Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutMN-BFC-2006-11-14OFFICE OF BOARD OF FIRE COMMISSIONERS CITY OF ITHACA 310 WEST GREEN STREET ITHACA, NEW YORK 14850 - -- NOTICE - -- THE REGULAR MEETING OF TEL (607) 272 -1234 FAX (607) 272 -2793 THE ITHACA BOARD OF FIRE COMMISSIONERS WILL BE HELD ON: TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 14, 2006 AT 6:00 P.M. AT THE ITHACA CENTRAL FIRE STATION 310 WEST GREEN ST., ITHACA, NY. "An Equal Opportunity Employer with an Affirmative Action Program" rile Recycled Paper ITHACA BOARD OF FIRE COMMISSIONERS NOVEMBER 14, 2006 AGENDA I. CALL TO ORDER II. APPROVAL OF MINUTES - III. ADDITIONS /DELETIONS TO THE AGENDA IV. PERSONS WISHING TO SPEAK TO BOARD OF FIRE COMMISSIONERS V. CORRESPONDENCE VI. MEMBERSHIP CHANGES: VII. MISCELLANEOUS REPORTS: A. TOWN OF ITHACA B. AUDIT C. TOMPKINS COUNTY FIRE ADVISORY BOARD VIII. DEPARTMENT REPORTS: A. CHIEF: B. DEPUTY CHIEF /TRAINING C. FIRE PREVENTION BUREAU REPORT - Codes Division - Fire Investigation Unit - Juvenile Firesetters Program - Public Education IX. OLD BUSINESS - X. NEW BUSINESS - XI. ADJOURN ITHACA BOARD OF FIRE COMMISSIONERS NOVEMBER 14, 2006 MINUTES PRESENT: Commissioners Romanowski, Gilligan and Alexander; one vacancy; Common Council Liaison Robin Korherr. ABSENT: Commissioner Williams. I. Chair Romanowski called the meeting to order at 1805 hrs. II. Chair Romanowski made a motion to approve the minutes of the October 10, 2006 meeting as written. Seconded by Comm. Gilligan. Carried unanimously. III. Additions /Deletions to the Agenda: - Chair Romanowski - add Fire Police requirements to Old Business - Comm. Gillian - add Bunker proposal from Philip Yam - discussion - under New Business. - Chair Romanowski - add Letter to Mayor regarding BFC vacancy to New Business. IV. Persons wishing to speak to Board of Fire Commissioners: None V. Correspondence: - Letter from Lyman Baker regarding Steve Williams' membership status in Co. 2. It was noted that until a training program is scheduled (for his Fire Police application), his status remains the same as any social member in the company. VI. Membership Changes - None VII. Miscellaneous Reports: A. Town of Ithaca - Chair Romanowski provided a written copy of his report to the Town of Ithaca (see copy in the Minute Book). B. Audit - the audit was reviewed and approved. C. Tompkins County Fire Advisory Board - minutes of the 09/25/06 ITHACA BOARD OF FIRE COMMISSIONERS NOVEMBER 14, 2006 - MINUTES PAGE 2 meeting were distributed. VIII. Department Reports: A. Chief's Report (see complete written report in Minute Book). Chief Wilbur highlighted his report and answered questions as follows: - 2006 Operating Budget status discussion - Spreadsheets as of October 31, 2006 were provided. Items such as fuel costs and insurance are out of our control - both items are over budget; there were no extraordinary incidents this month! The 2007 Operating Budget provides for increase in staff and capital expense for vehicles and equipment which is a significant change in many years. Personnel additions are effective 04/01/07. - County communications and 911 program - Jim King from Jefferson County will be in town to conduct information meetings regarding the new systems; towers are either up or in progress of being installed; subscribers continue to work on defining the "talk groups" and equipment needs; IFD has a capital project for equipment purchases (but I PD does not). - No news on Assistance to Firefighters (AFG) or SAFER grants has been received; notification came today of $5,000 award for the child safety seat program. - Chief Wilbur reported that the Community & Neighborhood Services Committee of Common Council expressed their desire (at last week's meeting) to continue discussions regarding IFD personnel needs - to keep the momentum going on gradual increases in staffing. The next discussion will take place at a "Chiefs "' meeting to be scheduled in early December. - DC Dorman facilitated a collaboration between the Tompkins County Chapter of the American Red Cross and the Ithaca Fire Department to provide child safety seats and smoke detectors to populations that ITHACA BOARD OF FIRE COMMISSIONERS NOVEMBER 14, 2006 - MINUTES PAGE 3 can benefit from these programs throughout the County. - HIV Testing - NYS Civil Service Law regarding education, testing and counseling - IFD provides for this but has no formal policy; however one will be developed as soon as possible. - NIMS training continues - IFD is almost complete with training. - The 2002 Pre - Disaster Mitigation Grant - final version was completed on 10/31/06! If approved, the plan included in the grant would allow eligibility for future mitigation grants. - Training Center Usage Report - see breakdown provided by AC LaBuff in Chief's written report. - The Baden Powell Council of the Boy Scouts of America has agreed to purchase the Carolina Skiff boat and trailer for $5,000 (to use at Camp Barton). - A week long trench rescue training program was held to train new personnel and refresh skills for those who have had training previously. Participants included people from IFD, DPW, W &S - very good collaboration and good for departments to work together. - A Gorge Assessment Group comprised of City department and Cornell University representatives are meeting to work on issues like signage, education, legislation, etc. - work that needs to be done prior to any resource recovery legislation. - The Thurston Ave. bridge is open with one lane going North - the automatic mutual aid with Cayuga Heights FD is suspended until the bridge closes again. - An agreement with the Tompkins County Health Department to manage IFD's immunization program is in process of being put into place - they would administer the program, purchase and administer ITHACA BOARD OF FIRE COMMISSIONERS NOVEMBER 14, 2006 - MINUTES PAGE 4 vaccinations, keep records, etc. B. Deputy Chief /Training - (see complete written report in the Minute Book). Deputy Chief Dorman offered highlights of his report and answered questions as follows: - The new pickup was delivered - there are a couple of issues that need to be worked out. - New 962 will be ordered shortly - possibly a hybrid - Friday, November 17, 2006 marks the 10th anniversary of the on- duty death of Police Officer Mike Padula. A memorial service will be held at 11 AM at Immaculate Conception church. - The NYS Office of Fire Prevention & Control has issued a directive that all out -of -state training be reported to that department. DC Dorman is unsure of the reason for this. C. Fire Prevention Bureau Report - See complete written report by AC Parsons in the Minute Book. IX. Old Business- - Fire Police project - Chair Romanowski would like to send a 2nd letter to Company Captains to encourage those interested to submit their updated applications. Unless more are received, the project will be put on hold. The Board suggested to request information back by the February 2007 meeting. Chair Romanowski reported again that Sheriff Peter Meskill has agreed to provide the training. X. New Business - - Comm. Gilligan suggested sending a letter to the Mayor requesting her criteria to appoint a representative of the City to the BFC - so far she has rejected two candidates. It's been two years since the ITHACA BOARD OF FIRE COMMISSIONERS NOVEMBER 14, 2006 - MINUTES PAGE 5 vacancy was created. Chief Wilbur would like to see someone who, obviously, has the willingness, time and energy to devote to the department and be a community -type representative - ie business community representative or landlords - people that we have dealings with. - Station 9 Bunker, and Company 9 Captain, Philip Yam has met with the Fire Chief and provided a written proposal to the Board to reactivate the Bunker Program. (see copy in the Minute Book) . Highlights of a lengthy discussion that followed are: - Chief Wilbur noted that Philip is highly motivated and cares about the bunker program; however, there are a couple of inaccurate statements in his proposal: the IAFF has no involvement in funding of the program; and his statement regarding use of 2% monies is his conclusion, not the Fire Chief's. - Chair Romanowski wants to be sure we are not excluding anyone not affiliated with Cornell University. - The proposal is to achieve 12 candidates for a training class for August 2007; - Comm. Gilligan would like to take this opportunity to start initiating discussion and decisions - by February 2007 at the latest - and, if approved, would like to make this a priority for the new Municipal Training Officer; - Chair Romanowski feels the new MTO will take some start -up time, but would need to embrace the program from day one; - DC Dorman reported the new MTO may come with some certifications already and will be an in -house person who will have knowledge of programs, etc. He also reported that 2% funds are not eligible for this type of use. -DC Dorman also indicated that the $30,000 Philip states that would be needed for the program is not included in the 2007 budget, is mostly for staff (instructor) costs, and does not include cost of physical exams or protective gear. - Comm. Gilligan pointed out that there would need to be minimal effect on administrative staff - volunteers can assist with the administration of the plan. ITHACA BOARD OF FIRE COMMISSIONERS NOVEMBER 14, 2006 - MINUTES PAGE 6 At this time, Comm. Gilligan made a motion that the Ithaca Board of Fire Commissioners and Department staff will look at the viability of revitalizing the Bunker Program - to include proper financing and administration assistance to make it work. Seconded by Chair Romanowski. Carried unanimously. Robin Korherr asked if we have a legal opinion on use of 2% funds. Chief Wilbur reported that Patricia Dunn has provided it and we will revisit the issue. DC Dorman and Chair Romanowski again concurred that 2% funds cannot be used for this purpose. - Chief Wilbur announced that December 7, 2006 is the 100 year anniversary of the Chi Psi fire that killed 3 IFD bunkers and other residents of the fraternity. A memorial service will be held in the City Cemetery as well as other remembrances are being planned. Also, Michael Lane is presenting a history of the mansion and the tragedy and will be held at the Dryden Village Hall tomorrow night at 7:30 PM. - Robin Korherr announced that also tomorrow night, at 9 PM, Court TV is airing a documentary and re- enactment of the Harry Uhl boating accident on Cayuga lake that killed him and the search that followed for the person who caused the crash. XI. Hearing no other business, the meeting adjourned at 1915 hrs. Respectfully submitted, IL i4t-- Christine M. Wilbur, Clerk Ithaca Board of Fire Commissioners (Minutes will be reviewed for approval at the December 12, 2006 meeting) CITY OF ITHACA 310 West Green Street Ithaca, New York 14850 -5497 OFFICE OF THE FIRE CHIEF Telephone: 607/272 -1234 Fax: 607/272 -2793 Monthly Report of the Fire Chief to the Board of Fire Commissioners, for the November 14, 2006, meeting. LIFE SAFETY DIVISION Administration 1) Career Personnel Report See report from Deputy Chief Dorman. 2) Operating Budget Status a) Spreadsheets current to 31 OCT 06, with revenue and operating budget program account distributions, are included. b) Extraordinary incident cost summary: No incidents since last report. C) 2007 Operating Budget: The 2007 City Budget was adopted at the regular Common Council meeting of 01 NOV 06. The Town Board adopted the Town budget, with modifications to the Fire Department budget as a result of the changes made to the City Budget, on 09 NOV 06. These budgets include new positions as follows: one municipal training officer, one fire fighter, one part- time data entry clerk. 3) County Communications and 911 Program a) Tower sites for the 800 MHz communication system remain under construction. Some of the new towers are up, and others are in progress. Engineering and site problems have slowed progress on this aspect of the project. In the meantime, work continues on the operational aspects of the system, particularly in the design of the talk group structure to be used. At the same time, work continues to define user equipment needs and allocations, which will help define the expenses to be passed on to system users. 4) Grants and Donations a) Assistance to Firefighters Grants (AFG): The 2006 version of the AFG and SAFER grants are being awarded now, with regular announcements coming out An Equal Opportunity Employer with a commitment to workforce diversification." 11 Fire Chief's Report for November 2006 14 NOV 06 Page 2 of 4 about what departments have received grants. To date we have received no word of any award. [No change from last month.] b) Governor's Traffic Safety Committee Grant: We received notice today of an award of $5,000 out of $7,500 requested to fund our child safety seat program through 2007. This comes from the Governor's Traffic Safety Committee, which functions out of the Department of Motor Vehicles. 