HomeMy WebLinkAboutMN-IURA-2014-03-27Approved: 5/29/14
108 East Green Street
Ithaca, New York 14850
(607) 274-6559
(607) 274-6558 (fax) ax)
MINUTESMINUTES
ITHACA URBAN RENEWAL AGENCY
Common Council Chambers, City Hall
8:30 A.M., Thursday, March 27, 2014
Members: Svante Myrick, Tracy Farrell, Chris Proulx, Karl Graham (9:31 AM), Eric Rosario, Ellen
McCollister (Common Council Liaison)
Excused: None
Staff: Nels Bohn, JoAnn Cornish, Charles Pyott
Public: None
I. Call to Order
Chair Myrick called the meeting to order at 8:38 A.M.
II. Agenda Additions/Deletions
None.
III. IV. Public Hearing #1 ― 2014 HUD Entitlement Grant (cont.)
On a motion by Farrell, seconded by Rosario, and unanimously approved, Chair Myrick re‐opened the
Public Hearing to continue project‐by‐project sponsor presentations.
1. ALTERNATIVES IMPACT (AFCU) ― BUSINESS CENTS PROGRAM
Speaker Title/Affiliation Comments‐in‐Brief
Mary Beth
Bunge
AFCU
Development
Director
Originally launched as a consulting service for small businesses,
Business CENTS evolved into a full‐service small business training
program, serving thousands of Tompkins County clients through one‐
on‐one coaching, workshops, entrepreneurship instruction, a 9‐week
professional training course, etc.
Jennifer
Cunningham‐
Ryan
AFCU Business
CENTS Program
Assistant
The workshops cover things like health insurance, internet marketing,
etc., and also provide networking opportunities. (Past clients include
Lot 10, Northstar, Emmy's Organics, Mighty Yoga, Redmoon
Caregivers, and Sarah’s Patisserie.) Many clients begin as part‐time,
home‐based, or service‐oriented businesses. 63% of clients are
women. 16% are minorities. Two‐thirds of clients are at HUD median‐
Ithaca
Urban
Renewal
Agency
IURA Minutes
March 27, 2014
Page 2 of 15
Speaker Title/Affiliation Comments‐in‐Brief
income levels or below; many of them have gone into business to
supplement their personal income. The program identifies and
creates services based on actual client needs. AFCU is now seeking to
provide a greater variety of services, more tailored to the community.
Professional consultants would provide clients with services like legal
aid, book‐keeping, graphic design, web site development, etc. Clients
would pay a low monthly fee over one year to access all the services.
The goal is to serve approximately 24 clients. Based on past
enrollment, AFCU is confident it would reach that target in the first
year (aiming to exceed it in subsequent years). AFCU is still
developing the pricing structure, which will be affordable.
Heather
Sanford
The Piggery,
President
The Piggery launched 6 years ago and has grown from 2 to 12 staff,
with $1M in sales. It projects reaching $2M over the next 18 months.
Its wages are much higher than other retail/trade businesses. Sanford
and her husband benefitted greatly from the Business CENTS program.
They are now well‐connected to the local small business and food‐
growing communities.
Proulx noted he likes the concept. He asked how the pricing structure would be determined and
whether it would be based on actual incurred costs.
Cunningham‐Ryan replied they are in the beginning stages of determining that, but are currently
working with a rough figure of $350/month (around what a similar West Coast‐based program
charges), which would be a bargain for all the services provided.
Proulx asked if any agreements with the consultants had been made. Cunningham‐Ryan replied, no
formal agreements have been made, but they have started building relationships.
Bohn asked how the program would use IURA funds. Bunge replied they could either be used as
working capital or as financial reserves. The intent is for the program to become self‐sustaining
after the first year.
2. HISTORIC ITHACA ― WORK PRESERVE JOB TRAINING
Speaker Title/Affiliation Comments‐in‐Brief
Alphonse
Pieper
Historic Ithaca
Executive
Director
Pieper noted that Historic Ithaca Board of Directors President Dennis
Stein could not be here today, but he has conveyed the Board’s
support for the program. The program strives to adapt to meet the
IURA Minutes
March 27, 2014
Page 3 of 15
Speaker Title/Affiliation Comments‐in‐Brief
needs of people it serves. Participants learn building and
craftsmanship to renovate products for resale in the Significant
Elements store. Two participants are now fully‐employed. The
program helps participants fully engage themselves as parts of a team,
all the while building up their self‐esteem and confidence. The
program started providing paid stipends this year. Significant
Elements earned $2,570 in sales and fees generated by participants.
