Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutTB 2026-08-20 attTB 8-20-26 Page 1 of 13 TOWN OF DRYDEN TOWN BOARD MEETING August 20, 2026 Zoom Hybrid Present: Supervisor Jason Leifer, Cl Daniel Lamb, Cl Leonardo Vargas- Mendez, Cl Christina Dravis, Cl Spring Buck Elected Officials: *Rick Young, Highway/DPW Superintendent Dan Wakeman, Tompkins County Legislator, District No. 10 Other Officials: Loren Sparling, Town Clerk (appointed) Other Town Staff: *Cassie Byrnes, Secretary to the Supervisor *denotes attendance via Zoom Supv Leifer opened the meeting at 6:15 p.m. Board members and audience recited the pledge of allegiance. TOWN CLERK RESOLUTION #170 (2026) – APPROVE MINUTES Supv Leifer offered the following resolution and asked for its adoption: RESOLVED, that this Town Board hereby approves the meeting minutes of July 9 and July 16, 2026. 2nd Cl Lamb Roll Call Vote Cl Vargas-Mendez Yes Cl Buck Yes Cl Dravis Yes Cl Lamb Yes Supv Leifer Yes PUBLIC HEARING LOCAL LAW REPEALING AND REPLACING ARTICLE IX OF CHAPTER 240 OF THE TOWN CODE REGARDING CONSERVATION SUBDIVISIONS AND ADDRESSING RELATED MATTERS Supv Leifer opened the public hearing at 6:17 p.m. He explained that consultant Nan Stolzenburg gave a presentation to the Board last week about the proposed changes to the conservation subdivision law. This presentation has been made available on the Town website for public review. Some potential amendments have already been raised. Tonight, the Board will take further comments. The public hearing will not be closed and will be continued to next month. Marie McRae (a Climate Action Committee and Zoning Advisory Group [ZAG] member, but here speaking as an individual) described feeling that, under the existing law, the Town had been unable to protect land, natural beauty, or habitat for future residents. She said that N Stolzenburg’s new four-step process – starting from site analysis rather than lot-line drawing, considering the character of the land at the outset – gave her hope that meaningful conservation outcomes were achievable, while acknowledging the proposal remains complex. TB 8-20-26 Page 2 of 13 Martha Robertson (an Ellis Hollow resident, Affordable and Workforce Housing Committee [AWHC] member, and former ZAG member) praised N Stolzenburg’s presentation as highly effective (“a picture is worth a thousand words”) and encouraged residents to view it on the Town’s YouTube channel. On substance, she confirmed the AWHC’s request that the Rural Residential (RR) district be removed from those zones mandating the conservation subdivision process and remain voluntary, given uncertainty about how the new process will play out in practice and its potential effect on housing supply. The Town needs more housing. She also flagged a proposal discussed last week to require conservation subdivisions on RR land that overlaps with State Agricultural Districts and asked the Board to first map exactly where that overlap occurs before adopting such a requirement. Cl Lamb noted that New York State-designated agricultural districts can change periodically, so it might be difficult for the Town to establish this in the law. (When she offered comment later in the public hearing, Nancy Munkenbeck added that the State-designated agricultural districts get reviewed every eight years, but, every March, a resident can ask the State to be added or removed from the list of districts. She also noted that there is high-quality farmland in areas not labeled as State- designated agricultural districts [e.g., on Ringwood Rd] and not-so-good farmland that is.) M Robertson reported that the Town’s new Sewer and Water Task Force – which she thanked the Board for approving – held its first meeting and will hold its second next Monday, with a mandate to identify areas well-suited for denser housing that overlap with existing or planned infrastructure. She hopes that the new conservation subdivision law does not inadvertently create roadblocks by requiring conservation subdivisions in locations that might not be optimal for them. Craig Anderson submitted a handout (see attached) to Board members and summarized key points from it. He recommended requiring maximum lot sizes in conservation subdivisions and making small lot development mandatory (e.g., roughly 10 building lots on a 20-acre parcel, with roughly half the total acreage retained as conservation land), rather than continuing the historical pattern of large lots (citing the Mill Creek/Bluebird/Ed Hill Road example of, all told, 71 lots spread across roughly 1,200 acres). He argued the Town already has a multi-year supply of large lot inventory and that smaller mandatory maximums (½- to ¾- acre) would better serve residents priced out of the current housing market. He advised revising the minor subdivision law (which currently allows subdivision on two-acre lots with no open space requirement and no cap other than a numeric lot count exemption) to instead serve buyers who want larger, more private lots (e.g., raising the minimum to 4-5 acres). At the same time, he suggested tightening the number of lots that qualify as a minor subdivision, so it is not used to bypass conservation requirements. C Anderson recommended pairing small lot clusters with a shared/community well or shared septic system. He preferred shared wells only, reasoning that septic fields consume more land and are harder to maintain (citing ongoing issues at Hanshaw Village and Beaconview), while shared wells can coexist with individual septic systems on half-acre lots. He argued that the current and proposed laws do not do enough to prevent farmland loss, since a developer meeting the open space requirement can then develop on land that includes prime farmland (if that is what is available). The Town should want to protect all prime farmland. He recommended prioritizing