5) Strategic Planning During budget hearings there was discussion among members of Common Council about how best to structure a plan to address the Fire Department's long- standing staffing requests and needs. That discussion was raised again at the regular 08 NOV 06 meeting of the Community Services Committee of Common Council. In particular, they remain very interested in knowing that a process to engage this issue is underway, and that they will receive regular reports on progress of the effort. Department leadership will meet to draft a process to formally engage this effort. We will report out at the next Board of Fire Commissioners meeting. Fire Prevention Bureau 1) Assistant Fire Chief Parson's report of Fire Prevention Bureau activities will be distributed at the Board meeting. 2) Smoke detector and child safety seat programs: Deputy Chief Dorman made the Tompkins County Chapter of the American Red Cross with the Ithaca Fire Department child safety seat and smoke detector programs. The Red Cross routinely serves the populations that often benefits from these programs. This collaboration and expanded outreach effort should result service to more people in need than would happen otherwise. Safety Section 1) Safety Stand Down: The final report still has not been completed. 2) Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) Testing: New York State Civil Service Law, section 178, requires we provide education, testing, and counseling to "public protection personnel" who may have been exposed to HIV. Copies of this law are attached to this report. The department does not currently have a policy that implements this law, but one will be developed as soon as possible. Fire Chief's Report for November 2006 OPERATIONS DIVISION Response 1) Monthly Call Report See distributed reports for 2006 YTD. 2) Emergency Management 14 NOV 06 Page 3 of 4 1) Efforts continue City -wide to insure compliance with National Incident Management System (NIMS) requirements. ICS 200 are being delivered now, and ICS 300 courses are in planning. Preparations are underway for a tabletop exercise for city departments. [No change from last month.] 2) Pre - Disaster Mitigation Grant: Starting in 2002, the City of Ithaca engaged in a project to develop a pre- disaster mitigation plan. This plan is required to insure eligibility for future mitigation grants. The grant application and plan have seen a series of drafts and revisions, the most recent of which was submitted on 30 OCT 06. If approved, expenses incurred in the development of this plan may be reimbursed. Further, certain projects already underway or completed may eligible for some level of reimbursement. Future projects may qualify for funding up front. As of this date, we have not heard the status of the final submittal. Support 1) See Deputy Chief Dorman's report. 2) Training Center report for October 2006 from Assistant Chief LaBuff: IFD 19 Hours Tompkins County 41 Private 0 NYSOFPC 16 Total 76Hours Maintenance is ongoing. 3) Boat Disposition Baden - Powell Council of the Boy Scouts of America has indicated they will buy the Carolina Skiff boat and trailer from the Fire Department for the price of $5,000. Final purchase and transfer is in the works. Fire Chief's Report for November 2006 14 NOV 06 Page 4 of 4 Training 1) See report from DC Dorman. 2) Trench Rescue Training: A special week -long trench rescue training program was held to train new personnel and refresh skills for those who had been trained when the Lake Source Cooling Project training was held. Additionally, personnel from the Department of Public Works were in attendance. This inter - departmental collaboration and training worked out very well and should pave the way for future trainings. VOLUNTEER SERVICES DIVISION Recruitment and Retention 1) No report. Service 1) Volunteer service hours reports for the period 01 JAN to 31 OCT 06, and bunker service hours reports from inception to 31 OCT 06, will be distributed at the meeting. Respectfully submitted, J:_ " WA &', Brian H. Wilbur Fire Chief Attachments ITHACA FIRE DEPARTMENT BOARD OF FIRE COMMISSIONERS REPORT November 2006 PERSONNEL STAFFING LEVELS 1 Chief 1 Deputy Chief 5 Assistant Chiefs 8 Lieutenants 49 Fire Fighters 64 On duty personnel 1 Fire Fighter on Injury Leave 1 Recruit Fire Fighter 1 Fire Alarm Superintendent 1 Executive Assistant 1 Financial Clerk 0.5 Financial Clerk Total employees as of 11/01/06 — 69.5 MUTUAL AID CALLS — From: Cayuga Heights (5) To: West Danby SELECTED CALLS — No Report SUPPORT 20 Vehicle work orders were written and 4z were closed. TRAINING — See Attached report. Submitted by: J. Thomas Dorman, Deputy Chief Date Printed: 11 /1/ 06 Page 1 M Ln M V- r O M Ln N O O 00 w O w w Ln Ln N M N (D M W Ln M r r I' Ln ^ r- LD N O M N r W Lfl It O Lo 6) q. N M N r M N N N r Cp N N N r J O N M M M d' r M M N O N� M M Ln r - (.p L!) N M N N M N r M M W O M Ln r Ln O N W N LL O J w w M Co CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO C4 w Ln u) W W 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Q Cp r N CO O CO v M r V- V- M N CO Ln N N 00 M N 0 N \ N \ r \ N \ M \ r \ r \ \\ N N r \ \\ O 00 r- \ r \ \ N \ N \ \ \ r \ W w N Ln r, N Ln w M r ti N M O O J O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O W \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \O \ \ \ \ \ \ D \ \ M \ \ M \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ M \ \ \ \ \ \ CO CO N M CO 00 N Ln M r CO } L Z Ln O O O mIt 0't 0 N Ln M r s O ro O M 00 m Lfl Ln r 2 C7 Z W O O O N O c0 ';I- M LO W O O It w O N O O N r M N V, 00 V' N N IT M CO 00 N 00 LO N N� M IT 00 Ln Q CO M Ln Ln M ct M N Ln N r W J_ O O r- It 00 N M 00 O Ln LO N Ln � O r 0 w N r W M N M CO N M Ln M M N M 00 Ln M M Ln 00 LD M M M M N Ln �t Lfl N C 2 N W O Z O N N 00 O M M Ln 1- O It w O V' N O m N M Ln M Ln M M N Ln r N Ln M r CM \j N \ M N r Ln O N Ln Ln O CD r I M M r N M r- M M M 00 IT O N M Ln r N N 00 Ln _ N M N N M N r O Ln r (.D N 00 N W c.