126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA , N . Y. 14850
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273-1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No. 14 (aa)
Approval Quarterly Payment to Coddington Road Community Center
Resolution No . 21 (aa)
WHEREAS , the Coddington Road Community Center has requested that the Town
of Ithaca Town Board authorize and approve a quarterly payment in the amount of
$ 1 , 474. 00 to them because they are running low on funds to operate ; and
WHEREAS , the Town of Ithaca has budgeted $9 , 013 . 00 in its 1996 Budget to make
payments to the Coddington Road Community Center for the services it provides town
residents through the year, and through its Summer Program ; now therefore be it
RESOLVED , the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca does hereby approve the
quarterly payment of $ 1 , 474 . 00 to the Coddington Road Community Center.
MOVED : Councilwoman Grigorov
SECONDED : Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov, aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff, aye . Carried
unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
4� OF1r
9 TOWN OF ITHACA
126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA, N . Y. 14850
� Y
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273-1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No. 15
Association of Towns 1996 Resolutions
Resolution No . 22
BE IT RESOLVED , that the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca provisionally
approves the Association of Towns 1996 Resolutions , but hereby instructs the Town 's
Delegate , Catherine Valentino and Alternate Delegate , Carolyn Grigorov to exercise
discretion in voting based upon any information that may be provided during the floor
discussions of the resolutions at the Association of Towns Annual meeting February 18
to February 21 , 1996 ,
MOVED : Councilman Wolff
SECONDED: Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov, aye ; Councilman Klein , aye;
Councilman Conley, aye; Councilwoman Russell , aye; Councilman Wolff, aye. Carried
unanimously.
DATED: February 12 , 1996
Aa T
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
OF IT�
TOWN OF ITHACA
2ml04� 126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA , N . Y. 14850
� Y
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273- 1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No . 16
Appointment Acting Deputy Town Supervisor
Resolution No , 23
WHEREAS , Town Supervisor, Catherine Valentino and Deputy Town Supervisor,
Carolyn Grigorov will be attending the NYS Association of Towns Annual Meeting in
New York City, New York from February 18 to February 21 , 1996; and
WHEREAS , it is necessary that the Town Board appoint a Deputy Town Supervisor
to act during their absence while attending the said meeting ; now therefore be it
RESOLVED , the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca does hereby appoint
Councilman David Klein as acting Deputy Town Supervisor for the period February 18
to February 21 , during the absence of the Town Supervisor and Deputy Supervisor;
and be it further
RESOLVED , as said Deputy Town Supervisor, Councilman Klein shall be
empowered with all duties and responsibilities as may be imposed as Deputy Town
Supervisor by Town Law, General Municipal Law , and Public Officers Law ; and be it
further
RESOLVED , Councilman Klein is hereby authorized to sign checks on behalf of the
Town of Ithaca and the Southern Cayuga Lake Intermunicipal Water Commission .
MOVED : Councilman Wolff SECONDED: Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov, aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff , aye . Carried
unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
C., Lk lq,- A- �,
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
qty OF 1T�
TOWN OF ITH ACA
l 126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA, N . Y. 14850
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273-1704
RESOLUTION : Agenda Item No . 18
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Resolution Establishing Time and Place of
Special Election on Proposition
Resolution No . 24
WHEREAS , the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca at a meeting duly called and
held on December 11 , 1995 , adopted a resolution authorizing the acquisition of land
and construction of a new Town Hall , authorizing the expenditure of funds from the
Town Building Reserve Fund for such purpose , and authorizing the issuance and sale
of serial bonds for the balance of the costs of such project , and
WHEREAS , said resolution was adopted subject to a permissive referendum ;
and
WHEREAS , a petition requesting a referendum was filed with the Town Board
on January 8 , 1996 ; and
WHEREAS , it appears that said petition was subscribed and authenticated in
accordance with law by a number of electors equally or exceeding, five percent of the
total votes cast for Governor in said Town at the last general election held for the
election of State! officers in November, 1994; and
WHEREAS , the aforesaid petition called for the submission to the voters of the
Town of Ithaca of a proposition approving the resolution of the Town Board referred to
above;
NOW, THEREFORE, be it
RESOLVED , as follows :
Section... A special election of the residents and taxpayers of the Town of
Ithaca is hereby authorized and directed to be held on the 12th day of March ,
1996 between the hours of 12 : 00 noon and 8 : 00 p . m , for the purpose of voting
by ballot on the proposition hereinafter set forth .
Res . No . 24/96
Page 2 .
Section 2 . The polling places at such election are hereby designated as follows:
Board of Cooperative Educational Services , 555 Warren Road , Ithaca, New
York,
Smith Building , for election districts Nos . 6 , 7, 8 and 9 .
Ellis Hollow Road Apartments , 1028 Ellis Hollow Road , Ithaca:, New York, 14850 ,
for election districts Nos . 4, 5 and 11 .
Ithaca Veteran Volunteer Fireman's Association Building , 638 Elmira Road ,
Ithaca , New York, for election districts Nos . 1 , 21 3 and 100
Section 3 . The notice of such special election shall be in substantially the
following form :
Legal Notice
NOTICE OF SPECIAL ELECTION
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that a Special Election of the residents and
taxpayers of the Town of Ithaca, Tompkins County, New York, will be held
in said Town on the 12th day of March , 1996 , at which the polls will be
kept open between the hours of 12 : 00 noon and 8 : 00 p . m . for the purpose
of voting upon the following proposition :
Proposition No . 1
Shall the resolution of the Town Board of the
Town of Ithaca authorizing the acquisition of
the premises at 119 West Court .Street , Ithaca,
New York and the construction thereon of a
new Town Hall at a cost not to exceed
$2 , 000 , 000 . 00 inclusive of land purchase
costs , said acquisition and construction to be
financed by the expenditure of all of the funds
in the Town Building Reserve Fund of
approximately $ 1 , 350 , 000. 00 , the issuance of
General Obligations Serial Bonds in the
amount of not more than $500 , 000 . 00 and the
balance from current funds , be approved ?
Res . No. 24/96
Page 3.
The polling places at such election will be as follows :
Board of Cooperative Educational Services , 555 Warren Road ,
Ithaca , New York, Smith Building , for election districts Nos. 6 , 79 8
and 9 .
Ellis Hollow Road Apartments , 1028 Ellis Hollow Road ,
Ithco3ca, New York, 14850 , for election districts Nos . 4 , 5 and
11 .
Ithaca Veteran Volunteer Fireman 's Association Building ,
638 Elmira Road , Ithaca , New York , for election districts
Nos . 1 , 29 3 and 10 .
All electors of the Town of Ithaca, Tompkins County, New York, who are
registered voters of the Town on February 16 , 1996 or with a registration
po%)tmarked no later than February 16 , 1996 and received by the Board of
Elections no later than February 21 , 1996 , shall be qualified to vote at
such Special Election .
By order of the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca.
Dated : February 12 , 1996
Ithaca , New York
Join Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
Section 4 . The Town Clerk is hereby ordered and directed to give notice of such
election by publication thereof in the Ithaca Journal , said publication to be at
least 10 days prior to the date of such Special Election , and by posting on the
signboard of said Town a copy of such notice at least ten days before such
Special Election .
Section 5 . The following resident taxpayers of said Town are hereby designated
to act as election inspectors and machine custodians as respectively indicated
below:
Election Inspectors for BOCES - Smith Building Velma Markwardt
Margaret Tollinger
Constance Thomas
Lori Chase
Res . No . 24/96
Page 4 .
Election Inspectors for Ellis Hollow Apartments A. Cecilia Linscott
Gertrude Gray
Janet Wilkinson
Gladys Hastings
Election Inspectors for Ithaca Veteran Volunteer John Pearson
Fireman ' s Association Building Ruth Pearson
Mary Robertson
Norma Stevenson
Machine Custodians Michael Mosely
Rob Doper
Section Ei. The Town Clerk is hereby ordered and directed to arrange for the
installation of voting machines at the above locations for use at said Special
Election , and also to prepare for the use of the election officials the necessary
oaths and certificates of election , ballot strip , and other materials , and also to
procure and deliver to such election officers any and all necessary
paraphernalia for the proper conduct of such election .
Section 7:. Absentee ballots and military ballots shall be issued upon application
no later than seven days prior to the election or otherwise in accordance with the
provisions of Town Law Section 84-a. Absentee ballots shall be returned to the
Office of the Town Clerk, no later than 5 : 00 p . m . March 12 , 1996 in order to be
counted . The Town Clerk shall , on the day of the election , transmit all absentee
ballots received by her to the appropriate election inspectors for processing as
set forth in Town Law Section 84-a.
Section This resolution shall take effect immediately.
MOVED : Councilwoman Grigorov SECONDED: Councilman Wolff
Roll Call Vote : Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ;
Councilman Klein , aye ; Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye;
Councilman Wolff, aye . Carried unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
OFIp
TOWN OF ITHACA
4t 21 0 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA , N . Y . . 14850
� Y
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273- 1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No, 19
Public Hearing Date : Capital Project
SCLIWC Master Meter Agreement
Resolution No, 25
BE IT RESOLVED , that the Town Clerk is hereby authorized and directed to
advertise for a public hearing to be held at the regular meeting of the Town Board on
March 11 , 1996„ at 6 : 30 p . m . , in order that the Town Board may consider an agreement
for a capital project with the Southern Cayuga Lake Intermunicipal Water Commission
for the installation of master meters on transmission lines, issuance of bonds for the
same , and execution of an agreement to participate in such project, all at a maximum
cost to the Town of- Ithaca of $ 100 , 0000
MOVED : Councilman Klein
SECONDED : Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff, aye . Carried
unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
0"" Lk T,
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
4� OF 1P
_ TOWN OF ITHACA
126 EAST SENECA STREET , ITHACA, N . Y . 14850
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273-1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No . 20
Public Hearing Date : Modification Ithacare SLUD
Resolution No, 26
BE IT RESOLVED , that the Town Clerk is hereby authorized and directed to
advertise for a public hearing to be held at the regular meeting of the Town Board on
March 11 , 1996 , at 7 : 00 p . m . , in order that the Town Board may consider modification
of the Ithacare SLUD .
MOVED : Councilman Klein
SECONDED : Councilman Conley
Supervisor Valentino , aye; Councilwoman Grigorov, aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff, aye . Carried
unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
OF I r�
E TOWN OF ITHACA
126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA, N . Y . 14850
� Y
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273- 1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No . 22
,Approval Agreement NYS Department of Transportation
to Provide Federal Emergency Relief
Resolution No . 27
WHEREAS , severe run off and flooding has created extensive damage to many of
the Town of Ithaca roadways , including Stone Quarry Road ; and
WHEREAS , Stone Quarry Road is on the Federal Highway System ; and
WHEREAS , the Town of Ithaca has applied for and been approved for relief under
the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) Emergency Relief Program ; and
WHEREAS, to receive the emergency funds , an agreement must be executed
between FHWA and the Town of Ithaca; and
WHEREAS , the Attorney for the Town has reviewed the said agreement; now
therefore be it
RESOLVED , that the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca approves the execution of
the agreement between the FHWA and the Town of Ithaca for emergency relief funds
for Stone Quarry Road in substantially the form submitted to this meeting with such
changes therein as the Town Supervisor may approve ; and be it further
RESOLVED , that the monies from this emergency relief will be entered into revenue
account DB45891 , FHWA Aide and the repairs will be expended from the D65110. 175
Disaster Relief Personnel Services and DB5110. 475 Disaster Relief Contractual ,
MOVED : Councilwoman Grigorov SECONDED : Supervisor Valentino
Supervisor Valentino , aye; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff, aye . Motion
carried unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996, _
Joad Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
4� OF 1P
_ TOWN OF ITHACA
126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA , N . Y . 14850
� 1a
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGIAWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273-1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No. 23
NYS Department of Parks and Historic Preservation
Consolidation of Tax Parcels
Resolution No . 28
WHEREAS , -the Town Engineer has recommended consolidating tax parcels within
Buttermilk Falls State Park and Robert Treman State Park; and
WHEREAS , the Town Engineer has discussed the possibility with the State Parks
staff who suggested consolidation could be considered if a request was made by the
Town Board; now therefore be it
RESOLVED , that the Town Board hereby authorizes the Town Supervisor to request
that the NYS Department of Parks and Historic Preservation consider consolidating
contiguous tax parcels within the State Park boundaries into a single tax parcel for
each of the said parks .
MOVED : Supervisor Valentino
SECONDED : Councilwoman Grigorov
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov, aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff, aye. Motion
carried unanimously.
DATED : Februarys 12 , 1996
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
OFIp
a TOWN OF ITHACA
1 126 EAST SENECA STREET , ITHACA , N . Y . 14850
� Y
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273-1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No , 24
Christopher Circle Water Tank and Pump Station
Resolution No . 29
WHEREAS , the Christopher Circle Pump House is a masonry building in excess of
30 years old in need of repairs to the exterior walls and roof; and
WHEREAS , the Town Engineer has developed plans to provide a new roof,
upgraded thermal insulation and a new exterior shell to repair and improve the building ;
and
WHEREAS , the Town Board has reviewed the proposed building design ; and
WHEREAS , the Town Engineer has solicited proposals from three contractors to
construct the improvement in compliance with Town Procurement Policies ; and
WHEREAS , the Town Engineer has determined that Richard Lobdell 's proposal to
build the pump station improvement for $ 11 , 770. 00 is a reasonable and responsible
proposal and recommends that the Town Board accept the said proposal ; now
therefore be it
RESOLVED , that the Town Board hereby authorizes the expenditure of $ 11 , 770 . 00
and accepts the proposal by Richard Lobdell Construction to provide the said repairs to
the Christopher Circle Water Tank and Pump Station . Funds to be expended from
account number F8340. 4861
MOVED : Councilman Klein SECONDED : Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff, aye . Motion
carried unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996 Arl� WON�
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
OF 1 P�
F _ 9 TOWN OF ITHACA
126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA , N . Y. 14850
_1 `1►�'� Y 04
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273- 1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No . 25
Authorization for Tompkins County Intermunicipal Cable Television Commission
to Negotiate Cable Franchise Agreement for Town of Ithaca
Resolution No . 30
WHEREAS , the Town of Ithaca ("the Town ") is provided cable service by Time
Warner Cable; and
WHEREAS , the Town recognizes the advantages of cooperation with other
municipalities with regard to cable franchise issues ; and
WHEREAS , the Tompkins County Intermunicipal Cable Commission has been
formed pursuant to Article 5-G of the New York General Municipal Law for the purpose
of advising municipalities on matters pertaining to cable television franchising and
service, and holding public hearings when and where appropriate , all in order to
promote the provision of quality cable television service at reasonable rates to the
residents of Tompkins County; and
WHEREAS , the Town is a member of the Tompkins County Intermunicipal Cable
Television Commission ; and
WHEREAS , every effort will be made to ensure that the ongoing work to renegotiate
a cable television franchise between Time Warner Cable and the Town will be
incorporated into the work of the Tompkins County Intermunicipal Cable Commission ;
now therefore be it
RESOLVED , that the Town does hereby authorize the Tompkins County
Intermunicipal Cable Television Commission ("the Commission ") to negotiate with Time
Warner Cable the renewal of the Town ' s cable franchise , including conducting such
public hearings as the Commission deems appropriate , Reserving however to the
Town the ultimate approval , disapproval or amendment of the franchise agreement so
negotiated ; and it is further
Res. No . 30/96
Page 2 .
RESOLVED„ that the Commission is hereby authorized to obtain from Time Warner .
on behalf of the Town such information as the Commission deems appropriate , and this
resolution shall be deemed specific instruction and direction of the Town to Time
Warner to provide such information as the Commission , as agent of the Town , may
request.
MOVED : Councilman Wolff
SECONDED : Councilman Conley
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye; Councilman Wolff, aye . Motion
carried unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
4� OF 1P
a TOWN OF ITHACA
4� 126 EAST SENECA STREET , ITHACA, N .Y . 14850
10
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273-1704
Town Board Meeting 2/ 12/96
Agenda Item No . 27
Pearsall Place Pump Station
Transformer Removal and Disposal Contract
Resolution No . 31
WHEREAS , three old transformers and an electrical switch have been stored in the
Pearsall Place pump station and must be removed and properly disposed of as a
hazardous waste; and
WHEREAS , the Town Engineer has received a proposal from Westinghouse
Electric Corporation to remove and properly dispose of the said equipment, and
Westinghouse Electric Corporation was the only firm willing to make . a proposal for this
operation ; now therefore be it
RESOLVED , that the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca hereby authorizes the
expenditure of a maximum of $4 , 000. 00 for the removal of the said electrical equipment
and accepts the proposal by Westinghouse Electric Corporation to remove and
properly dispose of the said equipment for the estimated cost of $3 , 350 . 00 . Funds to
be expended from account number F8340 . 486 .
MOVED : Councilman Wolff
SECONDED : Councilman Conley
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff, aye. Motion
carried unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
4� OF I r
_ 9 TOWN OF ITHACA
2 126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA , N . Y. 14850
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273-1704
Town Board Meeting 02/12/96
Additional Agenda Item No , 1
1996 Budget Amendments
Resolution No . 32
WHEREAS , the Town of Ithaca agreed to pay the Tompkins County SPCA $ 1959. 00
that would assist in covering a short fall of 1995 funds from the County and ,
WHEREAS , an agreement for payment of these funds was not executed until 1996
and therefore no accommodation was provided in the 1996 budget and ,
WHEREAS , the special election will cause additional unbudgeted expenses
estimated at $500 . 00 , but that could be even higher, therefore be it
RESOLVED , that the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca does hereby approve and
authorize 1996 budget amendments to increase A3520 . 400 Animal Control by
$ 1 , 959 . 00 , increase Al 450 . 401 Election Supplies $500. 00 , and decrease Al 9900400
Contingent Account by $2 , 459 . 004
MOVED : Councilwoman Grigorov
SECONDED : Councilwoman Russell
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov, aye; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff, aye . Motion
carried unanimously.
DATE : February 12 , 1996
/.
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
4zy OF 120
TOWN OF ITHACA
04$ 126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA, N .Y. 14850
Y
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273-1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item Additional No. 2
Informational Newsletter = Referendum New Town Hall
Resolution No . 33
BE IT RESOLVED , the Town Clerk is hereby authorized and directed to prepare and
distribute an informational newsletter regarding the proposal and referendum for the
new Town Hall to the residents of the Town of Ithaca prior to the Special Election to be
held on March 12 , 19968
MOVED : Councilman Klein
SECONDED : Councilman Conley
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye; Councilman Klein , aye,
Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell , aye; Councilman Wolff, aye. Motion
carried unanimously.
DATED : February 12 , 1996
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
OF Ir
TOWN OF ITHACA
126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA, N . Y. 14850
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273-1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No, 28
EXECUTIVE SESSION
Authorization to Institute Proceedings for Injunction
Resolution No, 34
BE IT RESOLVED , the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca does hereby authorize
and direct the Attorney for the Town to institute the proceedings for an injunction
against the individual discussed during the Executive Session .
MOVED: Councilman Wolff
SECONDED : Councilman Conley
Supervisor Valentino , aye ; Councilwoman Grigorov, aye ; Councilman Klein , abstain
(due to possible conflict of interest) ; Councilman Conley, aye ; Councilwoman Russell ,
aye ; Councilman Wolff, aye. Motion carried .
DATED: February 12 , 1996
7
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
I
41y OF I Thy
TOWN OF ITHACA
1
� 126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA, N . Y . 14850
Y
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273-1704
Town Board Meeting 2/12/96
Agenda Item No. 26
EXECUTIVE SESSION
Agreement Individual Employee
Resolution No , 35
BE IT RESOLVED , the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca does hereby authorize
and direct the Town Supervisor to enter into an agreement of settlement of any claims
whatsoever for unemployment compensation or otherwise with the individual employee
discussed in Executive Session .
MOVED : Councilwoman Grigorov
SECONDED : Councilman Wolff
Supervisor Valentino , aye; Councilwoman Grigorov , aye ; Councilman Klein , aye ;
Councilman Conley, abstain ; Councilwoman Russell , aye ; Councilman Wolff, aye .
Motion carried .
DATED : February 12 , 1996
Joan Lent Noteboom , Town Clerk
OF 1p
TOWN OF ITHACA FINAL
21
& 044- 126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA, N . Y . 14850
� Y
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273- 1704
TOWN BOARD MEETING
February 12 , 1996
5 : 30 p. m .
AGENDA
1 . Call to Order .
2 . Pledge of Allegiance .
3 . Reports of Town Officials :
a . Town Supervisor
b . Director of Engineering
c . Highway Superintendent
d . Director of Planning
e . Director of Building and Zoning
f. Town Clerk/ Director of Administrative Services
4 . Report of Town Committees .
5 . Review of Correspondence :
a . James and Phyllis Baker - New Town Hall .
b . NYSDOT - Route 366 at Judd Falls Road , Tower Road , Caldwell Road .
c . Rhonda Engman = Ithacare SLUD #7 .
d . Yervant Terzian - Flooding .
e . Lucile P . Macera - Flooding .
6 . Consider acceptance of 1995 Annual Reports of Town Officials .
7 , PERSONS TO BE HEARD ,
8 . 6 : 30 p . m . , PUBLIC HEARING - To consider a , " LOCAL LAW PROVIDING FOR
ADDITIONAL LEVELS OF INCOME ELIGIBILITY FOR THE PARTIAL TAX
EXEMPTION FOR REAL PROPERTY OWNED BY PERSONS WITH LIMITED
INCOMES WHO ARE 65 YEARS OF AGE OR OVER
TB Agenda 2/ 12/96
Page 2 .
9 , Consider SEAR related to a , " LOCAL LAW PROVIDING FOR ADDITIONAL
LEVELS OF INCOME ELIGIBILITY FOR THE PARTIAL TAX EXEMPTION FOR
REAL PROPERTY OWNED BY PERSONS WITH LIMITED INCOMES WHO ARE
65 YEARS OF AGE OR OVER
10 . Consider enactment of a , " LOCAL LAW PROVIDING FOR ADDITIONAL LEVELS
OF INCOME ELIGIBILITY FOR THE PARTIAL TAX EXEMPTION FOR REAL
PROPERTY OWNED BY PERSONS WITH LIMITED INCOMES WHO ARE 65
YEARS OF AGE OR OVER " .
11 . 6 : 45 p . m. , PUBLIC HEARING : To consider application on behalf of the Town of
Ithaca by Tompkins County for a Small Cities Community Development Block
Grant .
12 . Set Public Hearing date to consider the second phase of the application on behalf
of the Town of Ithaca by Tompkins County for a Small Cities Community
Development Block Grant .
13 . 7 : 00 P . M . , PRESENTATION : Saddlewood Farms .
14 , Consent Items : Consider resolution approving and/or authorizing the following :
a . Town Board Minutes - 12/ 11 /95 , 12/29/95 , 1 /8/96 .
b . TOWN OF ITHACA WARRANTS .
c . Town of Ithaca , 1995 Year End Budget Amendments .
d . Quarterly Investment Report .
e . 1995 Annual Investment Report .
f . BOLTON POINT WARRANTS .
g . Attendance Government Finance Officers Association Conference .
h . Attendance Code Enforcement Officials Annual Conference .
I . AttendancE) Annual Cornell Turfgrass Management Short Course .
j . Spring Brush and Leaf Pick Up Dates .
k . Appointments - Joint Youth Commission .
I . Appointment - Conservation Board Chair.
m . Appointments - Conservation Board .
n . Appointments - Ethics Board .
o . AppointmE� nt - Tompkins County Environmental Management Council .
p . AppointmEmt - Automated Data Processing Committee .
q . AppointmE, nt - Justice Court Clerk .
TB Agenda 2/ 12/96
Page 3 .
14, Consent Items - Cont' d :
r . Appointment - Permanent Status , Principal Account Clerk Typist.
s . Appointment Deputy Highway Superintendent.
t . Appointment - Highway Laborer to MEO .
u . Additional Civil Service Classifications .
v. Deputy Town Clerk' s - Assignment of Duties and Responsibilities .
w . Revisions Drug & Alcohol Testing Policy & Procedures .
x. Participation in CIVITAS program .
y. Water Billing Refund .
z. Sewer Repair Reimbursement .
aa . Coddington Road Community Center Quarterly Payment .
