HomeMy WebLinkAbout2021-07-13 CAC MinutesTown of Danby Conservation Advisory Council Minutes Page 1 of 12
Town of Danby Conservation Advisory Council (CAC)
Minutes of Video Conference (Zoom) Meeting on
Tuesday, July 13, 2021
Danby, New York
Council Members present: Clare Fewtrell (chair), Joel Gagnon, George
Adams, Don Schaufler, Margaret Corbit, Jonathan Zisk, Mary Woodsen,
Brittany Legaly
Council Members absent:
Others present: Elizabeth Keokosky (secretary), Ronda Roaring (Danby
resident), Katharine Hunter (Danby resident and former CAC member)
Zoom Meeting was officially called to order at 7:08.
Deletions or Additions to Agenda: Fewtrell is moving item 3 (Logging
Ordinance) on Agenda to second place
Privilege of the Floor (PoF): Adams let the group know that he is leaving
CAC for another organization (where he is on the board) that meets at the
same time CAC does. He also let the group know that a disease is being
passed on to birds from birdfeeders and that birdfeeders should be taken
down. (Afternote: Salmonellosis - clean feeders and baths with a 10%
bleach solution.)
Approval Minutes MOTION for June 8, 2021
Gagnon moved to approve
Zisk seconded
All voted yes except Legaly, who abstained, and Schaufler, who
was having technical difficulties.
REPORTS AND UPDATES
1. Easement Signs - Adams
Adams reported that there was a computer graphics technical
problem with art work that is holding up sign production, and that he
will finish this task of the Easement signs before he leaves. Janice
Town of Danby Conservation Advisory Council Minutes Page 2 of 12
(the town clerk) will be unavailable to help since she will be out of
town 3 weeks on family business.
2. Logging Ordinance (from now on referred to as Timber
Harvesting Ordinance) – Adams, Zisk, and Schaufler
(Secretary’s note: this is especially detailed so that Adams can use
suggestions in updating current draft version)
Adams reported on Version 5.7 of Logging Ordinance (which
members found very readable and improved). Code Enforcement
Officer, Steve Cortright, had been invited to attend this discussion but
he had a conflicting meeting elsewhere.
Adams said that his goal was to decide which questions were left for
CAC to answer and which questions had to be answered by the town
lawyer.
He mentioned that Cortright, who had been given this version to read,
had been concerned about protection of local roads when State
crews were logging in the State Forest - without a permit being
required. He would have liked to impose some sort of liability on the
State. But Adams thought that activity might be exempt from the
ruling we are discussing.
Adams posed the question “When do we decide this is complete
enough to pass on to town board?“
Gagnon reminded group that we are only recommending this
ordinance to the Town Board and they then have to approve it, and
they are the ones to send it to and communicate with the town
lawyer.
Performance Bond: Adams said that Zisk had pointed out that we
don’t have enough specifics on performance bonds. But Adams
thought a lawyer could put that in properly. Gagnon said that the
town has been using a method of imposing a performance bond for
highway use for a long time, dating back to fracking rules, and was
hoping Adams could have gotten that information from the Highway
Department. At a minimum that could be referenced.
Town of Danby Conservation Advisory Council Minutes Page 3 of 12
Highway Department: Schaufler had yet to get hold of the Highway
Department for this information; he said he would. Adams said we
needed buy-in from Highway Department, as we had from Cortright,
who had said he considered the law enforceable as written. But
Cortright might be an exception, since he comes from a logging
family, so we have to make sure that any Code Enforcement Officer
could feel comfortable enforcing it.
Definitions: Cortright said that the document needed definitions. He
dealt with people who didn’t know what words like BMP (Best
Management Practices) mean. It turns out that the document cited
as a reference has a glossary. But Cortright said that you needed to
define words like standard and full cord, so there is a need to provide
additional definitions not in the referenced document.
Fewtrell questioned Zisk and Schaufler, the others on the committee,
about how they felt about the current version. Both seemed satisfied
but Schaufler brought up a few problems.
Multiple harvest contractors: Schaufler mentioned that the logger and
the trucker may be two different entities. That needs to be fine-tuned.
He thought it was asking too much information for the trucker to tell
the Town ahead of time which roads will be used, but if the Town can
shut down roads, he’s OK with it. Fewtrell said that we need to know
who the truckers are. Adams said that we need to know which
subcontractors are being used, so the same mechanism can be
applied – we just need to replace the word “logger” with “harvest
contractors.” Corbit and Fewtrell emphasized getting full contractor
contact information so s/he can be reached immediately if need be.
Corbit wanted to change reference to 1) low density zone - to modify
or take it out altogether and just say the Town. This was agreed on.
