HomeMy WebLinkAboutMay_12,_2010_Regular_Meeting[1].pdfTown of Enfield
Regular Town Board Meeting Minutes
Enfield Community Building
Wednesday, May 12, 2010
6:00.m.
Present: Deputy Town Supervisor Jean Owens, Town Councilperson Chris Hern, Town Councilperson
Debbie Teeter, Supervisor Roy Barriere arrived late, Town Highway Superintendent Barry Rollins, Town
Clerk Alice Linton
Excused: Town Councilperson Stephanie Gaynor
Presentation: Deputy Town Supervisor Owens introduced Steve Messmer, Project Manager with Delta
Engineers at 6:20 p.m. He spoke about the issue of road preservation that towns have faced for large scale
development, wind farms, and natural gas drilling. He stressed his program is not pro or con the drilling
industry – this is purely a technical issue about the whole responsibility to protect public assets. There are
all opinions on the gas drilling issue, but Delta Engineers is looking at the fact that public roads will be
affected by gas drilling activities and we will pay up front or at the end, but either way local roads will be
affected and it will be a big issue.
Steve spoke about his program that started in Sullivan County to investigate the potential impacts of gas
drilling, and local roads was one of the major impacts, so Sullivan County commissioned a study to try to
identify what municipalities can do to protect local roads. Sullivan County is encouraging the
proliferation of this program because they feel the more towns that come together using the same
methodology, the greater chances New York has of having a unified defensible approach protecting local
roads.
The firm has a double professional basis – legal and engineering. The firm has done Road Use
Agreements in conjunction with wind farm activity in the past. A Road Use Agreement is the core
document of how we interact with a large scale construction activity that is going to impact roads. A Road
Use Agreement needs engineering and local law to back up the agreement.
Road Use Agreements should be written in the best interest of the town or municipality, not in the best
interest of the user that you’re trying to regulate. There are two approaches to regulating heavy traffic –
reactive (recover after the damage) and proactive (upfront protection for cost of repairs should they
occur).
If the Town of Enfield were to hire Delta Engineers, there would be three phases to their work. Phase one
would be to establish a road inventory, condition inventory and cost inventory database to allow for fair
determination of damage assessments. Phase two would be to provide a template Road Use Agreement
Law, permit applications and training of town personnel to implement the permit process through the
Delta Automated Road Use Agreement processing website. Phase 3 would involve implementing the
permit process.
The standard cost to set the system up is a one time lump sum of $8,500.00. The town would also have to
have a permit manager who would work closely with Delta Engineers.
Deputy Town Supervisor Owens opened the meeting at 6:55 p.m. by leading the assemblage in the Pledge
of Allegiance to the Flag.
Enfield Town Board Meeting, May 12, 2010
2
Privilege of the Floor:
Risa Sokolsky spoke in support of Assembly Bill A.10633 – Amending State Environmental
Conservation Law to Allow Local Governments to Enact or Enforce Certain Laws and Ordinances.
Approval of Minutes:
Councilperson Teeter moved, with a second by Councilperson Hern, to approve the minutes of the April
14, 2010 regular town board meeting and the minutes of the April 26, 2010 special town board meeting.
Vote: Councilperson Hern aye, Deputy Town Supervisor Owens aye, Councilperson Teeter aye.
Correspondence:
Letter from Enfield Volunteer Fire Company president Dennis Hubbell to Enfield Town Supervisor Roy
Barriere regarding blacktop resurfacing in and around the fire station within the next few months at a cost
of approximately $4,000. This is not a request for additional funds, but rather for information only. The
work will be done in two phases to allow for emergency exits and sufficient curing time.
Audit Claims: Budget Amendment No. 8-2010
WHEREAS, the Town Board of the Town of Enfield voted to purchase a backhoe at the April 26, 2010
Special Board meeting, NOW THEREFORE BE IT
RESOLVED, that the Highway Fund Estimated Revenues Account DA510, titled “Estimated Revenues”,
be increased by $63,900.00; Highway Fund Estimated Appropriations Account DA910, titled “Estimated
Appropriations”, be increased by $63,900.00; the Equipment Reserve balance be decreased by
$63,900.00; Highway Fund Account DA9950.9 titled “Interfund Transfer Equipment Reserve” be
decreased by $76.00 and Highway Fund Account DA5130.2, titled “Equipment”, be increased by
$63,976.00.
Deputy Town Supervisor Owens moved, with a second by Councilperson Teeter to approve Budget
Amendment No. 8-2010.
