Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutDSEIS-Appendix-F_Revised-Visual-Impact-Assessment-1.pdfHARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. 77 South Bedford Street Burlington, MA 01803 T 781.229.0707 F 781.229.7939 W www.hmmh.com ÂÂÂÂÂÂÂÂ#* T o m p k i n s C o u n t y T o m p k i n s C o u n t y S c h u y l e rS c h u y l e r C o u n t yC o u n t y Cayutaville RdTower RdGriffin RdBlack Oak RdCulver Rd Weatherby RdCounty Line RdSaxtonHillRd Rumsey Hill RdRothermich RdHarvey Hill Rd 7c 7b 7a 6 54 3 1 ©0 2,000 4,000 Ft Black Oak Wind Farm, LLCEnfield, New YorkPath: G:\Projects\306XXX\306590_Black_Oak_Wind\GIS\306590_Black_Oak_Figure1_Turbine_Location_Option1-3.mxdÂProposed Wind Turbines Figure 1Turbine Locations Met Tower Location#* HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page 3 HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page 4 HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page 5 HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page 6 HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page 7 HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page 8 " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " "ÂÂÂÂÂÂÂ#* 5 M ile B u fferFingerLakesTrailFinger LakesTrail FingerLak esTrail Finger LakesTrailT o m p k i n s T o m p k i n sC o u n t y C o u n t y S c h u y l e r S c h u y l e rC o u n t y C o u n t y UV79 UV228 UV227 UV327 UV224 UV96 UV13 UV228 Robert TremanState Park Finger Lakes National Forest NewfieldHamlet Odessa NorthwestIthaca Connecticut HillWildlife Management Area NewfieldState Forest Texas HollowState Forest Alpine Enfield Newfield Perry City Mecklenburg Cayutaville Krum Corner Smith Valley Reynoldsville Butternut Park Christian Hill Whipple Corner Duboise Corner Kennedy Corner Kellogg Corners Millers Corners Cloverland Park Van Dorn Corner Meadowbrook ParkTrumbull Corners Spaulding Corner Bostwick Corners Applegate Corner Black Oaks Corners Black Oak Wind Farm, LLCEnfield, New YorkPath: G:\Projects\306XXX\306590_Black_Oak_Wind\GIS\306590_Black_Oak_Figure6_Option1_7a7b_Visibility.mxdFigure 6Daytime Viewshed Analysis Resultsfor Option 1 Wildlife Management Area National/State Park or Forest Village/Hamlet TrailRoads ©0 1 2 3 Miles Proposed Wind Turbines Â1 2 3 Number of Potentially Visible Turbines 54 6 7Met Tower#* " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " "ÂÂÂÂÂÂÂ#* 5 M ile B u fferFingerLakesTrailFinger LakesTrail FingerLak esTrail Finger LakesTrailT o m p k i n s T o m p k i n sC o u n t y C o u n t y S c h u y l e r S c h u y l e rC o u n t y C o u n t y UV79 UV228 UV227 UV327 UV224 UV96 UV13 UV228 Robert TremanState Park Finger Lakes National Forest NewfieldHamlet Odessa NorthwestIthaca Connecticut HillWildlife Management Area NewfieldState Forest Texas HollowState Forest Alpine Enfield Newfield Perry City Mecklenburg Cayutaville Krum Corner Smith Valley Reynoldsville Butternut Park Christian Hill Whipple Corner Duboise Corner Kennedy Corner Kellogg Corners Millers Corners Cloverland Park Van Dorn Corner Meadowbrook ParkTrumbull Corners Spaulding Corner Bostwick Corners Applegate Corner Black Oaks Corners Black Oak Wind Farm, LLCEnfield, New YorkPath: G:\Projects\306XXX\306590_Black_Oak_Wind\GIS\306590_Black_Oak_Figure7_Option1_7a7b_FAA_Visibility.mxdFigure 7Nightime FAA Lighting Viewshed Analysis Results for Option 1 Wildlife Management Area National/State Park or Forest Village/Hamlet TrailRoads ©0 1 2 3 Miles Proposed Wind Turbines ÂNumber of Potentially Visible FAA Lights 1 2 3 4 5 6 7Met Tower#* HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page 11 HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page 12 aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa!( !( !( !( !( !(!( !( !( !( !( !( !( !( !( !( !( !( !( !( !( !( !( !( !( !( !( !( !( !( !( !( !( !( !( !( !( !( !( !( !( !(!( !( !( !( !( !( !(!( !( !(!( !( !( !(!(!( !(!(!( !( !( !( !( !( #*ÂÂÂÂÂÂÂ5 M ile B u fferNewfieldCovered Bridge Enfield Falls Mill and Miller's House Lattin-Crandall Octagon Barn FingerLakesTrailFinger LakesTrail FingerLak esTrail Finger LakesTrailT o m p k i n s T o m p k i n sC o u n t y C o u n t y S c h u y l e r S c h u y l e rC o u n t y C o u n t y UV79 UV228 UV227 UV327 UV224 UV96 UV13 UV228 Robert TremanState Park Finger Lakes National Forest NewfieldHamlet Odessa NorthwestIthaca Connecticut HillWildlife Management Area NewfieldState Forest Texas HollowState Forest 3 9 1 65 8 4 2 7 66 65 64 63 62 61 60 59 5857 56 5554 5352 51 5047 48 46 45 44 4241 34 33 32 40 30 49 38 39 35 36 37 29 22 26 1413 17 12 24 10 27 23 20 18 11 16 21 25 28 19 15 78 77 76 74 7372 71 69 68 67 75 70 Enfield ES Odessa-Montour JSHS Alpine Enfield Perry City Mecklenburg Cayutaville Krum Corner Smith Valley Reynoldsville Butternut Park Christian Hill Whipple Corner Duboise Corner Kennedy Corner Kellogg Corners Millers Corners Cloverland Park Van Dorn Corner Meadowbrook ParkTrumbull Corners Spaulding Corner Bostwick Corners Applegate Corner Black Oak Wind Farm, LLCEnfield, New YorkPath: G:\Projects\306XXX\306590_Black_Oak_Wind\GIS\306590_Black_Oak_Figure8_Receptor_LOS_Option_2.mxdFigure 8Inventoried Resource Line-of-SightWildlife Management Area National/State Park or Forest Village/Hamlet TrailRoads ©0 1 2 3 Miles Proposed Wind Turbines ÂLine of Sight - Visible Line of Sight - Not Visible #*Met Tower aaPhoto Location !