HomeMy WebLinkAbout1990-10-230
1
Date:getober 23rd, 113130
To Jack. Baker, Chr. , Dt�yderi 'down Z. B. n.
S I'nFz)llwood 10r•ive
Fruf��vX l lLar New York.
Frarn:Heramy Mi Slater, Zr= iriirig R Building Cl =ide Enf1 =1rcern(='nt Df ics
Town of Dryden
E5 E. Main Street
Dryden, New York 13033
Sub. = Rie ached �-� 1 e Z.B. A. Hear i 1r�g Date Fl =lr Noverab�,&mlr 1990,
Dear Jack:
Plp�ase
bL4
advised
that
it
has
himcome
necessary
to
reschedule
the
IUov mF
+r'
6th
r e
).
rj,y
+scijsdUlcd
rti rtig
Saar
^d
of
AFM L
E71
hearing 5e5siov) tin, WEDNESDAY NOVf;-.' 1BER 14th 113900
AS YOU May Ov% niay 10i0t
General Election Lay
differe;?rit P-1cm:?ntion d],
facility. Thp r'ex re�
available i5 the 14th
r'Leca111 Tuesday November 6th, is
and sin= the 'down Hall is used fi-ir
stricts; wc� ��n not h,&:�vc? Ur*e '=if the
t0io that thiR ball is
of NovembLar.
Tf YOU rjr• :kIrl Of tHa, bi :'lard menqh*r`S have zrly prizziblems with
this date, please deride rnC:il leC'U IVE�l bLZ2twLa rn yj= jjsr,sQl,ves
an acceptable day arid 1 ct me know by n1D later t harp M drida
October 29th 4�kt 844 -9120 between 7:30 A. M. arid i :Oo P, M.
at 844 - '371,5 evL=nlr,g5. if I do ricit hear from you by that
date, 1' 11 prrzice:p.:d with scheduling fimir t:he 14th.
Very truly your,
Henry M. Slater
CC: ill. 1 Z. T. R. Bizziard Members
Jean Ryan, Recording Secretary Dr den Town Z. Bm no
— --
OCT L 3 1 5K
1
I
1
Q rl
or•
F i
Date ;October 22nd, 1990
Try: Al l Members and Town Saver nment nUents
Frore:Henry M. Slater, Zi -ining Building Cede Enf1z)rceripnt Office
Town of Dryden
65 E. Main St reet
Dryden, New York 13053
Gub.:Required Pr^iv4�jte 5 'pewage Syeterrr Design Changes Inforril4jk tir-Y1
,Session, October *_'3th, 19130.
Ladies 1 Gentlemen:
Plea Se
find attached
a copy of
the mateklial sent t- r-rs by
the Ti= irapkins
County
DLapartriinnt
of Environrrrental }lea1.th. fps
yo{.t I I
note, these
changes are
Mandatory and wi 11 take
effect
bw_c;Rme
Some
on
December
goals
Ist iggOm
that
that
In a recent
phone � Y�V r ~satiar7
like
with
attend
Triwn
Cruncil(llal7
please
note. t11140!1�
you Should
you
ROVIAld
Roberts, it
accomplish
bw_c;Rme
Some
of
apparent,
the
goals
Department
that
that
some
the
of
P. n.
tFtie
ne
Zoning
charlpos
District
may
purposed to
distribute
Thieve.
this
data
It
to
was
each
them
of yltil,m
that
Ron
for review
suggested
and
thzkt
informatirr,
to do so.
and
so
that
c :lu
could
attend
if
you
would
1,i
See
If you
Should
like
to
attend
this
sessiron,
please
note. t11140!1�
you Should
you
call.
thpa
Tompkins
County
Health
Department
as
as
possl ble
for
a reservation.
The
nrunber; is.
273_17275.
Ve Y truly oUr
He M. Slater
0 C 2 3 19$9
. ILI
[i7
E,
TOMPIONS
SUZANNE W $TOPI =N, A.N., M.P.S.
Public Fleallh Dlreclor
[ rlm 941
EnWIMnMenUl H"11h 01villon
401 Heirl• 0, betas Driv*
llheee, Nww Torn 148W13to
TO Sewage System Contractors, Design Consultants, Tompkins County Board of
Realtors, Tompkins /Cortland Name Builders Assoc., Code Enforcement
Officers, Planning Commissioner Hanson
FROM: John M. Andersson, P.E., Director of Environmental Healt
Steven Kern, Senior Public Health Sanitarian 5K
DATE: September 29,1990
SUBJECT: General Information Meeting - Individual Sewage Systems
There will be a general informational rneeting concerning the revised Now York
State Sanitary Code hart 75 and Appendix 75 -A, which regulates Individual Sewage
Systems, in the Sadd Conference Room In the County Biggs A Building at 301 Harris
H. Dates Orive,.Ithaca, NY, on Monday, October 29, 1990 at 7!00 p.m.
The purpose of the meeting is to introduce the nevo code previsions as a prelude to
future public meetings, hearings, and educattan sessions.
Enclosed is a summary of how the 75 -A revisions compare to current practices of
the Tompkins County Heaith Department for your reference and information. Copies
of Part 75 and Appendix 75 -A are available from the Environmental Health offices
at 401 Harris 8. Dates Drive, Ithaca, NY 14850 for a cost of 13.25, if you wish
to obtain a copy in preparation for the meeting.
We would appreciate a telephone call to our office at 273 -7275 if you plan to
attend the meeting.
JMA /91< /kk
EnC5.
cc: Suzanne Stopen, Publit Health Director
Dr. Fox, Chairperson, Board of Health
Frank Preto, Chairperson, Health Committee
E I
TS CO
SUZANNt A. StOPEH, R.N., M,P.S.