15 . Consider 1996 Resolutions of the Association of Towns of the State of New York ,
16 . Consider appointment of Acting Deputy Supervisor during absence of Town
Supervisor and Deputy Supervisor.
17 . Consider setting work session date to discuss 1996 Priorities Work Plan .
18 . Consider resolution setting date for referendum related to the acquisition of a new
Town Hall , and establish polling places and procedures related to same .
19 . Consider setting public hearing date for Capital Project related to the SCLIWC
Master Meter Agreement and possible bonding for same .
20 . Consider setting public hearing date to deliberate modification of the SLUD , and
extension of time for construction for Ithacare .
21 . Discussion of Six Mile Creek Conservation District ,
22 . Consider approval of agreement with NYS Department of Transportation , to provide
Federal EmE� rgency Relief .
23 . Consider request to NYS Department of Parks and Historic Preservation to
consolidate tax parcels .
24 . Consider approval to rebuild pump house at Christopher Circle .
25 . Consider approval of by- laws for the County Cable Commission .
r ,
TB Agenda 2/ 12/96 `
Page 4 .
26. Consider EXECUTIVE SESSION ,
27. Consider contract with Westinghouse Electric Corporation to remove and dispose
of electrical transformers at Pearsall Place Pump Station .
28 . Consider reaffirming authorization for the Town Attorney to bring civil action on
building code violation .
29 . Consider ADJOURNMENT,
SUPERVISOR' S REPORT
FEBRUARY 1996
The first month was quite an experience. January 19 we had the flood. The lost of
Sandbank road and other washed out road shoulders is a wake-up call for the power of
nature. The snow and ice this winter has put us on notice to watch the budget carefully.
Februca y began to look better . We had the good news that our share of the sale
tax was $ 137, 000 more that we had planned in our 1996 budget. I added that amount to
our outside village fund because we may need to use some or all of this money to pay for
highway costs due to the flood, snow and ice this winter. We are hopeful that Federal
money will pay for repairing Sandbank road, but we will have to pay first and be
reimbursed in 1997 . I need to find the most cost effective way to cover this expense. The
new year did not get off to the best start and I will be overseeing the budget very carefully
to keep our expenses under control.
For the new town hall we are still projecting that we will have $ 1 , 500 . 000 by the
- end of this year. The total now is $ 1 ,355 , 386 . 98 with $ 160,000 . to be added from 1996
sales tax revenue.
Item 17 on the agenda consider setting a work session date to discuss 1996
Priorities Work Plan is something new. I would like the Town Board and Dept. Heads to
spent some tirne without the distraction of other Town business. I thought it would be
good to get together early in the year decide our priorities for this year and try to look
ahead three years at least. Hopefully we can began to get a realistic start on a five year
plan as a goal.
Some other good news is that the books for all town accounts were closed the
first week of February. This process has always taken until mid May in the past and we
have always had to ask for an extension. We are trying to improve some of our accounting
practices so that we can monitor revenues and expenses faster and more efficiently in the
future.
( See Back )
I noticed some items that Chairman of the County Board of Representatives
Stuart Stein mentioned in his report for 1996 that we should consider. First, he would like
the county to begin revaluation of property in 1997. The last complete revaluation was
done in 1990. Second he is creating a new special committee to be called Intermunicipal
Cooperation and Service Consolidation that he will chair. He states that "This effort may
call for the County to decentralize some services, transferring the to the towns, villages,
and city" , he goes on to state "I see this as a careful step-by-step process focusing on one
service at a time to determine whether it can be provided more efficiently, and at lower
cost to all " . It seems to me that the Town of Ithaca should stay informed of the progress
of this import.int committee.
We are working on the review of our health insurance. We will have a proposal for
the personnel committee on a uniform policy for retires health and dental insurance at our
February meeting.
Town Engineer ' s Report for 2 / 12 / 96
Town Board Meeting
DEVELOPMENT REVIE?d
No Construction activity during the month of January 1996 .
EARTH FILL PERMITS
Five Mile Drive , Immaculate Conception Cemetery
Approximately 500 cy of fill has been added to site during January
with the source of material being foundation excavations from the Rte
13 bridge project . Sediment control fencing is being maintained
around the fill area and no problems occurred during the thaw of
January 19 ,
WATER PROJECTS
The Town Engineering staff is continuing to work with the Bolton Point
staff to implement the master metering program for connections to the
water transmission main . The plans and specifications have . been
completed and the contract documents for all of the maste . metering
locations are being asse:wled with the Town of Ithaca acting as
contracting agent for member municipalities of SCLIWC . The
amended master meter agreeTLent will be reviewed by the Town Board at
the February meeting . After approval , the Town Engineering staff will
assist the Bolton Point staff in construction administration .
The Town Engineer is working with the Bolton Point staff to develop
an engineering evaluation and implementation program for the SCLIWC
capital plan .
The Town Engineer has beer_ meeting with the City Engineer and SCLIWC
member municipal engineers to develop a proposal for an engineering
evaluation to include the entire water infrastructure for the area .
This evaluation may become a part of the City of Ithaca water supply
study .
Agenda Item 3c
HIG14WAY SUPERINTENDENT ' S BOARD REPORT FOR JANUARY
Town Board Meeting , February 12 , 1996
Let it Snow ,, Let it Rain , Let it Snow ! ! ! Wow ! What a Month ! !
In January , there was a tremendous amount of snow fall . The
Highway / Parks crews spent 1 , 231 . 65 hours of time on snow removal
( This includes making a tank to disperse calcium ) . This included
716 . 5 regular time and 495 . 15 hours of over time . We used
approximately 250 tons of salt and 230 tons of sand . The fire
houses on West Hill and South Hill were salted ten times , and
plowed eight: of those ten times .
Not to be outdone , the rains started and wrecked havoc with
culverts , streams , roads , etc . Within 2 % weeks , most of it on
January 19 and 20 , we spent 728 . 75 hours working on alleviating and
repairing storm damage , with 198 . 25 being overtime . We used 340 . 21
tons of Cru :� hed Bank Run and 73 tons of salt .
Between there major weather events , we worked 92 hours at picking
up Christmas; trees , which was curtailed until January 30 because of
the flood . They are now picked up .
We did some General Repair work , using 109 . 5 hours . Work included
repairing roads , working on Annex building , etc .
We worked 133 hours on machinery maintenance and repairs . This
includes 32 hour of overtime . Twenty - four hours were spent on
fixing man holes , and 29 . 5_ hours on a water valve repair on Elm
Street Ext .
1996 Work Plan : The advent of all the storm damage has altered our
1996 work plan . We have not worked out all the details of this
work plan at this time . We know that we have the funding to repair
Stone Quarry Road , Stone Quarry is on the Federal Highway System .
I have met with the people from the Federal - Aid Highway System and
they have assessed the damage . The Town Board will be considering
a resolution on the agreement with New York State Department of
Transportation ( DOT ) which will reimburse the Town for all repairs
on Stone Quarry . This money is provided by the Federal Government
to fund projects on local roads which are on the federal - aid
highway system .
All other damages we will repair with our own forces with the
exception of Sand Bank Road .
As I am writing this , we are planning to contract out the repair of
Sand Bank Road . There are still funding issues that we need to
work through . This funding will ultimately have an effect on our
work plan and the direction we head as we prioritize .
I have met with staff from the Army Corp of Engineers . He assessed
damage and is gathering information for Federal Emergency
Management .Agency ( FEMA ) . The same information will be used by
State Emergency Management Organization ( SEMO ) .
I have also met with Gordon Reimels from DOT Region 3 on the
damages on Sand Bank Road . He agreed with our initial damage
assessment and was going to contact Albany SEMO with the
information . My understanding is that we will be reimbursed 75
percent by FEMA and 12 % percent by SEMO . The rest ( 12 % percent )
will have to be paid for by the Town ' s funds .
Attached you will find the damage estimates and as we work through
the funding issues , we will provide the Town Board with the
information.
February Proms ects
i . Snow Removal as necessary
2 . Flood Damage assessments and repairs .
3 . Genera .! Repairs .
sit
Agenda Item 3c
Park and Open SAace Manacter ' s Report January 1996
Town of Ithaca Town Board Meeting February 12 1996
10 Snow :removal for walkways and bikeways took 104 hours in
January . Parks staff also worked 146 hours helping highway
with road snow removal .
2 . Parks staff contributed 22 hours towards Holiday tree curbside
collection .
39 Jerry Strosnider and Tim Eighmey successfully completed the
two week short course in Turfgrass Management held January 8 ,
through 19 , 1996 at Cornell University ,
4 . Parks staff worked a total of 129 hours during the flooding on
January 19 , 1996 , and on repairs to Highway/ Parks facilities
during the following week .
51 Routine maintenance and renovation of the new workshop
building , totalling 190 hours , completed our work for January .
February Parks Projects
10 Snow removal as needed .
2 . Continue workshop renovations .
3 . Assist in clearing Muriel Street backlot sewer right - of - way .
4 . Workshop projects : Nesting boxes and ADA compliant picnic
table Construction .
ghk
Agenda Item #3d
Planning:g irector' s Report for February 12, 1996 Town Board Meeting
(This report covers the period between the December 11 , 1995 and February 12, 1996
Town Board meetings .)
DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
Planning staff hats been working on the following projects under Planning Board
review jurisdiction:
South Hill Complex Subdivision and Site Plan Modification, Danby Road
Final Subdivision Approval was granted at the December 19, 1995 Planning
Board meeting for the proposed subdivision of + / - 3 .68 acres into four lots .
Site Plan Approval had previously been granted for a retail / office
development to consist of approximately 37,500 + / - square feet. The proposed
subdivision is to enable financing to be obtained by the applicant. Final Site
Plan Approval for modifications to the plan was also granted to permit
changes in finished floor elevations, addition of a basement for the proposed
building on lot #2, and changes in site parking, grading and landscaping.
Recommendation on Rezoning Indian Creek SLUR, Trumansburg Road
The Planning Board held a public hearing at its December 19, 1995 meeting on
Codes and Ordinance' s recommendation to rezone the Indian Creek SLUR
parcel back to its previous Agricultural zoning. The Planning Board
recommended that the Town Board take no action on the rezoning at this time,
since the owner of the property is negotiating with a potential. buyer who
wants to develop a retirement community like that permitted in the SLUD, and
that the proposed rezoning be revisited in 180 days (see attached copy of
Planning Board resolution) .
Recommendation on Rezoning Cornell Univ. Parcel, East King Road
The Planning Board held a public hearing at its December 19, 1995 meeting on
Codes and'. Ordinance' s recommendation to rezone a parcel owned by Cornell
University from MR Multiple Residence to R-30 Residence . The parcel was
part of the previously proposed Beacon Hills / Chase Pond multiple residence
development which never occurred. Cornell purchased the parcel, and has
incorporated it into its South Hill Swamp. The Planning Board recommended
that the Town Board rezone this parcel to R-30 (see attached copy of
resolution) .
Ithacare Center Senior Living Community, Danby Road
The Planning Board accepted the Final Environmental Impact Statement as
t complete at its December 19, 1995 meeting. Staff prepared the Statement of
Findings for the Planning Board, which was adopted at their January 23, 1996
meeting. .A public hearing to consider Preliminary Site Plan Approval for
Alternative B.3 has been scheduled for the Planning Board's February 6, 1996
meeting, at which time it is anticipated that the Planning Board will send a
recommendation to the Town Board to modify SLUR No. 7 to permit the
modified building footprint and configuration. A copy of the Planning Board's
Statement of Findings is included in Town Board member packets.
Albanese Subdivision, East Shore Drive
The Planning Board granted Preliminary and Final Subdivision Approval at
the January 9, 1996 meeting for the subdivision of a 6.41 + / - acre parcel into
two lots to create one new building lot.
Cayuga Vista Subdivision, Danby Road
The Planning Board considered a sketch plan at their January 9, 1996 meeting
for the proposed subdivision of the Cayuga Vista property, previously
approved as a 32 unit townhouse development, into 12 clustered lots. Twelve
townhouse units in three buildings have already been built. The proposal is to
modify the remainder of the cluster area into 9 lots and to add 3 lots on
adjacent land.
Bates Subdivision, Burleigh Drive
The Planning Board granted Preliminary and Final Subdivision Approval at
the January 23, 1996 meeting for the subdivision of a 29,300 square foot lot into
two lots to be purchased by two adjoining landowners and consolidated with
their lots.
Conversion of Pleasant Grove Apartments, Pleasant Grove Road
The Planning Board considered a sketch plan at their January 23, 1996 meeting
for the proposed conversion of several buildings in the Pleasant Grove
Apartment complex to other uses. Building 14 is proposed to be converted to
a satellite maintenance facility; Building 12 would be converted to office and
storage space for housekeeping staff; and Buildings 1 and 2 would become
temporary offices for graduate students during the course of renovations to
Sibley and Tjaden Halls. The site is zoned MR Multiple Residence across from
Hasbrouck Apartments.
2
ZONING BOARD SEOR REVIEWS
SEQR reviews were done in conjunction with the following actions before the Zoning
Board of Appeals :
Glenn Hubbell, 1308 Mecklenburg Road - Use variance to continue
operation of an antiques and second hand goods shop in an Agricultural
District. A 5 year time 4 &uni ted variance was granted by the ZBA in
1990 .
Linea Dolph and David Dunbar, 1457 Trumansburg Road - Use
variance to permit the keeping of horses for hire in an R-30 Residence
District. A 5 year time limited variance was granted by the ZBA in
1990 .
CURRENT PLANNING DEPARTMENT PROTECTS
Planning Department staff is working on the following projects:
Conservation District: As a follow up to the joint Codes & Ordinances and Planning
Committee meeting held in December, a revised draft of the Conservation District
has been prepared for Town Board review. The draft will be distributed for the
February 12th Town Board meeting, and discussed at the March meeting.
Analvsis of MR, Commercial , Industrial and Special Land Use Districts: The Codes
and Ordinances Committee has completed an analysis of the above-referenced zoning
districts on parcels where no development has occurred, and has prepared draft local
laws for selected rezonings . Public hearings for recommendations on two proposed
rezonings were held by the Planning Board on December 19th (see descriptions under
Planning Board reviews). Another proposed rezoning (Mans parcel, E. King Road)
will be scheduled for Planning Board hearing in late February or March.
Parks , Recreation and Open Space Plan Update: A full draft of the plan has been
completed, and has been provided to the Parks and Greenways Committee of the
Conservation Board for preliminary review. It is anticipated that a revised draft will
be presented to the full Conservation Board in March, after which it will be
distributed to other Boards and Committees for review, including the Public Works
and Planning Committees .
Cornell GEIS / SI:UD : The Cornell Precinct 7 Special Land Use District (SLUR) was
enacted by the Town Board at the December 11 , 1995 meeting.
Town of Ithaca / Cornell University Transportation Committee: Subsequent to the
enactment of the Cornell SLUR, the Town of Ithaca / Cornell Transportation
Committee was set up, and held its first meeting on January 8, 1996 . The
3
1
Committee' s purpose is to study and make recommendations to the appropriate
bodies on transportation issues related to Precinct 7 and surrounding areas. The
Committee established the following as priority projects: 1 ) to provide safe and
efficient pedestrian and bike movement between East Hill Plaza and Cornell campus
and to connect with campus routes, and 2) to examine the signalization at Route 366
and the potential closing of Judd Falls Road from Tower Road to Rt. 366. The
Committee' s next meeting will be March 11 , 1996 .
Ithaca-Tompkins County Transportation Council (ITCTC): A draft of the County
Trail / Corridor Study was reviewed by the ITCTC Planning Committee at its
December 12, 1595 meeting. A revised draft is being prepared by the consultant for
presentation in February.
The ITCTC charged the Planning Committee with providing recommendations on the
scope of the Northeast Connector Study, which has set up a Study Group to do that.
This is in response to discussions and correspondence with NYSDOT regarding the
support of and availability of state funds for this project, which is in the
Transportation Improvement Program (TIP) . It appears that the state will come up
with funds to support this project, but it will have to be a focused and well-defined
study, and probably scaled down from the funds originally indicated in the TIP . The
Study Group includes NYSDOT, Tompkins County, Towns of Ithaca and Dryden,
Villages of Lansing and Cayuga Heights, and Cornell University. The Town of
Lansing is also invited to participate.
ISTEA Grant Applications : Staff worked on two grant applications for ISTEA
enhancement fwnds for bicycle / pedestrian trails . The Town is cooperating with the
City on a combined proposal for a trail linking Buttermilk Falls State Park and the
future Black Diamond Trail. The City was responsible for preparing the application
for this project.
Staff also prepared and submitted a grant application for the proposed William and
Hannah Pew Trail in the Eastern Heights / Snyder Hill area of the town, which would
link the Eastern Heights neighborhood with the southern terminus of the East Ithaca
Recreationway (at the Pine Tree Walkway), and would link several of the Town' s
parks in this area . The project also includes a Maple Avenue pathway extension to
link the two separate segments of the existing East Ithaca Recreationway.
Both projects were determined to be eligible by the state under ISTEA criteria, and
are in the process of being reviewed by the state. Grant recipients will probably be
announced in April 1996.
Inlet Valley Parcels: As a follow-up to the Town and City interest in acquiring for
park purposes the two parcels in Inlet Valley that were being offered at auction by
the County, the City hired a consultant to prepare a Phase I Environmental Site
Assessment. Planning and Engineering reviewed the Environmental Assessment and
found it left questions relating to possibility of existence of exposed basement and
4
underground fuel tank unanswered. A meeting between Town and City officials is
being scheduled to follow up on the Environmental Assessment and the acquisition
process in the near future .
County Waterfront Study: Staff prepared a letter of agreement between the Town and
County and sent the letter with a check representing the Town' s share of the project.
Meetings with the consultant have been initiated on preliminary map work and
strategies to obtain public input.
Saddlewood Farms , Mecklenburg Road: Planning and Engineering staff have been
involved in preliminary discussions with Landmark America, a development
company from Portland, Maine, regarding a proposed 270 + / - unit apartment
complex on Mecklenburg Road. The proposal would consist of 125 low income
rental units (under the Federal Low Income Housing Credit program) . The
remainder would be market rate rental units. Town Board members met at the site
on February 3, 1996. The developer is scheduled to give a presentation at the
February 12, 1996 Town Board meeting. The site is primarily zoned AG Agricultural
with a small portion on the eastern edge zoned R-15 Residence. The proposal would
require a rezoning (probably to MR Multiple Residence) .
Cornell - Lake Source Cooling Project: Staff attended a briefing by Cornell on January
22, 1996, regarding an update on their plans for the Lake Source Cooling project.
Based on their preliminary evaluation, Cornell has decided to move ahead with the
preparation of an Environmental Impact Statement. It is likely that the NYS Dept. of
Environmental Conservation (DEC) will be the Lead Agency for the environmental
review, since DEC would have to issue about half of the required permits . Cornell
has a purchase agreement for the Noah' s Boat Club (East Shore Sailing) site at 1000
East Shore Drive, which has been identified by Cornell as the preferred site for two
key parts of the project. The pumping facility would be housed in a 50' by 50'
building on the lakeshore portion of the site. The heat exchanger would be in a 100'
by 150' building on the east side of East Shore Drive . The remainder of the site
would not be needed for the project, and could be available for other uses, such as
public access / recreation. Further discussions between Cornell and Town staff
regarding environmental, zoning and other issues, will be initiated soon.
Tompkins County Small Cities Community Development Block Grant (CDBG)
Application: Staff has been working with the County on an application for Small
Cities CDBG funds which the County would submit on behalf of the Town. If
approved, funds would be placed in a revolving loan fund to provide low interest
loans to local businesses . This is part of the County' s Economic Development
program. The emphasis of this program is on job creation. The Town Board will be
holding the first of two public hearings on this application at the February 12, 1996
meeting.
Filename: 1 files\ townbd \ tpre0296 .m em
5
ADOPTED RESOLUTION : Indian Creek SLUD Parcel t
Trumansburg Road
Rezoning from SLUD 96 to AG
Recommendation to the Town Board
Planning Board, December 19 , 1995
MOTION by Fred Wilcox, seconded . by James Ainslie :
WHEREAS :
1 , The Town Board of the Town of Ithaca has requested that the Town of Ithaca Codes
and Ordinances Committee conduct a townw-ide analysis of undeveloped parcels where
current zoning may no longer be appropriate, and
2. The Codes and Ordinances Committee has completed such an analysis, and has
recommended that a number of parcels be rezoned in order to be consistent with the
Town of Ithaca Comprehensive Plan recommendations, and
3 . A specific proposal of the Codes and Ordinances Committee is to rezone the lands in
the Indian Creek Special Land Use District No . 6 . consisting of 69 . 83 +/- acres, and
designated as Town of Ithaca Tax Parcel No . 24- 1 -23 , located on Trumansburg Road,
to its former designation as AG Agricultural, and
4. The Town of Ithaca Codes and Ordinances Committee has referred said proposed
rezoning to the Town of Ithaca Planning Board for their recommendation, and
5 . The Planning Board, at a Public Hearing on December 19 , 1995 , has reviewed the
Zoning Analysis : Vacant Parcels (MR. SLUD . BUS . IND) for the Babcock - Indian
Creek Parcel (Draft 9/25/95 ) prepared by the Town planning staff, a Full
Environmental Assessment Form Parts I and II prepared by the Town planning staff,
and a draft Local Law amending the Town of Ithaca Zoning Ordinance Rezoning
Lands in the Indian Creek Special Land Use District on Trumansburg Road to
Agricultural, and
6. The Director of Planning received a letter from Bruce Babcock, owner of subject
parcel, dated December 18 , 1995 , indicating that he is currently negotiating with a
serious buv€:r who is interested in developing a Retirement Community of
approximately the same size as was approved in SLUD 96 ,
Indian Creek SLIUD Parcel _ Page 2
Trumansburg Road
Rezoning from SILUD #6 to AG
Recommendation to the Town Board
Planning Board, :December 19, 1995
NOW, THEREFORE , BE IT RESOLVED:
11 That the Town of Ithaca Planning Board hereby recommends that the Town of Ithaca
Town Board take no action on the above-described rezoning at this time, and that the
proposed rezoning be revisited within 180 days from the date of this resolution, unless
the owner comes forward with a specific request to the Town Board at an earlier date.
Aye - Smith, Cornell, Finch, Ainslie, Wilcox, Kenerson, Bell .
Nay - None.
The MOTION was declared to be carried unanimously .
Starr Hays, Recording Secretary,
Town of Ithaca Ply n=a Board.
7
M , Bry t, Adm. ' strative Secretary .
1 / 18/96 .
(Fik+vme: SW RmI01mkrin.Fin)
POY;4
S
v
ADOPTED RESOLUTION : Cornell University Parcel
East King Road
Rezoning from MR to R-30
Recommendation to the Town Board
Planning Board, December 19 , 1995
MOTION by Herbert Finch, seconded by James Ainslie :
WHEREAS .
1 , The Town Board of the Town of Ithaca has requested that the Town of Ithaca Codes
and Ordinances Committee conduct a townwide analysis of undeveloped parcels where
current zoning may no longer be appropriate, and
20 The Codes and Ordinances Committee has completed such an analysis, and has
recommended that a number of parcels be rezoned in order to be consistent with the
Town of Itl:taca Comprehensive Plan recommendations, and
3 . A specific proposal of the Codes and Ordinances Committee is to rezone lands on East
King Road owned by Cornell University, consisting of 4. 8 +/- acres, and designated as
Town of Ithaca Tax Parcel No . 44- 1 -4 . 313 , from MR Multiple Residence to Residence
District R-30 . and
4. The Town of Ithaca Codes and Ordinances Committee has referred said proposed
rezoning to the Town of Ithaca Planning Board for their recommendation, and
5 . The Planning Board, at a Public Hearing on December 19 , 1995 , has reviewed the
Zoning Analvsis : Vacant Parcels (iylR. SLU'D . BUS . IND) for the Cornell - East King
Road Parcel (Draft 9/25/95) prepared by the Town planning staff, a Short
Environmental Assessment Form Parts I and Ii prepared by the Town planning staff,
and a draft :Local Law amending the Town of Ithaca Zoning Ordinance Rezoning
Lands on Ecrist King Road Owned by Cornell university (Tax Parcel No . 44- 1 -4 . 313 )
from Multiple Residence to Residence District R-30,
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED .
