HomeMy WebLinkAbout2008-01-14 V
S
Town of Lansing
•
Monday, January 14, 7: 15 PM PLANNING BOARD
PLANNING BOARD MEMBERS
c•rt,utIsr ,v,
* Nancy Londa * Tom Ellis
Larry Sharpstcen * Lin Davidson, Chairman
Viola Miller * David rfritfield
Larry Ccidenra
Matlhcry Besenier, Town Board Liaison
* Richard Platt, Zoning and Code Enforcement Officer
favid Herrick, RE. Town of Lansing Engineer
Lorraine Moynihan Schmitt, Esq .
Darby Kiley, TOL Environmental Planner
Public Present
C. Scott Pinney
Timothy Cornell
General Business •
Lin Davidson called the Planning Board Meeting to order at 7:15 PM .
Agenda Amendment - . T . Landscape Excavation, Owner Timothy
Cornell )
Richard Platt, CEA explained to the board that originally Mr. Cornell was on
the Agenda for this meeting however, after some discussion with Darby liley
they contacted Ms. Moynihan Schmitt for der opinion . After some discussion,
Ms .. Moynihan Schmitt and Mr- Krogh agreed this would be considered a
Commercial Greenhouse. Mr , Platt explained to the Planning Board that Mr .
Cornellbusiness is landscaping and excavation - This sac, Mr . Platt discussed this
•ith Chairman Lin Davidson and Larry Sharpsteen and they both felt that the
Ordinance does not have a classification kr Mr . Cornell' s business,
Mr. Cornell advised the members that lie would like to relocate his business
around the cnrner from where it is now, On e portion of the same parcel . rater
further discussion with the Planning Board Members , it was determined that this
is a Zoning Board of Appeals issue .
r
AAPPROVED� 77 ` ,
ED Amemled 1281418 Harming Board
• Larry Sharpsteen made a motion recommending to the Zoning Board of Appeals
that in the Planning Board' s view when you are moving a business 200 yards like
Mr. Cornell' s, under the circumstances there should be no problem .
David Hatfield seconded .
VOTE AS FOLLOWS :
Thomas Ellis - Aye
David Hatfield - Aye
Nancy Loncto - Aye
Viola Miller - Aye
Larry Sharpsteen - Aye
Larry Zuidema - Aye
Lin Davidson - Aye
MOTION CARRIED .
The Planning Board will set a Public Hearing for Mr . Cornell' s Site Plan Review
at the first Meeting in February .
Other Business
A brief discussion was held with regards to the outcome of the Site Plan review
for the Lama Storage. Nancy Loncto felt the printed sign attached to the fence
• was not what the Planning Board had in mind . Ms . Loncto furthei stated that
she is pleasantly delighted with the lighting. Larry Zuidema stated it looks very
nice, they choose good colors . Mr . Platt will make a site visit to check out the
Sign .
Zoning Ordinance Update
The Members continued updating the Zoning Ordinance via the computer with
Dick Platt. (On Tape in the Code Enforcement Office)
Larry Sharpsteen made a motion to pass the proposed Zoning Ordinance
changes on to the Town Board for their review . Thomas Ellis seconded .
VOTE AS FOLLOWS :
Thomas Ellis - Aye
David Hatfield - Aye
Nancy Loncto - Aye
Viola Miller - Aye
Larry Sharpsteen - Aye
Larry Zuidema - Aye
Lin Davidson - Aye
111 MOTION CARRIED .
2
APPROVED Amended 1 :28/08 Planning Board
•
David Hatfield made a motion to adjourn the meeting at 9 : 25 PM . Larry
Sharpsteen seconded .
VOTE AS FOLLOWS :
Thomas Ellis - Aye
David Hatfield - Aye
Nancy Loncto - Aye
Viola Miller - Aye
Larry Sharpsteen - Aye
Larry Zuidema - Aye
Lin Davidson - Aye
MOTION CARRIED.