Public Heailh Dlreclor
TUt
FROM %
DATE:
VOJL LT i
Tompkins County Board of Health
F HL41TH
EnYlranmenW Fleolkh alYldpm
401 bends E. Date* Drive
I1hoeo, Now Yar1k 1 40 50 -1 314
Sohn M. Anderssnn, P.E., Director of Environm 1 Hea h
Steven Kern, Senior Public Health Sanitarian
July l3, 1490
Part 75 -A Review
'
Part 75 -A revisions
of
the New York State
Sanitary
Code is effective
across
the State on December
1,
1490. While
the
Tompkins
County Realth
Department's
individual
sewage program has
not conformed
to the very rigid 75-A in
existence
in years past,
we feel
the restate
will now take
steps to ensktre that the
counties
with sewage programs
do
conform.
While
the new
75 -A is more liberal than
the old
75 -A, it is more
restrictive
than
current
Tompkins
County Health
Department
codes and policies.
After spending many hours reviewing Part 75aA of the New York State
Sanitary Code, we feel the attached are changes to the way we now apply individual
sewage system standards. The impact of the change, and our recommandation on how
or if to implement the change, are also notedd
In order to implement these changes, we need to modify most or all of
the system specification sheets, train our field staff, and train installers, code
officials, etc.
The changes will also require modifications to {articles I, VI, and VIE
of the Tompkins County Sanitary Code. We envision this happening through a series
of public meetings, draft codes, and finally, a public hearing prior to adoption
by the Tompkins County Board of Health, and finally filing at the New York State
Health Department. This cannot happen before Spring 1991.
The most 8igniflf$nt thanges are highlighted below:
i. The minimum vertical dimension from the bottom of a system to a
restriction (rock, maximum high groundwater, unsuitable soil? will
be two feet instead of three feet. The Tompkins County Board of
Health can adopt a greater distance. We may recommend one later
(especially in areas where wells are prevalent).
2. The imposition of a maximum slope is significant, and will restrict
the area where on -site systems are allowed. Towns where the percent
of land is over 1S percent aret Newfield (36X), Caroline 1247.1,
Danby (23%), Ithaca (17x1, Dryden tle%), Enfield (9%), Groton 179'.1,
Lansing (6%), and Ulysses (42). If we accept enginearkng designs on
steeper slopes, casts will increase,
s
ILI
Memo to TompkinO County Board of Health
July 13, 1990
p6ge Two
3. L-arger tanks and dual septic tanks are often required, which will
increase cost but also impraves the systemn
4. Maximum trench width of 24" instead of 36" will increase length of
trenches and total area necessary for a system.
5. Six -month settling for raised systems means this alternative will
not Often be usedl the lesser known mound *sill be the builders'
chbire.
6. Pumps are mandated for all mounds and sand filters, increasing cast.
7. The dispersion trench foilowir+g a sand filter will he replaced by a
mound, causing more raised sand filters and increased cost.
S. All these changes have a deep effect on subdivision approvals. The
State Wealth Department has recommended that of the alternative
tystemsp only raised systems be allowed in subdivisions. Cur
experience with raised systems in subdivisions is mixed. More
thought ig needed hereR the lot size for any alternative may need to
be increased.
JMAIkr
Ott.
cc: Suzanne Stopen, Public Health Director
CL
I U!,
m
e,
cr
Q
,a
6
IT
Ch
�F
a
C2 LF)
n
[x
Z �
We u
w U)
0. 2
IL
O O
IMME 3
lu
m
0]
ri
ro
0
u
�r
14
ti
crk
D
I=
a,
C
L
L.
LI
s
in
w-■
kn
1�
w
Q
lu
1L
a
M
OD
v
L
i° „
+°x' m a
C ° 'a
m CL r-
o
ym C I
.� ti o t- w
In G j
w dP ra
jp► .,
m r. cri rc 4,% dp
C a, C r -�
m 4i s o m
. + }�y e� di � o �
Ll '04 ,, o sx
.. � � m
0 a u %tr v� u w 1 u la
CL
r
L
' u u
in m 0 V 4 v
+� LM
m +x CL u :" i
.,
EW few 4m e L 111 fo
L f ul m QI %I a' .r
L] J ul C 1 j
0 14 tU
e -ri Jn X FMO ■ O C L . C], A
-" 4A v 01 L11 Or 4kb e �QI1 I
cd L+1 14 O U #+ QL ., 1� a -P w 47 1v ED a tr 'lt u R m
lb C V 1p L +s ■ 0 -P m QI � Lx 43 m �
L dc rM C 16 ri 0' u U1 ul M a.r 1n 4;b "fi Ep (A O +* r 4 U1
V
++ 0 AI m nl UI %. o L- •+ 0
.. trl t� M +0 U t to u
Ql ... d ++ w bl [A � r � 111 A M m ul
O up v q1 al lfl N v 3 iQ
v v 7t w dl m 1V ill
ra ■ L t� 1R Id s- or in i!1 p C N 01 1!1 G tlt ru
OL 0- CL la '' C 1a it w 6L L In k C .� i ra fig {m - Gq1 ri
e, w C1 p m ■t m 9* L I r 4 CI L l p1 u :1 L. L Q L,
4 6 L 1! 1a :# x p] [r1 17 u U U 11
Imo- 'o F- R F L: C
r.
