HomeMy WebLinkAboutMN-PLCM-1938-1939 P LANK NG COMMIS YON �+
I S r�
' Special Dinner Meeting February 21, 1938
Ithaca Hotel
6.00 P. m.
PRESENT
Chairman - Ho sme r
Mayor - Myers
Commissioners - Perry, Hewitt, Dillon, Montilion, Miscall
Engineer -- Marble
Forester - Baker
City Clerk - springer
In addition to the above named members, there were twenty-
one guests present at this, the 6th annual dinner of the Planning
Commission which is known as the Tarbell Dinner.
Chairman Hosmer welcomed the guests and expressed his thanks
for their attendance, and explained that the purpose of this +1get to-
gethert+ was to crystalize ideas, and plan for the betterment of the
City.
The Chairman introduced the following speakers:
Commissioner of Public Works Sawdon gave a very interesting
description of the growth and needs of the Water Department , stating
that it seemed wise to make improvements and replacements as we go
along rather than to allow the system to deteriorate to a point where
a bond issue will be necessary.
City Engineer Marble emphasized the importance of a com-
prehensive study of the present sanitary sewer system, stating that
many lines are now too small, and that plans for replacement should
consider the future growth of the City,, as well as the present needs.
Health Officer Broad explained how the health of a community
has a definite relation to the water and sewer systems, and called
attention to the fact that many houses in the City are not connected
with the sewer system, nor do they have City water connections.
He stated that he was mainly interested in housing condi
tions, and that he felt the condition of some City owned properties
should be remedied, to conform with the newly revised Sanitary Code
rather then remain as they are to set a precedent for privately owned
property.
He expressed the opinion that it might be advisable for the
City to condemn and remove some of its buildings.
Police Commissioner VanValkenburg stated that the need of
additional parking areas, widening of certain streets and additional
space for the Police Department were the things most needed for his
department. He also submitted a detailed list of suggestions for
traffic relief.
Supt. Kulp of the Board of Education stated that the Board
of Education are not thinking in terms of expansion, since the rapidly
declining birthrate is reflected in the attendance in the elementary
schools.
He stated that the Board of Education now controls 17 acres
of playgrounds, but that an additional playground was needed in the
southwestern part of the City, and that the Board would be interested
in acquiring land for such purpose.
Commissioner of Public Works Miscall expressed the opinion
that at least a part of the Stewart Park Fund should be used for
capital improvements" in the vicinity of Stewart Parkt duggesting that
a pier extending 1000 feet into the lake with a 601 T end to serve as
a boat harbor would attract many people to enjoy the natural beauties
of the park.
He also stressed the need of wading pools for children in the
First Ward, stating that they could also be used for skating rinks
in the winter.
Planning Commission -2- February 21, 1939
Another suggestion which received favorable comment was the
idea of the Bounty turning over to the City for the use of the Police
Department, the old County Clerkts office. The transfer might help
to settle the tax dispute, and Cdr. Miscall felt that it could be
worked out by the cooperation of the various City and County Boards.
Alderman Rogalsky explained the attitude of the Common
Council toward City planning, stating that it was their wish to
cooperate at all times, but that the welfare load, together with the
debt service had become a burden to the City, and therefore is seemed
necessary to reduce the budget as requested by the Planning Commission.
He also expressed the opinion that the City should not en--
gage in any business in competition with taxpayers.
Mayor ,,dyers was called upon to review the -ideas and remarks
advanced by the previous speakers.
He expressed his faith in the managment of the various City
departments and called particular attention to the parking situation
which has become a serious auestion.
He thanked those present for their interest and assistance
in his administration.
The Chairman declared the meeting open for discussion at
this time.
In answer to an inquiry, Oommissioner Sawdon stated that
additional pumping stations would be installed, to supply water to
newly developed sections.
A general discussion ensued, during which various ideas on
City planning were advanced.
The traffic problem appeared to be one of the most serious
questions, and one Q•hioh needs immediate attention.
After thanking the guests for their cooperation, Chairman
Ho sorer declared the meeting aujourned.
E
E
y
F. _ . Springers _
Secretary
Ithaca, N. Y.
February 19th, 1939•
Mr. Harry J. VanValkenberg,
Commissioner of Police,
Ithaca, N. Y.
My dear Commissioner:
I am herewith submitting a few suggestions
to be presented to the joint meeting of the Planing Commission,
Monday evening February 219t.
The carrying out of this programs would be
of great help to the public and this department, as it would give
wider streets and eliminate traffic congestion in areas that are
now congested and a hinderanee to the movement of traffic.
Cutting back the curbing and widening of the following streete,viz;
200 block North Aurora Street, between Seneca and Buffalo Streets,
both sides of street.
100 block South Tioga Street, between State and Green Streets, east
side of street.
100 and 200 block North Tioga Street, between State and Buffalo Streets,
both sides of street.
100 block North and South Cayuga Street, between Green and Seneca Streets,
both sides.
400 block College Avenue, between Dryden Road and Oak Avenue, both sides
of. street. This is a very narrow street and gateway to Cornell Campus
and when cars are parked on both sides of street �t is very congested.
300 block East Seneca Street, between Aurora and arker Street, North
aide.
300 block fast Buffalo Street, between Aurora and Parker Streets, both
sides of street.
100 block West Seneca Street, between Cayuga and Geneva Streets, both
sides of street.
100 block West Green Street, between Cayuga and Geneva Streets, both
sides of street.
F
Routing heavy traffic around State Street business section;
I think we are all agreed that the automobile
is here to stay and fill continue to be the one big problem which
will give the police department plenty of worry from congestion
caused by double parking and slow moving trucks slowing up the
movement of all traffic, )(I would suggest that the planing commission
look into the advisability of extending Green Street through to
Aurora Street, thence east. intersecting with State Street near the
foot of State Street Hill, which would make it possible to route all
east bound trucking around the Business area, thereby eliminating
about Shirty percent of the present delay on State Street due to
these heavy vehicles which are slow in getting their loads under way
- when waiting for traffic signals.
T believg that,I have covered the more important
streets in the above recommendation. With k d t regards, I am,
e 07
,since ou ,
`' hief o Police.
H.J. VAN VALKSNBVRG F
C01IM[.e[ONSQ ,e'S: WILLIAM MARSHALL
DEPART
M � OF POLICE
ITHA }'4i-$' >�ORS
m
It would be well also to look into the possibility
at some near future date,of cutting a street thru
from State to Senaca,Xorthc- of the Eagles building.
This would help to relieve congestion at this point
on State. Many cars now use State street to make a
U turn at this point,and it is simply good fortune
- that we have not had accidents at this point. By
cutting a street thru to eeneoa this condition would
be materially relieved.
Some definite thought ought to be given to the cramped
quarters of the police department. Sooner or later
these quarters will have to be expanded. At the
present time we do not have sufficient locker room,or
any plane to install a pistol range. Tt has been our
experience that it is not feasible. to use a pistol
range at any great distanoe from headquarters, The
men,i f there is a. pistol range at hand can get in a
definite &, mount of practice every month without any
disturbance to routine.
We are at pre6e1xt--*6rking- os vomer els 1 =-
j G4* z i.
a photographic department. or rogues gallery. Te thi -we have some space to work this out,but the quarters
will not permit of any further expansion.
Yours truly
Commissioner
PLANNING COMMISSION PROCEEDINGS
City of 'Ithaca, N. Y.
Regular Meeting 4:00 P. M. February. 25, 193
PRESENT
Chairman — Hosmer
Commissioners — Miscall, Treman, Montillon, Dillon, Hewitt, Perry
City Clerk — springer
Engineer marble
Forester — Baker
MIS Minutes of the preceding meeting were duly approved.
x
flas
ASR IMMINOS TO IDINTIFY CITIES The Clerk read a communication
Mr. Heydecker, Director of State Planning, requesting that adequate
air markings be -installed to guide airplanes.
The Clerk was instructed to inform Mr. Heydecker, that Ithaca has
at least two such signs.
Chairman Hosmer volunteered to contact University authorities in
regard to marking the Armory or some other University building.
EAST GREEN_ STREET EXTENSION The matter of extending E. Green Streeth'
through to E. State Street was discussed, and the City Engineer was
requested to prepare and present a sketch for consideration at the 3 '
next meeting.
PUB�L ,C, LIBRARY Chairman Hosmer stated that the Special Chamber of
Commerce Committee had made no recent report, and that there seemed
to be some question as to the advisability of building at this time.
T ACC 2OLLEGE Commissioner Dillon reported that the Directors of
Ithaca College are contemplating an expansion program, as a greatly
increased attendance is anticipated_ for next fall, and that they have
expressed a desire to consult with the Ithaca Planning Commission,
and secure their assistance in formulating plans.
He stated that through the College approximately : 500,000.00
annually is circulated in Ithaca, and that he felt their problems
should be studied and worked out by the City of 'Ithaca.
SANITARY SEVER. SYSTEM The Commissioners devoted some time to the
study of the map compiled by the City Engineer covering the
Sanitary Sewer System of the City.
It was regularly moved, seconded, and carried, that the Planning
Commission recommend to the Board of Public Works and the Common
Council that a complete study of the Sewer System be made by the City.
STREET _WIDENING AND PAVING The matter of relieving traffic on con--
jested streets was discussed, and it was decided that by widening and
paving E. Seneca and E. Buffalo Streets from Aurora to Eddy Streets ,
it would relieve State Street where the most serious oondition row
exists.
By Commissioner Miscall, seoonded by Commissioner Uontillon:
Resolved, that the Planning - Commission favors the widening and fi
paving of the aforementioned streets, and reouest the City Engineer
to prepare a project for this work for presentation at the next meet—
ing*
eet—
ing• Carried.
.D..MLOP 4ENT OF THE PARK SYSTEM Forester Baker reported that he is
working on plans for development of the Park System which he expects
to have completed, and ready to submit to the Commissioners at their
next meeting. ;
C N9 AF,4 YG IN It was suggested that authorities of Correll
University be acquainted with the fact that numerous cabins are being
erected on their property along the Inlet , and that since these cabins '
etre very unsightly, they should be prohibited.
4 -
717 1
V �
Planning Commission -2.- February 25, 1935
IRUCKD,IPOT The serious hinderance to traffic, caused by the numer-
ous large trucks, unloading freight in the busy streets was discussed,
and it was decided that a committee should be appointed to study the
possibilities of establishing a central depot with warehouse facilities
for the use of these trucks. '
The Chairman appointed Commissioners Miscall, Dillon and Hewitt
to the Committee, and the Clerk was requested to secure data from the
Mayors' Conference.
On motion the meeting adjourned.
F. H. Springer .
City Clerk
l
f
I
I
PLANNING COMMISSION PROCEEDINGS
City of Ithaca, N.Y.
REGULAR MEETING 4:oo P.M. MARCH 25, 1938
s,
4 _ PRESENT -
Chairman - Hosmer
Commissioners - Miscall,Hewitt
Clerk - Springer
Engineer - Marble
Forester - Baker
k
Due to laok of quorum the meeting was adjourned.