Karen Coleman Significant
Elements Skills
Educator
The program has made an amazing difference for young people.
Significant Elements receives referrals from The Learning Web, the
Ithaca Youth Bureau, Department of Social Services (DSS), and Cornell
Cooperative Extension of Tompkins County. Participants range from
18‐30 years old. They enter the program with little or no
professional/educational success. They receive consistent ongoing
one‐on‐one consultation and support. The program allows
participants to set goals, identify desired skill‐sets, and revise their
goals, as needed.
Penny
Romantic
City Youth
Employment
Services Program
Assistant
Participants do not know why they are not succeeding in their
professional and/or educational endeavors, when they enter the
program. The program allows them to make amazing progress. Not
one referral has been rejected.
There were no questions from the IURA.
3. CITY OF ITHACA ― LAKE STREET BRIDGE PROJECT
Speaker Title/Affiliation Comments‐in‐Brief
Addisu Gebre City of Ithaca
Bridge Systems
Engineer
The project is targeted for the southeast corner of the Lake Street
Bridge. The project’s goal is to improve public safety and create
aesthetic enhancements. The site is currently underdeveloped and
underused. It is in poor shape, with safety hazards, no clear lighting,
and no designated walkway to the creek. The project would include
installation of a stairway to the creek, new bike racks, additional
fencing, and an extended sidewalk from the parking lot on the top of
the hill, as well as two designated sidewalks, plantings, benches, and
possibly a scenic outlook area with interpretive signage. There would
be both short‐term and long‐term benefits associated with the
project: increase the number of visitors to the area, improve the site’s
IURA Minutes
March 27, 2014
Page 4 of 15
Speaker Title/Affiliation Comments‐in‐Brief
ecological performance, serve as a recreational resource, eliminate
safety hazards, improve the surrounding neighborhood, inspire more
physical activity, etc. The completion of the project design should
take place in April 2015, with construction beginning in November
2015. The New York Department of Transportation would oversee the
project.
Annette
Marchessault
Trowbridge Wolf
Michaels, LLP
Principal
The project presents a valuable opportunity for synergy with the
larger Lake Street Bridge Replacement Project. The park is a diamond‐
in‐the‐rough. It is a historically and culturally rich site.
Farrell indicated she loves the project’s concept; however, she wondered if tourism money may be
available for it. Gebre replied he is not sure. That has not been discussed; although it could
certainly be explored.
Cornish added that City staff could discuss the idea with the County’s Senior Planner and Tourism
Coordinator, Tom Knipe.
Farrell asked if the project could take place after completion of the Lake Street Bridge Replacement
Project. Gebre replied, conceivably.
Marchessault further responded that there is definitely an advantage to completing both projects at
the same time, in order to exploit the efficiencies and economies that would come with that (e.g.,
the design team would already be in place, bids could be made at same time, the same contractor
could be used, etc.)
4. TOMPKINS COMMUNITY ACTION ― HOUSING FIRST PROGRAM
Speaker Title/Affiliation Comments‐in‐Brief
Lee Dillon Tompkins
Community
Action Executive
Director
Tompkins Community Action received funding in 2013 to serve hard‐
to‐house people; and it was deemed such a great idea that they
decided to return for more funding. Part of the program has resulted
in new partnerships. The Department of Social Services housing
solutions team meets regularly to discuss how to house the homeless.
Tompkins Community Action also recently performed a HUD point‐in‐
time homeless count, in conjunction with the Ithaca Police
Department, which was successful. Danielle Harrington has met with
the Rescue Mission and Loaves and Fishes, to collaborate on
additional outreach to the community.
IURA Minutes
March 27, 2014
Page 5 of 15
Speaker Title/Affiliation Comments‐in‐Brief
Danielle
Harrington
Tompkins
Community
Action Energy &
Housing Services
Director
Tompkins Community Action has already identified two men to
provide the rental subsidy to. Staff would perform a daily check‐in to
make sure the two participants are doing alright (i.e., that they are
safe, healthy, active, etc.). Harrington emphasized it is a special
population that needs a little more one‐on‐one attention. There is
definitely a need to keep the program going and continue expanding
it. The program also facilitates vital connections with mental health
professionals, like Rick Shaw and the County Mental Health
Department’s Single Point of Entry (SPOE) program.