+.. " ■+
I
� Q
u
,r w
va -13
.mow W In m 111 Y 111 ro Cp
wk 41 er M 93 "9 ■LD t* p 462 p rb To •T
13 3 �l 00 m #' AP rr4 G UT fI
111 r-1 Q +� �F li a "0 -0 U +t C I
.� L. O l- + mi 461 OF 7
�
u
L *' • 1 ■A ryi CI 111 +r
1.. C In q t. r .w rp LP QJ
C i 4J -m $ C+ L Ilf ... L N 17 in
O a+ V G Q1 } L`t re -4 -P 4p lu m r
fll 7 + rn .Q ktw g l 10 0 O D {11 4
.. 1 111 t +t 1 1� rt
•.* •F4 "� 4 .. � Q1 1
i
110 -r #+ .. u 99 if _ rd
L l 40 it r4 r4 "E L t rd In ■A Lk 1l Ja Yx
ilf b 3 IQ IQ I 1h L ant
1 cc m X11 ",
1u
Ch
to
IOL
ttk
UI
.CT
c
r0
N
z O
S O`
CC +"
i� 47
C'
13
J C
d• fi
S p7
L�
w- 4P
Z 4
7 to
lop CL
u
C1J
►-4 UI
NZ ;PFL
jCL Z
r 0
IU
!t
Out
y
IY
C
u
C
8
E
its
L
CT
G
k
i+
a
M-
C�.1
E
Q�
a-
AIM
I
L
a
[x
Al tj M at
c e
� .rI Iri
k
CL
1 C
1f
PIA to
NINE 41% -0 Y' }. T
to + >- W #
QP a C1] ra ' r -U s
Ll Ifl 41 IJI L 1•,1
! • f i • . 1 dr 'Py
-P I11 ow 4+ >% *0 UI +t 41 GI +> III I4mm #P 4'
a 171 n CL NF- 01 a, 1 1 a M a C4
GI 1= dI 41 .$ 4J C GJ 01 1= UI 'r1 * 41 Pr
u IV u 41 U u Pu a V r0 iyJ CP t` IJ 11
£C C3 d c � u tx Q u C[ GI u <F fj
In
{a
ir" G
1„I !-i P•rt 10
r1 r L11
ap In 11? LIP
DI E r" un C > QJ In 3
1J
C G 111 11 4x r JC •. C L 4-
Q "*- G
rd CL v CL 40V to up fu FU
rd ■ .ai CL to m E CL 0 # 96 p d1 r
u REi I11 y�I Or C13 ID P -+ ,C
'I3 7 7 I11 11J Cti L 1- Cl I_ -0 r.J
iJt �v 114 # IZ M * + # O # Ci ru Ili .►
111 4P L Y4 •+'r 4,10 _ j]I 1'- -G� ' IA L dI •] C .+ Ii
qu (11 j=L Li C >, QI r-, > C f) 1_ Ir7
jc� q+m A + E 111 cr t 0 t CD" AI 14 dI ,,I U1 4P IIJ
U C3 411 Ir4 !+ I N 7' w .. 1 'Q C u ID *+ r
c DI Jr Y7 CL rr +� = #, .,y uF U1 � Ql IJJ
&I J= L pP •. +I W 41 }- U %T . O #]I #' ., .r4 #s L I,
L 1~+ l; L 1n L ■ .•-1 ,.+ xy C�- C u C i ^I III �-
a+ C+ gd r0 dI C it 111 C: LM CT! QI w 6 •-�
C w 1- CX O 3 P•y #+ #a d 40 ' VS L r1 L
Ita M M Q 111 IR ! 111 al >• Q U1 11 ro O
d 13 +> v C: 4 N d! dI it D e -f1 ! -0 U III 7r !+
Ll � 4 V• W +Y Y 'P•r .N .i •1 111 i+} a1
1y1 dF 9I d! + 9 u � 1L of +-y L , U g rU M 00 O IP Irl •-'
G1 Y! U7 1n rn 4" rd 41 A Up f-1 IL U 01 'r+ Jck 13 114 a., � Ll !1 u
I Ik to ] ga 11s > ma rd IT J= d! fu ; 14- a
1 L L1 A t 41 0� 1� o O G Ct LI .�• u }r >� C,4 oj CL
N
x u v m u e U x Imp i M: qs it N .•P x i_ 4- uI
L1 C e L) C: 5 8 G L1 C 1 # QI U LS C, a O P•y +q +_I La 01 al ,
H w 1 pm, I..4 UI H F C Jo 1` H Up tJ_ CL C Ii iJ III
dl r�
'4'k YI!
CIS C
L 1 r 4— O
`! fr r r1
* 1J r-I C1 rb . t. a !�
JP 41,11 al la 4 C# >� � W ry
1} RI
C
r 0 +••r ! 7 1a O l0 .rI .� } ,.+ i� fd 7
u rd mll • + w 'O dI E 41 •r+ 1< +r-
1J UL AI tm d G +b ID t- -u 90 C+
4A # 01 U1 �1 C L P•rt 111 .+ dl lm %11 IG b
In E 10. in � at U X41 t0 d! L -� tlri W 4
> c M 1n U Y D dI r11 r: a ; rU III
•7C 111 L 1< C -ri Ull 8 4j 1 .r4 ^'� 13 .M j
3r. 1D C 11 1= s U CC E Cr 1D W N dJ U dt
Cfi g t III E 0 a Ian
I dr ID .. rq L 41 L4 L J 1 v.
> ^' ED + D 11 I- Py d1 -, ..4 IL ! d1 . 01
m A3 9x CI1 + Q1 +i + .1.1 fa Or i
LI
nJ Pq I c 1,011 :3 # -� 1n �- rr r- .,1 ON 0 —• u!
.ri M C1 1 ., 1R M j" dJ rT C1 9-4 r11 L: N 1:: . r
to I4 kJ V M 0 Q U �- 14 -. K L-
41 4+ C LL 7 Jr C J3 C rd Ul I_r J3 r4 Ito 0 V i�
CD CQ qm C C1] IM 1< CO tH C C4 isi�,` 01 ,w 117P, F OF fI� .q -..