F.H.SPRINGER
City Clerk
P1AXV1,NG C TS8ION PRO=IMS
CITY 0r ITU"t N.Y.
REGULAR MEETING 4:00 P.M. APRIL 299 1938
PRESENT :
CHAIRMU - Roamer
COMMISSIONERS - Misoall, Treman;Dillon,Hewitt.
CLERK - Springer
ENGINEER - Marble '
FORESTER - Baker
MI1VTE9 Minutes of the preceding meeting were duly approved.
HoUSING ACT :- A letter from the American Institute of Architects
ih. regard the Federal Housing Aot, was read and ordered placed
on file.
LoNG Wa FILANCIAL P A request fora copy of the long range
financialplan Of s Commission was received from the Secretary
of the National Conference on City Planning.
The Clerk was instructed to inform the Conference that this
Oomission has no such long range financial Plan-
AIR, CGS :- Chairman Roemer reported that the matter of painting
e wor "Ithaos" with directional arrows, on the Drill Hall roof
has been taken up with the University Authorities, who will
render a decision in a short time.
Mr. Roomer, stated that Mr. Smith of the Chamber of Commerce had'
expressed the opinion that that body might be able to finance the
cost of Installing the sign if approved by the University.
PFJ LIC L :- Chairman Hosmer reported that the consensus
of opinion expressed at a Committee Meeting held April 14 indicated
that this. did not seem to be the proper time to raise money for the
building, either by taxation or by bonds. The Committee however,
are aware of the possibilities of securing Government aid, and are
ready to function, should funds be made available.
RUZIF;CATION OF OITX S TS :- Mr. Treman reported that a number of
people ave shown interest in the idea of beautifying city streets,
and he spoke particularly of the condition on the east side of
University Avenue, where the soil has been washed away, and the
planting destroyed. .
He suggested that catch basins be installed, and new planting put in,
and the parking of cars in that section be regulated or prohibited.
Engineer Marble stated that the Board of Public Works have inr
strutted him to prepare a blanket project for submission to the
W.P.A. , and that it was his intention to include the installation
of curbs and gutters on the east side of University Avenue, in
the project.
Mr. Treman stated that there are many spots in the City which could
be beautified by planting, and suggested that the Chairman appoint a
Committee to take these matters under consideration.
By Oommissioner Misoall : seconded by Commissioner Dillon
RESOLVND, that the Chairman appoint a Committee with power,to study
the matter of street beautification and improvements, and submit
suggestions, to the Board of Public Works,with the recommendation
� that they be included in the W.P.A. blanket project. .
I? AA•^•T, a.c.A/ Y0S^AQIf ^AARGA. t<a111 darried. .
ZASJ SR STREET EXTENSION Engineer Marble reported on his survey
o e extension on o East Green Street to East State Street.
The assessed valuation of property involved was $145,000.00, and the
Commissioners agreed the expense was too great to consider at
this time.
BY Commissioner Miscall : seconded by Commissioner Dillon
RESOLVED: that the report of the Engineer be accepted and the
drawing placed on file for future reference.
Carried.
�4REE1ItIDENING A�TD PAYING ; Engineer Marble presented plans for
wi-fienng and paving fast Buffalo 04 flat Seneca Streets from
Aurora to Eddy Street.
By Commissioner Miscall : seconded by Comm. Dillon
RESOLVED, that the plans submitted by Engineer Marble be approved in
principal and that they be presented to the Board of Public I
with the suggestion that thewaft be Inc ud®d In the W.P.A* p7ro j#ot. 1_0
P.C. -2- 4-29-39
RM&QMNT OF PARK SYSTEM ;- Forester Baker presented a very
comprehensive report of "Future Park Development for the City
of Ithaca", in which he outlined many desirable improvements.
He stated that many ideas advanced in the report will require a
great deal of study and planning to accomplish and that the whole
plan was one to be developed over a period of years.
It was suggested that Mr. Baker and the City Engineer and
Commissioners study the report, with the idea of including some
of the work in the W.P.A. program,
It Was regularly moved, seoonded and carried that the report be
accepted with thanks and placed on file with the City Clerk
for ,reference.
D _ OT Commissioner Hewitt reported for the Committee
appointe t0 investigate the matter in regard to the establishment
of a central truck depot.
He Stated that there seems to be no particular rule followed by
Cities in the State, and that the Committee should continue their
study of the problem.
A report received from the Bureau of Municipal Information. in
regard to restrictions of deliveries in the business sections
of Cities was discussed and the Clerk was instructed to have
copies of the report made to distribute to each of the Commissionersg
Commissioner Hewitt reported that a Map of the City,
prepared several years ago, is now in possession of
Mr. F.A. Rogal sky.
Since this Map is the property of the City and is of considerable
value it was suggested that the Chairman write Mr. Rogalsky
and asked to have the Map returned.
On motion the meeting adjourned.
0 F.H.Q NGER
Secretary
- -.�
nm
PLANNING COMMISSION PROCEEDINGS
CITY OF ITHACA, N.Y.
r
REGULAR MEETING 4:oo P.M. MAY 27,1939
PRESENT:-
Chairman - Hosmer
Commissioner - Misoall,Hewitt
Clerk-Springer
gngineer-Marble
Forester - Baker
Due to lack of quorum meeting was adjourned.
F.H.SPRINGER
Secretary
F .
I
i
E
t
i
t
j
K..
:t
1.2
LAN�tI !'�C�N PROti3Zfit��i
City of Ithaca, N. Y.
Regular Meeting 4;00 P. M. June 24, 1938
PRESENT
Chairman - Hosmer
Oommissioners - Miscall, Treman, Montillon, Hewitt, Perry
B.P.W. Commissioner - Sawdon
Maor Stewart and 3 municipal officers of Hornell, N. Y.
City Clerk - Springer
Engineer - Marble
Forester - Baker
MINUTES Minutes of the preceding meeting were duly approved.
MAYORS' CONFERENCE Chairman Roomer reported the attendance of
several commissioners at the meeting of the Planning Boards at
the Elmira meeting on June 9th.
i SUB Engineer Marble presented the plan prepared
or r. oe a for a new development on Cornell St. and stated
that he has asked for approval of the plan, and sale of lots 1,
2 and 3 shown thereon.
By Commissioner Misoall, seconded by Commissioner Hewitt:
Resolved, that the plan as presented be approved in principal.
Be It Further Resolved, that the sale of lots 1, 2 and 3,
facing Cornell St. be approved. Carried.
It was stated that Dr. Hoefle also wishes approval of the
sale of lots 4 and -5 shown on the map, but it was not considered
necessary to take action on the matter at this time.
N PLANN Chairman Hosmer reported that
the M.I.T. Is to conduct a program in planning at Cambridge, Mass.
from July 5 to July 22nd.
BERGHOLTZ TR,A2TT Public Works Commissioner Sawdon reported that
a committee appointed by Mayor Myers have been investigating the
possibility and. advisability of purchasing the Bergholtz Tract
on N. Cayuga Street.
He stated that the Banking Department have urged the Tompkins
Go. Trust Co. to dispose of this tract and that the bank will sell
Y at a reasonable price.
He stated that no price has been made, but that if the City
does not buy the tract, the Bank will probably sell it off in lots,
which would probably result in the erection of many una�ghtly
buildings.
Mr. Sawdon felt that in order to protect the Stewart Park
section and remove the nuisance of the present trailer camp, it
seemed desirable for the City to acquire this property, and asked
for an expression from the Commissioners.
By Commissioner Miscall, seconded by Commissioner Montillon.
Resolved, that the Planning Commission approve the purchase
of the Bergholtz tract. Unanimously Carried.
Commissioner Treman entered the Council Chamber at this time.
MIT + L.� ST. WATER TANK Public Works Commissioner Sawdon re-
ported that it was the intention of the Rater Department to re-
move the old tank to improve the appearance of the school grounds,
but that a representative of the Board of. Education has requested
that a portion ,be left to be used as a swimming pool.
He stated that the Dater Department are willing to leave a
` portion of the tank, but that the matter was brought to the atten-
tion of the Planning Commission for their consideration.
Commissioner Perry expressed the opinion that there would
be no objections if the ground was properly landscaped, and the
pool properly managed.
By Commissioner Hewitt, seconded by Commissioner Montillon:
Whereas it has come to the attention of the Planning Com-
mission that the Board of Education propose to use the old
Mitchell St. water tank as a swimming pool.
Now Therefore Be It Resolved, that this Commission accept
the idea, in principal., and recommend to the Board of Education
that proper landscaping be carried out, and advise them of Its
willingness to review their pians for development.
Carried.
13
{
Planning Commission -2-- June 24, 1939
VISITORS Considerable time was given to discussion of planning
{
problems with the delegates from Hornell who are desirous of
establishing a Planning Commission in that City.
On motion the meeting was adjourned to reconvene at the call of
the Chairman.
a
r. H Springer
ty Clerk
f
i
1.4
V
PLANNING COMMISSION PROCEEDINGS
City of Ithaca, N. Y.
Regular Meeting 4:00 P. M. September 30, 1938
PRESENT
Chairman - Hosmer
Commissioners - fireman, Montillon, Dillon, Hewitt
Forester -- Baker
Clerk -- Springer
NUT-s. Minutes of the preceding meeting were duly approved,
ERSHIP N.Y. FED T NF OFFICIAL PLANNING BOARDS The Clerk
called attention to an Invitation to join the State Federation of
Planning Boards at the annual membership dues of $10.00.
By Commissioner Treman, seconded by Commissioner Montillon:
Resolved, that this Board become a member of the Federation,
and the Clerk be instructed to forward membership dues at once.
Carried.
BINGHAMTONMEETING Ohairman Hosmer reported on his attendance at
a meeting of Planning Boards in Binghamton during the summer.
IMOA, OOL_LEGE PRQJEgJ The Ithaca College project which has been
filed with the P.W.A. in New York was discussed, and the Commission
ere present were unanimous in approving the project.
By Commissioner Dillon, seconded by Commissioner Treman
Resolved, that this Board approves the action of the Common
Council in sponsoring the Ithaca College project.
Unanimously Carried.
BJAUTIFJgAJJq# OF CITY STREWS Commissioner Treman suggested
at the committee appointed y the Chairman on April 29, 1938 to
study the matter of street beautification and improvements, be
urged to prooeed with their study and be prepared to make a report
at the next meeting, in order to submit suggestions to the Board
of Public Works before their Budget is prepared.
The Chairman asked the committee consisting of Commissioners
Montillon, Hosmer, Engineer Marble and Forester Baker to be pre— .
pared to make their report which will be the special order of
business at the neat meeting.
MUING Chairman Hosmer reported that the air marking on
University Armory has been completed.
F. H Springer
Secretary
io
V V(
PUMIN6 oo W18,910H PROQMINGS
City of Ithaca, N. Y.
Regular Meeting 4:00 P. M. October 28, 1938
PREOW T
QhaixmAn w Room=
Commissioners - Miscall, Treman, Montillon
Engineer - Marble
Forester -- Baker
Clerk - Springer
MINUTE$ Minutes of the preceding meeting were duly approved.