1 . That the Town of Ithaca Planning Board, pursuant to Article XIV, Section 78 of the
Town Zoning Ordinance, hereby finds that:
a. There is a need for the proposed zoning change in the proposed location:
b . The existing and probable future character of the neighborhood in which the
subject site is located will not be adversely affected;
Adopted Resolution Page 2
Cornell University Parcel, East King Road
Rezoning from MR to R-30
Recommendation to the Town Board
Planning Board, December 19 , 1995
C , The proposed zoning chance is in accordance with a comprehensive plan of
development of the Town.
2. That the Town of Ithaca Planning Board hereby recommends that the Town of Ithaca
Town Board approve the proposed rezoning of Town of Ithaca Tax Parcel No . 44- 1 -
4. 313 as described in the attached draft Local Law from MR Multiple Residence to
Residence District R-30 .
Aye - Smith, Cornell, Finch, Ainslie, Wilcox, Kenerson, Bell .
Nay - None .
The MOTION was declared to be carried unanimously.
Starr Hays, Recording Secretary,
Town of Ithaca Planning Board.
Mary Bryar
Administrative Secretary .
1 / 18/96 .
lFi Inume:Aur\Rewh\Comelrs.tinl
Agenda 3 e
TOWN OF [THACA
REPORT OF BUILDING PERMITS ISSUED
FOR THE MONTH OF JANUARY 1996
YEAR TO DATE
ru or Power ( YEAR iIOF PER NUTS AMOUNT a AMOUNT
JINGLE FAMILY AITACIIED 1 1996 0 0 0 0
IRLSIDISICES 1995 0 0 0 0
SINGLE FAMILY DETACHED j 19961 1 369000 1 36,000
RCSIDENCrS 1995 .3 206,000 3 :06,000
1 1996 0 0 0 0
TWO FAMILY RESIDENCE4 � 1995 0 0 0 0
_ 1996_ 1 13,685 1 139685
RF7N0VA7T0N3 t 1995 3 38,100 3 38, 100
i 1996 0 0 0 0
CONVERSIONS OF USE 1995 0 0 0 0
i 1996 0 0 0 0
ADDITIONS TO FOOTPRINT 1995 1 149000 1 14,000
1996 0 0 0 0
MULTIPLE RESIDENCES I 1995 0 0 0 0
i 1 Hair Graphics East 5,000
1 TC ProteQQional Bldg Remodel Suite t[ 80-000
1996 2 35,000 2 33,000
BUSINESS j 1995 0 0 0 0
- ----- -- - —' � 1996 0 – --- 0 0 0
CULTURAL j 1993 0 0 0 0
1996 0 0 0 0
INDUSTRIAL 1995 0 0 0 0
1996 1 CU Modular Offices at Wilson Lab 261.000 1 261 ,000
EDUCATIONAL ` 1995 l :57,596 1 237,396
MISCELLANEOUS 1
1996 1 Fireplace damage repair 49914 1 49914
CONSTRUCTION 1 1995 3 33,500 3 33 ,300
TOTAL. NUMBER OF 1996 6 1020599 6 402,599
PERMITS ISSUED _ 1995 11 5499196 11 549,196
TOTAL. FEES 1996 6 840 6 840
RECEIVED 1995 11 1 ,330 11 1 ,330
Date Prepared: February 2, 1996
Deni L Holford
Building/Zoning Department Secretary
- 2 -
TOTAL. CERTIFICATES OF OCCUPANCY ISSUED THIS MONTII - 14 -
1 . 6 Lagrand Court - new single4arrtily dwelling.
? . 121 Snyder Hill Road - replace existing wood stove.
3. 101 Dates Drive - renovations to outpatient staff offices, '
4. 955 Coddington Road - remodel basement.
5. 142 Whitetail Drive - new outside wood deck
6. to Judd Falls Road - renovations to building area around court #5, temporary certificate.
7. 1. 119 Pennsylvania Avenue - existing single-family dwelling.
8. 215 Pennsylvania Avenue - study room in basement
9. 172 East King Road - new hospicare residence and administrative offices, temporary certificate.
10. llhaca College Student Uniurt - modifications to food service areas.
H . 883 Taughannock Boulevard - new single- family dwelling. -
12. 225 Coddirtgtun Road - existing two-family dwelling.
13. Ithaca College - renovations of bathrooms at Terrace 31
14. 1301 Trumansburg Road - renovate suite J.
TOTAL CERTIFICATES OF OCCUPANCY YEAR TO DATE, 1996- 14
TOTAL CERTIFICATES OF OCCUPANCY YEAR TO DATE 1995 - 17
COMPLAINTS INVESTIGATED THIS MONTH - 6
1 . 225 Pennsylvania Avenue - noiec violation - pending.
2. 1216 Trumansburg Road - building code - pending.
3. 939 Fast Shore Drive - flooding - no violation found.
4. 198 "1'areytort Drive - flooding - pending.
5. t 14 Whitetail Drive - tloodina- -abated.
6. Compton and Danby Road - property maintenance - abated.
From December 1995
1 . East Hill Plaza (Hair Graphics) - building code - abated.
From November 1995
1 . Danby Road, Ithaca College Science Building - building code - abated.
2. 623 Elmira Road - building code - abated.
From October 1995
1 . 310 St. Catherine Circle "property maintenance - pending.
2. 139 Ridgecrest Road - zoning - abated.
From September 1995:
1 . 140 Ridgecrest Road - building code - pending.
From May 1995 :
1 . 1152 Danby Road - zoning and building code - pending legal action
From April 1995:
1 . 128 Salem hive - illegal basement apartment - pending.
- 3 -
n Janu 1995:
1022 Danby Road. 97C - occupancy - pending legal action.
From November 1994:
1 . Various Cayuga Vista properties - occupancy - pending legal action.
From March 19()4:
1 . 132 Forest Home Drive - building code - pending.
From Febnl.M 199:L
1 . 155 Poole Road - ZBA conditions violated - pending.
From line 11300:
L Various Sapsucker Woods properties - occupancy - pending.
TOTAL COMPLAINTS INVESTIGATED YEAR TO DATE, 1996 - 6
TOTAL COMPLAINTS INVESTIGATED YEAR TO DATE, 1995 - 10
TOTAL FIELD VISITS THIS INIO14TH - 71
Uniform Building Code - 38
Local Law and Zoning Inspections - 16
Fire Safety - 3 (4 multiple dwellings [3 buildings, 1 I I units], 3 churches, 1 restaurant)
Safety ReinsTections - 1 ( 1 public assembly)
Occurrences - 5 (4 chimney [3 howses, l hotel] , 1 rubbish hospital)
Fire Occurrence Reinspections - 3 (mo(el chimney)
TOTAL FIELD VISITS YEAR TO DATE, 1996 - 71
TOTAL, FIELD VISITS YEAR TO DATE, 1995 - 78
TOTAL SIGN PERiIMITS THIS MONTH - 2 Veteran Volunteer Firemen's Association
TOTAL SICK PERMITS YEAR TO DATE, 1996 - 2
TOTAL SIGN PERMITS YEAR TO DATE, 1995 - 0
ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS
1 MEETING - 3 NEW CASES - AGENDA ATTACHED
TOWN OF ITHACA ZONING BOARD bF APPEALS
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARINGS
WEDNESDAY , JANUARY 24 , 1996
7 : 00 P . H .
By direction of the Chairman or the Zoning Board of Appeals NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that
Public Hearings will be held by the Zoning Board of Appeals of the Town of Ithaca on
Wednesday , January 24 , 1996 , in Town Hall , 126 East Seneca Street , ( FIRST Floor , REAP.
Entrance , WEST Side ) , Ithaca , N . Y . , COMMENCING AT 7 : 00 P . M . , on the following matters :
APPEAL of Glenn Hubbell , Oamer / Appellant , requesting variance of the requirements of Article
V . Section 18 and 19 of the Town of Ithaca Zoning Ordinance , for the operation of an antiques
P and second hand goods shop in an Agricultural District at 1308 Hecklenburg Road , Town of
a Ithaca Tax Parcel No , 27 - 1 - 14 . I . ( Residence District R- 30 regulations apply ) . Said Ordinance
02 2 does not permit antique and second hand businesses in a residential district . A five year
3 time - limited variance was granted by the Board on December 12 , 1990 and has since expired .
A APPEAL of Linna Dolph and David Dunbar , Appellants , requesting a variance from Article V ,
P Section 18 and 19 , of the Zoning Ordinance , to permit the keeping of horses for hire at 1457
P Trumansburg Road , Tom of Ithaca Tax Parcel No . 23 - 1 - 27 , Residence District R- 30 . Said
'I Ordinance does not allow the keeping of horses for hire in R- 30 zones . A five year time -
P limited variance was granted by the Board on August 15 , 1990 and has since expired .
0
APPEAL of Margaret Rumsey , Appellant , Hark Wheeler , Agent , requesting a Certificate of
q Occupancy under Article YIV , Section 77 , Paragraph 5 of the To;m of Ithaca Zoning Ordinance
o for the Buttermilk Falls Bed and Breakfast located at 110 East Buttermilk Falls Road , To
a of Ithaca Ta:c Parcel No . 38 - 1 - 2 , Residence District R- 30 . A Certificate of Occupancy h
e� been denied by the Toy-m Building Inspector .
Said Zoning Board of Appeals will at said time , 7 : 00 p . m . , ' and said place , hear all
persons in support of such matters or objections thereto . Persons may appear by agent or in
person . Individuals 4ith visual or . hearing impairments or other special needs , as
appropriate , will be provided with assistance , as necessary , upon request . Persons desiring
assistance must make such a request not less than 48 hours prior to the time of the public
hearing .
i
Andrew S . Frost
Building Inspector/ Zoning Enforcement Officer
273 - 1783
Dated : January 17 ,, 1995
Publish : January 19 , 1995
'Agenda Item No . 3f.
Town of Ithaca
Tax Collection
January 1996
Monthly Report
1996 Tax Warrant - Town of Ithaca
Total Town Warrant : $3 , 648 , 842 . 62
1 / 11 /96 Payment : Town of Ithaca Supervisor - 755 , 000. 00
(Tax Bill Receipts: 1/2 - 1 / 11 )
1 /23/96 Payment: Town of Ithaca Supervisor - 1 , 210 , 722 . 00
(Tax Bill Receipts : 1 / 12- 1 / 18 )
1 /29/96 Payment: Town of Ithaca Supervisor - 650 , 000 . 00
(Tax Bill Receipts : 1 / 18 - 1 /25 )
TOTAL WARRANT BALANCE DUE - 1 /31 /96 $ 1 , 033 , 120062
1996 In Lieu of Taxes
Due : Groff Associates , Ellis Hollow Elderly Housing $ 11521867
Ithaca Elm - Nlaple Houses , Inc. $ 8 , 349 . 80
TOTAL IN LIEU OF TAXES DUE : $ 9 , 871 . 47
Billed : Tompkins County Medical Office Bldg . $3 , 571 . 78 Town
$8 , 207. 73 Fire
(Will not be received , Tompkins Co . Billed to Warrant)
Received : Groff Associates , Ellis Hollow Elderly Housing $27 , 618 . 30
(Town Portion - $ 1 , 521 . 67 , Balance School & County)
*In Lieu of Tax from Ithaca Elm - Maple Houses , Inc. , West Village Place , is unknown until
received in April/May. Payment based upon gross basic rents , calculated by HUD .
(See Back)
Tax Collection Monthly Report -
January 1996
Page 2 .
1996 Tax Roll Installment Payments
Total Number of Installment Payments : 386
Total Collected - Installment Payments : $330 , 521 . 52
Total Collected - ($ 1 . 00 Fee Per Installment) : $386600
Total Collected - Installment 1 % Penalties : $219.26
Total Installment Service Charge Paid to
Tompkins County Budget and Finance: $ 15 , 739.26
1996 Tax Warrant - Tompkins County
Total County Warrant: $ 316399350022
�Zy OF 17P
TOWN OF ITHACA
zi 4� 126 EAST SENECA STREET , ITHACA, N . Y . 14850
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273. 1704
Agenda Item No , 3f.
Town Clerk/Director Administrative Services
Monthly Report - January 1996
Town Clerk: A great deal of time was spent with the new Town Supervisor assimilating
her to the files , reviewing ongoing items , receiving instructions as to the operation
procedures she wishes to develop and implement during her term .
Town Board information and documentation preparation was completed , i . e .
appointments , beginning year resolutions , etc .
Tax Collection : Betty Poole and Mary Saxton deserve the utmost praise for their
professional and timely handling of the tax collection process . Some small problems
did occur with wrong amounts being paid and deadlines being missed by the taxpayers.
Betty and Mary met these challenges , addressed them in a timely manner, were always
kind and courteous to the taxpayers . A special thanks to Stanley Schrier, and Joy
Daley for their extra help during the busy times . (Financial report attached . )
Personnel : Sherm worked very hard to prepare the year end payroll closings , and
prepare the W2 forms and 1099 forms for distribution to the employees and
independent contractors . Tom VanDerzee of Ciaschi , Dietershagen , Little , Mickelson ,
LLP . , reviewed the forms before distribution to insure accuracy.
Meetings were held with Jeff Farmer , Sprague Insurance and the representative from
Blue Cross Blue Shield to review policies and consider savings .
Accounting : Closing of 1995 was the main focus of the month . Work begins on the
1995 Annual Financial Report . Meetings were held with various individuals regarding
the Town ' s financial procedures and accounts .
Respectfully submitted ,
Joan Lent Noteboom
Town Clerk/ Director Administrative Services
FORM NO. 1002- N TOWN CLERK'S MONTHLY REPORT WILLIAMSON IAw BOOR CO..VICTOR. NV 145"
TOWN OF Ithaca NEW YORK (Month) _ January 19 91; Agenda 3
TO THE SUPERVISOR:
Pursuant to Section 27, Subd. 1 , of the Town Law, I hereby make the following statement of all fees and moneys received by me in
connection with my office, during the month above stated, excepting only such fees and moneys the application and payment of which
are otherwise provided for by law:
LICENSE CATEGORY NUMBER OF LICENSES SOLD OR ISSUED
COMMISSION COMMISSION TOTAL USED
SENIOR (65 * I Military Disability)
FISHING - SEASON 1 , 00
HUNTING (Small Game)
BIG GAME (Deer and Biter)
TRAPPING
BOWHUNTING (Big Game License Required)
MUZZLELOADING (Big Game License Required)
SPORTSMAN
FISHING - J DAY
JUNIOR TRAPPING (Under 16 yrs.)
SPECIAL SECOND OEE:R PERMIT (See Big Game Guide)
TURKEY PERMIT (Available at DEC offices only)
NON-RESIDENT FISHING - SEASON
NON-RESIDENT HUNTING - SEASON (Small Game)
NON-RESIDENT BIG GAME (Deer ONLY)
NON-RESIDENT FISHING - 5 DAY -
NON-RESIDENT HUNTING - 5 DAY
NON-RESIOEN r MUZZLELOAOING
NON-RESIDENT BOWHUNTING
NON-RESIDENT BEAR TAG
NON-RESIOEN r COMBINATION
NON-RESIDENT TURKEY PERMIT (AVWaW •t OEC oncrs aW l
JUNIOR ARCHERY ( 14-, 15 Years)
LOST LICENSE ($5.00 Per Slamp Lost)
JUNIOR HUNTING ( 12- 15 Yeats)
S 1 . 00 AGO - TOTAL COMMISSIONS b S
Marriage Licenses No. to No. @ j
Marriage Certificates @
—1— Marriage Transcripts 10 . 00 10 _ n0
A 1255 TOTAL TOWN CLERK FEES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . j 11 . 00
A 1010 — 1090 REAL PROPERTY TAXES ; INTEREST and PENALTIES ;
A 2001 PARK and RECREATION CHARGES
A 2110 ZONING FEES S A 2115 PLANNING FEES $
A 2570 GAMES OF CHANCE TOWN SHARE . . . . . . . LICENSE ; FEES TOTAL
A 2540 BINGO TOWN SHARE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . LICENSE ; FEES TOTAL
A 2544 24 DOG LICENSE - SPAYE-D-ANB ++ tyf ERE¢ 319 1 505 —F rn ? 1 o 1578—T (d�4 � nn 48 . 00
_43_ DOG LICENSE - UNSPAYED AND UNNEUTERED 8962464 –D to 8962500–K @ S2 00 186 . 00
— puLEl2tecl { 21683 )
A 2545 _ OTHER LICENSES Tax Search 1 @ $ 5 . 00 5 . 00
A 2555 __ BUILDI14G PERMITS Zoning Ordinance 5 @ $8 . 50 42 . 50
A 2590 OTHER PERMITS Copies & Misc . ( 11 . 00 Check Return Fee ) 15 . 80
A 2655 MINOR SALES Comprehensive Plan 2 @ $ 12 . 00 24 . 00
A 2770 OTHER UNCLASSIFIED REVENUES Enumeration 117 @ $ 1 , 00 117 . 00
TOTAL TOWN REVENUES TO SUPERVISOR . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . j 449 . 30
Amount paid to SUPERVISOR for Games of Chance Licenses
Amount paid to SUPERVISOR for Slate Share of Bingo Licenses
Amount paid to D.E.C. lot& Conservation Licenses 13 . 00
Amount paid to COUNTY TREASURER for Dog Licenses 190 . 15
Amount paid to STATE HEALTH DEPARTMENT for Marriage Licenses
Amount paid to ()Bit_ of Ap , & Markets 2Eaf mrr Fickvrtr 3 . 00
Amount paid to Slate for Sales Tax on Sale of Dogs
SPCA Contract 569 . 35
IN
Received Payment of these amounts: _ TOTAL DISBURSED . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $ 1224 . 80
Fe _,iiary 7 19 96 ii ' r; , : . �. �i t ! . .• Supervisor
STATE OF NEW YORK, COUNTY OF Tompkins , TOWN OF Ithaca
Joan Lent Noteboom being duly sworn, says that She is the Clerk
of the Town of Ithaca that the foregoing Is a full and true statement
of all Fees and Moneys received by her pucin ..th� mgllt (above stated, excepting only such Fees the application and payment of which are
otherwise provided for by law. 1 , - ' ' I ' 1- ' � '"'
Subscribed and Sworn to before me This HITl'. RY PUBLIC A i T�iJ
SrAfE OF NEW YOR � � Town Clerk
d:. of _ [•E � 1i f= L2Yc/ 14(1 # 4640 427
� � flOtary Public
Plepatu ut JuphC? n Remu on rnal a Supervil0l, retain Copy 10r G1etN's record
TOWN OF ITHACA HIGHWAY / P?LRKS DEPARTMENT Benda 6
ANNUAL REPORT FOR 1995
Hiahway Sumerintendent ' s Report
It has been accomplished ! ! 1995 marks the year that Judd Falls
Road in Forest Home was rebuilt . ( Now we get to work on the
downstream Forest Home Bridge . ) This project has had years of
design and community debate . before it was accomplished . The
lessons we learned from this process , and a , few others we were
involved in , will help us . in the future . It has already helped us
to better understand what we _ need to do to serve our taxpayers
better . It also helps us understand the hard choice we sometimes
need to make . to keep our infrastructure in place and - well
maintained .
The Highway/ Parks Department has need for more space for storing
ecuicment , - maintenance , and office space . In 1995 , we accuired a
building and land which helps to alleviate some of this probl-em .
There is still. an ongoing need for space , and we will work toward
alleviating that need in the most cost effective manner possible .
The summer of 1995 was a good summer for us to get a lot of outside
work done . The• lack of rain allowed us to plan work and accomplish
it without having to change plans . This year I tried to convince
our residents in our more residential - areas that oil and stone
surface treatment was the way to go . - Although , aesthetically it is
not as appea :. ing as other surface treatments , . it is the most
efficient and cost effective . way to provide preventive maintenance
to our roads • The outcome of this , however , is that in our
residential areas .we will not .use oil and stone in our pavement
preventive maintenance programs .
In 1995 we initiated some discussicn with the Village of Cayuga
Heights on possible ways to consolidate some services . We think
there might be ways that we could work together to . .. provide
efficient and more cost effective services to our taxpayers . We
hope to expand. on these discussions in 1996 among ourselves and our
reevective boards .
To continue our efforts to get a better focus on costs , etc . , the
Highway / Parks Department upgraded its computer capabilities in
several ways . In 1995 our Department purchased two new software
programs which allows us to " track " eauipment maintenance , employee
times , complaints ( received from residents , etc . ) , sign
maintenance , road maintenance , and other programs that we have yet
to analyze . The names are Highwayman Helper and ZMap . To better
run ZMap , we upgraded our RAM capability from 4 MB to 12 ME , We
also r.) urchased a laser print .
r. 1995 , the Town has moved one step closer to having a
Cc ... -� = hensive Traffic Plan in place . There will be more progress
i n 1996 on this plan with the Tc .v Planning Department , the
r
Highway/ Parks Department Annual Report - Page 2
Metropolitan Planning Organization ( MPO ) , and many others working
towards this goal . The hoped - for outcome will be more efficient
movement of traffic ; cars , pedestrians , and bicycles , throughout
the Town with as little impact as possible on our infrastructure
maintenance program and open spaces .
The Highway/ Parks Department has continued to upgrade our operating
procedures . We continue to work on our training program which
include any updated training information . Team work is our end
goal , and we are working toward it . Gail Kroll , our Secretary ,
functions more as an Administrative Assistant . She has
consistently helped streamline the flow of information and deals
politely with the public . Gail always enhances the operation of
our Department and other departments that we work with .
Along with this , Gail and I have worked together with Tompkins
County , Sherm DeSanto , and . others to build a Drug and Alcohol
Testing program , which is mandated by the Federal Government .
Park and Oven Svaee Manaeer ' s Report
Projects and Accomplishments :
1 . South Hill Trail improvements : Installed six benches and
three map boxes . Over 1 , 000 maps have been distributed to
users of the trail thus far . " . Ai trail bed was topdressed
_ with : sand to cover loose gravel in response to complaints . -
-21 Christopher Circle . Water Tank site was regraded , seeded , and
plantings added . More plantings will be added in 19960
3 . A major drainage improvement project at Northview Park was
completed . The entrance path was reworked . to eliminate
flooding from an open ditch adjacent to the path . `
4 . Our wildflower and bluebird nesting box programs were both
expanded .
5 . All eight play structures were inspected . Minor repairs were
made , and all were sealed with preservative .
6 . East Ithaca Recreation Way from Maple Avenue to Game Farm Road
was resurfaced for the first time since it was originally
constructed in 1983 .
70 Two summer youth workers were employed during July and August
through the job training program . They assisted parks staff
with regular grounds maintenance work .
Highway/ Parks Department Annual Report Page 3
8 . Community Service Crews assisted parks on many occasions
collecting litter along bikeways and trails and trimming
brush .
P 11
9 . We put into service our new four wheel drive , one - ton dump
truck - Ln August . Fitted with an eight foot .plow and cinder
spreader , .: : -it ._ will. .-, . serve as the plow : . -for quick ixesponse
situations , fire stations , and dead - ends . ,10 Parks. Parks mowed all ^water tanks and pump `stations , and many .sewer
line rights - of - way and water " T " main lines with the boom
mower . More frequent mowing and the removal of - certain'
obstacles will continue to improve the : efficiency of =' -this
task . _
11 . Numerous landscape restorations were done as' a result of water
and sewer line work and repairs .
12 . Some initial trail clearing and mowing - at - ° the
Tomlinson / Glendale Park site on Bostwick Road were done .
ghk
,rY :,t
zj j
F •
1995 Annual Report
_ - . _. . ._
Highway
Regular . , Overtime - Overtime . ..
General Repairs 17 , 828 . 00 75 . 00 General Repairs 75 . 00
Machinery 1 , 867000 " - 41000 Machinery % r ✓-41 . 00
Snow Removal 11943050 . - - 1 , 397. 75 Snow Removal . . . . 1 , 397.75
Perm. Improv," P 51947.25
7075 - Perm. Improv 7. 75
Brush _& Weeds .1 , 968 .25 . ._ _ 5850 . ..: :.Brush & Weeds --- 5050
Water Maint. 320. 00 - 15 . 00 Water Maint. - 15 . 00
Sewer Maint, 467 . 50 32 . 00 Sewer Maint, 32000
Time Off 21660000
Pine Tree Walkway Enclosure of Culvert Pipes took 357 hours which was included in the Perm.
Improv. totals .
