HomeMy WebLinkAbout1993-01-19"TOWN BOARD MEETING
PUBLIC HEARING
Convenience, Store 750 Fall Creek Rd
.JANUARY 19, 1993
Supv Schug called the meeting to r. trder at E%s 45PM
Supv Schug read the notice that was published in the newspaper
('.111ricerning the appl icat ion, f� Ir a coriveriience str.ire at 750 Fall
Creek Rd. (cI Dpy in minute book.)
QUESTIONS ANI) /OR COMMENTS
Richard Devine, 767 Fall Creek Rd. - he lives across the road
f ri.- +m this prl.jposed convenience st r.1re. There ' was a 1 r.1t .1f traffic
when the pizza sti:ire was there. With a ci.Dnvertience stare there
will be a lot r +Hare traffic involved. He is nc1t sure what he
intends in set l ing there, but if there ire any alcoholic is beverages
connected with i t q we do riot need that. 'There ere i s a g e r.1d store
already i n McLean now. He felt t hat we . did not need a place f• •r
the kids to hang arljund. He did rent think. arn.1ther store was
necessary since it is r.in l y 3 miles t Dryden and a l l kinds of
stores. There are a lot of people that use this highway between
Cortland and Ithaca because it is shorter er arid is ci.ingest ed in the
m orning with the wi.Ir.k traffic and the schor.11 buses.
Kenneth Roc-iney - there has been a traffic study cOLUrit on that
• highway and has been rated for 370C.) cars a day. If the
convenience sty Ire appl icat ir. in is appri.Ived they wiJuld be applying
fc.1r a 1 a.'Gui.- it license. They wi.Juld expect tr.1 have operating hours
that wi.Juld fit within the community. In the winter time they
wO U 1 d be c l i.ised by 9 e i OPM on most days. In the surnmer time
possibly 1 (') u 00PM and that would be mostly on Friday and Saturday.
As far- as people hanging around in that area, they are there now.
It might be something that will be inherited, but is nothing that
he has created.
Richard Devine -- since the pizza parlr.lr has closed they do not
have the kids hanging around any ri1r.ire.
Kenneth Ri:_icnney
had. However,
he
as a
is .aware
bus i
ness
rif
man
the
it
is
reputatir.in
riot
the pizza
his interest
parlor,
t i.i create
Anyone
a hangout. He
C� art 1 an(I area
runs
arid
hie
several
is
c� imm
other
i t t ed
ncnt
cl.Dnven
t rJ
i ence
that
prof
stores
ess i
in
r.ina 1 i
the
sm where
while
ever he gees.
He plans
r.oln i.iffering
a
service
to the
community.
Why shy iuld the
residents
have
to
g� �
t� � Dryden,
Cr.irt
land,
Freevi 1 le i �r Ithaca
tr. 1
get
gas.
They
plan
:,n
selling
gas
at
the
convenience and
deli
store.
Richard
Devine
- they
dr.1 not
need
gas in
the village.
Anyone
that
travels
are
there.
to
these areas
He dr.ies
ncnt
is going
want
tr.1
gas in
get
the
their
village
gas
of
right
McLean.
while
they
al.
SPECIAL PERMIT REVIEW
App irant : K %enneth L. Rooney K John CooDe.r� _ Date: Dec.
Otion:__Reo v� i_ Exist in __Conveni�ent_Stor,e iroc1�UdingSa1e of Gasoline for
Motor, Vehicles.
Sites 750 Fall
Creek.
Road. near h arti l et of
McLean,. NY
Zoning District:
RB
1 Hearing Date:
19th, 1993
Submitted
to
County
on:Review by:
_January _
Henry M. Slater
Sect i in 1303, SPECIAL PERMIT Req •_t i rernent s Review
1) . Name of the applicant, name of business and legal owner of the
property /premises.
—_
Supplied See 1/3 3/3 attached, 2). Has a property survey map or o=lt her legal descr i pt i on of premises been
provided?
_ SuDDl iedoSee attached drawings 1/3, 2/3 K 3/3.
3) . Has t he applicant provided a detailed description of proposed used use which
includes, off street parking, read cuts, and other site uses relative to
project ?____All such facilities are preexisting, and have been reviewed_
by the Beard for the�Tcseph_Allirgton hearingfor a similar use which_
was approved on 11/13_/90. _� - -- — - --
4). Has a sketch of site and site improvements been supplied?
— . - Althou h sketch is somewhat lacking in exact detail. I believe it is
adeg!_iate for review of a^prio�r approved Ilse. _
•. Is Sewage disposal and water supply facilities existing or proposed
and permitted by what means?
Preexist_inn with No changes prop =osed or rreegUired.
6) . Has applicant provided a description of current Uses of the premises
adjacent to the project site? Yes, copy attached.
7). Has applicant provided a general statement appraising the effect of the
proposed project and use on the adjacent properties, the environment and
future deve 1 opment of the neighborhood and community in general? _
S�= �niewh t,genera b +_tt does make an attemp±.t�Li.sum u the positive aseect
o f t h e
8)m Applicant has provided copies of all permits or application for sl_tch
permits required by all other local, state or federal agencies necessary
for this pryIject. Special Permit is now being applied for..App_licant
w 11 r,ecguire e_ fo od permit which has been applied f• =or.
C•= vnments or r_oDncerns: A Special Permit for this project site for the
same use _was ?ppri::ved by— the _I)r� den Town Board can 11/13/90, Copy attached._
The only .difference is rna_pi ^_a Or s�_ibs and sandwiches. Applicants also
sj_tggest „__that they__wc �!_ild..L_ in times install nasol ire service. Gasoline would
be a__perArqitted use within _an_(RB —I) Zone, if a neighborhood service which it
would be in the McLean area. Such _insta11at ions _ar__e Under the sIA ervis_ion
of DEC. Syracuse. NY. _
Henry M. Slater
Town Pyard Members
Mahlon Perkins, Town Attorney
George Schlecht, Engineer
Jean Barrett, Tompkins Co r= 'lanning
TOWN OF DRYDEN i DRYDEN, NEW YORK
65 EAST MAIN STREET, DRYDEN, NEW YORK 13053
807444 -8120 In the Heart of the Finger Laker Region
0NING & BUILDING CODE ENFORCEMENT
•
December 29, 1992
James Schug, Dryden Town Supervisor
E5 East Main Street
Dryden, NY 13053
Re: Special Permit Application Form.
Dear Jim:
I've completed a preliminary review of the above mentioned
applicaticin and find that application sufficiently complete to
forward that appl icat iori, all sUppcirt ing documents and my review
comments to you and the beard for your review.
At t
P 1_i b 1
need
ester
reca
his t
is Hp
ncp 1
bIish
1 1, F,
irne, I'm asking th
wring Date for thi
ess than (2) weeks
a hearing date pr
:45 PM JanUary 19
at you and the be
s application P1
lead time from t
icir to that heari
1993 was I
lard determine a
ease keep in rn i nd, we
he time that you
rig. As you911
and t i rnee
s_iggested as a possible date
All concerns that I have determined are listed on the attached
comment and review form,
If y111_I shc�I_I 1 d have any questions, concerns or desire further
detail, please feel free to contact me as necessary.
Very truly yours,
, A ot) L . //)/I, ) 4�-
Henry
y Slater
Zoning R- BUi lding Cade Enforcement Officer
cc: Town Beard Members
Mah 1 i_in R. Perkins, Dryden
George Sch .l echt, Engineer
Susanne Lloyd, Dryden Town
Town Attorney
Clerk.