STREET BEAUTIFICATION AND IMPROVEMENT Chairman Montillon of the
special committee submitted a report containing suggestions for
the beautification and improvement of City streets. After die
ou ssion, it was moved
By Commissioner Montillon, seconded by Commissioner Treman:
Resolved, that the following suggestions numbered l to 6 be
submitted to the Board of Public Works with the recommendation
that they be considered by that Board in the preparation of their
budget for 1939-
1. Installation of curb on east side of University Ave; in-
stallation of necessary catch basins; fill, grade and planting, to
eliminate car parking, except in sections which may be provided
by setting back of curb.
2. Elimination of blind intersections at northeast corner of
Stewart Ave. and Fall Creek Drive, southeast corner of N. Cayuga
and Lewis Sts. , northeast corner of N. Cayuga and North Sts. , in
addition to other intersections to be reported by Forester Baker.
3. grade and seed parking between curbs and sidewalks gen-
erally throughout City; crushed stone where impractical to seed.
Improvement to entrance to Percy Field, and intersection
of Kline Road including planting; provision for short time parking
west of Lake Road overlooking Percy. Field.
5. Replant creek bunks, particularly as seen when approach- ,
ing the Fall Creek bridge on N. Cayuga $t. and upstream to Ithaca
P .
Falls.
E 6. Grade, plant and generally rehabilitate the section at
the intersection of the new Spencer Road and Albany and Plain Ste.
looking to permanent effectiveness with a minimum of maintenance.
Unanimously Carried.
FLORAL AVE. Commissioner Montillon' s report -called attention to
the fact that Floral Ave. has become an artery for heavy through
traffic and should be improved.
Commissioner Misoall called attention to the fact that the
State is considering the extension of the State highway through
the Avenue.
By Commissioner Miscall, seconded by Commissioner Uontillon:
Whereas, it is the sense of this Commission that Floral Ave.
in it present state conAtitutes a menace to public health, and
Whereas, Floral &v%% has become a through artery of traffic.
Now Therefore Be It Resolved, that this Commission recommend
to the Board of Public Works the improvement of this section as
a project worthy of consideration, and
Be It Further Resolved, that purchase of land in this seo-
tion, when advantageous to the City, be recommended.
Carried.
16
v
Planning Commission Proceedings -2- Ootober_ 29, 1938
CLEAN UP SERVICE The report called attention to paper and other
debris on private property, and suggested that the City extend its
street cleaning service to other sections of the City and that
owners of private property be asked to cooperate.
TAUGHANNOC$ BLVD. It was regularly moved, seconded and carried
that the Board of Public Works be commended for the work done on
Taughannock Blvd.
BUDGET The Clerk called attention to the necessity of consider-
ing the budget for 1939, at the next meeting.
TRAFFIC CONJESTION
By Commissioner Miscall, seconded by Commissioner Treman:
Whereas, the Planning Commission feel, due to the congestion
Qf traffic on State St. that it is necessary to furnish other
arteries.
Now Therefore Be It Resolved, that the Board of Public Works
be requested to seriously consider the widening and paving of E.
Buffalo St. from Aurora St. to Stewart Ave. and the widening of
E. Seneca St. from Aurora St. to Schuyler Pl. and paving from
Aurora St. to Stewart Ave. Carried.
CITY PLAN
By Commissioner Miscall, seconded by Commissioner Montillon:
Resolved, that the City Engineer be authorized and directed
to employ a draftsman to proceed with work on the City Plan.
Carried.
On motion the meeting was adjourned to reconvene at 4 P.M.
November 18, 1938.
7hr
F. H. Springer
City Clerk
V V
PLANNING COMMISSION PROCEEDINGS
City of Ithaca, N. Y.
Regular Meeting 4:00 P. M. November 19, 1939
PRESE141T
Chairman -- Hosmer
00mmis7ioners - Miscall, Treman, Montillon, Dillon
Clerk - Springer
Engineer -- Marble
Forester -- Baker
MINUTES Minutes of the preceding meeting were duly approved.
BUDGET Chairman Hosmer explained that it was necessary to pre-
pare the budget for 1939 and that it seemed necessary to receive
F more funds than last year in order to complete the City map, and
to make preliminary investigation in a flood survey.
After further discussion it was moved
By Commissioner Miscall, seconded by Commissioner Treman:
Be It Resolved, that the Council be requested to provide an
appropriation of $1000.00 in the 1939 budget for the use of the
I Planning Commission, and the Clerk was directed to file the budget
! with the Common Council. Carried.
CHAIRMAN HOSMERIS REPORT Chairman Hosmer presented and read a
sta a ent which he had prepared after going over the minutes of
the Commission for the past decade.
He pointed out that many of -the projects discussed and
approved by the Commission have been brought to pass, but that
many worthy suggested projects have been tabled, or overlooked.
The report contained an extensive list of worthy projects
which have not been acted upon and suggested that some of them
be revived and pushed to completion.
After furthex4.di-saWnioti--,i-l.vasnmaved
By Commissioner Montillon, seconded by Commissioner Treman:
Resolved, that Chairman Hosmer be authorized to prepare a
list of the more worthy projects, and submit to the Board of
Public works, and request their consideration of the projects in
the preparation of their budget for 1939. Carried.
PERMANENT RECORD OF APPROVED PROJECTS Commissioner Treman
suggested, and the Commissioners agreed, that a part of the
minutes book be set aside in which to keep a record of projects
approved.
It was felt that such a record would greatly aid in keeping
important matters before the Commissioners.
On motion the meeting was adjourned to reconvene at the call
of the Chairman.
71,
F. H. tinger
City Clerk
x . 4
PLANNING 001jUISSION PROCEEDINGS
City of Ithaca, N. Y.
Postponed Regular heeting 4:00 P. x. February 3, 1939
PRESENT
Commissioners - Treman, 'Hontillon, Dillon, Geherin, Perry, hiscall
Attorney - Powers
Clerk - Springer
. Engineer - Marble
Building Comm. - Lunn
Forester - Baker
HdQ__.IRUAN The Clerk announced it in order to appoint a temporary
Chairman or proceed to elect a permanent Chairman to succeed Prof.
Hosmer.
By Commissioner Perry, seconded by Commissioner Miscall:
Resolved, that we proceed to elect a permanent Chairman.
Carried.
It was moved by Commissioner Geherin, seconded by Commissioner
Treman:
Resolved, that Commissioner L'iscall be named Chairman of the
Ithaca City Planning Commission.
There being no further nominations, a vote was taken, and
Commissioner 11iscall was duly named Chairman of the Commission.
Chair-man Uiscall expressed his appreciation, and asked for
the continued cooperation of all the members.
HI TES Minutes of the preceding meeting were duly approved.
PET TION ZONE CHANGE. The Clerk reported that the Common Council
had referred the petition for zone change of the 300 block of
S. Corn St. fr.om "A" residential to commercial classification to
the Planning Commission for investigation and recommendations.
By Oommissi,oner Dillon, seconded by Commissioner Geherin:
Resolved, that the Chairman appoint a committee to investigate
and report at a special meeting to be called by the Chairman.
Carried.
Chairman iiscall appointed the following committee:
Commissioners y:ontillon, Dillon, Geherin.
agNE ORDINANCE Chairman Miscall reported that the City Attorney
is making progress on revision of the zoning ordinance.
AAT , AL DINNER Commissioner Dillon inquired if the Oommiscioners
felt the custom of holding an annual dinner should be continued.
By Commissioner Perry, seconded by Commissioner .::ontillon:
Resolved, that arrangements be made for the annual dinner, to
take place during the month of iarch. Carried.
ASTER CITY PLAN Commissioner `;ontillon expressed the opinion
that preparation of the master plan should be continued as funds
will permit.
The City Engineer presented for inspection a number of prints
already prepared showing existing highways and announced that this
part of the work was approximately 2/3 completed.
Discussion of plans to aid traffic conjestion at the foot of
E. State Street followtd,, and it ras moved:
By Commissioner montillon, seconded by Commissibner Treman:
Resolved, that the City Engineer study the situation and pre-
pare plans of the various solutions suggested, and submit to the
Board for consideration. Carried,
�e
Planning Commission -2- February 11939
E. BUFFALO E. SETdECA STREETS WIDENING The Engineer submitted
p sne as prepared for the Board of Public Works for the work in
widening and paving Buffalo and Seneca Streets from Aurora Street
east.
By Commissioner Treman, seconded by Commissioner Geherin:
Resolved, that the plans as submitted be and they hereby are
approved in principal. Carried.
DUTIES OF CO: .:ISS OVERS For the benefit of members, Chairman
111soall explained the duties of the Planning Board, and expressed
the hope that any member would bring ideas and suggestions for
consideration of the Commission.
On motion the meeting was adjourned to reconvene at the call
of the Chairman.
F. H. S ringer
City Clerk
F
OQ"
law
s
w410
'Ao } I
F
� s
,
5" ll
PLANNING COMMISSION PROCEEDINGS
City of Ithaca, N. Y.
Adjourned Regular Meeting 4:00 P. M. February 14, 1939
PRESENT
Chairman - Miscall
Commissioners - Treman, Dillon, Geherin, Perry, Mitchell
Attorney - Powers
Clerk - Springer
�
Engineer - Marble
Chairman lrisoall stated that this meeting had been called to
consider the report of the committee appointed to study the peti-
tion for zone change of the 300 block of S. Corn Street.
COX-.ITTEE REPORT The report of the committee (a copy of which is
herewith appended) recommended "Zone be not changed", but expressed
willingness to permit the establishment of a bakery in this block,
ML. N. Si lmons appeared for Air. Romsey, and explained that
his client had proceeded in good faith, after a building permit had
been issued by the Building Commissioner.
Chairman liscall expressed the opinion that it was not within
the power of the Planning Commission to prohibit the establishment
of a bakery in the block, and that the report of the committee
should be accepted.
By Commissioner Mitchell, seconded by Commissioner Perry:
Resolved, that the report as submitted be accepted and be
placed on file. Carried.
MOUND WIRES Chairman Hisoall reported that Mayor Asyere had
expressed his desire to have all wires and cables placed underground
when new pavements are laid.
By Commissioner Geherin, seconded by Commissioner Kitchell:
Resolved, that this Board recommend to the Board of Public
Works that all wires be placed underground when the E. Buffalo and
Seneca Streets pavements are laid. Carried.
0OULL UNIVERSITY PROJECT Engineer Uarble presented plans for
aW.P.A. project which the University have asked the City to
sponsor, for the construction of a new street from Eddy St. to
College Ave.
By Commissioner Dillon, seconded by Commissioner Treman:
Resolved, that the pians be approved in principal, with the
suggestion that roadway be widened as much as possible.
Carried.
On motion the meeting adjourned.
F. H. 8 roger
City Clerk
a. -
- - s
5
PLANNING 007"ISSION PROCEEDINGS
City of Ithaca, N. Y.