2) in the permitting process add the time frame – explicitly say that
logging cannot start until a permit has been issued and the permit will
have an expiration date. A decision to issue or deny a permit should
occur within a specified period of time after the application is
submitted. Recognizing that time matters, information packages will
be sent to local contractors so they will be aware that Danby is now
requiring permits for timber harvesting. The statement about logging
Town of Danby Conservation Advisory Council Minutes Page 4 of 12
not starting until a permit has been issued may need repeating. Also
it was noted that a statement saying that the permit will have an
expiration date needs to be added as it was inadvertently left out of
the current version.
Does group support sending Logging Ordinance to town board
when Adams adds in these corrections? (see Appendix I)
Corbit moved to recommend
Zisk seconded
Unanimous in favor
Gagnon added that it doesn’t have to be in final form but just in the
ball park. He said when it is in its final form there will be a public
forum and an opportunity for public comment.
Gagnon asked when document would be ready? Since typos and
changes still had to be incorporated, it was decided that it would
tentatively be put on town board agenda for July 21st. It was agreed
that the name would be Timber Harvesting (law/ordinance?}, since
this is more inclusive than “Logging”.
3. Easement Website & Rack Cards – Margaret Corbit & Mary
Woodsen
Progress is not being made on the new website but there is a new
page for CAC on the old website. Corbit reminded CAC members
that someone with access to the full version of Adobe Acrobat can
make revisions to a pdf file. Fewtrell said that she would contact the
Town Planner, who might have this version.
4. Easement Updates – Clare Fewtrell
Wimsatt easement: Gagnon told the group that he and the lawyer had
signed the Wimsatt easement. Jeffrey Wimsatt hadn’t signed as yet.
The easement had been approved at one of the June Town Board
meetings.
Fewtrell asked that Schaufler take charge of arranging the annual
easement inspections and distributing the new easement . Zisk and
Corbit volunteered to help Schaufler. Gagnon suggested that Adams
coordinate with Cindy in main office about delivery of easement
Town of Danby Conservation Advisory Council Minutes Page 5 of 12
signs. David West should be asked if they could be stored in his
office until they have been distributed.
Fewtrell reminded group that now was a good time to get back to
other easements that had been started and also potential new ones
including CAC members that had said they were interested.
Gagnon noted that Dan Hoffman and Mark and Micaela Karlsen
might not need the Planned Development Zone because of zoning
rule changes that will replace it. They need to accommodate putting
in 3 dwellings.
5. Changes to Easement Template – Clare Fewtrell & Joel Gagnon
The changes being discussed were the result of rethinking the
Easement Template during the recent Wimsatt Easement
negotiations and also other language and updates that improve and
make more explicit the usability of the template. During the lengthy
discussion of this agenda item, Fewtrell screen-shared the marked-up
template document and comments in “Review” mode displaying all
the tracked changes. Each change was discussed separately.
Some high lights of this discussion were:
It was decided that Gagnon’s references to useful individual solutions
from past easements would not be included in the template and
would be discussed as a separate document at the next CAC
meeting
Article I: added “Restricted Forest Use Zone” which had been
approved by the Town lawyer but not yet by the Town Board.
Article II: Clarification was made on the fact that use zones follow a
hierarchy and the Residential and Active Use Zone includes
everything allowed in the other Zones. It reflects the hierarchal order
of zones by increasing restriction, so farm activities are included in
the Residential and Active Use Zone.
Article II: discussion of 2.03 Forest and Agriculture Management
Zone -C4 Applying fertilizers, fungicides, pesticides, herbicides, their
regulation, and what is sustainable and what is enforceable by CAC.
Town of Danby Conservation Advisory Council Minutes Page 6 of 12
Took out “only in accordance with State and Federal Regulations” as
being too limiting. And discussion of C6 Best Management Practices
(BMP).
Gagnon moved to send the Easement Template document to
Town Board with changes as discussed in Review mode.
Cobit seconded
Unanimous, except for absence of Schaufler, who left the
meeting due to an imminent storm.
Gagnon said he would put it on the Town Board agenda for July 21st.
Regenerative Agriculture and Role Conservation Organizations
can Play in Promoting Climate-resilient Agriculture – Elizabeth
Keokosky
Due to the overtime on the meeting this agenda item was put off until
the August meeting but there was a preliminary agreement on the
importance of Agricultural Conservation easements, and Keokosky
was given the go-ahead to start initial organization of a series of
Agricultural Education presentations.