•
• Town of Lansing Planning Board
January 14, 2008
Visitors Please Sign In Below : (Please Print)
Name Address
-�; rr., Cornu\ \
II
•
http : //www . lansingtown . com/
S
II4
. _
e1/417a u IrTOWN of' SING
® Q \ "Ho►ue of Iadu.gfry, AgriculLANture and Scenic Beauty "
'9 `
�a� h ZONING , PLANNING AND CODE ENFORCEMENT
y"4 "-.1,,, All Box .186
Lansing, NY I :6882
44
' I
,'i •
� � F-u, ail : 6ilrcodee@twcn}-. rr . cun ,
Town of Lansing
Planning Board Meeting
January 14, 7: 15 PM
Lansing Town Hall - Board Room
http ://www . lansingtown. com/
Agenda
Time: Agenda Topics
7:1.5 PM Public Comments/Concerns
•
Land Use Ordinance Updates
2007 Site Plan Reviews
.Duthie/Putnam , Dance Studio — Site Plan Approved with Conditions .
Lama Airport Storage — Site Plan Approved with Conditions
Lauzun- Expanded Business- Site Plan Approved-referred to Town Board
(Special Permit)
Inman - Mobile Home Set Up- Site Plan Approved with Conditions
Brock- In Home Law Practice — Site Plan Approved with Conditions
DeCraw- Antiques & Used Goods — Site Plan Approved with Conditions
Wheaton ' s - Heating & Air. - Site Plan Approved with Conditions
Moskow - In Home :Business- Computers — Site Plan Approved
® Pirro — Garage — Site Plan Approved
Canzler- Carport — Site Plan Approved
Global Phoenix- Warehouse Expansion — Site Plan Approved
Wheaton ' s — Heating & Air (2 " d site) Site Plan Approved
IMR.- Storage Shed — Site Plan Approved with Conditions
• Building Permits
"Gown of Lansing
Tompkins County New York
1993 -2007
45 �I
40 - I — — .
a
35 'I
r
� w
30 - — — _ -- O Sgle Res
25 -- H. ■ Multi Res
20 — ._ _ — ❑ Mobile H .
7 ni
15 - ~— ' -- e Per • le Pee e lee ere p weeOBusiness
0 li_ 1' n _ . ! LI - I, �I
1993 1995 1997 1999 2001 2003 2005 2007
Note: excludes permits required for additions, alterations and renovations_
® Average # new single family residence permits for 1993 to 2007 = 35 . 6
2007 = 31
Average # excluding 2002 -04 housing boom years = 33 . 1
15 year trend : mixed
5 year trend : down
Average # multiple residence permits 1993 to 2007 = 1 . 1
2007 = 0
15 year trend : mixed
5 year trend : level at 0 or 1 per year
Average # new mobile home permits for 1993 to 2007 = 12 . 9
2007 = 4
10 year trend : down
5 year trend : level from 4 to 6 per year
Average # new business permits for 1993 to 2007 = 1 . 7
2007 = 0
15 year trend : down
5 year trend : level at 0 or I per year
Average total new construction permits per year = 51 . 3
2007 = 35
15 year trend : mixed
5 year trend : down
Source : Town of Lansing Records
Prepared by L. W. Zuidema, Member, Planning Board
9 April 2008
w i-
» co
I-- LI i I I 1-I- � I
m0 o0o00CD000000000Oo000000000010 . 000 t
O A A AIA P W W W WIW W W W Lv N Lv N �v Lv N N` NIN I 0 •
M { r. +. 0 9� as W az (� ., W t70 40
ti ` ti
m O O O o N N J N N N N O O O O O N N N N NICD N N °
A Oto UD tDcflOO) N N ('V NJ ON �V N (_J N LJ N J�V N N �3OOOO CO tD
-.
ro O 25
2325 ` » 25 � 1 t 1 ` 25 CD
23c> 00000000
Ct) O O . OIO 0 0 0 0 0 O O O O o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O . 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O ?
-- r V . 4 V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V V �/ V V V V V V - !