(Karl Graham arrived at 9:31 a.m.)
Bohn observed that part of the funding request is $50,000 for tenant rental assistance, from HOME
funds, while the other part is $30,000 for support services funding, from CDBG funds. He asked the
applicant if the IURA could evaluate both requests separately. Dillon replied, yes, the IURA can
assess them separately; although funding is definitely needed for a part‐time staff person.
Farrell asked if the program is scalable at all. Dillon replied, yes.
5. THE LEARNING WEB OF TOMPKINS COUNTY ― HOUSING SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM
Speaker Title/Affiliation Comments‐in‐Brief
Dale
Schumacher
The Learning
Web Executive
DIrector
The program helps house homeless youth in an independent setting.
The apartments are only available for a limited number of youth (12‐
18 months). If the participants are employed, they are asked to
contribute 30% of the rent. Participants are required to formally apply
for the program, including an essay, goal‐setting, etc., and are held to
high expectations from the very beginning. Participants set personal
goals, meet with the case manager, and are actively encouraged to
pursue further full‐time education and/or employment/training.
Participants are in contact with the case manager several times a
week, with apartment inspections once a week, and a general
emphasis on learning life‐skills (e.g., budgeting/savings).
Aurora Ulbing Former
Participant
The program was absolutely crucial for her. When she entered the
program, she was a new mother in a destructive relationship, with no
job and no place to live. It was the scariest time of her life. As a result
of the program, she re‐enrolled in school. Her mentor was the
strongest person in her life, at that time. The program made her
IURA Minutes
March 27, 2014
Page 6 of 15
Speaker Title/Affiliation Comments‐in‐Brief
comfortable that she had a safe and stable place to raise her
daughter. Since then, she has moved into another apartment. She
plans on continuing her education after graduation, and entering the
workforce.
There were no questions from the IURA.
6. CATHOLIC CHARITIES OF TOMPKINS/TIOGA ― SECURITY DEPOSIT ASSISTANCE PROGRAM
Speaker Title/Affiliation Comments‐in‐Brief
Josh Clarke Catholic Charities
Director of
Development
Operating since 2004, the program has helped hundreds of the most
vulnerable residents, who otherwise not have been able to obtain
money for a security deposit ― having exhausted every other source
of potential assistance and risking homelessness. In 2014, 27
households were helped. The list of landlords participating in the
Department of Social Services’ own security deposit program has been
shrinking, which leaves Catholic Charities as the only current stable
source of this kind of funding.
Ellie Hall Minnis Catholic Charities
Samaritan Center
Director
She is on the frontline and sees people profoundly in need of help. In
the last 7 business days alone, they received 16 calls for security
deposits. The program genuinely needs all the money it asks for.
Graham asked why landlords have not been accepting Department of Social Services vouchers.
Minnis replied she suspects they believe they have had bad experiences in the past and it is not
worth their effort. Clarke added that there seems to some concern among landlords that they
would not receive the funds from DSS.
7. ITHACA NEIGHBORHOOD HOUSING SERVICES (INHS) ― MINI‐REPAIR PROGRAM
Speaker Title/Affiliation Comments‐in‐Brief
Paul Mazzarella INHS Executive
Director
The program has been offered for over 25 years and covers a variety
of small repairs for existing low‐ to moderate‐income homeowners
(primarily low‐income seniors and women living alone). The program
helps them make repairs (e.g., fixing steps, plumbing, electrical, etc.),
which enables them to age in place. The program also has an
IURA Minutes
March 27, 2014
Page 7 of 15
Speaker Title/Affiliation Comments‐in‐Brief
important concomitant benefit of allowing INHS staff to perform
informal inspections to identify needed repairs which would have
potentially more serious consequences for the beneficiaries (e.g.,
broken furnaces). INHS consistently identifies problems that require
more extensive work than the program supports, at which point they
are handled through the Homeowner Rehab Program.
Farrell noted that in 2013 INHS projected the program would serve 60 people; however, it only
served 50 while conducting 110 projects. This suggests to some IURA members that outreach
efforts may need to be expanded. Mazzarella replied that INHS does not actually perform any
major outreach effort, since it is concerned that would lead to far more demand than it could meet.