Regular Meeting 4:00 P. M. February 24, 1939
PRESENT
Chairman - Miscall
Commissioners - Treman, Montillon, Geherin
Clerk - Springer
Engineer - Marble
Forester - Baker
MINUTES Minutes of the preceding regular and special meetings j
were duly approved.
i
STANDING COMMITTEES The Chairman presented the following list of
appointments to standing committees, and requested the Board to
suggest changes if found advisable:
Zoning Civic Improvements
A. H. Treman, Chairman W. J. Mitchell Chairman
E. D. Montillon E. D. Dontill0
J. . E. Perry iii. A. Dillon
City Plan Capitalized Budget and Finances
E. D. Montillon, Chairman J. F. Geherin, Chairman
A. H. Treman W. J. Mitchell
W. J. Mitchell A. H. Treman
Recreational Facilities Relations with other Depts. and Publicity
W. A. Dillon, Chairman J. E. Perry, Chairman
F J. E. Perry W. A. Dillon
J. F. Geherin J. F. Geherin
.. By Commissioner Montillon, seconded by Commissioner Treman:
Resolved, that all the persons hereinabove appointed by the
Chairman be and they hereby are approved. Carried.
ANNUAL TARBELL DINNER The Chairman reported on the annual Tarbell
dinner held at t e Ithaca Hotel, February 20, 1939i which was
attended by 92 persons.
He reported that a number had expressed appreciation for the
opportunity to attend a gathering of this sort and that they felt
much good would come from the meeting.
Several persons were called upon to give short talks, and the
various subjects discussed, revealed a real interest in City planning
ZONE DAPS Engineer Marble presented corrected zone maps for .,atten-
tion of the Board.
By Commissioner Montillon, seconded by Commissioner Geherin:
Resolved, that the Clerk be directed to mail corrected copies
to real estate men and others who may be interested. Carried.
CITY PLAN By Commissioner Geherin, seconded by Comm. Montillon:
Resolved, that the City Plan Committee and the City
Engineer proceed with preparation of the. Master City Plan.
Carried.
ACQUISITION OF LAND Commissioner Treman expressed the thought that
it would bewell for this Board to suggest to the proper City offi-
cials the importance of acquiring rights of way and other vacant
property in the City, with the view of constructing new streets to
relieve traffic, and to establish neighborhood parks and wading pools
By Commissioner Treman, seconded by Commissioner Geherin:
Resolved, that the matter be referred to the City Plan Committee
for study and recommendations. Carried.
On motion the meeting adjourned. ,
H. Sp, nge.r, Ci C .
Planning Mesion Banquet
Ithaca Hotel, February 20, 1939
i
This banquet is sponsored by the Planning Commission
and is an annual gathering started by George Tarbell, January
20! 1933, and has this year been extended to include other in-
terested groups. The following is a list of those who have
indicated their acceptance of the invitation to attend. The
notation following each name is an indication of their repre-
sentation:
Names Representation
A
Adams, Armand Alderman
Baker, R. S. B City Forester
Baldwin, Harry Ithaca Savings & Loan
Barns, Amos Alderman
Betten, Cornelius Cornell Univ. Faculty
Boyd, W. A. Ithaca Enterprises
Bretz, J. P. Finger Lakes State Parks Comm.
Button, E. D. Fire Commissioner
Button, John L. Ithaca Auto Club
Burns, John Real Estate
Burns, Pm. Tompkins Co. Trust Co.
C
Campbell, J. Contractor
Carey, H. A. Bd. of Health
Carpenter, G. D. Supt. 'Water & Sewer Depts.
Chamberlain, A. W. Tompkins Co. Trust Co.
Conley, J. Dist. Director W.P.A.
Cook, G. L. Bd. of Education & Hospital
Cook, G. L. Jr. Ithaca Savings Bank
Coyle, T. J. National Youth Admin.
Crandall, Carl Finger Lakes State Parks Comm.
Crowley, Daniel Democratic County Chairman
Crumb, E. D. Shell Union Oil Corp.
D
Dahmen, E. F.Y.S. Highway Dept.
Dall, J. J. Jr. Contractor P.W.A.
Dean, Frank Ithaca Public Schools
Dillon, W. A. Planning Board
Dixon, E. J. Board of Zoning Appeals
" Driscoll, J. J. Board of Zoning Appeals
E
Egbert, J. Bd. of Public Works
F
Feinberg, A. N. Tompkins County Bar Assoc.
" G
Geherin, J. F. Planning Board
Gillette, E. S. Alderman
H '
E Hall, E. F. , M.D. Obstetrician
Hamm, A. County Tv.P.A. Director
Hewit, C. Architect
Hines, J. Cayuga rotors
Hollister, E. C. Cornell Univ. Faculty
Hoover, F. alderman
Hopper, Roy P. Bd. of Public Works
J
Job, Leonard President, Ithaca College
K s
Kenerson, C. J. Xorse Chain Co. & First Nat 11 Bank
Kenerson, Y. horse Chain Co.
Kittler, Alfred Lehigh Valley R. R.
Kopf, D. FJ. Editor, Cornell Daily 9=
Kulp, Claude Supt. of Schools
j
Ramos R®pTe eeaatioa
L
Larkin, J. V. National Park Servioe
Leatchneauer, J. Alderman
Leonard, V. Bd. of Zoning Appeals
Lunn, J. Building Commissioner
Lee, D. Boardman Bd. of Zoning Appeals
�i
Xaol:esey, J. _ CoM11 Univ. Faoulty
Malcolm, G. A. Cornell Univ. Faculty
Marble, T. F. City Engineer
Mazza, Ralph Alderman
latchell W. J. Finger Lakes Parks Comm.
Aonroe, S. Civil Service Comm.
Montillon, F. Planning Board
-,ungle, Ralph Bd. of Education
?dyers, J. Mayor
MoOlintock, Cornell Univ. Dept. of Bldgs. & Grds.
MoNamarra, J. Prudential Insurance
Iascall, Leonard Planning Bd. - Bd. of Public Works
satchel, Earl Supt. Tompkins Co. Memorial Hoop.
N
Neill, L. D. _ Supervisor
Normile, S. D. L. & W. R. R.
0
Osborn, R. C. _ Supervisor - Bd. of Welfare
P
Painter, R. _ Ithaca Schools Faculty
Patterson, Leslie Bd. of Health
Peer, Sherman Stewart Park Comm.
Post, John Welfare Commissioner
. . Price, Don A. N.Y. State Gas & Electric Corp.
R
Reamer, John Ex Mayor -- Ithaca Laundries
Sainburg, P. C. Bd. of ►elfare
Saperstone, D. A. Sport Shop
Y Sawdon, C.. L. Bd. of Public Forks
Simpson, Harold City Judge
Smith, L. P. Ex Mayor - Ithaca Gun Shop
Smith, Ralph Chamber of Commerce
� . Spaid, F. 0. N. Y. Telephone Co.
Springer, Floyd City Clerk
Stone, A. G. Sinking Fund Comm.
Stutz, Harry Ithaca Journal News
Sullivan, J. Le American Federation Labor
Thompson, H. F. T Alderman
_ Townsley, E. D. Bd. of Zoning Appeals
Treman, Alan Planning Board
V
Vail, Carl ` Alderman
Vorhees, E. L. Lehigh Valley R. R.
7
Tard, A. A. Contractor
Weatherlow, Hugh Cornel Univ. Supt. Bldgs. & Grds.
Weaver, F. N. Y. Telephone Co.
Whipple, G®o, Treman, King & Co.
T'hitaker, G. Resident Engr. P.^.A. Project 11913
%lcox, H. Atwaters
.,2-
V "
PLANNING 0010JISSION PROCEEDINGS
City of Ithaca, N. Y.
Regular Meeting 4:00 P. M. March 31, 1939
PRESENT
Chairman - Miscall
Commissioners - Montillon, Geherin, Mitchell
Clerk - Springer
Engineer Marble
Forester - Baker
1
KINUTES :. inutes of the *preceding meeting were duly approved.
GEO. E. CLAPP LETTER The following letter was read by the Clerk:
March 14 1939
Pyr. Leonard Hi scall
Chairman Planning Commission
Ithaca, N. Y.
Hy dear Sir:
This is written by the suggestion of one of the members
of the Planning Commission, and is in reference to proposal to
plant shrubbery on the east side of University Ave.
I have lived at 204 University Ave. for ten years, and
can see several reasons why this project should not go through.
They are enumberated below, and in expressing these opinions, wish
to state that the several residents with whom I have talked are not
in accord with the projeot.
Firstly - It will be a continual source of expense to the
t. City. The subbase is of solid rock, and during the summer months
this place is flooded at times, whioh wouldwash away the top soil,
and no doubt some of the shrubs. If the City constructed a curb
it is problematical that this area would not be flooded.
F.
Secondly - There is the crying need for other projects
which seem more desirable, and in as much as the residents do not
desire it, and University Ave. is not a main artery of traffic,
this money could be diverted to something that the people want.
Thirdly - Because of the contour of the land few of the
residents on the Avenue have garages, and it makes an ideal place
to drive off the pavement, thus eliminating- a traffic problem.
Even residents with garages use this space during icy reather be-
cause they cannot drive into their own. Becsuee of this space it
is easier for the apartment houses in this r..eighborhood to secure
tenants.
G:
F In vein of these f^cts I trust that you and the other
members of the Comlaission will not press this issue to plant shrubs.
The Avenue is very beautiful in its present condition because the
City in past times planted forsythia.
Very respectfully
George E. Clapp
204 University Ave.
To be read at the next meeting. Ithaca, IT. Y.
The Chairman referred the letter to the committee on Civic
improvement for study and report.
PO"ER ATD D TIES OF PLAYN NGC - SB ON The Chairman explained
that he duties and powers of Planning Commissions ase outlined in
the General-City Law, -and it was regularly moved, seconded and
carried that conies of the Law be distributed to the Commissioners.
23.
RAILWAY MAIL CLUB OF NEW YORK, INC.
33 est 34th Street
New York, N. Y.
60e March 142 1939
Mr. Leonard Miscall
Chairman Planning Commission
Ithaca, N. Y.
My dear Sir:
This is written by the suggestion of one of the
members of the Planning Commission, and is in reference to
proposal to plant shrubbery on the east side of University
Ave.
I have lived at 204 University Ave. for ten years,
and can see several reasons why this project should not go
through. They are enumerated below, and in expressing these
opinions, wish to state that the several residents with whom
I have talked are not in accord with the project.
Firstly - It will be a continual source of expense
to the City. The subbase is of solid rock, and during the
summer months this place is flooded at times which would
wash away the top soil, and no doubt some of the shrubs. If
the City constructed a curb it is problematical that this
area would not be flooded.
Secondly - There is the crying need for other
projects which seem more desirable, and in as much as the
residents do not desire it, and University Ave. is not a
main artery of traffic, this money could be diverted to
something that the people want.
Thirdly - Because of the contour of the land few
of the residents on the Avenue have garages, and it makes an
ideal place to drive off the pavement, thus eliminating a
traffic problem. Even residents with garages use this space
during icy weather because they cannot drive into their own.
Because of this space it is easier for the apartment houses
in this neighborhood to secure tenants.