(Local Sensitive Areas !!(National Register of Historic Places Æc Library n School HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page 14 ÂÂÂÂÂ" " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " Æc Æc nn nnn n !!( !!( !!(aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaÂÂÂ#* 5 M ile B u fferNewfieldCovered Bridge Enfield Falls Mill and Miller's House Lattin-Crandall Octagon Barn FingerLakesTrailFinger LakesTrail FingerLak esTrail Finger LakesTrailT o m p k i n s T o m p k i n sC o u n t y C o u n t y S c h u y l e r S c h u y l e rC o u n t y C o u n t y UV79 UV228 UV227 UV327 UV224 UV96 UV13 UV228 Robert TremanState Park Finger Lakes National Forest NewfieldHamlet Odessa NorthwestIthaca Connecticut HillWildlife Management Area NewfieldState Forest Texas HollowState Forest 79 64 63 62 57 56 54 35 34 47 49 18 17 48 33 38 84 8382 81 80 Newfield Public Library Enfield ES Newfield MSNewfield ES Odessa-Montour JSHS Alpine Enfield Perry City Mecklenburg Cayutaville Krum Corner Smith Valley Reynoldsville Butternut Park Christian Hill Whipple Corner Duboise Corner Kennedy Corner Kellogg Corners Millers Corners Cloverland Park Van Dorn Corner Meadowbrook ParkTrumbull Corners Spaulding Corner Bostwick Corners Applegate Corner Black Oaks Corners Black Oak Wind Farm, LLCEnfield, New YorkPath: G:\Projects\306XXX\306590_Black_Oak_Wind\GIS\306590_Black_Oak_Figure9_Photo_Simulation_Locations.mxdFigure 9Viewer Locations Chosen for Photosimulation AnalysisNumber of Visible Turbines 7654321 Wildlife Management Area National/State Park or Forest Village/Hamlet TrailRoads ©0 1 2 3 Miles !!(National Register of Historic Places aaReceptor Photograph Location aaReceptor Photograph Location Option Proposed Wind Turbines ÂProposed Wind Turbine Option ÂMet Tower Æc LibrarynSchool #*Met Tower HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page 16 HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page 17 HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page 18 HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page A-1 HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page A-2 HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page A-3 Figure A1 Photosimulation PS#80 Cayutaville Road - Original Image HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page A-4 Figure A2 Photosimulation PS#80 Cayutaville Road - Simulation Image Turbine 7A HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page A-5 Figure A3 Photosimulation PS#81 at Black Oak Road - Original Image HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page A-6 Figure A4 Photosimulation PS#81 at Black Oak Road - Simulation Turbine 7B HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page A-7 Figure A5 Photosimulation PS#81 at Black Oak Road - Simulation Turbine 7B & 7C HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page A-8 Figure A6 Photosimulation PS#81 at Black Oak Road - Simulation Turbine 7C HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page A-9 Figure A7 Photosimulation PS#82 at Corner of Black Oak Road and Harvey Hill Road –Original Image HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page A-10 Figure A8 Photosimulation PS#82 at Corner of Black Oak Road and Harvey Hill Road – Simulation Turbine 7B HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page A-11 Figure A9 Photosimulation PS#82 at Corner of Black Oak Road and Harvey Hill Road – Simulation Turbine 7B and 7C HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page A-12 Figure A10 Photosimulation PS#82 at Corner of Black Oak Road and Harvey Hill Road – Simulation Turbine 7C HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page A-13 Figure A11 Photosimulation PS#83 at Harvey Hill Road Viewer Location 1– Original Image HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page A-14 Figure A12 Photosimulation PS#83 at Harvey Hill Road Viewer Location 1– Simulation 7B HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page A-15 Figure A13 Photosimulation PS#83 at Harvey Hill Road Viewer Location 1– Simulation 7C HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page A-16 Figure A14 Photosimulation PS#83 at Harvey Hill Road Viewer Location 2– Original Image HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page A-17 Figure A15 Photosimulation PS#83 at Harvey Hill Road Viewer Location 2– Simulation Turbine 7B HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page A-18 Figure A16 Photosimulation PS#83 at Harvey Hill Road Viewer Location 2– Simulation Turbine 7B & 7C HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page A-19 Figure A17 Photosimulation PS#83 at Harvey Hill Road Viewer Location 2– Simulation Turbine 7C HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page A-20 Figure A18 Photosimulation PS#84 at Black Oak Road Meteorological Tower– Original Image HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page A-21 Figure A19 Photosimulation PS#84 at Black Oak Road Meteorological Tower– Simulation HARRIS MILLER MILLER &HANSON INC. Revised Visual Impact Assessment for Black Oak Wind Farm Project February 23, 2016 Page B-22 APPENDIX B Guyed Lattice Tower Example Specifications The Industry Standard