HomeMy WebLinkAbout2011-03-29® Town of Dryden
Conservation Board Meeting Minutes
March 29, 2011
tMembers Present: Nancy 'Munkenbeck, Steven Bissen, Milo Richmond, Charles Smith, Bard
Prentiss, Stanley Marcus, David Makar, Bob (last name), Peter Davies, Craig Schutt
Additional Staff Present: Katie Stoner, Jane Nicholson
Agenda:
I. Agenda - Additions, deletions. adjustments.
2. EMC Update
3. Old Business —
a. Sustainability Report'A community snapshot' -Katie Stoner
b. Open Space Plan - report from Jane Nicholson
4, Town Board Update - This is an opportunity for the Town Board liaison and/or tile'1'own Supervisor
or other Town Board members to address the Conservation Board.
5. New Business:
a. Aquifer protection plan
Nancy: Call to order at 7:30pm
Any changes to the agenda- no changes
EMC report- no changes
Community Snapshot - what developed as a sustainable inventory
Sustainability Report
Katie: Sustainability Presentation
® -brief overview of what datasets are available and what we'd like to do in the future
- looking forward feedback to set goals and create recommendations that will lead to an
action plan
- questions regarding comp plan (an update to it)
Goals for implementation?
Katie: meant to identify gaps in research; the data is not complete, more observational trends but
used to facilitate action
- overview of those general trends (demographics, economics)
What's
the difference between
household and family
income?
Katie:
There's a footnote in the
report describing the
difference
Are these from the 2010 census?
Katie: No, had to use existing in order to move forward
Clarifies that this is existing data sets, not primary
Is this an unusual percentage- that 44% of workforce employed in Tompkins County`?
Katie: Clarity that this is a Dryden percentage
® This should be clarified; question of who the 44% Includes and where they are working
C
Katie: Concludes chat the rn ajority is working outside the Ccnnty- so this number may not work
Comment about transportation on Route l 3 in the morning
Questions regardirig the Geographic area that the school district represents
Crime has to be over a certain time period- can't be over the lase century
Katie: to look into it (the time period)
What healthcare resources do we have specific to the Town of Dryden?
fancy= Doctor Claypack- (sp? }- Dryden laamily Medicine might be ably to help
Katie; I evie of environmental indicators
need a measure oI' how much CO2 crnissions is corn i ng from hoLtsing (burning of woods, Fuel,
etc_); can NYSCG tell you how many units they arc providing heat units for? Number of units
being heated with natural gas- if' "you know how many arc left, you can figure out how many are
using some other heat source
Katie: Not sure it's worth it; have % of honrico ners heating with woods, fuel, et.c
Comment: oil is small?
Taney: Natural gas isn't avadabte to rnost
Cutnment: is most the population in the villages where they wouldn't have acce55 to natural gas?
Nancy. What % of pop is in the village?
Coin men t: might be uwfuI to focus on the things we can manage- Iegislatien
Katie; A Iot of questions have been asked that can be answered, but going txo foI Ic>%v -up on these
other points
Abi) ut whieh areas. has highest impacts: Roues 13 ur Caroline?
Katie: Rev1Qwofhow she got the figures (using ICLE1)
Comments; how are they getting these measures?
Katie: comments that they are using some measure to get the numbers
Comment: Appendix that elaborates on the model you are using; the assumptions- looks
deterministic, and the world isn't_
I atie0 Can do that, written already For Town of Ithaca
Mild; blot doubting the model, but needs to be cited
Cornmcnt: Competing rnodels?
Corn rnent: Speaking of energy- iwntion hydrofr I&Ing in the snapshot?
Nancy /Petei - Can't be in the one we have now; only future
Arc the ocher `l'awn's working on the same initiative"?
Katie' Focused ]Hare on energy to the 'f own of Ithaca; City hfired a ] -year sustainabIIttty
coordinator; Dryden Encrgy Coordinator- Ken Thompson
Communication between them seems to be establishing a Iong -term Advisory Team {as
mentioned on the last slide)
itntiarly, about sharing resources between school districts; this might make sense to share with
othermuni,I ]ities
U
C
Major thing lacking is any analysis of the agriculture- there is quite a bit in the Township; there
is a broad cover of it; eating healthy, but this isn't sustainability. I want to see some indication of
how much of the Town is in pasture, ariable, woodland - and how these are changing for housing
developments? Fallow? What is sustainability ??