In view of these facts I trust that you and the
other members of the Commission will not press this issue to
plant shrubs. The Avenue is very beautiful in its present
condition because the City in past times planted forsythia.
Very respectfully
George E. Clapp
204 University Ave.
Ithaca, N. Y.
To be read at the next meeting.
PHONES M !ON 3-SI32
aiZYaap Ala tt Club of AtW �or�, �tt�.
3 3 0 W E S T 3 4 T H S T R E E T
NEW YORK, N.Y.40 1
1.7,`
4-1
. 1
ax,
r _
`� 1J
PHONE: M .SON 3-5132
afY�ap
Out Club of Atw Pork, .Nc.
33 0 WEST 34TH STREET
NEW YORK, N.Y.
Gt�A*-�! �. 2w�-•� a..d- �� /�.�-n-�--Com.--�` � -,�-
77
O'G(
1�
64
A�
� , . ,e-d �
PHONE: M' ,toN 3-5132
acirnapacir Club ofebavr , .3ttc.
3 3 0 WEST 34TH STREET
NEW Y®R K, N.Y.
Planning Commission -2- March 31, 1939
_IILTG HM Commissioner 1:ontillon stated that the meeting hour
of 4 P.M. often conflicted with other engagements and asked if the
hour could be changed to 4:15 or 4: 30 P.M.
By Commissioner Geherin, seconded by Commissioner Mitchell:
Resolved, that the regular meeting be and the same is hereby
fixed at 4: 30 P.V.- on the last Friday of each month.
Carried.
ACQUISITION OF LAND Commissioner I;ontillon reported on the
progress of the City Plan Committee in the matter of investigation
of -properties which it is felt the City should purchase for future
development.
JOHNSON BOAT HOUSE PROPERTY Chairman Kiscall called attention to
a small piece of land owned by the City, in the vicinity of the
Johnson boat house, for which Mr. Johnson wishes to trade a larger
piece in another location.
He explained that the lard, offered in exchange could be used
in connection with the proposed improvements to the Golf Course.
Forester Baker displayed plans snowing the proposed change in
the course, and relocation of the club rouse.
By Commissioner ;itcnell, seconded by Commissioner ;ontillon:
_ Resolved, that it is the sense of this Board that the exchange
be made. Carried.
TRAFFIC DIVERSION Engineer marble presented a sketch showing
necessary rights of way for the street proposed to divert traffic
from East State to East Seneca Street.
The Chairman referred the sketch to the Civic Improvement
Committee for study and report.
WADING POOL A sketch for a wading pool, suitable for various
locations, was studied by the Commissioners.
The plan was referred to the Recreational Facilities Committee
for study and report.
On motion the meeting was adjourned.
F. H. pringer
City Clerk
PLANNING COMMISSION PROCEEDINGS
City of Ithaca, N. Y.
Regular Meeting 4: 30 P. M. April 28, 1939
P'IF,SF'!'T
I- =.i rman - 1.1i scall
,onmissioners - 111ontillon, Dillon, Mitchell
Engineer - Marble
Forester - Baker
Clerk °pringer
MINUTES Minutes of the preceding meeting were duly approved.
UlIVERS'ITY AVE. PARKING Commissioner Mitchell reported on the
matter of planting in the parking on the east side of Uniaversity
Ave. and asked to have a further study made to ascertain if, part
of the space can be retained for the parking of cars and the bal-
ance to be landscaped.
The matter was referred to the City Engineer and Forester for
study and report.
C ZONE CHANGE REQUEST Mr. George W. Sharpe appeared for A.B. Pyle
of l ilkW. t8 ate Street to request approval of a zone change of
F the westerly part of W. State Street on the 1100 block from "A"
residential to commercial.
He called attention to the fact that one half of.the block in
auestion is now commercial, and that 90' of the property owners
adjoining this block have signified their approval in writing of
the change.
The matter was referred to the committee on zoning with power,
to investigate and make recommendations to the Common Council.
ZONE CHANGE A letter from C. Chaddook Head was received request-
ni"g azone change of the east portion of the 300 block of E.
Buffalo Street be changed from "A" residential to commercial to
enable him to establish a small poultry business on the second floor
of a barn in the rear of 313 E. Buffalo Street.
By Commissioner Rrontillon, seconded by Commissioner Mitchell:
Resolved, that the Clerk be directed to inform Mr. Head that
when approval of the Board of Health is obtained, this Board will
act upon the zoning question. Carried.
TRAFFIC DIVERSION The Civic Improvement Committee reported prog-
ress on their study of the traffic diversion, problem.
WADING POOLS The Recreational Facilities Committee promised action
on the etudy of locations for wading pools.
W. P.A. PROJECTS- Chairman Miscall reported that in adopting the
tentative budget for 1939, the Common Council have made no provi-
sion for the continuance of W.P.A. projects, and that he felt the
Council should provide funds for such projects, which will help to,
reduce the -relief load.
By Commissioner Mitchell, seconded by Commissioner Montillon:
Whereas, the Common Council has made no_ provision for the con-
tinuance of W.P.A. projects for the coming season, and
Whereas, it is the opinion of the Planning Commission that
W. P.A. projects are best for the public interest.
Now Therefore Be It Resolved, that the Planning Commission
urge the Common Council to set up funds to permit the continuance
of W.P.A. projects throughout the coming season. Carried.
ONING ORDINANCE Attention was called to the fact that numerous
requests are being made for zone changes, and that the completion
of the new zoning ordinance would aid materially in acting on
these requests.
By Commissioner Hontillon, seconded by Commissioner Mitchell:
Resolved, that this Commission urge the City Attorney to com-
plete the new zoning ordinance. Carried.
On motion the meeting was adjourned..,-
F. K pringer, iffity Clerk 2J
PLANNING COMMISSION PROCEEDINGS
City of Ithaca, N. Y.
Special Meeting 4: 30 P. M. May 23, 1939
PflE4�+-r�
01iairman - Miscall
Commissioners - Dillon, Montillon, Treman, Geherin
Engineer - Marble
Porester - Baker
Clerk •- Springer
Chairman Miscall explained that the meeting had been called
at the rcquest -of Commissioner Treman to consider the removal of
trees a`': the corner of State and Plain Streets.
The Chairman stated that the civic improvement committee of
the Chamber of Commerce had written- Mr. R. C. Osborn and Mr.
Gallagher of the A & P Company reporting the sentiment of the
public as opposed to the removal of the trees, and that in reply,
Mr. Gallagher had approved leaving the trees if they did not
interfere with the construction of the buildingor cause damage
tQ the building after construction and had writen Cdr. Osborn to
hat effect.
The City Engineer and Forester were requested to consult with
the architect in regard to allowing for the roots of the trees
when building the foundation wall.
Be Commissioner Treman, seconded by Commissioner Geherin:
Resolved, that the Board of Public Works be requested that in
the future all requests for removal of trees from city streets be
referred to the Planning Commission for their consideration before
permission is given. Carried.
Vy Commissioner Montillon, seconded by Commissioner Dillon:
hereas, the present trees are an irreplaceable asset to the
streets, and
Whereas, removal being against the public interest.
Now Therefore Be It Resolved, that it is the sense of this
Commission that all the trees at the northeast corner of State and
Plain Streets bereserved, except the two northerly trees on
p
Plain Street , at the entrance of the proposed drivewa .
a
� rried.
By Commissioner Treman, seconded by Commis-sioner Geherin:
Resolved, that a copy of these minutes be transmitted to Mr.
R. C. Osborn, Mr. E. A. Gallagher, Mr. V. C. Schneider, local
superintendent of the A & P, and to Mr. Ray Burns, architect.
Carried.
On motion the meeting was adjourned.
F. H. Sglerk
City
)1
PLANNING OCUMISSION PROCEEDINGS
City of Ithaca, N. Y.
Regular Meeting - 4: 30 P. M. May 26, 1939
PRESENT
Mayor - Myers
Chairman - Hisoall
Commissioners - Treman, Hontillon, Perry, Hitchell
Clerk - Springer
Engineer - Marble
HINUT41 Minutes of the preceding regular, and special meetings
were duly approved.
. B. ECLE GAS STATIM Attorney L. N. Simmons appeared for Mrs
Pyle, and presented a petition signed by approximately 90%
of the property owners within. 200 feet of the lot in the 1100 block
of W. State Street, giving consent to the erection of a gas filling
station to be located at 1111 W. State Street.
Mr. Simmons stated that if approval is given, the owners will
deed 10 feet of the lot on the east side of Floral Avenue to the
city for the purpose of widening that street.
By Commissioner Hitchell, seconded by Commissioner Montillon:
Resolved, that this Commission recommends that a permit be
granted to construct a gas station at 1111 W. State Street in accord-
anoe with Sec. S, Par. a of the Zone Ordinance.
Ayes 3 Miscall, Montillon, Mitchell
Nays 1 Perry
Commissioner Treman did not vote. Motion Carried,
40 KING__ORDINANCE Chairman Hi.soall reported that the City Attorney
is making progress on the Zoning Ordinance and had intended to
present a part at this meeting but was unable to do so on account
of illness.
7l C.MM/S S •N< �
IU SS OONNN.Y.B. Q Treman called attention to the confer
enoeenoe of FeFederation of Official Planning Boards to be held
in connection with the Mayors Conference in Niagara Falls on June
5, 6 and 7th. and stated that he felt this Board should be repre-
sented at the oonference.
By Commissioner Treman, seconded by Commissioner Perry:
Resolved, that Chairman Miscall be and he hereby is authorized
to attend the conference. Carried.
On motion the meeting was adjourned,
fe
er
F.S
.,
�r:aL
rrJ
'C
PLANNING CC MISSION PROCEEDINGGS
City of Ithaca, N. Y.
Regular Meeting 4:30 P. M. June 30, 1939
Present
E
Chairman rman - Mi s c3al l
Commissioner - Montillon
Engineer - Marble
Clerk - Springer
Due to lack of quorum, meeting was adjourned.
F. H. Springer
Secretary
PLANNING OCMKISSIQN PROCEEDINGS
City of Ithaca, N. Y.
Regular Meeting 4: 30 P. M. July 29, 1939
PRESENT
Chairman - Miscall
Commissioner - Treman
Engineer Marble
Attorney - Powers
Forester - Baker
Clerk - Springer
Due to lack of quorum, the meeting was postponed.
F. H. Springer
City Clerk
G ,
i
PLANNING CCiaassION PROCEEDINGS
City of I thaoa, N. Y.
Postponed Regular Meeting 4:30 P.M. August 25, 1939
r
f
f
Due to lack of quorum no meeting was held.
f
F. H. pringer
City Clerk
f
f .
II'
f'
f
I .
i
'j
l
29
V
PLANNING C OSI SSI ON PRCCEEDI NG8
CITY OF ITHACA, N. Y.
Special Meeting 5:00 P. M. September 15, 1939
PRESENT
Chairman - Mi scall
Commissioners - Treman, Montillon, Dillon, Geherin
Engineer - Marble
Forester - Baker
Clerk •- Springer
Chairman Miscall explained that the meeting was called to act
upon a petition referred to this Board by the Common Council,
requesting a change. of zoning of the westerly portion of the
1100 block of West State Street and to transact such other busi-
ness that might properly come before the meeting.