Regular and Overtime Hours Worked
9
8
6
N
H
O
4
3
2
1
a
Machinery Perm . Improv. Water Maint. Time Off
General Repairs Snow Removal Brush & Weeds Sewer Maint.
Parks and Open Space
Oitine Maintenance 3159
Wndscape Restore. 619
Trail Const. & Maint. 545
Sow Removal 523
Yard Wast Coll . 487
Grounds Maint, 473
Tree & Shrub Maint. 449
. Misc. Const. &Workshop 442
Misc. Park Improv. 368
Hgwy/Parks Planting 341
Park Structures Maint. 158
t. :d
v
(41 . 8 %) Routine Maintenance
(8 .2%) Landscape Restore .
- (2 . 1 '7'0') Park Structures Maint.
(7 .2 07/0) Trail Const. & Maint, ; (4. 5 %) Hgwy/Parks Planting
F
(6 . 9%) Sow Removal (4.9 70) Misc. Park Improv.
(6 .4%) Yard Wast Coll . (5 . 8%) Misc. Const.&Workshop
(6 .3 %) Grounds Maint. (5 . 9 %) Tree & Shrub Maint.
Regular Hours Worked
(34 . 0%) General Repairs
(8 . 1 °/o) Machinery
4Y:-
(8 .4%) Snow Removal
, L .
( 11 .6%) Time Off
(25 .9%) Perm. Improv. ( 1 .44 Vate err Mainft t
(8 . 6%) Brush & Weeds
It It
I -ell
CA t
.i
Overtime Hours Worked
d
I s � (2.6%) Machinery
(4. 8%) General Repairs
.lM N
(88 .8%) Snow Removal AR M&
t
t ,
- R-914 � QdS
Y•
1 � .:.ir I�'I ml
6
1 .0% = Water Maint. 0 .5% = Perm. Improv .
0 .3 % = Brush & Weeds
Town Engineer ' s Annual Report to the Town Board
for 1995
1995 was a busy year for the Town Engineering Department with
✓ an emphasis based on developing a strong maintenance and
engineering support program for Town facilities . The working
resources of the department were improved with an additional CADD
workstation and Microstation software and the delivery of the
entire planimet: ric map package from NYSEG . Some progress in
Records . Management and data processing capabilities were seen and
will continue into 1996 . The department staff totals 5 , including
the Town _ Engineer , Assistant Town Engineer , Assistant to the . Town
Engineer , Water and Sewer Maintenance Supervisor and Engineering
Technician . Along with maintenance of the water and sewer
facilities the Engineering Department provides technical support to
all other departments , including support of our expanding computer
system .
WATER PROJECTS
The Town Engineering staff worked with the Bolton Point staff
to . develop construction plans to implement the master metering
program for connections to the water transmission main . . . The SCLIWC
agreement includes a provision that all connection , points on the
transmission main to - the member municipalities will be metered for
the purposes of monitoring water consumption . The Town has the
responsibility to construct the meter site and SCLIWC will provide
and maintain 'the, meter . The project will be- bid for construction
during 1996 . _ _ u
Three Town - water storage tanks were inspected _ during 1995 . -
The inspection process includes draining the , . tank , entering the
tank to inspect_ the internal coating - system , operation . ; of . - .all
valves and controls , inspection , of the cathodic protection system
and inspection of the exterior coating . The inspection reports Are
the basis for scheduled maintenance on the tanks . The three tanks
inspected were :
1 . Ridgecrest - Structure in good condition , interior
coating in poor condition , valving and controls in good
condition , controls located in pit should be relocated to
above ground structure , site access in f air . condition
.
21 Sapsucker Woods - . Structure in good condition , interior
coating in poor condition , valving and controls in good
condition , controls located in pit should be relocated to
above ground structure , site access in fair condition ,
trees should be cleared around tank and fence .
3 . Danby Road - Structure in good condition , interior
coating in good condition , exterior coating in -fair
condition with spot repairs required , valving and
controls in good condition , site access fair , access road
a
Town Engineers 1995 Annual Report _ _ . 2
titt
And drainage in need of regrading and repair .
The Troy Road and Coddington Road water extension project was
completed and received final health department approval in 1995 .
The extension of the 12 " watermain ' across Rte . 13 at
Buttermilk Falls Road was - completed as a betterment in conjunction
with the NYSDOT improvement of Rte : 13 . This is a first step - in_
extending the main along Buttermilk Falls Road to the State park -to
replace an existing 6 " watermain which is deficient and in poor
condition . This project is planned for construction in 1996 .
Survey work * required for the - evaluation of a proposed new
water tank on the East Hill was started with the assistance of
Cornell student interns . The survey information is being utilized
in developing a water system model using the Cybernet computer
program .
A Cybernet model for the South Hill water system has been
developed and will used to assist in - system optimization and
reviewing - the mpacts ' of several - development * projects along ' Danby
Road .
The Town. Engineer began working with the Bolton Point staff �to
develop an engineering evaluation fora new - transmission water `
storage tank which is proposed for the Burdick Hill Road tank - site . `
This additional tank is an element of the SCLIWC capital plan and
will provide - needed additional storage which will allow for energy
savings ' due - to off peak pumping , sufficient reserve stor_ age, and
maintenance on the ' ,' existing steel tank . The cost of the
improvement will be covered by existing fund balance and will note
require borrowing .
SEWER PROJECTS
Construction of the north West Haven Road and Mecklenberg Road
sewer extension was completed in � 1995 . - The project included 8 " PVC
sewer line and a flow monitoring station at the city line .
A short section of sewer was being installed under Rte 13 at
the City line to allow for future sewer service to Buttermilk Falls
Road east including the Buttermilk Falls State Park . This work was
being done as a betterment in conjunction with reconstruction of
Rte . 13 ,
The Town. Engineer is working with the Finger Lakes State Parks
to develop a sewer plan to serve the Buttermilk Falls State park .
This may be installed as part of the improvements to the park `
facilities planned for possible construction in 1996 .
4
Town Engineers 1995 Annual Report 3
The snow storm on November 15 - 16 , 1995 resulted - in power
interruptions and voltage drops in the northeast portion of the
Town and caused failures of several pump stations in the Forest
Home area , Two of the large pump stations operate on 3 - Phase power
and the reduced voltage on leg of the 3 - phase caused several coils
in the motor starters to burn out . The controls are over 20 years
old' and replacement parts are not readily available which resulted
in several days of semi - automatic operation ( pumps had to be
manually started twice a day ) . No residents were adversely
affected , but an evaluation of the - controls is underway to
determine if an upgrade ' of the controls which - would provide
additional protection in the case of power outages is appropriate .
The Town and City staff worked cooperatively to handle this
emergency .
The Town Engineer has been working with the City DPW on a plan
for improving the sewage transmission capacity that is jointly
used . The Joint Sewer agreement has been going through a revision
by a sub - committee of the - SJS regarding ' plant capacity and
transmission sewer improvements and maintenance responsibility .
One component of an improved sewer , system was incorporated in the
plans for the NYSDOT project for improvements on the Octopus . The
City has been negotiating with DOT regarding the construction of
and cost of - the betterment and the City intends to bond the sewer
betterment package and bill the Town on an annual basis - for the
appropriate share of the cost .
--The Northeast sewer system , which is served by the Village of
Cayuga Heights WWTP , was the subject - of a significant maintenance
inventory program . The workplan includes clearing right - of - ways ,
cleaning sewers and inspection with a television camera that is
being purchased by the SJS . The inspection will result in a work
plan for reducing infiltration problems on the Town system to help
relieve the wet weather hydraulic load - on the Cayuga Heights
treatment plant .- - Work completed during 1995 included clearing of
the backlot sewer between Sapsucker Woods Road and Salem Drive .
Several manholes were also repaired in that line .
The Town gook delivery on the new Jet Rod in early april and
it was put to good use on a major grease blockage in the East Hill
Plaza area . The accumulation of grease which caused sewers to back
up in the commercial and office facilities on Judd Falls Road was
very extensive and took two days to thoroughly clean up : The
source of the grease apparently was restaurants in the East Hill
Plaza and the facility owner was being billed for the cleanup .
DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
Three Town of Ithaca subdivision projects requiring
f -
Town Engineers 1995 Annual Report . 4
Engineering Staff compliance review were active during 1995 . Two
of these projects involved the construction of new town roads along
with _ utilities and drainage improvements . A Town of Dryden
subdivision , Peregrine Hollow off of Snyder Hill Road , abuts the
Town of Ithaca and was reviewed for environmental impacts and for
sewer service considerations .
10 Saponi Meadows , Seven Mile Drive
The first phase ._ of the - Saponi Meadows Subdivision ,
located on Seven Mile Drive proceeded slowly throughout the
year _ and has not received final acceptance . The initial
construction included approximately 1000 feet of road , 2700
lineal feet of 8 " sewer main, and 1400 lineal feet of 811 DIP
water main . Installation of the sanitary sewer main and the
water main has been completed and tested and acceptance is
pending final certification by the owners engineer..- The road
base and related drainage was constructed during the summer of
1995 , and the developer is waiting until the 1996 construction
season to - complete the road pavement .
2 . Sanctuary. Woods , Sapsucker Woods Road
=. ! Construction of the Sanctuary Woods Subdivision road and
utility improvements .. was .. . completed during - the - - - 1995
construction season . The Town Board accepted the completed
improvements in December and once the deeds are transferred ,
the Town will take maintenance and operation responsibility .
. . _ The improvements included ..approximately 800 lineal feet . .of
roadway , watermain and sanitary sewer main , . . .
30 Ecovill. age , Mecklenburg Road
The Ecovillage Subdivision and first resident group
development was also approved by the Planning Board and the
Town Board . This project included approximately 1200 lineal
feet of 8 " PVC sewer which will be dedicated to the Town . , The
sewer has been installed and was inspected by Town Engineering
staff and acceptance of the facility is pending final record
drawings and certifications from the developer ' s Engineer .
The -. Water system for the site is being constructed as a
private: water system which will use the Town ' s West Haven Road
water main as it ' s source of supply .
Peregrine Hollow Sewer District , Snyder Hill Road , Town of Dryden
The Town of Ithaca received a request from the Town of
Dryden to allow a connection to the Town of Ithaca Slaterville
Road Sewer from the proposed Peregrine Hollow Sewer District .
The request was accompanied by an engineering report from
Town Engineers 1995 Annual Report _ _ - " _ _. 5
Ralph Varn. , the developer of the Peregrine Hollow Subdivision
in the Town of Dryden . The Town Engineer evaluated the
proposal ELnd prepared a draft agreement to allow the Town of
Dryden to transport sewage through Town of Ithaca sewer lines .
This connection would allow the Town of Dryden to utilize
sewage treatment capacity it owns as a partner in the Ithaca
Area Wastewater Treatment Facility . The agreement includes
provisions; that make Dryden responsible - foi: costs of
improvements required for the Dryden usage including a portion
of maintenance costs . The Town of Dryden created a new sewer
district for this project and requested the purchase of
additional capacity in the IAWWTP for this sewer extension .
This sewer district consists only of property that is the
Peregrine Hollow subdivision . The developer -prepared
construction drawings for the connection to the Town Sewer .
A part of the sewer improvements are in the Town of Ithaca and
will be dedicated to the Town n upon completion . All flows will
be metered. through a sewer . monitoring station at or near the
Town Line . At the end of the year , the initial phase of the
sewer had been constructed by the developer but has not _ yet
been accepted by the Town . The sewer was plugged at the Town
line pending approvals and execution of required agreements :
EARTH FILL PERMITS
Earth fill permits -are required - for excavation or fill
placement in - excess of 50 CY - per year on parcels in the Town of
Ithaca unless the project has received a building permit or other
Town approval . The ' Town Engineer issues permits administratively
if the volume is less than 250 CY and the Board of Zoning Appeals
issues the permits for larger projects . If a project exceeds 2500
CY of excavation or fill a Planning Board review and recommendation
is required . Two major earth fill permits were issued during .1995 ,
including * _ . .
1 . Five Mile Drive , Tax Parcel 31 . - 2 - 26 . 2
An earth fill permit for placement of up to 60 , 000 cubic yards
of clean fill - with the potential source of fill being the Rte .
96 Project was issued 9 / 28 / 95 .
29 Cornell University Library Annex , Precinct 7 , Rte 366 '
An earth :fill permit was issued 9 / 28 / 95 for placement of
approximately 12 , 500 cubic yards of earth fill for the
restoration of the old land fill adjacent to the Library Annex
in the Orchards area . This site is above the recreation way
and Cascadilla Creek and may include some work in wet land
areas along with related stormwater management improvements .
Town Engineers 1995 Annual Report
. _ 6
The plan .includes improvements to a detention area adjacent to
the Life safety building on Palm Road , and a new detention
area to the east of - the campus stores building .
Cornell University . is preparing an earth fill permit
application for the restoration of -the old land fill adjacent
to the Library Annex in the Orchards area . This site is above
the recreation way and Cascadilla Creek and may include some
work in wet land areas - along with related stormwater
management improvements . -
FACILITIES
Town Hall
The .Town Hall needs and space analysis was completed with the
assistance of HOLT &C . The search for a new Town Hall site resulted
in the evaluation of many . sites both in the City of Ithaca and the
Town . - After selection by _ . the Town Board , schematic design
development proceeded and a proposal for the new Town Hall was
brought forward-. The staff is anticipating completing the process
and being in 'the new Town Hall in 1996 .
Highway and Parks Facility _
The Town closed on the purchase of the Gatch parcel adjacent
to the Highway garage . on Seven Mile Drive on January 31 , - and __
renovations for the parks shop " and equipment storage _, space have
proceeded through out the year using Town forces . r
HIGHWAY AND PARKS PROJECTS
The Judd Falls Road reconstruction project was designed and
constructed . Project work included drainage improvements ,
replacement of the base , replacement of curb and gutter , . and new
pavement . Cornell University participated in the project with a
rehabilitation of the Plantations Road pipe -under pass .
project received a great deal of interest from the residents and
many features to accommodate local concerns were incorporated . into
the final design . The design included the use of recycled asphalt
pavement for-, binder , and the use of modified asphalt pavement .
The Downstream Forest Home bridge project was not constructed
during 1995 as originally planned due to design complications and
funding problems . The project was nearing final design at the end
of the year and construction in 1996 is anticipated . The project
is currently under NYSDOT and Federal review . John Lampman , the rs
County Project Manager , has indicated that , based on his
' h
Town Engineers 1995 Annual ReAort 7
conversations with NYSDOT , this revised schedule should not
jeopardize the ISTEA funding .
The Town Engineering staff surveyed the road drainage at the
north end of Sapsucker Woods Road after a request from a landowner
and the lab of ornithology . A proposed ditch profile and culvert
replacement laas designed which may serve to reduce drainage
problems that have affected several residents in the area .
Implementation of remedial measures will be a cooperative effort
between the Town of Ithaca Highway department and the Town of
Dryden .
A topographic survey of the Maple Avenue Road right - of - way was
completed by the Engineering Staff at the request of the Highway
and Parks department and a plan map is being prepared . The
information will be the basis for safety improvements to Maple
Avenue and access improvements for the recreation way which are in
the planning stage . Cornell University made improvements to the
Maple Avenue -Parking lot and provisions for a walkway along Maple
Avenue were included in their plans .
The portion of Elm Street Extension at the crossing of the Coy
Glen has been an area of concern for several years due to unstable
road banks and a sharp curve at the bottom of a steep grade . The
Engineering and Highway departments are in the process of
developing an improvement plan for this area and a topographic
survey of the area was completed . This information will be used to
develop construction plans and cost estimates for the safety
improvements .
C . \MEMOS\ERPT95AR . REP
TOWN OF ITHACA PLANNING DEPARTMENT
ANNUAL REPORT FOR 1995
CORNELL SPECIAL LAND USE DISTRICT
A major accomplishment in 1995 was the adoption of the Cornell Special Land Use
District (SLUR) for Precinct 7. Staff worked with a Town Board committee and
Cornell representatives in revising the draft SLUR legislation during 1995 . This work
also resulted in a side agreement with Cornell University regarding the development
of state and federal facilities in Precinct 7 and the establishment of the Town of
Ithaca / Cornell University Transportation Committee, which will study and make
recommendations on transportation issues related to Precinct 7 and surrounding
areas .
DEVELOPMENT REVIEW
A major portion of Planning Department time was spent in support of the activities
of the Planning Board in the review of subdivisions, site plans, special approvals,
recommendations to the Town Board, and other planning activities . A "Summary of
Town of Ithaca Planning Board Actions - 1995" is attached to this report. The
Planning Board approved a total of 49 actions during 1995, including 9 final
subdivision approvals, 14 final site plan approvals and 11 recommendations to the
Town Board.
In 1995, the Planning Department received 43 development review applications
consisting of 25 site plan reviews, 12 subdivision reviews, 3 lot line modifications,
and 3 fill permits . A total of $3,843 . 00 was collected in non-refundable application
fees, and $16,516 . 00 was collected in refundable review fees. No new escrow.
accounts were established (an escrow account is set up when a review fee deposit for
a project excedes $1 ,000). Planning, engineering and legal time charged to these
projects totaled $16,344.50 (as of September 30, 1995) . There are 4 projects which
have outstanding; balances. Payment has been requested from . the applicants.
Significant Planning staff time was also spent on the following specific projects :
Ithacare DEIS and FEIS: The Ithacare Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS)
was accepted by the Planning Board in June 1995. Staff spent a significant amount of
time working with the appplicant on the preparation of the Final Environmental
Impact Statement (FEIS). The FEIS was accepted as complete on December 19, 1995.
Staff is currently working on a draft of the Statement of Findings, which is expected
to be completed in January or February 1996 .
EcoVilla ze SLUL!: Staff worked with the Planning Board, Attorney for the Town and
First Residents' Group in completing the Special Land Use District (SLUD) for the
EcoVillage project on Mecklenburg Road. The SLUR was adopted by the Town
Board in January 1995 . Final subdivision and site plan approvals were granted by
the Planning Board at the June and July 1995 meetings.
PEZ Meetings: The Planning, Engineering, Zoning and Highway Departments
continued to meet in 1995 on a bi-weekly basis to coordinate development reviews
and compliance issues .
Zoning Board SI=OR Reviews : The Planning Department staff prepared SEQR (State
Environmental Quality Review Act) reviews, including Environmental Assessment
Forms and staff recommendations on environmental impact) for the Zoning Board of
Appeals on area and use variances and special approvals.
Town Board SEOR Reviews : Staff prepared SEQR reviews for locals laws and other
Town Board actions .
CONSERVATION BOARD
The Planning Department provided staff regular support to the Conservation Board
during 1995. Staff attended Conservation Board meetings and submitted quarterly
vouchers and reports to the State for reimbursement under the Local Environmental
Assistance Program (LEAP) . Funding for the LEAP has been discontinued for the
State' s 1995-96 fiscal year. Staff also provided support to the Environmental Review
Committee. In addition, progress was made on the following major initiatives in
cooperation with the Conservation Board,
Parks , Recreation and Open Space Plan Update: Staff continued work with the Park
and Greenway Committee to update the 1977 and 1984 Park and Open Space Plans.
All draft chapters have been completed, includeing recommendations, cost estimates
and a 5 Year Capital Plan. A completed draft Plan is now being assembled, which
will be reviewed. by the Park and Greenway Committee and the Public Works
Commitee, after which the Plan will be forwarded to the Town Board for
consideration.
Environmental Atlas : Staff continued efforts with the Environmental Atlas /GIS
Committee to advance the preparation of an Environmental Atlas for the Town of
Ithaca. The purpose is to assemble a single source of data on significant
environmental fE! atures in the town in digital format so that both maps and
information can be quickly accessed and overlaid for analysis . Preliminary base
maps for Unique Natural Areas and wetlands in the town were prepared. This will
be a continuing effort over the next several years, and will be integrated into a GIS
format as the Town develops a new GIS system.
PLANNING COMMITTEE
The Planning Department worked with the ' Planning Committee on a number of
initiatives which had been recommended as implementation measures in the Town of
Ithaca Comprehensive Plan (Sept. 12, 1993), including the following.
Six Mile Creek Conservation District: A proposed Conservation District for the Six
Mile Creek area has been drafted and revised several times during 1995 . A public
meeting was held with residents of the Six Mile Creek area to obtain input on the
proposed zoning district. A special joint meeting of the Planning Committee and
Codes and Ordinances Committee was held in December 1995 to work out details of
the proposed local law. Final revisions be made and public hearings will be held in
early 1996 .
Defining Buildable Land in Subdivisions: A draft amendment to the Subdivision
Regulations was .prepared by the Planning Committee to clarify the procedure for
determining the location and number of dwelling units or lots in conventional and
clustered subdivisions. The proposal was forwarded to the Codes and Ordinances
Committee, and the Attorney for the Town is researching legal aspects of the
proposal.
Rural Residential, District: The Planning Committee began an analysis of a possible
new 'Rural Residential" District. This would be comparable in format to the R 30
District, but would have a lower density and would be applied to areas not served
by or planned for public sewer or water. Work on this proposal will continue in
1996 .
CODES AND ORDINANCES COMMITTEE
The Planning Department assisted the Codes and Ordinances Committee with several
important initiatives in 1995 .
Fees in Lieu of Parkland : Staff worked with Codes and Ordinances on revising a
draft local law to establish fee amounts in lieu of parkland reservation for
subdivisions and multi-family developments. The Town Board adopted the new
local law in September 1995 .
Sunset Provisions for Subdivision Aoprovals and Preliminary Site Plans : The Town
Board approved ZLn amendment to the Subdivision Regulations to extinguish
abandoned subdivisions and a new local law to provide for expiration of preliminary
site plans if a final site plan is not submitted to the Planning Board within a certain
time limit.
Analvsis of MR , Commercial , Industrial and Special Land Use Districts: At the
request of the Town Board, the Codes and Ordinances Committee undertook an
analysis of parcels where no development has occurred in the above-referenced
t
zoning categories . Specific parcels were identified with relevant information on
ownership, acreage, development potential, surrounding zoning, etc.
Recommendations for rezoning certain of these parcels were made, and public
hearings are in the process of being scheduled at the Planning Board for
recommendations on the proposed rezonings .
Zoning Ordinance Revision: The Codes and Ordinances Committee initiated a
comprehensive review of the current Zoning Ordinance to determine where revisions
may be appropriate, especially in light of the Comprehensive Plan that was adopted
in 1993 . This work will continue in 1996 and will include recommendations to the
Town Board for updates, clarifications, reorganization, and in some cases zoning
district changes . This work will be coordinated with the Planning Committee.
ITHACA-TOMPKINS COUNTY TRANSPORTATION COUNCIL (ITCTC)
The Town Planner serves on the ITCTC Planning Committee and attended bi-
monthly meetings in 1995 . The Town Planner served as liason to the Steering
Committee for the County Trail / Corridor Study, which was completed in draft in
December 1995 . Staff also participated in the Route 96 / Octopus Project Mitigation
Committee in the early part of 1995, which included discussions on detouring traffic
during construction, the need for dissemination of information to the public on the
status of construction, coordination between various agencies, and the role of public
transit and park-,and-ride lots as possible mitigation measures .
OTHER PLANNING DEPARTMENT PROJECTS
The Planning DE!partment worked on a number of other projects during 1995 .
Eastern Heights Park - Dedication of General Purpose Land as Parkland: The
Planning, Engineering and Parks Departments provided assistance to the Town Board
regarding the dedication of the General Purpose lands at Eastern Heights Park as
parkland. Research and maps were provided, and a site visit to the park was
conducted. The Town Board dedicated the General Purpose land as parkland in July
1995.
Inlet Valley Parkland: Staff assisted the Town Board with research and analysis of
several parcels in Inlet Valley that had been placed on the auction block by the
County. Research focused on the parcels' potential use as parkland. A Phase I
Environmental Site Assessment was conducted to determine whether there are any
known contamination problems with the parcels. Work will continue on this into
1996 .
Affordable Housing Pro2osals : Staff spent considerable time during 1995 discussing
several proposed. affordable housing proposals with the applicants regarding several
properties within the town. Two major project proposals may be forthcomimg
during 1996 .
I
Cayuga Lake Waterfront Planning The Town has agreed to participate in a joint
program with the County, City of Ithaca, Chamber of Commerce and Cornell
University to enhance the Cayuga Lake waterfront. The County has successfully
obtained a grans: for this project. The project has been initiated and will continue in
1996 .
