HomeMy WebLinkAboutMN-SJC-2009-08-12 SJC MEETING
August 12, 2009
SJC Members Staff
Wade Wykstra, Chair
Mayor Carolyn Peterson
Supervisor MaryAnn Sumner
Pat Leary
Mary Tomlan
Joel Zumoff
Erik Whitney
Scott Gibson
Jeff Soule
Dan Ramer
Steve Thayer
Bill Gray
Absent
Supervisor Herb Engman
Rich DePaolo
Guests
Peter Cavagnaro, Johnson Controls
Krisy Gashler, Ithaca Journal
Jose Lozano, IAWWTF
Roxanna Johnston, WRC
Lynn Smith, IAWWTF
Wade called the meeting to order at 12:34PM.
Approval of July minutes – MaryAnn moved the minutes. Seconded by Joel, after discussion
and corrections noted, the motion passed without dissent. Pat Leary abstained. Page 1,
Verizon Monopole (2nd paragraph), Verizon indicated they would not do a visual rendering of
the tower until we indicated our interest in moving forward with the project. Page 3, Headwork
Loading Study was presented by Jimmie Joe Carl, of MRB Consultants. Carolyn asked for
formal resolutions to be included in SJC minutes.
WRC (Water Resources Council)/CU Monitoring Partnership – Roxy Johnston gave a
presentation on the history of the lake monitoring plan which began with Cornell Lake Source
Cooling (LSC) and subsequent upgrades to the Ithaca Area Wastewater Treatment Facility.
The plan focuses on only the southern basin of Cayuga Lake and is available on the City’s
website.
Staff is requesting the approval of the SJC to officially join the Monitoring Partnership. Jose
Lozano gave a short presentation on why it would be advantageous for us to continue what we
have been doing in an unofficial capacity. Jose said he feels that the WRC should not have
endorsed Cornell’s permit for Lake Source Cooling without In Lake Monitoring. He stated that
other entities have expressed the same opinions.
1
Dan said that he has been to WRC meetings and was concerned that we, as an entity, do not have
a formal voice in what takes place. The WRC meetings take place on the 1st Wednesday of each
month at 3:30PM at The Cooperative Extension building.
The members agree that it is important for this facility to be a formal member of the WRC/CU
Partnership.
This discussion will continue at the September meeting of the SJC.
Energy Reduction – Peter Cavagnaro, Johnson Controls
Pete updated the committee on the financial and technical aspects of this project. A $6M Grant
application (NYSEFC) has been submitted and we have not yet received a response.
Another available grant is the $500,000 EPA Showcase Community Grant Program. The initial
response from that grant is that it was not accepted citing cost-sharing issues. JCI will follow-up
on that to get clarification.
Carolyn asked if a NYSERDA Energy Grant due August 24th was a possibility for this project.
Erik responded that as a wastewater facility, we are not eligible. Bill noted that the City would
have to apply for that grant.
Pete discussed the co-generation, gas production, and the digester cover. The digester mixer is
out of date and new technology is being researched.
Financial Report – Steve Thayer
Steve distributed the current financial reports. Third Quarter payments have been received from
all three owners. Septage Service revenue has made up a little ground. Unclassified revenue
(debt service) will be billed to the entities in October. Expenses are on budget. Positive result is
$703,000 to date. There have been no Capital expenses in the last month.
Staff has submitted their 2010 Budget Proposal to the Mayor. We are still waiting for
consumption numbers from the City and Town of Ithaca. We are also waiting for insurance
costs, etc. This discussion should take place at the September meeting.
Operators Report Summary– Dan Ramer
We participated in a curtailment readiness test with Troy Power.
Interviews for the Trainee/Instrumentation position have been completed.
Staff conducted an inspection of the Carcass Digester at the Cornell Vet School on July 15th and
July 17th. The Watertown facility reports that the material is working well in their digesters.
The Sand Recirculation Pumps in the Actiflow System have had a major seal failure. A
replacement seal is estimated to cost $8,000. Ed Smith, Operator/Mechanic, has recommended
replacing the pump with a more appropriate pump designed to pump abrasives at a cost of
$10,000. This pump is available from a sole supplier (Wifley).
2
3
A VFD (variable frequency drive) in the Actiflow System has failed. We are planning to
purchase a new ABB drive.
Staff is continuing to collect and analyze data from the Doppler Current Profiler deployed in the
inlet to Cayuga Lake. Jose will be providing an update on the results of the data at a later date.
The fully signed fire alarm contract has been sent to the vendor and we are waiting for them to
respond. Erik noted that we are expecting a $4,000 invoice from Stearns & Wheler for their
work on this project.
Engineering Report Summary – Scott Gibson
Staff is preparing a written notice to Crane-Hogan to officially discontinue further discussions on
delay claims.
Headworks Loading Study
MRB will compile a list of pollutants of concern and locations for supplemental testing. Overall,
the characteristics of the waste received by the plant represent typical, normal domestic waste
with no immediate concern.
Wade noted that Cornell hydrolysate was not discussed in this meeting. Carolyn noted that the
September meeting will be dedicated to the 2010 budget. Scott noted that Headworks loading
will be discussed at the October meeting.
On a motion, the meeting was adjourned.
The next meeting is scheduled for September 8, 2009 at 12:30PM.