purchase of development rights (PDR) and conservation easement mechanisms (citing partners such as the Finger Lakes Land Trust, National Land Trust, and USDA/NRCS “buy-protect-sell” programs) as a first option ahead of subdivision-based set-asides. TB 8-20-26 Page 3 of 13 In discussion with Board members, C Anderson clarified that his intent to “give people what they want” was to serve households currently priced out of the housing market (i.e., that reducing minimum lot sizes is intended as an affordability measure, not a developer accommodation) and that he supports strong farmland protection (including mandatory conservation subdivisions in RR parcels within State Agricultural Districts), provided landowners are compensated (e.g., through PDR programs). Cl Lamb worried that that compensation might create another layer of complication to get housing built. Regarding striking a balance in the proposed conservation subdivision law, C Anderson suggested that the Town distinguish between conservation subdivisions in the RA zoning district and the CV zoning district and set separate (but similar) rules for them. Nancy Munkenbeck raised several technical drafting points. She recommended against limiting the excluded wetlands definition to only DEC-mapped wetlands, noting that the Town Planner confirmed the County’s wetland overlay is more extensive than the DEC’s, and suggested that the County’s overlay should also be considered. In addition, she suggested adding streams and stream buffers to the list of unbuildable/excluded lands. She questioned whether steep slopes and rocky outcrops should automatically be excluded as unbuildable, noting both can be built on (citing hillside construction in Switzerland and the heating/cooling advantages of slope-built homes). She suggested that if the Planning Department does not want to permit such construction, it should simply be prohibited rather than folded into the “preserved” land calculation. Such landforms would automatically be preserved if a developer cannot build on them. N Munkenbeck further recommended a sequenced approach: first designate unbuildable land (streams, floodplains, wetlands, critical/rare habitat), then apply a target of preserving at least 50% of prime agricultural land, using the State’s tiered farmland classifications (prime farmland, prime farmland if drained, and farmland of statewide importance). She noted the Town currently has no designated Critical Environmental Areas (CEAs), so that protection category is unlikely to apply in the near term. (An earlier attempt to designate five CEAs was rescinded after public opposition.) N Munkenbeck cautioned that Nan Stolzenburg’s example subdivision design eliminated any large, monitorable block of open space for pastureland. All that pastureland was in the backyards of people’s houses. If land is going to be conserved, the Town must be able to monitor the conservation on that land in some reasonable way. She argued that conservation subdivisions should prioritize protecting usable habitat and farmable soil over residents’ scenic view of greenery, which she considered a weaker rationale. It is hard to place any structure in this town where one cannot see greenery. She thanked the Board for holding the public hearing and hoped that people would have the chance to discuss these issues more, as it seems that discussion is what needs to happen. Chuck Geisler (an AWHC and ZAG member) presented prepared slides framing three questions: (1) whether the law is potentially exclusionary; (2) whether it is truly density neutral, as ZAG discussions have assumed; and (3) how it could be improved from a housing standpoint. On exclusion, he argued that removing roughly half of a very large land area (74% of the Town, per the acreage breakdown) from the developable pool will tend to raise, not lower, housing prices, disproportionately affecting low- and moderate-income residents. He also noted TB 8-20-26 Page 4 of 13 that without sewer and water infrastructure, the remaining 50% available for housing will still require relatively large lots, limiting affordability gains for the foreseeable future. He pointed out that homeowners in the housing portion of a cluster development typically remain financially responsible for maintaining the adjoining open space parcel (via a homeowners’ association or similar), an added cost that falls hardest on lower-income buyers. On density neutrality, he disputed the premise that the proposal is density neutral, citing the 14-year track record of large lots (17-acres on average) as evidence that, absent a legally mandated smaller minimum parcel size, density will not increase. He also noted that many developers currently use the minor subdivision process (below the major subdivision threshold) specifically to avoid open space and conservation requirements altogether, and, citing the Dryden2045 update to the Comprehensive Plan, stated that more than half of the Town’s recent development has occurred through this back door, undermining the effectiveness of the new conservation subdivision requirements unless minor subdivisions are also addressed. He offered the following recommendations: ∙ Reduce maximum parcel sizes ∙ Revisit the 50/50 open space to housing split, suggesting ratios such as 60% housing/40% conservation (or 70/30) could be considered rather than treating 50/50 as fixed ∙ Allow more flexibility for voluntary conservation mechanisms such as deed restrictions as alternatives to mandatory set-asides ∙ Encourage, not merely permit, conservation subdivision development in already- serviced nodal areas through incentives ∙ Consider eliminating the minor subdivision exemption entirely so developers cannot bypass conservation requirements ∙ Reward developers who provide higher density housing, unit-type diversity, expedited