Fewtrell requested that a write-up on this be sent to all members
6. Planning Group Working Group Reports – Joel Gagnon,
Jonathan Zisk & Elizabeth Keokosky
This item wasn’t covered – please go to the minutes of these groups
on their webpages at the Danby town website. Or go to next
Monday’s Town board meeting at 7pm (it will also will be recorded).
Thanks and Appreciation to George Adams who is leaving.
There was no Executive session
Next Meeting via Zoom is on August 10th at 7p.m.
Adjournment at 9:25
_____________________________________________
Submitted by Elizabeth Keokosky (Secretary)
Town of Danby Conservation Advisory Council Minutes Page 7 of 12
Appendix I – Timber Harvesting Law Draft 6.1 (submitted to Town
Board)
Local Law to Amend the Zoning Ordinance
Related to Timber Harvesting in the Town of Danby, New York
Be it enacted by the Town Board of the Town of Danby in the County of Tompkins, as follows:
Section 1. Authority
This local law is enacted pursuant to the provisions of the Municipal Home Rule Law (MHRL)
of the State of New York and any other pertinent provisions of the Laws of the State of New
York.
Section 2. Statement of Purpose
The purpose of this law is to promote the health and safety of the residents of the Town of Danby
by protecting the natural environment as affected by timber harvesting. The Town recognizes
that timber resources are of significant value and will be harvested. The Town also recognizes
that if harvesting practices are carried out poorly, they can result in significant and direct
environmental damage to the property and to the adjacent lands and waters. This law requires
landowners and their agents to be responsible for following Best Management Practices when
harvesting timber. Proper management practices will limit subsequent environmental damage,
particularly from soil erosion and sediment-laden run-off. Therefore, the following requirements
are intended to regulate those harvesting activities that are most likely to cause environmental
damage, such as crossing streams, working on steep hillsides, clearings to stack, load or move
logs and to provide for reclamation.
Section 3. Amendments to the Zoning Ordinance
A. The Town of Danby Zoning Ordinance, Article III: entitled ‘Definitions,’ Section 301 –
DEFINED TERMS is amended by adding the following definitions:
1. Cord All use of cords of wood as a measure will mean standard full cords, not face
cords.
2. Board Foot is a measure of finished lumber, with thickness of 1 inch and area of one
square foot. As it is customary to measure the volume of a harvest in board feet while the timber
is still in the form of logs, there are standardized methods to approximate the board feet
contained in a log. This law will use {Doyle, International,???} rule for determining board feet.
3. Hazard of Damage will be used to mean any potential to cause pollution of streams or
wetlands, loss of top soil and erosion where activity has removed all vegetation, contamination
of soil or aquifers with petroleum products, sedimentation, altered runoff patterns, decreased
biodiversity, loss of rare or endangered plants and animals, destruction of critical habitat and
damage to public roads in the Town.
4. Timber Harvest Operator is used to mean the person or company contracted to fell and
move timber within the harvested area and prepare it for loading, be that saw logs or firewood.
This may be the same or a separate operator from the trucking company that moves the harvested
timber over Town roads.
Town of Danby Conservation Advisory Council Minutes Page 8 of 12
5. Other terminology with specified usage or meaning in the context of a Timber Harvest
will be interpreted according to the Glossary that is part of the Best Management Practices
publication incorporated by reference in part III.
B. The Town of Danby Zoning Ordinance, Article VI: entitled ‘Zone Regulations,’ Section 600 –
LOW DENSITY RESIDENTIAL ZONE is amended by adding the following to Sub-section 1.
PERMITTED PRINCIPAL USES:
d. Forest management and other forest resource uses. Timber harvesting is subject to the
requirements in § 715.
[CAC anticipates significant modification to the Town’s zoning maps and
rules. This ¶ B and C stipulation of where the Timber Harvest regulation
fits within the structure of the Town’s laws is thus subject to change and its
best placement is left to the Town Board and legal guidance]
C. Suggested placement of this law within the zoning laws.
The Town of Danby Zoning Ordinance, Article VII: Special Regulations is amended by
adding a new Section 715, entitled ‘TIMBER HARVESTING as follows:
D. The Text of the Timber Harvesting Law:
I - Conflict with Other Provisions
Whenever the requirements of this law are at variance with the requirements of any other
lawfully adopted rules, regulations, ordinances or laws, the most restrictive shall govern.
II – When Is a Permit Required?
A. Exempt Activities
The following activities may be carried out without a permit:
1. The felling of trees that pose a hazard to roads, utilities or buildings or any other harm
and any cutting of trees ordinarily incidental to property maintenance or landscaping
work.