I
I
i
i
APPLICATION, FOR
SPECIAL PERMIT
0 TOWN or DRYDEN
DRYDEN, NEW YORK
MAIL OR BRING TNIs FORM
T0: Town Clerk
Town of Dryden Special Permit No
Dryden, New York Application date
Parcel Number
Zone
Appltcation is hereby made to (Build (], Extend [J, Convert
A Structure located at S� F r, n u, r) r%\
To be Used for
Owner or Land
If Construction
Name
c.
q
,.
Is for other than present Land Own er S o
_" o_
Tire Structures) will be as follows:
Type of Construction r C,
Number of Stories
Number of Units
Type or Neat _n
`T - --
umber or Baths
Square Ft. Floor Area:
Basement
First Floor
Second Floor
Over Second
Town of brydon, Now York,
_ At a Cost of
Builder
cling Address V(
rlequired Permits Obtained . Date
Tompkins County health Dept.
town Clerk:
Street Opening
Blasting
Supervisor:
Water Tap
Sewer Tap
Ifiphway Supt:
Culverts
Driveway
Bldg, hrspector
Multiple tte�idence
The Undersigned applies for permission to do the above, In accordance whir all provisions or r2egulations of the Town o► bryden, New York, or others Iravin p rs of all Laws
"rents and information given herein are correct to the best or his belief,
and affirms that ail state.
Date of hearing z 9�
SIGNATUn
Date of Advertising 3
Fee Paid Advertising ,�
AUDitESS _
Special Permit Approved .
Oc"I Permit Denied
Under Article XIII of tine
Zoning Ordinance.
PHONE N0.
ry `�
I
I,i Kenneth ►�cx�n E .. -, �- ,c�1 -gin Cc�(�e�
Ij
c'` -� 2uver 0 C�cmerl� ��1 1; n( lorf)
; n e C,_ tee, -Its, ��c��,c:•l n e_ c�. `� 1
� r,47>>' cIL-40 e � -)G )v I 00 _
\ea3L-A\�,
0 � L-
�c.���
c"k
.,
•
0
CD�
✓��� ltd tee- -�.,e ���� l
WIM
cZ a�
l�
,_W..
14 -16 -4 (2187) —Text 12
PROJECT I.D. NUMBER
817.21
Appendlx C
State Environmental Ounlity givlew
SHORT ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT FORM
•
For UNLISTEb ACTIONS Only
PART I— PROJECT INFORMATION (To be completed by Applib8nt t5r Prolect sponsor)
SEQR
1. APPLICANT /SPONSOR
2. PROJECT NAME
Kenneth Rooney & John Cooper
Reopen Existing Convenience Store
3. PROJECT LOCATION:
Municipality Town of Dryden county Tompkins
4. PRECISE LOCATION (Street address and road Intersections, prominent landmarks, etc., or provide map)
750 Fall Creek Road Freeville, NY near the Hamlet of Mc Lean NY
A site plan is attached to project package.
5. IS PROPOSED ACTION:
❑ New ❑ Expansion ElwOdif Ication /alteration Prior Approval Granted 11/13/90
6. DESCRIBE PROJECT BRIEFLY:
It is our desire to reopen under new ownership what was Allington's
Pizza, Subs and General Convenience Store within the same site and
structure. We also desire, in the future,.to install fuel tanks
and provide gasoline service to the Mc Lean Area.
7. AMOUNT OF LAND AFFECTED:
Initially N/A acres ultimately N/A acres No Changes are proposed,
8. WILL ACTION COMPLY WITH EXISTING ZONING OR OTHER EXISTING LAND USE RESTRICTIONS?
�PROPOSED
y
Wes ❑ No If No, describe briefly
IL
9. WHAT IS PRESENT LAND USE IN VICINITY OF PROJECT?
DResldentlai ❑ Industrial ❑ Commercial Agriculture ❑ Park/Forest /Open space ❑ Other
Describe:
10. DOES ACTION INVOLVE A PERMIT APPROVAL, OR FUNDING, NOW OR ULTIMATELY FROM ANY OTHER GOVERNMENTAL AGENCY (FEDERAL,
STATE OR LOCAL)?
UYes ❑.No If yes, list agency(s) and permitiapprovals
Special Permit by Town of Dryden To prior Owner 11/13/90
11. DOES ANY ASPECT OF THE ACT; ''N HAVE A CURRENTLY VALID PERMIT OR APPROVAL?
Yes ❑ N . 11 yes, !ist acency name and permit /approval If gasoline service is included,
a Permit from NYS DEC Syracuse will be required prior to tank
installation.
12. AS A RESULT OF PROPOSED ACTION WILL EXISTING PERMIT /APPROVAL REOUIRE MODIFICATION?
KxYes ❑No Prio"fi10wnerS?S ecial-:;Per.mitctEx 0i'red:
ais Required.
I CERTIFY THAT THE INFORMATION PROVIDED ABOVE IS TRUE TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE
Applicant /sponsor name: Date: 12/11/92
Signature:
I If the action is In the Coastal Area, and you are a state agency, Complete the
• Coastal Assessment Form before proceeding with this assessment
OVER
1
P
i
i
I
i
t..
t
a
L 0
•
l •
•
s .a 1
dw
i
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Sler � �- n ' • `�
.♦ s
I 1 w 1/'�••+ I
. J, :11-
o..
-a
• v
•
O W Y\
I
i
AL
�• • �•
.� eve fampop
`: v r.. op.w'
•� g a
34y -Gross %uCA ve ��ea G QveaL.
G r u S S � /cb� � rC'o.
Gvoss larK spare re / 5 40
p °1
I .
Iu
•0
.Q
a
a.
Oak
f �s.
f; `?
is �. ;•�:� � "•.`� ,�•.��1•� �I
f•
so
• l� A/ i �f
sue.
r
u
I n
W
PJ
u
1
k
i�
t
A%
H
Joss
1..
.
;;.- .. it
to
me
$o 0 \ so. so III's *0010
40, so
cn
,O
1
. f I
so 4
sm
,1
i •
go
a
•
0
•
i
,
0
r
8
i
0
v G
I}
r
r
F,
r!
,l
a�
a
iA
a
mr."O JO NA101 16 107 !O 3N17
/,Qo/
o4U
r
o'o
Du+
h
X
m
T 1C , �av3svq acv. ,vya
r�
o,
I I
h O
N
ft
�O
O
� �On
200,,
/3
0
•
r.
N
Cd
Y
O
� a
Z �u
O 04
'O V)
Cd
Cd
O *�
3
O
U
En
.�
X
E-•
H
w
a
w
0
d
4-J
a
v
L
z
H
z
O
a
d
H
H
a
AIJ
•rA
r-4
to
-ti
E
wi
0
4mm-
3
0
H
a�
-d
A
N
3
z
PO
IE
r�
Fw
GN
Oh
cn
cn
Ir
N
6
C1
N
cad
A
U)
N
O
s
1"+
0
G
b
G
0
r4
0
r4
co
41
U)
.o
a
d
En:
•r4
En
d
O
. VM4
0
a
r`
v
n
m
t�
co
fu
b
.r+
w
n
a.
r-4
9A
d
r\
v
n
cc
1
c
O
a
x
G
O
•ri
1J
�o
ayi
0
0
co
r-+
a
H
r-i
r�
rn
b
H
G
co
t�
ul
.c
u
�o
r4
G
0
a
rn
r-4
.r4
u
r.