permitting, or affordable housing set-asides, citing County programs that set aside roughly 20% of units for affordable housing as a model He ended by saying that the Town is doing a good job but could do more to improve this. Anne Clark (Conservation Board co-chair, but here speaking as an individual) framed the overall effort as a “wicked problem” requiring trade-offs among housing, ecological, conservation, natural resource, agricultural, and scenic tourism goals. She agreed that unbuildable land (including non-DEC [e.g., federal] wetlands) should be excluded from the 50% calculation. She also advocated for houses being placed back from the road, which would allow road travelers to see viewsheds and not houses. She argued that habitat and farmland value increase exponentially with the size and contiguity of a preserved block – recommending the Town favor one large contiguous set-aside over several small, scattered parcels, even if that means the set-aside percentage dips somewhat (e.g., 40% contiguous rather than 50% fragmented). She also contended that clustering housing into walkable, service-adjacent nodes/neighborhoods is generally more affordable, more socially desirable, and cheaper for the Town to serve (utilities, bus routes) than dispersed large-lot development. She recommended using incentives rather than rigid mandates to steer developers toward that outcome. Evan Carpenter declined to be repetitive of prior speakers, insisting instead that the law should be split into two separate frameworks for agricultural land versus conservation land, since the goals differ. He recommended that more than 50% of a farm subdivision remain in active farming to preserve large, contiguous, farmable fields. He called for consistent TB 8-20-26 Page 5 of 13 terminology across the current and draft law (citing usage of the terms farmland, ag land, pastureland, and fertile/fallow/idle land) and that it be aligned with State Agriculture and Markets definitions. He asked whether the Town would like to have open land or green land; farmers will keep the open fields open, green, worked, and enjoyable for viewing, more so than private landowners. He asked that septic fields not be sited on farmland, since tillage equipment and septic infrastructure are incompatible. He also inquired whether the Town’s existing Agriculture and Farmland Protection Plan had been consulted in drafting the law, and whether the proposal had been submitted for the required County Section 239 review. Although Board members suspected these to be true, they will seek confirmation from Ray Burger, Director of Planning. Craig Schutt raised concern that neither the Town’s Agriculture and Farmland Protection Plan nor its Natural Resources Conservation Plan appears to have been consulted or referenced during the ZAG drafting process, noting that an Agriculture Advisory Committee member serving on the ZAG was reportedly unaware of the agricultural plan. He then read several goals from the land use policies section of the Town’s adopted Agriculture and Farmland Protection Plan, including granting agriculture primacy in agricultural zones; directing residential development away from productive farmland to minimize fragmentation and farm/non-farm conflicts; and protecting farmers from incompatible non-agricultural uses that may render farming impractical. He argued the current draft does not fully reflect those previously adopted Town policies and asked that the Board reconcile the new law with these existing documents before adoption. Tony Salerno (Planning Board chair) responded to these comments on behalf of the Planning Board. He clarified that many of the issues raised (e.g., PDR programs and plans that protect land from being subdivided) fall outside the scope of the conservation subdivision law itself, which only governs how a major subdivision must be laid out once a landowner chooses to subdivide. It does not restrict whether land can be subdivided at all but regulates them so that they are in accord with the priorities outlined in the Comprehensive Plan. He noted N Stolzenburg’s overall recommendations did incorporate the Town’s existing plans and zoning during her audit process, even though the conservation subdivision law itself addresses only one piece of that larger picture. He confirmed that a Planning Board member had already produced a map overlaying the State Agricultural Districts with the RR zone, showing roughly 23% overlap, and offered to circulate it. T Salerno noted the Planning Board retains discretion, on a project-by-project basis, to prioritize which resources (agricultural land, steep slopes, habitat, etc.) take precedence when they conflict. He explained the deliberate absence of fixed minimum or maximum lot sizes in the draft. Appropriate lot size depends heavily on use. For farming, large lots are needed. For clustered housing, small lots are needed; how small these lots are depends on the availability of shared water/sewer or municipal service. A single fixed number would work poorly across these differing parcels and infrastructure conditions, and the choice was made not to put minimum and maximum lot sizes in the proposed law. He indicated that concepts developed for the conservation subdivision law are expected to be extended in future zoning phases to other development types, including Planned Unit Developments (PUDs), manufactured home parks, and multifamily housing. In response to a comment from Cl Buck, T Salerno confirmed that minor subdivisions have not yet been addressed and remain a topic for a future phase of the broader zoning rewrite, and acknowledged the phased, section-by-section approach makes it difficult for the public to see how individual pieces fit together. TB 8-20-26 Page 6 of 13 C Anderson championed the idea of phasing in the zoning rewrite as a single