Vote: Councilperson Hern aye, Councilperson Owens aye, Councilperson Teeter aye.
Councilperson Teeter noted that there are 2 bills to be charged to Celebrations because we are receiving
funds from the County Tourism Fund for a couple of beautification projects in the town.
Budget Amendment No. 9-2010
WHEREAS, the Town of Enfield will be reimbursed by Tompkins County Tourism funds for community
beautification, NOW THEREFORE BE IT
RESOLVED that General Fund account A1990.4 titled “Contingency” be reduced by $400 and General
Fund Account A7550.4 titled “Celebrations” be increased by $400.00.
Deputy Town Supervisor Owens moved, with a second by Councilperson Hern to approve Budget
Amendment No. 9-2010.
Vote: Councilperson Hern aye, Councilperson Owens aye, Councilperson Teeter aye.
Enfield Town Board Meeting, May 12, 2010
3
Councilperson Hern moved, with a second from Councilperson Teeter, that the Town Board authorize the
supervisor to pay General Fund Vouchers #123-148 dated May 12, 2010 in the amount of $12,309.99 and
Highway Fund Vouchers #79-92 dated May 12, 2010 in the amount of $80,352.77.
Vote: Councilperson Hern aye, Deputy Town Supervisor Owens aye, Councilperson Teeter aye.
Committee Reports:
Code Enforcement: Alan Teeter reported that for the month of April 9 building permits were issued,
which brings the total for the year to 23 including 4 new homes; 1 certificate of occupancy was issued; 2
certificates of compliance were issued; 9 building inspections were done; 3 progress checks were
completed; 7 meetings with owners/builders were held; 2 complaints were received which were both valid
and 1 was resolved; 2 letters of compliance were sent; 1 fire and safety inspection was done and 2 home
inspections were completed. Both Alan and Carl Staley have received the required 24 hours of in-service
training. There will be new building codes coming out this September and the code enforcement officers
will need to attend mandatory training, but there will be no charge.
Planning Board: Jim McConkey reported there was no meeting this month. The committee hopes to
complete a draft of the site plan review law so it can be presented to the Town Board.
Health Insurance Consortium: No report
Enfield Community Council: No report
Enfield Volunteer Fire Company: Larry Stilwell reported for April there were 22 calls, 15 emergency
medical service calls, 1 CO detector call, 1 motor vehicle accident, 1 vehicle fire, 1 smoke condition with
no fire found, 2 mutual aids to Newfield, a mutual aid to Odessa and also covering the Mecklenburg
station. The old fire truck is now being advertised in Pennsylvania to see if a buyer can be found for it.
New members are welcome. The EVFC thanked the highway department for their assistance over the
weekend for use of their road barricades.
Facilities Manager: Councilperson Hern reported there are high levels of radon gas in the vault at Town
Hall. It is usually recommended that a specialist be hired to evaluate the facility and come up with a
mitigation plan. Chris asked the Board to consider hiring a specialist to evaluate the situation. He was
asked to bring more information back to the Board.
Supervisor Barriere joined the meeting at this time (7:15 p.m.)
Communication Access Committee:
Councilperson Hern reported the committee’s first meeting was held Tuesday, April 27. The committee
decided to meet the first Tuesday of each month. Chris was chosen to chair the committee. He has been in
communication with Chuck Bartosch of Clarity Connect regarding his fiber/wireless combination project
that he’s attempting to get grant money for. There is a questionnaire that will be in the community
newsletter which can be submitted to Chris and he will forward the results on to Clarity Connect.
Facilities Development:
Councilperson Owens reported information continues to be gathered for the bond attorney. Resource
Associates has been asked to finish the driveway permit application so it will be in place for the highway
superintendent to begin that project.
Enfield Town Board Meeting, May 12, 2010
4
TC Council of Governments: Supervisor Barriere reported that a resolution was passed in support of
convening a county wide task force to assist the municipalities in preparing for the future drilling
activities. No updates on the county health consortium.
County Legislator’s Report:
The County Legislature is looking to adopt a budget with an approximate 5% increase in county taxes.
They are looking at the county solid waste contract and are still pursing broadband.
Old Business:
Road construction permits – Councilperson Teeter is working on road permit forms with Highway
Superintendent Rollins.
Mass Gathering permits – Councilperson Teeter will bring a fee schedule to the next meeting.
Vehicle/equipment inventory and replacement plan – Supervisor Barriere will be going over the list of
equipment we currently have, the replacement value, and the expected replacement date with Highway
Superintendent Rollins.