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 oleo 0 0000000000 oto O O O O O V
Z V V0V V V V V V � V V V V V V V V V V V V V -z4 V V V V V V � V V V V V V V V V V � I
CO o ,, o6OOoobo6666o00bb00loo0oobo10o ' a666 66obat
W co W W co W W Co W W N N N N N N N N N N O O O O O pp O O of
(D CO V O vi a CO N -+ O (O COV , O cn A W N -+ O tO O V O) , (J1 A Co N —h O (o COV O) , (.J) a W _N �
MKKM , KKZ KMKlz > 73000 ' 71IO03 > OKWOCIODz � 02300 >
O O C O O O O O , O O O N at t0/i in 0 0 to ® o C: "' N y 0 1 t/l I - CDD 0 y (D ,�
O o O O o O O o o o O o o o O p O 0 O C o m m o O • O -n 3 m 3 O o m 3 n tp , 3 O
0 0 0 O , O O O O C O O C ; 0 o o -Ao a 0 0 p l71 m , 0 O O o Y. v Q a 0 c O C c
cnw > > > > DD ~ DDnoDD � 3 OO = Q0D � gD • -S Na. 0 -. - N
m m o 3 n a -0 a o -0 c a a N 0' M o. — c a z f 0 fpm m 3 (j (�
- r. ° Im ° p O O ' O. a1:1 m O o `o' N � . 2 D D D 5 `o' co --, 0 co 1 1 2 -0 a 2 'Zink
c a 3 10 c -T. c N o o to C c m m -0 -0 Da -0 c o o c o. O ® m sv a+ 0 m to CD ; ro o
Co. ... a 3 < 0 7 < < 3 3 0 3 O 0 c c 3 c 13 3 V y 3 3 O 41 0 3 m O N D) SD
0 m 0 cD m t0 C n. Q 0. a c ro m o. o, =. ? .. < r. co - CI It on -
_
c9 gm m CD �' m �. N N71 3 N m 3 3 to (7 (� 3 A N co� (n . t0 (p ,t>a n ° np Z O (0 (fl CO tD
2 2 at mes. co in N m m m C. (n 2 2 2 C7 m 3 3 m 171 1 ,, I • 7 fa -0 I 7 , i
N (m5) EI0 N m O 7 O O O, ,� c 3 .....
o m m 0 N CO= � � N CO 3 Mi m Ori Cu a: ("D m O Ces
D
_+. 7. 7 to o CO V (o p V V 0) CO (D t0 m N d ,tO -_e. D) CD 0 t= O O ' - 0 = C ton
(0 to ' K K 3 K _• is c a; m (o .. c' I xi D °) Co m o m 10 m
� � � o c c Men
d m 3 ' • • A 0 N) cn r- � (n Vi . w D 7! �
_ m_ (n3
3 0 y N us. fDi o _= r B 7 is is '17 N c n3) N apt o a O� c a C I c
11 c 0 0 3 C) l a 3 m c a � S -o m o p < to � v (05 5 3_ � o
(Dm - ro 3 30 3 coca) > > w CDCDacoo -0 _ 3v, (° 0
a 3 " t a. Ca � � M � 0m � I m a) c •o -4
c
-rata x0 F -I cn al -v
ro7 O , NQ O m 3a , (D . S . O to as rn n- d
tD n - 3 D) a i m w 3
XJ -I o -0 O 0 d o T m m (0 m 3 3 3
p CO O , 3 r. • w 0 �' =, m ed m 0 (a
fl. x ^ 3 0 o r m 0 ro o, 0 I v „ o d
CO
o ° a ' * , CD W chl 3 N c oI I Doi
Q C) m Icn 0 0 a (0 m ro
D ' m v o a, <' m 3 c ,, a
a 0 �, tO m cD o N
o (7).-• m o 3 to 0 I o
OI - N_ 0 a-
�, co d I D .p CD CID o
C to
cn O m V' im
N < � oo
' NIS
I �
3 3 I I
I I co
N N
I = I
IC
I tt) `G
3 0I
I m
I610IIZ
I
11 I 00
w1I
I � HI I
HwH , HHHLHHHw
HIHLHH1 I H
1
11
1 1II I
•
1 1 II 1 1 1II1 I 1 1 I III � 1 1 1 I
. W
a o I * 1 _,_� III- _�•►_ ,_I_i i + _1_l_ �, 14 • - •;
r -:- - •i- -
• o 0 0rc, i0c, c, 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 01010 0 0 0 0010101OlO 00 ' 0 0 0 0 , 0 0 p ItO $ co . co V V V -4 V -4 V V V V V o 0) 010) O (T o O TN °)