Tompkins County _Airport Master Plan Update: The Town Planner served on the
Airport Land Use Committee and attended several meetings during 1995. Work
focused on an updated land use map of . areas surrounding the Airport and an
analysis of anticipated /planned development in the area.
Geographic Information System (GIS) : Staff conducted research and assembled
information of possible GIS software and hardware that could be obtained by the
Town. Funds were approved in the 1996 Budget to acquire and implement a GIS
system. This will probably begin in the 2nd Quarter of 1996.
ISTEA Grant Acplications : Staff worked on two grant applications for ISTEA
enhancement funds for bicycle / pedestrian trails. One is a combined application with
the City of Ithaca for a trail linking the future Black Diamond Trail with Buttermilk
Falls State Park, with a bridge crossing Elmira Road on the new abutments. The
second invloves the William and Hannah Pew Trail in East Ithaca and a extension of
the East Ithaca Recreationway along Maple Avenue. Both projects have been
determined by the State to be eligible under ISTEA criteria. The applications will be
finalized in early 1996.
Respectfully submitted,
Jonathan Kanter, Director of Planning
January 8, 1996
SUMMARY OF TOWN OF ITHACA PLANNING BOARD ACTIONS - 1995
Preliminary Subdivision Approvals Granted 3
Final Subdivision Approvals Granted 9
(Includes actions where prelim. &
final approval were simultaneous)
Preliminary Situ Plan Approvals Granted 5
Final Site Plan Approvals Granted 14
(Includes actions where prelim. &
final approval were simultaneous)
Rezoning or Other Recommendation to Town Board 11
Sign Review Board Recommendation to ZBA 4
Special Approval Recommendation to ZBA 3
TOTAL ACTIONS 49
I — I •
OAR 0 0 ! o Q, zo �'
i� �3 - I �3 C7 -
77
M C �^� is it
I H a
t G] C[r r f #
if
' • 3-
r
W W 3
i! D N N ( W js Ln
i� m W w ? ,
N V) i w
H
p w t�
r
J co W r in
N W l If U Ln L�
co
91 r ±i
I tttt N J W N W I ?. O
Ln m c f� w � b H
t;
w J :,
� ?�-� `� � H
�! t � .1 j H 6 y
co Ln'{ U
Ln ]
Ln r m ^
W N J1 t j
co 3
r J m +; a too
3 J a%
W
t
co r co ,p I k
( � � m � 1
, . . p y
� w a% Ln
n co m !
t
Ln W t
r m
Ln m w �n
ko r r r i m
m r m 31
i
o C30pa �
� I
PS O C 0 N O N O
tU r F• tZ O > N Z O O Q y +
f-- N r C ra n7 (( _ 11 i
°L2 O i Q (J1 # U] 'TJ < C H I
b f a H PC
CD �Q n .0 z i ,� 4 i H c� ;{ fy-1 p
I I O 1 D! i 0 cn 1 1
H
1 1 I I CM O I � � t � j tit
cn j
t I I Q�l 1 f j
it I 1 I f2 S j j C
"'
to
u I t l t '• � � ' :'
' 1 i
C� m N 6 r ! ►"'' � CTi : r j m tr � J CEO
�a
m Ut
O UIbN2
�r w O O O ; C
a) INS" k1lbb
ftj
d
1 I UQ! A) i i 1 s ^. if H
cot
cD r i m stns m r
I 1 I C
GV
t'T � f� � � 19b I (S)
i
1 ! 1 0 1 m I r r
N w I ° C l
�
4
if
U] j C-Z
co
s �
W r j r m Ln i
m Ob 1 r I Ob °P co C
Ob
Iili i{ C.fa
co jtn
ob
co
i
j As r r 3 m r i to
II
co ! tp ;
co lob
Ln
N
I CJI
%0 Ln J r
Ln ko
rQ
t
°
' �� N
ro � xxH -� wv � ncn
rc m r O
O 0 to rr N F-+ N L< N G ? H � C d
M rs O fD rt c'r F+- rr rt O z t
(D (D NwHG 0a 0 O
N W a a 0 M 0 M s
c* 'C (D G ? N
N R `G x G h- N rs rs En ' H M z O
O O 0 rf Fes-- (D N (D i4 f � H H H
a s to F- ° c* ~raj H j � 0 cn G1 s C
rrra a C,D czn Enn 'TJcn O � H
rOnl�- f ; t~+ Z �sC%J i ~3C: H �
HCr ;L' M 'IH iz C �
ifO ( G0) [a m
o
O O
i !
v �
C4 _.
x � mr ° 1O 'jv i � _ ty
r r N ? i 1 =
Q1Is-' ip r .P W r J bA cn Co Co
co
0 I 11t t
uj
N z 1 �P € m m irJJ fk0 C=
W . 0
C
G co sOr W n
cn
j C=l
Q1 Im r m N m W DD N IP bob b I tD t m N W a
tD i H
.w T 0
Cot
jA
r W (n O r7 O O O W I r `; m r i Ln tQ
G (D M rr 'C3 (D Cn > * !
� � ; H
fl (D O a a '} tD f N ( J c-' if
0 ct PC rt . c'► tM � G Cl {# p m m N C9 ! O s f Z a t�
cr! cal t G n ' I 1 S
(D a G rS C i ', f N G
E Q' h-j as
O\ µ rj If
J jm m ( N 10 CO � r[. �
t s :f H—i(D ril LC tri°n, rr Ei { i1 C„
Cot LJ tD (n
cam.+ cn
co I
41
H M Imr mp m I �
r N ►3 I I i � � ^�
cn
IrrN rWti H i' t
t.�
Cot Z i r r Ln W Ln 0 00 '
►�- OD }j H C7
t I 3
� Cc � ra cnp cn < O
M I z
NIm rm m r 'C Em N iPJ N N � 0
n
rr
µ ss N A QW1 Q�1 j i
O 1 tD
O to r m s J lob to K'
O1 N
B N a% N Cnn tD
CO r N III N 000
W
i
N N co N co j
w bob 01 N J W !i
if i,
I W N t �J � W � � �D #•
it t W N J N
Ln
I INN I I;
co
;
' ! r `
N { ' t
N ! t C W
J i W CO y � it y; W
1995 YEAR - TO - DATE FEES COLLECTED BYTHF BUILDING/ZONING DEPARTN(F. NT
MONTH BUILDING I ZONING SIGNS FIRE BUILDING CERTIFICATES OUNDATION ' PERATING TOTALS
PERMITS rOARD OF' SAFETY PERMIT OF PER 41ITS PERMITS
A PPEALS _:CTENSTONS OCCUPANCY
JAN 19330.00 340.00 0.00 25.CoU 30.00 150.00 0.00 0.00 1.575.00
FEB 545.00 440.00 0.00 81.001 0,001 50.00 0.00 0.001 1. 116.00
MAR '1'_0.00 420.00• 468.70 104.00 0.00 125.00 50.00 50.00 1.937.70
APR 340.00 3350 _ 144.00 25.00 100.00 4).00 0.00 1.6.1250
MAY ").00 480.00 0.00 131.00 75.00 0.00 0.00 50.00 i 1.56.00
JUN 935.00 280.00 0.00 181100 50.00 525.00 0.00 0.0ol 2.921.00
JIM 1375.00 :60.00 25.99 L^4 .00 0.00 LS.CO 0.00 0.001 3.00999
AUG 1,485.001 80.00 0.00 81.00 :0.00 50.00 0.00 0.00 1.736.00
SEP I ^_.1^0.00 I 280.00 0.00 75.001 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 2.455.00
OCT 310.00 240.00 S%.00 0.00 25.00l 162.M 0.001 0.001 79350
NOV 1.475.00 ?50.00 21Z.00 25.001 75.00 T.00 000 150.00 1197.00
DEC 610.00 340.00 0.00 218.75 50.00 0.00 0.00 7.400.00 j 758.75
ALS I 13.ti25.00 I 3.y<i0.00 I 796. 19 1.189 .75 380.00 1337.50 100.01) 7.650.00 ( 21.(7'3.44
1994 TOTALS
MONTH BUILDING ZONING SIGNS FIRE BUILDING CERTIFICATES OUNDATION PERATING TOTALS
PERMITS OARD OF SAFETY PERMIT OF PER.NfrrS PERMITS
APPEALS `{TENSIONS OCCUPANCY
TOTALS 17.070.00 1 3.W. .00 1 514.00 950.00 330.00 3.100.00 350.00 2.000.00 279-4.00
OF IT�
F a TOWN OF ITHACA
210�4- 126 EAST SENECA STREET, ITHACA , N . Y. 14850
� Y
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273- 1704
AGENDA ITEM N0 , 6
1995 ANNUAL PERSCNDTEL REPORT
ACCOMPLISIO ENTS :
1 . CERTIFIED PAYROLL UNDER CIVL SERVICE
2 . ESTABLISHED TOWN EMPLOYMENT POSITIONS PER CIVIL SERVICE
3 . EESTABLISHED FEDERAL DRUG kNllD ALCOHOL TESTING PROGRAM
4 . VIOLENCE IN THE WORKPLACE QUESTIONNAIRE APPROVED AND
:TENT OUT TO TOWN EMPLOYEES
5 . EESTABLISHEED SAFETY AND SECURITY POLICY
6 . REVISED THE EMPLOYEE GRIEVANCE PROCEDURE
7 . ANALYZED THE PAYROLL SYSTEM : RECEIVED QUOTES FROM
FOUR PAYROLL FIRMS AND DECIDED ON DATARITE
8 . ESTABLISHED VACATION AND PERSONAL TIME TO TAKE EFFECT
ON JANUARY 1st OF EACH YEAR INSTEAD OF ON ANNIVERSARY
laa # 6
ASSISTANT BUDGET OFFICER
1995 ANNUAL REPORT
In 1995 revenues were down slightly due mainly to a drop in
the Mortgage Tax . I spent a great deal of time throughout the . year
managing the budget and keeping a close eye ( and purse string ) on
Town funds . My efforts were successful ; we were able to target
our funds on necessary projects as well as day to day needs and
still have healthy fund balances at year end .
I have been working with Computel , a utilities auditing firm .
They have spent months researching our telephone , electric , - water ,
and telemetering services and looking for ways to - save us money .
They have recommended some changes to our electric service . _ They
have discovered errors in tariffs and rate charges . . So -far they
have saved the Town almost $ 40 , 000 . 00 . They hope to conclude their
study shortly and I will be presenting a more detailed report in
the months tof dome
.
Our interest income on investments has risen significantly
this year . I have been doing some wise investing of Town monies in
higher yielding Repurchase Agreements and Lworking on a more
detailed cash flow analysis . There is still a need to watch our
investments and continually change our strategies . to keep up with
the new banking laws and our changing economy .
Some research has been done into electronic banking services .
Electronic Funds Transfer ( EFT ) and electronic bill payment _plans
would be very helpful to the Town . While no decisions have been
made it will. be wise to keep in touch with ' the , bank
representatives . Their programs are constantly improving and the
services they offer could greatly lighten work loads .
Working with our independent auditors , I have put into action
a plan for auditing our Justices . Our independent auditors have
audited Judge Wallenbeck ' s and Judge Larkin ' s records through June
of this year . They will return in early 1996 to complete the audit
through December 1995 . In 1996 I will audit the Justices ' records
annually with the independent auditors returning every third year
or when a Justice leaves office . I am hoping this is the first
step of an internal auditing plan .
Although 'they have not been put into action yet , a five - year
budget and five - year capital plan have been developed . These plans
will make it easier for us to see into the future to cultivate
budgets and projects with low impact on the taxpayers . I would
like to continue to work on these plans and hopefully have them up
and running by mid 1996 .
Jackie Whi. te completed the basic Municipal Accounting course
offered by Ni' S Audit and Control and attended classes on
networking . She has come a long way this year understanding
municipal accounting and how our funds function . Jackie has taken
on several additional tasks this year including bond payments ,
Cornell sewer billing , Forest . Home water billing , lighting bills ,
etc . This will be Jackie ' s second year end closing with the Town
of Ithaca . Her growth in understanding accruals and encumbrances
will allow her to provide more assistance in closing the books for
the fiscal year .
In addition to his regular duties , George Eberhardt has been
working on our fixed assets throughout the year , He has
established a data base program with all the pertinent data which
Is continually updated during the year . In 1996 we have budgeted
for a fixed asset software program . This will - be an immense help
in providing information on inventory , depreciation , replacement
plans and much more . I am hoping that George ' s duties will -. be
expanding in this area . George and I have been working together -,to
improve his purchasing skills . He is getting familiar with our
stock of supplies on hand and the fluxuation of it usage . George
searches catalogs for - best prices , ' best quality , and best deals on
our office supplies . He is improving his understanding of
technical terms such as those needed in ordering supplies for
Highway -rand Water and Sewer departments . In the future I would
like George - to hone his purchasing skills and perhaps develop an
Inventory of office supplies ' to help eliminate shrinkage .
The Automatic Data Processing ( ADP ) Committee has had a _ busy
year . We worked to replace ' as � many of the old 286 computers as
possible . We researched , recommended , purchased and licensed
standardized " word processing and spreadsheet software for all
computers . Elimination of unlicensed programs is in the works .
There was a virus that infected all our. machines . Mike quickly
" cured " them with Norton Anti - virus programs . .. We have initiated a
backup program that will be uniform throughout the offices and help
eliminate lost data . The - Committee has begun to educate ourselves
in windows and networking . Members went to Bolton Point to see
( and admire ) the Windows for Workgroups used there . Larry Parlett
is an ' expert in this field and graciously explained how to set up
a system and how it works . In 1996 the Committee would like to be
able to make an recommendation to the Board on our system needs .
Respectfully submitted
Sally E . Alario
Assistant Budget Officer
i
TOWN OF ITHACA
INVESTMENT REPORT
FOR THE QUARTER 10/01 - 12/31 /95
REPURCHASE AGREEMENTS
DATE RATE OF MATURITY INTEREST
ACQUIRED AMOUNT INTEREST DATE EARNED
08/23/95 $6009000.00 5. 55% 10/10/95 $4,379. 18
08/23/95 $579217. 92 5. 55% 11 /20/95 $774.32
08/23/95 $1 , 187,947. 64 5955% 11 /21 /95 $16,256.98
10/10/95 $604,379. 18 5.35% 12/11 /95 $5,492940
12/07/95 $700,000.00 5.25% 03/07/96 ***************
12/07/95 $57,992.24 5900% 03/07/96 ******************
12/11 /95 $609,871 .58 5935% 03/11 /96 *******************
SAVINGS
END OF MONTH RATE OF INTEREST
MONTH BALANCE INTEREST EARNED
10/31 /95 $1 ,607,492.95 3.25% $4,513.49 _ . ..
11 /30/95 $29895,244.40 3.25`Yo $5,938.35
12/31 /95 $1 ,741 ,848. 87 3.25% $6,205. 13
INTEREST CHECKING
END OF MONTH RATE OF INTEREST
MONTH BALANCE INTEREST EARNED
10/31 /95 $156,829. 57 175% $451 .90
11 /30/95 $107,041 . 12 1 .75% $286.49
12/31 /95 $1 ,079,885. 63 1 .75% $574.58
i
i
i
TOWN OF ITHACA
ANNUAL INVESTMENT REPORT
FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING 12 / 31 / 95
This annual investment report for the fiscal year 12 / 31 / 95 is being
submitted to the Town of Ithaca Town Board as specified in the Town
Investment Policy adopted 05 / 11 / 87 , and revised 05 / 07 / 90 .
Proposed changes to the investment policy : None .
Investment income for 1995 from :
Repurchase Agreements 173 , 621 . 52
S2LVings 48 , 915 . 01
Interest checking 4 , 825990
Grand Total 1995 Interest 227 , 362 . 43
Due to a slight rise in interest rates , . cash availability , and some
improvements of investment strategies interest earned for 1995 was
more than double the amount earned in 1994 .
A listing of investments and collateral at year - end are included in
the independent auditor ' s report to be distributed to the Board
under separate cover .
Respectfully submitted
Sally Alario
Assistant Budget Officer
01 / 24 / 96
FEB- 12- 1996 11 43 ROM SCLIWC a' BOLTON POINT TO 27317 04 P . 01
V�l
Southem Cayuga Lake
lntelrmunicipa! Water Commission
Year End Closing Transfers
to the
1995 Operating Budget
Transfer Awopriation Unes
Anount From Une To Line
$1 ,2009Cb 8310.460 !n-House Training 8310.405 A uditor Alt am
i
$325900 8310.410 Office Supplies 8310.411 Printing and Postage
$218.00 8310.410 office Supplies 8310.437 DOW Processing
$1100400 834x. 102 Dist. Overhime 1MG. 101 Dist, Personal Svcs.
$60400 8340.201 Dist_ Equipment 8340.212 Tools/Equip. Port, & Supplies
31 .M00 9080. 800 Health ins erg 9010.800 Stage Retirement
MAP/ 93w tz 41A oo*4 rwL 93209101 61M 4
E4 z q401 7 { i
.��
�' lan� t From
Co�D9pt j Co. w7p 1
?NCt16 * Phone M
: . -ax # r-ax IF
'10,Rag
_ 7q 1
r
y
TCTRL P . O1
it
i
TOWN ::
LTHACA.<: . . . . . .. . :
IiTGHWAY .
� .
PARKS ;;DE3I�RTiMEi�T
AND: : . ::: . .:. ::: . :. . . . . .. :.L T:. :.3ST. NF. O:.D
PRO ::....R�.. .:e�f.: .f. ...e. ...c. . ..t... .».:'r:..D�..t:e.a. :,D:t:. .. :De. . :a..::::t::>:::e;::=:,::::<.::,<:>.>:.::<»::.>.•:;::;<>;::::::::><;::;::::>:.>;:::::
Q;.2i. . . ..
::::::::,:::.:: : : ::::»: >?: :: .:
:
A rov
ed ' b ToGm..<.Soard :: and,: :.:.;;:.;:;:.;;:.;.: :.;.:.: .
1'. : . . . . . . . . . . : . . Town• :Attarae .: .:::.•::;: .:: : :::<:>
sure
PURPOSE OF POLICY
The U . S . Department of Transportation ( DOT ) has issued regulations pursuant to the Omnibus
Transportation Employee Testing Act of 1991 ( the Act which govern the use of drugs and
alcohol by commercial, motor vehicle drivers , and which also require the Town to conduct
mandatory drug and alcohol testing of covered drivers ) . The regulations require testing to
begin on January 1 , 1996 . It is the Town ' s intention to comply fully with the law and with
DOT ' s regulations governing drug and alcohol use and testing . In the event DOT ' s regulations
are amended , the Town reserves the right to apply the amended requirements immediately .
The purpose of this document is to outline the policy of the Town of Ithaca to comply with
Federal guidelines to maintain a drug and alcohol free work place for ' Commercial Drivers
License ( CDL ) drivers employed by the Town of Ithaca . The Town of Ithaca is firmly committed
to operating in the safest and most efficient manner possible . As a responsible employer ,
the Town of Ithaca is also committed to promoting the safety and welfare of its employees and
the public .
This policy was developed and will be implemented in accordance with the federal rules and
regulations of the Department of Transportation , Federal Highway Administration ( FHWA) 49 CFR
parts 40 , 382 , 3910 anal " 394 - - Controlled Substance Testing , which are applicable to the Town
of Ithaca .
POLICY PROCEDIIRES
�M_PLOYEE RESPONSIBILITY
It is the responsibility of each affected employee to comply with this policy . Any violation
of this policy , the law , or DOT regulations by an employee shall be grounds for disciplinary
action , up to and including discharge from employment .
APPLICABILITY
Drug and alcohol testing will be conducted on any current and/or prospective " driver " who may
be required to operate a " commercial motor vehicle " , as defined. by the .DOT ( see " Definitions "
below ) ,
All applicants for positions with the Town as a driver of a commercial motor vehicle ,
regardless of whether they are a new applicant or a current employee , will be notified of the
Town ' s drug and alcohol testing policy at the time they apply for a covered driver position
with the Town . They will also be informed that any offer of employment as such a driver will
be conditioned on their compliance with the policy .
DEFINITIONS
" Accident " means any occurrence involving a commercial motor vehicle operating on a public
road which results in :
1 ) a fatality ; or
2 ) a Town driver being cited for a moving traffic violation .
" Alcohol " means the intoxicating agent in beverage alcohol , ethyl alcohol , or other low
j 0 lecular weight alcohols including methyl and isopropyl alcohol .
Alcohol Concentration or Content " means the alcohol in a volume of breath expressed in terms
f grams of alcohol per 210 liters of breath as indicated by an evidential breath test ( EBT ) .
" Alcohol Use " means the consumption of any beverage , mixture , or preparation including any
medication , containing alcohol .
Drug & Alcohol Testing Policy and page 2
Procedure
" CDL " means Commercial Drivers ' . License .
" Commercial Motor Vehicle " . means a motor vehicle or combination of motor -vehicles that
1 ) has a gross combination weight rating of 26 , 001 or more pounds , `- inclusive of a
towed unit with a gross " vehicle weight rating or more than 10 , 000 pounds ; or
2 ) has a gross vehicle rating of 26 , 001 or more pounds ; or -
3 ) is designed to transport 16 or more passengers ( including the driver ) ; 'or
4 ) transports placarded hazardous materials .
" Confirmation Test " for alcohol testing means a second test , following a screening test with
a result of 0 . 02 or greater , that provides quantitative data of alcohol concentration . For
urine testing , a confirmation test means a second analytical procedure ( Split Specimen) to
identify the . presence of a specific drug or metabolite which is independent of the initial
test . Such a test is one ordered and paid for by the employee by contacting the lab which
performed . the initial test and requesting that a urine sample be sent to a lab (certified by
the Department of Health and Human Services ) selected by the employee .
" Driver " means any employee required by federal law and regulation to possess a CDL in order
to operate a commercial vehicle as defined by federal law and regulation . For the purposes
of pre - employment /pre - duty testing only , the term driver includes a person applying to the
Town to drive a commercial motor vehicle .
" Driving " ( Safety Sensitive Function ) includes the following activities of an employee who
holds a federally required CDL :
1 ) all time at or on Town property , or on any public property , waiting to be
dispatched,, unless the driver has been relieved from duty by his or her
supervisor ;
2 ) - all time inspecting equipment as required by federal regulations or otherwise
inspecting , servicing , or conditioning any commercial motor vehicle at any time ;
3 ) all time spent driving a federally defined commercial motor vehicle ; : ,-
4 ) all time , other than driving time , in or upon any commercial motor vehicle ;
5 ) all time loading or unloading a vehicle , supervising or assisting in the loading
or unloading , attending a vehicle being loaded or unloaded and remaining in
readiness to operate the vehicle ;
6 ) all :time spent performing the driver requirements under federal regulations
relating to accidents ; and
7 ) all time repairing , obtaining assistance , or remaining in attendance upon a
disabled vehicle .
" Drug " means
1 ) any substance listed on Schedule I of Appendix D to Sub - Chapter B of Title 49 of
the Code of Federal Regulations or other substance identified in Schedule I ,
2 ) an amphetamine or any formulation thereof ;
3 ) a narcotic drug or any derivative thereof ; or
4 ) any other substance which renders the driver incapable of safely operating a
motor vehicle .
Urinalysis will involve testing for the following drugs :
a . Marijuana
b . Cocaine
C , Amphetamines
d . Opiates ( including heroin )
e . Phencyclidine ( PCP )
" Medical Review Officer ( MRO ) " means a licensed physician responsible for receiving
laboratory results generated by the Town ' s drug testing program who has knowledge o:
substance abuse disorders and has appropriate medical training to interpret and evaluate an
individual ' s confirmed positive test result together with his or her medical history and any
other relevant bio - medical information .
Drug & Alcohol Testing Policy and
Procedure Page 3
" On - Duty Time " means all time from the time a driver begins work —ie— teed to be ae "' -'- until the time he or she is relieved from work and all responsibility for
tarticipating rforming work . On - Duty time shall also include all time spent travelling to and
in either a drug or alcohol test which it is pursuant to a random , reasonable
spicion , post - accident , or follow- up test as directed by or on behalf of the Town .