2. The cutting of less than 4000 board feet or 10 cords of firewood per year.
3. The clearing of a building site as approved in an issued building permit. The extent of the
cleared area shall be delineated in the soil disturbance forms that supported the building
permit application.
4. Harvesting timber from land owned by the state of New York performed under the
supervision of the NY DEC.
[CAC recognizes that timber harvesting activity carried out under NYS DEC
supervision carries significant risk of, and has been the cause of, some
damage to the Town’s roads. We have some concern as to whether existing
Town laws regulating heavy loads and road use can be applied in these cases
because of the exceptions for “agricultural use” provided in the road use law.
Town of Danby Conservation Advisory Council Minutes Page 9 of 12
Regulatory means to hold the harvest operators or truckers responsible for
damage should be devised but may not be part of this law]
B. Non-Exempt Activities
Because each of these activities poses some hazard of damage, work that will involve any of
them shall be carried out only if a permit is issued. It will be a violation of this law to perform
these activities without a permit.
1. Any activity associated with the harvest that involves the movement of heavily loaded
trucks or other heavy equipment using Town roads.
2. Any construction or alteration of temporary culverts or shoulders of Town roads to
create access to the area harvested or to facilitate loading of trucks and equipment.
3. Any activity that will involve temporary piling of logs within 50 feet of the road
centerline.
4. Harvesting of more than 4000 board feet or 10 cords of firewood.
5. Moving equipment and logs across any permanent stream.
C. It is hereby required that a timber harvesting permit application be filed with the Town Code
Enforcement Officer by anyone desiring to harvest timber by any means or to any extent that is
not exempt from this law. The property owner and the Timber Harvest Operator(s) shall apply
for such permit jointly.
D. No person, firm, partnership, corporation or other entity shall engage in any timber harvesting
activity, including felling, skidding, modification of roadside ditches for access or clearing trails
and landings, unless the aforesaid entity has obtained a timber harvesting permit issued by the
Town Code Enforcement Officer.
E. It will be a violation of this law if the application is found to understate the extent, location,
insurance coverages required, worker safety considerations, hazard of damage or volume of the
harvest to such a degree that the permit issued cannot fully provide for the protection of the
water bodies, the workers, the roads and the neighboring properties.
F. Permits must be prominently posted at the point of road access to/from logged area.
III – Best Management Practices Required
It shall be a violation of this law if any timber harvesting pursuant to this Section fails, in the
judgment of the Code Enforcement Officer, to adhere to the Best Management Practices [BMP]
described in the Chemung County Soil and Water Conservation District’s publication “Best
Management Practices During Timber Harvesting Operations”.
IV – The Permit
The Timber Harvest Permit will identify the persons responsible for the harvest and state the
period during which the permit is in force. It will be issued when a complete and accurate
Timber Harvest Application has been submitted to the Code Enforcement Office and found to
Town of Danby Conservation Advisory Council Minutes Page 10 of 12
satisfy all requirements of this law. If the application is found deficient in any way, a Request for
Supplemental Information will be issued. In either case, the Code Enforcement Office will
provide its finding within 10 business days after receipt of the application.
V – The Timber Harvest Application
The Timber Harvest Application will state the information required for a permit:
1. Applicants’ certificate of insurance or bond for $250,000/$500,000 property damage and
personal liability, specifically covering damage to roadways and culverts is required, as is Proof
of Workers' Compensation Insurance coverage..
2. Names, addresses, phone numbers and email addresses of landowner and for each trucking
firm, timber harvest operator and forester who will perform the harvest. This must be contact
information that can be used for emergencies and violation notices that need a response in less
than 24 hours.
3. A plan of the property to be harvested, in printed or electronic form. The basis of this plan
shall be a topographic map which has been supplemented with the following:
a) Tax parcel number[s] for the parcel[s] containing the area to be harvested.
b) Property boundaries, streams, stream crossings, landings, road access.
c) Area to be logged, clearly marked, showing setbacks from roads and water bodies.
d) Explicitly planned egress and routing of any trucks expected to have GVW greater than 8
tons per axle,
4. Planned dates for start and completion of harvest.
5. Estimate of cords, tons, or board feet of timber to be harvested.
6. An application fee of $100 or other amount that the Town Board may set.
7. A description of the specific Best Management Practices that will be used to protect the stream
crossings, skid and haul roads, landings and access points to public roads and any maps,
descriptions, or drawings of particular engineered measures which address hazards of damage
that the Code Enforcement Officer identifies to the applicant, including a revegetation plan to
prevent erosion of steep harvest locations.
8. If the timber harvesting is done under contract, the names and contact information of the
parties and the effective dates of the contract.