OICTI Ui1CT al ICT CM CT CT (T A A A A A
NI NI0000010OOINNNOOI
a A a a a a A A A , co CA W CO CO
2 0 O O O Olo O O O , O 0 0 0 0 0 0 OIO Olo O O , O 0 0 0 0 0 0100 O O O O O OHO O O O
r V V V V V V • V ; V V V V V V V V IV V V V V ' V V V V V V V V V V V V V V , V v V V V , V
5 000000000000000000000 [000 ( 000100000000 • 0000
Z V -%1 -I.4 V 4.14 V V V V V V V V V V V V V V� V ..1.1 V V V -/%1 V V V V V V V V V V V V V
I 1 I 1 I 1 ' I 1 1 , 1 I 1 I 1 1 1 I I I 1 1 1 1 I I I
Cn b , oo0000000000000boo6oboo0ol0obobb00oo $ 00
V V V V V V V V V V o o O a) o O) o a) 0) CAN N an (n (n (n ' CT (J) (T ui a a a a A A . A A
(0 03 V Cl) CT A Cw) N -1 O 1 CO I (b -4 Cr) to A co N -' 0 CO (b V 0) CT A GJ I N -. 0 CD CO V o CJ1 I A W N 1 -• 0
O 0 0 0 o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o OicD o o o o o o o m o CD o , o o o o ro o o
= , a. .r c r.' e . C .--. = .-* - r1; •1 = -. re-. C (A (J • 0 - (A C •+ = U) =. =
O O O O o o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O , O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O . O O O ' O 0 0 0 O O o 0 o O
7 3 7 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 7 3 7 0 3 l3 3 3 7 3 E C 3 7 3 3 3 3 7 L 3 i 3 3 3 3 7 C 3 m
O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 • O 1O ' O 0 0 0 0 • O • O O O O O • O O
D > ' D D D D 0 0 0 0 0 > > > > > > > n > 3 o 0 0 0 0 > 2> > 3 * 3 0 0 > > 3 D D
Cl _ a U ro O "0 p t n '0 a •b i , m ' n O m) O -p a I co 0 13 a t Cp Ca. n
'a a c /3 c 0 m 0 m M m 0 (3 13 m It 2 0 0 m ? 0 3 1 -p -0 m 0 .. > co o ti o < C1 o n
O O C o C O -0 o t , p B o -0 (n d m
< < 3 < 3 < ro w Cn - - < 3 < < " < =O• - 3 3 of) 1J v 7 < < a ru ro I- -0 -a << 3 r 7 j
ro CD , m m mmC C CO m y D ro , W mmc c CDM _ c 0 C , c m _ I C°
._ . KeiM _ Q as z: c . Ka (n0-) • - n > 0ac cn 3l0. < (SaDse- O KN)
ro -• a) pp - m c ro Tt• m (n (O • m A- (0 ro re roc)
m e ro c� a.55 i ci i _ m c c m L m ow c -n Z 73 70 i' a �. ' ro �, Fir. (n n n a CD o •n s o
'0 m O o cn o < m m m 3 m ° v ro m in
(a 3 r. zto m co 5 � ' 3 v
CI N '� • (7 - ... ro C �) D) - (p (D 3 3 q 0! d C 0) sli at W d :. O +i m N (D 7� m c.]
p 7. .Z7 _ iQ .-• 7. �• N CU Z. ro 7• j' O 3 3
- v _ _
m C- C a 7 (D CO lO < O O to U) � y n 'o < I'- m CO , C Oo 3 -0 (p _ COO 0 Fro I
< C a Q ^ ^ (D 0 co G. O n o 1 m �.-. V 1 -0 1 m .. ^ N :V m
(o' `< W Cnfnc * .< r p CAn o T KKK ZIo n Do Do y
`L t0 Q. N• A C C .� � p) ,. C Q < o X c ccTc7c _. o < N ' Z o o o I Z < O
Ca ON %. 3 0 G m .� o. ... = O .+ a. S c <. v -6- ro O
-i O •'•I K. N 4 <. 00 > C!) co ro — I _* CO <D co X * -4
O V X01 O N1 0 ri C I d a n CD
m -0
ro rn 3
c � Im �• � mov ' � D � D ET
r. ". I na] n. '1 )-
"' m D 1Ft.
