HomeMy WebLinkAbout2010-11-03'1'13 I 1 -3 -30
TOWN OF DRYDEN
TOWNBOARD MEETING
AND BUDGET HEARING
November 3, 2010
Present; Supervisor Mary Ar111 Sumner, C1 Stephen Stelick, Cl Joseph
Solomon, Cl Jason Leifer, Cl 0,,, I rd
Makar
elc;cted Officials; Bambi L, Avery, Town Clerk
Supv Sumner opened the rneeting and PLLblic clearings at 7,00 p -rn- She distributed
and reviewed her 2011 budget summary. The value of tlte_ town's taxable propertY has
increased by 1,5%, Appropriations in the general funds are up 5A % and revenues are dav4 n
0,1 %- Appropriated fund balanuQc increased by 13.6 %. This wiII keep the tax rate stable- The
levy increased I. ' -
In the Fire Protection District, Supv Sumner said they struggled to keep the tax rate
c_ven with last year, but the Cre departments Have serious ad di IlionaI expenses this year,
Neptune needs spate- mandated bailout equipment- There are new bunker progroma in the
Freeville and Varna Fire Departments- The bunker programs Ore ;� %tep tovrard having people
available at all times to respond without actually having to pay their. They receive a p4we to
live at no ch;�rgc in exchange for signing tip for coverage shifts- A substantial amount of fund
banshee was used for fire depaT- twenl's and will not be able to be maintained in the future.
The town contracts with Dryden Ambulance, Inc, for about half their actual costs
Dryden Ambulanr e does charge for ambulance service. The ambulance h a % some paid staff.
The Town will also be contracting with Slate rville; Arnbu [an cc. They cover a portion of the
southweL% L area of the town-
With respect to special districts, Supv Sumner said Cortland Sewer and Varna WAI:e'r
are the only ones with �;ubstanHa1 increases- In some cases, additional expense %gas covered
with fund balance.
The increase u1 the general fund appropriations is about $300,000- S upv Sumner �;Oid
about $160,000 of that {Silt be going to capital reserves. Total salary hicreases amount to
about $26,000. The amount in the continguncy line is $70,000.001
Robert Jacobson, a resident of the Cortland road sewer district, thanked the board for
sending the postcards to residents in special districts this year- I•ie asked the Town Board to
make_ an effort to work vvi the, Village of Dryden to coordinate any actions taken with respect
to water. Supv Sumner asked Cl Stelick and Cl Solomon to schedule an initial meeting with
Village representatives, Supv Sumner explained there is old water line (From the late 1300's)
that nli3S e)LltSiejC the Village bnundaric � and serves property along North Street. The old line
keeps breaking and needs to be rep] a red I
Supv Sumnr_r %aid the Health Department is concerned with village water- quand1:v
r €,Ost. be good For two days when their best well is out of service, ar,d the their water source
doesn't meet that criteria. They also aging welter mains that need to be replaced and that.
can be quite cosilly- The Village and ToTan are talking about the past5ibility of forming a water
district tlial: includes the village and the Cortland Road Scwer District. The Town is developing
Ngu I c7I"5
TB I 1 -3 -1 U
a water
source on the
south side
of the Village 1lhot wquId serve
the Village's needs
and at that
level of
c_oopf' ration to
also serve
Cortland Road. This would be
a fomrard- 1'hin kin r,
solution,
A resident {,f the Meadow Drive f Leisure Lake Lighting Uistricll 1igked how the is rate
figured year to year aisd why there is fluctuation? Squpv Sumner and Cl Makar explained th(:
Town Heeds to raise enouSh revenue to pay the electric bill, make any necessary repairs and in
t5ome years there is an available fund balance_ A few years ago there were new poles and lights
added. The formula was also changed to a per unit charge from being computed on assessed
values. S upv S urn ner said there has been no policy for setting rates, but she is hoping for
better long range planning_
Each special district ho.s its own fund balance.