� Q W _J N -N O z O W _. M N O 00 Ln ti c0 M O \ M M CD r- 00 N r- N N Ln n Q N Cn Ln N 00 V' M Ln r N (� _ Lfl M M M co N M V' CD N Of D O 2 z O O W O O (D M Ln W 00 O M 'l' O r- M 00 r 00 N 00 M M N O '- r O co I- M t- Ln �- C0 M u'1 N - r- 00 00 n \ N r r Ln O � 0- M M N It M Ln M m 0 M M M M M M O N O V, V' N M r N N r- Ln _ N M N N M N r IT O Ln r CD N 00 N W Q W J_ V7 N M O O Ln N 00 M M N M [t CD M M M N M N M IT D 0 0 0 0 0 0 O M m- It � IQ- 't cD O O O Q Q a o_ Q N N — — — — — — — 1 j (D O (O OD V O CJi ? W N 1 O (0 W OV M (n A W N y 0 (D 'p Oi O CD -n m z m m D ?1 1 D � C cn D D C7 -� O OC r0 m m m Z m m p > o m r c c G) m °r° o D y Oz O CO o O Cl) p m -, K z m m z z D m = p 0 D n c D p 0 D O m n m < rn cm D 0 0 > z z Z � 0 m D Z m ZO O< m m O O m O m O O z -n m p D U) m � z -n z < 1 � = Z T m m � � � D m D m CT = D D m D n -0 Z m p D O z m :1) O z 0 Z o m o n N 3 D m < D < m O 7 m n m z 0 °� o C- iv w w N N � Ul (Ti U7 _ W V 1 1 1 N TI J O O W N 1 N O N W W ) fD V7 V U1 Ut cr z O �■ W Ul N V 1 A N (p co CD V N N cn U7 al p al 3 -■ 6 _ N N .rt � N) O N w 1 v W W co i N D =* O N cn v V V N N O CS Z (n (n Ul (n - 7 n 0 O N � al 1 � Ut IV V N (Nn W V 4f r 3' VI Ul U7 U7 `� O U1 (n N N N : CD � CO A O 00 N O 1 L C O cnn Ut Cn A N CD ° N al N 1 w O L O N �o O A N V O o) Ui A U7 w n r NW A � nn A co N w -4 to r _ _ N _ O N :lj D1 (n (N Ii al � N A N N N Ir K) W 1 W N 1 W O O K) (n U1 N Ul (N Oi Z O C O v (D d � O a 1 1 rn w -- rn W si OV W O w0 N N O A (°O O O O W W U1 UW1 O OD W Cn Ut Vn Vn M (n U' N (n ° (Vii (Vii (n (Nn A oo Cn O � C N N N CD "O P V 0) (NJ7 A W N C1 CD a / cn V m O n^^ --j '\ cn Z '�^^ V! 0 j T> V D p m W O 0) m D m � D r- m D c p Z W 0 0 m Z C: z p X < ZO 0) N n O can m � < C7 z O m D > z d o � m Cl) m O cn c m 3 J z D o m m � O c O N C71 Ul .41 W 00 V U1 C- 7 N 3 rF 3• � wp 1 (O U7 CD Ul W U) N CY' W � fD � � z A vO cn Ul 00 N 0) CP O V ., "* O . �■ 0 3 CO cri W O N �' -a 0 ,-► O T rn y oO Cil CTi rn � cn `G y V N A CD O O V C CD Cn N _ cn CV71 O> U7 L CO _3 ^! CD O • cn A co _ D c U 3 3 N N � A O co O N CD 'G T W Q N N A N O .O► T cn z O O v A O d J O N wp 1 (O U7 CD c U) W V O (n O = 00 N N cn O N = N � Cyl N Tompkins County Fire, EMS, Disaster Advisory Board Meeting: September 25 from 1945 to 2107 Attending: Beth Harrington Lyle Neigh Larry Lanning Ben Caskey Dave Putnam Dave Cornelius Lee Shurtleff T.C. Department of Emergency Response Ithaca Fire Department Enfield Newfield Freeville At -Large T.C. Department of Emergency Response Excused: Mike Hattery T.C. Legislator 1. Minutes of the Previous Meeting There was a motion made and seconded to approve the minutes of the previous meeting as distributed. Motion was passed. 2. Communications Project Update (Lee Shurtleff)[Hand -out "Radio Systems "] Lee reported that the access roadways to almost all tower sites have been completed. The Curtis Road and Mt. Pleasant towers went up this week; the Ithaca College monopole will be erected next week. Lee has checked tower "visibility" after their installation. 6 of the towers will be `freestanding" lattice structures at 180 -190 feet; lights are only required on towers over 200 feet. It is hoped that tower shelters will be built during October and November, with antennae hung in December. Lee has continued to meet with various Town Boards about the project. The 911 Committee will be meeting with consultants this week to help define talk groups and explain operational aspects of the communications project. The County will probably initially "front" the money to buy equipment, and seeking equipment grants is ongoing. 3. 2007 Budget [Hand -out Budget Explanation to Martha Robinson] The County Administrator has made his recommendations to the Legislators with a fiscal target of 0% increase; to meet this budgetary goal, 1.6 million dollars will need to be cut from the current County budget. The only public safety department that was targeted for cuts was this office for $73, 000. The only lines that could be possibly cut to achieve this reduction are personnel (DoER or dispatch staff) or service contracts. In 1997, dispatch handled 56,000 total calls; to date, this 1 year over 180,000 have been received, with 15,000 of them being 911 calls. The total number of incidents hasn't increased that much, but with cellular technology, there are multiple calls about the same incident. Contract salaries and fringe benefits make up the largest portion, items that are not within Lee's control. Taking money from the service contract line is a gamble, since we still have to maintain the old radio system for another year until the new communications system is up and in service. Another budgetary item that needs to be considered is keeping money available for ongoing communications upgrades, which has been a problem in the past. Phone revenues bring in about $500,000 annually, which is for operations and equipment, and cannot be used for salaries. $28,000 comes from the NYS Department of Health for the EMS Coordinator's position; another $23,000 comes through SEMO and there are other miscellaneous grants. 4. Training NIMS compliance training has been offered by this office to many different disciplines and agencies, including Public Works and Highways, Sheriff's Office, etc. The compliance deadline is September 30, 2006. The County did pass the NIMS resolution. DoER has been named "point of contact" for signing off on Tompkins County compliance. 5. Other Tompkins County was included in the NYS June flood declaration and FEMA and SEMO representatives have been working with local municipalities during the recovery period. Tompkins County is expected to receive over $2 million dollars through the public assistance program. All the dispatch staff and several members of the fire and EMS community recently completed the EMD (emergency medical dispatch) course. The community members will be serving on an EMS advisory and quality assurance committee. It is hoped that EMD dispatching will begin sometime later this year. A new taw will allow active fire and EMS providers in NYS to claim $200 tax credit on their 2007 state income tax. There was a question about a letter sent out to former City of Ithaca Fire Police members. The letter seemed to imply that background checks were going to be done on those members still interested, but the letter was unclear as to whether or not the unit was being reactivated. Some follow -up is needed. Respectfully submitted, Beth Harrington ITHACA FIRE DEPARTMENT - November 7, 2006 BFC: Comm /co.officers,etc.CURRENT BOARD OF FIRE COMMISSIONERS WORK # HOME # TERM EXP. Robert Romanowski, Chair 160 Bundy Rd. 279 -5012 273 -2235 06/30/09 VACANT 1224 Trumansburg Rd. 277 -7948 Treas. Don Wood 06/30/07 William D. Gillligan 1224 