Property Tax vs. Sales Tax information – Councilperson Owens has gathered some numbers for parcels
which are tax exempt - most are state owned. After adding up the numbers she found about $2,700,000 in
tax exempt state owned tax parcels. The amount we would be reimbursed, if we were on property tax
levy, would be $7 per thousand. It doesn’t matter what our tax rate is, that is what the state reimburses per
thousand. Relying on sales tax, in this economic climate, is a bit iffy. With property taxes, you have an
understanding of what the taxes will be. Councilperson Owens suggested that, if the Board decides to go
back to receiving property taxes as opposed to receiving sales tax from the county, the decision needs to
be made in the next month or so – in advance of the budget process. Also if the Board makes this
decision, they will need to inform residents so they understand why we would be accepting property tax
revenues as opposed to sales tax revenues. Supervisor Barriere asked Councilperson Owens to put this
information together using actual numbers – for example what 2010’s numbers would have been using
this process. Councilperson Teeter asked for further clarification. Councilperson Owens explained that if
we went from sales tax to property tax revenue, the county would not get property taxes from Enfield and
would not give us sales tax. This would have worked out to be approximately $18,000 more revenue for
Enfield in 2010. Also, we would receive property taxes early in the year and have the opportunity to
realize interest on these funds, whereas sales tax revenue comes in throughout the year.
Time Warner Cable Update – Supervisor Barriere stated he redid the resolution and passed it on to Time
Warner Cable and they did not accept it. They wanted to change some things and have not counter-offered
as of now.
Wind Farm Update – The thirty day period in which interested and involved parties can respond ends
May 17. After that time, Frank Pavia will put together the Notice of Positive Declaration and Resolution
Issuing the Declaration. We’ll have that for the June town board meeting and Parts 2 and 3 of the EAF
will need to be completed as well.
Councilperson Teeter asked if Black Oak Road is a town road. John Rancich, wind farm developer,
responded Black Oak is a county road up until it hits Connecticut Hill Road where it changes to a town
road. It is a town road for about ¾ of a mile. It was suggested to Tompkins County that they not redo
Black Oak Road until the heavy traffic is done going up and down the road and John Rancich has stated
Enfield Town Board Meeting, May 12, 2010
5
his intent to work with the Town of Enfield to compensate for any damage to the town road during wind
farm development.
Highway Superintendent’s Report:
Buddy Rollins reported he continues to work on the Vehicle/Machinery Inventory Report. The completed
report would be very useful to have at budget time. The new backhoe was delivered and is now in service.
The crew will be on Rothermich Road replacing pipes. Buddy asked the board to make sure all permits
are in place for him to begin road work at the site of the new highway facility. North Applegate Road will
be closed next week between Hayts and Iradell Road for replacement of a cross-over pipe. Clean-up week
has been a little slow – 4 dumpsters have been filled so far.
New Business:
CHIPS Funds - Supervisor Barriere reported that at this point CHIPS funds are not in the governor’s
budget. Until the final budget is passed, we shouldn’t spend anything that was proposed for CHIPS.
Dog Control/Enumerator – Town Clerk Alice Linton reported the last enumeration done in Enfield was in
2004. Currently we have approximately 700 dogs licensed, but feel there are probably over 300
unlicensed dogs. Alice recommended paying an enumerator $2 for each dog found (licensed or
unlicensed) and 50 cents per mile.
Discussion: During the last enumeration, 700 miles were traveled. That would probably remain about the
same, especially if we hire someone who lives in Enfield. If the enumerator found 300 unlicensed dogs
and they are fined $5 each that would go a long way to offset the cost to the town for the enumeration.
Councilperson Teeter moved to authorize the supervisor to enter an agreement with Regina Leonard to
conduct a dog enumeration and pay her at the rate of $2 per dog found (licensed or unlicensed) plus $.50
per mile traveled within the Town of Enfield. Motion seconded by councilperson Owens.
Discussion: The enumerator should knock on all doors in the town. In 2006 there were over 300
unlicensed dogs found. She found 1,088 dogs total. This enumerator would be a part-time, temporary
employee of the town.
Vote: Councilperson Hern aye, Councilperson Owens aye, Councilperson Teeter aye, Supervisor Barriere,
aye.
Announcements:
The county has notified Supervisor Barriere that a grant submitted by Sue Thompson, town historian, for
the 51st anniversary of Enfield School was approved for $500.00.
Adjournment: Councilperson Owens moved with a second by Councilperson Teeter to adjourn at 8:20
p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Alice M. Linton
Enfield Town Clerk