package rather than piecemeal amendments to reduce public confusion, a suggestion Cl Lamb indicated would add roughly a year of delay that the Town could not accommodate, given pending development applications (and more on the way). N Munkenbeck renewed a longstanding suggestion, previously raised without success, that the Town establish a dedicated Conservation Fund, akin to the existing Recreation Fund, to accept resident donations for future land purchases when they become available. If such a fund is created, the money will come in for these conservation ventures. The Board thanked all speakers, kept the public hearing open at 7:43 p.m., and indicated the discussion would continue at next month’s meeting. HIGHWAY DEPARTMENT Resolution – Purchase New 4066R Compact Utility Tractor, Not to Exceed $70,000 R Young requested the purchase of a John Deere 4066R compact utility tractor (with bucket and plow attachment) for the Highway Department, not to exceed $70,000, funded from budget code A1620.202 and procured via State OGS contract. The old tractor’s sander attachment will be transferred to the new unit. RESOLUTION #171 (2026) – PURCHASE NEW 4066R COMPACT UTILITY TRACTOR Supv Leifer offered the following resolution and asked for its adoption: RESOLVED, that this Town Board hereby authorizes the purchase of a new John Deere 4066R compact utility tractor using funds from budget code A1620.202, at an amount not to exceed $70,000 per Sourcewell contract. 2nd Cl Lamb Roll Call Vote Cl Vargas-Mendez Yes Cl Buck Yes Cl Dravis Yes Cl Lamb Yes Supv Leifer Yes Discussion – Adding Stop Sign at Intersection of Lake Road and W Lake Road Supv Leifer discussed a resident request to convert an intersection near West Lake Road into a three-way stop to slow traffic. R Young noted State highway law discourages using stop signs purely for traffic calming and recommended curve/reduced speed warning signage instead. A speed limit reduction request for the surrounding neighborhood is already in process, and the Town has arranged additional speed enforcement with the County Sheriff’s office. The one-day response time was noted as favorable. R Young reported ongoing road maintenance. Stone-oiling with fog-sealing will follow in a few weeks and additional paving projects are planned. Supv Leifer raised temporary rubber speed-strip options for Keith Lane. R Young noted they were good for short stretches but yielded mixed results from a prior speed bump trial on Yellow Barn Road (effective for the requesting resident but a noise nuisance for the four neighboring houses and problematic for snowplowing). He agreed to consider trying removable strips on Keith Lane next season. TB 8-20-26 Page 7 of 13 PLANNING DEPARTMENT In the absence of Planning Department representatives, Supv Leifer displayed the department’s monthly report onscreen, noting that the document is also available on the Town’s website. COUNTY BRIEFING D Wakeman reported several County resolutions supporting land preservation projects in Spencer, Newfield, and Caroline (on Thomas Road just over the town line) and noted a forthcoming public hearing on a proposed County animal abuse registry. In addition, he reported that the County accepted a clean financial audit from Insero and is temporarily covering vacancies in the Director of Finance and Assistant Director of Finance roles, with the County Administrator serving in an interim capacity. He noted approval of a pavement condition monitoring service for County Highway Department vehicles to support long-term road resurfacing planning. He mentioned a presentation from Diane Cohen on Ithaca ReUse seeking additional funding, the County’s purchase of delinquent tax collection software, and a freeze on property assessments during implementation of new Tyler assessment software. Cl Lamb raised the Freese Road bridge project, expected to go out to bid later this year, and asked for County support given rising costs. D Wakeman acknowledged that the bridge is owned by the County, and that it was advantageous to the County to have the Town take the lead on the project. R Young noted the existence of a decade-old grant to help fund this, with no alternate funding source available. Cl Lamb also flagged that the County’s tourism grant program requires a two-thirds local match (e.g., $60,000 in matching funds for a $30,000 award from a $265,000 total program), which he characterized as an unfavorable match ratio. He feels the match should be the other way around. R Young noted an underused state tourism funding stream (attached to CHIPS) that could also be explored. Supv Leifer confirmed that a $1 million infrastructure grant for the Hanshaw Village water system has been awarded to Tompkins County, which will help remediate existing water system issues and encourage additional lot development in adjacent areas. Cl Lamb expressed appreciation for the County’s partnership with the Town on this. DRYDEN FIRE Chief Pete Tyler reported that, in July, Dryden Fire answered 49 total calls (inclusive of 15 rescue calls, 12 service calls, and 10 mutual aid calls). An average of just under eight (8) firefighters responded per call (attributed in large part to recently graduated new firefighters) with an average response time of just over 3 minutes. Community engagement highlights included a daycare visit (ages 4-8) with roughly 10 ambulance and fire volunteers; a career day involving Groton and Dryden High School students that resulted in a thank you letter from a school superintendent; and a first-time collaboration with roughly 17-18 Resident Assistants (RAs) at TC3 aimed at building accountability around malicious or repeated non-emergency calls (e.g., covered fire alarms) from student housing. The Department’s junior firefighter camp is running at full capacity across both age groups this