SHADE TRESS Commissioner Treman expressed displeasure at
t e recent action of the Board of Public Works, in granting
4: permission to remove the tree at the East line of the Osborn
property at the. Corner of State and Plain Streets, without
ki
first referring the matter to the Planning Commission and felt
= 1939 should
that the resolution
passed by this Board on May 23,
again be called to the attention of the Board of Public Forks.
By Commissioner Treman, seconded by Commissioner Montillon:
Resolved, that it is the sense of this Board that all a
requests for removal of trees from City streets be referred to
the Planning Com,�iission for their consideration before permission
is given. Carried.
CITY MAPS Engineer Marble reported that he has prepared
a project for submission to the W. P. A. for work on sewer and
other maps and that the total estimated cost is $5., 500# 00t of
which #1712.00 will be the sponsor 's share.
By Commissioner Montillon, seconded by Commissioner Geherin: �
Resolved, that this Board recommend submission of the pro-
ject
ro-
ject to W. P. As and urge approval. Carried.
ZCN 'CHANGZ6 Chairman Miscall stated that the Common Council
hae referred the petition for a change in zoning in West State
Staeet to this Commission for study and report, with the fol-
lowing memorandum, "in the event that the Planning Commission
shall recommend the change of any area other than that described
in the petition herein, advertisement shall refer to such
recommendation and describe such other or different area in
addition to the area described in the petition. "
By Commissioner Dillon, seconded by Commissioner Montillon:
Resolved, that this Board recommend that the zoning be
changed for all of the remainder of the block bounded by West
State Street, Floral Avenue, and West Seneca Street, from "A"
Residential, to Commercial Classification.
Ay es 4
Nays 0 Carried.
Commi ssi one r Treman did not vote.
On motion the meeting was adjourned.
T
7
IN H. Springer
City Clerk
PLANNING OC6'CIISSION PROCEEDINGS
City of Ithaca, N. Y.
Regular ieeting 4: 30 P• M. September 29, 1939
?RESENT
Chairman - iii s cal l
Commissioners - Treman, Montillon, Geherin, Perry
Attorney - Powers
Engineer - Marble
Clerk - Springer
Forester - Baker
MINUTES Y,zinutes of the preceding meeting were duly approved.
ZONE CRD NANAttorney Powers presented a draft of six (6)
articles of the new zoning ordinance which were discussed by the
Commission. He stated that the question of location of gas sta-
ti ons and the establishment of trailer camps had not been settled,
and that a proposed amendment to the sanitary code to regulate
trailers was being studied by the Board of Health..
L'r. Powers agreed to send mimeographed copies of the completed
articles of the zone code to the Commissioners for their consider-
ation.
Chairman !Usoall requested Oommissioner Treman, Chairman of
the Zoning Committee, and Commissioner liontillon, Chairman of the
City Plan Committee, to study the completed articles and make
recommendati ons.
On motion the Meeting was adjourned.
r
F. .H. pringer
K City Clerk
ri
N.
PLANNING OMISSION PROCEEDINGS
City of Ithaca, N. Y.
Special Meeting 4: 30 P. M. October 19, 1939
PRESENT
Chairman - Miscall
Commissioners - Treman, Montillon, Dillon, Geherin, Perry
Engineer - Marble
Clerk - Springer
HOEFLE SUBDIVISICK Chairman Miscall explained that the meet-
ing was called to discuss the request of Dr. Hoefle, for approv-
al of the sale of additional lots in his new development on
Cornell Street.
Attention was called to the fact that only the preliminary
plan had been presented for approval and that the final plan
has not been filed.
By Commi ssi oner Dillon, seconded by Commi ssi oner Perry:
Resolved, that Dr. Hoefle be notified that he must meet
the requirements set forth in the rules and regulations gov-
erning subdivisions, and submit a final plan as set forth in
section "O" thereof. Unanimously Carried.
UAP PROTECT Chairman Mi.scall reported that a project has been
submitted for W.P.A. approval, which will further the comple-
tion of a master plan, and furnish maps of all sewers and water
mains and will monument all city property, and suggested that
the committee on Civic Improvements study the project.
On motion the meeting was adjourned*
F. H. pringer
Ci Clerk
t
f
32
ter
PLANNING COMMISSION PROCEEDINGS
City of Ithaca, N. Y.
Regular Meeting 4: 30 P. M. October 27, 1939
PRESENT
Chairman - Ki scall
Commissioners - Treman, biontillon, perry
Engineer - Marble
Clerk - Springer
Forester Bele.T
MINUTES Minutes of the preceding meeting were duly approved.
HOEFLE ,SUBDIVISION Engineer Marble presented Uap 43 of the Hoefle
subdivision on as prepared by C. Crandall, and stated that approval of
the map, and sale of lots No. 1 to 11 has been requested.
By Commissioner Treman, seconded by Commissioner Perry:
Resolved, that the plot plan of lots 1 to 11 inclusive, as
shown on "Map #3 subdivision for H. C. Hoefle on Cornell Street,
Ithaca, N. Y. , " made by 0. Crandall, O•E. , October 25, 1939, be re-
turned to H. 0. Hoefle, and that the Clerk of the Planning Commis-
si on certify approval on such map for the Planning Commission,
after the following slight amendments are made to such map:
1. Add. s. note to show that courses and distances along Home-
stead Road are of chords.
2. Give name of adjoining property owners on east, and of the
subdi vi si on on the west.
3. Indicate the relationship of the lot line meridian used,
to either true north or magnetic north of 1939-
4. Indicate the bearing between lots S and 11.
5. Indicate the bearing of the south line of the subdivision.
Carried.
By Commissioner Treman, seconded by Commissioner Xontillon:
Resolved, that this approval be on the further understanding
that in conveying lots No. 1 and 2, the triangular corners in-
dicated as within the street lines shall be reserved for street
purposes, and that a cloth print of the above mentioned map be
filed in the County Clerk i s office, and a blue print in the City
Clerks office, and before any lots are sold or contracted for sale,
east of lots 10 and 11, further approval of this Commission must
be obtained.
Further, that particular attention be called to section ISD" of
the rules and regulations of the Ithaca Planning Commission.
Carried.
CIVIC IMPROVM1ENT§ Commissioner Montillon for the Civic Improve-
ment Committee submitted the following list of suggested improve-
ments with the further recommendation that a survey of all bridges
be made to determine a definite program of replacement, thus avoid-
ing the necessity for an excessively large bond issue in .any
particular year; that Floral Avenue and Taughannock Blvd. be paved
in the near future and that the 000perati on of the State be sought
in financing these prof eota;that a connection between Eddy Street
and College Avenue, south of Oascadilla Hall be constructed.
LIST OF IMPR TS
a East State Street, Albany Street to Mitchell Street.
a Dryden Road, Bryant Avenue to new concrete west of Ithaca Road.
a Fulton Street, Vilest Seneca Street to West State Street.
a Construction of new bridge coresing Six Mile Creek at Plain
Street.
(a) Construction of new bridge across Six Mile Creek at Van Natta
Pumping Stati on.
(a) Extension of Green or Clinton Streets or both to cc eat with
{files Gtr** ;
I
Planning Commission -2- October 27, 1939
e Treatment of University Avenue on-easterly side.
, a Renewal and repairs to creek walls along Six Mile Creek.
a Improvement of the airport.
(b Repaving and widening of College Avenue from Kitchell Street
to Oak Avenue.
(b) Repaving and widening East Buffalo Street, Aurora Street to
Eddy Street.
(b) Removal of rails and repaving of Tioga Street, State Street to
Falls Street.
b Removal of rails and repaving Thurston Avenue.
c Removal of rails and repaving of Eddy Street to campus gate.
o Widening and paving of East Seneca Street, Aurora Street to
Schuyler Place.
(c� Repaving and widening of Seneca Street, Aurora Street to West
State Street.
By Commissioner Perry, seconded by Commi ssi oner Uontillon:
Resolved, that the recommendations submitted by the Civic
Improvement Committee be approved and included with other recommend-
ations to be submitted to the Mayor for consideration during budget
preparation.. Carried.
ACNE CHANGE A letter from Attorney L. N. Simons was read, pro-
testing the decision of the Common Council in regard to the re-
quested zone change in the block between rest State and West Buffalo
Streets at Floral Avenue.
By Commissioner Montillon, seconded by Commi ssi oner Treman:
Resolved, that a special committee be appointed, consisting of
three members of the Planning Commission, including the Chairman,
to study the question of zoning in the area from Buffalo Street
south, along Floral Avenue to Clinton Street, between West Hill and
the Lehigh Valley R.R. tracks. Carried.
Chairman Miscall appointed Commissioners %r"ontillon and Geherin,
to serve on the committee.
F. Wo Spring
Secretary
j
434
r
E
r
F
L
f
R
PLANNING 0M1MISSION PROCEEDINGS
City of Ithaca, N. Y.
Regular Meeting 4: 30- P- M. November 24, 1939
PRESENT
Chairman - Miscall
Commissioners - Treman, Montillon, Geherin, Perry, Mitchell
Engineer - Marble
Clerk - Springer
Forester - Baker
MINUTES- Minutes of the preceding meeting were duly approved.
ONE CH NGE The special committee appointed at the last meeting,
o study the question of zoning in the area from Buffalo Street
south along Floral Avenue to Clinton Street between Nest Hill and
the L.V.R.R• tracks, submitted the following report with recommenda-
tions:
Ithaca, N. Y.
The City Planning Commission
Committee to consider change of Zone in the block bounded by Floral
Ave. , West State St. and West Seneca St.
Committee - Commissioners Misoall, Geherin and Montillon
The Committee recommends that the zone classification of that
westerly portion of this block now zoned as A Residential be changed
to Commercial.
The easterly end of the block is now zoned Commercial. The
boundry between the two zones at present cuts obliquely across one
of the properties facing W. State St. Incidentally this undesirable
situation would be obviated by the change recommended.
The Committee has visited, observed and studied the conditions
on the tract in question. The outstanding fact on the ground is
the identity of the character of use and development of this tract
with those areas adjacent to the south, east and north. The land
lies on a level contiguous with these areas. It is separated from
areas to the west by the abruptly rising grades of Zest Hill. All
of the property fronting the hill streets is distinctly removed not
only in level but in distance.
There seems, to the committee, that there is no sound, justi-
fiable reason why the tract concerning which their opinion is asked
should be zoned differently from adjoining level areas mentioned.
These areas are zoned Commercial and Industrial. The entire terri-
tory is occupied by a poor and deteriOrated residential use.
The change of zone would in no wise interfere with the existing
use. Nor would it interfere with an extension of this use. On the
other hand, it would seem likely that incident to any sale of this
property for residential purposes would go a deterioration of
occupancy.
The assessable value in this neighborhood now is very small.
The only increase in value to the owners or to the city would appear
to lie in a use other than residential.