O
z0
N
cu
ro
cn
w
a
r4 I
r-4
.r♦
�u
a,
u
y
«f
•r�l
.O
a
U
.0
N
G
0
a�
c
i
d
TSi -19 -93 page 2
. Kenneth Rcnoney - car- L- inderst and his concerns about traffic flow
and n• -rise that might be created. Studies show that most people
shop closer to home. He is committed to work with the neighbors
if there are any pri -1b l ems, and ncit let this become a hangout like
it was for the pizza parli -Jr. He has never Seen a better place to
put gas in, because there are two entrances and/or exit's to this
1 I -Icat i on.
Clm
Roberts
i cat ed
to the
federal
Fie w
- wanted
hOUght
have to
tie
to the
to
know
if
ready
he was asking for approval of a
gas
station
building.
with this
application.
Kenneth RN oney - this
that this was a separate
go through DEC, arid all
qovernmental agencies
would still like the
is a long cgImp l
entity, due
of the state,
for their regulations.
co riven i ence store.
i cat ed
to the
federal
Fie w
process. Fie t
fact that you
and local
Without gas,
i l l. co me back.
hOUght
have to
tie
to the
board
when
he is
ready
for
the
gas.
building.
Clm Rt.- lberrts - was concerned about the parking if there was a gas
station there.
Kenneth Ro r.1ney - there is plenty NDf parking in the lot. He works
for United Refininq that service [:uik Fill arid Red Apple. There
is more parking space there then s� ime of the other locations that
they have.
Clm Roberts - wanted to know what he intended for hours of
operat ion.
Kenneth R• ucNney - tentatively E-, s i aC;AM Mon. t hru Fri. and 7 s C )C )AM orl
Saturday and Sun. In the winter time cli -king Mon. thru Thurs.
9 s tat PM and 1 U s C)C)F'M or, Fri. arid Sat. and 7 s C) PIM on Surf.
Clm
Rol-.1ney --
Robert
s . -
wanted t o kni-.1w if he was doing any rent -1vat i ons
within
l IDr was<
He
would call it
the
s work.
building.
Kenneth
Rol-.1ney --
They
plan on using
the, same rJut
1 i ne that the
Pizza par
l IDr was<
He
would call it
mr.1re c,Dsriiet i
s work.
Closed 'public hearings 7sUC)FM
o`I
N
i
i
P
•
•
TBI- 19 - -93 Flage
PUBLIC HEARING
JANUARY 19, 1993
ZONING ORDINANCE AMENDMENT
S,_lpv Schug called the meeting to order at 7oUOPM
Supv Sr_hug read the rn.it ice that was published in the newspaper
concerning the Zr on i ng ord i nar-ice amendment. (ccipy in minute book )
QUESTIONS AND /OR COMMENTS
Alan
there was
On the other
pry �pcJsed.
would be
Dclbson,
Etna.
that.
interested
Lane - wanted to knew if there was any shortage
age
of
changing
RD
the
or
area
leaving
land
in
the
if
as
town?
Z.O. Slater - he thciught it would be a matter of i opinion.
.. 7p . - wanted to knc �w whc� was requesting this zr.ining change?
Supv Schug -- back. in September Mrs. Prj-,chazka who c1wns the land,
but does not live in the tc1wn requested the change' so that she
might be able to sell her property. When the request came up the
Town Beard referred it to the Planning Beard for their review.
'The Planning Beard saw n� t prc lblenl with the change.
Graham DcIbson, Etna Lane - wanted to kric1w what the original
request was for the zciriing change.
Supv Schug -
lot rezi-Ined.
is nc •w being
E=tna Lame arid
there was
On the other
pry �pcJsed.
would be
a request
This
considered
by r.jne person to
side of Kirk Read is the
i one lot •t ri..lris between Kirk
spot zcin i ng and
have their one
same zone that
Road and
we try riot do
that.
interested
The
neighbors
in
changing
in
the
or
area
leaving
were
the
asked
zone
and is represented
if
as
they
it is.
wi-Juld
be
Marjorie Dobson - when the zcining was changed years ago from RB
tt- RB1 r,lany people in the cr.mmupity took part in- going door to
door. Mulch thought went into, the rezr.tning arid she can see no
reason for changing it. Right now on Etna Lane it is qUiet where
people can walk with their children and ride bicycles. The more
traffic that would be generated would certainly be a detriment.
:[n the immediate area that vou want to rezone, yciu canric it forget
the I.C.)o families that are living in the me ibi le h� Mme park. They
c�Y'e part of ciffr' cc�rllrll�_ll'llty.
She is opposed tr. this zoning change.
Dr. Walter
this prc1pc
Baurle,
used
ciwns 20 acres
change. The r.a.4iner of
or, the
the
south side
8 acres
that
c If
requested
Rt 13 of
the
change lives
in
Maryland
and is represented
by
a
real
estate
agent in
a number
Dryden
of years.
who
has
This
unsuccessfully
absentee
r_Dwner
tried to
and local
sell
rea
1
her
estate
land for
C 3
�f.
I
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
ZONING ORDINANCE AMENDMENT
TOWN OF DRYDEN
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that the Town Board of the Town of Dryden
will hold a public hearing on a proposed amendment to the Town of
Dryden Zoning Ordinance. The proposed amendment is as follows:
Section 401
of the
Town of Dryden
Zoning Ordinance as last
amended is hereby
amended
as follows:
The public
"Section 401. All land in the
within one of the established zones as
Town of Dryden shall fall
shown on a map entitled
"Town of Dryden
Zoning
Map" originally prepared by Egner and
Niederkorn Assoc.,
Inc.
and last revised
1/19/93.
The area to be effected by such change is more particularly
described as follows:
ALL THAT TRACT OR PARCEL OF LAND situate in the Town of Dryden,
County of Tompkins and State of New York, bounded and described as
follows:
BEGINNING at a point marking the intersection of Kirk Road with New
York State Route 13; proceeding thence from said point of beginning
westerly and along the centerline of New York State Route 13 to its
intersection with the centerline of New York State Route 366,
proceeding thence northerly and northeasterly along the centerline
of New York State Route 366 to the point of intersection of said
centerline with the centerline of the abandoned Lehigh Valley
Railroad property; proceeding thence along the centerline of the
abandoned Lehigh Valley Railroad property in a generally easterly
and northeasterly direction to a point in the centerline of Kirk
Road; proceeding thence in a southerly direction along the
centerline of Kirk Road to the point or place of beginning, which
includes the following Town of Dryden Tax Parcel Nos. 44 -1 -11.2;
44 -1 -12; 44 -1 -13.3; 44 -1- 13.412; 44 -1 -13.5; 44 -1 -17; 44 -1 -18; 44 -1-
21.1; 44 -1 -21.2; 44 -1 -21.3; 44 -1 -21.4; 44- 1-2291; 44 -1 -22.2; 44 -1-
27.1; and 44 -1 -27.3.
This amendment shall
take effect after publication and
as
provided by law.
The public
hearing on
the proposed amendment will be held
at
7 : 00 o'clock P.
M.1 prevailing time at the Dryden Town Hall,
65
East Main Street, Dryden,
New York on January 19, 1993, at which
time interested
parties will
be heard.
Susanne Lloyd
Town Clerk
CJ
MAHLON R. PERKINS
December 22, 1992
MAHLON R. PERKINS, P C.
