HomeMy WebLinkAbout2026-10-13-CAC-minutesTown of Danby Conservation Advisory Council (CAC)
Minutes of In-person Meeting in Town Hall, and Via Videoconferencing
Tuesday, Oct. 13, 2026
Council Members Present: Pacific Austin, Joel Gagnon, Anne Klingensmith, Don Schaufler
Council Members Absent/Excused: Margaret Corbit, Jonathan Zisk
Others Present: Katharine Hunter
Meeting called to order: Chair Anne Klingensmith called the meeting to order at 7:05pm.
Agenda Review: Additions or Deletions: No additions or deletions were made.
Privilege of the Floor: None
Approval of Minutes: The draft September meeting minutes, incorporating minor
corrections from members, were moved for approval by Joel Gagnon and seconded by
Pacific Austin. Motion carried.
Easement Summaries: Don Schaufler presented his summary of the Melchin/Schott
easement, which Joel praised for capturing the provisions limiting cabins so they do not
become permanent residences. The group asked that the summary also record the owner
of record and the local caretaker, Ed Schott, with contact information, and the history of
how the original Melchin property was divided: the upland agriculture and forest portion
went to Eric Palmer with a provision allowing a cabin, and the steep ravine portion, mostly
Environmental Protection Zone, became the Schott parcel. Anne described the goal for
every easement folder: a summary of what is distinctive about the easement, the original
signed agreement, and all monitoring reports in a standard set of sub-folders, with
duplicates moved to the “old forms” archive and the Palmer 1, Melchin/Palmer 2, and
Melchin/Schott pieces named consistently. Because the monitoring form template was
filled in by mistake, Anne will ask Margaret Corbit for a blank copy, and Pacific suggested
making templates read-only.
Easement Monitoring: Anne shared a draft chart of each easement’s steward, summary
status, and monitoring dates, which she will circulate with the agenda for members to
complete. Past monitoring records are missing for most easements, and the group
stressed the importance of locating them. Anne reported that Brad Rausch, a Danby
resident who cannot commit to council membership, has offered to serve as a volunteer
monitor. The group discussed a fair screening process, likely an application adapted from
the CAC membership form with a question about working sensitively with landowners. A
new monitor would be assigned one easement, ideally for several years, and the steward
would accompany them on a first visit to explain the process using the easement summary
and would review their first report. Easements with more sensitive landowner relationships
would remain with council members. How and when will we put up easement signs? No
plan has yet been made for posting signs. The signs need mounting holes; Don will ask
Greg for them and drill the holes, and members agreed they can be nailed to trees along
easement boundaries.
Updates on Ongoing and Potential Easements:
West Jersey Hill Road: Joel reported on behalf of Greg that a subdivision application is in
process for a West Jersey Hill Road property whose rear portion, including part of Lick
Brook, is prime easement territory. The owner is interested in an easement there with a
cluster subdivision on the balance, and Greg has proposed a joint walk with the Planning
Board; he will send details.
Hill Road: The council has not heard back from the Hill Road owners since suggesting they
discuss their ideas further with Greg. Anne will check with Greg on whether they have been
in touch.
Altman: Members discussed a draft comparison of the Altman easement with the CAC
template. Questions were raised about whether the cultural-steward section could allow
permanent structures if ownership changes, whether humanure is permitted in Tompkins
County, and whether an organic-fertilizer requirement could be enforced. Members agreed
that provisions the CAC cannot monitor should be stated as the owners’ preference, not as
requirements. A motion to forward the easement to Guy Krogh, attorney for the town, was
raised, and the group deferred a vote until members have reviewed the comparison.
Resilience Fair Report: Don reported that the fair was well organized, larger than last year,
and well attended despite rain and competing events.
Annual Report: Kristin McCarthy has agreed to prepare this year’s annual report, drawing
on the year’s agendas and minutes as was done last year.
Items for Next Month’s Agenda: Review of the Altman easement comparison, the draft
application for volunteer monitors, the monitoring chart, and scheduling of the
Melchin/Schott walk.
Member Announcements: None
Adjournment: The meeting was adjourned at 7:54pm.
Submitted by Kristin McCarthy, Secretary.