< sI rom1 rom m
I cn CD °� °: I CD c 0 3 = t1 m
o I = 0 . 0 v Q , ro 0 + a g m a 3 co
x� I 2ro (" rono (o < a al Kro o
3 to
I (� �� 3 1 y' p_j m -
nro a05 o ro (n
O a O tU 3 0 I ? 6
� < I I ac ^ I I no) 0O
O to 7 tQ � 1 � p co co
0
a c v I o 3
N I g) cn d
3 I mlw n
n 1 _ 1 � c I o
I � � o -I
I I a < 1 o N
II I
I i N, - 0
1 I oo IIII
a
it CAI
i I 1 1g•
1 I a
1 I --.
LHH to• XVIII
III 1
II III 12 1
I 1
II . ' IIi1 1 I I II .
II I 1
IIII 11I 1 I
1 I III
1 1 I 1
IIII I , II
I II IIII IIII 1I1I
I 1111 11 it i I IIS
1 II I I I I 11 , E 1i11
H
IIIIIIIIIII •
111III II 1k I � � I W IIIIIIIII � I
. W
, _ _ _4 , . _; _. _� � _ I . •
sur � I , , , _. , , 1 , 1 , 1 , , t , , , � , 1 1 I -I-t -I I I w 1- 1
N D N 1 � N N Q NJ N -1 -• , 10 O O O 0 0 O O O O I o �t01 t0 OD CD to to O O O CO 03
I O I O O O O O
� A A ` 1 �. A -R3
11R3
A A 1
N , N N N N 1 N N N N N N-RI; O O O o ER o " O O t31 O N QN Cn 0 Ul 0 0 tT tT 0 A O o o o o V V1V V , V , cc z D � OA N AA A A AR3AA AAAAAAAm N N N N N N N N N NINNINININ N N N N N N N N N N3 RS- N N f� v v C� W G� S
c39 0 oIOlo0000O0O10000OOOOOOgo00Op OQ000O
o o O p O O 01 O O O g 0 0 0 0 0 0 OI O O OI 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 p O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
CD r _ V V V V VIV� V V V V V V V V V -4 V1V V -.4 V V V V V --41 -%I_ V V VIV V V V V V V � V
-I - I1 ' _I 1I-I I .on -4 I ,
Q 010000 + olot ° o OOOOOOOOOo OIoIo o o o o oHaloaolo , 000a
Z v . VvV VVV ! V7! VV V �I vNvvVVV �! VVVVtilVVtlV V V V �I
to 1I I o0 000 oaoo o o o b o 0 0 0 0 0
O O O O o o O o o o CO cC p 2 O I t0 8 t0 t0 t0 ao Qo ao 0o ao t" 00 O O o0
-1101 01 .P G1 N a 1 O 1 (0 03 � V Q) , CT A _CJ Nr, O to OD , 0/ Ul A W N , � + O cD CO V 03 CJS �A I W N -1 0
KK • MKM377 , 7a ' K33Ka3KIMKISKK3KM !f 'S 313I3M373 .Z73 '' MK aKK
o o o o o o ' CD o o o o o o 10 o o o o o o o c o o o o o o 0 o m 0 s 0 0 0 0 0 0
C .+ - = .' c. to = C . c. r.; • c I = C_: = c. V1 0 >= s C = C
0 10 0 0 0 0 0 IO O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O 0 0 0 0 0 0 O IO O O O o
7 7 3077 °-- 7 7 7 7 3 3 3 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 3 3 3 7 3 7 7 3 7 C C 7 3 7 i3 Do
0 0 0 0 0 0 O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O o 0 0 0 O 0 0 O O O O O O