INHS does conduct an income‐qualification verification process (often through Office for the Aging
referrals). He noted many program beneficiaries call numerous times for service, although INHS
does have rules placing a cap on the number of requests that can be made. He noted that if all
current beneficiaries were served without restriction, the number of beneficiaries would probably
be around 50 per year.
8. ITHACA NEIGHBORHOOD HOUSING SERVICES (INHS) ― HOMEOWNER REHAB PROGRAM
Speaker Title/Affiliation Comments‐in‐Brief
Paul Mazzarella INHS Executive
Director
The average age of the housing stock in Ithaca is over 100 years old, so
there are constant maintenance needs to be taken care of ― many of
them are in low‐ to moderate‐income households who have a hard
time affording a contractor. INHS receives calls regularly, many of
which are urgent (e.g., replacing roof or heating system). The
program is scalable, so it could be partially funded. Once a
homeowner signs up for the program, INHS staff conducts a full
inspection of the house, identifies what is urgent, helps with the
bidding process and construction management, and generally serving
as a bridge between homeowner and contractor.
Farrell asked what kinds of Federal regulations are associated with the program. Mazzarella replied
the principal regulations concern lead paint. Federal regulations contain several thresholds for lead
paint. If the work amounts to less than $5,000, for example, not much further work is required.
Work amounting to $5,000‐$25,000, on the other hand, requires a full inspection of the house,
inside and out, and requires that every instance of lead paint be handled in a specific way. Work of
more than $25,000 requires complete remediation (i.e., removing all lead paint hazards,
IURA Minutes
March 27, 2014
Page 8 of 15
encapsulation, etc.), which is very expensive, so INHS rarely does that and the vast majority of the
work is done for less than $25,000.
9. ITHACA NEIGHBORHOOD HOUSING SERVICES (INHS) ― CHT NEW CONSTRUCTION PROGRAM
Speaker Title/Affiliation Comments‐in‐Brief
Paul Mazzarella INHS Executive
Director
INHS currently has a backlog of properties/projects it would like to
move forward on. This particular funding request would combine
both HOME and non‐HOME funds for the new construction.
Mazzarella noted he already discussed the application and the
limitations associated with each funding stream with Bohn. Bond
funding is only permitted to subsidize the difference between the
total development cost and the market value on completion. Since
that rarely produces enough of a subsidy to benefit a low‐ to
moderate‐income homebuyer, additional assistance is provided
through HOME funding to make it more affordable. The complicated
aspect of the program is that INHS does not know precisely what the
market value of a house will be, so it has to make an educated guess.
Mazzarella noted both the 314 S. Plain Street and 214 Second Street
projects have already been started and should be finished reasonably
quickly. There is a timing issue associated with them: INHS cannot sell
them until the funds are approved by Common Council, some months
from now.
Farrell asked if there were no way of salvaging the 315 First Street building. Mazzarella replied, no.
It would simply not be worth the expense.
Bohn observed that HOME funding restrictions require that a house that is built but not sold within
9 months must be rented out. He asked if there is sufficient demand for INHS to identify buyers for
all the units within the proposed timeframe. Mazzarella replied, yes. Demand is strong. They have
not yet built a house in the city that has not sold quickly.
Graham asked if INHS has had any security‐related incidents with any houses that sit empty for
months. Mazzarella replied, no.
On a motion by Farrell, seconded by Graham, and unanimously approved, Chair Myrick closed the
Public Hearing.
IURA Minutes
March 27, 2014
Page 9 of 15
IV. Review of Draft Meeting Minutes: February 27, 2014
Rosario moved, seconded by Graham, to approve the February 27, 2014 meeting minutes, with no
modifications.
Carried Unanimously 5‐0
V. Economic Development Committee (EDC)
A. Request from e2e Materials, Inc. for Second Amendment to 2010 Loan Agreement to Extend
Interest‐Only Repayment Period an Additional Six Months (CD‐RLF #27)
Proulx reported that EDC discussed the request on a conceptual basis and had no problem with it
(although there was no official recommendation, since there was no quorum present at the last
meeting).
Graham asked if anyone has a sense of the long‐term viability of the business. Bohn replied the
business initiated a series of changes to its business model and operations, and things have
progressively improved, although it is spending a considerable amount of capital making the transition.
Viability should be determined in the next 9 months.