ATTORNEYS AND COUNSELLORS AT LAW
20 WEST MAIN STREET
P. O. BOX 27
DRYDEN, NEW YORK 13053
James F. Schug, Town Supervisor
Town of Dryden
65 East Main Street
Dryden, New York 13053
RE: Proposed Zoning
Etna Lane, Route
Dear Jim.
Enclosed is a copy of
by the Town Board at
will note that I have
parcels Henry Slater
Change Area of Kirk Road,
13 and Route 366
a proposed resolution which can be
its year end meeting on December
revised Schedule A by adding three
thought should be included.
TELEPHONE
( 607 ) 844-9111
considered
29. You
additional
By copy of this letter I am forwarding another copy of the Notice
of Public Hearing to the Code Enforcement officer, Town Clerk and
Town Engineer adding the three additional parcels.
If you have any questions,
Very truly yours,
Mahlon R. Perkins
Town of Dryden Attorney
please give me a call.
MRP /lm
Enclosure
pc:, Susanne Lloyd, .Town Clerk (w /copy
` ''!ate otry �r `d Enfclrcemen
(w /copy of Notice of Public
George Schlecht, Town Engineer
(w /copy of Notice of Public
0
of Notice of Public Hearing
t'70ffT-Cer '^
Hearing)
Hearing)
• NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
ZONING ORDINANCE AMENDMENT
TOWN OF DRYDEN
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that the Town Board of the Town of Dryden
will hold a public hearing on a proposed amendment to the Town of
Dryden Zoning Ordinance. The proposed amendment is as follows:
Section 401 of the Town of Dryden Zoning Ordinance as last
amended is hereby amended as follows:
"Section 401. All land in the Town of Dryden shall fall
within one of the established zones as shown on a map entitled
"Town of Dryden Zoning Map" originally prepared by Egner and
Niederkorn Assoc., Inc. and last revised 1/19/93.
The area to be effected by such change is more particularly
described as follows:
ALL THAT TRACT OR PARCEL OF LAND situate in the Town of Dryden,
County of Tompkins and State of New York, bounded and described as
follows:
BEGINNING at a point marking the intersection of Kirk Road with New
York State Route 13; proceeding thence from said point of beginning
• westerly and along the centerline of New York State Route 13 to its
intersection with the centerline of New York State Route 366;
proceeding thence northerly and northeasterly along the centerline
of New York State Route 366 to the point of intersection of said
centerline with the centerline of the abandoned Lehigh Valley
Railroad property, proceeding thence along the centerline of the
abandoned Lehigh Valley Railroad property in a generally easterly
and northeasterly direction to a point in the centerline of Kirk
Roads proceeding thence in a southerly direction along the
centerline of Kirk Road to the point or place of beginning, which
includes the following Town of Dryden Tax Parcel Nos. 44 -1 -11.2;
44 -1 -12; 44 -1 -13.3; 44 -1- 13.412; 44 -1 -13.5; 44 -1 -17; 44 -1 -18; 44 -1-
21.1; 44 -1 -21.2; 44 -1 -21.3; 44 -1 -21.4; 44 -1 -22.1; 44 -1 -22.2; 44 -1-
27.1; and 44 -1 -27.3.
This amendment shall take effect after publication and as
provided by law.
The public hearing on the proposed amendment will be held at
7 :00 o'clock P. M., prevailing time at the Dryden Town Hall, 65
East Main Street, Dryden, New York on January 19, 1993, at which
time interested parties will be heard.
• Susanne Lloyd
Town Clerk
1
I
i
I
1'r- I V'L kAJU0 f -- 0 1.
811.21 SEAR
Appendlx A
State EnvlronmOntel Quality Ravlow
FULL ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT FORM
,e: The full EAF is designed to help applicants and Agenciet determine, in an orderly manner, whether a project
..;
Prepaied by Proj6d Oonsot
NOTICE: This document is designed to assist in determining whether the action proposed tTiay have a significant effect
on the environment. Please complete the entire form, Parts A through F. AnSWert to theta questions will be considered
as part of the application for Approval and may be subject to further verification and public review. Provide any additional
information you believe will be heeded to complete PArts 2 and I
1is expected that completion of the full EAF will be dependent on information currently available and will not Involve
w studies, research or investigation. If Information requiring such additional work It unavailable, to indicate and specify
each instance.
NAME OF ACTION
�f Eze wit/ - - 70
LOCATION OF ACTION (Include Street Addres , Municipality and County)
r
NAME OF APPLI`CANNTISPONSOR BUSINESS TELEPHONE
ADDRESS
CITYIPO
NAME OF OWNER (II dllle(ent)
ADDRESS
CITYIPO
ST
STATE I ZIP CODE
BUSINESS TELEPHONE
STATE ( ZIP CODE
3
DESCRIPTION OF ACTION oger Z �G
�r3 "e- .
Please Complete Each Question— Indicate N.A. if not applicable
A. Site Description
Physical setting of overall project, both developed and undeveloped areas.
1. Present land use: OUrban lndustrial [6ommercial residential (suburban) ORural (non -farm)
C
uForest ?Agriculture ?,Other
2. Total acreage of project area: ��'?'� acres.
LY AFTER COMPLETION
I
APPROXIMATE ACREAGE PRESENT
— acres /5/ acres
Meadow or Brushland (Non - agricultural) acres
acres
Forested / acres
ides-�r
Agricultural (Incitchards, cropland, pasture, etc.) 666
ares acres
c
Wetland (Freshwater -or tidal As per Articles 24, 25 of ECL) -�� acres . 7� acres
Water Surface Area acres
Unvegetated (Rock, earth or fill) acres
��� acres 3 acres
Roads, buildings and other paved surfaces _ Acres Z acres
Other (Indicate type.
3. What is predominant Soil type(g) on project site? .>/,r' % of site
a. Soil drainage: OWell drained �_ % of site DModerately well drained _..—
OPoorly drained % of tite
b. If any agricultural land is involved, how many acres of soil are classified within toil group 1 through 4 of the NYS
• Land Classification System? acres. (See 1 NYCRR��3770/0). .
4. Are there bedrock outcroppings on project site? Yet L7No
a. What is depth to bedrock? v✓ (in feet)
2
i
I
5. Approximate percentage of proposed project site with "slopes: 0-10% ___lt7,L gy ❑10 -15 % %
1115% or greater %
6. is project substantially contiguous to, or co►}tain a building, cite, or- district, listed on the State or the National
Registers of Historic Placest OYes o
Is project substantially contiguous to a site listed on the ReglO& of National Natural Landmarks?
What is the depth of the water tablet (in feet) LO f, 4:5"
9. Is site located over a primary, principal, or sole source aquifer? GYes ?0100
GYes
10. Do hunting, fishing or shell fishing opportunities presently exist in the project area? OYes l�fVo
11. Does project site contain any species of plant, or a
OYes ONo According to
Identify each species
010
!#e thatis Identified as threatened or endangered?