" Refuse to Submit " to an alcohol or urine test means that a driver :
1 ) fails to provide adequate breath for testing without a valid medical explanation
( documented to the Town by a licensed physician ) after the driver has received
notice of the requirement for breath testing in accordance with the provisions
of this policy ; or
ails to provide adequate urine for testing without a valid medical explanation
( documented to the Town by a licensed physician ) after he or she has received
notice of the requirement for urine testing in .accordance with the provisions of
this policy ; or
3 ) engages in conduct that clearly obstructs the testing process _
" Screening Test " , also known as the initial test , in alcohol testing means an analytical
procedure to determine whether a driver may have a prohibited concentration of alcohol in his
or her system . In urine testing , it means a screening to eliminate " negative " urine
specimens from further consideration .
" Substance Abuse Professional ( SAP ) " means a licensed physician , a licensed or certified
. psychologist , social worker , employee assistance professional or addiction counselor
( certified by the National Association of Alcoholism and Drug Abuse Counselors Certification
Commission ) with knowledge and/ or clinical experience in the diagnosis and treatment of
. alcohol and drug - related disorders .
E UIRED TESTING
e Town is required to conduct drug and alcohol tests under several different circumstances
as follows :
1 ) pre - employment and pre - duty ( drug tests only) ;
2 ) following certain accidents ;
3 ) on a random basis ;
4 ) upon a reasonable suspicion ;
5 ) upon a return to duty after engaging in conduct that is illegal under the Act or
under regulations issued pursuant to it ; and
6 ) periodic follow- up testing for individuals engaging in conduct that is illegal
under the Act or under regulations issued pursuant to it ,
1 . Pre - Employment and Pre - Duty Testincr -
Any applicant , required to be tested under federal law , who refuses or fails to submit
to a pre - employment or pre - duty drug and aleehel test as directed , or whose result is
positive for the test , will not be considered for employment with the Town . A current
worker who applies for a driver position and who refuses or fails to submit to a
duty drug and -al test as directed , or whose result is positive for the test , may
be subject to discipline , up to and including discharge from employment .
2 , Post Accident Testing
Within 32 hours a :° ter an accident as defined above , involved employees will be tested
and removed from :service pending the outcome of the test ( s ) . The alcohol
test should be conducted within 2 hours , and no later than 8 hours after the accident .
If the test is not conducted between 2 and 8 hours following the accident , . a record
stating the reasons for the delay shall be prepared and maintained, on file . Drug tests
shall be conducted within 32 hours following the accident . If such a test is not
administered within 32 hours as required , a record stating the reasons why a test was
not promptly administered shall be prepared and maintained in file ,
Drug & Alcohol Testing Policy and - Page 4
Procedure
3 . Random Testing
All drivers will be subject to random drug and alcohol testing . - Selection of employees
to be tested will be administered by a third party management company using : a
computerized random selection program . This program will ensure that every covered
employee has an equal opportunity of being selected at any given time .
Notification of an employee ' s selection will not be provided until the employee ' s tour
of duty in which the drug and alcohol test is to be conducted . Immediately upon
notification of being randomly selected the employee is to proceed to the collection
facility .
4 . Reasonable Suspicion Testing
a . Drug Test : Drivers are required to submit to a urinalysis for the purpose of
detecting the presence of controlled substances when a supervisory employee has
reasonable suspicion as defined below .
Under a finding of reasonable . suspicion , the employee will be removed from
service without pay pending the outcome of the test ( s ) . The employee will be
returned to service with back pay if the outcome of the test ( s ) is negative .
In all cases where an employee is subjected to reasonable suspicion testing , an
evidentiary report of reasonable suspicion must be completed and signed by a
supervisor before the test is administered . Supervisory employees will not be
permitted to make any findings of reasonable suspicion unless they first receive
at least one ( 1 ) hour of training in the physical , behavioral , and performance
indicators .of probable drug. use .
" Reasonable Suspicion " exists when there are any facts , circumstances , physical
evidence , physical signs and symptoms , or a pattern of performance and/or
behavior that would cause a trained supervisor to reasonably conclude that a�
employee has violated the prohibitions of this policy . The determination of
reasonable suspicion must be based on specific , contemporaneous , ; articulable `` °
observations concerning the appearance , behavior , speech , or body odors of the
driver ( which may include indications of the chronic and withdrawal effects of
controlled substances ) , -
b . Alcohol Test : Reasonable suspicion for alcohol testing exists when a trained
supervisory employee suspects that alcohol involvement has interfered with an
employee ' s present ability to safely perform a driving function . This suspicion
must be based on specific , contemporaneous , articulable observations concerning
the appearance , behavior , speech , or body odors of the driver .
51 Return - to - Duty Testing
After completing any required rehabilitation , any driver who tested positive must have
a negative Return- to - Duty test result before returning to work .
60 Unannounced Follow- up Testing
Upon returning to work ( after a negative Return- to - Duty test ) an employee will be
subjected to unannounced Follow Up tests for up to 60 months . At least six tests must
be conducted in the first 12 months upon employees who are returning to work following
alcohol related suspensions .
METHODS OF TESTING
To ensure the integrity and accuracy of each test , all specimen collection , analysis , and
laboratory procedures shall be conducted in accordance with DOT rules . This includes , among
other things : '
1 ) procedures to ensure the correct identity of each driver at the time of testing
2 ) a chain of custody procedure to protect a driver ' s urine specimen ;
3 ) The use of " split " urine samples to allow for a verification of an initial
positive test ;
Drug & Alcohol Testing Policy and Page 5
Procedure
4 ) the use of` a trained breath alcohol technician ( BAT ) and DOT approved testing
devices for conducting alcohol tests ;
5 ) the use of` a federally approved lab as selected by the Town or by a contractor
that may be retained by the Town to perform testing ;
6 ) the confirmation of an initial positive urine test by a second test ;
7 ) the confirmation of an initial positive breath test by a second test ; and
8 ) the Town ' s appointment of a qualified MRO to review urine test results .
TEST RESULTS -
For Alcohol Tests
In the event that an initial breath test registers an alcohol concentration level that is
less than 0 . 02 , the te :; t result will be reported as a " negative " , and no additional test will
be required at that time .
In the event that an initial breath test yield a result of 0 . 02 or greater , a second ,
confirmatory test will be performed . In the event that the confirmatory test registers less
than 0 . 02 , the test result will be reported to the Town as " negative " . Any driver whose
confirmatory test registers 0 . 02 or more but less than 0 . 04 will be prohibited from driving
until at least the next: regularly scheduled duty period , but for no less than 24 hours after
the test is given . Such a driver may also be subject to additional disciplinary action by
the Town , up to and including termination . -
A driver who has a cone= irmatory test which registers 0 . 04 or greater will , at a minimum , be
suspended from all driving functions until federal regulations are satisfied so as to allow
a return to work , and will be subject to additional disciplinary action by the Town , 9to
and including termination -
For Drug Tests
efore a urine test result will be confirmed as positive for illegal drugs , the driver will
e given the opportunity to speak with the Town ' s MRO and demonstrate that there was a
egitimate medical explanation for the positive test result . . : If the MRO determines that ' a
�-iegitimate medical reason ' does exist , the test result will be reported to the Town - as
" negative " . If the MRO determines that a legitimate medical reason for the positive result
does not exists , the test result will be reported to the Town as a positive . The driver will
be notified by the Town and will have 72 hours to request that the MRO send the split sample
to a second approved la.b . The cost of the second test shall be paid by the driver . Pending
the outcome of the second test , the driver will be prohibited from driving .
TESTING PROGRAM CONFIDENTIALITY
The result of all individual drug and alcohol tests will be kept in a secure location with
controlled access . All individual test results are confidential and will be released only
to the Town as employer , the SAP , or MRO . Employees must give written authorization for
others to have access to these records , except as required by law . If a driver initiates a
grievance , hearing , lawsuit , or other action , however , as a result of a violation of these
rules , the Town may release appropriate information to the decision maker .
PROHIBITED ACTIVITIES
A driver for the Town shall not :
1 ) report for duty or remain on duty requiring the performance of driving functions
while the driver has an alcohol concentration of 0 . 02 or greater ;
2 ) possess any amount of alcohol ( including alcohol found in medications , food , or
other alcohol - containing products ) while on duty or operating a commercial motor
vehicle ;
3 ) use alcohol. at any time while performing any driving function ;
4 ) use alcohol. within four hours prior to performing any driving function ;
5 ) use alcohol within eight hours following an accident or until the driver
undergoes a. post - accident alcohol test , whichever occurs first ;
6 ) refuse to submit to an alcohol or urine test ;
8 ) fail to inform the Superintendent of therapeutic or non - therapeutic drug use ;
Drug & Alcohol Testing Policy and : Page 6
Procedure
9 ) report for duty or remain on duty when required to drive when the driver uses any
drug , except when the use is pursuant to the instructions of a physician who ha.
advised the driver that the drug does not adversely affect the driver ' s ability
to safely operate a commercial motor vehicle ( see also " Use of Prescribed an
Over - the - County Medication " below) ; and
10 ) report for duty , remain on duty , or perform driving functions when testing '
positive for drugs .
A driver , excluding applicants for covered driving position , who violates these prohibitions
will be subject to the actions mandated by the DOT and will also be subject to disciplinary
action , up to and including discharge from employment . For those employees who need a . CDL
in order to perform work duties , the Town considers the CDL to be a qualification for
employment . In the event an employee is relieved of work duties as a result of a violation
of federal regulations or this policy , the employee will not be assigned other work during
a mandated absence . Accrued paid leave , if any , may be taken to permit an employee who . is
removed from work duties to remain in a full pay status . An ,. ...L ' _1ee whA -tests pesitive—€sue
drugs a seeead time shall a7atematleally be ter-minated .
CONSEQUENCES FOR ENGAGING IN PROHIBITED ACTIVITIES
Any driver engaging in conduct prohibited under the Act or under regulations issued pursuant
to it shall not perform a driving function . Any driver who engages in a prohibited activity
( as outlined above ) , if allowed to return to duty by the Town , must first satisfy any return
to duty requirement and referral , evaluation and treatment program prescribed by a SAP as
required by federal regulations before the driver may be permitted to drive . All costs
associated with evaluation , treatment , and repeat testing shall be borne by the driver ,
Any driver engaging in conduct prohibited by federal law or regulation or this policy will
be subject to disciplinary action by the • Town , up to and including discharge from employment .
A driver whose urine test result is positive may also be subject to civil and criminal
penalties imposed by DOT .
- Each driver .who ' tests positive shall be advised by the Town of the resources available . to the
. driver in evaluating - and resolving problems with alcohol or controlled substance use , as the ,.
case may be , including the names , addresses , and telephone numbers of SAP ' s and counselling
. and treatment programs .
APPEAL PROCEDURES
Upon testing positive , a driver may file ' an appeal with the Ind}vidIta4. desigeaedt the-dews
to hear s;aeh appeal Highway Superintendent , by submitting written notice of the grounds for
an appeal within five days after the employee receives notice of the test result . Following
receipt of an employee ' s notice of appeal , the employee shall have an opportunity to be
heard . The employee may be accompanied by a representative whose role in the hearing shall
be solely to advise the employee as to his or her rights or responsibilities . Pending the
resolution of the appeal , no disciplinary action shall be taken other than actions which the
Town is required to take under federal law or regulation .
The employee and any representative who may appear on his behalf shall be provided with a
written decision . In deciding an appeal from a positive breath or urine test result , the
Town Highway Superintendent shall take into account the original test
result , any re - testing done by the employee at the employee ' s expense , and any other
pertinent information that the employee or Town may provide . In deciding an appeal from a
positive controlled substance test result , the test result pertaining to the split sample
shall be taken into account . In instances where the Town Highway Superintendent is involved
as an appellant , the Town shall designate an alternate indiv-2dual to administer the appeal
proce ure .
USE OF PRESCRIBED AND OVER - THE - COUNTER MEDICATION
The Town of Ithaca will permit prescribed and over - the - counter medication and/or the use of
medication on the company premises , specifically prescribed for the employee by their
physician , that is clearly labeled with the employee ' s name , the name of the medication , anc
the physician ' s Federal Drug Enforcement Administration license number , provided the
substance is used at the dosage prescribed or authorized and it does not impair their ability
to perform in their job or endanger their safety or the safety of others . It is the
responsibility of the employee to notify their immediate supervisor that they are using a
Drug & Alcohol Testing policy and _ page 7
Procedure
prescription drug or over- the - counter drug and to produce documentation of this drug prior
to commencing work .
the MRO will make a good faith judgement , with knowledge of the employee ' s assigned duties
d on the basis of the available medical history , .whether use of the substance by the
employee at the prescribed or authorized dosage level is consistent with the safe performance
of the employee ' s duties . Any medication brought on the Town of Ithaca ' s property must be
carried in its original container .
TOWN AND MRO COMMUNICATIONS
An employee tested for drugs must contact his or her supervisor and the Town ' s MRO daily
while awaiting the result of the test and must also advise of their whereabouts and a
telephone number where he or she may be reached during time away from work . An employee who
refuses to do so or fails to contact the Town ' s MRO will be considered insubordinate and
subject to disciplinary action , up to and including discharge from employment . In addition ,
an employee who fails to contact his or her supervisor and the Town ' s MRO shall waive his or
her rights to speak with the Town ' s MRO before a test is confirmed to the Town as positive .
INFORMATION ON DRUGS AND ALCOHOL
Each employee will be provided with education material and information concerning :
1 ) the effects of drugs and alcohol on an ' individual ' s health , work , and personal
life ;
2 ) the signs and symptoms of a drug or alcohol problem ; and
3 ) the available methods of intervention and treatment when a problem does exist .
QUESTIONS
uestions regarding this policy , associated testing requirements , education material and
•elated counseling service may be direct to Fred Noteboom , Gail Kroll , or Gregory and Howe
our third party administrator) .
NOTIFICATION OF TESTING FOR EMPLOYEES /APPLICANTS
The Town of Ithaca requires successful completion of a urinalysis drug test as part of its
pre - employment screening process . Further details will be provided to applicants who
successfully met the Town of Ithaca ' s other criteria for employment . Because we are required
to notify applicants of our intent to conduct urinalysis drug testing , we ask that you sign
and date this notice .
Additionally , the Town of Ithaca requires successful completion of a urinalysis drug test
and/or breath alcohol test if the Town of Ithaca has reasonable suspicion that the employee -
is under the influence of drugs and/or alcohol which adversely affects or could adversely
affect the employee ' s job 'performance . The Town of Ithaca also requires employees in
occupations that have been designated as safety- sensitive by the Federal Regulations to
undergo random urinalysis drug testing and the rate of 50 percent of the total covered
employees in the consortium ( of which the Town is a member ) per year . Random alcohol tests
will be conducted at the rate of 25 . percent of the total FHWA covered employees in the
consortium per year only . Drug tests are conducted for the Town of Ithaca . by an ' outside ,
professional laboratory . = -
I , have received , reviewed , and understand the Town of Ithaca ' s
drug and alcohol policy . Additionally , the Town of Ithaca ' s drug and alcohol policy was
explained to me by an authorized Town of Ithaca representative . -
Date Employee Applicant ' s Signature
Employee Applicant ' s Printed Name
Date - Witness ' s Signature
Witness ' s Printed Namely
Memorandum February 6, 1996 AGENDAll3
FROM : John Wolff
TO : Town Board
FROM: John P . Wolff � �(
SUBJECT : Proposed NYSEG Pipeline
The New York State Electric & Gas has proposed a new natural gas pipeline from Ithaca to
Binghamton as part of the Seneca Lake Storage Project. This issue has generated much
controversy among residents . Several concerns have been raised, including the adverse effect such
a pipeline would have on the ecology and on families residing in areas immediately affected by its
construction. Given. the continuing economic decline of the Binghamton service area, many have
questioned the need for such a pipeline. Most importantly, meaningful public consideration of
these and other issues has not been undertaken as required by law. Article VII of the public service
law specifically requires a forum "to which access will be open to citizens, groups, municipalities
and other public agencies to enable them to participate in these decisions . " The Coddington Valley
Association, a group of concerned Danby and Caroline residents who have been excluded from the
process, have pursued legal channels to persuade the New York Public Service Commission (PSC)
to require NYSEG to re-open public hearings pertaining to the issue of the need for such a project.
Under the provisions of the current proposal, two (2) parcels in the Town of Ithaca would be
affected and one of four Metering and Regulating stations would be located in the Town at the
junction of the CNG line. The interests of the Town should not be limited by the comparatively
modest impact this project would have on lands within the Town. The Town of Ithaca shares an
interest with other municipalities in assuring citizens a fair and open process in such matters and a
chance to raise legitimate concerns . To this end, I am introducing the attached resolution. Under
the provisions of this resolution, the Town of Ithaca would urge the PSC to approve the petition for
rehearing and permit all interested parties to comment on the issue of need. However, the Town
would not be commenting specifically on the issue of nerd_ or any of the other concerns raised by
the Coddington Valley Association.
This is an important opportunity for the Town of Ithaca to raise important substantive issues .
Oftentimes discussion over procedural issues is where substantive issues are argued and decided.
Under article VII of the public service law, municipalities have the right to participate in the
process . By going on record in this matter, the Town of Ithaca will be exercising that right.
Furthermore, proactive steps to promote a healthy dialogue with the PSC in such matters reaffirms
the Town' s presence in the decisionmaking process .
Other municipalities and officials are taking action to this effect. The Town of Danby will be
considering passage of a similar resolution at their nest Town Board meeting. The Town of
Caroline has passed a resolution calling on NYSEG to clarify its position pertaining to need for
such a project. Assemblyman Martin J . Luster has written to PSC chairman John O ' Mara urging
the PSC to re-hear the project (see letter encloses!) . While it is unclear whether or not the County
Board will consider any specific action on this case, Rep . Frank Proto has communicated a similar
message to the PSC and has urged individual municipal officials to contact the PSC in their
capacity as elected representatives .
The Public Service: Commission is scheduled in the near future to determine whether or not the
issue of need should be re-opened. Regardless of their decision on this matter, it is clear that the
PSC needs to have a more open decisionmaking process to ensure all sides are equally heard. The
Town of Ithaca has a strong interest in assuring a fair process .
i
Resolution to Urge the Public Service Commission to Rehear the Issue of Need for a Proposed
NYSEG Gas Pipeline
Whereas, New York State Electric and Gas Corporation (NYSEG) on March 14, 1995
filed an application for a Certificate of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need for the
Seneca Lake Storage Project and Gas Transmissions Facilities; and
Whereas, the prime route for the east line of the transmission facilities passes through the
Town affecting two (2) land parcels in the Town of Ithaca; and
Whereas, a Metering and Regulating station would be located in the Town at the junction
of the CNG line; and
Whereas, on February 21 , 1995 , NYSEG mailed a notice to parties it identified as
interested in the project stating that "the proposal will be subject to extensive analysis and a series
of public hearings" and "after the hearings are concluded, the PSC will decide whether the
proposed facilities should be built. . . "; and
Whereas, NYSEG filed a motion on March 14, 1995 to bifurcate the required PSC review
of the project into two phases, phase 1 of which would address the Salt Cavern Storage Facility,
the west pipeline routing, and the "public need" for the project, with phase 2 addressing the routing
of the gas line from the Town of Ithaca to the Town of Union (in Broome County) ; and
Whereas, Administrative Law Judge Jeffrey Stockholm approved the "unopposed" motion
to bifurcate the proceedings on May 3 , 1995 ;
Whereas, the public statement hearings on the east line routing were held i
after the official record on the issue of public need had been closed, denying affected residents the
opportunity to testify on this issue; and
Whereas, Chapter 272 of the laws of the State of New York, 1970, creating the Article
VII review process for such transmission facilities sets forth in section 1 of this Chapter the
legislative intent as follows : "the legislature hereby declares that it shall be the purpose of this act
to provide a forum for the expeditious resolution of all matters concerning the location of. . .gas
transmission facilities . . .in a single proceeding to which access will be open to citizen groups,
municipalities, and other public agencies to enable them to participate in these decisions . "; and
Whereas, the Town Board of Ithaca believes that affected residents have been denied their
due process rights pursuant to Article VII of the public service law;
Now Therefore, it is :
Resolved that the Ithaca Town Board strongly urges the Public Service Commission to
approve the petition for rehearing on the issue of public need so that interested residents may have
an opportunity to provide relevant testimony.
1524 Laws of NEW Yoxg, 1970 [ (;ggp,
272]
of such increased rate or charge, the commission shall by order
require the interested company to keep accurate account during mg th
the pendency of the hearing, in detail, of all amounts received legislr
by reason of such increase , or by reason of an increase received minin
as a result of the establishment of temporary rates by the commission Qualit
specifying by whom and in whose behalf such amounts are paid, might
and upon completion of the hearing and decision may, on appli- proce .
cation , by order require the interested company to refund, with ties m
interest, on or before a day filed in the order, to the persons in into a
whose behalf such amounts were paid, such portion of such increased result eqv
rates or charges as by its decision shall be found not justified are ei
and, in the case of temporary rates, may by order authorize public
appropriate reparation to the company if such temporary rates public
Axere found inadequate ; of the
f 7 , provided no refund or reparation shall
be required to be paid [from excess moneys received] urith respect more
to rates in force pending the completion of the hearing for a time provi,c
longer than two determination con
g pears prior to the final dete. urination and in no ar
event for a time longer than that specified in the order of the ties s a c
commission. If the corporation does not comply with such order legisla
within the time limited therein, any person or persons for'- whose this a
benefit such order was made may, within one year from the date matte?
of the order but not after, bring action in a court of competent Macilit
jurisdiction to recover the money to which he or they are entitled agent:
under said order. In any such action a copy of the order of the and Ic
commission duly certified shall be prima facie evidence of the to ciS91
facts set forth in the order. The commission after reasonable them
notice to the company interested may, by order, direct the company The
to issue and deliver to shippers or consumers, tickets, printed slips to con
or tokens specifying the excess received by the company over rates major
existing prior to the filing of the schedule. order
§ 2. This act shall take effect immediately, these
lation
views
cerned
CHAlyrER 272 porar_
3S- ACT to amend the: public service law, the condemnation law and the public siting
authorities law, in relation to the siting and operation of major utility trans- faciliti
mission facilities and providing for the establishment of a temporary state makin:
commission on the environmental impact of major public utility facilities, should
and making appropriations therefor facilit
Became a law April 29 , 1970 , with the approval of the Governor. Passed on at the
message of necessity pursuant to article III, section 14 of the Constitution § 9
by a majority vote, three-fifths being present
a new
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly,
do enact as follows :
Section 1 . The legislature hereby finds and declares that there
is at present and will continue to be a growing need for public util. Sectio2
ity serc-ices including electric , gas , water and stwm utilities which
will require the construction of major new facilities . It is recog-
nized that such facilities cannot be built without in some way af$eat-
EzPLA:
r
i
[ CHAP. 272] LAWS op NEw YORx, 1970 1525
by order t ing the physical environment where such facilities are located. The
it during legislature further finds that it is essential in the public interest to
received minimize any adverse effect upon the environment and upon the
received quality of life of the people of the state which such new facilities
)mmissian might cause . The legislature further finds that present practices,
are paid, proceedings and laws relating to the location of such utility facili-
on appli- ties may be inadequate to protect environmental values , and take
and, with into account the total cost to society of such facilities, and have
) ersons in resulted in delays in new construction and increases in costs which
increased ' are eventually passed on to the people of the state in the form of
t justified higher utility rates and the possible threat of the inability of the
authorize public and investor-owned utilities to -meet the needs of the people
4ary rates of the state for economic and reliable utility services. Fturther-
;tion shall more, the legislature finds that existing provisions of law do not
;th respect provide adequate opportunity for individuals, groups interested
for a time in conservation and the protection of the environment, municipali-
and in no ties and other public bodies to participate in timely fashion in the
ier of the decision to locate a specific major facility at a specific site . The
such order legislature therefore hereby declares that it shall be the purpose of
for whose this act to provide a forum for the expeditious resolution of all
a the date matters concerning the location of electric and gas transmission
competent facilities presently under the jurisdiction of multiple state and local
re entitled s agencies including the courts of the state, and all matters of state
der *f the and local law, in a single proceeding to which access will be open
ice of the to citizens, groups , municipalities and other public agencies to enable
reasonable them to participate in these decisions,
e company The legislature further finds that there is a need for the state
hinted slips to control the siting of thermal electric generating plants and other
over rates major electric , gas, water and steam facilities within the state in
order to minimize -any adverse effect on the environment which
these facilities may occasion but that the formulation of such legis-
lation requires consultation with , and the active solicitation of the
views of, interested persons and public and private bodies con-
cerned with the various aspects of the problem. Therefore , a tem-
porary state commission is hereby established to investigate present
siting practices of utility companies with regard to locating major
nd the public facilities , the considerations which should be brought to bear in
utility trans- making such decisions , the appropriate state procedures which
iporary state
itytp fac ilities, should be established to regulate and determine the siting of such
facilities ,
facilities and to propose legislation in this area to the legislature
at the nineteen .hundred seventy-one session.
r. Passed on
Constitution § 2 . The public service law is hereby amended by adding thereto
a new article , to be article seven, to read as follows :
;nd Assembly, , ARTICLE VII
SITING OF MAJOR UTILITY TRANSMISSION FACILITIES
� that there
public util- Section 120 . Definitions .
lities which 121 . Certificate of enL•iron?nental compatibility and public
It is reecog- need .
way affect- EXPLANATION — utter in italics is new ; matter in brackets [ ] is old law to be omitted.