D z D D . g DI3 D D tU > > g D _ D D t, a DDD rn D * � D G) ,> g g D * D •-
[ 1 0 t3 -0 a n C11 V a 13 0 'o ED a w n a) a a tD a
o n •a -a a a o 13 ED o 'c m. O. /3 a 8 c -o I0 o w ° < m• .o 0 a' -0 c 0 a tn, o -o v
c °, 3888 c o v c a ' I ' c o o 3 c o m c ia ' o ® a c w a DP, 3 Q c<► c a <
73CD0CDCDC -1CD , t, - (Dva2mCD3 CD - 37z < -0CDamm 'aofCD to3m -0
Km mz001 < PKtn9 acnaKccncno -^ ., ZKo to a FrK1 7 -1 a � a tcaniKcng
co a 0 < o o m tD a F. n .oo. = 10 Ia CD o `n m n m " 3 3 - o m sv m ca o
3 p = t7 tT sl 7 cle,13 Z 7 r CD CD ^" CO O `� C>' c� .C6 3 _ D 17 Mr. CD C7
c0 O 3 to co -s tO m to O 3 c • 3 r = to 7 C IP Z - ZJ c 7 3' _
7 CJ O O itl m CO J a c c (D �° O n tD Cn �� Cp to !Q C o CU tD
3 n N 3 CS 2 3 700 _ Vt ^� c• • 7 dW O C_D N j Cn CD7. co co ^' CD Ian a 3 ' a s� CD 07 O 7.
ICt) _ JNOI I (D fn Stn W „ 3j zI3 NOGtfl ocOn 'O .. <, n XJ3
_ _ < O
_2.-10 it
a D = = tpo
10 0 ,� 3 Zj P O O O Cn 7 D sl CD z tD <
Dn NOO ' O 0E O N * r\) ;‘) Dtas Oto 54 7,1 CD CD 3 3 m ( so ca 0
'O 1 m O V V n o 7 a 7• O O to '' (D CD „ 7 0 Co * 7 17. * N
'0 Vf o y CD 7 O c tp n O O CD CD r I. . () (h t1 O 7 a ^ 0
4 �+ v, 10. ,� o vi Ca 0 -4 V 0 tow n 3 Cap - 3 , fa 0 v 0
St): c O 7:1 ' O ^ o v' O to N N < N Z r.0 O CD n 0 AO 3
'.' ”' 7 O r. W C 7r A 41 in C N (S . = O 3 .-. N s 17
co ooLl I -- 7 � c' y EJ -- v_, opy � -„ a � � o w
o• to a copa m c to m 1 a) = to 7 I.E. c I ,-
1 D I 0 p 7
O CD to 3 O , 0 (0 n im an to yr 0) a . CD xr Cin r A co 3 cc: 3 - X•
aj Ico
a 3 M a a (1:,
N to (D N to O b ? co 0 C3i D N 5 0 Q co
co I
`Q3 ,to ? vm, omI � � � � � o � � Who 3 uoi
_ o
r I o m 3 lis
I _ Im , 3 ,f` a CD n o N z c
O a I4: `� I I ' 3 33a. to 1 sl fag d0 o — X 1 N Al
7I F to = CZ Cp it .... t71 a O O V O I13 .� tD
d 07N — SU c a a CD j. 7 7 I ,..4 10 1 In
I I 3 t, A Vi ICap I • 3 a. co pa IQ C
10 ) p n@ n a (7 O�• O C
wD I31 CO D ... n 7 N N Co" m0
I mI : 0 G) N 0I [2::1 PI o nI ' °� y O m °' IIoIa� o I �I I14::?:
� — I � 3 .0
O wu . > co 10 a, - I
Iv i l
a a w
0 3 cwD Im I
I 1X 11 Ica:o
1......
� � II II
IIIII � 3 HI -> '011IIi
I i
Iii
is
1 o I I
IITS 1I
`y .2 , 1 II I
1 I i
I � IIIa.. 11 1I1 I111HH1D i III
IIx. I I I 1101' 1 1 11111 T � IHTH
I1 1111 11 IIII I I111i Io1111 N 1
It W I c1 1 1111 I •
II IIIII I► I � � ll IIIIIl , , I � � 1111 II1 , 111ll