HomeMy WebLinkAbout2019-09-16Dryden Rail Trail Friends and Task Force
Minutes of the Meeting Monday, September 16, 2019
7:00 – 9:00 p.m. Freeville Village Hall
Attendance: Bob Beck, Diane and Chris Tessaglia-Hymes, Kathy Wolf, Stephanie Goddard,
Kevin Dean, Todd Bittner, Bruno Schickel, David Bravo Cullen, Deb Siegert, Alice Green,
Susan Ashdown, Mary Millick, John Kiefer, Rose Borzik, Loren Sparling, Steve Winans, Nancy
Munkenbeck, Brent Hollister
Call to order (7:02 p.m.) – Bob Beck
Additions to agenda
Approval of July minutes
Triad Foundation grant received – Bob, Bruno
This $15,000 grant will cover materials for the refurbishment of the trestles at the Game
Farm section of the trail. Foundation officials said they would encourage us to apply again
since they like to continue funding projects that they like. Bruno said their grants are
usually $10,000 to 20,000. He wants to get Roy Park, Jr. out to walk the trail.
Brief reports on:
• Project Lead trail work and Family Reading Partnership Story Walk
installation— Alice, Milo, Bob
In July, a terrific team of 10 teens helped clear a trail section near Rte. 366 in Etna,
under the leadership of Cooperative Extension’s Jeff Panik with Bob, Milo and Alice.
They also installed a new Story Walk—featuring pages from the preschoolers’ book
Steam Train, Dream Train - on the Schug trail section beginning near Dryden Agway.
Project Lead is a volunteer summer pre-employment program for 11-15 year olds.
• Booths at Dryden Lake Festival and Freeville Harvest Festival– Alice, Susan,
Mary Millick, Stephanie Goddard, Kathy Wolf, John K., Bob
The booths were an opportunity to greet the public and answer questions about the
trail. A raffle at the Dryden Lake Festival, and sales of trail merchandise brought in
$230. The Freeville Festival brought in $20 in sales; raffles were not permitted
there. Alice thanked all the volunteers who staffed the booth, and especially Susan
who made or procured all the raffle items. She added that all the proceeds were
applied against costs of the water bottles, caps, patches etc. There is plenty of
inventory and any new sales will go to the Trail.
Trail surface work – Bruno
Work on the trail surface continues. Bruno said he started working on the washout near the
FH Fox Bridge. He brought in material from grading other parts of the trail. Next, volunteers
have seeded it down. They drove in steel stakes and black plastic snow fence along the steep
sides. Bob, Bruno, Todd, Alice and John L. did a walk through afterwards and discussed how
to preserve trees and habitat along the trail in that area and west of the Fox Bridge. Todd
noted this is a beautiful section of the trail for views along the ravines. Bruno reported that
about three weeks ago, Rick Young called to ask permission to send his large machine over
to work at Game Farm to keep the brush down. However, they continued over Mt. Pleasant
and cleared some trees and shrubbery that had been intended for saving. But he said that
the good news is: the clearing on the trail section from the Stevenson Rd to Mt. Pleasant was
helpful. Bruno then brought in a dozer and bobcat and graded and crowned the section. He
also did trimming and added a culvert pipe in the Gary Sloan easement section, and he said
the whole section is pretty good now. This was about $6000 worth of work in machine time
and materials. He said he’s gotten great feedback from people walking down through there.
Update on planned Game Farm trestle and Fox Bridge work – Bruno
• Todd asked if signs have been placed on both sides of the Fox Bridge. Bob reported
that the Highway Superintendent wants to consult with the Town Attorney before
putting up those signs. Todd said he understands that the NYS general obligations
law will cover the Town, so having a sign that shows due diligence will raise the bar
in a lawsuit. Bob was concerned that if the signs are placed, there won’t be any
enforcement capacity. Todd said now that the Town officially owns the bridge; a
sign is better than no sign. A barrier would be even better to keep people off the
bridge before it is ready for official opening. Alice said she would check in with the
Town attorney.
• On the railing work for the Fox Bridge, Bruno said he and his crew could do the
carpentry work, so that DPW needs to do only the welding. Traffic on Route 366
beneath has to be stopped one lane at a time while the railings construction is under
way.
• Todd asked, how confident are we that the next time we need to coordinate with
Town DPW for trail clearing, the communication will be more clear? Bob said Bruno
has volunteered be the point person from the Task Force to DPW staff, responsible
for explaining to the crew who reports for the job. Todd said it might be
appropriate for the Town Board to request that DPW crews not employ their
articulated arm bush mower without a member of the Task Force present.
• Bruno and Bob have talked with Evan Wills at the Game Farm to see if the DEC has
looked at the plan for trestle renovations that Bruno made and had stamped by an
engineer. He said that the opportunity for rebuilding the trestles this year is waning.
It would be good to clear the section between the two trestles. The Town
equipment can come in by creating a little access road, that wouldn’t require going
over either trestle.
Update on Game Farm Road at-grade crossing – Bob, Alice, Todd, John L.
The Town received a draft agreement from County Highway Chief Jeff Smith, stipulating
their requirements for a study and an engineering plan for the crossing. It appears to
require a study of all crossing alternatives. Bruno asked why. Bob said that at the June
meeting of stakeholders at the crossing, it seemed that they agreed that the at-grade
crossing is the appropriate solution. John Lampman has volunteered his time to help
prepare the plan. Todd said the Town’s request for a speed reduction will require a traffic
study, which may meet some of the plan requirements
Alice said that the Town has asked for the speed limit reduction, and is planning to
approach the Town of Ithaca and Cornell to help with any costs for the study, as well as with
installation and maintenance costs for the crossing.