12. Are there any unique or unusual land forms on the project iite? (i.e., cliffs, dunes, other geological formations)
CYes L�flo Describe
13. Is the project site presently used by the community or neighborhood as an open space or recreation area?
Dyes uNo If yes, explain
14. Does the present sitp include scenic views known to be important to the community?
CYes En o
15. Streams within or contiguous to project area:
a. Name of Stream and name of River to which it is tributary —
16. Lakes, ponds, wetiand areas within or contigu? to project area:
a. Name -iP/l �a�✓y�
b '
. Slit .(In Atres)
17. Is the site served by existing public utilities? El 'ei CVo
a) If Yes, does sufficient capacity exist to allow connection? Rfes `=No /
b) If Yes• will improvements be necessary to allow connection) CYes :rNo ����✓��+'
18. Is the site located in an agricultural istrict certified pursuant to Agriculture and Markets Law, Article 25 -AA,
Section 303 and 304? OYes t�o
19. Is the site located in or substantially contiguous o a Critical Environmental Area designated pursuant to Article 8
of the ECI. and 6 NYCRR 617? OYes Vo
20. Has the site ever been used for the disposal of solid or hazardous wastes? OYei 2100
B. Project Description Z, �-
1. Physical dimensions and scale of project (fill in dimensions as appropriate)
a. Total contiguous acreage owned or controlled by project sponsor acres.
b. Project acreage to b4- developed: acres initially; acres ultimately.
c. Project acreage to remain undeveloped acres.
d. Length of project, in miles: (If appropriate)
e. If the project is an expansion, indicate percent of expansion proposed 96;
f. Number of off - street parking spaces existing ; proposed
g. Maximum vehicular trips generated per hour (upon completion of project)?
h. If residential: Number and type of housing units:
One Family Two Family Multiple Family Condominium
• Initially
Ultimately
L .Dimensions (in feet) of largest proposed structure height; width; ~ length.
J. linear feet of frontage along a public thoroughfare project will occupy ist ft.
3
d
2. How much natural material (Le., rock, earth, etc.) will be removed from the site? tons/cubic yards
,0
3. Will disturbed areas be reclaimed? OYes ONo ON /A
a. If yes, for what intend.. purpose Is the site being reclaimed?
b. Will topsoil be stockpiled for reclamation? OYes ONO
C. Will upper subsoil be stockpiled for reclamation? OYes ONO
�. How many acres of vegetation (trees, shrubs, ground covert) will be removed Front site? acres.
5. Will any mature forest (over 100 years old) or other locally- important vegetation be removed by this project?
Oyes ONO
6. If single phase project: Anticipated period of construction months, (including demolition).
7. If multi - phased:
a. Total number of phases anticipated (number).
b. Anticipated date of commencement phase 1 month year, (including demolition).
c. Approximate completion date of final phase month year,
d. Is phase 1 functionally dependent on subsequent phases? OYes ONO
8. Will blasting occur during construction? OYes ONO
9. Number of jobs generated: during construction ; after project is complete
10. Number of jobs eliminated by this project
11. Will project require relocation of any projects or facilities? OYes ONo If yes; explain
11. Is surface liquid waste disposal Involved? Oyes ONo
a. If yes, indicate type of waste (sewage, industrial, etc.) and amount
b. Name of water body into which effluent will be discharged
13. Is subsurface liquid waste disposal involved? CYes nNo Type
4V'YVill surrace area of an existing water body increase or decrease by proposal? CYes ONO
Explain 0
15. Is project or any portion of project located in a 100 year flood plaint Oyes ONO
16. Will the project generate solid waste? OYes ONO
a. If yes, what is the amount per month tons
b. If yes, will an existing solid waste facility be used? OYes ONO
c. If yes. give name ; location
d. Will any wastes not go into a sewage disposal system or Into a sanitary (andfillt OYes ONO
e. If Yes, explain
17. Will the project involve the disposal of solid waste? Oyes ONO
a. If yes, what is th#.&ticipated rate of disposal? tons /month.
b. If yes, what is the.anticipated site life? years.
18. Will project use herbicides or pesticides? Oyes ONO
19. Will project routinely produce odors (more than one hour per day)? Oyes ON0
20. Will project produce operating noise *Oxceetling the local ambient noise levels? OYei ONO
21. Will project result in an increase in energy use?
If yes , indicate type(s)
Oyes ONO
22. If water supply is from wells, indicate pumping capacity gallons /minute.
0 Total anticipated water usage per day gallons /day.
24. Does project involve Local, State or Federal funding? OYes ONO •'
If Yes, explain
4
'i
Submittal
' type Date
City, Town, Village Board 934es ONo 1,.N ,rJE,it/7 ' Tp %s/, 400
City, Town, Village Planning Board OYes ONO
City, Town Zoning Board (]Yes ONo
city, County Health Department Oyes ONO
Other Local Agencies Oyes ONO
Other Regional Agencies OYes ONO
State Agencies Oyes ONO
Federal Agencies OYes ONO
C. Zoning and Planning Information
1 . Does proposed action involve a planning or zoning decisiont QYes, ONo
If Yes, dicate decision required:
`-' oning amendment Ozoning variance ❑special use erm'
p it Osubdivisiori Osite plan
Inew /revision of master plan Gresource management plan Ooiher
2. What is the zoning classification(s)of the sitet
3. What is the maximum potential development of the site if developed as permitted by the present zoning?
d. What is the proposed zoning of the site?
5. What is the maximum potential development of
AOO AaL407 ( Fwy7dvsr6
site if developed as permitted.by the proposed zoning?
5. Is the proposed action consistent with the recommended uses in adopted local land Use plans? Cfes
•What are the predominant land use(s) and zoning classifications within a Y. mile radlus of proposed action?
ONO
8. Is the proposed action compatible with adjoining/surrounding land uses within A ' /., mile? fees ONo
9. If the proposed action is the subdivision of land, how many lots are proposedt eVW
a. What is the minimum lot size proposed?
10. Will proposed action require any authorization(s) for the formation of sewer or water districts? OYes 210
11. Will the proposed action creatt'� demand for any community provided Service4 trecreation, education, police,
fire protection)? Oyes LO
a. If yes, is existing capacity sufficient to handle projected demand? Moll ONo
12. Will the proposed act4n4eiult in the generation of traffic significantly above present levels? OYes No
a. If yes, is the existing road network adequate to handle the additional traffict Oyes ONO
D. Informational Detalls
Attach any additional information as may be needed to clarify your project. If there are or may be any adverse
impacts associated with your proposal, please discuss such impacts and the measures which you propose to mitigate or
avoid them.
E. Verification
I certify that the information provided above is true to th best of my knowledge.
>p 7
Iicant /Sponsor Name ���.� ..iP Of Date ✓y/ 9 %�
Sloture �
o Title�JrcTi .i ii ✓���� /�✓EEir
If the action is in the Coastal Area, and you are a state agency, complete the Coastal Asie'""Ment Porm before proceeding
with this assessment.
.� 5
FOR
C1
D I AL
f, L
a
WMAI IC
•
•1
►.
IP'e`. d
pf;N
Al
U
,m
Kr3NI% I . tou;
c N ID N
g c Q an
U
J
U
U
C
CD
O
A; �IV373vqrl
V46
1�
cb
O
4 —
1
R
i11
I 2�0
G
v � i
c 3
� r
e
N I I
Ono
i
J
U O
� C
L
� O
N U
cf
N
c e
c sr.
i
I
J
=ID i
�IDQ«
�i-
.� s J I I
� U J
e
qo,
I
Q T sv
wi 'w; css
� C 4
� U
Q I
C
AID tTi
a Y I
~ &.
man
�y
w o 7
I O
J
U
_Q
_o
c sell !-
CP
i
y
i
t-
W G
. ®.
A�
N
n
4!
lam
T
AAJ
Q
V7
I
I
I
�J
CLO
r.