week. P Tyler also reported that both the fire and ambulance audits came back positive. TB 8-20-26 Page 8 of 13 Cl Lamb thanked the Department for hosting the Family Health Network Mobile Medical Unit and noted the unit’s positive experience at TC3 may lead to a regular presence there, with discussion of a future permanent health clinic near or in the Village. He previewed an upcoming discussion on a proposed battery energy storage system (BESS) law, noting strong developer and State (NYSERDA) interest in expanding battery storage in New York, and committed to involving the fire department in that process before any law is adopted. P Tyler confirmed that the Dryden Fire Department receives ongoing best practice updates on battery and electric vehicle incident response. Cl Lamb discussed the pending Neptune-Etna fire company merger (approved in February), noting the petition remains before the State Attorney General’s office. P Tyler noted that a membership vote is expected soon, so the merger is progressing. A committee led by Mark Bell is monitoring the Etna facility and assets in the interim, though the Department has not yet taken on maintenance responsibilities pending the merger’s completion. P Tyler mentioned a regional measles health alert (not yet present in Tompkins County, though patients have been transported through local hospitals). The Department is monitoring exposure minimization best practices given the illness’s high contagiousness. DISCUSSION/ACTION ITEMS Resolution – Acceptance of Audited Financial Report for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2025 This resolution accepts the Town’s financial audit report, which was presented last week. Resolution #172 (2026) – Acceptance of Audited Financial Report for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2025 Cl Lamb offered the following resolution and asked for its adoption: Whereas, the Town of Dryden entered into a contract for auditing services with Insero & Co, CPAs, LLP, for the purpose of conducting an external audit of the town’s financial records for fiscal year 2025, and Whereas, the audit firm of Insero & Co, CPAs, LLP, has completed its audit of the financial statements of the Town of Dryden for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2025, and has presented the Financial Report to the Town Board, and Whereas, the audit firm as opined the 2025 financial statements contained in the prepared Financial Report present fairly, in all material respects, the financial position and the results of operations of the Town as of, and for, the year presented in the Financial Report, Whereas, the audit team has reviewed the results with the Finance and Personnel Director and presented their findings to the Town Board, Resolved, that the audited Town of Dryden Financial Report, pending any editing changes by the auditors, for the period ended December 31, 2025, is hereby accepted and will be filed in the Town Clerk’s office. 2nd Supv Leifer Roll Call Vote Cl Vargas-Mendez Yes TB 8-20-26 Page 9 of 13 Cl Buck Yes Cl Dravis Yes Cl Lamb Yes Supv Leifer Yes Resolution – Amending Resolution #146 (2026) Establishing the Sewer and Water Task Force This resolution amends Resolution #146 (2026), which established the Sewer and Water Task Force, to update its membership. Cl Vargas-Mendez noted that Dryden Village Public Works representative Paul Savin should be replaced by Mike Murphy, with P Savin continuing to attend meetings as needed. Resolution #173 (2026) – Amending Resolution #146 (2026) Establishing the Sewer and Water Task Force Supv Leifer offered the following amended resolution and asked for its adoption: Whereas, the Town Board established the Sewer and Water Task Force (SWTF) with Resolution #146 (2026) providing a general framework, and Whereas, the availability of members has now been confirmed, and Whereas, Tompkins County has awarded the Town a $4992 Housing Affordability and Supportive Infrastructure Grant, Now therefore be it resolved, that the SWTF may consist of representatives from the Town Board, AWHC, other Town boards, the Villages, Tompkins County, the Town's Department of Public Works, interested Town residents, and Cornell, and Be it further resolved, that the Town Board appoints the following members to this task force: • Jordan Betts, Town of Dryden DPW • Scott Hopkins, Town resident, retired engineer • Miles McCarty, Village of Freeville Mayor • Martha Robertson, Town Affordable and Workforce Housing Committee • Mike Murphy, Village of Dryden DPW • Kate Supron, Campus-Community Liaison at Cornell University • David West, Tompkins County Planning and Sustainability Be it further resolved, that the Town Supervisor is authorized to sign a contract with Tompkins County and other documents necessary to execute the HASIG grant. 2nd Cl Vargas-Mendez Roll Call Vote Cl Vargas-Mendez Yes Cl Buck Yes Cl Dravis Yes Cl Lamb Yes Supv Leifer Yes Resolution – Appoint Bobette Butts to the Veterans Committee This resolution appoints Bobette Butts to the Veterans Committee. Cl Dravis added that she is a former art teacher who had years ago expressed interest in establishing a Hometown TB 8-20-26 Page 10 of 13 Heroes banner program in the Town. She has since attended a Committee meeting via Zoom, and the Committee would really like to have her on board. RESOLUTION #174 (2026) – APPOINT VETERANS COMMITTEE MEMBER Cl Dravis offered the following resolution and asked for its adoption: RESOLVED, that this Town Board hereby appoints Bobette Butts to the Veterans Committee. 2nd Supv Leifer Roll Call Vote Cl Vargas-Mendez Yes Cl Buck Yes Cl Dravis Yes Cl Lamb Yes Supv Leifer Yes Resolution – Appoint Tim Lavis to the Rail Trail Task Force This resolution appoints Tim Lavis to the Rail Trail Task Force (RTTF), following a recommendation from the RTTF itself. RESOLUTION #175 (2026) – APPOINT RAIL TRAIL TASK FORCE MEMBER Cl Lamb offered the following resolution and asked for its adoption: RESOLVED, that this Town Board hereby appoints Tim Lavis to the Rail Trail Task Force. 