HomeMy WebLinkAboutCB 2026-09-29 finalCB 2026-09-29
Final
1
CONSERVATION BOARD
September 29, 2026
Hybrid
Present: Anne Clark (co-chair), Jeanne Grace (co-chair)*, Steve Bissen*, Gian Dodici, ,
Nancy Munkenbeck, Craig Schutt
Absent: Kate McKee, Andrew Miller, Tim Woods, Naomi Cator-Szymanski (alternate)
Guest: Diane Karasevicz
Liaisons: Spring Buck (Town Board)*
“*” denotes attendance via Zoom
The meeting was called to order at 7:04 p.m. and attendance was taken
Review and Acceptance of Minutes
C Schutt offered the following resolution and asked for its adoption:
RESOLVED, that the Conservation Board of the Town of Dryden hereby accepts the
meeting minutes of July 28, 2026, as written.
2nd G Dodici
Roll Call Vote A Clark Yes
J Grace Yes
S Bissen Yes
G Dodici Yes
N Munkenbeck Abstain
C Schutt Yes
Reports: Agriculture Committee
Nothing to report for this month as they did not meet.
Reports: Climate Action Committee
A Clark reported that the Repair Café was held Saturday at the Dryden Center for
Community and felt it was successful. She even mentioned there was a knife-sharpening
station.
The committee is giving feedback on an update to the town’s climate action
preparedness document.
She will be collecting resources on emergency shelters and community resilience. She
will begin at the end of October.
Environmental Management Council
S Bissen update that the EMC met on September 10 and heard from Jonathan Zisk of
the Town of Danby on efforts to make conservation easements easier to establish. S Bissen will
share Danby’s website through the meeting chat and suggested Dryden consider a similar
streamlined process. https://danby.ny.gov/conservation-easements/
CB 2026-09-29
Draft
2
Reports: Town Board
S Buck shared that the Town held a joint meeting with the villages of Dryden and
Freeville to advance to a fire district, and fire chiefs sounded positive. Another joint meeting is
set for this Thursday. The Town Board’s next several Thursday sessions, including the third
Thursday of October, will focus on 2027 budgets.
Reports: Zoning Advisory Group
N Munkenbeck reported that the committee is still working on the language for
definitions. No one present attended the latest ZAG meeting, which was reported secondhand
to have covered affordable housing. She attended a public meeting at Danby on the start of the
agricultural zoning rewrite. Discussion highlighted conflicts between farm-based event venues
(for example, a cider farm hosting weddings with late-night music) and neighbors. Caroline is
among the closest in New York without municipal zoning but has voted to adopt it.
Members noted that Dryden's own zoning definitions are outdated and contradictory,
and that fixing them, with precise definitions, is a main focus of the zoning improvement effort.
An outdated requirement on how manufactured homes must be sited was cited as likely to be
dropped.
Ed Hill Subdivision Updates
Discussion centered on the future of the Trillium Woods parcel, which the developer of
Trillium Woods Farm is expected to donate to the Town of Dryden. Although no formal proposal
or decision has been made, members agreed that the Conservation Board should prepare to
participate in decisions about the parcel’s assessment, use, and management.
Members reached consensus that the Board should be proactive. The chair will email
the Planning Board and Town Board this week, stating that the Conservation Board expects to
be consulted and is ready to assist with site assessment and development of a wri tten
management plan.
Committee members also expressed concerns about portions of the developer’s
environmental assessment but did not adopt a formal response.
The wooded parcel is at the corner of Fall Creek Road and Ed Hill Road. The developer
is expected to donate most of it to the Town, while the adjoining wetland is expected to be
donated to the Wetland Trust. S Buck confirmed that no donation has yet been formally
proposed or approved.
The property has been selectively logged twice in approximately 30 years, most recently
within the past several years. It contains a two-track path, muddy areas, and several vernal
ponds. Trillium is abundant, and at least two less-common flowering species, including violet,
may be present. Because the site has not been surveyed, the locations and extent of any rare
plant populations remain uncertain.
Members envisioned a small, low-impact public preserve with an educational focus. The
nearby high school and its sustainability club could provide volunteers and support learning
opportunities.
Space for approximately three vehicles may be available at the northwest corner along
the road, where Norway spruce and European larch grow. Creating parking may require
CB 2026-09-29
Draft
3
removing some conifers. A deep roadside ditch and an existing crossing would also need
attention; one member offered a contact who could install a culvert.
Trails should avoid isolated rare plant populations. Jeanne Grace suggested that a
boardwalk could keep visitors on a defined route and that deer fencing could protect the
trilliums, while acknowledging the potential cost.
Trails should avoid isolated rare plant populations. J Grace suggested that a boardwalk
could keep visitors on a defined route and that deer fencing could protect the trilliums, while
acknowledging the potential cost.