Proulx moved, seconded by Rosario:
2nd Modification to e2e Materials, Inc. Loan (CD‐RLF #27)
WHEREAS, on February 17, 2014, e2e Materials, Inc. requested a 2nd loan modification to extend
the interest‐only repayment period for an additional 6 months, and
WHEREAS, on November 22, 2011, the IURA issued a $100,000 loan to e2e Materials, Inc. (e2e) for
machinery and equipment to establish a prototyping facility for production of molded
biocomposites located at 239 Cherry Street, Ithaca, NY, and
WHEREAS, the 5‐year loan bears a 9% interest rate and provided an 2‐year interest‐only period and
monthly payments due to amortize the loan balance over the remaining 3‐year period, and
WHEREAS, on March 21, 2013 the IURA approved a request to extend the interest‐only payment
period for an additional 12 months that ends on March 30, 2014, and
WHEREAS, e2e has submitted a January 31, 2014 shareholder report documenting their efforts and
prospects to increase revenues, and
WHEREAS, the IURA loan is secured by a shared 1st security interest in machinery and equipment
with Tompkins County Area Development, which provided e2e with $125,000 of loan financing,
and
IURA Minutes
March 27, 2014
Page 10 of 15
WHEREAS, TCAD has authorized an additional 6‐month interest only period on their loan to e2e,
and
WHEREAS, as of 2/28/14 e2e is current on the IURA loan, which has an outstanding principal
balance of $90,170.22, and
WHEREAS, e2e has submitted job reporting to the IURA documenting the creation of 5 full‐time
jobs filled by low‐ and moderate‐income persons, and
WHEREAS, at their March 11, 2014 meeting, the IURA Economic Development Committee
considered this matter and recommended the following, now, therefore be it
RESOLVED, that the IURA hereby approves a 2nd modification of the loan to e2e Materials, Inc.
(CD‐RLF #27) as follows:
• Loan repayment schedule: establish an additional 6‐month period of interest‐only payments
through September 30, 2014;
• Loan term: extend loan term an additional 6 months, from 72 months to 78 months;
• Reporting: require submission of shareholder reports no less than quarterly; and
RESOLVED, that the IURA Chair, upon the advice of IURA legal counsel, is authorized to execute all
necessary and appropriate documents to implement this resolution.
Carried Unanimously 5‐0
B. Write‐Off Outstanding Loan Balance Due from Finger Lakes Wine Center, Inc. as Uncollectible
(PB‐LF #4)
Proulx explained the IURA has no other recourse but to write‐off the loan balance, in this case. The
operation is defunct and there are no remaining assets (a small final ~$1,400 payment was recently
made).
Proulx moved, seconded by Farrell:
Write‐Off Loan to Finger Lakes Wine Center, Inc. (PB‐LF #4)
WHEREAS, in 2010, the IURA issued a $100,000 loan to the Finger Lakes Wine Center, Inc. (FLWC)
for a $750,000 project to establish a 3,300 square foot wine education center, including wine
tastings, exhibits and retail sales, at 237 S. Cayuga Street, Ithaca, NY, and
WHEREAS, the 11‐year loan was structured to require 1% interest‐only payments monthly with an
annual principal payment equal to 50% of net profits, and
WHEREAS, the IURA loan is secured by all business assets of FLWC, and
IURA Minutes
March 27, 2014
Page 11 of 15
WHEREAS, the physical project was successfully completed and opened to the public on November
6, 2010, and
WHEREAS, the project’s employment goal to create 2.5 FTE jobs was satisfied, and
WHEREAS, revenues did not meet projections and the enterprise never achieved profitability, and
WHEREAS, the wine center ceased operations in September 2012 with an outstanding principal
balance of $100,000, and
WHEREAS, letters were sent by FLWC legal counsel on August 14, 2013 informing unsecured
creditors that the FLWC Board voted to dissolve itself and that it was unable to meet outstanding
financial obligations, and
WHEREAS, final balance sheet available for FLWC shows a total liabilities of $174,480 and assets of
$5,038 as of 10/8/12, and
WHEREAS, as of 3/1/14, total interest and late charges due on the IURA loan equal $2,533.34 and
the outstanding principal balance is $100,000, and
WHEREAS, IURA staff has conducted due diligence to collect on collateral, resulting in receipt of
$1,841.62 to be applied to interest and late charges, and
WHEREAS, there are no further marketable FLWC assets of value to sell that would result in net
proceeds after considering staff time and expenses, and
WHEREAS, the IURA Economic Development Committee reviewed this matter at their March 11,
2014 meeting and recommends the following; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, that the IURA hereby writes off the $100,000 loan to Finger Lakes Wine Center, Inc. and
recognizes the debt as uncollectible.