Trumansburg Rd. 255 -7594 272 -7948 06/30/08 Paul Alexander 1215 E. State St. 280 - 3900/274 -2142 273 -4935 06/30/08 Steven Williams 235 Hector St. 273 -1723 273 -0848 06/30/09 Robin Holtham Korherr 1307 N. Cayuga St. 280 -4065 273 -1126 (City Liaison) CAYUGA HOSE CO. #1 2004 Captain Jack Bordoni 1 Lt. Andy Consalvi Treas. David Cornelius Sec. Earl Kaiser 3171/2 Utica St. 406 Utica St. 11 Autumn Ridge Cr. 272 -5629 ? RESCUE STEAMER & CHEMICAL Co. #2: (as reported 11/06/06 272 -2918 273 -0423 256 -3210 Capt. James Perry 1049 Warren Rd. Apt. #2, Ithaca, NY 14850 No Phone 1 Lt. Jim Lamb 222 Van Kirk Rd., Newfield, NY 14867 No Phone 2nd Lt. Maynard Richardson 128 Esty St., Ithaca, NY 14850 272 -2133 Sec. Raymond Wheaton 12 011i Rd., Newfield, NY 14867 564 -7227 Treas. Paul Alexander 1215 E. State St. 273 -4935 TORNADO HOOK & LADDER CO. #3 2005 (as reported 7/25/05) Capt. Susan Begg 104 N. Titus Ave. 272 -2472 1 Lt. Frank Canton 113 Park Lane, Ithaca, NY 14850 273 -7849 Treas. Eileen Camp 54 Mill St., Dryden 844 -9894 Sec.Raymond Wheaton 12 011i Rd., Newfield, NY 14850 564 -7227 ?UREKA PATROL CO. #4 (as reported 06/12/03) Capt. Matt Whittemore 289 Hayts Rd. 277 -5922 1 Lt. Bob Troy ? ? 2 Lt. Bill Fox, Sr. Nate's Floral Estates 273 -0793 Treas. Les Brown 62 Decker Rd., Newfield 273 -5958 TORRENT HOSE CO. #5 2005 Captain Josh Grant 965 Danby Rd. 351 -2995 1 Lt. ? 2 Lt. ? Sec. Ray Bordoni 1008 Beckingham Dr., St. Augustine, FL 32092 SPRAGUE STEAMER & HOSE CO. #6 (as reported 09/12/05) Capt. Jackl Gould 102 Happy Lane 273 -8705 1 Lt. Jim Rogers 205 3rd St. 273 -1559 2 Lt. Earl Neigh 157 Graham Rd. 256 -0294 Sec. Bill Gilligan 1224 Trumansburg Rd. 277 -7948 Treas. Don Wood 257 Iradell Rd. 272 -6230 CATARACT HOSE CO. #7 2004 (Reported 07/25/05)- send mail to PO Box 592 Capt. Robert Doner 330 Piper Rd., Newfield, NY 14867 564 -7604 1 Lt. Albert Hile 410 Valley Manor, Newfield, NY 14867 564 -9018 2 Lt. Sec. Dave Quick 918 N. Aurora St. 272 -9141 Treas. John Beach PO Box 6794, Ithaca, NY 14851 391 -7038 (work) ,%IERITON FIRE CO. #9 2003 (as reported 05/06/06 Capt. Philip Yam 309 College Ave. 1 Lt. Dan Dauplaise 309 College Ave. 2 Lt. Rob Cook 309 College Ave. Sec. Dan Daupliase 309 College Ave. Treas. Dan Maas 118 Hawthorne Pl. 272 -4099 1st Tuesday 1st Thursday 4th Monday 2nd Monday 1st Thursday 1st Thursday 1st Tuesday 2nd Sunday Statistical Summary Ithaca Board of Fire Commissioners - 11/14/06 There are 27,629 records in the Incidents Table. Between Sunday, January 1, 2006 and Tuesday, Jovember 14, 2006 there were 3,554 incidents. Currently there are an average of 11.18 incidents per day. Average response time for the department is 4.29 minutes. The average duration of an incident is 20.42 minutes. 200 150 100 50 0 600 500 400 300 200 100 0 Incidents by Hour of the Day f PFFM II? L PO . .... I O O O O O O O O O O r r - r - r - ,- ,- - N N N N Incidents by Day of the Week �t M W � ME 350000 300000 250000 200000 150000 100000 50000 0 SUN MON TUE WED THU FRI SAT Dollar Loss by Hour of the Day O O O 0 O O 0 0 0 0 r r r r - r r r r- r N N N 04 Loss Statistical Summary Ithaca Board of Fire Commissioners - 11/14/06 There are 27,629 records in the Incidents Table. Between Sunday, January 1, 2006 and Tuesday, Jovember 14, 2006 there were 3,554 incidents. Currently there are an average of 11.18 incidents per day. Average response time for the department is 4.29 minutes. The average duration of an incident is 20.42 minutes. 700000 600000 500000 400000 300000 200000 100000 0 Dollar Loss by Day of the Week SUN MON TUE W® THU FRI SAT Incidents by First Responding Unit 16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 Average Response Time by Unit A A 1 11 ME AII�IIY... CA CO (fl LO C) CO N L 1�t N CO � It Ch O O O O O CO O d' U) It CO O O CA Cn Cn 0) O Cn CA a) O CA O M OJ CA Runs Civil Service Law, Article 11, §178 13 NOV 06 page 1 § 178. Medical examination of public protection officials to detect and identify the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). 1. Definitions. For the purposes of this section: (a) "Assailant" means a person arrested and charged with a crime, as defined in section 10.00 of the penal law, or a person committed to, certified to, or placed in the custody of the department of corrections or any other correctional facility or county jail. (b) "Medical examination" includes a physical examination or test performed by a physician or other appropriate health care worker to determine if a public protection official has been exposed to or infected by the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). Tests may include, but need not be limited to, the most accurate, sensitive, and timely tests available used for the early identification of the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). (c) "Public protection official" means any state, county or municipal police officer, peace officer, firefighter, emergency medical technician, corrections officer, or sheriff who is acting under the scope of authority of his or her official position. (d) "Significant risk of transmission" means the alleged conduct of or actions taken by an assailant or any other action, situation or event that occurs while a public protection official is performing his or her official duties that has created a recognized and significant risk of infection of a public protection official with the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), as determined by the commissioner of health, consistent with guidelines, protocols, and findings of the United States centers for disease control and prevention. 