2nd Cl Dravis Roll Call Vote Cl Vargas-Mendez Yes Cl Buck Yes Cl Dravis Yes Cl Lamb Yes Supv Leifer Yes Petition – Speed Limit Reduction on Chaffee Road and W Lake Road Prompted by a petition, this resolution requests a speed limit reduction on Chaffee Road and West Lake Road (the opposite side of the lake from the area discussed earlier in the meeting). Resolution #176 (2026) – Requesting a Speed Limit Reduction on Chaffee and W Lake Roads Supv Leifer offered the following resolution and asked for its adoption: Whereas, Chaffee Road and W Lake Road are the primary access routes to Dryden Lake Park and connect to NYS Route 38 (Dryden-Harford Road); and Whereas, neither Chaffee Road nor W Lake Road has ever had posted speed limit signage, meaning the default statutory speed limit of 55 mph currently applies to both roads; and TB 8-20-26 Page 11 of 13 Whereas, this default 55 mph speed limit creates a dangerous condition for disabled and non-disabled residents and visitors, pedestrians, bicyclists, runners, and other users of the adjacent Jim Schug Trail who must cross or travel alongside these roads; and Whereas, a petition was initiated in December 2024 seeking a reduced speed limit of 30 mph on these access roads, with e-signatures collected from concerned residents in support of this request; and Whereas, medical letters of support were also submitted with the petition that attest to the difficulty some Chaffee Road residents would have in avoiding oncoming traffic quickly; and Whereas, the Town Board finds that reducing the speed limit to 30 mph on these roads would promote the health, safety, and general welfare of Town residents and visitors to Dryden Lake Park and the Jim Schug Trail; Now, therefore, be it resolved, that the Dryden Town Board hereby requests that the speed limit on Chaffee Road and W Lake Road be reduced to 30 mph and that the NYS Department of Transportation conduct a study of the area to determine whether such a reduction in speed limit is warranted and whether there are other traffic mitigation and safety measures that should be considered and implemented. 2nd Cl Lamb Roll Call Vote Cl Vargas-Mendez Yes Cl Buck Yes Cl Dravis Yes Cl Lamb Yes Supv Leifer Yes ADVISORY BOARD UPDATES Affordable and Workforce Housing Committee Cl Vargas-Mendez had nothing new to report from the Affordable and Workforce Housing Committee this month. He added that the Water and Sewer Task Force has already held their first meeting. Conservation Board Cl Buck reported that the Conservation Board met and had a lively discussion, but there is nothing to report. Climate Action Committee Cl Dravis reported that the Climate Action Committee held another Repair Café in July with lower turnout than prior events (attributed to summer/vacation season), with the next one scheduled for October. A new speaker series launches on September 22 at 7 p.m. at the Dryden Center for Community, with the inaugural topic being the history and overview of the Climate Action Committee. A community member in attendance at the last meeting raised interest in reviving the community garden behind Town Hall, which the Committee discussed informally; no action has been taken yet, but a Town newsletter item may follow. Supv Leifer noted future athletic field development in that area may affect available space. TB 8-20-26 Page 12 of 13 Veterans Committee Cl Dravis reported that the Veterans Committee continues to plan Operation Greenlight (green light bulbs) for November alongside the Hometown Heroes banner program. A new committee member was appointed earlier tonight to help lead banner design work. Planning Board Cl Buck reported that the Planning Board discussed no additional items beyond conservation subdivisions. Cl Lamb noted that ZAG discussions have begun on BESS with State (NYSERDA) encouragement and interest from both private developers and State-backed entities. He emphasized the potential for meaningful tax revenue (including payment-in-lieu-of-taxes arrangements) with comparatively low service impact if implemented safely. Supv Leifer informed the Board that Ray Burger is working to schedule a BESS developer presentation for the Board on a date that does not conflict with other public hearings, particularly fire district- related items. Rail Trail Task Force Cl Dravis reported that, in July, the Rail Trail Task Force added a direct website link from the Town’s homepage to DrydenRailTrail.com. There was agreement among Task Force members to informally refer to the NYSEG section of the trail as the Beaver Pond Bridge section. The Route 13 bridge remains on schedule for completion at the end of October, with an official celebration planned for spring. Four additional informational trail kiosks are being planned for Game Farm, Monkey Run, the Route 13 bridge, and Etna. The Pinckney-to-Route 366 segment of the trail is already seeing traffic. A separate August update by Cl Lamb noted the new pedestrian bridge structure is expected to arrive as a single contiguous piece around September 21 (placement date to be confirmed), that the project for the most part remains on schedule with visible progress (buttress installation underway). Additional easement work continues for the Etna-to-Freeville segment of the trail. The County tourism grant match requirement was again cited as a funding challenge for this project. Agriculture Advisory Committee Supv Leifer reported that the Agriculture Advisory Committee discussed the conservation subdivision proposal at its most recent meeting, mirroring the topics raised during tonight’s public hearing. DRYC (Dryden Recreation and Youth Commission) Supv