TI
C
v
O
N
a
o
E-
=
00
000
3
ch
D
O
d;
O
i
C
U
�
v
co
ca
oD 00
tn
O
rn
c�
m
o
N
O
i
JJ
N
ti"
O
"0
4;
O
O
1.r
Q;
�.
4
—�Ucl.
lam
T
AAJ
Q
V7
I
I
I
�J
J
3 August 1992
is i AUG — 6 1992
Town Board, Town of Dryden
Mr. James Schug, Supervisor
65 East Main Street
Dryden, New York 13053
REr Request for a zoning change from R -B4 to RD on 8.9 acres +
Tax - Map- Number 444-27.3, owned by Fiances Hazell Prochazki
Dear Mr. Schug, and.Members of the Boards
The subject pareel of 8.9 acres ± fronts on Route 13 betkeex Kirk Road
and Etna lane being part of the real property purchased by my father and mother
from the Kirk family in the late nineteen - twenties. My parents, Cyril Eben and
Frances Penniman Hazell, lived on the property until their respective deaths,
and I was raised in the house they built on "Airy Acres." After my father's
passing in the Spring of 19800 the real property came to me, and I have tried
to market the property since that time.
The parcel of 8.9 acres + on which I in requesting the zoning change
to RD has been on Multiple Listing as well as listed with the Pogtzline Agene y
for ten years. During these several years this eorner property has not been
attractive to residential buyers, other than individual lots for trailers. The
site has been attractive to buyers for commercial uset indeed, the only serious
offers I have received have been from such buyers. One such prospective buyer
went so far in the process as to apply for a Variance about two years ago, which
variance was denied. This action is hard for me to understand since a variance
was granted on the Route 13 frontage just aeross Etna Lane from the subject
8.9 acre f parcel.
It is my understanding that the land fronting on Route 13 was changed
from RD to R44 in the earl$ seventies, and that no residential building permits
have been requested along this stretch of Route 13 since that time. Taking into
account- the prospective widening and up- grading of this part of Route 13 by the
State in the near future, it seers even less likely that residential buyers
will be interested in building homes on this parcel'of 8.9 acres t , situated
as it is adjacent to an RD Zone and Flanked by a commereial user just across
• Etna Iane.
E
I
r
•
Town Board, Town of Dryden 3 August 1992 pg.2
In conclusion, I ask that you give my request for a change of zoning
from R -B4 to RD on the subject parcel of 8.9 acres f , Tax- Map- Number 194 -27.3,
your favorable consideration= and respeetfully suggest that the change from
R -B4 back to the RD Zoning of the seventies would be a more realistic approaeh
to successfully marketing the 8.9 acres + at this location on Route 13. My
father always felt that the Route 13/Etna Lane corner was a natural for commercial
use, and it would be good to see it cleaned up and in use again, rather than the
overgrown, forlorn and unwanted appearance it now presents.
E
Mrs. F. H. Proehazka
Box 313, Owings Mills,
Maryland 21117
0
Sincerely,
U 0C )6-A
.r
i
Finger Lakes Land Trust
-4 P.O. Box 4745
7° Ithaca, New York 148524745
C
... working to, conserve the natural integrity of the Finger Lakes Region.
January 17, 1993
Town of Dryden Planning Board r iowv, -8e4„d
Henry M. Slater, Zoning and Building
Code Enforcement Officer
65 East Main St.
Dryden, NY 13053
Dear Mr. Slater and Members of the Dryden Planning Board5tA,a i Lnv-, 7.�odA
On behalf of the Finger Lakes Land Trust, we would like to express our concern about
the proposed zoning amendment adjacent to our Etna Nature Preserve.
The Etna Nature Preserve would certainly be negatively affected by commercial or
large scale residential developments in the area proposed for rezoning. Of special importance
to the Preserve are the lands just to the east of the Preserve, and the possible negative effects, -
on the two waterways flowing through the Preserve from the area proposed for rezoning. The
Preserve is heavily used by the Etna community as well as school and college groups and
citizens from a wide area. We feel that it is important to keep the Preserve in as good
condition as possible so that future generations will be able to enjoy it as well. While small, as
it currently exists, it is nevertheless surprisingly rich -in plants and wildlife. The trails are
heavily used by people wishing to experience the tranquillity and the variety of life that
• currently characterize it.
At the present time, there is a corridor of less intensely developed land along Etna Lane
that connects this land to undeveloped land on the south side of route 13. Changing the zoning
as proposed would - effectively separate the less developed areas to the north and south of route
13. Such habitat fragmentation is a recognized cause of the alarming loss in biological diversity
that we see happening today. This, too, could have a negative impact on the_public preserve.'
The current zoning of the area requires a variance procedure for more - :intense uses than
those permitted in R -131 zones. This process gives the community an opportunity to directly
influence land use decisions that would affect them. The proposed changes would remove that
level of public participation. While Site Plan. Review might alter a proposal that met the new
zoning regulations, it could not prevent it all together since such a use would now be allowed.
For these reasons, we urge you not to make the proposed change in zoning. Thank you
for your consideration.
Sincerely yours,
John Wertis, President
Carl Leopold, Founding President
Betsy Darlington, Director of Land Protection
SnC��Vyy
[Representing the 14 Boarl Members and the membership of about 500]
•
0
JAN -19 -93 TUE
James W. Hanson, Jr.
Commissioner of Planning
14:31
rot ll9 of yHr!/'4.gll.p
to
oo
;� to P. �iS ICb,ptlt
DEPAI�` I NT :'.0 E NNING 111 �. '1'' �
f 1!S!
Diggs luloid t� A,, 3�.� pals �Qal a nrivc
,.
k , 1 0Br
January 19, 1993
Mr. Henry Slater, Zoning Officer
Town of Dryden
65 E. Main Street
Dryden, NY 13053
Re; Zoning Review Pursuant to §239 -1 and -m of the New York State General
Municipal Law
Action.: Rezoning of 164 Acres from R -B -1 to R -D.
Dear Mr, Slater;
P. 01
Telephone
(607) 274 -5360
This letter acknowledges your referral of the proposal identified above for review and comment by
the Tompkins County Planning Department pursuant to §239 -1 and -m of the New York State
General Municipal Law.
After a thorough staff review, the Department has several concerns with this proposal, including
the impact of the rezoning on traffic, the environment, and community development, The
department concludes that the proposal, as submitted, will have a significant deleterious impact on
both County and State resources and facilities. The Department's particular concerns under §239 -1
and -m are the traffic impacts of the proposed rezoning and the limitations of the soils for the type
of development proposed. The Deparrtment's concerns with the proposed rezoning is outlined
below_
Truk: The resulting development from the proposed rezoning may negatively impact present
traffic circulation and safety along Route 13, Route 366, and Kirk Road. Presently, there are sight
distance problems at the intersections of Route 13 and Kirk Road, .Route 366 with Kirk Road, and
Route 366 with Route 13, therefore, an increase in the traffic load may augment the number of auto
incidents. Because of these conditions, traffic should be directed onto Etna Lane when possible.
For example, the driveway cut for parcel 27.3 should be located on Etna Lane,
• The proposed rezoning would increase residential and commercial traffic on Route 13,
necessitating improvements to that highway, including measures for additional capacity, signals,
and a lower speed limit. The implementation of a traffic circulation plan and access management
techniques could mitigate these impacts on Route 13. For example, to minimize curb cuts on
Route 13, the driveway for parcel 11.2 should be located on Route 366 instead of Route 13.