2. Examination of public protection officials. (a) Whenever a public protection official has been exposed to a significant risk of transmission of the Civil Service Law, Article 11, §178 13 NOV 06 page 2 human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) while performing his or her official duties, the employer of such official shall provide to such public protection official an appropriate medical examination to determine if such official has been exposed to or infected with the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). Such medical examination of a public protection official should be provided within eight hours of notification to the employer or designated agent of the employer of an incident that has created an exposure risk to the official. (b) Should it be determined by the examining physician or other attending health care worker that a significant risk of transmission has occurred, or should any medical examination conclude that a public protection official has been exposed to or infected with the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), then such official shall be offered counseling and additional testing, as appropriate and consistent with treatment guidelines issued by the commissioner of health. Such counseling may include a discussion of the risk of the transmission of the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) from the exposure he or she may have experienced and the spectrum of tests commercially available for the prompt and reliable diagnosis of such infection. Information from any such medical examination of a public protection official shall be confidential information pursuant to article twenty- seven -F of the public health law and shall not be made available to the employer without the written authorization of the affected public protection official. 3. Payment for medical examinations. Payment for medical examinations, additional testing, treatment services, counseling services, and any other additional services provided pursuant to subdivision two of this section shall be covered by subdivision three of section ten of the workers' compensation law; provided that any employer which is not required to and does not provide coverage pursuant to subdivision three of section ten of the workers' compensation law may finance such payments for all of the foregoing services provided for by this section from municipal funding Civil Service Law, Article 11, §178 page 3 13 NOV 06 sources, including, but not limited to, employee accident and disability benefit programs, workers' compensation funds, health insurance benefits, accident and disability retirement plans, or any other source of funds that the municipal employer deems appropriate. 4. Guidelines. The commissioner of health shall issue guidelines to facilitate the identification of circumstances potentially exposing a public protection official to a significant risk of transmission of the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). Such guidelines shall be consistent with criteria accepted by the federal centers for disease control and prevention. Such guidelines shall also provide information regarding related counseling and testing procedures available to such individuals. 5. Confidentiality. Any information gathered pursuant to the provisions of this article which is deemed confidential under any other provision of law shall be treated in a confidential manner and shall not be distributed, be made available or be disclosed by the employer. C C) .ZJ O 5 (n 3 T m .-O T _0 -n N 7 � N CD ? rr CAD N N CD O :' CD C CD rr+ CD 1+ -z. CD C �' CD Q Qo CL F. 01) rn �+ 0 _0 o CD CD m nNi p - ° m m r* v 'a m CD CD p -< CD v N N O< r+ Q -0 'a 3 CD cn CND CD n Z � p N m r+ p r+ W E3 CD D p � CD < r+ p m (D 0 y N N rr CD cn O (D C C CD f— p U) D N 7O < N N N N N N N N N N N N N N o o 00 rn U, - - - rn rn rn n O U, O 4 O N O cn 0 O 40 IG4 1164 /.0 64 6A 69 69 64 64 64 64 64 64 64 c W J (n O N O — O V — cn N — Cn Z O O 00 (n O cn O O O N v O O O O O w O O O M,� < N O O (3) O O 00 O O _D m V O ° O V O Z cn Ln a) m Q cn w 44 " " bR 69 404 40 64 44 44 fA fy4 69 N W Vl -N 00 W N O Vi J J J W 4 N Cfl O O V M M O O In N -N O V N N V1 N In W In N O O Cn V O CD cn — X "`Nn 00 0 0 W CO 00 < N J m Z C m v Q W N O N O V O O N ul \ 4 \ n c � \ (7 rr CD V 69 � �_ 64 V 64 0) 64 N 69 O 64 w 69 V ' 64 N Vl 4 W _ — _' O O V O N rn � — N O V A (n (n 0 O N O m m 3 Cn O w N rn w O Oo �' 0o m y W 00 O w 00 CD N C� = m 69 b3 64 Ffi 46q 64 f-R FA 6g t-R 46} {4 6a 64 64 D N W C!n -A co w — N O U1 — — —, N w P O O 'J rn N cn W o Cn Ul rn v Cn - O c�D cn w O ct� rn N N � N Q O CD cn w 3 r+ 44 64 64 64 64 64 64 64 64 69 64 64 64 64 64 N 4�- 0) _;�- (D 4 — N O M — N W 00 O O 00 0- C n (3) v N O Oo O W W (n 00 :P� N N Ul a) 00 p W W 00 V7 Vt N O Vi O p' co w O O O N C) r+ OD 0o Q D D T M m O M 3 Z N 0 V• O r'F IO W i n n O r+ W d n fD N C c a j d o ' N 3 K N r� A . a m 3 m 9 " ^) CD " 3 rt n .t CD m i n �_ c c'b c m m c I4 V w m o a o Budget Oo j N CD N V In In CO ? W V OD w O O W V CO 00 o o w tD ? ? w O (n cn o O O O cn O V CD D) N O O W cn -� W r) N cn O O O Q) a N N 00 O N cn cn V O O 4 O O O w w CO O O O (n a) ? A ? A A ? A ? ? ? ? A ? N N N N O V V V M N V O O O -N W O N O cn O O cn Account Numbers Administration & L, _ N N J, $ Planning 12050 0 ? A O 'V N .A .A b cD -4 W M O N a) ? N O i. -CO -A (n O W Fire Prevention L, _ - N Bureau 12100 m N Vt w ID lD J .A co V W O1 D ? CO Safety Section q °D 12150 N O CO V Ln lD N V O cn A N O O O O (D (n Ln V W - Response Section m v v m 12200 A 00 A w Ca o V n (. f w D) v W ? o D) N N Support Section N N V N N W _w w .C. m A W 12250 lD Vt V a) N V1 ID ? N cn W O O N CO V A N o V C1 w w V O V O O W V V !9 O O m CO lD N O D O Emergency m D m w w Management ° N 00 w a V ° j a1 r) w L' V 12300 w W O N w w ? Training Bureau _ N 12350 v _ N w tD N lD O O cD O 0a m a Membership L„ w Section 12400 °) O O V w A Service / Duty L, w Section 12450 N O W (n A N CO Balance N O N N N Vt N O _ N W _ ? w W W N (D -P _ N Q) w LO O) O co O to V Cn w A N N N cn A CO 00 � W C N N N O W 00 ? (n N M M Vt O N Ln W O C O V V to CO O in W lD N O O w O u I � O _ Percent Expended CO D) O O w 00 w lD A O CO D) CO O O O 00 O N w N O M ? O w V M W W W V cD O O W w i N w V V e gg �� o� o 9z o o 9z o 9z o 0 0� o o a D D T M m O M 3 Z N 0 V• O r'F IO W i n n O r+ W d n fD N CITY OF ITHACA 310 West Green Street Ithaca, New York 14850 -5497 OFFICE OF THE FIRE CHIEF Telephone: 607/272 -1234 Fax: 607/272 -2793 November 12, 2006 Board of Fire Commissioners Ithaca Fire Department 310 W Green St Ithaca, NY 14850 Dear Board Members: The following is the Fire Marshal's report for October 2006. Codes Division: The Codes Division received 26 complaints in the month October. There were 19 complaints closed out, 9 complaints were forwarded to the Building Department, and 6 Complaints forwarded to the Town of Ithaca Code Enforcement Department. The Codes Division issued 31 parking violations during October. The Codes Division performed 35 Operating Permit Inspections, witnessed 6 sprinkler hydro test/inspections, and 6 fire alarm tests. The division issued 17 operating permits for assembly occupancies, 4 fire alarm system certificates, and 3 sprinkler system certificate. Fire Investigation Unit: There