YF % z i Tti M r1 t� 1_ I`{ ,.•I #� � cu l� U'I C� M L {V+ � Ur m 1-0 F4
m -
N
01
crr"
rm
Fj
U
Z ON
r•1
++L cr
W
C3
iE 13
4 LP
W
L
Fa
�l
L1
CL
0 �
#
t>1
it
111
la
O
-•i
TI
FM
cr
0
ra
+I'
F
1p
a
L
L
Q
E
El
Iw
1
4
C
V)
N
40
GJ
Lt
t
0
r,t
b
L
u
F
r`}
'+f
,F4
L
�A
-.y
M
tl1
S
N
CL
CL aw
lm
lm
16 4L.r
.m
:J W +r
4C +•-� 4+
1 �
--+ #.
-"1 44 a..
7. Irp In
•'+ � qu
m
1
C* L
r
l3
I
t
In
i
jL 4,b
L1 it
0
RJ
L
L
1T
Yl •"�
ap
N Q
91
C %M
C3
4*
IMP
1 QF
NOE
u
Pit
ILIO` p!
h
CL
Lip
qy
i
1C
Let
•
Cu
kc
4j* to
CL
.a
a
u07 O
iC LfI
a
8 u
6p
1•-r 1
Cr 06
0
1k ra
-•"r O' 1C
f.
Li
YY U
r•1
1U L a s
QF �
4t (ll Rr
41 = t11
10 %P� IMP
o +t
CL
ut u -0 jp�
r 1Y i= ro pl
J�
,.n O 111 0 ' i • O !:•1
U F id N d Al u
d UI
FM ar C L G L1 U tJ m� I�
Q, O r7 O 4x d Q J: rn er
1d #
1�
i • al A3
43 } >I
V nj
d
u�� 4! ++ -P
YM u r O
.1'11 'r# 41
ib , ,1� ' .
- 4 • i ,
L
C: C G 9l Ol
#s l-* rs1t1, N 1L LE
d >4 14
' + 01 u to w C a
C I=
O O ill 0) C Q
:1 :P L W QJ L # dot N
G C ID I= L'
d c !OL C C
u C3 4 w,M �in j y
LJ
IQ + . r0
0 13 C- -P
rL O L"
+i 7 4+ al
C {�
� t L UI
7 2 F 00 • .1 # Ix III to
6 OI QI M L
r-r
rd 'L � � 41 '*� tll :G Q
Q 1A Is M ur L Ilk E V !_ "t-
$ .- Y L1 3 043 }}M L L 3
'� al I 11w it C a [C m
' *� L•! f
ra CL
Lo
!' Cn OF Q! L
L. m se,1
L Ui .� •,.• .� 1n 0! As
L .-. .-.
a C A r V'= u 'L*�111 yy
lip . ra
f
wk pmq .ma�yyy IA �{ 1 {ul ��}(1% P4 y[*� u!
p Y lF tT Y 46t
ML I
•
III
43
Ir�I
�fu
i1
nJ
u
O
l# IU
w fb
ru fg
rip m
u U
a
1••1 "
m
w
.r..
L
OF
rm
lip
SC
1` tlr
fIS
4= QI
#►
L1 r*
CU
M" L
rti
I �
Y
F
7 w,
w +4
K
11F
a
C
Y
m
firr"
[71
UI
IL
Al
OJI
7
D
�
in
4t
�Y
N
rt
E
1UI
i
L7
•••
i
X11
as
1a
to
L1
ni
Ell
Ll
' -
r)
CT
F
I6
IL
Cl
11r
11
49
*!
N
k
Jul
Imp
1.•I
tn
�4
NZ
tn
r�
IMP
91
0
iJ'
M
-N
•
"
}i
Ilk
l.J
UP
-+
'_
+I)
-r+l
ih
.�
'MP
4A
1
+0
Ir
CLA
S
#
1M,
Ur
14
fu
low
1A
14
0
ji
0
1L
1b
IV
t
ar
•+t
CL
#i
�
•.•r
w
1p
0
RJ
L
L
1T
Yl •"�
ap
N Q
91
C %M
C3
4*
IMP
1 QF
NOE
u
Pit
ILIO` p!
h
CL
Lip
qy
i
1C
Let
•
Cu
kc
4j* to
CL
.a
a
u07 O
iC LfI
a
8 u
6p
1•-r 1
Cr 06
0
1k ra
-•"r O' 1C
f.
Li
YY U
r•1
1U L a s
QF �
4t (ll Rr
41 = t11
10 %P� IMP
o +t
CL
ut u -0 jp�
r 1Y i= ro pl
J�
,.n O 111 0 ' i • O !:•1
U F id N d Al u
d UI
FM ar C L G L1 U tJ m� I�
Q, O r7 O 4x d Q J: rn er
1d #
1�
i • al A3
43 } >I
V nj
d
u�� 4! ++ -P
YM u r O
.1'11 'r# 41
ib , ,1� ' .