9. If the timber harvest is the execution of a timber sale that has been recorded with the county
clerk, the document control number of the registration.
10. Contact information for the insurer who provided the certificate of insurance, if such
information is not present on the certificate.
VI . The Permitting Process
1. Property owner obtains an application packet from Town Clerk which will contain:
a. application forms,
b. a copy of this law,
c. a copy of Best Management Practices During Timber Harvesting Operations
d. a map of the Department of Environmental Conservation [DEC] listed streams in the Town
e. a list of resources to aid land owners in achieving a safe and economical harvest, which may
include NYS DEC cooperating consultant foresters, Cornell Cooperative Extension contact,
Tompkins County Soil and Water Conservation District [SWCD] contact, DEC district 7 contact,
Town of Danby Conservation Advisory Council Minutes Page 11 of 12
description of the advantages of having a forester oversee the harvesting and sale of timber,
description of the benefits of having a harvest conducted under a contract, and advice on how to
choose a Timber Harvest Operator.
2. property owner and timber harvest operator(s), if any, complete the Timber Harvest
Application and submit it, with fee, to the Code Enforcement Officer
3. The Code Enforcement Officer may circulate the permit application
a. to Town Planner for questions of adequate stormwater control,
b. to Conservation Advisory Council for questions about protected or sensitive wetlands or
vegetation and to certify that a harvest does not violate the terms of any conservation easement.
c. to Highway Department for questions about risk of impact to Town roads, culverts and
roadside drains and for a determination of a performance bond amount proportional to such risks,
if any, which bond should be posted as a condition of the permit.
4. If the Code Enforcement Officer finds hazards of damage of the proposed harvest against
which the application’s documentation of the harvest and of BMPs do not assure adequate
safeguards, the Code Enforcement Officer may issue a Request for Supplemental Information
such as but not limited to a Stormwater Pollution Protection Plan (SWPPP), engineering
drawings specifying how stream crossings will protect water quality, etc. Then the Timber
Harvest Operator, Forester and Owner will file this supplemental documentation as amendments
to their Timber Harvest Application.
5. If the application meets the criteria for a Timber Harvest Permit, including any supplemental
documents requested by the Code enforcement Officer and if any required bond has been posted,
the Code Enforcement Officer will issue a permit and send a copy of the approved permit to
NYS DEC Region #7 Office, Tompkins County Soil and Water Conservation District, the Town
Highway Superintendent, the Town Planning Department and the contiguous landowners.
VII - Regulation and Penalties for Offenses
A. It shall be the duty of the Code Enforcement Officer to enforce the provisions of this
ordinance.
B. The Code Enforcement Officer, may with due cause and without hindrance, reasonably enter,
examine and survey all grounds affected by the timber harvest in order to ascertain whether BMP
are being followed and whether uncontrolled stormwater runoff is contaminating water bodies on
or outside of the planned harvest area.
C. It will be a violation of this law if the Highway Superintendent finds that harvest activity is
damaging roads beyond normal wear and tear. The Highway Superintendent may specify
measures to remediate damage or suspend the harvesting operation until suitable weather
conditions restore load-bearing capacity of the road.
Town of Danby Conservation Advisory Council Minutes Page 12 of 12
D. Release of bond: If a performance bond was posted, it shall be returned at conclusion of the
harvest providing :
1. The Code Enforcement Officer determines that any required clean-up or restoration work has
been performed in compliance with the BMP.
2. The highway department determines that roads, ditches and access points are undamaged or if
damaged, satisfactorily repaired.
[Does the Town already have a mechanism for taking and securely holding a
bond that is to be returned later upon satisfaction of conditions?]
E. Upon notification by the Code Enforcement Officer to the applicant of any violation
hereunder, the timber-harvesting permit granted to such applicant shall be suspended and/or
revoked. Upon suspension or revocation, as the case may be, all operations shall immediately
cease, and the applicant shall take immediate steps to address the violation. Such suspension or
revocation notice may contain conditions to be met to obtain reinstatement of the permit.
F. Any person violating any provision of this law shall be guilty of an offense punishable by a
fine set by the Code Enforcement Officer which may not to exceed $10,000.00 or other amount
that had been established by vote of the Town Board at the time the permit was issued.
G. Pursuant to 150.20 of the Criminal Procedure law and in accordance with section 10(4)(a) of
the Municipal Home Rule Law, the Code Enforcement Officer of the Town is hereby authorized
to issue and serve appearance tickets in respect to any violation of this law.
H. In addition to or as an alternative to the above provided penalties, the Town Board may also
maintain an action in the name of the Town in a court of competent jurisdiction to compel
compliance with or restrain by injunction any violation of this law.