were no fire investigations during the month of October. Juvenile Fire Setters Program: There were no referrals to the program in the month October. Public Education: There were 5 Public Education Details, 2 Fire Drill2 witnessed, and 5 Child Car Seat Inspections in the month of October. In October, the Fire Prevention Bureau was busy with its routine activities involving the investigation of complaints, inspections of properties requiring operating permits, and inspections. The Fire Prevention Bureau spent both time and money getting the message out about the importance of smoke detectors in residential occupancies. The department purchased commercial time from two local radio groups for radio commercials to run over two week period in the middle of October. The commercials emphasized the "An Equal Opportunity Employer with a commitment to workforce diversification." Z "t Ithaca Fire Department Printed: 16:42:35 Bunker Duty Hours Report 11/14/06 T`T-me Badge Credit Off Sick Family Hours Available kick* k�ckkkkicickkic*** �c** �ckkick�cickicic* ickkF�ck�cic�c�ckk*************** * * * * * *'c * *�ckyckkk�c�c�cYc LADBURY , JOEL 04539 2515.00 2460.3 .00 .00 54.75 COOK , ROBERT 04585 702.00 705.00 12.00 -15.00 DAUPLAISE , DANIEL 04586 708.00 724.00 .00 .00 .00 -16.00 DEGANY , OPHIR 04587 579.17 522.50 14.00 .00 42.67 GRANT , JOSHUA 04588 1077.50 1029.9 .00 47.65 KARIUS , BRANDON 04591 285.50 310.50 .00 .00 .00 -25.00 SCHLEIERMACHER , JOHN 04594 431.40 394.00 .00 37.40 VANN , JUSTIN 04595 242.75 237.00 .00 .00 14.00 -8.25 WALLENSTEIN , DANIEL 04590 497.30 346.00 .00 14.00 137.30 YAM , PHILIP 04596 592.00 472.50 56.00 16.00 47.50 Ithaca Fire Department Printed: 16:48:07 Report Period VFF Duty Hours List 11/14/06 Date Start: 01/01/06 Date End 11/14/06 Name Badge Credit ************************************************* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * ** CANTONE , FRANK 04413 46.25 GILLIGAN , WILLIAM 04188 117.00 JUPITER , KEN 04362 .00 Y `GORE , CARL 04574 99.50 1 -S , DANIEL 04193 134.75 Proposal for Incoming IFD Bunkers and Volunteers Program 14 November, 2006 Current State With less than a handful of active volunteers, two bunkers at Station 9, four bunkers at Station 5, and two at Station 6, the combination state of the Ithaca Fire Department is diminishing. After this year, both bunkers at Station 9 will graduate, leaving it empty for the first time ever and with no further ties to the Cornell University student population. A Discussion with Chief Brian Wilbur In a September meeting with the Chief, he supported a new class of bunkers and volunteers provided that the new system be successful in creating at least 12 bunkers and be sustainable in the future. Budgeting Chief Wilbur suggested an estimated amount of $30,000 to run the program. Since the City of Ithaca and the IAFF have eliminated funding for training bunkers and volunteers, we must use 2% funds in order to continue the program. The Chairmen of the 2% Committee, Mr. Leon, referred me to Mike Kuferman, an attorney of the State Comptrollers Office which audits spending of these funds. He informed me that the 2% Funds can be spent according to the judgment of the members of the company. He stated that the FASNY guidelines handbook is a "guide ", and that the only restrictions on spending would be found in the City of Ithaca Charter. The City of Ithaca Charter makes note of the distribution of the 2% Funds, but does not specify how they are spent. Hence, volunteer companies can spend 2% funds on training, which Mike stated would be a perfectly good reason to spend the money. Each year, the eight companies receive $5,000- $6,000 in 2% funds which totals about $40,000 - $48,000. Company 9 has saved over $26,000 in its accounts. Company 9 has four members with three of the four leaving in May, 07. Because of this, current members of Company 9 are willing to put forth whatever it takes to implement the new training program in order to maintain members. Other volunteer companies have shown interest in supporting the new training program. Each Captain has been notified of this proposal and has agreed to suggest funding at the next company meetings. The Vice President of Cornell University Public Relations has also been contacted. He showed support for our program and stated that Cornell would be interested in funding provided that a more detailed proposal was established. This plan will be written up after a thorough attention to past training programs costs is done. A new tuition program for bunkers will be instituted. Since rent -free living in the IFD stations saves so much money ($5,000 per year), each incoming bunker must pay some amount to support the costs of training. At this point, we have considered $500. Chief Wilbur particularly liked this idea in that it would give new bunkers incentives to work harder in their fire training. It would also help prevent bunkers from quitting the program early. It has been suggested that the money be returned to the bunkers after 2 years of service. Should there be 12 bunkers each paying $500, then that is another $6,000 to use for training if the money is not returned. Lastly, IFD has created the position of a Municipal Training Officer, which will lower the total expenses of the training program as it will be that officer's duty to perform much of the work needed to coordinate the program. Putting these figures together, it is very likely that we will reach the needed $30,000. The question is can we make it sustainable? The answer is YES. A new training program will not be conducted every year, but once every 2 or 3 years, depending on how the volunteer companies are willing to donate. Each company would need to donate at most $3,500 every 2 or 3 years. Recruitment About 20 strong applicants will be needed in order fulfill at least 12 spots since people often cancel out based on the physical test or arising conflicts. At Cornell and Ithaca College, flyers will be posted. Also, career offices will be notified to distribute the information over their email listserves. On my own, I have already acquired 4 people interested in the program and are signing up to ride -along Engine 9 within the next few weeks. IFD Firefighter Trainers I have spoken with one IFD Asst. Chief who agreed to fully run the program should it become available again. From meeting with firefighters around Station 9 and Central, many have been interested in