- 4 • i ,
L
C: C G 9l Ol
#s l-* rs1t1, N 1L LE
d >4 14
' + 01 u to w C a
C I=
O O ill 0) C Q
:1 :P L W QJ L # dot N
G C ID I= L'
d c !OL C C
u C3 4 w,M �in j y
LJ
IQ + . r0
0 13 C- -P
rL O L"
+i 7 4+ al
C {�
� t L UI
7 2 F 00 • .1 # Ix III to
6 OI QI M L
r-r
rd 'L � � 41 '*� tll :G Q
Q 1A Is M ur L Ilk E V !_ "t-
$ .- Y L1 3 043 }}M L L 3
'� al I 11w it C a [C m
' *� L•! f
ra CL
Lo
!' Cn OF Q! L
L. m se,1
L Ui .� •,.• .� 1n 0! As
L .-. .-.
a C A r V'= u 'L*�111 yy
lip . ra
f
wk pmq .ma�yyy IA �{ 1 {ul ��}(1% P4 y[*� u!
p Y lF tT Y 46t
ML I
•
III
43
Ir�I
�fu
i1
nJ
u
O
l# IU
w fb
ru fg
rip m
u U
a
1••1 "
m
w
.r..
L
OF
rm
lip
SC
1` tlr
fIS
4= QI
#►
L1 r*
CU
M" L
rti
I �
Y
F
7 w,
w +4
K
ds
C!
F�
E 4s
a
ul
1. ?�
UP 1]
Oh ill
L i
u
N 11
L
a-r
1 ul ,G1
L
,•.
b!r a lip
t} u! t
11F
a
C
Y
[T
firr"
Ilk
UI
IL
Al
OJI
D
in
4t
�Y
N
rt
E
1UI
i
L7
•••
i
X11
as
to
L1
ni
Ell
Ll
' -
r)
CT
F
I6
ds
C!
F�
E 4s
a
ul
1. ?�
UP 1]
Oh ill
L i
u
N 11
L
a-r
1 ul ,G1
L
,•.
b!r a lip
t} u! t
M
a
C
Y
[T
firr"
I,i
UI
Al
OJI
D
x]
�Y
N
rt
E
ds
C!
F�
E 4s
a
ul
1. ?�
UP 1]
Oh ill
L i
u
N 11
L
a-r
1 ul ,G1
L
,•.
b!r a lip
t} u! t
M
a
C
Y
�
firr"
I,i
L
4-
Ur
w
4,
1b
IL
Cl
11r
11
49
CL
$.
U!
i=
Ul
1.•I
++
q
NZ
T]
r�
Q
111
Vk
.w
4P
Jr
Ilk
l.J
UP
-+
'_
+I)
ih
.�
CLA
S
I—
L1
Ur
I'h
ds
C!
F�
E 4s
a
ul
1. ?�
UP 1]
Oh ill
L i
u
N 11
L
a-r
1 ul ,G1
L
,•.
b!r a lip
t} u! t
. �
a
Cit
2
�
1�
|]
■
E
k
$
Q
� ■
4jF
22
Li
kk
�
z
\ �
s
�
k
■
�
2
2
�
da
2
4
■
CP
it
§
[
k
)
¥
f
�
0
:
4PO
g
�
%
b
�
CL
■
13 do
4A N
§ lip
t
■
uk 17 LE
■
k �
_:
CL
CL
r
qlp
@
I �
■ �
% +0
2 ®
t
2 ®
&40
ap k .
93 § ƒ
CL
2 im
■
&L �L
fCL ■
cx
E
0
LP
4§
m
H
tp
al
Ic
_
2
■
k
is
�
�
�
�
)
-
■
ch
■
�
�
�
�
_
�
�
c
_
2
2
CL
■
2
G
k
�
,
�
�
0
�
�.
2
,
■
�
@
�
2
�
�
[
2 t
� ■
2
r �
k tp
/2
fo
f
2 E
_ .
® z a
k2�
&
Lp
13
{
�
k2
� o
2 LA
I �
■
|.
�
o �
2 o
Lo 19
�2
V ' &
f k
C Lot q
In is
wt—
��k
U 7�
■
cl
0-0
�
2
�2
L
�
:
Date September Elsto, Iggo
To Jack B■k■r Chr.,Dryden Town 24 A. p.
5 Krollwood Drive
Freeville New YorR
From Henry M. Slat
Town of Dryde
E5 E. Main St
Dryden, New Y
Sub.: ZoEinu VarlB
Dear Jack:
E, Zoi
r n ng & Building Code Erforcemere Offi=@
n
feet
oxk !3053
rice Agenda, for Oetob@r end -1990
please find lrelo5ed a copy of (!) application For Zorin§
Varian =o Hear-trig request*
7 =30 G@r u
eld Hoag i� reqC#tlnn permisGior to creAte a
non- EOnformir§ lot which will have 75 feet of road fr &a�aHe
as apposed to the Dryden Town zoning Ordin&rce requirm,ent
of !@S feet.
Sincerely,
Z �� "Slat r
CC n ±1 ^R @wbers of the Dryden Towr z. e, n.
Jean Ryan, Nee, See., Dryd @m Town Z. r. q,
Ithaca
SF=
PUPI..I51•1
Journal
Newq
Iatar4
1,23
I I
the
Wm
,hate
Str
Pmet
Ttf'Fkca
New
York
14P
yr,r
Fit t en Dizzinna C Irr, Legal Ads
PL-E
SF=
PUPI..I51•1
no
Iatar4
hi
I I
the
Ti�iwrr
cpf
DRYDE=N.
t ha rr WE!)IgEgDrIY EPTEMD R 26th, 7. `3 9 r_r And
PLEASE TARE NOTICE that tine 7r_�r,zr�g Hv:Far•d
of Dr'ydert w111 cl�irrdr_irt a p u b I is IIC-:ar•i
a p p I icAt iizirr of Oura18 Hi=ia ll of 571 Mze xrt st
„it }isciYr a V8k`i AnCp to Lmitahtls3h a rron�cinr,fizi
;LA t ,_ir. Atozziut 86 Lower Creek Road Etna wi.tpj 1.