•
lJ
JAN -19 -93 TUE 14:32
P.52
Environment: The Planning Department has four concerns with this proposal in terms of its affect
on the environment. First, this is a Type I action under the State Environmental Quality Review
Act (SEQRA), therefore, Parts 11 and Iii of the Full Environmental Assessment Form (FEAF) need
to be completed. The proposal entails a change in the allowable uses within any zoning district
affecting twenty -five or more acres (see Environment 1 Impact Review in New Yolk, Benders
New York Practice Theory, 1992).
Second, the Etna Bird Sanctuary, a Unique Natural Area (UNA), adjoins the subject area. The
department and the Environmental Management Council do not have specific information on the
composition of this UNA. You may wish to inventory the area for significant vegetative cover,
species, and other enviromux�entally sensitive components prior to approving a proposal for
rezoning or development.
Third, more than three quarters of the subject area is composed of wet soils or marshy conditions,
and because of this land is less suitable for higher density residential and conunercial uses.
This area should not be targeted for these purposes. Also, there is no water or sewer service
available to these properties, and no extension is likely in the foreseeable future. Since these soils
are poorly suited for private sewers, iutcreased costs will be incurred for more sophisticated septic
systems designed for these conditions, Finally, Federal wetlands and State Department of Health
regulations would either prohibit development in much of the area or significantly add to the cost
through more. expensive disposal systems (see attached map).
Finally, the answer to question fifteen under Section A on the FEAF indicates that there are no
streams in the subject area. According to the maps enclosed for our review and based upon a site
visit, there are at least two streams traversing the properties proposed for rezoning.
Community Development: The Planning Department commends your survey of property owners
adjacent to the subject area. we are concerned, however, that the Town might rely on the
acceptaitce of this proposal by a small population of residents. The results of the survey may not
indicate the sentiment`of the community as a whole, which will be affected by the proposed zoning
change. Finally, we 'recognize that this proposal furthers strip development along Route 13 and it
is not a logical extension of the Etna community.
Aside from the §239 review, I hope these comments are constructive for your planning purposes.
If you have any continents or questions, or if you would like staff assistance on some of the
technical aspects mentioned in this review, please give me a call at 274 -53600
s .Hanson, Commissioner
•
CI
MAHLON R. PERKINS, P. C.
ATTORNEYS AND COUNSELLORS AT LAW
20 WEST MAIN STREET
P. 0. BOX 27
DRYDEN, NEW YORK 13053
MAHLON R. PERKINS
December 22, 1992
James F. Schug, Town Supervisor
Town of Dryden
65 East Main Street
Dryden, New York 13053
RE: Proposed Zoning Change Area of Kirk Road,
Etna Lane, Route 13 and Route 366
Dear Jim:
TELEPHONE
( 607) 844 -9111
Enclosed is a copy of a proposed resolution which can be considered
by the Town Board at its year end meeting on December 29. You
will note that I have revised Schedule A by adding three additional
parcels Henry Slater thought should be included.
By copy of this letter I am forwarding another copy of
of Public Hearing to the Code Enforcement Officer, Town
Town Engineer adding the three additional parcels.
If you have any questions, please give me a call,
Very truly yours,
Mahlon R. Perkins
Town of Dryden Attorney
MRP /lm
Enclosure
pc: Susanne Lloyd, Town Clerk (w /copy of Notice
Henry M. Slater, Code Enforcement Officer
(w /copy of Notice of Public Hearing)
George Schlecht, Town Engineer
(w /copy of Notice of Public Hearing)
the Notice
Clerk and
of Public Hearing)
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
• ZONING ORDINANCE AMENDMENT
TOWN OF DRYDEN
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that the Town Board of the Town of Dryden
will hold a public hearing on a proposed amendment to the Town of
Dryden Zoning Ordinance. The proposed amendment is as follows:
Section 401 of the Town of Dryden Zoning Ordinance as last
amended is hereby amended as follows:
"Section 401. All land in the Town of Dryden shall fall
within one of the established zones as shown on a map entitled
"Town of Dryden Zoning Map" originally prepared by Egner and
Niederkorn Assoc., Inc. and last revised 1/19/93.
The area to be effected by such change is more particularly
described as follows:
ALL THAT TRACT OR PARCEL OF LAND situate in the Town of Dryden,
County of Tompkins and State of New York, bounded and described as
follows:
BEGINNING at a point marking the intersection of Kirk Road with New
York State Route 13; proceeding thence from said point of beginning
westerly, and along the centerline of New York State Route 13 to its
• intersection with the centerline of New York State Route 366;
proceeding thence northerly and northeasterly along the centerline
of New York State Route 366 to the point of intersection of said
centerline with the centerline of the abandoned Lehigh Valley
Railroad property; proceeding thence along the centerline of the
abandoned Lehigh Valley Railroad property in a generally easterly
and northeasterly direction to a point in the centerline of Kirk
Road; proceeding thence in a southerly direction along the
centerline of Kirk Road to the point or place of beginning, which
includes the following Town of Dryden Tax Parcel Nos. 44 -1 -11.2;
44 -1 -12; 44 -1 -13.3; 44 -1- 13.412; 44 -1 -13.5; 44 -1 -17; 44 -1 -18; 44 -1-
21.1; 44 -1 -21.2; 44 -1 -21.3; 44 -1 -21.4; 44 -1 -22.1; 44 -1 -22.2; 44 -1-
27.1; and 44 -1 -27.3.
This amendment shall take effect after publication and as
provided by law.
The public hearing on the proposed amendment will be held at
7:00 o'clock P. M., prevailing time at the Dryden Town Hall, 65
East Main Street, Dryden, New York on January 19, 1993, at which
time interested parties will be heard.
Susanne Lloyd
• Town Clerk
a�
TS1 -19 -u Rage 4
agent have a primary interest in making this change because it is
their interest in the absence of selling the land ti_i make some
better effcir�t. Their idea is changing the land ti�i FAD. will make
the land moire saleable. What we are really doing is initiating a
movement that effects local peiiple far the benefit cif a Maryland
resident and a.Dryden real estate agent. He is cippcised to this
change.
Carl Lei_ip =:gild, Fiit_!nding President cif the Finger Lakes Land Trust
they own the Etna reserve that is adjacent to -this proposed
'change. Fur,ct icirt of . this reserve depends upon the water. It is �
the riiar h quality that riiak.es it attractive as a nature reserve.
Without the marsh and clean water there it wi- it_!ld be useless. To
soften the zci'rtinq regt_!irernents cif the prciperty upstream would be
very detrimental and he would urge the board not to change the
restrictions that exist in that area.
Betsy
Darl
ingti gin,
Directcir
t any demand for ecimrirerc i a 1 lot-1 bt_!t
There was no req uest for a
cortimerc
i
c jf
Land
f
Protection - -read a letter to
the
board.
(c:
~cipy
- the request
in
minute
book)
Kermit C'arscirts, 1604 Dryden Rd. - he would think that the
Plarininr Bciard shciuld. be looking at this plan to see if there was
any justification for this ch arig e t ci rein marc i a l. It seems to him
frcim c ibservat icin aver the years that generally speaking zc.1ning
ordinances prciv i de much rncire commercial land then can ever be
used, and shcit_!ld not be controlled by the real estate market.