Carried Unanimously 5‐0
C. Termination of Funding Agreement for eLab Downtown Retail Support Program (CDBG #9 2012)
Bohn reported that the program simply did not achieve its goals. The program sponsors have been
informed no further funds would be made available to them and the funding agreement would be
terminated. A total of $4,400 was paid into the program, with the remainder ($7,600) being rolled
back into CDBG funds.
D. Committee Vice‐Chairperson Report
None.
IURA Minutes
March 27, 2014
Page 12 of 15
VI. Neighborhood Investment Committee (NIC)
A. 2014 Re‐Certification of Greater Ithaca Activities Center, Inc. (GIAC) as Community‐Based
Development Organization (CBDO)
Farrell noted there was one remaining question at the NIC meeting about GIAC’s board composition. It
is assumed it is qualified, but more information is needed. Bohn recommended that this agenda item
be deferred until the required information is received.
Graham disclosed for conflict‐of‐interest purposes that he is directly related to GIAC Director Marcia
Fort.
B. Amend Funding Contract with The Learning Web for Housing Scholarship Program to Authorize
Use of Funds for Security Deposits (HOME #4 2013)
Farrell noted that Housing Scholarship Program tenants have historically obtained security deposit
assistance through the Catholic Charities Security Deposit Assistance Program. The Learning Web’s
landlord, however, will no longer accept a security deposit through Catholic Charities. As a result, The
Learning Web is asking to be able to use some of its Housing Scholarship Program funds as rental
security deposits.
Proulx asked if this were part of a broader trend of landlords being concerned with security deposits.
Farrell responded that may be the case with the DSS program.
Bohn explained that IURA launched the Housing Scholarship Program based on the assumption that
the program’s beneficiaries could simply apply to Catholic Charities for the security deposit, if needed.
The IURA funding agreement with The Learning Web does not authorize use of HOME funds for
security deposits, though it is an allowable use under HOME regulations.
Farrell moved, seconded by Graham:
2013 HUD Entitlement Program ― Amendment #1 to Funding Contract for
Housing Scholarship Program (2013 Project #4)
WHEREAS, on March 11, 2014, The Learning Web requested a modification to their funding agreement
for the Housing Scholarship program to authorize use of funds for security deposits, and
WHEREAS, on October 23, 2013 the IURA executed a $78,000 funding agreement with Learning Web,
Inc. for the Housing Scholarship program, and
WHEREAS, per the funding agreement HOME funds are being used to assist at least 6 low‐ and
moderate‐income households in accessing affordable rental housing by paying solely for rent and
utilities for a period not to exceed 18 months while the household works toward achieving
independence, and
IURA Minutes
March 27, 2014
Page 13 of 15
WHEREAS, use of HOME funds under the agreement is limited to tenant‐based rental assistance for
rent and utility payments only, and
WHEREAS, in the past, tenants in the program have secured security deposit assistance through the
IURA‐funded Catholic Charities’ Security Deposit Assistance Program, and
WHEREAS, The Learning Web’s landlord won’t accept a security deposit through Catholic Charities and,
WHEREAS, Catholic Charities projects it will exhaust its 2013 allocation of security deposits in the next
30 days, and
WHEREAS, The Learning Web projects they will still meet their program objectives if funds are
authorized for security deposits, and
WHEREAS, there is no change to the scope, beneficiaries or authorized location of the project,
therefore no public hearing or Action Plan program amendment is required, and
WHEREAS, the Neighborhood Investment Committee reviewed this proposal at their meeting on
March 14, 2014 and recommended the following; now, therefore be it
RESOLVED, that the funding agreement with The Learning Web, Inc. for the 2013 Housing Scholarship
program (2013 project #4) be amended to permit use of HOME funds to pay security deposits in
addition to rent and utilities, and be it further,
RESOLVED, that the IURA Chairperson, upon advice of IURA legal counsel, is hereby authorized to
execute any necessary and appropriate documents to implement this resolution.
Carried Unanimously 5‐0
C. Committee Chairperson report
None.