.I. P5 feet 0f pF.AbI iC r- ;:id fri_intage and XtU
s9 to, tIon 75 1 Of the Dryden Town Zoning Midin
{rAID F♦F_ARIf wi i ,Z Fie
P, Mm prevai 1 arty *ane
Dryden I�lew� Yr,rnk apt
giver+ •rn IDF3pZIrtrar,itY
by agent.
hu I d o rr TLIE SDPY OC I
at the Dryden Towr-
wh i r%h t• i me all i nt
tcr tae heard. Pink Szn
Datad. SQpterrabern ti 1st, I9'1c)
Henry hT, S1a=mtter',
Ziziniriq Officer
Town of Dryden
i- ApPQals rf the Towri
r,rl t LC4ns1'.dnr tIrr..,
r e t Etna hje-vj Y�LgrIr -F,ci
r ruing rwQ ai.cjertiL i .
lass th;�ri the requi.r r-20
req�_ea; J.nq A v��r�i,m!�rrc:
anr_e to do scim
1113ER 2ND, 199 {_r A'r 7 • ,::;i
1.14111. 65 E. Main St9kNvov
€?r Qsted 1arsi.Dr, Will r,
rioty appeza r x rr pr'7 ^f;'ll!qr•, =:a r'•
9 TOWN Or UMEN
NEW YORK
AP LAL TO
BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS
TOWN OF DRYDEN
Having been dented permi ss i orr to
ko� LP t S n
At O Y1 . o ou.r 8 iz) Y . 4c a GCS
Dryden, N.Y. as
shown on the t1ccorrrrr;1nylrrg Ikppllc;ntlon and /or or other supporting (1c)cruoinnts,
for the stated reason that the lssumince vF srich per-rairt would be irf Vlol,-�tinrr of
Section or Sertlon(s)
- . _ f i} 3 J
c the Town of Drydeo 7Qnirig Ordinance
the UNDERSIGNED respectfully 50banits this appeol from sij�lh denial and Tt, 5i1P[xar1:
of- the appeal, affirms that Strict olaservancc or the Ordinance would iiiiPOSe
PRACTICAL DIFFICULTIES ; nmd /or UNNECESSAPY BARDSI.IIT' tns fnl lowr-q
cVe
I am.I1CJ�L
rwxv et.i 11 1
If you have additional supporting details of informs )tinrr9 Please atulch such
details to tills application an make rcrererrce to such klttachrnent.
I}1T1:D Dryden, N.Y. llpp iralit STgnatnre:
4z.2 z4VOI
Address : 4
Phone Muni bc r ;
Date
f
U-7,cl
A
til
I 1
I.. Aq part of a
agreed to split
a) She will
with 173.7
map) .
ZBOA Pg .
divorce settlement, my wife and I have
the property as f of to ws ;
retain the house and the land around it
feet of road frontage (A on the survey
b) I will get the 6,39 acres in lack of the house
{� on the survey map) plus the storage building and
some land around it with 75 feet of read frontage
(C on Ehe survey map). I Propose making this into
one large parcel.
Parcel A remains a conforming lot in all reapects.
3- Marcel C has a storage b1lilding On it which conforma
to all zoning ordinances.
4. Parcel B has no road frontage and
Present. This situation causes both
and economic hardship. The creat.aorn
access to parcel U, and would only be
F
s unusable at
Practical diff -iculty
of parcel C would give
used for such access.
�
I
�
�
}
I .
7
r
�/
— 1
\
LT �mj JNW ow.
by
/ P. q[ ®'
/;2±
b1� N\
f b
¥z(m;
\�|!
# �
, | /
\ | { } }
�\
�
..�
f f !
� f 2
N
� \
�(
! r•
rk
Ef� �
Ila
�
, L
LF
{
\ 2
w 2
k 2
)
,fvh�
�
,
+� p
#
ewe
[f
�
-4 12F
- }\
f�
�
! �
— �........ jy-ze\�
D \
f |r
Mk I v �{
/ �r
.
[ /
. \ !
�r�=
/ `
$
°
/.\ . .
,
� ..
. ..
�
�
�
,�j
. � ..
9� �.
/
��\� }
ka `�
■,
�f
1 9
/-
� ^
-�, rI
IF
k�@
@4�
« ` m
Km,
;\ [ &
IN,
/�
f/
Al
� | .
# \ h 2
7 kfm %
� ,
!■ F ° k
4 �
��-
�l
« r ¥ z
■:
�£
m�
�
m
�
,
,
0
,
' ms
t
�
/ Kpm r i
!
�
IF
\
.�
r |
IF IL
L
.!L
) f
! ;
/�
P
]
/
IF
\
�l
« r ¥ z
■:
�£
m�
�
m
�
,
,
0
,
' ms
t
�
/ Kpm r i
!
�
IF
\
.�
r |
IF IL
L
.!L
) f
! ;
/�
P
]
/
IF
\
�
|
\
r
�-=
P
/
\
r
J
.:
IF
--
_�
It
I
EI
I
.m
IIIIIP
..
y
r
IIIIIII
1
A '
n
t-
JJQep A,�t..
i jl
o LO a *
o
rl
JIt.aR
o•
1
ff •� ' � i .:
I %I w
t �. � �:•� 'off
aaIN2
adat �eUA 4 1�
/♦fore C1
t
3
J ~
a w
Z �
� � n
Ar
ko /Jn�ev
fI
• .l
p w _
1
I
of
Y�
1
r
o
tipw o
I
`f
tf
i
i
t I
,
r j
.r
, r
. r
:I
A FT
3.•s:
JO
So#if.
�• ' •� L�MYD.
� f i
L to
M.wv,Y/C yfl
1.