At the northwesterly corner of the block in question, the
corner of W. State St. and Floral Ave. , there is a request for a use
Other than residential. The committee feels that rezoning to permit
this use, would be an improvement and is desirable. The development
sought would inevitably give a better visability at a corner now
obstructed in view and the fact that the gift to the city of ten
feet of land along Floral Ave. is involved should be noted.
Respectfully submitted,
for the Committee - Eugene D. Montillon, Chairman 5
a _
r
At a regular meeting of the Planning Commission on October 27,
1939, the following resolution was passed:
"Resolved, that the recommendations submitted by the Civic Im-
provement Committee be approved and included with other recommenda-
tions to be submitted to the L:ayor during budget preparation. "
This report is submitted by the Planning Commission with the
idea that it will be helpful to the City in preparing its budget.
The Commission feels that sometime annual improvements will be part
of a general improvement program which will be embodied in a master
plan which will cover the work to be done for a period of years. An
important item to be considered when capital outlays are made for
improvements is the sequence in which they are made. A well prep4red
and carefully thought our master plan will make it possible to choose
items which will be of maximum public interest both from the service
standpoint and the financial cost involved.
x.
The Commission has considered the items mentioned herein and
offer them as suggestions for improving the City.
At the beginning of the year when the Planning Commission was
organized for the year 1939, it was decided to break the work of the
Commission down to six standing committees; these c.owiittees with
their membership are appended below. It is the feeling of the Plann-
ing
laning Commission that by breaking its membership into committees, they
have been better able to study the various problems that are presentee
' to them or that they feel there is an urgency of taking up.
Zon1 E Civic Improvements
A. H. Treman, Chairman Mitchell, Chairman
E. D. 111,ontillon E. D. 1dontillon
J. E. Perry W. A. Dillon
City Plan Canitali zed Budget and _Finanoes
E. D. It ontillon, Chairman J. F. Geherin, Chairman
` A. H. Trernian W. J. Mitchell
W. J. YLitohell A. H. Treman
Recreational Facilities Relations with other Depts. and
-.~ Publicity
W. A. Dillon, Chairman J. E. Perry, Chairman J. E. Perry W. A. Dillon
J. F. Geherin J. F. Geherin
You will find in this report original recommendations of the
various committees as submitted to the Planning Commission. Also
you will find the recoml.iendations of the Planting Commission after
they have acted on these reports.
OOMITTEE REPORTS
CITY OF ITriACA
THE CITY PLANNING COP.,`�'. ISSION
00M;ITTEE ON CITY PLAN
To,-Mr. Leonard ?di scall
Chairman of the Commission.
The Committee understands that its function is to study and seek
the establishment of a waster Plan for the City of Ithaca. Such a
plan, when endorsed by the proper legal authority, would provide
the pattern for future improvements, changes and extensions within
the city.
During the year 1938 a start was made toward such a plan. The
expenditure of a portion of the Commission's appropriation for the
work made this possible.
Early in the current year, 1939, the Commission authorized the
expenditure of all or part of its appropriation for work on the
plan. Later a idaster Plan work project was submitted to the W.P.A.
...2- 1�
Pending approval of this project by the W.P.A. , the Commission's
appropriation has been held in reserve. It is believed that a much
more efficient and economical use of the money can be made in ampli-
fication of the W.P.A. project, than were it used separately.
Your committee urges that the Common Council be req ested to re-
appropriate the unexpended balance of the Commission's 1939 appropri-
ation, ear-marking it for Master Plan work and that appr val be
sought of the W.P.A. Master Plan project.
The work to date on the Master Plan consists in the compilation
of facts.
An outline street map of the City, at 100 scale, in sections,
on standard size sheets has been drawn as a basis for f they plottin&
This map, based on data from all available sources, is correct and
accurate to a degree that previously no general map of the city has
been. Plottings have been made of Paving, Storm Sewers, City Rights-
of-Way and City Owned Property.
Much remains to be done both in the compilation of facts and
the recording of the same on the map. Included here are Sanitary
Sewers and Water lines.
Before proposals of change are attempted, all pertinent facts
should be clearly on record to guide the study of such changes.
A New Zone Map is an item of real importance and practical
city economy. Such a map should be accurate and detailed which
the present map is not. The revision of the Zoning Ordinance now
being carried forward by the City Attorney, with occass' onal review
by' the Planning Commission, should be paralleled by a study of the
map looking especially to a definition of the boundary ines between
zones. Some of these now out across property ownership lines most
incoherently. The Planning Commission, about a year ago, reviewed
the zone distributions of the present map with care and put on
record, for further study, certain suggested zone changes.
Only with money to work with, can this important Mdertaking
of a Master Plan go forward. Your Committee earnestly 3-ecommends
that the Commission seek for this undertaking the sympathetic con-
sideration,, approval and support of the Common Council.
Respectfully submitted,
Eugene D. Eont i ltl on
Chairman of the Comiittee.
The Committee on City Plan
Hr. A. H. Treman
Mr. W. J. Mitchell
Hr. E. D. . ontillon
REPORT OF COMMITTEE ON RECREATIONAL FACILITIES
Ithaca, N.Y.
Nov. 61 1939
Mr. Leonard IjIscall, Chairman,
Ithaca Planning Comm.
Ithaca, N. Y.
Dear Ifr. iii scall:
Sometime ago, I made a survey regarding the wading pools for
children. I found the best locations as follows:
South of Six Mile Creek .
Vicinity of the West Side House
Vicinity of Cascadilla St. , it would be necessary o use one
of the parks
Another wading pool might be located close to Fall Creek School
South Hill, could be served by present pool at Van Natta's Ilam
The Brys:at Tract section, offers several locations
i
-3--
I am forwarding a copy of this letter to k1r. Geher nand 1r.
John Perry, so that they may submit a similar report to you.
F.
Very truly yours,
William A. Dillon,
406 First National Bank Bldg.
REPORT OF CO Qi'ITTEZ ON CIVIC IMPROVE3:1ENTS
At a meeting of the Civic Improvement Committee of the Plann-
ing Commission at City Hall, Thursday, October 26, 1939 the attached
list of improvements was classified into three classes a:nnely Class
€' A, B, and C with that work which the Committee deems most urgent
placed in Class A.
The committee recowiends further that a survey of 11 bridges
should be made to determine a definite program of replacement and
thus avoiding the necessity for an excessively large bond issue in
any particular year.
of
Fr The committee discussed the paving/Floral Avenue and Taughannock
Boulevard and recommends that these streets should be paved in the
near future and that cooperation be sought from the State of New
York in the financing of these projects.
The committee further recommends that a new street connection
between Eddy Street and College Avenue, south of 0asoadilla Hall
be constructed.
Respectfully submitted
Eugene D. 1ontillon w o substituted
for W. J. Mitchell
LIST OF IMPROVEI. TS
(a) East State Street, Albany Street to Mitchell Street
(a) Dryden Road, Bryant Avenue to new concrete west of Ithaca Road.
(a) Fulton Street, West Seneca Street to nest State Street.
(a) Construction of new bridge crossing Six Yile Creek at Plain St.
(a) Construction of new bridge across Six ?:file Creek at Van Natta
Pumping Station.
(a) Extension of Green or Clinton Streets or both to ocnneot with
Giles Street.
(a) Treatment of University Avenue on easterly side.
(a) Renewal and repairs to creek walls along Six Lille Creek.
(a) Improvement of the airport.
(b) Repaving and widening of College Avenue from Mitche 1 Street to
Oak Avenue.
(b) Repaving and widening East Buffalo Street, Aurora S reet to
Eddy Street.
(b)' Removal rails and repaving of Tioga Street, Stata. Street to
s< Falls Street.
(b) Removal of rails and repaving Thurston Avenue.
(c) Removal of rails and repaving of Eddy Street to campus gate.
(c) Widening and paving of East Seneca Street, Aurora Street to
Schuyler Place.
(o) Repaving and widening of Seneca Street, Aurora Stre t to West
State Street.
,...w,v! iE�... ..
7-1
} i•
d
RVO
t "' TIONSfiE 00124
`
Ur
The Planning Commission, after carefully studying a d consider-
t ing the report of its various committees offers the foll wing reccm-
�f' mendations which it feels will promote .the general welfa a and
accomplish the work necessary to, be done in an economical way for ¢
the taxpayers. The recommendations must of necessity be general.
It is our intention to give the various boards a choice of projects
so that work can be done within the capacity of the city to pay.
PUBLIC, IraPROVE11ENTS
Paving,
1. East State Street, Albany Street to Mitchell. S+reet. a)
2. Dryden Road, Bryant Avenue to new concrete weet- of Ithaca Road. (a)
. Fulton Street, Nest Seneca Street to West State Street. (a)
4. Repaving and widening of College Avenue from Mitchell Street to
Oak Avenue. (b)
5. Repaving and widening East Buffalo Street, Aurora Str et to
Eddy Street. (b)
6. Removal of rails and repaving of Tioga Street, State treet to
Falls Street. (b)
' The Commission feels that the paving of Tioga Stree thruout
its entire length can wait .until some future time but wo d like
to note that it considers the first three blocks (State t. to Court
St. ) of immediate importance. These blocks are alwaydi s c ngested
due to the location of several private and public builgs within
their limits. In the first two blocks (State St. to Bu falo St. )
the curbs are in bad shape and the sidewalks much too wi e. This
extra sidewalk width could be readily transferred to the street
pavement. The Commission recommends that the first three blocks
be paved but if limited funds only are available then it recon.iends
that the first two blocks be paved.
7. Removal of rails and repaving Thurston Avenue. (b)
9. Removal of rails and repaving of Eddy Street, from S ate Street
to campus gate. (c)
9. Widening and paving of East Seneca Street, Aurora St eet to
Schuyler Place. (c
10. Repaving and widening of Seneca Street, Aurora Streei to West
State Street. (c
11. Paving Floral Avenue. Aggressive action should be taken to
obtain state aid in paving this street so that it may serve as
an arterial highway.
Bridge Construction
The Commission would like to note at this point th t many of
the bridges within the city are living on borrowed time Many of
them are out of date and some of them have such a low c nacity that
the passage of modern traffic is dangerous. This fact hould be
borne in mind for during the next 10 years the city will probably
have to spend considerable ;Honey on building new, stronlrer,, and
more modern bridges. A comprehensive survey of the bridges is
needed.
1. Construction of new bridge crossing Six hi le Creek a Plain St. (a)
2. Construction of new bridge across Six Mile Creek at an Natta
Pumping Station. This improvement will make Giles S reet service-
able as an arterial way. (a)
3. Construction of a new bridge across Cascadilla creek at Lincoln
Street. (b)
4. Construction of a new bridge across Oasead lla creek at Ma.rsball
street (a)
..r
Creek Improvements
1. Renewal and repairs to creek walls along Six Hile creek.
2. Cleaning of Cascadilla creek of debris and fill from Aurora Street
to Lincoln Street.
General Improvements
1. Treatment of University Avenue on easterly side so as to improve
its appearance.
2. Extension of Green or Clanton Streets or bot'Z •;o connect with
Giles Street.