training new bunkers. What is the next step? Chief Wilbur invited me to come to the next IFD Chief's staff meeting to propose my ideas. At that point, he would make a decision on whether or not to run the program. The main goal for now is acquiring the committed support from the volunteer companies and the Board of Fire Commissioners. The tricky is part is getting everyone to reach out and contribute all at once, especially when everyone is waiting for the others to commit. Once a program is fully set in stone, recruitment will be much easier to conduct and we will be able to finally get the wheels rolling on this much - needed program. Philip M. Yam, Captain Neriton Hose & Ladder Company 9 Ithaca Fire Department If you have any concerns, questions, or suggestions, please contact me: Phone: (607) 227 -8954 Email: pmy3 @cornell.edu CITY OF ITHACA 310 West Green Street Ithaca, New York 14850 -5497 OFFICE OF THE FIRE CHIEF Telephone: 607/272 -1234 Fax: 607/272 -2793 November 12, 2006 Board of Fire Commissioners Ithaca Fire Department 310 W Green St Ithaca, NY 14850 Dear Board Members: The following is the Fire Marshal's report for October 2006. Codes Division: The Codes Division received 26 complaints in the month October. There were 19 complaints closed out, 9 complaints were forwarded to the Building Department, and 6 Complaints forwarded to the Town of Ithaca Code Enforcement Department. The Codes Division issued 31 parking violations during October. The Codes Division performed 35 Operating Permit Inspections, witnessed 6 sprinkler hydro test /inspections, and 6 fire alarm tests. The division issued 17 operating permits for assembly occupancies, 4 fire alarm system certificates, and 3 sprinkler system certificate. Fire Investigation Unit: There were no fire investigations during the month of October. Juvenile Fire Setters Program: There were no referrals to the program in the month October. Public Education: There were 5 Public Education Details, 2 Fire Dri112 witnessed, and 5 Child Car Seat Inspections in the month of October. In October, the Fire Prevention Bureau was busy with its routine activities involving the investigation of complaints, inspections of properties requiring operating permits, and inspections. The Fire Prevention Bureau spent both time and money getting the message out about the importance of smoke detectors in residential occupancies. The department purchased commercial time from two local radio groups for radio commercials to run over two week period in the middle of October. The commercials emphasized the "An Equal Opportunity Employer with a commitment to workforce diversification." co Fire Marshal's Report for October 2006— Page 2 importance of smoke detectors in the home, and reminding the listeners the importance of maintaining their smoke detectors. I met with the Tompkins County Landlord's Association during the last week in October and presented their group with information on proper smoke detector placement, as well as the proper types of smoke detectors they should be using. During the presentation to the Landlord's Association, I emphasized the importance of smoke detector maintenance, periodic inspections, documentation of inspections, and the replacement of smoke detectors at 10 -year intervals. I have received feed back from those who attended the presentation, and response has been very positive. An information fact sheet was posted on the Fire Department's Website that provides information for students and occupants of rental property about the proper actions they should take when a smoke detector sounds an alarm, or a farm alarm system is activated in their home or apartment. In the past several months we've seen an increase in the number of complaints filed that report disabled smoke detectors and fire alarm systems that have been tampered with by the people occupying residential occupancies. I met with Collegetown Neighborhood Council last week, and I made that group aware of the problem that we are seeing with smoke detectors and fire alarm systems. I have prepared the proposed changes to the Fire Prevention Code of the City of Ithaca and they are now in draft format. The changes are being reviewed by the Fire Chief, and will be reviewed by the City Attorney. The code changes will be sent to the City Administration Committee for approval at the end of November. Pending the approval of the Administration Committee, the revised code will be sent to the Common Council for final approval in December. The changes in the City's Fire Prevention Code are required because of changes in Title 19 NYCRR Part 1203 - Minimum Standards for Administration and Enforcement of the Uniform Code. The NYS Legislature enacted those changes in 2005. The revised version of Title 19 NYCRR Part 1203 will be come effective on January 1" 2007. The changes in the Minimum Standards for Administration and Enforcement of the Uniform Code require that the City of Ithaca inspect all buildings, which are not already being inspected on an annual basis, to be inspected at a frequency not to exceed 36 months. I have also proposed some additional changes to the Fire Prevention Code, beyond what is required by New York State. Those changes include the requirement for an operating permit for elevators, and the requirement for all elevator certified inspections to be filed with the fire department by the qualified elevator inspector. The New York State Uniform Fire Prevention and Building Code already requires the certified inspections of elevators. The purpose of requiring an operating permit is so that we can better track the maintenance of those elevators that are installed throughout the City of Ithaca. Respectfully Submitted, 0 A wla)liV C Thomas Parsons Assistant Fire Chief Fire Marshall ►s dew-W TE�F- 104e }4J 0/- e-,( F y a ifrlr- cp..����G,c� o•,� T�� �xr,�o,�,o..�r..� -,�,y ��c,a�vTs ,��s" .� ,.s��>y.Y,�,�z,�� 4X s �0 �>,P� iPFv,�� i� �5v�o i//So/ 1�,�l�ir•�® 911 Aee, --s - ew 17� X le -,4c) 70&)xe -es p 6 «,5 *Age /x) leocss . 71'14 /4l/, f$"aJT1- C-0*T%,oJ ,4� o,Codr*.4 A eU A P.OG, f`,4H_5 A4e l/ip_,7,r? W,4y AIJO ,gart,� UN /L` AAz ,& a �y 4 X Acae�e,�T ,� s,� -, ,�� is �, p, fNE; r ,tiv,OL "6.4LJ_C / 5 I % /rV ,(Wc- 1�w- 6 1- 1,a(14 Fa:c f .ye7 : AF>(Fzx,1g,@. ,sake G,oL.00- 6 -0J?j(> 73 A)OZi 7-AV-45 IWA4 . 7AV- 01- (aeel -41- j-; P> go,4- ' his 43i5e f <)7�> 771f /%tfr/,41- 140,0 -02y T;PA,t15A"cr ,p4(' 15 Q,c1411� cp svr�r i� r