VII. Other New/Old Business
A. Cayuga Green Project, Request from Cayuga Green, LLC for IURA Approval of Proposed Exterior
Building Modifications for TC3 Coltivare Project, 235 S. Cayuga St.
Bohn reported that the new Coltivare culinary center proposes several modifications to the Cayuga
Garage building that require the IURA’s consent per the lease agreement for the ground floor
commercial space between the IURA and Cayuga Green LLC, the master lessee. Cayuga Green, LLC has
reached an agreement with the TC3 Foundation to sublease 16,000 square feet for the culinary center;
however the project cannot proceed unless exterior modifications are approved by the IURA. He
noted the Planning and Development Board already approved the changes (with a few minor
conditions). None of the proposed changes would negatively affect the asset value for the IURA. Bohn
recommended approval.
IURA Minutes
March 27, 2014
Page 14 of 15
Proulx moved, seconded by Farrell:
Cayuga Green, Approve Exterior Modifications for
TC3 Coltivare Project, 235 S. Cayuga Street (Parcel A)
WHEREAS, Cayuga Green, LLC requests IURA approval of proposed exterior changes to the Cayuga
Garage to facilitate TC3’s Coltivare project that will sublease approximately 14,000 square feet of
ground floor commercial space at the Cayuga Garage facility for a culinary teaching center, including a
commercial restaurant, and
WHEREAS, the IURA master leases the 22,900 SF ground floor commercial premises of the Cayuga
Garage to Cayuga Green, LLC, and
WHEREAS, 14,000 SF of lease space at the premises remains unfinished and vacant, and
WHEREAS, section 11(D) of the IURA lease requires the written consent of lessor to any modifications
to the exterior of the building other than the relocation of doors and exterior signage in accordance
with applicable building codes and the zoning ordinance, and
WHEREAS, proposed exterior modifications are shown on the modified site plan review application
dated 2/18/14, which includes:
• Addition and removal of several doors
• Conversion of cloth awnings to metal channel canopies
• Signage
• Linear green LED lighting and installation of banners
• Exhaust and make‐up air louvers/vents, and
WHEREAS, the Planning & Development Board has approved exterior modifications for the TC3
Coltivare project; now, therefore, be it
RESOLVED, the IURA hereby authorizes Cayuga Green LLC’s request for modifications to the exterior of
the Cayuga Garage to facilitate TC3’s Coltivare project as approved by the City of Ithaca Planning &
Development Board and subject to the following additional conditions:
• An easement be granted over Parcel D to provide access and maintenance from the public way
for any new egress door installed on the eastern elevation (Parcel A) at Cayuga Green LLC’s
expense, and
• Any vines removed on the eastern elevation be replaced in‐kind, and be it further
RESOLVED, that the IURA Director of Community Development is hereby authorized to provide written
consent on behalf of the IURA for the approved exterior modifications, and be it further
IURA Minutes
March 27, 2014
Page 15 of 15
RESOLVED, that should any additional exterior modifications be required to facilitate the Coltivare
project, the IURA Chairperson is authorized to approve such exterior modifications.
Carried Unanimously 5‐0
B. Review of IURA Financials: February 2014
Bohn reported that there are two past due loans, but progress continues to be made. Neighborhood
Pride LLC is past due, but has been making progress to sell its equipment and property. The sale of its
property and equipment is anticipated by Neighborhood Pride LLC to be sufficient to pay back all
project lenders.
C. IURA Chairperson Report
None.
D. Community Development Planner Search
Farrell reported the search committee interviewed 4 people and selected 2 finalists, who will be
undergoing reference checks.
E. Common Council Liaison Report
None.
F. Staff Report
Bohn reported that the 215‐221 W. Spencer Street property sold for $110,000. The buyer plans to
build multi‐unit housing on it.
Bohn announced that the 701 Cliff Street building has been demolished. An asking price of $37,500 has
been set for the sale of the land, which would allow multi‐family housing.
Bohn reported that Community Housing of Ithaca (CHI) has completed its obligations for suspending its
PILOT agreement with the IURA for their Adams Street housing project. The property in question has
now been made taxable and the back payments of delinquent PILOT charges have been paid. The
PILOT agreement will remain suspended as long as the property remains on the tax rolls.
VIII. Adjournment
The meeting was adjourned by consensus at 10:49 A.M.
— END —
Minutes prepared by C. Pyott, edited by N. Bohn.