Members suggested considering modest improvements to the vernal ponds, where past
logging left debris in unsuitable locations.
Members favored preparing a written management plan, although they agreed that
development could wait a year or two. The plan should address trail layout and maintenance,
restoration goals, public access, parking, and the use of hand tools rather than heavy
machinery. Several members and acquaintances have relevant hand-tool experience. Finger
Lakes Land Trust preserve management plan was suggested as a model. J Grace also
encouraged the Board to consider partnerships with organizations that manage distinctive
natural areas and have fundraising capacity, including the Finger Lakes Land Trust and
Cornell Botanic Gardens. Members considered The Nature Conservancy unlikely to pursue a
site of this size.
As an initial step, members suggested inviting Cornell Botanic Gardens botanists, and
possibly plant pathology or mycology specialists, to conduct a brief survey or "mini BioBlitz" to
identify rare species and better understand the site's ecological value.
The chair circulated the Full Environmental Assessment Form submitted for the
Trillium Woods Farm development, saying several statements in it seemed inaccurate or
unsupported. Members shared similar concerns and have written comments in their own
copies. Members acknowledged that such reviews are often treated as a checkbox process; no
formal response was adopted, and no one proposed a specific action beyond the individual
comments already made.
Concerns Raised
Rare plants. The form states there are no endangered plants, but globeflowers, a New York
State-listed plant, may be in the adjoining wetlands. It has not been confirmed or ruled out.
The flowering window was missing, flowers are needed to identify it, and beaver-driven
water level changes may be affecting the area.
Traffic. The form claims no increase in traffic, yet the road would go from two or three
driveways to roughly eleven more, each with multiple cars.
Wetlands and runoff. Members consider it hard to argue the project will not affect nearby
wetlands through added runoff, especially given the proposed house placement. Water use
estimates were questioned.
Impervious surface. Roof area alone appears to exceed the stated 1.8-acre increase.
Mowed lawn also infiltrate water poorly compared with native grasses.
Members acknowledged that such reviews are often treated as a checkbox process, and
no one proposed a specific action beyond the individual comments already made. Discussion
CB 2026-09-29
Draft
4
centered on the future of the Trillium Woods parcel, which the developer of Trillium Woods
Farm is expected to donate to the Town of Dryden. The wooded parcel is at the corner of Fall
Creek Road and Ed Hill Road. The developer is expected to donate most of it to the Town, while
the adjoining wetland is expected to be donated to the Wetland Trust. S Buck confirmed that
no donation has yet been formally proposed or approved. Members agreed that the
Conservation Board should prepare to participate in decisions about the parcel's assessment,
use, and management, and reached consensus that the Board should be proactive. The chair
will email the Planning Board and Town Board this week, stating that the Board expects to be
consulted and is ready to assist with site assessment and development of a written
management plan.
The property has been selectively logged twice in approximately 30 years, most recently
within the past several years. It contains a two-track path, muddy areas, and several vernal
ponds. Trillium is abundant, and at least two less-common flowering species, including violet,
may be present. Because the site has not been surveyed, the locations and extent of any rare
plant populations remain uncertain.
Several members envisioned a small, low-impact public preserve with an educational
focus. The nearby high school and its sustainability club could provide volunteers and learning
opportunities, such as monitoring the decay of downed trees.
Space for approximately three vehicles may be available at the northwest corner along
the road, where Norway spruce and European larch grow. Creating parking may require
removing some conifers. A deep roadside ditch and an existing crossing would also need
attention; one member offered a contact who could install a culvert.
Reports: Rail Trail Task Force
The bridge over 13 is coming along and members would like to plant wildflowers
and other native plants. G Dodici has offered to buy wildflower seeds for this location.
Old Business: Ditching Updates
A recurring topic: members described ditches being deepened after the state required
larger culverts and drainage pipes, which some believe creates problems where none existed.
Spring Buck noted the state has pushed larger culverts because of expected increases in
rainfall and recalled a state presentation to the EMC on the subject. Members stressed that
culvert size should depend on location in the watershed and proper hydrology rather than
simply “bigger is better,” and that regulations differ for stream culverts, road culverts and
driveway culverts. The chair will check the actual state rules because past claims about
regulations have sometimes proved inaccurate.
Next Steps
• Notify the Planning Board and Town Board that the Conservation Board expects to
participate in the parcel’s assessment and management planning.
• Obtain a sample Finger Lakes Land Trust preserve management plan (a member will
bring one to the next meeting).
• Arrange a walkthrough with the current landowners, who are open to visit.
• Consider a spring visit to observe vernal pond activity and a summer follow-up to
determine whether the entrance remains dry.
CB 2026-09-29
Draft
5
There being no further business, on motion made by A Clark, seconded by C Schutt,
the meeting was adjourned at 8:26 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Allison Kjellander-Cantu
Deputy Town Clerk