Nancy: This sounds like something for the OSP
,Motto for Ag & Life Sciences is sustainability- the extent to which ag is sustainable- this is a
major function of any Township where there is major ag; there is a reasonable proportion which
is not in this plan; have to start off with what is the status of agriculture in this Township and
what is being made to make sure this will remain for future generations, or make it better
"Sustainable" used as a misunderstanding of "conservation "; NYS report on agriculture; if there
are changes by economic demands, where will it take us
Nancy: Active ag lands that are in ag district; and vice versa; might want to separate Forestry
from ag
Managed versus non- managed
Nancy: there is an
overlay
for ag
use, and ag assessment, ag district- three different databases
that don't overlap
(county
level)-
Josh can retrieve
In defining sustainability - needs more information in there; sustainal
landscape? Economics? (balanced input /output ?) Energy? What is it
As you approach it of a snapshot, all these things come to mind how
What is worth emphasizing'? Opportunities for school? What do you
® to achieve sustainability?
•
)ility of what? Existing
that is significant to sustain'?
are we going to measure?
consider the most important
Katie: It's not my role to say; about facilitating role so that everyone has a say. About figuring
out what matters in sectors, achieving, etc. Going to come in 2 phase where individual level
about what it means to "me% bring brainstorming together and concrete areas
Comments regarding composting at the Town level and in the schools
Understanding this is a baseline; insert in front of the goals and objectives "measurcable ";
"sustainability" requires measurable goals and objectives and a timeline
Katie: Question about defining this for the public sector
Comment regarding; informational infrastructure- broadband- is missing
Open Space Plan Review
Jane: Brief overview of picking up the Plan from where we left off
Goals for the Open Space Plan
Define open space
Revisit our purpose and vision
Revisit goals and objectives
l
I]
The inventniy- three systems and subcommittees?
Develop a timeline
Nancy: Agriculture- the way it Iooked
towards preserving land structure in g(
development rights- north end of the 1
-go beyond conserving ag
- focus almost entirely on ag lands that
north -end of County
Mary Ann - Farmland Protection flan;
to be going did not
:neral; primarily in
own; with sail and
would be on Focus
overlap with dell ni
- preserving ag in genert�19 Dan saw it
terms of land- purchase of
contiguous lands
oFdevelopnient rights'? Then just
ng open space
rwlancy: Open space is
anything that
does not have a built
environment; but with recreation—
overlapping recreation
trail through
cunservation area;
interchangeable
Not compelled to put them together; might hinge on the use of the area
Deep plans scparate? Kook at I MP? Might be easier to move forward, avoid conflict
CBI came
to it
that
recreation; passive rec
is appreciated,
understand
the active rcc, but see need
to idelltlfy
t}EOSC
in separate
categories that
are na in confl1C#
anywhere
]Nancy: Is this a DEC initiative? Think ing in terms of CEA- hMoric and bu ilt environment carne
into; wasn't addressed in C EA
Active and
passive
recreation-
Fish and Wildlife reports (IBS Fish and Wi]dlil1c Service)
C: mplctect
in 2010
— maintain
ecological services
Jane: Separate active and passive? Refer to active In the RMP?
Organizedltearn sports as opposed?
Cross -re fore nce-
1. 0eflnition: m
Recreation — excluding R.M11; looking ore into the traIIsmm�erhphasizing
building on trails (look at iseportl); reeroatilon is not just Cor the youth, wheelchair and
accessibility to more tkser groups (could be in nor purview) mm look at trails in NY
(snowinobilc- local cornlnunity group that does it- Cayuga Club)
2_ Types of recreation: bird1ng, orienteering (open space re o) trapping, hunting. fish ing, dog
walking, snowiliohiIinglsnowmshueinglxc, walk/jog, photography, bouldering?
Kayaking/canoe, swimming
Nancy Meeting adjourned+ 9:23PNI