Update on trail & highway signs – Diane, Bob
Diane has designed welcome and street crossing road name signs that went to the printer
today. The welcome sign is 12”w x 16”h and the street name signs are 12”w x 4”h. When
approaching an intersection, trail users will see a stop sign with the street name sign above
it. As they enter from the intersection, they will see the welcome sign containing our logo
and rules of the trail. One post will be mounted with signs on either side. Signs have been
ordered for all 16 intersections along the trail: 32 each of welcome signs, street name signs
and stop signs. Bob noted the highly-reflective 12” x 12” stop signs received are plastic
rather than metal, which reduced the cost from $39 apiece to $6.25 each.
TAP grant scope update – Todd, Bruno, John K., John L., Bob
It’s been about 6 weeks since there has been a client meeting. A question has arisen about
how much of the trail work should be included in the scope of the work for the grant. With
further information about the stipulations of the TAP grant, it may not be in the Town’s best
interest to include some sections in the scope of the work. Federal standards could increase
the costs of the stone dust surfacing, and create significant delays in keeping up the
momentum of the trail.
Todd added that part of our assumption was that volunteers and DPW could complete parts
of the work. After more experience working with the NYS Parks grant, it has become clear
that it is administratively challenging to prepare and submit claims for all these
contributions. He said these factors have prompted the TAP grant subcommittee to take a
step back and try to figure out alternatives and cost benefits.
John said as time goes by it gets simpler because Bruno is doing a lot of the work that can
done under the Parks grant, so there’s less that could serve as a match for the TAP grant.
Todd said we have to have the bridge go to and from somewhere, that is, the trail has to be
100 percent stone dust surface and ADA compatible up to an intersection on either side of
the bridge. The stone dust work is not included in the parks grant. There’s a 20 percent
match required by the TAP grant. If work funded by NYS Parks can’t be part of that match,
the local share may be more than originally expected. An option is to remove Game Farm Rd
to Monkey Run Rd from the scope of the grant.
One of the suggestions to help with grant questions was to connect with Tim Logue, City
Engineer, who has more experience in dealing with TAP grants. The meeting with Logue
was set for 2:30 pm September 19. Another suggestion was to go ahead and solicit
expressions of interest from prospective engineering companies (a DOT-required list of 15)
that might submit proposals to design the project, to gain their input on scope options.
Mutt Mitt dispensers: donation & installation – Stephanie, Bob
Bob thanked Stephanie for donating funds towards three “dog poop bag” dispensers that
have now been installed in the Dryden to Freeville Trail section. She also offered to keep
the dispensers filled with mitts. The Village of Freeville has three keys to the dispensers.
Stephanie and Kevin said the situation is a lot better than it was before. Bob said there’s still
some education needed, so dog owners know how to use the bags and remove them, rather
than throwing them along the trail.
New price quote for 10 trail benches – Bob
Scott Roudebush, the owner of the Roudebush Company, which produced ten benches now
installed on the Dryden to Freeville Trail section, has contacted Task Force about another
order for more benches. Bob said they gave us a good price for quality benches. About
$360 per bench. Bruno said that benches could go in some sections this fall; Monkey Run to
Route 13 is a possibility. If we had them we could install them, he added. It takes about 4
weeks to get them in. Roscoe Brothers Woodworking, which donated the routing of “Dryden
Rail Trail” on a board for each bench, has closed, but there are still nine extra routed name
boards available to use on the new benches. The group agreed to order 10 more benches.
Renew discussion of Friends of DRT fundraising options – Bruno, Mary M., Susan,
Diane, Stephanie
Mary described her background in development and shared some suggestions for Rail Trail
fund-raising including: Raffles, a Doug’s Fish Fry fund raiser and more. Bruno suggested
evening walks with a suggested contribution. Steph noted that the Freeville Community
Council is doing a morning walk and talk Oct. 6. Nancy suggested a nature-oriented game
that identifies plants along the trail. Another fun run was also suggested.
Todd reminded the group that Friends of the Trail can solicit donations but Town
employees and appointees cannot. Diane suggested that the Friends could meet separately
to plan. She asked whether the DRT should form a non-profit 501(c)(3) organization, to
enable sale of trail items on line, etc. Todd suggested checking with a tax advisor about
what are the thresholds for fund raising amounts that require 501(c)(3) status.
First Kiosk Donor
Bruno announced that his wife, Amy Dickinson, has offered to memorialize the Freeville
kiosk.
Comments from the Public
Kevin reported that there were William George Agency cars chasing two students who ran
away, at high speeds up to 45 mph along the trail at 7:40 pm recently. He called NYS police
and two state troopers arrived on the scene. He asked the troopers to let Bob Beck know
about the incident. Bob said the Tompkins County Sheriff’s office could also be contacted.
Motorized vehicles (except emergency vehicles, are prohibited on the Rail Trail, and there
are new caution signs at the trail crossing. Bruno suggested speed bumps could be added to
slow down illegal speeders. Also, the Town of Dryden could notify the William George
Agency that it’s not acceptable for their cars to travel at high speed on the off-road Rail
Trail.
Kevin asked again about the Town installing a privacy fence on his private property along
DPW Drive. Task Force and Town Board members reiterated their previous response that
the property is not part of the trail right of way, the Town has already contributed to
privacy by plantings along the ROW, and any further fencing is the responsibility of the
property owner.
Next Meeting Scheduled for 7 pm Monday October 21 at Houtz Hall in Etna
Adjournment at 9:25 pm
Submitted by Alice Walsh Green