Leifer reported interest from County Youth Services and Rural Youth Services (Cornell Cooperative Extension) in retaining a grant writer, building on previously allocated Town funding, to pursue additional grant opportunities, including NY PLAYS and a field grant currently under review. The Board discussed locating a prior Request for Proposals (RFP) template to solicit a grant writer, pending clarification of which specific grants to prioritize. There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 8:23 p.m. Respectfully submitted, TB 8-20-26 Page 13 of 13 Loren Sparling Town Clerk Proposed Conservation Subdivision Comments I believe the proposed Conservation Subdivision law does not incorporate many of the guiding principles found in the Dryden 2045 Comprehensive Plan, The Right to Farm Law, Farmland Protection Plan, and the Open Space Plan. Missing are several key goals that encourage diversity in housing options, ensure farm-friendly zoning, redirect housing away from farming operations, requiring cluster housing development, smaller lot sizes, Farmland and Agriculture protection, housing options for mix of age groups, housing Affordability and accessibility. In addition, without the addition of clear provisions and parameters stating what the town is seeking from the development, this proposed law will result in a continuation of the same large-lot development and the loss of farmland that Dryden has experienced in the past. _______________________________________________________________ History The current Conservation subdivision law is 14 years old. It has produced four Conservation Subdivisions. Two in Ellis Hollow, both cluster subdivisions, a total of 10 lots on 20 acres, 10+- acres was placed in conservation. Bluebird SD, 7 large lots on 70+- acres. Mill Creek SD, 44 large lots on 800+ acres. Both Bluebird and Mill Creek used deed restrictions to meet open space requirements. There are currently two proposed subdivisions, Fresse Rd, a cluster subdivision, 5 lots on 4 acres, Ed Hill, 24 large lots on 220 acres, using deed restrictions to meet open space requirements. A comparison of land used to create these two different types of subdivisions. Cluster Development concept. 15 lots created on 25+- acres 1 house per 1.7 acres Conservation Subdivision 75 lots created on 1000 + acres large lot concept 1 house per 13.4 acres Proposed Changes (in red) I propose that the new Conservation Subdivision law require the building of Custer Subdivisions. No more large lots. Set a maximum building lot size of between ½--¾- acre. This requirement would necessitate either a community septic system or a community water system, leaving that choice to the developer. The law would also implement incentive bonuses allowing developers to create a few larger lots mixed in with the smaller lots—such as allowing one (1) 1-2 acre lot for every two (2) ½ acre lots. This incentive would shift the current large lot development pattern and promote a mix of housing options within the same subdivision. This mix of lot and housing sizes is a goal of Dryden 2045 Plan. Other Recommendations and Changes v§240-9.10 Streets, Driveways and Trails. B. Common driveway access shall be allowed to the maximum extent feasible to minimize curb cuts. No more than four eight single-family dwelling units may be served by a single shared Common driveway. Maximum length of a Common Driveway, not more than 1000 feet, Common Driveways are limited residential and Home Occupation Level 1 and 2 uses only. ● Adding more lots to a Common Driveway is an incentive to the developer. Limiting length would be helpful for the first responders. _______________________________________________________________ §240-9.4 Dimensional Standards. A.. A major subdivision within the Conservation Zoning District (CV,) must preserve at least fifty percent (50%) of the parcel’s total acreage excluding NYS DEC-protected wetlands and Federal wetlands, and buffers as open space land. B. A major subdivision within the Rural Agricultural Zoning District (RA,) must be preserved at least ?? percent (??%) of the parcel’s total acreage excluding NYS DEC-protected wetlands and Federal wetlands, and buffers as open space land. The Rural Agriculture Zoning District (RA) has fewer land constraints when compared to the Conservation Zoning District (CV). This makes Farmland more vulnerable to development, it’s easier to develop. Farmland is also the developers' first choice when looking for property. A statement the consultant said last month still puzzles me, “as long as the developer meets the open space requirements, they can build on Prime Farmland.” That’s not what farming wants! I believe it would be better for Farmland if section 240-9.4 were split into 2 sections, (CV) and (RA.) Having a separate section for (RA) will allow Agriculture to incorporate some unique subdivision methods and open space preservation opportunities that are available today. Open space requirements on farmland can be secured using different methods, Purchase of Developmental Rights (PDR), Farm Land Trust, Finger Lake Land Trust, NRCS-USDA, Buy-Proctect-Sell. These purchase agreements and preservation techniques should be used in the Law. Incorporating these into the Subsidition Law may help to keep the farmland in production while preserving open space, without penalizing the landowner. ______________________________________________________________ §240-9.4 Dimensional Standards. E. When the major subdivision is proposed within a New York State Certified Agricultural District or within 500’ of such district, building and water well setbacks from cropland or pastureland Farmland shall be one hundred (100) feet. The setback from existing barnyards housing livestock Farm Operation shall be three hundred (300) feet. _____________________________________________________________ §240-9.9 Open Space Standards. G. The required open space may be used for community septic systems and community water well. No Community septic system or community water well shall be installed on farmland. _____________________________________________________________ Add Special Provision Any subdivision of Farmland located within Rural Residential Zoning District (RR), and also located within the NY State Agricultural District, must abide by the Conservation Subdivision Law for the Rural Agriculture District (RA) Change Minor Subdivision Law The majority of homes built in the past 14 years have used this Law. It’s time to modify the Minor Subdivision Law to encourage new development patterns to conform with the Dryden2045 Plan. The current Minor subdivision law allows creation of up to 4 lots, it has a 2 acre minimum lot size, no open space requirements, and it can also be created using flag lots. All done with only a Planning Department review. . I’m recommending larger lot sizes to help create more open space. Larger lot sizes would make them less attractive to builders and developers. Driving them to create a cluster subdivision instead. Additional recommendations, ● Lower the total number of lots that can be created from 4 to 3. ● Allow only one flag lot per Subdivision. ● Increase the minimum lot size to 4-5 acres. ● Require Planning Board Site Plan Review ______________________________________________________________ Definitions The following terms have no Definitions. All definitions need to be consistent throughout the document and align with Town Zoning Law and NY State Agriculture & Markets Law ● Agricultural Lands, Agriculture fields, Agricultural areas, Cultivated land, Cropland, Pastureland ○ Change to Farmland and add a new definition ● Old fields, ○ Change to Idle-fallow farmland and add a new definition. ● Fertile Agricultural soils, ○ Change to; Fertile Farmland? or Prime Farmland, Farmland of statewide importance and add new a definition ● Active Agricultural land with farm Buildings, ○ Change to Town Definition; Farm Operation ● Barnyards, animal housing, ○ Change to Town Definition, Farm Operation This proposed Conservation Subdivision Law does very little to protect farmland, nothing to encourage diverse and affordable housing options, and it overlooks many of the guiding visions and principles found in the Dryden 2045 Comprehensive Plan. While much of the document is sound, some sections need improving. Let's work together to make this law meet the expectations and vision of the Dryden 2045 Comprehensive Plan. I encourage the Town Board to Vote No on this current proposed Conservation Subdivision Law. Additional note. It would be helpful to review a complete Subdivision Law, not just a section at a time, so one can better interpret how the many sections will interact together. I am requesting that the ZAG committee finish writing complete Subdivision Law before it goes to a public hearing for adoption. Thank you, Craig Anderson HOUSING IMPACT OF REVISED CD LAW? * Is the law potentially exclusionary? (yes) * Is it “Density Neutral”? (no) * Can the law be improved from a housing standpoint? (yes) LAND & HOUSING CONTEXT Total Town Land: 60,160 acres (100%) Zoning Districts: Rural Res. (RR) 8,000 “ (13.5%) Rural Ag. (RA) 17,808 “ (30.0%) Conservation (CV) 26,315 “ (44.0%) Land where 50% open space set-aside required: 74% (or 44,123 acres) 1. EXCUSIONARY POTENTIAL * 50% of 44,123 acres removed from development. * Clustered development on remaining 50% subject to min. lot size dictated by lack of S&W (not “small” and affordable). * Cluster owners may be compelled to co-own 50% of required open space, an additional cost and access burden. 2. IS NEW LAW DENSITY NEUTRAL? Meaning: no loss or gain in density with CD compared to density prescribed by the underlying zoning district(s). ** No guarantee of this. Density increases when DUs remain small. ** 14 year pattern: 4 CDs covering 1,212 acres and providing 71 housing units. (or ~ 1 unit/17 acre average) ** Minor Subdivision preference: > half our housing development in 14 yrs. (4 or fewer development units), i.e., larger DUs on subdivision lots. Point: Clustering with smaller-sized units could happen but could also give way to larger, less affordable housing. As our DRYDEN2045 states: ”A significant portion of the residential acreage of the town (56%) is comprised of rural residences (i.e., single-family homes with more than 10 acres),… This is significant because this properties are likely to be less affordable.” (p. 44) RA 20-Acre Lot with and without 50% Open Space Requirement With 50% Requirement: Base = 20 Dwelling Units (DUs) 50% preserved as open space (20 => 10-acre base) 10 acres clustered for housing (minus 2 acres for roads, utilities, setbacks, storm water) Diverse housing scenario 1: two 2 acre + four 1-acre parcels = 6 parcels Diverse housing scenario 2: four 1/2 acre + six 1-acre parcels = 10 parcels Density bonus of 2 DUs on base of 10 acres = total of 12 parcels Without 50% Requirement: Base = 20 Dwelling Units (DUs) Open space protection through deed restrictions (??) Large-lot single-family dwelling likely Minor Subdivision option of 4 parcels with possible housing diversity 50% open space optional No density bonuses 3. CAN THE PROPOSED LAW BE IMPROVED FROM A HOUSING STANDPOINT? 1.Reduce the maximum parcel size; more housing on less land (adds climate benefits). 2.Consider 40%-60% balance (instead of 50%-50%) 3.Voluntary open space protection leveraged w/ bonuses 4.Encourage CD development in nodal areas where infrastructure costs are low, especially S&W. 5.Eliminate minor/major subdivision distinction 6. Developer friendly density(+ other) bonuses: ** Housing diversity ** Flexibility in lot size ** Expedited permitting ** Affordable housing commitmentsd