TOWN OF DRYDEN
ZONING BOnRD OF APPEALS
40 OCTOBER 21 19W
MEMBERS S PR£5E lT0 feting Chairman Dominic Bordonaro, Ann Everett
and Alan LaMotte.
Also present but not limited to: H. Slater, C. Cotteri,ll, Randy
Mail, David Russell Wallace} David Goyett, Harald Weiser, and
Howard Lelik, Joann Schaff and Gerald Hoag, applicant.
The
Zoning
Board
of
Appeals
Meeting
was
call
to
order
on
October
2,
1990
at 7:55
PM
by
Acting
Chairman
Dominic
Bordonar^o.
D
prose
could
membe
L
f a
t d pu
S(!7 us
edirrg
be h
r•s co
decis
blic
Sion ens
due to
eard ton
uld read
ion soul
Part icip
ued whethe
lack of me
i ght and d
the minut
d not be r
ation that
r to hear the case
mber�s being present
ecision adjaurned,
es in order to r*eac
eached tonight. It
the hearing would
One case was heard as follows:
HARDLO HOAGa
variance to
about 88 Lo
125 feet of
variance to
Ordinance.
of 571 Main Street, Etn
establish a nonconfor -mi
war Greek Road Etna with
public road frontage an
sections 753.1 of the Dr
Al N
n g )*
les
d is
yderr
e
eai
s t
re
Ta
nr� ad j Du
The m
until th
h a cone
was dec
be heard
Yo
de
ha
qu
wn
rk
nt i
n t
est
Zo
rn the
atter
e other
fusion,
ided due
.
to obtain ak
a 1 1 of at or
he required
ing a
ning
Acting Chair man 1). Bor~donaro read the public Notice as
published in the Ithaca Journal and flirther stated:
Having been denied perm
feet of road frontage a
New Fork as shown on th
or other supporting doe
i455LLance of such permit
fission to
t or about
e accompan
uments, fo
would be
The undersigned respectfully
denial and in support of the
observance of the Ordinance
and/or Unnecessary Harwdship
explanation and Survey map
create a
BB Lower
y ing appl
r the sta
in violat
lqt with less than 125
Creek {load, Ithatca,
ication and /ors plains
ted reason that the
ion of Section 753.1.
submits this appeal frDm such
appeal, affirms that strict
would impose practical Difficulties
as follows: See attached
The explanation is as follows:
El
40
E111
1. As part of a
agreed to split
a) She will
with 173.7
map)*
ZBOA Pg. 2
ON
divorce settlement, my wife and I have
the property as follows:
retain the house and the land around it
feet of road frontage (A on the survey
b) I will get the 6.39 acres in back of the house
(B on the survey map) plus the storage building and
some land around it with 75 feet of road frontage
(C on the survey map). I propose making this into
one large parcel.
2. Parcel A remains a conforming lot in all respects.
3. Parcel. C has a storage building on it which conforms
to all zoning ordinances.
4& Parcel B has no road frontage and
present. This situation causes both
and economic hardship. The creation
access to parcel B, and would only be
�I
is unusable at
practical difficulty
of parcel C would give
used for such access.
ZBOA pg. 8
OPENED TO COMMENTS PROM THE FLOOR
RANDY HALL. of 84 Lower Creek Road owner of the property nest to
the property in question stated he was here:
1.
To
clarify
Road
the notice he had received and to hear what was
being
trailers that when
proposed,
development.
2. His concern is that when he purchased his home he bought it
due to the property being in a rural area and hence forth he has
had a home built behind him by Mr. RLlssell and then the Hoags
built next door. A housing development is going in above his
property with at least 8 or 10 Domes and no one has ever
notified him of any of the development. He is concerned about
septic systems and water supply, which has never been great in
that area, and haw this will affect his property.
His privacy has also been affected and he is concerned whether
Mr. Hoag would ewer develop the piece of property with a housing
development} subdivision, as all of the property in question
adjoins his.
Wood
Road
has
trailers that when
told may be turned in to a
development.
He awns an acre of
land which shows as "Selover"
an
the
map.
Mr
an
we
wa
Pardon
y other
re grant
s not en
st becau
a
t
P
t
5
ro
Yp
do
L
t
e
explained th
e of variance
That becaus
led to develo
a variance ma
t procedur
which may
e a varian
pe the prat
yant ed.
e for subdivisions or
be requir ~ed if this
ce is granted the owner
perty any way he desired
Ann Everett asked why the property could not he divided on the
road frontage so that it did comply with the codex and to
descri be the land?
Mr, Haag answered that d�Le to an in ground swimming pool it was
not feasible for road frontage of la5l each. The land was
describes} as being an opened field with a hedipe row, swamp and
trees with a stream /pond located at the back of the property.
The Board reviewed the map.
Ann Evav4ett : Q. What do yaU intend on doing with the (7 acmes)
land?
G. Haag : A. Hi
do
D
f
la
s wi
esn'
ve h
r an
nd i
fe wo
t hav
im th
d som
s wor
uld like to purchase the house but
P enough money and has proposed to
t land which he needs a variance
e money. Without the variance the
thless_
++.. What do you intend t o do with it?
ZBOA Pg. 4
A. Possibly build a house. There is a place
® there now by the pond for the children.
(Cub— Scouts, chickens) He does not live
there.
iI1
C]
A.
LaMotte
at
asked
wanted was the variance. He
if
he
wanted
the variance
now in
order to
home
assure
him,
the
if
the
the
proposed
would
also
settlement was
agreed
on, that
he
would
have
for
legal
development
grounds
and
for
future use?