CHAIRMAN
THE ASSEMBLY Legislative Commission on
,l�- t Public Management Systems
All STATE OF NEW YORK '
Subcommittee on Libraries
' - ALBANY Subcommittee on Rural Health
•r-ey� '
COMMITTEES
MARTIN A. LUSTER Aging
semblyman 125th District Agriculture
Energy
Health
Higher Education
MEMBER
Joint Legislative Commission on
Rural Resources
January 9 , 1996
John F . O ' Mara , Chairman
State of New York
Public Service Commission
3 E«pire State= Plaza
Albany. , New York 12223 - 1350
Re : Cage 95 - T - 0248 ( Seneca Lake Storage Project Gas
Transmission Facilities )
Dear Chairman O ' Mara :
I write in support of the petition of the Coddington Valley
Association ( originally Lewis Freedman ) for re - hearing of the above
mentioned project and. , in particular , a reversal of the
Commission ' s opinion and order dated September 14 , 19950
I have reviewed many of the relevant documents in this case
and have concluded that many of my constituents who have a stake in
the outcome of this proceeding have been denied due process and a
fair onportunity to be heard on the issue of " need " for the
construction of this project .
An objective reading of the record reveals a process
controlled by New York State Electric and Gas ( NYSEG ) ; a process
clearly designed to avoid any meaningful consideration of the need
issue . Although a bifurcation of the routing issues in the eastern
and western portions of the area affected by the proposed pipeline
could be justified , the attachment of the " need " issue to the west
routing issuer was a successful attempt to avoid public input and
involvement in the process .
Nearly every party to this proceeding has acknowledged the
fact that the eastern portion of the pipeline was likely to draw
more public attention and opposition than the western section . By
requiring the need determination to be considered in the Phase I
process , a meaningful discussion of that issue was precluded . The
justification for this statement is easily demonstrated . In May ,
1995 Public Statement Hearings on Phase I were held in Watkins
Glen , Montour. Falls and Horseheads . A total of four ( 4 )
individuals spoke . On the other hand , the Coddington Valley
Association representing hundreds of residents in and near the
ALBANY OFFICC: Room 639. Legislative Office Building. Altanv. New York 12248. (S 18) 455-5444
DISTRICT OFFICE: 106 East Court Street, Ithaca. New Yerx 14650. (607) 277-8030
eastern portion of the pipeline who have expressed a desire to be
heard on the issue of need have been foreclosed .
This situation was compounded by the fact that in July , 1995
a public notice in local newspapers announced the public hearings
to be held in the east line area . The notice stated that NYSEG was
proposing the west and east lines , a storage facility and further
stated that evidentiary hearings would be held , " to determine
whether , or to what extent , the company ' s proposals ( were ]
justified . " This notice was erroneous and misleading because in
actuality , the official record for Phase I was closed prior to the
beginning of the August hearings . The entire issue of need for the
project was closed to public comment before any public statement
hearings were held in the vicinity of the east pipeline route .
Mr . Chairman , this proceeding has all the earmarks of a " deal
done in the dark . " NYSEG ' s acclaimed " outreach " efforts were a
carefully disguised mechanism to avoid public participation in the
reed determination, Their entire ou= ose was to limit public
knowledge of and participation in the underlying decisions while
giving the appearance ( by encouraging extensive public involvement
on the issue of corroder selection ) of doing just the opposite .
The worst part of this is the acquiescence of the PSC in this
charade . This was a misuse of the procedure of bifurcation and an
abdication of responsibility by the Public Service Commission .
I respectfully refer the Commission to the petition and briefs
submi fled in support thereof . In 1900 I chaired the Assembly Task
Force on Utility Rate Settlements . As a result of the Task Force ' s
work regulations were promulgated and adopted by the PSC which
substantially improved the process by which rate increase
negotiated agreements could be achieved without jeopardizing the
public ' s right to know . Clearly , the same type of initiative is
needed regarding Article VII applications .
For all of the foregoing reasons I urge the Commission to
reverse and annul the determination. of September 14 , 1995 insofar
as it adopts a finding of public need authorizing the construction
and operation of ' the subject project .
Respectful y ours ,
Martin A . L ster
Member of Assembly
125th District
MAL / kkb
CRITIQUE OF NYSEG ' S PROPOSED SENECA LAKE STORAGE
PROJECT
by the Coddington Valley Association
January 25 , 1996
SUMMARY OF CODDINGTON VALLEY ASSOCIATION POSITIONS
Citizens denied due process . NYSEG " bifurcated " the project ,
and decided the need while discussing the West Line . NYSEG then
told East Line residents that they couldn ' t discuss anything but
" site -specific routing issues " . . . in other words , how the pipeline will
cross their properties , not if it will .
The approval process was cut short. The " expedited schedule " ,
6 months from application to start of construction on the west line ,
prevented adequate review of the need for the project and possible
alternatives . Numerous procedural short-cuts were taken . The
Judge hearing the case expressed concern about this several times
during the need hearings .
NYSEG ' s projected demand growth of 1 . 75 % per year is
exaggerated . NYSEG ' s figure is more than four times the
prediction for upstate New York State natural gas demand growth
( 0 . 4 %) , and the Binghamton economy continues to decline .
Energy Conservation was not even considered . Reasonable
growth in gas demand could be met through conservation programs ,
known as " demand- side management" or DSM . NYSEG has rejected
conservation strategies , preferring instead their self-described
" aggressive marketing efforts " , which include ads for snow melters
and towel warmers .
Environmental and social costs were dismissed as minimal .
NYSEG produced detailed estimates of construction costs , but only
described environmental and social impacts as " minimal " or as
having " no significant impact " . Route selection almost invariably
favored the cheapest alternatives .
NYSEG wants to use herbicides to maintain the pipeline
route , in spite. of widespread resident opposition . Many
herbicides that once were thought to be safe are now known to be
dangerous to human health , wildlife and the environment . Many
herbicides are now showing up in drinking water. NYSEG opposes
such restrictions , even though non - use of herbicides on the entire
East Line would only cost an additional $ 3 , 500/year.
1 1 / 25 / 96
OVERVIEW OF THE NYSEG GAS PIPELINE PROJECT New York State Electric & Gas ( NYSEG ) has proposed a new natural gas pipeline
from Ithaca to Binghamton. This pipeline is part of the Seneca Lake Storage Project,
which has three components: ( 1 ) An underground salt cavern gas storage area on the
west side of Seneca Lake, north of Watkins Glen ( 2 ) A new 16 " pipeline ( the "west
line " ) running south from that storage area to an existing CNG Transmission Corporation
( CNG ) pipeline in Big Flats ( 3 ) A new 12 " pipeline ( the " east line" ) that runs from the
CNG pipeline in the Town of Ithaca, southeast to Binghamton. The lines are hi- pressure,
transmission-only pipelines, carrying natural gas for the Binghamton area. The gas
will not be generally available to Ithaca or any of the other communities along the lines,
though residents whose land is directly crossed by the line will have a chance to hook up,
at a later date, for a cost of a few thousand dollars. NYSEG claims that the new pipeline is
needed to meet growth in peak-day demand (the amount of gas that might be needed in a
20- 30 year period) and to replace the capacity of two aging propane storage tanks used
to provide extra gas on peak days.
THE CODDINGTON VALLEY ASSOCIATION
The Coddington Valley Association ( CVA) was formed in early fall 1995 by a
group of residents who were concerned about the proposed " east pipeline" , since the
prime ( NYSEG-preferred) route would run through the Valley, roughly parallel to
Coddington Road. Since then, the Association has grown to nearly 200 members and has
engaged the services of Doug Ward, a well-regarded environmental lawyer from Albany.
At Public Statement Hearings in November, and Evidentiary Hearings in December
1995 , members raised questions about construction techniques, destruction of
woodlands and wetlands, herbicide use , devaluation of property, and the overall need for
the east line.
OVERVIEW OF THE APPLICATION AND APPROVAL PROCESS, TO DATE
In the fall of 1994 and early 1995 , a series of " Public Open Houses" were held
by NYSEG to inform citizens about the Seneca Lake Storage Project and its preliminary
pipeline routes. These gatherings were informal, and are not part of the official record
of the storage project.
In March of 1995 , NYSEG applied to the PSC for approval of the project. At that
time , NYSEG requested that the approval process be " bifurcated" ( split) into two parts:
Phase I , to address the overall need for the project, the salt-cavern storage facility, and
the routing of the west pipeline; Phase II , to address the routing of the east pipeline. In
April , this request for bifurcation was granted by PSC Administrative Law Judge Jeffrey
Stockholm.
In May, Public Statement Hearings on Phase I were held in Watkins Glen,
Montour Falls, and Horseheads. Four people spoke.
In July 1995 a Public Notice in local papers announced the first set of Public
Hearings to be held in the east line area in August. This Notice discussed the entire
Project, stating that NYSEG was proposing the west and east lines, and a storage facility.
The same Public Notice stated that evidentiary hearings would be held later, "to
determine whether, or to what extent, the company' s proposals (were] justified" .
In actuality, the official record for Phase I was closed before the beginning of the
August hearings. Thus the issue of need for the entire project was closed to public
comment before any Public Statement Hearings were held along the east pipeline route.
East line residents had earlier received notices that the issue of need would be decided
after all hearings were concluded.
2 1 / 25 / 96
i
'l
On September 14, 1995 , the Public Service Commission issued Opinion No. 95-
15 , which granted approval of Phase I , that is, of the storage facility, of the west
pipeline route, and of the entire need for the project.
It is possible that NYSEG , in requesting bifurcation of the Project had other
motives besides speeding up the approval process. NYSEG ( p. 3 of the motion for
bifurcation, in the application for the project) characterizes the West Line as being
" located in sparsely populated areas, so that land use impacts would not be a significant
factor. " Thus the request could have been made to minimize public opposition and
discussion on the topic 'of need. Since the East Line runs through a region that is more
heavily populated, and affects a population with a history of actively speaking out on
issues, and will have greater environmental and land use impacts ( as stated in the
application , with respect to the West Line, the East Line will have more acres of forest
cleared, more miles of forest brush land crossed, more streams crossed, more wetlands
crossed, more deer winter concentration sites crossed, more active agricultural lands
crossed, more miles with steep slopes crossed, more miles in which soils with severe
erosion hazard crossed, more miles of residential areas crossed, more miles of
residential strip development crossed, and greater distance of floodplain crossed) , the
issue of need would have been more likely to be contested by people in the vicinity of the
East Line. The number of people who spoke at the public hearings in each location, and
their comments, provide evidence for this statement: at the Public statement hearings
for Phase I , four members of the public spoke. In the first round of Phase II hearings,
approximately 34 people spoke. Due to public interest, a second round of hearings was
scheduled on Phase II , in which approximately 40 people spoke.
CODDINGTON VALLEY ASSOCIATION LEGAL ACTIONS TO DATE
The Coddington Valley Association has submitted a petition to the PSC requesting a
rehearing on PSC Opinion No. 95 - 1 5 ( Opinion and Order Granting A Partial Certificate
of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need) because bifurcation effectively shut
out residents of the east pipeline route from discussions on the overall need for the
project. Granting a rehearing would allow reconsideration, by the PSC and the public, of
the issue of " public need" for the Seneca Lake Storage Project and allow residents in the
area of the eastern line to comment on this issue on record for the first time. A
rehearing would allow the public to carefully examine NYSEG ' s predictions of growth in
the natural gas demand for the Binghamton area, and to bring up demand side management
( DSM ) based on energy-efficiency and other alternatives to building a new pipeline. The
PSC is expected to rneet on February 7 , 1996 , to decide whether or not to reopen this
debate.
Testimony concerning the east line has been submitted by CVA members and has
already become part of the official record of Phase 11 of the proposal. At Evidentiary
Hearings on December 19 , 20 and 21 , 1995 , CVA members defended their testimony
and questioned PSC , Department of Environmental Conservation, and NYSEG staff on their
testimony.
The CVA testimony discusses such issues as the use of energy-efficiency
measures to reduce new gas demand, the costs of the pipeline to society due to
environmental damage and losses in the quality of life , the health and environmental
hazards of the herbicides used to maintain the pipeline , potential damage to
environmentally sensitive areas crossed by the pipeline, and an alternative route to the
proposed pipeline that involves upgrading an existing Columbia pipeline .
3 1 / 25 / 96
OVERVIEW: IS THE SENECA LAKE STORAGE PROJECT, NEEDED?
The CVA has requested that public need for the project be re- examined because
there are a number of powerful and important arguments against the entire project that
we will have been prevented from making unless the request for a rehearing is granted.
These include the following: ( 1 ) The growth in net gas usage will not be as high as NYSEG
predicts. ( 2 ) The realistic growth could be met through demand-side, rather than
supply-side, measures. ( 3 ) The propane tanks could be refurbished instead of retired,
or could be replaced with liquified natural gas tanks.
In addition, even if the salt-cavern storage area and west pipeline are built, the
CVA believes that there is a viable alternative to building a new ( east) pipeline:
upgrading the Columbia A-5 gas pipeline. This proposal, called the Columbia Tap
Alternate A, provides a number of the same benefits as NYSEG ' s original proposal for the
east line, such as increased gas deliverability to Binghamton, access to additional natural
gas supplies, and increased flexibility in gas purchasing arrangements. Environmental
damage would be reduced by limiting construction to areas that have already been
disturbed. Furthermore, the capital cost of the Columbia Tap alternative
( approximately $45 million total for salt- cavern storage, west line construction, and
A- 5 upgrade) is actually less than the capital cost of NYSEG ' s proposal ( $ 57 million) .
OVERVIEW OF CVA CONCERNS ABOUT A NEW PIPEUNE
CVA believes that the PSC is required by law to consider the environmental and
social costs of a gas transmission line , as well as the capital costs. For most of these
externalities, actual dollar values can and should be determined or estimated. But money
is not necessarily the most significant factor in life. For example, a clean and healthy
environment is crucial for humans and other species to exist.
Most people would probably agree that their quality of life is the most important
thing to them. People' s quality of life may be determined, in part, by money, but it is
also affected by the beauty, peace and comfort they find in their surroundings, their
perception of their own and loved one' s safety, their health, and their future security.
The various ways that the pipeline will impact the quality of people' s lives and the
environment include contamination of ecosystems and private wells with herbicides,
restrictions on land use placed on residents, increased risks to people' s safety due to fire
and explosion hazards , intrusion into resident' s private surroundings, potential loss of
property values, clearing of forests resulting in death or habitat loss for many species,
soil erosion and siltation, degradation of wetlands and trout streams, and demolition of
scenic gorges due to blasting through bedrock and vegetation removal at stream
crossings.
4 1 / 25 / 96
LEAGUE OF WOMEN VOTERS
NRG ,,. ., y1 ;. ew OFTOMPKINS COUNTY
�l9 N,au��.tee . ITHACA , NEW YORK
144650 • for January 25 , 1. 996
The League of Women Voters of Tompkins County stands for informed citizen
participation in government , so it is appropriate for us to express our concern
about how public participation in Public Service Commission (PSC) proceedings
is handled . Our natural Resources Committee has , over a long period of time , been
involved in utility issues , especially NYSEG generation siting proposals , in which
both need and environmental compatibility had to be established under Public Service
Law . NYSEG is now proposing a gas storage facility in Watkins Glen , to serve
possible " need " in the Binghamton area , and to be connected with gas supply pipelines ,
in part through Tompkins County . We have several concerns about this proposal , the
" Seneca Lake Storage Project Gas Transmission Facilities " project , identified as
PSC Case 95 -T- 024 £1 .
I . Public participation
NYSEG crafted a public information and outreach process for this proposed project
that stressed pipeline routing and offered to respond to individual landowner ' s
concerns at informal , unofficial "open-house " meetings . Focexample , in the Feb . 21 ,
1995 , letter NYSEG sent to interested parties , NYSEG states that: the least-cost option
to assure adequate: supply and provide for growth is to develop a natural gas storage
facility , and that: the public will have opportunity to state its views during
public statement hearings -- and that after those hearings the PSC will decide whether
to grant the proposed project an Article VII certificate of environmental compatabilit:-
and public need .
Meanwhile , at official , on- the- record meetings , NYSEG was stressing the importance
of expediting this project application so that construction could begin as soon as
possible in order to meet winter peak gas demand . NYSEG successfully convinced
the Administrative: Law Judge and the statutory parties ( DEC , Ag & Markets , OPRHP , and
DPS staff ) to split the _proceedings into two parts , "west " and ' Yeast " , so that the
storage facility and its western pipeline _ could be decided first . This meant that
the need for the project would be decided along with the routing of the west pipeline
in a Phase 1 portion , leaving the eastern pipeline routing for a Phase 2 . However ,
the " interested public " did not receive mailings explaining this "bifurcation" ,
with the result that , by the time there were official public-statement hearings in
the " eastern" Tompkins County area , the "need" for the project had already been
decided , without their public input .
NYSEG ' s strategy of focussing on pipeline routing at their unofficial public
information meetings and giving the impression that need would be dealt with later ,
while at the same time conveying at the official hearings that there is no public
opposition to their--need claims , had the perverse result of leaving the public out
of timely consideration of the need issue . Moreover , the expedited process that
NYSEG requested and was granted meant that them was no Phase 1 judge ' s recommended
decision to which one could take written exception , but rather the PSC itself issued
its opinion based directly on the transcribed record of the official hearings .
Ironically , pages 4- 6 of the PSC ' s September 14 , 1995 , Opinion and Order 95- 15
approving the west route and certifying the need praise NYSEG ' s public outreach
program .
Public Service Commission regulations for Article VII contemplate public partici-
pation , and this participation should not be lert to the applicant - to ensure .
The applicant ' s interests cannot be assumed to be identical with the public interest ,
since the applicant must concern itself with its corporate interest . We suggest the
PSC should not leave public outreach to a "middleman " ( especially one that is not
neutral ) , but should take a more pro - active role itself in ensuring public
participation .
( more )
LWV-TC NR , 25 January 1996 , p . 2
II . Need
The question of need is a threshhold question ; if the project cannot be justified
on the basis of need , there are no other questions to be answered . The next threshhold
to cross is one of considering alternatives to meeting whatever need there is .
Apparently the " need " for this project is predicated on a projected 1 . 75 % growth
in gas demand in the Binghamton area , an area of major corporate down-sizing .
Without NYSEG ' s promotional marketing tactics , it is far from clear that this
growth could be realized .
In addition , this past year NYSEG greatly reduced its energy conservation program ;
in concert with other NYS investor-owned utilities , it is moving away from stressing
conservation , efficiency , and demand- side management , and instead is focussing
once again on inverted rate structures and other growth incentives . These very actions
clearly affect the question of need . . Were the PSC to direct NYSEG to return to
promoting energy conservation and efficiency , any need for this project could
evaporate .
The proceedings in this case are virtually silent on both these issues .
III . Economics
It is no doubt true that a gas storage vault can help even out any demand peaks
and supply problems -- but can NYSEG demonstrate this to be the " least -cost " option?
Over what period of time ? Considering what alternatives ? Other parties in the ._. .
eastern route area have identified the possibilities of connecting to existing gas
pipelines and / or using existing pipeline routes rather than creating a whole new
gas transmission line . And as above , would conservation be a cheaper alternative ?
IV-. ' Environmental considerations
The League of Women Voters believes in the wise use of natural resources and
protecting them for future generations . With this in mind , we comment on two other
areas on interest .
1 ) Pesticides . The use of pesticides brings with it serious concerns of water
f
and soil pollution and plant and animal damage . Maintenance o rights -of -way for
any certified pipeline can be accomplished without routine use. of pesticides ,
as the Broome County Environmental Management Council demonstrated in its December 14
letter to Judge Stockholm . Therefore , certification of any pipeline route should be
conditioned on no use of pesticides .
2 ) Wetlands . Wetland have fragile soils , and care should be taken to avoid
pipeline routing through wetlands , where equipment used to lay pipes would permanently
compress wetland soils , doing serious damage to wetland functioning . Maintenance
of pipelines in wetland areas is also very probelmatic , since both pesticide use
and mowing are incompatible with wetland function .
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION :
Dooley Kiefer 257 - 7453
Lynn Leopold 273- 3457
Janis Putnam 539 - 7547
STATEMENT ON PROPOSED NYSEG GAS PIPELINE BETWEEN TOWN OF ITHACA AND BROOME COUN'T'Y
January 25 , 1996
I am William E . Gibson , a resident of the Town of Ithaca , residing at 101
Poole Road , Ithaca , New York 14850 . I am a Staff Associate of the Center for
Religion , Ethics and Social Policy ( CRESP ) and Director-Emeritus of CRESP ' s
Eco-Justice Project .
I strongly support the reopening of consideration of the need. for this
pi .eline and the expansion of natural gas delivery capacity that it
represents . The conclusion that the project Tas needed was made prematurely ,
without opportunity for environmental , consumer , and community organizations
and concerned citizens to express their views .
Sound public policy will give highest priority to minimizing the need for
energy consumption . Rather than multi -million dollar investments in fossil
fuel infrastructure , we need immediate and long- term investments in energy
efficiency technologies and in research and development to utilize
alternatives to fossil fuels , together with reliance on Demand Side
Management . Such investments would be highly beneficial from an economic as
T
ell as an environmental standpoint .
The combustion of fossil fuels , including natural gas , emits carbon dioxide
and makes these fuels the chief contributors to the buildup of greenhouse
gases in the upper atmosphere . The most recent findings of the
Intergovetnment: al Panel on . Climate Change ( i_CC ) present further evidence of a
serious threat to the planet ' s future from global warming . The IPCC again
calls for strenuous efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions . Meanwhile the
United States has failed even to make significant progress toward meeting the
modest obligat '." ons that it accepted by ratifying the 1992 Climate Change
Convention .
The industry ' s determination to pursue a huge market increase for natural gas
constitutes avoidance and delay of the inevitable priority that ought to be
given now to energy conservation , energy efficiency , Demand Side Management ,
and the transition to renewable , nonpollutir.s:4 sources of energy . It may be
understandable in terms of the industry ' s objectives of growth and increased
profits , but this does not mean that it serves the public interest . Even
apart from the enormous longer - term e2conomic and environmental costs from
climate change , it detracts investments and initiatives from focusing on the
efficiencies that would adequately satisfy needs while yielding early economic
and environmental benefits to all consumers and most businesses .
These considerations put a large burden of proof on the argument that there is
need for the new pi ,.)eline . If there are urgent reasons for reducing
dezendence on fossil fuels , it is foolish to build unnecessarily the
infrastructure for greatly ex,:)anded usage .
Once that infrastructure is in place , we cannot expect the industry to 'ceep
the use of natural gas ( along with that of coal and oil ) down to the lowest
feasible level .
Concern for the long- term ;ublic interest re_uires reopening the question of
t: e need for the new pi ;eli ne .
e .
Agenda Item No 4 .
TO : Town Bo ^ rd
FROM : Joan Lent Noteboom
DATE : January 12 , 1996
RE : Recreation Partnership Board
The first meeting of the Recreation Partnership Board was held on January 11 ,
1996 . JoAnn Cornish - Epps , Town of Ithaca representative was elected Vice-Chair.
Program Update :
Ban Tam Basketball participation increased from last year.
Boys: 45 to 80
Girls : 20 to 35
Family Swim - Numbers are steady of about 40 to 50 each week . The program runs
through March .