The Town's districts were formed at different times, and as debts are retired and
main tenanc ce in cm. ases, the Town will explore the pogsibi1ity and financial benefit of
consolidating some of the districts,
Items new this year in the budget include a Business Process Analysis and the land use
study in Voma, An equipment reserve fund was cstabli shed last year for Flighwoy and DFW so
those budgets should not see significant increases and dccreawes due to equipment purchases_
R Jacobson irtt�uWed about the charges to TC3 and Dryden Central School in the
Cortland Road Sewer District and Supv Sumner explained that their charges are pursuant to a
special agrcrTncnt with those entities. To get the amount to be levied on a district, they take
the amount required to maintain . {listzict, subtract the revenue from u: cage, and the
difference is how much is to be raised by taxes. TC3 pays a very barge usage bill and they also
own a lot of the infrastructure that serve; 1'.hcir facilities, including pipes, pumps and their own
water tower.
The {;o t of electricity in the Varna Lighting DisLriCC in 2009 was $3,429. DPW
estimates $3,000 for rnainl.<nonce in the Marna Sewer District- In 20109 they spent $1,000.
This year they needed a new sewer pump (expense tok(.;n from fund balance), and will replace
mother in 20111
Cl Makar noted that if a properi:y's assessed value has stayed 11he .same, their general
town tax should go down a bit,
Harold Simmons asked the board for a projected cyst. for infrastructure to accommodate
new housing in Varna. He has been told that. it. wi11 cost the town $1.25 for every $1.00 that it
collects in taxes. That figure comes from an Ohio Mate University study and includes all
services, not just special district_ Supv Sumner said that is a planning concept and she
dofCtm't have information to s0y how it would work 1n Marn a. . She told Mr Simmons tbat when
a new development puts additional demand on o district, the costs attributed to that
development will be borne by the developer,
RESOLUTION #151 - ADOPT SFZCL&L DISTRICT & AS,SESSMMMT ROLLS
Cl Makar offered the following resolution o.nd asked for its adoption:
RESOLVED, that thl& Town Board does hereby adopt the Special District and
Assessment Rolls for the Town of Dryden for 2011.
Rd Cl Stelick
41 Roll C,a1111ote
Cl Stelick Yes
Cl Solomon Yes
1' c2oi';
TO 11-3-10
upV Sumner Yes
Cl maka.r Yes
] Leifer Yes
RESOLUTION 0152 - ADOPT gall GENERAL BUDGET
CI Makar offvri d the following resolution and asked for its adoption.
RESOLVED, that: Chis Town Board hereby adopts the preliminary genonal budget as the
Town of Dryden's general budget for 201.l-
n" Cl teHrk
Roll Call Vote
Cl
Stelick
Yes
Ol
Solomon
Yes
Supv Sumner
Yes
Cl
Makar
Yep
Cl
[,eifer
Yes
RESOLUTION # 153 - ADOPT 2011 SPECIAL DISTRICTS BUDGET
Cl Makar offered the following re olw.ion and asked for its adoption.
RESOLVED, that this Town Board hereby adopts the preliminary special [1i 'k1'riCts
budget as the Town of Dryden's special districts budget for 2011.
2 ",' O] Stelick
Roll Call Vote
Cl
stelick
Yes
Cl
Solomon
Yes
Supv Sumner
Yes
Cl
Makar
Yes
CI
Leifcr
Yes
The nc:w paper
published the
legal notice
for
the fire
contracts
incorrectly. li:
ha,d to be
rep ob]ished, and that
public hearing
veil] be ]geld
[November
10 at 7:00
p -m-
On motion made, seconded, end unanimously carried, the board adjourned to e3cecui:ivu
session to discus% o matter of current litigation a1: 7.55 p.m. and returned i1n m.gulay- session at
SL I() p -m.