3. Improvement of the airport.
The Commission feels that the maintenance of the airport
facilities is a very important service. Some time in the near
future our airport will have to be enlarged in order to accommodate
larger ships which will probably land here. Extension to the south
at the present time is blocked by the Lehigh Valley loop and freight
yard. The site of the present city dimip would make an ideal place
for the Lehigh Valley to locate future freight yards and loop. If
a plan could be worked out so that this change could be made, Ithaca
would have one of the best airports in the east.
Also the possibility of extending the airport to the North
should be studied. This fill could be made with dredged material
which will probably be available without charge to the city in the
next year or two.
Nursery
We wish to recommend the extension of the present city nursery
so that the City Forester may enlarge his planting program.
Zoning
The Commission wishes to advise the Layor that it is continally
studying the zoning map and is endeavoring to correct many inequali-
ties or errors that exist in it. They are also making a study of a
revised zoning ordinance which the city attorney has almost completed.
Passage of the new zoning ordinance will bring Ithaca up to date as
far as city law goes. However, the Commission feels that many of
these zoning inequalities should be ironed out and will make recom-
mendations to the Cotn.iion Council from time to time.
Vaster Plan
The Commission would like to recommend a series of five year
programs for such iters as paving, water extension, sewerage faoili
ties, storm water facilities and also curb and gutter improvement,
and possibly street 'lighting, but feels it is unable to embark on
such an ambitious program until the completion of a master plan for
the city. We urge the Common Council to appropriate the necessary
funds so that the W.P.A. project now submitted for a master plan,
may be started. The Commission realizes that any extensive repav-
ing program will bring with it changes of the water supply system,
sewer system and probably street lighting and sidewalks. It is such
complications as these which tend to emphasize the necessity of
careful planning of improvements ahead of time, i.e. a :Waster plan.
Recreational Facilities
While Ithaca is the center of one of the finest recreational
areas in the nation the City has been negligent in providing park
facilities within its boundaries. Additional playgrounds are
needed for the younger children. It is possible that the City might
cooperate with some of the existing service centers and furnish
wading pools. The Commission is in full accord with the suggestions
made by the Committee on Revreational Facilities.
..:
uRM
11 In
Further the Commission suggests the continued improvement of
Stewart Park and the Newmczm Golf Course. A club house at the golf
course is needed and by the public support given this enterprise
she Commission reeom'Jends its construction in the near future.
Advice should also be sought as to the practicability of ex—
tending the present 9 hole course to 18 holes. Certain lands con—
tiguous to both parks are suitable for park and recreational pur—
poses and their purchase should be considered.
1,ai,nt enance
The Commission urges that the present city plant and services
be maintained in the interest of economy and efficiency. Also an
effort should be made to extend and improve our street lighting
facilities after a survey has been made and an orderly plan adopted.
The Matter of unsightly power and light lines and poles should be
given serious consideration. When t'_ley are eliminated property
values usually rise. In most locations a backlot distribution of
power lines will suffice and in this way the service companies are
not put to the expense of installing underground conduit.
Flood Control
The Commission submits here a copy of a report made in 1937 by
a special committee which investigated flood control methods.
Although our last disastrous flood oecured in 1935 the threat of
another is ever with us. The Cor_nnission feels that this matter
should be seriously considered and that a continuous effort should
be made to secure the help of the Federal or State Government or the
Finger LaI.es State Parks Commission in the construction of detention
dams outside of the city liclits in Enfield and Buttermilk Creeks.
You will note that under the heading of Capital Improvements, items
a, c and d have been completed. This work was done in 1939. Nothing
ofa flood control nature was accomplished in 1939•
Report of the Special Committee of the Planning Conznission
to Consider %leans of Flood Control
` To Members of the Planning Commission:
:., The corinittee after investi gating the various angles of flood
g g
:. control both in the office and on the ground beg to submit the r
following report:
Many floods occurring today are considered serious when the
same amount of water a few years ago caused no alarm. This is part-
ly due to reclamations and improvements in various areas within the
city. The present golf course was formerly the city diunp and a
good portion of it was low land, the same applies to the airport.
In the southern section of the city much building has been done in
an area which has always been susceptible to ;periodic floods. It
is the responsibility of the city to do all it can to relieve flood
conditions as can be handled with funds in reasonable amounts. There
is no chance ever to :Hake Ithaca absolutely dry and flood proof for
the simple reason that the community could not stand the expenditure.
A program for lessening the menace of floods divides itself into
two parts, namely:
I. A program of maintenance of existing facilities.
II. Capital improvements.
I. Program of maintenance; under this heading your committee ,
suggests the following:
a. Regular cleaning of creek beds within the city limits.
b. Regular inspection of creek beds, removal of trees which
might fall into the stream, eto. The city should also endeavor to
secure the cooperation of the surrounding townships in inspecting
and maintaining creek banks outside of the city limits.
e. Regular inspection and maintenance of drainage ditches,
culverts, catoh basins, etc.
-7-
II. Capital improvements. A complete program for capital im-
provements should result from a study of all conditions contribut-
able to floods. We suggest that the City Engineer be granted an
appropriation of at least $5000. to engage the necessary counsel
in collecting information, for designing structures and anything
else, which in his Judgment he feels is necessary to render a com-
plete report and plans for flood protection. The committee feels
there are certain problems which are anparent and need little in-
vestigation and also immediate attention. They are as follows:
a: Raising road and widening bridge on W. Clinton St. extension.
b. Substitution of a rigid frame type of structure for the
present bridges on Caecadilla Creek at Aurora, Tioga and Cayuga Sts,
c. Replacement of bridge at Brindley Street.
d. Installation of large culvert to take care of Williams
Brook.
e. Deepening of Fall Creek channel from mouth to the Lehigh
Valley R.R. Co. bridge.
Tile city at all times should use its prestige and influence
in agitating for a low lake level as far as practicable. The
committee feels that a careful investigation of conditions will
indicate that the low lands south of the city might well be used as
a detention area. If this is found to be true, the city may have
to discourage building in that section and possibly purchase land
outside the city limits for storage purposes.
Anything done to hold back the water from Enfield and Butter-
milk Creeks will tend to alleviate conditions in Ithaca, For this
reason we feel the city should aid the Finger Lakes State Park
Oommission in any manner possible in obtaining detention dams on
both of the above mentioned creeks.
By the sarme token, detention dams on Six :file, Fall and Oas--
eadilla Creeks would aid considerably. The city .must agitate for
these either through state or federal channels.
It is vitally necessary that the city at all times cooperate
with Cornell University in maintaining the portion of creeks, and
gorges which run through its property.
The comriittee realizes that improvements in the city itself
have contributed somewhat to floods. The installation of the more
complete storm sewer system has certainly tended to dimin more water
into the inlet in a shorter time than heretofore. The increase
in the paved area of the city has also contributed its share. These
questions will all be considered and we believe solved in the report
that the City Engineer is recommended to mace. "e respectfully urge
the Common Council to appropriate the sutra asked for above so that
_ this work may be started as soon as possible. Any delay in beginn-
ing this study will also delay the work that should be done in
solving our flood problem.
Respectfully submitted
Leonard wiseall, Chairman
R. S. Hosmer
T. F. Larble, City Engineer
ex-officio
GENERAL
The Oommission would like to note also at this time that while
we have an excellent water supply and good distribution facilities
our supply lies in the mercy of one structure namely the Potters
Falls dam which imnounds the Potters Fall reservoir. This reservoir
is slowly filling in and our capacity for storage is being corre-
spondingly reduced. Sometime in the near furture an effort should
be made to either build a new dam or find a means of insuring a
water supply while the present reservoir is being cleaned out and
restored to its original storage capacity. This is necessary for
as the city grows the demand for water also grows.
Or
The Commission at this time would like to congratulate the
city on their workmanlike manner in hazidling the construction of
the new sewage disposal plant. The building is a beautiful addi-
tion to the city plant and the grounds are nicely landscaped although
we would recommend that the landscaping be continued so as to further
improve its appearance. We also want to take this opportunity to
thank the following city officials who aided us greatly in doing our
work throughout the year and also in preparing this report. They
are as follows: Joseph B. 1.1yers, Mayor; Thomas F. Marble, City
Zingineer; Richard S. Baker, City Forester; Floyd H. Springer, City
Clerk; GeorgeD. Carpenter, Supt. of the Water Department and the
un
individual me.mbers of the Board of Public Works and Co,.xmon Oo oil
who have freely given us their advice and time.
Respectfully submitted,
A. H. Treman
E. D. Hontillon
W. A. Dillon
J. F. Geherin
J. E. Perry
W. J. *,,Atchell
L. 11iscall, Chairman
V
Planning Commission -2- November 24, 1939
By Commissioner Mitchell, seconded by Commissioner Montillon:
Resolved, that the report with recommendations as submitted
be and hereby is approved.
Be It Further Resolved, that these recommendations be submitted
to the Common Council with the recommendation that this section be
changedto "Commercial Zone".
AYes 4
Nays 1
Not Voting 1 Carried and Approved.
OIVM IMPRO UMT REOOEWDATION§ Chairman Miscall presented a
very comprehensive list of suggested improvements, a copy of which
is herewith appended, which embodied recommendations submitted by
the various committees of the Planning Commission made during the
past year, and outlined a program of future as well as present day
development. During discussion of the report, various amendments
were made after which it was moved
By Commissioner Mitchell, seconded by Commissioner Perry:
Resolved, that the report as amended be approved and adopted
and a copy presented to the Mayor for his consideration.
Carried.
ET The Clerk called attention to the necessity of preparilag
&- budget estimate for 1940 for presentation to the Council at their
next meeting to be held December 6, 1939. It was explained that
there is approximately $200.00 balance left in the appropriation for
1939 and it was suggested that Common Council be requested to
appropriate the sum of $450.00 for 1940. This sum to be applied
towards a Master Plan project which has been approved by the Council
and submitted to W.P.A. authorities for approval.
By Commissioner Geherin, seconded by Commissioner Miscall:
Resolved, that the budget for the year 1940 be and the same
hereby is approved and adopted and a requisition ordered filed
with the Common Council for an appropriation of #450.00 and the
Olerk be directed to file the budget with the Oommon Council.
Carried.
On motion the meeting was adjourned.
F. H. pringer
Oity Clerk
PLANNING COMMISSION PROCEEDINGS
City of Ithaca, N. Y.
Regular Meeting 4:30 P.. M. December 22, 1939
PRESENT
Chairman - Mi scall
Commissioners - Treman, Montillon, Dillon, !.itchell
Attorney - Powers
Engineer - Marble
Forester - Baker
Clerk - Springer
MINUTES Minutes of the preceding meeting were duly approved.
ZONE ORDIN�ANCE Attorney Powers presented a draft of the pro-
posed zone ordinance and it was discussed at length.
It -was suggested that mimeographed copies be made and sent
to the Commissioners and the Aldermen for consideration.
By Commissioner Treman, seconded by Commissioner Yontillon:
Resolved, that the new Zone Ordinance be approved in ptin-
cipal, and that the new zoning map be carefully studied and
revised, and adopted as a part of the zoning ordinance.
Carried.
r On motion the meeting was adjourned.
F. H. Spri ger
Secretary
37.