Organic Puppet Theater will be giving performances on 6 Saturdays , 4 Sundays , and 2
evenings . Spaces are needed to accommodate up to 250 people .
Summer Daze Brochure is being revised to make it "more user friendly" .
An additional staff member has been hired to increase the after school programs . A
theater program for after school is being considered .
Cass Rink - There has been a 30 % decrease in public skating from last year. Fitness
skate and skating for seniors are available from 6 : 30 a . m . to 8 : 30 a . m . each morning .
The Army Reserve Center on the West Hill has been secured free of charge for six
weeks next summer for some of the summer programs . The kitchen will be available .
Cass Lights - $ 140 , 000 has been appropriated in the City of Ithaca budget to replace
the lights at Cass Park. The Board of Public Works is reviewing options and will be
making a recommendation to a new Study Committee in March . The lighting company
they are working with has indicated the new lights could reduce the glare by as much
as 90% .
Baseball Policy - A new policy of team set up will be initiated and tried this spring .
Each team will only be allowed sixteen members . Ten of those members can be
I'� players the coach has already chosen and placed on the first ten lines of the
Agenda Item No . 4 " 2/ 12/96
Page 2 .
application , six members will be chosen by the Youth Bureau from new applicants or
transfers , they will be included on the last six lines of the application . If the six extra
slots are not needed for new kids and transfers , the coach can then add other
members .
It is hoped this system will eliminate the concerns voiced by parents that teams are
"stacked", and slots are not available for other children . If the system works for
baseball , it will be expanded to the other programs such as soccer.
The Youth Bureau will be holding a mandatory clinic for the first year coaches starting
this year. Emphasis will be placed on sportsmanship and dealing with reminding other
coaches , parents , and the kids on appropriate behavior at games . It was suggested
that for at least this year all the coaches should have to attend the mandatory clinic.
The Recreation Board is working on the direction which will be taken once the pilot
program is completed this year. A review of the budget, program effectiveness , and
contributions by towns is underway. Next month the Board will be working with all the
financial information to design an agreement of participation to present to the towns so
the program can be ongoing .
The Ithaca Town Board must give direction to its representatives as to their concerns
related to the funding , participation , and program needs . This direction is essential to
developing an agreement which will be acceptable to all the towns , and which will allow
the program to continue .
Respectfully submitted ,
r
Joan Lent Noteboom
1122 Danby Road
Ithaca , NY 14850
RECREATION PARTNERSHIP BOARD
1996 WORK PLAN
Review of 1995 Accomplishments:
• Launched the ;partnership board with membership from all participating
municipalities
• Added Groton to participating towns
• Reviewed all :[YB recreation programs
• Responded to issues:
Policy for admitting residents of non-member municipalities
Cass Park lights
Sports league policies
• Developed a rnenu of choices for 12-hour custom programs and other new
program development
• Re-organized :IYB recreation department after two key staff retirements
• Worked on a new scholarship policy for better use of resources
• Maintained all. core progams and
• Raised 1995 participation by about 507o over 1994
Goals for 1996:
Program
• Continue to offer core programs
• Provide custom programs in each remaining municipality
• Add programs for teens including youth council and options for girls
• Develop seniors programs
• Move back to the Stewart Park building and expand its use as a community
services Molding
• Survey all program participants for evaluation
Ply :
By June 1996 : Complete plan for after the pilot for circulation to all municipalities
Elements of the plan to include:
a method for shared decision making
a system for shared finance
Timeline :
—ie -1 (A fnf (pifn (D (niCA € CA € Z * E (-- � ' � € c. C . 0 Ecf i !n -n m (Aen p Wig DeD � €
8 , 0 ° € m m m ��, ��° €o m � ° ° w '� � w € w € m ` � € � ° : to � fy Fa' � v . c m € � c
F � F °
!y F
AFD ? �. ew € > =. F ? e � A� Ip Fo n '- C) € x fen N 7C' F .► C ;O
€ r' � � yiS Al step fp ': N �n : tni — ' - em �. -' f - ? F ? 09 � Ff � p ca 3 ca
Ofcn S' € � � fo Ef- men � e � � ¢' ! can' p . S OF io Eo 3 E 'cf2 S FO m fy € : Ca € �SU—► € o o a3 : 03 iO3 0 :: CD €`� u"', ' -- cn cnSSSSfA .� € m m EO m � € � � ' ° . � `c °—' F � � E � € m
r ' y ip cr v {tj) � i� 3 i �tMEOtED � � �_ ? � emit ! W (A � EVMi !�-. � 0 : n (7i CA% : . .
NE � � � � fv, cc cr 2) e`n� � . ev m N ° o m ?� ?: � � 3 m wen eQl� € CD E �
� ! N � e p i SDA� 33 � FO } 1O � ; � t . � € CC t � ` NEE tt >Sm
CD
SEEMED
CD E iN i EC1e €� ° Q € N F N E 33 t i � fy 10
€ ! } } E c7 } F ? 3 € Qi t
* tN } }tt} NiCJiF I S � A � � } N ii
A i ` i -�
L1 AEA (n Ln c) : N) ( ,,tatiM t%4 tee — € V4 Cn CTfN W Niht � € W w a) WFCJ� AiA 07 ` A € —` iAi � Dt =
V
OD : N � co } W VFO OiCJlECO -+ : V N : tQb4 CJ1F �4 VEW O CT1EW V4 � EVe (T VFCT (0 —• iViQ� FjEQ� r' i }
EN � �44 € D
A E -+ Nf I } N € CA) € } NF -► � F � � `
-+ iCT N } CDE _aFV : � FNiVt —� AeCT W � Nt i NFWt -+ 83 CO NeV CT NiW ' WF
NtW VE137 VeIA N } CTFNEAEN NeCTiWi C71iC0 l73 OEIA U1 ; CT A ; A CO V € O CTiN € 0
m
E i i I Z
M : Em
wtN p er € Ne CC)
ttt4 mEtO AN CA) N)N € WEN � '• FWtW } � NFO � jWEN eJteW FOFC) Vt0 —+ ? U1 Wi -+ tAF 0 : tm
FD
F } F € F f € `tC
` ` A �
D ` 7�
WfW NEN We O � € -a W C7! € N � CD € W Ln co O } Aii � • 1 ijt � o) FN � N CJ� -+ € Ja n ' ERi
Ai -
� !lINECO WfW -` + V € O i ! A Co . tAtcoECT co 0 Wf <Oi0 CTt tCiOFO CDF �1 V4 CO NJ NfCC) D } t0
t j € DT m
N 6rni t lilt I 1 i ! 0 ! WL : .J �i j WE t �
cDE —+ VE WEA WECO } € Veo� ' .+ F iCJ't } w Co . lA } (n € eW } WE I FA CA) I ic7 NEO lAfN O ! j . N
Z
CA)C) co W ? W VEW O ? W NeO : N ? W } � E ` t � iN iOl CO � Wt � t � .J zi 0
...r..... .»_ e _ » a i _ - i -a A , co : _._� . j
it i77
cn
f E i f it t
OFtlt i 3!3 t N33 € t WF i m tN
VEWEjt N : i jiCT } N ! OEV i � F iV : 0 OICOE ; NEAE eN € Ai NF W , EN CT . N A .
f 1 t 1 f ! } + € 3 € € Z
Ze E
A . N
t � Ej 1 : VEW FCJ1FWi ?. NEWO + O) EGT1 : e0 [p € W 1eV � 1 € VI EW t
O , NEW W Q) EV . t
ZE
� ? � ND j : mot coENEG1 ' N • W � :
IV
i
M -
-n :
N ' A � ! t } €
New + i iNE I t —+ E € EA , W } NE } ; N --aEVFV • VtA
Mi e
t
i e f E
f
€
t
C:) : G, i } } E CO , ie e � � i 1 E ! m
ft E ' : _.1. 1E : � : A : � ' � A3 � i : t N N A Wi0t 0 '
c) C)NE N . E - +-j -... .. .-..................
i.....
WI
.............1......a..._........:......j......�. . ...p...»fit.... .. .. ..
i E ! — E € } } 3 f of
!
t . + .. t . .. t.. + t j € m
fE f € 3
t t S
NeNi E eN ; + ESE } EW } N ' At fCD I
1906
Lucile P. Maeera O
115 Rich Road F 17'H,q �,q
Ithaca, NY 1480 k
607-273-4736 January 29, 1996
Highway Department
Town of Ithaca
106 Seven Mile Drive
Ithaca, NY 1485Ci
Gentlemen :
During the area flooding on Friday, January 19, the ditch in front of the apartment
attached to my home at 115 Rich Road overflowed, washing out part of the
driveway in front of the apartment.
In addition, the shoulder along the road between the apartment driveway and my
house driveway :has been washed away so that there is a sharp drop of several inches
from the pavement directly in front of my mailbox and Journal paper box . I believe
this could be a hazard, especially for an unsuspecting mailman or paper-route
driver .
The ditch uphill from the washed- out driveway has become filled with debris that
covers more than half of the opening in the culvert pipe . The next heavy rain we
have will probably again cause water coming down the hill to overflow the same
driveway and wash out the same shoulder along the road because of this blockage of
the culvert.
Much of the blockage is caused by stones washed down the hill in the ditch, but I am
fairly certain that the drainage ditch along Rich Road has not been cleaned out for at
least two years . Prior to the flooding, it was filled with an accumulation of dried
grass, leaves, small shrubs, etc .-- all the stuff that tends to grow in such places over
time . It just couldn' t handle the added burden of an unusual amount of water . I
know that many other ditches in this area overflowed considerably on January 19,
and you no doubt have your work cut out for you.
I suggest that, over the long run, it might be more economical for the Town to clean
out these ditches every summer so there is less damage to repair from snow melt
and heavy spring rains .
Over the short run, I hope you can schedule an early remedy for the problem on
Rich Road--we are bound to see more heavy rains in the next few months .
-2-
Aside from my concern over the condition of the ditch. and blockage of the culvert, I
am concerned over the " fill" that has been washed out of my driveway. One
railroad tie now lies completely exposed. Will the Town repair this damage ? I look
forward to a response. I can be reached at the above number most days after
1 :00 p .m.
Sincerely,
Lucile P. Macera
1pm
cc: Ithaca Town Supervisor
126 E . Seneca Street
Ithaca, NY 14850
Agenda Item # 5C'F1Y
OFIT ' ` ..
F TOW OF ITHACA
126 EAST SENECA STREET , ITHACA , N . Y . 14850
� Y
TOWN CLERK 273-1 ;21 HIGHWAY 7.72- 1656 PARKS 273-3035 ENG ;NE=RING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273- 1704
January 31 , 1996
Ronda C . Engman
571 South Danby Road
Spencer, New York 1488'
Ms . Engman:
Thank you for your letter of January 15, 1996, regarding the Ithacare Special Land
Use District (SLUD ) . First, a clarification is in order. The Town Board did not issue
a building permit to Ithacare . The proviso that the Town Board review the status of
the SLUR was done in conjunction with the adoption of the SLUD in 1994
(Resolution dated January 13 , 1994) . Before any building permit can be issued, the
Ithacare project has to receive site plan approval, which is under consideration by the
Planning Board.
The Planning Board has just adopted their Statement of Findings on the Ithacare
Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) on January 23, 1996, and has recommended an
alternative building location and configuration (Alternative B .3 in the EIS) to that
originally proposed . I understand that this modification in the proposal will require
a modification in the SLUR, and the Town Board would have to hold a Public
Hearing to consider such a modification. The Town Board at that hearing will also
consider the appropriateness of continuing the SLUR zoning on the Ithacare site, as
per the January 13 , 1994 resolution.
The Planning Board circulated the EIS to the Town Board for comment during the
public review period, and the Town Board will issue its own Findings, as an
Involved Agency, at the time it considers the SLLD modification.
Thank you for your interest in this matter.
Sincerely,
J
Catherine Valentino , Supervisor
Town of Ithaca
cc : Town of Ithaca Town Board
JAN 1 7 M6
RONDA C - ENGMAN
571 South . Danby Rd.
Spencer . NY 14883
607-589- 4031
January 15 , 1996,
Catherine Valentino
Ithaca Town Board
126 E . Seneca St: .
Ithaca , NY 14850
Dear Ms . Valenti.no $
I am aware that the Town Board issued a building permit to Ithacare with the
proviso that , if Ithacare has not commenced construction in a substantial manner
by February 1 , 1. 996 , that the Town Board would review the status of the entire
proposal and consider whether to continue the zoning of such area as a special
land use district . ( Draft Statement of Findings , Town of Ithaca Planning Board . )
Since the EIS was not available when the special land use district was formed
and the building permit issued , I hereby request that , should Ithacare not
commence construction by February 1 , 1996 , the Town Board hold a public hearing
before making a decision whether or not to continue the zoning of the area as
a special land use district .
Sincerely ,
J
SWEYOLAKAN FARMS Aui.Mda # 5c% -
JAMES L BAKER AND PHYWS P. BAKER
380 BOSTWICK ROAD-ITHACA, NEW YORK 14850
(607) 272-1750 "
January 4 , 1.996
Ithaca. Town Board
126 E . Seneca St .
Ithaca , NY 14850
Dear Board :
Re : Opposition ' to new town hall
We would like to express our opposition to a new
town hall of any kind . Most of us work in less than
perfect working conditions , and we still manage to do
I I our jobs .
� I
Very truly yours ,
^1
I
i James & Phyllis Baker
A
i
� I
� I
d agenda 5d
January 29 , 1996
OF T °T�rzian
109 Brandywine Road
Ithaca, NY 14850
Town Supervisor
Town of Ithaca
126 E . Seneca Street
Ithaca, NY 14850
Dear Supervisor :
Nature is powerful indeed but fortunately humans have been able to learn to live with it as best
they can . The flooding events of January 19 , 1996 however indicated that the Town of Ithaca
has not made a serious effort to co-exist peacefully with nature .
We live on the comer of Brandywine Road and Christopher Lane and every time there are heavy
rains (with or without snow or ice on the ground) that intersection becomes a dangerous lake
flooding the surrounding properties and causing significant damage. Accidents and fires
(documented) have occurred in the past under such circumstances , not to speak of the great loss
of property.
Please, is it possible for the town to correct this dangerous situation . We (myself and neighbors)
are willing to help .
hope you respond with some constructive suggestions .
Sincerely,
Yervant Terzian
Agenda # 5 b
o i `.
STATE OF NEON YORK
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
333 EAST WASHINGTON STREET
SYRACUSE , N . Y. 13202
CMARL=s E. MOYNIHAN , P. E. JOHN Be CALY
REGIONAL DIRECTOR COMMISSIONER
January 12 , 1996
Mr , William E . Wendt
Cornell University Transportation Services
116 Maple Avenue
Ithaca , New York 14850 - 4902
Dear Mr , Wendt :
Re : Route 366 at Judd Falls Road ,
Tower Road , and Caldwell Road
As you are well aware , there have been many concerns raised with the
tr= ee subject intersections over the last several years .
Or_ August 24 , 1993 , we did establish an all way stop at the Route 366
intersection with the south leg of Judd Falls Road and the Synchrotron
Lab Road , So far , this seems to be working very well .
We were reluctant to do this at the north leg of Judd Falls Road
because of the grades on Route 366 at this spot . The way that the
north and south legs of Judd Falls Road are offset from each other
also has been. a concern to us for many years . This grade and offset
make it almost impossible for us to have a good traffic operation ,
The best way to resolve this problem would be to close off the north
lea of Judd Falls Road between Route 366 and Campus Road . We realize
that such a closure would divert substantial additional traffic to
Tower Road and Caldwell Road , and in recognition of that fact , we are
w" ling to install three - color traffic signals at both of these
intersections; with Route 366 if the North Judd Falls Road closure can
Ice accomplished . we also would have the ability to install proper
ifleft turn lanes at either location should the need arise in the
futur
Mr . William E . Wendt _
January 12 , 1996
Page 2
Please review this proposal with the appropriate local officials and
advise us of their thouahts . we would be very happy to sit down and
discuss the possibilities for this with anyone if you think that would
be helpful .
Any questions on this matter may be rSferred to Barry Stevens or Ray
McDougall of our Regional Traffic Group at ( 315 ) 428 - 43800
I look forward to hearing from you soon !
very truly yours ,
All
1 '
CYPRT ES E . MO` Fi.�V , P * E *
Regional Director of Transportation
cc : William Mobbs , Commissioner of Public Works
John witcomb , Supervisor , Town c -E Ithaca
TOWN OF ITHACA
AFFIDAVIT OF POSTING AND PUBLICATION
I r Joan T Pnt Noteboom , being duly sworn , say that I am
the 'Down Cleric of the Town of Ithaca , Tompkins County , New York ;
that the following notice has been duly posted on the sign board
Of the 'Town Clerk of the Town of Ithaca and that the notice has
been duly published in the local newspaper : ( Ithaca Journal )
Notice of Public Hearing
Small Cities Community Development Block am
Location of sign board used for posting : Town Clerk ' s Office
East Seneca Street
Date of Porting : January 16 , 1996 Ithaca , NY 14850
Date of Publication : January 22 , 1996
wn Clerk , Town of Ithaca
STATE OF NEW YORK )
COUNTY OF TOMPKINS ) SS :
TOWN OF ITHACA )
S9worn to and subscrVryy Px�ofAore me this _ / a � day of
�L ' Notary Public, State of New York
Registration #01SA5044003
Qualified in Tloga County —
My Commission Expires May 22, 1997 Notary 15mn
OF 1P
TOWN OF ITHACA
E' og� 126 EAST SENECA STREET , ITHACA , N . Y . 14850
TOWN CLERK 273-1721 HIGHWAY 273-1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273-1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273-1783
FAX (607) 273- 1704
TOWN OF ITHACA
PUBLIC HEARING AUTHORIZATION
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE , that the Town of Ithaca Town Board has
authorized the first public hearing for the purpose of discussing
its 1996 U . S . Department of Housing and Urban Development ( HUD )
Small Cities Community Development Block Grant and Abbreviated
Consolidated Plan , This hearing will take place on February 12 ,
1996 at 6 : 45 p . m . , at the Town of Ithaca Town Hall , 126 East Seneca
Street , Ithaca , New York ; and
PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE , all citizens at the aforementioned
time and place shall be afforded the opportunity to voice their
approval or opposition of the said grant and plan ; and
PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE , individuals with visual
impairments , hearing impairments or other special needs , will be
provided with assistance as necessary , upon request . Persons
desiring assistance must make a request not less than 48 hours
prior to the time of the public hearing .
Joan Lent Noteboom
Town Clerk
January 16 , 1996
�-*� T6WNi0PITHACA�'`P"}I
GPUBL10.MEAR1NM4'AU
�;ATMORIZATION l
PUBLISH : January 22 , 1996 .. 3
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE'lthat ,,
the Tovr tof:,;klthccoliv n •
Board, ha��authorize`d the�fiFat�r
public hid 1 u
for :.th e�f r 5
pp .
oseo e'tIscussingrits „1,
U 'S'�Depdrfinentl of�hHouaing;��
and3 Urkion''�Developmegt :1
(HUD)!�Smcll fillies ,Commu
niy DevelogmentaBlock Grant
and0Abbre3ldted, 'Conaoll ;
dated+Plari,;iTh(s'x 'Ingtwill ..
tdk°e'.p pigceVen+FebrOrry12;
h996uot6 45 �p rnatthei
Town" of*slthaco;�Toivn,Hall,;. >
,l 26�Eaet .' Seneca��Street,.;I
Ithaca NiZYork ''and ;
PLEASEIJAKEEFU�THER NO ,
ICE ollr�citizena'r at, -t
'dforementloqed ` tlme xendtr
sp Dead e. "glltb9;.1 ordedkth'e
'opporhinity. to,voicq;tfieltkap- !t
�gro�l�'ar�oppoaltlon�;of ftie�
areal 4 r6nfsandf 6n;- and .n'::
' `PLEASE�TAKE;`FPJRTHER} OQ'
N
TICE; Indlv,Iduala .,wIth4YIsual ,
impairments;hearing"-Impaiv;w
�menta orOother special°needs;'j
;vrlll�fbe�pFovldeddwith e`asalr,�
tents aa)-rieceasory,t:upon re• ;
queatPersona{desring �assis
tgnee a mustPnoki,W— requ ;h
u e ,
notle ?(fhann�lQ, hourap►lor„.
to the NmeFqOf ihefpubhe heaar::
In g`
1lJoanWlent,Noteboom
17anuary:22;'x•996:
TOWN OF ITHACA
AFFIDAVIT OF POSTING AND PUBLICATION
I Joan Lent Noteboom , being duly sworn , say that I am
the 'Town Clerk of the Town of Ithaca , Tompkins County , New York ;
that the following notice has been duly posted on the sign board
of the Town Clerk of the Town of Ithaca and that the notice has
been duly published in the local newspaper : ( Ithaca Journal )
Public Hearing Notice
Aged Exemptions
Location of sign board used for posting : Town Clerk ' s Office
126 East Seneca Street
Date of Pasting : February 1 , 1996 Ithaca , NY 14850
Date of Publication : February 2 , 1996
T n Clerk , Town of Ithaca
STATE OF NEW YORK }
COUNTY OF TOMPKINS ) SS :
TOWN OF ITHACA ) ;
Sworn to and subscribed before me this 1a 'hh day of _
ly
1661 . 'ZZ Aew Sajldx3 UOISSIWW03 AW
AW03 e6o11 ul pallllenp
£omowsly u0119Jls1688 Notary 1 i c
)PoA MON 10 81ejS 'oll9ud tieioN
uopeS •p Ajew
�ti UP' 12
1' r � � UWN OF J . r�. 1 � I CA
1 21 �- 126 LAST- SENECA STREET , ITHACA , N . Y . 14850
TOWN CLERK 273 -- 1721 1 IIG1IWAY 273- 1656 PARKS 273-8035 ENGINEERING 273- 1747 PLANNING 273-1747 ZONING 273- 1783
FAX (607) 273- 1704
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
TOWN OF ITHACA
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE , that the Town Board of the Town of Ithaca
will hold a public hearing at a regular meeting of the Town Board
on February 12 , 1996 , at 6 : 30 p . m . , at the Town Hall , 126 East
Seneca Street , Ithaca , New York in order that they may ,consider a ,
" LOCAL LAW PROV 'I' DING FOR ADDITIONAL LEVELS OF INCOME ELIGIBILITY
FOR THE FARTIAT ., 'PAX EXEMPTION FOR REAL PROPERTY OWNED BY PERSONS
W :f- '1'il L1M :C '1' 1 : 1� :LI� CUMI E; W11O ARE 65 YEARS OF AGE' OR OVER .
PLEASE 'PAIGE 1 UR'P1IER NOTICE , all citizens at the aforementioned
time and place shall be afforded the opportunity to voice their
approval or opposition of the said contract .
PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE , individuals with visual
impairments , hearing impairments or other special needs , will be
provided with assistance as necessary , upon request . Persons
desiring assistance must make a request not less than 48 hours
prior to the time of the public hearing ,
Joan Lent Noteboom
Town Clerk
February 1 , 1996
PUBLISH : February 2 , 1996 NOTICE OF' •'�'P BLC
HEARING ,
TOWN OF ITHACA
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE; that
the Town Board of the Town
I• of Ithaca will hold , a public
hearing at o regular, meeting
of the Town Board on Feb-
ruory 12 1996, at 6:30
pp m., at L Town , Hall 126
Eost Seneca Street, - Ivaco,
Now York ; in order that theY
IAaW' PROVIDING 1`OR.ADDI
TIONAL LEVELS OF INCOME
ELIGIBILITY FOR THE PARTIAL
TAX EXEMPTION FOR REAL
PROPERTY OWNED BY PER•:
SONS WITH LIMITED IN-
COMES : -WHO ; ARE 65
YEARS OF AGE OR OVER."
PLEASE .TAKE FURTHER NO
TICE, all cltizens at the
oforementlonned. ltime and
place shall be afforded the
opportunity to voice their qp-
proyal for oppposition of ,the
said conhacf.;
PLEASE - TAKE FURTHER NO*
TICE, Individuals with visual
Impairments;•• hearing Impair,
ments or othir speclal needs,
,will ' be • provided .With , assis•
,lance as necessary, upon re•
quest. Personi -desiring assis-
tance must nuke' a . request
' not lees than '48 • hours rior ,
to the time of; the Public dear•
Ing, .
Joan lent oonbColon
Feb=Mary 2, 1996 . � '