RESOLUTION #134 - RESOLUTION ON APPROVAL OF PROPOSED SETTLEMENT OF
FIRSTENEROY V. CITY OF ITHA A
Cl Makar offered thc following resolution and asked for its adoption;
WHEREAS, , in 20095 the City of Ithaca was narned as a third -party defendant in a
lawsuit initially involving VirstEnergy Corp, (FirstFnergy) and N(. -w York State Electric & Gas
Corp. (NY m
EG), regarding liability for the cost of remedia6on of containation at property in
the City of Ithaca referred to as the First Street Sife, which is now the location of the Ithaca
Area Wastewater Treatment Facility (IAVdTV) and owned by 1:he Towais of Dryden and Ithaca
and the City of Ithaca; and
Puye 3 411`5
TB 11 M3_ 10
WHEREAS, in the lawsuit: against the City, Firsl'E riergy seeks contribution from the
C:ily, under the federal Comprehe, ive Pnvironmental Response , Compensation and Rccovm
Act (OERCLA - a strict liability statute) for any financial liability FirstEncr&y May be found by
the Court to have, for said contamination and rernediation; and
WHEREAS, the site in question was the location, frorn approximately 1929 until 1934,
of a manufactured gas plant operated by KY 60 and/or FirstEner v, Arid a by- product of such
gas manufacturing is coal Isar, now known to be a hazardous substance; and
WHEREAS, the City obtained the site in question from NYSEG in 1959, and, in the
1980s, in collaboration with the Towns of OTyden and Ithaca, constructed the IAWTF there;
and
WHEREAS, during excavation for said construc6on, large quantities of coal tsar and coal
tar-contaminated soil were discovered below I.he ground, and were treated in :a.ccordance with
L
nstructions frorri NYSE;G and the NYS Department of Environmental Conservation, including
storage on -site for over 10 years prior to removal and disposal by MY PC - and.
WHEREAS, the Town of Orydea, Tawas of Ithaca and C;il:y of Ithaca entered into an
°Agreement As to Legal Defense Costs and DaTLFLa es (if any) Associated with a l,awsuit AgEdnst
the City of I thaca Regarding the Jthaca Area Wastewater Treatment. Fad Site'; and
WHEREAS,
the [ally retained
Menter, Rudin
$& Trivelpiece of Syracuse, New York,
special coungcLl, to
provide
a defense
in this mat.lx.,r,
and
W14ERI }A , a motion for suinmarV U dgrn(rnt dismissing the case against the City was
recently denied by the Unitcrd .States District Court, on the grounds that there were questions
of facie as tjo whether the construction of the IAW'f F and the treatinent of the contamination
discovered during that process in some way exacerbsW.d the contamination; and
HERSAS, L5pecial co tinsel, its consultation with the City, the Towns of 1]r }Eden and
Ithaca and IAWTF representatives, negotiated a proposed settlement of this matter, which
settlement is recommended by special counsel, the C;i1'.v Anlorney, and the attorney for tho
Town of f ryden in order to limit the legal costs and to avoid the risks and urilnr >ns of treat
(and potential appeals),
NOW, TI•I]EREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED THAT the 'I own [hoard of the Town of ]Dryden
hereby approves the settlement of the case of PirwtEnera v. the City of fthac;o, et al, prodded
such settlement shall include the following terms1 paiym<rnt of $200,000 to First Ener y, by or
through the City, in ten (10) equal, annual payments of 20,000 eia eh (i,e., with no interest),
together with a release by FirstFnergy of the Town of Dryden from any and all further liability
for the con ts�mination or remediaYtion of the first Street Site; and be it further
RESOLVED, that the Towai Board hereby authorizes the Supervisor, upon the advice of
the Attorney for thy Tow17, to execute all agreements and other documents which may be
necessary or desirable to implement the settlement referenced herein, and be it further
RESOLVED, that the above - described payments shall be made from fhe appropriate
account(sj of the IAWTF, accordin g to the terms ref the "Agreement A,L5 to Legal Defense Costs
and Damages (if any) Associated with a Luw%quit Against the City of Ithaca Rcgarding the Ithaca
Area Wastewater Treatment Facility Site' dated bec6,mber 29, 2009.
2n4E C1 ,Solomon
0 Roll Call Voile Cl Stelick Yes
Cl Solomon Yes
pqp 4 1wr 5
Eg ±
Sam Sumner Yes
Cl daka Yea
cl b;f r Yea
There mg rofurther bu s in e ,nn moti on niade, seco nes d an 4 unarm mouaU ramie%
the meeting was adjourn 18 p.m,
Rr,pec±m2 5mit ,
4U Ba L Avery
Town Clerk
Q&,«S
Tc"n of- Dryden
Town Board Meeting
November 3, 2010
-\ Y) C) 0 �.(,A
k��/Cde cohf��a��-
Address or Board
Zs9 04\
jle��ZO4
00) /)/- Me
Name
- Please
Phnt
-\ Y) C) 0 �.(,A
k��/Cde cohf��a��-
Address or Board
Zs9 04\
jle��ZO4
00) /)/- Me