• There is an. encirri7i=it_ls articit_!rtt of commercial land alcing cit_!r roads
and this is one of them. Anyone that wants c.cimmercial land Should
ricA have any trouble in finding parcels that are perfectly
adequate f� i t their _se m The best _se for this l and , particularly �
frcirti what yc U have= .just heard fr ^iarn the Finger' L_Gak.es Lartd Tr�!sat,
is for . more ripen Uses which doesn't provide more traffic cir riiore
runoff and dries rn_it destroy the quality of the naip+_!ral area
adjacent tci it. Hie ti-hi.nk.s -Maybe a certain artlot_!nt of planning went
into enlarging this, but on the negative side, it is a response
to a requec.t t- sprit veining. An individual parcel cif land that j
someone wz.--krit s t ci sell for ccirtimerc i a.1 use and -the response inse i s t �
enlarge it,
Dr.
.jt_!st
Bat_!r l e,
a hope=
- there
tci ,sell
wasri'
the Iarid.
t any demand for ecimrirerc i a 1 lot-1 bt_!t
There was no req uest for a
cortimerc
i
a l
t_cse for that
land=
C,t_!pv
Scht_!g
- the request
was for less restrictive zcining.
Kermit Warsciris - there is, rtli.ire than . enough corilrtlerc i a l l y zoned
land in the general area. There are already commercial areas with
vacant owned stores. He would reci_irtrmend that the town caref t_! 1 ly
study the zcining to see if there are not mcire areas that are
improperly Ported ccimmerc i C:i 1 land that shi.„it_! l d be cut back to
residential zcined 1A. rid. He we it_!.ld go the either way.
•
n
U
TBI- 1`3 -93 Page 5
Laura Stealer, 147 Hunt Hill Rd. - is a member of the Finger
Lakes Land Tri_kst and she suppcirts the letter that was written to
the town bi -Jard and is c ippo sed tc j any zoning change in that area.
Susan
Schwan,
577
Main
St ,-
her
land
abuts
to
this
zoning
change
and is
developed
against
lets
this
have
prcipcised
a
read that
change.
can
If
handle
Rt
13
this
is
going
traffic.
tc# be
Right
now it
located
is very
there.
dangerclus
What
Cayuga
tizzi
Crushed
even
walk
Stc one
on
Etna
or
who
Lane
ever
with
it
Sery -Rite
was there
before
has left
a legacy
cif
.junk
that
will
probably
be
there
forever
and we
have
to
live
with
that.
Lets
be
cauticius
about
what
daily
we
basis
give for
and
perm
are
i
very
ss i c in
much
as our
a
clZimmunity.
neighbors.
She
We
is
live
cipposed
t
here Carl
to this
a
z oning
change.
Diane Tessag1ia, 8 Etna Lane -
was because of the residential
Ithaca is 'a massive commercial,
of Dryden would want that to ha
little secticin intoi light comme
sense of community and sense of
opposed tc. 1 the zc 1ning change.
the
type
stri
ppen
rcia
res
one reason she m ived
community. On Rt. 1
p and did not think
here. Even turning
1 zone criuld take aw
ident ial atme.- sphere.
to Etna
South of
the Town
this
ay the
She is
'Ted Sandquist, 1609 Dryden Rd. - he supports everything that has
been said a-rid is opposed to the change.
Alan Dobson, 21 Etna Lane - the propc ised zoning change cuts
across his property. He wishes tr.1 cippi -.1se this change on two
grounds. First it moves the commercial area from ,just over 100
0
yards from the center of Etna and now it is more like c one half a
mile. If yC,11.1. do this there is n o chance cif them getting peciple to
buy 1 arid to develop in this area. The sect ind point is cane from
him perscorially. He was ccinsiderim _In building a hi_Ime tizzi retire
in can his prc ipert y and he will ric it do so if it is zoned
commercial next tci hire. He is cinly ccinsiderirrg this at this time,
but the action today will determine whether he carries -.in with
his plan or not.
Supv Schug - the person that wanted tc i buy that 8 car 1C.) acres
wanted t ct put in a ! 1.sed car show rocim and put in a read cut on
Rt. 13. The town has no cc intrizil cif rciad cuts over the state
highways but the town bciard would not allow the special permit
unless the applicant had his access fri-Drn either c;ne of the side
roads Etna Lane car% Kirk Rd. Rt 13 is dangercius ern ugh as it is.
The town board has no vested interest in changing this zone. We
were requested to take a 1 ook at it and it was by a local real
estate agent and a person why 1 lives clot cif town. If the neighbors
and the pec iple whc, live here dr.:ln' t want it, then the town board
a�
'FB1 -13 -93 Flage 6
is not giving to change it. Yrziu have to remember that changing the
:er.ining does open up the pciss.ibi 1 ity of more light crimmer•ciai.
There is ronthing the town board can do under the existing zoning
if homes are built on the priW1perty that is there. Two family and
single family homes which are allowed, but will create more
traffic and carp pollute because irif the septic systems. There is
n� � guarantee !try 1 ess you want to � keep it i:: ipen and wild forever
that you give the land ti_i the Finger Lakes Land Trust or the
people in the area get t• 1gether and purchase the property.
Graham Dobson, Sig Etna Lane - is opposed to this zoning change.
He has built his house there knowing that the land around him was
lDned residential and aro-. 1t her business wi -Du 1 d riCit be allowed
there. With this change it has been moved closer to Etna rather
than keeping it along Rt. 137. There have been twi -.1 requests for
variances at the r.11d Cayuga Crushed plant and have been turned
down twice by the Z oning BrDa.rd of Appeals which is a go od
indicat ic- in we dr.- in' t want that type of business there. The
businesses that they keep trying ti.- i put in there are riii:: ire [_If the
large truck. plants. No rz ine has tried to put in something like the
Plrudential building which looks nice. On both sides of Etna Lane
is very marshy and New York State has passed sizime laws to pri.-it ect.
the wetlands.
Pieter Hr.1pper, 1621 Dryden Rd. - is opposed to this zizining change,
because this property is a woriderf!1.1 piece i-. 1f property for
wildlife.
Rick plarlett - wi.-indered if the trailer park
contacted abr.iut this zi-ining. There are at 1
will pri_ibably be there all their lives. The
with, this zrining change. If the town beard
zoning, these people shiDuld also be contact
people and will be affected by this change.
change.
people were ever
east 1iO renters and
y shc-iuld be co:� idered
di.- tes change the
ed because they are
He is c. ipposed to this
Russell Schaff - Etna Lane - is -ippi_1sed to this change. He can
riot see C-Any benefit ti-.1 the pi_Issible rezE_Ining to any members of
the community 1Dr the quality of the land in the area. The only
potential benefit would to be to the 1 andk -1wner why i does riot live
there.
Nina Hopper, 1621 Dryden Rd - is opposed to the change and also
her neighbor Felecit_y Gage of 1611 who is linable to c- tttend
tomight s meeting is also opposed to the change.
Judy Auble, 620 Main St. Etna - is also r. 1pposed to this change.
Greg Smiley - 461
in that area.
Main St. Etna -- is
r.1ppcised
to a.n_y z1:: 1ning change
Dr. Baur1e was
concerned abr.iut the
quality
c-if the land and the
runoff for water.
He was ippi::ised to the
z oning
change.
•
•
TB I - 1?1-133 Page 7
Pam Kellogg, 2 Kirk. Rd. - is also oppr used to the zoning change.
Supv Schug - thanked everyone for coming and gave the town board
a very definitive mess'age as to � the feeling of the neighborhood.
Closed pl_tbl is hearing o B0 1opm
Susanne Lloyd
Dryden "'own Clerk
I
1
I
�I
I
t