G. Hoag
answered
in
the
affirmative,
occur.
that
that
the
his
lawyer
had advised
him to
obtain
the
variance
before
doesn't
finalizing
to
see
the agreement.
land
developed
Joann
Schaff
at
also
wanted was the variance. He
stated
to
that
land and have his
without
their
home
as part
of the divorce settlement.
the
variance
the
the
property
would
also
be
limited
about
for
future
development
sale
and
if
it
should
to
stipulate
occur.
Mr.
Hoag stated
at
this time all he
wanted was the variance. He
intends
to
keep the
land and have his
wife buy out his part of
their
home
as part
of the divorce settlement.
DAVID
RUSSELL
WALLACE stated
he
owned
parcel
#45 -1
-29.02 shown
as
Coleman
on
the
map.
He
was
also
concerned
about
future
development
and
wishes
the
Board
to
stipulate
that
the
land
could
not be subdivided.
He
doesn't
want
to
see
this
land
developed
and
had
offered
to
purchase
the
land
from
him.
MR. HALL would /has offered to purchase in order to keep it
rural.
DAVID GOYETT speaking for CHARLES GOYETT, 17 Wood Road, was also
concerned about future subdivision.
HAROLD WELSER, has life use of 72 Lower Creek Road, was
concerned about future subdivision. Would not object to
single home being built.
also
HOWARD LILIK, 78 Lower- Creek Road, did not object to a variance
as long as it wasn't for a subdivision.
D. BORDONARO: He hasn't applied for a subdivision, so we can't
address that issue. We can't deny some thing he
hasn't applied for. He has applied to have a non
conforming lot for access so he could lay claim to
it and say he owns it. He would be free then,
with out further approval, to build a house once
he went through the proper procedure. Obtaining a
building permit, and assuming he conforms with
Health Department regulations for well and septic.
If he ever decided to subdivide or any thing else
he would have to go through another process for
approval. Right not it is for a single
residential lot.
III
ZBOA Pg. 5
There were not objections to a single residential lot.
HEARING CLOSED AT 8:30 PM
Mr. Bordonaro explained the procedure of deliberation and
decision, that the public was welcome to stay for the decision
or call the Zoning Office in the morning.
MEETING OPENED AT 8150 PM
MOTIONS AND DECISION MADE.
ATTACHED.
Respectfully submitted,
J.
C4�
)rding Secretary
Ed
NOTICE OF DECISION
TUESDAY OCTOBER 21 1990
A public hearing to consider the application submitted by GERALD HOAG of
571 Main Street, Etna, New York to obtain a variance to create a lot with
less than 125 feet of road frontage at or about 88 Lower Creed Road,
Ithaca, New York and is requesting a variance to Section 753.1, of the
Dryden Town Zoning Ordinance.
A public
Appeals
motion
hearing was duly
on Tuesday, October
conducted
2,
1990
by the
with
members
Town
of Dryden Board of Zoning
present: Acting Chairman,
Dominic
on
Bordonaro,
Alan
LaMotte,
and
Ann
Everett.
Hoag be granted the variance
without
FINDINGS:
UNDER PRACTICAL DIFFICULTIES AND ECONOMIC INJURIES:
1. The divorce settlement may or may not be accepted if the property
is divided and conformed to the law.
20 The
motion
land
made
is
currently
by
locked
Alan
Everett
on
all
YES
four
Gerald
A.
sides
Hoag be granted the variance
without
requested
access
unless
the
following
variance
is
granted
to
provide
such
access.
30 Granting the variance will not necessarily have an adverse affect
on the community as it stands.
A
motion
was
made
was
by
Ann
Alan
Everett
that
YES
(3)
Gerald
A.
Everett,
Hoag be granted the variance
as
requested
with
the
following
stipulations:
that a one family dwelling be placed on the acreage.
Second
to the
motion
was
made
by
Alan
LaMotte.
VOTE
YES
(3)
A.
Everett,
A.
LaMotte,
and D. Bordonaro.
NO
DECISION:
jr
(0)
VARIANCE GRANTED.
0
ABSTAINED (0)
Respectfully submitted,
9&"C
Dominic Bordonaro,
Acting Chairman
C
1
it
NOTICE OF DECISION
TUESDAY OCTOBER 21 1990
A public hearing to consider the application submitted by GERALD HOAG of
571 Main Street, Etna, New York to obtain a variance to create a lot with
less than 125 feet of road frontage at or about 88 Lower Creed Road,
Ithaca, New York and is requesting a variance to Section 753.11 of the
Dryden Town Zoning Ordinance.
A public hearing was duly conducted by the Town of Dryden Board of Zoning
Appeals on Tuesday, October 2, 1990 with members present: Acting Chairman,
Dominic Bordonaro, Alan LaMotte, and Ann Everett.
FINDINGS:
UNDER PRACTICAL DIFFICULTIES AND ECONOMIC INJURIES:
1. The divorce settlement may or may not be accepted if the property
is divided and conformed to the law.
2. The
motion
land
was
is
currently
locked
Ann
on
all
that
four
Gerald
(3)
sides
Everett,
without
access
unless
A.
LaMotte,
the
variance
is
granted
to
stipulations:
provide
such
access.
3. Granting the variance will not necessarily have an adverse affect
on the community as it stands.
A
motion
motion
was
made
by
Ann
Everett
Alan LaMotte.
that
VOTE
Gerald
(3)
A.
Everett,
Hoag be granted the variance
as
requested
A.
LaMotte,
with
the
following
stipulations:
that a one family dwelling be placed on the acreage.
Second
to the
motion
f
was
made
by
Alan LaMotte.
VOTE
YES
(3)
A.
Everett,
A.
LaMotte,
and D. Bordonaro.
NO
DECISION:
jr
(0)
VARITNCE GRANTED.
ABSTAINED (0)
Respectfully submitted,
Dominic Bordonaro,
Acting Chairman